of 16
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
1/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 1
MENU
Articles
About
Best Articles
Complete Archive
Downloads
Books
Audio
Video
Courses
Conversations & Connection
Overcome Anxiety
Dating & Relationships
Courses Log In
Subscription
Subscribe
Log In
THE RISE AND
FALL OF KEN
MARK MANSONPersonal Development That Doesn't Suck
MM.NET
Now reading:The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
Audio Version
Mark's Commentary
Print PDF
http://markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/subscribehttp://premium.markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/courseshttp://markmanson.net/videoshttp://markmanson.net/audiohttp://markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/abouthttp://markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/https://twitter.com/share?original_referer=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilber&text=The%20Rise%20And%20Fall%20of%20Ken%20Wilber&url=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilber&via=IAmMarkMansonhttp://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilberhttp://markmanson.net/archivehttp://markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/log-inhttp://markmanson.net/subscribehttp://markmanson.net/subscribehttp://premium.markmanson.net/http://markmanson.net/dating-relationships-coursehttp://markmanson.net/overcome-anxiety-coursehttp://markmanson.net/connection-coursehttp://markmanson.net/courseshttp://markmanson.net/videoshttp://markmanson.net/audiohttp://markmanson.net/bookshttp://markmanson.net/downloadshttp://markmanson.net/archivehttp://markmanson.net/best-articles/http://markmanson.net/abouthttp://markmanson.net/archive
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
2/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 2
Ken Wilber is the smartest man you’ve never heard
of. He’s a philosopher and mystic whose workattempts to integrate all fields of study into one
single model or framework of understanding.
When I say, “all fields of study,” I mean that literally. Wilber believes that
every field of knowledge contains at least one aspect of truth, no matter howsmall, and that reconciling disparate disciplines is a matter of integrating
what’s right about them rather than discounting them for being partially
wrong. As Wilber often puts it: “No one is smart enough to be wrong 100% of
the time,” and therefore we should focus on what’s right and leave out the res
Neurobiology, Jungian archetypes, horticultural societies, hermeneutics,
Hegelian dialectics, systems theory, Zen koans, post-structuralism, VedantanHinduism, capitalist economic systems, transpersonal states of consciousness
neo-Platonic forms — the list goes on and on — all explained and fit together
neatly in one map of reality, what he semi-ironically calls, “A Theory of
Everything.” Above all, he manages to explain it all in lucid and brilliant prose
You literally feel yourself getting smarter as you read him.
WILBERJune 4, 2012 14 minute read by Mark Manson• •
http://markmanson.net/author/mark-mansonhttp://markmanson.net/ken-wilber
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
3/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 3
An intellectual prodigy as a child, Wilber was a Doctoral student at Duke
University in biology when he quit his program in order to, as he put it, “sit in
a room by myself and stare at a wall for five years.” He then went on a binge of
studying eastern spirituality, religion, and psychology.
Here’s a video of him stopping and starting his brain waves using differentforms of meditation:
I discovered Wilber when I was 19. That same year I read his books, all 15 of
them. They were dense, but it was a watershed moment in my intellectual and
personal growth. Discovering him was truly conscious-expanding. After
understanding his model, the rest of the world felt simpler. Also, I had a very
Ken Wilber Stops His Brain Waves
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LFFMtq5g8N4
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
4/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 4
powerful spiritual experience when I was a teenager, but could never reconcile
any sort of spiritual practice or belief with scientific knowledge and rigor.
Wilber did that for me. He’s been one of the most influential thinkers, if not
the most influential thinker in my life.
There’s not nearly enough room on this blog to do Wilber’s theory justice. Buif you’ve got time and are up for an intellectual exercise, you can find a
summary of his integrated psychological model here, a brief overview of his
AQAL model here, and a long-form critique of his work here.
Of course, the best way to learn about his material is to go to the man himself.
recommend everyone begin with A Brief History of Everything followed byntegral Psychology and his masterpiece, Sex, Ecology, Spirituality .
Instead of attempting to explain his work, I’ll instead outline a few of the most
important ways that he’s influenced my own thinking:
1. Nothing is 100% right or wrong, they merely vary in their degree of
incompleteness and dysfunction. No one or nothing is 100% good or evil,they just vary in their degree of ignorance and disconnection. All
knowledge is a work in progress.
2. Leaps in evolution usually occur in a manner of “transcending and
including,” not by wiping out what came before. For instance, the
evolution to the developmental level of a single-cell organism did not wipout molecules, but included them into a greater order of complexity.
Wilber asserts that this pattern of evolution occurs with all phenomena.
Rational thought did not eliminate emotion, but included it into a greater
developmental level of consciousness. Industrial societies did not wipe ou
agriculture, but transcended agriculture into greater levels of efficiency
and prosperity. If we’re going to truly evolve, we do so by including and
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1570627444/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=entsblo-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=1570627444http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1570625549/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=entsblo-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=1570625549http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1570627401/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=entsblo-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=1570627401http://www.integralworld.net/meyerhoff-ba-toc.htmlhttp://www.kheper.net/topics/Wilber/Wilber_IV.htmlhttp://www.kenwilber.com/Writings/PDF/SummaryofMyPsychologicalModel_GENERAL_2000_NN.pdf
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
5/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 5
integrating what came before into something greater, not by wiping it out.
3. Related to Point #2: the goal of spirituality is to transcend the ego, not to
demolish it or repress it. Many spiritual leaders who claimed to have rid
themselves of ego, it turns out, merely repress it. The results are horrible
and sometimes tragic.
4. Wilber has a concept called the “Pre/Trans Fallacy” which states that
people often mistake what’s pre-conventional (earlier phase of
development) for being post-conventional (later stage of development)
because neither is conventional. One example he uses is the New Age
spiritual movements which glorify a return to an infantile state of acting
purely on emotion and desire. They mistake these earlier, narcissistic
emotional whims for spiritual experiences, since both emotional revelry
and spiritual experiences are non-rational experiences. Since their
emotional revelry is non-rational, and spiritual experiences are non-
rational, they confuse the two. This concept can be applied in many areas
of personal and social development.
5. Perception contains interior and exterior modalities, or Wilber’s solution
to the Mind-Body Problem in philosophy. You can cut open someone’s
brain, track the neurons firing when they think about a cat, but which is
real, the neurons firing or the thought about the cat? It depends who you
ask. The problem arises when one assumes that our thoughts and behavio
are controlled by the physical assortment of neurons firing. It implies that
our minds are not autonomous and that we lack free will. Wilber states
that both the interior and exterior modes of consciousness are not only
equally real, but reflections of one another. Indeed, research into neuro-
plasticity (the ability to change the physical configuration of your brain
through changing thought patterns and behavior) is beginning to back up
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind%E2%80%93body_problem
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
6/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 6
this conclusion.
6. Hierarchies exist, but they don’t necessarily equal moral superiority.
There are higher levels of development and complexity, people of greater
skills and talents, but that does not mean they are morally superior or
more complete expressions of reality or that lower levels on the hierarchy
should not be honored. For instance, nuclear science is a higher form of
human understanding than voodoo magic or religious dogma, but Wilber
argues that this does not mean one should be imposed onto the other.
Each has its uses depending on where a person’s level of consciousness is
The beauty of integrating ALL fields of knowledge into a single model is that
the model has wide implications on EVERY field of study. Once you
understand Wilber’s conclusions, it becomes apparent how his model and
ideas could benefit everything from politics to science to psychology to
spirituality.
A MOVEMENT IS BORN
In 1999, coming off the success of his monster 1,000-page magnum opus, Sex,
Ecology, Spirituality, and the model of consciousness and development it
presented, Wilber started Integral Institute, a think-tank and academic
institution to set the foundation to disseminate Wilber’s ideas to the world.
World-famous leaders and thinkers such as Al Gore, Tony Robbins , Nathanie
Branden, Alex Grey, David Deida and Tony Schwartz gave ringing
endorsements. Seminars and websites were created, conferences convened. It
seemed a legitimate spiritually-infused intellectual movement was taking form
and was soon to uproot conventional “non-integral” forms of thinking in
http://markmanson.net/diversify-your-identityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_Institutehttp://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1570627444/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=entsblo-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=1570627444
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
7/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 7
science, academia, politics,
and society in general.
Among Wilberites, there
was a bursting enthusiasm.
For his entire career, Wilberhad been an intellectual
recluse, turning down every
interview and refusing to
prescribe any sort of action
or application of his model
to the world around him. Hespent more than 20 years in
radio silence. But that was
about to change. At the time,
Wilber talked about the birth of a new integral zeitgeist which he believed
would sweep through conventional thought and change how the world
perceived itself. And we believed him. Wilber’s work had changed our lives, so
naturally we couldn’t wait to see what the actual application of his model coulddo for society at large.
In early 2005, I excitedly attended an Integral Intensive weekend in Boston.
Not only did I want to engage with other “second-tier” thinkers, but I wanted
to somehow get involved and help promote Wilber’s ideas. As a lowly
university student, I scrounged up almost of all of the money I had in order to
go (to this day, it is the only self-help seminar I’ve ever attended).
But upon arrival, my idealism took a punch in the gut. And although the
weekend was an enjoyable experience and in some ways powerful, by the time
left, something didn’t sit right.
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
8/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 8
GREAT LIGHT CASTS A GREAT
SHADOW
At the weekend seminar, I couldn’t shake the feeling that what we wereparticipating in was thinly-veiled self-indulgence and little more. In hindsight,
I think this was as much a branding problem (from a business perspective) as
an organizational problem (social perspective). Integral Institute built their
movement in order to influence academia, governmental policy, to get books
and journals published, and to infuse these ideas into the world at large. Yet,
here we were, spending money to sit in a room performing various forms of
meditation and yoga, having group therapy sessions, art performances, andgenerally going on and on about how “integral” we were and how important
we were to the world without seemingly doing anything on a larger scale about
it.
If you want to be a self-development seminar and motivate people, then be a
self-development seminar and motivate people. If you want to be a formalinstitute and have serious effects on policy and academia, then do that. Don’t
half-ass both and muddy them with gratuitous talks and performances. The
irony in all of this was that Wilber’s integral framework applied to
organizations and business and should have accounted for these branding issues ,
but didn’t. The ironies would soon continue to mount.
Following Wilber online, the conversation seemed to only become more andmore insular. With an onslaught of problems in the world crying out for an
integral perspective and solution — terrorism, the Iraq War, climate change,
world hunger, financial crises. The silence coming from the Integral crowd wa
deafening. Major global and social issues were often only referred to in passing
as descriptors for a certain level of consciousness development with the
overarching implication being that “they” are not as highly developed as “we”
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
9/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 9
are.
We’re “second-tier” thinkers. We’re going to change the world… as soon as
we’re done talking about how awesome and “second-tier” we are.
Instead, most conversations involved esoteric spiritual topics, impulsive self-expressionism, and re-explaining the integral model in 4,102 different ways.
For a philosophy based on including and integrating as much as possible, its
followers sure expressed it by forming a nicely-sealed bubble around
themselves.
Evidence of this came when Wilber’s critics popped up. Experts in many of the fields Wilber claimed to have “integrated” questioned or picked apart
some of his assumptions. In Wilber’s model, he uses what he refers to as
“orienting generalizations,” ways of summarizing entire fields of study in
order to fit them together with other forms of knowledge. Wilber admits in his
work that he’s generalizing large topics and that there is not consensus in man
fields, but that he’s constructed these generalizations to reflect the basic and
agreed-upon principles of each field of study.
Well, a number of experts began questioning Wilber’s choice of sources. And
as for the claims that what he portrayed as consensus in some fields such as
developmental psychology or sociology, it turned out there was still quite a bit
of debate and uncertainty around some of Wilber’s “basic” conclusions.
Often, what Wilber portrayed as the “consensus” of a certain field actuallyamounted to an obscure or minority position.
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
10/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 10
Critics also picked apart Wilber’s model itself, showing minor contradictions
in it. And a number of people caught on to his shockingly meek understanding
of evolutionary biology and his puzzling insinuations of intelligent design.
Wilber’s eventual response to many of these critics was nothing short of
childish — a dozen-or-so page (albeit extremely well-written) verbal shit storm
that clarified nothing, justified nothing, personally attacked everyone, and
straw-manned the shit out of his critics’ claims.
For many, that was the day the intellectual giant fell, the evolution stopped, th
so-called “Einstein of consciousness” took his ball and went home.
From there, the integral movement began to sputter. Rabbi Marc Gafni, a
spiritual leader with whom Wilber aligned himself and even co-sponsored
seminars, was later indicted in Israel for child molestation. Despite this, Wilbe
http://www.kenwilber.com/blog/show/46
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
11/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 11
and his movement refused to distance themselves or repudiate him. In fact, th
whole integral scene doubled down, claiming that its critics were “first-tier
thinkers,” and were coming up with lies in order to attack a greater, higher
level of consciousness that it didn’t understand.
The seminars slowed to a crawl. Wilber’s health deteriorated greatly (he wasdiagnosed with a rare disease that keeps him bed-ridden). He stopped writing.
Ten years on, despite developing some fans in academia (some in high places),
Wilber’s work had yet to be tested or peer-reviewed in a serious journal. Much
of his posting online devolved into bizarre spiritual claims (such as this one
about an “enlightened teacher” who can make crops grow twice as fast by
“blessing them”).
The brilliant scientist-turned-monk-turned-recluse-turned-New-Age-celebrity
whose ideas changed everything for so many people (myself included),
devolved into the butt of another New Age joke. How the mighty have fallen.
A CAUTIONARY TALE
Although flawed, Wilber’s integral perspective continues to be an inspiration
in my life. I do believe he will be written about decades or centuries from now,
and will be seen as one of the most brilliant minds of our generation. But as
with most brilliant thinkers, his influence and ideas will be carried on by other
in ways which he did not anticipate or intend.
Wilber’s story is a cautionary tale. His intellectual understanding was
immense, as much as I’ve ever come across in a single person. He also tapped
into some of the farthest reaches of consciousness, spiritual or not, that
humans have self-reported. I do believe that. But ultimately, he was done in by
http://headthegong.com/blog/has-ken-wilber-jumped-the-shark/http://www.integralworld.net/redd.html
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
12/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 12
his pride, his need for control and, well, ironically his ego.
The point is, if Wilber can succumb to it, any of us can. No one is immune. N
matter how brilliant and how “enlightened” we are, we’re all animals.
Wilber was a baby boomer in the US through the 60’s and 70’s. He came upthrough many of that generation’s eastern spiritual movements. These
movements were started by eastern teachers and subscribed to a dogma that an
enlightened awareness could develop someone into a flawless individual, an
immutable authority. Despite Wilber’s massive understanding of human
psychology and consciousness, he never seemed to shake this dogma. It
followed Wilber through his career and eventually manifested in himself.When he was younger, he notoriously followed Adi Da, a spiritual leader who
was later found to be sexually abusing female followers. Yet he stood by him.
Later in his career, he also aligned with Andrew Cohen, a spiritual leader who
was found to be physically and emotionally abusing his followers. And again,
he stood by him. Why? Because Wilber maintained they had genuinely reache
the farthest limits of human awareness and understanding.
What Wilber taught me is that no depth of spiritual experience can negate our
physical and primal drives for power, lust and validation. As primates, we’re
wired to seek someone to look up to as well as to be looked up to by others.
And that’s true whether we’re experiencing Godhead or bodhisattva or not.
It’s inescapable.
Wilber also showed me that a brilliant mind does not necessarily make a
brilliant leader. Wilber bragged in an interview that he never planned anything
at Integral Institute, because planning would not represent a “second-tier”
leadership. Despite massive funding, enthusiasm, brain power and demand,
Integral Institute found a way to fail.
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
13/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 13
The grand irony here is that Wilber’s model itself, the Integral framework,
accounts for and describes everything I said in the paragraphs above . Wilber failed
in the exact ways his own model predicted. His model champions the idea of
transcending the ego, not negating it. It calls for crowdsourced intellectual
rigor and peer review. It goes on, at length, about the shadow self and how our
unconscious desires sabotage our greater goals. It covers our primal andbiological nature and how our lower impulses must be accepted and kept in
check.
Yet he would succumb to the same faults he warned us about.
David Foster Wallace states in his speech “This Is Water” that we all choosesomething to worship, whether we realize it or not. Wilber would say what we
choose to worship is dependent on the stage or level of consciousness we’ve
developed to. And he would be right.
But what he seems to have missed is that worshipping consciousness development
itself, Wilber’s so-called “second-tier” thinking, leads to the same disastrous
repercussions Wallace warned of: vanity, power, guilt, obsession.
No one is immune.
As humans, we have a tendency to cling to ideologies. Any positive set of
beliefs can quickly turn malevolent once treated as ideology and not an honest
intellectual or experiential pursuit of greater truth. Ideology does in entireeconomic systems and countries, causes religions to massacre thousands, turn
human rights movements into authoritarian sects and makes fools out of
humanity’s most brilliant minds. Einstein famously wasted the second half of
his career trying to calculate a cosmological constant that didn’t exist because
“God doesn’t play dice.”
http://postmasculine.com/this-is-water
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
14/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 14
Stay Connected: Follow @iammarkmanson
Wilber’s brilliance will always be a part of me. But what he really taught me is
this: There is no ideology. There is no guru. There is only us, and this, and the
silence.
[ Image credit: susivinh ]
DID YOU LIKE THIS ARTICLE?
Every couple weeks I send out a newsletter with new articles and exclusive
content for readers. It's basically my way of keeping in touch with you and
letting you know what's going on. Your information is protected and I never
spam.
Subscribe to stay connected.
SHARE
TWEET
GOOGLE+
318,405 people like this. Sign Up to see what your
friends like.Like Sha re
OUR EMAIL ADDRESS
SEND ME THE EBOOK
https://www.facebook.com/campaign/landing.php?campaign_id=137675572948107&partner_id=markmanson.net&placement=like_plugin&extra_1=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilber&extra_2=SAhttps://plus.google.com/share?url=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilberhttps://twitter.com/share?original_referer=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilber&text=The%20Rise%20And%20Fall%20of%20Ken%20Wilber&url=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilber&via=IAmMarkMansonhttp://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilberhttps://www.flickr.com/photos/susivinh/6626448401/sizes/lhttps://twitter.com/intent/follow?original_referer=http%3A%2F%2Fmarkmanson.net%2Fken-wilber&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw®ion=follow_link&screen_name=iammarkmanson&tw_p=followbutton
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
15/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
http://markmanson.net/ken-wilber 15
RELATED ARTICLES YOU MAY LIKE -
How to 80/20 Your Life Being Special Isn’t So
Special
No, You Can’t Have It All The Three Loves Theory
The Zen Dilemma
http://markmanson.net/the-zen-dilemmahttp://markmanson.net/the-zen-dilemmahttp://markmanson.net/three-loves-theoryhttp://markmanson.net/three-loves-theoryhttp://markmanson.net/you-cant-have-it-allhttp://markmanson.net/you-cant-have-it-allhttp://markmanson.net/being-specialhttp://markmanson.net/being-specialhttp://markmanson.net/80-20-your-lifehttp://markmanson.net/80-20-your-life
8/16/2019 The Rise and Fall of Ken Wilber
16/16
6/3/2016 The Rise And Fall of Ken Wilber
© 2016 Infinity Squared Media LLC Terms and Conditions / Privacy Policy / Affiliates / Contact / Subscribe / Login
SUPPORT THE SITE AND GET
ACCESS TO MORE AMAZING
SHIT
Hi there. This is the part of the website where I put a big toothy grin on my fa
and scream “BUT WAIT! THERE’S MORE!” at you in hopes to hold your
attention for more than 30 milliseconds.
Because wait, there actually is more. If you’d like to learn more about where
some of the ideas from these articles came from and hear my responses to crit
feedback, and if you’re interested in hearing me answer reader questions like I
Anne fucking Landers and talk a bit more about my own experiences, my
business ventures, and what I eat for breakfast on Sundays, well, then there
actually is more. A lot more, actually.
Become a subscriber to the site and get all that extra cool stuff. Just click the
retty, pretty button below to get started.
CLICK ME
https://markmanson.net/subscribehttp://markmanson.net/log-inhttp://markmanson.net/subscribehttp://markmanson.net/contacthttp://markmanson.net/affiliateshttp://markmanson.net/privacy-policyhttp://markmanson.net/terms-and-conditions