The Centre for Veterinary Epidemiology and Risk Analysis
The TB Diagnostics and Immunology Research Centre
The Badger Vaccine Project
Biennial Report, 2010 -11
The Centre for Veterinary Epidemiology and Risk Analysis
The TB Diagnostics and Immunology Research Centre
The Badger Vaccine Project
Biennial Report, 2010-11S.J. More and D.M. Collins (editors)
H.K. More (illustrations)
ISBN: 978-1-905254-64-4
Biennial Report, 2010/20112
PR
Ef
AC
E
Preface
The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) provides ongoing financial support to three research units within the UCD School of Veterinary Medicine at University College Dublin:
• TheCentreforVeterinaryEpidemiologyandRiskAnalysis(CVERA); • TheTBDiagnosticsandImmunologyResearchCentre;and • TheBadgerVaccineProject.
TheseunitseachworktosupportDAFMpolicy,inspectorateandlaboratorystaffintheareaofanimalhealth.TheTBDiagnosticsandImmunologyResearchCentreandtheBadgerVaccineProjectfocusonbovinetuberculosisresearch.CVERAisanationalresourcecentre,providingpolicyadviceandconductingepidemiologicalresearchonawiderangeofanimalhealthissues.Inaddition,CVERAprovidesgeneralsupporttogovernment,industryandtheveterinaryprofes-sion(pre-andpost-graduation).
Thisreportdocumentsworkconductedby,orinassociationwith,thesethreeUCD-basedresearchunitsduring2010and2011.
SimonJ.MoreEamonnGormleyLeigh Corner
UCD School of Veterinary MedicineUniversity College DublinBelfield,Dublin4,Ireland
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 3
PR
Ef
AC
E
Acknowledgements
The Centre for Veterinary Epidemiology and Risk Analysis
CVERAworkscloselywithcolleaguesfromawiderangeoforganisations,bothinIrelandandinternationally,andtheirinputisgratefullyacknowledged.Stafffromeachofthefollowingorganisationswereco-authors,withCVERAstaff,ofinternationalpeer-reviewedscientificpaperspublishedduring2010-11.
University College Dublin • UCDCollegeofAgriculture,FoodScienceandVeterinaryMedicine • UCDInstituteforFoodandHealth • UCDSchoolofAppliedSocialScience • UCDGearyInstitute • UCDSchoolofMathematicalSciences • UCDSchoolofPublicHealth,PhysiotherapyandPopulationScience
Rest of the Republic of Ireland • AnimalHealthIreland • CorkCountyCouncil • DepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM) • DAFMVeterinaryLaboratoryService • EmlaghLodgeVeterinaryCentre • EnferScientific • MSDAnimalHealth • Privatepractitionersandconsultants • TCDSchoolofNaturalSciences • Teagasc • TheIrishCattleBreedingFederation • UCCSchoolofBiological,EarthandEnvironmentalSciences
United Kingdom • InstituteofBiological,EnvironmentalandRuralSciences,AberystwythUniversity,Aberystwyth,Wales • InstituteofEvolutionaryBiology,UniversityofEdinburgh,Edinburgh,Scotland • InstituteofLifeSciences,SchoolofMedicine,SwanseaUniversity,Swansea,Wales • PeterGorerDepartmentofImmunobiology,KingsCollegeLondon,London,England • SchoolofBiologicalSciences,UniversityofEdinburgh,Edinburgh,Scotland • ScottishAgriculturalCollege,EdinburghandMidlothian,Scotland • TheRoslinInstitute,Midlothian,Scotland • VeterinaryEpidemiologyandEconomics,Hertfordshire,England • TheRoyalVeterinaryCollege,England • VeterinaryLaboratoriesAgency,Weybridge,England
Rest of World • DepartmentofLargeAnimalSciences,TheRoyalVeterinaryandAgriculturalUniversity,FrederiksbergC,Denmark • DepartmentofMedicine,MountSinaiSchoolofMedicine,NewYork,U.S.A. • DepartmentofPopulationMedicine,UniversityofGuelph,Ontario,Canada • FoodSafetyandSanitationDivision,MinistryforFood,Agriculture,ForestryandFisheries,RepublicofKorea • NationalVeterinaryResearchandQuarantineService,RepublicofKorea • WageningenUniversity,Wageningen,TheNetherlands
Biennial Report, 2010/20114
PR
Ef
AC
E
The TB Diagnostics and Immunology Research Centre
StafffromthecentreacknowledgethehelpandsupportofDistrictVeterinaryOffice(DVO)staffinprovidingsamplesfortheIFN-gtest.
The Badger Vaccine Project
StaffworkingontheBadgerVaccineProjectacknowledgethecontributionandsupportofKevinKenny,FrancesQuigleyandcolleaguesatthemycobacteriologylaboratory(DAFMVeterinaryLaboratoryService,Backweston,Celbridge,Co.Kildare,Ireland),andPaddySleemanofUniversityCollegeCorkforfieldcraft.GlynHewinson,MarkChambers,SandrineLesellier,andstaffattheAnimalHealthVeterinaryLaboratoriesAgency(AHVLA,UK)arealsothankedfordevelopingandcarryingoutmanyoftheimmunoassaysusedinthebadgervaccinestudies,andforcontrib-utingtechnicalexpertiseandadvicefortheresearchprogramme.
Illustrations are copyright of Hannah More. Unless otherwise stated, photographs are sourced from fotolia.com.
further information
Inthisreport,projectsareeither:
• Complete,whichincludesthoseprojectswhererelevantpeer-reviewedpapers,orequivalent,havebeenpublishedin2010/11,or
• Current,whichincludesthebalanceofactiveprojectscoveringthespectrumfromanadvancedresearchconceptthroughtofinalwrite-up.
ManuscriptpreparationisconductedinaccordancewithUniformRequirementsforManuscriptsSubmittedtoBiomedicalJournalsoftheInternationalCommitteeofMedicalJournalEditors(previouslytheVancouverGroup).Forfurther information, see www.icmje.org.Guidelinesforthetransparentreportingofspecificstudytypes(forexample,theCONSORTstatementfortransparentreportingoftrials,www.consort-statement.org)arefollowed.
An up-to-date list of all peer-review papers produced by, or in association with, the Centre for Veterinary EpidemiologyandRiskAnalysis,theTBDiagnosticsandImmunologyResearchCentreandtheBadgerVaccineProjectisavailableatwww.ucd.ie/cvera.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 5
PR
Ef
AC
E
Affiliated staff members
The Centre for Veterinary Epidemiology and Risk Analysis
Board of management • SimonJ.More(UCD)School, College and University representatives • UniversityVPforResearch • Principal,UCDCollegeofAgriculture,FoodScienceandVeterinaryMedicine • HeadofUCDSchoolofVeterinaryMedicine • ProfessorMichaelDoherty,UCDSchoolofVeterinaryMedicineFrom the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine • StateVeterinaryService: ❍ MartinBlake ❍ Michael Sheridan ❍ MargaretGood • VeterinaryLaboratoryService ❍ Dónal Sammin • DAFMpolicy ❍ PhilipCarroll
Staff
Full-time Half-time AssociatesSimonJ.More(UCD)(Director) MaryCanty(DAFM) MartinDownes(untilDecember2010)InmaAznar(DAFM) ElizabethLane(DAFM) JamesO’Keeffe(DAFM)TracyA.Clegg(UCD) AnthonyDuignan(DAFM)DanielM.Collins(UCD) PaulWhite(DAFM)GuyMcGrath(UCD) IsabellaHiggins(UCD)
ConsultantsDanCollins,UCDSchoolofVeterinaryMedicine,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland(ProfessorEmeritus)GabrielleKellyandDavidWilliams,UCDSchoolofMathematicalSciences,UniversityCollegeDublin,IrelandPaddySleeman,SchoolofBiological,Earth&EnvironmentalSciences,UniversityCollegeCorkWayneMartin,UniversityofGuelph,CanadaFranciscoOlea-Popelka,DepartmentofClinicalSciences,ColoradoStateUniversity,UnitedStatesofAmericaMartdeJongandKlaasFrankena,UniversityofWageningen,TheNetherlands
The TB Diagnostics and Immunology Research CentreEamonnGormley TaraFitzsimonsMairéadDoyle KevinaMcGill
The Badger Vaccine ProjectEamonnGormley ElviraRamovicLeigh Corner Marian TeelingMarionBarrett AnthonyDuignan(DAFM)DeniseMurphy EamonCostello(DAFMVeterinaryLaboratoryService)
Biennial Report, 2010/20116
PR
Ef
AC
E
Overview
The Centre for Veterinary Epidemiology and Risk Analysis
TheUCDCentreforVeterinaryEpidemiologyandRiskAnalysis(UCDCVERA)isthenationalresourcecentreforveterinaryepidemiologyinIreland,locatedwithintheUCDSchoolofVeterinaryMedicineatUniversityCollegeDublin.TheCentrewasinitiallyestablishedastheTuberculosisInvestigationUnit,butinrecentyearshasbroadeneditsremit to cover a wide range of international, national and local animal health matters, including:
• Epidemiologicalsupportforthecontrolanderadicationofregulatoryanimaldiseases,whichincludesnationalprogrammesforbovinetuberculosis,bovinebrucellosisandbovinespongiformencephalopathy;
• WorkinsupportofAnimalHealthIreland(www.animalhealthireland.ie), which is providing a proactive, coordinatedandindustry-ledapproachinIrelandtonon-regulatoryanimalhealthconcerns(suchasmastitis,fertilityandinfectiousbovinerhinotracheitis);and
• Epidemiologicalsupportforabroadrangeofotheranimalhealthandwelfareissuesrelatingtoemergencyanimaldiseasepreparednessandresponse(forexample,avianinfluenza,bluetongueandequineinfectiousanaemia),on-farminvestigations,welfareoffarmedlivestockandhorses,healthofcompanionanimalsandfarmedfish,andinterna-tionalcollaboration.
UCDCVERAstaffworkcloselywithnationalpolicy-makers,bothingovernmentandindustry.Staffalsocontributetotraininginveterinarymedicine,bothtoundergraduatesandpostgraduate.Abroadrangeofexpertiseisrepresentedwithin the Centre, including agriculture and animal sciences, database development and management, geographic informationsystems,statistics,veterinarymedicineandepidemiology.TheCentreisstaffedbyemployeesofUniversityCollegeDublinandoftheDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM).
The Badger Vaccine Project
Thebadgervaccineprojectisaprogrammeofresearchwiththeobjectivetodevelopavaccinetocontroltuberculosisinbadgersandtobreakthelinkofinfectiontocattle.Instudieswithcaptivebadgers,wehavedemonstratedthatvaccinationofbadgerswithBCGbyanumberofroutes,includingoraldelivery,generateshighlevelsofprotectiveimmunity against challenge with M. bovis.Wearecontinuingtocarryoutstudieswithcaptivepopulationofbadgerstorefinethevaccineandaddressissuesrelatingtotheeventuallicensingofthevaccineasaveterinarymedicine.WearealsoevaluatingdiagnostictestswithcolleaguesatAHVLA(WeybridgeUK).Afieldtrialcommencedin2009totesttheefficacyoftheoralBCGvaccineinfree-livingbadgersoverawidegeographicareainCo.Kilkenny.Thevaccinationphaseofthefieldtrialwillbecompletedin2012,followedbydetailanalysisoftheresults.Itishopedthatthe data and experience generated during the field trial will lead to implementation of a vaccination strategy within thenationalcontrolprogramme.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 7
PR
Ef
AC
E
TB Diagnostics and Immunology Research Centre
Thegamma-interferon(IFN-g) assay is used as a tool to assist in the eradication of bovine tuberculosis from the national cattleherd.AllofthetestingiscarriedoutinthelaboratorybasedatUCD.Intheperiod2010-2011,13,662bloodsamplesweresubmittedtothelaboratoryfortesting.Themajorityofsamplesoriginatedfrombovinereactorre-testherds,wherethetestwasusedtoidentifyinfectedanimalsthatweremissedbytheskintest.Otherstrategicusesofthetestweretargetedatinconclusivereactorre-testsandconfirmationoftheexposurestatusofskintestpositiveanimals.Thenumberofsamplessubmittedwasfewerthanin2008-2009(28,000samples);thiswaspartlyduetothereducednumberofinfectedanimalsintherecentyears.Inaddition,thefocusoftestingwastargetedatthehighestat-riskexposedcohortsofanimals,basedonepidemiologicalinvestigation.ThisresultedinidentificationofahigherproportionofIFN-gpositiveanimalsamongthesamplessubmittedfortesting.In2008-2009,26%ofsamplessubmittedwereposi-tivetotheIFN-gtest.In2010-2011thisincreasedto33%,demonstratingamoreefficientandcost-effectiveusageofthetest.ThelaboratorycontinuestoconductresearchwithaviewtoimprovingtheperformanceoftheassayunderIrishconditions.Recentstudieshaveinvestigatedtheperformance,inIrishcattle,ofanimprovedassayplatformdevelopedbyPrionicsLtd.Resultsofthisanalysisareexpectedin2012.
BO
VIN
E T
UB
ER
CU
lO
SIS
8 Biennial Report, 2010/2011
9Biennial Report, 2010/2011
BO
VIN
E T
UB
ER
CU
lO
SIS
Bovine tuberculosis
Tuberculosis in cattle
- Improving surveillance .............................................................................................. 10
- Improving management of high risk herds ................................................................ 18
- Supporting studies .................................................................................................... 27
The role of wildlife in bovine TB
- Improved understanding of ecology and TB epidemiology ......................................... 35
- Infection control strategies ........................................................................................ 41
Contributing to national TB policy
- The national programme .......................................................................................... 50
- Quality control .......................................................................................................... 56
National maps
- Density of TB incidence ............................................................................................. 58
- APT per DED ............................................................................................................. 60
Biennial Report, 2010/201110
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g s
urv
eilla
nce
Improving surveillance
Field-based surveillance
Using latent class analysis to estimate the test characteristics of the interferon-g test, the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test and a multiplex immunoassay under Irish conditions
Clegg, T.A.1, Duignan, A.2, Whelan, C.3, Gormley, E.4, Good, M.2, Clarke, J.3, Toft, N.5, More, S.J.1, 4
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM, 3 Enfer Scientific, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 5 Department of Large Animal Sciences, The Royal Veterinary and
Agricultural University, Frederiksberg C, Denmark
Veterinary Microbiology 151, 68-76 (2011)
Considerable effort has been devoted to improving the existing diagnostic tests for bovine tuberculosis (single intradermal comparativetuberculintest[SICTT]andg-interferon assay [g-IFN])andtodevelopnewtests.Previously,thediagnosticcharacteristics(sensitivity,specificity)havebeenestimatedinpopulationswithdefinedinfectionstatus.However,theseapproachescanbeproblematicastheremaybefewherdsinIrelandwherefreedomfrominfectionisguaranteed.Weusedlatentclassmodelstoestimatethediagnosticcharacteristicsofexisting(SICTTandg-IFN)andnew(multipleximmu-noassay[Enferplex-TB])diagnostictestsunderIrishfieldconditionswheretruediseasestatuswasunknown.ThestudypopulationconsistedofherdsrecruitedinareaswithnoknownTBproblems(2,197animals)andherdsexperiencingaconfirmedTBbreakdown(2,740animals).ABayesianmodelwasdeveloped,allowingfordependencebetweenSICTTand g-IFN,whileassumingindependencefromtheEnferplex-TBtest.Differenttestinterpretationswereusedfortheanalysis:SICTT(standardandsevereinterpretation),g-IFN(asingleinterpretation),andarangeofinterpretationsfortheEnferplex-TB(level-1[highsensitivityinterpretation]tolevel-5[highspecificityinterpretation]).Thesensitivityandspecificity(95%posteriorcredibilityintervals;95%PCI)ofSICTT[standard]relativetoEnferplex-TB[level-1]andg-IFNwere52.9-60.8%and99.2-99.8%,respectively.Equivalentestimatesforg-IFNrelativetoEnferplex-TB[level-1]andSICTTwere63.1-70.1%and86.8-89.4%,respectively.SensitivityofEnferplex-TB[level-1](95%PCI:64.8-71.9%)wassuperiortotheSICTT[standard],andspecificityoftheEnferplex-TB[level-5]wassuperiortog-IFN(95%PCI:99.6-100.0%).TheseresultsproviderobustmeasuresofsensitivityandspecificityunderfieldconditionsinIrelandandsuggestthattheEnferplex-TBtesthasthepotentialtoimproveoncurrentdiagnosticsforTBinfectionincattle.Theextentofthatpotentialwillbeassessedinfurtherstudies.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology, 151, Clegg, T.A., Duignan, A., Whelan, C., Gormley, E., Good, M., Clarke, J., Toft, N., More, S.J., Using latent class analysis to estimate the test characteristics of the interferon-g test, the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test and a multiplex immunoassay under Irish conditions, 68-76, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
A follow up study of the g-interferon test results from the latent class analysis
Clegg, T.A.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Gormley, E.2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Theobjectiveofthisstudyistoidentifyriskfactorsassociatedwithanimalsfalselytestingpositivetothegamma-inter-ferontest.ThestudywillfollowanimalsfromaverylowbTBprevalenceareathatweretestedusinggamma-interferonin2008.Theseanimalswerefolloweduntiltheendof2010toidentifyanythatwere‘true’bTBpositivesinthefollow-upperiod.AnimalsthatwerefoundtobebTBnegativewillbeexaminedtoidentifyriskfactors,suchasageorlocation,thatmaybeassociatedwithtesting(falsely)positivetothegamma-interferontestin2008.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 11
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Imp
rovin
g su
rveillance
Primary isolation of Mycobacterium bovis from bovine tissues: Conditions for maximising the number of positive cultures
Corner, L.A.L.1, Gormley, E.1, Pfeiffer, D.U.2
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 Royal Veterinary College, Hertfordshire, United Kingdom
Veterinary Microbiology (in press)
InstudiesofMycobacterium bovisinfectioninanimalsadefinitivediagnosisrequirestheisolationoftheorganism.However,theoptimumconditionsfortheprimaryisolationofM. bovishavenotbeendetermined.Theaimofthisstudy was to determine for primary isolation of M. bovis,(a)theincubationtimerequiredtoachievemaximumsensi-tivity(i.e.,thenumberofpositivesamplesidentified),(b)theeffectofdecontaminantsonbacterialgrowthrates,and(c)theinfluenceofmediaandthenumberofslopesofmediaonthenumberofpositivesamplesdetected.Twoagar-basedmedia,modifiedMiddlebrook7H11(7H11)andtuberculosisbloodagar(B83),andanegg-basedmedium,Stonebrink’s(SB)werecompared.Threedecontaminants,2%(w/v)sodiumhydroxide(NaOH),0.75%(w/v)and0.075%(w/v)cetylpyridiniumchloride(CPC,alsocalledhexadecylpyridiniumchloride,HPC)and0.5%(w/v)benza-lkoniumchloride(BC)wereevaluatedagainsttreatmentwithsteriledistilledwater.Theinoculatedmediaslopeswereincubatedforupto15weeks.Coloniesfirstappearedafter2weeksonallmediatypesand75%ofpositiveslopeswereidentifiedby8weeks.Anincubationtimeof15weekswasrequiredtoidentifyallpositivesamples.Theslowestgrowthwasassociatedwithinoculathatcontainedthefewestviablebacilli.Thetimetotheappearanceofcolonieswasinflu-encedbymediumtype:themediantimetodetectionofcolonieswas28dayson7H11andB83,and36daysonSB.However,SBreturnedthegreatestnumberofpositivesamples.Decontaminationproceduresincreasedtheminimumincubationtimerequiredtodetectpositivecultures,probablyduetothetoxiceffectofthedecontaminants.Increasingthe number of inoculated slopes resulted in an increased number of positive samples and a decreased time to the detec-tionofcolonies.Overall,thedetectionofM. bovis was significantly influenced by the choice of media, the decontami-nantandthedurationofincubationofcultures.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology, Corner, L.A.L., Gormley, E., Pfeiffer, D.U., Primary isolation of Mycobacterium bovis for bovine tissues: Conditions for maximising the number of positive cultures, in press, Copyright 2012, with permission from Elsevier.
The comparative performance of the single intradermal test and the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test in Irish cattle, using tuberculin PPD combinations of differing potencies
Good, M.1, Clegg, T.A.2, Costello, E.3, More, S.J.2, 4
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The Veterinary Journal 190, e60-e65 (2011)
Innationalbovinetuberculosis(bTB)controlprogrammes,testingisgenerallyconductedusingasinglesourceofbovinepurifiedproteinderivative(PPD)tuberculin.Alternativetuberculinsourcesshouldbeidentifiedaspartofabroadriskmanagementstrategyasproblemsofsupplyorqualitycannotbediscounted.ThisstudywasconductedtocomparetheimpactofdifferentpotenciesofasinglebovinePPDtuberculinonthefieldperformanceofthesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest(SICTT)andsingleintradermaltest(SIT).ThreetrialpotenciesofbovinePPDtuberculin,asassayedinnaturallyinfectedbovines,namely,low(1192IU/dose),normal(6,184IU/dose)andhigh(12,554IU/dose)wereused.ThreeSICTTs(using)wereconductedon2,102animals.Testresultswerecomparedbasedonreactor-statusandchangesinskin-thicknessatthebovinetuberculininjectionsite.Therewasasignificantdifferenceinthe
Biennial Report, 2010/201112
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g s
urv
eilla
nce
numberofreactorsdetectedusingthehighandlowpotencytuberculins.IntheSICTT,highandlowpotencytuber-culindetected40%moreand50%fewerreactors,respectively,thannormalpotencytuberculin.Furthermore,useofthelowpotencytuberculinintheSICTTfailedtodetect20%of35animalswithvisiblelesions,andintheSIT11%ofthevisiblelesionanimalswouldhavebeenclassifiedasnegative.TuberculinpotencyiscriticaltotheperformanceofboththeSICTTandSIT.Tuberculinofdifferentpotencieswillaffectreactordisclosurerates,confoundingbetween-yearorbetween-countrycomparisons.IndependentchecksoftuberculinpotencyareanimportantaspectofqualitycontrolinnationalbTBcontrolprogrammes.
Reprinted from The Veterinary Journal, 190, Good, M., Clegg, T.A., Costello, E., More, S.J., The comparative performance of the single intradermal test and the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test in Irish cattle, using tuberculin PPD combi-nations of differing potencies, e60-e65, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
The comparative performance of the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test in Irish cattle, using tuberculin PPD combinations from different manufacturers
Good, M.1, Clegg, T.A.2, Murphy, F.1, More, S.J.2, 3
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Veterinary Microbiology 151, 77-84 (2011)
Irelandcurrentlyobtainsitsavianandbovinetuberculinpurifiedproteinderivatives(PPDs)fromasinglesource.Becauseproblemsofsupplyorqualitycannotbediscounted,itisprudentthatIrelandidentifyalternativesupplier(s)aspartofabroadriskmanagementstrategy.Therefore,theaimofthisstudywastocomparetheperformanceofanumberofdifferenttuberculincombinations(thatis,pairingsofbovineandavianPPD;withdifferentmanufacturers)inthesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest(SICTT),ascurrentlyperformedinIreland.Thestudywasrandomised,controlledanddouble-blinded.Atotalof2,172cattlewereusedinthestudy.EachanimalwastestedusingtwoSICTTs,the first based on the tuberculin combination in current use, and the second using one of six trial tuberculin combi-nations.Analyseswereconductedtocomparebothreactor-statusandskinincrease.Foreachcontrol/trialtuberculincombination,therewasgoodagreementbetweenthecontrolandtrialreactor-status.Differencesinskinincreasesweremainlyconfinedtoanimalscategorisedaseithernegativeorsevereinconclusive.However,themeasureddifferenceswereminor,andunlikelytohaveasignificantimpactontheactualtestoutcome,eitherforindividualanimalsorforherds.Inconclusion,whilefurtherstudiesdeterminingsensitivityandspecificityinIrelandwouldhavetobedoneintheeventofachangeintuberculinPPDthereshouldbeminimaldisruptionofthenationalprogrammeifalternativetuberculinPPDsmeetingWHO,OIEandEUregulationswereused.Inthisstudy,theprecisionoftheguineapigbio-assaytoassesstuberculinpotencywaslowandthereforeIrelandshouldmaintainitspracticeofperiodicallyassessingpotencyinnaturallyinfectedcattle,eventhoughthisisnotcurrentlyrequiredunderWHO,OIEorEURegulations.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology, 151, Good, M., Clegg, T.A., Murphy, F., More, S.J., The comparative performance of the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test in Irish cattle, using tuberculin PPD combinations from different manufac-turers, 77-84, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 13
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Imp
rovin
g su
rveillance
Evaluation of the methodological quality of studies of the performance of diagnostic tests for bovine tuberculosis in cattle using QUADAS adapted for veterinary use
Downs, S.H.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Broughan, J.M.1, Goodchild, A.V.1, Abernethy, D.A.4, Cameron, A.5, Cook, A.J.1,
de la Rua-Domenech, R.6, Greiner, M.7, Gunn, J.8, Nuñez-Garcia, J.1, Rhodes, S.1, Rolfe, S.9, Sharp, M.10,
Upton, P.1, Vordermeier, H.M.8, Watson, E.8, Welsh, M.11, Whelan, A.O.8, Woolliams, J.A.12, Parry, J.E.1,
Clifton-Hadley, R.S.1
1 Centre for Epidemiology and Risk Analysis, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 2 UCD CVERA,
3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 Veterinary Service, Department of Agriculture and Rural Development, Belfast, Northern Ireland, 5 AusVet Animal
Health Services Pty Ltd, Brisbane, Australia, 6 Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London, United Kingdom, 7 Federal Institute for Risk
assessment (BfR), Berlin, Germany, 8 Bacteriology, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 9 Office of the
Chief Veterinary Officer, Welsh Assembly Government, Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom, 10 Pathology and Host Susceptibility, Animal Health and Veterinary
Laboratories Agency, Lasswade, Midlothian, United Kingdom, 11 Veterinary Sciences Division, Agri-Food & Biosciences Institute (AFBI), Belfast, Northern
Ireland, 12 The Roslin Institute, Roslin Biocentre, Roslin, Midlothian, United Kingdom
AsystematicreviewwasconductedtoidentifystudiesthatmeasuredtheperformanceofdiagnostictestsforbTBincattle.Therehasbeenlittleassessmentofthemethodologicalqualityofthesestudiesdespitetheimportanceofthesetestsinnationalsurveillanceandcontrolschemes.ReferencepapersthatappearedtohaveeligibledatawerereviewedusingtheQUADAS(QualityAssessmentofDiagnosticAccuracyStudies)instrumentadaptedforveterinaryuse.Duringthestudy190referencespublishedbetween1934and2009wereassessedusingVETQUADASbyatleastoneof18reviewers.Ofthese,107werescoredby2reviewersand83alsohadeligibleestimatesofsensitivityandorspecificityforthesystematicreview.Asimilarpatterninthedegreetowhichmethodologicalcriteriaweremetwasobservedacrossstudiesofdifferenttypesofdiagnostictests.Inreferencesscoredbytworeviewersitemsmeasuringinternalvaliditywereassessedashavingbeenmetin31-83%ofstudies.Inonly31and45%ofstudiesrespectivelydidreviewersassessthattheindextestwasinterpretedwithoutknowledgeofthereferencestandardandthereferencestandardinterpretedwithoutknowledgeoftheindextest.ThereviewshowedthatthereisconsiderablescopeforimprovementinthemethodologicalqualityofstudiesmeasuringperformanceofdiagnostictestsforbTB.
Biennial Report, 2010/201114
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g s
urv
eilla
nce
Systematic review to identify primary research estimating the performance of diagnostic tests for bovine tuberculosis in cattle
Downs, S.H.1, Parry, J.E.1, Nuñez-Garcia, J.1, Broughan, J.M.1, Abernethy, D.A.2, Cameron, A.R.3, Cook, A.J.1,
de la Rua-Domenech, R.4, Goodchild, A.V.1, Greiner, M.5, Gunn, J.6, More, S.J.7, 8, Pritchard, E.6, Rhodes,
S.6, Rolfe, S.9, Sharp, M.10, Vordermeier, H.M.6, Watson, E.1, Welsh, M.11, Whelan, A.O.6, Woolliams, J.A.12,
Upton, P.U.1, Clifton-Hadley, R.S.1
1 Centre for Epidemiology and Risk Analysis, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 2 Veterinary Service,
Department of Agriculture and Rural Development, Belfast, Northern Ireland, 3 AusVet Animal Health Services Pty Ltd, Brisbane, Australia, 4 Department
for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London, United Kingdom, 5 Federal Institute for Risk assessment (BfR), Berlin, Germany, 6 Bacteriology, Animal
Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 7 UCD CVERA, 8 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 9 Office of the Chief
Veterinary Officer, Welsh Assembly Government, Cardiff, Wales, 10 Pathology and Host Susceptibility, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency,
Lasswade, Midlothian, United Kingdom, 11 Veterinary Sciences Division, Agri-Food & Biosciences Institute (AFBI), Belfast, Northern Ireland, 12 The Roslin
Institute, Roslin Biocentre, Roslin, Midlothian, United Kingdom
The aim of this study was to conduct a systematic review to identify studies that have estimates of the sensitivity and specificityofdiagnostictestsforbTBincattlethatcouldbeusedinastatisticalmeta-analysisoftestperformance.Detailedreviewwasconductedbyaworkinggroupof18reviewers.Comprehensivesearchcriteriaweredevelopedandtheprocessofreviewstandardised.Nolimitswereappliedbyyear,language,regionortypeofdiagnostictestintheinitialsearch.9,782referenceswereidentifiedinitiallyandabstracts,whereavailable,wereeachreviewedbytworeviewers.EntirereferencesofthosethatpassedthroughtheinitialreviewwererandomlyallocatedtoreviewersfordetailedreviewifEnglishlanguage(n=215)andtonativespeakerreviewersifnon-Englishlanguage(n=46).Anagreedrangeofdatawasextracted.Therewere119referenceswitheligibleperformanceestimates(published1934-2009)foroneormoreof14differentdiagnostictests.Studiesvariedincattlepopulationselection,referencestandardandthethresholdsandscalesoverwhichperformancewasmeasured.MethodsforidentifyingstudiesthatcontainperformancedatafordiagnostictestsforbTBareunspecific.Informationprovidedinabstractsofstudiesoftestperformanceneedstobestandardised.LargescalestudiesoftheperformanceofdiagnostictestsforbTBincattlearestillneeded.
Results from a meta-analysis of sensitivity and specificity of diagnostic tests for bovine tuberculosis in cattle
Nuñez-Garcia, J.1, Downs, S.H.1, Parry, J.E.1, Abernethy, D.A.2, Broughan, J.M.1, Cameron, A.R.3, Cook, A.J.1,
de la Rua-Domenech, R.4, Goodchild, A.V.1, Greiner, M.5, Gunn, J.6, More, S.J.7, 8, Pritchard, E.6, Rhodes, S.6,
Rolfe, S.9, Sharp, M.10, Upton, P.U.1, Vordermeier, H.M.6, Watson, E.6, Welsh, M.11, Whelan, A.O.6,
Woolliams, J.A.12, Clifton-Hadley, R.S.1
1 Centre for Epidemiology and Risk Analysis, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 2 Veterinary Service,
Department of Agriculture and Rural Development, Belfast, Northern Ireland, 3 AusVet Animal Health Services Pty Ltd,, Brisbane, Australia, 4 Department
for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London, United Kingdom, 5 Federal Institute for Risk assessment (BfR), Berlin, Germany, 6 Bacteriology, Animal
Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 7 UCD CVERA, 8 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 9 Office of the
Chief Veterinary Officer, Welsh Assembly Government, Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom, 10 Pathology and Host Susceptibility, Animal Health and Veterinary
Laboratories Agency, Lasswade, Midlothian, United Kingdom, 11 Veterinary Sciences Division, Agri-Food & Biosciences Institute (AFBI), Belfast, Northern
Ireland, 12 The Roslin Institute, Roslin Biocentre, Roslin, Midlothian, United Kingdom
A meta-analysis study was conducted using data extracted during a systematic review of references that reported the sensitivity(Se)and/orspecificity(Sp)ofdiagnostictestsforbovinetuberculosis(bTB)incattle.Performanceswereestimated,for14differentdiagnostictestsandmodificationsofthetests,usingbinarylogisticregressionmodelsadjustingforrelevantcovariates.ParametersinthemodelswereestimatedusingMonteCarloMarkovChainwiththecategorybestrepresentingtestconditionsinGreatBritainandinIrelandasbaseline.Estimatesforthemostcommon
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 15
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Imp
rovin
g su
rveillance
testsusedinGBfortheinterferongammabloodtestusingbovineandbovine-avianPPDwere0.87(95%BayesianCredibleInterval0.72,0.95)and0.67(95%BCI0.49,0.82),respectively,forSeand0.97(95%BCI0.94,0.98)and0.98(95%BCI0.96,0.99)forSpandforthesingleintradermalcomparativecervicaltuberculinskintestusingstandardinterpretationwere0.50forSe(95%BCI0.26,0.78)and1(95%BCI0.99,1.00)forSp.
Bovine tuberculosis: Effect of the tuberculin skin test on in vitro interferon gamma responses
Schiller, I.1, Vordermeier, H.M.2, Waters, W.R.3, Whelan, A.O.2, Coad, M.2, Gormley, E.4, Buddle, B.M.5,
Palmer, M.3, Thacker, T.3, McNair, J.6, Welsh, M.6, Hewinson, R.G.2, Oesch, B.7
1 Federal Veterinary Office, Bern, Switzerland, 2 Veterinary Laboratory Agency, Addlestone, United Kingdom, 3 National Animal Disease Center, Agricultural
Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Ames, Iowa, USA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 5 AgResearch, Palmerston North, New Zealand,
6 AFBI-Veterinary Sciences Division, Stormont, Northern Ireland, 7 Malcisbo AG, Zurich, Switzerland
Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology 136, 1–11 (2010)
Bovinetuberculosis(bTB)isadiseaseofzoonoticandeconomicimportance.Inmanycountries,controlisbasedontestandslaughterpoliciesand/orabattoirsurveillance.Fortesting,cellmediatedimmune-(CMI-)basedassays(i.e.,tuberculinskintest(TST)supplementedbytheinterferongamma(IFN-gamma)assay)aretheprimarysurveillanceanddiseasecontroltestsforbTB.Thecombineduseofthein vivo and in vitroCMIassaystoincreaseoverallsensitivityhasraisedthequestionofwhethertheIFN-gammaresponseisinfluencedbyinjectionofpurifiedproteinderivatives(PPDs)forTST.PublisheddataontheinfluenceoftheTST,appliedasthecaudalfoldtest(CFT)orthecomparativecervicaltest(CCT),ontheIFN-gammaassayarecontradictory.Reviewingpublisheddataandincludingadditionaldata,thefollowingconclusionscanbedrawn:(1)innaturallyinfectedcattle,PPDadministrationforthesingleorrepeatedshort-intervalCCTneitherboostsnordepressesPPD-specificIFN-gammaproduction.Disparateresultshavebeenconcludedfromsomestudiesusingexperimentalinfections,emphasizingtheimportanceofconfirminginitialexperimental-basedfindings with studies using cattle naturally infected with Mycobacterium bovis.(2)IncattleexperimentallyinfectedwithM. bovis,PPDadministrationforCFTboostsPPD-specificIFN-gammaproductionforupto7dayswithoutanyeffectontestinterpretation.Importantly,innaturallyinfectedcattle,CFT-relatedboostingselectivelyincreasesthein vitro M. bovisPPD(PPD-B)response3daysafterCFT,resultinginanincreasedPPD-BresponserelativetotheresponsetoMycobacterium aviumPPD(PPD-A).Innon-infectedcattle,itcannotbeexcludedthattheCFTinducesamildboostofthePPD-specificresponse,particularlyinanimalssensitizedtoenvironmental,non-tuberculousmycobacteria,thusdecreasingthespecificityoftheIFN-gammaassay.(3)Ingeneral,thereisalackofdataclearlycharacterizingtheeffectofTSTsontheIFN-gammaassay.FurtherstudiesarerequiredtoclearlydescribetheeffectsofbothCFTandCCTinnon-infectedanimalsandinnaturallyinfectedcattle,especiallyinlowreactinginfectedcattle.
Reprinted from Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology, 136, Schiller, I., Vordermeier, H.M., Waters, W.R., Whelan, A.O., Coad, M., Gormley, E., Buddle, B.M., Palmer, M., Thacker, T., McNair, J., Welsh, M., Hewinson, R.G., Oesch, B., Bovine tuberculosis: Effect of the tuberculin skin test on in vitro interferon gamma responses, 1-11, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/201116
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g s
urv
eilla
nce
Development and evaluation of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for use in the detection of bovine tuberculosis in cattle
Waters, W.R.1, Buddle, B.M.2, Vordermeier, H.M.3, Gormley, E.4, Palmer, M.V.1, Thacker, T.C.1,
Bannantine, J.P.1, Stabel, J.R.1, Linscott, R.5, Martel, E.5, Milian, F.6, Foshaug, W.7, Lawrence, J.C.5
1 National Animal Disease Center, Agricultural Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Iowa, USA, 2 AgResearch, Hopkirk Research Institute,
Palmerston North, New Zealand, 3 Animal Health & Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Addlestone, Surrey, United Kingdom, 4 UCD School of Veterinary
Medicine, 5 IDEXX Laboratories, Westbrook, Maine, USA, 6 Instituto Nacional de Investigaciones Forestales, Queretaro, Mexico, 7 Antel Biosystems, Lansing,
Michigan, USA
Clinical and Vaccine Immunology 18, 1882-1888 (2011)
AsaconsequenceofcontinuedspilloverofMycobacterium bovis into cattle from wildlife reservoirs and increased globali-zationofcattletradewithassociatedtransmissionrisks,newapproachessuchasvaccinationandnoveltestingalgorithmsareseriouslybeingconsideredbyregulatoryagenciesforthecontrolofbovinetuberculosis.Serologictestsofferoppor-tunities for identification of M. bovisinfectedanimalsnotaffordedbycurrentdiagnostictechniques.ThepresentstudydescribesassaydevelopmentandfieldassessmentofanewcommercialELISAthatdetectsantibodytoM. bovis antigens MPB83andMPB70ininfectedcattle.Pertinentfindingsinclude:specificantibodyresponsesweredetected~90-100days after experimental M. bovischallenge,minimalcross-reactiveresponseswereelicitedbyinfection/sensitizationwithnon-tuberculous Mycobacteriaspp.,andtheapparentsensitivity/specificityoftheELISAwithnaturallyinfectedcattlewas63%/98%respectively,withsensitivityimprovingasdiseaseseverityincreased.TheELISAalsodetectedinfectedanimalsmissedbytheroutinetuberculinskintestandantibodywasdetectableinbulktankmilksamplesfromM. bovis-infecteddairyherds.AhighthroughputELISAcouldbeadaptedasamovement,border,orslaughtersurveillancetest,aswellasasupplementaltesttotuberculinskintesting.
Reprinted from Clinical and Vaccine Immunology, 18, Waters, W.R., Buddle, B.M., Vordermeier, H.M., Gormley, E., Palmer, M.V., Thacker,
T.C., Bannantine, J.P., Stabel, J.R., Linscott, R., Martel, E., Milian, F., Foshaug, W., Lawrence, J.C., Development and evaluation of an
enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for use in the detection of bovine tuberculosis in cattle, 1882-1888, Copyright 2011, American Society
for Microbiology.
Specificity of the tuberculin test in cattle herds adjacent to peat-land areas in Ireland
White, P.W.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA , 2 DAFM
InIreland,wherepeat-landsoccuronthemarginsofgrassland,thereissomeconcernthatcattlemaybecomesensitizedtoenvironmentalmycobacteria,andresultinfalsepositivereactiontothetuberculinskintest,orasocallednon-specificreactor(NSI).Thisisevidencedbythefindingoflowlesionratesinreactorsfromcertainareas.Todate,littleworkhasbeendonetoassessthisissueoftestspecificity.Thisstudydescribestherelationshipbetweenvisiblelesionratesatslaughterhouseamongstandardreactoranimalsandlikelihoodofexposuretoenvironmentalmycobacteriaatpastureadjacenttopeatland,withinCo.Tipperary,overtheperiod2007-2009.Theaimofthisstudyistomodelthelikeli-hoodofdetectingapostmortemlesionatslaughterinstandardreactorsderivedfromherdsgrazingwithin500mofpeatland(exposed)comparedtoherdsgrazedmorethan2kmawayfrompeat-land(unexposed).LandusewillbedeterminedbyreferencetotheCorine™dataset,usingArcGISsoftware.Wewillanalyzethedataattheanimallevel.Datawillbeanalysed using a multivariable logistic regression model with the presence of a visible lesion at slaughter as the positive outcome.Animalsshowingnovisiblelesion(NVL)willhavenegativeoutcomes.Theexposureofinterestwillbeprox-imitytopeat-land.Otherexplanatoryvariableswillincludepreviousanimalandherd-levelbTBtestreadings,andothernationallyavailabledata.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 17
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Imp
rovin
g su
rveillance
Factory surveillance
Relative effectiveness of Irish factories in the surveillance of slaughtered cattle for visible lesions of tuberculosis, 2005-2007
Olea-Popelka, F.J.1, Freeman, Z.1, White, P.W.2, 7 Costello, E.3, O’Keeffe, J.2, 7
Frankena, K.4, Martin, S.W.5, More, S.J.2, 6
1 Animal Population Health Institute, Department of Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, Colorado State University,
USA, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 4 Quantitative Veterinary Epidemiology, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands,
5 Department of Population Medicine, Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph, Ontario, Canada, 6 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 7 DAFM
Irish Veterinary Journal (in press)
InIreland,aspartoftheongoingbovinetuberculosis(bTB)control/eradicationscheme,everyanimalisexaminedatslaughterforitsfitnessforhumanconsumption.TheaimofthisstudywastodeterminetherelativeeffectivenessoffactoriesinsubmittingandsubsequentlyinhavingthesesuspectlesionsconfirmedasbTBlesionsduringtheyears2005-2007inIrelandandtoprovideanupdatefrompreviouslypublisheddataforyears2003-2004.During2005-2007datawereavailableon4,401,813cattlefromattestedherds,fromwhichdataforpotentialconfoundingfactorswasavailablefor3,344,057animalsslaughteredatexport-licensedfactories,ofwhichtherewere37duringthatperiod.Fromtheseanimals,8,178suspectlesionsweresubmittedforlaboratoryconfirmation.Lesionsfrom5,456(66.7%)animalsweretestedaspositive,2,453(30%)asnegativeand269(3.2%)wereinconclusiveforbTB.Logisticregressionwasusedtodetermineadjustedsubmissionandconfirmationrisksforeachfactorywhilecontrollingforconfoundingfactors.Factoryrankingsbasedonadjustedandcruderisksweresimilar.Theaveragecrudesubmissionriskforallthefactorieswas25lesionsper10,000animalsslaughtered,rangingfrom0to52.Thecrudeconfirmationriskvariedbetween30.3%and91.3%.Substantialvariationbetweensurveillanceeffectivenessinthe37factorieswasfound.Comparedtopreviousyears(2003-2004),therewasanincreasedbTBlesionsubmissionandconfirmationrisk.ContinuedmonitoringoftheeffectivenessofslaughtersurveillanceinIrelandisrecommended;emphasisshouldbeplacedoneffortstoimprovebTBsurveillanceinfactorieswithlowerrankings.
Copyright 2012 Olea-Popelka et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Evaluation of a risk-based approach to meat inspection for bovine tuberculosis in Ireland
Kelly, D.1, Aznar, I.2, More, S.J.2, 3
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Theaimofthisstudywastoconsidertheriskfactorsforthefindingofsuspectbovinetuberculosis(bTB)lesionsatpostmortemmeatinspectioninIreland.TuberculintestingresultsforbTBandlaboratorysubmissionofsuspectpostmortembTBlesions,wereanalysed.Theyear2009wasselectedforanalysisinwhich1,515,217bovineswereslaugh-teredinIreland.MultivariablelogisticregressionanalysisofthedatashowedthattheageoftheanimalwasagoodpredictorofthepresenceofbTBlesionsatmeatinspection.Inanimalsundertheageofthree,thesuspectlesionidentifi-cationrateislessthanhalftherateforanimalsagedthreeandabove.Theimpactofarisk-basedmeatinspectionsystemforbTBinIreland,i.e.byareducedmeatinspectionsystemforyoungerbovines,wasconsidered.
Biennial Report, 2010/201118
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g m
anag
emen
t o
f h
igh
ris
k h
erd
s
Improving management of high risk herds
Introduced infection
Study of herds that introduced new animals during the course of a restriction for bovine tuberculosis
Clegg, T.A.1, Higgins, I.M.1, Blake, M.2, Healy, R.2, Good, M.2, More, S.J.1, 3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
During a movement restriction for bovine tuberculosis, a farmer may wish to buy new cattle in order to either replaceanimalslostasaresultofbovinetuberculosis(bTB)ortoenableroutinemanagementpracticestocontinue‘asnormal’(inspiteofthebTBrestrictionsimposed).Permissiontoallowtherestockingofrestrictedherdsiscurrentlyanareaofpolicyuncertainty,duetotheunknownrisksofthepurchasedanimals.Theobjectivesofthisstudyarei)todeterminewhetherrestockingduringrestrictionisassociatedwithincreasedbTBrisk,ii)toprovideanoverviewofeventsassociatedwitheachrestockedepisodeandtoclarifytheinfectionstatusofanimalsthatareintroducedduringrestrictionsandiii)ontheprovisothatthereisevidenceofanincreasedbTBrisk,toidentifythepracticesrelatingtorestockingthatarethemostriskyandtodeterminewhethertheincreasedriskisassociatedwiththesourceortherestockedherd.
Predictors of the first between-herd animal movement for cattle born in 2002 in Ireland
White, P.W.1, 5 Frankena, K.2, O’Keeffe, J.1, 5 More, S.J.1, 3, Martin, S.W.4
1 UCD CVERA, 2 Quantitative Veterinary Epidemiology, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine,
4 Department of Population Medicine, Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph, Ontario, Canada, 5 DAFM
Preventive Veterinary Medicine 97, 264-269 (2010)
Movementofanimalsbetweenfarmsrepresentsapotentialriskofbovinetuberculosis(bTB)andotherdiseasetransmission.Theobjectivesofthisstudyweretoidentifyandquantifyriskfactorsassociatedwiththefirstbetween-herdmovementofanimals(denotedasriskmove).Arandomsampleof1percentofIrishcalfbirthsregisteredfor2002(20,182animals)wasselected.Descriptiveandsurvivalanalysisonmovementovertheperiod2002-2005wasperformed.Atotalof12,119(60%)ofanimalsexperiencedariskmoveoverthe4-yearstudyperiod.Amongthosethatmoved,57%didsowithinthefirst12monthsofage.Foranimalsindairyherds,anearlypeakinriskmoveeventswasobservedwithinthefirst12weeksofage;whereasinanimalsfromsucklerherds,alaterriskmovepeakwasobservedbetween21and36weeksofage.Thesurvivalmodelsidentifiedanumberofriskfactors:twothatappearedmostimportantinpredictingariskmoveweregenderandenterprisetype.Maleshadahazardratioof2.6timesthatoffemales.Thehazardsforenterprisetype,variedovertime,thusatime-varyingcovariate(ent_type×ln(time))wasincludedintheCoxmodel.At7daysofage,femalesinsucklerherdswereat0.14timesthehazardoffemalesindairyherdsforriskmove,andovertime,thehazardsconverged,equalisedbyday140,andthendiverged,sothatby4yearsofage,femalesinsucklerherdswereat4.64timesthehazardoffemalesindairyherds.Herdswithahistoryofsellinganimalsinpreviousyearsmaintainedthatrecordduringthestudyperiodwithincreasedhazardofriskmove.Enterprisetypeinteractedwithgendersothatrela-tivetofemales,malesfromdairyherdswereatgreaterhazardofriskmovethanmalesfromsucklerherds.Hazardofriskmovewasalsoafunctionofln(herdarea),sothateachdoublingoffarmareawasaccompaniedbya30.6%decreaseinthehazards.Themainconclusionwasthatriskofmovementrelateddiseasetransmissionalsodependsonthepurposeofthemovementwhetherforbreedingorforbeeffinishing.Whilemaleswereatgreater
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 19
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Imp
rovin
g m
anag
emen
t of h
igh
risk herd
s
hazardofmovementthanfemales,theywouldhaveashorterlifespan,thuslimitingtheopportunityforfurthertransmissionpost-movement.
Reprinted from Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 97, White, P.W., Frankena, K., O’Keeffe, J., More, S.J., Martin, S.W., Predictors of the first between-herd animal movement for cattle born in 2002 in Ireland, 264-269, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Local TB persistence
Risk of bovine tuberculosis for cattle sold out from attested herds during year 2005 in Ireland: a descriptive analysis
Berrian, A.M.1, O’Keeffe, J.2, 5, White, P.W.2, 5 Norris, J.4, Litt, J.4, More, S.J.2, 3, Olea-Popelka, F.J.1
1 College of Veterinary Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, Colorado State University, Colorado, USA, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine,
4 University of Colorado, Colorado, USA, 5 DAFM
Bovinetuberculosis(bTB)isaninfectiouscontagiousdiseasecausedbyabacterium,Mycobacterium bovis (M. bovis).ThesignificanceofbTBliesintradeimplicationsandzoonoticpotential.Althoughindustrializedcountrieshavesignifi-cantly reduced the prevalence of M. bovisinfectioninbothhumansandcattle,bTBpersistsinsomedevelopedcountries,includingtheRepublicofIreland.AretrospectivecohortstudywasconductedtodeterminetheriskofbTBamonganimalssoldoutfrom“clear”herdsduringtheyear2005.Herdsfromwhichtheanimalsweresoldoutwereclassifiedas“exposed”and“non-exposed”(ourmainriskfactor)tobTBaccordingtotheirpreviousbTBhistoryduringtheyear2005.Ourstudysamplewascomprisedof338,960animals,fromwhich124,360weresoldoutfrom“exposed”herdsand214,600animalsweresoldoutfrom“non-exposed”herds.TheoverallriskofbTBduringthe2-yearperiodaftertheanimalsweresoldoutwas0.69%.TheoddsoftestingpositivetobTBwas1.94(95%CI=1.79-2.11,p=<0.0001)foranimalssoldoutfrom“exposed”herdscomparedtoanimalssoldoutfrom“non-exposed”herds.Otherconfoundingfactors(ageandgender)andbTBbreakdownseverityduring2005wereincludedinouranalysisandhadasignificantassociationwiththeriskofbTBattheanimallevelinIreland.Thistypeofanalysisshouldinthenearfutureincorporateotherriskfactorsinordertodemonstratequalityassurancethatcanbesupported,trackedandguaranteed.
A retrospective cohort study of the risk of TB among suckler calves whose dam tested positive to the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test (SICTT)
Bourke, M.1, Aznar, I.2, More, S.J.2, 3
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Theverycloserelationshipofasucklingdamwithheroffspringandtheircontactviathesucklingprocessandgroomingraisesthequestionofwhetherornotaninfecteddamcouldpossiblytransmittuberculosistoheroffspringviaeithertheoralorrespiratoryroute.TheaimofthisstudyistoassessthehypothesisthatcalveswhosedamsfailedtheSingleIntradermalComparativeTuberculinTest(SICTT)willhaveanincreasedriskoffailingthetestinthefuturecomparedtothosewhosedamswerenegativetotheSICTT.Aretrospectivecohortstudywasdesigned.DatafromallsucklerherdswhichfailedtheSICTTtestinCo.Clarein2007willbeobtainedfromAnimalHealthComputerSystem(AHCS)operatedbytheDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM).Acontrolsampleofsucklercowsnegativestotheskintestandtheirrespectivecalveswillbealsoobtained.
Biennial Report, 2010/201120
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g m
anag
emen
t o
f h
igh
ris
k h
erd
s
Shorter-term risk of Mycobacterium bovis in Irish cattle following an inconclusive diagnosis to the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test
Clegg, T.A.1, Good, M.2, Duignan, A.2, Doyle, R.2, More., S.J.1, 3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Preventive Veterinary Medicine 102, 255-264 (2011)
InIreland,newcasesofbovinetuberculosis(bTB)aredetectedusingbothfieldandabattoirsurveillance(MoreandGood,2006).Fieldsurveillanceisconductedthroughannualtestingofallcattleusingthesingleintradermalcompara-tivetuberculintest(SICTT).Ananimalmaybedeemeda‘standardinconclusivereactor’(SIR)totheSICTTifthebovineresponseis>2mmandbetween1and4mm>theavianresponse.TheherdownerthenhasthreechoicesforthemanagementoftheSIR:option1istohavetheanimalretestedafteraminimumperiodof42days(aninconclusivereactorretest,IRR),option2istoslaughtertheSIRand,providedtheanimalhasnovisiblelesions,haveafullherdtest42daysaftertheSIRleavestheherd,option3istoslaughtertheSIRandhavethelymphnodesexaminedusinghistologyand/orcultureforbTB.Inthecurrentstudy,weexaminethebTBriskforSIRsbothatslaughterpriortotheIRRandattheIRR,andthefuturebTBriskofTIRanimals(so-called‘transientSIRs’;SIRanimalswithanega-tiveSICTTresultatthesubsequentIRR)thatmovedfromtheherdofdisclosurewithin6monthsoftheIRR.WealsoinvestigatefactorsassociatedwiththefuturebTBstatusofSIRsatslaughterpriortotheIRRandattheIRR.ThestudypopulationincludedallSIRsidentifiedinIrelandbetween2005and2009inclusiveinaherdotherwiseOfficiallyTBfree(OTF).Between11.8%and21.4%ofSIRsslaughteredpriortotheIRRwereconfirmedbTBpositiveatpostmortem(usinghistologyorcultureifhistologywasnotdefinitive),comparedto0.13–0.22%ofSICTT−vecohortanimals.ThepostmortembTBlesionrateofSIRsislowerthanthelesionratereportedforreactoranimalsbetween2005and2009ofbetween34%and39%,reflectingthedoubtfulinfectionstatusoftheseanimals.Between20.3%and27.9%ofherdswererestrictedattheIRR.Theherdrestrictionrateamongstthenationalherdbetween2005and2009variedfrom5.09%to6.02%.TIRsthatmovedoutofthedisclosingherdwithin6monthsoftheIRRwere12timesmorelikelytobebTBpositiveatthenexttest/slaughtercomparedtoallanimalsinthenationalherd.ThesameincreasedriskdidnotapplytotheSICTT−vecohortanimalsthatmovedoutofthesameherdsatthesametime.Basedonarangeofmeasures,SIRsandTIRsareeachatincreasedbTBriskintothefuture.Consequently,differentialtreat-mentofTIRanimalswouldbejustified.
Reprinted from Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 102, Clegg, T.A., Good, M., Duignan, A., Doyle, R., More., S.J., Shorter-term risk of Mycobacterium bovis in Irish cattle following an inconclusive diagnosis to the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test, 255-264, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Longer-term risk of Mycobacterium bovis in Irish cattle following an inconclusive diagnosis to the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test
Clegg, T.A.1, Good, M.2, Duignan, A.2, Doyle, R.2, Blake, M.2, More, S.J.1, 3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Preventive Veterinary Medicine 100, 147-154 (2011)
InIreland,newbovinetuberculosis(bTB)casesaredetectedusingbothfieldandabattoirsurveillance.Duringfieldsurveillance,ananimalmaybedeemeda‘standardinconclusivereactor’(SIR)tothesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest(SICTT)ifthebovineresponseis>2mm,andfrom1to4mmgreaterthantheavianresponse.LittleisknownaboutthefutureinfectionriskposedbySIRanimalsthatpassasubsequentretest,so-called‘transientSIR’(TIR)animals.TheobjectiveofthisstudywastocriticallyevaluatethefuturebTBstatusofTIRanimals,byexaminingthe
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 21
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Imp
rovin
g m
anag
emen
t of h
igh
risk herd
s
futureriskofbTBdiagnosisoverthe4yearsfollowinginitialSIRdiagnosisandclearanceatthesubsequentretest.ThestudyincludedallTIRsthatwereidentifiedasSIRsin2005inotherwisefreeherdsattestswithnootherreactorsatthattestandthatwereclearatthesubsequentretest.Theanalysiswasrestrictedtocowsthatwereneithersold,otherthandirecttoslaughter,norexportedfromtheherdduringthefollowupperiod(totheendof2009).Fivecontrolcowswererandomlyselectedfromeachstudyherd.Aparametricsurvivalmodelwithsharedfrailties,toaccountforclusteringwithinherds,wasdevelopedtomodeltimefrompassingaretesttofuturebTBdiagnosis.Thefinalparametricsurvivalmodelcontainedthevariables:TIRstatusin2005,inconclusivestatusduringthefollow-upperiod,location,herdrestrictedduringthestudy,timesincelastrestrictionwithintheherdandage.ThetimeratiofortheTIRstatusvariablewas significant (p<0.001)indicatingthatonaveragethetimetodiagnosiswithbTBforTIRswas78%shortercomparedtothenon-TIRs.Thefrailtytermwassignificant(p<0.001)indicatingthatanimalswithinsomeherdsweremorelikelytobecomereactorscomparedtootherherds.TheseresultshaveimportantimplicationsfornationalpolicyandfuturemanagementofTIRanimals.Further,privateveterinarypractitionersandtheirclientsshouldbeawareoftheincreasedriskassociatedwithTIRs.
Reprinted from Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 100, Clegg, T.A., Good, M., Duignan, A., Doyle, R., Blake, M., More, S.J., Longer-term risk of Mycobacterium bovis in Irish cattle following an inconclusive diagnosis to the single intradermal compara-tive tuberculin test, 147-154, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Effect of distance between a previously Mycobacterium bovis-infected herd and clear herds on the occurrence of bovine tuberculosis breakdowns in Ireland
De Ruiter, M.1, White, P.W.2, 3
1 Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 DAFM
Thisstudylooksatherdssurroundingarecentlyderestrictedherdandseekstoanswerthefollowingquestion-whatistheanimallevelbTBriskinthe4calendaryearsfollowingderestriction?Wewillconductaretrospectivecohortstudy,comparingherdsthatwere(caseherds)andwerenot(controlherds)derestrictedin2005(caseherds).Thestudywillfocusonfutureanimaltestoutcomes,uptoendof2008,foranimalspresentwithinneighbouringherds.Herd-levelexplanatoryvariables(forcaseherds)includenumberofreactors,numberofstandardreactors,indicesoflengthofrestriction,andherdsizeatthe2005completedepisode.Amongherdssurroundingcaseherds,amatchingnumberofcontrolherdswillbeselectedatrandomwithincounty,asonefromeachofthefollowingzones:i:Fromcontiguousherdswithin25m(directneighbours)ofaderestrictedherd;ii:Fromcontiguousherdswithin26m-150mofaderestrictedherd;iii:Fromcontiguousherdswithin151m–1kmofaderestrictedherd.Eachcomparisonherdwillberandomlyassignedanenddateofrestrictionwithin2005,stratifiedbymonth,tofollowthesamedistributionasthecaseherds.Foreachcaseherd,andcontrolherds,alistofanimalspresentatthe2005derestrictiondatewillbereconsti-tutedfromCMMSrecords(the“studypopulation”).Subsequentanimaltestoutcomesforthestudypopulationwillbecompareduptotheendof2008betweenanimalsfromcasevs.controlherds.
Biennial Report, 2010/201122
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g m
anag
emen
t o
f h
igh
ris
k h
erd
s
Risk of bTB associated with animals moving out of derestricted herds
Doornbosch, M.1, White, P.W.2, 3
1 Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 DAFM
Thisstudyseekstoanswerthefollowingquestion-forherdsthatwererecentlyderestricted,whatistheanimallevelbTBriskforanimalssoldtootherherdscomparedtothoseremainingwithintheherds?Wewillconductaretrospec-tivecohortstudy.Forherdsderestrictedin2005(caseherds),acomparisonoffutureanimaltestoutcomeswillbemadewithherdsthatremainedunrestricted(controlherds).Herd-levelexplanatoryvariablesforcaseherdsincludenumberofreactors,numberofstandardreactors,indicesoflengthofrestriction,andherdsizeatthe2005completedepisode.Foreachcaseherd,amatchingnumberofcontrolherdswillbeselectedfromherdsthatremainedunrestrictedin2005andprecedingyearsasfollows:Group1:unrestrictedduring2004and2005,Group2:unrestrictedduring2003,2004and2005andGroup3:unrestrictedduring2002,2003,2004and2005.Eachcomparisonherdswillberandomlyassignedanenddateofrestrictionwithin2005,allowingforseasonalvariationstofollowthesamedistributionasthecaseherds.Foreachcaseherd,andcontrolherd,alistofanimalspresentatthe2005derestrictiondatewillbereconstitutedfromCMMSrecords(the“studypopulation”).Detailsofsubsequentbetween-herdmovementswillbeextractedfromCMMSfortheperioduptoendof2008.Thosemovingoutoftheirstudyherdtoanotherherdwillbeclassedas“movers”,andtheremainderclassedas“non-movers”.Bymeansofasurvivalanalysis,animaltestoutcomesforthestudypopulationwillbecomparedovertimebetweenmoversvs.non-moversreconstitutedfromcaseandcontrolherds.
The temporal and spatial patterns of bovine tuberculosis in County Kilkenny cattle herds, 1998 to 2008
Fennelly, N.1, Griffin, J.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Clegg, T.A.2, McGrath, G.2
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Theuseofepidemiologicalmethodsisanintrinsiccomponentofdiseasemanagementandcontrol.TheobjectiveofthisstudyistoexamineBovineTuberculosis(bTB)inCountyKilkennycattleherdsfrom1998to2008inclusiveandusetheinformationtoenhancetheunderstandingoftheepidemiologyofthediseaseinthecounty.Thestudywillexaminethe long term changes that have occurred over the decade (secular trends), and will investigate cyclical disease patterns andseasonaldiseasepatterns.Spatialdiseasepatternsmaybevisualisedandanalysedbyusingcartographic(mapping)orgeographicinformationsystems(GIS)methods.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 23
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Imp
rovin
g m
anag
emen
t of h
igh
risk herd
s
Impact of the national full herd depopulation policy on the recurrence of bovine tuberculosis in Irish herds, 2003 to 2005
Good, M.1, Clegg, T.A.2, Duignan, A.1, More, S.J.2, 3
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Veterinary Record 169, 581 (2011)
ThisstudyevaluatedtheimpactoftheIrishherdbovinetuberculosis(bTB)depopulationpolicy(depopulation,disinfec-tion,contiguoustestingandlocalbadgerremovalwhereimplicated)ontherecurrenceofbTBinfection,bycomparingthefutureriskinrestockedherdsfollowingdepopulationforeitherbTBorbovinespongiformencephalopathy(BSE)during2003to2005.Eachherdwasassigneda‘previousbTBrisk’,basedonbTBhistoryduringthefiveyearsbeforedepopulation.FuturebTBriskwasestimated,usingamultivariableCoxproportionalhazardmodelfortime-to-break-downforeachstudyherd,toidentifyriskfactorsassociatedwithbTB.FuturebTBriskvariedsignificantlybyreasonfordepopulationandpreviousbTBrisk.HerdsdepopulatedforbTB(bydefinition,athighbTBrisk)werenotsignificantlydifferentfromBSEherdswithnooralowpreviousbTBrisk.BSEherdswithahighpreviousbTBriskwerefoundtobeatsignificantlygreaterfuturebTBrisk.HerdbTBdepopulationmeasures,ascurrentlyappliedinIreland,areshowntobeeffectiveinenablingherdstoattainandretainbTBfreedomfollowingrestocking.Basedonthedatapresented,andconsistentwithcurrentknowledgeofthebTBepidemiology,localbadgerremovalcontributestoeffortstolimitrecur-renceofbTBinIreland.
Reproduced from Veterinary Record, Good, M., Clegg, T.A., Duignan, A., More, S.J., 169, 581, Copyright 2011, with permission from BMJ Publishing Group Ltd.
The association between weather and bovine tuberculosis
Jin, R.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Kelly, G.1
1 UCD School of Mathematical Sciences, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Inatimewhenitiswidelyacknowledgedthatclimatechangeisoccurringglobally,theissueofweatherinrelationtotheepidemiologyofbovineTBneedsgreaterunderstanding.Fortheperiod2005-2009,weexaminetheinfluenceofweathervariablesonTBincidenceincattleherdstogetherwithwellestablishedriskfactorsintheareaofwestCountyWicklowintheeastofIrelandwhichuntilrecentlyhadaseparatedistrictveterinaryoffice(DVO).Dataforthisstudywereobtainedfromthreesources:DatafromthenationaldatabaseofTBtestinghistory(VetNet)maintainedbytheDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM),meteorologicaldatafromtheIrishMeterologicalOfficeandbadgerdatafromtheWildlifeUnitofDAFMallforwestCountyWicklow.Thedatawillbeanalysedusingstatisticaltoolsrelatedtogeneralizedlinearmixedmodelsandtimeseries.InitialresultssuggestthathighrainfallisassociatedwithincreasedbTBlevelsincattleherds.
Biennial Report, 2010/201124
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g m
anag
emen
t o
f h
igh
ris
k h
erd
s
Estimation of the between-herd reproduction ratio for contiguous spread of bovine tuberculosis
White, P.W.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM
Bovinetuberculosis(bTB)isarecurringdiseaseburdenfortheIrishcattlesector,withbetween20,000-30,000reac-torsbeingremovedannuallyunderthenationalherdtestingprogram.WhileGIStechniqueshavedemonstratedthatclusteringofbTBexistsincattleherdsonawiderspatialscale,relativelylittleworkhasbeenpublishedontheriskofbTBtransmissionamongherdswithin25m(i.e.directlycontiguous)ofoneother.Neighbouringherdswithin25mofaherdexperiencinganewbTBepisode(indexherd)maycomeintocontactwithbTBinfectedcattleandcouldbecomeinfectedwithbTBasaresult.Alternatively,bothindexandneighbouringherdscouldbeexposedtoacommoninfectedwildlifesource.ThepatternofcontiguousspreadamongherdswithinareasofdifferingbadgerdensitymayprovidesomeusefulinsightsintothenaturebTBclustering.ThestudypopulationwillconsistofherdswithinRemoval(lowerbadgerdensity)andReference(higherbadgerdensity)areasoftheFourAreaProject,comprisingpartsofCork,Donegal,KilkennyandMonaghan.Byuseofherdtestingdatafortheperiodofproactivebadgerremoval,betweenAugust1997andSeptember2002,wewillidentifyherdsexperiencingoneormorebTBepisodes(indexherds).UsingLPISdatafor2001,wewilldeterminecontiguousherdswithin25mofanindexherd,andassessthepreviousbTBhistoryofthose(contiguous)herdsasapotentialsourceofbTBexposurefortheindexherd.Usingthisinformationwewilldevelopamathematicalmodeltocalculatethebetween-herdreproductionratio(R
0)forabTBepisodeamongneighbouringherds
at25m.ThekeyfactorofinterestasadeterminantofR0willbetreatmentarea(removalorreference).
How important is neighbourhood spread in the persistence of bovine tuberculosis in Irish cattle herds?
White, P.W.1, 5 Frankena, K.2, O'Keeffe, J.1, 5 Martin, S.W.3, More, S.J.1, 4, de Jong, M.C.M.2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 Quantitative Veterinary Epidemiology, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 3 Department of Population Medicine,
Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph, Ontario, Canada, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 5 DAFM
Akeyfeatureofbovinetuberculosis(bTB)islocalpersistenceofinfection,characterisedbyrecurrentepisodesinoneormoreneighbouringherds.Localpersistencecouldbeattributedto:residualinfectionthatpersistsintheindexherd,despite testing following initial disclosure, neighbourhood or contiguous spread by cattle-to cattle transmission over farm boundaries,and/orinfectionofherdsviaacommonwildlifesource,e.g.thebadger.Acase-controlstudywasconductedontheassociationbetweentheoccurrenceofabTBepisodeincattleherdsintheRepublicofIreland,andanumberofpossibleriskfactors;thebTBhistoryofneighbouringherdswithin1km,theherdsownbTBhistory,herdsize,enterprisetype,numberoffarmfragments,andthepurchasingofcattle.Neighbouringherdsweredividedintothreezonesbasedontheirclosestassociationwithastudy(own)herdas:zone1(0-25m),zone2(26-150m)andzone3(151-1000m).Thecharacteristicsof3,909herdsthathadabTBepisodein2006werecomparedwiththoseof98,872herdsthatwerebTBtested,andremainedclearthroughout2006.TheresultshighlightanassociationbetweenbTBandanincreasedanimal incidence within two subsets of neighbouring herds: (i) herds directly contiguous during the previous 2 years, and(ii)herdsatadistanceof>25metresinthepreviousyear.Furtherstudieswillbenecessarytodeterminetowhatextenttheassociationat(i)maybeconfoundedbytheexistenceofawildlife(badger)source.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 25
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Imp
rovin
g m
anag
emen
t of h
igh
risk herd
s
Predictive models
Stochastic herd-level modelling of freedom from bTB infection for testing strategies applied in differing risk scenarios in Great Britain
Parry, J.E.1, Clifton-Hadley, R.S.1, de la Rua-Domenech, R.2, Broughan, J.M.1, Abernethy, D.A.3,
Cook, A.J.1, Goodchild, A.V.1, Greiner, M.4, Gunn, J.5, More, S.J.6, 7, Nuñez-Garcia, J.1, Rhodes, S.1,
Rolfe, S.8, Sharp, M.9, Upton, P.1, Vordermeier, H.M.10, Watson, E.10, Welsh, M.11, Whelan, A.O.10,
Woolliams, J.A.12, Downs, S.H.1, Cameron, A.13
1 Centre for Epidemiology and Risk Analysis, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 2 Department for
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London, United Kingdom, 3 Veterinary Service, Department of Agriculture and Rural Development, Belfast, Northern
Ireland, 4 Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), Berlin, Germany, 5 Bacteriology, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey,
United Kingdom, 6 UCD CVERA, 7 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 8 Office of the Chief Veterinary Officer, Welsh Assembly Government, Cardiff,
Wales, United Kingdom, 9 Pathology and Host Susceptibility, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Lasswade, Midlothian, United Kingdom,
10 Bacteriology, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 11 Veterinary Sciences Division, Agri-Food &
Biosciences Institute (AFBI), Belfast, Northern Ireland, 12 The Roslin Institute, Roslin Biocentre, Roslin, Midlothian, United Kingdom, 13 AusVet Animal Health
Services Pty Ltd, Brisbane, Australia
The performance of surveillance system components (including diagnostic tests and slaughterhouse inspection), which makeupabovinetuberculosissurveillancesystemwereevaluatedusingastochasticmodel.Thisfirstcalculatestheprobabilitythataherd,withspecificcharacteristicsandbTBsurveillancehistory,isfreefrominfection.Thesensi-tivityoffurthersurveillancerequiredtomeeta‘target’probabilityoffreedomfrominfectionisthencalculatedandsubsequentdecisionsontheselectionofcomponents,whichofferadequatesensitivity,canbebasedonspecificity(expectednumberoffalsepositives),timetoachievefreedom,andthereforecost.Themodelrequiredseveralinputsincluding evidence from previous herd surveillance, the prior probability that the herd was infected (estimated using localprevalenceofbTB),thedistributionsofanimal-levelsensitivityandspecificityofdiagnostictests(derivedfromameta-analysisofdiagnostictestperformance)andtheriskofintroductionofinfectionintotheherd(derivedfromtheobservedincidenceofbTBinGBriskscenarios).Wheretheprobabilityofintroductionofinfectionwashigh,itwasdifficult to achieve and maintain a high target probability of herd freedom from infection even with the most sensi-tiveofcomponents.Conversely,whereintroductionofinfectionwaslow,componentswithlowsensitivitymaystillprovideadequateprobabilityoffreedomfromTB.
Biennial Report, 2010/201126
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
EIm
pro
vin
g m
anag
emen
t o
f h
igh
ris
k h
erd
s
From explanation to prediction: developing a predictive model for recurrent bovine tuberculosis in Irish cattle herds
Wolfe, D.M.1, Berke, O.1, Kelton, D.F.1, White, P.W.2, 4 More, S.J.2, 3, O’Keeffe, J.2, 4 Martin, S.W.1
1 Department of Population Medicine, Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph, Ontario, Canada, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary
Medicine, 4 DAFM
Preventive Veterinary Medicine 94, 170-177 (2010)
Thereisagoodunderstandingoffactorsassociatedwithbovinetuberculosis(bTB)riskinIrishherds.Asyet,however,thisknowledgehasnotbeenincorporatedintopredictivemodelswiththepotentialforimproved,risk-basedsurveillance.ThegoalofthestudywastoenhancethenationalherdscoringsystemforbTBrisk,thusleadingtoimprovedidentifi-cationofcattleherdsathighriskofrecurrentbTBepisodes.AretrospectivecohortstudywasconductedtodevelopastatisticalmodelpredictiveofrecurrentbovinetuberculosisepisodesincattleherdsintheRepublicofIreland.Herd-leveldiseasehistorydatafortheprevious12years,theprevious3years,thepreviousepisode,andthecurrent-episodewereusedinsurvivalanalysestodeterminetheaspectsofdiseasehistorythatwerepredictiveofarecurrentbreakdownwithin3yearsofaclearedbTBepisode.Relativetoherdswith0-1standardreactorsinthecurrentbTBepisode,hazardratiosincreasedto1.3and1.6forherdswith2-5and>5standardreactors,respectively.Comparedtoherdswith<30animals,hazardratiosincreasedfrom1.8to2.5andthento3.1forherdswith30-79,80-173,and>174animalsrespectively.Relativetoherdswith<4herd-leveltestsintheprevious3years,herdswith4-5and>5testshad1.1and1.4timesgreaterhazardofabTBbreakdown.HerdsthatdidnothaveabTBepisodeinthe5yearspriortotheir2001episodewere0.8timeslesslikelytobreakdowninthenext3yearsthanherdsthatdid.Herdsbreakingdowninthespringorsummerwere0.8timeslesslikelytosufferarecurrentbreakdownthanherdsbreakingdowninautumnorwinter(thiswaslikelyduetoseasonalityintestingregimes).ThepresenceofaconfirmedbTBlesionwasnotpredictiveofincreasedriskofrecurrentbTB.Despitetheavailabilityofdetaileddiseasehistory,thepredictiveabilityofthemodelwaspoor.OneexplanationforthiswasthatherdssufferingarecurrenceofbTBontheirfirsttestafterclearingabTBepisodeweredifferentfromherdsthatbrokedownlaterintheperiodatrisk.Futureresearchmightneedtoincludeadditionalvari-ablestoidentifywhichsubsetsofherdbTBepisodes,ifany,haveidentifiablefeaturesthatarepredictiveofrecurrentbreakdowns.
Reprinted from Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 94, Wolfe, D.M., Berke, O., Kelton, D.F., White, P.W., More, S.J., O’Keeffe, J., Martin, S.W., From explanation to prediction: developing a predictive model for recurrent bovine tuberculosis in Irish cattle herds, 170-177, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 27
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Sup
po
rting
stud
ies
Supporting studies
Genetics, milk production
Evidence for genetic variance in resistance to tuberculosis in Great Britain and Irish Holstein-Friesian populations
Bermingham, M.L.1, Brotherstone, S.2, Berry, D.P.3, More, S.J.4, 5, Good, M.6, Cromie, A.R.7,
White, I.M.S.2, Higgins, I.M.4, Coffey, M.8, Downs, S.H.9, Glass, E.J.1, Bishop, S.C.1,
Mitchell, A.P.9, Clifton-Hadley, R.S.9, Woolliams, J.A.1
1 The Roslin Institute, Midlothian, United Kingdom, 2 Institute of Evolutionary Biology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 3 Teagasc
Moorepark, 4 UCD CVERA, 5 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 6 DAFM, 7 The Irish Cattle Breeding Federation, 8 Scottish Agricultural College, Midlothian,
United Kingdom, 9 Veterinary Laboratories Agency-Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom
BMC Proceedings 5 (Suppl 4), S15 (2011)
Here,wejointlysummarisescientificevidenceforgeneticvariationinresistancetoinfectionwithMycobacterium bovis, theprimaryagentofbovinetuberculosis(TB),providedbytworecentandseparatestudiesofHolstein-FriesiandairycowpopulationsinGreatBritain(GB)andIreland.Thestudiesquantifiedgeneticvariationwithinarchiveddatafromfieldandabattoirsurveillancecontrolprogrammeswithineachcountry.Thesedataincludedresultsfromthesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest(SICTT),abattoirinspectionforTBlesionsandlaboratoryconfirmationofdiseasestatus.ThresholdanimalmodelswereusedtoestimatevariancecomponentsforresponsivenesstotheSICTTandabattoir confirmed M. bovisinfection.Thelinkfunctionsbetweentheobserved0/1scaleandtheliabilityscalewerethecomplementarylog-logintheGB,andlogitlinkfunctionintheIrishpopulation.Theestimatedheritabilityofsuscepti-bilitytoTB,asjudgedbyresponsivenesstotheSICTT,was0.16(0.012)and0.14(0.025)intheGBandIrishpopula-tions,respectively.Forabattoirorlaboratoryconfirmationofinfection,estimateswere0.18(0.044)and0.18(0.041)fromtheGBandtheIrishpopulations,respectively.EstimateswereallsignificantlydifferentfromzeroandindicatethatexploitablevariationexistsamongGBandIrishHolsteinFriesiandairycowsforresistancetoTB.Epidemiologicalanalysis suggests that factors such as variation in exposure or imperfect sensitivity and specificity would have resulted in underestimationofthetruevalues.
Copyright 2011 Bermingham et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Genetic correlations between measures of Mycobacterium bovis infection and economically important traits in Irish Holstein-Friesian dairy cows
Bermingham, M.L.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Good M.4, Cromie, A.R.5, Higgins, I.M.2, Berry, D.P.1
1 Teagasc Moorepark, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 DAFM, 5 The Irish Cattle Breeding Federation
Journal of Dairy Science 93, 5413-5422 (2010)
Mycobacterium bovisistheprimaryagentoftuberculosis(TB)incattle.ThefailureofIrelandandsomeothercountriestoreachTB-freestatusindicatesaneedtoinvestigatecomplementarycontrolstrategies.OnesuchapproachwouldbegeneticselectionforincreasedresistancetoTB.Previousresearchhasshownthatconsiderablegeneticvariationexistsfor susceptibility to the measures of M. bovis infection, confirmed M. bovis infection, and M. bovis-purified protein derivative(PPD)responsiveness.Theobjectiveofthisstudywastoestimatethegeneticandphenotypiccorrelations
Biennial Report, 2010/201128
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
ESu
pp
ort
ing
stu
die
s
between economically important traits and these measures of M. bovisinfection.Atotalof20,148and17,178cowswith confirmed M. bovis infection and M. bovis-PPDresponsivenessrecords,respectively,wereavailableforinclusionintheanalysis.First-tothird-paritymilk,fat,andproteinyields,somaticcellcount,calvinginterval,andsurvival,aswellasfirst-paritybodyconditionscorerecords,wereavailableoncowsthatcalvedbetween1985and2007.Bivariatelinear-linearandthreshold-linearsiremixedmodelswereusedtoestimate(co)variancecomponents.Thegeneticcorrela-tions between economically important traits and the measures of M. bovis infection estimated from the linear-linear and threshold-linearsiremodelsweresimilar.ThegeneticcorrelationsbetweensusceptibilitytoconfirmedM. bovis infection andeconomicallyimportanttraitsinvestigatedinthisstudywereallclosetozero.Mycobacterium bovis-PPDresponsive-nesswaspositivelygeneticallycorrelatedwithfatproduction(0.39)andbodyconditionscore(0.36),andnegativelycorrelatedwithsomaticcellscore(-0.34)andsurvival(-0.62).Hence,selectionforincreasedsurvivalmayindirectlyreduce susceptibility to M. bovis infection, whereas selection for reduced somatic cell count and increased fat production and body condition score may increase susceptibility to M. bovisinfection.
Reprinted from Journal of Dairy Science 93, Bermingham, M.L., More, S.J., Good M., Cromie, A.R., Higgins, I.M., Berry, D.P., Genetic correlations between measures of Mycobacterium bovis infection and economically important traits in Irish Holstein-Friesian dairy cows, 5413-5422, Copyright (2010), with permission from the American Dairy Science Association.
Genotype by environment interaction of susceptibility to Mycobacterium bovis infection and economically important traits in Irish Holstein-Friesian cows across areas of low and high TB incidence
Bermingham, M.L.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Good, M.4, Cromie, A.R.5, McGrath, G.2, Higgins, I.M.2, Berry, D.P.6
1 The Roslin Institute, Midlothian, United Kingdom, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 DAFM, 5 The Irish Cattle Breeding Federation,
6 Teagasc Moorepark
Mycobacterium bovisistheprimaryagentoftuberculosisincattle.Thereisconsiderablegeneticvariationforsusceptibilityto M. bovis infection, and both favorable and antagonistic genetic correlations exist between susceptibility to M. bovis infectionandhealth,fertilityandproductiontraitsinIrishHolstein-Friesiandairycattle.Theeffectivenessofbreeding
programforincreasedresistancetoTBandperformanceinothereconomicallyimportanttraitsmaybehinderedviagenotypebyenvironmentinteraction,wherebydifferentgenotypesresponddifferentlytochangesintheenvironment.Theobjectiveofthisstudywasthereforetoidentifytheexistenceandscopeofgenotypebyenvironmentinteractionforsusceptibility to M. bovisinfectionandothereconomicallyimportanttraitsofHolstein-FriesiandairycattleacrosslowandhighTBincidenceareasinIreland.Thesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest(SICTT)wasusedasameasureofsusceptibility of cows to M. bovisinfection.Atotalof19,892cowswithtuberculintestrecordsbetween2000and2008wereavailableforinclusionintheanalysis.Firsttothirdparitymilk,fat,andproteinyield,somaticcellcount,calvingintervalandsurvival,aswellasfirstparitybodyconditionscorerecords,wereavailableoncowscalvingbetween1985and2007.TuberculosisincidenceinIrelandfortheyears2000to2008wasmappedusingGeographicalInformationSystemsmethodology.ThedatawassplitintotwoenvironmentsbasedonaSICTTreactordensitythresholdof0.34cattleperkm2peryear.Bivariatelinearsiremixedmodelswereusedtoestimate(co)variancecomponentsbetweentraitsacrossthehighandlowTBincidenceenvironments.HomogeneousgeneticvariancewasobservedforvarianceresponsetotheSICTTacrossthelowandhighincidenceenvironments(P>0.05).ThegeneticcorrelationbetweenresponsetotheSICTTin the low and high incidence environment was not significantly less than unity (P>0.05);indicatingthatre-rankingofsiresislimited.However,heterogeneousgeneticcorrelationswereestimatedbetweenthreeparitymilkfatproductionandresponsetotheSICTTacrossthehigh(0.30-0.35)andlow(-0.10--0.02)incidenceenvironments.Hence,selectionforincreasedmilkfatproductionwillincreasesusceptibilitytoTBinhighincidenceareas.TheabsenceofenvironmentalsensitivityofresponsetotheSICTTacrossenvironmentsindicatesnationallevelselectionisfeasible.TheheterogeneousgeneticcorrelationbetweenmilkfatproductionresponsestotheSICTT,however,needstobeconsideredinthedesignofbreedingprogramsinordertoaccuratelypredictrateofgeneticgainacrossTBincidenceenvironments.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 29
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Sup
po
rting
stud
ies
Genetics of animal health and disease in cattle
Berry, D.P.1, Bermingham, M.L.2, Good, M.3, More, S.J.4, 5
1 Teagasc Moorepark, 2 The Roslin Institute, Midlothian, United Kingdom, 3 DAFM, 4 UCD CVERA, 5 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 5 (2011)
There have been considerable recent advancements in animal breeding and genetics relevant to disease control in cattle, whichcannowbeutilisedaspartofanoverallprogrammeforimprovedcattlehealth.Thisreviewsummarisesthecontributionofgeneticmakeuptodifferencesinresistancetomanydiseasesaffectingcattle.Significantgeneticvariationin susceptibility to disease does exist among cattle suggesting that genetic selection for improved resistance to disease will befruitful.Deficienciesinaccuratelyrecordeddataonindividualanimalsusceptibilitytodiseaseare,however,currentlyhinderingtheinclusionofhealthanddiseaseresistancetraitsinnationalbreedinggoals.Developmentsin‘omics’tech-nologies, such as genomic selection, may help overcome some of the limitations of traditional breeding programmes and will be especially beneficial in breeding for lowly heritable disease traits that only manifest themselves following exposure topathogensorenvironmentalstressorsinadulthood.However,accesstolargedatabasesofphenotypesonhealthanddiseasewillstillbenecessary.Thisreviewclearlyshowsthatgeneticsmakeasignificantcontributiontotheoverallhealthandresistancetodiseaseincattle.Therefore,breedingprogrammesforimprovedanimalhealthanddiseaseresistanceshouldbeseenasanintegralpartofanyoverallnationaldiseasecontrolstrategy.
Copyright 2011 Berry et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Bovine tuberculosis and milk production in infected dairy herds in Ireland
Boland, F.1, Kelly, G.E.1, Good, M.2, More, S.J.3, 4
1 UCD School of Mathematical Sciences, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Preventive Veterinary Medicine 93, 153-161 (2010)
Thisstudydescribestherelationshipbetweenbovinetuberculosis(TB)andmilkyieldinTB-infecteddairyherdsinIreland.Thestudyhadtwoobjectives:todeterminewhethercowsdetectedasTBreactors(andthussubjecttoimme-diateslaughter)werelikelytobethehighermilk-producingcows,andtodeterminewhethersubclinicalTBinfectionwasassociatedwithreducedmilkproductionatoraroundthetimeofdisclosure(detection).AllIrishdairyherdsrestrictedfromtradingbetweenthe1stJune2004andthe31stMay2005asaresultoftwoormoreTBreactorsbytheSingleIntradermalComparativeTuberculinTest(SICTT)wereconsideredforstudy.Thedataconsistedof419herds.DatawerecollectedonallTBreactorsandarandomsampleof5non-reactorcowsintheseherds:adatasetof4,340cows(2,342TBreactorsand1,998non-reactors).Previousmilkdataforthecowsweretakenintoconsiderationandthusalllactationsonacowwereanalysedtogetherwiththeyearsoflactations.Therewasaninherenthierarchicalstructurein the data, with lactations nested within cows and cows within herds and thus a linear mixed model with two random effectswasusedtodescribethedata.Theresultsofthisstudyshowedthatforalllactationsandyearsunderinvestigation,milkyieldwassignificantlylowerforTBreactorcows,withdifferencesrangingfrom120kg(2003,lactation3)to573kg(2001,lactation1),whencomparedtothenon-reactorcows.
Reprinted from Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 93, Boland, F., Kelly, G.E., Good, M., More, S.J., Bovine tuberculosis and milk production in infected dairy herds in Ireland, 153-161, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/201130
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
ESu
pp
ort
ing
stu
die
s
Bovine tuberculosis and udder health in Irish dairy herds
Boland, F.1, Kelly, G.E.1, Good, M.2, More, S.J.3, 4
1 UCD School of Mathematical Sciences, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The Veterinary Journal (in press)
Theassociationbetweenbovinetuberculosis(TB)infectionstatusbasedonresultsfromtheSingleIntradermalComparativeTuberculinTest(SICTT)andmilkproductionhasbeendescribedindairycowsinTB-infectedherdsinIreland.Thebiologicalbasiswasuncertain,butcouldberelatedtoincreasedTBsusceptibilityamonglowerproducingdairycows.Inthisstudy,therelationshipbetweensomaticcellcount(asanobjectivemeasureofudderhealth)andSICTTreactivity(asaproxyforTBinfectionstatus)wasinvestigated.SomaticcellcountsofTBinfectedcows,bothduringandpriortothelactationofdiagnosisofTBinfection,wereexaminedandcomparedtonon-infectedcows.AllIrishdairyherdsrestrictedfromtradingbetweenJune2004andMay2005asaresultoftwoormoreTBreactors(testpositive)totheSICTTwereconsideredforstudy.Datawerecollectedon4,340cowsfrom419herds.Previouslacta-tiondataforthecowsweretakenintoconsiderationandalllactationsofacowwereanalysedtogetherwiththeyearsoflactations.Therewasaninherenthierarchicalstructureinthedata,withlactationsnestedwithincowsandcowswithinherdsandsoalinearmixedmodelwithtworandomeffectswasusedtodescribethedata.Milkproduction(305-daymilkyield)wasalsoincludedinthemodelasafixedeffect.Theresultsofthestudyshowedthatforalllactationsandyearsunderinvestigation,somaticcellcountsforSICTTreactorcowswhencomparedtothenon-reactorcowswerenotsignificantlydifferent.Inthisstudypopulation,TBinfectionstatuswasnotassociatedwithudderhealth.
Reprinted from The Veterinary Journal, Boland, F., Kelly, G.E., Good, M., More, S.J., Bovine tuberculosis and udder health in Irish dairy herds, in press, Copyright 2012, with permission from Elsevier.
Evidence of genetic resistance of cattle to infection with Mycobacterium bovis
Brotherstone, S.1, White, I.M.S.1, Coffey, M.2, Downs, S.H.3, Mitchell, A.P.3, Clifton-Hadley, R.S.3,
More, S.J.4, 5, Good, M.6, Woolliams, J.A.7
1 School of Biological Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 2 Scottish Agricultural College, Midlothian, United Kingdom,
3 Centre for Epidemiology and Risk Analysis, Veterinary Laboratories Agency-Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 4 UCD CVERA,
5 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 6 DAFM, 7 The Roslin Institute, Midlothian, United Kingdom
Journal of Dairy Science 93, 1234-1242 (2010)
Anecdotal evidence points to genetic variation in resistance of cattle to infection with Mycobacterium bovis, the causative agentofbovinetuberculosis(bTB),andpublishedexperimentalevidenceindeerandcattlesuggestssignificantgeneticvariationinresistanceandreactivitytodiagnostictests.However,suchgeneticvariationhasnotbeenproperlyquantifiedintheUnitedKingdomdairycattlepopulation;itispossiblethatitexistsandmaybeafactorinfluencingtheoccurrenceofbTB.Usingmodelsbasedontheoutcomeoftheprocessofdiagnosis(ultimatefatemodels)andontheoutcomeofa single stage of diagnosis (continuation ratio models, herd test-date models), this study shows that there is heritable variationinindividualcowsusceptibilitytobTB,andthatselectionformilkyieldisunlikelytohavecontributedtothecurrentepidemic.ResultsdemonstratethatgeneticscouldplayanimportantroleincontrollingbTBbyreducingboththeincidenceandtheseverityofherdbreakdowns.
Reprinted from Journal of Dairy Science, 93, Brotherstone, S., White, I.M.S., Coffey, M., Downs, S.H., Mitchell, A.P., Clifton-Hadley, R.S., More, S.J., Good, M., Woolliams, J.A., Evidence of genetic resistance of cattle to infection with Mycobacterium bovis, 1234-1242, Copyright 2010, with permission from the American Dairy Science Association.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 31
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Sup
po
rting
stud
ies
Genome-wide transcriptional profiling of peripheral blood leukocytes from cattle infected with Mycobacterium bovis reveals suppression of host immune genes
Killick, K.E.1, Browne, J.A.1, Park, S.D.E.1, Magee, D.A.1, Martin, I.1, Meade, K.G.2, Gordon, S.V.1, 3,
Gormley, E.4, O’Farrelly, C.5, Hokamp, K.6, MacHugh, D.E.1,3
1 UCD College of Agriculture, Food Science & Veterinary Medicine, 2 Teagasc Grange, 3 UCD Conway Institute of Biomolecular and Biomedical Research,
4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 5 TCD Comparative Immunology Group, School of Biochemistry and Immunology, 6 TCD Smurfit Institute of Genetics
BMC Genomics 12, 611 (2011)
Mycobacterium bovisisthecausativeagentofbovinetuberculosis(bTB),apathologicalinfectionwithsignificanteconomicimpact.Recentstudieshavehighlightedtheroleoffunctionalgenomicstobetterunderstandthemolecularmechanisms governing the host immune response to M. bovisinfection.Furthermore,thesestudiesmayenabletheiden-tificationofnoveltranscriptionalmarkersofbTBthatcanaugmentcurrentdiagnostictestsandsurveillanceprogrammes.Inthepresentstudy,wehaveanalysedthetranscriptomeofperipheralbloodleukocytes(PBL)fromeightM. bovis-infectedandeightcontrolnon-infectedage-matchedandsex-matchedHolstein-FriesiancattleusingtheAffymetrix® GeneChip®BovineGenomeArraywith24,072geneprobesetsrepresentingmorethan23,000genetranscripts.Controlandinfectedanimalshadsimilarmeanwhitebloodcellcounts.However,themeannumberoflymphocyteswassignifi-cantly increased in the infected group relative to the control group (P=0.001),whilethemeannumberofmonocyteswassignificantlydecreasedinthebTBgroup(P=0.002).Hierarchicalclusteringanalysisusinggeneexpressiondatafromall5,388detectablemRNAtranscriptsunambiguouslypartitionedtheanimalsaccordingtotheirdiseasestatus.Intotal,2,960genetranscriptsweredifferentiallyexpressed(DE)betweentheinfectedandcontrolanimalgroups(adjustedP-value threshold ≤0.05);withthenumberofgenetranscriptsshowingdecreasedrelativeexpression(1,563)exceedingthosedisplayingincreasedrelativeexpression(1,397).SystemsanalysisusingtheIngenuity®SystemsPathwayAnalysis(IPA)KnowledgeBaserevealedanover-representationofDEgenesinvolvedintheimmuneresponsefunctionalcategory.Morespecifically,64.5%ofgenesintheaffectsimmuneresponsesubcategorydisplayeddecreasedrelativeexpressionlevelsintheinfectedanimalscomparedtothecontrolgroup.Thisstudydemonstratesthatgenome-widetranscriptionalprofilingofPBLcandistinguishactiveM. bovis-infectedanimalsfromcontrolnon-infectedanimals.Furthermore,theresults obtained support previous investigations demonstrating that mycobacterial infection is associated with host tran-scriptionalsuppression.Thesedatasupporttheuseoftranscriptomictechnologiestoenabletheidentificationofrobust,
reliabletranscriptionalmarkersofactiveM. bovisinfection.
Copyright 2011 Killick et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Impact of delayed processing of bovine peripheral blood on differential gene expression
Sheridan, M.P.1, Browne, J.A.2, MacHugh, D.E.2, 3, Costello, E.4, Gormley, E.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD Animal Genomics Laboratory, 3 UCD Conway Institute of Biomolecular and Biomedical Research,
4 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service
Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology (in press)
RT-qPCRcanbeusedtoaccuratelydetermineexpressionlevelsofgenesfollowingRNAextractionfromtissuesamples.IfbloodisthesourceoftotalRNA,itisoftendesirabletoprocessthesamplesimmediatelyfollowingcollectionbecausedelaysinprocessingforRNAextractionmayinfluencemRNAexpressionestimatesobtainedfromRT-qPCRanalyses.
Biennial Report, 2010/201132
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
ESu
pp
ort
ing
stu
die
s
However,thismaynotbefeasibleifthesiteofbloodcollectionisdistantfromtheprocessinglaboratory.Inthepresentstudy,theeffectsofdelaysintheprocessingofbloodsamplesonmRNAexpressiondatawasinvestigatedusingapanelof23functionallydiversegenesfromfivedifferentgeneontology(GO)categoriesinperipheralbloodsampledfromtenage-matchedhealthycattle.VenousbloodwascollectedinTempus™BloodRNAtubes,whichcontainreagentsthatlysebloodcellsimmediatelyandstabilisetheRNAsignature(T0).Bloodwasalsocollectedinconventionallithiumheparincollection tubes, and stored at ambient temperature for T4, T6 and T8h,priortototalRNAextraction.ThemRNAexpressionprofilesofthese23genesweredeterminedbyRT-qPCRandcomparedacrossthetimecourse.Thirteengenesshowedsignificantup-ordown-foldchangesinmRNAexpressionoverthe8htimecourse.AmongtheGOcategories,genesintheImmuneResponsecategoryshowedthemostdifferentialexpression.TheseresultsalsodemonstratedthatthechangesinmRNAexpressionfortheIFNGgene,whichencodesthecytokineIFN-g,didnotcorrespondtoIFN-g proteinlevelsestimatedusingELISA.
Reprinted from Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology 145, Sheridan, M.P., Browne, J.A., MacHugh, D.E., Costello, E., Gormley, E., Impact of delayed processing of bovine peripheral blood on differential gene expression, 199-205, Copyright 2012, with permission from Elsevier.
Transcriptional profiling of immune genes in bovine monocyte-derived macrophages exposed to bacterial antigens
Taraktsoglou, M.1, Szalabska, U.1, Magee, D.A.1, Browne, J.A.1, Sweeney, T.2, Gormley, E.3, MacHugh, D.E.1, 4
1 UCD Animal Genomics Laboratory, 2 UCD Molecular Biology Laboratory, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 UCD Conway Institute of Biomolecular
and Biomedical Research
Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology 140, 130-139 (2011)
TheinvolvementofToll-likereceptors(TLRs)andotherimmunesignallinggenesduringchallengeofbovinemacro-phageswithbacterialproductsderivedfromdisease-causingbacteriaincattlewasinvestigated.Anin vitro cell culture model of bovine monocyte derived macrophages (MDM) was established and these cells were exposed to purified protein derivative(PPD-b)derivedfromMycobacterium bovisandtolipopolysaccharide(LPS)derivedfromEscherichia coli.Following24hincubation,totalRNAwasextractedandexpressionofimmunerelatedgeneswasdeterminedbyrealtimequantitativereversetranscriptionPCR(qRT-PCR).ExpressionofaselectionofgenesspanningtheTLR-2andTLR-4pathways,fromtheinitialactivationofthereceptorstotheproductionofpro-inflammatorycytokinesandchemokineswasdetermined.ResultsfromrepeatexperimentsusingMDMfromsevendifferentage-matcheddairycattleshowedthatPPD-btreatmentcausedsignificantup-regulationoftheTLR2 and TLR4genesandtheexpressionprofileofTLRadaptormoleculessuggestedthatthissignallingisMYD88-dependent.Conversely,LPScausedsignificantup-regulationof TLR4viaaMYD88-independentsignallingpathway.Significantup-regulationofgenesinvolvedwithNF-kBsignal-lingwasalsodetectedinPPD-b-andLPS-treatedsamplesaccompaniedbytheexpressionofpro-inflammatorycytokine(TNF, IL1B, IL6)andchemokinegenes(IL8, CCL5, CCL3).Overall,LPSchallengeresultedinamoremarkedup-regu-lationofimmune-relatedgenes.Furthermore,themagnitudefold-changedifferenceingeneexpressionsuggests,atleastinpart,thatbovinemacrophagesproduceIFN-gasaresultofLPSchallenge.
Reprinted from Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology, 140, Taraktsoglou, M., Szalabska, U., Magee, D.A., Browne, J.A., Sweeney, T., Gormley, E., MacHugh, D.E., Transcriptional profiling of immune genes in bovine monocyte-derived macrophages exposed to bacterial antigens, 130-139, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 33
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS IN
CA
TT
lE
Sup
po
rting
stud
ies
Tuberculosis in other farmed livestock species
Granuloma encapsulation is a key factor for containing tuberculosis infection in minipigs
Gil, O.1, 2, Díaz, I.3, Vilaplana, C.1, 2, Tapia, G.4, Díaz, J.1, 2, Fort, M.3, Cáceres, N.1, 2, Pinto, S.1, 2, Caylà, J.5,
Corner, L.A.L.6, Domingo, M.3, Cardona, P.-J.1, 2
1 Unitat de Tuberculosi Experimental (UTE), Institut per a la Investigació en Ciències de la Salut Germans Trias i Pujol, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona,
Badalona, Catalonia, Spain, 2 CIBER Enfermedades Respiratorias, Instituto Carlos III, Palma de Mallorca, Spain, 3 Centre de Recerca en Sanitat Animal
(CReSA) (UAB-IRTA), Bellaterra, Catalonia, Spain, 4 Pathology Department, Hospital Universitari Germans Trias i Pujol, Badalona, Catalonia, Spain,
5 Tuberculosis Investigation Unit of Barcelona, Servei d’Epidemiologia, Agència de Salut Pública, Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain, 6 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
PloS One 5, e10030 (2010)
A transthoracic infection involving a low dose of Mycobacterium tuberculosis has been used to establish a new model of infectioninminipigs.The20-weekmonitoringperiodshowedamarkedTh1responseandpoorhumoralresponseforthewholeinfection.Adetailedhistopathologicalanalysiswasperformedafterslicingtheformalin-fixedwholelungsofeachanimal.Alllesionswererecordedandclassifiedaccordingtotheirmicroscopicaspect,theirrelationshipwiththeintralobularconnectivenetworkandtheirdegreeofmaturityinordertoobtainadisseminationratio(DR)betweenrecentandoldlesions.CFUcountsandevolutionoftheDRwithtimeshowedthattheproposedmodelcorrelatedwithacontainedinfection,decreasingfromweek9onwards.ThesefindingssuggestthattheinfectioninducesaninitialTh1response,whichisfollowedbylocalfibrosisandencapsulationofthegranulomas,therebydecreasingtheonsetofnewlesions.Twotherapeuticstrategieswereappliedinordertounderstandhowtheycouldinfluencethemodel.Thus,chemotherapywithisoniazidalonehelpedtodecreasethetotalnumberoflesions,despitetheincreaseinDRafterweek9,withsimilarkineticstothoseofthecontrolgroup,whereasadditionofatherapeuticM. tuberculosis fragment-based vaccineafterchemotherapyincreasedtheTh1andhumoralresponses,aswellasthenumberoflesions,butdecreasedtheDR.Byprovidingalocalpulmonarystructuresimilartothatinhumans,themini-pigmodelhighlightsnewaspectsthatcouldbekeytoabetterunderstandingtuberculosisinfectioncontrolinhumans.
Copyright 2010 Gil et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Biennial Report, 2010/201134
TU
BE
RC
Ul
OS
IS I
N C
AT
Tl
ESu
pp
ort
ing
stu
die
s
Tuberculosis in goats on a farm in Ireland: epidemiological investigation and control
Shanahan, A.1, Good M.1, Duignan A.1, Curtin, T.1, More S.J.2, 3
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Veterinary Record 168, 485 (2011)
Thispaperdescribesanoutbreakoftuberculosis(TB)causedbyMycobacterium bovis in a dairy goat herd on a farm in Ireland,where66.3percentoftheherdtestedpositivetothesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest(SICTT)atinitialdetection.Anepidemiologicalinvestigationwasconductedtodeterminetheoriginoftheoutbreak,consideringissuessuchasanimalmovementsandherdmanagementpractices.Infectionwasintroducedwithaconsignmentofgoats,asdeterminedbythevariablenumbertandemrepeatprofile.InfectionwaseradicatedusingatestandcullprogrammeinvolvingtheSICTT,theinterferon-gassayandamultipleximmunoassay(EnferplexTB).
Reproduced from Veterinary Record, Shanahan, A., Good M., Duignan A., Curtin, T., More S.J., 168, 485, Copyright 2011, with permission from BMJ Publishing Group Ltd.
Application of the Enfer Chemiluminescent Multiplex ELISA System for the detection of Mycobacterium bovis infection in goats
Shuralev, E.1, Quinn, P.1, Doyle, M.2, Duignan, A.3, Kwok, H.F.4, Bezos, J.5, Olwill, S.A.4, Gormley, E.2,
Aranaz, A.5, Good, M.3, Davis, W.C.6, Clarke, J.1, Whelan, C.1
1 Enfer Scientific, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 DAFM, 4 Fusion Antibodies Ltd., Belfast, Northern Ireland, 5 Centro de Vigilancia Sanitaria
Veterinaria (VISAVET), Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Madrid, Spain, 6 Department of Veterinary Microbiology and Pathology, College of Veterinary
Medicine, Washington State University, Washington, USA
Veterinary Microbiology (in press)
A study was conducted to optimise a multiplex serological immunoassay for use in identification of goats infected with Mycobacterium bovis.Toassessassayspecificity,31goatswithahistoryofbeingfreefromM. bovis infection were used.Todetermineassaysensitivity,180SingleIntradermalComparativeTuberculintest(SICTT)positivegoatswererecruited.Additionally,286SICTTnegativegoatsclassedaspotentiallyexposedanimalspresentinthesamepositiveherdswerealsoincludedinthestudy.Theresultsoftheassaydemonstratedaspecificityof100%.Themultiplexassaydetected57/60SICTT(95.0%)positiveanimalsinoneM. bovisinfectedherdand120/120(100%)inasecondherd.Inaseparateexperiment,28M. capraecultureconfirmedinfectedgoatsfromSpainwereassayed,ofwhich24(85.7%)werefoundpositiveinthetest.Theresultsshowthatinclusionofanantibodybasedassaycanimprovetheabilitytoidentify M. bovis and M. capraeinfectedgoats.Withfurtherdevelopmentandvalidationthemultiplexassaymayproveto be a useful tool for control of M. bovis and M. capraeinfectioningoats.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology 154, Shuralev, E., Quinn, P., Doyle, M., Duignan, A., Kwok, H.F., Bezos, J., Olwill, S.A., Gormley, E., Aranaz, A., Good, M., Davis, W.C., Clarke, J., Whelan, C., Application of the Enfer Chemiluminescent Multiplex ELISA System for the detection of Mycobacterium bovis infection in goats, 292-297, Copyright 2012, with permis-sion from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 35
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E IN
BO
VIN
E T
BIm
pro
ved u
nd
erstand
ing
of eco
log
y and
TB ep
idem
iolo
gy
Improved understanding of ecology and TB epidemiology
Badger ecology
Can Eurasian badger (Meles meles) numbers be predicted from sett attributes and capture history? An application and evaluation of multivariable modelling
Byrne, A.W.1, 2, O’Keeffe, J.3, 5 Sleeman, D.P.2, Davenport, J.2, Martin, S.W.4
1 Teagasc Athenry, 2 UCC School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, 3 UCD CVERA,
4 Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, Canada, 5 DAFM
Predictingbadgernumbersfromsettcharacteristicsandcapturehistoriesisofconsiderableappliedimportance.Thisability would be useful in generating probable badger densities for disease and strategic models of bovine tubercu-losis(bTB)control.Modellingisofinteresttoelucidatethefactorsthatmayimpactonbadgercaptureatlocalscales.Furthermore, badger management and vaccination programs would benefit by increasing the probability of efficiently capturingthetargetbadgerpopulations.Withinthiscontext,itwillbeinvestigatedwhetherbadgercapturenumberscanbepredictedfromfieldsignsandpreviouscapturehistories.Therelativebenefitsofdifferentmodellingapproacheswillalsobeexplored(GLM,GEE,Zero-inflatedwithPoissonorNegativeBinomialdistributions).Thedifferentmodellingtechniqueswillbecomparedintermsofmeanpredictederrorandcoverage.
Impact of culling on relative abundance of the Eurasian badger (Meles meles) in three counties in Ireland
Byrne, A.W.1, 2, O’Keeffe, J.3, 5 Sleeman, D.P.2, Davenport, J.2, Martin, S.W.4
1 Teagasc Athenry, 2 UCC School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, 3 UCD CVERA,
4 Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, Canada, 5 DAFM
TheEurasianbadger(Meles meles)hasbeenimplicatedintheepidemiologyofbovinetuberculosis(bTB)incattlepopulationsintheRepublicofIreland.BadgerpopulationshavebeensubjecttoaregulatedcullingregimeinareaswithchronichistoriesofbTBcattleherdbreakdowns.Removaldatacollectedduringthisregimefrom2004to2010willbeusedtomodeltheimpactofcullingonpopulationsinareasundercapture.Additionally, changes in field signs of badger activity will be used as an index of abundance to verify the outcomesoftheremovalmodels.Theremovalintensitieswillalsobeinvestigatedandcomparedwithpreviousexperimentalculls.Thesemodelswillelucidatetrendsinbadgerpopulationdensityovertimeinresponsetothecullingregime.
The ecology of the Eurasian badger (Meles meles) in Ireland: a review
Byrne, A.W.1, 2, Sleeman, D.P.2, O’Keeffe, J.3, 4 Davenport, J.2
1 National Biodiversity Data Centre, Waterford Institute of Technology, 2 UCC School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 DAFM
TherehasbeenextensiveresearchontheecologyoftheEurasianbadgerinIreland.Despitemuchoftherecentliterature focusing on disease (bovine tuberculosis) dynamics relating to badgers, a great deal of insight into the autecologyofthespeciesinIrelandhasemerged.AstudywillbeundertakentoreviewallrelevantandavailablestudiesrelatingtoIrishbadgerpopulations.Particulareffortwillbemadetoinvestigate‘greyliterature’(non-peer
Biennial Report, 2010/201136
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E I
N B
OV
INE
TB
Imp
rove
d u
nd
erst
and
ing
of
eco
log
y an
d T
B e
pid
emio
log
y
reviewedmaterial,includingnationalanddepartmentalresearchreportsandtheses)-oftenignoredworkthatmaycontainvaluableobservations.Thestudywillalsocomparethedifferencesandsimilaritiesofbadgerpopula-tionsbothwithin,andoutsideofIreland.
Diet of the European badger (Meles meles) in the Republic of Ireland: A comparison of results from an analysis of stomach contents and rectal faeces
Cleary, G.P.1, Corner, L.A.L.2, O’Keeffe, J.3, 4 Marples, N.M.1
1 TCD School of Natural Sciences, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 DAFM
Mammalian Biology 76, 470-475 (2011)
Thedietsofmammalshavebeeninvestigatedprimarilythroughtheanalysisoffaecalsamples.Inourstudyweanalysedbothstomachcontents,andrectalfaecesfromEuropeanbadgers.Thisapproachenabledadirectcomparisonoftheinformationderivedfromthesetwosources.Thedietarycomponentsfoundfromeachsourcewerethesame.However,it was found that, compared to stomach contents, the contribution to the diet, by volume, of plant litter, earthworms, TipulidlarvaeandadultCarabidbeetlesweresignificantlyoverestimatedbyfaecalanalysis,whilethoseofNoctuidlarvaeandCarabidbeetlelarvaeweresignificantlyunderestimated.Theanalysisofstomachcontentsshowedclearevidenceofseasonalityintheconsumptionofearthworms,Carabidbeetlelarvae,TipulidlarvaeandNoctuidlarvae.Thisseasonalitywasnotasevidentwhenthedietwasinferredbytheanalysisoffaeces.Weproposethatananalysisofstomach contents rather than of faeces, more accurately reflects the relative proportions of ingested food types, and the seasonalityofthediet.
Reprinted from Mammalian Biology, 76, Cleary, G.P., Corner, L.A.L., O’Keeffe, J., Marples, N.M., Diet of the European badger (Meles meles) in the Republic of Ireland: A comparison of results from an analysis of stomach contents and rectal faeces, 470-475, Copyright Deutsche Gesellschaft für Säugetierkunde 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Analysis of movement patterns of satellite-tracked badgers in Co. Wicklow
Delaney, J.1, Povey, C.1, Fay, B.1, Donnelly, S.1, Mullen, E.2, MacWhite, T.3, Maher, P.3, Gormley, E.4,
Good, M.3, Kelly, D.J.1, Marples, N.M.1
1 TCD School of Natural Sciences, 2 National Parks and Wildlife, 3 DAFM, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Wehaveusedhomerangedatafromsatellite-trackedbadgerstoplot‘MinimumConvexPolygon’(MCP)homerangesforeachbadgerineachmonthandhavelookedatthetrendsinaverageMCPvaluesthroughouttheyear.Theresultshaveshownthathomerangesforthemajorityofindividualsweregreatestinsummerandsmallestinwinter.Thisprovidessupportforourcurrentknowledgeoftheactivityofbadgers,asweknowthattheyarerelativelyinactiveinwinterandmuchmoreactiveinsummer.However,someindividualsappeartousealmosttheirwholesummerrangethroughout the winter season, suggesting that there is greater variation in winter behaviour than has been found previ-ously.Wearealsoinvestigatingwhetherageorsexhaveanynoticeableeffectsonhomerangesize.Todothisweareusingkernelestimates(generallyconsideredtobethebestassessmentofhomeranges)aswellasMCPs,inordertogetamoreaccuratepictureoftheirbehaviour.Thesatellite-trackinginformationonbadgermovementsisalsobeingusedto study the effects of temperature and precipitation on the home ranges by comparing the data generated during a mildwinter(2011-12)andarelativelycoldwinter(2010-2011).WearemodellingthevariationofMCPandkernelestimatesofthebadgerswithage,sex,county,rainfallandtemperaturedata.Fromthesemodelswehopetoidentifythefactorsthatbestexplainthevarianceinthedataset.Anotherstudyislookingatthethefrequencyofbadgerincur-
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 37
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E IN
BO
VIN
E T
BIm
pro
ved u
nd
erstand
ing
of eco
log
y and
TB ep
idem
iolo
gy
sionsintoorneartofarmbuildings,andwhethertheyactivelyavoidsuchincursions.Wearealsoexaminingthepreferencesofbadgersforforagingindifferentvegetationtypes.Theresultsofthisworkwillprovidefundamentalinformationonthenatureofbadgers’interactionswithfarmsandmayhaveimplicationsforthetransmissionratesoftuberculosisfrombadgerstocattle.
The effect of badger removal on road casualty mammals
O’Shea, F.1, Sleeman, D.P.2, Davenport, J.2
1 DAFM, 2 UCC School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences
Irish Naturalists’ Journal 31, 118-122 (2010)
Recordsofafiveyearsurveyofmammalianroadcasualtiesintwodifferentparts(removalandreferenceareas)oftheCo.CorkportionoftheFourAreaBadgerProjectarereported.Thereweremorehedgehog,domesticcatandfoxcasualtiesintheremovalarea,butonlythefirsttwospeciesdifferedtoastatisticallysignificantextentfromthereferencearea.Howsuchstudiesmightbeimprovedandthepossibleimplicationsforepidemiologyandbiodiversityarediscussed.
Reproduced with permission of the Irish Naturalists’ Journal.
Badger road casualties in rural areas of the Republic of Ireland
Sleeman, D.P.1, Collins, D.M.2, Davenport, J.1
1 UCC School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, 2 UCD CVERA
Roadcasualtiesareacauseofmortalityforbadgers.ThisprojectwilllookatsuchcasualtiesinrelationtoanumberofpreviouslyestimatedpopulationsinruralareasintheRepublicofIreland.
The badgers (Meles meles (L.)) of Little Island, Co. Waterford
Sleeman, D.P.1, Partridge, T.2, O’Boyle, I.2, Gormley, E.3, Toolan, D.4
1 UCC School of Biological, Earth and Environmental Sciences, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service
Irish Naturalists’ Journal 31, 94-99 (2010)
Ahighdensityislandpopulationofbadgersisdescribed.Themethodsusedinthestudytocapture,anaesthetizeandidentifybadgers,aswellastomapterritories,aredetailed.Theislandhadeightmainsettsandsixterritories.Oneterritoryhadthreemainsetts,twoofwhichhadsmallsub-territories.Badgerscapturedintheinitialstudy,andthosefounddeadfrom1998-2007,aredetailed.Thefindingofbadgerswithouttuberculosiswhichwereunwell(emaciated,withheavyectoparasiteinfestations),inbuildingsisrecorded.Theimplicationsforbadgerresearchanddiseasemanagementarediscussed.
Reproduced with permission of the Irish Naturalists’ Journal.
Biennial Report, 2010/201138
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E I
N B
OV
INE
TB
Imp
rove
d u
nd
erst
and
ing
of
eco
log
y an
d T
B e
pid
emio
log
y
TB epidemiology
Estimating the extent of spatial association of Mycobacterium bovis infection in badgers in Ireland
Kelly, G.E.1, McGrath, G.2, More, S.J.2, 3
1 UCD School of Mathematical Sciences, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Epidemiology and Infection 138, 270-279 (2010)
Mycobacterium bovis infects the wildlife species badgers Meles meleswhoarelinkedwiththespreadoftheassociateddiseasetuberculosis(TB)incattle.Controloflivestockinfectionsdependsinpartonthespatialandsocialstructureofthewildlifehost.HerewedescribespatialassociationofM. bovis infection in a badger population using data from the firstyearoftheFourAreaProjectinIreland.Usingsecond-orderintensityfunctions,weshowthereisstrongevidenceofclusteringofTBcasesineachthefourareas,i.e.aglobaltendencyforinfectedcasestooccurnearotherinfectedcases.Usingestimatedintensityfunctions,weidentifylocationswhereparticularstrainsofTBcluster.Generalizedlineargeostatistical models are used to assess the practical range at which spatial correlation occurs and is found to exceed 6 in allareas.Thestudyisofrelevanceconcerningthescaleoflocalizedbadgercullinginthecontrolofthediseaseincattle.
Reprinted from Epidemiology and Infection, 138, Kelly, G.E., McGrath, G., More, S.J., Estimating the extent of spatial asso-ciation of Mycobacterium bovis infection in badgers in Ireland, 270-279, Copyright 2010, with permission from Cambridge University Press.
Spatial clustering of TB-infected cattle herds prior to and following proactive badger removal
Kelly, G.E.1, More, S.J.2, 3
1 UCD School of Mathematical Sciences, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Epidemiology and Infection 139, 1220-1229 (2011)
Bovinetuberculosis(TB)isprimarilyadiseaseofcattle.InbothIrelandandtheUK,badgers(Meles meles) are an impor-tantwildlifereservoirofinfection.ThispaperexaminedthehypothesisthatTBisspatiallycorrelatedincattleherds,establishedtherangeofcorrelationandtheeffect,ifany,ofproactivebadgerremovalonthis.Wealsore-analyseddatafromtheFourAreaProjectinIreland,alarge-scaleinterventionstudyaimedatassessingtheeffectofproactivebadgercullingonbovineTBincidenceincattleherds,takingpossiblespatialcorrelationintoaccount.Weestablishedthatinfected herds are spatially correlated (the scale of spatial correlation is presented), but at a scale that varies with time and indifferentareas.Spatialcorrelationpersistsfollowingproactivebadgerremoval.
Reprinted from Epidemiology and Infection, 139, Kelly, G.E., More, S.J., Spatial clustering of TB-infected cattle herds prior to and following proactive badger removal, 1220-1229, Copyright 2011, with permission from Cambridge University Press.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 39
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E IN
BO
VIN
E T
BIm
pro
ved u
nd
erstand
ing
of eco
log
y and
TB ep
idem
iolo
gy
Tuberculosis in cattle herds are sentinels for Mycobacterium bovis infection in European badgers (Meles meles): the Irish Greenfield Study
Murphy, D.1, Gormley, E.1, Collins, D.M.2, McGrath, G.2, Sovsic, E.3, Costello, E.3, Corner, L.A.L.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service
Veterinary Microbiology 151, 120-125 (2011)
InIreland,badgersareremovedinresponsetotuberculosis(TB)breakdownsincattleherds(focalculling).Prevalencestudies,conductedusingadetailedpostmortemandbacteriologicalexamination,showedthat36-50%ofbadgerswereinfected with Mycobacterium bovis.FocalcullingformspartofthemediumtermnationalstrategyforthecontrolofbovineTBincattleandisbasedonthepremisethatbadgersinareaswithherdbreakdownshaveahigherprevalenceofinfectionthanthebadgerpopulationatlarge.However,thehypothesisthatcattlecanbeusedassentinelsforinfectioninthebadgerpopulationhasneverbeenformallytested.Inthisstudywetestedthehypothesisbydeterminingtheinfectionprevalenceinbadgersinareaswheretherehadbeenhistorically,aconsistentlylowprevalenceofinfectionincattle.LowcattleTBprevalenceareasweredefinedasthoseherdswith≤2standardreactorsintheannualroundofskintestingoverthepreceding5years(Greenfieldsites).UsingGIS,andadjustingforvariationinlanduse,previouscullingandcattledensity,198Greenfieldsiteswereidentifiedandsurveyed,and138areaswithbadgersettsorsignsofbadgeractivitywereidentified.Asinglebadgerwasremovedfrom87sitesandallwereexaminedusingdetailedpostmortemandbacteriologicalprocedures.AprevalenceofM. bovisinfectionof14.9%wasfoundintheGreenfieldsitebadgers.Thisprevalence was significantly lower (P<0.001)thaninbadgersremovedduringfocalculling(36.6%).TheresultsvalidatetheuseofcattleassentinelsforTBinbadgersandsupportthemediumtermnationalstrategyforthecontrolofbovineTB.ThegeographicvariationinM. bovisinfectionprevalenceintheIrishbadgerpopulationswillbeusedwhendevisingstrategiesfortheincorporationofbadgervaccinationintothelongtermbovineTBcontrolprogramme.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology, 151, Murphy, D., Gormley, E., Collins, D.M., McGrath, G., Sovsic, E., Costello, E., Corner, L.A.L., Tuberculosis in cattle herds are sentinels for Mycobacterium bovis infection in European badgers (Meles meles): the Irish Greenfield Study, 120-125, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Mycobacterial infections in multiple species: Implications for diagnosis and control
Corner, L.A.L.1, Gormley, E.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The Veterinary Journal (in press)
This paper discusses the significance of the ever-increasing numbers of different pathogenic mycobacterial species affecting bothdomesticandwildanimals.Throughadvancesindiagnosticsandincreasedepidemiologicalinvestigations,itshouldbepossibletodefinethereservoirstatusofeachanimalhostandtoestablishthesignificanceintermsofinfectionrisk.
Adapted from The Veterinary Journal 191, Corner, L.A.L., Gormley, E., Mycobacterial infections in multiple species: Implications for diagnosis and control, 141-142, Copyright 2012, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/201140
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E I
N B
OV
INE
TB
Imp
rove
d u
nd
erst
and
ing
of
eco
log
y an
d T
B e
pid
emio
log
y
Mycobacterium bovis infection in the Eurasian badger (Meles meles): the disease, pathogenesis, epidemiology and control
Corner, L.A.L.1, Murphy, D.2, Gormley, E.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service
Journal of Comparative Pathology 144, 1-24 (2011)
Eurasianbadgers(Meles meles) are an important wildlife reservoir of tuberculosis (Mycobacterium bovis)infectioninIrelandandtheUnitedKingdom.Aspartofnationalprogrammestocontroltuberculosisinlivestock,considerableefforthasbeendevotedtostudyingthediseaseinbadgersandthishasleadtoarapidincreaseinourknowledgeoftuberculosisinthishost.Tuberculosis in badgers is a chronic infection and in a naturally-infected population the severity of disease can vary widely, fromlatentinfection(infectionwithoutclinicalsignsandnovisiblelesions)toseverediseasewithgeneralizedpathology.Thehigh prevalence of pulmonary infection strongly supports the lungs as the principal site of primary infection and that inhala-tionofinfectiousaerosolparticlesistheprincipalmodeoftransmission.However,otherroutes,includingtransmissionviainfectedbitewounds,areknowntooccur.Theantemortemdiagnosisofinfectionisdifficulttoachieve,asclinicalexamina-tionandimmunologicalandbacteriologicalexaminationofclinicalsamplesareinsensitivediagnosticprocedures.Becauseinfectioninthemajorityofbadgersislatent,thegrosspostmortemdiagnosisisalsoinsensitive.Adefinitivediagnosiscanonly be made by the isolation of M. bovis.However,togainahighlevelofsensitivityinthebacteriologicalexamination,alargenumberoftissuesfromeachbadgermustbeculturedandsensitiveculturemethodsemployed.Thetransmissionandmaintenance of M. bovis in badger populations are complex processes where many factors influence within-population preva-lenceandratesoftransmission.Badgersocialstructuresandthelongevityofinfectedanimalsmakethemanidealmainte-nance host for M. bovisinfection.Badgersaredirectlyimplicatedinthetransmissionofinfectiontocattleandtheinabilitytoeradicatethediseasefromcattleis,inpart,aconsequenceoftheinteractionsbetweenthetwospecies.Adetailedunder-standingandknowledgeoftheepidemiologyandpathogenesisofthediseasearerecognizedasfundamentalfordevisingnewstrategiestocontrolinfectionwithaviewtolimitinginterspeciestransmission.Vaccination,inspiteofformidablechallenges,is seen as the best long-term strategy option and studies with captive badgers have shown that vaccination with M. bovis BacillusCalmette-Guérin(BCG)inducesprotectionwhendeliveredbyavarietyofroutes.Continuedresearchisrequiredtodevelopeffectivetechnologiestocontrolthediseasebothinbadgersandcattle.Acombinationofstrategies,whichemploytheoptimaluseandtargetingofresources,islikelytomakeasignificantcontributiontowardseradicationofthedisease.
Adapted from Journal of Comparative Pathology, 144, Corner, L.A.L., Murphy, D., Gormley, E., Mycobacterium bovis infection in the Eurasian badger (Meles meles): the disease, pathogenesis, epidemiology and control, 1-24, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
The prevalence and distribution of Mycobacterium bovis infection in European badgers (Meles meles) as determined by enhanced post mortem examination and bacteriological culture
Murphy, D.1, Gormley, E.1, Costello, E.2, O’Meara, D.2, Corner, L.A.L.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service
Research in Veterinary Science 88, 1-5 (2010)
The accurate diagnosis of Mycobacterium bovisinfectioninbadgersiskeytounderstandingtheepidemiologyoftuber-culosisinthisspeciesandhassignificantimplicationsfordevisingstrategiestolimitspreadofthedisease.Inthisstudy,badgers (n=215)intheRepublicofIrelandwereexaminedpostmortemandtissueswerecollectedfromarangeofanatomical locations and pooled into groups for bacterial culture of M. bovis.Byassessingconfirmedgrossvisiblelesions
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 41
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E IN
BO
VIN
E T
BIn
fection
con
trol strateg
ies
(VL)alone,infectionwasdetectedin12.1%ofbadgers.However,byincludingtheresultsofallculturepositivepooledsamples,theoverallinfectionprevalenceincreasedsignificantlyto36.3%.Two-thirds(66.7%)ofinfectedanimalshadnovisiblelesions(NVL).Whilethethoraciccavity(lungsandpulmonarylymphnodes)wasfoundtobethemostcommon site of infection, in a proportion of animals infection was absent from the lungs and draining lymph nodes and wasconfinedtothelymphnodesofthecarcaseorthehead.Thismayindicateanearlyextrapulmonarydisseminationofinfection or alternatively, in the case of the head lymph nodes, a secondary pathogenic pathway involving the lymphoid tissuesoftheupperrespiratorytract(URT).
Reprinted from Research in Veterinary Science, 88, Murphy, D., Gormley, E., Costello, E., O’Meara, D., Corner, L.A.L., The prevalence and distribution of Mycobacterium bovis infection in European badgers (Meles meles) as determined by enhanced post mortem examination and bacteriological culture, 1-5, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Infection control strategies
Badger removal
A comparison of the effectiveness of badger removal programs: Wildlife Administration Unit vs. pre-2004 licenced capture
McGrath, G.1, Clegg, T.A.1
1 UCD CVERA
Inresponsetosevereoutbreaksoftuberculosisincattle,anepidemiologicalinvestigationiscarriedouttoestablishthesourceofinfection.Ifbadgersareimplicated,badgerremovalisconductedunderlicencebytheDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine.Fromthelate1980’suntil2004,thebadgerremovalprogramcomprisedoftheremovalofbadgersasasingleeventfromsettsfoundwithin1kilometreofthebreakdownherd.Since2004,themethodofbadgerremovalchangedfromthissingleremovaleventtoacontinuedremovalofbadgersfromsetts(mainsetts1.5kilometresandothersetts2kmfromthebreakdownherd).Thisstudyaimstocomparetheeffectivenessofthesetwobadgerremovalapproachesbyexaminingtheircomparativesurvivaltimesfollowingtheinitialbadgerremovals.Severityoffuturebreakdownscouldalsobeusedasameasureofdeterminingeffectiveness.Thestudycouldbeexpandedtoincludetheeffectonneighbouringfarmsand/orfarmsuptoadefineddistance.
Risk-based badger removal and the subsequent herd breakdown rate for Bovine Tuberculosis in Co. Monaghan, Ireland
White, P.W.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM
Forthepurposesofthisstudy,aherdisclassedasan“indexherd”where,followinganER76epidemiologicalinvestiga-tionintothesourceofabTBbreakdown,approvalisgrantedforlocalbadgerremoval.ThisstudyaimstoassesstheeffectoflocalbadgerremovalontheriskofanextherdbTBbreakdownamongneighbouringherdssurroundinganindexherd.Toachievethis,wewillconductasurvivalanalysiswiththeoutcomebeingtimetonextbreakdownforherdssurroundingsettsfromwhichbadgerswereremovedundertheWildlifeUnitprogram.Herdexposureismeasuredastheproportionofaherd(s)landareawithin1kmofanysettremoval.WewilltestthehypothesisthatthehazardofbTBforherdswithahighpercentageoflandareawithin1kmofsettremovaldonotdifferfromherdswithalowpercentageoflandareawithin1kmofsettremoval.
Biennial Report, 2010/201142
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E I
N B
OV
INE
TB
Infe
ctio
n c
on
tro
l st
rate
gie
s
Progress towards a badger vaccine
Badger tuberculosis vaccine
Gormley, E.1, Murphy, D.2, Costello, E.2, Duignan, A.3, Corner, L.A.L.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 3 DAFM
a. Vaccine development (studies with captive badgers)ThefirstphaseofresearchintoBCGvaccinationagainsttuberculosisincaptivebadgers,anintegratedseriesofsevenexperimentsandassociatedstudiesthatcommencedin2001,hasbeencompleted.ThesestudieshaveestablishedasproofofprinciplethatvaccinationofbadgerswithBCG,whendeliveredbyavarietyofroutes,canprotectbadgersagainsttuberculosis.TheBCGvaccinehasbeenchosenforusebasedonitsavailability,lowproductioncostandmuchexperienceofitsapplicationindomesticandwildanimals,andhumans.AnoralvaccinedevelopedbyDr.FrankAldwell,OtagoUniversity,NewZealand,hasbeenshowntoworkincaptivebadgersandpavesthewayfordevelopmentoforaldeliverysystemsforuseinwildbadgers.Inourmostrecentstudy,wehaveshownthattheoralvaccineiseffectiveagainstchallenge with a low dose of M. bovis,atlevelslikelytobeencounteredunderconditionsofnaturaltransmission.Thedatahasgivenusamuchbetterunderstandingofhowthevaccineislikelytoperformundernaturalconditionsandwillfacilitatethedevelopmentofstrategiestodeliverthevaccinetobadgerpopulations.Aspartofthesestudies,andworkingcloselywithcolleaguesatAHVLA(WeybridgeUK),wehelpeddevelopandassessarangeofin vitro diagnostic assays based on the immunological responses of badgers to challenge with M. bovis.
b. The vaccine field trialThesuccessofthecaptivebadgerstudieshaspavedthewayforthetestingoforalBCGvaccineinalarge-scalefieldtrial.TheBCGvaccinefieldtrialhastwoprincipalobjectives.ThesearetovalidatetheresultsofcaptivebadgerstudiesandshowthatBCGvaccineisprotectiveinnaturallyexposedwildbadgers,andtoestimatevaccineefficacyunderfieldcondi-tions.TheaimofthefieldtrialistoestimatetheefficacyofBCGvaccineandtodemonstrateprotectioninawildbadgerpopulationbycomparingprevalenceoftuberculosisinvaccinatedandnon-vaccinatedbadgersafterthreeyears.AsecondaryoutcomeofthefieldtrialwillbetomeasuretheeffectofBCGvaccineinbadgers with pre-existing M. bovisinfection.Inadditiontoprovidingameasurement of protection and an estimate of vaccine efficacy, the field trial will provide a practical basis for understanding the logistics of oral vaccinedeliverytowildbadgerpopulations.
ThefirstcapturesweepcommencedinSeptember2009and,todate,fivecapturesweepsofthevaccinefieldtrialhasbeencompleted.Thetrialareaofapprox.755squarekilometresisdividedintothreezones(Figure1)eachwithadifferentlevelofvaccinecoverage.Vaccineandplacebo are blind coded and field staff are unaware of the vaccine status ofthebadgerstheyaretreating.Badgerscapturedinthemiddlezonearerandomlyassignedvaccineorplaceboonapproximatelya50:50basis,100%ofbadgerscapturedinthenorthandsouthwillreceiveeithervaccine or placebo therefore there will be a gradient of vaccine cover from 0%to50%to100%vaccinationfromnorthtosouthorsouthtonorth.
• Theentiretrialareahasbeentrappedforthefifth timeoverAutumn/Winter2011
• Duringthefifthsweepofthetrialarea,badgers werecapturedandexaminedon250occasions(Table1)
• Thetotaltreatmentstodateacrossthethree zonessincestartoffieldtrialisshowninTable2
Figure 1 – Outline of vaccine trial area and divisions into three zones
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 43
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E IN
BO
VIN
E T
BIn
fection
con
trol strateg
ies
Table 1. Age and sex of the badgers examined (n = 250) in sweep 5 of the vaccine trial
Cub Juvenile Adult Old Total
Female 0 38 69 19 126
Male 0 34 82 8 124
Total 0 72 151 27 250
Table 2. Treatment to date in the three zones of the trial area*
1* 2* Total**
Zone A 0 408 408
Zone B 99 108 207
Zone C 369 1 370
Total 468 517 985
*Badgersreceiveeithervaccineorplacebo,blind-coded1&2**Totalincludes208badgersthatwererevaccinatedinsweep3,4and5
Attheendofthe3yearstudyperiod(Aug2012),thetrialsitewillbedepopulatedandallbadgerswillbeexaminedfortuberculosis by detailed post mortem examination that will include an examination for visible lesions, histologic lesions, andmycobacteriology.TheisolationofM. bovis from post mortem or clinical samples (wound exudates or tracheal swabs)willbeusedtodefineacaseoftuberculosis.Theresultsandexperiencegainedfromthefieldtrialwillfacilitatethedevelopmentofstrategiesforintroductionofvaccinationintothenationalprogram.
c. Development of badger immunodiagnosticsWehavecontinuedtodevelopandassessarangeofimmunodiagnosticteststhatwillberequiredfortuberculosissurveil-lanceinbadgerpopulationstomonitortheeffectofvaccination.Thiswork,carriedoutincollaborationwithAHVLAWeybridgeandwithEnfergroup,isfocusedondevelopingcell–mediatedimmuneandantibodybaseddiagnostictestsforbadgers.Todate,wehaveestablishedthatthesensitivityofalltheimmunodiagnosticassaysimprovesasthediseaseseverityincreasesandthatthisismorepronouncedwiththeserologicalbasedassays.Theserologytestsarebeingappliedtothefieldtrialbloodsamplesandwillassistinthevalidationofthetestsonnaturallyinfectedbadgers.
Biennial Report, 2010/201144
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E I
N B
OV
INE
TB
Infe
ctio
n c
on
tro
l st
rate
gie
s
Trial design to estimate the effect of vaccination on tuberculosis incidence in badgers
Aznar, I.1, McGrath, G.1, Murphy, D.2, Corner, L.A.L.3, Gormley, E.3, Frankena, K.4, More, S.J.1, 3, Martin, W.5,
O’Keeffe, J.1, 6 De Jong, M.C.M.4
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 Quantitative Veterinary Epidemiology, Wageningen University,
Wageningen, The Netherlands, 5 Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, Ontario, Canada, 6 DAFM
Veterinary Microbiology 151, 104-111 (2011)
The principal wildlife reservoir of Mycobacterium bovisinIrelandistheEuropeanbadger.StudiesintheRepublicofIreland(RoI)haveshownthatbadgersculledinassociationwithcattleherdtuberculosisbreakdowns(focalculling)haveahigherprevalenceofinfectionthanthebadgerpopulationatlarge.Thisobservationisonerationaleforthemediumtermnationalstrategyoffocalbadgerculling.Avaccinationstrategyforthecontrolofbovinetuberculosis(bTB)inbadgersisapreferredlong-termoption.TheBacillusCalmette-Guérin(BCG)vaccinehasbeenshowntodecreasediseaseseverityincaptivebadgersundercontrolledconditions.Asthevaccinehasbeentestedinacontrolledenviron-ment with precise information on infection pressure, it cannot be assumed a priori that the effects of vaccination are similarinthewild,whereotherenvironmentaland/orecologicalfactorsprevail.ForthisreasonwehavedesignedavaccinefieldtrialtoassesstheimpactofvaccinationontheincidenceofTBinfectioninawildbadgerpopulation.Theselectedstudyareaforthevaccinetrial(approximately755squarekilometers)isdividedintothreezoneseachofwhichhassimilarcharacteristicsintermsofsize,numberofmainbadgersetts,cattleherds,cattleandlandclassificationtype.Threevaccinationlevels(100%,50%and0%)willbeallocatedtothethreezonesinawaythatagradientofvaccina-tioncoverageNorthtoSouthisachieved.Themiddlezone(zoneB)willbevaccinatedata50%coveragebutzoneAandCwillberandomlyallocatedwith100%or0%vaccinationcoverage.VaccinationwithinzoneBwillbedonerandomlyatindividualbadgerlevel.Theobjectiveofthispaperistodescribethedesignofafieldtuberculosisvaccina-tiontrialforbadgers,theepidemiologicalmethodsthatwereusedtodesignthetrialandthesubsequentdataanalysis.TheanalysiswillenableustoquantifythemagnitudeoftheobservedvaccinationeffectonM. bovis transmission in badgersunderfieldconditionsandtoimproveourknowledgeofthebiologicaleffectsofvaccinationonsusceptibilityandinfectiousness.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology, 151, Aznar, I., McGrath, G., Murphy, D., Corner, L.A.L., Gormley, E., Frankena, K., More, S.J., Martin, W., O’Keeffe, J., De Jong, M.C.M., Trial design to estimate the effect of vaccination on tuberculosis incidence in badgers, 104-111, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Using simulation to estimate the power of a badger vaccine trial against Mycobacterium bovis in badgers
Aznar, I.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Frankena, K.3, de Jong, M.C.M.3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 Quantitative Veterinary Epidemiology, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands
TheaimofthisstudywastoestimatethepowerofabadgervaccinefieldtrialdesignedintheRepublicofIrelandtohelpinthecontrolofbovinetuberculosisusingsimulationtechniques.Theeffectsofsamplesize(recapturepercentage),sensitivityandspecificityofthediagnostictest,transmissionratebetweenunvaccinatedbadgers,VaccineEfficacyforSusceptibility(VES)andVaccineEfficacyforInfectiousness(VEI),onstudypowerweredetermined.Samplesizehadasmalleffectonpower.Studypowerincreasedwithincreasingtransmissionratebetweennon-vaccinatedbadgers.ChangesinVEShadahigherimpactonpowerthanchangesinVEI.However,thelargesteffectonstudypowerwasseenbychangesinthespecificityofthediagnostictest.Theeffectofchangesinsensitivityonstudypowerwasmuchlower.Therefore,itiscriticalthatthediagnostictestusedinthebadgervaccinetrialisoptimizedtomaximisetestspecificity.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 45
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E IN
BO
VIN
E T
BIn
fection
con
trol strateg
ies
Infection dynamics and effective control strategies of tuberculosis in badgers and cattle of Ireland
Aznar, I.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Frankena, K.3, de Jong, M.C.M.3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 Quantitative Veterinary Epidemiology, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands
Themainobjectiveistoassesstheimpactofinterventionsonbovinetuberculosis(bTB)prevalenceincattleandbadgers;forthisamathematicalmodelofbTBtransmissionthatdescribesthediseaseincattleandbadgersintheRepublicofIrelandwillbedeveloped.Thehypothesisisthatcontrol,withtheultimategoaloferadication,cannotbeachieveduntilbadger-to-cattletransmissioniseffectivelyaddressed.Datafromongoingfieldtrials(particularlydatarelatedtoefficacyofthebadgervaccine)anddatafrompreviousresearchworkwillbeutilizedtoinformparameterestimation.Experimentalwork(theexactnatureofwhichwilldependonidentifiedgapsintheknowledgerequiredforparameterestimation)willalsobecarriedout.
Optimisation of a multiple antigen ELISA test to be used in a badger vaccine trial
Aznar, I.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Frankena, K.3, de Jong, M.C.M.3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 Quantitative Veterinary Epidemiology, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands
ThemainobjectiveofthisstudywastooptimizeadiagnostictestforM. bovis infection in live badgers trapped during thebadgervaccinetrialinIrelandusingamultiplexchemiluminiscentassay(EnferScientific).Atotalof215bloodsamples(including200bloodsamplesusedbyWhelanet al.,2009)weretestedagainstapanelof8M. bovisantigens.Theoptimizationwasdonewhilekeepingspecificityat99.99%toallowforareasonablepower(60-80%)tobeobtainedinthevaccinetrial.WealsoaimedtoexploretheeffectsofvaccinationontestcharacteristicsandreviewtheimplicationsforanalysisofthedataobtainedfromtheKilkennybadgervaccinetrial.
Biennial Report, 2010/201146
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E I
N B
OV
INE
TB
Infe
ctio
n c
on
tro
l st
rate
gie
s
Bacillus Calmette-Guérin vaccination reduces the severity and progression of tuberculosis in badgers
Chambers, M.A.1, Rogers, F.1, 2, Delahay, R.J.2, Lesellier, S.1, Ashford, R.1, Dalley, D.1, Gowtage, S.1,
Davé, D.1, Palmer, S.1, Brewer, J.1, Crawshaw, T.1, Clifton-Hadley, R.1, Carter, S.2, Cheeseman, C.2, Hanks,
C.2, Murray, A.2, Palphramand, K.2, Pietravalle, S.2, Smith, G.C.2, Tomlinson, A.2, Walker, N.J.2, Wilson, G.J.2,
Corner, L.A.L.3, Rushton, S.P.4, Shirley, M.D.F.4, Gettinby, G.5, McDonald, R.A.2, Hewinson, R.G.1
1 Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Surrey, United Kingdom, 2 Food and Environment Research Agency, York, United Kingdom, 3 UCD School of Veterinary
Medicine, 4 School of Biology, University of Newcastle, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom, 5 Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of
Strathclyde, Glasgow, United Kingdom
Proceedings of the Royal Society B 278, 1913-1920 (2011)
Controlofbovinetuberculosis(TB)incattlehasprovenparticularlychallengingwherereservoirsofinfectionexistinwildlifepopulations.InBritainandIreland,controlishamperedbyareservoirofinfectioninEurasianbadgers(Meles meles).BadgercullinghaspositiveandnegativeeffectsonbovineTBincattleandisdifficult,costlyandcontroversial.HereweshowthatBacillusCalmette-Guérin(BCG)vaccinationofcaptivebadgersreducedtheprogression,severityand excretion of Mycobacterium bovisinfectionafterexperimentalchallenge.Inaclinicalfieldstudy,BCGvaccinationoffree-livingbadgersreducedtheincidenceofpositiveserologicaltestresultsby73.8percent.Incommonwithotherspecies,BCGdidnotappeartopreventinfectionofbadgerssubjectedtoexperimentalchallenge,butdidsignificantlyreducetheoveralldiseaseburden.BCGvaccinationofbadgerscouldcompriseanimportantcomponentofacompre-hensiveprogrammeofmeasurestocontrolbovineTBincattle.
Reprinted from Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 278, Chambers, M.A., Rogers, F., Delahay, R.J., Lesellier, S., Ashford, R., Dalley, D., Gowtage, S., Davé, D., Palmer, S., Brewer, J., Crawshaw, T., Clifton-Hadley, R., Carter, S., Cheeseman, C., Hanks, C., Murray, A., Palphramand, K., Pietravalle, S., Smith, G.C., Tomlinson, A., Walker, N.J., Wilson, G.J., Corner, L.A.L., Rushton, S.P., Shirley, M.D.F., Gettinby, G., McDonald, R.A., Hewinson, R.G., Bacillus Calmette-Guérin vaccina-tion reduces the severity and progression of tuberculosis in badgers, 1913-1920, Copyright 2011, with permission from The Royal Society.
Oral vaccination of badgers (Meles meles) with BCG and protective immunity against endobronchial challenge with Mycobacterium bovis
Corner, L.A.L.1, Costello, E.2, O’Meara, D.2, Lesellier, S.1, 5, Aldwell, F.E.3, Singh, M.4, Hewinson, R.G.5,
Chambers, M.A.5, Gormley, E.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 3 Immune Solutions Ltd., Centre for Innovation, The University of Otago,
Dunedin, New Zealand, 4 LIONEX GmbH, Braunschweig, Germany, 5 TB Research Group, Department of Statutory and Exotic Bacteria, Veterinary
Laboratories Agency Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom
Vaccine 28, 6265-6272 (2010)
Eurasianbadgers(Meles meles) are a reservoir host of Mycobacterium bovis and are implicated in the transmission of tuberculosistocattleinIrelandandGreatBritain.Thedevelopmentofavaccineforuseinbadgersisconsideredakeyelementofanylong-termsustainablecampaigntoeradicatethediseasefromlivestockinbothcountries.TheaimofthisstudywastoinvestigatetheprotectiveresponseofbadgersvaccinatedorallywithBacilleCalmette-Guérin(BCG)encapsulated in a lipid formulation, followed by experimental challenge with M. bovis.Agroupofbadgerswasvacci-natedbyinoculatingtheBCG-lipidmixturecontainingapproximately108colonyformingunits(cfu)ofBCGintotheoesophagus.Thecontrolgroupwasshaminoculatedwiththelipidformulationonly.Thirteenweeksaftervaccination
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 47
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E IN
BO
VIN
E T
BIn
fection
con
trol strateg
ies
allthebadgerswerechallengedwithapproximately104 cfu of M. bovisdeliveredbyendobronchialinoculation.Bloodsamplesweretakenthroughoutthestudyandthecellmediatedimmune(CMI)responsesinperipheralbloodweremonitoredbytheIFN-gammaELISAandELISPOTassay.At17weeksafterinfectionallthebadgerswereexaminedpostmortemtoassessthepathologicalandbacteriologicalresponsestochallenge.Allbadgersinbothgroupswerefoundtobeinfected.However,asignificantprotectiveeffectofBCGvaccinationwasmeasuredasadecreaseinthenumberandseverityofgrosslesions,lowerbacterialloadinthelungs,andfewersitesofinfection.TheanalysisofimmuneresponsesshowedthatvaccinationwithBCGdidnotgenerateanydetectableCMIimmunologicalresponses,howeverthe levels of the responses increased in both groups following M. bovisinfection.TheresultsofthestudyshowedthatvaccinationwithoralBCGinthelipidformulationgeneratedaprotectiveeffectinthebadgers.
Reprinted from Vaccine, 28, Corner, L.A.L., Costello, E., O’Meara, D., Lesellier, S., Aldwell, F.E., Singh, M., Hewinson, R.G., Chambers, M.A., Gormley, E., Oral vaccination of badgers (Meles meles) with BCG and protective immunity against endobronchial challenge with Mycobacterium bovis, 6265-6272, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Control of tuberculosis in badgers by vaccination: Where next?
Gormley, E.1, Corner, L.A.L.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The Veterinary Journal 189, 239-241 (2011)
Withthedevelopmentofanoralvaccineforuseinbadgerscontinuing,thispaperexaminesarangeofstrategicoptionsavailableforvaccinationthatmightbeemployedtocontrolanderadicateTBinbadgers,andthebeneficialimpactthiswillhaveincattleherds.
Adapted from The Veterinary Journal, 189, Gormley, E., Corner, L.A.L., Control of tuberculosis in badgers by vaccination: Where next?, 239-241, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/201148
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E I
N B
OV
INE
TB
Infe
ctio
n c
on
tro
l st
rate
gie
s
Evaluation of attractant flavours for use in oral vaccine baits for badgers (Meles meles)
Kelly, D.J.1, Corner, L.A.L.2, Gormley, E.2, Murphy, D.2, Costello, E.3, Aldwell, F.E.4, Marples, N.M.1
1 TCD School of Natural Sciences, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 4 University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand
European Journal of Wildlife Research 57, 767-774 (2011)
Europeanbadgers(Meles meles) are a wildlife reservoir for Mycobacterium bovisinfection(tuberculosis)inIrelandandtheUKandareimplicatedinthetransmissionofinfectiontolivestock.VaccinationofbadgerswiththehumanBCGvaccine(BacilleCalmetteGuérin)isconsideredasanimportantstrategytoreducetheburdenofdiseaseinthisspecies,andapragmaticapproachislikelytoinvolveoralvaccination.Inthisstudy,weevaluatedninedifferentflavoursforuseasattractantsinaprototypeoralvaccinebaitforEuropeanbadgers(M. meles): aniseed, apple, cocoa powder, carob powder,curry,fish,garlic,peanutandstrawberry.Thebaitmatrixwascomposedofanaturallipidformulation,devel-opedasavehiclefororalvaccinationagainsttuberculosisinwildlife.A‘foodforwork’paradigmwasemployedduringthetrialstoensuretheanimalswereactivelyseekingthebaits.Thetrialsshowedcarobandcocoapowderswereequallyattractiveandmoreattractivethananyoftheothercandidates.Carobandcocoashowpotentialasbaitattractantsforbadgersandmightformpartofanovelvaccinedeliverysystem.
With kind permission from Springer Science+Business Media: European Journal of Wildlife Research, 57, 2011, 767-774, Kelly, D.J., Corner, L.A.L., Gormley, E., Murphy, D., Costello, E., Aldwell, F.E., Marples, N.M., Copyright Springer-Verlag 2011.
The development of a bait delivery system for oral vaccination of badgers against tuberculosis
Kelly, D.J.1, Gormley, E.2, Corner, L.A.L.2, Marples, N.M.1
1 TCD School of Natural Sciences, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Thisworkhasidentifiedthepotentialofcarobasanattractantforusewithoralvaccinebaitsandhasestablishedtheimportanceofpre-feedingwhenintroducing“flapjack”baitsto“naïve”Irishbadgerpopulations.Wehavefoundthatpre-feedingwasmosteffectivewhenthetrialbaitsweremostsimilartothepre-fedbaits,andthatpackagedbaitscanbeignorediftheyarenotcoatedinanattractant.Theresultsalsosuggestthatburyingbaitsmaystimulatenaturalfeedingbehaviours.Thiscouldimplythatburiedbaitsmaybemoreattractivetobadgersthanbaitsplacedinsettentrances,despitethelatterbeingmoreeasilyavailable.Thedevelopmentofabaitfororalvaccinationiscontinuing.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 49
Th
E R
Ol
E O
f W
IlD
lIf
E IN
BO
VIN
E T
BIn
fection
con
trol strateg
ies
Protection of Eurasian badgers (Meles meles) from tuberculosis after intra-muscular vaccination with different doses of BCG
Lesellier, S.1, Palmer, S.1, Gowtage-Sequiera, S.1, Ashford, R.1, Dalley, D.1, Davé, D.1, Weyer, U.1,
Salguero, F.J.1, Nuñez, A.1, Crawshaw, T.2, Corner, L.A.L.3, Hewinson, R.G.1, Chambers, M.A.1
1 Veterinary Laboratories Agency-Weybridge, Surrey, United Kingdom, 2 Veterinary Laboratories Agency-Starcross, Exeter, United Kingdom,
3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Vaccine 29, 3782–3790 (2011)
Mycobacterium bovisinfectioniswidespreadinEurasianbadger(Meles meles)populationsinGreatBritainandtheRepublicofIrelandwheretheyactasawildlifereservoirofinfectionforcattle.Removalofinfectedbadgerscansignificantlyreducetheincidenceofbovinetuberculosis(TB)inlocalcattleherds.However,controlmeasuresbasedoncullingofnativewildlifearecontentiousandmayevenbedetrimentaltodiseasecontrol.VaccinatingbadgerswithBacillusCalmette-Guérin(BCG)hasbeenshowntobeefficaciousagainstexperimentallyinducedTBofbadgerswhenadministeredsubcutaneouslyandorally.Vaccinationmaybeanalternativeorcomplementarystrategytootherdiseasecontrolmeasures.Asthesubcutaneousrouteisimpracticalforvaccinatingwildbadgersandanoralvaccinebaitformulationiscurrentlyunavailable,weevaluatedtheintramuscular(IM)routeofBCGadministration.IthasbeendemonstratedthattheIMrouteissafeinbadgers.IMadministrationhasthepracticaladvantageofbeingrelativelyeasytoperformontrappedwildbadgerswithoutrecoursetochemicalimmobilisation.WereporttheevaluationoftheefficacyofIMadministrationofBCGDanishstrain1331attwodifferentdoses:thedoseprescribedforadulthumans(2-8×105colonyformingunits)anda10-foldhigherdose.Vaccinationgeneratedadose-dependentcell-mediatedimmune response characterised by the production of interferon-g(IFNg) and protection against endobronchial chal-lenge with virulent M. bovis.Protection,expressedintermsofasignificantreductionintheseverityofdisease,thenumber of tissues containing acid-fast bacilli, and reduced bacterial excretion was statistically significant with the higherdoseonly.
Reprinted from Vaccine, 29, Lesellier, S., Palmer, S., Gowtage-Sequiera, S., Ashford, R., Dalley, D., Davé, D., Weyer, U., Salguero, F.J., Nuñez, A., Crawshaw, T., Corner, L.A.L., Hewinson, R.G., Chambers, M.A., Protection of Eurasian badgers (Meles meles) from tuberculosis after intra-muscular vaccination with different doses of BCG, 3782–3790, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/201150
CO
NT
RIB
UT
ING
TO
NA
TIO
NA
l T
B P
Ol
ICy
The
nat
ion
al p
rog
ram
me
The national programme
The number of TB reactors detected in Ireland each year between 1959 and 2011.
Progress in tuberculosis eradication in Ireland
Sheridan, M.1
1 DAFM
Veterinary Microbiology 151, 160-169 (2011)
IrelandranaconventionaltestandslaughterBovineTuberculosiseradicationprogrammefrom1954until1988.ThisprogrammefulfilledourtradingrequirementsbutfailedtoeradicateTB.Atthispointamajorinitiative,ERAD,waslaunched targeted with reducing the disease levels by half within a four-year period and devising the strategy and supportsnecessarytoachievefinaleradication.ThelessonslearnedatthattimehaveinformedIreland’seradicationprogrammeeversince.Eradicationwasnotpossiblewithoutdevelopingsolutionstoaddressthewildlifediseasereservoirandotheridentifiedconstraints.Since1992theprogrammeobjectiveshavebeenrestated.Itisnoweffectivelyaninterimcontrol programme where significant resources have been invested in research and development aimed at overcoming theidentifiedconstraintstoeradication.Policyisinformedbyscienceanddebateamongstakeholdersisgenerallyknowl-edgeableandbalanced.Thispaperoutlinesdevelopmentsinrecentyearsandsetsoutourexpectationsforprogressintheperiodahead.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology, 151, Sheridan, M., Progress in tuberculosis eradication in Ireland, 160-169, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 51
CO
NT
RIB
UT
ING
TO
NA
TIO
NA
l T
B P
Ol
ICy
The n
ation
al pro
gram
me
Perspectives on the history of bovine TB and the role of tuberculin in bovine TB eradication
Good, M.1, Duignan, A.1
1 DAFM
Veterinary Medicine International, article ID 410470 (2011)
Tuberculosisremainsasignificantdiseaseofanimalsandhumansworldwide.BovinetuberculosisiscausedbyMycobacteriawithanextremelywidehostrangeandserious,althoughcurrentlyprobablyunderdiagnosed,zoonoticpotential.Wherebovinetuberculosiscontrolsareeffective,humanzoonoticTB,duetoMycobacterium bovis or M. caprae, isuncommonandclinicalcasesareinfrequentincattle.Therefore,thecontrolandultimateeradicationofbovinetuber-culosisisdesirable.Tuberculintestsaretheprimaryscreeningtoolusedinbovineeradication.Thechoiceoftuberculintestisdependentontheenvironmentinwhichitistobeused.Tuberculinpotencyiscriticaltotestperformance,andtheaccuratedeterminationofpotencyisthereforeparticularlyimportant.Thedesignofacontroloreradicationprogrammeshouldtakeintoconsiderationthefundamentalscientificknowledge,theepidemiologicalprofileofdisease,theexperi-ence of other eradication programmes, and the presence, in the same ecosystem, of maintenance hosts, in which infection isself-sustainingandwhicharecapableoftransmittinginfection.Acontroloreradicationprogrammewillnecessarilyrequiremodificationasitprogressesandmustbeunderconstantreviewtoidentifytheoptimaldesirablegoals,theefficacyofpolicy,andconstraintstoprogress.
Copyright 2011 Good and Duignan. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Management of the Irish TB eradication programme: the development and application of new measures of performance
Higgins, I.M.1, Williams, D.H.2, More, S.J.1, 3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Mathematical Sciences, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
PerformancemanagementinnationalTBprogrammeshasnotbeenstraight-forward.Thereisabroadrangeofreasonsforthis,includinginfectionepidemiology,testinterpretationanddatacollectionandmanagement.Asoneexampleofthecomplexityinvolved,althoughTB-relateddatainIrelandarecollectedattheleveloftheevent(test,breakdown),somerelatetotheanimal(whichisnestedwithinherd)andsometotheherd.InIreland,nationalprogressiscurrentlymeasuredusingthenumberofreactorsper1,000tests(APT),whichiscomputationallysimple,however,thereareanumberofdifficultieswiththisapproach.ThispaperdescribesworktodefineperformancemeasurestoassistwithongoingreviewoftheIrishprogramme,tocreateautomatedmethodstoenableongoingmeasurement,andtoreviewprogress.Arangeofperformancemeasures,linkedtodefinedperiodsofherdtradingrestriction following indications of M. bovis infection, have been developed to separately assess the effectiveness of surveillance (to detect new cases: herd disease incidence, percentage of herds remaining disease free) and control (to clearinfectionfollowingcasedetection:restrictionduration,numberofreactorsperrestriction,%singlereactorbreakdowns,%3rd/4threactorretests,inter-episodeinterval,repeatrestrictions).Programmingwasconductedusing SAS®(SASInstituteInc.,Cary,NC,USA)withextensiveuseofSAS®macroprogramming,usingTBherdsummaryresultsfromthenationalAnimalHealthComputerSystem(AHCS)asdatainputs.Thefinalsetofprogrammescanberunwithoutintervention.ThesurveillanceandcontrolmeasureshavebeencalculatedforallactiveIrishherds,andsummarizedbyDistrictVeterinaryOffice(unitofprogrammemanagement),productiontype,herdsizeandpastdiseasehistory.Incontrasttocurrentmethods,theseherd-levelmeasureseffectively
Biennial Report, 2010/201152
CO
NT
RIB
UT
ING
TO
NA
TIO
NA
l T
B P
Ol
ICy
The
nat
ion
al p
rog
ram
me
partitionactivitiesinIrelandrelatingtodetectionofnewcases(surveillance)andtheresolutionofcasesfollowingdetection(control).Thisinformation,providedonanongoingandtimelybasiswillbeofbenefittonationalandregionalprogrammedecision-makers.
TB in Ireland - visualising the current picture
McGrath, G.1
1 UCD CVERA
ThecurrentmethodologiesusedtovisualisetheprevalenceoftuberculosisinIrelandincludethematicmapping(posi-tiveanimaltestsperthousandtestsperdistrictelectoraldivision)anddensitymaps(kerneldensitiesofpositiveanimals/population).Thisprojectwillinvestigatepossiblenewwaysofdisplayingthechangesintuberculosisprevalenceovertimetoprovideabettervisualisationoftherecentdecreaseinreactornumbers.Amethodologyisrequiredthatismoresensitivetorepresentingproportionallysmallchanges.Theproposedmethodwillinvolveassigningherdleveldatatoauniformhexagonalgrid.Ameasureofmeanprevalencewillbecalculatedforadefinedperiodoftime.Eachyearwillthen be displayed as a deviation above or below this mean level thus showing the relative temporal trend in prevalence foreachunitthroughtime.
An evaluation of the Irish Single Reactor Breakdown Protocol for 2005 to 2008 inclusive and its potential application as a monitor of tuberculin test performance
Good, M.1, Duignan, A.1
1 DAFM
Veterinary Microbiology 151, 85-90 (2011)
UndertheIrishBovineTuberculosis(bTB)EradicationProgrammeallherdsaresubjectedtoatleastonetestper annum.TheSingleIntradermalComparativeTuberculinTest(SICTT)isusedinIrelandforthedetectionofcattleinfectedwithMycobacterium bovis.TherehavebeenconcernsregardingthespecificityoftheSICTT,notablybyfarmers,andparticu-larlyinherdswherethedetectionofasinglepositiveanimalintheabsenceofanobvioussourceof(bTB)infectioncouldbeperceivedasa“false”positive.Toaddressthisissuetheso-called‘SingletonProtocol’wasestablishedaspartoftheIrishbTBeradicationprogramme.Thisprotocolallowsfortheearlyrestorationoffreetradingstatustoherdswhereasingle positive animal was detected and where the herd was not confirmed as infected with M. bovis by epidemiological investigation,bypostmortem,bylaboratoryexamination,orbyfurthertest.Thispaperpresentsdatafromthe2005to2008,inclusive,bTBprogrammesonthenumberofherdsthatwereassessed,whichqualifiedforinclusionunderthe‘SingletonProtocol’andtheoutcomeforqualifyingherdsuptoandincludinghavingstatusrestoredearlyasaconse-quenceofinclusioninthatprogramme.TheoutcomeofthisprotocolreaffirmsthereliabilityoftheSICTTatcurrentlevelsofinfection.Furthermoreitisadvocatedthatthe‘SingletonProtocol’becontinuedasamonitorofherdsinwhichasinglepositiveanimalisdisclosed,andasoverallinfectionlevelsofbTBfalltheoutcomemaybeusedasonemeanstoassessprogresstowardsbTBeradicationinIreland.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology, 151, Good, M., Duignan, A., An evaluation of the Irish Single Reactor Breakdown Protocol for 2005 to 2008 inclusive and its potential application as a monitor of tuberculin test performance, 85-90, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 53
CO
NT
RIB
UT
ING
TO
NA
TIO
NA
l T
B P
Ol
ICy
The n
ation
al pro
gram
me
Singleton area risk: Can areas of temporo-spatial clustering in singleton reactors be defined?
McGrath, G.1
1 UCD CVERA
There is evidence that non-specific infection or singleton reactors occur as a result of environmental conditions found onfarmsclosetobog,reclaimedwetlandandlakes.Ifthisisthecase,theyshouldclusterisspaceandtime.Wewouldexpecttheretobeaspatialconsistencywhichshouldbediscernible.Theobjectiveofthisstudyistoattempttoiden-tifyifthisspatial/temporalclusteringofsingletonreactorsexists.Ifthereisadiscernibleeffect,areasofpersistenthighsingletonriskcouldbedefinedandassignedbacktoallherdsfallingwithintheseareasprovidingveterinaryinspectorswithanadditionallayerofinformationtoaidindecidinghowtointerpretandmanageherdswithsingletonreactors.
Evaluation of single reactor bovine tuberculosis breakdowns, based on analysis of reactors slaughtered at an Irish export meat plant
Murray, D.1, Clegg, T.A.2, More, S.J.2, 3
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The‘SingletonProtocol’wasadoptedbytheIrishDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM)in1996toaddresstheincompletespecificityoftheSingleIntradermalComparativeTuberculinTest(SICTT)usedinIrelandforthedetectionofanimalsinfectedwithbovinetuberculosis(bTB).Theprotocolallowstheearlyrestorationofdisease-freestatustoherdswithasinglereactorbreakdown,wheretheherdwasnotconfirmedasinfectedwithMycobacterium bovis byepidemiologicalinvestigation,bypostmortemexaminationorbyfurthertest.ThecurrentstudyexaminestheabilityoftheSingletonProtocoltoidentifyfalsepositivereactors,thesubsequentherdreactorratefollowingsinglereactorremovalandanalysesthefactorsleadingtoapositivepostmortemlesionoutcomeandapositivereactorretestresult.Postmortemlesionresultswereobtainedfor371reactoranimalsfromsinglereactorbreakdownsthatwerekilledatanexportmeatplantoveranineteen-monthperiod.EpidemiologicalandtestdatafortheseanimalsandtheirherdswereobtainedfromDAFMdatabasesandanalysedbyunivariateandmultivariatestatisticalanalysis.Singletoncandidateshadan18.7%lowerlesionratethansingleanimalbreakdownsnotmeetingthesingletoncriteria.Nosignificantdifferencewasfoundbetweensingletonsandnon-singletonsinthesubsequentreactorretestresults.SkinthicknessattheSICTTisthemostsignificantdeterminantofapositivelesionresult.TheareabTBhistorywasshowntobeasignificantvariableinproducingapositivereactorretestresult.
Biennial Report, 2010/201154
CO
NT
RIB
UT
ING
TO
NA
TIO
NA
l T
B P
Ol
ICy
The
nat
ion
al p
rog
ram
me
Bovine tuberculosis trends in the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland, 1995 to 2010
Abernethy, D.A.1, Upton, P.2, Higgins, I.M.3, McGrath, G.3, Goodchild, T.2, Rolfe, S.4, Broughan, J.2, Downes, S.2,
Clifton-Hadley, R.2, Menzies, F.1, de la Rua-Domenech, R.5, Blissit, M.6, Duignan, A.7, More, S.J.3, 8
1 Department of Agriculture and Rural Development, Belfast, Northern Ireland, 2 Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Weybridge, United
Kingdom 3 UCD CVERA, 4 Office of the Chief Veterinary Officer, Welsh Assembly, Cardiff, Wales, 5 Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs,
London, England, 6 Scottish Government, Edinburgh, Scotland, 7 DAFM, 8 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Europeanlegislation,principally64/432EECand78/52EEC,formsthebasisofnationalprogrammesandgovernsthesurveillanceandcontrolmeasuresappliedbyMemberStates.TheUnitedKingdomincludesthecountriesofNorthernIreland,England,WalesandScotland.ThelatterthreearecollectivelyreferredtoasGreatBritainwhileNorthernIrelandislocatedwiththeRepublicofIrelandontheislandofIreland,separatedfromGreatBritainbytheIrishSea,Historically,bTBpolicywithintheUnitedKingdomwasdeterminedseparatelyforGreatBritainandNorthernIreland,leadingtodifferencesinstrategyandmanagement.DevolutionofresponsibilityforagriculturetotheWelshandScottishadministrationsin1998furtherregionalisedpolicydevelopment.Thus,althoughprogrammemeasureswerelargelystandardisedthroughEuropeanlegislation,somedifferencesoccurred,largelyinresponsetospecificrisksorbTBpreva-lence.ComparingbTBtrendsprovidesanopportunitytolearnfromdifferingexperiencesandgainpossibleinsightintofactorsthatmaypromoteorimpedeprogresstowardseradication.Suchcomparisons,however,arehamperedbydifferencesinmeasurementofdiseaseparametersandsummarystatistics.Thisprojectwillseektoidentifyandwhereverpossible,reducethesedifferencestoallowdirectcomparisonoftrendsbetweenthejurisdictions.
Photograph by E. Gormley.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 55
CO
NT
RIB
UT
ING
TO
NA
TIO
NA
l T
B P
Ol
ICy
The n
ation
al pro
gram
me
Bovine tuberculosis in Europe from the perspective of an offically tuberculosis - free country: Trade, surveillance and diagnostics
Schiller, I.1, Waters, W.R.2, Vordermeier, H.M.3, Jemmi, T.1, Welsh, M.4, Keck, N.5, Whelan, A.3, Gormley, E.6,
Boschiroli, M.L.7, Moyen, J.L.8, Vela, C.9, Cagiola, M.10, Buddle, B.M.11, Palmer, M.2, Thacker, T.2, Oesch, B.12
1 Federal Veterinary Office, Bern, Switzerland, 2 National Animal Disease Center, Agricultural Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Iowa, USA,
3 Veterinary Laboratory Agency, Addlestone, United Kingdom, 4 AFBI-Veterinary Sciences Division, Stormont, Northern Ireland, 5 Laboratoire Départemental
Vétérinaire de l’Hérault, Montpellier, France, 6 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 7 Unité de Zoonoses Bactériennes, AFSSA-LERPAZ, Maisons-Alfort, France,
8 Laboratoire Conseil Général de la Dordogne, France, 9 Ingenasa, Madrid, Spain, 10 Istituto Zooprofilattico dell’Umbria e delle Marche, Perugia, Italy,
11 AgResearch, Palmerston North, New Zealand, 12 Prionics AG, Schlieren, Switzerland
Veterinary Microbiology 151, 152-159 (2011)
Switzerlandhasbeenofficiallyfreeofbovinetuberculosis(OTF)since1960.Since1980thecontrolofbovinetubercu-losis(bTB)hasbeenreducedtopassiveabattoirsurveillance.IsolatedcasesofbTB,partlyduetoreactivationofhumanMycobacterium bovisinfectionswithsubsequenttransmissiontocattle,havebeennoticedinthelastyears.InEurope,theoverallprevalenceofbTBisslightlyincreasing.BothOTFandnon-OTFcountriesreportincreasesintheproportionofbTBpositivecattleherds.CurrentbTBeradicationandcontrolprogramsinEuropearefacingarangeofchallenges.Wholeherddepopulationisbecomingalessattractiveoptionforeconomicreasonsandduetoanimalwelfareconcerns.Liveanimaltradeisincreasingbothatnationalandinternationallevels.RegardingthesetendenciesandtakingintoaccountthechronicityofbTBinfection,pre-movementtestingisbecomingincreasinglyimportantasacentraltoolforeradicationandforprotectionagainstre-introductionofbTB.Pre-movementtesting,howeverspecificallyfocusesontheinfectionstatusofindividuals,requiringahighlevelofdiagnosticaccuracytocorrectlydiagnoseinfectedanimals.CurrentscreeningtestsforbTB,however,havebeendesignedtomeetdemandsasherdtests.Thisillustratesthatthemodificationofexistingand/orthedevelopmentofnewdiagnosticsforbTBmightbeneeded.Thetuberculinskintest(TST),theprimaryscreeningtestforbTBmayincertainsituationshavelowsensitivity.Theinterferongamma(IFN-g) assayisacceptedtobemoresensitivecomparedtoTST.Reducedspecificity,however,especiallyinareasoflowbTBprevalenceraisesconcerns.NewantigencombinationsincludingRv3615c,OmpATbandothershavebeenshowntocomplementESAT-6andCFP-10inthewholebloodIFN-g assay and resulted in improved sensitivity (compared to ESAT-6andCFP-10)andspecificity(comparedtotuberculins).Lesiondetectionafterslaughterrepresentsacost-effec-tiveprocedureforpassivesurveillanceofbTB,especiallyinareasoflowprevalenceorinregionsfreeofbTB;however,itssensitivityisverylow.Thisillustratesthattradeislinkedwithacertainrisktore-introducebTBinOTFregionsorcountriesandthattheremaybedelaysindetectingare-introductionofbTB.Inconclusion,regardingthefactthatsomeparameterslinkedwithbTBprogramsarechanging,thedevelopmentofimproveddiagnostictestswithahighreliabilityforuseasindividualanimaltestswillbeimportantforfutureeradicationofbTB,inlinewithinternationalcommitmenttohighstandardanimalhealthprograms.
Reprinted from Veterinary Microbiology, 151, Schiller, I., Waters, W.R., Vordermeier, H.M., Jemmi, T., Welsh, M., Keck, N., Whelan, A., Gormley, E., Boschiroli, M.L., Moyen, J.L., Vela, C., Cagiola, M., Buddle, B.M., Palmer, M., Thacker, T., Oesch, B., Bovine tuberculosis in Europe from the perspective of an offically tuberculosis free country: trade, surveillance and diagnostics, 152-159, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/201156
CO
NT
RIB
UT
ING
TO
NA
TIO
NA
l T
B P
Ol
ICy
Qu
alit
y co
ntr
ol
Quality control
The relative effectiveness of, and reporting accuracy among, testers during field surveillance for bovine tuberculosis in Ireland
Clegg, T.A.1, Good, M.2, Duignan, A.2, More, S.J.1, 3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
FieldsurveillanceusingtheSingleIntradermalComparativeTuberculinTest(SICTT)ispotentiallyproblematic,notingitsrelianceonarangeoffactors,includingtheskillsandexperienceofthetester.Theobjectiveofthisstudyistoquantifytherelativeeffectivenessof,andreportingaccuracyamong,testersduringfieldsurveillancefortuberculosisinIreland.Alltesterswhocarriedoutatleastoneannualherdtestin2006areincludedinthestudy.Relativetestingeffectivenesswillbeassessedbycomparingthenumberofobservedandexpectedherdrestrictionspertester.Thelatterwillbepredicted,usingalogisticregressionmodelandtesterswillberanked,basedontheratioofobservedandexpectedrestrictions.ReportingaccuracywillbebasedonthebovinemeasurementsinSICTTnegativeanimals.Thestudywillalsobeextendedtolookat2007to2010dataandtocomparechangesintherankingoftestersovertime.
A review of Irish tuberculin assays
Duignan, A.1, Costello E.2, Good M.1, Kenny K.2
1 DAFM, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service
BovinetuberculinPPDhasbeendescribedasapoorlydefined,complexmixturecontainingmorethan100individualcomponentsinvariousstagesofdenaturationandisknowntovarywidelybothinproteincontentandantigenicprofile.Themostreliablemeasureofthepotencyofatuberculinisbyassayinthespeciesinwhichitwillberoutinelyused.DAFM routinely conducts 2-3 potency assays on bovine tuberculin each year in cattle naturally infected with M. bovis.The trials are conducted by the DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service on tuberculins chosen at random from the supply tobeusedinthefield.Thepotencyofatuberculinisestimatedbycomparingthesizeofthereactions,elicitedbyanintradermalinoculation,tothesizeofthereactionsofa‘standard’tuberculinofknownpotency.ThisprojectwillgiveanoutlineoftheevolutionofPPDtuberculinsandanaccountofassayscarriedoutonIrishreactorcattle.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 57
CO
NT
RIB
UT
ING
TO
NA
TIO
NA
l T
B P
Ol
ICy
Qu
ality con
trol
Quality control in the national bovine tuberculosis eradication programme in Ireland
Duignan, A.1, Good, M.1, More, S.J.2, 3
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
TheIrishBovineTuberculosis(bTB)eradicationprogrammeoperatesundernationallegislationandfulfilstherequirementsoftheEUTradeDirective64/432.Theprogrammeincludesannualsingleindradermalcomparativetuberculintest(SICTT)screeningofallherds,promptremovaloftestreactorsandfurtherconsequentialretestingofherds.Continuousevaluationofallrelevantactivitiesisessentialtodeliveraneffectivenationalprogrammeandtoreassureallstakeholdersthatthehighestpossiblestandardsareattained.Qualitycontrol(QC)isarecognisedprocessinthedeliveryofqualityproductsorservices.ThisprojectwillpresentareviewofQCinthebTBeradica-tionprogrammeinIreland,withparticularemphasisonfieldsurveillance.AbroadrangeofprogrammeelementssubjectedtoQC,willbedescribed,includingpersonnel,training,equipment,tuberculinsandlaboratory.Particularattentionwillbepaidtofieldsurveillance(specifically,PrivateVeterinaryPractitioner(PVP)performance).
Description of opinions among stakeholders of factors affecting the quality of SICTT testing in Ireland
Meskell, P.1, Mulreany, M.2, More, S.J.3, 4
1 DAFM, 2 Institute of Public Administration, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Thesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest(SICTT)istheprimarymethodoffieldsurveillanceforbovinetuberculosis(bTB)inIreland,andanumberofmethodsareusedtosafeguardtestingquality.Asyet,littlehasbeendocumentedabouttheopinionsofstakeholdersonthisissue.ThepurposeofthisstudyistodescribeopinionsamongstakeholdersoffactorsaffectingthequalityofSICTTtestinginIreland.Thestudyisbeenconductedusingseveralqualitativemethods,includingfocusgroupsandsemi-structuredinterviews.
Biennial Report, 2010/201158
NA
TIO
NA
l M
AP
SD
ensi
ty o
f TB
in
cid
ence
Density of TB incidence
Density of TB incidence per square km during 2010 (kernel density with search radius at 10km).
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 59
NA
TIO
NA
l M
AP
SD
ensity o
f TB in
ciden
ce
Density of TB incidence per square km during 2011 (kernel density with search radius at 10km).
Biennial Report, 2010/201160
NA
TIO
NA
l M
AP
SA
PT p
er D
ED
APT per DED
APT (reactors per 1000 tests) per district electoral division, 2010.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 61
NA
TIO
NA
l M
AP
SA
PT per D
ED
APT (reactors per 1000 tests) per district electoral division, 2011.
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
S
62 Biennial Report, 2010/2011
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 63
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
Non-regulatory cattle health issues
Animal Health Ireland .............................................................................................. 64
Biosecure diseases
- Biosecurity ................................................................................................................ 66
- Johne’s disease ......................................................................................................... 67
- Bovine viral diarrhoea (BVD) ...................................................................................... 70
- Infectious bovine rhinotracheitis (IBR) ........................................................................ 71
- Leptospirosis ............................................................................................................. 72
Non-biosecure diseases and conditions
- Milk quality ............................................................................................................... 74
- Fertility ..................................................................................................................... 78
- Calf health ................................................................................................................ 80
Biennial Report, 2010/201164
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SA
nim
al H
ealt
h I
rela
nd
Animal health Ireland
Food chain control - pre-harvest phase
More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Aglobalapproachisneeded,fromfarmtotable,toensurethatfoodforhumansissafetoeat.Thepre-harvestphase,duringprimaryproduction,isthefirststepinthefoodchain.Controlsatthisstageofthefoodchainarecritical.Inthisdocument, attention will be paid to three broad components of food chain control in the pre-harvest phase: the safety ofanimalfeeds,animalhealth,andtraceability.Bynecessity,thisisabriefoverviewofacomplexsubject,andmore-detailedreviewsareavailable(includingSmuldersandCollins2002).
Animal Health Ireland: providing national leadership and coordination of non-regulatory animal health issues in Ireland
More, S.J.1, 2, Doherty, M.L.2, Downey, L.3, McKenzie, K.4, Devitt, C.3, O’Flaherty, J.5
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 Private consultant, 4 UCD School of Public Health, Physiotherapy and Population Science,
5 Animal Health Ireland
Revue scientifique et technique / Office international des épizooties (OIE Scientific and Technical Review) 30,
715-723 (2011)
LivestockproductionplaysanimportantroleintheIrisheconomy.Regulatoryanimalhealthissuesaretheresponsibilityofgovernment,butuntilrecentlytherehasbeennonationalcoordinationofnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissues.ThisgaphasrecentlybeenfilledwiththeestablishmentofAnimalHealthIreland(AHI),anot-for-profit,partnership-basedorganisationprovidingnationalleadershipandcoordinationofnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissuesinIreland.AnimalHealthIrelandprovidesbenefitstolivestockproducersandprocessorsbyprovidingtheknowledge,educationandcoordinationrequiredtoestablisheffectivecontrolstrategies,bothon-farmandnationally.ThispaperpresentsabriefoverviewofthecontextforAHI,andofitsestablishmentandinitialactivities.Non-regulatoryanimalhealthissueshavebeenprioritised.Aseriesofworkprogrammes(eachfocusingonahigh-priorityissue)havebeenestablished.Partnershipiscriticaltosuccess,bothforAHIasanorganisationandforeffectivefarm-leveltransferofknowledge.Thismodelfornationalleadershipandcoordinationofnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissuesmaybeofrelevanceelsewhere.
Reproduced with permission from the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) (www.oie.int/en/publications-and-docu-mentation/scientific-and-technical-review-free-access/list-of-issues /).
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 65
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
An
imal H
ealth Irelan
d
Setting priorities for non-regulatory animal health in Ireland: results from an expert Policy Delphi study and a farmer priority identification survey
More, S.J.1, 2, McKenzie, K.3, O’Flaherty, J.4, Doherty, M.L.2, Cromie, A.R.5, Magan, M.J.4
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 UCD Institute for Food and Health, 4 Animal Health Ireland, 5 Irish Cattle Breeding Federation
Preventive Veterinary Medicine 95, 198-207 (2010)
AgricultureisaveryimportantcontributortotheIrisheconomy.InIreland,nationalanimalhealthserviceshavebeenagovernment,ratherthananindustry,responsibility.In2009,AnimalHealthIreland(AHI)wasestablishedtoprovideapartnershipapproachtonationalleadershipofnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissues(thosenotsubjecttonationaland/orEUregulation).Theobjectivesofthisstudyweretoelicitopinionfromexpertsandfarmersaboutnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissuesfacingIrishlivestockindustries,includingprioritisationofanimalhealthissuesandidentificationofopportunitiestomaximisetheeffectiveuseofAHIresources.ThestudywasconductedwithexpertsusingPolicyDelphimethodologyoverthreerounds,andwithfarmersusingapriorityidentificationsurvey.Non-regulatorybovinediseases/conditionswereprioritisedbybothexpertsandfarmersbasedonimpactandinternationalcompetitiveness.Foreachhigh-prioritydisease/condition,expertswereaskedtoprovideanassessmentbasedoncost,impact,internationalpercep-tion,impedimenttointernationalmarketaccessandcurrentresourceusageeffectiveness.Furtherinformationwasalsosought from experts about resource allocation preferences, methods to improve education and coordination, and innova-tivemeasurestoimprovepreventionandmanagement.Therewascloseagreementbetweenresponsesfromexpertsanddairyfarmers:eachgavehighestpriorityto3diseaseswithabiosecurityrisk(subsequentlytermed‘biosecurediseases’)(bovineviraldiarrhoea[BVD],infectiousbovinerhinotracheitis[IBR],paratuberculosis)and4diseases/conditionsgenerallywithoutabiosecurityrisk(‘non-biosecurediseases/conditions’)(fertility,udderhealth/milkquality,lameness,calfhealth).Beeffarmersalsoprioritisedparasiticconditionsandweanlingpneumonia.Theadverseimpactofbiosecurediseasesiscurrentlyconsideredrelativelyminorbyexperts,butwouldincreasesubstantiallyintime.Therearealreadysubstantialcoststofarmsandagribusinessfromnon-biosecurediseases/conditions.Expertspreferredanequalalloca-tionofresourcesbetweenthesebiosecureandnon-biosecurediseases/conditions,withemphasisonadopting/adaptinginternationalmodels,educationandawareness-raising.Theresultsfromthisstudyproviderobustinsightsaboutnon-regulatoryanimalhealthprioritiesinIreland,asperceivedbyexpertsandfarmers,usingmethodologiesthatarebothtransparentandinclusive.Theyhavealreadybeenextremelyinfluentialinshapingnationalpolicy,asafoundationforinterdisciplinary(andmulti-agency)cooperation,asacontributiontoeffortstoencouragestakeholderresponsibility-taking,andtoongoingdevelopmentofpostgraduateandundergraduateveterinaryeducationinIreland.
Reprinted from Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 95, More, S.J., McKenzie, K., O’Flaherty, J., Doherty, M.L., Cromie, A.R., Magan, M.J., Setting priorities for non-regulatory animal health in Ireland: results from an expert Policy Delphi study and a farmer priority identification survey, 198-207, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/201166
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SB
iose
cure
dis
ease
s
Biosecure diseases
Biosecurity
Design of a model for prediction of the probability of introduction of infectious agents into animal populations
Geraghty, T.1, O’Grady, L.1, Jonsson, N.2, More, S.J.1, 3
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, Scotland, 3 UCD CVERA
Theconsequencesofdiseaseintroductionintoanimalpopulationsareincreasinglyunderstood.Quantitativeriskassess-mentmodelsfordiseaseintroductionhavebeendescribedfornationalimportriskanalysisbuttheiruseatindividualfarmlevelislimited.Wedescribethedesignofaquantitativedeterministicmodeltoestimatetheprobabilityofintro-ductionofinfectiousdiseaseintosusceptibleindividualfarmpopulations.Themodelneedstotakeaccountofthreecomponents:(1)exposureofthefarmanimalstoexternal,potentialsourcesofinfection,(2)thepresenceofinfectiousagentinthepotentialinfectionsource,and(3)exposuresufficienttosupporttransmissiontoafarmanimal.Thefirstofthesecomponentsisinfluencedbyfarm-specificvariables,thethirdbyagent-specificvariablesandthesecondbyboth.Thismodeloffersadvantagesoverexistingriskassessmenttools.Totalprobabilityofdiseaseintroductionandprobabilityofintroductionfromasinglefarmvariablecanbecalculatedandusedforbenchmarkingherdsandtoidentifyhighriskfarmvariablesrespectively.
Bioexclusion of diseases from dairy and beef farms: Risks of introducing infectious agents and risk reduction strategies
Mee, J.F.1, Geraghty, T.2, O’Neill, R.3, More, S.J.2, 4
1 Teagasc Moorepark, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 4 UCD CVERA
Infectiousdiseasesrepresentamajorthreattothehealthandwelfareofcattleherdsinternationally.Introductionofinfectious agents into dairy and beef farms may be either through direct (purchased cattle, movement of resident cattle and contact with contiguous cattle) or indirect (visitors, fomites, biological materials and the environment) transmis-sionroutes.Inthisreview,theevidencesupportingthesetransmissionroutesfortheintroductionofinfectiousdiseasesispresented.Intheabsenceoferadicationprogrammesformanyendemicinfectiousdiseases,bioexclusionisthekeymanagementprocesstoreducetherisksthattheypresent.Variousameliorativebioexclusionstrategieshavebeenrecom-mendedintheliteratureandtheevidencesupportingtheseprotocolsisalsoreviewedhere.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 67
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
Bio
secure d
iseases
Johne’s disease
Risk factors associated with Johne’s disease test status in dairy herds in Ireland
Barrett, D.J.1, Mee, J.F.2, Mullowney, P.3, Good, M.3, McGrath, G.4, Clegg, T.4, More, S.J.4, 5
1 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 2 Teagasc Moorepark, 3 DAFM, 4 UCD CVERA, 5 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Veterinary Record 168, 410 (2011)
Johne’sdiseaseisachronic,granulomatousenteritisofruminantscausedbyMycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis(MAP).AlthoughtherecentprevalenceandeconomicimpactofclinicalandsubclinicalJohne’sdiseaseinIrishdairyherdshavebeenreported,therearenopublishedstudiesexaminingtheriskfactorsfordetectionofMAPbyindividualfaecalculture(IFC)inIrishdairyherds.Thisshortcommunicationdescribesacase-controlstudyaimingtoidentifytheriskfactorsassociatedwithdetectionofMAPbyIFCinIrishdairyherds.Caseherds(n=86)weredefinedasherdswithoneormoreIFC-MAP-positiveresultsintheDAFMVeterinaryLaboratoryServicedatabasefromsamplesvoluntarilysubmittedbyprivateveterinarypractitionersbetween1995and2007.Controlherds(n=125)weredefinedasherdswithnoIFC-MAP-positiveresultsintheDAFMVeterinaryLaboratoryServicedatabaseinthesameperiodandwithnoELISA-positiveanimals(over12monthsofage)inwhole-herdsamplingcarriedoutaspartofanationalserosurveyin2005.AquestionnairewasdesignedtocollectdataonherdandmanagementfactorsplausiblylinkedtothedetectionofMAPindairyherds.ThequestionsrelatedtopracticescarriedoutbeforeandaftertheyearofMAPdetectioninthecaseherdsandthesameyear(thereferenceyear)inthecontrolherds.Proportionally,morecaseherdownersoperatedadairy-onlyenterprisecomparedwithcontrolherdowners.Therewasnogeographicalclusteringinthedistributionofcaseandcontrolherds.Threesignificantriskfactors(cattleimportation,depopulationandherdsize)andoneprotectivefactor(borrowingcolostrum)remainedinthefinalmodel.WiththeimpendingabolitionofmilkquotasintheEuropeanUnionin2015,manydairyherdsarelikelytobeexpanded.ThisstudyhighlightsthepotentialbiosecurityrisksforJohne’sdiseaseassociatedwithherdexpansion.
Adapted from Veterinary Record, Barrett, D.J., Mee, J.F., Mullowney, P., Good, M., McGrath, G., Clegg, T., More, S.J., 168, 410, Copyright 2011, with permission from BMJ Publishing Group Ltd.
Genetic associations between Johne’s disease and susceptibility to Mycobacterium bovis and Mycobacterium avium subsp avium in Irish Holstein Friesian dairy cows
Bermingham, M.L.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Good, M.4, Cromie, A.R.5, Mullowney, P.4, Higgins, I.M.2, Berry, D.P.6
1 The Roslin Institute, University of Edinburgh, Scotland, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 DAFM,
5 The Irish Cattle Breeding Federation, 6 Teagasc Moorepark
Johne’sdiseaseincattleiscausedbyMycobacterium avium subsp paratuberculosis(MAP).Arecentstudydemon-stratedthatsignificantgeneticvariationexistsforsusceptibilitytoMAPinfectioninIrishHolsteinFriesiandairycows.Nevertheless,dataonJohne’sdiseaseoccurrenceisnotcollectedroutinelyonIrishdairyfarms.TheobjectiveofthisstudywastoestimatethegeneticassociationsbetweenresistancetoMAPinfectionandmeasuresofsusceptibilitytoM. bovis and M. avium subsp aviuminfection.SerologicalresponsetoMAPwasusedasameasureofcowsusceptibilitytoJohne’sdisease.Thesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintestwasusedasameasureofsusceptibilityofcowsto M. bovis and M. aviuminfection.Atotalof4,581cowserologicalresponsetoMAPrecords,19,663M. bovis-PPDresponsivenessrecordsand15,824M. avium-PPDresponsivenessrecordswereavailableforinclusionintheanalysis.Geneticandresidual(co)variancecomponentsbetweenserologicalresponsetoMAPandsusceptibilitytoM. bovis-PPDandM. avium-PPDresponsivenesswereestimatedusingbivariatelinearanimalmodels.SerologicalresponsetoMAPwasstronglypositivelygeneticallycorrelated(0.84±0.20)withsusceptibilitytoM. avium-PPDresponsiveness.
Biennial Report, 2010/201168
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SB
iose
cure
dis
ease
s
Susceptibility to M. avium-PPDresponsivenesswasnotgeneticallycorrelated(0.03±0.32)withserologicalresponsetoMAP.TheresultsfromstudysuggestthatselectionforreducedM. avium-PPDresponsivenessmayindirectlyincreaseresistancetoMAPinfectionwithinthenationalHolsteinFriesiandairyherd.
Genetic variation in serological response to Mycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis and its association with performance in Irish Holstein-Friesian dairy cows
Berry, D.P.1, Good, M.2, Mullowney, P.2, Cromie, A.R.3, More, S.J.4, 5
1 Teagasc Moorepark, 2 DAFM, 3 Irish Cattle Breeding Federation, 4 UCD CVERA, 5 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
livestock Science 131, 102-107 (2010)
Paratuberculosis,alsoreferredtoasJohne’sdisease,isacontagiousandchronicdiseaseinruminantscausedbyMycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis(MAP).Fewestimatesofthegeneticvariationinmeasuresofsuscep-tibilitytoMAPareavailableintheliteratureandevenlesshaveattemptedtoelucidatethegeneticassociationsbetweenmeasuresofsusceptibilitytoMAPandperformanceindairycattle.TheobjectivesofthisstudyweretoestimatethegeneticvariationinserologicalresponsetoMAPin4,789Holstein–Friesiandairycowsfrom44Irishdairyherds,andtoquantifyitsgeneticassociationwithperformancetraitsmeasuredinthefirstthreelactationsofgeneticallyrelatedanimals.Univariatemixedlinearandthresholdanimalmodelswereusedtoestimatevariancecomponentsandgeneticcorrelationswereestimatedusingbivariateanimallinearmixedmodels;MAPserologicalresponsewastreatedasacontinuousvariableanddichotomousvariable.TheprevalenceofMAPinthesamplepopulationwas4.4%.Thisfigurecannot be extrapolated to the national dairy herd as the sample population was biased towards herds with increased likelihoodofMAPinfection.EstimatesofheritabilityforMAPserologicalresponsevariedfrom0.07to0.15dependingonthemodelofanalysisandwhetherserologicalresponsewastreatedascontinuousorbinary;standarderrorsvariedfrom0.024to0.062.GeneticcorrelationsbetweenMAPserologicalresponseandlactationmilk,fatandproteinyieldwerenegativeorclosetozeroalthoughnotalwaysmorethantwostandarderrorsfromzero;strongernegativegeneticcorrelationswereevidentinolderparityanimals.SerologicalresponsetoMAPwasnotgeneticallycorrelatedwithmilkfatconcentrationbutwaspositivelygeneticallycorrelatedwithmilkproteinconcentrationinfirstlactationandnega-tivelycorrelatedwithcalvinginterval.TherewaslittleornogeneticassociationbetweenserologicalresponsetoMAPandsurvival.ResultsfromthisstudycorroboratepreviousinternationalsuggestionsthatselectionforreducedserologicalresponsetoMAPispossible,althoughthisdoesnotnecessarilyimplyaconcurrentselectionforeitherreducedpreva-lenceofclinicaldiseaseorincreasedresistancetoMAPinfection.
Reprinted from Livestock Science, 131, Berry, D.P., Good, M., Mullowney, P., Cromie, A.R., More, S.J., Genetic variation in serological response to Mycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis and its association with performance in Irish Holstein-Friesian dairy cows, 102-107, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 69
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
Bio
secure d
iseases
Control of Johne’s disease: an international review
Geraghty, T.1, Graham, D.2, Mullowney, P.3, More, S.J.1, 4
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 Animal Health Ireland, 3 DAFM, 4 UCD CVERA
NationalbovineJohne’sdisease(JD)controlprogrammesexistinseveralcountriesincludingAustralia,Canada,Denmark,theNetherlands,theUnitedKingdomandtheUnitedStatesofAmerica.Programmedesignvarieswithindustryspecificvariables,thegoalsoftheprogrammeandthenatureoftheimplementingbody.Importantdifferencesalsoarisefromthenecessarysubjectiveinterpretationofincompletescientificliteratureinareasincludingtestreliabilityandepidemiology.OrganisationsdevelopingnewJDcontrolprogrammescanbenefitfromthecombinedexperiencesofexistingnationalcontrolprogrammes.Thisarticlereviewsthestructure(laboratoryandnon-laboratoryherdscreening,herd classification, intervention guidelines, ability to respond to new scientific developments), implementation and limi-tationsofexistingJDcontrolprogrammestoinformthedevelopmentofavoluntarynationalprogrammeinIreland.
Evaluation of alternative testing strategies for estimating likelihood of infection with Johne’s disease in Irish cattle herds
More, S.J.1, 2, Sergeant, E.S.G.3, Strain, S.4, Kenny, K.5, Cashman, W.6, Graham, D.7
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 3 AusVet Animal Health Services, Orange, Australia, 4 Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute, Belfast,
Northern Ireland, 5 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 6 Glanmire, Cork, 7 Animal Health Ireland
AnimalHealthIreland(AHI)isfacilitatingnationaldiscussionandactiononarangeofnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissuesinIreland,includingJohne’sdisease(JD).Atechnicalworkinggroupiscurrentlyworkingtodeveloptheframe-workforavoluntarynationalJDcontrolprogramme,drawingoninternationalandnationalscienceandbest-practice.Theprogrammewillinvolveherdclassification.However,testingrequirementsforinitialherdscreeningandsubsequenttestingforJDinsuckleranddairyherdsinIrelandarecurrentlynotknown.Somedataareavailablefromearlierscien-tificwork(Sergeantet al.2008;Tavornpanichet al.2008)andcountryprogrammes,however,thesearenotdirectlyapplicabletoIreland.TheobjectiveofthecurrentprojectistodevelopandtestanepidemiologicalmodeltoevaluatearangeoftestingstrategiesinanIrishcontext,withafocusondetectionprobability(givenaspecifieddesignprevalence)andcosteffectiveness.AsimulationmodelwasdevelopedintheprogramminglanguageR.Keymodelinputsincludedtestsensitivityandspecificityestimates,thedesignprevalence,testingoptionsandtestingcosts.Onlythreetestsareconsideredinthemodel(theindividualserumELISA,theindividualmilkELISAandthefaecalculture),asthesearetheonlytestswheresufficientlyrobustscientificdataareavailablethroughinternationalpeerreviewedpublication.KeymodeloutputsincludeSeH(theprobabilitythatinfectionwillbedetected,ifpresentatthedesignprevalenceorgreater)andProbF(theprobabilitythatinfectionintheherdiseitherabsentoratverylowprevalence(lessthanthedesignprev-alence)).ProbF,whichisinfluencedbySeH,thepriorprobabilityofinfectionandtheprobabilityofintroduction,couldformthebasisforherdclassification.
Biennial Report, 2010/201170
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SB
iose
cure
dis
ease
s
Bovine viral diarrhoea (BVD)
Considerations on BVD eradication for the Irish livestock industry
Barrett, D.J.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Graham, D.A.4, O’Flaherty, J.4, Doherty, M.L.3, Gunn, H.M.1
1 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 Animal Health Ireland
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 12 (2011)
AnimalHealthIrelandhasproducedclearguidelinesforthecontrolofBovineViralDiarrhoea(BVD)infectioninIrishcattleherds.Inthecourseofdevelopingtheseguidelinesitwasclearthataframeworkforregionaland/ornationalBVDcontrolwouldberequiredtoincreasetheuptakeofBVDcontrolatfarmlevelandreducetheoverallprevalenceofthedisease.ThispaperassessedtheeconomicimpactofBVD,epidemiologicalaspectsofthediseasetoitscontrol,modelsofBVDcontrolandinternationalexperiencesofBVDcontrolprogrammes.Thetechnicalknowledgeandtesttech-nologyexiststoeradicateBVD.Indeed,manycountrieshavedonesosuccessfullyandothersareembarkingoncontrolofthedisease.TheidentificationandprompteliminationofPIcattlewillformthebasisofanycontrolprogramme.Thetradeofsuchanimalsmustbecurtailed.PregnantandpotentiallypregnantbovinescarryingPIfoetusesposeasignifi-cantthreat.Internationalexperienceindicatessystematic,wellcoordinatedprogrammeshavethemostsuccess,whilevoluntaryprogrammescanmakegoodinitialprogressbutultimatelyfail.Thefarmingcommunitymustbuyintoanyproposedprogramme,andwithouttheirsupport,failureislikely.TobuyintotheprogrammeandcreatesuchademandforBVDcontrol,farmersmustfirstbewellinformed.Itislikelythatstemmingeconomiclossandimprovingproduc-tivitywillbetheprimarymotivatoratindividualfarmlevel.
Copyright 2011 Barrett et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Aspects of bovine viral diarrhoea virus seroprevalence and vaccination in dairy and beef herds in the Republic of Ireland
Cowley, D.J.B.1, Clegg, T.A.2, Doherty, M.L.3, More, S.J.2, 3
1 MSD Animal Health, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Bovine-viraldiarrhoea(BVD)isaninfectiousdiseaseofcattlewithaworldwidedistribution.Herd-levelprevalencevariesamongEuropeanUnion(EU)memberstates,andprevalenceinformationfacilitatesdecision-makingandprogress-monitoringwithregardtocontrolanderadicationprogrammes.TheprimaryobjectiveofthepresentstudywastodescribeaspectsofherdBVDseroprevalence(basedonpooledsera)andcontrolonIrishfarms,includingvaccineusage.PreliminaryvalidationofanindirectBVDantibodyELISAtest(SVANOVA,BiotechAB,Uppsala,Sweden)usingpooledserawasconductedaspartofthepresentstudy.Thistestwasthenusedinacross-sectionalstudyofastratifiedrandomsampleof1171Irishdairyandbeefcowherdsin2009,forwhichvaccinationstatuswasdeterminedbytelephonesurvey,andtheseroprevalenceofBVDinIrelandwasestimatedinnon-vaccinatingherds.Comparisonofherd-levelclassificationwasconductedinasubsetof111dairyherdsusingthesameELISAonbulkmilktank(BMT)samples.Associationsbetweenpossibleriskfactors(herdsize(quartiles))andherd-levelprevalenceweredeterminedusingchi-squaredanalysis.Theherd-levelBVDprevalenceinnon-vaccinatingherdswas98.7%(95%CI-98.3-99.5%)inthecross-sectionalstudywithnosignificantdifferencebetweendairyandbeefherds(98.3%vs98.8%,respectively,p=0.595).95.4%agreementinherdclassificationofseroprevalencewasfoundwithbulkmilkcomparedtoserumpoolresultsinnon-vaccinatingherds.19.2percentoffarmersusedBVDVvaccine;81%ofvaccinatedherdsweredairy.Theresultsfromthisstudyindicatethatthetrueherd-levelseroprevalencetoBovineVirusDiarrhoea(BVD)virusinIreland
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 71
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
Bio
secure d
iseases
isapproaching100%.ThepresentstudywillassistAnimalHealthIreland(AHI),anindustry-governmentpartnershipchargedwiththenationalleadershipandcoordinationofnon-regulatoryinfectiousdiseasesinIreland,byprovidingusefulinformationtoguidepolicyandevaluateprogresstowardscontrol.
Cost benefit analysis of Irish BVD eradication programme
Stott, A.W.1, Humphry R.W.1, Gunn G.J.1, Higgins, I.M.2, Hennessy, T.3, O’Flaherty, J.4, Graham, D.A.4
1 Scottish Agricultural College, Edinburgh, Scotland, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 Teagasc, 4 Animal Health Ireland
Bovineviraldiarrhoeavirus(BVDV)causesaneconomicallyimportantendemicdisease(BVD)ofcattleinIrelandandworldwide.Systematiceradicationbydetectionandremovalofinfectious(BVDVcarrier)cattlehasbeensuccessfulinseveralregions.Wethereforeassessedthebenefits(diseaselossesavoided)andcosts(testingandcullingregime)ofapossiblefutureeradicationprogrammeinIreland.Publishedbio-economicmodelsofBVDVspreadinbeefsucklerherdsanddairyherdswereadaptedtoestimatethebenefitsoferadicationinIreland.AsimplemodelofBVDVspreadinbeeffinisherherdswasdevisedtoestimatethebenefitsoferadicationinthissector.Asixyeareradicationprogrammeconsistingof5inter-relatedvirologicalandserologicaltestingprogrammesisoutlinedandcosted.WefoundthattheannualisedbenefitsofBVDVeradicationinIrelandexceededthecostsbyafactorof5inthebeefsucklersectorandafactorof14inthedairysector.Correspondingpaybackperiodswere1.2and0.5yearsrespectively.Theseresultshigh-lightthesignificanteconomicimpactofBVDvirusontheIrishcattleindustryandsuggestacleareconomicbenefittoeradicationusingtheproposedapproach.Thistypeofcost-benefitanalysisisconsideredanessentialprerequisitepriortoundertakinganeradicationcampaignofthismagnitude.
Infectious bovine rhinotracheitis (IBR)
Aspects of bovine herpesvirus-1 infection in dairy and beef herds in the Republic of Ireland
Cowley, D.J.B.1, Clegg, T.A.2, Doherty, M.L.3, More, S.J.2, 3
1 MSD Animal Health, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica 53, 40 (2011)
Infectionwithbovineherpesvirus-1(BHV-1)causesawiderangeofdiseasemanifestations,includingrespiratorydiseaseandabortion,withworld-widedistribution.TheprimaryobjectiveofthepresentstudywastodescribeaspectsofBHV-1infectionandcontrolonIrishfarms,includingherd-levelseroprevalence(basedonpooledsera)andvaccineusage.ThecharacteristicsofadiagnosticindirectBHV-1antibodyELISAtestwhenusedonserumpoolswereevaluatedusinglabo-ratoryreplicatesforuseintheseroprevalencestudy.TheoutputfromthisindirectELISAwasexpressedasapercentagepositivity(PP)value.Aproposedcutoff(PCO)PPwasappliedinacross-sectionalstudyofastratifiedrandomsampleof1,175Irishdairyandbeefcattleherdsin2009,usingserumpools,toestimateherdseroprevalence.Thestudywasobservational,basedprimarilyontheanalysisofexistingsamples,andonlyaggregatedresultswerereported.Forthesereasons,ethicalapprovalwasnotrequired.Bulkmilksamplesfromasubsetof111dairyherdswereanalysedusingthesameELISA.Informationregardingvaccineusagewasdeterminedinatelephonesurvey.APCOPPof7.88%wasdeter-minedtogive97.1%sensitivityand100%specificityrelativetotheuseoftheELISAonindividualseragivingmaximi-zationoftheprevalenceindependentYouden’sindex,onreceiveroperatingcharacteristicsanalysisofreplicateresults.Theherd-levelBHV-1seroprevalencewas74.9%(95%CI-69.9%-79.8%),withnosignificantdifferencebetweendairyandbeefherds.95.5%agreementinherdclassificationwasfoundbetweenbulkmilkandserumpools.Only1.8percent
Biennial Report, 2010/201172
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SB
iose
cure
dis
ease
s
offarmersusedBHV-1markervaccine,80%ofwhichwaslivewhile75%ofvaccinatedherdsweredairy.Asignificantassociationwasfoundbetweenherdsize(quartiles)andseroprevalence(quartiles).TheresultsfromthisstudyindicateBHV-1infectionisendemic,althoughBHV-1vaccinesarerarelyused,inthecattlepopulationinIreland.
Copyright 2011 Cowley et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Dynamics of individual animal Bovine Herpes Virus-1 antibody status on 9 commercial dairy herds
Geraghty, T.1, O’Neill, R.2, More, S.J.1, 3, O’Grady, L.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 3 UCD CVERA
Research in Veterinary Science (in press)
BovineHerpesVirus1(BoHV-1)isanimportantviraldiseaseofcattleworldwide.Inendemicallyinfectedherds,thereisanincompleteunderstandingoftheepidemiologyofBoHV-1infection.Wedescribethedynamicsofanimal-levelBoHV-1antibodystatuson9endemicallyinfectedcommercialdairyherds,basedontheresultsofserialmilkantibodytesting.Resultswereusedtoidentifyprimaryexposure,secondaryexposure(fromre-activationorre-exposure)anddevelopmentoftest-negativelatentcarrier(TNLC)status.4,153testresultsfrom828cow-lactationswereanalysed.Primaryexposureoccurredontwoherds,secondaryexposureoccurredonallherdsanddevelopmentofTNLCstatusoccurredineightherds.Incidenceofsecondaryexposurereducedovertimeandmayhavebeenrelatedtoincreasingtimesinceparturition.Regularsecondaryexposureisrequiredtomaintainmeasurableantibodystatus.
Reprinted from Research in Veterinary Science, Geraghty, T., O’Neill, R., More, S.J., O’Grady, L., Dynamics of individual animal Bovine Herpes Virus-1 antibody status on 9 commercial dairy herds, in press, Copyright 2012, with permission from Elsevier.
Leptospirosis
Seroprevalence of Leptospira Hardjo in the Irish suckler cattle population
Ryan, E.G.1, Leonard, N.1, O’Grady, L.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Doherty, M.L.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
Priortothepresentstudy,theseroprevalenceofleptospirosisinIrishsucklerherdswasunknown.Inthisstudy,wedescribe the herd and animal-level prevalence of LeptospiraHardjoinfectionintheIrishsucklercattlepopulation.Forthepurposesofthestudy,the26countiesoftheRepublicofIrelandweredividedinto6regionsfromwhicharepresentativenumberofherdswereselected.Aherdwasconsideredeligibleforsamplingifitwasnotvaccinatingagainst leptospirosis and if it contained ≥9breedinganimalsofbeefbreed≥12monthsofage.Intotal,288randomlyselectedherdswereeligibleforinclusionintheseroprevalencedatasetanalysis.Serologicaltestingwascarriedoutusingacommerciallyavailablemonoclonalantibody-captureELISA,(sensitivity100%;specificity86.67%).Herdswerecategorisedaseither“freefrominfection”or“infected”usingtheepidemiologicalsoftwaretool,FreeCalc2.0.Usingthisclassification,237herdswere“infected”(82.29%).TheSouthWestandSouthEastregionshadthehighestherdpreva-lence.Theregionaleffectonherdprevalencewaslargelymirroredbybreedingherdsize.Atrueanimal-levelprevalenceof41.75%wascalculatedusingtheepidemiologicalsoftwaretool,TruePrev.Therewasastatisticallysignificantregional
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 73
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
Bio
secure d
iseases
trend,withtrueprevalencebeinghighestintheSouthEast(P<0.05).ThemedianBreedingHerdSize(BHS),whencategorisedintoquartiles,hadastatisticallysignificantinfluenceonindividualanimaltrueseroprevalence(P<0.001);trueseroprevalenceincreasedwithincreasingBHS.LeptospirosisisawidespreadendemicdiseaseintheRepublicofIreland.ItispossiblethateconomiclossesduetoleptospirosisinunvaccinatedIrishsucklerherdsmaybeunderestimated.
Herd-level risk factors associated with Leptospira Hardjo seroprevalence in the Republic of Ireland
Ryan, E.G.1, Leonard, N.1, O’Grady, L.1, Doherty, M.L.1, More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
TheaimofthepresentstudywastoinvestigateriskfactorsforherdseropositivitytoLeptospira HardjoinIrishsucklerherds.Herdswereconsideredeligibleforthestudyiftheywereunvaccinatedandcontained≥9breedinganimalsofbeef breed which were ≥12monthsofage.Thecountrywasdividedintosixregionsusingcountyboundaries.Herdandindividualanimalprevalencedatawereavailablefromtheresultsofaconcurrentseroprevalencestudy.Herdswereclas-sifiedas“freefromInfection”or“infected”ataminimumexpected40%within-herdprevalence.Questionnaireswerepostedto320herdschosenrandomlyfrom25countiesintheRepublicofIreland.Thequestionnairewasdesignedtoobtaininformationaboutvaccination;reproductivedisease;breedingherddetails;thepresenceofrecognisedriskfactorsfrompreviousstudies;andhusbandryoneachfarm.Datacollectedfrom128eligibleherds(n=128)weresubjectedtostatisticalanalysis.FollowingtheuseofPearson’sChi-SquareTest,thosevariablesassociatedwithaherdbeing“infected”with a significance level of P<0.2wereconsideredascandidatesformultivariablelogisticregressionmodelling.Breedingherdsizewasfoundtobeastatisticallysignificantriskfactoraftermultivariablelogisticregression.Theoddsofaherdbeingpositiveforleptospiralinfectionwere5.47timeshigher(P=0.032)inherdswith14to23breedinganimalscompared with herds with ≤13breedinganimals,adjustingforregion,and7.08timeshigher(P=0.033)inherdswith32.6to142breedinganimals.BreedingherdsizewasidentifiedasasignificantriskfactorforleptospiralinfectioninIrishsucklerherds,whichwassimilartofindingsofpreviousstudiesofleptospirosisindairyherds.
Biennial Report, 2010/201174
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SN
on
-bio
secu
re d
isea
ses
and
co
nd
itio
ns
Non-biosecure diseases and conditions
Milk quality
A HACCP-based approach to mastitis control in dairy herds. Part 1: Development
Beekhuis-Gibbon, L.1, Whyte, P.1, O’Grady, L.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Doherty, M.L.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 2 (2011)
HazardAnalysisandCriticalControlPoints(HACCP)systemsareariskbasedpreventiveapproachdevelopedtoincreaselevelsoffoodsafetyassurance.Thisispart1ofapilotstudyonthedevelopment,implementationandevalua-tionofaHACCP-basedapproachforthecontrolofgoodudderhealthindairycows.ThepaperdescribestheuseofanovelapproachbasedonadeconstructionoftheinfectiousprocessinmastitistoidentifyCriticalControlPoints(CCPs)anddevelopaHACCP-basedsystemtopreventandcontrolmastitisindairyherds.TheapproachinvolvedthecreationofanInfectiousProcessFlowDiagram,whichwasthencross-referencedtotwoproductionprocessflowdiagramsofthemilkingprocessandcowmanagementcycle.TheHACCPplandeveloped,maybesuitableforcustomisationandimple-mentationondairyfarms.Thisisalogical,systematicapproachtothedevelopmentofamastitiscontrolprogrammethatcouldbeusedasatemplateforthedevelopmentofcontrolprogrammesforotherinfectiousdiseasesinthedairyherd.
Copyright 2011 Beekhuis-Gibbon et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 75
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
No
n-b
iosecu
re diseases an
d co
nd
ition
s
A HACCP-based approach to mastitis control in dairy herds. Part 2: Implementation and evaluation
Beekhuis-Gibbon, L.1, Devitt, C.2, Whyte, P.1, O’Grady, L.1, More, S.J.1, 3, Redmond, B.2, Quin, S.2, Doherty, M.L.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD School of Applied Social Science, 3 UCD CVERA
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 7 (2011)
Part1ofthestudydescribedthedevelopmentofaHazardAnalysisandCriticalControlPoint(HACCP)basedprogrammeandaccompanyinghandbookforthecontrolofmastitis.Thispaperdescribestheimplementationandevalu-ationofcustomisedHACCP-basedprogrammes,whichweredevelopedfromthehandbookandassessedonsixIrishdairyfarms.Bothquantitativeandqualitative(actionresearch)researchmethodologieswereusedtomeasurethesuccessof implementation and efficacy of control of sub-clinical mastitis as measured by Somatic Cell Counts (SCC) and the degree of compliance by farmers in adopting and maintaining recommendations throughout the course of the study period.NooveralldifferencesinSCCbeforeandduringtheimplementationofthestudywerefoundwhenallsixfarmswereconsideredtogether.ThreeofthesixstudyfarmsexperiencedasignificantdecreaseinherdmilkrecordedSCCduringtheimplementationofthecontrolprogramme.Anessentialpartofthestudywasachievinginitialagreementonrecommendationsaswellasongoingmonitoringofcomplianceduringthestudy.ThispilotstudyshowsthatHACCPcanbeimplementedonfarmsasameansofworkingtowardsthecontrolofmastitisandthatfarmerattitude,andunder-standingofmastitisarecrucialintermsofmotivationirrespectiveofpracticalapproachesusedtomanagemastitis.
Copyright 2011 Beekhuis-Gibbon et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
An estimation of the effect of dilution due to milk yield on milk somatic cell count across cow parities in a grass-based system
Boland, F.1, Kelly, P.T.2, O’Sullivan, K.3, Berry, D.P.4, O’Brien, B.4, More, S.J.5, 6
1 UCD School of Mathematical Sciences, 2 Munster AI, 3 University College Cork, 4 Teagasc Moorepark, 5 UCD CVERA, 6 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
ThisstudyinvestigatestheinfluenceofparityontheassociationbetweenSCCandmilkyield.Itiswellrecognised,basedonpublishedinternationalwork,thathighSCCsareassociatedwithadropinmilkyield.Asyet,however,thereislimitedunderstandingoftherelativeimportanceofthiseffectacrossdifferentparities.Theresultsareimportant,bothfromtheperspectiveofimprovedscientificknowledge,andalsotoprovidekeyparametersfortheTeagascMooreparkeconomicmodelingofmastitisimpact.
The relationship between herd size in Ireland and milk somatic cell counts: A retrospective cohort study
Canty, M.J.1, Higgins, I.1, McGrath, G.1, More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
StudiesexaminingtherelationshipbetweenherdsizeandelevatedSCChaveconflictingreportsoftheassociationbetweenthetwo.ThemainobjectiveofthisstudywastodeterminetherelationshipbetweenherdsizeinIrelandandelevatedindividualcowgeometricmean24hmilkSCCabove200,000cells/ml[MSCC200]andabove400,000cells/
Biennial Report, 2010/201176
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SN
on
-bio
secu
re d
isea
ses
and
co
nd
itio
ns
ml[MSCC400]inanentirelactation,andtodeterminetheinfluenceofherdexpansionontheseparameters.IndividualcowmonthlycompositemilkrecordingsfromallIrishcowsenrolledwithICBFwereobtainedfor2009.Multivariablerandomeffectlogisticregressionmodelswerefitted.Theeffectofherdexpansionwasexaminedbyfittinganinterac-tiontermbetweenherdsizeandherdexpansion.Resultsshowthat26.25%and10.68%ofcowshadMSCC200andMSCC400,respectively.Themajorityofthesecows(62.59%)werefromherdsthathadnotexpanded(33.45%)orhadundergone ≤15%expansion(29.14%)inthepastfouryears.HerdsizewasassociatedwithMSCC200andMSCC400afteradjustingforanumberofvariables,withtheoddsofMSCC200andMSCC400higherinlargerherds.Therewasnointeractionbetweenherdsizeandherdexpansioninthemodelsfitted.InIreland,largermilkrecordingherdsmayneedtopayparticularattentiontotheirSCCstatus.Caution,however,shouldbetakenwheninterpretingtheresultsoftheeffectofherdsizefromthisandotherstudiesonSCCduetodifferenceindeterminationandcategorisationofherdsize.Resultsalsorevealthattherewaslittleherdexpansioninthesemilkrecordingherdsoverthefouryearsexamined.However,thismaychangesignificantlyinthenearfuturegiventhegrowingglobaldemandfordairyproducts.
Drivers and constraints to improving milk quality in Ireland
Devitt, C.1, McKenzie, K.2, Heanue, K.3, More, S.J.4, 5, McCoy, F.6
1 Private consultant, 2 Motiveworks, 3 Teagasc, 4 UCD CVERA, 5 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 6 Animal Health Ireland
Approximately85%ofannualproductionfromIreland’sdairyindustryisexported,highlightingtheneedforongoingimprovementinqualityinacompetitiveinternationaltradingenvironment.However,severalrecentstudieshavehighlightedconcernswithudderhealth/mastitisandassociatedintramammaryantibioticusageonIrishdairyfarms.CellCheck,anationalmastitiscontrolprogramme,waslaunchedbyAnimalHealthIreland(AHI)inlate2010.Aprocesscalled‘terrain-mapping’wasconductedtounderstandindustrychallengesanddriverstomilkqualityimprovement.In-depthqualitativeinterviewswere completed with n=12representativesfromdifferentsectorsoftheIrishdairyindustry.Disagreementexistsinacknowledgingindividualstakeholderresponsibilityincontributingtomilkqualityimprovement,andinagreeingonthebestwayforward.Thisisdespiteconsensusontheneedtoredefinequalitymilkabovecurrentregulatorystandards, and of the common recognition of opportuni-ties.Disagreementstranslateintoconcernsaboutlackofcommitment and active response to what should be an integratedindustry-ledresponse.Opportunitiesforincre-mentalchangeintheIrishdairysectorareunderminedbyan emphasis on maintaining the private good over contrib-utingtothepublicgood.AnimalHealthIrelandprovidesanopportunitytobuildstakeholderagreement.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 77
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
No
n-b
iosecu
re diseases an
d co
nd
ition
s
Current practices to manage milk quality on Irish dairy farms
McCoy, F.1, Devitt, C.2, McKenzie, K.3, More, S.J.4, 5, Heanue, K.6
1 Animal Health Ireland, 2 Private consultant, 3 Motiveworks, 4 UCD CVERA, 5 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 6 Teagasc
ApilotprogrammeoffarmerworkshopswasrecentlyconductedaspartofthenationalCellCheckmilkqualityprogramme.Theobjectiveofthisworkshopwastodeliverbestscience&practiceinformationaroundmastitiscontroltofarmers,andtoencouragetheuptakeofkeybestpracticesineverydaymilkingroutines.Anopportunityarose,aspartofthispilot,toreportcurrentpracticestomanagemilkqualityonIrishdairyfarms.Thisprojectreportsthesefindings,withearlyresultshighlightingdifferencesbetweenthereportedfrequencyofkeybehaviours,andthequalityofthesebehaviours,includinglinerchangeandteatdisinfection.
Mapping milk production in Ireland
McGrath, G.1, Clegg, T.1
1 UCD CVERA
ThisprojectseekstopresentanationalmapofmilkproductionbasedondatasuppliedbytheIrishCattleBreedingFederationformilkrecordingherds.AGeographicalInformationSystemwillbeemployedtogenerateatriangularirregularnetworktocreateasurfacethatwillberepresentativeoftheentirecountrybasedonasampleofapproximately6,000herds.
Insights into udder health and intramammary antibiotic usage on Irish dairy farms during 2003-2010
More, S.J.1, 2, Clegg, T.A.1, O’Grady, L.2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
ThispaperpresentsinsightsintoudderhealthandintramammaryantibioticusageonIrishdairyfarmsduring2003-2010,basedondatafromseveralsources.Threedatasourceswereused,includingdataonmilkrecordingdata,intramammaryanti-bioticsalesandanimalhealthassessment.Themilkrecordingdataincludedasingleunadjustedherd-levelsomaticcellcount(SCC)valueforeachherdateachmilkrecording,beingthearithmeticmeanofcow-levelSCCofeachcowatthatrecording,weightedbycow-levelyield.ThesedatawereusedtocalculatethepercentageofherdseachmonthwheretheunadjustedherdSCCexceeded200,000and400,000cells/mL.Twologisticgeneralisedestimating-equations(GEE)modelsweredeveloped,theoutcomevariablebeingeithertheprobabilitythatthemonthlySCCofaherdwasgreaterthan400,000cells/mLorlessthanorequalto200,000cells/mL.SpringherdshadalowerprobabilityofahighSCC(>400,000cells/mL)duringFebruarytoOctobercomparedtonon-SpringherdsbutahigherprobabilitybetweenNovembertoJanuary.TheoddsofahighSCCweregreaterin2005,2006,2009and2010butlessin2007and2008comparedto2004.SmallerherdshadhigheroddsofhavingahighSCCcomparedtolargerherds.Wepresentthenumberofintramammarytubesandthequantityofactivesubstance(kg)soldannuallyinIrelandduring2003-2010.Weinferanincidenceofclinicalmastitisof54.7casesper100cow-yearsatrisk,assuming4tubespertreatmentregime,oneaffectedquarterpercow,tubesrestrictedtoclinicalcasesonlyand100%oftreatedcasesconsiderednewcases,basedondatacollectedonsalesofin-lactationintra-mammaryantibiotics.Withdifferingassumptions,thisestimatevariedbetween26.1and77.9casesper100cow-yearsatrisk.Usingdataonsalesofdrycowtherapyintra-mammaryantibiotics,wealsoinferthatmostIrishdairyfarmersuseblanketdrycowtherapy.UdderhealthisaconcernonanumberofIrishdairyfarms.HighSCCresultswerepresentthroughouttheyear,butmoremarkedtowardsthestartandendofeachmilkingseason.AnimalHealthIrelandrecentlycommencedamajornationalprogramme,CellCheck,incollaborationwithabroadrangeofstakeholders,tosupportnationalSCCimprovement.
Biennial Report, 2010/201178
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SN
on
-bio
secu
re d
isea
ses
and
co
nd
itio
ns
The effect of data adjustment for somatic cell counts, as outlined in EU legislation, on herd eligibility to supply raw milk for human consumption
More, S.J.1, 2, Clegg, T.A.1, O’Grady, L.2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
RegulatorySCClimitshavebeenestablishedinmanydairyproducingcountries,toimprovemilkqualityandherdproductivity.WithintheEuropeanUnion,rawmilkmustcomplywithmicrobiologicalcriteriaandstandardsforplatecountandsomaticcellcount,asrequiredunderEURegulation853/2004.Inthecurrentstudy,weexaminetheeffectofdataadjustmentforsomaticcellcounts,asoutlinedincurrentEUlegislation,onherdeligibilitytosupplyrawmilkforhumanconsumption,usingIrishdataforillustration.
Fertility
Breeding soundness evaluation of 36 bulls with reduced reproductive performance: a retrospective study
Beltman, M.E.1, Canty, M.J.2
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
Theobjectiveofthisstudywastodeterminethefertilitystatusof36bullspresentedwithahistoryofreducedreproduc-tiveperformancetoUniversityVeterinaryHospital,UniversityCollegeDublinbetween27/11/2006and14/03/2011.Afullbreedingsoundnessevaluation(BSE)wasperformedonallbullsbythesameclinicianatsubmission.ComponentsoftheBSEincludedafullgeneralclinicalexam,assessmentofthelocomotionsystemandassessmentofthereproductivetract.Reproductivetractevaluationcomprisedmeasurementofthescrotalcircumference(cm),assessmentoftesticlesforshame,symmetryandconsistency.Thepenisandprepucewereassessedbyinspectionandpalpationandtheaccessoryglandswereassessedviarectalpalpation.Subsequentlyasemensamplewasobtainedbyelectro-ejaculation.Followingsemencollectiontheparametersassessedwere;volumeoftheejaculate(ml),colouroftheejaculate(1=almostclear,2=skimmilk,3=milk),spermconcentration(x106),spermmotility(1to5),percentagelivesperm(%)andpercentagenormalsperm(%).Theseresultswereusedtoclassifyanimalsasfertile,sub-fertileorinfertileonthedayofexamination.Achi-squaretestwasusedtoassesstheunadjustedrelationshipbetweenfertilityclassificationandcolour,andfertilityclassificationandmotility.Ageatexamination,scrotalcircumference,semenvolume,concentration,percentagelivespermandpercentagenormalsperm,allcontinuousvariablesweredividedintocategoricalvariablesbasedonquartiles.Theaverageageofbullsatexaminationwas2.7±0.21years(range1.2–5.8).Noneofthe36bullspresentedwithphys-icalabnormalities.AftertheBSEandsemenevaluation,15wereclassifiedasfertile,8assub-fertileand13asinfertile.Colour (P<0.001)andmotility(P=0.05)weresignificantlyassociatedwithfertilityclassification.Afterconvertingfromcontinuous to categorical variables, concentration (P<0.001)andpercentagelivesperm(P=0.002)werealsoassociatedwithfertilityclassification.Ofthosebullsclassifiedasinfertile,motilespermwerefoundinonly3samplesexamined.Inconclusion,BSEwasperformedon36bullswithquestionablefertility.Ofthese36bulls,nonewerephysicallyabnormaland15/36(42%)hadnormalsemen.Oftheparametersmeasuredcolouroftheejaculate,spermmotilityaswellasconcentrationandpercentagelivespermweredirectlyrelatedtooverallfertilityoutcome.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 79
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
No
n-b
iosecu
re diseases an
d co
nd
ition
s
Effect of body condition score at key reproductive stages and vaginal mucus score on production and reproduction parameters in dairy cows
Beltman, M.E.1, Duane, M.1, Canty, M.J.2, Mulligan, F.J.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
Theobjectivesweretwo-fold:i)toinvestigatetheeffectofBodyConditionScore(BCS)atcalvingandat1stserviceonthefollowingproductionandreproductionparameters:vaginalmucusscoreat3-4weekspostpartum,calving-1stservice,calving-conception,numberofserves,peakdailymilkyield,milkfatandproteinat1stmilkrecording,averagemilkyieldduringdurationofthestudy,conceptionratesto1stand2ndserviceandoverallpregnancyrate,andii)toinvestigatetheeffectofvaginalmucusscoreat3-4weekspostpartumonthesameparameters,aswellastotalyieldfatandprotein.NinetyspringcalvingFriesian/Holsteincowsonacommercialdairyfarmwereused.BCSwasrecordedonascalefrom1-5atcalvingandat1stserviceandvaginalmucusscorewasrecordedbetween3and4weekspostpartumonascalefrom0-3.AllotherproductionandreproductionparameterswerecollectedattheendofthebreedingseasonandalldatawereanalysedusingChisquareanalysis.CowswithaBCSlowerthan2.5atcalvingtendedtohavealongercalving-1stserviceinterval(p=0.068).ThegroupofcowsthathadaBCSof2.5hadasignificantlylower(p=0.04)overallpregnancyrateandreceivedmoreservicesthanallotherBCSgroups.CowswithaBCSof2.25at1stservicehada lower pregnancy rate than the cows in all the other groups, but these cows also tended to have received less services per conception.Cowswithahighvaginalmucusscoreatcalvinghadasignificantlower(p<0.05)averagedailymilkyieldintheexperimentalperiodandasignificantlowertotalyieldprotein.Inconclusion,lowBCShadanegativeeffectonsomeof the reproductive parameters measured and uterine infection as measured by vaginal mucus score had a negative effect onsomeoftheproductionparameters.
Key factors affecting dairy cow fertility in Ireland - pilot study
Lane, E.A.1, Beltman, M.2, More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The analysis of herd management records allows for accurate assessment of the current status of the herd, a crucial deci-sionmakingtooltoimplementeffectivechange.Theaimofthisstudyistoevaluatetherelativeimportanceofsomecowandmanagementfactorsonreproductiveindicesinmoderateyieldingseasonaldairyherds.Breedingrecordsofallcowswerecollectedon10seasonalcalvingherds,duringherdhealthvisits,between2007and2009.Individualcowidentities(n=1,174),calvingdate,allservicedates,lactationnumber,andpregnancydiagnosisoutcomeswererecordedforallmilkingcows.Logisticregressionmodellingwillbeusedtodeterminetheeffectofcowfactorsincludingparity,timingofcalvingrelativetostartofbreedingseasonandnumberofdayspostpartumatfirstservice,onreproductiveindices.Herdfactorsincludingaverageheatdetectionefficiencyandherdsizewillbeinvestigated.
Key factors affecting dairy cow fertility in Ireland - larger study
Lane, E.A.1, More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The analysis of herd management records allows for accurate assessment of the current status of the herd, a crucial deci-sionmakingtooltoimplementeffectivechange.Monitoringofsuchchangestoensuretheireffectivenessisessentialtothesuccessofanyprogramme,while,participationindiscussiongroups,allowsforpeercomparisons,akeyfactorinmotivatingherdmanagementchange.Theaimofthispaperistocalculatethefertilityindicesofherdsrecordedon
Biennial Report, 2010/201180
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h I
SS
UE
SN
on
-bio
secu
re d
isea
ses
and
co
nd
itio
ns
theIrishCattleBreedingFederation(ICBF)’sdatabasetoenableeffectiveevaluationofthefertilityperformanceoftheIrishdairyherdandtodeterminethekeydriversofinfertilityintheIrishdairyherd.Breedingrecorddataofthe2009breedingseasonfromallspringcalvingIrishdairyherdsregisteredforICBF’sHerdPlusservice,thathadaminimumofsixrecordingsduring2009,werecollectedfromdatabase.Individualcowidentities(jumbotagandnationalidentifiers),dateofbirth,lactationnumber,EstimatedBreedingIndex(EBI;milkandfertility)2009calvingdate,allservicedates,sireandinseminatorforeachservice,pregnancydiagnosisoutcomes,subsequentcalvingdate,recordedmilkyields,fatandproteinconcentrationsateachrecordingperiodweregatheredforallmilkingcowswithineachherd.Logisticregres-sionmodellingusingthestatiscalpackageSTATAwillbeutilizedtoanalysethedataset.Analyseswillbeconductedatanimalleveltakingclusteringwithinherdintoaccount.
Calf health
Calf health from birth to weaning. I. General aspects of disease prevention
Lorenz, I.1, Mee, J.F.2, Earley, B.3, More, S.J.1, 4
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 Teagasc Moorepark, 3 Teagasc Grange, 4 UCD CVERA
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 10 (2011)
Calfhooddiseaseshaveamajorimpactontheeconomicviabilityofcattleoperations.Thisisthefirstinathreepartreviewseriesoncalfhealthfrombirthtoweaning,focusingonpreventivemeasures.Thereviewconsidersbothpre-andperiparturient management factors influencing calf health, colostrum management in beef and dairy calves and further nutritionandweaningindairycalves.
Copyright 2011 Lorenz et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Calf health from birth to weaning. II. Management of diarrhoea in pre-weaned calves
Lorenz, I.1, Fagan, J.2, More, S.J.1, 3
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 3 UCD CVERA
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 9 (2011)
Calfhooddiseaseshaveamajorimpactontheeconomicviabilityofcattleoperations.Thesecondofthisthreepartreviewseriesconsidersthemanagementofdiarrhoeicdiseasesinpre-weanedcalves.Inneonatalcalfdiarrhoea,oralrehydration therapy is the single most important therapeutic measure to be carried out by the farmer and is usually successfulifinstigatedimmediatelyafterdiarrhoeahasdeveloped.Continuedfeedingofmilkormilkreplacertodiarrhoeiccalvesisimportant,topreventmalnourishmentandweightlossinaffectedcalves.Indiscriminativeanti-biotic treatment of uncomplicated diarrhoea is discouraged, whereas systemically ill calves can benefit from systemic antibiotictreatmentforthepreventionofsepticaemiaorconcurrentdiseases.Ancillarytreatmentsandspecificpreventivemeasuresarediscussed.Eimeriosishasahigheconomicimpactonthefarmingindustriesduetodirectcost of treatment and calf losses, but especially due to decreased performance of clinically as well as sub-clinically
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 81
NO
N-R
EG
Ul
AT
OR
y C
AT
Tl
E h
EA
lT
h IS
SU
ES
No
n-b
iosecu
re diseases an
d co
nd
ition
s
affectedanimals.Emphasisliesonprophylacticormetaphylactictreatment,sincethedegreeofdamagetotheintes-tinalmucosaoncediarrhoeahasdeveloped,makestherapeuticinterventionunrewarding.
Copyright 2011 Lorenz et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Calf health from birth to weaning. III. Housing and management of calf pneumonia
Lorenz, I.1, Earley, B.2, Gilmore, J.3, Hogan, I.4, Kennedy, E.5, More, S.J.1, 6
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 Teagasc Grange, 3 Emlagh Lodge Veterinary Centre, 4 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service,
5 Teagasc Moorepark, 6 UCD CVERA
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 12 (2011)
Calfhooddiseaseshaveamajorimpactontheeconomicviabilityofcattleoperations.Athreepartreviewserieshasbeendevelopedfocusingoncalfhealthfrombirthtoweaning.Inthispaper,thelastofthethreepartseries,wereviewdisease prevention and management with particular reference to pneumonia, focusing primarily on the pre-weaned calf.Pneumoniainrecentlyweanedsucklercalvesisalsoconsidered,wherethekeyriskfactorsarerelatedtothetimeofweaning.Weaningofthesucklercalfisoftencombinedwithadditionalstressorsincludingachangeinnutrition,environmentalchange,transportandpainfulhusbandryprocedures(castration,dehorning).Thereductionofthecumu-lative effects of these multiple stressors around the time of weaning together with vaccination programmes (precondi-tioning)canreducesubsequentmorbidityandmortalityinthefeedlot.Inmoststudies,calveshousedindividuallyandcalveshousedoutdoorswithshelter,areassociatedwithdecreasedriskofdisease.Eventhoughitposesgreatermanage-mentchallenges,successfulgrouphousingofcalvesispossible.Specialemphasisshouldbegiventoequalagegroupsandtokeepinggroupsstableoncetheyareformed.Themanagementofpneumoniaincalvesisreliantonasoundunderstandingofaetiology,relevantriskfactorsandofeffectiveapproachestodiagnosisandtreatment.Earlysignsofpneumoniaincludeincreasedrespiratoryrateandfever,followedbydepression.Thesinglemostimportantfactordeter-miningthesuccessoftherapyincalveswithpneumoniaisearlyonsetoftreatment,andsubsequentadequatedurationoftreatment.Theefficacyandeconomicalviabilityofvaccinationagainstrespiratorydiseaseincalvesremainsunclear.
Copyright 2011 Lorenz et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Calf mortality in Ireland
Lorenz, I.1, Higgins, I.M.2, Canty, M.J.2
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
TheobjectiveofthisstudyistodeterminethemortalityrateofallcalvesinIrelandbornbetween1stJuly2009and31stJune2010,andtoidentifyriskfactorsassociatedwithcalfmortality.
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
82 Biennial Report, 2010/2011
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 83
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
S
Other animal health and welfare issues
Animal welfare ......................................................................................................... 84
- Bovine welfare .......................................................................................................... 84
- Equine health and welfare ........................................................................................ 87
- Porcine welfare ......................................................................................................... 91
Emergency issues ..................................................................................................... 92
Transmissible spongiform encephalopathy (TSE) .................................................. 93
Q fever ...................................................................................................................... 94
Companion animal epidemiology ........................................................................... 96
Cadmium exposure in cattle ................................................................................... 98
International collaboration ..................................................................................... 99
Miscellaneous ......................................................................................................... 101
Biennial Report, 2010/201184
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
An
imal
wel
fare
Animal welfare
Bovine welfare
A review of bovine cases consigned under veterinary certification to emergency and casualty slaughter in Ireland during 2006 to 2008
Cullinane, M.1, O’Sullivan, E.2, Collins, G.1, Collins, D.M.3, More, S.J.3, 4
1 DAFM, 2 Cork County Council, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Irish Veterinary Journal 63, 568-577 (2010)
Theemergencyandcasualtyslaughterofcattleforhumanconsumption(incaseswhereanimalsarelikelytohavesufferedfromacuteorchronicpain,respectively)inIrelandrequiresthattheanimalisaccompaniedtotheslaughter-housebyanofficialveterinarycertificate(VC)completedon-farmbytheowner’sprivateveterinarypractitioner(PVP).NopublisheddataiscurrentlyavailableinIrelandbasedoninformationprovidedintheseVCs.Inthispaper,wepresentareviewofbovinecasesconsignedunderveterinarycertificationtoemergencyandcasualtyslaughterinIrelandduring2006to2008.AllVCsduringtheyears2006(whereavailable),2007and2008werecollectedfromfourlargeIrishslaughterhouses.Thedatawerecomputerized,andanalysedusingdescriptiveandspatialmethods.Intotal,1,255VCswereenrolledintothestudy(1,255studyanimals,1,072studyherds),798(63.6%)and457(36.4%)animalswereconsignedtoemergencyandcasualtyslaughter,respectively.VCswerecompletedthroughouttheyear,withconsignedanimalstravellingameandistanceof27.2kmfromfarmtoslaughter.Thetimeelapsedbetweenveterinarycertificationandslaughterwasgreaterthanthreedaysfor18.2%ofallstudyanimals.In965(76.9%)animals,thecertifiedsuspecteddisabilityrelatedtothelocomotorysystem,mostcommonlyasaresultoffractures.Amonganimalsforwhichdatawereavailable,11.9%weretotallycondemnedatpost-mortem.Thetransportofanimalswithfracturedlimbsand/orotherpainfulconditionsisasignificantanimalwelfareconcern.
Printed with permission from the Irish Veterinary Journal.
Veterinary certificates for emergency or casualty slaughter bovine animals in Ireland: are the welfare needs of certified animals adequately protected?
Cullinane, M.1, O’Sullivan, E.2, Collins, G.1, Collins, D.M.3, More, S.J.3, 4
1 DAFM, 2 Cork County Council, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
AllemergencyandcasualtybovinesintheRepublicofIrelandthataredeemedtobefitforhumanconsumptionmustbeaccompaniedtotheslaughterhousebyanofficialveterinarycertificate(VC).Inapreviousstudy,Cullinaneet al.(2010)conductedareviewofbovinecasesconsignedunderveterinarycertificationtoemergencyandcasualtyslaughterinIrelandduring2006to2008.Thecurrentstudywillfurtherevaluatetheoriginalresults,withemphasisontheperiodofvalidity,transportdistanceandtransportconditions.ItwillalsoconsiderwhetherornotthecurrentVCadequatelyprotectsthewelfareneedsofthecertifiedbovineanimal.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 85
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SA
nim
al welfare
Identification of key performance indicators for on-farm animal welfare incidents: possible tools for early warning and prevention
Kelly, P.C.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Blake, M.1, Hanlon, A.J.2
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 13 (2011)
TheobjectiveofthisstudywastodescribeaspectsofcasestudyherdsinvestigatedbytheDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM)inwhichanimalwelfareincidentsoccurredandtoidentifykeyperformanceindica-tors(KPIs)thatcanbemonitoredtoenhancetheEarlyWarningSystem(EWS).DespiteanEWSbeinginplaceforanumberofyears,animalwelfareincidentscontinuetooccur.QuestionnairesregardingwelfareincidentsweresenttoSuperintendingVeterinaryInspectors(SVIs),resultingin18herdsbeingchosenascasestudyherds,12ofwhichhadaclearlydefinedwelfareincidentdate.Foreachstudyherd,dataonsixpotentialKPIswereextractedfromDAFMdatabases.TheKPIsforthoseherdswithaclearlydefinedwelfareincidentdatewerestudiedforaconsecutivefouryearwindow,withthefourthyearbeingthe‘incidentyear’,whenthewelfareincidentwasdisclosed.Forstudyherdswithoutaclearlydefinedwelfareincidentdate,theKPIsweredeterminedonayearlybasisbetween2001and2009.Wefoundthat the late registration of calves, the use of on-farm burial as a method of carcase disposal, an increasing number of movestoknackeriesovertimeandrecordsofanimalsmovedto‘herdunknown’werenotableonthecasefarms.FourKPIswereprominentonthecasestudyfarmsandwarrantfurtherinvestigationincontrolherdstodeterminetheirpotentialtoprovideaframeworkforrefiningcurrentsystemsofearlywarningandprevention.
Copyright 2011 Kelly et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
On farm animal welfare: the utility of databases for early warning
Kelly, P.C.1, Higgins, I.2, More, S.J.2, 3, Blake, M.1, Hanlon, A.3
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
During the last four years, the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) has sponsored two studies toinvestigateon-farmanimalwelfareincidentsthathaveoccurredonIrishfarmsandthathavebeeninvestigatedbyDAFM.Thefirststudy(unpublished)lookedatincidentswhichoccurredbetweenSeptember2006andMarch2007.Themorerecentstudyonanimalwelfareincidentslookedspecificallyat18casestudyherdsandidentifiedfourpotentialkeyperformanceindicator(KPIs),theinformationonwhichwasdownloadedfromDAFMdatabases,thatcouldbeusedtoenhancetheEarlyWarningSystem(EWS),i.e.lateregistrationsofcalves,anincreaseintheuseofon-farmburialasamethodofcarcasedisposal,anincreaseinthenumberofcarcasessenttoknackeriesandanimalsmissingfromtheherdprofilethatcannotbeaccountedfor.ThatstudyrecognisedtheneedfortheseKPIstobestudiedincontrolherdsto see if they also occur in the national herd or if they are more notable in the case study herds and therefore of use in enhancingtheEWS.Insummary,theobjectiveofthiscurrentstudyistoexamine,incontrolherds,thefourKPIsiden-tified in the earlier DAFM study to see if their occurrence is irregular and potentially indicative of other problems occur-ringonthefarm.
Biennial Report, 2010/201186
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
An
imal
wel
fare
A sociological study investigating reasons for animal welfare incidents on-farm
Devitt, C.1, Kelly, P.2, More, S.J.3, 4, Blake, M.2, Hanlon, A.3
1 Independent consultant, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 UCD CVERA
In2004,theDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM)inconjunctionwiththeFarmAnimalWelfareAdvisoryCouncil(FAWAC),establishedanEarlyWarningSystem(EWS)aimedatpreventingfarmanimalwelfareincidentstakingplaceonIrishfarms.Despiteitsestablishment,welfareproblemsonIrishfarmsstillpersist.ArecentDAFMsponsoredstudyonanimalwelfareincidentslookedspecificallyat18casestudyherdsandidentifiedfourpoten-tialkeyperformanceindicators(KPIs)thatcouldbeusedtoenhancetheEWS,i.e.lateregistrationsofcalves,anincreaseintheuseofon-farmburialasamethodofcarcasedisposal,anincreaseinthenumberofcarcasessenttoknackeriesandanimalsmissingfromtheherdprofilethatcannotbeaccountedfor.Anecdotalevidencefromthatstudyandotherssuggestalinkagebetweensocialfactorsandwelfareincidents.Thesecompriseeconomic,health,psychologicalfactors,examplesincludingthedeathofaparent,illhealth,depression,andproblemsrelatedtoalcoholuse.Thisevidencesuggeststhatsuchlife-eventscanhaveadirectandindirectroleonindividualfarmmanagement.ThereisnoevidenceofresearchinIrelandonlinkagesbetweensocialfactorsandanimalwelfareincidents.ItisthereforeproposedthatthisstudywillinvestigateandaimtoidentifysocialfactorsthatcontributetoanimalwelfareincidentsonIrishfarms.Thisstudywilltakeaqualitativeapproach,usingin-depthface-to-faceinterviewstoexploreandidentifythesefactors,andconsiderhowtheycontributedtoanimalwelfareincidentsinIreland.
Use of farmer focus groups to evaluate a welfare scheme for suckler beef cattle
Dwane, A.M.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Blake, M.3, Hanlon, A.J.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 DAFM
SchemestoimprovefarmanimalwelfarehaveexistedinEuropesincethe1990s.ReformoftheCommonAgriculturalPolicy(CAP)in2003providedfundsforanimalwelfareinitiatives.In2008,Ireland’sDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM)launchedtheAnimalWelfare,RecordingandBreedingSchemeforSucklerHerds(‘SucklerScheme’).Themainaimsoftheschemeincludeenhancingwelfarestandardsandimprovinggeneticqualityofthenationalbeefherd.Thisisavoluntaryschemebasedoneconomicincentives.Initialuptakewaswidespreadwithapprox-imately50,000farmersjoining(approximately76%ofregisteredbeefsucklerherds).Littleresearchhasfocusedontheattitudesofbeeffarmers’toanimalwelfareschemes.Theobjectivesofthisstudyweretoseekfarmers’opinionsofthe‘SucklerScheme’,toexploretheunderlyingreasonsfortheseopinionsaswellasperceptionsofthescheme’srelationshiptowelfare,andtoelicitideasforimprovingfutureschemes.Inthisstudy,fourfocusgroups(eachcomprising7+sucklerfarmers)wereconductedinNovember2009infourregionsofIreland.Participantsweresourcedthroughlocalveteri-nariansandinvitedtoattendthefocusgroups.Ethicalapprovalwasobtainedinadvanceandparticipantsreceivedafullexplanationofhowdatawouldbemanagedbeforeconsentingtotakepart.Audiorecordingsweretranscribedverbatimandthen‘coded’fortopicsandviewsmentioned.CodingandthematicanalysiswerecarriedoutusingNVIVO8,asoft-wareprogrammedesignedforqualitativedataanalysis.Themajorityofparticipantsperceivedalltheschememeasuresasbeingimportantandrelevanttogoodfarmingpracticeswhileacknowledgingthatnotallmeasuresrelatedtowelfarebutrathertodatacollectionandbreedingofbeefcattle.Therewasstrongconsensusthatthemeasuresrelatingtotheminimumageatfirstcalvingandtomeal-feedingatweaninghaveapositiveimpactonanimalwelfareandhealth.Twomeasureswerecriticizedforbeingimpractical(i.e.theamountofpaperworkforrecordinganimaleventsandthecondi-tionsconcerningthedisbuddingofcalves).Theconditionsforthetimingofweaningwerealsocriticizedforhavinganegativefinancialimpactatsales.Participantsalsosuggestedadditionalmeasuresthatcouldfurtherimproveanimalwelfare.Theinabilitytoproducehigh-qualitybeefanimalsataprofitisofconcerntofarmers.Themajorityanticipatedthatthedatabeingcollectedviatheschemewouldhelpinformdecisionswhentryingtobreeda‘quality’beefanimal.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 87
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SA
nim
al welfare
Use of farmer focus groups to explore compliance issues relating to a welfare scheme for suckler beef cattle
Dwane, A.M.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Blake, M.3, Hanlon, A.J.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 DAFM
On-farmanimalwelfareisprimarilydeterminedbyfarmercompliancewithregulations(andqualityassurancestand-ards).Thelevelsofcompliance,however,mayprovedifficulttoassess.Ireland’sAnimalWelfare,RecordingandBreedingSchemeforSucklerHerds(‘SucklerScheme’)waslaunchedbytheDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM)in2008,providingfinancialincentivestosucklerbeeffarmersforimplementinganumberofspecifiedwelfarepractices.Initialuptakeoftheschemewaswidespreadwithapproximately50,000farmersjoining(approximately76%ofeligibleherds).UsingtheSchemeasacasestudy,ourresearchhasfocusedonexploringthefactorsthatinfluencebeeffarmers’willingnessorabilitytocomplywithwelfareguidelines.Inthisstudy,fourfocusgroups(eachcomprising7-9farmers)wereconductedin2009.Participantsweresourcedthroughlocalveterinariansandinvitedtoattend.Audiorecordingsofdiscussionsweretranscribedverbatimandthen‘coded’fortopicsandviewsmentioned.CodingandthematicanalysiswerecarriedoutusingNVIVO8.Whenaskedtolisttimeswhenwelfareismostatrisk,participantsrespondedasfollows:calving(88%),weaning(69%),nutrition/bodyconditionduringpregnancy(25%),handling(25%),housing(22%)anddisbudding/dehorning(16%).Allfourgroupscommentedthatallexistingschememeasureswererelevanttogoodfarmingpracticesandthereforeshouldcontinue.Participantssuggestedamendmentstoanumberofmeasuresasfollows:changedisbuddingages;simplifypaperwork;changethetraining;increaseschemepayments;andchangeweaningrules.Focusgroupsprovidescopefordeeperexplorationintotheattitudesandbeliefsunderlyingparticipants’answersinawaythatmoreconventionalsurveysmaynot.Theyalsoprovideanopportunityforfarmerstodiscusscomplianceissueswithouttheriskofincurringafarminspectionorfinancialpenalty.Farmersseemmotivatedtocomplywhencriteriaresultinfinancialbenefit,arepracticalandworkable,impactpositivelyonwelfareandhealth(e.g.minimumageatfirstcalvingandmeal-feeding),oraresuchthatfailuretocomplymaytriggerinspectionand/orlossofpayments(e.g.attendanceattraining).Farmersseemlessmotivatedtocomplywhencriteriaseemimpracticalatfarmlevel,mayhaveanegligibleorevennegativeeffectonwelfare(e.g.agefordisbudding),areover-complicated(e.g.paper-work),lackconsistency,ormaycausefinancialloss(e.g.Weaning).
Equine health and welfare
Evaluation of current equine welfare issues in Ireland: causes, desirability, feasibility and means of raising standards
Collins, J.A.1, Hanlon, A.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Wall, P.G.3, Kennedy, J.4, Duggan, V.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Public Health, Physiotherapy and Population Science, 4 UCD Geary Institute
Equine Veterinary Journal 42, 105-113 (2010)
SignificantpotentialthreatstothehealthandwelfareofhorsesexistinIrelandwhensupplyexceedsdemandandtheidentificationsystemforhorsesisnotyetrobust.TheobjectiveofthisstudywastosecureengagementwithstakeholdergroupsanddeterminetheirperceptionofequinewelfareinIrelandandencouragethedevelopmentofinclusive,ratherthanimposed,policysolutions.A3round,web-basedPolicyDelphiincorporatingnovelvignettemethodologywasconductedfromNovember2007–March2008tocanvassopinion(inbothquantitativeandqualitativeforms)ontheperceivedmostsignificantequinewelfareissues.Vignettes(narrativesdepictingpotentialcompromisetoequinewelfare)wereemployed.Quantitativedatawerecollectedintheformofscoringona9pointLikertscalewithlabelledend-points,qualitativeinformationastextsubsequentlyanalysedforthemes.All44respondentscompletedallrounds.Majorequinewelfareissueswereidentifiedaswelfareofhorsesduringthedisposalprocessandatunregulatedgatherings.Assessed
Biennial Report, 2010/201188
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
An
imal
wel
fare
quantitativelyona9pointLikertscale(0=minimal;8=maximal),respondentsscoredthedesirabilityandfeasibilityofimprovingstandards,median8and6,respectively,forbothissuesidentified.Basicthemesidentifiedinrespondents’quotesasreasonstoraiseequinewelfarestandardswereideological,protectionofanimalwelfare,safe-guardingthereputationoftheequineindustryandsafety(ofpeople,horsesandenvironment).Themesforreasonsforlowstandardsweresocietalnorms,fiscalpressures,indolence,indifferenceandignorance.Themesunderpinningpotentialmeansforachievingmeaningfulchange(solutions)werelegislation,enforcement,education/training,fiscalremedies,increasingawarenessandacombinationofthese.Mechanismsaimedatraisingstandardsmustbebasedonanunderstandingofmotivationaldriversforcurrentlylowstandards.Thechallengeistotranslatethefindingsandthisheightenedawarenessintomeaningfulchangetothebenefitofhorsesandthosewhocareforthem.
Reprinted from Equine Veterinary Journal, 42, Collins, J.A., Hanlon, A., More, S.J., Wall, P.G., Kennedy, J., Duggan, V., Evaluation of current equine welfare issues in Ireland: causes, desirability, feasibility and means of raising standards, 105-113, Copyright 2010, with permission from EVJ Ltd.
Case study of equine welfare on an Irish farm: 2007-2009
Collins, J.A.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Hanlon, A.1, Duggan, V.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
Veterinary Record 167, 90-95 (2010)
ThisreportdescribestheprogressioninwelfarestandardsforhorsesonahorsefarmintheRepublicofIrelandbetween2007and2009.Visitstothefarmwereundertakenandinformation,intheformofwrittennotesanddigitalrecordingofobservationsandexaminations,wasgatheredinconsultationwithofficialsfromtheGardaí(theIrishpolice),theDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarineandtheIrishSocietyforthePreventionofCrueltytoAnimals.Furtherindependentveterinarycorroborationofclinicalfindingsandlaboratorysupportoccurredfollowingseizureofthehorses.Thecomplexrealityofon-farmequinewelfareproblemsandthedifficultiesinachievingaresolutionarediscussedcomparedwithotherspeciesconventionallyconsideredtobefood-producinganimals.
Reproduced from Veterinary Record, Collins, J.A., More, S.J., Hanlon, A., Duggan, V., 167, 90-95, Copyright 2010, with permission from BMJ Publishing Group Ltd.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 89
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SA
nim
al welfare
Aspects of the owning/keeping and disposal of horses, and how these relate to equine health/welfare in Ireland
Collins, J.A.1, Hanlon, A.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Wall, P.G.3, Duggan, V.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Public Health, Physiotherapy and Population Science
Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 11 (2011)
Irelandhaslongbeenrenownedasamajorcentreforthebreeding,rearingandkeepingofhorses.Since2007,however,therehasbeenincreasingconcernforhorsehealthandwelfarestandards,andlinksbetweentheseconcernsandthestructures,governanceandfundingoftheIrishequineindustrieshavebeenreported.Thispaperaddressestwocentralissues:firstly,thelocalgovernanceof,tradeinanddisposalofunwantedhorses;andsecondly,mechanismsemployedtoimprovestandardsofcaregiventohorsesownedbycertaincommunities.Primaryinformationwasgatheredthroughvisitstohorsepoundsrunby,andonbehalfof,LocalAuthorities,tosocialhorseprojects,tohorsedealeryards,ferryports,horseslaughterplantsandknackeries.Theapproachadoptedbymembersofagivengroup,e.g.ferryports,isdescribed and differences are highlighted, for example in how different Local Authorities implement the Control of HorsesActof1986,andhowthechoice,forexample,ofdisposalrouteaffectsthestandardofanimalwelfare.Thereisa pressing need for a more centrally mandated and uniformly applied system of governance to safeguard the health and promotethekeepingofhorsestoahigherwelfarestandardinIreland.Fundamentaltoanunderstandingofwhythereisinsufficientoversightofthekeepingandproperdisposalofhorsesisthelackofacomprehensive,integratedsystemfortheregistration,identificationandtracingofequidaeinIreland.
Copyright 2011 Collins et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Use of qualitative methods to identify solutions to selected equine welfare problems in Ireland
Collins, J.A.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Hanlon, A.3, Wall, P.G.4, McKenzie, K.5, Duggan, V.3
1 Norbrook Laboratories Ltd (Ireland), Newry, Co. Down, Northern Ireland, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 UCD School of Public
Health, Physiotherapy and Population Science, 5 Motiveworks, Dublin
Veterinary Record (in press)
ThispaperexplorestheviewsofthoseintheIrishequineindustry,organisationsandgovernmentregardingnecessaryimprovementstoequinewelfareinIrelandatunregulatedgatheringsandduringthedisposalprocess.Threequalitativeresearchmethodswereemployed,namelysemistructuredinterviews,focusgroupsandastructured,facilitatedwork-shop.Representativesfromindustry,welfaresocieties,sociallydisadvantagedgroupingsandgovernmentengagedwiththis process and shared their views regarding horse welfare and implementable solutions with merit to address welfare problems.AconsensuswasachievedthatequinewelfareinIrelandcouldbeimprovedbythedevelopmentofacompre-hensiveidentificationsystem,aCodeofPracticeforhorsegatherings,ahorselicensingscheme,ring-fencedfundingtopromote responsible, humane horse disposal and better means of raising awareness of the value of safeguarding horse welfareforthebenefitofallparties.
Reproduced from Veterinary Record, Collins, J.A., More, S.J., Hanlon, A., Wall, P.G., McKenzie, K., Duggan, V., in press, Copyright 2012, with permission from BMJ Publishing Group Ltd.
Biennial Report, 2010/201190
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
An
imal
wel
fare
The development and application of a tool to assess the welfare of equidae at fairs and markets in Ireland
Collins, J.A.1, Johnson, J.1, Hanlon, A.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Duggan, V.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
Unregulatedhorsegatherings,suchasfairsandmarkets,areconsideredtobeofhighvalueculturally,sociallyandeconomicallytoIreland.However,aDelphistudycompletedin2008byCollinset al.identifiedwelfarestandardsforhorsesatsucheventsasoneofthetwomostsignificantequinewelfareconcernsinIreland.Inthispaper,wedescribethedevelopmentofanequinewelfareassessmentprotocol,basedontheFiveFreedoms,whichemploysmeasurementofbothwelfareinputsandoutputs,andearlyattemptstoapplythisprotocolatfairsandmarketsinIreland.Thirtyparame-ters(basedonasemi-qualitative5pointLikertscale)wereeachmeasuredonthirtyoccasionsalongsidedetailsofweather,horsenumbersandthepresenceofanorganisingcommittee.Thedataset(n=30)wasdividedintothreesubsets(withsome overlap) to enable the analyses of welfare scores for individual events (n=14),inter-observervariabilityinscoresatevents scored simultaneously but independently by the first two authors, JC and JJ (n=5), and change over time at any one event (n=8).Bythecriterionofimportanceadoptedbytheauthors,thefreedomofhorsestoaccesswater,feedandshelter(resourceinput)andtheabilityofhorsestodrinkandfeed(currentoutput)weredeemedtobeundulycompro-mised.Thepresenceofanorganisingcommitteewasnotfoundtobeprotectiveofequinewelfare.Itissuggestedbytheauthorsthatacombinedapproach(inputandoutput-basedmeasures)totheassessmentofequinewelfareatunregulatedgatheringsbeadoptedbutthatfurtherworkisrequiredtorefinetheprotocoltoensurethatrepeatabilityandreproduc-ibilityofscoringareachievedinitsimplementation.
Development of a bio-security assessment tool and its application at equine events in Ireland
Johnson, J.P.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Collins, J.A.3, Duggan, W.E.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 Norbrook Laboratories Ltd (Ireland), Newry, Co. Down, Northern Ireland
Thereisthepotentialfordiseasetransmissionwhereverhorsesgatheringroups.TheinconsistentapplicationofdiseasecontrolmeasuresacrossthehorseindustriesinIreland,thehighlycontagiousnatureofmanyoftheequineinfectiousdiseases, the potential for the spread of disease from sub-clinically infected horses and increased transport of horses to internationaleventstogethermeanthatallhorsesareputatriskofdiseasetransmission,particularlyintheeventofanoutbreakofanexoticequinedisease.Theobjectivesofthisstudyweretodevelopabio-securityassessmenttoolforuseatequineevents,toapplythetoolintheinvestigationofthepotentialforcontagiousdiseasetransmissionatequineeventsinIreland,andtodeterminetheinfluenceofthedegreeofregulationofeventonriskofdiseasetransmission.Ascoringsystemwasdevelopedtoidentifybio-securityrisksatequineevents.Thiswasbasedonbothdirectandindirectriskfactorswhichcontributetocontagiousdiseasetransmission.Riskfactorsincludedcategoriessuchascontactbetweenhorses, contact with fomites, feeding facilities, degree of public access, control of wildlife, sanitation of stables and housingventilation.Theregulationstatusofeacheventwasdeterminedbasedonacombinationofpublishedgoverningrulesandobservationoftheirenforcementduringon-sitevisits.Highlyregulatedeventshadsignificantlyloweroverallrisklevelsthanpartiallyregulatedevents(p<0.003);overallrisklevelofpartiallyregulatedeventsdidnotdiffersignifi-cantly from that of unregulated events (p=0.051).
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 91
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SA
nim
al welfare
A retrospective study of horses investigated for weight loss despite a good appetite (2002-2011)
Metcalfe, L.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Duggan, V.1, Katz, L.M.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
Weightlossdespiteagoodappetiteisafrequentdiagnosticchallengeforequineveterinarians;however,therearefewobjectivereportsandlittledescriptiveinformationregardingriskfactorsandprognosticindicators.Theaimofthisstudy was evaluate the relationship between historical and clinicopathological findings and final outcome in order to identifyriskfactorsandprognosticindicators.Medicalrecordsofhorsesreferredforinvestigationofweightlossdespiteagoodappetitewerereviewed.Datacollatedincludedhistory,signalment,clinicalanddiagnosticfindings,diagnosesandoutcome(survivalvsnon-survival).UnivariableassociationswereevaluatedwithaMann-WhitneyUtest,Fisher’sExacttest(categoricalorbinarydata)orPearson’srankcorrelation(continuousdata),withP ≤0.05consideredsignifi-cant.Fortycasesmettheinclusioncriteria.Albuminconcentrationsatadmissionweresignificantly(P=0.008)higherinsurvivors(29.1±6.5g/L)thannon-survivors(22.8±5.4g/L)andpositivelycorrelatedwithoutcome(r 2=0.23;P =0.005).Animalswithlowtotalprotein(P=0.029,OR=7,95%CI=1.22–40.1)andalbumin(P=0.032,OR=6,95%CI=1.22–29.5)concentrationswereatgreaterriskfornon-survival.Bodyconditionscorewaspositivelycorre-lated with total protein (r 2=0.17;P=0.03)andalbumin(r 2=0.53;P<0.0001)concentrationsatadmissionanddura-tion of clinical signs (r 2=0.19;P=0.03).Theseverityofhypoproteinaemiaandhypoalbuminaemiaarerelatedwithaworseningprognosis.Sincebodyconditionscoreispositivelyassociatedwithalbuminconcentration,itcouldpotentiallybeusedasaprognosticindicatorforsurvivalinconjunctionwithalbuminconcentration.
Porcine welfare
The use of meat inspection as a surveillance tool for improved pig welfare
Harley, S.1, O’Connell, N.2, Boyle, L.3, More, S.J.1, 4, Hanlon, A.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland, 3 Teagasc Moorepark, 4 UCD CVERA
Foodanimalwelfareissynonymouswithfoodqualityandlinkedtofoodsafety.Thislinkisevidentatslaughter,whenante-mortem and post-mortem inspections are conducted to ensure that the animal is fit for human consumption, carcassesthataredamagedasaresultofbruising,lesions,diseaseandinjuryaretrimmedorrejected,dependingontheextentofdiseaseanddamage.Damagetocarcassesislikelytobeindicativeofthehousing,andmanagementoftheanimalduringtheproductionperiod,andthusreflecttheanimalswelfare.Diseaseandinjurysuchaslesionsandbruisingareundeniablyanindicationofpoorwelfare.Themainobjectivesofthisresearchistoexploretheuseofcarcasscondemnation as a surveillance tool for farm animal welfare and to examine the process of carcass condemnation of swineinIreland,includingthereportingmechanismsandtheeconomiclossestothefarmerandtheprocessor.
Biennial Report, 2010/201192
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
Emer
gen
cy i
ssu
es
Emergency issues
A qualitative assessment of the risk of spread to and within the commercial poultry industry, following the introduction of H5N1 avian influenza into Ireland, and of potential risk mitigation measures
Aznar, I.1, Crowe, O.2, Wilson, J.3, Duignan, P.J.4, Gaynor, S.4, Neilan, R.4, McLoon, D.5, McArdle, P.J.4, More, S.J.1, 6
1 UCD CVERA, 2 Birdwatch Ireland, 3 National Parks and Wildlife Service, 4 DAFM, 5 Private practitioner, 6 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Thispaperdescribesworkconductedin2008toqualitativelyassesstheriskofspreadtoandwithinthecommercialpoultryindustry,followingtheintroductionofH5N1avianinfluenzaintoIreland,andofpotentialriskmitigationmeasures.Fourtransmissionrouteswereconsidered,includingspreadamongwildwaterbirds,spreadfromwildwater-birds to non-commercial avian operations, spread from wild waterbirds to commercial poultry (directly or via non-commercialavianoperations)andspreadwithinthecommercialpoultryindustry.ThereisconsiderablepotentialinIrelandforspreadofH5N1avianinfluenzaamongwildwaterbirds,andfromwildwaterbirdstonon-commercialavianoperations.Incontrast,theopportunityforspreadtoandwithinthecommercialpoultrysectorisvariable,dependingonabroadrangeoffactorsincludingproductionsystem,watersourceandmanagement.Anumberofimportantriskmitigationmeasureswereidentified,focusingonimprovedinformationandawareness,riskbasedsurveillanceandmain-tenanceofup-to-datedatabases.Eachoftheseissueshasnowbeenconsideredindetail,bothbyDAFMandindustry.
An outbreak of piroplasmosis in horses in Ireland
Bailey, D.1, Leadon, D.L.2, Brangan, P.1, de Waal, T.3, Lenihan, P.4, Larkin, J.1, Ennett, F.1, Gaynor, S.1, More, S.J.3, 5
1 DAFM, 2 Irish Equine Centre, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 4 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 5 UCD CVERA
Anoutbreakofpiroplasmosis(causedbyTheileria equie)occurredinhorsesinIrelandduring2009.Theobjectiveofthispaperistodescribetheoutbreak,thetransmissionofT. equiwithinIrelandandaspectsofoutbreakmanagement.
Outbreak of bovine brucellosis in County Clare, Ireland, during 2005
Hayes, M.1, Kilroy, A.1, Ashe, S.1, Power, S.2, Kenny, K.2, Collins, D.M.3, More, S.J.3, 4
1 DAFM, 2 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Veterinary Record 166, 107-111 (2010)
ThispaperdescribesaninvestigationofanoutbreakofbovinebrucellosisinCountyClare,Ireland,during2005.ItislikelythatinfectionontheindexfarmwaslinkedtoapreviousoutbreakofbrucellosisinCountyClare.DuringMarchtoMay2005,transmissionofbrucellosiswithintheherdwasrapid;thiswasfacilitatedbyarangeoffactors,includingclosecontactbetweencattlekeptinwinterhousing,andthemixingofanimals,bothduringgrazingandathousing,throughouttheyear.Containmentofthedisease,includingonlylimitedspreadtoonecontiguousherd,wasfacilitatedbytherecentconstructionofashedforwinterhousing.
Reproduced from Veterinary Record, Hayes, M., Kilroy, A., Ashe, S., Power, S., Kenny, K., Collins, D.M., More, S.J., 166, 107-111, Copyright 2010, with permission from BMJ Publishing Group Ltd.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 93
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
STran
smissib
le spo
ng
iform
encep
halo
path
y (TSE)
Transmissible spongiform encephalopathy (TSE)
Factors contributing to sample quality for the BSE active surveillance programme in the Republic of Ireland
Cahill, A.1, Collins, D.M.2, Aznar, I.2, More, S.J.2, 3, Griffin, J.1, Sheridan, H.1
1 DAFM, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
TheRepublicofIreland’sactivesurveillanceprogrammeforBSEinvolvesthecollectionofbrainstemtissuesamplesfromcertaincategoriesofcattle,includingcattlewhichdieonfarm(fallencattle).SomeofthesesamplesareofpoorqualityduetoautolysisandthishasimplicationsforaccurateBSEdiagnosis.TheRepublicofIrelandisobligedunderEUlawtotakemeasurestominimisesampleautolysis.Dataonthedegreeofautolysisofallsamplestakenbetween2007and2011havebeencapturedontheAHCS(AnimalHealthComputerSystem).TheobjectiveofthisstudyistoidentifyriskfactorsforpoorsamplequalityinfallenanimalsintheRepublicofIreland.
Bovine spongiform encephalopathy in the Republic of Ireland before and after the reinforced feed ban: epidemiology, spatial analysis and risk factors
Ryan, E.1, McGrath, G.2, Sheridan, H.3, More, S.J.2, 4, Aznar, I.2
1 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 DAFM, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Bovinespongiformencephalopathy(BSE)isapriondiseaseofcattle,spreadbycontaminationofcattlefeed.IntheRepublicofIreland,areinforcedfeedbanonmammalianmeatandbonemeal(MBM)wasintroducedon1stOctober1996tostopfurtherinfectionofcattle.BetweenthenandJuly2010,44casesofBSEfrom40herdshavebeenborn,termed“bornafterthereinforcedban”or“BARB”BSEcases.Theobjectivesofthisprojectweretodescribetheepide-miologyoftheseBARBcases,todeterminearea-levelriskfactorsforBSEandhowtheyrelatedtothestageoftheBSEepidemic,andtoevaluatewhetherthespatialpatternofBSEcaseswasnon-randomandhadchangedovertime.
Confirmed BSE cases in Ireland during 2010 & 2011.
Biennial Report, 2010/201194
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
Q f
ever
Q fever
Q fever in humans and farmed animals in four European countries
Georgiev, M.1, Afonso, A.1, Neubauer, S.2, Needham, H.3, Thiery, R.4, Rodolakis, A.5, Roest, H.J.6, Staerk, K.7,
Stegeman, J.A.8, Vellema, P.9, van der Hoek, W.10, More, S.J.11, 12
1 European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), 43121 Parma, Italy, 2 Friedrich-Loeffler-Institute, Institute for Bacterial Infections and Zoonoses, Naumburgerstr.
96a; 07743 Jena, Germany, 3 European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC), 171 83 Stockholm, Sweden, 4 ANSES, Sophia Antipolis
Laboratory, Ruminant Pathology Unit, Sophia Antipolis, 5 Institut national de la Recherche Agronomique (INRA) Ur1282 Infectiologie Animale et Santé
Publique F37380 Nouzilly France, 6 Department of Bacteriology and TSEs, Central Veterinary Institute, part of Wageningen UR, Lelystad, the Netherlands,
7 SAFOSO, Safe Food Solutions Inc., Bremgartenstrasse 109a, CH 3012 Bern, Switzerland, 8 University of Utrecht, Dept. Farm Animal Health, PO Box
80.163, NL-3508TD Utrecht, 9 Department of Small Ruminant Health, Animal Health Service GD Deventer, Arnsbergstraat 7, P.O. Box 9, 7400 AA Deventer,
the Netherlands, 10 Centre for Infectious Disease Control, National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, PO Box 1, 3720 BA Bilthoven, the
Netherlands, 11 UCD CVERA, 12 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Qfever,isazoonoticbacterialdiseaseinhumans,causedbyC. burnetii,andalargerangeofanimalscanbeinfected.ThispaperpresentsareviewofQfeverandC. burnetii infection in humans and farmed animals, using case studies from fourEuropeancountries.Inallfourcountries,theserologicalprevalenceofC. burnetii infection and reported incidence ofQfevervariesbroadlyinbothfarmedanimalsandhumans.Animalproximityandcontactwithinfectedanimalsortheirbirthproductshavebeenidentifiedasthemostimportantriskfactorsforhumandisease.Intrinsicfarmfactors,suchasproductionsystemandmanagement,influencethenumberofoutbreaksinanarea.Potentialcontroloptionsarecommon methods of disease control have included measures to increase diagnostic precision and general awareness, and toreducehumanexposureandspillover.Thisstudyhighlightsimportantgapsinknowledge,andfutureresearchneeds.
Seroprevalence of Coxiella burnetii antibodies in sheep and goats in the Republic of Ireland
Ryan, E.1, Kirby, M.1, Clegg, T.2, Collins, D.M.2
1 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 2 UCD CVERA
Veterinary Record 169, 280 (2011)
QfeverisazoonoticdiseasecausedbyCoxiella burnetii, a bacteria whose main reservoirs are goats, sheep and cattle but whichcanalsoinfectawiderangeofmammals.TheobjectiveofthisstudywastoestimatetheprevalenceofexposuretoC. burnetiiinsheepandgoatsintheRepublicofIreland.Serumfrom2,197sheepfrom119flocksand590goatsfrom66 herds, randomly sampled, were tested for the presence of C. burnetiiantibodiesusinganindirectELISA.Insheep,15/2,197(0.7percent)samplesfrom10/119(8.4percent)flockswerepositive.Ingoats,2/590(0.3percent)samplesfrom1/66(1.5percent)herdwerepositive.TheresultsconfirmtheexposureofsheepandgoatstoC. burnetii in the RepublicofIreland.
Adapted from Veterinary Record, Ryan, E., Kirby, M., Clegg, T., Collins, D.M., 169, 280, Copyright 2011, with permission from BMJ Publishing Group Ltd.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 95
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SQ
fever
Prevalence of Coxiella burnetii (Q fever) antibodies in bovine serum and bulk-milk samples
Ryan, E.D.1, Kirby, M.1, Collins, D.M.2, Sayers, R.3, Mee, J.F.3, Clegg, T.2
1 DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 Teagasc Moorepark
Epidemiology and Infection 139, 1413-1417 (2011)
Qfever(Coxiella burnetii)isazoonoticdiseaseofincreasingpublichealthimportance.Theobjectiveofthisstudywastoestimatetheprevalenceof,andriskfactorsassociatedwith,exposuretoC. burnetiiincattleintheRepublicofIreland.Bulk-tankmilksamplesfrom290dairyherdsand1,659serafrom332dairyandbeefherds,randomlysampled,weretestedbyindirectELISAtodetectantibodiestoC. burnetii.Intotal,37.9%ofbulk-milksampleherdsand1.8%ofsera(from6.9%ofherds)wereantibodypositive.Ofriskfactorstestedusinglogisticregressionanalysis,onlylargeherdsize(bulk-milkanalysis)anddairybreed(serumanalysis)significantlyincreasedtheoddsofbeingposi-tive for antibodies to C. burnetii.HerdswithpositivemilkorserumsampleswererandomlydistributedthroughouttheRepublicofIrelandandnoclusteringwasobserved.TheuseofanELISAtotestbulk-milksamplescollectedbyrandomizedstratifiedsamplingisacost-effectivemethodbywhichnationalherdprevalencecanbeestimatedbyactivesurveillance.
Reprinted from Epidemiology and Infection, 139, Ryan, E.D., Kirby, M., Collins, D.M., Sayers, R., Mee, J.F., Clegg, T., Prevalence of Coxiella burnetii (Q fever) antibodies in bovine serum and bulk-milk samples, 1413-1417, Copyright 2011, with permission from Cambridge University Press.
Keem beach, Achill Island. Photograph by E. Gormley.
Biennial Report, 2010/201196
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
Co
mp
anio
n a
nim
al e
pid
emio
log
y
Companion animal epidemiology
The spatial distribution of pet dogs and pet cats on the island of Ireland
Downes, M.J.1, Clegg, T.A.1, Collins, D.M.1, McGrath, G.1, More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
BMC Veterinary Research 7, 28 (2011)
Thereisconsiderableinternationalresearchregardingthelinkbetweenhumandemographicsandpetownership.Inseveral international studies, pet ownership was associated with household demographics including: the presence of childreninthehousehold,urban/rurallocation,levelofeducationandage/familystructure.Whatislackingacrossallthese studies, however, is an understanding of how these pets are spatially distributed throughout the regions under study.ThispaperdescribesthespatialdistributionofpetdogandpetcatowninghouseholdsontheislandofIreland.In2006,therewereanestimated640,620petdogowninghouseholdsand215,542petcatowninghouseholdsinIreland.These estimates are derived from logistic regression modelling, based on household composition to determine pet dog ownershipandthetypeofhousetodeterminepetcatownership.Resultsarepresentedusingchloroplethmaps.ThereisahigherdensityofpetdogowninghouseholdsintheeastofIrelandandinthecitiesthanthewestofIrelandandruralareas.However,inurbandistrictstherearealowerproportionofhouseholdsowningpetdogsthaninruraldistricts.There are more households with cats in the urban areas, but the proportion of households with cats is greater in rural areas.ThedifferenceinspatialdistributionofdogownershipisareflectionofagenerallyhigherdensityofhouseholdsintheeastofIrelandandinmajorcities.Thehigherproportionofownershipinthewestisunderstandablegiventhehigherproportionoffarmersandruraldwellingsinthisarea.SpatialrepresentationallowsustovisualisetheimpactofhumanhouseholddistributiononthedensityofbothpetdogsandpetcatsontheislandofIreland.Thisinformationcanbeusedwhenanalysingriskofdiseasespread,formarketresearchandforinstigatingveterinarycare.
Copyright 2011 Downes etal. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Companion animal ownership: understanding the attitudes, beliefs and behaviour of pet owners towards their pets
Downes, M.J.1, McKenzie, K.2, More, S.J.3, 4
1 School of Veterinary Medicine and Science, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom, 2 Motiveworks, Dublin,
3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Petownersownpetsforavarietyofreasonsincludingcompanionship,protection,andasworkinganimals.Ownershipisalsoacontributortoowners’physicalandmentalhealth.Somestudieshavebeenconductedonissuesrelatingtoownership,includingpetneuteringandobesity.Asyet,littledataareavailablefromqualitativeresearch.Inthisstudy,weinvestigatepetowners’attitudes,beliefsandbehaviourstowardstheirpets,withspecificemphasison,diet,weightcontrolandexercise.Aninterview-administeredsurveyquestionnaireandfocusgroupdiscussionswereconductedforthestudy.DatawascodedandmanagedusingNvivo8qualitativedataanalysissoftwareandStataSEVersion10®.Severalthemesforowningapetemergedinthestudy,mostcommonlyassociatedwithcompanionshipandchilddevelopment.Ownerstendtospoiltheirpet(s)withfooddespitebeingawarethatthiscouldleadtotheirpetbecomingoverweight.Ownersbelievethatcatsexercisethemselves,whereasdogsneedtobewalkedofftheleadtoexerciseproperly.Havingapetwasconsideredtheequivalenttohavinganextrapersoninthefamily.Ourresultshelpprovideinformationonhowownersandtheirpetsmaybenefitfromtailoredcounsellingaboutpetexerciseandneutering.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 97
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SC
om
pan
ion
anim
al epid
emio
log
y
Neutering in Ireland: Investigating risk factors for neutering and examining owner attitudes and beliefs towards neutering
Downes, M.J.1, More, S.J.2, 3
1 School of Veterinary Medicine and Science, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom,
2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Companion animal over-population is an old problem which causes significant costs to humans and governments every year(Olsonet al.1991).Over-populationhasbeenassociatedwithownersbeingunconcernedaboutneuteringtheirpetsor allowing them to stray (Soto et al.2005;Natoliet al.2006;Wenget al.2006).Catownersaremorelikelytoneuterthan dog owners (Franti et al.1980;Leslieet al.1994;PossandBader2007;Downeset al.2009;Faver2009;McKayet al.2009).Inthisstudy,weinvestigateriskfactorsforneuteringapetandexaminepetowners’attitudes,beliefsandbehaviourstowardstheirpets,withspecificemphasisonneutering.Datafrom3sourceswereincludedinthisstudy;acomputer assisted telephone interview, one to one interviews and focus group discussions conducted specifically for the study.DatawascodedandmanagedusingNvivo8qualitativedataanalysissoftwareandStataSEVersion10®.Reasonsforneuteringincluded,preventingunwantedpregnancies,tolimitwanderingbehaviourandpreventdisease.Individualpetcharacteristicsplayedaroleinthedecisionofownerstoneutertheirpet(s).Someownerssuggestedthattheywouldbereluctanttoneuteragainafterpastexperience.
Factors associated with furry pet ownership among patients with asthma
Downes, M.J.1, Roy, A.2, McGinn, T.G.3, Wisnivesky, J.P.3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 Departments of Pediatrics and Community and Preventive Medicine, Department of Medicine, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York,
U.S.A., 3 Divisions of General Internal Medicine and Pulmonary, Critical Care and Sleep Medicine, Department of Medicine, Mount Sinai School of Medicine,
New York, U.S.A.
Journal of Asthma 47, 742-749 (2010)
Exposuretoindoorallergensisanestablishedriskfactorforpoorasthmacontrol.Currentguidelinesrecommendremovingpetsfromthehomeofpatientswithasthma.Thiscross-sectionalstudywasconductedtodeterminethepreva-lence of furry pet ownership in asthmatics compared to non-asthmatics and to identify factors associated with furry pet ownershipamongthosewithasthma.Secondaryanalysisassessedcharacteristicsamongasthmaticsthatmightbeassoci-atedwithallowingafurrypetintothebedroom.UsingdatafromTheNationalAsthmaSurveycollectedfrom2003to2004,wecarriedoutunivariateandmultipleregressionanalyses,in2009,toidentifyindependentpredictorsoffurrypetownershipinasthmasufferersaftercontrollingforpotentialconfounders.Overall,asthmaticsweremorelikelytoownafurrypetthannonasthmaticindividualsinthegeneralpopulation(49.9%versus44.8%,p<.001).Multivariateanalysis showed that female sex, older age, white race, and high income were independent predictors of furry pet owner-shipamongasthmatics.Additionally,68.7%ofpatientswithasthmawhoownafurrypetallowedthemintotheirbedroom.Higherincomeandcarryingout<or=2environmentalcontrolpracticesinthehomewereassociatedwithincreasedlikelihoodofallowingafurrypetintothebedroom.Furrypetownershipisequallyormorecommonamongasthmaticscomparedtothosewithoutasthma.Themajorityofasthmaticswithfurrypetsallowthemintothebedroom.Recognizingandaddressingtheseproblemsmayhelpdecreaseasthmamorbidity.
Reproduced with permission of Informa Healthcare, Journal of Asthma, 2010; 47: 742-749, Copyright © 2010, Informa Healthcare. Reproduced with permission of Informa Healthcare.
Biennial Report, 2010/201198
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
Cad
miu
m e
xpo
sure
in
cat
tle
Cadmium exposure in cattle
National survey of cadmium in bovine kidneys
Canty, M.J.1, Collins, D.M.1, Scanlon, A.2, More, S.J.1, 3, Sheridan, M.2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 DAFM, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Ofalltheanimaltissues,liversandkidneyconstituteaspecialdilemmainthattheyhaveatendencytobioaccumulatetoxicmetalssuchaslead(Pb),cadmium(Cd),mercury(Hg)andarsenic(As).Maximumlevels(ML)forHg,Pb,Cdandtin(Sn)infoodstuffsaresetbyCommissionRegulationNo.1881/2006(amendedbyNo.629/2008),whichincludesbovinemuscle,liversandkidneys.Cadmium,awidelydistributedenvironmentalindustrialpollutant,hasnobeneficial biological role and may be highly toxic when introduced into the body by ingestion or inhalation to both animalsandhumans.Cadmiumisnoteasilyclearedbythecellsandthepoorefficiencyofcellularexportsystemsexplainsthelongresidencetimeofthiselementinstoragetissuessuchastheintestine,theliverandthekidneys,resultinginolderanimalshavinghigherliverandkidneyCdconcentrationsevenifthelevelsintheirdietsandwaterareconsistentlylow.Cadmiumhasnoknownbiologicalfunctionineitheranimalsorhumansbutmimicstheactionsofotherdivalentmetalsthatareessentialtodiversebiologicalfunctions.Cadmiumbioavailability,retentionandconse-quentlytoxicityareaffectedbyseveralfactorssuchasnutritionalstatus(lowbodyironstores)andmultiplepregnancies,pre-existinghealthconditionsordiseases.Theobjectiveofthisstudyistodeterminecadmiumconcentrationsinbovinekidneysrandomlycollectedfromcattleoverfiveyearsofagefromthe26countiesofIreland.
Cadmium review
Lane, E.A.1, Canty, M.J.1
1 UCD CVERA
Nobiologicalrolehasbeendescribedforcadmium(Cd)inanimalsanditspresenceinanimaltissueisconsideredunnec-essary.Cadmiumisconsideredtobeoneofthemosttoxicsubstancesintheenvironmentduetoitswiderangeoforgantoxicityandlongeliminationhalf-life.BatteriesareanimportantsourceofCdpollution,additionally,combustionofcoal, smelting, mining, alloy processing and industries that employ Cd as a dye are also potential sources of Cd pollu-tion.AgriculturalpracticessuchastheapplicationofsewagesludgeandcontaminatedfertilizersarealsosourcesofCdcontamination.AbsorptionofCdoccursviatherespiratoryanddigestivesystem.Approximately10to50%ofCdfumesareabsorbedbytherespiratorysystem.While,Cdispoorlyabsorbedviathedigestivetract,comparedtosimilardivalentcations,ZnandFe;approximately5%oforalCdisabsorbed.Onceabsorbed,Cdcirculatesinredbloodcellsorboundtoalbumininplasma.Cadmiuminteractswiththemetabolismofessentialminerals;calcium,zinc,iron,copperandselenium.ThemajorityofnewbornruminantshavealowCdburden.Accumulationoccursslowlyovertime,primarilyinliverandkidneys.Intheliveritmayinduceandbindmetallothionein,thiscomplexisreleasedslowlyintocirculationandthenaccumulatesinkidneys.Athighlevels,dietaryCdcancausedecreasedfeedintake,andloweredweightgain,anaemia,decreasedboneabsorptionandabortionsandCdtoxicityhasbeenreportedinmanyspeciesincludingcattle.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 99
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SIn
ternatio
nal co
llabo
ration
International collaboration
Quantitative Rose Bengal test for diagnosis of bovine brucellosis
Cho, D.1, Nam, H.1, Kim, J.1, Heo, E.1, Cho, Y.1, Hwang, I.1, Kim, J.1, Kim, J.1, Jung, S.1, More, S.2, 3
1 Bacteriology and Parasitology Division, National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service, Anyang, Republic of Korea,
2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Journal of Immunoassay and Immunochemistry 31, 120-130 (2010)
TheRoseBengalTest(RBT)isthemostwidelyusedscreeningtestforbrucellosisinbothhumansandanimals.Owingtoitsapparentsimplicityofreading,however,interpretationsoftheRBTresultscanbeaffectedbypersonalexperience.ThisstudydescribesasimplewaytoimprovetheaccuracyanduniformityofreadingtheRBTreactionbycountingthenumberofagglutinatedparticlesusingtransparentOHPfilmwithQuantityOne®, which was originally designed tocountthebacterialcolonynumbersonagarplates.Usingthissystem,thereactivitiesofthreeRoseBengalantigensfromdifferentsourcesagainstinternationalstandardserum(1,000units,VLA,UK)couldbenumericallymeasured:theintensityscalerangedfromzerotoaround1,600.ThissystemenabledustocomparetheantigenicityofRoseBengalantigensfromthreedifferentsourcesbyusingstatisticalanalysessuchasregressionandmeanintensity.Collectively,mathematical measuring of the reaction intensity used in this study may help interpret subtle test results by providing morereliabledataandadditionalstatisticalinformationontheherd.Inaddition,themethodwouldalsobeapplicabletootheragglutinationtestforotherdiseases.
Reprinted from Journal of Immunoassay and Immunochemistry, 31, Cho, D., Nam, H., Kim, J., Heo, E., Cho, Y., Hwang, I., Kim, J., Kim, J., Jung, S., More, S., Quantitative Rose Bengal test for diagnosis of bovine brucellosis, 120-130, Copyright 2010, with permission from Taylor and Francis Ltd.
Epidemiological characteristics of bovine brucellosis in Korea, 2001-2004
Nam, H.-M.1, Kim, C.-H.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Yoon, H.1, Kim, S.J.1, Lee, B.-Y.1, Park, C.-K.1, Jeon, J.-M.1, Wee, S.-H.1
1 Bacteriology and Parasitology Division, National Veterinary Research & Quarantine Service, Republic of Korea,
2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
ThispaperdescribestheepidemiologicalcharacteristicsofbovinebrucellosisinKoreaduringJanuary2000-September2004,whichencompassestheperiodwhentheincidenceofbovinebrucellosisincreasedabruptly.DatafromtheNationalAnimalInfectiousDiseaseDataManagementSystemwereusedforthisstudy.Arangeofepidemiologicalmeasureswerecalculatedincludingannualherdandanimalincidence.Duringthestudyperiod,therewere1,183outbreakson638farms.Inbeefcattle,annualherdincidenceincreasedfrom0.15(2000)to11.5(2004toSeptember)outbreaksper10,000andannualanimalincidencevariedbetween3.4(2000)and105.8(2004,toSeptember)per100,000,respectively.On401(62.9%)farmsduringthisperiod,infectionwaseradicatedwithoutrecurrence.Recurrenceofinfectionwassignificantlyhigheronfarmswhereabortionwasreported(53.3%)comparedtofarmswhereitwasn’t(30.0%).Onbeefcattlefarms,infectionwasintroducedmostfrequentlythroughpurchasedcattle(46.2%).Basedontheresultsofthisstudy,theestablishmentandspreadofbrucellosisintheKoreanbeefcattlepopulationwasmainlyduetoincompleteorinappropriatetreatmentofabortedmaterialandthemovementofinfectedcattle.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011100
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
Inte
rnat
ion
al c
olla
bo
rati
on
Mycobacterium bovis in Korea: an update
Wee, S-H.1, Kim, C-H.2, More. S.J.3, 4, Nam, H-M.1
1 National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service, Republic of Korea, 2 Food Safety and Sanitation Division, Ministry for Food, Agriculture, Forestry and
Fisheries, Republic of Korea, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The Veterinary Journal 185, 347-350 (2010)
ThispaperreportschangesinthecattlepopulationandtheincidenceofbovinetuberculosisintheRepublicofKoreabetween1960and2007,anddiscussespotentialfactorscontributingtotherecentlyobservedincreaseindiseaseincidence,particularlyinbeefcattleanddeer.Althoughtherehavebeenongoingrefinementstotheexistingprogramme, further improvements in current strategies are needed, including surveillance of susceptible animal species,bothdomesticandwild,andongoingsurveillanceofthehumanpopulation.
Reprinted from The Veterinary Journal, 185, Wee, S-H., Kim, C-H., More. S.J., Nam, H-M., Mycobacterium bovis in Korea: an update, 347-350, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
An outbreak of highly pathogenic avian influenza at a public animal exhibit in Seoul, Korea during 2008
Yoon, H.1, Moon, O.K.1, More, S.J.2, 3, Park, C.K.4, Park, J.Y.1, Lee, Y.J.1, Lee, S.D.1, Ha, J.K.1, Jeong, S.K.1,
Jeong, J.W.1, Lee, S.J.1
1 Veterinary Epidemiology Division, National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service, Republic of Korea, 2 UCD CVERA, 3 UCD School of Veterinary
Medicine, 4 Centre for Animal Disease Diagnosis, National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service, Republic of Korea
Zoonoses and Public health 57, 142-145 (2010)
ThisstudydescribesthefirstrecordedoutbreakofHPAIinthecityofSeoul,incaptivebirdsheldinanexhibitionforpublicviewingatalocaldistrictoffice.Theindexcasesweretwopheasants,whichhadbeenintroducedintotheexhibiton24April,4dayspriortodeath,fromastoreinalocalmarketinGyeonggi-do.DucksandchickensfromanHPAIoutbreakfarm,subsequentlyconfirmedon4May,hadalsobeenheldinthisstore.Thisoutbreakhighlightsthepoten-tialroleoflocalmarketsinAIVtransmission.ThisoutbreakledtoconsiderablepublichealthconcerninKorea,however,nohumancaseswerereported.Thenon-commercialpoultrysectorneedstobeconsideredinnationalplansforprepar-ednessandresponse.
Reprinted from Zoonoses and Public Health, 57, Yoon, H., Moon, O.K., More, S.J., Park, C.K., Park, J.Y., Lee, Y.J., Lee, S.D., Ha, J.K., Jeong, S.K., Jeong, J.W., Lee, S.J., An outbreak of highly pathogenic avian influenza at a public animal exhibit in Seoul, Korea during 2008, 142-145, Copyright 2010, National Veterinary Research and Quarantine Service.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 101
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SM
iscellaneo
us
Miscellaneous
Endophyte review/opinion paper
Canty, M.J.1
1 UCD CVERA
Animalsgrazingorconsumingconservedforagescanencounterproblemsifforagesareinfectedwithanendophyte,whichproducestoxinswhichareharmfultoanimals.Endophytesarefungithatlivewithinaplantandtherelationshipbetweenagrassanditsendophyteissymbiotic.Thegrassprovidesthenutrientsandtheendophyteproducestoxinsthatfendoffinsects,diseasesandgrazinganimals.Endophytesaretransmittedonlythroughgrassseed.Differencespeciesofendophytefungusinfectdifferentspeciesofgrass.PrincipallyweareconcernedwiththefungusNeotyphodium coen-ophialum,whichproducesover32toxicalkaloidsincluding17ergotalkaloidsthataffectlivestock.Theprincipaltoxinisergovaline,whichamongstotheralkaloids,causesfescuetoxicosisinlivestock.Thesetoxinsarevasoconstrictors,theyconstrict blood vessels and reduce circulation to the body extremities, interfering with the animals ability to regulate bodytemperatureandcausingconditionscalled‘fescuefoot’incoldweatherand‘summerslump’inhotweather.Theobjectiveofthisstudyistodeterminetheroleoftheendophyteergovalineonanumberoffarmswherepooranimalperformancehadbeenreported.
Graduate Certificate in Dairy Herd Health
Cashman, D.1, Williams, E.J.1, Doherty, M.L.1, More, S.J.1, 2, Mulligan, F.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD CVERA
Onlinelearningisgrowinginpopularityasamethodtodeliverlifelonglearningtoveterinaryprofessionals,asmanyareunabletocommittofull-time,on-campuseducationalprogrammes.Thenumberofacademicstaffengaginginthismethodofeducationaldeliveryislow,however.Therearechallengestothedevelopmentanddeliveryofhigh-qualityonlinelearningprogrammes,recentreductionsinuniversityresources,bothhumanandfinancial.TheDairyHerdHealthgroupintheUniversityCollegeofDublin,aimedtoovercomethesehurdles,andsetouttodevelopanddeliveranonlinegraduatecertificateindairyherdhealth.Targetedatveterinariansoutinpractice,practitionerswillbeequippedwithtoolsforherddataanalysis,practicalherdevaluationskills,andanabilitytointegratethemultiplefacets of dairy herd health for the development of holistic herd level solution that are set in context with regard to herd profitabilityandanimalhealthandwelfare.TheCertificatewassuccessfullydeliveredin2011.Thispaperoffersaframeworkforthedevelopmentofonlinegraduateprogrammeswithlimitedresourcesandnoviceacademicstaffnewtoonlinedeliveryofprogrammes.Wereflectonthechallengesthatacademicstaffmembersencounteredinthedesignanddeliveryoftheironlineteachingstrategies.Finallyweproviderecommendationsonhowtoovercometheseteachingandlearningchallenges.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011102
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
Mis
cella
neo
us
Preface. SVEPM 2010 – The role of veterinary epidemiology in animal health in the world today
Martinez, T.A.1, Pfeiffer, D.U.2, More, S.J.3, 4
1 Veterinary Epidemiology and Economics, Hertfordshire, United Kingdom, 2 Veterinary Epidemiology and Public Health Group, Royal Veterinary College,
Hertfordshire, United Kingdom, 3 UCD CVERA, 4 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Preventive Veterinary Medicine 100, 89 (2011)
ThisprefaceprovidesanintroductiontoaspecialeditionofPreventiveVeterinaryMedicine,basedonresearchpresentedatthe2010SocietyofVeterinaryEpidemiologyandPreventiveMedicineconference.Thepapersrangefromclassicalapproachesofobservationalepidemiologyappliedtocurrentproblems,tomorenoveltechniquesinvolvingcontactstructureandsocialnetworkanalysis,andculminatewithanintroductiontoadvancedstatisticalmethodsofanalysingBayesiannetworks.
Adapted from Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 100, Martinez, T.A., Pfeiffer, D.U., More, S.J., Preface. SVEPM 2010 – The role of veterinary epidemiology in animal health in the world today, 89, Copyright 2011, with permission from Elsevier.
Evidence is at the core of scientific method: A challenge for clinicians
More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The Veterinary Journal (in press)
Evidenceisatthecoreofthescientificmethod,providingthebasisforacquiringnewandcorrectingandconsolidatingexistingknowledge.Withinthedisciplinesofveterinarymedicine,evidenceisgenerallygatheredthroughexperimenta-tionand/orobservation,withconclusionsthenbeingdrawnusinginductiveand/ordeductivereasoning.Therearemanyissuesrelatingtoscientificevidence,althoughonlytwoareconsideredinthispaper.Firstly,scientificevidenceneedstobepresentedtoend-users,includingclinicians,policy-makersandotherscientificresearchers,inamannerthatfacilitatescrit-icalevaluation,hencetheimportanceofinternationallyreportingguidelines.Secondly,scientificevidence,combinedwithclinicaljudgementandexpertise,formsthefoundationforevidence-basedveterinarymedicine(EBVM).Thisguestedito-rialprovidesanintroductiontoaseparatecritiqueofEBVM,includingstrategiestoincreaseitsadoptioninclinicalpractice.
Adapted from The Veterinary Journal, 191, More, S.J., Evidence is at the core of scientific method: A challenge for clinicians, 11-12, Copyright 2012, with permission from Elsevier.
Improving the quality of reporting in veterinary journals: how far do we need to go with reporting guidelines?
More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
The Veterinary Journal 184, 249-250 (2010)
Publicationintheinternationalpeer-reviewedliteratureisoneofthemostimportantoutputsofanyresearch.Despiteitsimportance,however,thequalityofreportingisvariable.Guidelineshavebeendevelopedbyinternationalscientific
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 103
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SM
iscellaneo
us
teamstopromotethequalityofreportingofresearchstudies,therebyimprovingboththevalueandreliabilityofmedicalresearchliterature.Increasingly,keymedicaljournals,eitherrequireorrecommendauthorcompliancewithreportingguidelines.Asyet,however,asimilarapproachisnotstandardpracticeamongveterinaryjournals.Thiswouldbepartlyresolvedthrougheffortstoraiseawarenessofthesereportingguidelinesamongveterinaryresearchers.Inaddition,veterinaryjournalsshouldrequireauthorcompliancewithrelevantreportingguidelines,intheinterestofhighqualityreportingofveterinarymedicalresearch.
Adapted from The Veterinary Journal, 184, More. S.J., Improving the quality of reporting in veterinary journals: how far do we need to go with reporting guidelines?, 249-250, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Markers of the uterine innate immune response of the mare
Nash, D.M.1, Sheldon, I.M.1, 2, Herath, S.1, 3, Lane, E.A.4
1 Department of Veterinary Clinical Studies, The Royal Veterinary College, London, United Kingdom, 2 Institute of Life Sciences, School of Medicine, Swansea
University, Swansea, United Kingdom, 3 Peter Gorer Department of Immunobiology, Kings College London, London, United Kingdom, 4 UCD CVERA
Animal Reproduction Science 119, 31–39 (2010)
Reproductiveefficiencyinmaresislowandpersistentmating-inducedendometritis(PMIE)isanimportantcauseofsubfertility.Mating-inducedendometritis(MIE)anobligateprecursortoPMIE,isaubiquitous,transientinflammatoryresponsetothepresenceofsperm,seminalcomponentsandpathogens.However,thespecificinflammatorypathwaysthatderivefromMIEandthatmayalsobeprecursorstoPMIEarenotclear.Theabilitytoidentifyandmeasurerobust,repeatablemarkersofinflammationintegraltoMIEmaybekeytounderstandingtheprogressiontoPMIE.Theaimofthestudywasto(i)refineaprotocolforinducingMIEandindoingsotestarangeofcellularandmolecularparam-etersasvalidmarkersofMIEtofacilitatefuturestudiesofmaressusceptibletoPMIE(ii)concurrentlyidentifythoseparameterswithpotentialasinflammatoryindicatorsduringMIEtoinformandenhanceearlytreatmentregimensinpractice.Mating-inducedendometritiswasinducedinponymaresusingastringentprotocol;maresweretreatedintrau-terinewithfrozen/thawedsemen(n=5;FTS)orfrozen/thawedextender(n=6:FTEx).Theparameterstestedweremeasured before treatment were compared to samples collected at strategic time points after treatment: uterine cytology usingcytological(at8,16,24,48and72haftertreatment)orhistologicalanalysis(at24and72h);uterinebacteri-ology(at24and72h);secretionofprostaglandinF2∝(PGF2∝;at8,16,24,48and72h);peripheralconcentrationsofserumamyloidA(SAA;at24h);endometrialmRNAgeneexpression,focussinguponIL8 and TLR4, as examples of genespertinenttoinflammation(at24h).Uterineneutrophilcellnumbersinbothtreatmentgroupsincreasedat8(P <0.001),16(P<0.01)and24(P<0.01)hafterinsemination,indicativeofMIEanddistinguishedbetweendifferenttreatmentsbecauseneutrophilnumbersweregreaterfromFTSmaresthanFTExmares8hafterchallenge.Uterineneutrophil cell numbers, assessed by histology, increased (P<0.001)24and72haftertreatment.ProstaglandinF2∝ concentrations increased (P<0.05)16haftertreatments,whileSAAconcentrationsandbacterialgrowthscoreswerenotsignificantlydifferentaftertreatment.EndometriumfromponymaresexpressedmRNAforIL8 and TLR4 but expressionwasnotalteredafterinsemination.TheprotocolinducedMIE,asconfirmedbyuterinecytologyandmaybeusedhereafterasarepeatableandrobustmethodforstudyingimmunemechanismsthatunderlieMIEandsomayaidtheunderstandingofprogressiontopersistentinflammation.Itcanbeconcludedthatoftherangeofparameterstested,neutrophilcellnumbersbycytologicalanalysisandPGF2∝wereregardedasthemostaccuratemarkersofinflammationduringMIEandimportantforuseinpractice.
Reprinted from Animal Reproduction Science, 119, Nash, D.M., Sheldon, I.M., Herath, S., Lane, E.A., Markers of the uterine innate immune response of the mare, 31-39, Copyright 2010, with permission from Elsevier.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011104
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
IS
SU
ES
Mis
cella
neo
us
Endometrial explant culture to study the response of equine endometrium to insemination
Nash, D.M.1, 2, Sheldon, I.M.1, Herath, S.1, Lane, E.A.3
1 Department of Veterinary Clinical Studies, The Royal Veterinary College, North Mymms, United Kingdom, 2 Institute of Biological, Environmental and Rural
Sciences, Aberystwyth University, Aberystwyth, United Kingdom, 3 UCD CVERA
Reproduction in Domestic Animals 45, 670–676 (2010)
Mating-inducedendometritis(MIE)isubiquitousinthehorseafternaturalmatingandartificialinseminationwithfrozen/thawedsemencausingthemostaggressiveresponse.ThemajorityofmareseliminateMIE24-48hafterinsemination.Anendometrial explant culture was tested as a potential in vitroexemplarforsperm-inducedMIE.EndometrialprostaglandinF2∝ (PGF2∝)secretionandexpressionofinterleukin-8(IL-8)wereusedasmarkersofinflammation.Endometrialexplantswereculturedfromutericollectedfromfollicularphasemares.Explantswerechallengedwith1or10x106sperm/mlfrozen/thawedsemen,chilledsemen,washedspermorseminalplasma.Mediumwascollected24and72hafterchallengeandassayedforPGF2∝byradioimmunoassay.Treatmentofendometrialexplantswithfrozen/thawed,chilledsemenorwashedspermdidnotchangethesecretionofPGF2∝comparedwithuntreatedcontrols.However,24hafterchallengeculturedexplantsexpressedIL-8.Thein vitro endometrial explant system did not represent the in vivoresponsetosemenwhenPGF2∝wasusedasamarkerofinflammation,yettheuseofgeneexpressionasaninflammatorymarkerwarrantsfurtherinvestigation.
Reprinted from Reproduction in Domestic Animals, 45, Nash, D.M., Sheldon, I.M., Herath, S., Lane, E.A., Endometrial explant culture to study the response of equine endometrium to insemination, 670-676, Copyright 2010, with permission from John Wiley and Sons.
Essential elements and heavy metal concentrations in a small area of the Castlecomer Plateau, Co. Kilkenny, Ireland: Their potential to impact on animal performance
Canty, M.J.1, McCormack, S.2, Lane, E.A.1, Collins, D.M.1, More, S.J.1, 3
1 UCD CVERA, 2 Teagasc Johnstown Castle, 3 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Many ruminants are solely or mostly dependant for their nutrients, including essential elements, on the forage available to them, eitherinitsnaturalstateorconservedashayorsilage.AsoilandherbagesurveywascarriedoutinAprilandSeptember2007,ina3.1kmx3.0kmgrid,incorporating106and46samplingpoints,respectively,ontheCastlecomerPlateau,Co.Kilkenny,Ireland.Theaimwastodeterminethenutrientandheavymetalstatusofsoilandherbageinthesamplingarea,andtoexaminetheconcentrationsobservedfortheirpotentialtoimpactonanimalperformance.LowsoilpHandhighsoillimerequirementswereidentifiedwithinthesamplingarea.TheconcentrationsofCa,Cu,SeandZnwerelowinsoilsandherbage.TheseconditionsaresimilartothosefoundonotherfarmsinIreland.Fluoridewasdetectedin61ofthe97herbagesamplesinApril2007,butonlyfourexceeded40mg/kgdrymatter,themaximumtolerablelevelforcattle.Mineralimbalances(Ca,Cu,SeandZn)observedinpasturescausedbylowsoilmineralstatus,exacerbatedbylowsoilpH,couldimpairanimalperformanceintheareastudied.
Small area study/milk recording data
Lane, E.A.1, Canty, M.J.1, Clegg, T.A.1, More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Theaimwastodeterminetheinfluenceoflocalindustryonmilkproductioninsurroundingfarms.Datawerecollectedfrom all dairy farms (n=14)participatinginanationalmilkrecordingschemewithin8kmofabrickfactory.Herdidentifier,individualcowidentifier,dateofbirth,mostrecentcalvingdate,parity,dateoftest,24hourmilk,fat,protein
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 105
OT
hE
R A
NIM
Al
hE
Al
Th
AN
D W
El
fA
RE
ISS
UE
SM
iscellaneo
us
andlactoseyield,somaticcellcountateachmilkrecordingevent(n=13,773).Aherdmean24hourestimatedmilkyield was calculated per herd per month over the six year period (n=557).Therewasasignificanteffectofherdoforigin(P<0.0001),parity(P<0.05)andnumberofdaysinmilk(P<0.01)ontheherdaveragemilkyield.Meanmilkyieldswere lower (P<0.01)ontheindexfarmcomparedwithallfarmswiththeexceptionofherds5and10.Therewasnoaffect (P>0.05)year,ornumberofcowsinherd,orsomaticcellcountsonherdaveragemilkproduction.Milkyieldwas highest (P<0.001)insecondquarterofyearandlowest(P<0.001)infourthquaterofyear.Univariateanalysisdemonstratedthatherdslocatedwithin5kmofthebrickmanufacturingunit,milkproductionwaslower(P<0.0001)whenthebrickmanufacturingunitwasinproduction(18.8±0.37kgs/day)comparedwithwhenitwasclosed(21.7±0.41kgs/day).Milkproductionwasnotdifferentforherdsthatwerelocatedbetween5to8kmfromtheunit.Mixedmodelanlaysiswillbeconductedtodeterminetheoveralleffectofbrickmanufacture,accountingforbiologicallyimpor-tantfactorsincludingherdoforigin,parityandtimeofyear,onmilkproductioninthesurroundingherds.
Image quality & radiological safety
Skelly, C.1, Redmond, B.2, More, S.J.1, 3, McAlister, H.1
1 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine, 2 UCD School of Applied Social Science, 3 UCD CVERA
X-rays have long been used in veterinary practice both as a screening tool for developmental conditions and for diag-nosticpurposeswhendealingwithsickanimals.Howeverthereislimitedinformationregardingtheradiographicproto-cols,imagequalityandradiationsafetystandardsofveterinarypracticesinIreland.Thisprojectisdesignedtoassessthechangesthathaveoccurredinradiographicprotocolsandimagequalityoveraten-yearperiodthathasseengreattechno-logical advancement and to determine the attitudes and perceptions of the personnel involved in veterinary radiography towardsradiationsafety.
Can a national fertility programme improve dairy herd performance in Ireland? A review
Lane, E.A.1, Crowe, M.A.2, More, S.J.1, 2
1 UCD CVERA, 2 UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
DairyingisakeyelementoftheAgri-foodindustryinIreland.Althoughthenumberofdairyingunitsisdecreasing,milkproductivityandvalueareincreasing.Allindicatorssuggestthatfarmsaresettoexpand.Reproductiveperformanceisreducingworldwideandinfertilityisaseriousconstrainttofarmexpansion.Intensivelymanageddairyherdsmustachievefertilitytargetstoensurelong-termeconomicviability.Computerprogrammestomanagefertilityweredevelopedinthesixties and recent advances enable the development of sophisticated integrated computerised programmes for fertility, healthandproductionfacilitateherdmanagement.Theanalysisofherdmanagementrecordsallowsforaccurateassess-mentofthecurrentstatusoftheherd,acrucialdecisionmakingtooltoimplementeffectivechange.Monitoringofsuchchangestoensuretheireffectivenessisessentialtothesuccessofanyprogramme.Furthermore,participationindiscussiongroups,allowsforpeercomparisons,akeyfactorinmotivatingherdmanagementchange.AnationalprogrammesuchastheInCalfprogrammeoffersIrelandtheopportunitytoavailofahighlyresourcedeffectivereproductiveperformanceprogrammethatisinoperationforsimilarproductionsystemsintheSouthernHemisphere.Wemustbemindfuloftheexcellentresourcesalreadyinexistenceinthecountry;theICBFdatabaseoffersusopportunitiestoamalgamatetheInCalfprogrammewithakeydatabasetofurtherenhancethepossibleoutcomesforourdairyindustry.Additionally,successfulfarmerdiscussiongroupsarealreadyoperationalinIrelandrunbyourfarmadvisoryserviceTeagasc.Capacitybuildingmust be at the foremost of the programme and the encouragement of farmer, advisor and industry participation is para-mount.ThesearechallengesourindustrymustembracetoenhancetheIrishagriculture.
106 Biennial Report, 2010/2011
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 107
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Scientific support
Epidemiological support ........................................................................................ 108
Statistical scientific support .................................................................................. 111
Geographic Information Systems (GIS) scientific support .................................. 113
Database scientific support ................................................................................... 116
Biennial Report, 2010/2011108
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Epid
emio
log
ical
su
pp
ort
Epidemiological support
Key CVERA contacts: Simon More, Inma Aznar, Mary Canty, Liz Lane
TheUCDCentreforVeterinaryEpidemiologyandRiskAnalysis(CVERA)providesepidemiologicalsupportinawidevarietyofareas.CVERAstaffareactiveinsupportofon-farminvestigationsbyundergraduateveterinarystudents,andofresearchprojectsbypostgraduatestudents,atUniversityCollegeDublin(UCD).WorkingcloselywithcolleaguesinIrelandandinternationally,theyalsocollaborate,eitherinaleadorsupportrole,onabroadportfolioofresearchprojects,contributingepidemiologicalexpertisetothedesign,conduct,analysisandfinalisationofscientificresearch.CVERAcontinuestoprovideepidemiologicaltrainingtostaffoftheDepartmentofAgriculture,FoodandtheMarine(DAFM),throughthe6-monthlyepidemiologicalmentoringgroup.EpidemiologicalstaffinCVERAincreasinglyworkatthescience-policyinterface,providingscientificadvicetosupportpolicydecision-making,bothinIrelandandinterna-tionally.InIreland,CVERAworkscloselywithgovernmentorganisations(includingDAFM,theFoodSafetyAuthorityofIreland(FSAI),andtheMarineInstitute)andwithAnimalHealthIreland(AHI).Internationally,CVERAstaffcontributetotheworkoftheEuropeanFoodSafetyAuthority(EFSA).Ingeneral,epidemiologicalsupportisunder-takenincollaborationwithotherCVERAstaff,withexpertiseinstatistics,geographicinformationsystemsanddatabasemaintenanceandinterrogation.
ThefollowingprovideanoverviewofsomeoftheepidemiologicalsupportprovidedbyCVERAduringthelast2years:
Scientific information in support of national and international policy decision-making
MostofCVERA’sworkisconductedatthescience-policyinterface,withCVERAstaffconductingscientificresearchandprovidingscientificinformationinsupportofpolicydecision-making.
InIreland,CVERAworksverycloselywithDAFM,principallyinthebroadareaofregulatoryanimalhealth(includingbovinetuberculosis,emergencydiseasepreparednessandresponse,andanimalwelfare).CVERAstaffworkinclosecollaborationwithAHI,providingscientificsupportthroughTechnicalWorkingGroups(TWGs;ongoingchairoftheTWGsonJohne’sdiseaseandmastitis,pastchairoftheTWGsonbiosecurityandcalfhealth)andthroughappliedscientificresearch,focusedonkeyAHIissues.SimonMoreisamemberofFSAI’sBiologicalSafetySubcommittee.
Internationally,SimonMoreisamemberofEFSA’sAnimalHealthandWelfarePanelandhascontributedtoeachofthefollowingAHAWworkinggroups:
• Meatinspection(chair,2010-) • Qfever(chair,2010) • Theuseofagammainterferontestforthediagnosisofbovinetuberculosis(member,2011-) • ReviewoftheEuropeanUnionSummaryReportontrendsandsourcesofzoonoses,zoonoticagentsand
food-borneoutbreaksin2010–specificallyforthedatarelatedtobovinetuberculosis,Echinococcus,Qfever,brucellosisandnon-foodbornezoonoses(member,2011-)
• TBindeer(member,2009)
Since2008,hehasbeenamemberoftheEpidemiology&WildlifeRisksProgrammeAdvisorySub-Group,whichformspartofDefra’sBovineTBScienceAdvisoryBodyintheUK.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 109
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Epid
emio
log
ical sup
po
rt
Epidemiological teaching
UCD taught programmes
CVERAstaffmakeasubstantialcontributiontoUCDtaughtprogrammes,bothtoundergraduateandpostgraduatestudents, in the following courses:
Veterinary Medicine • VET10030 Applications and Integration 1 (development of several problem-based learning exercises,
1styearMVBprogramme) • VET30170 Veterinary Herd Health and Population Medicine(lectures,4thyearMVBprogramme) • VET30290 Veterinary Medicine(practicalclasses&farmvisits,5thyearMVBprogramme) • VET40180 Herd Health Investigations Skills (module coordinator, online learning,
GraduateCertificateinBovineHealthManagement) • VET30070 Clinical reproduction programme(lectures,4thyearMVBprogramme) • VET20020 & VET30390 Equine reproductive physiology (lectures, 2ndyearMVBprogramme)
Veterinary Nursing • VNUR10240 Veterinary Reception and Management Skills
(lectures,1styearVeterinaryNursingDegreeprogramme) • VNUR30310 Introduction to Research (lecture, 3rdyearVeterinaryNursingDegreeprogramme)
Other taught programmes • AESC40020 Epidemiology and Zoonoses(lecture,Mastersstudents,AgriculturalandEnvironmentalSciences) • ANSC30130 Animal health, welfare and behaviour (lectures, Animal Science students) • MDSA10210 Science Medicine and Society (lecture, Medicine and Medical Science) • Advances in Infection Biology(lecture,InfectionBiologyThematicPhD)
Non-UCD taught programmes
CVERAstaffhavealsocontributedtothefollowing:
• Certificate programme in stud management (LizLanelecturesonanapproachtofoalingmares,IrishNationalStud)
• European Diploma in Animal Reproduction sub species Bovine (DiplECAR (Bovine)). (LizLanewastheofficialsupervisorforMarijkeBeltman)
Epidemiological training for DAFM staff
CVERAcoordinatesanepidemiological mentoring group, to support veterinarians with an interest in the practical applicationofveterinaryepidemiologyintheirwork.ThegroupmetinPortlaoise,Co.Laois,inMay2010andinFebruaryandNovember2011.Themeetingincludesinformalsupportforfundamentalepidemiologicalissues(forexample,‘writingscientificpapers’,epidemiologicalstudydesigns’etc).Inaddition,agroupofepidemiologicalmentors(fromCVERAandelsewhere)areprovidingsupporttogroupmembersonepidemiologicalprojectsthattheyareleading.Somecurrentprojectsinclude: • SeánAshe,InvestigationofoystermortalityinIreland • DorothyBailey,Investigationofthepiroplasmosisoutbreakinhorsesduring2009 • AidanCahill,FactorsaffectingBSEsamplequality
Biennial Report, 2010/2011110
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Epid
emio
log
ical
su
pp
ort
• BoscoCowley,PrevalenceofIBRandBVDwrite-up • MaryCullinane,Furtheranalysisoftheemergencyslaughterdata • AnthonyDuignan,QualitycontrolinthenationalbovineTBprogramme • AndreaDwane,Criticalreviewofthesucklerwelfarescheme • NickyFennelly,BovineTBtrendsinKilkenny • MartinHayes,CorrelationbetweenSICCTandgamma-interferontests • DamienKelly,Evaluatingtheconceptsofrisk-basedsurveillanceinthenationalbovineTBprogramme • PaddyKelly,Evaluatinganearlywarningsystemforon-farmanimalwelfareincidents • PeterMullowney,Managementofherpesvirusinfectioninoysters • DeclanMurray,Analysisofsinglereactorbreakdowns • JohnO’Gorman,AnalysisofAHCSform1 • EoinRyan,OngoingepidemiologicalworkwithBSEandQfever
Severaloftheseprojectswererecentlypublishedintheinternationalpeerreviewedliterature.
Animal Health Ireland
CVERAhasworkedinclosecollaborationwitharangeofotherpartnerstowardstheestablishmentof,andsubsequentlyinsupportof,AHI,anot-for-profit,partnership-basedorganisationprovidingnationalleadershipandcoordinationofnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissuesinIreland.Partnerorganisationsincludelivestockfarmers,processors,serviceprovidersandgovernment.InIreland,aselsewhere,regulatoryanimalhealthissuesaretheresponsibilityofgovernment.Untilrecently,however,therehasbeennonationalcoordinationofnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissues.AHIwasestablishedspecificallytofillthisgap.Forsomeyears,CVERAsoughttobuildascience-baseinsupportofAHI’sformation,providingacriticalreviewofcurrentperformanceinnon-regulatoryanimalhealthinIreland,andbuildingacaseforincreasedprivatesectorinvolvementinnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissues.FollowingAHIestablishmentinearly2009,CVERAhasbeenheavilycommitted,withotherpartners,inprovidingscientificinformationinsupportofnationaldecision-makinginthisarea,throughAHI’stechnicalworkinggroups,focusingonareasincludingbiosecurity,calfhealth,Johne’sdiseaseandmastitis.CVERAisalsoleadingorcontributingtoanumberofhighlyappliedresearchprogrammesintheseareas.
Irish Veterinary Journal
IncollaborationwithMichaelDoherty,theEditor-in-Chief,SimonMorehasworkedtoestablishtheIrish Veterinary Journal asanopenaccessjournal,withintheBioMedCentral(BMC)stable.BMCcurrentlypublish227internationalpeer-reviewedjournals,allopenaccess,mostinpartnershipwithscientificsocieties.Thejournal,located at www.irishvetjournal.org, now has the potential to reach its full potential, providing an international showcaseforhigh-qualityIrishveterinarymedicalresearch.Thejournalisnowindexedwidely,includinginPubMed,andhighlyvisibleinternationally.AsstatedbyMichaelatitsrecent“re”-launch:
“The aspirations and achievements of the Irish veterinary profession and Irish veterinary science are world-class, in terms of patient care, national disease control, veterinary education and research. This exciting new relationship between Irish Veterinary Journal and BioMed Central, providing open access publishing and concomitant increased international standing, is entirely in keeping with those aspirations and achievements.”
CVERAisleadingtheIVJarchivingproject,whichseekstocreateacompleteelectronicarchiveoftheIrish Veterinary Journal, fromvolume1in1946.Atthispoint,allpeer-reviewedjournalarticlesfromvolume57(2004)areavailableonline.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 111
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Statistical scientific su
pp
ort
Statistical scientific support
Key CVERA contacts: Tracy Clegg, Mary Canty
CVERAprovidesstatisticalsupportinavarietyofareasrangingfromstudydesign,statisticalanalysis,interpretationofresultsandassistancewithpublishingresults.SupportismainlyprovidedtopersonnelinDAFMonvariousresearchareas.Inaddition,statisticalsupportisprovidedtoAHItechnicalworkinggroupsasrequestedandtoresearchersinUCDVeterinaryMedicineandotherorganisations.AdviceandtechnicalexpertiseisalsoprovidedbyCVERAforthestatisticalsoftwarepackagesSAS,STATA,SPSSand,toalesserextent,WINBUGS.
During2010-2011,inadditiontocoreprojectsalreadydescribed,CVERAprovidedstatisticalsupportandadvicetoarangeofresearchprojectsasfollows:
Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM)
Routine support
• EstimationofthepotencyoftuberculinsuppliedtoIreland.AroundtwiceeachyearDAFMcarriesouttrialsoncattlethathavealreadytestedpositivetotheSingleIntradermalComparativeTuberculinTest(SICTT)inordertoestimatethepotencyoftuberculinsuppliedtoIreland.CVERAreceivesthedatafromthesetrialsandrunstheappropriate models to estimate the potency of the tuberculin batches tested
• SelectionofarandomsampleofherdsforasurveillanceprogrammeonBluetonguevirusintheIrishcattlepopulation
• Providestatisticalsupportannuallytoassistinthequantitativecomparisonoftheperformanceofindividualprivateveterinarypractitioners(PVPs)inrelationtoSICTTtestingforbovinetuberculosis
Statistical support
• Providedstatisticalassistancewiththedatacollection,descriptiveanalysisandtheuseoflogisticregressionforastudyofbovinetuberculosisinanimalsslaughteredfromsinglereactorbreakdownatanIrishexportmeatplant
• Assistedwiththesampleselectionandanalysisofprevalenceforasurveyofthedistributionofparatuberculosis(Johne’sdisease)incattleherdsinIreland
• ProvidedstatisticaladviceforastudyoftuberculosisingoatsonafarminIreland • Assistedwithdescriptiveanalysisofbovinecasesconsignedunderveterinarycertificationtoemergencyand
casualtyslaughterinIrelandduring2006to2008 • Advisedonthestudydesigntoidentifynon-complianceofsheepidentification • PerformedstatisticalanalysisusingsurvivalanalysistocomparetheperformanceofSICTTtestingcarriedoutby
TVIscomparedwithherdstestedbypvpswhentestingherdsforbovinetuberculosis • Advisedonthestatisticalanalysisofthecalvingintervalofcowsin5beefherdsbyvariousriskfactors
Biennial Report, 2010/2011112
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Stat
isti
cal
scie
nti
fic
sup
po
rt
UCD School of Veterinary Medicine
Teaching
• VNUR30310 Introduction to Research (lecture, 3rdyearVeterinaryNursingDegreeprogramme)–lecturesandtutorials on statistics
Statistical support
• Statisticaladviceprovidedontheappropriatenon-parametricteststouseforthestudy:Comparisonofultrasound-guidedversus“blind”techniquesforintra-synovialinjectionsoftheshoulderareainhorses:scapulohumeraljoint,bicipitalbursaandinfraspinatusbursa
• Assistedwiththestatisticalanalysisforastudyofaretrospectivereviewofweightlossdespiteagoodappetitein horses
• StatisticaladviceprovidedontheappropriatemethodstousetocompareSCCmeasurementsforthestudy: AHACCP-basedapproachtomastitiscontrolindairyherds.Part2:Implementationandevaluation
• AssistedwiththedescriptivedataanalysisofDelphiresultsfromthestudy:EvaluationofcurrentequinewelfareissuesinIreland:Causes,desirability,feasibilityandmeansofraisingstandards
• Adviceprovidedonthestudydesigntocomparedifferentdiagnosticimagingtechniques • Assistedwiththestatisticalanalysistocomparebiosecurityrisksathorseevents • Assistedwiththedataanalysisforastudyofpersistent-postbreedingendometritisinmarescomparingswabs
takenbeforeandafterbreedingfromthevaginaanduterus • Contributedtoastudyonthenumberofherdrestrictionsduetobovinetuberculosisforaprojectbasedonherds
inWestWicklow
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 113
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Geo
grap
hic In
form
ation
Systems (G
IS) scientific su
pp
ort
Geographic Information Systems (GIS) scientific support
Key CVERA contacts: Guy McGrath, Daniel M. Collins
CVERAprovidesabroadrangeofGISscientificsupporttoresearchanddiseaseeradicationprojectsrunbyDAFM.Additionally,GISsupportisprovidedtoUCDVeterinaryMedicineandotherorganisations.ListedisasampleofGISworkconductedinCVERAwhichisnotcreditedformallythroughpeerreview.
The Wildlife Unit
a. An independent monitor
CVERAactsasanindependentmonitorfortheNationalParksandWildlifeServices(NPWS)withintheDepartmentofArts,HeritageandtheGaeltachttoensureoperationsoftheWildlifeUnit(DAFM)arewithinpre-agreedcriteria.Thisincludes verifying individual badger removal licences and calculating a running total of the total area of land under treat-mentbycounty.Six-monthlyreportsareproducedforthetwogovernmentDepartments.
b. Administration
InadditiontomonitoringandreportingonWildlifeUnitactivities,CVERAmaintaintheGIScomponentoftheWildlifeUnitadministrationcentreinJohnstownCastle,Co.Wexford.ThiscentreprovidesallDistrictVeterinaryOfficeswiththerelevantmapsandortho-photographytocompletebadgersurveysinareaswheretuberculosisbreak-downsincattlehavebeenattributedtowildlife.ThebadgersettsfoundthroughsurveyingaredigitisedandmaintainedcentrallyontheGIS.Spatialqueriesareemployedtovalidatesettlocationandreduceinputerrors.
c. Vaccine trial
Avaccinethatprotectsbadgersfrombovinetuberculosisiscurrentlybeingtrialled.ThefieldtrialareainwestKilkennywasselectedbaseduponlocation,herdcountandcattledensity,existingsettdensity,topologyandlanduseusingGIS.Additional locations in other counties have been identified to replace badger culling with vaccination as part of an addi-tionaltrial.OngoingGISsupportwillbeprovidedforthemaintenanceandanalysisoftheseprojects.
d. General Wildlife Unit tasks
Specificqueriesandissuesconsideredtobeoflocalimportancearedealtwithonanad hocbasis.ThisincludesmappingneighbourhoodTBtestinghistorytoassistindecisionmakinginproblemareas.AllDistrictVeterinaryOfficesaresuppliedwithA0mapsannuallyshowingthelocationoftheirsettsandcaptureblocks.
Technical GIS support
Administrative
IntheeventofanoutbreakofaClassAdisease,CVERAprovideGISsupporttotheDAFM’sNationalDiseaseControlCentre.InthecaseofFootandMouthdisease(FMD),CVERAliaisewiththeIrishmeteorologicaloffice,MetÉireann,toestablishthewindborneriskofinfectiontofarmsinthevicinityofanindexcase.CVERAarecurrentlyinvolvedintheprocessofunifyingFMDzonemappingwithourGIScounterpartsintheDepartmentofAgricultureandRuralDevelopment,NorthernIreland.CVERAhaveprovidedcontingencymappingsupportfordiseasesassociateswithbovine,avian,equine,porcineandovinespecies.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011114
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Geo
gra
ph
ic I
nfo
rmat
ion
Sys
tem
s (G
IS)
scie
nti
fic
sup
po
rt
Epidemiological
CVERAassistinthespatialcomponentsofadiversearrayofepidemiologicalprojects.Theseprojectsinclude:
• SelectingrandomsitesnationallyforthesurveyofCulicoides • HerdselectionbygridsquareforannualBluetonguesurveillance • ClusteranalysisofJohne’sDisease • ClusteringofCryptosporidium • Associatinglocalclimaticeventswithpoorperformanceonastudyherd • Aerialdispersionmodelling • Continuationofdiseasedensity‘greenblob’maps2007throughto2010 • MappingofleadlevelsinbovinesintheSilverminesarea
General administrative GIS support
CVERAprovidesregularGISadministrativereportstoDAFM.ExamplesofGISadministrativereportstotheDepartment include:
• EstimatingthedistancebetweenmainfarmsandtheircorrespondingcountyDistrictVeterinaryOffice(DVO) • CalculatingthecatchmentareasforDAFMVeterinaryLaboratoryServiceregionaloffices • CalculatingDVOfarmcatchmentareas • ProvidingmappingassistancefortheearlystagesoftheN11badgertrackingproject
Ad hoc GIS support
CVERAprovidesonce-offGISsupporttoarangeofprojectsconductedbytheDepartment,UCDVeterinaryMedicineandothercollaboratingagencies.ExamplesofrecentGISsupportinclude:
• CreatingamapforDVOsshowinglivetransportrestingstopsinFranceunderEUwelfarerequirements(DAFM) • MappingthesubmissionofequinecasestotheUCDVeterinaryHospital(UCD) • Thelocationofroadsstudiedforapaperonroadcasualtymammals(UCC) • TheterritoriesandbadgersettlocationsofLittleIsland,Co.Waterford(UCC) • MapsillustratingvariousaspectsoftheIrishequineindustryaspartofapublicationentitled“Challengesand
solutionstosupportgoodequinewelfarepracticeinIreland”(UCD) • SelectiononaControlareafortheN11badgertrackingproject(DAFM) • Constructionofanational10metreDigitalTerrainmodel(DTM)ofIreland • CreationofacompleteseamlessLandParcelIdentificationSystem(LPIS)coverageofIrelandfrom1999with
spatial attribution applied to the most recent entries • TrichinellamapsandbovinedensitymapsforDAFMVeterinaryLaboratoryService • Piroplasmosismapping(DAFM)
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 115
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Geo
grap
hic In
form
ation
Systems (G
IS) scientific su
pp
ort
Provision of geographic data
CVERAprovidecollaborativeagencieswithgeographicdata.Someoftheseprojectsinclude:
• TheprovisionofLandParcelIdentificationSystem(LPIS)toNationalParksand WildlifeServices(NPWS)onanongoingbasis
• TheprovisionofFourAreaProjectdataandGISassistancetoTheSchoolofNaturalSciencesin Trinity College Dublin
• TheprovisionofdatatotheUCDSchoolofMathematicalSciencesforaprojectbasedonherds intheWestWicklowarea
• Theprovisionofdataforaprojectentitled“EffectofdistancebetweenapreviouslyMycobacterium bovis-infected herdandclearherdsontheoccurrenceofbovinetuberculosisbreakdownsinIreland
• TheprovisionofspatialdatatomodelthebadgerpopulationsinIreland • Theprovisionofdataforaprojectaimedatevaluatingarisk-basedapproachtomeatinspection
forbovinetuberculosisinIreland • TheconversionofIrishgeographicXYlocationdatatointernationallat/longstandard • Theprovisionofmappingresourcesaspartofveterinarystudentherdinvestigations • AnnValleycatchmentconstructedwetlanddatasupport • Theprovisionofdataforanationalwildlifesurvey
Biennial Report, 2010/2011116
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Dat
abas
e sc
ien
tifi
c su
pp
ort
Database scientific support
Key CVERA contact: Isabella Higgins
ProvisionandpreparationofdataforresearchprojectsforCVERA,PhDtheses/publicationsandsupportforarangeofprojectsfromthementoringgroup
Maintenance and conversion of the following databases to SAS® datasets
CVERAmaintainsacopyofthefollowingnationaldatabases: • AnimalHealthComputerSystem(AHCS)database ❍ TBHerdtestsummaryrecords ❍ TBAnimallevelrecords ❍ TBFactorysurveillancedatabase • AnimalIdentificationandMovementsSystem(AIMS)databaseEachisconvertedtoSAS®datasets,tofacilitatedataextractionandanalysis.
Data extraction
Dataextractionfromtheabove-mentioneddatabaseshasorisbeingusedforabroadrangeofprojects,including:
• CostbenefitanalysisofIrishBVDeradicationprogramme;descriptivedataforsuckler,dairyandbeeffatteningherdsbyherdsize
• CalfwastageprojecttoestimatecalfmortalityinIreland;dataextractionfromAIMSandcollationwithICBFdatafrommilk-recordingherds
• Winddistributionmodels;provisionofassistancewiththehandlingofrawdata • ThematicmappingofbovineTBincidencepersquarekm;provisionofAPTfiguresonaDEDbasis(forkernel
densitywithsearchradiusat10km)fortheyears2010and2011 • GeneticsoftuberculosisinIrishdairycows;mergingoflinkablerecordsfromAHCS,AIMS(formerlyCMMS,
CattleMovementMonitoringSystem)andtheIrishCattleBreedingFederation(ICBF)databasetocreateanimaland herd level records of animal breeding and disease control
• Provisionofdemographicdataforaretrospectivecohortstudyontherelationshipbetweenherdsize,herdexpansionandmilksomaticcellcounts
• ProvisionofdemographicdataonfarmsselectedforthestudyonmolecularepidemiologyofCryptosporidium parvum subtypes using multi-locus subtyping approach and geographic information system approach
• Identifykeyperformanceindicators(KPIs)thatcanbemonitoredtoenhancetheEarlyWarningSystem(EWS)forAnimalHealthandWelfare;dataextractionfromAIMSofthefollowingdata:Lateregistrations,Cattleexitsbyon-farmburial,Cattlemovestotheknackery,CattlemovestoherdE800andTotalcattleexits(movetothefactory,abattoir,mart,privatesale,knackery,on-farmburial,locateorE800)
• Investigatingthelong-termsurvivalandmovementofBVDantigenpositiveanimalstotheknackery/laboratory,factoryorotherfarms;provisionofmovementdatafromAIMSfortheseanimals,asconfirmedbyDAFMVeterinaryLaboratoryServiceduring2010
• ProvisionofepisodebaseddataandmovementrecordsasafollowuptopreviousworkonthegeneticsoftuberculosisinIrishdairycows.ThemainobjectiveofthisfurtherstudyistofinemaptheregionsofthegenomeassociatedwithTBandtoinvestigateusingbeefanimalsandtocreatemoreaccuratedependentvariables(i.e.geneticmeritforTBonsires)
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 117
SC
IEN
TIf
IC S
UP
PO
RT
Datab
ase scientific su
pp
ort
General database support
CVERAprovidesgeneraldatabasesupportthrougheachofthefollowing:
• SupportthestructureofepidemiologicaldatastorageinSAS®
• Ensuretimelyandaccuratemanagementofepidemiologicaldata • Leadon-goingdatamaintenanceefforts • Ensureepidemiologicaldataisenteredaccurately • ProgramminginSAS®requestsforanalysesofepidemiologicaldata • AssistwithSAS® upgrades • Recommendandassistintheimplementationofprocessimprovementsfordataexchange • Create,editandupdateepidemiologicaldatasetsasrequested • Interactwithandrespondtoepidemiologicaldataquestions • Participateinprojectsanddepartmentmeetingstomaintainawarenessofchangingneedsastheyrelateto
epidemiological data usage • Identifynewepidemiologicaldatarequirementsandchangestoexistingepidemiologicaldata
Creation of episode-based data
DetailedworkwasconductedtocreateadatabaseofTBbreakdownepisodesfortheperiod1989-2010.ThisworkwillformthebasisofextensivefutureworkinthestudyofTB,includingeachofthefollowingresearchprojects:
• Compilationandvalidationofepisode-baseddatafortheRestockingStudyandidentificationofthestudypopulation
• Provisionofextensivetabulateddataovertheperiod1995-2010ofbovineTBtrendsinIrelandaspartofworkincollaborationwithEngland,NorthernIreland,ScotlandandWalesusingepisode-baseddata,AHCSTBherdtestsummaryrecordsandTBanimaltestrecords
• Thedevelopmentandapplicationofnewmeasuresofperformance,relatingtothemanagementoftheIrishTBeradicationprogramme.Thisprojectwillassistwithongoingprogrammereviewtoenableongoingmeasurementand to review programme progress
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
118 Biennial Report, 2010/2011
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 119
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Publications
During 2010-11 ....................................................................................................... 120
Prior to 2010 ........................................................................................................... 128
Biennial Report, 2010/2011120
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Du
rin
g 2
01
0-2
01
1
During 2010-2011
Peer reviewed papers
Aznar,I.,McGrath,G.,Murphy,D.,Corner,L.A.L.,Gormley,E.,Frankena,K.,More,S.J.,Martin,W.,O’Keeffe,J.,DeJong,M.C.M.,2011.Trialdesigntoestimatetheeffectofvaccinationontuberculosisincidenceinbadgers.Veterinary Microbiology151,104-111.
*Barrett,D.J.,Mee,J.F.,Mullowney,P.,Good,M.,McGrath,G.,Clegg,T.,More,S.J.,2011.RiskfactorsassociatedwithJohne’sdiseaseteststatusindairyherdsinIreland.Veterinary Record168,410.
*Barrett,D.J.,More,S.J.,Graham,D.A.,O’Flaherty,J.,Doherty,M.L.,Gunn,H.M.,2011.ConsiderationsonBVDeradicationfortheIrishlivestockindustry.Irish Veterinary Journal64,12.
Beekhuis-Gibbon,L.,Devitt,C.,Whyte,P.,O’Grady,L.,More,S.J.,Redmond,B.,Quin,S.,Doherty,M.L.,2011.AHACCP-basedapproachtomastitiscontrolindairyherds.Part2:Implementationandevaluation.Irish Veterinary Journal64,7.
Beekhuis-Gibbon,L.,Whyte,P.,O’Grady,L.,More,S.J.,Doherty,M.L.,2011.AHACCP-basedapproachtomastitiscontrolindairyherds.Part1:Development.Irish Veterinary Journal64,2.
Bermingham,M.L.,Brotherstone,S.,Berry,D.P.,More,S.J.,Good,M.,Cromie,A.R.,White,I.M.S.,Higgins,I.M.,Coffey,M.,Downs,S.H.,Glass,E.J.,Bishop,S.C.,Mitchell,A.P.,Clifton-Hadley,R.S.,Woolliams,J.A.,2011.EvidenceforgeneticvarianceinresistancetotuberculosisinGreatBritainandIrishHolstein-Friesianpopulations. BMC Proceedings5(Suppl4),S15.
Bermingham,M.L.,More,S.J.,Good,M.,Cromie,A.R.,Higgins,I.M.,Berry,D.P.,2010.Geneticcorrelationsbetween measures of Mycobacterium bovisinfectionandeconomicallyimportanttraitsinIrishHolstein-Friesiandairycows.Journal of Dairy Science93,5413-5422.
Berry,D.P.,Bermingham,M.L.,Good,M.,More,S.J.,2011.Geneticsofanimalhealthanddiseaseincattle.Irish Veterinary Journal64,5.
Berry,D.P.,Good,M.,Mullowney,P.,Cromie,A.R.,More,S.J.,2010.GeneticvariationinserologicalresponsetoMycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosisanditsassociationwithperformanceinIrishHolstein-Friesiandairycows.Livestock Science131,102-107.
Boland,F.,Kelly,G.E.,Good,M.,More,S.J.,2010.BovinetuberculosisandmilkproductionininfecteddairyherdsinIreland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine93,153-161.
Brotherstone,S.,White,I.M.S.,Coffey,M.,Downs,S.H.,Mitchell,A.H.,Clifton-Hadley,R.S.,More,S.J.,Good,M.,Woolliams,J.A.,2010.EvidenceofgeneticresistanceofcattletoinfectionwithMycobacterium bovis.Journal of Dairy Science93,1234-1242.
Chambers,M.A.,Rogers,F.,Delahay,R.J.,Lesellier,S.,Ashford,R.,Dalley,D.,Gowtage,S.,Davé,D.,Palmer,S.,Brewer,J.,Crawshaw,T.,Clifton-Hadley,R.,Carter,S.,Cheeseman,C.,Hanks,C.,Murray,A.,Palphramand,K.,Pietravalle,S.,Smith,G.C.,Tomlinson,A.,Walker,N.J.,Wilson,G.J.,Corner,L.A.L.,Rushton,S.P.,Shirley,M.D.F.,Gettinby,G.,McDonald,R.A.,Hewinson,R.G.,2011.BacillusCalmette-Guérinvaccinationreducestheseverityandprogressionoftuberculosisinbadgers.Proceedings of the Royal Society B278,1913-1920.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 121
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Du
ring
20
10
-20
11
Cho,D.,Nam,H.,Kim,J.,Heo,E.,Cho,Y.,Hwang,I.,Kim,J.,Kim,J.,Jung,S.,More,S.,2010.QuantitativeRoseBengaltestfordiagnosisofbovinebrucellosis.JournalofImmunoassay and Immunochemistry31,120-130.
***Cleary,G.P.,Corner,L.A.L.,O’Keeffe,J.,Marples,N.M.,2011.DietoftheEuropeanbadger(Meles meles) in the RepublicofIreland:Acomparisonofresultsfromananalysisofstomachcontentsandrectalfaeces. Mammalian Biology76,470-475.
Clegg,T.,Duignan,A.,Whelan,C.,Gormley,E.,Good,M.,Clarke,J.,Toft,N.,More,S.J.,2011.Usinglatentclassanalysis to estimate the test characteristics of the interferon-g test, the single intradermal comparative tuberculin test and amultipleximmunoassayunderIrishconditions.Veterinary Microbiology151,68-76.
Clegg,T.A.,Good,M.,Duignan,A.,Doyle,R.,Blake,M.,More.S.J.,2011.Longer-termriskofMycobacterium bovis inIrishcattlefollowinganinconclusivediagnosistothesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest. Preventive Veterinary Medicine100,147-154.
Clegg,T.A.,Good,M.,Duignan,A.,Doyle,R.,More.S.J.,2011.Shorter-termriskofMycobacterium bovisinIrishcattlefollowinganinconclusivediagnosistothesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintest. Preventive Veterinary Medicine102,255-264.
Collins,J.,Hanlon,A.,More,S.J.,Wall,P.,Kennedy,J.,Duggan,V.,2010.EvaluationofcurrentequinewelfareissuesinIreland:causes,desirability,feasibilityandmeansofraisingstandards.Equine Veterinary Journal42,105-113.
Collins,J.,More,S.J.,Hanlon,A.,Duggan,V.,2010.CasestudyofequinewelfareonanIrishfarm:2007-2009.Veterinary Record167,90-95.
Collins,J.A.,Hanlon,A.,More,S.J.,Wall,P.G.,Duggan,V.,2011.Aspectsoftheowning/keepinganddisposalofhorses,andhowtheserelatetoequinehealth/welfareinIreland.Irish Veterinary Journal64,11.
Corner,L.A.L.,Costello,E.,O’Meara,D.,Lesellier,S.,Aldwell,F.E.,Singh,M.,Hewinson,R.G.,Chambers,M.A.,Gormley,E.,2010.Oralvaccinationofbadgers(Meles meles)withBCGandprotectiveimmunityagainstendobronchialchallenge with Mycobacterium bovis.Vaccine28,6265-6272.
Corner,L.A.L.,Murphy,D.,Gormley,E.,2011.Mycobacterium bovisinfectionintheEurasianbadger(Meles meles): the disease,pathogenesis,epidemiologyandcontrol.Journal of Comparative Pathology144,1-24.
Cowley,D.J.B.,Clegg,T.A.,Doherty,M.L.,More,S.J.,2011.Aspectsofbovineherpesvirus-1infectionindairyandbeefherdsintheRepublicofIreland.Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica53,40.
Cullinane,M.,O’Sullivan,E.,Collins,G.,Collins,D.M.,More,S.J.,2010.Areviewofbovinecasesconsignedunderveteri-narycertificationtoemergencyandcasualtyslaughterinIrelandduring2006to2008.Irish Veterinary Journal63,568-577.
Downes,M.J.,Clegg,T.A.,Collins,D.M.,McGrath,G.,More,S.J.,2011.ThespatialdistributionofpetdogsandpetcatsontheislandofIreland.BMC Veterinary Research7,28.
Downes,M.J.,Roy,A.,McGinn,T.G.,Wisnivesky,J.P.,2010.Factorsassociatedwithfurrypetownershipamongpatientswithasthma.Journal of Asthma47,742-749.
Gil,O.,Díaz,I.,Vilaplana,C.,Tapia,G.,Díaz,J.,Fort,M.,Cáceres,N.,Pinto,S.,Caylà,J.,Corner,L.,Domingo,M.,Cardona,P.-J.,2010.Granulomaencapsulationisakeyfactorforcontainingtuberculosisinfectioninminipigs.PLoS One 5,e10030.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011122
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Du
rin
g 2
01
0-2
01
1
Good,M.,Clegg,T.A.,Costello,E.,More,S.J.,2011.ThecomparativeperformanceofthesingleintradermaltestandthesingleintradermalcomparativetuberculintestinIrishcattle,usingtuberculinPPDcombinationsofdifferingpoten-cies.The Veterinary Journal190,e60-e65.
Good,M.,Clegg,T.A.,Duignan,A.,More,S.J.,2011.ImpactofthenationalfullherddepopulationpolicyontherecurrenceofbovinetuberculosisinIrishherds,2003to2005.Veterinary Record169,581.
Good,M.,Clegg,T.A.,Murphy,F.,More,S.J.,2011.Thecomparativeperformanceofthesingleintradermalcomparativetuber-culintestinIrishcattle,usingtuberculinPPDcombinationsfromdifferentmanufacturers.Veterinary Microbiology151,77-84.
#Good,M.,Duignan,A.,2011.AnevaluationoftheIrishSingleReactorBreakdownProtocolfor2005to2008inclu-siveanditspotentialapplicationasamonitoroftuberculintestperformance.Veterinary Microbiology151,85-90.
#Good,M.,Duignan,A.,2011.PerspectivesonthehistoryofbovineTBandtheroleoftuberculininbovineTBeradi-cation.Veterinary Medicine International,articleID410470.
Gormley,E.,Corner,L.A.L.,2011.Controloftuberculosisinbadgersbyvaccination:Wherenext?The Veterinary Journal189,239–241.
Hayes,M.,Kilroy,A.,Ashe,S.,Power,S.,Kenny,K.,Collins,D.M.,More,S.J.,2010.Anoutbreakofbovinebrucel-losisinCountyClare,Ireland,during2005.Veterinary Record166,107-111.
***Kelly,D.J.,Corner,L.A.L.,Gormley,E.,Murphy,D.,Costello,E.,Aldwell,F.E.,Marples,N.M.,2011.Evaluationofattractant flavours for use in oral vaccine baits for badgers (Meles meles).European Journal of Wildlife Research57,767-774.
Kelly,G.E.,McGrath,G.,More,S.J.,2010.EstimatingtheextentofspatialassociationofMycobacterium bovis infection inbadgersinIreland.Epidemiology and Infection138,270-279.
Kelly,G.E.,More,S.J.,2011.SpatialclusteringofTB-infectedcattleherdspriortoandfollowingproactivebadgerremoval.Epidemiology and Infection139,1220-1229.
Kelly,P.C.,More,S.J.,Blake,M.,Hanlon,A.J.,2011.Identificationofkeyperformanceindicatorsforon-farmanimalwelfareincidents:possibletoolsforearlywarningandprevention.Irish Veterinary Journal64,13.
Killick,K.E.,Browne,J.A.,Park,S.D.E.,Magee,D.A.,Martin,I.,Meade,K.G.,Gordon,S.V.,Gormley,E.,O’Farrelly,C.,Hokamp,K.,MacHugh,D.E.,2011.Genome-widetranscriptionalprofilingofperipheralbloodleukocytesfromcattleinfectedwithMycobacteriumbovisrevealssuppressionofhostimmunegenes.BMC Genomics12,611.
Lesellier,S.,Palmer,S.,Gowtage-Sequiera,S.,Ashford,R.,Dalley,D.,Davé,D.,Weyer,U.,Salguero,F.J.,Nunez,A.,Crawshaw,T.,Corner,L.A.L.,Hewinson,R.G.,Chambers,M.A.,2011.ProtectionofEurasianbadgers(Meles meles) fromtuberculosisafterintra-muscularvaccinationwithdifferentdosesofBCG.Vaccine29,3782–3790.
Lorenz,I.,Earley,B.,Gilmore,J.,Hogan,I.,Kennedy,E.,More,S.J.,2011.Calfhealthfrombirthtoweaning.III.Housingandmanagementofcalfpneumonia.Irish Veterinary Journal64,14
Lorenz,I.,Fagan,J.,More,S.J.,2011.Calfhealthfrombirthtoweaning.II.Managementofdiarrhoeainpre-weanedcalves.Irish Veterinary Journal64,9.
Lorenz,I.,Mee,J.F.,Earley,B.,More,S.J.,2011.Calfhealthfrombirthtoweaning.I.Generalaspectsofdiseaseprevention.Irish Veterinary Journal64,10.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 123
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Du
ring
20
10
-20
11
Martinez,T.A.,Pfeiffer,D.U.,More,S.J.,2011.Preface.SVEPM2010–Theroleofveterinaryepidemiologyinanimalhealthintheworldtoday.Preventive Veterinary Medicine100,89.
More,S.J.,2010.Improvingthequalityofreportinginveterinaryjournals:howfardoweneedtogowithreportingguidelines?The Veterinary Journal184,249-250.
More,S.J.,Doherty,M.L.,Downey,L.,McKenzie,K.,Devitt,C.,O’Flaherty,J.,2011.AnimalHealthIreland:providingnationalleadershipandcoordinationofnon-regulatoryanimalhealthissuesinIreland.Revue scientifique et technique / Office international des épizooties (OIE Scientific and Technical Review)30,715-723.
More,S.J.,McKenzie,K.,O’Flaherty,J.,Doherty,M.L.,Cromie,A.R.,Magan,M.J.,2010.Settingprioritiesfornon-regulatoryanimalhealthinIreland:resultsfromanexpertPolicyDelphistudyandafarmerpriorityidentificationsurvey.Preventive Veterinary Medicine95,198-207.
Murphy,D.,Gormley,E.,Collins,D.M.,McGrath,G.,Sovsic,E.,Costello,E.,Corner,L.A.L.,2011.Tuberculosisincattle herds are sentinels for Mycobacterium bovisinfectioninEuropeanbadgers(Meles meles):theIrishGreenfieldStudy.Veterinary Microbiology151,120-125.
Murphy,D.,Gormley,E.,Costello,E.,O’Meara,D.,Corner,L.A.L.,2010.TheprevalenceanddistributionofMycobacterium bovisinfectioninEuropeanbadgers(Meles meles) as determined by enhanced post mortem examination andbacteriologicalculture.Research in Veterinary Science88,1-5.
Nash,D.M.,Sheldon,I.M.,Herath,S.,Lane,E.A.,2010.Endometrialexplantculturetostudytheresponseofequineendometriumtoinsemination.Reproduction in Domestic Animals45,670–676.
Nash,D.M.,Sheldon,I.M.,Herath,S.,Lane,E.A.,2010.Markersoftheuterineinnateimmuneresponseofthemare.Animal Reproduction Science119,31–39.
**O’Shea,F.,Sleeman,D.P.,Davenport,J.,2010.Theeffectofbadgerremovalonroadcasualtymammals.Irish Naturalists’ Journal31,118-122.
*Ryan,E.,Kirby,M.,Clegg,T.,Collins,D.M.,2011.SeroprevalenceofCoxiella burnetii antibodies in sheep and goats intheRepublicofIreland.Veterinary Record169,280.
*Ryan,E.D.,Kirby,M.,Collins,D.M.,Sayers,R.,Mee,J.F.,Clegg,T.,2011.PrevalenceofCoxiella burnetii(Qfever)antibodiesinbovineserumandbulk-milksamples.Epidemiology and Infection139,1413-1417.
Salguero,F.J.,Lesellier,S.,Nuñez,A.,Corner,L.,Crawshaw,T.,Chambers,M.,2010.IntramuscularBCGvaccina-tion reduces significantly the pathology induced by Mycobacterium bovis in badgers (Meles meles).Journal of Comparative Pathology143,347.
Schiller,I.,Vordermeier,H.M.,Waters,W.R.,Whelan,A.O.,Coad,M.,Gormley,E.,Buddle,B.M.,Palmer,M.,Thacker,T.,McNair,J.,Welsh,M.,Hewinson,R.G.,Oesch,B.,2010.Bovinetuberculosis:Effectofthetuberculinskintestonin vitrointerferongammaresponses. Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology136,1–11.
Schiller,I.,Waters,W.R.,Vordermeier,H.M.,Jemmi,T.,Welsh,M.,Keck,N.,Whelan,A.,Gormley,E.,Boschiroli,M.L.,Moyen,J.L.,Vela,C.,Cagiola,M.,Buddle,B.M.,Palmer,M.,Thacker,T.,Oesch,B.,2011.BovinetuberculosisinEuropefromtheperspectiveofanofficallytuberculosisfreecountry:trade,surveillanceanddiagnostics. Veterinary Microbiology151,153-159.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011124
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Du
rin
g 2
01
0-2
01
1
Shanahan,A.,GoodM.,DuignanA.,Curtin,T.,More,S.J.,2011.TuberculosisingoatsonafarminIreland:epide-miologicalinvestigationandcontrol.Veterinary Record168,485.
#Sheridan,M.,2011.ProgressintuberculosiseradicationinIreland.Veterinary Microbiology151,160-169.
**Sleeman,D.P.,Partridge,T.,O’Boyle,I.,Gormley,E.,Toolan,D.,2010.Thebadgers(Meles meles (L.)) of Little Island,Co.Waterford.Irish Naturalists’ Journal31,94-99.
Taraktsoglou,M.,Szalabska,U.,Magee,D.A.,Browne,J.A.,Sweeney,T.,Gormley,E.,MacHugh,D.E.,2011.Transcriptionalprofilingofimmunegenesinbovinemonocyte-derivedmacrophagesexposedtobacterialantigens.Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology140,130-139.
Waters,W.R.,Buddle,B.M.,Vordermeier,H.M.,Gormley,E.,Palmer,M.V.,Thacker,T.C.,Bannantine,J.P.,Stabel,J.R.,Linscott,R.,Martel,E.,Milian,F.,Foshaug,W.,Lawrence,J.C.,2011.Developmentandevaluationofanenzyme-linkedimmunosorbentassayforuseinthedetectionofbovinetuberculosisincattle.Clinical and Vaccine Immunology18,1882-1888.
Wee,S-H.,Kim,C-H.,More.S.J.,Nam,H-M.,2010.Mycobacterium bovisinKorea:anupdate.The Veterinary Journal 185,347-350.
White,P.,Frankena,K.,O’Keeffe,J.,More,S.J.,Martin,S.W.,2010.Predictorsofthefirstbetween-herdanimalmove-mentforcattlebornin2002inIreland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine97,264-269.
Wolfe,D.M.,Berke,O.,Kelton,D.F.,White,P.W.,More,S.J.,O’Keeffe,J.,Martin,S.W.,2010.Fromexplanationtoprediction:developingapredictivemodelforrecurrentbovinetuberculosisinIrishcattleherds.Preventive Veterinary Medicine94,170-177.
Yoon,H.,Moon,O.K.,More,S.J.,Park,C.K.,Park,J.Y.,Lee,Y.J.,Lee,S.D.,Ha,J.K.,Jeong,S.K.,Jeong,J.W.,Lee,S.J.,2010.AnoutbreakofhighlypathogenicavianinfluenzaatapublicanimalexhibitinSeoul,Koreaduring2008.Zoonoses and Public Health57,142-145.
# CVERA Board of management
* DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service
** UCC School of Biological, Earth & Environmental Sciences
*** School of Natural Sciences, Trinity College Dublin
Scientific opinions
(J.D. Collins [UCD CVERA] and J.M. Griffin [DAFM] with other members of the Scientific Panel on Biological Hazards (BIOHAZ), and S.J. More [UCD CVERA] with other members of the Panel on Animal Health and Welfare (AHAW) of the European Food Safety Authority [EFSA])
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.Scientificopiniononthepracticeofharvesting(collecting)feathersfromlivegeesefordownproduction.EFSA Journal8,1886.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.ScientificopinionontheincreasedmortalityeventsinPacificoysters,Crassostrea gigas.EFSA Journal8,1894.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.Scientificopiniononthepandemic(H1N1)2009influ-enzaanditspotentialimplicationsforanimalhealth.EFSA Journal8,1770.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 125
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Du
ring
20
10
-20
11
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.Scientificopinionongeographicdistributionoftick-borneinfectionsandtheirvectorsinEuropeandtheotherregionsoftheMediterraneanBasin.EFSA Journal8,1723.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.Scientificopinionontheroleoftickvectorsintheepide-miologyofCrimean-CongoHemorrhagicFeverandAfricanSwineFeverinEurasia.EFSA Journal8,1703.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.Scientificopiniononwelfareaspectsofthemanagementandhousingofthegrand-parentandparentstocksraisedandkeptforbreedingpurposes.EFSA Journal8,1667.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.Scientificopinionontheinfluenceofgeneticparametersonthewelfareandtheresistancetostressofcommercialbroilers.EFSA Journal8,1666.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.ScientificopiniononAfricanswinefever.EFSA Journal8,1556.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2010.Scientificopiniononbovinebesnoitiosis:anemergingdiseaseinEurope.EFSA Journal8,1499.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2011.ScientificopiniononEpizooticUlcerativeSyndrome.EFSA Journal9,2387.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2011.Scientificopiniononbluetonguemonitoringandsurveil-lance.EFSA Journal9,2192.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2011.Scientificopiniononbluetongueserotype8.EFSA Journal 9,2189.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2011.Scientificopiniononthemonitoringfortheemergenceofpossiblenewpandemicstrainsofinfluenzainanimals.EFSA Journal9,2109.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2011.Scientificopinionconcerningthewelfareofanimalsduringtransport.EFSA Journal9,1966.
EFSAPanelsonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW)andBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.ScientificopiniononQfever.EFSA Journal8,1595.
EFSAPanelsonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW)andonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.Scientificopiniononhatcherywasteasanimalby-products.EFSA Journal9,2321.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.ScientificopiniononasecondupdateontheriskforhumanandanimalhealthrelatedtotherevisionoftheBSEmonitoringregimeinsomeMemberStates.EFSA Journal8,1946.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.ScientificopiniononBSE/TSEinfectivityinsmallruminanttissues.EFSA Journal8,1875.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.ScientificopinionontheresultsoftheEUsurveyforChronicWastingDisease(CWD)incervids.EFSA Journal8,1861.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.Scientificopiniononlimetreatmentofsolidpigandpoultrymanure.EFSA Journal8,1681.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011126
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Du
rin
g 2
01
0-2
01
1
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.ScientificopinionontheanalyticalsensitivityofapprovedTSErapidtests–newdataforassessmentoftworapidtests.EFSA Journal 8,1591.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.ScientificopiniononthelinkbetweenSalmonellacriteriaatdifferentstagesofthepoultryproductionchain.EFSA Journal8,1545.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.ScientificopiniononthequantificationoftheriskposedbybroilermeattohumancampylobacteriosisintheEU.EFSA Journal8,1437.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.ScientificopinionontheriskoftransmissionofTSEsviasemenandembryotransferinsmallruminants(sheepandgoats).EFSA Journal8,1429.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2010.StatementonfoodsafetyconsiderationsofnovelH1N1influenzavirusinfectionsinhumans.EFSA Journal8,1629.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.ScientificopinionontheriskposedbyShigatoxin-producingEscherichia coli(STEC)andotherpathogenicbacteriainseedsandsproutedseeds.EFSA Journal9,2424.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.Scientificopiniononon-sitetreatmentofpigcarcasses. EFSA Journal9,2425.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.Scientificopiniononcompostingon-farmofdeadpoultry. EFSA Journal9,2427.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.Scientificopinionontherevisionofthequantitativeriskassess-ment(QRA)oftheBSEriskposedbyprocessedanimalproteins(PAPs).EFSA Journal9,1947.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.ScientificopiniononaquantitativeestimationofthepublichealthimpactofsettinganewtargetforthereductionofSalmonellainbroilers.EFSA Journal9,2106.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.Scientificopiniononhatcherywasteasanimalby-products. EFSA Journal9,2321.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.Scientificopiniononanupdateonthepresentknowledgeontheoccurrenceandcontroloffoodborneviruses.EFSA Journal9,2190.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.ScientificopiniononthereviewontheriskforhumanandanimalhealthrelatedtotherevisionoftheBSEmonitoringregimeinthreeEUMemberStates.EFSA Journal9,2142.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.ScientificopiniononCampylobacterinbroilermeatproduction:controloptionsandperformanceobjectivesand/ortargetsatdifferentstagesofthefoodchain.EFSA Journal9,2105.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.Scientificopinionontheefficacyandmicrobiologicalsafetyofirradiationoffood.EFSA Journal9,2103.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.ScientificopiniononareviewoftheBSE-relatedriskinbovineintestines.EFSA Journal9,2104.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.ScientificopiniononthecapacityofoleochemicalprocessestominimisepossibleriskslinkedtoTSEinCategory1animalby-products.EFSA Journal9,1976.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 127
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Du
ring
20
10
-20
11
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.Scientificopiniononthepublichealthrisksofbacterialstrainsproducing extended-spectrum b-lactamasesand/orAmpCb-lactamasesinfoodandfood-producinganimals. EFSA Journal9,2322.
EFSAPanelsonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),ContaminantsintheFoodChain(CONTAM)andAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2011.Scientificopiniononthepublichealthhazardstobecoveredbyinspectionofmeat(swine).EFSA Journal9,2351.
EFSAScientificCommitteeandEFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2011.JointscientificopiniononanypossibleepidemiologicalormolecularassociationbetweenTSEsinanimalsandhumans.EFSA Journal9,1945.
Academic theses
Collins,J.,2010.ChallengesandsolutionstosupportgoodequinewelfarepracticeinIreland.PhDthesis.UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Downes,M.J.,2010.Thehuman-animalbond:thedemographicsofpetsandpetownershipontheislandofIreland,petownershipinasthmaticsintheUSAandownerattitudestowardspets.PhDthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Good,M.,2011.Thetuberculintestanditsroleinthestrategicmanagementanderadicationoftuberculosisincattle.PhDthesis,UtrechtUniversity,TheNetherlands.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011128
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prio
r to
20
10
Prior to 2010
Peer reviewed papers
Aguilar,D.,Infante,E.,Martin,C.,Gormley,E.,Gicquel,B.,Pando,R.H.,2007.ImmunologicalresponsesandprotectiveimmunityagainsttuberculosisconferredbyvaccinationofBalb/CmicewiththeattenuatedMycobacterium tuberculosis(phoP)SO2strain.Clinical and Experimental Immunology147,330-338.
Ashe,S.,More,S.J,O’Keeffe,J.,White,P.,McGrath,G.,Aznar,I.,2009.SurvivalanddispersalofadefinedcohortofIrishcattle.Irish Veterinary Journal62,44-49.
Baldock,F.C.,More,S.J.,Peeler,E.J.,2008.Anintroductiontoimportriskanalysisforaquaticanimals. Fish Veterinary Journal10,29-53.
Barrett,D.J.,Clegg,T.A.,Healy,A.M.,Doherty,M.L.,2006.AstudyofdrycowtherapyandeffectsonSCCin10Irishdairyherds.Journal of Veterinary Medicine Series A53,140-144.
Bermingham,M.L.,More,S.J.,Good,M.,Cromie,A.R.,Higgins,I.M.,Brotherstone,S.,Berry,D.P.,2009.GeneticsoftuberculosisinIrishHolstein-Friesiandairyherds.Journal of Dairy Science92,3447-3456.
Brangan,P.,Bailey,D.,Larkin,J.,Myers,T.,More,S.J.,2008.ManagementofthenationalprogrammetoeradicateequineinfectiousanaemiafromIrelandduring2006.Equine Veterinary Journal40,702-704.
Cashman,W.,Buckley,J.,QuigleyT.,Fanning,S.,More,S.,Egan,J.,Berry,D.,Grant,I.,O’Farrell,K.,2008.Riskfactors for introduction and within-herd transmission of Mycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis(MAP)infec-tionon59Irishdairyherds.Irish Veterinary Journal61,464-467.
Chapwanya,A.,Clegg,T.,Stanley,P.,Vaughan,L.,2008.ComparisonoftheImmuliteandRIAassaymethodsformeasuringperipheralbloodprogesteronelevelsinGreyhoundbitches.Theriogenology70,795–799.
***Cleary,G.P.,Corner,L.A.L.,O’Keeffe,J.,Marples,N.M.,2009.ThedietofthebadgerMeles melesintheRepublicofIreland.Mammalian Biology74,438-447.
Clegg,T.A.,More,S.J.,Higgins,I.M.,Good,M.,Blake,M.,Williams,D.H.,2008.Potentialinfection-controlbenefitforIrelandfrompre-movementtestingofcattlefortuberculosis.Preventive Veterinary Medicine84,94-111.
Collins,D.M.,deLisle,G.W.,Collins,J.D.,Costello,E.,1994.DNArestrictionfragmenttypingofMycobacterium bovisisolatesfromcattleandbadgersinIreland.Veterinary Record134,681-682.
Collins,J.,Hanlon,A.,More,S.J.,Duggan,V.,2008.ThestructureandregulationoftheIrishequineindustry:linkstoconsiderationofequinewelfare.Irish Veterinary Journal61,746-756.
Collins,J.,Hanlon,A.,More,S.J.,Wall,P.G.,Duggan,V.,2009.PolicyDelphiwithvignettemethodologyasatooltoevaluatetheperceptionofequinewelfare.The Veterinary Journal181,63-69.
Collins,J.D.,1999.Tuberculosisincattle:interpretationandapplicationoftuberculintestandpost-mortemdata. UK Vet5,40-44.
Collins,J.D.,1999.Tuberculosisincattle:reducingtheriskofherdexposure. UK Vet5,35-39.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 129
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prior to
20
10
Collins,J.D.,2001.Tuberculosisincattle:newperspectives.Tuberculosis81,17-21.
Collins,J.D.,2006.Tuberculosisincattle:strategicplanningforthefuture.Veterinary Microbiology112,369-381.
Collins,J.D.,Wall,P.G.,2004.Foodsafetyandanimalproductionsystems:controllingzoonosesatfarmlevel.Revue scientifique et technique / Office international des épizooties (OIE Scientific and Technical Review)23,685-700.
Connolly,D.J.,Dwyer,P.J.,Fagan,J.,Hayes,M.,Ryan,E.G.,Costello,E.,Kilroy,A.,More,S.J.,2008.Tuberculosisin alpaca (Lama pacos)inIreland.2.Resultsofanepidemiologicalinvestigation.Irish Veterinary Journal61,533-537.
Corner,L.A.,2006.Theroleofwildanimalpopulationsintheepidemiologyoftuberculosisindomesticanimals:howtoassesstherisk.Veterinary Microbiology112,303-312.
Corner,L.A.,Costello,E.,Lesellier,S.,O’Meara,D.,Gormley,E.,2008.ExperimentaltuberculosisintheEuropeanbadger (Meles meles) after endobronchial inoculation with Mycobacterium bovis:II.Progressionofinfection.Research in Veterinary Science85,481-490.
Corner,L.A.,Costello,E.,Lesellier,S.,O’Meara,D.,Gormley,E.,2008.VaccinationofEuropeanbadgers(Meles meles) withBCGbythesubcutaneousandmucosalroutesinducesprotectiveimmunityagainstendobronchialchallengewithMycobacterium bovis.Tuberculosis88,601-609.
Corner,L.A.,Costello,E.,Lesellier,S.,O’Meara,D.,Sleeman,D.P.,Gormley,E.,2007.ExperimentaltuberculosisintheEuropeanbadger(Meles meles) after endobronchial inoculation of Mycobacterium bovis:I.Pathologyandbacteriology.Research in Veterinary Science83,53-62.
Corner,L.A.,Pfeiffer,D.U.,Abbott,K.A.,2004.TherespiratorytractasahypotheticalrouteofinfectionofcattlewithMycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis.Australian Veterinary Journal82,170-173.
Corner,L.A.L.,Clegg,T.A.,More,S.J.,Williams,D.H.,O’Boyle,I.,Costello,E.,Sleeman,D.P.,Griffin,J.M.,2008.TheeffectofvaryinglevelsofpopulationcontrolontheprevalenceoftuberculosisinbadgersinIreland.Research in Veterinary Science85,238-249.
Corner,L.A.L.,Murphy,D.,Costello,E.,Gormley,E.,2009.TuberculosisinEuropeanbadgers(Meles meles) and the controlofinfectionwithBacilleCalmette-Guérinvaccination.Journal of Wildlife Diseases45,1042-1047.
*Costello,E.,Flynn,O.,Quigley,F.,O’Grady,D.,Griffin,J.,Clegg,T.,McGrath,G.,2006.GenotypingofMycobacterium bovisisolatesfrombadgersinfourareasoftheRepublicofIrelandbyrestrictionfragmentlengthpoly-morphismanalysis.Veterinary Record159,619-623.
*Costello,E.,O’Grady,D.,Flynn,O.,O’Brien,R.,Rogers,M.,Quigley,F.,Egan,J.,Griffin,J.,1999.Studyofrestric-tion fragment length polymorphism analysis and spoligotyping for epidemiological investigation of Mycobacterium bovis infection.Journal of Clinical Microbiology37,3217-3222.
*Costello,E.,O’Reilly,P.F.,Yearsley,D.K.,O’Grady,D.P.,O’Reilly,L.M.,Collins,J.D.,Monaghan,M.L.,Bassett,H.F.,1997.Astudyofanenzyme-linkedimmunosorbentassayforthediagnosisoftuberculosisincattle.Irish Veterinary Journal50,35-38.
*Costello,E.,Quigley,F.,Flynn,O.,Gogarthy,A.,McGuirk,J.,Murphy,A.,Dolan,L.,1998.Laboratoryexaminationofsuspectedtuberculouslesionsdetectedonabattoirpostmortemexaminationofcattlefromnon-reactorherds.Irish Veterinary Journal51,248-250.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011130
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prio
r to
20
10
Crowe,O.,Wilson,J.,Aznar,I.More,S.J.,2009.AreviewofIreland’swaterbirds,withemphasisonwinteringmigrantsandreferencetoH5N1avianinfluenza.Irish Veterinary Journal62,800-811.
Davison,K.E.,Hughes,L.J.,Gormley,E.,Lesellier,S.,Costello,E.,Corner,L.A.,2007.Evaluationoftheanaestheticeffectsofcombinationsofketamine,medetomidine,romifidineandbutorphanolinEuropeanbadgers(Meles meles).Veterinary Anaesthesia and Analgesia34,394-402.
Dolan,L.A.,Lynch,K.,1992.Badgersandbovinetuberculosis.Irish Veterinary Journal45,133-135.
Doran,P.,Carson,J.,Costello,E.,More,S.J.,2009.AnoutbreakoftuberculosisaffectingcattleandpeopleonanIrishdairyfarmin2005,followingtheconsumptionofrawmilkfromacowwithtuberculousmastitis.Irish Veterinary Journal62,390-397.
Downes,M.,Canty,M.J.,More,S.J.,2009.DemographyofthepetdogandcatpopulationontheislandofIrelandandhumanfactorsinfluencingpetownership.Preventive Veterinary Medicine92,140-149.
*Egan,J.,Leonard,N.,Griffin,J.,Hanlon,A.,Poole,D.,2001.Asurveyofsomefactorsrelevanttoanimalwelfareon249dairyfarmsintheRepublicofIreland/dataonhousing,calvingandcalfhusbandry.Irish Veterinary Journal54,388-392.
Eves,J.A.,1999.ImpactofbadgerremovalonbovinetuberculosisineastCountyOffaly.Irish Veterinary Journal 52, 199-203.
Fend,R.,Geddes,R.,Lesellier,S.,Vordermeier,H.M.,Corner,L.A.L.,Gormley,E.,Costello,E.,Hewinson,R.G.,Marlin,D.J.,Woodman,A.C.,Chambers,M.A.,2005.UseofanelectronicnosetodiagnoseMycobacterium bovis infec-tioninbadgersandcattle.Journal of Clinical Microbiology431745-1751.
Flanagan,P.A.,Kelly,G.,1996.Astudyoftuberculosisbreakdownsinherdsinwhichsomepurchasedanimalswereidentifiedasreactors.Irish Veterinary Journal49,704-706.
Frankena,K.,White,P.W.,O’Keeffe,J.,Costello,E.,Martin,S.W.,vanGrevenhof,I.,More,S.J.,2007.QuantificationoftherelativeefficiencyoffactorysurveillanceinthedisclosureoftuberculosislesionsinattestedIrishcattle.Veterinary Record161,679-684.
Good,M.,Clegg,T.,Sheridan,H.,Yearsely,D.,O’Brien,T.,Egan,J.,Mullowney,P.,2009.Prevalenceanddistribu-tionofparatuberculosis(Johne’sdisease)incattleherdsinIreland.Irish Veterinary Journal62,597-606.
Gormley,E.,2007.DiagnosisofMycobacterium bovisinfectionincattle.Bulletin of the International Dairy Federation 416,101-109.
Gormley,E.,Collins,J.D.,2000.ThedevelopmentofwildlifecontrolstrategiesforeradicationoftuberculosisincattleinIreland.Tubercle and Lung Disease80,229-236.
Gormley,E.,Corner,L.,2009.ControlofTBinwildlifebyoralBCGvaccination.Expert Review of Vaccines8,1339-1342.
Gormley,E.,Costello,E.,2003.Tuberculosisandbadgers:Newapproachestodiagnosisandcontrol.Journal of Applied Microbiology94,80-86.
Gormley,E.,Doyle,M.B.,Fitzsimons,T.,McGill,K.,Collins,J.D.,2006.Diagnosis of Mycobacterium bovis infection in cattlebyuseofthegamma-interferon(Bovigam®)assay.Veterinary Microbiology112,171-179.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 131
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prior to
20
10
Gormley,E.,Doyle,M.B.,McGill,K.,Costello,E.,Good,M.,Collins,J.D.,2004.Theeffectofthetuberculintestandtheconsequencesofadelayinbloodcultureonthesensitivityofagamma-interferonassayforthedetectionofMycobacterium bovisinfectionincattle.Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology102,413-420.
Grange,J.M.,Collins,J.D.,O’Reilly,L.M.,Costello,E.,Yates,M.D.,1990.IdentificationandcharacterisationofMycobacterium bovisisolatedfromcattle,badgersanddeerintheRepublicofIreland.Irish Veterinary Journal43,33-35.
Griffin,J.M.,Dolan,L.A.,1995.Theroleofcattle-to-cattletransmissionofMycobacterium bovis in the epidemiology of tuberculosisincattleintheRepublicofIreland:Areview.Irish Veterinary Journal48,228-234.
Griffin,J.M.,Hahesy,T.,Lynch,K.,Salman,M.D.,McCarthy,J.,Hurley,T.,1993.Theassociationofcattlehusbandry practices, environmental factors and farmer characteristics with the occurrence of chronic bovine tuberculosis indairyherdsintheRepublicofIreland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine17,145-160.
Griffin,J.M.,Martin,S.W.,Thorburn,M.A.,Eves,J.A.,Hammond,R.F.,1996.Acase-controlstudyontheassocia-tionofselectedriskfactorswiththeoccurrenceofbovinetuberculosisintheRepublicofIreland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine27,75-87and27,217-229.
Griffin,J.M.,More,S.J.,Clegg,T.A.,Collins,J.D.,O’Boyle,I.,Williams,D.H.,Kelly,G.E.,Costello,E.,Sleeman,D.P.,O’Shea,F.,Duggan,M.,Murphy,J.,Lavin,D.P.T.,2005.Tuberculosisincattle:theresultsofthefour-areaproject.Irish Veterinary Journal58,629-636.
Griffin,J.M.,Williams,D.H.,Kelly,G.E.,Clegg,T.A.,O’Boyle,I.,Collins,J.D.,More,S.J.,2005.TheimpactofbadgerremovalonthecontroloftuberculosisincattleherdsinIreland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine67,237-266.
Hammond,R.F.,McGrath,G.,Martin,S.W.,2001.Irishsoilandland-useclassificationsaspredictorsofnumbersofbadgersandbadgersetts.Preventive Veterinary Medicine51,137-148.
Hayes,M.,Ashe,S.,Collins,D.M.,Power,S.,Kenny,K.,Sheahan,M.,O’Hagan,G.,More,S.J.,2009.AnevaluationofIrishcattleherdswithinconclusiveserologicalevidenceofbovinebrucellosis.Irish Veterinary Journal62,182-190.
Healy,A.M.,Hanlon,A.J.,Weavers,E.,Collins,J.D.,Doherty,M.L.,2002.Abehaviouralstudyofscrapie-affectedsheep.Applied Animal Behaviour Science79,89-102.
Healy,A.M.,Hannon,D.,Morgan,K.L.,Weavers,E.,Collins,J.D.,Doherty,M.L.,2004.ApairedcasecontrolstudyofriskfactorsforscrapieinIrishsheepflocks.Preventive Veterinary Medicine64,73-83.
Healy,A.M.,Morgan,K.L.,Hannon,D.,Collins,J.D.,Weavers,E.,Doherty,M.L.,2004.PostalquestionnairesurveyofscrapieinsheepflocksinIreland.Veterinary Record155,493-494.
Healy,A.M.,Weavers,E.,McElroy,M.,Gomez-Parada,M.,Collins,J.D.,O’Doherty,E.,Sweeney,T.,Doherty,M.L.,2003.TheclinicalneurologyofscrapieinIrishsheep.Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine17,908-916.
Kelly,G.,Condon,J.,More,S.J.,Dolan,L.,Higgins,I.,Eves,J.,2008.AlongtermobservationalstudyoftheimpactofbadgerremovalonherdrestrictionsduetobovineTBintheIrishmidlandsduring1989–2004.Epidemiology and Infection136,1362-1373.
Kelly,P.T.,O’Sullivan,K.,Berry,D.P.,More,S.J.,Meaney,W.J.,O’Callaghan,E.J.,O’Brien,B.,2009.Farmmanage-mentfactorsassociatedwithbulktanktotalbacterialcountinIrishdairyherdsduring2006/07.Irish Veterinary Journal 62,36-42.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011132
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prio
r to
20
10
Kelly,P.T.,O’Sullivan,K.,Berry,D.P.,More,S.J.,Meaney,W.J.,O’Callaghan,E.J.,O’Brien,B.,2009.Farmmanage-mentfactorsassociatedwithbulktanksomaticcellcountinIrishdairyherds.Irish Veterinary Journal62Supplement,45-51.
Lane,E.A.,2008.Problembasedlearninginveterinaryeducation.Journal of Veterinary Medical Education35,631-636.
Lane,E.A.,Austin,E.J.,Crowe,M.A.,2008.Oestroussynchronisationincattle-currentoptionsfollowingtheEUregulationsrestrictinguseofoestrogeniccompoundsinfoodproducinganimals:areview.Animal Reproduction Science109,1-16.
Lane,E.A.,Sweeney,T.,Ryan,M.,Roche,J.F.,Crowe,M.A.,2009.RelationshipbetweenserumgonadotropinsandpituitaryimmunoreactivegonadotropinsandsteroidreceptorsduringthefirstFSHincreaseoftheestrouscycleandfollowingsteroidtreatmentinheifers.Animal Reproduction Science112,66–82.
Lee,B-Y.,Higgins,I.M.,Moon,O-K.,Clegg,T.A,McGrath,G.,Collins,D.M.,Park,J-Y.,Yoon,H-C.,Lee,S-J.,More,S.J.,2009.SurveillanceandcontrolofbovinebrucellosisintheRepublicofKoreaduring2000to2006.Preventive Veterinary Medicine90,66-79.
*Leonard,N.,Egan.J.,Griffin,J.,Hanlon,A.,Poole,D.,2001.Asurveyofsomefactorsrelevanttoanimalwelfareon249dairyfarmsintheRepublicofIrelandPart2:Dataonincidenceofdisease,cullingandbiosecuritymeasures.Irish Veterinary Journal54,454-456.
Lesellier,S.,Corner,L.,Costello,E.,Lyashchenko,K.,Greenwald,R.,Esfandiari,J.,Singh,M.,Hewinson,R.G.,Chambers,M.,Gormley,E.,2009.ImmunologicalresponsesandprotectiveimmunityinBCGvaccinatedbadgersfollowing endobronchial infection with Mycobacterium bovis.Vaccine27,402-409.
Lesellier,S.,Corner,L.,Costello,E.,Sleeman,P.,Lyashchenko,K.,Greenwald,R.,Esfandiari,J.,Singh,M.,Hewinson,R.G.,Chambers,M.,Gormley,E.,2008.Antigenspecificimmunologicalresponsesofbadgers(Meles meles) experimen-tallyinfectedwithMycobacteriumbovis.Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology122,35-45.
Lesellier,S.,Corner,L.,Costello,E.,Sleeman,P.,Lyashchenko,K.P.,Greenwald,R.,Esfandiari,J.,HewinsonR.G.,Chambers,M.,Gormley,E.,2009.Immunologicalresponsesfollowingexperimentalendobronchialinfectionofbadgers(Meles meles) with different doses of Mycobacterium bovis.Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology127,174-180.
MacHugh,D.E.,Gormley,E.,Park,S.D.E,Browne,J.A.,Taraktsoglou,M.,O’Farrelly,C.,Meade,K.G.,2009.Geneexpression profiling of the host response to Mycobacterium bovisinfectionincattle.Transboundary and Emerging Diseases 56,204-214.
Maher,P.,Good,M.,More,S.J.,2008.Trendsinthenumberof,andrateatwhich,cowsareculledfromtheIrishcattlepopulation,2003to2006.Irish Veterinary Journal61,455-463.
Martin,C.,Williams,A.,Hernandez-Pando,R.,Cardona,P.J.,Gormley,E.,Bordat,Y.,Soto,C.Y.,Clark,S.O.,Hatch,G.J.,Aguilar,D.,Ausina,V.,Gicquel,B.,2006.TheliveMycobacterium tuberculosis phoP mutant strain is more attenu-atedthanBCGandconfersprotectiveimmunityagainsttuberculosisinmiceandguineapigs.Vaccine24,3408-3419.
Martin,S.W.,Eves,J.A.,Dolan,L.A.,Hammond,R.F.,Griffin,J.M.,Collins,J.D.,Shoukri,M.M.,1997.Theasso-ciationbetweenthebovinetuberculosisstatusofherdsintheEastOffalyProjectArea,andthedistancetobadgersetts,1988-1993.Preventive Veterinary Medicine31,113-125.
McCarthy,G.,Shiel,R.,O’Rourke,L.,Murphy,D.,Corner,L.,Costello,E.,Gormley,E.,2009.Bronchoalveolarlavagecytologyfromcaptivebadgers.VeterinaryClinicalPathology38,381-387.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 133
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prior to
20
10
McGrath,G.,Abernethy,D.A.,Stringer,L.,More,S.J.,2009.Anall-islandapproachtomappingbovinetuberculosisinIreland.Irish Veterinary Journal62,192-197.
Meade,K.G.,Gormley,E.,Doyle,M.B.,Fitzsimons,T.,O’Farrelly,C.,Costello,E.,Keane,J.,Zhao,Y.,MacHugh,D.E.,2007.InnategenerepressionassociatedwithMycobacterium bovis infection in cattle: toward a gene signature of disease.BMC Genomics8,400.
Meade,K.G.,Gormley,E.,O’Farrelly,C.,Park,S.D.,Costello,E.,Keane,J.,Zhao,Y.,MacHugh,D.E.,2008.Antigenstimulation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells from Mycobacterium bovis infected cattle yields evidence for a novel geneexpressionprogram.BMC Genomics9,447.
Meade,K.G.,Gormley,E.,Park,S.D.E.,Fitzsimons,T.,Rosa,G.J.M.,Costello,E.,Keane,J.,Coussens,P.M.,MacHugh,D.E.,2006.Geneexpressionprofilingofperipheralbloodmononuclearcells(PBMC)fromMycobacterium bovis infected cattle after in vitroantigenicstimulationwithpurifiedproteinderivativeoftuberculin(PPD). Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology113,73-89.
Monaghan,M.L.,Doherty,M.L.,Collins,J.D.,Kazda,J.F.,Quinn,P.J.,1994.Thetuberculintest.Veterinary Microbiology40,111-124.
Monaghan,M.L.,Quinn,P.J.,Kelly,A.P.,McGill,K.,McMurray,C.,O’Crowley,K.,Bassett,H.F.,Costello,E.,Quigley,F.,Rothel,J.S.,Wood,P.R.,Collins,J.D.,1997.Apilottrialtoevaluatethegamma-interferonassayforthedetection of Mycobacterium bovisinfectedcattleunderIrishconditions.Irish Veterinary Journal50,229-232.
More,S.J.,2007.ProgressinIrelandtowardstheeradicationofbovinetuberculosis.UK Vet Livestock12,60-63.
More,S.J.,2007.Shapingourfuture:animalhealthinaglobaltradingenvironment. Irish Veterinary Journal60,540-545.
More,S.J.,2008.AcaseforincreasedprivatesectorinvolvementinIreland’snationalanimalhealthservices. Irish Veterinary Journal61,92-100.
More,S.J.,2009.Globaltrendsinmilkquality:implicationsfortheIrishdairyindustry. Irish Veterinary Journal62Supplement,5-14.
More,S.J.,2009.Whatisneededtoeradicatebovinetuberculosissuccessfully:anIrishperspective. The Veterinary Journal180,275-278.
More,S.J.,Aznar,I.,Bailey,D.C.,Larkin,J.F.,Leadon,D.P.,Lenihan,P.,Flaherty,B.,Fogarty,U.,Brangan,P.,2008.Anoutbreakofequineinfectiousanaemia(EIA)inIrelandduring2006:theinvestigationmethodology,theinitialsourceofinfection,diagnosisandclinicalpresentation,themodesoftransmissionandspreadintheMeathcluster.Equine Veterinary Journal40,706-708.
More,S.J.,Aznar,I.,Myers,T.,Leadon,D.P.,Clegg,T.A.,2008.Anoutbreakofequineinfectiousanaemia(EIA)inIrelandduring2006:themodesoftransmissionandspreadintheKildarecluster. Equine Veterinary Journal40,709-711.
More,S.J.,Cameron,A.R.,Greiner,M.,Clifton-Hadley,R.S.,CorreiaRodeia,S.,Bakker,D.,Salman,M.D.,Sharp,J.M.,DeMassis,F.,Aranaz,A.,Boniotti,M.B.,Gaffuri,A.,Have,P.,Verloo,D.,Woodfood,M.,Weirup,M.,2009.Definingoutput-basedstandardstoachieveandmaintainTBfreedominfarmeddeer,withreferencetoEUmemberstates.Preventive Veterinary Medicine90,254-267.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011134
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prio
r to
20
10
More,S.J.,Clegg,T.A.,McGrath,G.,Collins,J.D.,Corner,L.A.L.,Gormley,E.,2007.Doesreactivebadgercullingleadtoanincreaseintuberculosisincattle?Veterinary Record161,208-209.
More,S.J.,Collins,J.D.,Good,M.,Skuce,R.A.,Pollock,J.M.,Gormley,E.,2006.Preface,editorial. Veterinary Microbiology112,89-89.
More,S.J.,Collins,J.D.,Gormley,E.,Good,M.,Skuce,R.A.,Pollock,J.M.,2006.4thInternationalConferenceonMycobacterium bovis:workshopreports.Veterinary Microbiology112,383-391.
More,S.J.,Good,M.,2006.ThetuberculosiseradicationprogrammeinIreland:areviewofscientificandpolicyadvancessince1988.Veterinary Microbiology112,239-51.
Murphy,D.,Corner,L.A.L.,Gormley,E.,2008.AdversereactionstoMycobacterium bovisBacilleCalmette-Guérin(BCG)vaccinationagainsttuberculosisinhumans,veterinaryanimalsandwildlifespecies. Tuberculosis88,344-357.
Murphy,D.,O’Keeffe,J.,Martin,S.W.,Gormley,E.,Corner,L.A.L.,2009.AnassessmentofinjurytoEuropeanbadgers (Meles meles)duetocaptureinstoppedrestraints.Journal of Wildlife Diseases45,481-490.
*Murphy,T.M.,Fahy,K.N.,McAuliffe,A.,Forbes,A.B.,Clegg,T.A.,O’Brien,D.J.,2006.Astudyofhelminthpara-sitesinculledcowsfromIreland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine76,1-10.
Nash,D.,Lane,E.A.,Herath,S.,Sheldon,I.M.,2008.Endometrialexplantcultureforcharacterizingequineendometritis.American Journal of Reproductive Immunology59,105–117.
ÓMáirtín,D.,Williams,D.H.,Dolan,L.,Eves,J.A.,Collins,J.D.,1998.Theinfluenceofselectedherdfactorsandabadger-interventiontuberculosis-controlprogrammeontheriskofaherd-leveltraderestrictiontoabovinepopulationinIreland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine35,79-90.
ÓMáirtín,D.,Williams,D.H.,Griffin,J.M.,Dolan,L.A.,Eves,J.A.,1998.TheeffectofabadgerremovalprogrammeontheincidenceoftuberculosisinanIrishcattlepopulation.Preventive Veterinary Medicine34,47-56.
O’Connor,J.,More,S.J.,Griffin,J.M.,O’Leary,E.,2009.ModellingthedemographicsoftheIrishcattlepopulation.Preventive Veterinary Medicine89,249-254.
O’Grady,L.,O’Neill,R.,Collins,D.M.,Clegg,T.A.,More,S.J.,2008.Herdandwithin-herdIBRprevalenceamongIrishherdssubmittingbullsforentrytoabullperformancetestingstation.Irish Veterinary Journal61,809-815.
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,Butler,D.,Lavin,D.,McGrath,G.,O’Keeffe,J.,Kelton,D.,Berke,O.,More,S.,Martin,S.,2006.AcasestudyofbovinetuberculosisinanareaofCountyDonegal,Ireland. Irish Veterinary Journal59,683-690.
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,CostelloE.,WhiteP.,McGrathG.,CollinsJ.D.,O’KeeffeJ.,KeltonD.F.,BerkeO.,MoreS.J.,MartinS.W.,2008.Riskfactorsfordisclosureofadditionaltuberculouscattleinattested-clearherdsthathadananimalwithaconfirmedlesionoftuberculosisatslaughterduring2003inIreland. Preventive Veterinary Medicine85,81-91.
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,Fitzgerald,P.White,P.,McGrath,G.,Collins,J.D.,O’Keeffe,J.,Kelton,D.F.,Berke,O.,More,S.J.,Martin,S.W.,2009.TargetedbadgerremovalandthesubsequentriskofbovinetuberculosisincattleherdsincountyLaois,Ireland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine88,178-184.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 135
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prior to
20
10
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,Flynn,O.,Costello,E.,McGrath,G.,Collins,J.D.,O’Keeffe,J.,Kelton,D.F.,Berke,O.,Martin,S.W.,2005.SpatialrelationshipbetweenMycobacterium bovisstrainsincattleandbadgersinfourareasinIreland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine71,57-70.
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,Griffin,J.M.,Collins,J.D.,McGrath,G.,Martin,S.W.,2003.BovinetuberculosisinbadgersinfourareasinIreland:doestuberculosiscluster?Preventive Veterinary Medicine59,103-111.
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,Phelan,J.,White,P.W.,McGrath,G.,Collins,J.D.,O’Keeffe,J.,Duggan,M.,Collins,D.M.,Kelton,D.F.,Berke,O.,More,S.J.,Martin,S.W.,2006.QuantifyingbadgerexposureandtheriskofbovinetuberculosisforcattleherdsinCountyKilkenny,Ireland. Preventive Veterinary Medicine75,34-36.
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,White,P.W.,Collins,J.D.,O’Keeffe,J.,Kelton,D.F.,Martin,S.W.,2004.BreakdownseverityduringabovinetuberculosisepisodeasapredictoroffutureherdbreakdownsinIreland. Preventive Veterinary Medicine63,163-172.
Partridge,T.,Toolan,D.P.,Egan,J.,More,S.J.,2008.ControlofMycobacterium bovisinfectionintwosikadeerherdsinIreland.Irish Veterinary Journal61,27-32.
Pawitan,Y.,Griffin,J.M.,Collins,J.D.,2004.AnalysisandpredictionoftheBSEincidenceinIreland. Preventive Veterinary Medicine62,267-283.
Richardson,E.,Good,M.,McGrath,G.,More,S.J.,2009.TheuseofGeographicInformationSystem(GIS)andnon-GISmethodstoassesstheexternalvalidityofsamplespost-collection. Journal of Veterinary Diagnostic Investigation21,633-640.
Richardson,E.K.B.,Mee,J.F.,Sanchez,C.,Crilly,J.,More,S.J.,2009.DemographicsofanimalspositivetoMycobacteria avium subspecies paratuberculosisonfaecalculture,basedonlaboratorysubmissionstotheCorkRegionalVeterinaryLaboratoryduring1989to2006.Irish Veterinary Journal62,398-405.
Richardson,E.K.B.,More,S.J.,2009.DirectandindirecteffectsofJohne’sdiseaseonfarmandanimalproductivityinanIrishdairyherd.Irish Veterinary Journal62,526-532.
Ryan,E.G.,Dwyer,P.J.,Connolly,D.J.,Fagan,J.,Costello,E.,More,S.J.,2008.Tuberculosisinalpaca(Lama pacos) inIreland.1.Aclinicalreport.Irish Veterinary Journal61,527-531.
Sheridan,H.A.,McGrath,G.,White,P.,Fallon,R.,Shoukri,M.M.,Martin,S.W.,2005.Atemporal-spatialanalysisofbovinespongiformencephalopathyinIrishcattleherds,from1996to2000. Canadian Journal of Veterinary Research69,19-25.
**Sleeman,D.P.Davenport,J.,More,S.J.,Clegg,T.A.,Collins,J.D.,Martin,S.W.,Williams,D.H.,Griffin,J.M.,O’Boyle,I.,2009.HowmanyEurasianbadgersMeles meles L.arethereinIreland? European Journal of Wildlife Research55,333-344.
**Sleeman,D.P.,Davenport,J.,Cussen,R.,Hammond,R.F.,2009.Thesmall-bodiedbadgers(Meles meles (L.)) of RutlandIsland,Co.Donegal.Irish Naturalists’ Journal30,1-6.
**Sleeman,D.P.,Davenport,J.,Fitzgerald,A.,2008.IncidenceofvisitsbybadgerstofarmyardsinIrelandinwinter.Veterinary Record163,724&Sleeman,D.P.,Davenport,J.,Fitzgerald,A.,2009.Letterresponse. Veterinary Record164,668.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011136
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prio
r to
20
10
**Sleeman,D.P.,Davenport,J.,More,S.J.,Clegg,T.A.,Griffin,J.M.,O’Boyle,I.,2009.Theeffectivenessofbarrierstobadger Meles melesimmigrationintheIrishFourAreaproject.European Journal of Wildlife Research55,267-278.
Southey,A.K.,Sleeman,D.P.,Gormley,E.,2002.SulfadimethoxineandrhodamineBasoralbiomarkersforEuropeanbadgers (Meles meles).Journal of Wildlife Diseases38,378-384.
Southey,A.,Costello,E.,Gormley,E.,2002.DetectionofMycobacterium bovis infection and production of inter-leukin-2byin vitrostimulationofbadgerlymphocytes.Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology87,73-78.
Southey,A.,Sleeman,D.P.S.,Dalley,D.,Lloyd,K.,Chambers,M.,Hewinson,R.G.,Gormley,E.,2001.ImmunologicalresponsesofEurasianbadgers(Meles meles) vaccinated with Mycobacterium bovisBCG(BacilleCalmette-Guérin).Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology79,197-207.
Southey,A.K.,Sleeman,D.P.,Prendergast,J.,O’Sullivan,R.F.Mulcahy,M.F.,2001.Useofbiomarkerstoassessthefeasibility of delivering a vaccine to badgers (Meles meles).Journal of Zoology253,133-139.
Wee,S-H.,Nam,H-M.,Moon,O-K.Yoon,H.,Park,J.Y.,More,S.J.,2008.Usingfield-basedepidemiologicalmethodstoinvestigateFMDoutbreaks:anexamplefromthe2002outbreakinKorea.Transboundary and Emerging Diseases55,404-410.
Wee,S-H.,Yoon,H.,More,S.J.,Nam,H-M.,Moon,O-K.,Jung,J-M.,Kim,S-J.,Kim,C-H.,Lee,E-S.,Hwang,I-J.,2008.Epidemiologicalcharacteristicsofthe2002outbreaksoffoot-and-mouthdiseaseintheRepublicofKorea.Transboundary and Emerging Diseases55,360-368.
Whyte,P.,McGill,K.,Collins,J.D.,Gormley,E.,2002.TheprevalenceandPCRdetectionofSalmonellacontamina-tioninrawpoultry.Veterinary Microbiology89,53-60.
Williams,E.J.,Sibley,K.,Miller,A.N.,Lane,E.A.,Fishwick,J.,NashD.M.,Herath,S.,England,G.C.W.,Dobson,H.,Sheldon,I.M.,2008.TheeffectofEscherichia coli lipopolysaccharide and tumour necrosis factor alpha on ovarian func-tion.American Journal of Reproductive Immunology60,462–473.
Wolfe,D.M,Berke,O.,More,S.J,Kelton,D.F,White,P.W.,O’Keeffe,J.J.,Martin,S.W.,2009.Theriskofapositivetest for bovine tuberculosis in cattle purchased from herds with and without a recent history of bovine tuberculosis in Ireland.Preventive Veterinary Medicine92,99-105.
Young,J.S.,Gormley,E.,Wellington,E.M.H.,2005.MoleculardetectionofMycobacterium bovis and Mycobacterium bovisBCG(Pasteur)insoil.Applied and Environmental Microbiology71,1946-1952.
# CVERA Board of management
* DAFM Veterinary Laboratory Service
** UCC School of Biological, Earth & Environmental Sciences
*** School of Natural Sciences, Trinity College Dublin
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 137
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prior to
20
10
Books/book chapters
Buncic,S.,Collins,J.D.,Smulders,F.J.M.andColin,P.,2009.Biologicalfoodsafetyinrelationtoanimalwelfare.In Food Safety Assurance and Veterinary Public Health. Volume 5: Welfare of Production Animals: Assessment and Management of Risks,485-532.F.J.M.Smulders,B.Algers(eds).WageningenAcademicPublishers,TheNetherlands.
Quinn,P.J.,Collins,J.D.,2006.TheeffectofwildlifereservoirsofMycobacterium bovis on programmes for the eradica-tionoftuberculosisincattleinIreland.In Mycobacterium bovis Infection in Animals and Humans,124-135,2ndEd.,C.O.Thoen,J.H.Steele,M.J.Gilsdorf(eds),BlackwellPress,London.
Scientific opinions
(J.D. Collins [UCD CVERA] and J.M. Griffin [DAFM] with other members of the Scientific Panel on Biological Hazards (BIOHAZ) and S.J. More [UCD CVERA] with other members of the Panel on Animal Health and Welfare (AHAW) of the European Food Safety Authority [EFSA])
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2008.Scientificopinionontuberculosistestingindeer.EFSA Journal645,1-34.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2009.Scientificopiniononguidanceongoodpracticeinconductingscientificassessmentsinanimalhealthusingmodelling.EFSA Journal7,1419.
EFSAPanelonAnimalHealthandWelfare(AHAW),2009.ScientificopiniononEpizooticHemorrhagicDisease.EFSA Journal7,1418.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2006.ScientificopiniononthebreedingprogrammeforTSEresistanceinsheep.EFSA Journal382,1-46.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2003.Opinionontuberculosisinbovineanimals:risksforhumanhealthandcontrolstrategies.EFSA Journal13,1-52.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2003.ScientificopinionontheinterpretationofresultsofEUsurveil-lanceoftransmissiblespongiformencephalopathies(TSEs)inovineandcaprineanimals,cullingstrategiesforTSEsinsmallruminantsandtheTSE-relatedsafetyofcertainsmallruminantproducts.EFSA Journal12,1-6.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2004.ScientificopiniononBSE-relatedcullingincattle.EFSA Journal57,1-8.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2004.ScientificopiniononthescientificjustificationforproposingamendmentstotheUnitedKingdomDateBasedExportScheme(DBES)andtotheOverThirtyMonths(OTM)rule.EFSA Journal56,1-4.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2004.ScientificopinionontheapplicationoftheUnitedKingdomformoderateriskBSEstatus.EFSA Journal55,1-3.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2005.ScientificopiniononthequantitativeriskassessmentoftheanimalBSEriskposedbymeatandbonemealwithrespecttotheresidualBSErisk.EFSA Journal257,1-30.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2005.ScientificopiniononaquantitativeassessmentofriskposedtohumansbytissuesofsmallruminantsincaseBSEispresentintheseanimalpopulations.EFSA Journal227,1-11.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011138
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prio
r to
20
10
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2005.ScientificopinionontheassessmentoftheagelimitincattlefortheremovalofcertainSpecifiedRiskMaterials(SRM).EFSA Journal220,1-7.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2006.ScientificopiniononthequantitativeassessmentofthehumanBSEriskposedbybovinevertebralcolumnincludingdorsalrootgangliawithrespecttoresidualBSErisk.EFSA Journal359,1-14.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2006.ScientificopiniononanassessmentofthepublicandanimalhealthrisksassociatedwiththeadoptionofavisualinspectionsysteminvealcalvesraisedinaMemberState(orpartofaMemberState)consideredfreeoftuberculosis.EFSA Journal358,1-15.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2006.ScientificopiniononthequantitativeassessmentofthehumanBSEriskposedbygelatinewithrespecttoresidualBSErisk.EFSA Journal312,1-29.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2007.Scientificopiniononcertainaspectsrelatedtothefeedingofanimalproteinstofarmanimals.EFSA Journal576,1-41.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2007.Scientificopinionontheassessmentofthelikelihoodoftheinfec-tivityinSRMderivedfromcattleatdifferentagegroupsestimatedbybackcalculationmodelling. EFSA Journal476,1-47.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2007.ScientificopiniononcertainaspectsrelatedtotheriskofTransmissibleSpongiformEncephalopathies(TSEs)inovineandcaprineanimals.EFSA Journal 466,1-10.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2007.ScientificopinionontherevisionoftheGeographicalBSERisk.EFSA Journal463,1-35.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2007.ScientificopiniononthequantitativeriskassessmentontheresidualBSEriskinsheepmeatandmeatproducts.EFSA Journal442,1-44.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2008.Scientificopiniononaquantitativemicrobiologicalriskassess-mentonSalmonellainmeat:sourceattributionforhumansalmonellosisfrommeat.EFSA Journal625,1-32.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2008.Scientificopiniononconsumptionofbeeftongue:humanBSEriskassociatedwithexposuretolymphoidtissueinbovinetongueinconsiderationofnewresearchfindings. EFSA Journal700,1-24.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2008.ScientificopiniononaTSEriskassessmentfromcarcassesofovineandcaprineanimalsbelow6monthsofagefromTSEinfectedflocksintendedforhumanconsumption. EFSA Journal719,1-27.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2008.Scientificopiniononmicrobiologicalriskassessmentinfeedingstuffsforfoodproducinganimals.EFSA Journal720,1-84.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2008.ScientificopinionontheriskforhumanandanimalhealthrelatedtotherevisionoftheBSEmonitoringregimeinsomeMemberStates. EFSA Journal762,1-47.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2008.Scientificopiniononfoodborneantimicrobialresistanceasabiologicalhazard.EFSA Journal765,1-87.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011 139
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prior to
20
10
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2008.ScientificopiniononthehumanandanimalexposureriskrelatedtoTransmissibleSpongiformEncephalopathies(TSEs)frommilkandmilkproductsderivedfromsmallruminants.EFSA Journal849,1-37.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2009.Scientificopiniononassessmentofthepublichealthsignificanceof meticillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus(MRSA)inanimalsandfoods.EFSA Journal993,1-73.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2009.ScientificopinionongeneticTSEresistanceingoats.EFSA Journal995,1-25.
EFSAPanelonBiologicalHazards(BIOHAZ),2009.ScientificopinionontheupdatedriskforhumanandanimalhealthrelatedtotherevisionoftheBSEmonitoringregimeinsomeMemberStates.EFSA Journal1059,1-40.
Academic theses
Barrett,D.J.,2004.AstudyofmastitisinIrishdairyherds.MVMthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Costello,E.,1994.AstudyofantibodyELISAmethodsforthediagnosisoftuberculosisincattle.MVMthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Doherty,M.L.,1994.Studiesondiagnostictestsfortuberculosisincattle.PhDthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Eves,J.,2001.Acase-controlstudyontheincidenceofbovinetuberculosisinanareaofextensivebadgercullinginCountyOffaly,Ireland.MVMthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Griffin,J.M.,1994.Acase-controlstudyontheassociationofselectedriskfactorswiththeoccurrenceofbovinetubercu-losisintheRepublicofIreland.MScthesis,UniversityofGuelph,Canada.
Griffin,J.M.,2003.AsimulationmodelfortuberculosisincattleinIreland.PhDthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Hahesy,T.,1995.StudiesonaerosoldispersalofamarkerorganismincattleslurryandchemicalinactivationofM. bovisinslurry.MScthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Lesellier,S.,2007.ImmunologicalresponsesofEuropeanbadgers(Meles meles)vaccinatedwithBCGand/orexperimen-tally challenged with Mycobacterium bovis.PhDthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
McGrath,G.,2001.AnevaluationoftheroleofGeographicalInformationSystemtechnologyforthepredictionofbadgersettlocationinIreland.MScthesis,TrinityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Murphy,D.,2009.TuberculosisinEuropeanbadgers(Meles meles):prevalence,pathogenesisandvaccinedevelopment.PhDthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
O’Corry-Crowe,G.,1992.Thesocialandgeneticstructureofabadger(Meles meles, L.,1758)populationincentralIreland.PhDthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,2002.StudiesonbovinetuberculosisincattleandbadgersinIreland.MScthesis,UniversityofGuelph,Canada.
Biennial Report, 2010/2011140
PU
Bl
ICA
TIO
NS
Prio
r to
20
10
Olea-Popelka,F.J.,2007.TheidentificationoffactorsrelevanttothecontrolofbovineandbadgertuberculosisinIreland.PhDthesis,UniversityofGuelph,Canada.
O’Leary,S.,2005.Moleculardetectionandcharacterisationofbrucellosisinbovines.PhDthesis,UniversityCollegeDublin,Ireland.
Sheridan,H.,2001.AspatialtemporalanalysisofBSEinIreland.MScthesis,UniversityofGuelph,Canada.
Wolfe,D.M.,2007.Studiesonbovinetuberculosis(Mycobacterium bovis)incattleinIreland.MScthesis,UniversityofGuelph,Canada.
UCD School of Veterinary MedicineUCD Veterinary Sciences Centre
University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, Ireland
ISBN: 978-1-905254-64-4
Designed by JD Design, www.jddesign.ie Printed by Copi-Print, Library Building, UCD