Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Jaan-Henrik KainChalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approachin Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Planning as strategic choice
The Strategic Choice Approach
The Strategic Choice Approachin Swedish research on urban water
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
The Strategic Choice Approach in Ghana?
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Planning as a process of strategic choice
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Planning as a process of strategic choice
From Friend and Hickling (2005)
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Planning as a process of strategic choice
- Numerous planning instruments
From Friend and Hickling (2005)
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
- Numerous planning instruments
- Different decision-makers
Planning as a process of strategic choice
From Friend and Hickling (2005)
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
- Numerous planning instruments
- Different decision-makers
- Pressures…
Planning as a process of strategic choice
From Friend and Hickling (2005)
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
- Numerous planning instruments
- Different decision-makers
- Pressures…
- Uncertainties…
Planning as a process of strategic choice
From Friend and Hickling (2005)
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
- Numerous planning instruments
- Different decision-makers
- Pressures…
- Uncertainties…
- Planning as a multi-stakeholder process
Planning as a process of strategic choice
From Friend and Hickling (2005)
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
From Friend and Hickling (2005)
- Numerous planning instruments
- Different decision-makers
- Pressures…
- Uncertainties…
- Planning as a multi-stakeholder process
- Planning as strategic choice to make progress
Planning as a process of strategic choice
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
After Friend and Hickling (2005)
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Shaping decision areas:
– What are the problems?
– How are they interlinked?
– What is the focus?
After Friend and Hickling (2005)
The Strategic Choice Approach
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Designing alternatives:
– What are the options?
– How may they be linked
into alternative solutions?
After Friend and Hickling (2005)
The Strategic Choice Approach
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Comparing alternatives:
– What are the evaluation
areas?
– What are the pros and cons
of the alternatives?
– Is there a best alternative?
After Friend and Hickling (2005)
The Strategic Choice Approach
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Choosing alternatives:
– What alternative is chosen?
– Who will take action?
– What are the remaining
uncertainties?
– What to do about them?
After Friend and Hickling (2005)
The Strategic Choice Approach
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
After Friend and Hickling (2005)
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
After Friend and Hickling (2005)
Participation:
– Who are the stakeholders?
– Who should/will participate?
– Why should they participate?
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
After Friend and Hickling (2005)
Participation:
– Who are the stakeholders?
– Who should/will participate?
– Why should they participate?
Worldviews:
– What are our aspirations?
– What are our different aims?
– How is our common future?
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
in Swedish research projects
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
in Swedish research projects
Planning of waste water management
in a smaller peri-urban area of the City of Södertälje
- with focus on user participation in the planning process
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
in Swedish research projects
Tentative planning of future
urban water and organic waste management systems
in the City of Uppsala
- participation by higher officials
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
in Swedish research projects
Evaluation of different approaches to future urban water
and organic waste management in the City of Gothenburg
- evaluation by politicians -> decision-making
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
in Swedish research projects
Evaluation of different alternatives for future
drinkig water provision in the City of Södertälje
- evaluation by officials and consultants -> decision-making
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
The Strategic Choice Approach
in Swedish research projects
Shaping of organisation and focus of a Climate Change Council
in the City of Malmö for mitigation of and adaptation to
effects of climate change (ongoing project)
- participation by officials from different bodies
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization,
based on taken-for-granteds or too narrow worldviews
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization
- Facilitation of multi-criteria evaluations,
both through graphics
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization
- Facilitation of multi-criteria evaluations,
both through graphics and software
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization
- Facilitation of multi-criteria evaluations
- Management of uncertainties,
of different kinds
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization
- Facilitation of multi-criteria evaluations
- Management of uncertainties,
of different kinds and importance
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization
- Facilitation of multi-criteria evaluations
- Management of uncertainties
- Building of commitment,
over time and uncertainty
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization
- Facilitation of multi-criteria evaluations
- Management of uncertainties
- Building of commitment,
over time and uncertainty
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization
- Facilitation of multi-criteria evaluations
- Management of uncertainties
- Building of commitment,
over time and uncertainty
Jaan-Henrik Kain Chalmers Architecture
The Strategic Choice Approach in Sustainable Sanitation Planning
Strengths of the Strategic Choice Approach
- Opening up decision areas to avoid sub-optimization
- Facilitation of multi-criteria evaluations
- Management of uncertainties
- Building of commitment,
over time and uncertainty