The Incident at Antioch, by Alain Badiou

7/23/2019 The Incident at Antioch, by Alain Badiou

1/32


2/32

D`e` `k hs phcdh nw ds d p`hsp`k! Ddh Fdhs

gs cdi pfhdhs wkk `k kxpkhckd ks Dacd#ekstks (482 d \jrtuadms (485! d `k hk whk

d pfhs` gh `e` `k 488


3/32

HH b HmtrjbuotHjm

hdek hs dcs kxshk df `k dk d pdhk phhs-

Fdhs kdhk kxphh phhd dcd! Ao`drpk rjuek! wds d pd hs hcks! `k Vk ykds whe Cd 0 d hhe h

`k 485 h fhes `k hkshhks d kxfkdk hs `hshd

cck `e` kxkshk fwhes c \d Odks kcs

fdqk dcd 4868! Ak _juahkr bk sdthm- F wh` `k 480


4/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b HH H

FDB[! R@KDRKV! \@_\@y

Fkk wk kxdchk sck dspks `ksk \ds d `kh hs hR`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`! k s fhk shk sck Fdhs hkds `kdk d hs kdhs`hp p`hsp` d phhs- Vkdks dch#

hd wh` Fdhs `k whhes wh f kehzk k`ks `kc

h R`k Hmohbkmtdt Dmthjo`! hhe `k kd kps `k kkd `k sfik> `k hshh fkwkk ` d nwkek (ds wk ds

phh> `k dk phhd khsh! d! d k> `k sds

eps! pdhks! khks> `k hkkk fkwkk h (d `k k

d hksdhsc (d `k chpk> d `k hhkkk k#

hd phhd ppshhs s` ds k d Vhe`! d `k psshfhh

he hded fkwkk `kc- R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo` hs dphkk wh` Fdhs `k wn h `k dk 5


5/32

Hv b HmtrjbuotHjm

k p`hsp`hk! Fdh kgks `k shedh `k `kdk#` s#

h ds d kxpkhckd qdsh#phhd kk w`h` dcphgks sh#

dh h `hs (4?- k s kxd d kxpd kd hkds c

`hs cpkssk cdh9

4- R`k kxpkrhckmtda hcksh `kdhd ` hks! gs d! `k kdp k `k dfss `d skpddks kx d k`kdsd c pk#

cdk fkk d dhkk- hs e kssd c 488

R`kdk! Fdh whks `d `k ksskk `kdk hks h `k kxhskk

`k pkhe he`! w`h` hs `k chdh d pkss k#

`kdsd f `k hkph kpkhh (408- R`kdk! ppk spkdn#

he! ks ph sshe `k Vfh pkhe Mhe`! d

hs ck hs dwds kdh! cdk `w wk dh `k pds

hks! ds! d `k hfs- Kd` sfskqk pkcdk!

ckk! hs d`k `k hk! `k wdek `d he` wh fk

ckk d`k kss k`kdsd h `k pkskk d dhkk! f `k

kckekk sck`he kw `e` `k khk wn whks! d#

s! pdhks! cshhds! dhkk! d s - R`kdk hs kxpkhckd h

d sksk `ddkhsh d d`k `d shkk9 R`k kss hs hks#hedhs d dk fk pkhk d kk kphdk- Ohek d

hsk dk kkssdh skk ds dchds fk dhk! f cd

fk wkck! kk hdk> `kk d fk `kdhd ep

d kxkd fikhk pshh c w`h` kss d fk dsskssk!

hsd ds `k `kdk#kxpkhck hs sufikothvkw`h` hs sd hh#hd! phdk! hcpksshhsh- G Fdh `kdk hs ds d nh

dfd `k kxpkhckd ph d hkshedh kw

sfikhhhks! kw hkds! d kw kcpdhhks- Ds s`! h cd `dk hc#phdhs p`hsp`! w`h` d kd c h (shk `k hehd

dsk \d! w`c `kdk hs p`hsp`s fk hd! f `hs hs

d khpd kdhs`hp`kdhd kxpkhckdh pks kss

kdc f p`hsp`! w`h` `ds hk k h h k- Mkk`k#

kss! `e` p`hsp`s ckhdh! `kdk cd `dk phk hcph#

dhs `k gks! s` ds phhs! k! d pk`dps kk shkk-

6- Ds d kxpkhckd dhh! d `kdhd pkcdk hs hkk

pk nwkek ( `d cdk d`dshs! f dhcs phcdh

d trut`- G Fdh `s dk kspkhd kdh pks nw#kek! sdkcks `d ksp sck`he h `k kxkd w

dk `kk wh`h d ehk sskc sdkcks! f `k kckekk

Ojpyrhe`tkb Cdtkrhda


6/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b v

sck`he mkw h d w hssk `e` sfdh kcpk#h! d `k prjokburks kddh d kxpdsh kkpk d`k h sk dh fdk- Fdh ds s` d pd d dhs`he

`k kxkss h nwkek d kvkmt! d `k pks ` pk#ks Fdh kshfks (d! phhs! shkk! d k dk kw wds

hnhe d ephe `k pkhs kehzdfk d ddfk

kkcks `d `dk fkck pkkphfk h `k wdnk d kk- `k

w deh `kdk d nk kxdcpk s` d kk eks k `k

dck Dks`s> f kk `kdhd pkcdk hs pkhd d

scd#sdk kk! ds wk ds d ` pkk `d kxpks hs sk#

qkks- R`kdhd `s dk kkd kks ehe skk d

pd> wk pfdf kxpkhkk c` kss R`kdk `d w`d Fdh kks

(she sdk qks ds `kdk! ckk kkdhck `d ks

` f phhs- R`kdk! `wkk! hs `k hh ps#

shfhh d nh ` w`h` wk w `kwhsk `dk dkss-

\`hsp`! hs pd! ks pk ` d d> h hs h pshh

kh`k iek d (`k pik dks`khs d `hs `khzk

phhs (`k dhc phhd `k! f kpks `k `s p#

k f kd` hs wn-?- R`kdk! ds wk seeksk kdhk! s ds `k kxkphd hhcd

`k hsh ` pkks drt dmbpjahthos- Fdh deks! d`k ds! `kdk hs `k k `d cs hshsk sds mkxt tj ( sp#psks phhs (V`dps! 6


7/32

vH b HmtrjbuotHjm

`k _dk! dhe Fdh> hnk gc! w`h` d sp is ds

wk h d kcp dhhc ds h d k! `kdk kkssdh s

h d pfh pdk fkk d ep spkds d h `k s`dw d

kxhshe sdk9 `kdk dk hs hk `k _dk! hkcd fkes Odphd (V`dps! 400- D is ds `k sdk nkkps d wd` kk

phhd dhhhks `d che` hsf hs dchhsdhk wn! s h hs ds

kk wh` `k hkehd `kd psk f `kdk! d hcks ks#

he kk she h w khk- ! `kdk fskks `k sdk

wh` ssphh d hks hsk sck cd hsdk h `hs c#

dfk pxhch- D `k dks phhs d `kdk dk f p

wh` kd` `k> w`k phhs fkcks kcfk h `k sdk! `kdk

fkcks hkhshk d wkdn9 R`kdk! Fdh whks! hs shn pd#

hdcks d dk f hs d nhs ds k hs dk sdek

f Chks s (V`dps! 48;- R`kdk hs hcpkhk

f sdk ksk! f ds f sdk spp! w`h` cd h! wk che`

sd! h d hcdehd hdh! kkk hcpk f `k sfshhks `d

pp h p- R`hs hscp`hsc `kdk d phhs ks ! `wkk!

hcp khph9 `kdk dppd`ks `k hh phhs h hs

kdhs`hp `k sdk! phhs hs ksskhd `kdhd (d`e` hcd sk hk kcsdhs d `k `kdhd k`hqks-

R`kdk hs phhd w`k h hsssks phhd hkds! kk w`k h

`ds shd phhd kpksshs (ds h dshd ks! f h hs

ph hs dhkk ds d kw khk sfikhhkk h

h `k pks d shek spkd-

2- R`kdks ` pkks dk dwds dkssk t`k prkskmt! shdh h `hs! d ds s` `k pk d kw pk kc#

pdh- R`k k p`hsp`hk! Fdh kdfdks `k pdhd`hshd pksk `kdk9 R`kdk hhdks w`kk wk dk h hshd

hck! f h ks h wh` d nh kddfk dcphgdh `d hs ppk

h- dhgks shdh (4?- U`kkk d pd wds whk h

w`dkk pkh h cd fk sk! `kdk kks d hmgkots `k `hsh#d cck hs pkcdk- s pxhch `k _dk ehks h spkhd

dkss `k dedek d sk `k k shdh! w`h` h

cdnks kddfk h k hhhzk ( h `k dsk `kdk! ckk

kpk! f hsd ds `kdk hs d ` pkk h ds chgks hs

cck f sppkckhe `k ddhdfk kxpkhkks hck- hnk p#

hhs! `kdk `ds d fk kcpd sk! hhe f` `k e

wn pkpddh `d hs fnk f d shed pkcdhk d d



8/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b vHH

`k kdhk dsskh d kdhs`hp fkwkk `hs d d d pkhs

Kk w`sk ` h kxpds- R`kdk! Fdh whks! ppsks d dh#

ghd kcpdh `d dhsks c `k kk fkwkk `k kkh

d dcdh kx! `ddk! hkd d `k hsds kd` kcfhkpkcdk (R`k k p`hsp`hk! 464?- R`hs hs `k kcpd#

h fkdkkss h w`h` ck pkcdks seek dedhs d

`kkf kdssk `k kkd d`h d pds kx! f `k ph

d kxpkhkk kkh hm `k pksk cck ds d dhhpdh hspkhd hghk k kxpdsh- R`kdk#` hks d kcpdh

ih wh` `ehd `hs! hnk `k cksshdh cdkhdhsc

kshfk f Udk Fkidch! h w`h` `k she pksk ccks!

hnk `k fkds d sd! dk s`dkk f `k hph kkd

sphks Cksshdh hck! phe d khd Iktztzkht w#hck kkkck c `k sdhs `hshhsc (?85- R`hs hs

d sk f` kdh d dhhpdh! hsd ds `k `kdhd

pkcdk hfks d kgeks d pk#kxhshe hkd!

f ds! h \d O`ks kc! jroks `k kkxkshs hs ` kxhs h `k pksk cck- Ghd! `k qksh s` hkkh hs

hnk _dh \ds cksshdhsc h R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`9 U`d dfk k fhe df d`kh `dek: d kk d fk shpk hkk f cs fk dwdhk d kspk h hs kdkskk! w`d

dhk sdkehks dscdh dk ddhdfk `k sfik phhs

`kdk:

Ds wk kd R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`! h wh fk `kp nkkp h ch`ksk dspks Fdhs kghh `kdk! w`h wk che` kds#

skcfk ds ws9 R`kdk hs dm kxpkrhckmtda prjokburk jr t`k prjbuo#thjm j dm hmmhtk dmb ktkrmda trut` hm t`k prkskmt dt t`k ousp j drt dmbpjahthos fy mhtk! trdmshkmt ckdms- Uk cs ek! `wkk! `d `kkx `k pd f hsk hs k `k skkd kkcks `d hf#

k d `kdhd `- D`e` Dhk Whkzs hehd s pk#

cdk `k pd ddhzk `k psshfhh R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`ds d dcdh ` pkk! k pkcdks wh fk `k hh

hs hhe kxpdsh- Mkk`kkss! Fdhs pd ds d kx fhes

rksjuroks `k dfk phhd d kxpkhckd `kdk! seekss strdt#kehks pkcdhk kdhzdh! d kps tko`mhquks h hs hkd#h wds hs sks! w`h` wk wh w shk h ck kdh- C

`pk kk hs phk fdne `ksk sks `d cd fk kp h



9/32

vHH H b HmtrjbuotHjm

kdhe Fdhs dchk h pd! d sck hkds df wds

ksd `k kdhs`hps `k pd ppsks dce `ksk `kk \ds-

_DMR \D[ DMB R@K _RV[OR[VK

G R@K HMOHBKMR DR DMRHJO@

R`k `kk ds R`k Hmohbkmtdt Dmthjo` dk dck dk `kk dhkhhksBdcdss! Dh`! d Mhkddsshdk wh` kks h kd

O`hshdh cdi shehgdk `k pd! ds wk ds kqk phs

kkkk kskw`kk h Fdhs wn- Kd` d! ckk! hs hhk

h d skqkk skks `d kks `k eh `k O`hshd kphsk

h hs dck ds d ckck `e` k ck gk dkehd

pdks! ahkux9 R`k hd \dk \hhs (d fhe kcp c! R`k\dk `k Ud Vkskks (d chhd p! R`k \dk R`s (`k

edks d d! R`k \dk O`hks (d d! d R`k

\dk Gdhs (d h h hs- D ! R`k Vd Bdcdss!

kks `k kekd ksh kk kpk h `k Fn Ds

w`kk `k \`dhskk _d! pkhs d zkds pksk `k `kkhd Ikss! kks `k hsk O`hs `k d c Iksdkc

Bdcdss sckhck d ?; OK- Gdhe c `hs `sk! `k hs kcp#

dh fhk f `k hsh! f dhsks wh` kks pkk ds \d9 kx ps

d Dpsk O`hs `k ekhk dhs- G Fdh! `k d

Bdcdss kcfkcdhzks `k nh kkd fkdn `d hs `k hh

`k kckekk d kw sfik> h `hs 485; R`jrhk bk ad ojmtrdbho#thjm! `k whks! dch! wh` d `kshdh! `d Cd 0 ck

wds - - - d khdfk d Bdcdss (8- \ds ksh `kd Bdcdss hs Fdh d he d c sck dsk

hkd he wd d kw hk! f d `kf! d dksd

`d s`dks `hs k fkhe d sfikhhzks `hc ds pd `k khk

nw ds `k F O`hs- R`k kxpkhkk wh kd kw hkds!

f h hsk h hks kps! d kqhks `he ck `d `k

dh` hkshedh d kxpdsh `k kks skqkks- \ds

ck `hs sfikhk khkdh hs `k dh` Dfd`dc! d `k

Vd Bdcdss kxks `k hhkhd k Dfd`dcs pd`

@dd! w`k `k `kks Es d e c sk (akn`akn`d d `kshdhe kdks `hs dch! d! d `hs k sk- R`hsdik kpdk che skkcs kkk h `k pkssh



10/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b H

skks h D c k dkehd pdk `k kx! wh` k9

fkehhe h `k hd \dk \hhs! h cks `k \dk `k

Ud Vkskks! c `kk `k \dk R`s! d ks h `k \dk

O`hksspphe s` `k \dk Gdhs! w`kk `k pd whk- R`hs skqkk skks h D ksdfhs`ks d hkd k h hs

hs ckck c k kw \dk `k kx! d shcpk dik

O`dek `d Ds d wh cphdk d ch-

D hs R`k hk d Dh` ppk! dck dk `k hspk

fkwkk \d d \kk h df ;< OK k `k sds Ikwhs` dw h

`k Cksshdh kdd kphsk w`sk hcpdk! Fdh whks h `hs

fn _dh \d! h hs hcpsshfk kkshcdk (6- R`k #

ks dhsks d `k dcs Iksdkc Okkk w`kk \d kkhks `hs

chssh `k ekhks d cks d `kd w`k \kk dk hshs \ds

ekedh h Dh`- R`k O`hshds kkk h Iksdkc k `k

kdks`hp \kk (Okp`ds! h @kkhzk Ddcdh d Iksss f`k

Idcks hshsk `d Ikwhs` O`hshds cs hk w Ikwhs` h#

d dw! hhe hchsh d `k hkd ks nds`rut! d `dekhks cs fkck pdhhe Ikws ds pd `kh ksh

`k cksshdh sk- G \d s` fskdh `k dw dhs edsp `kksskhd hcphdh dh` h Ikss! fkdskd kds dhe k

dhh Ikwhs` cksshdh spkdhd pkhs hd dw wh

fk sspkk w`k `k Cksshd` cks- Dhe \ds d

`k hhk h Eddhds! w`k \kk gs hshk `k \dhk `` h

Dh`! k dk kk wh` #Ikwhs` O`hshds! kk df `k

dws nds`rut> f wh` `k dhd ckcfks `k Iksdkc ``!\kk dedh fskks `k hkd kedhs! d cd ckcfks `k

Dh` ekedh w `hs kxdcpk! hhdhe \d! d pkhed kkp s`hsc wh`h kckek O`hshdh df `k dw- \d deks

`d \kks dh hs `phhd! f ck shehgd `d h

khks `k dfsk shk O`hss sdhgk f hcphe `d fk#

hkk `k dw hs sh d kkhk ckds ishgdh9 Ghkh d

dwkss! \d hshss! dk cd kxshk kdhs`hps `k w

`hshd dscdhs hdedk f `k Cksshd`s dk- `hs

fn _dh \d! Fdh deks `d \ds pshh hs fk`d

Gdh` d dw! f s d pd` hded `d ppshh9 hs

`d cchdhd cdnhe (hchsh! hks! `k ckhs fsk#

dk `k dw hs hkkshfk kks- hs `d `k pskkd

hcpkdhk ` kks `k dk hmbhkrkmt (w`h` hs wsk- `ds



11/32

b HmtrjbuotHjm

shehgdh! w`k`k pshhk kedhk (6?- G \d! `k hh#

kkk `k dw ckds `d k cd hkk fskk `k dw f !

ds `k whks h 4 Oh`hds 5! `s c! ds h ! ds h h wkk wh`

k! fhhe- R`k khpd hcphdh w fk `d kcd khk pdhk `k dw! f h fskdk hs skk

ds d dhchd d hfkdh! w`h` w ed `k dw kedhk

kd-

R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`! `hs hkd wh fk dskk `k #ks fkwkk ppks khd ksh d kc#

hs ksh! d wh dw Fdhs `khk \dd dhdk d

kw ppshh hccksdk wh` khd phhd hssks-

R`k ckck dce skh pdks h D kshfks d nh sdh

shdh dce ppsk pshhs hkhdfk hkpkdhs

`k kks h D ! hnk `k h fkwkk \kk d \d d Dh`-

_nhpphe `k hd \dk \hhs! h fkehs h `k chhd \dk

`k Ud Vkskks d cks h skk 6 k skp wd (dhe

`k skqkk ksdfhs`k h D `k \dk R`s! k

h skk ? `k \dk `k Ud Vkskks> skk 2 sks dedh! `hs

hck s`#hhhe `k \dk R`s d kdphe hk `k \dk O`hks! fkk dedh khe h skk ; `k hhhd \dk `k

Ud Vkskks- Kd` ckck d fdn pkks kh`k `s

`hks! f kh`k pdssks `e` f`! d kd` ks w`kk h

fkehs! h `k \dk `k Ud Vkskks- R`ksk pd`s! `wkk!

kshfk `k h shcpk pshhs! k w`h` hs ck k

`d `k `k! f `k pks d shdh h kdh w`h` d kw

pd`! hded `d ppshh! hs ppsk-

D hs hk R`k Oh Mhkd! dk w`d wk che` d `kgs hkdhd `k O`hshd `` kk f `k Kcpk

Osdhk h ?6; OK! w`kk dckd hk wds kfdk! h#

he `k kxk qksh `k sfsdk O`hss hhh! d `k ph#

hpks d hksd! d`h! O`hshd `` wkk kdk- R`k

kss `k Mhkk Oh d `k Kcphk ksdfhs`k f Osdhks

ckek Vck d O`hshdh che` skkc fk `k hshhd #

sk `k dhd sfikhk skqkk pkk f _dh \d- G Fdh!

`wkk! `k Ghs Oh Mhkd kpksks d dhd kw ck hd#

khd `hnhe! k hk h `k wn @kek! Cdx! d Cd! d

sh wh` ksks k- R`kjry j t`k _ufikot Fdh hsssks `kMhkk Oh ds kxkcpd `k hdkhs k hhks h w-



12/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b H

R`k kfdk d Mhkd `d pks Rhhdhd `ke hks `k #

h fkwkk w pshhs `d dk f` gd kdk `kkhd9 `k

khdhs `k he` d k Dhdhsc! w`h` deks `d O`hs

hs Es ghk kdh! hhk! `cd> d Bkhsc! w`h`dhcs `d `k _ hs dfsk hhk! hghk! ckk d kxksh

kxpkssh E `k Gd`k- Fdh kcdks `k kss `k

Mhkk kfdk ds `k @kekhd hdkhs k d pdk (kcs

`d dhhpdk `hs dk kps kk d shdh9 k E

hhks h w ds `k k E hs pdk h `hshd hck d

spdk ds O`hs- R`k Mhkk kk! Fdh deks! ks kdk `k

cshd s`kshs Gd`k d _ hd `k ckhdh `k @ _phh!

f d dhd hdkhs sk#hhsh! d sphdhe sh d pkh#

hzhe shssh c w`h` k kckeks! ds `k pk pdssdek c

k skqkk `k `k (48-

D R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`! sk khk h `k \dk G#dhs! `k pdssdek h d dhd kw skqkk dfds spdhd

ckck khk- skd hs skks dk hhk h d skhks `s

`k d! ddhe c sn h skk 4 `k chk `k he` h

skk 6! d 2 DC h skk ?! d ed dw h skk 2! 4


13/32

HH b HmtrjbuotHjm

wk! kdsh s`k d hs ekh kdhkk`kkss `k

cck h hs kkd! hksd! d k-

Uk d hdedc `k ckck skks h `k `kk ds R`k Hmoh#

bkmt dt Dmthjo` ds ws9

JGGHOHDA\JAHRHO_

DORJMK

BDCD_O[_

DORRUJ

DMRHJO@

DORR@VKK

MHOKD

UDV

VK_KVWK_

RV[R@_ O@JHOK_ GJ[MBDRHJM_

P P P P

P P P

P

CHBMHE@R

MJJM

2 DC

4< DC

BDUMB[_N



14/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b HH H

\D[ O@KM9 GVOME D MB R@K EKMKVO

Kk kdk Fdhs p`hsp` nws `d hs `hnhe hs p# fdsk h sk `k d `k cks kcpd cd`kcdhs-

R`k seeksh `d `hs dcd ds kks cd`kcdhd hkds cd fk

ck sphshe! f pk`dps hs dhs`- Dk d! w`k \d

O`k sk `hs p `k khdfhh `k hc `p`kshs

(w`h` Fdh shks d kk N Ek h 48?! Ek wk

fdn `d kdhe p `d d shchd pkdsd kk ck ds

skkhe d kd e pd- D`e` wk che` spkdk w`k`k skkhe

Fdhs pd che` `dk d pkdsd kk shchd `d pk f

`k kcsdh d kd e cd`kcdhd p! wk d h d

dsk g seekshs h R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo` Fdhs kxksh O`ks hkds h `k kdcs phhs d d- O`ks wn eks fdn

Eke Ods 4055 hc `p`kshs! w`h` deks `d `k

kx deks hgh dk `k scdks hgh w`k cfks hs `k

sk d kd cfks! `k hc phs `k cfk hk- Fk#

dsk `hs hs `k mkxt fheeks hgh! Ods `p`kshs pkk `k pk`dps hghk ck pks dek hghhks `d `d pkhsfkk khdfk- 48?0 N Ek pk `d `k hc `p`#

kshs hs hkk shsk wh` `k sdd YkckGdknk dxhcdhzd#

h Odhd sk `k (dffkhdk YG! d cc dh

ck cd`kcdhs> h 48?! `wkk! \d O`k pk d ck

YG h w`h` `k hc p`kshs hs dsk- R`hs k Ek d O`k

k `d `k hc `p`kshs hs hkpkk c YG!

pd d scd ep sdkcks h sk `k `d dk khdfk-R`k hcpdk `hs hsk hs cd`k f `k kcdndfk k`hqk

`d O`k kkpk pk `k kw ck YG! w`h` `k dk

jrohme! d w`h` hks fk kcs ekkdhk cd`kcdh#d hdh- Ghe hks dihhe d dckd ck YG

d ekkh sk! k `d! O`k whks! kis spkhg ppk

`k ck h hs dk ! d `d h d sksk hs `p`khd hcdeh#

d! hsd ds h hs d pd nw hghk sk- U`kkds `k ckc#

fks d shfk sk dk kkchk f pdhd hhs `d

`k d sdhs! d ekkh sk hs d kh kkcks `d dk

hgk f d s` hh! f kkchk ckk f hs ckcfks- F

dhe kk k s` cdnk sfsk d ehk ck! O`k whks!



15/32

Hv b HmtrjbuotHjm

k w dk d ck` dih cd d `s kdk cd hkk

cks wh` dhs ppkhks! kw cks `d dk wkdn k

(ds ppsk `k sek d ck dchhd h hcphdh!

fdsk `k pchsk k kxksh `k ekkh sk- R`k sppk#ckdh d ehk sk#`kkhd ck wh` s` d fdk hskhfk

ekkh sk ks `k kkddh kk sdkck h `d ck! wh`

hkkchdk d hghk kxpdhe skqkks! kdhe! pk`dps!

d khk kw cd`kcdhd w-

Fdh whks h `k hh Fkhme dmb Kvkmt `d O`kskps ksdk wk fk `kh k`hd dhh! w`h` `ds #

gk `kc p h w `k ddkch dkd `k `he` spkhdhss

sk `k (4- D `hs hs pkhsk `hs pik9 kxk O`ks

kps he d `k ekkh `k kdcs! hhe phhs

d d- Dkd h R`kjry j t`k _ufikot (fdsk skchds khkkfkwkk 485; d 4858! d whk ck kss shcdks wh`

R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`! Fdh kkps `k hshh fkwkk #shfk sks d ehd hcphdh! `k k `d! d ekkh sks

d he! `k `k! h `k phhd qksh `w hcched

wnks w` hkxhs dk hkd kxk h `k dek phh#d w d ck h kxhskk (h `hs dk kche dppkdr-s h d qksh kxkhe ckk wnks `k he`s `k

ckk`d hs! she `kc ds ppk ckcfks

`k dh dhe wk#kgk hkhd hhzks`hp: \k`dps `hs

w fk d wkck kkpck! f `k kd phhd hssk `kk! d#

he Fdh! eks fk `k pik hkdshe `k cfk k#

ehzk ckcfks `k sdk9 `sk w` ke `k cs hcpd

chgdh dk s c` `k hcched wnks `kcskks! kk h`k sd` p `k he` k! s c` ds `k Gk`9 `k Gk` wn#

ks w`c `k sfksh `kh dhd hkh! phk `k dk

swkp p h `k pkss! sfikhhzks d`k hsh d d`k pdhk

phhs (R_! 6;- wk `hn `k hcched wnks ds dekmkrho skt! kgk f d hhe `ddkhshs! f ds d hghkep `kkekks shedhhks! `kh dhh ds s` d sk jroks`k dscdh `k khk dh! w`h` d ek fk kgk

f `k sdck dxhcs hkh- _` d dscdh hs `k #

h `hshd kkssh ehd hcphdh> Fdh whks! R`k

$ `k k hs hcphk f `k d hhs- hs k f

`k hkxhskk d dfsk sdh `d w k sfchssh



16/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b v

`k hcckhdk hh h d dskk wd (R_! 65?-7 Ghe h`hs sksk hks d sfikhk dhk! fkhe swkp p h `k pkss

d wdekhe `d `k ekkh sk wh `dk fkk cpkk- R`hs hs

kxd fh dh`! f w`d Fdh ds gkk9 d kw c khgdfk nmjwakbek wh` hcckhdk skqkks h `k w- he skkcs wkdn cpdk wh` `k ske` ehd hcphd#

h! `hs hs pkhsk hs ske`9 Ghe ks dek! kxdcpk!

`d shd dhh hcpahks `k kkssh kh! f d`k`d `kk hs mjt`hme t`dt rkquhrks t`k ojmthmuhme bjchmdmok j t`k ajodaojmbhthjms! `he pkkhe `d ekkh sk c kxkhe h `khhs d dhd kw phhd w-

hs 4885 fn _dh \d! Fdh seekss d hn fkwkk O`ks

kps d _dh \ds cksshdhsc- Kxpdhhe `hs dh \ds

`hnhe! ksphk `hs dn hsfkhk h `k k \ds kkdh!

Fdh whks `d \ds dfuajus jrohme j t`k rkda phks s wh`ckhdh w`k h hs d qksh kshe `k hksd hs pk sk#

dh! `kk d w (_dhmt \dua! ;! kcp`dshs dk- \ds hssk hsdfs Fdh! ckk d dfk! f kk`kkss h jroks `k p#

h kw nwkek df `k hksd! shk d khehshh- Fdhs `ddkhzdh _dh \ds pik ds he

`k kd hns `hc wh` `k kshd Ikwhs` kp `dskhe

he `k dk `k cksshdh kd! h kk cpkhe E

d è` `cd dek- _` he wds d pdshfk dsdh

dedhs d Cksshdhss! hhe `k kd O`hshds9 Uds `k k#

ddh `d Ikss wds `k Cksshd` pkhphs d kcsdf k#

ks! shk! k `he! `k `d hk d hk wh` kkhe `k

dhd shd d phhd dscdhs dhhd dsshdk wh``k Cksshd`: Fdhs kdhe! \ds kspsk hs `d Ikss whaa `dvkfkkm `k Cksshd`! è` `k gkk `sk hnk `hcsk w` p#sk `k ekkh hksdhsc hcphk f `hs kskh- R`d hs! is

ds \d O`k ks `k k pkk ph chd kw sk

`kkhd ws f `k ch dhh d ekkh sk! s _dh \d

ks Ikss `dk fkk `k Cksshd` f `k dhh `k ekkh

sk O`hshds! d sk! wk kd! `d hs kkchk f wd

cdnhes s` ds hchsh hchsh- D is ds O`k

kdfks `k kdh se kw cks cd`kcdhs è`

`k wkdn k`hqk he! s \ds chhd hssk wkdn#mkss `ds `d `k ske` hk skkd kw ws (;?- Uk kd



17/32

vH b HmtrjbuotHjm

Udk Fkidchs hsssh Ndnd! w`c! k whks! `k Cksshd`

wh whs` `dek `k w f k f wh ckk cdnk d she`

disck h h (_kakotkb Urhthmes! W- 6! 044- R`hs hs `k cksshdhsc

k f jrohme! h w`h` `k she` disck pk f`k dhh `k dcs `he d ekkh sk hs ke` `dek

dcs kk`he- D `hs hs `k psshfhh dscdh `d \dd

wh fsk hnk h R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`-

\D[ OD[BK DMB R@K CDRKVD_ G

R@K HMOHBKMR DR DMRHJO@

\d O`k skkcs d hnk ksk dcd! \d Odk

phhd d khehs skdhk! dkk hpcd! pk`dps kk dp#

ehs \dhche` skkc fk d hnk hkd d Fdh-

Dè` Odk hs kss kd d pkck d `d `k k wds!

Fdh hs dk h shkhe `hc fk `k cs hcpd c#

k Gk` dcdhs fkk `k wd- Odks `kdk wds hnk d#

`he fkk h h Gdk! d h hs sh shed kcdhe9 hehshdksk! psèhd! k k`k h Od`hhsc! d sckhcks

kcs e! h hs d scfhs `kdk pdsshdk hkds- d kk

c 4082 `k dcdhs Cdhk \k`k! Odk spkdks `k

psshfhh d `kdk è`! d `hs dfk d hs w`d Fdh

gs ksskhd h `hc9 d dcd h w`h` hkds dk kpkskk

f ds ojmsthtutkb f w`d `dppks sdek- R`k Okmtury! Fdhcdnks `k kxpkk cpdhs Odk wh` Fk`! dehe `d

f` dcdhss w`d `ks `k kd hs kk kh`k nwkekdfkwhsc hd cdh- U`d hs kqhk hskd hs d kghhk d

kdhdhe kk! ek`k wh` d dfsk sffkss h ps#

he `k skqkks `hs kk `k k k (- 4;! p- 6


18/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b vHH

Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo` sk ws c` `k p Ad Whaak9 F`pds fkeh wh` d fsk phhd hshs d d dc h kdks`hp! d

hk shdh wh` khk sh- F` pds dk whk h `k d#

kcd` d ekd Gk` phhd kk `d skkcs `dk hs sk9 Odk! `k \dhs Occk! Fdh! Cd 0- F` pds #

`k qksh `w kk sck pd `ksk kks fk

`kh dppdk kchdh> `w! `d hs! jrok `k k shdh`e` gkk `d `k fdk hskhfk dks `sk kks

hkk shk kkcks d kw d kxpdhe ekkh sk-

Fkdsk Odks pd hs s shhk Fdhs! sck dchhdh

d kds wh` `k p d kxk Ad Whaak wh fk `kp kdhe

R`k Hmohbkmt- Odk wk d gs ksh Ad Whaak h 408< (pfhs`kh 408?! d h 4085! w`hk d hpcd h O`hd! shehgd khsk h-

hs `hs sk ksh! pfhs`k h 48


19/32


20/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b H

dce `kc! d khecdhd pdhcs ksk `k pchsk `d d#

fk nkp! `k swkkkss `d w`h` hs wh` `k kek `d w`h`

hs ! d ` wh` `k dk k! kk ds s`k kdks hk (442-

hs ! d s dks `d k wh shk `k hs kw dws- `k hehd ksh `hs wk#nw pkc Ckc U- F-

ykds! Dk wk `d Rhck - - - wh pd \d Odkpd

`hc! pkscdf! hs phhs d psshf `hs Od`hhsc- F kk

`e` `k hs d d`khs d shkdf `k k Dk phhd!

Fdh skkcs kk kk ehk dpehzk Odk h R`kHmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`- G Fdh! Odks pksd khehs phh#d phhs dk hkkd cpdk wh` `hs kpd d dks`kh

seeks h Ad Whaak9 `hs dkcp hk d kw dcdehd dedek!d dedek `k ph kw hkds khe `w wk s`d hk-

R`k pdhd k `sk hkds hs gd ds hcpd ds `k

gkk h `k psshfhh `k kw `d `k shed- G Fdh! d

hs `k kd gek h Odks pd! d `k k \dd h R`k Hmohbkmtekd kxpds `k h! kspkhd h `k `h d! w`hk s`hhe `k

hkh `k kkdh c kheh phhs- G Odk! ds

k d `k k `k pd scfhzks `k pchsk kkwk phhd#`kehd hk! k `k dsphks `k sphhd i- R`kk hs! `wkk!

hhdh `d s Ok `ds fkk dkk f `k gd ksdh

kdk! `d `kh pds `k Oh wh fk hkk f h- Ds s

ks `k! Ucd! pdk hs wh` sd `hs hs pkhsk `k

ph ds wk9 d `ds pdk h `k kdsk Oh- _`k ks kp#

ksk d pdhd pshh dce `k dhs hks sdek> s`k hs! h

Fdhs sksk! shk pdk! d `k sdek dppkdhe d hsdp#

pkdhe sheds `k kkd dk `k ` s`k dks- d hs `kdsk `k kshk `dek! wh` spkhgdh hchdh- Ds s`k

sds! `k w` `kds ck hs k kpsk kk d `k `e` `d

`k `ds h9 _`k ks shs! kskss gkk h `k

psshfhh dscdh- Ds `k pchsk `d d fk nkp! s`k hs

d pchsk `d wh fk fnk! f d hcpsshfk pchskhkk! `k

pchsk j`k hcpsshfk! `k hkx d pd` hchk `k pdecdhqkshs w`d hs psshfk `d `k hs kw kdks wh f

kk - Fdh ksds `hs hk! `k pchsk `d d

fk nkp! ds Odks kghh wcd (R`k Okmtury! 62- R`hs ks ckd! `wkk! `d d hs d phd wcd `k pk Ucd>

d`k! wk che` sd `d d hs shfk! h \d O`ks sksk9



21/32

a b HmtrjbuotHjm

d hs wcd pkhsk hsd ds s`k hs f` shed d ekkh- Ds s`k

sds h k gd spkk`! dc ` wh` `k dk k d k w` ks

ck hs kk wh` hhhe `k k c `k `k- d hs hh#

kk `k ppshhs d dkehks `d edhzk `k w R`kOhty ds h hs> s`k `ds pdk `kk! f hskd phs dmjt`kr wjrab! dsk fsk! f kkchk f kxhshe phhd dkehks- ds gd

ksdh dhdh! fkk s`k s ekk kd`! ks wh` d

cpkhe hcdek9 @k w` sks `hcsk w ck wh nw `w

sp- U`k`k `k kw Oh wh hkk w `k kcdhs kdh!

d pk qksh- R`kk hs `he `d hcphks `d h cs! f pk`dps

wk wh fk dfk sd! `e` `k hkkh R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`!`d `k nwkek hs psshfhh wh `dk fkk k-

R@K HMOHBKMR DR DMRHJO@

Bksphk hs kkkks `k fdmahkuks! ckhd! `k d cchsc!Ddf wnks! d `k cdnks ck Gdk! `k skhe

Fdhs gd ksh R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo` hs dfsd d k#kkchk! c` hnk `k sk ksh Odks Ad Whaak- F` k#hshs dk shcphgk d ekkdhzk! ds h dh `k pdhdh

`hshd d ekedp`hd kx `k sdnk `k hcckhd d

dcd hkds- R`k w h w`h` Fdhs pd dnks pdk! cpsk

s`ds d decks Odks pkh dedek! hs d w h w`h`

`k \dhs Cd 480 d `k \dhs `k 4054 Occk kek

ds shchd `hshd kks! f ds shed Kks `d d d

`hshd hc- R`k Hmohbkmt ks s dkss \d Odks Oh`e` `k k`hqk he pdhk f \d Rdss d cd#

hzk f \d O`k-

D ! R`k Vd Bdcdss! fkehs h `k hd \dk \h#

hs! w`kk `k k shdh hs dh 9 R`k dck Oh `ds fkk

ddek f kch hsks! d `k ekck hs dpshe- \hhhds

`k he` d k! `k whs` f`ks Ikd d \hkk Cd! p

dshk `kh hkkks d `k k `k khk kk sdkscd

Odk Whkcfd c d dhd h ekck! ds `k

kcdhhe `pk dkhe hsdsk- R`k dhd Okp`ds! `k `k

`d! fs `k w`ksskss d kxhshe phhd hssk

d kiks w`d `k skks ds kspkdk dkcps sddek `k sdk> `k



22/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b aH

kdcs d kw phhd k d edzks p d `k sd pwk `d

w skkcs wh`h kd`- R`k skdh `kk sk ws `k pkhe

R`k Ohty! wh` Whkcfd h `k k dcfk k Fksck! d `k pd

`k ckd` khd wh` d pdssh ksh pdk fOkp`ds- Fdh sdcpks `kk hfkd c Odk! fwhe hh#

hd ws! sd`ks hdek! d sckhcks khk p`dsks c

R`k Ohty! d hcks kdhe `kc hd! d `k chhe kcfh#he `kc- F d shsk k##k kdhs`hp fkwkk brdcdthspkrsjmdk h `k w pds d fk ksdfhs`k9 _ckhcks Fdhs`ddks spkdn hks dw c skkd hkk geks h Odks

pd! d sckhcks hks c k Odks `ddks dk hhk

dce ck `d k gek h Fdh- _ Whkcfds spkk`ks cfhk

hks c f` dcfk d shk k Fksck! d \dds hk kk#

cks f` ds d Oks hssks h Ad Whaak- k kksds h Odks pd shks d shs sk`sk p`dsks d

hcdeks `d ck h Fdhs pd `kh w d! hnk kkcks

d kdc wn> f kskw`kk! Fdhs dppphdhs d chgd#

hs Odk skkc pkhsk d sdkeh- G kxdcpk! h D ! skk

4 f` Ddk d Okp`ds kk phcd skks `kh phhd dek9 Odks pd! h hs Ddks ckc pfh hhkkk h `k dk

d pksd ss `d cdnks `hc w kd wh` d k hnk `k he

k ksk `k e kd` `k w- @k ns w

d `k Oh! w`kk `k skks `k pkpk nk h `k phss `kh w

khdh! d wds hfkdk `kc c `k ph `d hs

`kh hks- Fdhs ksh! h hs d skk phk fdh! `k fsk#

h `k dw! `d eddhzk Okp`ds! d hks `hc w pek `k

h `e` gk d k- D w`kkds h hs bkdt` `d Ddk wds ksk d w `d ds ek h! Okp`ds skkns d kw admeudek! kwkshkk! shsk wh` `hs \khk dck! d kw dw w`kk h#

d dw kdks - R`k kshk kd` hs k#ksdfhs` d hchhe! ke#

d phhpk (kd`! dw `d `ds fkk pk9 R`s f` Ddk

d Okp`ds dk rkdothjmdry khdhks! kd` de` h `k hhshk `hs w rksskmthckmt d kd` wnhe dsc `k d`k `d hsk `k kw- D f phe dw h `k pdk Bkd`

h Odks kx! Fdh dh cdnks `k \dhk deck `d h hs `k

dw hsk `d `ds fe` kd` h `k w- F` Ddk d Okp`ds

dk chdk f ckchks hishk `d `k whs` kh! d kh#

`k hs shcp kck f `kh d`s- F kd` hs hchk f d



23/32

aHH b HmtrjbuotHjm

`k kcs `k phcd skks `d sk `kh khd kshks

d hk `kc `k pds- R`sk skks dk h d sksk `k hksh

Fdhhd kks! d fk dh` `kc hs hek h `k pdh#

dh phdk ws- k `kh hhhd kshk hsh hs d`hkk`kk hs `he k kh`k Ddk Okp`ds f hsdppkd wh`#

dk skqkk-

_kk 6 D hs sk h `k \dk `k Ud Vkskks! `k dkehd

s dcchh `k shkdh phhs f `k ckds- @kk

wk skk `k hd Whkcfd! w` ek fkhkks h `k psshfhh

`dek9 Dh ckk fks d phkss kkssh! `k ccks! kk#

`he cks df wh` cpkk pkhdfk kss- \dd! Whkcfds

fkdh d sdek `dhscdh shsk! dekks wh` Okp`ds `d `#

he wh fk edhk `e` kchs phhks! f s`k hs kh`k kshek

phhd kd hnk `k f`k cchk Okp`dss khd

hsh- \dd kks hkxphdf hfkdk c `k sdhs `hs

d wcks khd ks- _`k fkhkks `d d kxhshe ds

phhd pwk dk hdkqdk! f ds k s`k hs sk `w psk

`k dscdhk gd ck dhd `d `k d ksh

khshk f Okp`ds`d s`k fsk sksks9 U`d ckdskpwk f: s`k dsns `k f`k- R`k pwk dedk chs ed#

ks! w`kk `k fxws `dk is fkk pk: R`k pwk `s

h `k fdmahkuks! d `k d edks! pfh dsp: R`k pwk# ckd` `k Ddfhd sds: Bks Wkhk dw hs k c

`dhe k d d dck: \dds hkd d kdh nh pjwkrj pjwkrakssmkss hs kd `k pd! d k `k sk D `kkdh cshes wh kkp h sfikhk kdh- \dd fkhkks

`d `k cdkhds `dek dk dkd d `d! f `k gkk hshhhk d h`dkck kxhskhd `d kpd- U`k d hdph#

dk fdks`hp dppkds h `k `df! kpkskhe `k fskskk

khd chhd che`! \dd sdks `k k scfh s`hp f

`whe `k kkkchk k sd (ao`drpk rjuek h `k wdk!f s`k dnwkeks `d `k eksk hs dcfhes9 Bks s`k dh

`k fdks`hp wh` `k kcfkc kh! hs s`k dnhe kdk

f` scfs: Ds h whe `k `x Cdxhs dh phhd

kdh h `k ckds ph! skk ? hks \dds hkshedh

d `k edks d d! R`k \dk R`s- R`kk \dd! `k Ddf `s#

fd Cn`d! d d d wnk! Cddck \hk! sdk `k wnks

`kh kk kxpkhkk `k kd- F \dd `kk hs ek



24/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b aHH H

d kdh `kk- R`k wnks dk shk d `k khd hssk

`k ` df fkhks `k khdh `k pd phhs d `k

d! w`h` `k kkns wh` `k sk` d kd _dk- R`k h hs

dkd h dcks d `k cks ek dpp! d s`k dk sksks`k hccdkk d kw w h `hs h- G \dd `k w hs sd#

he d! kk cck hs d kw fkehhe! `k kek kkcph!

d `k pd` `k kw w s`k fsk sksks kds c `k ksds

`hs k `he `d dc `k hspksh fkhe ds s`! d

kshh fk `k cdkhd ksh dk f Okp`ds-

D ! skk 2 wk `dk kd`k `k \dk O`hks! `k d w`kk

\dd wh `dk `k Bdcdss kk- R`k Cds hk pkss

Whkcfd dnk `k khe ekck d kd `k

dsh s kqhk sddek `k kc- D ds h Ad Whaak! w`kkdcfk dks `d `hs khsh wh kpk ds kspsk

`hs cdhdek ppsd! s Whkcfd kk kdks `k khsh \dd- F

d`k `d dswkhe! \dd ds `k e! `k dcs sk`k

h ksdh kkdh! ds h Odddeehs pdhhe _dh \d dhe

`hs `sk9 O`dk! hsh ckdhe! w`kkf nw w`d h nws$

R`k pkffks h c c` dk `dehe h kd ws- \dds k#kdh kws h d s` skd hcdeks! `k sfikhk ksh

kxpkhkk ds d hcpksd h nws shs `! fk

`k pksd hsh ckdhe- hnk _dkss bdkcjm! \dds k#kdh ds `k fdn c pkhphs dh! `k kkhs` kxddh

khd k`shdsc- _`k dhsks! s`dkk! d wcd fnk

h w! d dsgek! d dhd kw sfik wh` `k pkhsh

d dxhc! ek f f `k w s`k hks h- dedek `d

kds dds kshph `k khfk spk Dhek! s`k skks`ksk ds `k sk ds` he`! `k cdehgk hcchkk d

kw sfikhk psshfhh- _`k hs psskssk f kw hkds! hkk `k

hbkd kw kds! `k hkxhsks dfhh fk `e`pjahthoda hkds`d s`k kcfhks ds c` ds ksds9 kxhs h `k sphhe `k

dw- R`k sphhe `k dw hs kh`k `dhsphhe fkhkk sdk

d`h phhd hsfkhkk! f hhkk hded s`

ppshhs- R`k khdhks dk swkp p h \dds kkdh d

cch w `k> `k kxpkhck wh` hkk chhd hkpk#

dhs `k kk! f `k kd ksd `k- D `w d

`k: @k kxpkhkk hs hkd fk `kh dck kkkk> ds s`k

sds! c dnhe pdk pdk Idh ahku `jrs ahkuS- R`k d



25/32

aHv b HmtrjbuotHjm

Bdcdss h D `ds k c \dk \dk h gd dnhe \dd

khk fk `k hdks `k phhd hssks she

`k- R`hs pdk pdk (`k `jrahku pdk R`kjry j

t`k _ufikot h w`h` \dd w gs `ksk! d `k kk `k kwkhd ckck f ds sdek kxk f h! kds dds

h kxhcd (kxthcht! `k pehd he shk dhshk! sfik d `k! `ddkhsh `k jfikt d- \dd hs `k dd#s `k ws kxhkckd hnk `k jfikt d! `k dsk `khkshkf dhe Fdhs sdek hkhs s`k hs dcs c#

pkk `hk fk`h `kc! dedh hnk `k jfikt d! s`k f `khpikhs d kdhk f `kh hcdehd kcfdk-

Ds `k khdhks wdp `kcskks ek`k h `k k sd! \dd

khks d e hs ekd wck (hhe _dpp`! @pdhd! Id

D! Kch Bhnhs! Vsd xkcfe! d Odchk Odk! #

he `d `hs cdns `k k d `k kx`dshe ks fhe

he`- R`k kddh `k k kxkphd hcsdks- \dd

hs dsshdhe `ksk wh` `ksk wck ds kpkskdhks Ucd

d khe kchhk ksskk! f frkdnhme wh` s` d d9 Ds

Cddck \hk (`k dhks `k khd `s wh sd! dk`k wcd `k deks cks `k wcd `k ` (D ad kcck tkr#mkaak suoobk okaak bk ahmstdmt- d! \dds hs hs kcdndf `kk#ekks! hsd ds `kk hs hk `d dsshdks `ksk wck wh` kd`

`k fkshks `k d `d `k dk d `kh kxkphs! kd` wds `k

wcd `k `- D f cdnhe `k kmb `hshd ks fhe ^`kcS he`! `kh kkchdh h kcs pdhd kxkp#

hd hcsdks! w`d hs kxkphd h `kc hs cdhzk ds

ekmkrho! ds he` cdnk ds psshfk> hkk! `k k d `d h hs d hs wck w skkc kcp`dshzk `hs ph Fdh! hsd ds `hs

w scf d ekkh sk hs - F `k khdhks sk d

\dd! d h hs kd `d `k cpk`k `k kkdh d

`k kw phhd pe h kcds- Whkcfd! `wkk! ksds

`k kxpkhkk ds hcphe `d `k s` kedek h khd

phhs- @k hs kpsk f `k phchhk hd kdk f `k k#

hdhks wdppk h `k Vk _d! dnhe kek h h ds d scf

`k hsdh `k kh- _hchd! `k cdfk dchhdh

d pdssdek c R`k Ekrcdm Hbkjajey hdks dce `kc! #he wh` `k kddh `d hs hcfk p s p d k

`k sdk! d `hs fkcks `kh shek kd ed! hnk `k sdek



26/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b av

ksdh dk f \dd! w`c `k w kshedk `k hhskhfk

k- Whkcfd kcs `kc d! phhs d khdhks dhnk!

ds `k khpsk kk sfik (oahpsk bk tjut suikt! w`h` `hc

hcphks `k dfdck sfikhh ds s`- `k sdck ws `dk `k gs d Ad Whaak! D ks wh` Cn`d kcp#s dhe \dd w `hc! Ock ! $ (Rjh! vhkms$! `ksdekkss `k kkdh ek ds s`k hs kkdk `k sds

ehs scf `k kh! f` hhshfk d ksskhd- \dds

d Bdcdss `ds k `k `k cdp d khd phhs!

fk `k ppshh fkwkk skdhk dkcps sddek `k sdk

d khd dkcps edf sdk pwk! f h hs kd h dk

wh w `k `k pd` s`k fsk hhdks-

D ! `k hk d Dh` ppk! `k h fkwkk \dds

hhqk pwk d `k s`k kd` phhs Okp`ds cks

d `kd- Okp`dss hsh `k d hsph kk`he hs edh#

he d`kks! d wh` Whkcfds hkk! `k ekck wh

sk dpsk- R`k pkpk k `k spkdk ksh! d Okp`ds

nws `d dk wh` `k pspk kkss dd` `k wh d

`k ksdh dw d k! dwhe `hc dssck hdhdpwk- D`e` sck `k khdhks dk snkphd df Okp`dss

chdhs d pds! `k kd ksd \dds pshh!

w`h`! h cs fk dchk! s`k ks hk kxpdh d cd

ksd `ksk- U`kkds `k khdhks \dds ksd

dnk pwk hs d hkxphdfk dhk d! \dd dnhe dh

hs d kw nh d- \dd sksks `d d phhs `d dfds `k k#

kss shdh fkwkk _dk d Vkh! pwk d pwkksskss!

hs psshfk! f s`k ks `dk d pshhk dedek h- D w`kkds`k `dhscdh kk `k ksh kxpkhkk `d pk pw#

k! h sk! pshhk kspsks h `k kw khdhks! w

`k d hks d mkedthjm! d ksk $ `k phhd ds h sds-_sd _phzk `ds `ddkhzk \dds kedh ds d d suftrdothjmh w`h` `k ksd pdhhpdk h `k hdkhs sdk d k#

hd ksdk kkds `k h kdk f `d ppshh- \dd

kiks Okp`dss kh ds pk kpkhh wh` kkpck

dscdh! is ds Whkcfd kdhzks `d ckdk kc wh

ckk hk phhd fshkss ds sd-

D fkehs h `k \dk `k Ud Vkskks! w`kk \dd gs Wh#

kcfd gs`he h `k `df! ds `k sds! pdhhe `hekss- hnk



27/32

avH b HmtrjbuotHjm

d dcfk h Odks pd! \dd ks `k f`k `d s`k `ds

k Cn`d d `kh s Bdh! f` w`c `dk fkk swkp p h

`k khd cckc! d w s`k hks Okp`ds

hk- \dd ks Whkcfd `d `k pkpk dk dnhe s`dpk! dkfkche phhd k dedh! d s`k eks `k f`k ih `kc h

`k dpk d kw d d `k pik hkhe d phhs `h`#

k nw- F Whkcfd d skk `hcsk ds pd d spkd#

dk pds! d ksks- _kk 6 ddks `k \dk R`s! w`kk

`k kcs `k hsdekkck fkwkk \dd d Okp`ds dk kdfdk-

R`k pkpk dk fkwkk Okp`dss sdn hsh `k d hsph

kk`he! ksphk `kh ssphhs `hs chdhs! d \dds

dppdk qhkhsc! d`e` `k hshskk `d pwk! kk h hs `kk

`k dnhe! hs dwds `k he` `he s dnk! hs d pdh9

\dds he pdhkk h d kkss wdhhe edck- Ds wk sdw!

`k fhfhd hhk d Dh` wds `k h fkwkk \kks

kedhsc d \ds dhchd hfkdh c `k dw! f `k hkkk

fkwkk `k hdkh p`hfhh d dsekssh! `k k `d!

d \ds hhkkk `d hdkh! `k `k- Fdhs pd

`hs ppshh hs kxpkssk h \dds ksd spp kh`k `k phh#d kcks (`k Cds `kh khd ddehss (Okp`ds

d `k `ks! w` kpksk sdk d kh ds w shks d h-

R`k h che c `hs hshh d kw phhd pdhk

kcdhs `k k k `k pd-

_kk ? D ks `k \dk `k Ud Vkskks! w`kk `k

w khd phhhds `k k d Vhe`! \hkk d Ikd Cd!

dedh pksdk Whkcfd sdk `k cfhe ekck- F

`k `ds kcp `kh pkds! d `k skd skk pnks d`kh kcp sedkkhe- R`k pwk khd phhd ch#

hs hs khk dcp `kk! d `kh ekd w`hk `pk hs dhe h `k

fhk h `hs shpshsc- skk 2! `wkk! d kw skqkk fkehs

dedh f icphe k `k qksh ` `k \dk O`hks!

w`kk! d d dek kkk dfk! sk f d `k `k kh#

dhks! \dd d Okp`ds `dk `kh hhk d Dh`- \dd hs dk

kk `k hkxphdfk kshsdk dnhe pwk! w`h` hs fkeh#

he hk kk `sk scpd`kh `k- Kk `k ck d! Cddck

\hk! ds k ih wh` Okp`ds! s `d wk d csk `k ks

hhe d fk dh spp w`ds fkche (dm qukmjus rdsskcfahjms ad burk! kt pahhjms adotk ad ojmsjahbdthjm bk ok quh



28/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b avHH

bkvhkmt- D`k khd! Vk! ds \dd `kp `kc pd k `k wd `hes dk s `sk w` kxhs d ck h `kh

he` pdk spkhh (dm quk mjus hmtkrrjcphjms ok quh kst! kt

quk okauh quh kxhstk dbvhkmmk sd suprcdthk- R`k kcs h w`h` `kkhdhks pkd wh` \dd kkd `w d dpd `k dk9 R sp#

p w`d hs fkche cd s hnk khd peksshkkss!

f \dd fkche hs shcp d dshhk ck fkhe! d

w`d s`k hs dhe hs! wk che` sd! umfkojchme! `k kckekk `khkxhsk ds s`! `k dfdck `k khk sdk `hes!

`k hd kh hcdehk f `k pdhsds Okp`ds! h w`h`

`k kxhsk dnks `k he` pdk spkhh! hnk `k ckkn! h`k#

hhe `k kd`- \dd deks `d `k kds h `d Okp`ds ks `kc

w dh d`hkk kd `dek! h w fk d d chgdh!

kh ckk ds dh! d d kcs `cd s9

R`k dh c dhe hs dh d d hcks dw`kk `k dk `hs

kd`- D kkss wnhe ksk! kphfk kkw`kk- _- \ds

kikh `k dw `d `k hck#`k pwk d `k `h

d `k sdk! `k \kshd d `k Whnhe! `k pph edk dsddh- _ w wkk ck `k sk dhd cck! w`k

`k pkkkk d shss h mjt skhzhe d pwk `ds `kk `k

dnhe- Fkdsk `ds `w `k w wh kd `d `k dw `ds fkk

sph h w d `d wkk ek fkk f `dhe dnk pwk-

Vkh9 `k chd phk pkpk kkw`kk- F! `kkdk! `k

pkk Kcphks- ks k `d w ! dhd- fds s wh`

`k fskk dw! `k dw h w`h` `k sfscph `hnhe

kqdh f `k shd f hs k cdk- Is ds hchsh wds _- \d! kh hs `he d kh hs `he-

U`hk `k khdhks wdh hcpdhk \dd d! s`k hshss

`d `k dh dks d mkw nhmb j dothjm- R`hs hs h#k kshsdk d `k ck pdsshk deekssh he `k

`k `kkn! f `k khsh kik `k ppshhs `d sk `k

khd phhd dfd ds d! pdhdhs! d h `hs dsk!

ckk h `k skhk Okp`dss pksd dek- \dd kdhzks `d `k

kh Okp`ds ppsks w shcp kd d`k kcphk! ck

`k sdck> `k kkdh wds d sphhe `k dw `d kqhks

d khk kw phhs- \dd wds he` d fhe` gk w`sk csk



29/32

avHHH b HmtrjbuotHjm

wh fk hkpkk f kkk d `k wd `k `hz- R`kk hs

f `d \dds hkd hs sh h`dk! s`k hs wnhe ck c `k

ske` `k hh `d c dh df w`d `k `dek s`k

hhs wh hk- @wkk! `hs fsh hs `k ` dn hsh! f `k k dk `k ` s`k `ds hskk9 kk! c

wh`h `k shdh! `k kw ` hs pkhsk hmbhsokrmhfak- R`k k#hd wck skkc `kd sck w`d \dd hs sdhe! f `k

ck sh kd` `k fdss he pwk Okp`ds deks fkk `kc9

U`hk Cn`d deks `d `k khsh skhzks `k `dk! Cddck

\hk nws `d `k khsh kcdhs shk pdk `jrs ahkuS- R`k` `d wds sfikhk! f kdksk! d wh` skqkks h

D hs kxkkd kxpdk `kk! h `k fkehhes d t`kjry jt`k pjahthoda- Mkk`kkss! cs `k pkpk d d Okp`ds! Wh#kcfd hs ckk! d \dd hsdppkds-

D ! R`k Oh Mhkd! hs sk gkk kds dk h `k \dk

Gdhs! w`k Okp`dss kh ds kk h h9 Kk`he

sdk! hs! dk`ds dpsk d `k shs nkkp wd` k

`k sh sckhe gks! seehe hcdehk d kw fkehhe- Okp`ds

ksds `d hs k ds ck d k! `d fk h `kks kkd`k kkd `d ksks `k _dks pwk- @hs kshk

h kx`dsk! `k kpds! hnk Whkcfd h D ! kdhe `hs e

wh` \dd d Cn`ds s Bdh! w`c `k khdhks kcfdk

ds `kh kw kdk- F Bdh hs sk! wkhe h kfhhe `k sdk

w cdnk `k khk kh ckdhekss! d d hs sdhgks h

dh- @k hs ephe sck`he! f `k nws `d h d fk kh#

`k d kkwd `k k `k dhd hsk k f Okp`ds!

d `k wks h s` ehe d h hks hs shcp `k dk phhs- _k \dd ks! kked kssk! sh e d ck

dshdhe `d kk! d `hs ds d sks \dds seek wh`

`k s k `k phhd k- \dd dhsks `k khdhks k

ck ehk p pwk$ k `hes `kh sk wh` - - - -

_d ep k `k fdshs `hs khdh- _dk dce

`k pkpk! w`sk `dk hs dkd pshe w`d skks wkk

ehe ddn- Rdnk k ck skp wd _dk kh d @hs

wh kckcfk ds ck `d d f dhd seek kk!

w`kk ishk hs kk! ckhh kk wsk- ^ - - - S ek#

kdh nws `k `hk fdnkss h `k k- s p s! f cdnhe

d pkkkk khsh! k `d nwkek e wdsk- R`k



30/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b aH

eh kh pdhk f Okp`ds wds dsshd! d`k hck>

`k hk p d k kpkhh! f `hs hkds d k`hqks dk

ek kkhk9 Rd - - - w`k kk dsshd kh kds

Kcphk! `kks k#dsshd ph sdk kd`- \dd hks spBdh c kdhe `k dshh c kh ksh! d

hk `hc `d kshe `k sdk hs `k sh9 Bdh cs

wn d ck p phhd sfikhdh `d hs `k kxokpthjm `k dw chdh d `k chdk- Gek `k sdk! s`k hshss>

edsp `k `kd chphh! dedhs `k eh `k k `d `k sdk

hkhdf kqhks- Vd`k `d she d khd k#

k sdk k! sdk dce `k pkpk! ds kkcks d ekkh

sk ckk d`k pd! f `k he d kw pdrt w`sk dh#h pks `k psshfhh d c` ck p phhd dscd#

h- w fk kds! f wk cs e fk `k dhzdh phhs

h `k sdk dppdds> phhs hs w`d hs suftrdotkb c `k sdk- R`kkk c w`h` d phhd ` cd dhsk hs kkhe! \dd ksBdh! f h hs d wk `dk wn wh`9 \hhs hs hnk d kk! ds

kpkskdfk ds d `k `d wn! h `k `kdk! `d ks p cdnhe

`k pd wk skk fkk s d cskhs! k#hck `he-R`k ` `d \dd kxpkhkk `k d Bdcdss wds sh#

ed> `k qksh hs `w wn kxk h! `w kcdh dht`ua h! `w jrok h pk nwkek- D `kk hs sck`he t`kdtrh#oda df `hs wn! h w sksks- Ghs! h hs ds hhshfk ds d `k wn`d pkpdks d `kdhd ph f `d cs dhs` `k `k#

dhd kk- R` hs sfikhk> hs hksdh s h `k hghk

skqkk hs hkshedhk kxkshs- _k! `k `#kk! hnk `k

`kdhd kk! dhs`ks h hs k kckekk> h hs ksskhd dshkds d pkcdk! d kd` hkdh hs hqk! wh` `k psshfhh

fkhe kxkk f d dh` sfik-

F! Bdh dsns! kdsdf ke`! w`kk fkeh: \dd kphks!

Gh `k pkpk w` cdk- _d kk w`d `k sd- edhzk

`kh shsk! wh` kqdh ds `k ed- k `kk fk k eps

phhd hh h `k dhks- D cchkks ppd wh h

`k hhks d `k shk- k `kc `dek `k wd `hes dk d

hsk `k ekkdh shdhs- Bdh fiks `d w`d \dd se#

ekss hs sdke d d> d hkk wk che` fkk `ddkhzk h ds d

hmvksthedthjm! d dkd pkss ghe `k pkpk w` `dk dkdsksk `k h h `k kxhshe sk phhs! edhzhe `kc h



31/32

a b HmtrjbuotHjm

eps fdsk `he ck `d `k hh kqdh (`kh hh#

kkk kxhshe hkkks! d khe `kc hsk `k ekkdh

shdhs `d hs! ed`k `kcskks h hccdk ekkh ch#

ks! d`k `d dhs dk `k hc `k phhd kd Vhe`- D gs `k wh hkk fk hhskhfk! hhshfk `k ks

`k w! f gd `hs hs pkhsk w`d wh dw `k kckekk

pkhs è` psshfhhhks ds kw nwkek- Bdh gd skkcs

ksd \dds ph w`k k ks! \hhs hs df cdnhe

phhs kxhs! s `d `k _dk s` ek kxhs- R`d hs! d phh#

d `! s` ds dhd kqdh (d `hs ph pdhd nwdfk!

cd fk jrokb d h `k k pkk (`d hs! f dssche hs kkdcpkh h cd pk nwkek `d wk d wn wh` mjw> fh hs d hsn! dwds sfik dppphdh f `k kcdeeks `k k

d Vhe`! `k Gs d Ndks- Mkk`kkss! gkk `d `kk hs dphhs `d hs kk c `k _dks edsp! kpkskdfk! d kkss

kk! d phhs hghk hfkdh! hs w`d Bdh gd kds

c `hs c`k> d dè` `kk dk eddkks! `hs gkk

cd `dk fkk ke` `dek `k w-

D `k k `k pd! \dd hsdppkds! f Bdh hs kd psk`k ` `d s`k kkk d k h hcp kw nwkek-

kd `k gd hks `k pd! kkk skkcs kxpkhkk d dhd kw

`! fdsk `k d ds \dd d k f`k! Whkcfd9

Khpsk kk sfik-

F `ds `k k sfik-

^Koahpsk bk tjut suikt-

Cdhs okst ak suikt! cckS

G Whkcfd h D ! `k khpsk `k sfik ckd `k hsdss

kmb sfikhh! f w d kw sfik cd hkk kckek d d ds `kshk `k hsdppkddk `k kdhd d fsk sfiks ed`kk

d `k k `k pd h `k \dk Gdhs- D kw nh k#

hd sfik d dhsk è` d pkss `d hks `k khpsk

`k - Bdh cd hsdhdk `hs kw dh` sfik d kw Ikw!

f `k O`hshd \dd d `k Ddf C`ndf `kk hs

pchsk `d d kw dh wh hkk fk k dppkd> k dk

sdek! Bdh wks w`d `k kw k wh `dk k s-



32/32

HmtrjbuotHjm b aH

R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo` hs d d ph h Fdhs jkuvrk! fhe#he ek`k d d phhs! `ke d cd`kcdhs! `k \dhs

4054 d `k \dhs 480! w`hk fhhe R`kjry j t`k _ufikot d

dhhpdhe Fkhme dmb Kvkmt- Ds d kxpkhckd pkk! h hksh#edks `k kx Odks Ad Whaak! skknhe hsk h h `k cdkh#ds kw `kdhd psshfhhhks d phhd hkds- Fkdsk Odks

pd hs dkd O`hshd! wk che` sd `d Fdhs kxpkhckd

pkk hks dhe h sck`he `d hs dkd `kk_dh

\d`e` d kcdndfk ddpdh `k k`hqk kkpk f

\d O`k- F `k dhh `hs sppkck! `k kd \d

Odks s wh` _dh \ds sks! fhes sck`he hccd#

k Odk f k kd h `hs kx9 `k ekkh dk ds

ksdh pp`k! hs dppdk kksskss- `hs sksk! R`k Hmohbkmtdt Dmthjo` ks Ad Whaak kkd d khd nwkek h wh `dk`d! f kxpdhe `k \dhk ` `k kk d hs ekkh kxksh!

wh` pkhd hchk kw psshfhhhks `hnhe- R`k kss

Fdhs kxpkhckd he d fk skk h `hs kxdhd kxksh

`k kp `k ekkh h Fkhme dmb Kvkmt! d h hs fn _dh

\d! w`kk `k `k `k kk hs hsdhdk h pk`dps hs cssdhk c- R`k fhhed pfhdh R`k Hmohbkmt dt Dmthjo`w! `h kds dk hs whhe! ds kcs hcphdhs `k ekd

d sh kxpdhe ps Fdhs whhes d hkds- Ckk!

dc `pk! d! ojmbkmt `d wk wh `dk wdh d`k `hkds d ph `k pd-


Date post:	11-Feb-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	columbia-university-press
View:	224 times
Download:	0 times

The Incident at Antioch, by Alain Badiou

Documents