+ All Categories
Home > Documents > The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the...

The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the...

Date post: 31-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
22
1 The contexts and causes of suicide among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people Professor Pat Dudgeon and Chris Holland 1. Introduction Within a week of the November 2016 launch of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Suicide Prevention Evaluation Project’s (ATSISPEP) Solutions That Work report, the Western Australian Parliamentary Education and Health Standing Committee released its Learnings From the Message Stick report on Aboriginal youth suicide in WA remote areas. 1 The WA report contained a chapter titled Aboriginal Suicide Is Different, a reference to the title of the 1999 Tatz study on Aboriginal youth suicide. 2 The bookending of almost two decades of investigation by reports that emphasise the difference in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander suicide compared to other suicides was significant. That there are differences is important to recognise. Most obvious are: The differences in methods. A 2016 analysis of 102 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander suicides in the Kimberley between 2005 and 2014 found that hanging (asphyxiation by ligature, not usually involving the breaking of the neck) was the method used in 93 per cent of cases. 3 A 2011 study of 478 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander suicides and a comparator 8425 non-Indigenous suicides in Queensland over 1994 and 2006, including by analysis of coronial inquest reports and ‘psychological autopsies’ 4 (hereon ‘2011 Queensland study’) is a particularly useful source of data about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander suicide and will be referred to again in this paper. This reported hanging to be the method in around 90 per cent of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cases, far higher than in the non-Indigenous population where, nonetheless, hanging was the most used method of suicide (about 40 per cent of cases). 5 There was also significant contrast to the much greater variety methods of suicide observed in the non-Indigenous group. 6 Suicide is a behaviour or action, not a distinct psychiatric disorder. Like any behaviour, it results from the interaction of many different personal, historical, and contextual factors. Suicide may be associated with a wide range of personal and social problems, and have many different contributing causes in any individual instance. In fact, suicide is only one index of the health and wellbeing of a population, and it is important to view suicide in the larger context of psychological and social health, and wellbeing. Suicide is never the result of a single cause, but arises from a complex web of interacting personal and social circumstances. Excerpt from the Executive Summary of: Kirmayer L, Brass G, Holton T, et al. (2007). Suicide Among Aboriginal People in Canada, Aboriginal Healing Foundation, Canada.
Transcript
Page 1: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

1

ThecontextsandcausesofsuicideamongAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleProfessorPatDudgeonandChrisHolland

1. IntroductionWithinaweekoftheNovember2016launchoftheAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSuicidePreventionEvaluationProject’s(ATSISPEP)SolutionsThatWorkreport,theWesternAustralianParliamentaryEducationandHealthStandingCommitteereleaseditsLearningsFromtheMessageStickreportonAboriginalyouthsuicideinWAremoteareas.1

TheWAreportcontainedachaptertitledAboriginalSuicideIsDifferent,areferencetothetitleofthe1999TatzstudyonAboriginalyouthsuicide.2ThebookendingofalmosttwodecadesofinvestigationbyreportsthatemphasisethedifferenceinAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidecomparedtoothersuicideswassignificant.

Thattherearedifferencesisimportanttorecognise.Mostobviousare:

• Thedifferencesinmethods.A2016analysisof102AboriginalandTorresStraitIslander

suicidesintheKimberleybetween2005and2014foundthathanging(asphyxiationbyligature,notusuallyinvolvingthebreakingoftheneck)wasthemethodusedin93percentofcases.3

A2011studyof478AboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidesandacomparator8425non-IndigenoussuicidesinQueenslandover1994and2006,includingbyanalysisofcoronialinquestreportsand‘psychologicalautopsies’4(hereon‘2011Queenslandstudy’)isaparticularlyusefulsourceofdataaboutAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicideandwillbereferredtoagaininthispaper.Thisreportedhangingtobethemethodinaround90percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercases,farhigherthaninthenon-Indigenouspopulationwhere,nonetheless,hangingwasthemostusedmethodofsuicide(about40percentofcases).5Therewasalsosignificantcontrasttothemuchgreatervarietymethodsofsuicideobservedinthenon-Indigenousgroup.6

Suicideisabehaviouroraction,notadistinctpsychiatricdisorder.Likeanybehaviour,itresultsfromtheinteractionofmanydifferentpersonal,historical,andcontextualfactors.Suicidemaybe

associatedwithawiderangeofpersonalandsocialproblems,andhavemanydifferentcontributingcausesinanyindividualinstance.Infact,suicideisonlyoneindexofthehealthandwellbeingofa

population,anditisimportanttoviewsuicideinthelargercontextofpsychologicalandsocialhealth,andwellbeing.Suicideisnevertheresultofasinglecause,butarisesfromacomplexwebof

interactingpersonalandsocialcircumstances.

ExcerptfromtheExecutiveSummaryof:KirmayerL,BrassG,HoltonT,etal.(2007).SuicideAmongAboriginalPeopleinCanada,AboriginalHealingFoundation,Canada.

Page 2: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

2

• ThedifferenceandrapidincreaseintheratesofsuicidereportedbetweentheAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderandnon-Indigenouspopulation.Amongtheformer,suicideisarelativelyrecentphenomenonwithfewprecedentspriortothe1960s.7Yetfiftyyearslater,theAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuiciderateistwicethatofnon-Indigenouspeople.8

• Thedifferencesinagegroupswhoareattemptingandcompletingsuicides.Suicideisa

majorpublichealthconcerninboththeAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderandnon-Indigenouspopulations. Overallin2015,suicidewastheleadingcauseofdeathamongallpeople15-44yearsofage,andthesecondleadingcauseofdeathamongthose45-54yearsofage.9 ButthepeakageofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicideis30-34yearsformalesand20-24yearsforfemales;10 andthisisthreetimestheratefornon-Indigenouspeopleofthesameages.11Incontrast,thehighestproportionofsuicidedeathsofnon-Indigenousmalesoccursamongthose40-44yearsofage,whileforfemalesitisthe45-49yearagegroup.12

Further,whenconsideringthesuicidedeathsofallAustraliansunder18years,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleaccountedfor30percentofdeathsover2007-2011despitecomprisingonlythreetofourpercentofthetotalagegrouppopulation.13AboriginalandTorresStraitIslander15-24yearoldsareoverfivetimesaslikelytosuicideastheirnon-Indigenouspeers.14

However, the focuses of this paper are, first, the underlying historical, culturalpolitical,socialandeconomiccontextofthesituationofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleincontemporaryAustraliathatcontributetomanyoftheabovedifferences.Thesemanifestmostobviouslyatthecommunitylevel.ThesecondfocusisthecausesoreventsassociatedwiththesuicideofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderindividuals.Inrelationtothesefactors,muchoftheliteratureonsuicideinthegeneralpopulationisrelevanttotheexperienceofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples.Butaswillbediscussed,theunderlyinghistorical,culturalpolitical,socialandeconomiccontextisnot,inpractice,separablefromthesecausesoreventsandthatcontributetotheotherpatternsofdifferencediscussedabove.

ThispapercomprisesfouroverlappingpartsthatconsiderthefollowingcontextualandcausalfactorsthatcontributetosuicideamongAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples:

• Part1considersthehistoryofcolonisationandthesubsequentinteractionsofAboriginal

andTorresStraitIslanderpeopleswiththesocialandpoliticalinstitutionsofAustraliansocietythathavenegativelyimpactedonAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercommunitylifeand,inturn,keypopulation-levelprotectivefactorsagainstsuicide.

• Part2,relatedtotheabove,considersthespecificriskfactorsthatariseinimpacted

communitieswithspecificrisksattheindividuallevel–thisincludesalcoholanddruguse,impulsivityandchildneglectandabuse.

Page 3: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

3

• InPart3,thecumulativeimpactofstressorsisconsidered,andalsotheevidencefortheimpactofspecificstressors:familyandrelationshipbreakdown,acriminalhistory/pendinglegalmattersandunemployment.

• Part4looksatmentalhealthandtheaccessibilityoftheAustralianmentalhealthand

suicidepreventionservicestoAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleatriskofsuicide.

Fromthestarthowever,itshouldbeunderstoodthatthispaper’sfour-partstructureisanartificialconstruct,designedtoteaseoutthecomplexandinter-connectedcontextsandcausesofsuicideforanalysis.Inpractice,allorsomeinvariouscombinationsandwithvaryingemphasismightcontributetothesuicideofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderindividual.

Part1–ColonisationandCommunity

Thebroadcontextoftoday’shighAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicideratesisthetraumaticdisruptingeffectofcolonisationanditsaftermathoncommunities.Itisnoteworthythatpriortothe1950sand1960stherearefewifanyreportsofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicide.15Itsemergenceasapopulationhealthissuehasbeenconnected,inparticular,totheclosingofreserves,andtheendofformallegallyencodedracialdiscrimination.

Sowhywouldthisresultinincreasedsuicide?First,becauseinpracticetheliftingoflegaldiscriminationwasnotenoughtoredressthedeeppovertyandlackofevenbasichealthandassociatedservicesthatcharacterisedlifeonthereserves.Inshort,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderremainedsociallyexcludedfromthebenefitsofpolitical,socialandeconomiclife16(asdiscussedinPart2).Second,becausethisenabledAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplestoaccessbothwelfareandalcoholwithoutrestriction.HunterandMilroy(2006)contendthisledtowidespreaddysfunctioninmanycommunitiesleadingtoaperiodof‘normativeinstability’compoundedbyalcoholabuse.17 Theyalsoexplaintheunderlyingpsychologicalprocessesthroughwhichbroaderhistorical,socio-economicandcommunityfactorsmaybecomeinternalised,arguingthatAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderself-destructivebehavioursreflectvulnerabilitystemmingfrominternalstatesinformedbybothindividualexperienceandcollectivecircumstance.18

ParticularlyinfluentialinexplainingtherelationshipbetweenthecollectivefunctioningofIndigenouscommunitiesandsuicideratesinthemaretwostudiesbyChandlerandLalondeamongBritishColumbian(Canadian)FirstNations’youngpeople.Thesefocusedoncommunity-levelprotectivefactorsagainstsuicidalbehaviours:inparticularcommunityempowermentandculturalcontinuityas,inpractice,inseparableprotectivefactors.19Intheirfirststudy(1987–1992)culturalcontinuitywasdefinedaccordingtosixkey

Page 4: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

4

interconnectingindicatorsofself-governanceandculturalmaintenance:• achievementofameasureofself-government;• havelitigatedforAboriginaltitletotraditionallands;• accomplishedameasureoflocalcontroloverhealth;• accomplishedameasureoflocalcontrolovereducation;• accomplishedameasureoflocalcontroloverpolicingservices;and• hadcreatedcommunityfacilitiesforthepreservationofculture.20

Inthisstudy,ChandlerandLalondemappedsuicidesinall197communitiesor‘bands’inBritish ColumbiaandfoundthatcommunitiesthatachievedallsixmarkershadnocasesofsuicideamongyoungFirstNationspeople.Conversely,wherecommunitiesachievednoneoftheseprotectivemarkers,youthsuicideratesweremanytimesthenationalaverage.21Asecondstudy(1993–2000)includedtwootherindicatorsandfoundsimilarresultstothoseofthefirststudy.Theadditionalindicatorswere:

• ameasureoflocalcontroloverchildwelfareservices;and• thattheyarecharacterisedbyhavingelectedbandcouncilscomposedofmorethan50

percentwomen.22CommunityempowermentandculturalcontinuityarenowconsideredinanAustraliancontext.

CommunityEmpowerment

InAustralia,colonisationrequiredtheexerciseofallformsofstatepowertocontrolthelivesofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplescombinedwithamassiveinfluxofnon-indigenouspeople.Today,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplescompriseathreepercentminoritywithinAustralia,withconcurrentlimitedpoliticalpower.23Therighttoself-determinationofIndigenouspeoples(includingAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples)inpost-colonialsettingsisbroadlyunderstoodastherighttoself-governance.

Thishasbeenformallyrecognisedinthe2007UNDeclarationontheRightsofIndigenousPeoples,supportedbyAustraliain2009.24AboriginalCommunityControlledHealthServicesareemblematicoftheexerciseoftheaboverightwithinthehealthsystem,buttheconsistentapplicationoftheself-determinationprincipleintheoverarchingpoliticalandpolicy-developmentspaces,whichinvolvestheAustralianstatesharingpowerwith

Page 5: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

5

AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesindecision-makingthatimpactsuponthem,iscontested.25Atthecommunitylevel,thedisempowermentexperiencedatthenationallevelisoftenreflected.AsdiscussedbyTseyetal(2012),governancerefersto‘evolvingprocesses,relationships,institutionsandstructuresbywhichagroupofpeople,communityorsocietyorganisethemselvescollectivelytoachievethingsthatmattertothem.’26InAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersettings,eachcommunityisdifferentandgoodgovernanceisdefinedbyculturallybasedvaluesandnormativecodesaboutwhatis‘therightway’togetthingsdoneintermsoflegitimacy,leadership,power,resourcesandaccountability.27Incontrast,poorgovernanceisidentifiedbyfactorssuchascorruption,favouritism,nepotism,apathy,neglect,redtapeandself-servingpoliticalleadersandpublicofficials.28DataonAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples’experienceofcommunityandcommunitygovernancehasonlyjuststartedtobecollected.The2014–15AustralianBureauofStatistics(ABS)NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey(NATSISS)reportedthatinremoteareas,onlyabouthalfofrespondentsfelttheirlocalcommunityhadstrongleadership.29Onlyone-quarter(26percent)reportedtheycouldhaveasaywithintheircommunityonimportantissues,allormostofthetime,while51percentfelttheycouldhaveasaywithintheircommunityalittleornoneofthetime.30Sixteenpercentofrespondentsfeltthattheircommunitywasaworseplacetoliveatthetimeofthesurveythanitwas12-monthspriortothesurvey.31

EmpowermentatboththeindividualandcommunitylevelhasbeencentraltoeffortstoreduceAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidetodate.Inparticular,theongoingNationalEmpowermentProject(NEP)thataimstoempowercommunitiesbyeducationinidentifyingandaddressingchallenges(includingthoseassociatedwithsuicide)andsupportingtheircapacityforself-governanceandorganisationtoaddressthosechallenges.32CulturalContinuityCulturalcontinuityisanimportantconceptinIndigenoussuicidepreventioninpartbecauseinherentintheconceptisthatyoungpeoplehaveasenseoftheirpastandtheirculturesanddrawprideandidentityfromthem.Byextension,youngpeoplealsoconceiveofthemselvesashavingafuture(asbearersofthatculture).33

WithreferencetotheAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersocialandemotionalwellbeingconcept,culturallydefinedfamilyandkinrelationships;communityrelationships;theroleofElders,culturalpractice;connectiontocountry;andspiritualityandancestorsareconsideredaselementsofculturalcontinuityandthus–itcanbeextrapolated-protectivefactorsagainstsuicide.34[Thesocialandemotionalwellbeingconceptisotherwiseassumedknowledgeinthereader.]

Page 6: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

6

Assuchitisofconcernthatthereisevidencefor‘disconnection’fromtheseprotectivefactorsbeingexperiencedbyasignificantminorityofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesbothincommunitysettingsandotherwise.Noteworthyisthat:• Socialcontact/communitysupport.TheNATSISS2014–15reportedthatabout17per

centofrespondents,frombothnon-remoteandremoteareas,didnothaveweeklyface-to-facecontactwithfamilyorfriendslivingoutsidetheirhousehold.35Further,thatabouteightpercentofrespondentssaidtheywereunabletogetsupportfromoutsidetheirhouseholdinatimeofcrisis.36

• Familyandfriends.TheNATSISS2014–15reportedabout18percentofoverall

respondentssaidtheywereunabletoconfideinfamilyorfriendslivingoutsidetheirhousehold:13percentofremotelivingpeopleand35percentofnon-remotelivingpeople.37

• Removalfromfamily.In2012-2013intheABSAustralianAboriginalandTorresStrait

IslanderHealthSurvey,justoverhalf(54percent)ofrespondentsaged15yearsandoverreportedthattheyand/orarelativehadbeenremovedfromtheirnaturalfamily.Thosewhowereremovedfromtheirfamilyweremorelikelytohavehighlevelsofpsychologicaldistress(35percent)thanthoseneveraffectedbyfamilyremovals(26percent).38

• InfluenceofElders.TheNATSISS2014–15reportedabouthalfofAboriginalandTorres

StraitIslanderchildrenaged4–14yearswerenotincontactwithaleaderorelderonweeklybasis.Thecorrespondingproportionsinnon-remoteareaswereaboutthreequartersofchildrenaged4-14.39Onlyabouthalfofadultrespondentsagreedthatleadersinthecommunityhadtimetolistenandgiveadvice(52percent).40

Inrelationtothelatterpoint,Niezen’saccountofasuicideclusterinCanadianInuitcommunitiesrecognisedtheprotectiveandlifeaffirmingfunctionwhich‘culturalcontinuity’playsinstrengtheningyoungpeople’sself-identityandsenseofconnectednesswithfamilyandcommunity. Inparticular,heobservedthatpatternsofincreasinglyself-destructivebehaviourinyoungpeopleappearedtobemoreprevalentinthosecommunitieswheretherewasadisengagementofyoungpeoplefromoldergenerationsandtheabsenceofalmostanyopportunitiesforproductiveandcreativeactivity.41

Niezenobservedthatyoungpeopleincommunitieswhereindividualandcommunityidentitiesarefragile,andwheretheyarecutofffromthepositiveexampleandsocialpersuasionofoldergenerations,arelikelytogravitatetoapeergroupofsimilarlydisconnectedyouth.42Tatz’s(1999)studydiscussedthesenseofhopelessnessamongAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderyoungmenheconsideredtobeatriskofsuicideandsuggestedasimilarpatternofdisconnectionfromguidance.43Already,inAustralia,theNEPplacesastrongemphasisonleveragingculturalstrengths,involvingEldersandsupportingacommunity’sculturalrenewalonitsowntermsasamajorpartofitsworkwithincommunities.44

Page 7: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

7

Whiletheimplicationsofculturalcontinuityasaconceptareyettobefullyexplored,includingtheirapplicationinAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersettings,andinurbansettings,supportforculturalcontinuityisahighlyproductivelineofpolicydevelopmentinrelationtosuicideprevention(andmorebroadly,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples’mentalhealthandsocialandemotionalwellbeing)basedonculturalmaintenanceand,wherenecessary,reclamation.

SocialexclusionPartoftheaftermathofcolonisationisinterpersonalandotherformsofracismanddiscriminationandtherelatedconceptofsocialexclusionthatcontributetothebroadercontextofhighAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuiciderates.The‘sociallyincluded’havebeendefinedashavingtheresources,opportunitiesandcapabilitiestheyneedto:• Learn(participateineducationandtraining);• Work(participateinemployment,unpaidorvoluntaryworkincludingfamilyandcarer

responsibilities);• Engage(connectwithpeople,uselocalservicesandparticipateinlocal,cultural,civic

andrecreationalactivities);and• Haveavoice(influencedecisionsthataffectthem).45

Incontrast,socialexclusionisapositionofcollectiveorindividualpowerlessnessthatcanresultfromacombinationoflinkedproblemssuchasunemployment,discrimination,poorskills,lowincomes,poorhousing,highcrime,badhealthandfamilybreakdown.46

SocialinclusionconsideredasempowermentfollowstheexampleofAmartyaSenwhodefinespovertyintermsoflowcapabilitiesandfunctionings.Senarguesthatpovertyensueswhenindividualsorcollectiveslackcertainminimumcapabilities.Lowcapabilitiescantranslateintooutcomessuchasinadequateincomesoreducation,poorhealth,lowself-confidence,andultimatelyapersonalorcollectivesenseofpowerlessnessorhelplessness.47

In2013,theProductivityCommissionclassifiedAustralianpopulationgroupsusingaSocialExclusionMonitor.Thiscomprised29indicatorsacrosssevenkeylifedomainsincludingthosethatrelatedtopersonalpower:includingaccesstomaterialresources,employment,educationandskills,andhealthanddisability,toassesstheir‘deepandpersistentdisadvantage.’48

BetweenfiveandsixpercentofAustraliansenterincomepovertyinanygivenyear,andasimilarproportionexit.49Buttheriskofapersonremainingpersistentlyindisadvantageincreaseswithitsduration.Forexample,onaveragethelikelihoodofapersonexitingincomepovertywhohadexperiencedpovertyforsixormoreyears(inthepreviousnineyears)isaroundtwothirdslessthansomeonewhohadexperiencedincomepovertyforoneortwoyears.Notsurprisingly,employmentisacatalystformovingoutofdisadvantage.50

Page 8: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

8

TheProductivityCommissionassessedthatpeopleathighestriskofexperiencingdeeperormultipleformsofdisadvantagein2010includednotonlyAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleassuch,butalsopopulationgroupsamongwhomAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleareover-representedwhencomparedtonon-Indigenouspeople:thosewhoaredependentonincomesupport,thoselivinginpublichousing,unemployedpeople,peoplewithalong-termhealthconditionordisability,loneparents andpeoplewithloweducationalattainment.51

ForAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleperseitwasassessedthatoverall10.8percentofthepopulationwereinastateofdeepandpersistentsocialexclusionbetween2001and2010.Attheendofthatdecade,in2010,9.1percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleswereestimatedremaininthatstate,52comparedtoapproximatelyfivepercentinthegeneralpopulation.53Thisrepresentsareductionofonly1.7percentoverthedecade.

Notonlydocommunity-wideissues(forexample,alcoholanddruguse)involveindividuals,butasdiscussedaboveandasHunterandMilroypropose,collectiveself-perceptionscanbeinternalisedbyyoungAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleandprovideacontextforspecificriskbehavioursandotherfactorsassociatedwithsuicide.

Inpractice,thelinebetweencommunitylevelcontributorstosuicideandfactorsassociatedwithindividualsuicidescanbehard,ifnotimpossible,todrawwithanysenseofprecision.Indeed,socialexclusionprovidesacontextformanyoftheindividualriskfactorsandcausesdiscussedinParts2and3below.

Part2:Individualriskfactors

Alcoholanddruguse

The2011Queenslandstudyexaminedtoxicologyreportsfor216AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderandabout3600non-Indigenoussuicidecasesfortheperiod1998–2006.54Thecommonestprescriptionmedicationfoundin7.4percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidecaseswerebenzodiazepines55:withsedative,sleep-inducingandmuscle-relaxantproperties.Butcomparedtothedrugbeingreportedin27percentofnon-Indigenouscases,56usageassociatedwithsuicideisrelativelysmall.Likewise,opiates,withpainkillingandrelaxantproperties,werefoundinonly3.2percent ofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercasescomparedto16.4percentofnon-Indigenous.57Incontrast,alcoholwaspresentinalmost60percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidecasesatalcohol-bloodlevelsexceeding0.5mg/100ml(thedrinkdrivinglimit),aboutdoubletherateofthenon-indigenouspersons(about30percentofcases);with25percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidecaseshavingover0.2mg/100ml(fourtimesthedrinkdrivinglimit)intheirbloodattimeofdeath,comparedtosevenpercentofnon-indigenousdeaths.58

Page 9: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

9

ThehighalcoholusagefigurecouldindicatethatAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleareusingalcoholasapartoftheirmethodofsuicide,inpartperhapsbecauseofloweraccesstoprescriptionmedications,oruseofalcoholovertheirlifetime.Incontrasttothe60percent(justundertwointhree)whosetoxicologyreportsfoundhighalcoholbloodlevelsatthetimeofdeath,so-called‘psychologicalautopsies’revealedthatonlytwoinfivehadareportedhistoryofproblematicdrinking.59Cannabiswaspresentin30percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidecases;almostdoubletherateofnon-Indigenoussuicidecases.60LearningsFromtheMessageStick,reportedsuicideisthemostcommoncauseofalcohol-relateddeathsamongAboriginalmenandthefourthmostcommoncauseamongstAboriginalwomenincontrasttothenon-Indigenouspopulation.61 Further,itreportedhighlevelsofalcoholanddrugmisusehavealsobeennotedinalmostalldocumentedAboriginalsuicideclusters,withmanyoftheaffectedindividualsbeingeitherintoxicatedorinseverewithdrawal.62Therearetwowaysofinterpretingthisdata.Oneisthatalcoholandcannabisisbeingusedbyasignificantproportion(atleastuptohalf)ofthesecasesaspartofasuicidemethod.63Anotheristhatuseofthesesubstancesmightbecontributingtosuicide,includingthroughloweringprotectivefactorsagainstimpulsivesuicidalbehaviour.LearningsfromtheMessageStickreportedthatimpulsivenessisa‘distinctfeatureofAboriginalsuicidewhichiscommonlylinkedtoexcessivealcoholconsumption’.64Bythis,stressfuleventssuchasrelationalconflictorbreakdown(discussedbelow)maypromptanimpulsivesuicidalreactionundertheinfluenceofalcoholordrugs.65Impulsivity

AsreportedinLearningsfromtheMessageStick,insomecasesanimmediate“precipitating”stressortoasuicideisnotapparent,ormayappeartoberelativelyminor;66orasanacttogainattention.67 Further,thatimpulsivityanditsrelationshiptosuicidalbehaviourisacomplexissuethatcannotbesimplyattributedtoalcoholanddruguse.Itis,forexample,associatedwithFetalAlcoholSyndromeDisorders(FASD)andtraumaasdiscussedbelow.FASDisanumbrellatermtodescribe‘arangeofphysical,cognitive,behaviouralandneurodevelopmentalabnormalitiesthatresultfromtheexposureofafetustoalcoholconsumptionduringpregnancy’.68 ImpulsivenessisalsoacorecomponentofFASD,togetherwithlossofdecision-makingabilityandinabilitytopredicttheoutcomesofone’sactions.69

TheLililwanProjectisastudydesigned,inpart,toestimatetheprevalenceofFASDandassociatedfactorsinanAboriginalcommunity–theFitzroyValleyintheKimberley,WesternAustralia.70 About95percentofAboriginalchildrenbornover2002-2003inthecommunitywereinvolved.71FASorpartialFAS(pFAS)wasdiagnosedin13of108children,aprevalenceof120in1000,or12percent.72PrenatalalcoholexposurewasconfirmedforallchildrenwithFAS/pFASincluding80percentinthefirsttrimesterand50percent

Page 10: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

10

throughoutpregnancy.73LearningfromtheMessageStickreportcitedexpertswhoconcludedthatFASDwas‘absolutelylinked’withsuicideinKimberleycommunities.74Impulsivityhasalsobeenassociatedwithanindividual’slackofabilitytoself-sootheasaresultofuntreatedtrauma.75Traumaisnotamentalillnessbutreferstoexperiencesandsymptomsassociatedwithparticularlyintensestressfullifeeventsthatoverwhelmaperson’sabilitytocope.Forchildreninparticular,thesecanincludesexualabuse,asdiscussedbelow.WhatlimiteddataisavailablesuggestsrelativelyhighlevelsoftraumaintheAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpopulation.Post-TraumaticStressDisorder(PTSD)isonemanifestationoftrauma.A2008studyofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderprisonersinQueenslandreported12.1percentofmalesand32.3percentoffemaleswithPTSD.76Familyviolenceandchildabuse,childrenincare

Inhis2014,InvestigationintowaysthatStategovernmentdepartmentsandauthoritiescanpreventorreducesuicidebyyoungpeople,theWAOmbudsmenexaminedthedeathsof36youngpeoplebysuicideorsuspectedsuicideandfoundthat:

• 44percentweresaidtohaveexperiencedfamilyanddomesticviolence • 25percentwererecordedashavingallegedlyexperiencedsexualabuse • 22percentwererecordedashavingallegedlyexperiencedphysicalabuse,and • 33percentwererecordedashavingallegedlyexperiencedoneormoreelementsof

neglectduringtheirchildhood.77 Nationallyin2014-15,themostcommonreasonforsubstantiationforAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderchildrenaged0–17yearswasneglect(38.3percent)followedbyemotionalabuse(37.7percent).78AsnotedinLearningsfromtheMessageStick:

Whileallformsofabusesignificantlyincreasetheriskofsuicidalideationandsuicideattemptsforyoungpeople,researchsuggeststhatthelinkisstrongestincasesofsexualabuse.Theriskofrepeatedsuicideattemptsisreportedlyeighttimeshigherforyoungpeoplewithasexualabusehistorythanforthosewithout.Ithasbeensuggestedthatsexualabusecouldbespecificallyrelatedtosuicidalbehaviourbecauseitiscloselyassociatedwithfeelingsofshameandinternalattributionsofblame(withoutreferences)79

Likewise,CashmoreandShackel’s(2012)meta-analysisThelong-termeffectsofchildsexualabuse,reportedthatsexualvictimisation,bothinchildhoodandbeyond,isasignificantriskfactorforsuicideattemptsamongbothmenandwomen.80

WhilsttheactualprevalenceofchildsexualassaultbyAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderchildrenstatusisnotknown,datafromincidentsthatcometotheattentionof,andarerecordedby,policeareavailable.In2015,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderchildvictims

Page 11: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

11

(agedlessthan15years)ofsexualassaultaccountedfor48.4percent(NSW),54.5percent(Queensland),36.4percent(SA)and38.0percent(NT)ofsexualassaultvictimsineachjurisdiction.81LearningsfromtheMessageStickalsonotedthestrongassociationbetweenhighratesofsuicideamongyoungpeopleafterleavingcare.82 ItalsonotedthattheratesofchildprotectionintheKimberleyregionare,liketheratesofsuicideinthatregionextremelyhigh.83Exposuretosuicidalbehaviour

The2011QueenslandstudyreportedthatamongAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidecases,imitationappearstoplayanelevatedrolewhencomparedtotheevidenceforimitativebehaviorinnon-Indigenouscases.Intheformer,16.7percenthadexperiencedasuicideeventintheirsocialnetwork,comparedto8.8percentofnon-Indigenouscases.84This16.7percentamountedtoasamplegroupof71AboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidedeathswithasuicideintheirsocialnetwork.85Ofthese,almost50percenthadexperiencedthesuicideofadirectrelative,40percentthesuicideofanotherrelativeorafriend,andaboutoneineighthadexperiencedmultiplesuicidesintheirsocialnetwork.86Andamongyoungpeople,therearereportsthatasignificantpercentageofallAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidesintheNorthernTerritorybetween1996and2005arethoughttohavebeenpartof‘suicideclusters’asaresultof‘copy-cat’behaviours.87Similarly,inthe2001-2002WesternAustralianAboriginalChildHealthSurvey,amongthe16percentof12-17yearoldswhoreportedsuicidalthoughtsrateswereelevatedamongthosewhohadafriendwhohadattemptedsuicide.88

Reasonsfor‘clustering’requirefurtherresearch.However,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidesingeneral,andsuicideclustersinparticular,arecharacterisedbythesamechoiceofmethod(hanging,asdiscussedintheIntroduction)andoftenconcentratedingeographicallyisolatedareasasillustratedinDiagram1below.

Diagram1:ThenumbersofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidesbypostcode,

2001-12

Page 12: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

12

AkeypatterninAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidedeathsinAustraliaistheirconcentrationinremoteareasasillustratedbyATSISPEP’smapofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicideover2001-12bypostcode.Thedarkerthecolour,themoresuicideshaveoccurred.89Mechanismsimpliedtoincreasetheriskofsuicideimitation(ornormalisation)areconsideredtoinclude:desensitisationofyoungpeopletowardsdeathandsuicide;thevisibilityofsuicidesoccurringinthecommunities;and/orcommunicationaboutthesedeathsviamediaorwordofmouth.90

Copy-catorimitativesuicidalbehaviorisnotuniquetoAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercommunities.Internationally,ithasbeenestimatedthatbetweenoneandfivepercentofallsuicidesbyyoungpeopleoccurinthecontextofacluster.91WhilemostcommonlydocumentedinAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercommunitiesinAustralia,itisalsooccurringamongthenon-Indigenouspopulation.92Part3:Specificcausesassociatedwithsuicide

Associatedwithsocialexclusionanddisadvantageisgreaterexposuretostressfullifeevents.ThemostfrequentlyreportedstressfullifeeventsreportedbyAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesinthe2012-2013AATSIHSwere:• deathofafamilymemberorfriend(reportedby37percentofrespondents);• seriousillness(23percent);• inabilitytogetajob(23percent);and• mentalillness(16percent).93

TheseeventsaresharedexperiencesbetweenAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesandthenon-Indigenouspopulation.However,thereisevidenceforAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples’greaterandsimultaneousexposuretomultiplestressfulevents.Researchersreportthat1.9–2.6overlappingstressfullifeeventsareassociatedwithmildormoderatepsychologicaldistress,withbetween2.6and3.2eventsassociatedwithhighorveryhighpsychologicaldistress.94 Assuchitissignificantthatin2012–13,30percentofAATSIHSrespondentsover18yearsofagewereassessedwithhavinghighorveryhighpsychologicaldistresslevelsinthefourweeksbeforethesurvey.95Thatis,nearlythreetimesthenon-Indigenousrate.96 Inthesamesurvey,73percentofrespondentsaged15yearsandoverreportedthatthey,theirfamilyorfriendshadexperiencedoneormorestressfullifeeventsinthepreviousyear.97Thatrateis1.4timesthatreportedbynon-Indigenouspeople.98

A2009studyreportedthatthosewithhighandveryhighpsychologicaldistress(measuredbytheKesslerK-10scale)were21and77timesmorelikely,respectively,tobeexperiencingsuicidalideation.99Whenconsideringparticularindividualfactorsassociatedwithsuicide,the2011Queenslandstudy’isparticularlyuseful.Thisreportedthattwo-thirdsoftheentiresample(both

Page 13: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

13

AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderandnon-Indigenouscases)hadrecordsofbeingexposedtoatleastonerecentstressfullifeeventpriortosuicide,withnosignificantdifferencesobservedacrossageorgender.

ItreportedthemostcommonstressfullifeeventsfoundtoprecedeanAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicideare:• conflictwithpartners(relationshipconflict)andfamilymembers(familialconflict)or

otherpersons(interpersonalconflict);• pendinglegalmattersandcriminalhistory;and• lossofsignificantpersons(bereavement),withaparticularfocusonexposuretosuicide

inthesocialnetwork.100Therewerealsostrongassociationsnotedbetweensuicideandunemployment.

Relationshipbreakdownanddeathofsignificantpersons

The2011QueenslandStudyreportedthemostfrequenteventsprecedingallsuicidedeathswererelationshipproblems(eitherconflictwithapartnerorrelationshipbreakdown/separation),whichwerereportedin31.1percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderand29.6percentofnon-Indigenoussuicidecases–roughlythesameproportions.101However,thesecondmostcommonlifeeventreportedinAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicideswereconflicts,eitherwithfamilymembers(familialconflict)orotherpersons,suchasfriends,neighboursandcolleagues(interpersonalconflict).Thiswasatanelevatedratecomparedtothenon-Indigenouspopulation(13.9percentvs.8.2percent).

Relevanttosuicidepreventionandtouchingoncommunityfunctioningis‘lateralviolence,’atermthatdescribesthewayoppressedpeople,covertlyorovertlydirecttheirdissatisfactionsidewaystowardeachother,towardthemselves,andtowardthoselesspowerfulthanthemselves.Itresultsinpeopleturningoneachotherasopposedtothesystemsthatexcludeandoppressthem.102Lateralviolenceisaspectrumofbehavioursthatinclude:gossiping,jealousy,bullying,shaming,socialexclusion,familyfeuding,intra-organisationconflictand,ultimately,physicalviolence.Whilenotnamedassuch,manyelementsoffamilyfeudingcanbeseentoconstitutelateralviolence.LateralviolencewasidentifiedinthereportsoftheNEPasasignificantproblemincommunities.103

The2011Queenslandstudyalsoreportedthatbereavement/lossofasignificantpersonwasmorecommonamongAboriginalandTorresStraitislandersuicidecases(11.5percent),comparedtonon-Indigenouscases(8percent).104Inparticular,11.7percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitislandermaleswerereportedtohavesufferedabereavementcomparedto7.5percentofnon-Indigenousmales.105Inparticular,theage-distributionofAboriginalandTorresStraitislanderandnon-

Page 14: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

14

Indigenousbereavedpersonswhosuicidedwassignificantlydifferent:about32percentofbereavednon-Indigenoussuicidecaseswereolderthan55years,whileinalmostfourinfiveofbereavedAboriginalandTorresStraitislandercasespersonswereyoungerthan34years.106CriminalhistoryandpendinglegalmattersInJune2015,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplescomprised27percentofallprisoners107despitecomprisingaboutthreepercentofthepopulation.Theage-standardisedimprisonmentratewas13timesgreaterthanfornon-IndigenousAustralians.108

Notoftenconsideredistheimpactthatimprisonmentmighthaveonsuiciderates.Inparticular,apotentialsubjectoffutureresearchisproposedtobethe2011Queenslandstudyreportofacriminalhistoryin32.5percentoftheAboriginalandTorresStraitislandersuicidecases.Thiswasmorethantwicethatrecordedinnon-Indigenouscases(15.8percent).109Pendinglegalissuespriortodeathwerealsoreportedinthe2011QueenslandstudyatelevatedlevelsintheAboriginalandTorresStraitislandersuicidedeathsamplewhencomparedtothenon-Indigenoussample:at11.5percentcomparedto7.5percentrespectivelyoverall,andamongmalesat13.7percentv8.4percentforthenon-Indigenous.110

Almosthalf(about50percent)oftheAboriginalandTorresStraitislandersuicidecasesofmaleswithpendinglegalissueswereofyoungmen–lessthan24yearsofage.Amongthenon-Indigenouscomparatorsample,only17.2percentofdeathswereinthatagegroup.111Unemployment/inabilitytogetajob

The2011QueenslandstudyreportedalmosthalftheAboriginalandTorresStraitsuicidecasesinitssamplewereunemployedatthetimeoftheirdeath,whichwasalmosttwicemorethaninnon-Indigenouscomparatorcases.112 Thismirrorssomewhattheunemploymentrateitself,atleastforAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleaged15–24yearswhoareamongatthehighestriskofsuicide:• TheNATSISS2014–15reportedthattheunemploymentrateforAboriginalandTorres

StraitIslanderpeopleaged15yearsandoverwas20.6percent.113 Theratesandtheemployment‘gap’withthenon-Indigenous,werehighestamongAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleaged15–24years(31.8percentcomparedwith16.7percentfornon-Indigenouspeople)114

• TheunemploymentratewashigherforAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleaged

15yearsandoverinremoteareas(27.4percent)thaninnon-remoteareas(19.3percent).Bycomparison,theAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleunemploymentrateinmajorcitieswas14.0percent.ThestateswiththehighestunemploymentrateswereWesternAustralia(26.4percent)andQueensland(25.1percent).115

Page 15: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

15

Part4:AccesstoservicesaccordingtoneedThefinalpartofthepictureisnotacausepersebutreturnsustothecontextualfactorsthatareassociatedwithAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicideandultimatelyrelatetosocialexclusion.Inparticular,thatanAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpersonatriskofsuicideorwithamentalhealthproblemislesslikelytobeabletoaccesstheservicestheyneedthananon-indigenouspersoninthesameposition.Despitethepreviousdiscussionaboutimpulsivenessasariskfactorforsuicide,itisnoteworthythattheevidencesuggestsasignificantnumberofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidesarepre-meditatedandinmanycasesthatintenthadbeencommunicatedpriortodeathandthatthesepeopleweretosomedegreeidentifiabletofriends,familyandmentalhealthandsuicidepreventionserviceproviders:

• The2011Queenslandstudyreportedthatofthe478AboriginalandTorresStrait

Islandersuicidesthatwerethesubjectofthestudy,43.3percentinvolvedthepersoncommunicatingsuicidalintentintheirlifetime,with39.1percentcommunicatingintentinthe12monthspriortodeath.Thisincludes25percentofthecaseshavingahistoryofprevioussuicideattempts;16percentintheprevious12-months.116

• Inthe2001-2002WesternAustralianAboriginalChildHealthSurvey,16percentof12-

17yearoldsreportedsuicidalthoughtsand39percentofthesereportedanattemptedsuicide(i.e.about7percentofthetotalsample)duringthe12monthspriortothesurvey.117

• Self-harmcanbeawayofcopingwithstressandakintoa‘cryforhelp,’118butdata

collectionsdonotdistinguishbetweenself-harmforthispurposeandattemptedsuicide.In2014-2015,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleswerehospitalisedforself-harmat2.6timestherateofnon-IndigenousAustralians.119Rateshaveincreasedby55.6percentsince2004-2005.120

• Suicideisalsostronglyassociatedwithdepression.Ingeneralpopulationsuicide

research,peoplewhohavealreadyattemptedsuicideareconsideredtobeatthehighestriskofsuicide(at40xincreasedrisk)thananyotherpopulationgroup.Furtherincreasedriskwasrelatedtotherecencyofapreviousattempt,thefrequencyofpreviousattempts,andisolation.121 Inthe2012–13AATSIHS,12percentofrespondentsreportedfeelingdepressedorhavingdepressionasalong-termcondition;compared9.6percentinthetotalpopulation.122Over2008–2013,depressionwasthemostfrequentlyreportedmentalhealthrelatedproblemmanagedbyGPsamongAboriginalandTorresStraitislanderclients.123The2014–15NATSISSaskedwhetherrespondentswerehappy‘all’,‘most’,‘some’,‘little’or‘none’ofthetime.Nationwide,9.2percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplereportedbeinghappylittleornoneofthetime.124

Yetthe2011QueenslandstudyreportedthefollowingevidencethatsuggestssignificantlymoreAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleatriskofsuicidearenotaccessingthe

Page 16: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

16

supportand/orservicestheyneededpriortotheirdeathswhencomparedtonon-Indigenoussuicide:• 20.5percentoftheAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicidecaseshadatleastone

reportedmentalillnessatthetimeofdeath,comparedwith2,514(40.4percent)ofnon-Indigenoussuicidecases;

• 23.3percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercaseshadreceivedtreatmentfrom

amentalhealthprofessionalintheirlifetime,comparedto42.3percentofnon-Indigenous;

• 10.1%ofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercaseswereseenbyamentalhealth

professionalinlastthreemonthspriortosuicide,comparedto25.6percentofnon-Indigenouscases;125

• 1.9%ofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercaseshadarecordeduseofanti-psychotics,

comparedto4.4percentofnon-Indigenouscases.126Whileusageisimproving,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesand- itcanbeextrapolatedparticularlythoseatriskofsuicide-haverelativelylowaccessto/orarechoosingnottousementalhealthservices.

Inthe2012–13AATSIHS,onlyaboutoneinfour(27percent)ofadultswithhigh/veryhighlevelsofpsychologicaldistress,asdiscussedaknownriskfactorforsuicide,hadseenahealthprofessionalinresponseintheprevious4weeks.127128Primarymentalhealthcareisalsoparticularlyimportantfortreatingdepressionandcanbeagatewaytospecialistmentalhealthcareinseverecases.129AsmentalhealthandrelatedproblemsarereportedintheAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpopulationattwotothreetimestherateinthegeneralpopulation,twotothreetimestherateofusageofprimarymentalhealthservicesmightbeexpected.

Infact,over2008-2013,11percentofallproblemsmanagedbyGPsamongAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderclientswerementalhealthrelated:1.3timestherateforotherAustralians.130In2012-2013,8percentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleaccessedMedicaresubsidisedmentalhealthcareservices,(providedbyconsultantpsychiatrists,clinicalpsychologists,GPsandalliedhealthprofessionals):thesamerateasnon-Indigenouspeople,131despitethegreaterneed.Thereisevidencethatbecauseoflackofaccessto/oruseofprimarymentalhealthcareaccordingtoneed,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleswithmentalhealthproblemsareoverrepresentedinotherpartsofthehealthandmentalhealthsystem.Forcommunitybasedmentalhealthclinics,about9percentofcontactswereprovidedtoIndigenouspeoplesin2013-14:3.3timesthenon-Indigenousrate.132 In2012-13,IAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleaccountedforadisproportionate9percentofmentalhealth-relatedEDoccasionsofservice.Theyaccountedfor4.9percentmental

Page 17: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

17

health-relatedhospitalisationsincludingspecialisedpsychiatriccarein2012-2013;and4.1percentofallepisodesofresidentialmentalhealthcarein2013-2014.133Culturalracismincludesactionsbyinstitutionsthatarenotovertlyracistorbelievethemselvestoberacistbutamountto‘theobservanceandadministrationofpolicies,rulesandproceduresthatpurporttotreateverybodyequally,butareunfairlyorinequitablyadministeredorappliedindealingswithpeoplebelongingtoaparticularracial,ethnic,religiousorculturalgroup’.134Whetherevidenceofculturalracismornot,theNATSISS2014–15reportedthatninepercentofrespondentsagreedthattheirowndoctorcouldnotbetrusted,35percentthathospitalscouldnotbetrusted.135The2012-13ABSNationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderHealthSurvey(NATSIHS),reportedthat35percentofthosewhoreportedbeingtreatedbadlybecausetheywereAboriginaland/orTorresStraitIslanderusuallyrespondedbysubsequentlyavoidingthepersonorsituation.Suchisbackedupbyotherresearch.136AboutsevenpercentofNATSIHSrespondentsreportedthattheyhadavoidedseekinghealthcarebecausetheyhadbeentreatedunfairly.137CriticaltoaddressingculturalracismandimprovingaccesstohealthandmentalhealthservicesisthedevelopmentofAboriginalCommunityControlledHealthServicesandotherdedicated(ifnotcommunitycontrolledhealth)servicesaimedatAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples.

YetonlyabouthalfofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplescanaccess/orchoosetousesuch.Atthetimeofthe2011Census,theABSestimatestheIndigenouspopulationtonumber669,900persons.138Intheir2015ServiceReports,the203AustralianGovernmentfundedIndigenousprimaryhealthcareorganisations(IPHCOs)report323,600AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesclients.139ThisincludesAboriginalCommunityControlledHealthOrganisations(ACCHOs)whoidentifyashavingabout255,060AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesclients.140ThissuggeststhatIPHCOshadapproximately48.3percentofthetotalIndigenouspopulationasclients,andwithinthatcohorttheACCHOsabout38percent.StudieshavefoundthatforAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeople‘accesstoserviceiscriticaland,whereACCHOsexist,thecommunitypreferstoanddoesusethem.’141Withappropriateresources,anACCHOisabletoimplementaculturallycompetentandcomprehensiveprimaryhealthcaremodelbasedontheculturallyshaped,holisticconceptsofhealthunderstoodbythecommunitiestheyserve.142 However,inthe2015ServiceReports,ofthe203IPHCOs,includingACCHOs,55percentreportedservicegapsformentalhealthandsocialandemotionalwellbeing;and47percent-alcohol,tobaccoanddrugservicegaps.143

Wheresuchservicesdonotexist,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleareobligedtorelyongeneralpopulationhealthandmentalhealthservices.Assuch,itiscriticalthatsuchservicesareculturallysafeandthatitsstaff,andindeedtheorganisationitself,isculturallycompetenttoworkwithAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples.[Theseconceptsareassumedknowledgeinthereader.]

Page 18: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

18

OneoftheimportantcontributionstheAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderMentalHealthAdvisoryGroupmadetosuicidepreventionwastodevelopasetofOperationalGuidelinesAccesstoAlliedPsychologicalServicesProgram(ATAPS)AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSuicidePreventionServices.144Theseincludedqualityindicatorsforservicesto:

• provideculturallysafe,non-triggeringmanagement,treatmentandsupportto

AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesathighriskofsuicideorself-harmatacriticalpointintheirliveandtomitigatethereverberationsfromsuicideintheclient'scommunity;

• bestaffedbyadministratorsandcliniciansthataretrainedandunderstandmental

healthandsuicidepreventionculturalsafety;• establishmanagementprotocolsthatreflectthemultiplelevelsofdiversityfoundin

modernAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpopulations;and• bebasedonAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples'definitionsofhealth,

incorporatingspirituality,culture,family,connectiontothelandandwellbeingandgroundedincommunityengagement.145

Theguidelinesestablishthatahighquality,culturallycompetentservicewillbemadeavailablebyensuring:• AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesthatareprovidingservicesshouldhavethe

appropriatelevelofskillsandqualificationstodeliverservices;• AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoplesandnon-AboriginalandTorresStrait

Islanderpeoplesareprovidedwithopportunitiestodeveloptheappropriatelevelofskillsandqualificationstodeliverservices;and

• non-Indigenousprofessionalsandadministratorshaveundertakenmentalhealth

culturalsafetytrainingthatperpetuatestheNationalPracticeStandardswithinasocialandemotionalwellbeingframework,andpromotestheappropriateskills,knowledge,andattitudesrequiredtooptimallydelivermentalhealthservicestoAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples,includingthoseoftheStolenGeneration.146

TheseguidelinesholdgreatpromiseincludingbeyondtheATAPSscheme,whichisnowbeingmergedintothefundingpoolsofthePrimaryHealthNetworks.WhenappliedsuchguidelinescanensureaculturallyappropriateserviceattheverytimewhenavulnerableAboriginaland/orTorresStraitIslanderpersonislikelytoneeditmost.

ConclusionAsthispaperhassetouttodemonstrate,highAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersuicideratesarisefromacomplexwebofinteractingpersonalandsocialcircumstances.

Page 19: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

19

Forthoseconcernedwithsuicideprevention,thecontributorstosuicidecanbethoughtofintermsofriskfactorsatthecommunityandcollectivelevelthatincreasethelikelihoodofsuicidalbehaviour,andprotectivefactors(culturalcontinuity,empowerment)thatreduceit.

Further,thatwhilethe‘causes’associatedwithsuicideamongAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderindividualsareoftenthesameasthatinthegeneralpopulation,theprevalenceandinterrelationshipsamongthesefactorscandifferbecauseofwidercontextualfactors,nottheleastofwhichbeingcolonisationanditsaftermathandtheongoingimpactsoncommunities.

Infact,suicideisjustoneindicatorofdistressincommunitiesandcannotbemeaningfullydiscussedwithoutconsideringalcoholanddruguseandmentalhealthproblems.Allcanbeconsideredsymptomaticoftheneedforhealingatacollectivelevelamongothercultural,historical,andpoliticalconsiderations.

1.LegislativeAssembly,ParliamentofWesternAustralia(2016).Learningsfromthemessagestick,ThereportoftheInquiryintoAboriginalyouthsuicideinremoteareas,LegislativeAssembly.Committees.EducationandHealthStandingCommittee.Report11,ParliamentofWesternAustralia,Perth.

Page 20: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

20

2 TatzC(1999).AboriginalSuicideisDifferent,AboriginalYouthSuicideinNewSouthWales,theAustralianCapitalTerritoryandNewZealand:TowardsaModelofExplanationandAlleviation,AReporttotheCriminologyResearchCouncilonCRCProject25/96–7.Availableonline:http://crg.aic.gov.au/reports/tatz/tatz.pdf.[Verified12Dec2016.]3 McHughC,CampbellA,ChapmanM,etal.(2016).IncreasingIndigenousself-harmandsuicideintheKimberley:anauditofthe2005–2014data,TheMedicalJournalofAustralia,2016;205(1):33.4 DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).SuicideinindigenouspopulationsofQueensland,AustralianInstituteforSuicideResearchandPreventionNationalCentreofExcellenceinSuicidePreventionandWHOCollaboratingCentreforResearchandTraininginSuicidePrevention,AustralianAcademicPress,Brisbane,pp.32-33.5 Above,p.32.6 Above,p.32.7HunterE,MilroyH(2006).AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSuicideinContext,ArchivesinSuicideResearch;2006,10(2):141-157.8SteeringCommitteefortheReviewofGovernmentServiceProvision(2016).OvercomingIndigenousDisadvantage:KeyIndicators2016,ProductivityCommission,Canberra,p.8.42.9AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016).CausesofDeath,Australia,2015,ABScat.no.3303.0.Availableonline:www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/3303.0~2015~Main%20Features~Intentional%20self-harm:%20key%20characteristics~8.[Verified12 Dec2016.]10AustralianHealthMinisters’AdvisoryCouncil(2015).AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderHealthPerformanceFramework2014Report,AHMAC,Canberra,p.59. 11SteeringCommitteefortheReviewofGovernmentServiceProvision(2016).OvercomingIndigenousDisadvantage:KeyIndicators2016,ProductivityCommission,Canberra,p.8.44.12AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016).CausesofDeath,Australia,Above.13NationalChildren’sCommissioner(2014).Children’s’RightsReport2014,AustralianHumanRightsCommission,Sydney,p.62.14AustralianHealthMinisters’AdvisoryCouncil(2015).Above,p.59.15Hunter,E,Milroy,H(2006).Above.16Above.17Above.18Above.19Above.20 ChandlerM,LalondeC(1998).CulturalContinuityasaHedgeagainstSuicideinCanada’sFirstNations.TransculturalPsychiatry;199835(2):191–219.Chandler,M.J.&Lalonde,C.E.(2008).CulturalContinuityasaProtectiveFactoragainstSuicideinFirstNationsYouth.Horizons--ASpecialIssueonAboriginalYouth,HopeorHeartbreak:AboriginalYouthandCanada’sFuture.10(1),68-72.21Above.22Above.23AustralianBureauofStatistics(2010).EstimatesofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderAustralians,June2011,Notes,ABScatno.3238.0.55.001(webpage)http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/[email protected]/Lookup/3238.0.55.001Main+Features1June%202011?OpenDocument.[Verified12Dec2016].24UNGeneralAssembly(2007).UnitedNationsDeclarationontheRightsofIndigenousPeoples:resolution/adoptedbytheGeneralAssembly,2October2007,A/RES/61/295.25AustralianHumanRightsCommission(undated).RighttoSelfDetermination,(webpage)<https://www.humanrights.gov.au/right-self-determination>[Verified3March2016].26TseyK,McCalmanJ,BainbridgeR,etal.(2012).ImprovingIndigenouscommunitygovernancethroughstrengtheningIndigenousandgovernmentorganisationalcapacity,ClosingthegapClearinghouse,Resourcesheetno.10,ClosingtheGapClearinghouse,AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare,Canberra.27Above.28Above.29AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016).NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey,2014-15,ABScat.no.4714.0(webpage)http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4714.0~2014-15~Main%20Features~Social%20networks%20and%20wellbeing~4.[Verified12Dec2016.]30Above.31Above.32DudgeonP,CoxA,WalkerR,etal.(2014).VoicesofthePeoples:TheNationalEmpowermentProject:NationalSummaryReport2014:PromotingCultural,SocialandEmotionalWellbeingtoStrengthenAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercommunities,NationalEmpowermentProject,UniversityofWesternAustralia,Perth.33ChandlerM,LalondeC(1998)(2008).Above.34GeeG,DudgeonP,SchultzC,etal.(2014).‘SocialandEmotionalWellbeingandMentalHealth:AnAboriginalPerspective’,Chapter4,InDudgeon,MilroyandWalker(eds.)WorkingTogether:AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderMentalHealthandWellbeingPrinciplesandPractice–RevisedEdition,CommonwealthofAustralia,Canberra.35AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016).NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey,2014-15,ABScat.no.4714.0(webpage)http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4714.0~2014-15~Main%20Features~Social%20networks%20and%20wellbeing~4.[Verified12Dec2016.]36Above.37Above.38AustralianHealthMinisters’AdvisoryCouncil(2015).Above.39AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016).NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey,2014-15,ABScat.no.4714.0(webpage)AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016),NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey,2014-15,ABScat.no.4714.0(webpage)http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4714.0~2014-15~Main%20Features~Language%20and%20culture~3[Verified12Dec2016.]40AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016).NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey,2014-15,ABScat.no.4714.0(webpage)http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4714.0~2014-15~Main%20Features~Social%20networks%20and%20wellbeing~4.[Verified12Dec2016.]41NiezenR(2009).Suicideasawayofbelonging:CausesandconsequencesofclustersuicidesinAboriginalcommunities.InL.Kirmayer,G.Valaskakis(Eds)Healingtradition:thementalhealthofAboriginalpeoplesinCanada.UBCPress,Vancouver:2009.Referredtoin:SilburnS,RobinsonG,LeckningBetal.(2014).PreventingSuicideAmongAboriginalAustralians,Chapter9inDudgeon,MilroyandWalker(eds.)WorkingTogether:AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderMentalHealthandWellbeingPrinciplesandPractice–RevisedEdition,CommonwealthofAustralia,Canberra.42Above.43TatzC(1999).AboriginalSuicideisDifferent,AboriginalYouthSuicideinNewSouthWales,theAustralianCapitalTerritoryandNewZealand:TowardsaModelofExplanationandAlleviation,AReporttotheCriminologyResearchCouncilonCRCProject25/96–7,p.79.Availableonline:http://crg.aic.gov.au/reports/tatz/tatz.pdf.[Verified12Dec2016.]44DudgeonP,CoxA,WalkerR,etal.(2014).Above.45McLachlanR,GilfillanG,andGordonJ,(2013).DeepandPersistentDisadvantageinAustralia,rev.,ProductivityCommissionStaffWorkingPaper,Canberra,p.48.Referringto:AustralianSocialInclusionBoard(2012),SocialinclusioninAustralia:HowAustraliaisfaring,PrintingBlueStar,Canberra.46Abovep.12.47Above,p.6.Referringto:SenA(2000).Socialexclusion:Concept,applicationandscrutiny,SocialDevelopmentPapersNo.1,OfficeofEnvironmentandSocialDevelopment,AsianDevelopmentBank,June.48Above,p.9.49Above.50Above,p.20.51Above,pp.11-13.52Above,p.12(Table1).53Above.54DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.59.55Above,p.59.56Above,p.59.

Page 21: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

21

57Above,p.60.58Above,p.57.59Above,p.56.60Above,p.58.61 LegislativeAssembly,ParliamentofWesternAustralia(2016).Above,p.3.35.Referringto:WilkesE.etal.(2014)'HarmfulSubstanceUseandMentalHealth'inP.Dudgeon,H.MilroyandR.Walker(eds.),WorkingTogether:AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderMentalHealthandWellbeingPrinciplesandPractice,2ndedition,KulungaResearchNetwork,WestPerth,2014,pp129-130. 62Above,p.3.35.Referringto:Silburn,S.,Robinson,G.Leckning,B,etal.(2014).‘PreventingSuicideAmongAboriginalAustralians’inP.Dudgeon,H.MilroyandR.Walker(eds.),WorkingTogether:AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderMentalHealthandWellbeingPrinciplesandPractice,2ndedition,KulungaResearchNetwork,WestPerth,2014,p.155. 63Above,p.56.64Above,p.3.36.ReferringtoSubmissionNo.17fromLifelineWA,13May2016,p.6. 65Above,p.3.36.Referringto:SubmissionNo.12fromAustralianHumanRightsCommission,13May2016,AttachmentA: Mitchell,M.andGooda,M.,‘SelfHarmandHelp-SeekingAmongAboriginalandTorresStrait ChildrenandYoungPeople’,p.4.66Above,p.3.36.Referringto:SubmissionNo.14fromBeyondBlue,13May2016,p.8. 67Above,p.3.36.Referringto:SubmissionNo.12fromAustralianHumanRightsCommission,13May2016,AttachmentA: Mitchell,M.andGooda,M.,‘SelfHarmandHelp-SeekingAmongAboriginalandTorresStrait ChildrenandYoungPeople’,p.4. 68ClosingtheGapClearinghouse(2014).Fetalalcoholspectrumdisorders:areviewofinterventionsforpreventionandmanagementinIndigenousCommunities.ProducedbytheClosingtheGapClearinghouse.Resourcesheetno.36,AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare,Canberra;AustralianInstituteofFamilyStudies,Melbourne.69LegislativeAssembly,ParliamentofWesternAustralia(2016).Above,p.3.38.Referringto:DrMurrayChapman,ClinicalDirector,KimberleyMentalHealthandDrugService,TranscriptofEvidence,7June2016,p.8. 70FitzpatrickJ,LatimerJ,CarterM,OscarJ,etal(2015).Prevalenceoffetalalcoholsyndromeinapopulation-basedsampleofchildrenlivinginremoteAustralia:TheLililwanProject,JournalofPaediatricsandChildHealth51(2015)450–457.71Above.72Above.73Above.74LegislativeAssembly,ParliamentofWesternAustralia(2016).Above,p.3.38.Referringto:DrMurrayChapman,ClinicalDirector,KimberleyMentalHealthandDrugService,TranscriptofEvidence,7June2016,p.8.75LegislativeAssembly,ParliamentofWesternAustralia(2016).Above,p.3.37.Referringto:DrTracyWesterman,ManagingDirector,IndigenousPsychologicalServices,TranscriptofEvidence,12September2016,p.3. 76HeffernenE,AndersenK,DevA,etal,PrevalenceofmentalillnessamongAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleinQueenslandprisons.MedJAust2012;197(1):37-41.77LegislativeAssembly,ParliamentofWesternAustralia(2016).Above,p.3.41.Referringto:OmbudsmanWesternAustralia,InvestigationintowaysthatStategovernmentdepartmentsandauthoritiescanpreventorreducesuicidebyyoungpeople,OmbudsmanWesternAustralia,Perth,April2014,p.14. 78SteeringCommitteefortheReviewofGovernmentServiceProvision(2016).Above,p.4.87.79LegislativeAssembly,ParliamentofWesternAustralia(2016).Above,p.3.45.80CashmoreJ,ShackelR(2013).Thelong-termeffectsofchildsexualabuse,AustralianInstituteofFamilyStudies,ChildFamilyCommunityAustralia,Canberra.Availableonlineat:http://cdn.basw.co.uk/upload/basw_103914-1.pdf81SteeringCommitteefortheReviewofGovernmentServiceProvision(2016).Above,p.4.94.82LegislativeAssembly,ParliamentofWesternAustralia(2016).Above,p.3.48.Referringto:TheSenateCommunityAffairsReferencesCommittee,ForgottenAustralians:AreportonAustralianswhoexperiencedinstitutionalorout-of-homecareaschildren,ParliamentofAustralia,Canberra,August2004,p.155.83Above,p.3.47.84DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.65.85DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.65.86DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.65.87CentreforHealthPolicy,ProgramsandEconomicsMelbourneSchoolofPopulationHealth,TheUniversityofMelbourne(2012)Developingacommunityplanforpreventingandrespondingtosuicideclusters,LivingisForEveryone(LIFE)Framework,CommonwealthofAustralia,Canberra.p.7.Availableonline:http://www.livingisforeveryone.com.au/uploads/docs/Community%20Plan.pdf88ZubrickS,SilburnS,LawrenceD,etal(2005).TheWesternAustralianAboriginalChildHealthSurvey:ThesocialandemotionalwellbeingofAboriginalchildrenandyoungpeople,CurtinUniversityofTechnologyandTelethonInstituteforChildHealthResearch,Perth,p.340.89AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSuicidePreventionEvaluationProject,MapsandVisualInsights(webpage)http://www.atsispep.sis.uwa.edu.au/maps-visual-insights[Verified12Dec2016.]90DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.15.91CentreforHealthPolicy,ProgramsandEconomicsMelbourneSchoolofPopulationHealth,TheUniversityofMelbourne(2012)Above.p.5.92Abovep.7.93AustralianBureauofStatistics(2013).‘Familystressors’AustralianAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderHealthSurvey:FirstResults,Australia,2012-13,ABScat.no.4727.0.55.001,27/11/13,http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Latestproducts/C0E1AC36B1E28917CA257C2F001456E3?opendocument.[Verified12Dec2016.]94AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare,MeasuringtheSocialandEmotionalWellbeingofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderPeoples,Cat.No.IHW24,AIHW,Canberra,2009.95AustralianBureauofStatistics(2013).‘PsychologicalDistress’AustralianAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderHealthSurvey,FirstResults,2012,ABScat.no.4727.0.55.001,13,27/11/13,www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/9F3C9BDE98B3C5F1CA257C2F00145721?opendocument.[Verified12Dec2016.]96Above.97AustralianBureauofStatistics(2013).‘Familystressors’AustralianAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderHealthSurvey:FirstResults,Australia,2012-13,ABScat.no.4727.0.55.001,27/11/13,http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Latestproducts/C0E1AC36B1E28917CA257C2F001456E3?opendocument[Verified12Dec2016.]98Above.99ChamberlainP,GoldneyR,Delfabbro,P,etal.(2009)‘SuicideIdeation:TheclinicalutilityoftheK10’,Crisis,vol.30,no.1,pp.39–42.100DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.60on.101Above,p.61.102DudgeonP,CoxA,WalkerR,etal.(2014).VoicesofthePeoples:TheNationalEmpowermentProject:NationalSummaryReport2014:PromotingCultural,SocialandEmotionalWellbeingtoStrengthenAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandercommunities,NationalEmpowermentProject,UniversityofWesternAustralia,Perth,p.24.103Above.104DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.64.105Above,pp.64-65.106Above,p.65.107AustralianBureauofStatistics,‘AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderPrisoners’PrisonersinAustralia2015,ABScat.no.4517.0.Onlinepublicationhttp://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4517.0~2015~Main%20Features~Aboriginal%20and%20Torres%20Strait%20Islander%20prisoner%20characteristics~7.[Verified12Dec2016].108AustralianBureauofStatistics,‘Imprisonmentrates’PrisonersinAustralia2015,ABScat.no.4517.0.Onlinepublication:http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4517.0~2015~Main%20Features~Imprisonment%20rates~14[Verified12Dec2016].109DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerAetal.(2011).Above,p.63.110Above,p.63.111Above,p.63.112Above,p.48.113AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016),NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey,2014-15,ABScat.no.4714.0(webpage)http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4714.0~2014-15~Main%20Features~Labour%20force%20characteristics~6 [Verified 12Dec2016.]114Above.

Page 22: The contexts and causes of suicide among Indigenous ... · major public health concern in both the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non- Indigenous populations. Overall in

22

115Above.116DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.54.117ZubrickS,SilburnS,LawrenceD,etal.(2005).Above,p.340.118KlonskyE(2006).Thefunctionsofdeliberateself-injury:areviewoftheevidence,ClinPsycholRev.2007Mar;27(2):226-39.Epub2006Oct2.119AustralianHealthMinisters’AdvisoryCouncil(2015).Above,p.59.120SteeringCommitteefortheReviewofGovernmentServiceProvision(2016).Above,p.8.42.121HarrisE,BarracloughB,(1997).‘Suicideasanoutcomeformentaldisorders.Ameta-analysis’,TheBritishJournalofPsychiatryMar1997,170(3)205-228;DOI:10.1192/bjp.170.3.205.(Notethattherewassignificantvariationsbetweencountries).122AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare(2015).ThehealthandwelfareofAustralia’sAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples2015,Cat.no.IHW147.AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare,p.85.123AustralianHealthMinisters’AdvisoryCouncil(2015).Above,p.59.124AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016).NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey,2014-15,ABScat.no.4714.0,Table8A.7.19Selectedindicatorsofpositivewellbeing,AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopleaged18yearsorover,byStateandTerritory,2014-15(a),(b),(c)(webpage)http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4714.0~2014-15~Main%20Features~Social%20networks%20and%20wellbeing~4.[Verified12Dec2016.]125DeLeoD,SveticicJ,MilnerA,etal.(2011).Above,p.52.126Above,p.60.127AustralianHealthMinisters’AdvisoryCouncil(2015).Above,p.148.128Above.129WorldHealthOrganization(2015).‘Depression’(webpage)http://www.who.int/topics/depression/en/[Verified12Dec2016.].130AustralianHealthMinisters’AdvisoryCouncil(2015).Asabove,p.148.131Asabove.132AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare,(2015).’Characteristicsofpeoplewhousecommunitymentalhealthcareservices’,MentalHealthServicesinAustralia,https://mhsa.aihw.gov.au/services/community-care/client-characteristics/.[Verified29October2015.]133Asabove.134MarrieA,MarrieH(2014).AMatrixforIdentifying,MeasuringandMonitoringInstitutionalRacismwithinPublicHospitalsandHealthServices,Publishedonline:<http://www.avidstudy.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Matrix-Revised-2-9-14.pdf.[Verified12Dec2016.]135AustralianBureauofStatistics(2016).NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSocialSurvey,2014-15,ABScat.no.4714.0,(webpage)http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Lookup/by%20Subject/4714.0~2014-15~Main%20Features~Social%20networks%20and%20wellbeing~4.[Verified12Dec2016.]136AustralianHealthMinisters’AdvisoryCouncil(2015).Asabove.137Asabove.138AustralianBureauofStatistics,EstimatesofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderAustralians,June2011,Notes,ABScatno.3238.0.55.001,http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/[email protected]/Lookup/3238.0.55.001Main+Features1Junepercent202011?OpenDocument.[Verified12Dec2016.]139AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare(2015).AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderhealthorganisations:OnlineServicesReport—keyresults2013–14.AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderhealthservicesreportNo.6.IHW152.AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare,Canberra,p.24.140Asabove.141PanarettoK,WenitongM,ButtonSandRingI,(2014)‘Aboriginalcommunitycontrolledhealthservices:leadingthewayinprimarycare’,200(11)MedicalJournalofAustralia,200(11)649,p.650.142GeeG,DudgeonP,SchultzC,etal(2014).Asabove.143AustralianInstituteofHealthandWelfare(2015).AboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderhealthorganisations:OnlineServicesReport—keyresults2013–14.Asabove,p53,Table7.2.144DepartmentofHealthandAgeing(2012).OperationalGuidelinesfortheAccesstoAlliedPsychologicalServicesAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderSuicidePreventionServices(unpublished)DepartmentofHealthandAgeing,Canberra.145Asabove,p.4.146Asabove,p.5.


Recommended