+ All Categories
Home > Documents > THE (SO-CALLED) NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF GENERAL PRACTITIONERS

THE (SO-CALLED) NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF GENERAL PRACTITIONERS

Date post: 01-Jan-2017
Category:
Upload: vuongtuyen
View: 212 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
2
211 fit state of anatomical inspection, after more than a year has elapsed. A similar testimony in favour of the solution of the chloride. is borne by the assistant-surgeon of the Marine Hos- pital at Woolwich, who adds, "the great advantage which the chloride of zinc possesses over other agents employed for a like purpose, is, that it removes the disagreeable effluvium, without leaving one little less offensive in its room, and may therefore be made use of wherever this effect is required- in private as well as public buildings, in the sick bedchamber no less than in the crowded ward. The method adopted at this hospital is to supply each of the wards with a bottle of the diluted solution, which the nurses have directions to use whenever occasion may require, besides sprinkling it ,, over the floors before the morning and evening visits are made." Its utility in the dissecting-room is confirmed by the state- ments made by Mr. Bowman, Dr. Sharpey, Mr. Partridge, Dr. Murray, and Dr. V. Pettigrew, who concur in asserting, that in a proper degree of dilution its success is complete, and that it appears to preserve the colour and texture of the parts very admirably. It has, further, the very important advantage of not acting on the steel instruments employed, being in this respect equal to alcohol. Dr. Methven espe- ciallv mentions an instance in which the solution corrected advancing putrescence, and enabled him to dissect during July.’ He believes, further, it will be the means of saving many valuable lives, which are annually lost by wounds re- ceived in the course of dissection, as while dissecting this putrid body, he cut himself several times, and once received a punctured wound, without any bad consequences arising. Mr. M’Bain, of the "Mastiff," adds his testimony "to the rapid and perfect effects of the chloride of zinc solution upon animal matter in a state of putrefaction. Having frequent opportunities of dissecting or examining large fish &c. cast on shore, whilst undergoing decomposition, the task has been occasionally anything but agreeable, for want of a convenient power to destroy the putrefactive process. The chloride in these cases acts like magic; and as a great practical agent over one of the most important conditions of animal and vegetable matter-viz., putrefaction, it stands unrivalled." Its influence on board ship, in annihilating the offensive smell of bilge-water, and in sweetening between decks, is shown by the united evidence of captains, surgeons, and masters in the royal navy. Among other vessels, it was used on board the "Victoria and Albert" royal yacht, to remove a more than ordinary stench of bilge-water, and other offensive odours, with the most complete success. The surgeon states that she has remained comparatively sweet ever since, and when a bilge-water smell is occasionally perceptible, a slight appli cation of the fluid removes it. The solution has also been used for very disgusting privies, &c., effluvia from which it onicklv neutralizes. Mr. Henderson, the surgeon to the dock-yard at Ports- mouth, has employed the fluid in a severe case of open cancer, the fœtor from which was intolerable to the patient and attendants: this it destroyed so long as the dressings were kept moist therewith. Professor Quain has used it, he says, in the treatment of sloughing tumours with beneficial result, and he has no doubt it will supplant the chloride of lime and soda altogether in the removal of foetid odour. Mr. Gibson, surgeon of the " Eurydice," employed it in a case of angry ulcer, in the proportion of one part to four of water. An eschar was the result, the separation of which left the ulcer in a healthy condition. Several naval and other medical men have employed it as a disinfectant in hospitals, and on board ship, the general results being a marked diminution in the rate of mortality. Dr. Lindsay, Dr. Cronin, and Dr. Connor, of Cork, all bear testimony to its beneficial effects. Mr. Verling, surgeon of the " Vengeance," thus speaks:- " Having used the chloride of zinc rather extensively on board Her Majesty’s ship ’Vengeance,’ whilst employed in the conveyance of troops, I think proper to report to you the result thereof. We carried the first battalion of the forty- second regiment, consisting of about 700 men, women, and children, from Malta to Bermuda. Measles had prevailed epidemically in the regiment previously to their embarkation, but we received none on board labouring under the disease; yet, after being ten days at sea, several cases occurred simul- taneously among the soldiers, and on the 1st of April, having been then a month at sea, the disease appeared among our own people, ten cases occurring on that day, and from that day to the fifteenth of the month, when we arrived at Ber- muda, fresh cases were almost of daily occurrence, either among our own people or the troops. On getting rid of the troops, which we did at Bermuda, my attention was of course specially directed to every means whereby the contagion could be destroyed. Cleanliness and ventilation were duly attended to, and every part of the ship where the sick had been, after being cleaned and aired, was sponged well over with the solution of chloride of zinc several times. Than the result, nothing could be better; the disease totally ceased, no fresh case occurring after. On our passage from Halifax, with the sixtieth regiment on board, the weather was so bad, and the ship working so much, that it was quite impossible to open any of the lower-deck ports, on which deck the whole of the people lived, troops as well as our own people, for eight days; the air throughout the deck was exceedingly vitiated with every mixture of noxious smell, but the free use of the chloride of zinc tended, in a most surprising manner, to do away with the bad smell; so much so, that the surgeon of the regiment came to me to get some to use in the part of the ship where the ladies of the officers were. The effect of the chloride of zinc is most obvious in correcting all bad and offensive effluvia; and from the sudden and surprising manner in which the measles disappeared after its use, it is not, I think, too much to say, that it must have been very instru- mental in decomposing the miasm, or state of atmosphere in the ship, which tended to the generation of the disease." From all these statements, then, it is clear that the solution of the chloride of zinc is a powerful agent in neutralizing noxious gases, and in arresting the progress of decomposi- tion. Sir W. Burnett has therefore rendered, by its dis- covery, a great benefit to suffering humanity. On board ship, its influence in removing the offensive odours from bilge- water can hardly be too highly estimated, while its action in sweetening the wards of hospitals, and destroying noxious and infectious effluvia, seems to be equally evident. THE (SO-CALLED) NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF GENERAL PRACTITIONERS. THE National (?) Institute held its First Annual Meeting in one of the smaller of the Hanover-square Rooms, on Wednes- day, the llth inst. The attendance was, as might have been anticipated, from the past conduct of the Council of that body, exceedingly thin, there being scarcely a dozen persons upon the platform. The president, Mr. PENNINGTON, was absent, as were also many other gentlemen hitherto accustomed to take an active part in the proceedings of the Institute. The proceedings of the meeting, as might have been in- ferred would be the case, from the numbers and constitution, were listless, inanimate, and uninteresting. A report was read by the secretaries, the great labour and endeavour of which was to reconcile the members of the Institute to the opposition offered by the Council to the Medical Regis- tration Bill. This portion of the report elicited no sympathy from the few members present, some of them, on the con- trary, expressing strong disapprobation. A code of by-laws was also read to the meeting. Had these been framed a year or two ago, they might have been of some service in preserving the "Committee of the National Association," and the " Council of the Institute," from some of the many improper acts of which they have been guilty. They have arrived too late, however, and are now useless, for the Institute is tottering to the fall which it so richly de- serves. Several of the by-laws had reference to a museum and library-good things enough, but which the Institute is never destined to possess. One of the by-laws requires a word or two of special no- tice. It is this: " No member interested in the sale of any nostrum or specific remedy, or keeping a shop, for the retail of drugs, shall be eligible as a member of the Council." This by-law, carried into strict effect, would exclude every man officially connected with the Apothecaries’ Company, which is a trading body, the Hall itself being one large druggist’s shop. It shows, too, that the Council of the Institute are not less prone to maintain invidious distinctions amongst its members than the Council of the corrupt corporations. It appeared from the statement of the secretaries, that thirteen hundred members had enrolled themselves in the Institute on its first formation, but that nine hundred only had subscribed their guineas, and that the whole of this sum, with the exception of a trifling balance, had been expended- for what, it may be asked ? What good or useful purpose has such a large expenditure achieved ? and how many guineas does the Council think it will get for its next year’s opera- tions !
Transcript
Page 1: THE (SO-CALLED) NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF GENERAL PRACTITIONERS

211

fit state of anatomical inspection, after more than a year haselapsed. A similar testimony in favour of the solution of thechloride. is borne by the assistant-surgeon of the Marine Hos-pital at Woolwich, who adds, "the great advantage which thechloride of zinc possesses over other agents employed for alike purpose, is, that it removes the disagreeable effluvium,without leaving one little less offensive in its room, and maytherefore be made use of wherever this effect is required-in private as well as public buildings, in the sick bedchamberno less than in the crowded ward. The method adopted atthis hospital is to supply each of the wards with a bottle ofthe diluted solution, which the nurses have directions touse whenever occasion may require, besides sprinkling it ,,

over the floors before the morning and evening visits aremade."

Its utility in the dissecting-room is confirmed by the state-ments made by Mr. Bowman, Dr. Sharpey, Mr. Partridge,Dr. Murray, and Dr. V. Pettigrew, who concur in asserting,that in a proper degree of dilution its success is complete,and that it appears to preserve the colour and texture of theparts very admirably. It has, further, the very importantadvantage of not acting on the steel instruments employed,being in this respect equal to alcohol. Dr. Methven espe-ciallv mentions an instance in which the solution correctedadvancing putrescence, and enabled him to dissect duringJuly.’ He believes, further, it will be the means of savingmany valuable lives, which are annually lost by wounds re-ceived in the course of dissection, as while dissecting thisputrid body, he cut himself several times, and once receiveda punctured wound, without any bad consequences arising.Mr. M’Bain, of the "Mastiff," adds his testimony "to therapid and perfect effects of the chloride of zinc solution uponanimal matter in a state of putrefaction. Having frequentopportunities of dissecting or examining large fish &c. caston shore, whilst undergoing decomposition, the task has beenoccasionally anything but agreeable, for want of a convenientpower to destroy the putrefactive process. The chloride inthese cases acts like magic; and as a great practical agentover one of the most important conditions of animal andvegetable matter-viz., putrefaction, it stands unrivalled."Its influence on board ship, in annihilating the offensive smellof bilge-water, and in sweetening between decks, is shown bythe united evidence of captains, surgeons, and masters in theroyal navy. Among other vessels, it was used on board the"Victoria and Albert" royal yacht, to remove a more thanordinary stench of bilge-water, and other offensive odours,with the most complete success. The surgeon states that shehas remained comparatively sweet ever since, and whena bilge-water smell is occasionally perceptible, a slight application of the fluid removes it. The solution has also beenused for very disgusting privies, &c., effluvia from which itonicklv neutralizes.Mr. Henderson, the surgeon to the dock-yard at Ports-

mouth, has employed the fluid in a severe case of opencancer, the fœtor from which was intolerable to the patientand attendants: this it destroyed so long as the dressingswere kept moist therewith. Professor Quain has used it, hesays, in the treatment of sloughing tumours with beneficialresult, and he has no doubt it will supplant the chloride oflime and soda altogether in the removal of foetid odour. Mr.

Gibson, surgeon of the " Eurydice," employed it in a case ofangry ulcer, in the proportion of one part to four of water.An eschar was the result, the separation of which left theulcer in a healthy condition.

Several naval and other medical men have employed it asa disinfectant in hospitals, and on board ship, the generalresults being a marked diminution in the rate of mortality.Dr. Lindsay, Dr. Cronin, and Dr. Connor, of Cork, all beartestimony to its beneficial effects. Mr. Verling, surgeon ofthe " Vengeance," thus speaks:-" Having used the chloride of zinc rather extensively on

board Her Majesty’s ship ’Vengeance,’ whilst employed inthe conveyance of troops, I think proper to report to you theresult thereof. We carried the first battalion of the forty-second regiment, consisting of about 700 men, women, andchildren, from Malta to Bermuda. Measles had prevailedepidemically in the regiment previously to their embarkation,but we received none on board labouring under the disease;yet, after being ten days at sea, several cases occurred simul-taneously among the soldiers, and on the 1st of April, havingbeen then a month at sea, the disease appeared among ourown people, ten cases occurring on that day, and from thatday to the fifteenth of the month, when we arrived at Ber-muda, fresh cases were almost of daily occurrence, eitheramong our own people or the troops. On getting rid of the

troops, which we did at Bermuda, my attention was of coursespecially directed to every means whereby the contagion couldbe destroyed. Cleanliness and ventilation were duly attendedto, and every part of the ship where the sick had been, afterbeing cleaned and aired, was sponged well over with thesolution of chloride of zinc several times. Than the result,nothing could be better; the disease totally ceased, no freshcase occurring after. On our passage from Halifax, with thesixtieth regiment on board, the weather was so bad, and theship working so much, that it was quite impossible to openany of the lower-deck ports, on which deck the whole of thepeople lived, troops as well as our own people, for eight days;the air throughout the deck was exceedingly vitiated withevery mixture of noxious smell, but the free use of thechloride of zinc tended, in a most surprising manner, to doaway with the bad smell; so much so, that the surgeon of theregiment came to me to get some to use in the part of theship where the ladies of the officers were. The effect of thechloride of zinc is most obvious in correcting all bad andoffensive effluvia; and from the sudden and surprising mannerin which the measles disappeared after its use, it is not, Ithink, too much to say, that it must have been very instru-mental in decomposing the miasm, or state of atmosphere inthe ship, which tended to the generation of the disease."From all these statements, then, it is clear that the solution

of the chloride of zinc is a powerful agent in neutralizingnoxious gases, and in arresting the progress of decomposi-tion. Sir W. Burnett has therefore rendered, by its dis-covery, a great benefit to suffering humanity. On board ship,its influence in removing the offensive odours from bilge-water can hardly be too highly estimated, while its action insweetening the wards of hospitals, and destroying noxiousand infectious effluvia, seems to be equally evident.

THE (SO-CALLED) NATIONAL INSTITUTE OFGENERAL PRACTITIONERS.

THE National (?) Institute held its First Annual Meeting inone of the smaller of the Hanover-square Rooms, on Wednes-day, the llth inst.The attendance was, as might have been anticipated, from

the past conduct of the Council of that body, exceedinglythin, there being scarcely a dozen persons upon the platform.The president, Mr. PENNINGTON, was absent, as were alsomany other gentlemen hitherto accustomed to take an activepart in the proceedings of the Institute.The proceedings of the meeting, as might have been in-

ferred would be the case, from the numbers and constitution,were listless, inanimate, and uninteresting.A report was read by the secretaries, the great labour and

endeavour of which was to reconcile the members of the Instituteto the opposition offered by the Council to the Medical Regis-tration Bill. This portion of the report elicited no sympathyfrom the few members present, some of them, on the con-trary, expressing strong disapprobation.A code of by-laws was also read to the meeting. Had

these been framed a year or two ago, they might have beenof some service in preserving the "Committee of the NationalAssociation," and the " Council of the Institute," from someof the many improper acts of which they have been guilty.They have arrived too late, however, and are now useless, forthe Institute is tottering to the fall which it so richly de-serves. Several of the by-laws had reference to a museumand library-good things enough, but which the Institute isnever destined to possess.One of the by-laws requires a word or two of special no-

tice. It is this: " No member interested in the sale of anynostrum or specific remedy, or keeping a shop, for the retail ofdrugs, shall be eligible as a member of the Council." Thisby-law, carried into strict effect, would exclude every manofficially connected with the Apothecaries’ Company, which isa trading body, the Hall itself being one large druggist’s shop.It shows, too, that the Council of the Institute are not lessprone to maintain invidious distinctions amongst its membersthan the Council of the corrupt corporations.

It appeared from the statement of the secretaries, thatthirteen hundred members had enrolled themselves in theInstitute on its first formation, but that nine hundred onlyhad subscribed their guineas, and that the whole of this sum,with the exception of a trifling balance, had been expended-for what, it may be asked ? What good or useful purpose hassuch a large expenditure achieved ? and how many guineasdoes the Council think it will get for its next year’s opera-tions !

Page 2: THE (SO-CALLED) NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF GENERAL PRACTITIONERS

212

The meeting, long advertised, long trumpeted forth, wasbut a sorry affair-the very ghost of the meeting held in thesame rooms but two years ago. How sad must the contrasthave appeared to some of the once active functionaries. It ismore than doubtful whether we shall ever have to record a" Second Annual Meeting of the National Institute." Theghost, ere the termination of another year, will probably havevanished from earth, which is no proper place for such etherealgentry.

_________

Correspondence.BRANDING IN THE ARMY.

To the Editor of THE LANCET.SIR,—The editor of the Spectator has, in his paper of July

17th, protested in strong terms against the barbarous practiceof branding deserters from the army with an indelible markof infamy, the letter D, (deserter,)—" a stain," he observes,"that is not affixed to the most atrocious ruffian." Enter-

taining similar sentiments with the Spectator in this respect,and wishing, however feebly, to second his views, I have sub-joined some desultory facts and observations on the practiceof branding, which may perhaps interest some of your readers.Branding alleged delinquents is a very ancient mode ofpunishment, but it has only lately been introduced into theBritish army. Stigmatizing fugitive slaves on the foreheadwas a very common punishment by the Romans; and theearly Christians underwent a similar infliction, for the purposeof inducing them to renounce Christianity.We learn from Fielding, (" Causes of the Increase of

Robbers,") that in the reign of Edward VI. a law was madefor the punishment of idleness, which was enforced as

follows:—Runagate servants, or persons who lived idly forthree days, were to be marked with a hot iron on the breastwith the letter V, (vagabond;) and if a servant absconded for Ithe space of fourteen days, two justices of the peace mightorder him to be marked on the forehead or the ball of thecheek with a hot iron, with the sign of an S, (slave,) and beadjudged to be a slave to his said master for ever. This crueland unconstitutional statute was abrogat.ed in about two years.An indelible stigma, or brand of infamy, is a revolting andvindictive punishment. Branding in the hand or face was apunishment inflicted for thefts and other offences, until 1779;and it remained on the statute book, as a punishment formanslaughter, till the reign of George IV., when it wasabolished. It is remarkable, that when branding came to beconsidered, in popular opinion, a degrading and deterioratinginfliction in civil life, it was adopted in the army. Maimingand branding have been long known as punishments amongcertain classes of camp followers, which are subject to martiallaw. By the military code of Henry V., public and commonwomen were not permitted to remain in the camp, and anyone found with the army after admonition, was to be punishedwith " the fracture of her left arm." What class of officerswas to superintend the infliction of this punishment, and heldresponsible that it was effectually performed, is not stated inthe code in question.By the 11 Articles and Ordinances of War of the Army of

the Kingdom of Scotland, 1642," public women who followedthe army were, with other inflictions, liable to be branded." If any common whores shall be found following the army, ifthey be married women, and run away from their husbands,they shall be put to death without mercy; and if they be un-married, they shall be first marked by the hangman, andthereafter, by him, scourged out of the army." Fortunately,the officer who was responsible for the effectual performanceor execution of the sentence ordered by this law, is heresatisfactorily specified.

In 1807, branding of deserters became for the first time alegal punishment in the army, and by a recent enactment, adeserter may be branded, not only on the first, but on everysubsequent conviction of desertion, in addition to whateverother punishment a court-martial may be pleased to award.Hough, in his work on courts-martial, expresses regret thatthe punishment of branding deserters is not ianperative,instead of being permissive. He seems to forget that thereare various degrees of delinquency in the commission of thesame nominal crime. It may be remarked, that militarylawyers commonly lean to the side of severity; and certainlyit must be considered extremely severe justice, to uniformlyaward the highest degree of punishment for any one denomi-nation of crime. The punishment of branding deserters mayhave suggested itself to some officer who had been employed

in the West Indies, and observed the practice of markingrunaway slaves in that part of the world. The usage in thearmy is a very close imitation of the practice of brandingslaves in Jamaica.The following citations from advertisements respecting

fugitive slaves, in the Jamaica Royal Gazette, may be com.pared with quotations from the Police Gazette :--

Jamaica Gazette.

James, marked W. R. on different parts of his shoulders.Thomas, marked R. S. on shoulders.John Edwards, marked N. on breasts and shoulders.

Police Gazette, July 21st, 1847.Name. Corps. Marks and Remarks.W.S....... 30th foot ...... D.M. L....... 69th do....... D., 2nd desertion, &c.A. L....... 91st do....... D., 3rd desertion, &c.

The Spectator thus pithily discusses the moral effects ofbranding deserters :-

, " The man who is branded is for ever degraded : the stainis as deep upon his soul as upon his flesh; and he knows thathe is the scorn of the world." " There is ample punishmentin the military code for crimes, without attaching to thesoldier a mark of perpetual infamy, which renders him har.dened and desperate; which militates against repentance andamendment; and which is not inflicted upon other perjurersor felons."The mode of branding deserters hitherto adopted being

inefficacious, the brand not having been "indelibly impressed,"medical science has been put in requisition to see that themark is sufficiently graven into the skin, so that it cannot beerased. The operation of compulsorily branding a man ispractically a species of torture, which persons of all ranksdislike either to perform or to superintend, and hence, Ibelieve, it is very rarely effectually executed. The new law,by which a medical officer is directed to superintend the exe.cution of the sentence, and to be held responsible that theoperation is effectually performed by needles and gunpowder,will not mend matters. Having followed the example of theslave owners, in adopting the punishment of branding, it will,perhaps, be found necessary to imitate their mode of engravingthe brand into the skin. The operation of branding slaves inthe West Indies, as described by Mr. Bryan Edwards, (" His-tory of the West Indies,") is performed by heating a smallsilver brand, composed of one or two letters, (sometimes theinitials of the owner’s name,) in the flame of spirits of wine,and applying it to the skin, which is previously anointed withsweet oil. The application is instantaneous, and the painmomentary. Branding is a punishment which is unwillinglysubmitted to, and reluctantly executed. When performedby means of needles, it is tedious and painful, much more sthan when it is inflicted by the hot iron or the silver brand.It will therefore very rarely be executed, so as to be indeliblyimpressed or engraved into the skin. By reducing the painattending the operation, I do not think the objections to thepunishment of branding in any material degree removed, phy,sical pain forming but a very unimportant part of the inflic-tion.

Branding has never been a legitimate punishment in thenative army of the East India Company. In the nativestates of India, branding on the hand continues to be acommon punishment for theft. The restoration of the punish-ment of flogging sepoys, which lately took place, was madewith extraordinary care, to prevent it from being inflictedin excess. If my information be correct, commanding officersreceived private instructions from Lord Hardinge, enjoiningthem not to carry into effect the new articles of war. In re-

gard to this mode of corporal punishment, and in practice, ithas not been restored.

Branding, like flogging, is not a popular punishment in thiscountry, it being limited to the military profession, which isreckoned, par excellence, honourable. Flogging is still em-

ployed as a punishment in the navy, but the indelible andvindictive brand of disgrace has never been introduced intothis branch of our military force as a punishment for deser-tion.In the Grecian states slaves were hired to serve in the navy

or army, the master receiving payment for their services ; butas there was great danger of their running away or deserting.especially in war time, Antigenes of Rhodes,-the Hudson ofthe day,-established an insurance for slaves. For a yearlycontribution for each slave he undertook to make good hisprice to the owner in case of his desertion. This is the earliestapplication of the principle of insurance which has come to


Recommended