The impacts of gambling on families and young people
Associate Professor Nicki Dowling and Ms Sophie Vasiliadis
Chair: Dr Anna Thomas
This webinar is part of the CFCA information exchange webinar series, presented in
collaboration with the Australian Gambling Research Centre and the Victorian Responsible Gambling Foundation
Disclaimer
The views expressed in this presentation are those of the authors and may not reflect the views of the Australian Institute of Family Studies or the Australian Government.
Gambling in Australia
Gambling is a common activity in Australia
In 2011 around 64% of Australians gambled On average Australians spend > $1000 per capita in
a year We are the biggest gamblers in the world
Reproduced from The Economist, 2014
Gambling in Australia
Most ‘popular’ activities are lotto, scratch-it tickets, race betting, pokies
Highest spending is on pokies, casino games and race betting
Sports betting still a small market (play and expenditure) but growing rapidly
Gambling Expenditure, 2010-11°
*Australian Gambling Statistics Summary Tables 2010-11 ^ AGRC, Gambling in Australia Fact Sheet, 2014 ° Expenditure after winnings subtracted
GamingMachines Casino Racing
Lotteries,Lotto &Pools
Keno SportsBetting
InstantLottery
MinorGaming
OverallGambling
PER AUSTRALIAN ADULT* $619.98 $215.58 $157.39 $91.37 $16.64 $18.78 $12.23 $1.45 $1,133.42PER ADULT GAMBLER^ $3,169.77 $1,461.79 $697.39 $210.16 $185.77 $140.49 $38.57 $48.92 $1,759.27
$-
$500.00
$1,000.00
$1,500.00
$2,000.00
$2,500.00
$3,000.00
$3,500.00
Year
ly Sp
end
(A$)
Gambling-related Harm
Around 3% of the population experience moderate-severe problems from their gambling
Much larger proportion (possibly 19%) experiencing some concerns/harms related to their gambling
People around the gambler also harmed – perhaps 5-10 people per ‘problem gambler’
Gambling-related Harm
Gambling most associated with harm Linked to expenditure Pokies by far the biggest cause of harm Race betting Online sports betting again a growing phenomenon
Gambling-related Harm
Even a single episode of gambling can cause harm Unable to pay bills Inadequate money for food or socialising
Extended gambling problems lead to major, long term harm to gambler and to those around them unmanageable debt, poverty, homelessness Broken relationships, domestic violence, neglect of children, loss of trust loss of self-esteem, feelings of stigmatisation, social isolation Mental and physical health problems legal or forensic consequences Intergenerational transmission of gambling problems
Assisting those harmed by gambling
Low rates of formal help seeking Gambling problems rarely present in isolation High levels of comorbidity with other issues
Mental and physical health issues Alcohol and other drug issues Financial or forensic problems Relationship problems
If you are seeing people with these issues you are seeing people harmed by gambling
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
THE IMPACT OF GAMBLING PROBLEMS ON FAMILIES
Nicki Dowling Associate Professor of Psychology School of Psychology Deakin University Email: [email protected]
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
CONTENTS 1. What are the impacts of gambling
problems on families? – Impact on family relationships – Impact on the health and wellbeing of family members – Presenting issues of treatment seeking family members
2. How do family members cope with gambling problems?
3. What are the assessment and treatment options for family members?
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
WHAT ARE THE IMPACTS OF GAMBLING PROBLEMS ON FAMILIES?
Impact on Family Relationships Impact on Intimate Relationships
Source: Custer & Milt (1985)
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
Impact on Family Environments • Impaired family environments • Children exposed to family stressors
Common Problems Reported by Family Members The loss of household or personal money
Arguments
Anger and violence
Lies and deception
Neglect of family
Negatively affected relationships
Poor communication
Confusion of family roles and responsibilities
The development of gambling problems or other addictions within the family (Source: Kalischuk et al., 2006)
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
Problem Gambling and Family Violence • Growing international evidence that gambling
problems are associated with family violence • Systematic review (Dowling et al., in press)
• 38% of problem gamblers report victimisation • 37% of problem gamblers report perpetration • 11% of IPV perpetrators report gambling problems
• Violence extends to children and other family members
• Exact nature of the relationship yet to be determined
• Preliminary findings suggest problem gambling precedes both victimisation and perpetration (Suomi et al., 2013)
• Several factors implicated in the relationship • Victimisation: less than full employment, anger problems • Perpetration: younger age, less than full employment, anger
problems, impulsivity, alcohol and substance use
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
Impact on the Health and Wellbeing of Family Members
Impact on Family Member Emotional and Physical Health
Intimate partners Children Emotional disturbances
Anger Resentment Depression Anxiety
Depression Hopelessness Anxiety Confusion Guilt
Physical complaints
Headaches Gastrointestinal ailments Hypertension
Asthma Allergies Chronic headaches
Behavioural difficulties
Excessive drinking Smoking Over-/under-eating Impulsive spending
Running away Alcohol and tobacco abuse Overeating Lower academic/employment performance Illegal acts
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
Intergenerational Transmission of Gambling Problems • Problem gambling fathers: 11 to 14 times more likely • Problem gambling mothers: 7 to 11 times more likely
Risk factors Protective factors • Gambling at a young age • Parental drug and mental health
problems • Personal drug use • Gambling to reduce negative
emotions or increase positive emotions
• Gambling to socialise • Expecting gambling will lead to
positive outcomes (e.g., feelings of control or financial gain
(Source: Dowling, Jackson, Thomas, & Frydenberg, 2010)
• Being female • Having higher social resources and
networks • Being born in Australia • Having more siblings • Expecting gambling will lead to
negative outcomes (e.g., depression or overinvolvement)
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
Presenting Issues of Treatment-Seeking Family Members • Most common family impacts are:
• Impaired familial relationships • Emotional problems • Financial difficulties
Gambling Help Online family member clients
Emotional distress 98%
Impacts on their relationship with the gambler
96%
Impacts on their social life 92%
Impacts on their finances 91%
Impacts on their employment 84%
Impacts on their physical health 77% (Source: Dowling, Rodda, Lubman, & Jackson, 2014)
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
Fina
ncia
l
Emot
iona
l
Rela
tions
hip
Soci
al li
fe
Empl
oym
ent
Phys
ical
hea
lth
Partners Children Parents Siblings
Specific family impacts
Inability to trust gambler 63%
Anger 61%
Depression or sadness 59%
Anxiety 58%
Distress due to gambling-related absences
56%
Reduced quality time 52%
Breakdowns in communication
52%
(Source: Dowling, Suomi, Jackson, & Lavis, unpublished)
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
HOW DO FAMILY MEMBERS COPE WITH GAMBLING PROBLEMS?
• Surprisingly little information • Stress-strain-coping-support
model (Orford, Copello, Velleman, & Templeton, 2010)
• The most common strategies family members use are engaging coping strategies (Dowling et al., unpublished; Krishnan & Orford, 2002)
• This form of coping is associated with reduced health and wellbeing
Stress-strain-coping-support model. Source: Orford, Copello, Velleman, & Templeton (2010)
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
Coping Strategies Employed by Family Members Ineffective coping strategies Effective coping strategies • Nagging • Screaming • Constantly expressing disapproval • Threats • Ultimatums • Punishing • Rationalising • Emotional pleading • Financial assistance • Protective the image of the gambler • Bailing the gambler out of jail • Accompanying the gambler to
gamble • Asking the gambler to leave a venue • Providing referral information (Source: Markchuk, 2001)
• Setting boundaries/limits • Taking one day at a time • Going to church or finding
spirituality • Discovering new interests or
activities • Releasing guilt and responsibility • Recognising gambling as an
addiction • Gaining support • Taking financial control • Seeking professional assistance • Giving respect to the gambler • Making a conscious effort to stop
helping the gambler to gamble • Supporting the gambler in
treatment
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
WHAT ARE THE ASSESSMENT AND TREATMENT OPTIONS FOR FAMILY MEMBERS?
Problem Gambling Significant Other Impact
Scale (PG-SOIS) The following questions may help you determine if someone
else's gambling is affecting you in some way. In the last three months, how often:
1. Have you or your family experienced financial hardship
as a result of the other person’s gambling? 2. Have you experienced feelings of sadness, anxiety,
stress or anger due to the other person’s gambling? 3. Has the quality of your relationship with the other
person been affected by his/her gambling? 4. Has your social life been affected by the other person’s
gambling? 5. Has your ability to work or study been affected by the
other person’s gambling? 6. Has your physical health been affected by the other
person’s gambling? Response format: (0) Not at all; (1) Rarely; (2) Sometimes; (3) Often (Source: Dowling, Rodda, Lubman, & Jackson, 2014)
Assessment Options • Approximately 20% of
Australian treatment-seekers are family members
• Few assessment tools • Problem Gambling Significant
Other Impact Scale (PG-SOIS: Dowling et al., 2014)
• Problem Gambling Family Impact Measure (PG-FIM: Dowling, Suomi, Jackson, & Lavis, unpublished)
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
Treatment Options • May prefer lower intensity interventions • Few treatment specifically designed to
assist family members • Community Reinforcement and Family Therapy
(CRAFT) (Hodgins, Toneatto, Makarchuk, & Vincent
• Coping Skills Training (Rychtarik & McGillicuddy, 2006)
• Several couple-oriented treatments available
• Family members in treatment can improve problem gambling outcomes (Ingle, Marotta, McMillan, & Wisdom, 2008)
Deakin University CRICOS Provider Code: 00113B
KEY MESSAGES • The most common impacts for the family
members of problem gamblers relate to impaired familial relationships, emotional problems, and financial difficulties
• Family members are most likely to employ coping strategies that try to change the excessive gambling in emotional and controlling ways, which may, in turn, reduce their health and wellbeing
• Despite accessing gambling support services at high rates, there are few assessment tools and treatment approaches specifically designed for family members
Familial risk factors for problem gambling and young people
Ms. Sophie Vasiliadis Senior Research Officer
Australian Gambling Research Centre
Acknowledgements
This presentation includes unpublished findings from my PhD thesis, which is unfinished. I would like to acknowledge the support of my supervisors
Dr. Nicki Dowling and Prof. Alun Jackson.
The views expressed in this paper are those of the author and may not reflect the views of the Australian Institute of Family Studies or the Australian Government.
Impacts of problem gambling for children
Vulnerability to problem gambling among young people is higher in households where there is: Exposure to excessive gambling Positive emotional reinforcement for gambling Experience of early life stressors and trauma
Socialisation of gambling
Parents are the primary role models for young people
Parents normalise gambling by involving their children in gambling
“So I grew up thinking that having a bet on the races was very normal, that’s what you did on Saturday. That’s my upbringing.” (Saugeres, Thomas & Moore, 2014, p.137)
Strong positive emotions associated with gambling increases vulnerability (e.g. pride in gambling ‘skill’)
Socialisation of gambling
Gambling without negative consequences can be a strong risk factor
“…[my father] would cover my bets, I would never pay out of my own pocket. So it was always if I won I got the money but if I lost I never saw what would come out of my pocket…So I was always going to be set for a bad experience with gambling.” (Saugeres, Thomas & Moore, 2014, p.138)
Familial risk factors for problem gambling in young people
A range of familial factors are associated with problem gambling among young people, including Problem gambling Alcohol and drug abuse Avoidance coping styles Poor parental monitoring
Childhood trauma and problem gambling in young adulthood Survey of 17-22 year old Canadian students (Felsher,
Derevensky & Gupta, 2010)
Problem gamblers reported higher rates and severity of all forms of childhood trauma examined, compared to non gamblers, ‘at-risk’ and ‘social’ gamblers. Emotional abuse, Emotional neglect Physical abuse, Physical neglect
Neglect was the key risk factor for problem gambling
Childhood trauma and problem gambling in young adulthood U.S. study of adult problem gamblers in treatment
also reported association with parental neglect in childhood. (Grant & Kim, 2002)
Emotional neglect (low affection, nurture) and low protection (low monitoring, rules)
Impacts of familial dysfunction
Impacts of familial dysfunction are experienced by young people in a range of domains, including emotional strain psychosomatic conditions poor school performance behavioural problems legal problems
Case study: Bill*
Mother emotionally distant. Did not show affection. Father was admired, but had a drinking problem Age 11: moved to Australia from NZ Age 11/12: moved house and school Age 12: friend’s dad placed a bet for him on
Melbourne Cup
*Pseudonym
Case study: Bill*
Age 15: placing bets at TAB. Reading form guide ‘locked’ in his bedroom. Made Dad proud because a good NZ boy is good at drinking, rugby & punting. Arrested for stealing to fund his gambling. Dad cried.
Took him to Gambler’s Anonymous. Age 19: “Gambling was the love of my life” Age 25: In Pentridge jail, then homeless
Past year gambling participation among young people Adolescents
Approximately 60% to 70% gambled (Delfabbro et al., 2005; Dowling et al., 2010; Lambos, Delfabbro, Pulgies & DECS, 2007)
Young adults Approximately 65% to 85% gambled (ACER,
2011; Dowling et al., 2010)
Weekly participation by 18-25 year olds in Melbourne
Moderate–risk gamblers & Problem gamblers (n=120)
TAB 18% Professional Sports 13% Pokies – at a club 12% Cards at a house 12%
Internet & casino 10%
Source: YMEGS dataset (unpublished)
Problem gambling prevalence among young people in Australia
Problem gambling Approximately 3-4% of adolescents Approximately 3-6% of young adults Compared to approximately 1% of adults
Moderate-risk gambling Approximately 8-10% of adolescents Approximately 10-25% of young adults Compared to approximately 3% of adults
Signs and Pathways
Pathway 1 (Behaviourally conditioned) Sporty kids – involved in clubs Outer suburbs Friends who also gamble – Social motives Risk takers (not necessarily a risk factor) Access to money – working, family business etc
Signs and Pathways
Pathway 2 (Emotionally vulnerable) Fewer friends (if problem – secondary risk factor) Smoking, drinking, drugs, Poor coping skills Low connectedness – not alone but lonely Depression / Anxiety / Self-esteem Escape, coping motives
Signs and Pathways
Pathway 3 (Anti–social impulsivist) Smoking, drinking, drugs, sex, violence Family violence Familial gambling, drinking, drug use Impulsive and sensation seekers -> Risky behaviour Suspended or expelled Thrill, excitement motives
Conclusion
Family environment has a significant influence on young people’s vulnerability to problem gambling
Young people vulnerable to problem gambling are also vulnerable to range of other problems such as depression, impulsivity, drug and alcohol abuse, tobacco use, and social isolation.
Conclusion continued
Young people often do not present to health services for support with problem gambling
Professionals working with young people (e.g. health, social welfare, education) should screen for and address gambling issues with vulnerable young people
Questions