+ All Categories
Home > Documents > The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes...

The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes...

Date post: 26-May-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
14
The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 1 The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide Produced by Cathie Brady & Barbara Frank B&F Consulting, Inc and Susan Wehry, MD June 2009 Funding was provided by a grant from the Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals, using civil money penalties paid into the Nursing Home Residents’ Trust Fund. The grant was administered by the Governor’s Office of Elderly Affairs.
Transcript
Page 1: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

1

TheBigUneasy:

Katrina’sUnsungHeroes

Facilitator’sGuide

ProducedbyCathieBrady&BarbaraFrank

B&FConsulting,Incand

SusanWehry,MD

June2009

FundingwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheLouisianaDepartmentofHealthandHospitals,usingcivilmoneypenaltiespaidintotheNursingHomeResidents’TrustFund.

ThegrantwasadministeredbytheGovernor’sOfficeofElderlyAffairs.

Page 2: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

2

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSThisfilmisapartoftheNursingHomeStaffingProjectinitiatedafterHurricaneKatrinatoaddressstaffingneedsofNewOrleansareanursinghomes.TheprojectwasundertakenbytheWorkforceIssuesWorkgroup.TheWorkgroupwasavoluntarycollaborationamongorganizationsandindividualsconcernedaboutthewell‐beingofnursinghomes,staffandresidentsinthegreaterNewOrleansarea.ThegroupworkedtogetheronfindingsolutionstothenursinghomeworkforceissuesthatconfrontLouisiana.SponsoredbytheLouisianaHealthCareReview,theWorkgrouphadnolegislativemandate,formalstructure,orgovernmentalfunction.Stateagenciesandlong‐termcareorganizationsthatworkedtogethertohelpstabilizestaffinginnursinghomesafterKatrinathroughtheNewOrleansNursingHomeStaffingProjectinclude:

GulfStatesAssociationofHomesandServicesfortheAging

LouisianaDepartmentofHealthandHospitalsLouisianaHealthCareReview

LouisianaNursingHomeAssociationOfficeoftheStateLong‐TermCareOmbudsman,Governor’sOfficeofElderlyAffairs

ProjectFaculty:

CathieBradyandBarbaraFrank,B&FConsultingwww.BandFConsultingInc.com

SusanWehry,MDhttp://web.me.com/swehrymd

Allmaterialsfromthisprojectareavailableatwww.lhcr.org

Formoreinformation,contact:

LindaSadden,StateLong‐TermCareOmbudsmanGovernor’sOfficeofElderlyAffairs

412N.4thStreet,3rdFloorP.O.Box61

BatonRouge,LA70821Tel:(866)632‐0922Fax:(225)342‐7144

website:http://www.louisiana.gov/elderlyaffairs/LTCombudsman.html

Page 3: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

3

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroes

Facilitator’sGuide

TableofContents

Acknowledgements 2

Introduction 3

UsingtheFilm 5

DiscussionGuide 7

PriortoShowingtheFilm 7AfterShowingtheFilm 7

o GeneralDiscussion 7

o PsychologicalPreparedness 7

o GoodPracticesinanEmergency 9

o PersonalPreparedness 10

o LessonsinLeadership 10

o ThreeKeyResourcesonLeadership 11

Resources 14

Page 4: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

4

IntroductionWorsethanDesertStorm…Emergenciescanhappenanywhere.ThelessonslearnedfromKatrina,duringthestormanditsprotractedaftermath,haveuniversalapplicability.Theheroismofnursinghomestaffprovideslessonsinhumanityandcourage.Theleadershippracticesthatpreparedstafftorisetothechallengesexemplifythebestinleadership,inemergenciesandalsoindailyoperations.ThisfilmisapartofaprojectinitiatedafterHurricaneKatrinatoaddressthestaffingneedsofNewOrleansareanursinghomes.Theseneedsbecameparticularlyacuteinthemonthsthatfollowedthestormasresidentsandstaffbeganreturningtothedevastatedarea.Manyhomesevacuatedbeforethestorm;othersdidnotorcouldnotevacuateandstayeduntiltheywererescuedafterthecitywasmadeuninhabitable.Someneverstoppedoperations,despitethechaosaroundthem.Allfacedchallengesastheyworkedtoreturntofulloperation.Theirexperiencesvariedandyethadcommonthreads.Overthecourseofthreeyears,theprojectprovidedon‐siteassistanceandsharedlearningsessionstofacilitiesintheaffectedareas.Asthehomescomparedexperiences,theybecameawareofhowtheirowngoodpracticescontributedtopositiveresults.Togethertheysharedwaysofbuildingontheirexperiencesincrisisastheyworkedtoreturntonormaloperations.Sixofthehomesgraciouslyallowedustocapturetheirstoriesonfilmasawaytosharelessonslearned.Alltoldtheirstoriesinhopesofhelpingothers.Inthecourseoftheirtelling,bothextraordinarycharacterandexemplaryleadershiparerevealed.Whatemergedmostclearlyfromthestorieswasthatstrongleadershipandcommitmenttostaffbuiltbeforethestormservednursinghomeswellinatimeofcrisis.Wewitnessedcreativeandparticipatorydecision‐makingandthefosteringofrelationshipsthatallowedhomestobecomeemotionalhavensintimesofextremestress.Themostenduringtruthwelearnedisthis:Everynursinghomeisvulnerabletodisasters–bothnaturalandman‐made–andnoplanisinfallible.Thebestpreparation–andthebestresponse–istocareforstaff,becausepeopledobestinaclimateoftrustandteamwork,andwhentheyhavethesupporttheyneedtotakecareofresidents.ThisfilmisalsointendedasatributetothestaffofLouisiana’snursinghomeswhobroughtthousandsofresidentssafelythroughthestormandthedifficultiesthatfollowed.Oneofthestaffinthefilmsays,“disasterdoesn’tbuildcharacter,itrevealscharacter.”Whilethosestaffmembersinterviewedforthisfilmdisplayeddeepintegrityandcommitment,mostnursinghomesonmostdayshavethesamekindofpeoplefillingtheirranks.Mostnursinghomestafffindthattheworkofcaringforothersistrulyacallingthattheyrespondtoeveryday.

Page 5: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

5

UsingthisFilmThisfilmisintendedtopromotediscussion,generateideas,andserveasalearningtool.Thisguidehelpsyouextractlessonsfromthefilmaboutleadershippracticesandrelatedemergencypreparednesspractices.Itprovidesguidingquestions,highlightsgoodpractices,andidentifiesresources.MostpeopleheardsomestoriesaboutnursinghomesinNewOrleansduringKatrina.Almostallthecoveragefocusedontherareoccurrencesoftragedyandlostlives.Thisfilmtellsadifferentstory.Itisthestoryofnursinghomestaffwhokeptotherssafeandcaredfor,evenwhiletheirownsafetyandtheirownfamily’ssafetywasuncertain.Whataudiencesaresaying:

“Itshowedthecompassion”“Asareceivingfacilityitwasgoodtoseethewholepictureofwhatpeoplewentthroughtogettous–weknew‐butnotreally”“It’snotjustthetragedy–youshowedthepositives”

ThesearejustasamplingofcommentsheardwhenthefilmpremieredinLouisianainJune2009.Somenursinghomesplantousethefilmtohelpbuildteamwork;otherstoinspireempathy,compassionandunderstanding.Stillotherswilluseittohelptheirstaffhaverealisticexpectationsofwhatmaybeaskedoftheminanemergency,orwhenreceivingotherswho’vebeenthroughanemergencyevacuation.Thefilmcanbeusedinmanydifferentwaysbyanyoneaffiliatedwithnursinghomesandbythoseinterestedinarealstoryofhumanstrength,courageandcommitment.Usethefilmfor:

• Inspiration,Motivation,Appreciation–tosharewithstaff,asaninspirationalfilm,depictingthededicationofnursinghomestaff

• PreparationandEducation–tohelpstaffinnursinghomesandothercaresettingsthroughoutthecountrybeawareofwhatmaybecalledforintimesofdisasterorinbeingareceivingfacilitythattakespeopleinafteradisaster

• LeadershipDevelopment–toteachaboutanddevelopgoodleadershippractices• TeachingTeamwork–toarticulateconceptsandpracticesfor“beinginittogether”• Teachingwaystonurtureresilience–tosupportpsychologicalpreparedness;“steady

todaymeansreadytomorrow;”tobereadyforgoodleadershipandteamworkpracticesinacrisisbymakingthesepracticespartoftheday‐to‐day

• PlanningandCommunityAwareness–topromoteunderstandinginthecommunityaboutthesupportpeoplelivingandworkinginnursinghomesmayneedinadisaster

• SocialHistory–forknowledgeaboutahistoricalevent:howtheNewOrleansareanursinghomesrespondedduringKatrina

Page 6: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

6

Werecommendshowingthefilminitsentirety.TopicareasareeasilyaccessedsoyoucanreturntosectionsduringdiscussionusingthemenuprovidedontheCD.Theguidefocusesdiscussiononthethreeprimarythemes:

1. Preparation2. Nurturingresilience3. Practicinggoodleadership

Thefilmis49minuteslongandhasanintroductionandtwoparts:PartI:“Youcan’tjusthopeforthebest”

PartItellsthestoryofthesixnursinghomes’experiencesduringKatrinaanditsaftermath.Itdescribestheirpreparationfortheirstorm,gettingthroughthestormitself,andthenfacinganunprecedentedsetofchallengesasthecrisisgrewaroundthem.Thefilmcapturesbothindividualandorganizationalchallenges.Hearingdirectlyfromstaffastheytalkabouttheirexperienceshighlightstheseverityofthedifficultiespeoplefacedandhowtheysurvivedbyworkingtogether.Thissectionalsoillustratesthedegreeofplanning,preparation,andteamworkneededtosuccessfullyexecuteanevacuationofanursinghome.Ithelpsviewersthinkabouthowtheywouldpersonallyrespondtoasimilarsituation,andprovidesinformationabouteffectivepracticesindoingso.ItisthefoundationfordiscussionofwhatworkedinPartII.

PartII:“Sharingwhatworks”

PartIIcapturesreflectionsofstaffmembersfromthesamesixhomesastheysharewhatworked,anddescribesomeofthepracticesthatallowedthemtogetthroughthisdisasterandbackontheirfeet.Clearlyleadershipmadeadifferenceinhowthesesixhomesfared.Theirstoriesrevealleadershippracticesessentialtotheirsurvival,whichhadrootsintheireverydaywaysofleading.

FACILITATORTIPS:

• Asfacilitator,previewthefilmbeforeshowingittoagroup.• Allowparticipantsforreflectivetimepriortoandafterviewingthefilmtoabsorbits

emotionalimpact• Usepairedconversationand/orsmallgroupdiscussiontoallowspacefortheintimate

natureofthereflectionthefilmgenerates,inanysizegroup.• Theguideprovidessuggesteddiscussiontopics,andincludesresourcesonleadership.

Page 7: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

7

DiscussionGuidePriortoShowingtheFilmINTRODUCEFILM:

• Shareinformationabouthowandwhythefilmcameabout,usingthebackgroundfromtheAcknowledgementsandIntroductionsections.

• ShareanycurrentinformationyouhaveaboutrebuildingprogressinNewOrleans.DISCUSSION:AsktheaudiencetotalkinpairsaboutKatrina.Allowthisdiscussiontotaketime–itisapersonalreflectiontime.Possiblediscussionquestions:

1. WherewereyouwhenyoufirstheardofthedevastationinNewOrleans?Whatdoyourememberseeing?

2. WhatdoyourememberhearingaboutnursinghomesduringKatrina?

AfterShowingtheFilmGENERALDISCUSSIONAFTERVIEWING:Somepeoplemayhaveanemotionalreactiontothisfilm.Allowapauseafterthefilmends.Thenbeforeanyfocuseddiscussion,givetheaudienceafewminutestogathertheirthoughtsandshareinpairsorsmallgroupsbyinvitingpeopletodebriefonwhattheyjustviewed.Additionalgeneraldiscussion:asktheaudiencetoreflectbackonthediscussiontheyhadbeforeviewingthefilm.Askifafterviewingthefilm,theychangedwhattheyhadthoughtaboutthesituation.Havethemstartthisdiscussionintheiroriginalpairs,orinsmallgroups.

PSYCHOLOGICALPREPAREDNESSAskpeopletotalkinpairsforafewminutesabouthowtheymentallyprepareforsomethingstressfulorworrisome.ResourceInformation:Emergencypreparednessismultilayeredandeachlayeriscriticaltosuccess.Evacuationplans,shelteringplans,contingencyplansareallfornaughtifstaffandleaderslacktheemotionalreserveandfortitudetocarryoutthoseplans.Whenstaffsarepsychologicallyprepared,theyfeelconfident,competentandcaredabout,andnotonlycarryoutthoseplansbutdosoagainstallodds.Thiscapacityisoftencalledresilienceandisacapacitythatcanbedevelopedandnourished.AswithotherlessonsthatemergedfromKatrina,nurturingresilience‐whichwehavecalledpsychologicalpreparedness–beforethestorm,servednursinghomeswellinatimeofcrisis.Ifwearesteadytoday,wearereadytomorrow,nomatterwhattomorrowmaybring.

Page 8: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

8

Psychologicalpreparednesshasthreekeyingredients:1. Asenseofteam: WeareinthistogetherLeadersreinforcethisbybeingadailyvisiblepresence.Bywalkingabout,sayinghello,learningandaddressingresidentsandstaffbyname,sayingthanks,leadersconveyasenseofbeinginittogether. LeadersreinforcethisbyensuringtheneedsofstaffandtheirfamiliesaretakenintoaccountwhendevelopingevacuationplansLeadersreinforcethisbyrollinguptheirsleevesandworkingsidebysidewithstaff.Inshort,practicinggoodleadershipskillsbuildsasenseofteam.2. Asenseofconfidence: WecandothisStaffneedtohaveconfidenceinleadershipaswellasinthemselvesandeachother.Leadersearnconfidencebyregularlyprovidingaccurateinformationaboutemergencyplans,communicatingclearlyandoften,andestablishingclearroles.Leadersbuildconfidencebybeingcrediblewhichincludesbeingfair,consistentandreliable.Staffdevelopconfidencewhenleadersnoticeandpraiseajobwelldone(“catchmedoin’somethinggood”)androutinelysolicitandutilizetheirideas.3.Emotionalreserves: Wevalueyourhealth Promotingwellness‐instaffaswellasinresidents‐isahottopicinhealthcareandiscrucialtopsychologicalpreparedness.Goodhealthincludesbothphysicalandmentalhealth.Goodhealthhabitsandstressmanagementskillsboostbrainpowerandhelppreventdepletionofcriticalbrainreservesduringacrisis.Leaderssupporthealthinavarietyofwaysrangingfromprovidinghealthbenefitstoprovidingnutritiousfoodandensuringadequatesuppliestodothejob(astraightforwardwaytoreducestress).Leaderssupporthealthbymodelinggoodself‐care(“youroxygenmaskgoesonfirst”)andmaintaininganattitudeofoptimism.Leaderssupporthealthbyincorporatingstressbustersintotheworkplace(deepbreathing,laughing,stretching,takingabreak).DISCUSSION:Embeddedinthefilmarestepsleaderstooktoensurepsychologicalpreparedness:Howmanycanyouspot?Whatdoesyourorganizationhaveinplaceforpsychologicallypreparedness?

Page 9: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

9

GOODPRACTICESINANEMERGENCYYoucan’tjusthopeforthebestEmbeddedthroughoutthefilmareexamplesofgoodpracticesforevacuationsinadisaster.Livingthesepracticeshelpedthehomestogetthroughtryingtimesandmaintaintheirabilitytoprovidegoodcareevenonagymnasiumfloor.Thesesamepracticeshelpedstaffdealwiththecrisesthatensuedwhentheirbestlaidplansfellthrough.Theimportanceofbeingpreparedrunsthroughthisfilm.Thisfilmisidealasanaidfordisasterplanningorwhenyoureviewyourfacility’splanwithstaff.Ifyouareusingthisfilmasatoolfordisasterpreparedness,asktheviewerstowatchwithapencilinhandandtojotdownexamplesofgoodpracticesastheyseethem.Hereareexamplesofgoodpracticesthatyoucanhighlightandusetopromptdiscussionamongparticipantsaboutbestpractices.Theyarelistedalongwithsubsectiontitlesinthefilmsoyoucanreplaythemifyouwanttofocusinonaparticularareafordiscussion.DISCUSSION:Encourageparticipantstosharetipsandbestpractices,tohelpeveryonebebetterprepared.

• Onthebus:[Firstsectionin“Youcan’tjusthopeforthebest”]o Loadingabus:Thisisphysicallydifficultandisanenormousorganizational

undertaking.Haveyoueverdoneadrillinloadingabus?o Staffingonthebus:“Wehadnurses,CNAsandadministratorsonthebus.”Not

knowinghowlongtheridetotheirevacuationsitewouldtake,theymadesurethatthebushadadequatestaff,nomatterhowlongthejourney.

o Suppliesonthebus:“Wetookthemedicineincasearesidenthadaseizure.”EventhoughtheridetoBatonRougewasusuallylessthananhour,thestaffknewthatinaneventlikethiswouldtakemuchlonger.Sohavingmedicine,water,food,coolers,andcare‐relatedsuppliesonthebuswasanecessity.

o Systemsofchecksandbalances:Asystemforcheckingresidents,medications,andsupplieswasadheredto—“Youbringtheresidentstothebus,pickupthemedsfromthemedcartandcheckoffthattheresidentisonboard.”Tomakesurenooneisleftbehind,everywhere,includingclosetsarecarefullychecked.

• Attheevacuationsite:[“settingupshop”]

o Creatingasafespace:Astheypreparedtosetupshoponagymfloor,thehousekeepingstaffdisinfectedthemattresses.Keepingtheareawherecareisprovidedcleanisimportant.Howelsedidstaffinthefilmmaintaincleanliness?

o Communityassistance:“Wefindthatiftherearevolunteersinthecommunityatthereceivingend,peoplefeelwelcome.It’sjustsuchanupliftingthinganditreallyhelpsalotandthenifwecan[have]policemen,nationalguardsmentheretohelpoffloadthepatientsitreallydoesrelievealotofstress.’Doyouhavethe

Page 10: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

10

communitycontactsinplacetomakethishappen?Howdoyoudevelopthesecontacts?

• Planning,andHavingPlanB:[bestlaidplansand“I’mnotleavinganybody”]o Whenplanschange:RememberhowPatrickandKathyhadtomakePlanBwhen

theirevacuationsitewaschangedtoonethatcouldn’tsupportthem.Doyouhaveaback‐upplan?

o Courageinthefaceoftheunexpected:StaffatSt.Margaret’sDaughtersHomemovedresidentswhenthestormblewofftheroofoftheirshelter.StaffatChateauLivingCenterreadiedtomovetheirresidentswhentheyheardfloodwaterswerecomingtheirway.

o EmergencySuppliesandContingencies:[“itwashot”]Doyouhavethecapacitytocareforpeopleinapoweroutage?Doyouhaveworkingrelationshipswithrescuerswhocanbackyouupifyouneedit?

• CommunicationandStaffSupport:o Staff’sfamilies:[“Icouldn’tfindmyson”]Askstaffiftheyandtheirfamilieshave

createdanemergencyplan.Thisfilmcanbeusedasaspringboardfordiscussionabouthowyouplantosupportthosewhoevacuatewithyou.

o Backupcommunicationsystems:Howwouldyougetintouchwithpeopleandhowwouldtheygetintouchwithyou,intheeventofaregionaldisaster?

PERSONALPREPAREDNESSIfyouwouldliketoaskpeopletofocusontheirpersonalpreparednessandtothinkaboutwhatnursinghomestaffwentthroughasindividuals,herearesomesamplediscussionquestions:

1. Haveyouthoughtaboutwhatmighthappeninyournursinghomeifyouwereeverforcedtoevacuate?

2. Wouldyouchoosetoevacuatewiththehome,ortostaywithyourownfamily?3. Ifyoucould,wouldyoubringyourownfamilywiththehomeinanevacuation?4. Ifyouelectedtogowiththehome,whatwouldyoutake?5. Whatwouldthehomeneedtodotomakeitsoyouwouldchoosetogo?6. Couldyouliveinawingofanursinghome?Howmightyouseethingsdifferentlyifyou

livedwhereyouwork?7. Isyourfamilypreparedforadisaster?Doyouhaveplansforrelocationand

communication?8. Howdoyoukeepyourspiritsupwhenthingsarenotgoingwell?9. Doyouidentifywithanyoneinthefilm,andwhy?

LESSONSINLEADERSHIPTheleadershippracticesexemplifiedinthisfilmarerelevantnotonlytoemergencypreparednessbutalsotoeverydayleadership.Thesepracticescreateworkplaceswhere

Page 11: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

11

individualworkersthrive,andworkwellwitheachother.Workingwelltogetheriscrucialtobeingabletoprepareforandrespondtoanemergency.Itisalsocrucialforstaffretention.Goodleadershipisaskill,andlikeanyotherskill,themorewepracticeit,thebetterwegetatit.Katrinagavepeoplemanyopportunitiestoexerciseleadershipskills.MostofthetimelifedoesnotcomeatusquiteasfastasitdidforthosewholivedthroughKatrinaanditsaftermath.AdisastersuchasKatrinachallengespeoplecaughtinittobehaveinwaysthatordinarylifedoesnotcallforustodo.Clearlyleadershipmadeadifferenceinhowthesesixhomesfared.Theirstoriesrevealleadershippracticesessentialtotheirsurvival,whichhadrootsintheireverydaywaysofleading.Theirpracticesechothe“Level5leaders”JimCollinsdescribesinGoodtoGreat,JimCollinsasseeminglyordinarypeoplequietlyproducingextraordinaryresults.

THREEKEYRESOURCESONLEADERSHIPJimCollins,inhisbookGoodtoGreat,foundLevel5leadershiptobethemainingredientincompaniesthatwereabletomaketheleapfromgoodtogreat.SomeofthecharacteristicsofLevel5maybesurprising.Hetalksabouttheleadersbeinghumble,shy,gracious,self‐effacingandunderstated,yetfanaticallydriventopositiveoutcomesfortheirorganizations.CollinsnotedthatLevel5leaderschanneltheiregoneedsfromthemselvesandintothelargergoalofbuildingagreatcompany.HeespeciallyhighlightedthewayLevel5leaders“createaclimatewherethetruthcanbeheard,”usingfourkeypractices:

• Leadwithquestions,notanswers• Engageindialogueanddebate,notcoercion• Conductautopsieswithoutblame• Build“redflag”mechanisms

InTheLeadershipChallenge,apopularevidencebasedmanualonleadership,KouzesandPosnerfoundfivefundamentalpracticesthatenabledleaderstogetextraordinarythingsdone:

• Modeltheway• Inspireasharedvision• Challengetheprocess• Enableotherstoact• Encouragetheheart

SusanEaton,inher2002CMS‐fundedstudy,Whatadifferencemanagementmakes!,appliedleadershipconceptstonursinghomes,comparinghighandlowturnoverhomes.Sheidentifiedthefollowingkeymanagementpracticesatnursinghomeswithhighretentionandhighperformance:

Page 12: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

12

SeeResourceSectionformoreinformationabouthowtoobtaintheseresources.DISCUSSION:YoucanintroduceKouzesandPosner,andEatonpriortoshowingthefilmandaskviewerstowatchforexamplesoftheseleadershippractices,oryoucansharethisleadershipinformationafterthefilmisviewed.Askpeopleaboutleadershippracticestheysawinthefilm,and/ortosharebestpracticesinleadershiptheyareawareofintheirownworkplaces.LinktothepracticesdescribedinthesectiononPsychologicalPreparedness,aseverydaygoodleadershippractices.Youcanreplaysectionsthathighlightcertainpractices(asnotedbelow).Useanycombinationofthesepracticesasaspringboardforfurtherprobing.Otherpossiblediscussionquestions,withreferencestosubsectionsoftheguide,include:

• GoodLeadership:Whatmakesagoodleader?Selectquotesfromfilmthatspeaktothisissue“intheirownwords.”

• Goodleadershippriortoanevent/Goodpreparation:[“What’sthestory?What’stheplan?”]Askviewerstorespondtothefollowingquotefromthefilm:“Ifyoueverhavetohaveanevacuationoryouhavetogothroughsomethingtothisextent,Ihopethatyouhaveyourdailybusinessincheck.Becauseifyoudon’t,youwillprobablyfail.”Whatdotheythinkaboutthis?Whatisneededinthedailybusinessofleadershipinordertobesuccessfulinanevacuation?

• Communication:[“What’sthestory?What’stheplan?”]Communicationisessentialforanyorganization’ssuccess–whetherinsurvivingadisasterorretainingstaff.Identifyspecificexamplesofgoodcommunicationpracticesbysomeoftheleadersinthisfilm.

• ValuingStaff:[“Iknowwhatyou’regoingthrough”]Wouldyousaytheleadersinthisfilmvaluedtheirstaff?Respectedthem?Discovered–orre‐discovered–theircommonhumanity?Giveexamplesofeach.

Five Organizational/Management Practices Associated with High Retention, Attendance, and Performance From What a difference management makes! by Susan Eaton, 2002

“A Positive Chain” of high quality

leadership throughout the organization

Organizational practices that value staff in

policy and practice, in word

and deed

Human resource policies and

practices that invest in and support staff

Organization and work design to

reinforce intrinsic motivation of staff to

care for residents

Sufficient staffing and resources to provide humane

care

Page 13: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

13

• EnablingOtherstoAct:[“Ithinkwecanrunwiththis”]Onekeydimensionofgoodleadershipisenablingotherstoact.Discussexamplesinthefilmandthendiscussthewaysinyourorganizationthatyouenableotherstoact.

• ParticipatoryLeadership:[“Ithinkwecanrunwiththis”]o WhatdidyouthinkwhenBobsaid“I’llstealanyidea.Ifit’sworkingsomewhere,

I’llstealit,I’mnotproud.” Self‐check:Doyouseekoutgoodideasfromyourstaff?Ifso,whatis

yourmethodforgettinggoodideasfromstaff?Doyourewardgoodideas?

o DiscusswhatKellieandDenasaid,that,”Everyonehassomethingtoofferandyouvaluetheiropinion.Andwe’vecarriedthatforwardalotsincewe’vebeenback.Whenwe’remakingpolicychangeorbigdecisions,weinvitethepeopleinit’sgoingtoeffectandsayhowwillthisreallyaffectyoubecauseyoudothejobdaytoday.”Howdoyou/canyoumakethatoperationalwhereyouwork?

• TakingCareofStaff:Somenursinghomesdescribedprovidinghousingfortheirstaffafterthestorm.Whatdoyouthinkofthat?Howisitacomponentofgoodleadership?

• Ingenuity:[“Ithinkwecanrunwiththis”]Inthefilmtherewerenumerousexamplesofingenuity.[PortaJohns,cuttingupthetowels,themake‐shiftlaundry,buildingashower,contaminationsigns]

o Whatstruckyouasparticularlyingenious?o Self‐check:Areyourstaffabletotakeinitiative?Ifso,howdoyouencourage

them?Whathappensifagoodideadoesn’tworkoutaswellashoped?• DevelopingLeadershipinOthers:Howdidtheofficialleadersinthesehomesdevelop

theleadershipabilitiesofthosearoundthem?• BeinginCommunity:[“inittogether”and“eggsalad”]

o Whatdidstaffsayaboutteamworkandhowleaderspromotedit?o HowdidleadersModeltheWay?o Whatrelationshipsdoesyournursinghomehavewithothersinthecommunity

whoareresponsibleforcoordinatinglocalorregionaldisasters?

Page 14: The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes€¦ · The Big Uneasy: Katrina’s Unsung Heroes Facilitator’s Guide 4 Introduction Worse than Desert Storm… Emergencies can happen

TheBigUneasy:Katrina’sUnsungHeroesFacilitator’sGuide

14

ResourcesOtherresourcesthatyoumightfindhelpful:WhatYouDoMattersACurriculumforStaffStabilityThistrainingcurriculumistheculminationoftheLakeCharlesNursingHomeStaffingProject,ayear‐longlearningcollaborativedesignedtohelpnursinghomesintheLakeCharlesregionstabilizestaffingandresumetheirculturechangejourneyafterHurricaneRita.Themanualgivesparticipatinghomesawaytoreviewandrenewtheirworkandprovidesanopportunityfornon‐participatinghomestounderstandandusetheworktomakepositivechanges.Themanualincludesallofthematerialspresentedatthefourlearningsessionsalongwithinstructionsfortheiruse.ItisavailablebycontactingtheGovernor’sOfficeonElderAffairs,OfficeoftheStateLongTermCareOmbudsman,[email protected].

StaffStabilityToolKitbyB&FConsultingforQualityPartnersofRhodeIsland:Providespracticalguidanceforimprovingretentionandstabilizingday‐to‐daystaffing.Availableatwww.riqualitypartners.org.Clickon“HATChmodel”andthenon“Workforce.”GoodtoGreatbyJimCollinsarticulateswhatittakestogofromjustbeinggoodtobeinggreat.Itdescribesleadershipandorganizationalpracticesthathelpcompaniesexcel.TheLeadershipChallengebyJamesKouzesandBarryPosner:Writtenasafieldguidetoleadership,itidentifiesfivepracticesofexemplaryleadersanddescribeshowtoimplementthesepracticesineverydayleadership.Whatadifferencemanagementmakes!bySusanC.Eaton,commissionedin2002bytheCentersforMedicareandMedicaidServices(CMS):Comparesnursinghomeswithhighandlowturnovertoidentifymanagementpracticesthatcontributetoturnoverandpracticesthatcontributetostability.Availableonthewebat:www.BandFConsultingInc.comFromInstitutionaltoIndividualizedCarePartFour:The“How”ofChange:Whatadifferencemanagementmakes!aCentersforMedicareandMedicaidServices(CMS)SatelliteBroadcastandWebcastairedonFriday,September14,2007.Identifiespracticesthatsupportgoodleadershipintimesofchangeavailablethroughwww.Pioneernetwork.net

NewOrleansNursingHomeStaffingProject:ResourcesandmaterialsusedforlearningsessionsfromNovember2,2006throughJune30,2009,canbefoundat:http://www.lhcr.org.Clickon“NursingHomes”andthen“Workforce.”

Formoreinformationcontact:

B&FConsulting,Inc.‐‐www.BandFconsultinginc.com

SusanWehryMD‐‐http://web.me.com/swehrymd


Recommended