The Philip C. Jessup International LawMoot Court Competition

WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP JESSUP CUP ROUND

Saturday, 3 April, 1993, at 9:00 a.m.

Mayflower HotelWashington, D.C.

Case concerningThe Nationalization of Certain Properties

Final Round Judges:

Mary FooterBritish Institute of International and Comparative Law

Luis Miguel Diaz, AdvisorForeign Minister of Mexico

Talbert Fox, counselExxon Co. InternationalDr. Farin MirvahabiFormerly of U.S. Department of StateJames Grossman, ChairmanU.S. Foreign Claims Settlement Commission

Finalists:

1993 JESSUP CUP ROUNDAPPLICANT

University Of Melbourne,Australia

Richard BouttleSusan BrennanAlison DuxburyBryon KoTony Pitman

1993 JESSUP CUP ROUNDRESPONDENT

University Of HawaiiU.S.A.

Andrew BunnDavid FormanDavid McCauleyKarla Winter

President

Justice:

Justice:

INTERNATIONAL LAW STUDENTS ASSOCIATION

2223 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W. CONGRESS OF

Washington, D.C. 20008-2864 U.S.A. . INTERNATIONAL LAW SOCIETIESPHILIP C. JESSUP

1-202-939-6030 INTERNATIONAL LAWCABLE "AMINTLAW I LSA MOOT COURT COMPETITION

FAX 1 202-265.0386 \ N, -- I ,,I,,) CONFERENCE OF

o1 INTERNATIONAL LAW JOURNALS

1-202-797-7133

Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition

1993 International Semifinals

Summary of Results

1993 Jessup Competition Winner

University of Melbourne (Australia)

1993 Jessup Cup Round

University of Melbourne (Australia) v. University of Hawaii (USA)Applicant Respondent

Richard Bouttle Andrew BunnSusan Brennan David Forman

Alison Duxbury David McCauleyByron Ko Karla Winter

Tony Pitman

Semifinal Rounds

National University of Singapore v. University of Melbourne

University of British Columbia (Canada) v. University of Hawaii (USA)

Quarterfinal Rounds

McGill University (Canada) v. University of British Columbia (Canada)

Georgetown University (USA) v. University of Hawaii (USA)

National University of Singapore v. Ateneo de Manila University (Philippines)

University of Melbourne (Australia) v. University of Vienna (Austria)

HOST PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION: THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF INTERNATIONAL LAW

1993 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court CompetitionInternational Semifinals Competition

Preliminary Round Rankings(Teams marked with an * advanced to Final Rounds)

RankTeam University Win/Loss Raw RoundNo. Score Points

1* 537 National University of Singapore 4-0 1332 302* 486 McGill University (Canada) 4-0 1304 283* 533 Georgetown University (USA) 4-0 1303 31.54* 514 Ateneo de Manila (Philippines) 4-0 1268 305* 512 University of Melbourne (Australia) 3-1 1356.5 30.5

6* 464 University of Hawaii (USA) 3-1 1326 27.57 432 Northwestern University (USA) 3-1 1326 278* 487 University of British Columbia (Canada) 3-1 1311.5 28.59 383 South Texas College of Law (USA) 3-1 1297 2510 452 University of Pennsylvania (USA) 3-1 1293 2811* 448 University of Vienna (Austria) 3-1 1288 2712 335 University of Alabama (USA) 3-1 1287 21.513 435 University of Iowa (USA) 3-1 1280 23.514 513 George Washington University (USA) 3-1 1278 2215 471 Universidad Catolica de Los Andes (Colombia) 3-1 1277 2616 551 University of Adelaide (Australia) 3-1 1271 23.517 492 Columbia University (USA) 3-1 1263 2318 372 Suffolk University (USA) 3-1 1250 2119 416 University of Otaga (New Zealand) 3-1 1244 21.520 398 International Islamic University (Malaysia) 3-1 1232 24.521 554 Instituto de Estudios Internacionale (Chile) 3-1 1221 19.522 467 National Law School of India 3-1 1197 2123 470 Wake Forest University (USA) 2-2 1282 2124 438 Southern Illinois University (USA) 2-2 1267 1825 375 Incorporated Law Society of Ireland 2-2 1267 16.526 515 University of Minnesota (USA) 2-2 1265.5 1727 484 Dr. Ambedkar Government Law College (India) 2-2 1265 2028 508 Brigham Young University (USA) 2-2 1240 1529 379 Universidad de Costa Rica 2-2 1215 21.530 541 University of Hong Kong 2-2 1211 16.531 336 Universitetet I Oslo (Norway) 2-2 1203 1732 351 University of Botswana 2-2 1173 1333 371 University of Papua New Guinea 2-2 1116 14.534 354 National University of Taiwan 2-2 1094 1635 535 Brooklyn Law School (USA) 1-3 1292 13.536 483 University of Kiel (Germany) 1-3 1286 12.537 349 University de Paris I (France) 1-3 1257 10

38 445 St. Mary's University (USA) 1-3 1256 1139 334 DePaul University (USA) 1-3 1227 15.540 462 Strathclyde University (UK) 1-3 1199.5 1541 388 University of Monaco 1-3 1199 10.542 503 University of Wisconsin (USA) 1-3 1190 943 453 University of Istanbul (Turkey) 1-3 1185 944 321 University of Pretoria (South Africa) 1-3 1174 9.545 528 Universidad Nacionale Autonoma de Mexico 1-3 1157 11.546 350 University of Kyoto (Japan) 1-3 1127 1047 342 Elte University (Hungary) 1-3 1069 1348 485 Gonzaga University (USA) 0-4 1217 849 320 Erasmus University Rotterdam (Netherlands) 0-4 1195.5 1150 301 University of Helsinki (Finland) 0-4 1130 6.551 360 Universidad Catolica Andres Bellos (Venezuela) 0-4 1126 452 539 University of Lund (Sweden) 0-4 1103 3.553 *381 University St. Cyril and Methodius (Macedonia) 0-4 ---

* - Observer team

1993 U.S. National Champion

University of Hawaii

1993 U.S. National Runner-up

Georgetown University

* * * * *

Memorial Rankings - International Semifinal Preliminary RoundsAlona E. Evans Award Competition

Rank Team University ScoreNo.

*1 512 University of Melbourne (Australia) 234*2 432 Northwestern University (USA) 227*3 448 University of Vienna (Austria) 226*4 464 University of Hawaii (USA) 224* 515 University of Minnesota (USA) 224* 484 Dr. Ambedkar Government Law College (India) 224*5 487 University of British Columbia (Canada) 223.25

6 435 University of Iowa (USA) 220486 McGill University (Canada) 220

7 452 University of Pennsylvania (USA) 2198 537 National University of Singapore 218

4389 47010 48311 383

33512 51313 533

416372398

14 34915 51416 388

37517 55118 49219 379

47120 535

33421 33622 48523 541

35024 52825 44526 45327 32028 508

36029 462

55430 46731 351

32132 539

50333 301

37134 34235 354

Southern Illinois University (USA)Wake Forest University (USA)University of Kiel (Germany)South Texas College of Law (USA)University of Alabama (USA)George Washington University (USA)Georgetown University (USA)University of Otaga (New Zealand)Suffolk University (USA)International Islamic University (Malaysia)University of Paris I (France)Ateneo de Manila University (Philippines)University of MonacoIncorporated Law Society of IrelandUniversity of Adelaide (Australia)Columbia University (USA)Universidad de Costa RicaUniversidad de Los Andes (Colombia)Brooklyn Law School (USA)DePaul University (USA)Universitetet I Oslo (Norway)Gonzaga University (USA)University of Hong KongUniversity of Kyoto (Japan)Universidad Nacionale Autonoma de MexicoSt. Mary's University (USA)University of Istanbul (Turkey)Erasmus University Rotterdam (Netherlands)Brigham Young University (USA)Universidad Catolicas Andres Bellos (Venezuela)Strathclyde University (UK)Instituto de Estudios Internacionale (Chile)National Law School of IndiaUniversity of BotswanaUniversity of Pretoria (South Africa)University of Lund (Sweden)University of Wisconsin (USA)University of Helsinki (Finland)University of Papua New GuineaElte University (Hungary)National University of Taiwan

218216215214214213212212212212211210209209206205204204202202200199197197195192.5192189188188187187184182182181181180180177161

*Top 5 memorials entered in Baxter Award Competition

* * * * *

Dillard Award Competition(Best Memorials in World Regional Competitions)

Rank Team University ScoreNo. (120 possible)

*1 464 University of Hawaii (USA) 228*2 533 Georgetown University (USA) 222*3 432 Northwestern University (USA) 220.5*4 535 Brooklyn Law School (USA) 220* 486 McGill University (Canada) 220*5 514 Ateneo de Manila University (Philippines) 218* 483 University of Kiel (Germany) 218* 380 George Mason University (USA) 218

6 438 Southern Illinois University (USA) 216470 Wake Forest University (USA) 216

7 484 Dr. Ambedkar Government Law College (India) 2158 445 St. Mary's University (USA) 214.59 513 George Washington University (USA) 21310 416 University of Otaga (New Zealand) 212.511 551 University of Adelaide (Australia) 21112 350 University of Kyoto (Japan) 20313 374 Richtsuniversitet Leiden (Netherlands) 20114 462 Strathclyde University (UK) 19915 375 Trinity College Dublin (Ireland) 19816 309 Oklahoma City University (USA) 195

515 University of Minnesota (USA) 19517 372 Suffolk University (USA) 193.518 394 California Western (USA) 186

*Top 5 memorials entered in Baxter Award Competition

Richard Baxter Best Memorials Competition(Best Overall Individual Memorials)

The top five-ranked sets of memorials from the two preceding memorial competitions areincluded in the annual Richard Baxter Memorial Competition, which determines the best individualeffort on the part of teams with respect to their Applicant and Respondent memorials. Thememorials for the Baxter Competition are scored by category (A or R) by a set of experiencedjudges, and are scored only as against the other memorials in their respective Baxter Award field.

Rank University Score

Applicant Memorials

1. University of Minnesota (USA) 1152. Dr. Ambedkar Government Law College (India) 1133. University of Melbourne (Australia) 1104. Georgetown University (USA) 109

George Mason University (USA) 109Northwestern University (USA) 109

5. McGill University (Canada) 1076. University of Hawaii (USA) 1067. Brooklyn Law School (USA) 1058. Ateneo de Manila (Philippines) 1039. University of Vienna (Austria) 9910. University of Kiel (Germany) 9811. University of British Columbia (Canada) 94

Respondent Memorials

1. Dr. Ambedkar Government Law College (India) 1182. Northwestern University (USA) 1153. University of Minnesota (USA) 113

University of Melbourne (Australia) 113Brooklyn Law School (USA) 113

4. University of Hawaii (USA) 110George Mason University (USA) 110

5. University of Kiel (Germany) 1096. University of British Columbia (Canada) 1057. Georgetown University (USA) 1048. McGill University (Canada) 1039. Ateneo de Manila (Philippines) 10010. University of Vienna (Austria) 95

Oralist Rankings - Preliminary Rounds

Rank Ave.Score

1 38.6672 38.5003 38.0834 38.0005 37.833

37.8336 37.667

37.66737.667

7 37.50037.500

8 37.33337.33337.333

9 37.16737.16737.167

10 37.00037.00037.00037.000

11 36.91712 36.833

36.83313 36.667

36.66736.66736.66736.66736.66736.667

14 36.50036.50036.500

15 36.33336.33336.33336.33336.33336.33336.33336.333

16 36.16736.16736.167

Oralist TeamNo.

McCauley, DavidGaviria, PatriciaBrennan, SusanSayagues, RafaelArndt, DeborahRyan, NiamhConsuegra, AndresHarland, ChristopherHo, Seng-cheeJoiner, MollyRowley, GlennBhaduri, ProbalCorkery, G.Elstein, MatthewFriedrichs, GeorgMaragoudakis, CynthiaMehta, PrakashLilley, MichaelTan, Ken HweeTran, VanWood, ElizabethKiernan, JoshuaSmith, BarbaraWahlheim, WilliamBrown, KellyHalkerston, GraemeHarrington-McBride, CatherineJamal, MahmudKoh, DanielWayland, ChristopherXixis, GeorgeBuhler, KonradManzanares, RafaelMueller, MiriamBallestas, DianaDeal, MichaelDuxbury, AlisonJones, DanKutty, NoorunnisaSpencer, RandyWilson, DavidWinter, KarlaBaker, AllysonColayco, ManuelForman, David

464535512379432375471487537470508467375533483445533533537435383535470335445452513

486537486535448379483471432512438398508383464487514464

University

University of Hawaii (USA)Brooklyn Law School (USA)University of Melbourne (Australia)Universidad de Costa RicaNorthwestern University (USA)Incorporated Law Society of IrelandUniversidad de Los Andes (Colombia)University of British Columbia (Canada)National University of SingaporeWake Forest University (USA)Brigham Young University (USA)National Law School of India Univ. (India)Incorporated Law Society of IrelandGeorgetown University (USA)University of Kiel (Germany)St. Mary's University (USA)Georgetown University (USA)Georgetown University (USA)National University of SingaporeUniversity of Iowa (USA)South Texas College of Law (USA)Brooklyn Law School (USA)Wake Forest University (USA)University of Alabama (USA)St. Mary's University (USA)University of Pennsylvania (USA)George Washington University (USA)McGill University (Canada)National University of SingaporeMcGill University (Canada)Brooklyn Law School (USA)University of Vienna (Austria)Universidad de Costa RicaUniversity of Kiel (Germany)Universidad de Los Andes (Colombia)Northwestern University (USA)University of Melbourne (Australia)Southern Illinois University (USA)International Islamic University (Malaysia)Brigham Young University (USA)South Texas College of Law (USA)University of Hawaii (USA)University of British Columbia (Canada)Ateneo de Manila University (Philippines)University of Hawaii (USA)

36.16717 36.000

36.00036.00036.00036.000

18 35.91719 35.833

35.83335.83335.83335.83335.83335.833

20 35.66735.66735.66735.667

21 35.50035.50035.50035.500

22 35.33335.33335.33335.33335.33335.333

23 35.16735.16735.16735.16735.16735.16735.16735.167

24 35.00035.00035.00035.00035.00035.00035.00035.000

25 34.91726 34.833

34.83334.83334.833

27 34.667

Orton, LeslieBechky, PerryLaird, PeterLittrell, AmyRusnak, DeniseSykes, JeffKelly, ClaireBoll, AlfredFan, PeterNarancic, PerryOdman, AysePackard, DanielRozmus, ScottSirisha, G.Kadenge, NyaReiterer, MarkusRodriguez, AlvaroWatts, JamieLee, T.MeNulty, ShaelaSchweikert, EmmanuelShaar, PamelaGeorges, ElizabethHapp, RichardHendricks, DavidKupper, ZsuzsaLeppo, SaraRios, MarcosBunn, AndrewGamboa, JuanHorton, JohnKase, NedKunkle, ReginaMabry, AlexMarsnik, SusanTaliaferro, AshleyAthmaram, V.Barnard, WendyBaroque, TeddoroCassidy, JoannaDanvergne, CatherineMegret, FredericPlimpton, TaraTorres, StevenBroberg, K.D'Heureux, PatriciaFriedman, AlyssaLawrie, ColinMiddleton, KirstyBarton, Jane

445492503335438485535503541486453508432484435448471551541372492513432483487342492554464471335452513445515335484349514349487349553372336486372462462515

St. Mary's University (USA)Columbia University (USA)University of Wisconsin (USA)University of Alabama (USA)Southern Illinois University (USA)Gonzaga University (USA)Brooklyn Law School (USA)University of Wisconsin (USA)University of Hong KongMcGill University (Canada)Istanbul University (Turkey)Brigham Young University (USA)Northwestern University (USA)Dr. Ambedkar Gov't Law College (India)University of Iowa (USA)University of Vienna (Austria)Universidad de Los Andes (Colombia)University of Adelaide (Australia)University of Hong KongSuffolk University (USA)Columbia University (USA)George Washington University (USA)Northwestern University (USA)University of Kiel (Germany)University of British Columbia (Canada)Elte University (Hungary)Columbia University (USA)Instituto de Estudios Internacionales (Chile)University of Hawaii (USA)Universidad de Los Andes (Colombia)University of Alabama (USA)University of Pennsylvania (USA)George Washington University (USA)St. Mary's University (USA)University of Minnesota (USA)University of Alabama (USA)Dr. Ambedkar Gov't Law College (India)University of Paris I (France)Ateneo de Manila (Philippines)University of Paris I (France)University of British Columbia (Canada)University Paris I (France)Georgetown University (USA)Suffolk University (USA)Universitetet I Oslo (Norway)McGill University (Canada)Suffolk University (USA)Strathclyde University (UK)Strathclyde University (UK)University of Minnesota (USA)

34.66734.66734.66734.66734.667

28 34.58329 34.500

34.50030 34.333

34.33334.333

31 34.16734.16734.16734.16734.167

32 34.00034.00034.00034.00034.000

33 33.91734 33.833

33.83333.83333.833

35 33.66733.66733.66733.66733.66733.66733.66733.66733.667

36 33.50033.50033.50033.500

37 33.33333.333

38 33.16733.16733.16733.16733.16733.16733.16733.16733.167

Czerniecki, KrystanMarcus, AndrewPozen, JoeReager, KevinSonnevend, Pa'1Sobstad, MargretheGoote, M.M.Valetutto, DavidBradburn, MatthewDrage, ChristineMonago, FrankEllin, NinaFiesman, ElizabethHall, KellyJallow, IsatouKakaraya, DannyChia-wen, HuangHilicki, MichaelMcPheron, RonSchedelberger, WolfgangToteng, BoingotloBaartman, J. J.Castaneda, LeiaFraser, KymPalmer, JamesThiruvengadam, ArunDeclerca, P.J.M.Fajana, FranciscaLebotse, KabeloPetranji, DoraRiddell, Amanda-JaneSheia, ChristianThiessen, JornTlhowe, L.Woodke, PeterBoko, DumaDiaz C., HernandoKlingenberg, GitaKuwimb, JohnBoesten, EkeTriplett, Michael0'Halloran, SusanDietrich, OttoDobbs, ThomasFourie, HelenGarcia-Flores, LuisGidwani, VictorMaeda, MatohiroMaguire, ConorShockley, Pat

492513334485342336320383485508334349334470398371354435334448351320514551416467320372351342416554483351503351360301371388435375448470321528541350375438

Columbia University (USA)George Washington University (USA)DePaul University (USA)Gonzaga University (USA)Elte University (Hungary)Universitetet I Oslo (Norway)Erasmus Univ. Rotterdam (Netherlands)South Texas College of Law (USA)Gonzaga University (USA)Brigham Young University (USA)DePaul University (USA)University of Paris I (France)DePaul University (USA)Wake Forest University (USA)International Islamic University (Malaysia)University of Papua New GuineaNational Taiwan UniversityUniversity of Iowa (USA)DePaul University (USA)University of Vienna (Austria)University of BotswanaErasmus Univ. Rotterdam (Netherlands)Ateneo de Manila University (Philippines)University of Adelaide (Australia)University of Otaga (New Zealand)National Law School of India Univ. (India)Erasmus Univ. Rotterdam (Netherlands)Suffolk University (USA)University of BotswanaElte University (Hungary)University of Otaga (New Zealand)Instituto de Estudios Intemacionales (Chile)University of Kiel (Germany)University of BotswanaUniversity of Wisconsin (USA)University of BotswanaUniv. Catolica Andres Bello (Venezuela)University of Helsinki (Finland)University of Papua New GuineaUniversity of MonacoUniversity of Iowa (USA)Incorporated Law Society of IrelandUniversity of Vienna (Austria)Wake Forest University (USA)University of Pretoria (South Africa)Univ. Nacionale Autonoma de MexicoUniversity of Hong KongKyoto University (Japan)Incorporated Law Society of IrelandSouthern Illinois University (USA)

33.16739 33.000

33.00040 32.833

32.83332.83332.833

41 32.66742 32.50043 32.333

32.33344 32.25045 32.167

32.16746 32.00047 31.833

31.83348 31.667

31.66749 31.500

31.50031.50031.500

50 31.33351 31.16752 30.833

30.83353 30.50054 30.33355 30.167

30.16756 30.000

30.00057 29.833

29.33358 28.66759 28.50060 28.167

Terblanche, VilliersLeitner, KennethPutnam, MarkAutio, JukkaCanevi, IrmakLi-shin, LiuQuiroz, DavidRoscoe, JohnKurczewska, DanutaKinayatulcah, AzizullahNavarette, A.Owen, SandraKiss, CsabaMaria-Ortega, JoseMorojlu, SeyfiAl-Suood, HusnuWideroe, RolfCheung, Fai HungMiettinten, KirsiFu-ping, HuangTjiong, H.I.T.Van Weerell, PatrickWigal, SheriKindbom, AxelKokaz, JoclelyneKragseth, IngvildSibbel, LejoYamada, TakuheiTalaki, PekkaDelgoda, RuwinieFernandez-Leal, I.Durr, E.Hayashi, FumiakiAlmquist, JessicaChia-hsin, HsuMontiel, MarianaOsanai, AtsushiAlva, Francis

- Arguello, R. S.- Buottle, R.- Brooks, Dominic- Byrnes, William-- Doherty, Frances- Huntley, Paul- Knudson, Ginny- Ko, Byron- Pitman, Tony- Salas, M.- Villalobos, Mauricio

321388438301453354360388503398528515342528453398336541301354320539485539453336539350301371528360350539354360350371

379512551388462551515512512379379

University of Pretoria (South Africa)University of MonacoSouthern Illinois University (USA)Helsinki University (Finland)Istanbul University (Turkey)National Taiwan UniversityUniv. Catolica Andres Bello (Venezuela)University of MonacoUniversity of Wisconsin (USA)International Islamic University (Malaysia)Univ. Nacionale Autonoma de MexicoUniversity of Minnesota (USA)Elte University (Hungary)Univ. Nacionale Autonoma de MexicoIstanbul University (Turkey)International Islamic University (Malaysia)University of Oslo (Norway)University of Hong KongHelsinki University (Finland)National Taiwan UniversityErasmus Univ. Rotterdam (Netherlands)University of Lund (Sweden)Gonzaga University (USA)University of Lund (Sweden)Istanbul University (Turkey)University of Oslo (Norway)University of Lund (Sweden)Kyoto University (Japan)University of Helsinki (Finland)University of Papua New GuineaUniv. Nacionale Autonoma de MexicoUniv. Catolica Andres Bello (Venezuela)Kyoto University (Japan)University of Lund (Sweden)National Taiwan UniversityUniv. Catolica Andres Bello (Venezuela)Kyoto University (Japan)University of Papua New Guinea

University of Costa RicaUniversity of Melbourne (Australia)University of Adelaide (Australia)University of MonacoStrathclyde University (UK)University of Adelaide (Australia)University of Minnesota (USA)University of Melbourne (Australia)University of Melbourne (Australia)University of Costa RicaUniversidad de Costa Rica

- Wicks, Alison- Yost, Peter

551 University of Adelaide (Australia)515 University of Minnesota (USA)

( argued only one round, and thus did not qualify for best oralist award)

Best Oralist in the Jessup Cup Round

Susan BrennanUniversity of Melbourne