+ All Categories
Home > Documents > The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The...

The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The...

Date post: 30-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
51
The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann Arthur Rylah Institute for Environmental Research Department of Environment and Primary Industries, Heidelberg Arthur Rylah Institute Flora, Fauna & Freshwater Research
Transcript
Page 1: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

The biters and the bitten:

snake management in Victoria

Nick Clemann Arthur Rylah Institute for Environmental Research

Department of Environment and Primary Industries, Heidelberg

Arthur RylahInstitute

Flora, Fauna &Freshwater Research

Page 2: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Who am I?

Threatened Fauna Program Leader Arthur Rylah Institute

Dep’t Environment & Primary Industries (Heidelberg)

Most of my work is in Victoria, but have worked in Uzbekistan, USA, Argentina, Kazakhstan

Page 3: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

What we’ll cover today

•  The human side of human-snake interactions

•  Common Victorian snakes – identification challenges

•  What happens to relocated snakes - radiotracking

•  Snakebite

Page 4: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Threatened wildlife 1

Augmentation

(Spotted Tree Frogs, Mt Pygmy Possums)

Reintroductions (BT Rock Wallaby)

Relocating nuisance /

dangerous wildlife

Magpies Possums

Kangaroos Bees

SNAKES

Threatened wildlife 2

Ad hoc relocations

(Growling Grass Frogs, Striped Legless Lizards

etc.)

Translocation – a generic term

Page 5: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Snakes have had a bad rap ever since that little incident with the apple in the Garden

of Eden…

Page 6: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Of all animals encountered in suburbia, snakes were the least desired around homes Davies, R.G., Webber, L.M. and Barnes, G.S. (2004). Urban wildlife

management – it’s as much about people! In: Urban Wildlife: More Than Meets the Eye. Eds Lunney, D. & Burgin, S. Royal Zoological Society of New South Wales.

Page 7: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Australia’s snake fauna is unique – and not in ways that make them

endearing

European invaders learnt early that the potential for many Aussie species to kill was unmatched

anywhere on Earth…

Page 8: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

“I may mention that the bite of most of them in that country is almost instantaneously fatal”

Alexander Marjoribanks 1840 WRT Botany Bay

“If a snake bites you in this country, instant death follows. One of the most deadly and common snake’s bite is so bad that the person bit only shivers and falls dead immediately”

William Coke 1827

Page 9: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

•  ~ 60 licensed catchers in Victoria (~35 in greater Melb / Geelong areas)

•  Current strategy - capture and relocation

Page 10: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

5 km or less

Victorian snake management

DEPI permit: release “on public land within 5km of capture”

Page 11: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Scale of relocations?

Fate of snakes?

Impact at both donor & release sites?

Page 12: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

2 key issues:

Human dimensions opinions, biases, motivations, knowledge and behaviours of people and organisations involved in human-snake conflict

Biological / ecological implications of translocating snakes effects of capture / relocation on individuals,

impacts on conspecifics and other species at both the “donor” and release sites

Page 13: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Human dimensions

We* conducted questionnaire surveys of:

1.  Licensed snake catchers (n = 45)

2.  Residents (n = 225?) - won’t cover this today

*Clemann, N., McGee, T. and Odgers, J. (2004). Snake management on private properties in

Melbourne, Australia. Human Dimensions of Wildlife 9(2): 133-142.

Clemann, N. (2006). Practices, experiences and opinions of snake catchers and their clients in southern Australia. The Victorian Naturalist 123(6): 383-389.

Page 14: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Snake catcher’s questions

•  Number of call-outs / year?

•  % calls resulting in capture?

•  Months with highest number of calls?

•  Species involved?

•  Single or multiple release sites?

•  Criteria used to choose release sites?

Page 15: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Results - Snake catchers (n=14)

•  Call-outs / year: ~ 50 - 60 (ra. 2 – 550 / year)

•  Proportion resulting in capture: ~50 - 70% (ra. 30 - 100% - one catcher translocates 300 / season!)

•  Est. 1000 – 2000 translocated around Melb / Geelong each year

Page 16: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Months of calls received to remove snakes

024681012

September

October

November

December

January

FebruaryMarch Ap

ril

No.

con

trol

lers

who

rece

ived

cal

ls

Page 17: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Snake species caught by licensed controllers

02468

101214

Tiger S

nake

Copperh

ead

Easter

n Brown S

nake

Red-bell

ied Blac

k Sna

ke

Other s

pecies

No.

con

trol

lers

who

catc

h ea

ch s

peci

es

Page 18: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Geographic trends

Tiger Snakes predominate N, W and SW of Melbourne

Copperheads to the E and SE

Page 19: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Snake catchers

How far are snakes moved? – Most < 5 km (as per permit)

– others 10 – 50 km

Sites used for release: – “crown land within 5 km”

– Parks / reserves (e.g., Braeside Pk)

– “no comment” - 300 snakes / year

Page 20: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

2 use same release site (incl. the one who releases 300 / season!)

11 use different sites – based on location of capture or species

involved

– some mentioned fear of “overpopulating” release sites

Page 21: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Snake catchers

How are release sites selected?

–  “5 km radius of capture”

– as far from residents as possible

– as close to capture site as possible

–  “suitable habitat” - rocks, water, food, few predators etc.

– where other snakes observed

Page 22: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

•  Large scale, ongoing issue

•  Current strategy not a permanent solution – most residents have to call in catchers

numerous times

•  People taking matters into their own hands? –  risk of being bitten

– breaking law

Page 23: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Tiger Snake Notechis scutatus

photographs by Peter Robertson

Page 24: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Lowland Copperhead Austrelaps superbus

Highland Copperhead Austrelaps ramsayi

Photographs by Peter Robertson

Page 25: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Eastern Brown Snake Pseudonaja textilis

www.snakecatchers.com.au

www.australianmuseum.net.au

Page 26: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Red-bellied Black Snake Pseudechis porphyriacus

Page 27: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

White-lipped Snake Drysdalia coronoides

Page 28: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Effects of relocation on Tiger Snakes - spatial ecology / activity patterns

What happens to relocated snakes? A radio-tracking study

Butler, H., Malone, B. and Clemann, N. (2005). The effects of translocation on the spatial ecology of tiger snakes (Notechis scutatus) in a suburban landscape. Wildlife Research 32, 165-171.

Butler, H., Malone, B. and Clemann, N. (2005). Activity patterns and habitat preferences of resident and translocated tiger snakes (Notechis scutatus) in a suburban landscape. Wildlife Research 32: 157-163.

Clemann, N. and Butler, H. (2005). Venom ‘spitting’ during handling in an Australian elapid snake. Herpetofauna 35(2): 83-84.

Clemann, N. and Butler, H. (2006). Carrion scavenging by the Tiger Snake Notechis scutatus. Herpetofauna 36(1): 2-4.

Clemann, N., Butler, H. and Malone, B. (submitted). Thermal biology of tiger snakes (Notechis scutatus) in a suburban parkland in south-eastern Australia: a radio-telemetric study of translocated and resident snakes. Journal of Thermal Biology

Page 29: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Most previous research on relocated snakes from Nth America (mainly Rattlesnakes – major ecological differences to Australian snakes)

Page 30: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Westerfolds Park 123 ha urban

parkland ~15 km E of Melbourne

Page 31: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

460-559 560-659 660-759 760-859 860-959 960-1059

Snout-vent length (mm)

Num

ber o

f sna

kes

Size of Tiger Snakes caught at Westerfolds Park

Transmitter size meant we needed snakes 760 mm snout-vent length ≥

Page 32: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

•  Resident snakes (2F / 4M) caught at Westerfolds

•  Relocated snakes (4F / 4M) caught by snake catchers within 5 km of study site

•  Catchers asked not to release at Westerfolds prior to / during study

Page 33: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Challenges of fitting transmitters to beasts that lack limbs and a defined neck…

Page 34: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

•  Following surgery / recovery, residents released at capture point

•  Relocated snakes released at random points in “suitable habitat”

•  Tracked 2 - 5 times / week

Page 35: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

3 estimates of home range

100% Minimum Convex Polygon (MCP)

95% Harmonic Mean (Home Range)

50% Harmonic Mean (Core Range)

Page 36: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

MCP (ha ± 1SE) 95% HM ‘Home Range’

50% HM ‘Core Range’

Residents 3.30 ± 2.07 4.30 ± 1.769 0.957 ± 0.299

Trans. 19.45 ± 9.764 25.36 ± 8.125 1.331 ± 0.385

Range:

t = -1.731 d.f. = 11

P = 0.111

t = -2.805 d.f. = 11

P = 0.017

t = -0.748 d.f. = 11

P = 0.470

Residents Trans.

13.2 62.8

11.5 59.6

1.8 2.7

Page 37: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

October November December January February March

Residents

Translocated

Pro

porti

on o

f day

s th

at s

nake

s ch

ange

d lo

catio

n

Frequency of movements ( 5 m) ≥

Page 38: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

0

50

100

150

200

250

October November December January February March

Residents

Translocated

Dis

tanc

e pe

r mov

emen

t (m

) Distance per movement

Page 39: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Relocated snakes - large initial movements, then continue to move more than twice as far as residents

(mean 140 vs. 64 m, 2-way ANOVA with month and

group as the factors, F1,273 = 9.605, P = 0.002)

Page 40: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

•  Half the relocated snakes left park, crossed Yarra River, entered adjacent private properties

•  Some property owners not happy about this...

•  When returned back to the park, several snakes returned to these properties

Page 41: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

• Relocation did affect snakes –  Animal welfare issues? –  Spread of disease / parasites? –  Genetic considerations? –  Impact on conspecifics, competitors, predators, prey,

humans…?

• Potentially moving human-snake conflict from one area to another –  Liability issues?

Page 42: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

• What happens over other seasons / study sites / to other species?

• Worth trialing alternative management, such as short-distance relocation or “Living with Snakes”?

Page 43: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Heath shows his bitten finger, and thanks the staff of the Austin Hospital for effective treatment...

Good students are hard to come by…try not to let them die!

Page 44: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Source: Shine 1991

Page 45: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Red-bellied Black Snake Pseudechis porphyriacus

Eastern Brown Snake Pseudonaja textilis

Source: Shine 1990

Page 46: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Tissue necrosis following a bite from a South American Terciopelo

(Bothrops asper )

Page 47: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Source: Shine 1991

With the recent discovery of a new Taipan, approximately 80% of the snakes thought to be the most deadly on Earth occur in Australia

Page 48: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Snakebite management

•  Be prepared – how many ‘snake’ bandages do you have? (Setopress bandages best)

•  Don’t panic…at least not for long…

•  Do not wash the bite sight – swabs can be used by doctors to identify the snake

•  Both parts of ‘Pressure-Immobilisation’ 1st Aid technique are vital

Page 49: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Snakebite management

•  No wandering around – bring transport to the victim

•  Once bandaged, immobilise limb any way you can

•  What if bite is on face / neck? What if I’m a hundred miles up a track with no vehicle and communications?

Page 50: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Immediately: If others are present, have someone phone for medical assistance. If unable to phone, send someone for help.

Reassure the patient and encourage them to remain calm and still.

Applying a pressure immobilisation bandage

As soon as possible, apply a broad pressure bandage from below the bite site, upward on the affected limb (starting at the fingers or toes, bandaging upward as far as possible). Leave the tips of the fingers or toes unbandaged to allow the victim’s circulation to be checked. Do not remove pants or trousers, simply bandage over the top of the clothing.

Bandage firmly as for a sprained ankle, but not so tight that circulation is prevented. Continue to bandage upward from the lower portion of the bitten limb.

Apply the bandage as far up the limb as possible to compress the lymphatic vessels.

Page 51: The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria › marketing › assets › pod... · The biters and the bitten: snake management in Victoria Nick Clemann ... deadly and

Bind the splint firmly, to as much of the limb as possible, to prevent muscle, limb and joint movement. This will help restrict venom movement. Seek urgent medical assistance now that first aid has been applied.

First Aid for Bites on the Hand or Forearm 1 As soon as possible, apply a broad pressure bandage from the fingers of the affected arm, bandaging upward as far as possible. Bandage the arm with the elbow in a bent position, to ensure the victim is comfortable with their arm in a sling. Leave the tips of the fingers unbandaged to allow the victim’s circulation to be checked. 2 Bind a splint along the forearm. 3 Use a sling to further prevent limb movement.

It is vital to now apply a splint. Bind a stick or suitable rigid item over the initial bandage to splint the limb. Secure the splint to the bandaged limb by using another bandage, (if another bandage is not available, use clothing strips or similar to bind). It is very important to keep the bitten limb still.

Source: Australian Venom Research Unit


Recommended