Minutes of the Board of Trustees Meeting of March 24, 2016
1
THE QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
THURSDAY, MARCH 24, 2016
M I N U T E S
A meeting of the Board of Trustees was held in the Hon. Robert T. Groh Board Room of the
Central Library, 89-11 Merrick Boulevard, Jamaica, New York, Thursday, March 24, 2016 at
8:05 p.m.
PRESIDING: Carl Koerner, Esq., Chairman of the Board
PRESENT: Hon. Augustus Agate Martha Baker
Judy E. Bergtraum, Esq., Vice Chair
Maria Concolino
Matthew Gorton
Julissa Gutierrez
James Haddad, Esq.
Jukay Hsu
John Ottulich
Michael E. Rodriguez, Esq., Treasurer
Edward Sadowsky, Esq.
Earl G. Simons, Ed.D, Assistant Treasurer
Mayor, Hon. Bill de Blasio, Ex-officio
Represented by: Lydon Sleeper-O’Connell
Comptroller, Hon. Scott M. Stringer, Ex-officio
Represented by: Jimmy Yan, Esq.
Speaker, Hon. Melissa Mark-Viverito, Ex-officio
Represented by: Eve Cho Guillergan, Esq.
Borough President, Hon. Melinda Katz, Ex-officio
Represented by: Angelina Martinez-Rubio
Dennis M. Walcott
President and Chief Executive Office
Bridget Quinn-Carey
Vice President and Chief Operating Officer
Lewis Finkelman, Esq.
General Counsel
EXCUSED: Adrienne Adams
Lenore R. Gall, Ed.D
Haeda Mihaltses
Robert Santos, Esq.
Eli Shapiro, Ed.D, LCSW
Gabriel Taussig, Esq.
Minutes of the Board of Trustees Meeting of March 24, 2016
2
II. MINUTES: BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETING – February 25, 2016
It was moved by Mr. Rodriguez that the minutes of the Board of Trustees meeting of
February 25, 2016 be approved as submitted. The motion was seconded by Mrs.
Concolino. The motion passed unanimously.
III. REPORT OF THE CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD:
The Chairman of the Board planned to welcome Dennis M. Walcott, but unfortunately
he was delayed on a flight back to New York so the welcome was deferred until his
arrival.
The Chairman thanked Bridget Quinn-Carey, outgoing COO who completed five years
of service at Queens Library with her having also served the last 18 months as Interim
President & CEO. During the past 18 months it was not the best of times and there
were a number of challenges. Bridget had to deal with external examinations and audits
and internal changes. Throughout that period of time, Bridget acted in a most
professional manner and did an excellent job even with the rollout of six-day service
across the system which was accomplished in a short period of time. During this period
of time Bridget served as both the Interim President & CEO and COO where normally
there are two people and senior executives had to make do without that as well. We
have a very gifted staff and they stepped up to the challenge and at no time during this
18 month period was there a reduction in our services. Our service excelled and this is
a great accomplishment. We know Bridget is going to Hartford Library as their CEO.
We thank her for bringing her energy and skills to the people of Queens and that she
will bring that to the people of Hartford and will serve them well. Staff and Trustees
applauded her.
IV. COMMITTEE REPORTS
A. BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS COMMITTEE – March 24, 2016
The Buildings and Grounds Committee presented the report of the committee
meeting of March 24, 2016.
AT THE BOARD MEETING, MR. OTTULICH MOVED THAT THE REPORT
ITEMS OF THE BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS COMMITTEE BE ACCEPTED AS
PRESENTED. THE MOTION WAS SECONDED BY MS. BERGTRAUM. THE
MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. FINANCE AND INVESTMENT COMMITTEE – March 24, 2016
The Finance and Investment Committee presented the report of the committee
meeting of March 24, 2016.
AT THE BOARD MEETING, MR. RODRIGUEZ MOVED THAT THE REPORT
ITEMS OF THE FINANCE AND INVESTMENT COMMITTEE BE ACCEPTED
AND THE ACTION ITEMS BE APPROVED AS PRESENTED. THE MOTION WAS
SECONDED BY MR. SADOWSKY. THE MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Minutes of the Board of Trustees Meeting of March 24, 2016
3
C. EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE – March 24, 2016
The Executive Committee presented the report of the committee meeting of
March 24, 2016.
AT THE BOARD MEETING, THE CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD
RECOMMENDED THAT THE REPORT ITEMS OF THE EXECUTIVE
COMMITTEE BE ACCEPTED AND THE ACTION ITEMS BE APPROVED AS
PRESENTED WITH THE EXCEPTION THAT THE AGENDA ITEM RELATING
TO THE AMENDED BY-LAWS BE DEFERRED TO THE MEETING OF THE
FULL BOARD.
IT WAS MOVED BY MR. SADOWSKY AND SECONDED BY MR. RODRIGUEZ.
THE MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
V. OTHER BUSINESS
REPORT OF MINUTES OF THE QUEENS LIBRARY FOUNDATION BOARD OF
DIRECTORS MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 10, 2015
The Queens Library Foundation Board of Directors’ minutes of September 10, 2015,
approved by the Board of Directors of the Queens Library Foundation, were provided to the
Queens Library Board of Trustees for informational purposes.
AT 8:16 P.M. IT WAS MOVED BY JUDGE AGATE THAT THE MEETING MOVE
INTO EXECUTIVE SESSION TO DISCUSS EMPLOYMENT RELATED MATTERS
AND LITIGATION. THE MOTION WAS SECONDED BY MR. SADOWSKY AND
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY. ALL STAFF LEFT THE ROOM EXCEPT FOR THE
GENERAL COUNSEL
AT 9:00 P.M. TRUSTEE HSU LEFT THE MEETING.
AT 9:20 P.M. THE PRESIDENT AND CEO ARRIVED AND JOINED THE
MEETING AFTER A SEVEN-HOUR DELAY IN HIS FLIGHT INTO JFK
AIRPORT.
AT 9:38 PM IT WAS MOVED BY JUDGE AGATE THAT THE MEETING MOVE
OUT OF EXECUTIVE SESSION. THE MOTION WAS SECONDED BY MR.
HADDAD AND PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
IN EXECUTIVE SESSION, THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, AFTER DUE
DILIGENCE, VOTED TO REVISE THE BY-LAWS AND THAT THEY BE
PRESENTED FOR ADOPTION AT THE MAY 2, 2016 BOARD OF TRUSTEES
MEETING.
Minutes of the Board of Trustees Meeting of March 24, 2016
4
VI. PRESIDENT’S REPORT
1. President’s Report
The President apologized for his late arrival to the meeting as he was delayed at the
airport in Boston for several hours after attending a funeral for a close friend. He
thanked the Board for waiting so he could present his report. The President reported
that in the last two weeks, he had visited 44 community libraries and plans to visit
the rest over the next two weeks. The President added that he rode the book truck
one day to twelve of the community libraries and delivered and picked up books
and observed the back room operations and that having his desk on the first floor is
extremely helpful; his meetings are held there as well. He gets more than requests
for directions. The President related a few examples of patrons he has met – one
who was just released from prison and another who needs to leave his shelter during
the day so he spends his time at the Central Library. This is a great experience and
this is how he will continue to operate. The President thanked Bridget Quinn Carey
who has been outstanding during this transition as well as all of the staff who have
been truly supportive. 2. External Meetings and Outreach Activities – February 20, 2016 – March 14, 2016
The COO (as Interim President and CEO) provided the attached External Meetings and
Outreach Activities from February 20, 2016 – March 14, 2016.
3. External Meetings and Outreach Activities – February 29, 2016 – March 18, 2016
The President and CEO provided the attached External Meetings and Outreach
Activities from January 22, 2016 – February 19, 2016.
4. Key Performance Indicators – February 2016
The President provided the attached reports of key performance indicator statistics for
February 2016.
5. Open Budget Hearing Material Review
The President provided Open Budget Hearing materials for review. The hearing is
scheduled for April 4, 2016.
IT WAS MOVED BY JUDGE AGATE THAT THE MEETING BE ADJOURNED. THE
MOTION WAS SECONDED BY MR. SIMONS. THE MOTION PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 9:57 p.m.
______________________ Robert Santos, Esq.
Secretary Enclosures (6)
1) Report of the President and CEO
a) Interim President & CEO External Meetings and Outreach Activities – February 20, 2016 – March 14, 2016
b) President & CEO External Meetings and Outreach Activities – February 29, 2016 – March 18, 2016 2) Key Performance Indicators – February 2016
3) Open Budget Hearing Material Review
4) Buildings and Grounds Committee Report – March 24, 2016 5) Executive Committee Report – March 24, 2016
6) Finance & Investment Committee Report – March 24, 2016
President’s Report – March 24, 2016
External Meetings and Outreach Activities of the COO (as Interim President and CEO)
5
AGENDA ITEM: COO (AS INTERIM PRESIDENT AND CEO)
EXTERNAL MEETINGS AND OUTREACH
ACTIVITIES
February 20, 2016 – March 14, 2016
February 24, 2016 Meeting with Margaret Sullivan of Sullivan Studios
regarding space planning
Teleconference with Angelina Martinez-Rubio, General
Counsel, Borough President’s Office
February 29, 2016 Meet with Council member Vallone to provide update and
discuss capital projects
Tour of Central Library with Dennis Walcott
March 1-2, 2016 Library Advocacy – Albany, NY
March 3, 2016 Queens Library Foundation Board Meeting at Forest Hills
Community Library
March 8, 2016 Tour of Elmhurst Library with Borough President and
Trustees Concolino, Gall, Guillergan, Koerner, Schimmel
and Dennis Walcott, DDC
First Lady Chirlane McCray, Deputy Mayor Beury and
Korean Consul press event regarding launch of First Lady
McCray’s translation of her book “Talk to Your Baby” in
Korean with Eve Guillergan, Board representative for
Speaker, NYC Council and Dennis Walcott
March 10, 2016 Teleconference with Vornado regarding Rego Park
Community Library
Teleconference with Michael Woloz, Jeff Rodus and
Marty McLaughlin, Connelly McLaughlin & Woloz
President’s Report – March 24, 2016
External Meetings and Outreach Activities of the COO (as Interim President and CEO)
6
Testimony before City Council Queens Delegation at
Queens Museum, Flushing Meadows, Corona
March 11, 2016 Signing of Side Letter Agreement for Frontloading Annual
leave for Union-Represented Employees and Side Letter
Agreement for Union-Represented Security Guards and
Photo Opp with Local 1321
March 14, 2016 Meeting with Borough President, DDC, Trustees Adams,
Bergtraum, Ottulich, Santos and Taussig regarding Queens
Library Capital Projects
Collaboration with Museum of Chinese in America
(MOCA)
President’s Report – March 24, 2016
External Meetings and Outreach Activities of the President and CEO
7
AGENDA ITEM: PRESIDENT’S EXTERNAL MEETINGS AND
OUTREACH ACTIVITIES
February 29, 2016 – March 18, 2016
Tour of Central Library with Bridget Quinn-Carey
Library Advocacy Day, Albany, NY
Queens Library Foundation Board Meeting at Forest Hills
Community Library
Visit to Briarwood Community Library
Visit to Forest Hills Community Library
Visit to Glendale Community Library
Visit to Hillcrest Community Library
Visit to Hollis Community Library
Visit to Maspeth Community Library
Visit to Middle Village Community Library
Visit to North Forest Park Community Library
Visit to Pomonok Community Library
Visit to Rego Park Community Library
Visit to Ridgewood Community Library
Visit to South Hollis Community Library
Visit to Woodhaven Community Library
President’s Report – March 24, 2016
External Meetings and Outreach Activities of the President and CEO
8
Phone interview with Rob Pozarycki, Queens Courier
Visit to Baisley Park Community Library
Visit to Bellerose Community Library
Visit to Cambria Community Library
Visit to Central Community Library
Visit to Far Rockaway Community Library
Visit to Flushing Community Library
Visit to Fresh Meadows Community Library
Visit to Glen Oaks Community Library
Visit to Kew Gardens Hills Community Library
Visit to Laurelton Community Library
Visit to Rochdale Community Library
Visit to Rosedale Community Library
Tour of Elmhurst Library (new site) with Borough President and
Trustees Concolino, Gall, Guillergan, Koerner, Schimmel and
Bridget Quinn-Carey and Dennis Verriello
Phone interview with Jon Cronin, Queens Tribune
Teleconference with Vornado regarding Rego Park Community
Library
President’s Report – March 24, 2016
External Meetings and Outreach Activities of the President and CEO
9
Teleconference with Michael Woloz, Jeff Rodus and
Marty McLaughlin, Connelly McLaughlin & Woloz
Phone Interview with Karen Clements of Communities
of Color
Visit to South Jamaica Community Library
Visit to St. Albans Library Community Library
Signing of Letter Agreement and Photo Opp with Local
1321
WABC Up Close Interview with Bill Ritter
Meeting with Borough President, DDC, Trustees Adams,
Bergtraum, Ottulich, Santos and Taussig regarding
Queens Library Capital Projects
Collaboration with Museum of Chinese in America
(MOCA)
Teleconference with three library systems regarding
Commissioner Menin’s Working Group Meeting on
“One Book, One New York”
Visit to Lefrak City Community Library
Visit to Corona Community Library
Visit to Langston Hughes Community Library
President’s Report – March 24, 2016
External Meetings and Outreach Activities of the President and CEO
10
Visit to Poppenhusen Community Library
Visit to Whitestone Community Library
Visit to Bay Terrace Community Library
NY1 interview at Central Library
“One Book, One New York” working group meeting
with Julie Menin, Commissioner, Mayor’s Office of
Media and Entertainment to discuss ideas for a city-wide
community read program
Teleconference with Michael Woloz, Jeff Rodus and
Marty McLaughlin, Connelly McLaughlin & Woloz
Phone interview with Michael Gannon, QueensChronicle
Visit to Auburndale Community Library
Visit to Bayside Community Library
Visit to Douglaston-Little Neck Community Library
Visit to Queens Village Community Library
President’s Report
Key Performance Indicators
11
President’s Report – Key Performance Indicators Queens Borough Public Library
July 1, 2015 through February 29, 2016
Agency Circulation % Change
from last
year
In person
visits
% Change
from last
year
Program
Attendance
% Change
from last
year
Reference
%
Change
from last
year
Notes
Arverne 160,674 5.63 % 78,589 7.52% 6,883 19.02% 5,314 0.76% 4
Astoria 57,825 3.05 % 54,310 -15.56% 6,382 0.52% 11,777 -15.18%
Auburndale 101,565 -6.40 % 48,888 -8.07% 5,299 29.43% 13,255 10.95%
Baisley Park 37,099 38.92 % 47,308 26.06% 5,960 207.69% 19,997 36.85% 2
Bayside 258,175 -12.57 % 128,316 -0.88% 7,457 14.06% 37,568 38.78%
Bay Terrace 65,778 -5.81 % 53,693 -0.88% 5,754 -30.53% 14,746 -38.61%
Bellerose 88,401 23.56 % 64,330 22.52% 4,148 29.58% 23,186 70.20% 2
Briarwood 109,795 -9.34 % 82,041 -0.90% 14,624 14.69% 43,834 447.24%
Broadway 158,676 -4.76 % 169,681 -4.92% 6,882 -8.40% 20,891 225.76%
Broad Channel 50,699 -17.36 % 13,819 -6.94% 243 -58.46% 16 -76.47%
Cambria
Heights 58,321 -20.64 % 110,098 -12.27% 20,499 7.80% 10,897 16.97%
Corona 129,785 -13.42 % 144,899 -8.53% 16,131 -19.15% 8,657 -53.05%
Court Square 51,807 -6.08 % 53,618 4.61% 2,597 -10.45% 10,951 -30.73%
Douglaston 85,525 10.91 % 63,453 -0.42% 3,691 17.77% 10,718 -25.66%
East Elmhurst 38,282 -1.83 % 54,441 7.85% 5,096 -23.31% 3,965 -27.71%
East Flushing 70,419 -2.23 % 42,380 3.61% 3,427 56.70% 8,225 6.21%
President’s Report
Key Performance Indicators
12
Agency Circulation % Change
from last
year
In person
visits
% Change
from last
year
Program
Attendance
% Change
from last
year
Reference
%
Change
from last
year
Notes
Elmhurst 188,479 -12.29 % 88,875 -11.97% 1,032 35.79% 19,912 12.89%
Far Rockaway 79,857 -19.94 % 100,341 -18.76% 8,135 1.47% 18,490 9.65%
Forest Hills 255,946 -12.19 % 201,719 -7.17% 21,020 46.55% 138,087 34.66%
Fresh Meadows 380,262 -9.03 % 148,524 -3.55% 8,242 -5.64% 62,364 18.78%
Glen Oaks 212,729 -13.50 % 94,283 -10.08% 18,142 25.99% 43,731 49.32%
Glendale 66,196 10.02 % 41,138 1.07% 3,240 132.93% 5,150 -19.83%
Hillcrest 136,031 -7.69 % 75,060 -2.06% 2,153 -23.73% 8,330 -4.89%
Hollis 57,528 33.92 % 49,745 48.83% 3,752 166.29% 6,995 100.66% 2
Howard Beach 80,746 -15.36 % 52,932 -12.52% 1,739 -33.68% 13,007 10.88%
Jackson Heights 286,449 -12.44 % 272,190 -3.54% 12,924 -5.10% 71,927 32.61%
Kew Gardens
Hills 68,925 -6.93 % 67,129 6.09% 592 -44.93% 15,642 -8.91%
Langston
Hughes
56,179 -12.41 % 96,161 -11.48% 9,840 -7.80% 6,271 -63.04%
Laurelton 49,642 -16.37 % 73,145 -15.02% 11,497 19.14% 31,137 2.89%
Lefferts 98,114 13.48 % 116,437 19.65% 20,461 78.89% 25,987 -15.06% 2
Lefrak City 62,369 -10.16 % 82,814 -6.90% 8,906 41.01% 9,257 -0.72%
Long Island City 93,796 -4.67 % 102,209 -8.64% 38,876 46.31% 36,714 97.33% 8
Maspeth 139,962 -1.79 % 88,528 -5.38% 4,220 57.58% 24,332 37.52%
McGoldrick 104,537 -21.05 % 76,263 -9.14% 11,374 -21.25% 18,321 -5.14%
President’s Report
Key Performance Indicators
13
Agency Circulation % Change
from last
year
In person
visits
% Change
from last
year
Program
Attendance
% Change
from last
year
Reference
%
Change
from last
year
Notes
Middle Village 43,145 -19.48 % 28,317 -0.58% 3,724 1056.52% 4,220 8.21%
Mitchell-Linden 145,345 2.84 % 93,576 -0.74% 10,958 -2.88% 28,747 17.76%
North Forest
Park 81,578 -9.61 % 59,417 0.52% 1,815 101.89% 16,065 17.22%
North Hills 76,604 -6.39 % 59,768 -7.13% 4,849 -16.17% 20,124 24.86%
Ozone Park 81,611 -25.30 % 63,204 -14.75% 3,971 -21.01% 10,427 -11.72%
Peninsula 143,426 281.99 % 76,859 X 2,396 47.90% 1,950 -47.85% 1,4,8
Pomonok 64,294 -6.59 % 53,146 -3.35% 6,414 26.68% 18,224 202.77%
Poppenhusen 59,512 -7.16 % 47,487 -5.24% 3,076 9.27% 12,082 9.22%
Queensboro Hill 83,990 7.23 % 97,693 16.77% 2,894 -50.57% 7,299 -35.83%
Queens Village 77,841 -18.38 % 69,383 -3.51% 9,417 2.15% 12,280 57.72%
Rego Park 126,892 -5.27 % 123,776 1.31% 7,101 31.40% 12,154 -5.41%
Richmond Hill 109,117 -14.27 % 114,840 7.90% 32,028 39.17% 37,073 -10.48%
Ridgewood 118,474 -15.07 % 180,970 -14.96% 32,040 23.48% 49,591 23.92%
Rochdale
Village
41,929 19.88 % 85,059 50.23% 6,511 104.36% 11,733 194.43% 2,8
Rosedale 43,975 303.70 % 55,920 331.02% 6,947 732.97% 17,103 604.12% 2
Seaside 74,833 -32.50 % 60,965 0.83% 8,634 11.80% 262 -98.96% 4
South Hollis 41,466 -5.14 % 56,846 -4.96% 14,656 405.73% 33,232 27.02%
South Jamaica 36,492 -22.78 % 83,680 -10.09% 14,828 27.72% 10,386 -1.13%
President’s Report
Key Performance Indicators
14
Agency Circulation % Change
from last
year
In person
visits
% Change
from last
year
Program
Attendance
% Change
from last
year
Reference
%
Change
from last
year
Notes
South Ozone Park
57,082 -18.94 % 53,557 -7.72% 4,357 37.71% 16,054 -11.16%
St. Albans 46,322 -13.73 % 68,389 -4.86% 4,176 16.06% 3,804 37.83%
Steinway 161,682 -8.66 % 140,376 -3.72% 8,790 -45.46% 19,512 54.87%
Sunnyside 142,975 2.62 % 149,280 14.57% 12,692 25.01% 32,686 38.67% 2
Whitestone 93,215 -8.11 % 56,400 -6.70% 5,285 9.51% 41,720 63.11%
Windsor Park 105,637 -4.49 % 76,438 3.57% 5,456 27.30% 17,833 25.29%
Woodhaven 94,446 -5.52 % 82,576 0.99% 11,540 1.69% 10,609 10.18%
Woodside 97,715 -17.56 % 104,206 -2.07% 16,689 2.27% 23,720 3.03%
Community Libraries Total
6,190,171 -6.29 % 5,179,485 -0.24% 542,462 17.89% 1,268,541 19.52%
Central Library
Adult Learning
Center
1,927 25.13 % 0 -100.00% 4,604 88.77% 4,418 47.07% 6
Elmezzi LIC
Adult Learning
Center
1,036 -14.73 % 38,777 -2.82% 7,070 X 60 -91.56%
Elmhurst Adult
Learning Center 40 -21.57 % 11,161 -26.28% 4,481 -3.49% 1,683 82.93%
Flushing Adult
Learning Center 5,848 6.25 % 41,930 -26.99% 10,004 90.59% 2,080 90.65%
Peninsula Adult
Learning Center 277 648.65 % 0 0.00% 3,580 X 0 -100.00%
Rochdale Adult
Learning Center 841 294.84 % 0 0.00% 5,181 X 109 118.00%
President’s Report
Key Performance Indicators
15
Agency Circulation % Change
from last
year
In person
visits
% Change
from last
year
Program
Attendance
% Change
from last
year
Reference
%
Change
from last
year
Notes
Steinway Adult
Learning Center 1,612 10.49 % 0 0.00% 5,396 69.53% 646 27.92%
Adult Learning
Center Total 11,581 15.59 % 91,868 -34.40% 40,316 159.87% 8,996 38.06%
Central Adult
Fiction 60,009 -9.01 %
Central Adult
Fiction – Ask at
Desk
20,400 -15.09 %
Central Adult
Non-Fiction 123,886 -4.69 %
Central Adult
Non-Fiction –
Ask at Desk
73,657 -13.28 %
Central
International
languages
8,920 5.54 %
Central
International
Languages –
Ask at Desk
2,515 -29.63 %
Central Library
Current
Collection
24,996 9.98 %
Central Library
Fine Arts/Media
Center
357,102 -12.13 %
President’s Report
Key Performance Indicators
16
Agency Circulation % Change
from last
year
In person
visits
% Change
from last
year
Program
Attendance
% Change
from last
year
Reference
%
Change
from last
year
Notes
Central Library
Others 37,278 -21.43 %
Central Library
Hot Picks 25,405 36.09 %
Central Library
Interloan 669 -20.07 %
Central Library
Job Info Center 1,336 -27.59 %
Central Library
Young Adult
Room
54,048 -10.48 %
Children’s
Library
Discovery
Center
242,219 -7.07 % 198,965 7.38%
30,514 83.70% 23,534 -36.25%
Central Total 1,009,607 -8.92 % 986,037 11.30% 59,217 25.97% 218,330 -20.67% 3
Flushing 841,355 -24.06 %
Flushing IRC 18,142 -19.96 %
Flushing Job
Info Center (JIC) 595 -54.75 %
Flushing Media
Center 13,514 112.32 %
Flushing Total 911,094 -22.70 % 1,060,846 -13.38% 31,612 -15.25% 220,631 39.88% 7
President’s Report
Key Performance Indicators
17
Agency Circulation % Change
from last
year
In person
visits
% Change
from last
year
Program
Attendance
% Change
from last
year
Reference
%
Change
from last
year
Notes
E-book and E-
Magazines 350,167 -4.25 %
Virtual Music
and Movies 282,047 10.20 %
Virtual Library
Total 632,214 1.70 % 5
Langston
Hughes Black
Heritage
4,588 -18.04 %
Queens Village
Mail-A-Book 36,900 -5.97 % 3,457 118.38%
Miscellaneous
Other 2,248 -63.64 %
Miscellaneous
Total 393,904 -5.48 %
System Total 8,707,925 -9.06 % 7,361,064 -1.88% 676,188 19.82% 1,707,502 14.27%
Website Visits 5,122,983 0.14%
Wireless Use 320,510 27.16%
Computer
Sessions 1,986,671 -0.08%
Notes: 1 -- Library closed for renovation during a portion of the current fiscal year. 2 -- Library closed for renovation during a portion of last fiscal year. 3 -- Central Library partially closed during renovation in current fiscal year. 4 -- Closed/Partially closed due to damage from Hurricane Sandy. 5 -- Formerly called All E-Content; Streaming e-content metrics started 2/2014
6 -- CEL ALC moved from Annex to CEL branch starting Jan 2015 - no accurate gate count possible 7 -- Flushing Library partially closed for renovation in current fiscal year. 8 -- ALC programs listed under separate ALC location starting in FY16
President’s Report
Open Budget Hearing Material Review
18
President’s Report
Open Budget Hearing Material Review
19
President’s Report
Open Budget Hearing Material Review
20
President’s Report
Open Budget Hearing Material Review
21
Report of the Buildings and Grounds Committee of March 24, 2016
1
THE QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
MEETING OF THE BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS COMMITTEE
March 24, 2016
A meeting of the Buildings and Grounds Committee was held on Thursday, March 24, 2016 at
7:02 p.m. in the Hon. Robert T. Groh Board Room, Central Library, 89-11 Merrick Boulevard,
Jamaica, New York.
PRESIDING: John Ottulich,
Committee Chair
PRESENT: Judy Bergtraum, Esq.
Julissa Gutierrez
James Haddad, Esq.
Carl Koerner, Esq.
Dennis M. Walcott (teleconference: 7:02pm – 7:22pm)
President and Chief Executive Officer
Bridget Quinn-Carey
Vice President and Chief Operating Officer
Dennis Verriello
Interim Vice President Capital and Facilities Management
Lewis Finkelman, Esq.
General Counsel
EXCUSED: Adrienne Adams
Robert Santos, Esq.
Gabriel Taussig, Esq.
GUESTS: Hon. Augustus Agate
Jukay Hsu
Martha Baker
Maria Concolino
Michael E. Rodriguez, Esq., Treasurer
Edward Sadowsky, Esq.
Eli Shapiro, Ed.D, LCSW
Speaker, Hon. Melissa Mark-Viverito, Ex-officio
Represented by: Eve Cho Guillergan, Esq.
Borough President, Hon. Melinda Katz, Ex-officio
Represented by: Angelina Martinez-Rubio, Esq.
Comptroller, Hon. Scott M. Stringer, Ex-Officio
Represented by: Jimmy Yan
Report of the Buildings and Grounds Committee of March 24, 2016
2
THE QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
MEETING OF THE BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS COMMITTEE
March 24, 2016
Report
Report(s)
1. Sustainability Initiatives
The Library has actively explored strategies to reduce its contributions to climate change
while enhancing resilience to its impacts. Several initiatives have been implemented to
support the Mayor’s Office of Sustainability (MOS) and the Office of Recovery and
Resiliency (ORR) to advance long-term plans for sustainable growth and resiliency for the
City of New York. The Library has implemented the following projects that contribute to
the City’s goal of reducing environmental impacts:
Broadway The installation of a green wall is currently underway at this facility with an
anticipated completion date in late June 2016. A green wall consists of a
vertical planting system on outside walls where certain species of plants will
grow and completely cover the wall. The green wall will mitigate air pollution
levels by lowering extreme summer temperatures through photosynthesis and
absorb and clean air pollutants from the environment. This project includes
exterior seating for reading and Wi-Fi use. This project was funded by the
North Star Fund.
Central The Library partnered with the Greater Jamaica Development Corporation to
initiate an open space project at the Central Library through the installation of
seasonal plantings to improve the aesthetics of the exterior while improving the
local air quality in Jamaica, Queens.
In addition, the Mayor’s “Vision Zero" plan includes the possibility of a green
plaza to be constructed on Merrick Blvd to protect all pedestrians, including
those entering and exiting the Library.
Central The Library rolled-out a “No Waste” recycling program to educate staff on the
importance of conserving raw materials as means to reduce the need to
consume precious resources. Recycling is one of many “low-hanging fruit” that
effectively aids in the protection of raw materials and natural habitats for the
future by sending less trash to the landfills, which helps reduce air and water
pollution.
Report of the Buildings and Grounds Committee of March 24, 2016
3
System-Wide The Library received funding of $53,100 from the Department of
Citywide Administrative Services (DCAS) to implement an LED
lighting upgrade project at thirteen (13) community libraries. Over
1,400 LED lightbulbs were purchased and installed by Library
maintainers. LED lightbulbs typically use about 25%-80% less energy
than traditional lightbulbs and will last between three and twenty-five
times longer.
System-Wide The Library participated in the Department of Citywide Administrative
Services (DCAS) was awarded $50,000 in funding to design and
implement an energy smart competition to reduce energy consumption.
The Library implemented a "Flip the Switch" competition whereby
thirteen (13) community libraries competed to save the most energy in
their library from December 2014 - April 2015. Douglaston community
library won the grand prize by reducing their electric usage. Each of
the participating libraries received a portion of the $50,000 award to
purchase environmental science books and invest in sustainability-
related educational programming.
The Library hosted its first Earth Day event at Central Library on April
25, 2015. Several community organizations participated in activities
with residents. The purpose of the event was to teach children about
global warming and the importance of reducing carbon emissions. The
winners of the “Flip the Switch” energy reduction campaign were
announced at this event.
System-Wide The Library is presently in collaboration with both the Department of
Environmental Protection (DEP) and the Department of Design and
Construction (DDC) for the development of seven storm water and
surface water retention projects. The projects chosen were based on
storm water flood data.
2. Maintenance, Repair & Renovation
Maintenance, repair or renovation purchases awarded between February 1, 2016 and
February 29, 2016 in excess of $5,000 are provided below for informational purposes.
Approved procurement procedures were executed in accordance with the Library’s
Purchasing Policy including competitive quotations or in response to emergency
conditions as a matter of health and safety.
Steinway Emergency Management Inc. provided all labor and
materials to perform emergency spill recovery services. $5,500
Report of the Buildings and Grounds Committee of March 24, 2016
4
It was moved by Ms. Bergtraum that the meeting be adjourned. The motion was seconded by Mr.
Koerner. The motion passed unanimously.
There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 7:39 p.m.
_______________________________
John Ottulich, Chair
Buildings and Grounds Committee
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
1
THE QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
MEETING OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
March 24, 2016
A meeting of the Executive Committee of the Board of Trustees was held on
Thursday, March 24, 2016, at 7:40 p.m., in the Hon. Robert T. Groh Board Room of
the Central Library, 89-11 Merrick Boulevard, Jamaica, New York.
PRESIDING: Carl Koerner, Esq.,
Acting Chair, Executive Committee
Judy Bergtraum, Esq.
Matthew Gorton
Michael Rodriguez, Esq.
Edward Sadowsky, Esq.
Earl G. Simons, Ed.D
Bridget Quinn-Carey
Vice President and Chief Operating Officer
Lewis Finkelman
General Counsel
EXCUSED: Gabriel Taussig, Esq., Committee Chair
Robert Santos, Esq.
Dennis M. Walcott
President and Chief Executive Officer
GUESTS: Hon. Augustus Agate
Martha Baker
Maria Concolino
Julissa Guiterrez
James Haddad, Esq.
Jukay Hsu
John Ottulich
Eli Shapiro, Ed.D, LCSW
Speaker, Hon. Melissa Mark-Viverito, Ex-officio
Represented by: Eve Cho Guillergan, Esq.
Borough President, Hon. Melinda Katz, Ex-officio
Represented by: Angelina Martinez-Rubio, Esq.
Comptroller, Hon. Scott M. Stringer, Ex-Officio
Represented by: Jimmy Yan
ADMINISTRATIVE
COMMITTEE
MEETING
AGENDA
THURSDAY
AUGUST 8, 2002
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
2
THE QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
MEETING OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
March 24, 2016
REPORT
I. Action Item(s)
1. Contract Authorization – Marketing Platform
It was moved by Mr. Sadowsky that the Executive Committee recommend to the
Board of Trustees that the President and CEO be authorized to enter into a three
year contract with Oracle in the amount $248,640.
The motion was seconded by Ms. Bergtraum and passed unanimously.
2. Contract Agreement with the Berlin Rosen Consulting Firm to Coordinate
Tri-Li Advocacy Efforts and Provide a Community Mapping and Training
Program.
It was moved by Ms. Bergtraum that the Executive Committee recommend to the
Board of Trustees that the President and CEO be authorized to enter into a contract
with Berlin Rosen in the amount not to exceed $43,000 to provide Tri-Li
coordination services and community mapping and training services.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Rodriguez and passed unanimously.
3. Amended By-Laws
Mr. Koerner, Acting Committee Chair, recommended that discussion on the action
item for Amended By-Laws be deferred to the meeting of the full Board.
II. Report Item(s)
1. Personnel Report – 1/16/16-2/15/16
The President and CEO reported on the personnel report for the period of January 16,
2015 to February 15, 2016: Appointments, Promotions, Transfers, Leave Without
Pay, Return from Leave of Absence, and Separations.
IT WAS MOVED BY MR. RODRIGUEZ THAT THE MEETING BE ADJOURNED.
THE MOTION WAS SECONDED BY MS. BERGTRAUM. THE MOTION PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 7:57pm.
_________________________________
Carl Koerner, Esq.,
Acting Chair, Executive Committee
ADMINISTRATIVE
COMMITTEE
MEETING
AGENDA
THURSDAY
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
3
By-Laws of the Queens Borough Public Library
Adopted July 2, 1913, amended May 19, 1921, April 19, 1928 (Resolution 73), November 15, 1928
(Resolution 150), January 19, 1939 (Resolution 6), April 16, 1942 (Resolution 41), October 20,
1966 (Resolution 53, 54), May 15, 1975, January 1, 1980, March 20, 1980, November 19, 1981,
January 19, 1989, May 17, 1990, April 21, 1994, December 15, 1994, February 15, 1996, February
20, 1997, September 24, 2002, January 20, 2011, October 13, 2011, April 19, 2012, March 6, 2014,
May 22, 2014, and November 24, 2015
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
4
BY-LAWS
OF
QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
(A New York Not-for-Profit and Education Corporation
Incorporated under the Laws of 1907, Chapter 164)
ARTICLE I
MEMBERS
Section 1. Membership. Queens Borough Public Library (the “Corporation”) shall
not have members.
ARTICLE II
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
Section 1. Composition of the Board. The Board of Trustees of the Corporation
shall consist of nineteen trustees appointed alternately by the Mayor of the City of New York and
the President of the Borough of Queens, New York. The Mayor and President of the Borough of
Queens each shall inform the other of his or her appointments to the Board. The Corporation shall
maintain a record of appointments and advise each appointing party as to when it is the appointing
party’s turn to appoint a trustee. Any trustees appointed to a new term or to fill a vacancy on the
Board on or after June 1, 2014 must be either a resident of the Borough of Queens or own or
operate a business in the Borough of Queens. In making appointments and reappointments to the
Board of Trustees, the Mayor and the President of the Borough of Queens shall factor in the place
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
5
of residence of each trustee so that at least one resident of each of the community districts in the
borough of Queens is included among the appointed trustees.
In addition to the trustees appointed as set forth above, the Mayor, Comptroller,
Public Advocate, Speaker of the City Council of the City of New York and the President of the
Borough of Queens shall at all times be ex officio non-voting members of the Board of Trustees.
Each such ex officio trustee may designate a representative to serve ex officio in his or her place.
Section 2. Powers and Duties. The Board of Trustees shall have general power to
control and manage the affairs and property of the Corporation in accordance with the purposes and
limitations set forth in the Act incorporating the Corporation (Laws of 1907, Chapter 164 and the
amendments thereto, hereinafter referred to as the “Act of Incorporation as amended”) and shall
have full authority with respect to the distribution and payment of monies received by the
Corporation from time to time. The Board of Trustees may make such rules, regulations and
guidelines for the promotion and advancement of the Corporation and its purposes as the Board
may deem advisable.
The Board of Trustees, in addition to the powers and authority expressly conferred
upon it by these By-Laws, by the Act of Incorporation as amended, by statute and otherwise, is
hereby empowered to exercise all such powers as may be exercised by the Corporation, except as
expressly provided otherwise by the statutes of the State of New York, the Act of Incorporation as
amended or these By-Laws.
Section 3. Number. The use of the term "entire Board" herein refers to the total
number of trustees entitled to vote that the Corporation would have if there were no vacancies. The
number of trustees constituting the entire Board of Trustee shall be nineteen.
Section 4. Appointment and Term. Any appointed trustee who, as of December 31,
2014, was serving a five-year term on the Board of Trustees may continue to serve the remainder of
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
6
his or her five-year term and shall continue in office until his or her successor is duly appointed and
qualified, or until his or her earlier death, resignation or removal. Any trustee appointed to a new
term on or after January 1, 2015 shall be appointed for a three-year term and shall continue in office
until his or her successor is duly appointed and qualified, or until his or her earlier death,
resignation or removal.
Section 5. Vacancies. Any vacancy among the appointed Trustees arising at any
time and from any cause shall be filled by appointment which shall alternate between the Mayor
and the President of the Borough of Queens. Each trustee so appointed to fill a vacancy shall hold
office for the unexpired term of the vacancy filled and until the appointment and qualification of his
or her successor or his or her earlier death, resignation or removal.
Section 6. Resignation and Removal.
(a) Resignation. Any trustee may resign at any time by giving written notice to
the Chairperson, Vice Chairperson or Secretary of the Corporation. Such resignation shall take
effect at any time specified therein and, unless otherwise specified therein, the acceptance of such
resignation shall not be necessary to make it effective.
(b) Removal by Appointing Party. The Mayor and the President of the Borough
of Queens each may remove a trustee that he or she has appointed for misconduct, incapacity,
neglect of duty or where it appears to the appointing party that the trustee has failed or refuses to
carry into effect the Corporation’s educational purpose. The appointing party shall not be required
to obtain a recommendation from the Board of Trustees to remove a trustee that he or she
appointed. A trustee subject to such removal shall have the opportunity to submit to the appointing
party a response or appeal to any cause for removal within seven (7) business days of receipt of the
notice of removal and the appointing party shall review his or her reason for removal and any
response submitted to the appointing party by the trustee prior to removing the trustee.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
7
(c) Removal Recommended by the Board of Trustees. When the Board of
Trustees recommends removal of a trustee, the trustee subject to removal may appeal to both
appointing parties and either appointing party may remove the trustee where sufficient cause is
found. When one of the appointing parties recommends removal, such appointing party must
provide the subject trustee with notice and an opportunity to appeal, provided, however, that the
trustee subject to such removal may submit a written appeal to both appointing parties for review
and both appointing parties must agree on removal for such removal to be effective.
(d) Removal for Failure to Attend Board Meetings. If any appointed trustee
shall fail to attend three consecutive Board meetings without excuse accepted as satisfactory by the
trustees, such trustee shall be deemed to have resigned and the vacancy shall be filled as provided in
Article II, Section 5, of these By-Laws. The Secretary shall promptly notify a trustee in writing of
such automatic resignation; however, the giving of notice shall in no way be a condition precedent
to or alter the effectiveness of such automatic resignation.
Section 7. Annual and Regular Meetings. Regular meetings of the Board of
Trustees will be held at least six times a year, generally on the fourth Thursday of a month, at such
times and places as may from time to time be designated by the Board. The regular meeting of the
Board held in January of each year shall be deemed the annual meeting of the Board for the election
of officers and for such other business as may come before the meeting. The Board, by resolution,
may determine to reduce the number of meetings, including both regular and annual, of the Board
in a particular year to no less than four quarterly meetings, and may determine that a regular
meeting may be held on a day other than the fourth Thursday of the month. Every meeting of the
Board of Trustees, whether annual, regular or special, shall be open to the public and shall be held
in accordance with the provisions of Article 7 of the New York State Public Officers Law (the
“Open Meetings Law”).
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
8
Section 8. Special Meetings. Special meetings of the Board of Trustees may be held
upon the call of the Chairperson or any two other trustees serving as officers of the Corporation,
jointly. Special meetings may also be called upon the written request of three trustees to the
Chairperson, or in his or her absence, the senior trustee of the Board. Seniority shall be determined
according to the order in which the trustees were appointed. .
Section 9. Notice of Meetings. Notice of the time and place of any annual, regular
or special meeting of the Board of Trustees shall be mailed not less than five nor more than ten days
before the meeting to the usual address of every trustee. Notice of any meeting shall not be
required to be given to any trustee who attends such meeting without protesting prior thereto the
lack of notice to him or her, or who submits a waiver of notice, whether before or after the meeting.
Such waiver of notice may be written or electronic. If written, the waiver must be signed by the
trustee by any reasonable means including but not limited to facsimile signature. If electronic, the
transmission of the waiver must be sent by electronic mail and must set forth, or be submitted with,
information from which it can be reasonably determined that the transmission was authorized by the
trustee. Notice of all meetings of the Board of Trustees shall be given to the public in accordance
with the Open Meetings Law, provided that, notwithstanding anything to the contrary in the Open
Meetings Law, public notice of the time and place of a meeting of the Board scheduled at least two
weeks prior thereto shall be given to the public and news media at least one week before such
meeting.
Section 10. Quorum; Adjournments of Meetings. At all meetings of the Board of
Trustees, ten of the appointed trustees, present in person or by videoconference conducted in
accordance with the Open Meetings Law, shall constitute a quorum. Except as provided by law or
these By-Laws, at any meeting of the Board of Trustees at which a quorum is present, the vote of a
majority of the appointed trustees present at the time of the vote, provided a quorum is present at
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
9
such time, shall be the act of the Board. In the absence of a quorum, a majority of the appointed
trustees present may, without giving notice other than by announcement at the meeting, adjourn the
meeting from time to time until a quorum is obtained. At any such adjourned meeting at which a
quorum is present, any business may be transacted which might have been transacted at the meeting
as originally called. At any meeting of the Board of Trustees, only independent trustees may
participate in any Board deliberations or voting relating to any of the matters set forth in Section
712-a of the Not-For-Profit Corporation Law .
To comply with the Open Meetings Law, appointed trustees must be present in
person at a meeting or participate by videoconference for purposes of establishing a quorum and in
order to vote or otherwise take any action. Appointed trustees participating in a meeting by
conference telephone or similar communications equipment shall not be considered present in
person at the meeting for quorum or voting purposes. Trustee participation by videoconference will
qualify as being present in person only if the videoconference location is open to the public and the
use of such videoconferencing otherwise complies with the Open Meetings Law. Except as
otherwise provided by law or these By-Laws, ex officio trustees and their designated representatives
may attend and participate in all meetings of the Board, both in public and executive session but, as
they are not voting members of the Board, shall not be counted for the purpose of establishing a
quorum or in determining the number of votes necessary to adopt any motion or authorize any
action.
Section 11. Organization. The Chairperson shall preside at all meetings of the
Board of Trustees or, in the absence of the Chairperson, the then Vice Chairperson of the
Corporation or a temporary Chairperson as chosen by the appointed trustees present at the meeting
shall preside. The Secretary, if any, of the Corporation shall act as Secretary at all meetings of the
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
10
Board of Trustees. In the absence of the Secretary, the presiding officer may appoint any person to
act as Secretary of the meeting.
Section 12. Voting. At any meeting of the Board of Trustees, each appointed trustee
present in person shall be entitled to one (1) vote. The ex officio trustees are non-voting trustees.
ARTICLE III
OFFICERS AND AGENTS
Section 1. Officers. The officers of the Corporation shall include a Chairperson, a
Vice Chairperson, a Secretary, a Treasurer and an Assistant Treasurer, each of whom shall be
chosen from among the appointed trustees, and such other officers, if any, as the Board of Trustees
may from time to time appoint or elect. One person may hold more than one office in the
Corporation, except that one person may not hold both the offices of Chairperson and Secretary.
Section 2. Election, Term of Office and Removal. The officers of the Corporation
shall be elected annually by the Board of Trustees at the Board’s annual meeting in January. Each
shall continue in office until his or her successor shall have been elected and qualified, or until his
or her earlier death, resignation or removal. The Board shall form a Nominating Committee in
November of each year and a slate of candidates for the respective offices shall be presented to the
Board in December. No officer shall be elected for more than two consecutive terms for the same
office. Any officer of the Corporation may be removed at any time, with or without cause, by the
Board of Trustees.
Section 3. Vacancies. Any vacancy in any office may be filled by the Board of
Trustees by election of the Board after nomination by the Chairperson. Any officer so elected shall
hold office until the next annual meeting of the Board of Trustees and until the election and
qualification of his or her successor.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
11
Section 4. Chairperson; Powers and Duties. The Chairperson, who shall be chosen
from among the appointed trustees of the Corporation, shall have responsibility for the overall
supervision and direction of the Board of Trustees, and shall do and perform such other duties as
may be assigned from time to time by the Board. The Chairperson shall preside at each meeting of
the Board. He or she shall provide advice and counsel to the President and Chief Executive Officer
of the Corporation, assist with the oversight and implementation of the work of the Corporation and
shall be authorized to sign legal documents and other communications on behalf of the Corporation.
No employee of the Corporation may serve as Chairperson.
Section 5. Vice Chairperson; Powers and Duties. The Vice Chairperson of the
Board, who shall be chosen from among the appointed trustees of the Corporation, shall assist the
Chairperson in the supervision of the activities of the Corporation and its several officers and shall
have such other powers and duties as the Board of Trustees may prescribe. He or she shall act as
Chairperson of the Board in the absence or disability of the Chairperson of the Board. No
employee of the Corporation may serve as Vice Chairperson.
Section 6. Secretary; Powers and Duties. The Secretary, who shall be chosen from
among the appointed trustees of the Corporation, shall act as secretary of all meetings of the Board
of Trustees, and shall keep or cause to be kept, the minutes of all such meetings in the
Corporation’s minute book and certify the accuracy of the minutes. The Secretary shall attend to
the giving and serving of all notices of the Corporation and shall perform all duties incident to the
office of the Secretary, subject, however, to the control of the Board of Trustees. The Secretary
shall perform such other duties as required in these By-Laws and as shall from time to time be
assigned to him or her by the Board of Trustees.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
12
Section 7. Treasurer; Powers and Duties. The Treasurer, who shall be chosen from
among the appointed trustees of the Corporation, shall keep or cause to be kept complete and
accurate accounts of receipts and disbursements of the Corporation, and shall deposit or cause to be
deposited all monies and other valuable effects of the Corporation in the name and to the credit of
the Corporation in such banks or depositories as the Board of Trustees may designate. He or she
shall disburse or cause to be disbursed the funds of the Corporation as directed by the Board of
Trustees. The Treasurer shall serve as the Chair of the Finance and Investment Committee. At each
regular meeting of the Finance and Investment Committee and whenever otherwise required by the
Board of Trustees, the Treasurer shall render or cause to be rendered a statement of the accounts of
the Corporation. He or she shall at all reasonable times exhibit or cause to be exhibited the books
and accounts of the Corporation to any officer or trustee of the Corporation, and shall perform all
duties incident to the office of Treasurer, subject, however, to the control of the Board of Trustees,
and such other duties as shall from time to time be assigned to the Treasurer by the Board of
Trustees. The Treasurer shall, if required by the Board of Trustees, give such bond or security for
the faithful performance of his or her duties as the Board of Trustees may require. The expense of
any such bond or security shall be paid by the Corporation.
Section 8. Assistant Treasurer. The Assistant Treasurer, who shall be chosen from
among the appointed trustees of the Corporation, shall act as Treasurer in the absence or disability
of the Treasurer with all the powers of the Treasurer. The Assistant Treasurer shall perform such
other duties as shall from time to time be assigned to the Assistant Treasurer by the Board of
Trustees.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
13
ARTICLE IV
KEY EXECUTIVE PERSONNEL
Section 1. Key Executive Personnel. The key executive personnel of the
Corporation shall include the: (i) President and Chief Executive Officer; (ii) Chief Librarian; (iii)
Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer; (iii) Vice President and Chief Financial
Officer; (iv) Vice President and General Counsel; and (v) such other employees as the Board of
Trustees, from time to time, determines are key executive employees.
Section 2. Hiring and Compensation. The Board of Trustees shall appoint the
President and Chief Executive Officer of the Corporation. The Chief Librarian, Vice President and
Chief Operating Officer, the Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, and the Vice President and
General Counsel shall be appointed by the President and Chief Executive Officer with the consent
of the Board of Trustees. All key executive employees shall serve at the pleasure of the Board of
Trustees and may be removed with or without cause by the Board.
The Labor Relations Committee shall annually review and make recommendations
to the Board of Trustees regarding the compensation arrangements for the President and Chief
Executive Officer and other key executive employees in accordance with the policies and
procedures set forth in Article V, Section 4, of these By-Laws.
Section 3. Outside Employment. No key executive employee shall engage in any
employment, other than his or her employment with the Corporation, which is more than incidental.
“Incidental employment” is employment that requires no more than five hours per month of the key
executive employee’s time. No key executive employee may engage in any incidental employment
or, in the case of key executive employees employed by the Corporation as of the adoption of these
amended By-Laws, continue to engage in any incidental employment without having obtained the
prior approval of the Board of Trustees. No key executive employee may pursue such incidental
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
14
employment on Corporation time or use Corporation equipment, supplies, letterhead, resources,
personnel or confidential information for such incidental employment. Incidental employment with
a corporation, business, entity or person that does business with the Corporation shall not be
permitted.
Section 4. Annual Financial Disclosure. The executive director and other key
executive personnel shall annually complete and submit to the Corporation a financial disclosure
statement, providing such information as required by the Corporation. The Vice President and
General Counsel shall review the key executive annual financial disclosure statements on an annual
basis and report any issues that arise upon such review to the Audit Committee, except that the
Chair of the Audit Committee shall review the Vice President and General Counsel’s annual
financial disclosure statements on an annual basis and report any issues that arise upon such review
to the Audit Committee. Such annual financial disclosure statements shall be kept confidential to
the extent permitted by law.
Section 5. President and Chief Executive Officer. The salaried executive director of
the Corporation shall be known as the President and Chief Executive Officer. He or she, subject to
the approval and control of the Board of Trustees, shall have general control and direction of the
employees, business affairs and administration of the Corporation. He or she shall also perform
such other duties as he or she may be directed to perform by the Board of Trustees. The President
and Chief Executive Officer shall make reasonable efforts to attend all meetings of the Board of
Trustees and Board committees, including the Corporation’s annual public budget hearing, and such
New York City or State budget hearings and other meetings where action may be taken affecting
the interests of the Corporation.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
15
Section 6. Chief Librarian. The Chief Librarian, who shall report directly to the
President and Chief Executive Officer, shall manage and oversee all public library service
operations, activities and staff, and perform such other duties as he or she may be directed to
perform by the President and Chief Executive Officer.
Section 7. Chief Operating Officer. The Chief Operating Officer, who shall report
directly to the President and Chief Executive Officer, shall be in charge of the day-to-day
administrative operations and support functions of the Library, and perform such other duties as he
or she may be directed to perform by the President and Chief Executive Officer.
Section 8. Chief Financial Officer. The Chief Financial Officer, who shall report
directly to the President and Chief Executive Officer, shall support and oversee, in conjunction with
the President and Chief Executive Officer and appropriate committees of the Board of Trustees, all
fiscal responsibilities of the Library and oversee the Accounting, Accounts Payable, Budget
Management, Employee Benefits, Payroll and Treasury functions of the Library. The Chief
Financial Officer shall perform such other duties as he or she may be directed to perform by the
President and Chief Executive Officer.
Section 9. General Counsel. The General Counsel, who shall report directly to the
Chief Executive Officer, shall handle and advise on legal matters relating to the Library and
perform such other duties as he or she may be directed to perform by the President and Chief
Executive Officer.
ARTICLE V
COMMITTEES
Section 1. Committees of the Board. The Board of Trustees, by resolution adopted
by a majority of the entire Board of Trustees, shall designate from among its members an executive
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
16
committee, audit committee, labor relations committee, finance and investment committee,
buildings and grounds committee, nominating committee, and such other committees as it may
deem appropriate from time to time. Each such committee of the Board, with the exception of the
Executive Committee and Nominating Committee, shall have thereon at least three (3) appointed
trustees. The Executive Committee shall have thereon a minimum of seven (7) appointed trustees
and the Nominating Committee shall consist of five (5) appointed trustees. No committee shall
have the power to (a) alter, amend or add to these By-Laws, (b) make removals from office, (c) fill
vacancies in the Board of Trustees or in any committee of the Board, or (d) amend or repeal any
resolution of the Board which by its terms shall not be so amendable or repealable. Except as
provided otherwise in these By-Laws, members of Board committees and the Chairs of such
committees, all of whom shall be appointed trustees, shall be appointed by the vote of the Board of
Trustees on the recommendation of the Chairperson. Each committee of the Board shall serve at
the pleasure of the Board.
Section 2. Executive Committee. The Executive Committee shall be comprised of no
less than seven (7) appointed trustees and shall include the Chairperson of the Board, the immediate
past Chairperson of the Board provided he or she still is an appointed trustee, all other current
officers of the Board, and two additional trustees to be appointed by the vote of a majority of the
entire Board on the recommendation of the Chairperson. If the immediate past Chairperson of the
Board is a member of the Executive Committee, he or she shall serve as the Chair of the Executive
Committee. The Executive Committee shall recommend strategies and policies to build the Board’s
governing capacities, periodically review the Corporation’s By-Laws and recommend amendments
to the By-Laws as needed or appropriate, periodically evaluate the effectiveness of the Board and
its committees and recommend enhancements or other changes to improve effectiveness.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
17
Between meetings of the Board of Trustees, the Executive Committee shall have and
may exercise all of the powers of the Board except those powers not authorized to Board
committees by applicable law. Actions taken by the Executive Committee shall be reported to the
Board of Trustees at the next regularly scheduled meeting of the Board. The Executive Committee
shall have general charge of the administration of the affairs of the Corporation.
Section 3. Audit Committee. The Audit Committee shall oversee the Corporation’s
accounting and financial reporting processes and annual audits. The Audit Committee shall retain
the Corporation’s auditor, review the scope and planning of all audits with the auditor, and review
and discuss the results of such audits. The Audit Committee shall consider the auditor’s
performance and independence and report at least annually to the Board of Trustees on the auditor’s
activities. The Audit Committee, along with the CEO and the Vice President and General Counsel,
also shall oversee the adoption and implementation of, and compliance with, the Corporation’s
Conflicts of Interest Policy and Whistleblower Policy, as well as consider those issues that the
General Counsel apprises the Committee of regarding the annual financial disclosure statements
filed by key executive personnel. The Audit Committee, along with the President and Chief
Executive Officer and the Treasurer, shall present a report certified by an independent public or
certified public accountant or a firm of such accountants selected by the Audit Committee showing
in appropriate detail the financial information required by Section 519 of the New York Not-for-
Profit Corporation Law (“N-PCL”). The annual report shall be filed with the minutes of the
meeting of the Board of Trustees in which it is presented.
Members of the Audit Committee shall first be selected from those who have an
accounting, financial, and business operations background. Only “independent” appointed trustees
may serve as voting members or participate in formal deliberations of the Audit Committee. An
“independent,” appointed trustee shall be defined in accordance with the definition of “independent
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
18
director” set forth in Section 102(a)(21) of the N-PCL. Ex officio trustees may be non-voting
members and/or participate in formal deliberations of the Audit Committee provided that they also
qualify as “independent” trustees as defined above. An ex-officio trustee’s status as an employee of
the City of New York, in and of itself, does not disqualify him or her from being considered an
“independent” trustee.
No Trustee or ex-officio member, or his or her representative, shall be an Independent
Trustee for purposes of these By-Laws unless the Secretary of the Board of Trustees and the
General Counsel of the Library, after having received from the Trustee or ex-officio member, or his
or her representative, the most recent completed and executed Trustee Conflicts of Interest
Disclosure Form (as defined in the Conflicts of Interest Policy), have certified to the Board of
Trustees that they have affirmatively determined that such Trustee or ex-officio member, or his or
her representative, is an Independent Trustee. With respect to the Secretary of the Board, the
Chairperson and the General Counsel shall jointly ascertain the Secretary’s status as an Independent
Trustee.
Section 4. Labor Relations Committee. The Labor Relations Committee shall advise
the Board of Trustees on all matters relating to labor relations and oversee the contracting out of
Corporation services. The Labor Relations Committee shall review all union contracts and related
agreements entered into by the Corporation and submit the same to the Board for approval. The
Labor Relations Committee shall advise the Corporation on such matters as may arise from external
entities regarding the rights of employees. The Labor Relations Committee shall also periodically
review and make recommendations to the Board of Trustees regarding the compensation
arrangements for all key executive personnel, including contributions to employee benefit plans and
any other deferred compensation, as well as expense account and other allowances, all in a manner
consistent with the reasonable compensation requirements applicable to the Corporation and, in
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
19
particular, the safe harbor provided by the intermediate sanctions rules of Internal Revenue Code
Section 4958 and the accompanying Treasury Regulations, including by: (i) obtaining and relying
upon appropriate data of similar salaries paid to similar executives at comparable organizations; (ii)
evaluating the key executive employee’s performance in light of the goals and objectives relevant to
his or her compensation, and the Corporation’s performance relative to the Corporation’s mission;
(iii) evaluating the key executive employee’s contributions to the Corporation’s purposes and
activities, and how his or her qualifications contribute to his or her achievement of such goals; and
(iv) adequately documenting the basis for the Committee’s determination concurrently with making
that determination. The Labor Relations Committee also shall review the terms of any employment
agreements or severance agreements between the Corporation and the President and Chief
Executive Officer and, at the request of the Board, between the Corporation and any other key
executive employees.
Section 5. Finance and Investment Committee. The Treasurer shall serve as the Chair
of the Finance and Investment Committee. The other members of the Finance and Investment
Committee shall be selected from among the appointed trustees who have an understanding of
financial statements and investments. The Finance and Investment Committee shall regularly
review the Corporation’s financial statements and management’s performance analyses, and ensure
the accuracy and timeliness of the presentation of financial statements to the Board, assist the Board
in understanding the Corporation’s financial affairs, safeguard the Corporation’s assets, including
assessing the implications of proposed funding and ensuring that adequate risk-management
provisions are in place, and periodically review the Corporation’s financial policies and recommend
revisions of such policies to the Board.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
20
The Finance and Investment Committee shall approve annually a detailed estimate of
the amounts required for the proper maintenance of the Corporation during the next fiscal year and
regulate the imposing and collection of the Corporation’s fines and contributions subject to the
approval of the Board. The Finance and Investment Committee also shall review and oversee the
management of the Corporation’s investments, monitor investment performance and develop and
recommend changes to the Corporation’s investment strategy, policies and guidelines as needed,
recommend to the Board the retention of the external managers and advisors of the Corporation’s
investments and monitor the performance of such external managers and advisors, and periodically
review the Corporation’s written investment policy and recommend changes to the written
investment policy as needed or appropriate. The Finance and Investment Committee shall also be
responsible for those matters affecting the Corporation’s liability, property, workers’ compensation,
and such other insurance as may be necessary to manage the risk and protect the assets of the
Corporation, and shall review and recommend selection of appropriate carriers and other agents to
serve on behalf of the Corporation in matters of insurance and risk management.
Section 6. Buildings and Grounds Committee. The Buildings and Grounds
Committee shall recommend policies for the care and maintenance of the Library buildings and
grounds and approve such sites for additional Library buildings as may be deemed necessary for the
use of the Corporation when presented with the long-term capital plan, in coordination with the
Vice President, Capital and Facilities Management. The Buildings and Grounds Committee shall
also oversee the construction activities of the Corporation.
Section 7. Nominating Committee. A Nominating Committee shall be elected in
November of each year and present a slate of candidates for the officers of the Corporation to the
Board of Trustees in December. The Nominating Committee shall consist of five members, two of
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
21
whom shall be appointed by the Chairperson of the Board and three of whom shall be elected by the
Board.
Section 8. Meetings, Notices and Records. Each committee of the Board may provide
for the holding of regular meetings, with notice, and may fix the time and place at which such
meetings shall be held. Special meetings of each committee shall be held upon call by or at the
direction of the committee’s chairperson or, if there be no chairperson, by or at the direction of any
of its members, at the time and place specified in the respective notices or waivers of notice thereof.
Notice of each special meeting of a committee shall be given by first-class mail, telecopy, electronic
mail or hand delivery to each member of such committee and all other trustees, at least forty-eight
hours before the meeting. Notice of any meeting of a committee need not be given to any member
thereof who shall attend the meeting in person without objection or who shall waive notice thereof.
Notice of all meetings of committees and subcommittees of the Board shall be given to the public in
accordance with the Open Meetings Law, provided that, notwithstanding anything to the contrary in
the Open Meetings Law, public notice of the time and place of a meeting of a Board committee or
subcommittee scheduled at least two weeks prior thereto shall be given to the public and news
media at least one week before such meeting.
Section 9. Quorum and Manner of Acting. At each meeting of any committee of the
Board the presence of a majority, but not less than two, of the committee’s voting members then in
office shall be necessary and sufficient to constitute a quorum for the transaction of business, and
the act of a majority of the voting members present at any meeting at which a quorum is present
shall be the act of such committee; in the absence of a quorum, a majority of the voting members
present at the time and place of any meeting may adjourn the meeting from time to time until a
quorum shall be present.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
22
To comply with the Open Meetings Law, voting members of Board committees must
be present in person at a Board committee meeting or participate by videoconference conducted in
accordance with such Law for purposes of establishing a quorum and in order to vote or otherwise
take any action. Appointed trustees participating in a Board committee meeting by conference
telephone or similar communications equipment shall not be considered present in person at the
meeting for quorum or voting purposes.
Ex officio trustees and their designated representatives may attend and, except as
provided otherwise by law or these By-Laws, participate in all meetings of Board committees, both
in public and executive session but, as they are not voting members of the Board, shall not be
counted for the purpose of establishing a quorum for a meeting of a Board committee or in
determining the number of votes necessary to adopt any motion or authorize any action. All
members of the Board of Trustees, regardless of whether they are members of a particular
committee, may attend and, except as provided otherwise by law or these By-Laws, participate in
all meetings of Board committees.
Section 10. Removal. Any member of any committee of the Board may be removed,
with or without cause, at any time by the Board of Trustees.
Section 11. Committees of the Corporation. The Board of Trustees, from time to
time, may establish Committees of the Corporation to assist the Board in carrying out its duties.
Committees of the Corporation shall be advisory in nature and shall not have the authority to bind
the Board of Trustees or the Corporation. The members of the Committees of the Corporation, who
need not be trustees, shall be appointed by the Board of Trustees or the Chairperson of the Board
and may be removed with or without cause by the Board and, in the case of members appointed by
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
23
the Chairperson of the Board, may be removed with or without cause by the Chairperson. Each
Committee of the Corporation shall serve at the pleasure of the Board of Trustees.
ARTICLE VI
CONTRACTS, CHECKS, BANK ACCOUNTS, INVESTMENTS, ETC.
Section 1. Checks, Notes, Contracts, Etc. The Board of Trustees is authorized to
select such banks or depositories as it shall deem proper for the funds of the Corporation. The
Board of Trustees designates the President and Chief Executive Officer, the Executive Vice
President and Chief Operating Officer, the Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Treasurer
and Assistant Treasurer to sign checks, drafts or other orders for the payment of money,
acceptances, notes or other evidences of indebtedness on behalf of the Corporation. The President
& CEO is authorized to enter into contracts and to execute and deliver other documents and
instruments on behalf of the Corporation.
Section 2. Investments. The funds of the Corporation may be retained in whole or in
part in cash or be invested and reinvested from time to time in such property, real, personal or
otherwise, or stocks, bonds and other suitable forms of investment, as the Board of Trustees may
deem desirable, with regard to the limitations, if any, now imposed or which may hereafter be
imposed by law regarding such investments.
ARTICLE VII
TRANSACTIONS REQUIRING A SUPERMAJORITY VOTE
The following transactions must be authorized by the vote of at least three-fourths of
the entire Board of Trustees: the consolidation or merger of the Corporation, the dissolution of the
Corporation and any action by the Board of Trustees to amend the Act of Incorporation as
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
24
amended. The sale, lease, transfer, exchange or other disposition of all or substantially all of the
assets of the Corporation must be authorized by the vote of at least two-thirds of the entire Board of
Trustees.
ARTICLE VIII
OFFICE AND BOOKS
Section 1. Office. The office of the Corporation shall be located at such place within
the Borough of Queens, New York as the Board of Trustees may from time to time determine.
Section 2. Books. There shall be kept at the office of the Corporation correct books
of account of the activities and transactions of the Corporation, including a minute book, which
shall contain a copy of the Act of Incorporation as amended, a copy of these By-Laws, and all
minutes of meetings of the Board of Trustees and Board committees.
ARTICLE IX
CORPORATE SEAL
The seal of the Corporation shall be circular in form and shall bear the name of the
Corporation and words and figures showing that it is a not-for-profit organization which was
incorporated in the State of New York in 1907.
ARTICLE X
FINANCIAL ADMINISTRATION
Section 1. Fiscal Year. The fiscal year of the Corporation shall begin on the first day
of July each year to coincide with the New York City Charter requirements.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
25
Section 2. Approval of Annual Budget. Prior to the adoption of the Corporation’s
annual budget, the Finance and Investment Committee shall review all pertinent budgetary
materials with the President and Chief Executive Officer and any presentations of the President and
Chief Executive Officer concerning the budget, and shall recommend actions to the Board of
Trustees with respect to the budget and amounts required for carrying on the work of the
Corporation during the fiscal year then next ensuing. Upon the adoption of the budget of the City
of New York for the ensuing fiscal year, the Finance and Investment Committee shall review the
amount allocated to the Library and submit a proposed budget to the Board of Trustees for
approval.
Prior to the adoption of the proposed annual budget, the Board of Trustees shall hold
an annual budget hearing open to the public, provide the public with a 30 day period in which to
comment on the proposed budget and report all revenue sources of funding, both public and private,
for the budget. Notice of the public budget hearing shall be given to the public at least 30 days
prior to the scheduled hearing date. Such notice shall be provided on the Corporation’s website, on
fliers posted inside the Corporation’s main location and in each branch location and in any other
alternative manner chosen by the Board of Trustees.
The public budget hearing shall be a public forum held at a physical location, attended
by the Corporation’s trustees and President and Chief Executive Officer, or their designees, where
oral testimony is accepted and written testimony may be submitted for inclusion in the record.
Testimony at the public budget hearing may be presented in writing or orally, provided that the
Board of Trustees shall make rules designed to exclude repetitive, redundant or irrelevant
testimony. The Board of Trustees shall make a record of all testimony at each annual public budget
hearing.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
26
Section 3. Appropriations. No payments shall be made or authorized by the
Treasurer, or his or her designee, except pursuant to the appropriations authorized in the annual
budget adopted by the Board of Trustees. However, nothing contained in these By-Laws shall be
construed to prevent the Board of Trustees from making special appropriations from the funds of
the Corporation at any meeting of the Board.
ARTICLE XI
INDEMNIFICATION
Except as otherwise provided below and to the fullest extent authorized by law, the
Corporation shall indemnify any present or former trustee or officers of the Corporation or the
personal representatives thereof, made or threatened to be made a party in any civil or criminal
action or proceeding by reason of the fact that he or she, his or her testator or intestate is or was a
trustee or officer of the Corporation, or served with any other corporation, partnership, joint
venture, trust, employee-benefit plan, or other enterprise in any capacity at the request of the
Corporation, against judgments, fines (including excise taxes assessed on such a person in
connection with service to an employee-benefit plan), amounts paid in settlement and reasonable
expenses, including attorneys’ fees, actually and necessarily incurred as a result of such action or
proceeding or any appeal therein.
Expenses (including attorneys' fees) incurred in defending a civil or criminal action or
proceeding shall, to the fullest extent authorized by law, be paid by the Corporation in advance of
the final disposition of such action or proceeding upon receipt of an undertaking by or on behalf of
such trustee or officer to repay such amount as, and to the extent, the person receiving the
advancement is ultimately found not to be entitled to indemnification under this Article or
otherwise.
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
27
The foregoing right of indemnification and advancement of expenses shall not be
deemed exclusive of any other rights to which any person, his or her testator or intestate may be
entitled apart from this provision provided that no indemnification may be made to or on behalf of
any trustee or officer if a judgment or other final adjudication adverse to the trustee or officer
establishes that his or her acts were committed in bad faith or were the result of active and
deliberate dishonesty and were material to the cause of action so adjudicated, or that he or she
personally gained in fact a financial profit or other advantage to which he or she was not legally
entitled. Nothing contained in this provision shall affect any rights to indemnification to which
corporate personnel other than the trustees and officers may be entitled by contract or otherwise
under the law.
The Corporation may purchase and maintain insurance to indemnify the Corporation
and any person described in this Article to the fullest extent such insurance is permitted by law.
For the purposes of this Article XI, the officers of the Corporation shall include, in
addition to the officers provided for in Article III of these By-Laws, the key executive employees of
the Corporation provided for in Article IV of these By-Laws.
ARTICLE XII
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
A conflict of interest may arise when a person has an existing or potential financial
interest or other material interest that impairs or might appear to impair his or her independence or
objectivity in the discharge of responsibilities and duties to the Corporation. No person with a
conflict of interest shall be present at or participate in any Board of Trustee, Audit Committee or
other Board committee deliberations or voting on the matter giving rise to the conflict. Nor may
such person improperly influence the deliberation or voting on such matter. Any conflict of interest
Report of the Executive Committee of March 24, 2016
Revision to By-Laws
28
brought to the attention of the Board, Audit Committee or any other Board committee shall be
documented in the minutes of the meeting at which such conflict was discussed. These prohibitions
and requirements, as well as any other requirements with respect to conflicts of interest set forth in
Sections 715 and 715-a of the N-PCL or in any other applicable law, shall be reflected in the
conflict of interest policy adopted by the Corporation.
ARTICLE XIII
AMENDMENTS
The By-Laws of the Corporation may be adopted, amended, or repealed, in whole or
part, at any meeting of the Board of Trustees provided that no By-Law as to which more than a
majority vote is required for any specified action by the trustees may be amended, suspended or
repealed by a smaller vote than that required under the respective By-Law: and further provided that
any proposed adoption, amendment or repeal of the By-Laws, in whole or part, shall be read at a
meeting and voted upon at a subsequent meeting. Notice of the proposed action must be given in
the notice of meeting at which it is to be considered.
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
1
THE QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
MEETING OF THE FINANCE & INVESTMENT COMMITTEE
March 24, 2016
REPORT
A meeting of the Finance & Investment Committee of the Board of Trustees was held at
5:36 p.m. on Thursday, March 24, 2016, in the Hon. Robert T. Groh Board Room of the
Central Library, 89-11 Merrick Boulevard, Jamaica, New York 11432.
PRESIDED: Michael Rodriguez Esq.,
Committee Chair
PRESENT: James Haddad, Esq. (arrived at 6:16pm)
Carl Koerner, Esq. (via teleconference - 5:36pm, arrived at 5:53pm)
Earl Simons, Ed.D
Dennis M. Walcott (via teleconference)
President and Chief Executive Officer
Bridget Quinn-Carey
Vice President and Chief Operating Officer
Tracy Yogman
Chief Financial Officer
Lewis Finkelman, Esq.
General Counsel
EXCUSED: Robert Santos, Esq.
Matthew Gorton (Arrived at 7:40pm)
GUESTS: Hon. Augustus Agate (Arrived at 6:03pm)
Martha Baker
Judy E. Bergtraum, Esq. (Arrived at 5:42pm)
Maria Concolino
Julissa Gutierrez (Arrived at 6:13pm)
Jukay Hsu (Arrived at 6:53pm)
John Ottulich (Arrived @ 5:50pm)
Edward Sadowsky, Esq.
Speaker, Hon. Melissa Mark-Viverito, Ex-officio
Represented by: Eve Cho Guillergan, Esq.
Borough President, Hon. Melinda Katz, Ex-officio
Represented by: Angelina Martinez-Rubio, Esq.
Allison Fast, Eric Goia, amd Elliot Orly, J.P. Morgan
Alexander Lane, TD Private Client Wealth
Walter Dilingham, Jr., and John Lawson, Wilmington Trust N.A.
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
2
THE QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
MEETING OF THE FINANCE & INVESTMENT COMMITTEE
March 24, 2016
REPORT
1. 2015 Investment Performance Reports
Representatives from TD Private Client Wealth, Wilmington Trust, and JP Morgan Chase
gave presentations regarding the performance of Queens Library’s investments portfolio for
2015. The CFO will work with the investment advisors and review investment policies of
similar size non-profits and will recommend updates to our investment policy to the
Committee.
At 6:43pm, the Investment Presentations concluded.
Action Items
1. Approval of Bills for the Month of February 2016
It was moved by Mr. Koerner that the Finance & Investment Committee recommend to the
Board of Trustees the approval of the February 2016 bills in the aggregate sum of $3,285,451.
The motion was seconded by Mr. Simons. The motion passed unanimously.
2. Acceptance of Financial Reports for the Period Ending February 29, 2016
It was moved by Mr. Rodriguez that the Finance & Investment Committee recommend to the
Board of Trustees that the Budget Reports for Board approved operating funds and Balance
Sheets for all funds as of February 29, 2016 be accepted. The motion was seconded by Mr.
Simons. The motion passed unanimously.
Report
1. Payrolls for the Month of February 2016
The Chief Financial Officer reports the payrolls paid during the month of February 2016 in
the aggregate sum of $4,772,014 consisting of $185 in Fines & Fees Funds, $4,579,171 in
City Funds, $182,316 in Federal & State Funds, $5,198 in Board-designated & Private Grants
Funds, and $5,514 in the Workers’ Compensation Reserve Funds. All expenditures were made
in accordance with Budgets and Appropriations approved by the Board of Trustees.
IT WAS MOVED BY MR. RODRIGUEZ THAT THE MEETING BE ADJOURNED.
THE MOTION WAS SECONDED BY MR. KOERNER. THE MOTION PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7:01p.m.
_________ ______________________
Michael Rodriguez, Chair
Finance & Investment Committee
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
3
THE QUEENS BOROUGH PUBLIC LIBRARY
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
AS OF FEBRUARY 29, 2016
FINANCE & INVESTMENT COMMITTEE MEETING
MARCH 24, 2016
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
4
City General Fund
Budget Report as of February 29, 2016
In thousands
Estimated Revenues
Adopted
Budget
Current
Budget
Y-T-D
Actual
Open
Orders
Remaining
Balance
Percent
Remaining
City Appropriations 99,415$ 100,389$ 80,093$ - 20,296$ 20%
Interest Income 5 5 14 - (9) 0%
Rental 21 21 65 - (44) 0%
Sundry Revenues - - - - - 0%
Legal Settlement - - - - - 0%
Insurance Proceeds - - 5 - (5) 0%
Total Revenues 99,441$ 100,415$ 80,177$ -$ 20,238$ 20%
Appropriations
Personal Services 60,369$ 58,040$ 34,346$ - 23,694$ 41%
Health Insurance 13,747 14,253 7,614 - 6,639 47%
Social Security 4,705 4,733 3,044 - 1,689 36%
Unemployment Insurance 140 140 43 - 97 69%
Employee Welfare Fund 2,582 2,575 1,197 - 1,378 54%
Disability Insurance 273 237 11 - 226 95%
Workers' Compensation - - - - - 0%
Training 12 12 - - 12 100%
General Supplies 1,310 1,375 575 286 514 37%
Maintenance & Custodial Supplies 622 635 212 63 360 57%
Equipment 369 1,146 160 20 966 84%
Furniture 43 91 23 20 48 53%
Library Materials 3,088 4,048 2,096 190 1,762 44%
Contractual Services 1,705 1,706 753 155 798 47%
Postage 162 162 100 9 53 33%
Telecommunications 476 630 234 13 383 61%
Carfare, Travel & Mileage 38 38 27 - 11 29%
Maintenance & Repairs - Vehicles 137 137 88 - 49 36%
Maintenance & Repairs - Buildings 1,495 1,748 657 516 575 33%
Information Systems Services 1,778 1,888 891 41 956 51%
Rentals - Land/Buildings 1,311 1,311 971 - 340 26%
Heat, Light, and Power 2,939 2,936 2 2 2,932 100%
P & C Insurance Premiums 520 570 511 - 59 10%
Adult Literacy 1,620 1,774 994 6 774 44%
Anti Proverty - 5 1 1 3 60%
Program Support-Rosedale, FR,Ar - 25 5 4 16 64%
Programs - Friends of Briarwood - 5 1 2 2 40%
Technology Upgrades - Astoria - 5 - 5 - 0%
Early Childhood Literacy - 175 55 14 106 61%
Job Business Academy - 10 - 3 7 70%
Program Support- CD 31 - 5 - - 5 100%
Total Appropriations 99,441$ 100,415$ 54,611$ 1,350$ 44,454$ 44%
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
5
Fines and Fees Fund
Budget Report as of February 29, 2016
In thousands
Estimated Revenues
Adopted
Budget
Current
Budget
Y-T-D
Actual
Open
Orders
Remaining
Balance
Percent
Remaining
Fines on Overdue Items 1,433$ 1,433$ 846$ - 587$ 41%
Lost Library Cards 60 60 35 - 25 42%
Lost & Damaged Items Fees 305 305 188 - 117 38%
Interest Income- Fines/Fees 2 2 - - 2 100%
Total Revenues 1,800$ 1,800$ 1,069$ - 731$ 41%
Appropriations
Personal Services 11$ 11$ 4 - 7$ 64%
Social Security 1 1 1 - - 0%
Training 249 249 111 50 88 35%
General Supplies 24 24 4 2 18 75%
Equipment 33 33 - - 33 100%
Library Materials 535 535 360 16 159 30%
Contractual Services 1,072 1,072 441 177 454 42%
Information System Services 60 60 - - 60 100%
Total Appropriations 1,985$ 1,985$ 921$ 245$ 819$ 41%
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
6
Federal General Fund
Budget Report as of February 29, 2016
In thousands
Estimated Revenues
Adopted
Budget
Current
Budget
Y-T-D
Actual
Open
Orders
Remaining
Balance
Percent
Remaining
Federal USDF Program Refunds 2,787$ 2,787$ - - 2,787$ 100%
Total Revenues 2,787$ 2,787$ - - 2,787$ 100%
Appropriations
Telecommunications 2,787$ 2,787$ 1,020$ - 1,767$ 63%
Information Systems Services - - (26) 26 - 0%
Total Appropriations 2,787$ 2,787$ 994$ 26$ 1,767$ 63%
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
7
State General Fund
Budget Report as of February 29, 2016
In thousands
Estimated Revenues
Adopted
Budget
Current
Budget
Y-T-D
Actual
Open
Orders
Remaining
Balance
Percent
Remaining
Basic Grant Revenues 3,829$ 3,829$ (92)$ - 3,921$ 102%
Consolidated Systems Aid 1,509 1,509 - - 1,509 100%
Legal Settlements - - 24 - (24) 0%
County Prison Aid - - 0%
Total Revenues 5,338$ 5,338$ (68) - 5,406$ 101%
Appropriations
Personal Services 911$ 893$ 283$ - 610$ 68%
Health Insurance - - 7 - (7) 0%
Social Security 74 49 28 - 21 43%
Employee Welfare Fund - - - - - 0%
Pension - 43 60 - (17) -40%
Workers' Compensation - - - - - 0%
Training 51 51 21 7 23 45%
General Supplies 15 17 6 2 9 53%
Equipment 102 177 75 22 80 45%
Furniture - 357 77 73 207 58%
Library Materials 522 522 317 18 187 36%
Contractual Services 2,069 2,124 961 343 820 39%
Carfare, Travel & Mileage 5 5 - - 5 100%
Maintenance & Repairs - Buildings 777 1,633 329 693 611 37%
Information Systems Services 2,505 2,505 655 342 1,508 60%
Total Appropriations 7,031$ 8,376$ 2,819$ 1,500$ 4,057$ 48%
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
8
Board-Designated Fund
Budget Report as of February 29, 2016
In thousands
Estimated Revenues
Adopted
Budget
Current
Budget
Y-T-D
Actual
Open
Orders
Remaining
Balance
Percent
Remaining
Interest & Dividend Income 250$ 250$ 223$ - 27$ 11%
Library Merchandise Sales 2 2 - - 2 100%
Gains (Losses) on Investments 300 300 (751) - 1,051 0%
Total Revenues 552$ 552$ (528)$ - 1,080$ 196%
Appropriations
Training 10$ 10$ -$ -$ 10$ 100%
General Supplies 61 53 16 - 37 70%
Contractual Services 660 761 359 71 331 43%
Carfare, Travel & Mileage 12 12 6 - 6 50%
Maintenance & Repairs - Vehicles 6 6 - - 6 100%
P & C Insurance Premiums 3 3 - - 3 100%
Information Systems Services 7 - - 7 100%
Total Appropriations 752$ 852$ 381$ 71$ 400$ 47%
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
9
Workers Comp Fund
Budget Report as of February 29, 2016
In thousands
Estimated Revenues
Adopted
Budget
Current
Budget
Y-T-D
Actual
Open
Orders
Remaining
Balance
Percent
Remaining
Interest Income -$ -$ $ 1 $ - (1)$ 0%
Interfund Transfers - - - - - 0%
Total Revenues - - 1 - (1) 0%
Appropriations
Personal Services 72$ 72$ 46$ - 26$ 36%
Health Insurance 6 6 4 - 2 33%
Social Security 6 6 4 - 2 33%
Employee Welfare Fund 2 2 1 - 1 50%
Pension 8 14 13 - 1 7%
Workers' Compensation 200 194 79 - 115 59%
Contractual Services 125 125 75 15 35 28%
P & C Insurance Premiums 45 45 45 - - 0%
Total Appropriations 464$ 464$ 267$ 15 182$ 39%
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
10
BALANCE SHEET – FINES & FEES FUND GROUP At February 29, 2016
Assets
Cash & Cash Equivalents
Checking Accounts – Interest Bearing $ 1,824,241
Money Market Accounts 152,042
Repurchase Agreements -
On Hand
41,538
Accounts Receivable
Accounts Receivable and Employee Advances 12,269
Grants and Contracts Receivable
New York City -
New York State -
Federal Government -
Contributions Receivable
From New York State -
From Individuals, Corporations and Foundations -
Prepaid Expenses
Prepaid Others -
Other Assets
Interfund Receivables 313,918
Certificates of Deposit -
Investments -
Property & Equipment (net of depreciation) 808,952
TOTAL ASSETS $ 3,152,960
Liabilities and Fund Balances
Liabilities
Accounts Payable $ 15,875
Accrued Payroll & Related Expense -
Note Payable -
Compensated Absences Payable -
Deferred Revenue -
Other Liabilities and Interfund Payables -
Fund Balances
Invested in Capital Assets, Net of Related Debt (Unrestricted Funds) 808,952
Unrestricted - Other 2,328,133
Current Restricted -
Permanently Restricted (Endowments) -
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND FUND BALANCES $ 3,152,960
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
11
BALANCE SHEET – CITY FUNDS GROUP At February 29, 2016
Assets
Cash & Cash Equivalents
Checking Accounts – Interest Bearing $ 14,691,211
Money Market Accounts 1,006
Repurchase Agreements -
On Hand
94
Accounts Receivable
Accounts Receivable and Employee Advances 16,360
Grants and Contracts Receivable
New York City 11,514,625
New York State -
Federal Government -
Contributions Receivable
From New York State -
From Individuals, Corporations and Foundations -
Prepaid Expenses
Prepaid Insurance -
Prepaid Rent
-
Other Assets
Interfund Receivables -
Security Deposit -
Investments -
Property & Equipment (net of depreciation) 5,573,625
TOTAL ASSETS $ 31,796,921
Liabilities and Fund Balances
Liabilities
Accounts Payable $ 232,533
Accrued Payroll & Related Expense -
Note Payable 744,630
Compensated Absences Payable -
Deferred Revenue -
Other Liabilities and Interfund Payables 12,209,961
Fund Balances
Invested in Capital Assets, Net of Related Debt (Unrestricted Funds) 5,573,625
Unrestricted - Other 20,631,166
Restricted - Other (7,594,994)
Permanently Restricted (Endowments) -
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND FUND BALANCES $ 31,796,921
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
12
BALANCE SHEET – STATE & FEDERAL FUNDS GROUP At February 29, 2016
Assets
Cash & Cash Equivalents
Checking Accounts – Interest Bearing $ 664,855
Money Market Accounts -
Repurchase Agreements -
On Hand
80
Accounts Receivable
Accounts Receivable and Employee Advances 14,128
Grants and Contracts Receivable
New York City -
New York State 930,439
Federal Government -
Contributions Receivable
From New York State -
From Individuals, Corporations and Foundations -
Prepaid Expenses
Prepaid Other -
Other Assets
Interfund Receivables 54,996
Certificates of Deposit -
Investments 6,571,688
Security Deposits 25,667
Property & Equipment (net of depreciation) 27,858,273
TOTAL ASSETS $ 36,120,126
Liabilities and Fund Balances
Liabilities
Accounts Payable $ 76,125
Accrued Payroll & Related Expense -
Line of Credit Payable -
Compensated Absences Payable 5,512,627
Deferred Revenue -
Other Liabilities and Interfund Payables -
Fund Balances
Invested in Capital Assets, Net of Related Debt (Unrestricted Funds) 27,858,273
Unrestricted - Other 6,643,976
Restricted - Other (3,970,875)
10,047,780 TOTAL LIABILITIES AND FUND BALANCES $ 36,120,126
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
13
BALANCE SHEET – TRUST & AGENCY FUND At February 29, 2016
Assets
Cash & Cash Equivalents
Checking Accounts – Interest Bearing $ 1,240,061
Money Market Accounts -
Repurchase Agreements -
On Hand
-
Accounts Receivable
Accounts Receivable -
Grants and Contracts Receivable
New York City -
New York State -
Federal Government -
Contributions Receivable
From New York State -
From Individuals, Corporations and Foundations -
Prepaid Expenses
Prepaid Health Insurance -
Other Assets
Interfund Receivables -
Certificates of Deposit -
Investments -
Property & Equipment (net of depreciation) -
TOTAL ASSETS $ 1,240,061
Liabilities and Fund Balances
Liabilities
Accounts Payable $ 566,580 Accrued Payroll & Related Expense -
Note Payable -
Incurred Compensation Losses -
Deferred Revenue -
Other Liabilities and Interfund Payables 673,481
Fund Balances
Invested in Capital Assets, Net of Related Debt (Unrestricted Funds) -
Unrestricted – Other -
Restricted – Other -
Permanently Restricted (Endowments) -
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND FUND BALANCES $ 1,240,061
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
14
BALANCE SHEET–BOARD DESIGNATED & PRIVATE GRANTS FUND At February 29, 2016
Assets
Cash & Cash Equivalents
Checking Accounts – Interest Bearing $ 3,090,138
Money Market Accounts -
On Hand
551
Accounts Receivable
Accounts Receivable 32,591
Grants and Contracts Receivable
New York City -
New York State -
Federal Government -
Contributions Receivable
From New York State -
From Individuals, Corporations and Foundations -
Prepaid Expenses
Prepaid Other 896
Other Assets
Interfund Receivables 8,927
Certificates of Deposit -
Investments 3,300,988
Property & Equipment (net of depreciation) 1,077,068
Retail Inventory -
TOTAL ASSETS $ 7,511,159
Liabilities and Fund Balances
Liabilities
Accounts Payable $ 50,748
Accrued Payroll & Related Expense -
Note Payable -
Compensated Absences Payable -
Deferred Revenue -
Other Liabilities and Interfund Payables -
Fund Balances
Invested in Capital Assets, Net of Related Debt (Unrestricted Funds) 1,077,068
Unrestricted - Other 6,062,464
Restricted - Other 320,879
Permanently Restricted (Endowments) -
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND FUND BALANCES $ 7,511,159
Report of the Finance & Investment Committee of March 24, 2016
15
BALANCE SHEET – WORKERS’ COMPENSATION FUND At February 29, 2016
Assets
Cash & Cash Equivalents
Checking Accounts – Interest Bearing $ 1,809,277
Money Market Accounts -
Repurchase Agreements -
On Hand
-
Accounts Receivable
Accounts Receivable -
Grants and Contracts Receivable
New York City -
New York State -
Federal Government -
Contributions Receivable
From New York State -
From Individuals, Corporations and Foundations -
Prepaid Expenses
Prepaid Health Insurance -
Other Assets
Interfund Receivables -
Certificates of Deposit -
Investments -
Property & Equipment (net of depreciation) -
TOTAL ASSETS $ 1,809,277
Liabilities and Fund Balances
Liabilities
Accounts Payable $ 411
Accrued Payroll & Related Expense -
Note Payable -
Incurred Compensation Losses 461,720
Deferred Revenue -
Other Liabilities and Interfund Payables 865
Fund Balances
Invested in Capital Assets, Net of Related Debt (Unrestricted Funds) -
Unrestricted - Other 1,346,281
Restricted - Other -
Permanently Restricted (Endowments) -
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND FUND BALANCES $ 1,809,277