+ All Categories
Home > Documents > THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York...

THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York...

Date post: 05-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: barry-fagan-esq
View: 214 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
31
7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. … http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 1/31 ^mjc = ae ;= [S^RCGC KASRX AE XOC [XMXC AE ICZ \AR@ KASIX\ AE ICZ \AR@ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 4 XOC ^CA^FC AE XOC [XMXC AE ICZ \AR@ 4 b| MIHRCZ G) KSAGA& Mxxaric| Jcicrmf ae 4 xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar`& 4 4 ^fmlixlee& 4 KAG^FMLIX 4 'mjmli{x' 4 Lihc Ia) 4 ELR[X MGCRLKMI KAR^ARMXLAI mih 4 ELR[X MGCRLKMI CM^^RML[CLX& 4 4 Hcecihmix{) 4 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' =) Xol{ mkxlai l{ brasjox b| ^fmlixlee& xoc ^ca~fc ae xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar`& b| Mihrcz G) Ksaga& Mxxaric| Jcicrmf ae xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar` /‖Mxxaric| Jcicrmf‗,& bm{ch s~ai xoc Mxxaric| Jcicrmf“{ msxoarlx| sihcr Mrxlkfc 22'M ae xoc Jcicrmf Bs{lic{{ Fmz& [ckxlai 5;/=2, ae xoc Ccksxluc Fmz& mih xoc kaggai fmz ae xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar`) 2) ^fmlixlee& kag~fmlilij ae xoc mbauc'imgch hcecihmix{& mffcjc{ s~ai lieargmxlai mih bcflce m{ eaffaz{) XOC RCFCUMIX CIXLXLC[ ;) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi Kar~armxlai /‖Elr{x Mgcrlkmi‗, l{& mkkarhlij xa lx{ 2>>5 miismf rc~arx& ‖Mgcrlkm“{ fmrjc{x ~raulhcr ae bs{lic{{ lieargmxlai)‗ Lx cmrich (?)3 blfflai li rcucisc{ li 2>>5) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi a~crmxc{ li eluc ~rlgmr| bs{lic{{ {ckxar{4 Xlxfc Li{srmikc mih [crulkc{& [~cklmfx| Li{srmikc& Garxjmjc Lieargmxlai /likfshlij rcmf c{xmxc m~~rml{mf {crulkc{,& ^ra~crx| Lieargmxlai& mih Rl{` Glxljmxlai mih Bs{lic{{ [crulkc{) Lx hac{ bs{lic{{ li Icz \ar` baxo hlrckxf| mih xorasjo lx{ {sb{lhlmrlc{)
Transcript
Page 1: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 1/31

^mjc = ae ;=

[S^RCGC KASRX AE XOC [XMXC AE ICZ \AR@KASIX\ AE ICZ \AR@'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

4XOC ^CA^FC AE XOC [XMXC AE ICZ \AR@ 4

b| MIHRCZ G) KSAGA& Mxxaric| Jcicrmf ae 4xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar`& 4

4^fmlixlee& 4 KAG^FMLIX

4'mjmli{x' 4 Lihc Ia)

4ELR[X MGCRLKMI KAR^ARMXLAI mih 4ELR[X MGCRLKMI CM^^RML[CLX& 4

4Hcecihmix{) 4

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

=) Xol{ mkxlai l{ brasjox b| ̂ fmlixlee& xoc ^ca~fc ae xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar`& b|

Mihrcz G) Ksaga& Mxxaric| Jcicrmf ae xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar` /‖Mxxaric| Jcicrmf‗,& bm{ch

s~ai xoc Mxxaric| Jcicrmf“{ msxoarlx| sihcr Mrxlkfc 22'M ae xoc Jcicrmf Bs{lic{{ Fmz& [ckxlai

5;/=2, ae xoc Ccksxluc Fmz& mih xoc kaggai fmz ae xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar`)

2) ^fmlixlee& kag~fmlilij ae xoc mbauc'imgch hcecihmix{& mffcjc{ s~ai lieargmxlai

mih bcflce m{ eaffaz{)

XOC RCFCUMIX CIXLXLC[

;) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi Kar~armxlai /‖Elr{x Mgcrlkmi‗, l{& mkkarhlij xa lx{ 2>>5 miismf

rc~arx& ‖Mgcrlkm“{ fmrjc{x ~raulhcr ae bs{lic{{ lieargmxlai)‗ Lx cmrich (?)3 blfflai li rcucisc{

li 2>>5) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi a~crmxc{ li eluc ~rlgmr| bs{lic{{ {ckxar{4 Xlxfc Li{srmikc mih [crulkc{&

[~cklmfx| Li{srmikc& Garxjmjc Lieargmxlai /likfshlij rcmf c{xmxc m~~rml{mf {crulkc{,& ^ra~crx|

Lieargmxlai& mih Rl{` Glxljmxlai mih Bs{lic{{ [crulkc{) Lx hac{ bs{lic{{ li Icz \ar` baxo

hlrckxf| mih xorasjo lx{ {sb{lhlmrlc{)

Page 2: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 2/31

^mjc 2 ae ;=

8) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi ~raulhc{ rcmf c{xmxc m~~rml{mf {crulkc{ xa {mulij{ mih fami{& bmi`{&

mih axocr fcihlij ~raec{{laimf{ xorasjo lx{ zoaff| azich {sb{lhlmr|& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi

cM~~rml{cLX /‖cM~~rml{cLX‗,& mi m~~rml{mf gmimjcgcix kag~mi| ocmh}smrxcrch li Kmflearilm

mih Gm{{mkos{cxx{) cM~~rml{cLX kaihskx{ bs{lic{{ mih m~~rml{c{ rcmf c{xmxc li xoc {xmxc ae Icz

\ar`)

3) Zm{olijxai Gsxsmf& Lik) /‖ZmGs‗, l{ xoc kasixr|“{ fmrjc{x {mulij{ mih fami&

zlxo m{{cx{ xaxmflij (;85 blfflai) Li xoc elr{x xorcc }smrxcr{ ae 2>>:& ZmGs arljlimxch (==5

blfflai li rc{lhcixlmf garxjmjc fami{) ZmGs l{ cM~~rml{cLX“{ fmrjc{x kflcix)

^RCFLGLIMR\ [XMXCGCIX

5) Li xol{ crm ae zlhc{~rcmh garxjmjc fami hcemsfx{ mih oagc earckfa{src{& xoc

lihc~cihcikc mih lixcjrlx| ae xoc rcmf c{xmxc m~~rml{cr{ zoa hcxcrglic xoc umfsc ae oagc fami

kaffmxcrmf l{ ae ciargas{ lg~arxmikc) Rcmf c{xmxc m~~rml{mf{ mrc lixcihch xa ~raulhc barrazcr{

mih fcihcr{ zlxo mi lihc~cihcix mih mkksrmxc m{{c{{gcix ae xoc umfsc ae m oagc) Xol{ ci{src{

xomx m garxjmjc ar oagc c}slx| fami l{ iax sihcr'kaffmxcrmfltch& zolko li xsri ~raxckx{ barrazcr{

erag bclij aucr'cxcihch elimiklmff| mih fcihcr{ mih liuc{xar{ erag fa{{ ae umfsc li m

earckfa{src ~rakcchlij)

:) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi rckajiltc{ mih xasx{ xoc kcixrmf rafc lx ~fm|{& xorasjo lx{ m~~rml{mf

gmimjcgcix kag~mi| cM~~rml{cLX& li ~raxckxlij oagcazicr{& bs{lic{{ ks{xagcr{& mih xoc

cixlrc elimiklmf gmr`cx) M{ Elr{x Mgcrlkmi c~fmli{ li lx{ 2>>5 Miismf Rc~arx4

M~~rml{mf{ mrc s{ch xa c{xmbfl{o m ~ra~crx|“{ gmr`cx umfsc0 xocrcearc&limkksrmxc ar ermshsfcix m~~rml{mf{ hmgmjc xoc cixlrc gmr`cx mih omucicjmxluc ckaiaglk ceeckx{ xomx mrc emr rcmkolij) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi“{xolrh'~mrx|& siblm{ch umfsmxlai{ ‛ likfshlij li{srch umfsmxlai{ ‛ mrc mrc{asrkc rcmf c{xmxc mih fcihlij ~raec{{laimf{ kmi xsri xa ear mkksrmk|xomx bcicelx{ iax aif| xoc oagcazicr mih fcihcr& bsx asr imxlai“{

Page 3: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 3/31

^mjc ; ae ;=

ckaiag|)

Umfsc xa Kai{sgcr{4 Oagcazicr{& zoa ~fmkc m fmrjc liuc{xgcix lixoclr ~ra~crx|& kmi bc ~mrxlksfmrf| ulkxlgltch b| m~~rml{mf ermsh) Elr{xMgcrlkmi“{ zmrrmixch umfsmxlai{& zolko mrc {s~~arxch b| asr xolrh'

~mrx| ~cr{~ckxluc mih bmk`ch b| garc xomi m kcixsr| ae lixcjrlx|&ulrxsmff| cflglimxc rl{` erag xol{ x|~c ae ermsh)

Umfsc xa asr Bs{lic{{ Ks{xagcr{4 Limkksrmxcf| m~~rml{ch ~ra~crxlc{xomx gm`c xoclr zm| lixa fcihcr ~arxeafla{ likrcm{c xoc a~~arxsilx| earearckfa{src{) Asr imxlaimf {crulkc{ ~raulhc asr garxjmjc fcihcrks{xagcr{ zlxo m zcfkagch rc{asrkc ear siblm{ch m~~rml{mf{ xomx{mxl{e| likrcm{ch rcjsfmxar| kaikcri{& ocf~ xa mkksrmxcf| hcxcrglicumfsc& mih glxljmxc hcemsfx rl{`)

?) Hc{~lxc xoc{c rc~rc{cixmxlai{& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX omuc mbhlkmxch

xoclr rafc li ~raulhlij ‖xolrh'~mrx|& siblm{ch umfsmxlai{‗ ear cM~~rml{cLX“{ fmrjc{x kflcix&

ZmGs) Li{xcmh& cM~~rml{cLX lg~ra~crf| mffaz{ ZmGs“{ fami ~rahskxlai {xmee xa omih'~lk` 

m~~rml{cr{ zoa brlij li m~~rml{mf umfsc{ oljo ciasjo xa ~crglx ZmGs“{ fami{ xa kfa{c& mih

lg~ra~crf| ~crglx{ ZmGs xa ~rc{{src cM~~rml{cLX m~~rml{cr{ xa komijc m~~rml{mf umfsc{ xomx mrc

xaa faz xa ~crglx fami{ xa kfa{c) cM~~rml{cLX kag~ragl{c{ lx{ lihc~cihcikc cuci zolfc

~sbflkf| xasxlij xomx lihc~cihcikc& mih hc{~lxc g|rlmh zmrilij{ erag lx{ {cilar gmimjcgcix

xcmg mbasx xoc lffcjmf kaffs{lai liocrcix li xoc kag~ragl{c{ lx l{ gm`lij) Li{xcmh ae ~rc{crulij

lx{ lihc~cihcikc& zolko zasfh omuc ~raxckxch kai{sgcr{ mih bs{lic{{ ks{xagcr{ mfl`c&

cM~~rml{cLX koa{c xa ~raxckx aif| lx{cfe) Mih {cilar ccksxluc{ mx Elr{x Mgcrlkmi& xoasjo

zmrich b| cM~~rml{cLX“{ {cilar gmimjcgcix ae lx{ kag~ragl{ch lihc~cihcikc& iaicxocfc{{

hlrckxch cM~~rml{cLX xa kaixlisc lx{ zraijesf kaihskx)

<) Xol{ zraijesf kaihskx kai{xlxsxc{ m hckc~xluc& ermshsfcix& mih lffcjmf bs{lic{{

~rmkxlkc) Lx ulafmxc{ Icz \ar` fmz m{ zcff m{ echcrmf fmz mih rcjsfmxlai{)

DSRL[HLKXLAI

Page 4: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 4/31

^mjc 8 ae ;=

=>) Xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar` om{ mi lixcrc{x li xoc ckaiaglk ocmfxo mih zcff'bclij ae 

xoa{c zoa rc{lhc ar xrmi{mkx bs{lic{{ zlxoli lx{ barhcr{) Xoc [xmxc mf{a om{ mi lixcrc{x li

m{{srlij xoc ~rc{cikc ae mi oaic{x gmr`cx~fmkc li zolko ckaiaglk mkxlulx| l{ kaihskxch li m

kag~cxlxluc gmiicr& zlxoasx ermsh& hckc~xlai& ar kaffs{lai& ear xoc bcicelx ae gmr`cx~fmkc

~mrxlkl~mix{) Xoc [xmxc mf{a om{ mi lixcrc{x li s~oafhlij xoc rsfc ae fmz jcicrmff|) Xoc kaihskx

ae Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX lidsrch xoc{c lixcrc{x{)

==) Xos{& xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar` {sc{ li lx{ {aucrclji mih }sm{l'{aucrclji km~mklxlc{&

m{ ~mrci{ ~mxrlmc& mih ~sr{smix xa Ccksxluc Fmz ª 5;/=2,& Jcicrmf Bs{lic{{ Fmz ªª ;8< cx {c})

mih Icz \ar` kaggai fmz) Xoc [xmxc {sc{ xa rchrc{{ lidsr| xa xoc [xmxc& mih xa lx{ jcicrmf

ckaiag| mih rc{lhcix{& m{ zcff m{ ai bcomfe ae4 /=, ~cr{ai{ zoa abxmlich garxjmjc{& oagc

c}slx| fami{& ar rcelimikch xoclr oagc{ zlxo ZmGs mih m{ xa zoa{c oagc{ cM~~rml{cLX

kaihskxch xoc rcmf c{xmxc m~~rml{mf0 mih /2, ~cr{ai{ zoa basjox ZmGs fami{ {cksrch b|

garxjmjc{ xomx zcrc lg~ra~crf| m~~rml{ch b| hcecihmix{) Xoc [xmxc {cc`{ hl{jarjcgcix&

rc{xlxsxlai& hmgmjc{ likfshlij ka{x{& mih c}slxmbfc rcflce zlxo rc{~ckx xa hcecihmix{“ ermshsfcix&

hckc~xluc& mih axocrzl{c sifmzesf kaihskx)

EMKXSMF MFFCJMXLAI[

L) Xoc Rcmf C{xmxc Garxjmjc Lihs{xr|

M) Bmk`jrasih

=2) Ga{x ~ca~fc lixcrc{xch li ~srkom{lij ar rcelimiklij m oagc /‖barrazcr{‗, {cc` m

elimiklmf li{xlxsxlai /m ‖fcihcr‗, xa fcih xocg gaic| ai xoc ga{x emuarmbfc rc~m|gcix xcrg{

mumlfmbfc) Xrmhlxlaimff| xoc fcihcr& m{ ~mrx ae mjrcclij xa fami xoc esih{& zmixch xa ci{src xomx

xoc barrazcr zm{ mbfc xa rc~m| xoc fami mih xomx xoc fami zm{ mhc}smxcf| kaffmxcrmfltch li km{c

Page 5: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 5/31

^mjc 3 ae ;=

xoc barrazcr hcemsfxch) Xoc barrazcr mih xoc fcihcr omh m kaggai lixcrc{x li mkksrmxcf|

umfslij xoc sihcrf|lij kaffmxcrmf bckms{c baxo zmixch xa bc {src xoc barrazcr zm{ iax ~m|lij

xaa gsko ear xoc ~ra~crx| mih zasfh bc mbfc xa gccx xoc rc~m|gcix xcrg{& ar xomx ‛ li xoc cucix

ae hcemsfx mih earckfa{src ‛ xoc ~ra~crx| umfsc kasfh {s~~arx xoc fami)

=;) Xahm|& xoc fmih{km~c ae xoc garxjmjc lihs{xr| l{ }slxc hleecrcix erag xol{

xrmhlxlaimf gahcf) Rmxocr xomi oafhlij xoc garxjmjc fami{& fcihcr{ iaz rcjsfmrf| {cff xoc{c

garxjmjc{ li xoc elimiklmf gmr`cx{& clxocr hlrckxf| ar xa liuc{xgcix bmi`{ ar Jaucrigcix

[~ai{arch Cixcr~rl{c{ /‖J[C{‗,& {sko m{ xoc Echcrmf Imxlaimf Garxjmjc M{{aklmxlai /‖Emiilc

Gmc‗, ar xoc Echcrmf Oagc Fami Garxjmjc Kar~armxlai /‖Erchhlc Gmk‗,) Xoc fami{ mrc xoci

~aafch xajcxocr& {cksrlxltch& mih {afh xa xoc jcicrmf ~sbflk m{ garxjmjc bmk`ch {cksrlxlc{) Xoc

gaic| xomx xoc fcihcr rckcluc{ ear xoc {mfc ae xoc garxjmjc fami{ ar baih{ l{ xoci s{ch xa elimikc

icz garxjmjc{& likrcm{lij xoc fcihcr“{ ~raelx{ mih mlhlij lx{ {xak` ~rlkc) Xahm|& xoc um{x

gmdarlx| ae garxjmjc fami{ mrc {afh xa liuc{xgcix bmi`{ ar J[C{& fcmulij xoc arljlimf fcihcr

oafhlij emr eczcr garxjmjc{ li lx{ ~arxeafla)

=8) Xol{ rckaieljsrmxlai ae xoc zm| xomx garxjmjc{ mrc ocfh om{ xrmi{eargch xoc

likcixluc{ li xoc lihs{xr|) [~cklelkmff|& lx om{ xoc ceeckx ae gm`lij xoc fcihcr fc{{ uljlfmix mjmli{x

rl{`| fami{ {likc mi| rl{` l{ }slk`f| xrmi{ecrrch xa xoc ~srkom{cr{ ae xoc fami{) Garcaucr& m{ xoc

fcihcr hac{ iax oafh gmi| ae lx{ fami{ li lx{ ~arxeafla& xoc fcihcr“{ lixcrc{x li ci{srlij xoc

mkksrmk| ae xoc m~~rml{mf bmk`lij xoc fami l{ {cucrcf| hlglil{och) Cuci zar{c& bckms{c fcihcr{“

~raelx{ mrc hcxcrglich b| xoc }smixlx| ae fami{ xoc| {skkc{{esff| kfa{c& mih iax xoc }smflx| ae 

xoa{c fami{& xocrc l{ mi likcixluc ear m fcihcr xa ~rc{{src m~~rml{cr{ xa rcmko umfsc{ xomx zlff

mffaz xoc fami xa kfa{c& zocxocr ar iax xoc m~~rml{mf mkksrmxcf| rcefckx{ xoc oagc umfsc)

Page 6: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 6/31

^mjc 5 ae ;=

=3) Esrxocr dca~mrhltlij xoc ~rakc{{& garxjmjc bra`cr{ mih xoc fcihcr{“ fami

~rahskxlai {xmee /mf{a `iazi m{ ‖fami arljlimxlai {xmee‗, mrc mfga{x mfzm|{ ~mlh ai kaggl{{lai)

Xos{& xoc likagc ae xoc{c lihlulhsmf{ hc~cih{ ai zocxocr m fami kfa{c{ mih ai xoc {ltc ae xoc

fami) Mkkarhlijf|& bra`cr{ mih fami ~rahskxlai {xmee omuc {xraij ~cr{aimf likcixluc{ xa ~rc{{src

m~~rml{cr{ xa umfsc m oagc mx xoc gmlgsg ~a{{lbfc mgasix& {a xomx fami{ zlff kfa{c mih

jcicrmxc gmlgsg kaggl{{lai{) Ear xoc{c rcm{ai{& garxjmjc bra`cr{ mih fcihcr{ erc}scixf|

{sbdckx rcmf c{xmxc m~~rml{cr{ xa lixci{c ~rc{{src xa komijc umfsc{ li m~~rml{mf rc~arx{)

=5) Xoc liuc{xgcix bmi`{ mih J[C{ mf{a omuc mi lixcrc{x li liefmxlij /ar mx fcm{x li

iax }sc{xlailij, xoc umfsc ae xoc ~aafch fami{) Xoc umfsc{ ae xoc{c fami{ {cruc m{ m bm{l{ ear xoc

umfsc ae xoclr {cksrlxlc{) M{ {sko& xoc oljocr xoc umfsc ae xoc fami{ kfa{ch& xoc jrcmxcr xoc umfsc

ear zolko xoc {cksrlxlc{ mrc {afh ai xoc {ckaihmr| gmr`cx)

=:) Xos{& xoc aif| ~mrxlc{ sihcr xoc ksrrcix {|{xcg zoa zmix mi mkksrmxc m~~rml{mf

mrc xoc barrazcr{ mih xoc liuc{xar{ li xoc m{{cx'bmk`ch {cksrlxlc{ gmr`cx) Iclxocr ae xoc{c

~mrxlc{& oazcucr& om{ mi| kaixmkx zlxo& ar kaixraf aucr& xoc m~~rml{mf ~rakc{{)

B) Echcrmf mih [xmxc Fmz{ Rc}slrc M~~rml{mf Lihc~cihcikc

=?) Bckms{c ae xoc lg~arxmikc ae m~~rml{mf{ li xoc oagc fcihlij gmr`cx& {xmxc mih

echcrmf {xmxsxc{ mih rcjsfmxlai{ rc}slrc xomx m~~rml{mf{ bc mkksrmxc mih lihc~cihcix) Xoc

Silearg [xmihmrh{ ae ^raec{{laimf M~~rml{mf ^rmkxlkc /‖S[^M^‗, mrc likar~armxch lixa echcrmf

mih Icz \ar̀ fmz) [cc =2 K)E)R) ª ;8)880 =< I\KRR ª ==>5)=) S[^M^ rc}slrc{ m~~rml{cr{ xa

kaihskx xoclr m~~rml{mf{ lihc~cihcixf|4 ‖Mi m~~rml{cr gs{x ~crearg m{{ljigcix{ zlxo

lg~mrxlmflx|& abdckxlulx|& mih lihc~cihcikc& mih zlxoasx mkkaggahmxlai ae ~cr{aimf lixcrc{x{) Li

m~~rml{mf ~rmkxlkc& mi m~~rml{cr gs{x iax ~crearg m{ mi mhuakmxc ear mi| ~mrx| ar l{{sc)‗ S[^M^

Page 7: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 7/31

^mjc : ae ;=

Cxolk{ Rsfc /Kaihskx,)

=<) Echcrmf fmz {cx{ lihc~cihcikc {xmihmrh{ ear m~~rml{cr{ liuafuch li echcrmff|'

rcjsfmxch xrmi{mkxlai{) [cc =2 S)[)K) ªª ;;;= cx {c}) Xoc Kahc ae Echcrmf Rcjsfmxlai{ ~raulhc{

xomx mi li'oas{c ar ‖{xmee‗ m~~rml{cr mx m bmi` ‖gs{x bc lihc~cihcix ae xoc fcihlij& liuc{xgcix&

mih kaffckxlai esikxlai{ mih iax liuafuch& ckc~x m{ mi m~~rml{cr& li xoc echcrmff| rcfmxch

xrmi{mkxlai& mih omuc ia hlrckx ar lihlrckx lixcrc{x& elimiklmf ar axocrzl{c& li xoc ~ra~crx|)‗ =2

K)E)R) ª ;8)83)  Ear m~~rml{cr{ zoa mrc lihc~cihcix kaixrmkxar{ ar ‖ecc‗ m~~rml{cr{& xoc

rcjsfmxlai {xmxc{ xomx ‖xoc m~~rml{cr {omff bc cijmjch hlrckxf| b| xoc rcjsfmxch li{xlxsxlai ar lx{

mjcix& mih omuc ia hlrckx ar lihlrckx lixcrc{x& elimiklmf ar axocrzl{c& li xoc ~ra~crx| xrmi{mkxlai)‗

=2 K)E)R) ª ;8)83)

2>) Li 2>>3& echcrmf rcjsfmxar{ likfshlij xoc AX[ PAeelkc ae Xorlex [s~crul{laiW

~sbfl{och ‖Erc}scixf| M{`ch ]sc{xlai{ ai xoc M~~rml{mf Rcjsfmxlai{ mih xoc Lixcrmjcik|

[xmxcgcix ai Lihc~cihcix M~~rml{mf mih Cumfsmxlai Esikxlai{)‗ Zlxo rcjmrh xa m~~rml{mf

lihc~cihcikc& xoc haksgcix ~raulhc{4

;) Zoa {oasfh bc kai{lhcrch xoc fami ~rahskxlai {xmee ear 

 ~sr~a{c{ ae mkolculij m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc1 Kasfh fami

 ~rahskxlai {xmee {cfckx mi m~~rml{cr1

 Mi{zcr4 Xoc fami ~rahskxlai {xmee kai{l{x{ ae xoa{c rc{~ai{lbfcear jcicrmxlij fami uafsgc ar m~~raulij fami{& m{ zcffm{ xoclr {sbarhlimxc{) Xol{ zasfh likfshc mi|cg~fa|cc zoa{c kag~ci{mxlai l{ bm{ch ai famiuafsgc) Cg~fa|cc{ rc{~ai{lbfc ear xoc krchlxmhglil{xrmxlai esikxlai ar krchlx rl{` gmimjcgcix mrc

iax kai{lhcrch fami ~rahskxlai {xmee) Fami ~rahskxlai{xmee {oasfh iax {cfckx m~~rml{cr{) 

$ $ $3) Zoci {cfckxlij rc{lhcixlmf m~~rml{cr{& gm| fami ~rahskxlai

{xmee s{c m rcuafulij ~rc'm~~rauch m~~rml{cr fl{x& ~raulhch xoc

Page 8: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 8/31

^mjc ? ae ;=

fl{x l{ iax sihcr xoclr kaixraf1

 Mi{zcr 4 \c{& fami ~rahskxlai {xmee gm| s{c m rcuafulij& bamrh'm~~rauch fl{x xa {cfckx m rc{lhcixlmf m~~rml{cr& ~raulhchxoc hcucfa~gcix mih gmlixcimikc ae xoc fl{x l{ iax

sihcr xoclr kaixraf) [xmee rc{~ai{lbfc ear xochcucfa~gcix mih gmlixcimikc ae xoc fl{x {oasfh bc

lihc~cihcix ae xoc fami ~rahskxlai ~rakc{{) ) ) )

Esrxocr& xocrc {oasfh bc ~crlahlk lixcrimf rculcz ae 

xoc m~~rml{cr {cfckxlai ~rakc{{ xa ci{src xomx

m~~ra~rlmxc ~rakchsrc{ mrc bclij eaffazch mih xomx

kaixraf{ cl{x xa ci{src lihc~cihcikc) /Cg~om{l{mhhch,)

2=) Icz \ar̀ fmz likar~armxc{ S[^M^ mih rc}slrc{ xomx m [xmxc'kcrxlelch ar [xmxc'

flkci{ch m~~rml{cr gm| iax mkkc~x m ecc ear mi m~~rml{mf m{{ljigcix ‖xomx l{ kaixlijcix s~ai xoc

m~~rml{cr rc~arxlij m ~rchcxcrglich c{xlgmxc& mimf|{l{& ar a~lilai ar l{ kaixlijcix s~ai xoc

a~lilai& kaikfs{lai ar umfsmxlai rcmkoch& ar s~ai xoc kai{c}scikc{ rc{sfxlij erag xoc m~~rml{mf

m{{ljigcix)‗ I)\) Cck) Fmz ª =5>'|0 =< I\KRR ª ==>5)=)

LL) M~~rml{mf Gmimjcgcix Kag~milc{ Krcmxc

xoc M~~cmrmikc ae M~~rml{cr Lihc~cihcikc

22) Li rc{~ai{c xa xoc{c rsfc{ mih xoc xorcmx ae {xrlkxcr echcrmf ciearkcgcix& li [~rlij

2>>5& ZmGs mxxcg~xch xa li{sfmxc lx{cfe b| olrlij xza M~~rml{mf Gmimjcgcix Kag~milc{

/‖MGK{‗, ‛ cM~~rml{cLX mih lx{ xa~ kag~cxlxar Fcihcr“{ [crulkc& Lik) /‖F[L‗, ‛ xa aucr{cc xoc

m~~rml{mf ~rakc{{) Xoc{c kag~milc{ ~raulhc xoc m~~cmrmikc ae m {xrskxsrmf bseecr bcxzcci xoc

bmi`{ mih xoc m~~rml{cr{ xomx cflglimxc{ ~axcixlmf ~rc{{src ar kaieflkx{ ae lixcrc{x) Li xocar|& mi

MGK {cfckx{ m~~rml{cr{ lihc~cihcixf|& {cruc{ m{ xoc m~~rml{cr{“ {afc kaixmkx& mih kaggsilkmxc{

xoc siblm{ch rc{sfx{ xa xoc fcihlij li{xlxsxlai) Li xol{ zm|& {xrskxsrmff|& m fcihlij li{xlxsxlai

zasfh bc gsko fc{{ mbfc xa lg~ra~crf| liefscikc mi m~~rml{mf)

2;) cM~~rml{cLX ~sbflkf| kfmlg{ ai lx{ zcb{lxc xomx lx ~raulhc{ ds{x {sko m elrczmff

Page 9: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 9/31

^mjc < ae ;=

bcxzcci fcihcr{ mih m~~rml{cr{& mih xomx ‖ks{xagcr{ kmi bc m{{srch xomx Silearg [xmihmrh{ ae 

^raec{{laimf M~~rml{mf ^rmkxlkc /S[^M^, mih Elimiklmf Li{xlxsxlai{ Rcearg Rckaucr| mih

Ciearkcgcix Mkx /ELRRCM, jslhcflic{ mrc eaffazch mih xomx cmko m~~rml{mf l{ mshlxch ear

kag~flmikc)‗

LLL) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX Ulafmxc M~~rml{cr Lihc~cihcikc

Rc}slrcgcix{ b| ^crglxxlij ZmGs“{ Fami Arljlimxlai [xmee 

Xa [cfckx M~~rml{cr{ Zoa ^raulhc Oljocr M~~rml{ch Umfsc{

28) Hc{~lxc xoclr kfmlg{ ae lihc~cihcikc erag xoclr fcihcr kflcix{& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih

cM~~rml{cLX ulafmxc echcrmf mih {xmxc lihc~cihcikc rc}slrcgcix{ zlxo rcjmrh xa m~~rml{mf{

~creargch ear ZmGs& mih li halij {a hckcluc barrazcr{ mih liuc{xar{ zoa rcf| ai xoclr

~rakfmlgch lihc~cihcikc)

23) ZmGs rcxmlich cM~~rml{cLX li [~rlij 2>>5& mexcr ZmGs hcklhch xa kfa{c lx{

lixcrimf m~~rml{mf aeelkc mih xcrglimxc lx{ {xmee m~~rml{cr{) ZmGs }slk`f| bckmgc cM~~rml{cLX“{

fmrjc{x kflcix& ~raulhlij icmrf| ;> ~crkcix ae lx{ bs{lic{{ li Icz \ar`) Aucr xoc kasr{c ae xoc

bs{lic{{ rcfmxlai{ol~& cM~~rml{cLX kaihskxch garc xomi 25>&>>> m~~rml{mf{ ear ZmGs& rckclulij

aucr (3> glfflai erag ZmGs)

25) Lilxlmff|& cM~~rml{cLX cg~fa|ch m kagblimxlai ae li'oas{c {xmee mih xolrh'~mrx|

ecc m~~rml{cr{& likfshlij {agc ‖~rcecrrch m~~rml{cr{‗ lhcixlelch b| ZmGs& xa kaihskx m~~rml{mf{

ae rc{lhcixlmf ~ra~crx| ear ZmGs) cM~~rml{cLX mf{a olrch m~~ralgmxcf| 3> eargcr ZmGs

cg~fa|cc{ m{ {xmee m~~rml{cr{ mih M~~rml{mf Bs{lic{{ Gmimjcr{ /‖MBG{‗, mih ‛ mx ZmGs“{

rc}sc{x ‛ jmuc xoc MBG{ xoc msxoarlx| xa aucrrlhc mih rcul{c xoc umfsc{ rcmkoch b| xolrh'~mrx|

m~~rml{cr{) Aic'xolrh ae cM~~rml{cLX“{ {xmee m~~rml{cr{ mrc eargcr ZmGs cg~fa|cc{& mih mff ae 

xoc MBG{ mrc eargcr ZmGs cg~fa|cc{) cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix mhul{ch xoc fcmhcr{ol~ ae Elr{x

Page 10: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 10/31

^mjc => ae ;=

Mgcrlkmi xomx ‖zc omuc olrch mih ai bamrhch gmi| ae Zmgs“{ rcjlaimf gmijcr{ mih m~~rml{cr{

fm{x zcc`) Xoc| zlff bc li{xrsgcixmf li asr rcfmxlaimf mih a~crmxlaimf {skkc{{ zlxo xoc {mfc{

earkc)‗

2:) Sihcr kaixrmkxsmf mrrmijcgcix{ bcxzcci ZmGs mih cM~~rml{cLX& ZmGs kmi

komffcijc mi m~~rml{cr“{ kaikfs{lai{ b| rc}sc{xlij m ‖rckai{lhcrmxlai ae umfsc‗ /‖RAU‗, zoci

ZmGs hl{mjrcc{ zlxo mi m~~rml{ch oagc umfsc {cx earxo li mi m~~rml{mf rc~arx) ^rmkxlkmff|

{~cm`lij& xol{ ~crglx{ ZmGs xa m{` cM~~rml{cLX xa rckai{lhcr mih rml{c xoc umfsc m{{ljich xa m

oagc) Xorasjoasx xoc bs{lic{{ rcfmxlai{ol~& ZmGs om{ erc}scixf| arhcrch RAU{ erag

cM~~rml{cLX)

2?) B| cgmlf hmxch [c~xcgbcr 2<& 2>>5& m ZmGs ccksxluc zraxc xa cM~~rml{cLX“{

{cilar ccksxluc{ xa hcelic xoc rc{~ai{lblflxlc{ ae cM~~rml{cLX“{ MBG{ m{ xa RAU{ mih umfsc

hl{~sxc{4

) ) ) xoc easr m~~rml{cr{!rculczcr{ zasfh bc hlrckxf| liuafuch lic{kmfmxlai{ hcmflij zlxo4 RAU{& Umfsmxlai l{{sc{ zocrc xoc ~srkom{c~rlkc mih m~~rml{ch umfsc hleecr zlxo ia rckaiklflmxlai{!ds{xlelkmxlai{

b| xoc m~~rml{cr& Umfsc ksx{ zolko zc kaixlisc xa rckcluc erag |asrxolrh ~mrx| rculczcr{ /Zoafc{mfc,& ~ramkxlucf| gm`lij m hckl{lai xa

aucrrlhc mih karrckx xoc xolrh ~mrx| m~~rml{cr“{ umfsc ar

rculczcr“{ umfsc ksx& zoci kai{lhcrch m~~ra~rlmxc mih {s~~arxch ) ) ))

Li xol{ zm|& erag xoc asx{cx& ZmGs {asjox xa s{c cM~~rml{cLX xa ci{src xomx m~~rml{mf{ hlh iax

kagc li fazcr xomi ZmGs zmixch)

Page 11: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 11/31

^mjc == ae ;=

M) [sggcr ' Emff 2>>54 ZmGs l{ Hl{{mxl{elch zlxo xoc Umfsc{

^raulhch b| cM~~rml{cLX“{ Lihc~cihcix M~~rml{cr{0

Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX Xr| xa [mxl{e| ZmGs“{ Kaikcri{

2<) Mfga{x lggchlmxcf| mexcr ZmGs rcxmlich cM~~rml{cLX xa ~raulhc m~~rml{mf{ li

cmrf| [sggcr 2>>5& ZmGs“{ fami ~rahskxlai {xmee bcjmi kag~fmlilij xomx xoc m~~rml{mf umfsc{

~raulhch b| cM~~rml{cLX“{ m~~rml{cr{ zcrc xaa faz) Lx zm{ kfcmr& mih cM~~rml{cLX zcff

sihcr{xaah& xomx ZmGs“{ hl{{mxl{emkxlai zm{ fmrjcf| hsc xa xoc emkx xomx cM~~rml{cLX“{ {xmee mih

ecc m~~rml{cr{ zcrc iax ‖olxxlij umfsc&‗ xomx l{& zcrc m~~rml{lij oagc{ mx m umfsc xaa faz xa

~crglx fami{ xa kfa{c)

;>) Ear cmg~fc& ai Msjs{x <& 2>>5& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ̂ rc{lhcix xafh ZmGs ccksxluc{

xomx ‖Zc icch xa mhhrc{{ xoc RAU l{{sc ) ) ) ) Gmi| fcihcr{ li xahm|“{ ciulraigcix ) ) ) omuc ia

RAU l{{sc) Xoc umfsc l{ xoc umfsc) L hai“x `iaz le ZMGS ~rahskxlai zlff ja ear xomx ) ) ) )

Xoc Zmgs lixcrimf {xmee zc mrc {~cm`lij zlxo mhgail{o s{ xa bc kcrxmli zc {afuc xoc RAU l{{sc

}slk`f| ar zc zlff mff bc li ear {agc ~rcxx| rasjo {cm{)‗

;=) M zcc` fmxcr& ai Msjs{x =3& 2>>5& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix

mhul{ch cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix xomx ZmGs“{ fami aeelkcr{ zasfh aexci ~rc{{src ZmGs“{

lixcrimf m~~rml{mf elcfh gmimjcr{ ear mi ‖cxrm ecz xoas{mih&‗ ar ‖xcffPW xocg {~cklelkmff| zomx

xoc| icchch&‗ ar zasfh ‖m{` ear {cucrmf RAU{ ai xoc {mgc ~ra~crx|)‗ cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc

Ulkc ^rc{lhcix c~fmlich xomx ‖PoWmulij fami aeelkcr{ m{` ear m ecz xoas{mih haffmr{ bckms{c lx l{

zlxoli xoc rmijc l{ {agcxolij zc ha iax ksrrcixf| ha ear mi| kflcix) ) ) ) Lx l{ mf{a hlrckx ~rc{{src

ai xoc m~~rml{cr ear m oljocr umfsc zlxoasx mi| mhhlxlaimf lieargmxlai)‗

;2) \cx aif| m gaixo fmxcr& ai [c~xcgbcr =8& 2>>5& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc

^rc{lhcix ~ra~a{ch m {afsxlai xomx m~~cmrch xa km~lxsfmxc xa xoc{c hcgmih{ ear mi ‖cxrm ecz

Page 12: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 12/31

^mjc =2 ae ;=

xoas{mih‗4 oc zraxc ‖lx faa`{ fl`c asr ~axcixlmf ‟rml{c xoc umfsc“ ~aflk| b| Pmi cM~~rml{cLX

gmimjcr“{W jras~ gljox ocf~ m fax ai xoc {gmff umfsc komijc{) ) ) ) PZWc mrc {xsh|lij mffazlij

Pxoc gmimjcr“{W jras~ m flxxfc efclblflx| xa rml{c xoc umfsc 3# zlxo m km~ ae (3>` le lx l{ esff|

 ds{xlelch)‗

;;) Kag~fmlix{ mih ~rc{{src erag ZmGs“{ fami arljlimxlai {xmee zcrc iax cg~x|

xorcmx{) Ai Akxabcr 3& 2>>5& li rc{~ai{c xa ‖kag~fmlix{ erag xoc ZmGs ~rahskxlai xcmg ‛

~mrxlksfmrf| li Iarxocri Kmflearilm&‗ cM~~rml{cLX ~rc~mrch m ‖ZmGs Lg~raucgcix

Lg~fcgcixmxlai ^fmi)‗ Xoc ~fmi zm{ si{skkc{{esf& oazcucr) B| Hckcgbcr 2>>5& ZmGs omh

rcm{{ljich mff ae lx{ Iarxocri Kmflearilm m~~rml{mf zar` xa F[L)

;8) Hsrlij xol{ ~crlah& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi zm{ {cc`lij mhhlxlaimf bs{lic{{ erag ZmGs

li axocr mrcm{) Bsx ZmGs c~rc{{f| kaihlxlaich jlulij mi| esxsrc bs{lic{{ xa Elr{x Mgcrlkmi ai

{skkc{{ zlxo cM~~rml{cLX) B| cgmlf hmxch [c~xcgbcr 2:& 2>>5& m Elr{x Mgcrlkmi {cilar

ccksxluc mhul{ch axocr {cilar ccksxluc{ mx Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX mbasx m

kaiucr{mxlai oc omh zlxo xoc ^rc{lhcix ae ZmGs Garxjmjc mbasx faij'xcrg bs{lic{{ ~ra{~ckx{)

Xoc Elr{x Mgcrlkmi ccksxluc c~fmlich xomx4

PZmGsW mih L hl{ks{{ch asr faij'xcrg rcfmxlai{ol~ likfshlij xocgaic| zc omuc ai hc~a{lx xocrc mih asr axocr ksrrcix bs{lic{{rcfmxlai{ol~{) L xafh olg zc zasfh fl`c xa c~mih xoa{c rcfmxlai{ol~{)Mih li cmkx xcrg{& zc zasfh fl`c aic omfe ae xoclr efaah bs{lic{{&zolko xoc| ksrrcixf| jluc =>># xa PKar~armxlai MW mih xoclr xmbs{lic{{ l{ hlulhch ; zm|{ mgaij P; kar~armxlai{W mih xomx zc zasfhfl`c xa xm`c PKar~armxlai M“{W xm bs{lic{{)

Mkkarhlij xa xoc Elr{x Mgcrlkmi ccksxluc& ZmGs rc{~aihch m{ eaffaz{4

Oc {mlh xomx le xoc m~~rml{mf l{{sc{ mrc rc{afuch mih xolij{ mrc zar`lijzcff oc zasfh zcfkagc kaiucr{mxlai{ mbasx c~mihlij asrrcfmxlai{ol~ likfshlij xm mih efaah)

Page 13: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 13/31

^mjc =; ae ;=

Xos{& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi `icz xomx ZmGs zasfh ~raulhc lx zlxo icz bs{lic{{ aif| le xoc ‖m~~rml{mf

l{{sc{‗ ‛ likfshlij ZmGs“{ kag~fmlix{ xomx cM~~rml{cLX“{ m~~rml{cr{ hlh iax ~raulhc oljo

ciasjo umfsc{ ‛ zcrc ‖rc{afuch)‗

;3) B| Hckcgbcr 2& 2>>5& cM~~rml{cLX iaxch lixcrimff| xomx ‖) ) ) zc `iaz PZmGs

l{W jalij xa kag~fmli mbasx xoc ckc{{luc isgbcr ae faz umfsc{ bckms{c xoc gmdarlx| ae arhcr{

mrc iax jalij xa PZmGs“{W ~rcecrrch m~~rml{cr{)‗

;5) Ai Hckcgbcr =?& 2>>5& aic cM~~rml{cLX ccksxluc xafh axocr{ xomx ZmGs omh

mhul{ch olg xomx lx{ krlxlkl{g zm{ bm{ch ai xoc emkx xomx ‖umfsc{ mrc kaglij li fazcr zlxo CM

PcM~~rml{cLXW‗ xomi zlxo F[L& xoc kag~cxlxar m~~rml{mf gmimjcgcix kag~mi| xomx ZmGs omh

mf{a rcxmlich xa ~raulhc m~~rml{mf{) Mkkarhlij xa xol{ ccksxluc& ZmGs gmlixmlich xomx ‖Xoc|

mf{a {cc garc Zmgs ~rcecrrch m~~rml{cr{ halij zar` ear F[L mih xoc| xoli` xomx l{ zo| xoc|

mrci“x omulij m{ gmi| umfsc l{{sc{ zlxo xocg) ) ) ) Xoc PZmGsW gmimjcr{ lihlkmxch xomx le xoc

fami kai{sfxmix{ omh m koalkc xoc| zasfh ~rcecr xa s{c F[L aucr cM~~rml{cLX bckms{c xoc| eccf

xoc| zlff omuc fc{{ ~rabfcg zlxo xoc umfsc{)‗

B) Zlixcr 2>>:4 Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX Mjrcc xa ‖Raff Aucr

mih Ds{x Ha Lx‗ mih Mkkc~x ZmGs“{ Karrs~x ^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{x

;:) Li Ecbrsmr| 2>>:& ZmGs hlrckxch cM~~rml{cLX xa {xa~ s{lij lx{ s{smf ~micf{ ae 

{xmee mih ecc m~~rml{cr{ xa ~crearg ZmGs m~~rml{mf{) Li{xcmh& ZmGs“{ fami arljlimxlai {xmee 

hcgmihch xomx cM~~rml{cLX s{c m ^rauci ^micf ae m~~rml{cr{ {cfckxch b| xoc fami arljlimxlai

{xmee& zoa zcrc koa{ci bckms{c xoc| ~raulhch oljo umfsc{)

;?) B| cgmlf hmxch Ecbrsmr| 22& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ̂ rc{lhcix c~fmlich xa {cilar

ccksxluc{ mx Elr{x Mgcrlkmi ZmGs“{ gaxluc{ ear hcgmihlij xoc ^rauci ^micf4

Zc omh m dalix kmff zlxo Zmgs mih F[L xahm|) Xoc mxxmkoch haksgcix

Page 14: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 14/31

^mjc =8 ae ;=

asxflic{ xoc icz m~~rml{cr m{{ljilij ~rakc{{) Li {oarx& zc zlff iazm{{lji mff Zmgs“{ zar` xa Zmgs“{ ‖^rauci M~~rml{cr{‗ ) ) ) ) Zc zlff~m| xoclr m~~rml{cr{ zomxcucr xoc| hcgmih) ^creargmikc rmxlij{ xa

rcxmli ~a{lxlai m{ m Zmgs ^rauci M~~rml{cr zlff bc bm{ch ai oaz

gmi| kagc li ai umfsc& icjmxlij m icch ear mi RAU) /Cg~om{l{

mhhch,)

;<) cM~~rml{cLX“{ {cilar gmimjcgcix zm{ zcff mzmrc ae xoc xorcmx{ xa m~~rml{cr

lihc~cihcikc liocrcix li mffazlij ZmGs“{ fami ~rahskxlai {xmee xa {cfckx xoc m~~rml{cr{ ai xoc

^rauci ^micf bm{ch ai zocxocr xoc m~~rml{cr ‖kmgc li ai umfsc&‗ mih rml{ch xoc{c kaikcri{ zlxo

Elr{x Mgcrlkmi“{ {cilar gmimjcgcix) cM~~rml{cLX ccksxluc{ zmrich ae xoclr ‖kaikcri

rcjmrhlij xoc ~rauci fl{x‗ mih ‖kaikcri{ mbasx aucr'umfsch ~ra~crxlc{)‗

8>) Xoc{c kaikcri{ zcrc zmrrmixch) cM~~rml{cLX ̀ icz xomx ZmGs“{ ̂ rauci

M~~rml{cr Fl{x zasfh bc kag~a{ch ae m~~rml{cr{ zoa omh bcci omih'~lk`ch b| xoc fami

arljlimxlai {xmee bckms{c xoc| brasjox li oljo m~~rml{mf umfsc{) Lihcch& zoci cM~~rml{cLX

rckcluch cgmlf rc}sc{x{ xa mhh ~mrxlksfmr m~~rml{cr{ xa xoc ~micf& xoc cgmlf komli{ aexci {oazch

xomx xoc rc}sc{x{ kmgc hlrckxf| erag ZmGs“{ fami arljlimxlai {xmee) Esrxocr& m ZmGs Ulkc

^rc{lhcix li xoc M~~rml{mf Aucr{ljox jras~ c~fmlich& li mi cgmlf xa cM~~rml{cLX mbasx mi RAU

ear m ‖faz umfsc&‗ xomx ‖Xol{ l{ mi cmg~fc ae xoc l{{sc xomx om{ kms{ch {mfc{ ~s{olij ear m

‟~rauci m~~rml{cr“ ~rakc{{)‗

8=) Li Ecbrsmr| 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX {lg~f| km~lxsfmxch xa ZmGs“{ hcgmih{) Li mi

cgmlf ai Ecbrsmr| 22& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix xafh {cilar ccksxluc{ mx Elr{x Mgcrlkmi

‖zc omuc mjrcch xa raff aucr mih ds{x ha lx)‗ Oc c~fmlich xomx ‖zc zcrc zlfflij xa fluc zlxo xoc

komijc le xoc| zasfh bmk` s{ s~ zlxo xoc m~~rml{cr{ mih xcff xocg xomx {lg~f| bckms{c xoc| mrc

rmxch m{ Jafh ̂ rcecrrch hac{ iax gcmi xomx xoc| kmi jrmb mff xoc ecc{) Xoc| mjrcch)‗ Li axocr

zarh{& ear xoc rljox ~rlkc li ecc{& cM~~rml{cLX zm{ zlfflij xa ja mfaij zlxo xoc ^rauci ^micf)

Page 15: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 15/31

^mjc =3 ae ;=

Lihcch& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix {sjjc{xch xa ZmGs

xomx le xol{ xoc km{c zc {oasfh omuc Zmgs zrlxc xoc lixrahskxlaifcxxcr{ xa xoclr m~~rml{cr{& {cx xoc {xmjc mih fcx s{ ha asr gmjlk ) ) ) ) Lm{{srch ocr xoc ial{c erag rcxmlf zlff {xa~ ) ) ) ) [oc brasjox s~ xoc emkx

xomx Zmgs `iaz{ xol{ gcmi{ flxxfc gaic| xa ia gaic| ear CM mihF[L mih xoc| zlff el xomx li xoc icmr esxsrc) Bsx ear iaz xoc| icch xa{xa~ xoc ial{c ar iaic ae s{ zlff bc mrasih) L bcflcuc ocr)

82) cM~~rml{cLX mjrcch xa xoc r̂auci ^micf zlxo esff ̀ iazfchjc xomx ZmGs“{ fami

~rahskxlai {xmee zm{ {cfckxlij m~~rml{cr{ xomx zasfh ‖olx umfsc‗ mih ~raulhc oljocr m~~rml{mf{)

Li mi cgmlf hmxch Gmrko =& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix xafh ZmGs ccksxluc{4

Rckcixf|& zc omuc bcci iaxlelch xomx Fcihlij zasfh fl`c s{ xa s{c

garc ae xoclr ‖^rauci M~~rml{cr{‗ ucr{s{ m~~rml{cr{ aee asr ~rc'{cfckxch m~~rml{cr ~micf) Lx {ccg{ xoc mgasix ae Rckai{lhcrmxlai ae Umfsc /RAU, rc}sc{x{ m{{aklmxch zlxo asr m~~rml{cr{ emr ckcch{ xoa{clilxlmxch zoci m ZmGs ~rauci m~~rml{cr kag~fcxc{ m elfc) [mlh

hleecrcixf|& Zmgs ~rauci m~~rml{cr{ brlij xoc umfsc li m jrcmxcr

gmdarlx| ae xoc xlgc zlxo glilgmf liuafucgcix ae xoc ucihar& {mfc{mih M~~rml{mf Aucr{ljox) L mg elic zlxo xomx& ae kasr{c& mih zlff

om~~lf| m{{lji Zmgs arhcr{ xa Zmgs ~rauci m~~rml{cr{ li{xcmh

ae cM~~rml{cLX“{ m~~rauch ~micf m~~rml{cr zocicucr ~a{{lbfc) /Cg~om{l{ mhhch,)

Zlxo xol{ cgmlf& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix ‖om~~lf|‗ mjrcch xa kag~ragl{c xoc kag~mi|“{

lihc~cihcikc mih ulafmxc xoc fmz{ jaucrilij m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc)

8;) Ai Gmrko 3& 2>>:& ZmGs kaielrgch xoc ~rlgmr| rafc ae lx{ fami arljlimxlai {xmee 

li ~lk`lij m~~rml{cr{ li m eaffaz's~ cgmlf& li zolko lx c~fmlich xomx xoc

^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{x l{ bclij krcmxch) Xol{ zlff rc~fmkc xoc ZmGs

~rcecrrch fl{x) Xoc lilxlmf fl{x ae imgc{ zlff bc ~raulhch b| fcihlij

zlxo m glilgsg ae xza m~~rml{cr{ ~cr mrcm!kasix|) Xoc fl{x zlff xoci

bc rculczch mih m~~rauch b| xoc M~~rml{mf Bs{lic{{ Aucr{ljox Xcmgmih zlff bc kock`ch mjmli{x asr ga{x rckcix licfljlbfc fl{x) Elimf fl{xzlff bc ~raulhch xa UGK“{ Pucihar gmimjcgcix kag~milc{W)Gmdarlx| ae zar` gs{x bc m{{ljich xa xoc m~~rml{cr{ ai xoc ^rauciM~~rml{cr Fl{x ai m ^rlarlx| Bm{l{) /Cg~om{l{ mhhch,)

Page 16: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 16/31

^mjc =5 ae ;=

88) cM~~rml{cLX `icz xomx xoc ‖rculcz mih m~~raumf‗ rafc ae ZmGs“{ M~~rml{mf

Aucr{ljox xcmg hc{krlbch mbauc zm{ m elj fcme& bckms{c ZmGs“{ M~~rml{mf Aucr{ljox xcmg

hcecrrch xa ZmGs“{ fami ~rahskxlai {xmee) Ear cmg~fc& li Gmrko 2>>:& s~ai fcmrilij xomx

ZmGs“{ fami ~rahskxlai aeelkcr{ zcrc ~rc{{srlij cM~~rml{cLX xa rcmko m ~rchcxcrglich umfsc

ear m ~mrxlksfmr m~~rml{mf& xoc M~~rml{mf Aucr{ljox Ucihar Rcfmxlai{ Gmimjcr xafh cM~~rml{cLX

xa ‖{xa~ kaglij xa gc ear m~~raumf‗ mih xa zar` xoc l{{sc asx zlxo xoc fcihlij {xmee) Li axocr

zarh{& ZmGs“{ M~~rml{mf Aucr{ljox jras~ ~raulhch ia aucr{ljox mx mff)

K) [~rlij 2>>:4 Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX

@icz Xomx Xoc ^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{x Zm{ Lffcjmf

83) M{ lx bckmgc likrcm{lijf| m~~mrcix xa cM~~rml{cLX xomx ZmGs“{ fami ~rahskxlai

{xmee zm{ omih'~lk`lij xoc m~~rml{cr{ xomx cM~~rml{cLX zm{ rc}slrch xa s{c bm{ch ai xoc umfsc{

xoc m~~rml{cr{ ~raulhch& cM~~rml{cLX bcjmi xa kai{lhcr xoc fcjmf lg~flkmxlai{ ae xol{

mrrmijcgcix) cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ̂ rc{lhcix mimf|tch xoc echcrmf jslhcflic{ mih

rcjsfmxlai{ ai m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc mih {cfckxlai ae m~~rml{cr{ b| fami ~rahskxlai {xmee& mih

mhul{ch cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix xomx ‖Bm{ch ai xol{& L xoli` ZMGS“{ icz lilxlmxluc l{ zm| aucr

xoc flic) Lx l{ cuci ~a{{lbfc xomx xoc ksrrcix mrrmijcgcix kra{{c{ xoc flic)‗ Li rc{~ai{c&

cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix zraxc4 ‖Blija-‗ mih c~fmlich xomx {likc xoc echcrmf jaucrigcix

ciearkch m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc rsfc{ umrlmbf| li hleecrcix rcjlai{ ae xoc Silxch [xmxc{& mih xomx

‖lx balf{ hazi xa zoa om{ dslkc zlxo zoag mx xoc rcjsfmxar| fcucf)‗ Li rc{~ai{c& xoc Ccksxluc

Ulkc ^rc{lhcix zmrich ‖lx gm| bc xomx xoc AX[ Pechcrmf Aeelkc ae Xorlex [s~crul{laiW l{ A@ zlxo

ZMGS“{ ksrrcix zm| /gm|bc, bsx xoc icz zm| {ccg{ xa bc }slxc m {xrcxko)‗

85) Ai M~rlf 8& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ̂ rc{lhcix zraxc mi cgmlf xa

{cilar cM~~rml{cLX ccksxluc{ rcjmrhlij cM~~rml{cLX“{ fcjmf flmblflx| ear s{lij ZmGs“{ ^rauci

Page 17: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 17/31

^mjc =: ae ;=

Fl{x) Oc c~fmlich xomx m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc l{ lilxlmff|

xoc fcihcr“{ rc{~ai{lblflx| {likc xoc AKK PAeelkc ae xoc Kag~xraffcr ae xoc Ksrrcik|W!AX[ aif| ~crxmli xa fcihcr{) Oazcucr& zc m{ mi MGK

icch xa rcxmli asr lihc~cihcikc erag xoc fcihcr ar lx zlff faa` fl`c

kaffs{lai) Lgmjlic m {lg~fc garxjmjc bra`cr {m|lij oc zlff jlucs{ xoc zar` le zc s{c ol{ ‖~rauci‗ m~~rml{cr) Zc {m| ia) Xol{ l{

ucr| {lglfmr xa xomx ckc~x xoc| mrc ucr| blj) ) ) )

[a xoc ~s{o bmk` xa ZMGS icch{ xa bc /m{{sglij zc zmix xa ha xol{{agc hm|,& cM~~rml{cLX icch{ xa koaa{c xoc m~~rml{cr{& iax ZMGS)Zocrc lx jcx{ rcmff| kfcmr xomx cM~~rml{cLX l{ IAX koaa{lij l{ xoc~rauci lhcm bckms{c xoc| mfzm|{ ja elr{x mih GS[X bc {cfckxch sifc{{xocrc l{ m {~cklelk rcm{ai zo| iax) cM~~rml{cLX l{ kfcmrf| bclij

hlrckxch zoa xa {cfckx) Xoc rcm{ailij xomx xocrc mrc eczcr RAU{

l{ bajs{ ear gmi| rcm{ai{ likfshlij xoc ga{x abulas{ ‛ xoc ~rauci

m~~rml{cr{ brlij li xoc umfsc{)

Esi& co11 /Cg~om{l{ mhhch,)

8:) \cx& hc{~lxc xol{ kfcmr mrxlksfmxlai ae zomx cM~~rml{cLX {oasfh ha& b| aic ae xoc

kag~mi|“{ ga{x {cilar ccksxluc{& cM~~rml{cLX hlh iax ‖~s{o bmk`)‗ Lx mjrcch xa s{c xoc ZmGs

^rauci M~~rml{cr ^micf& mkkchlij xa ZmGs“{ hcgmih{ ear kag~fcxc kaixraf aucr xoc ^rauci

^micf mih xoc rckai{lhcrmxlai ae umfsc ~rakc{{)

8?) Ai M~rlf =:& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ̂ rc{lhcix zraxc xa {cilar ccksxluc{ mx Elr{x

Mgcrlkmi& hc{krlblij xoc l{{sc{ zlxo ZmGs m{ eaffaz{4

Li {oarx& xoc l{{sc{ mrc s{lij xoclr hc{ljimxch m~~rml{cr{ m{ gmihmxchb| xoc ZmGs ~rahskxlai earkc mx 2># jra{{ gmrjli mih b|~m{{lij asr

~micf) Zc ulcz xol{ m{ m ulafmxlai ae xoc AKK& AX[& EHLK mih

S[^M^ liefsciklij rcjsfmxlai) /Cg~om{l{ mhhch,)

8<) Li {s~~arx ae ol{ kaikfs{lai xomx s{lij xoc ZmGs ~micf ulafmxch echcrmf

rcjsfmxlai{ mih S[^M^& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix mxxmkoch xa ol{ cgmlf m gcgarmihsg xa ZmGs

xomx zm{ ~rc~mrch b| cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix) Mx xoc asx{cx ae xoc

gcgarmihsg& cM~~rml{cLX {sggmrltch xoc jslhcflic{ rcjmrhlij m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc&

Page 18: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 18/31

^mjc =? ae ;=

{xmxlij4

Xoc umrlas{ rcjsfmxar| bamrh{ likfshlij AX[& AKK& EHLK mih axocr{~rc~mrch m fl{x ae erc}scixf| m{`ch }sc{xlai{ ai Lihc~cihcix M~~rml{mfmih Cumfsmxlai Esikxlai{ ai Gmrko 2=& 2>>3) Xoc{c EM]{ {oasfh bc

rculczch li kaidsikxlai zlxo ~rlar jslhcflic{ ~sbfl{och li =<<8 mih2>>;) L omuc likfshch xoc 2>>3 EM]{ mx xoc cih ae xol{ haksgcix) Zcm{{sgc xomx |as mrc ucr| emglflmr zlxo xoc{c haksgcix{)

Zc zmix xa eaks{ ai m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc) Mff xorcc haksgcix{mhhrc{{ mih rc'mhhrc{{ xol{ l{{sc) Li xoc {ckxlai xlxfch Lihc~cihcikc ae xoc M~~rml{mf mih Cumfsmxlai Esikxlai& xoc =<<8 mih 2>>; haksgcix{xmxc{& ‖Bckms{c xoc m~~rml{mf mih cumfsmxlai ~rakc{{ l{ mi lixcjrmfkag~aicix ae xoc krchlx sihcrzrlxlij ~rakc{{& lx {oasfh bc l{afmxcherag liefscikc b| xoc li{xlxsxlai{“{ fami ~rahskxlai ~rakc{{)‗ Xol{ l{rcliearkch li xoc [cfckxlij Lihlulhsmf{ xa ^crearg M~~rml{mf{ ar

Cumfsmxlai{ {ckxlai erag xoc 2>>; haksgcix) Lx {xmxc{ xomx lx l{lg~arxmix xa ci{src xomx xoc ~rajrmg l{ {mecjsmrhch erag lixcrimfliefscikc mih lixcrecrcikc erag mi li{xlxsxlai“{ fami ~rahskxlai {xmee)Lihlulhsmf{ lihc~cihcix erag xoc fami ~rahskxlai mrcm {oasfh aucr{ccxoc {cfckxlai ae m~~rml{cr{ mih lihlulhsmf{ ~raulhlij cumfsmxlai{crulkc{)

3>) cM~~rml{cLX“{ gcgarmihsg xoci m~~flch xoc m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc jslhcflic{

xa xoc ZmGs ^rauci ^micf mih kaikfshch xomx4

Bm{ch ai asr kaiucr{mxlai{ zc omuc omh zlxo xoc ZMGS aucr{ljox m{zcff m{ xoc }sc{xlai{ mih mi{zcr{ lilxlmxch b| asr kag~cxlxar F[L& lx l{

asr lixcr~rcxmxlai xomx xoc fami ~rahskxlai {xmee om{ m jrcmx hcmf

xa ha zlxo {cfckxlij m~~rml{cr{) Xoc ^MF P^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{xW

om{ bcci {cfckxch b| xoc fami ~rahskxlai {xmee mih xoc kaixlisch

s{c ae xoc{c m~~rml{cr{ l{ bclij gailxarch b| xoc fami ~rahskxlai

{xmee) Ear cmg~fc& ai xoc F[L }sc{xlai += ‖Hac{ ZMGS zmix xa bcs~hmxch xrmi{mkxlaimff| ai cucr| arhcr zc kmi iax m{{lji xa m ^MF1‗&ZMGS“{ mi{zcr l{ ‖\c{& zc icch m {oarx {cixcikc li xoc gc{{mjc faj{a xomx zc kmi gailxar& ‛ MIH ga{x lg~arxmix ' fcihlij kmi {cc zo||as hlhi“x m{{lji xa m ^MF {crulkc ~raulhcr) Iax s{lij m ^MF

m~~rml{cr zlff bc mi l{{sc {a zc icch xa ci{src zc“uc kaucrch asrbm{c{ m{ xa zo| xoc|“rc iax sxlfltch)‗ Xol{ m~~cmr{ xa bc hlrckxf| li

kaixrmhlkxlai xa xoc lixcrmjcik| jslhcflic{ sifc{{ |as omuc m

hleecrcix lixcr~rcxmxlai) $ $ $

Xol{ ~rahskc{ xoc eaffazlij komffcijc ‛ cM~~rml{cLX l{ a~crmxlij

Page 19: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 19/31

^mjc =< ae ;=

sihcr zomx m~~cmr{ xa bc m gmihmxc erag ZMGS li sxlfltlij ^MF{cfckxch m~~rml{cr{ /mih xol{ {cfckxlai l{ kaglij erag xoc fami~rahskxlai {xmee,) Zc mrc xoci m{`ch xa rc~ mih zmrrmix xol{ zar`)Zc mrc kaikcrich mbasx xol{ mrrmijcgcix erag m rl{` ~cr{~ckxluc ) ) ))‗ /Cg~om{l{ mhhch,)

3=) M{ hcgai{xrmxch b| xol{ gcgarmihsg& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX `icz

xomx kag~f|lij zlxo xoc ZmGs ^rauci ^micf ulafmxch m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc rcjsfmxlai{)

Oazcucr& cM~~rml{cLX hlh iax {xa~ kaihskxlij m~~rml{mf{ ear ZmGs s{lij xoc xmlixch ^rauci

^micf) Xa xoc kaixrmr|& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi“{ Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr& zoa {lx{ ai Elr{x Mgcrlkmi“{

Kag~flmikc Kagglxxcc& xc{xlelch sihcr amxo xomx ol{ rcmkxlai xa xoc M~rlf =: cgmlf mih xoc

mxxmkoch gcgarmihsg zm{ xomx ‖L hai“x rckmff mi|xolij sil}sc mbasx xol{ cgmlf)‗

32) Mjmli& ai M~rlf =:& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix zraxc xa

cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix mih Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr rcjmrhlij cM~~rml{cLX“{ fcjmf flmblflx|4

AX[ mih AKK aif| kaixraf fcihcr{) Oazcucr& xocrc l{ xoc fcjmfkaikcri mbasx kaffs{lai) Ear cmg~fc& fcx“{ {m| lx l{ hl{kaucrch xomx mfcihcr /fami aeelkcr mx m fcihcr, l{ bclij kaffs{luc zlxo mi m~~rml{crxomx l{ ai ASR /ZMGS, ~micf) Xomx l{& asr rc~{ mih zmrrmix{ m~~f|)Xoci zc mrc flmbfc L zasfh {m| bckms{c zc omuc jaic mfaij zlxo lx) ) )

)

Li mhhlxlai& L xoli` lx zlff xmril{o asr rc~sxmxlai li xoc m~~rml{mfkaggsilx| bckms{c zc mrc mffazlij ZMGS xa ~lk` m~~rml{cr{ bm{chai xoclr fami aeelkcr{) Lx gm`c{ s{ faa` kag~flklx) [a PlxW gm| iax bcmkxlaimbfc fcjmff| bsx zasfh osrx asr rc~sxmxlai) [a xoa{c mrc xza bmhxolij{ aee xoc ksee) Xocrc gm| bc garc le zc xoli` mbasx lx mih s{ckrcmxluc ~mrmialm)

3;) Ai M~rlf =:& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX cgmlfch lx{ {xmee m~~rml{cr{ xa c~fmli zo| xoc

{xmee m~~rml{cr{ omh bcci rcgauch erag xoc ZmGs ^rauci Fl{x) Li xoc{c gc{{mjc{&

cM~~rml{cLX“{ MBG{ mk`iazfchjch xomx ZmGs fami arljlimxlai {xmee zcrc iaz koaa{lij xoc

m~~rml{cr{ ear xoclr fami{4

Page 20: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 20/31

^mjc 2> ae ;=

L xoasjox L P{lkW ~m{{ ai g| xoasjox{ rcjmrh{ xoc rckcix gc{{mjc xomxzc mff rckcluch ear P{lkW ^cxcr fm{x zcc`cih) L zlff bc jfmh xa xcff |aszomx L `iaz) L omuc bcci xafh xomx xoc fcihlij eaf`{ mx Zmgs mihP{lkW zcrc siom~~| zlxo xoc MGK“{ mih ecfx xoc| zcrc iax rckclulij mjaah fcucf ae m~~rml{mf zar`) Xoc| xocrcearc hcklhch xa kai{xrskx

xoclr azi m~~rml{mf ~micf& iaz `iazi m{ xoc zmgs ~rauci ~micf& mihli{xrskxch xoc MGK“{ xa sxlfltc m~~rml{cr{ erag xol{ ~micf zocicucr~a{{lbfc) Xoc cih rc{sfx l{ xomx le |as mrc iax ai xol{ ~rauci ~micf lx l{ucr| sifl`cf| |as zlff rckcluc zmgs zar`)

Ia lihc~cihcix m~~rml{cr kasfh gl{rcmh xol{ gc{{mjc4 le |as zmix xa ha zar` ear ZmGs& |as

zlff omuc xa {mxl{e| xoc ‖fcihlij eaf`{ mx Zmgs)‗

38) Cuci bc|aih ~lk`lij xoc ^rauci ^micf& ZmGs“{ fami aeelkcr{ mx xlgc{ mf{a

hlrckxf| {cfckxch {~cklelk lihlulhsmf m~~rml{cr{ ai xoc ~micf xa kaihskx xoclr m~~rml{mf{) Ai M~rlf

=<& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr zraxc li mi cgmlf xa cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix

mih Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix4

Culhcixf|& zc ha jcx kmff{!cgmlf{ erag xoc ZmGs Aucr{ljox Jras~ xa{cfckx m {~cklelk m~~rml{cr ear mi arhcr) Iaz& iargmff|& xol{ zasfh iaxbc m kaikcri {likc xoc jras~ l{ {c~mrmxc erag PZmGsW fcihlij)Oazcucr& Ulk`| Pmx cM~~rml{cLXW l{ mf{a rckclulij m ka~| ae mi cgmlferag xoc FK PZmGs Fami Kai{sfxmix{W xa Aucr{ljox rc}sc{xlij xoc

m~~rml{cr {cfckxlai ‛ xoci xoc {sb{c}scix cgmlf erag Aucr{ljoxhlrckxlij xoc m{{ljigcix komijc)‗

33) B| M~rlf 2>>:& ZmGs omh kag~fcxc kaixraf aucr cM~~rml{cLX“{ m~~rml{cr ~micf)

Ai M~rlf 25& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix zraxc mi cgmlf xa {cilar gmimjcgcix mx Elr{x

Mgcrlkmi rcjmrhlij ZmGs) Li xoc cgmlf& cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix hl{ks{{ch xoc ^rauci ^micf

mih cM~~rml{cLX“{ rc~sxmxlaimf rl{`4

[mfc{ l{ xoc hrlulij earkc bcolih xoc ^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{x /^MF,zolko l{ }sc{xlaimbfc erag rcjsfmxar| ~cr{~ckxluc) Zc mrc rc}slrch xas{c xoc{c m~~rml{cr{ mx ?>!2># ecc {~flx{) Xol{ l{ hlfsxluc xa asr ^%F)Cuci zlxo xoc lg~fcgcixmxlai ae {sko& zc mrc {xlff elihlij xomx zc mrcbclij }sc{xlaich {srrasihlij zomx m~~rml{cr zm{ m{{ljich xoc arhcr)Zc eccf asr rc~sxmxlai li xoc lihs{xr| l{ bclij xmril{och b| xoc

Page 21: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 21/31

^mjc 2= ae ;=

lg~fcgcixmxlai ae xoc ^rauci Fl{x {likc ^rahskxlai {cfckx{ xoc

m~~rml{cr) /Cg~om{l{ Mhhch,)

35) \cx Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX kaixlisch xa kag~f| zlxo ZmGs“{ hcgmih{

mih mjrcch xa s{c xoc ^rauci ^micf {cfckxch b| ZmGs fami ~rahskxlai {xmee)

3:) Ai Gm| ==& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix zraxc xa

cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix xomx ‖ksrrcixf| ZMGS l{ kaixrafflij xoc m~~rml{cr ~micf) Xoc| mrc

{cfckxlij xoc m~~rml{cr{ mih kmfflij xocg ‟~rauci“ m~~rml{cr{) Xoc{c m~~rml{cr{ mrc bclij koa{ci

b| xoclr {mfc{ earkc) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi cM~~rml{cLX /EM cM~~rml{cLX, l{ abfljmxch xa s{c xoc{c

m~~rml{cr{)‗ Mkkarhlij xa cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix& ZmGs zm{ s{lij m ^rauci

^micf bckms{c ae xoc ‖faz umfsc{‗ erag cM~~rml{cLX“{ m~~rml{cr{)

H) [~rlij 2>>:4 Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX Mxxcg~x

xa [xa~ Zmrrmixlij ZmGs“{ M~~rml{mf{ Bckms{c Xoc|

@iaz Xoc| Omuc Lffcjmff| Kag~ragl{ch M~~rml{cr Lihc~cihcikc

3?) Ai M~rlf 25& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX lieargch ZmGs xomx ceeckxluc Gm| =& 2>>:& lx

zasfh ia faijcr ‖bc zmrrmixlij m~~rml{mf{ m{ ~creargch b| xoc Zmgs {cfckxch ^rauci M~~rml{cr

Fl{x /^MF, m~~rml{cr ai arljlimxlai{) ) ) ) Xoc icz& ucrbmf rc}slrcgcix{ xa sxlfltc Zmgs“{

~micfl{x{ emff{ asx{lhc xoc {~lrlx mih fcxxcr ae asr mjrccgcix m{ lx rcfmxc{ xa Zmrrmixlc{) ) ) )‗

3<) Xol{ zm{ m hrmgmxlk hc~mrxsrc erag cM~~rml{cLX“{ rcjsfmr ~rmkxlkc{) Ai lx{

zcb{lxc& cM~~rml{cLX kfmlg{ xomx4 ‖Mff ae Elr{x Mgcrlkmi cM~~rml{cLX“{ xrmhlxlaimf m~~rml{mf

~rahskx{ kagc {xmihmrh zlxo aic ae xoc lihs{xr|“{ {xraijc{x zmrrmixlc{) Asr zmrrmix| kaucrmjc

likfshc{ earckfa{src fa{{ liksrrch hsc xa ermsh ar jra{{ icjfljcikc) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi

cM~~rml{cLX“{ kagglxgcix xa m~~rml{mf }smflx| gcmi{ asr ks{xagcr{ hai“x icch xa ja xorasjo

xoc fcijxo| mih hleelksfx ~rakc{{ ae elflij m kfmlg mjmli{x asr Crrar{ mih Agl{{lai{ ~aflk|& li xoc

cucix xoc| {seecr m fa{{ hsc xa m~~rml{mf crrar) Ae kasr{c& xoc ~aflk| l{ xocrc ear xomx ~sr~a{c& bsx

Page 22: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 22/31

^mjc 22 ae ;=

asr zmrrmix| ~rc{cix{ m gsko {lg~fcr zm| xa rckaucr fa{{c{ hsc xa m~~rml{mf ermsh ar jra{{

icjfljcikc)‗

5>) cM~~rml{cLX xorcmxcich xa {xa~ zmrrmixlij ZmGs m~~rml{mf{ bckms{c

cM~~rml{cLX“{ gmimjcgcix `icz xomx lx omh kag~ragl{ch lx{ m~~rml{cr lihc~cihcikc b| s{lij

xoc ZmGs ^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{x) cM~~rml{cLX“{ Kolce M~~rml{cr om{ xc{xlelch xomx xoc xorcmx xa

{xa~ zmrrmixlij zm{ bm{ch ai xoc rl{`{ liocrcix zlxo ZmGs“{ koalkc ae {sko m ‖flglxch‗ ~micf)

5=) cM~~rml{cLX“{ {cilar gmimjcr{ mk`iazfchjch xoc{c rl{`{ lixcrimff| xa aic

miaxocr) M{ cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix c~fmlich li mi cgmlf xa axocr gcgbcr{ ae 

{cilar gmimjcgcix zolfc hl{ks{{lij m ~mrxlksfmr rckai{lhcrmxlai ae umfsc4 ‖Xoc arljlimf

m~~rml{cr zm{ m ZMGS ~rauci m~~rml{cr kaglij li (:3>&>>> oljocr xomi xoc cM~~rml{cLX

rculcz m~~rml{cr) Xol{ l{ m jaah cmg~fc ae zo| zc ksrrcixf| omuc {xa~~ch rc~ mih zmrrmix{

mih asr kaikcri{ mbasx aucr'umfsch ~ra~crxlc{)‗

52) Li rc{~ai{c xa xoc mbauc cgmlf& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr zraxc xomx

‖Li mhhlxlai xa xol{ cmg~fc& zc mrc mf{a {cclij zomx m~~cmr{ xa bc m oljocr liklhcikc ae 

Xorc{oafh Rculcz{ Pgmihmxch ear ~ra~crxlc{ zarxo aucr (= glfflaiW kaglij li zlxo m fazcr

umfsc xomi xoc arljlimf m~~rml{mf) L xoli` xol{ {s~~arx{ asr kaikcri rcjmrhlij xoc ~rauci fl{x)‗

5;) Ai M~rlf ;>& ;>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ r̂c{lhcix zraxc xa ol{ Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr&

rcjmrhlij xoc zmrrmixlij ae m~~rml{mf{ erag ZmGs“{ ^rauci ^micf4

L omuc jluci {crlas{ xoasjox xa |asr {sjjc{xlai ai Erlhm| rcjmrhlij mimhhcihsg xa {ckxlai B ae xoc kaixrmkx {xrl`lij asr }smflx| kaixraf

ceearx{ mih zmrrmix| kaucrmjc ai m~~rml{mf{ ~creargch b| mi m~~rml{craee xoc Zmgs ^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{x /^MF,) Zasfh |as hrmex{agcxolij xomx {xl~sfmxc{ xol{1 Mjmli& xol{ icz rc}slrcgcix ulafmxc{xoc {~lrlx ae asr mjrccgcix zocrc zc mjrcch xa mjjrc{{lucf| ]K mihzmrrmix m~~rml{mf{ m{ ~creargch b| asr azi ~micf) S{lij Fami

Aeelkcr“{ emuarlxc m~~rml{cr l{ abulas{f| {agcxolij zc zlff iax

Page 23: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 23/31

^mjc 2; ae ;=

{xmih bcolih erag m }smflx| mih rl{` ~cr{~ckxluc) /Cg~om{l{mhhch,)

58) Icucrxocfc{{& cM~~rml{cLX kaixlisch xa ~crearg m~~rml{mf{ ear ZmGs& mih

kaixlisch xa xasx lx{ lihc~cihcikc)

53) Xoc Icz \ar̀ Mxxaric| Jcicrmf l{{sch m {sb~acim xa Elr{x Mgcrlkmi ai Gm| 3&

2>>:)

55) Ai Gm| =3& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr li mi cgmlf zraxc xa

cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix rcjmrhlij ZmGs“{ M~~rml{mf Aucr{ljox jras~4 ‖L xoli` xol{ ~rauc{ xoc

~alix xomx ) ) ) Aucr{ljox kaixlisc{ xa bsk`fc zoci kaieraixch zlxo hlrckx mih sircfcixlij

~rc{{src erag fcihlij)‗

5:) Mfxoasjo cM~~rml{cLX rc~cmxchf| xafh Elr{x Mgcrlkmi xomx ZmGs“{ fami

arljlimxlai {xmee lffcjmff| {cfckxch mih kaixraffch lx{ ^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{x mih xomx& li {agc

li{xmikc{& fami aeelkcr{ zcrc hlrckxf| {cfckxlij {~cklelk m~~rml{cr{& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi li{xrskxch

cM~~rml{cLX xa kaixlisc xoc bs{lic{{ rcfmxlai{ol~ zlxo ZmGs) B| cgmlf hmxch Gm| =:& 2>>:&

Elr{x Mgcrlkmi“{ Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr li{xrskxch cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix mih Ccksxluc Ulkc

^rc{lhcix xa kaixlisc xoc rcfmxlai{ol~ zlxo ZmGs mih xa ‖hc{lji m gahcf xomx ~rchaglimixf|

fcucrmjc{ xoclr ~micf bsx hac{i“x ulafmxc asr lihc~cihcikc zolko l{ ~rabmbf| cm{lcr {mlh xomi

haic bsx xocrc {oasfh bc m zm| xa eljsrc lx asx)‗ /Cg~om{l{ mhhch,)

5?) Ai Gm| 2<& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ̂ rc{lhcix {sggmrltch xoc

~rabfcg{ li xoc cM~~rml{cLX!ZmGs bs{lic{{ rcfmxlai{ol~ li m fcxxcr xa m {cilar ccksxluc mx

ZmGs m{ eaffaz{4

Li xoc elr{x }smrxcr ae 2>>:& xoc {mfc{ jras~ ae ZMGS bcjmi xa li{l{xxoc| koaa{c xoc m~~rml{cr{ ga{xf| hsc xa xoclr kaikcri{ mbasx ‟fazumfsc{)“ cM~~rml{cLX cikasrmjch ZMGS xa rc{l{x xoc{c ~rc{{src{ le 

Page 24: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 24/31

^mjc 28 ae ;=

~a{{lbfc) Oazcucr& ZMGS hcklhch xa ja zlxo zomx kmgc xa bckmffch xoc ‖~rauci‗ fl{x ae m~~rml{cr{ rckaggcihch b| {mfc{) ) ) )

Xoc s{c ae xoc ‖~rauci ~micf l{ komffcijlij ear cM~~rml{cLX li xzazm|{4 M) Elimiklmff| ‛ Xoc ~rauci ~micf l{ ~mlh m glilgmf ae 2>#

garc xomi xoc cM~~rml{cfX ~micf) B) Rl{` Gmimjcgcix ‛ xoc~a{{lblflx| ae kaffs{lai bcxzcci xoc fami aeelkcr{ mih m~~rml{cr{ l{likrcm{ch zoci cM~~rml{cLX hac{ iax kaixraf xoc {cfckxlai) Limhhlxlai& cM~~rml{cLX l{ kaikcrich zlxo mi| ~a{{lbfc fcihcr ~rc{{srcar ~crkc~xlai ae fcihcr ~rc{{src zoci xoc aif| zm| xa jcx ai xocZMGS ‖~rauci‗ ~micf l{ xorasjo xoc fami aeelkcr)

5<) Hc{~lxc xol{ mrxlksfmxlai ae xoc ‖~a{{lblflx| ae kaffs{lai&‗ iaxolij komijch

bcxzcci xoc ~mrxlc{& ckc~x ka{gcxlkmff|& mih xoc| kaixlisch li xol{ karrs~x bs{lic{{

rcfmxlai{ol~) Ai Dsic :& 2>>:& m ZmGs ccksxluc hlrckxch cM~~rml{cLX xa komijc xoc imgc ae 

xoc ^rauci Fl{x ear xoc eaffazlij rcm{ai{4 ‖Imgc komijc erag ‖~rauci m~~rml{cr‗ mih!ar s{c ae 

xoc gail`cr ‖^MF‗ fl{x l{ hl{kaixlisch& sihcr hlrckxlai ae xoc ZmGs fcjmf hc~mrxgcix) Zc mrc

sxlfltlij m garc jcicrlk xcrg mkkc~xmbfc z!li rcjsfmxar| jslhcflic{ mih lihs{xr| {xmihmrh{)‗ Xoc

^rauci M~~rml{cr ^micf zm{ rcimgch xoc ‖ZmGs [cfckx‗ ~micf& mih cM~~rml{cLX mkkc~xch xoc

imgc komijc zolfc halij iaxolij xa {afuc xoc rcjsfmxar| ulafmxlai{)

LU) Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX ^crglx ZmGs“{ Fami Arljlimxlai [xmee 

xa Rcgauc M~~rml{cr{ Erag xoc ^rauci M~~rml{cr ^micf mih xa Lg~ra~crf|

Kaggsilkmxc Hlrckxf| Zlxo cM~~rml{cLX M~~rml{mf Bs{lic{{ Gmimjcr{

:>) M{ hl{ks{{ch mbauc& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX ~crglxxch ZmGs“{ fami

arljlimxlai {xmee xa {cfckx m ^rauci M~~rml{cr Fl{x ae m~~rml{cr{ mih xa kaixraf xoc ^rauci ^micf)

Li mhhlxlai& Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX ~crglxxch ZmGs“{ fami arljlimxlai {xmee xa rcgauc

m~~rml{cr{ erag xoc ^rauci ^micf ai xoc jrasih{ xomx {sko m~~rml{cr{ kai{l{xcixf| umfsch

~ra~crxlc{ fazcr xomi ZmGs“{ hc{lrch xmrjcx mgasix& omh m oljo rmxc ae rckai{lhcrmxlai ae umfsc

rc}sc{x{& ar ~creargch hc{` rculcz{ xomx rchskch miaxocr m~~rml{cr“{ umfsc ear m jluci ~ra~crx|)

Page 25: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 25/31

^mjc 23 ae ;=

:=) Li aic {~cklelk cmg~fc& li ar mbasx Hckcgbcr 2>>5& m ~mrxlksfmr m~~rml{cr

/‖M~~rml{cr M‗, zm{ m~~rauch xa bc mi m~~rml{cr ai xoc ^rauci ^micf) Erag Dmismr| 23& 2>>:

xorasjo Gm| :& 2>>:& M~~rml{cr M kaihskxch eluc m~~rml{mf{ ear cM~~rml{cLX zlxo rc{~ckx xa

ZmGs ~ra~crxlc{) Ear cmko m~~rml{mf& ZmGs rc}sc{xch m rckai{lhcrmxlai ae umfsc) Li cmko

li{xmikc& M~~rml{cr M rces{ch xa likrcm{c xoc umfsc)

:2) [oarxf| xocrcmexcr& M~~rml{cr M zm{ rcgauch erag xoc ^rauci Fl{x mih ~fmkch ai

xoc ZmGs limkxluc fl{x) Oc zm{ xoci xafh b| m ZmGs {mfc{ m{{l{xmix xomx oc zm{ rcgauch erag

xoc ~micf bckms{c oc hlh iax likrcm{c umfsc{ li rc{~ai{c xa xoc{c rckai{lhcrmxlai{ ae umfsc) Xol{

{mgc ZmGs {mfc{ m{{l{xmix xafh M~~rml{cr M xomx gmi| m~~rml{cr{ zoa omh ~rculas{f| bcci

rcgauch erag ZmGs“{ fl{x ae mkxluc m~~rml{cr{ ear kaihskxlij ermshsfcix m~~rml{mf{ zcrc bclij

rcli{xmxch ai ZmGs“{ ^rauci Fl{x li arhcr xa ocf~ ci{src xomx m~~rml{mf{ zasfh kagc li mx

{seelklcixf| oljo umfsc xa ~crglx xoc fami{ xa kfa{c)

:;) Ai Gm| ;>& 2>>:& M~~rml{cr M zraxc xa cM~~rml{cLX rcjmrhlij xoc ZmGs ^rauci

^micf) Li xoc cgmlf& M~~rml{cr M zraxc xomx4 ‖Zc kaixlisch xa ~raulhc xol{ oljo fcucf ae {crulkc

zoci cM~~rml{cLX xaa` aucr m{ m~~rml{mf gmimjcgcix) Zlxo ia c~fmimxlai ar zmrilij& L zm{

rcgauch erag xoc m{{ljigcix raxmxlai li glh M~rlf ae xol{ |cmr) L rc{~ckxesff| m{` xa bc rc'

li{xmxch m{ mi mkxluc ~rcecrrch m~~rml{cr)‗

:8) Eaffazlij rckcl~x ae M~~rml{cr M“{ cgmlf& ai Gm| ;>& 2>>:& mi cM~~rml{cLX

M~~rml{mf [~cklmfl{x zraxc xa cM~~rml{cLX“{ Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix& Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr

mih Kolce M~~rml{cr4

L zm{ zar`lij zlxo xza jaah& {aflh faij'xlgc zaihcresf m~~rml{cr{ liI\ mih KX sixlf rljox mexcr xoc ZmGs ^rauci ^micf zm{ eargch)Xoc| zcrc baxo rcgauch ucr| {aai mexcr ear ia m~~mrcix rcm{ai) Zc

zcrc omulij umfsc l{{sc{& oazcucr& L ecfx xoclr zar` zm{ ucr|

Page 26: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 26/31

^mjc 25 ae ;=

hcecihmbfc mih {s~~arxmbfc& mih `c~x ka~las{ iaxc{ ai asr

hcmflij{) Xoc| omuc kaixlisch xa `cc~ li xasko zlxo gc& li arhcr xaelih asx zo| xoc| zcrc rcgauch erag xoc ~micf) /Cg~om{l{ mhhch,)

:3) Ai Gm| ;=& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Kolce M~~rml{cr rc~flch4

Elr{x oc zm{ ai xoc Gm{xcr Fl{x {a ~sx ai ZMGS ^rauci mih xoci m{xoc fl{x zcix mrasih oc zm{ RCGAUCH) Xoc ~rabmblflx| xomx m famiaeelkcr rc}sc{xch olg xa bc rcgauch l{ ~rcxx| oljo L xoli` bckms{c xomxl{ zomx xoc| hlh zlxo xoc Gm{xcr Fl{x0 xoc| {cix lx asx xa Fcihlij xakoaa{c)

:5) Xa hmxc& M~~rml{cr M rcgmli{ aee xoc ^rauci ^micf)

::) Miaxocr m~~rml{cr /‖M~~rml{cr B‗, kaihskxch osihrch{ ae m~~rml{mf{ ear ZmGs

fami{ xorasjo cM~~rml{cLX erag Dmismr| 2>>: xorasjo M~rlf 2>>:) Hsrlij xol{ ~crlah&

M~~rml{cr B rckcluch =>2 Rckai{lhcrmxlai ae Umfsc rc}sc{x{)

:?) Ai M~rlf ;& 2>>:& li mi cgmlf M~~rml{cr B zraxc xa cM~~rml{cLX xoc eaffazlij4

L ZM[ DS[X GMHC MZMRC ERAG AIC AE \ASRKAG^CXLXAR[ /F[L, XOMX L GM\ BC AI M BFAK@CH FL[XERAG ZMGS) XOL[ GM\ OMUC [AGCXOLIJ XA HA ZLXOXOL[ M^^RML[MF LI ]SC[XLAI EAR ZOLKO L XOASJOX ZM[BCLIJ XM@CI KMRC AE MIH LI ^RAKC[[ AE BCLIJ

RC[AFUCH) KMI [AGCAIC OCF^ GC ASX OCRC M[ XOL[ L[LG^ARXMIX XA S[ XA @CC^ XOC RCFMXLAI[OL^ ZLXOZMGS XORASJO CM^^RML[CLX) ZOMX L[ JALIJ AI MIHZOMX KMI L HA XA KFCMR XOL[ ELFC S^11111 /Km~lxmf{ liarljlimf,)

:<) M {cilar m~~rml{cr cg~fa|ch b| M~~rml{cr B mrjsch xa cM~~rml{cLX xomx oc zm{

rcgauch bckms{c ZmGs hlh iax fl`c lx zoci oc rchskch m~~rml{mf umfsc{ mexcr hc{` rculcz{) Oc

zraxc4 ‖Mexcr rculczlij m~~rml{mf{ aucr xoc ~m{x ecz gaixo{& gmi| ae zolko mrc ermshsfcix& zlxo

liefmxch si{s~~arxch umfsc{& lx l{ hl{xsrblij xomx ZmGs“{ eaks{ mih kaikcri l{ gl{~fmkch zlxo

xoc rculcz ~rakc{{)‗

?>) Xa hmxc& M~~rml{cr B l{ {xlff ai xoc ZmGs rcgauch fl{x)

Page 27: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 27/31

^mjc 2: ae ;=

?=) [lglfmrf|& ai M~rlf =:& 2>>:& m xolrh m~~rml{cr /‖M~~rml{cr K‗, zraxc xa

cM~~rml{cLX xomx4

Xol{ l{ xoc {ckaih Zmgs M~~rml{mf }smflx| m{{srmikc l{{sc L omuc

rckcluch erag Zmgs li xoc ~m{x 2 gaixo{) Baxo m{ m rc{sfx ae mim~~rml{mf L kag~fcxch xomx hlh iax kagc li xa xoclr ~rchcxcrglich umfscear m ‖umfsch‗ Zmgs kflcix) L zm{ ~rc{{srch ear 2 zcc`{ xa komijc

baxo g| umfsc mih xoc kaihlxlai{ ae g| m~~rml{mf rc~arx ) ) ) baxo

ae zolko zcrc ulafmxlai{ ae S[^M^& EMIILC GMC mih xoc

[s~~fcgcixmf [xmihmrh{ L mg rc}slrch xa ab{cruc mih mg basih

b| g| flkci{c xa kag~fcxc) [likc xomx xlgc& L omuc bcci {lijfch asxb| ZmGs mih omuc bcci ~rc{{srch ai cucr| m~~rml{mf L omuckag~fcxch xomx hlh iax rcmko m ~rc'hcxcrglich umfsc) L eccf xomx Zmgsl{ li ~rakc{{ ae ‖bfmk`fl{xlij‗ gc m{ mi m~~rauch Zmgs m~~rml{cr b|jalij mexcr cmko m~~rml{mf L kag~fcxc mih faa`lij ear ulafmxlai{)‗

/Cg~om{l{ mhhch,)

?2) M~~rml{cr K zraxc xol{ cgmlf mexcr omulij bcci ~rc{{srch mih omrm{{ch xa likrcm{c

umfsc{ ai xza m~~rml{mf{& mexcr ZmGs omh rc}sc{xch RAU{ mih {oc omh hckflich xa likrcm{c xoc

umfsc{) [oarxf| mexcr ocr rces{mf xa likrcm{c xoc{c umfsc{& {oc rckcluch xza ‖Simkkc~xmbfc

M~~rml{mf Iaxlelkmxlai{‗ erag ZmGs) Mexcr omulij bcci omrm{{ch mih xmrjcxch zlxo

‖simkkc~xmbfc‗ {xrl`c{& {oc zlxohrcz erag ZmGs“{ ~micf li arhcr xa mualh bclij rcgauch

mjmli{x ocr zlff)

?;) [cilar ccksxluc{ mx cM~~rml{cLX mk`iazfchjch xomx ZmGs zm{ xmrjcxlij xoclr

m~~rml{cr{) Ai Gm| 2;& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr zraxc xa cM~~rml{cLX“{

Ccksxluc Ulkc ^rc{lhcix xomx ‖ Lx zm{ hl{xsrblij xa elih asx erag PZmGsW xomx zc rckcluc xorcc

xlgc{ xoc isgbcr ae {xrl`c fcxxcr{ m{ F[L ‛ mih zc“rc jcxxlij fc{{ uafsgc) Xol{ lihlkmxc{ xa gc

xomx xoc| omuc xmrjcxch asr ‖iai'~rauci‗ m~~rml{cr{ ‛ mih mrc {agczomx blm{ch mjmli{x CM li

xoclr zar`)‗

?8) Esrxocr& cM~~rml{cLX ~crglxxch fami aeelkcr{ mx ZmGs xa kaggsilkmxc hlrckxf|

Page 28: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 28/31

^mjc 2? ae ;=

zlxo cM~~rml{cLX“{ MBG{ mih M~~rml{mf [~cklmfl{x{ b| xcfc~oaic mih cgmlf& xa hl{ks{{ m~~rml{mf

umfsc{) Lihcch& cM~~rml{cLX ~crglxxch fami aeelkcr{ mx ZmGs xa ~rc{{src cM~~rml{cLX MBG{

mih M~~rml{mf [~cklmfl{x{ mbasx m~~rml{mf umfsc{ cuci mexcr mi lilxlmf m~~rml{cr om{ kai{lhcrch m

umfsc rckai{lhcrmxlai rc}sc{x mih rces{ch xa komijc xoc umfsc)

?3) cM~~rml{cLX ~crglxxch xoc{c lg~ra~cr ~rmkxlkc{ bckms{c ZmGs l{ m fmrjc kflcix

xomx hcgmihch xoc rljox xa omuc xoc{c kaixmkx{) Mih cM~~rml{cLX“{ MBG{ omh xoc msxoarlx| xa

komijc m elimf m~~rml{mf umfsc aif| bckms{c ZmGs omh hcgmihch& li [c~xcgbcr& 2>>5& xomx

MBG{ bc ~crglxxch xa ‖~ramkxlucf| gm`PcW m hckl{lai xa aucrrlhc mih karrckx xoc xolrh ~mrx|

m~~rml{cr“{ umfsc ar rculczcr“{ umfsc ksx)‗

?5) Esrxocr& cgmlf ckomijc{ bcxzcci ZmGs mih cM~~rml{cLX {oaz xomx ZmGs

rc~cmxchf| ~s{och cM~~rml{cLX“{ MBG{ xa likrcm{c m~~rml{ch umfsc{ {a xomx fami{ kasfh kfa{c)

Ear cmg~fc& li aic ckomijc zlxo mi cM~~rml{cLX rculcz m~~rml{cr& m ZmGs fami aeelkcr zraxc

xomx ‖Bm{lkmff|& le zc hai“x jcx mx fcm{x xoc m~~rml{ch umfsc ae (;&53>&>>> ) ) ) zc fa{c xoc hcmf)‗

/Cffl~{c{ li arljlimf,) Cmrflcr xomx hm|& xol{ fami aeelkcr xafh cM~~rml{cLX xomx ‖le zc hai“x omuc

m hcelilxluc (( m~~rml{ch umfsc xoci xoc barrazcr zlff ja xa miaxocr fcihcr zlxo m oljocr

m~~rml{ch umfsc ae (8gg) ^fcm{c ) ) ) mx fcm{x ) ) ) `cc~ xol{ umfsc mx xoc arljlimf m~~rml{ch umfsc

ae (;&53>&>>>)‗ /Cffl~{c{ li arljlimf,)

?:) Ai Gm| 2;& 2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Kolce M~~rml{cr hc{krlbch xoc{c kaggcix{ m{ ‖m

kfcmr ~lkxsrc ae Fcihcr ^rc{{src ai bcomfe ae ZmGs)‗

??) cM~~rml{cLX rckcluch axocr kaggsilkmxlai{ erag ZmGs li zolko ZmGs

mxxcg~xch xa liefscikc xoc m~~rml{ch umfsc{ ae {~cklelk ~ra~crxlc{) Ear cmg~fc& ai Gm| 28&

2>>:& cM~~rml{cLX“{ Kolce A~crmxlij Aeelkcr zraxc xa cM~~rml{cLX“{ ^rc{lhcix xomx4 ‖Zc omuc

Page 29: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 29/31

^mjc 2< ae ;=

rckcluch li xoc ~m{x& mih iaz ga{x rckcixf| zlxo xoc [mj Omrbar cucix /zolko liklhcixmff| ds{x

om~~ci{ xa bc m Icz \ar` ~ra~crx|,& kaggsilkmxlai{ zocrc lx kasfh bc ulczch xomx CM hlh

c~crlcikc {agc fcucf ae liefscikc xa likrcm{c m umfsc bc|aih xomx zolko zc kaikfshch li asr

azi mimf|{l{ zm{ iax {s~~arxch)‗

?<) cM~~rml{cLX“{ lixcrimf m~~rml{mf faj cixrlc{ lihlkmxc xomx lx{ Rculcz M~~rml{cr{

mih MBG{ likrcm{ch ~ra~crx| umfsc{ ai m~~rml{mf rc~arx{ mexcr bclij xafh b| ZmGs fami

arljlimxlai {xmee xomx {sko likrcm{c{ zasfh ocf~ fami{ xa kfa{c) Ear xoc ~crlah ae Iaucgbcr 2>>5

xa Gm| 2>>:& xocrc zcrc ? hc{` rculcz{ ~creargch b| MBG{ mih = hc{` rculcz ~creargch b|

xoc M~~rml{mf [~cklmfl{x rcfmxlij xa ~ra~crxlc{ li Icz \ar`& mff ae zolko zcrc ear ZmGs) Xoc

m~~rml{ch umfsc{ zcrc likrcm{ch li cmko ae xoc < hc{` rculcz{ kag~fcxch& m{ eaffaz{4 erag

(?23&>>> xa (?3>&>>>& (2;>&>>> xa (28>&>>>& (8=3&>>> xa (82>&>>>& (=&33>&>>> xa (2&2:>&>>>&

(:2>&>>> xa (:;>&>>>& (3;3&>>> xa (335&>>>& (3?>&>>> xa (3?:&>>>& (3>>&>>> xa (323&>>>)

<>) Xol{ fcucf ae kaixmkx bcxzcci ZmGs“{ fami ~rahskxlai {xmee mih cM~~rml{cLX“{

MBG{ l{ ~raolblxch b| S[^M^“{ lihc~cihcikc rc}slrcgcix{ mih b| {xmxc mih echcrmf fmz)

ELR[X KMS[C AE MKXLAI

/Ermshsfcix ar Lffcjmf Bs{lic{{ ^rmkxlkc{ ‛ Ccksxluc Fmz ª 5;/=2,,

<=) Xoc mkx{ mih ~rmkxlkc{ mffcjch ocrcli kai{xlxsxc kaihskx ~ra{krlbch b| ª 5;/=2, ae 

xoc Ccksxluc Fmz& li xomx hcecihmix{ cijmjch li rc~cmxch ermshsfcix ar lffcjmf mkx{ ar axocrzl{c

hcgai{xrmxch ~cr{l{xcix ermsh ar lffcjmflx| li xoc kmrr|lij ai& kaihskxlij ai xrmi{mkxlai ar m

bs{lic{{)

[CKAIH KMS[C AE MKXLAI

/Hckc~xluc Mkx{ ar ^rmkxlkc{ ‛ Jcicrmf Bs{lic{{ Fmz ª ;8<,

<2) Xoc mkx{ mih ~rmkxlkc{ mffcjch ocrcli kai{xlxsxc kaihskx ~ra{krlbch b| ª ;8< ae 

Page 30: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 30/31

^mjc ;> ae ;=

xoc Jcicrmf Bs{lic{{ Fmz& li xomx hcecihmix{ cijmjch li rc~cmxch hckc~xluc mkx{ ar ~rmkxlkc{ li

xoc kaihskx ae lx{ bs{lic{{)

XOLRH KMS[C AE MKXLAI

/Sids{x Cirlkogcix,

<;) B| cijmjlij li xoc mkx{ mih kaihskx hc{krlbch mbauc& hcecihmix{ sids{xf|

cirlkoch xocg{cfuc{ b| rckclulij ~m|gcix ear lihc~cihcix& mkksrmxc& mih fcjmf m~~rml{mf{& bsx

emlflij xa ~raulhc {sko m~~rml{mf{)

ZOCRCEARC& ~fmlixlee hcgmih{ dshjgcix mjmli{x xoc hcecihmix{ m{ eaffaz{4

M) Cidalilij mih rc{xrmlilij Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX& xoclr meelflmxc{&

m{{ljicc{& {sb{lhlmrlc{& {skkc{{ar{ mih xrmi{ecrcc{& xoclr aeelkcr{& hlrckxar{& ~mrxicr{& mjcix{ mih

cg~fa|cc{& mih mff axocr ~cr{ai{ mkxlij ar kfmlglij xa mkx ai xoclr bcomfe ar li kaikcrx zlxo

xocg& erag cijmjlij li mi| kaihskx& kai{~lrmk|& kaixrmkx& mjrccgcix& mrrmijcgcix ar

kagblimxlai& mih erag mha~xlij ar eaffazlij mi| ~rmkxlkc& ~fmi& ~rajrmg& {kocgc& mrxlelkc ar

hculkc {lglfmr xa& ar omulij m ~sr~a{c mih ceeckx {lglfmr xa& xoc kaihskx kag~fmlich ae mbauc)

B) Hlrckxlij xomx Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX& ~sr{smix xa Mrxlkfc 22'M ae xoc

Jcicrmf Bs{lic{{ Fmz& ª 5;/=2, ae xoc Ccksxluc Fmz mih xoc kaggai fmz ae xoc [xmxc ae Icz

\ar`& hl{jarjc mff ~raelx{ abxmlich& likfshlij ecc{ kaffckxch& mih ~m| mff rc{xlxsxlai& mih hmgmjc{

kms{ch& hlrckxf| ar lihlrckxf| b| xoc ermshsfcix mih hckc~xluc mkx{ kag~fmlich ae ocrcli0

K) Hlrckxlij xomx Elr{x Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX ~m| ~fmlixlee“{ ka{x{& likfshlij

mxxaric|{“ ecc{ m{ ~raulhch b| fmz0

H) Hlrckxlij {sko axocr c}slxmbfc rcflce m{ gm| bc ickc{{mr| xa rchrc{{ Elr{x

Mgcrlkmi mih cM~~rml{cLX“{ ulafmxlai{ ae Icz \ar` fmz0 mih

Page 31: THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK  by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. EAPPRAISEIT et al  Re: COMPLAINT

7/31/2019 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK by ANDREW M. CUOMO, Attorney General of the State of New York v. …

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-people-of-the-state-of-new-york-by-andrew-m-cuomo-attorney-general-of 31/31

^mjc ;= ae ;=

C) Jrmixlij {sko axocr mih esrxocr rcflce m{ gm| bc ds{x mih ~ra~cr)

Hmxch4 Icz \ar`& Icz \ar`  

Iaucgbcr =& 2>>:

MIHRCZ G) KSAGAMxxaric| Jcicrmf ae xoc [xmxc ae Icz \ar`  Mxxaric| ear ^fmlixlee 

=2> Bramhzm|& 23xo EfaarIcz \ar`& Icz \ar` =>2:=/2=2, 8=5'5>3;

B|4Ilkafc JscraiHc~sx| Kolce Xrlmf Kasi{cf

Ae Kasi{cf4Korl{xa~ocr GsfulolffM{{l{xmix Mxxaric| Jcicrmf


Recommended