SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH & COMMUNITY MEDICINE THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES SYDNEY AUSTRALIA
THE WHAT, WHY AND HOW OF THE WHAT, WHY AND HOW OF KOORIE WELL-BEINGKOORIE WELL-BEING
DEVELOPING CULTURAL SAFETY AND CULTURAL EASE TO STRENGTHEN
FAMILIES
MURU MARRI INDIGENOUS HEALTH UNIT
2
3
THE WHAT, WHY AND HOW …THE WHAT, WHY AND HOW …
What do we know of the effects of
mental distress on Koorie families? Why is it so hard to lighten the burden
of community distress … to break
the inter-generational cycle? How can service providers and
organisations make a difference?
4
HOW, HOW, IN PARTICULAR …IN PARTICULAR …
Can cultural safety and cultural ease
bring about sustainable change in the way
both people and organisations work? Do you effectively engage Koorie
communities? Can all this help strengthen Koorie
families?
5
THE WHAT …THE WHAT …
What do we know of the effects of
mental distress on Koorie families?
6
INDIGENOUS MENTAL INDIGENOUS MENTAL DISTRESSDISTRESS Vic: 2 x Non-Koori rate of ‘Higher Mental
and Behavioural Disorders’* NSW: self-reported ‘mental distress’
almost 2 x Non-Koori rate** WA children: High risk of significant emotional/behavioural difficulties -
Nyoongah 24% > Wajella 15% ***
* Aboriginal Affairs Victoria ** NSW Health *** WAACHS
7
‘‘NOISE’ IN THE SYSTEMNOISE’ IN THE SYSTEM
Reports show a high level of generalised, or non-specific mental distress*
Clear Indigenous mental distress diagnoses, or ‘signals’, hard to assess owing to background ‘noise’
Example of Post-Natal Depression
* Gavin Stuart, former epidemiologist for NSW Health
8
JUST WHAT IS THIS ‘NOISE’? JUST WHAT IS THIS ‘NOISE’?
Dispossession – land, language, culture,
economic base → grief and loss ‘Stolen Generations’ Trans-Generational Trauma Racism/discrimination and ‘Clayton’s’
apartheid
9
INDIGENOUS MENTAL INDIGENOUS MENTAL DISTRESS: A LAYER MODELDISTRESS: A LAYER MODEL
10
““PSYCHOLOGY DOESN’T PSYCHOLOGY DOESN’T HAVE THE TOOLS … ”HAVE THE TOOLS … ”
to deal with catastrophe* complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder** complicated grief - “People with
complicated grief are basically stuck in a state of chronic grieving”***
* Erika Apfelbaum ** Derek Silove *** Paul Boelen
11
THE WHY …?THE WHY …?
Why is it so hard to lighten the
burden of community distress … to
break the inter-generational cycle?
12
GRIEF AND LOSSGRIEF AND LOSS
The losses from colonisation are
multiple Loss is an on-going Koorie
experience It’s both profound and pervasive
13
‘‘STOLEN GENERATIONS’STOLEN GENERATIONS’
14
‘‘STOLEN GENERATIONS’STOLEN GENERATIONS’
15
INCARCERATION AND INCARCERATION AND ‘STOLEN GENERATIONS’‘STOLEN GENERATIONS’ One third of all Aboriginal inmates in
NSW had been removed from their parents
as children 31% of female Aboriginal inmates in
NSW, and 21% of male, reported that their
parents had been forcibly removed from
their families as children*
16
TRANS-GENERATIONAL TRANS-GENERATIONAL TRAUMATRAUMA Holocaust literature – Yael Danieli Koorie research - Pat Swan /
Beverley Raphael, Jane McKendrick Critical Psychology – Erika Apfelbaum Critiques of Bio-Psychiatry –
Peter Breggin
17
T-G TRAUMA RECOGNISEDT-G TRAUMA RECOGNISED
DVA programme* for children - criteria: Both parents experiencing a mental illness
and /or alcohol /drug abuse problem One parent (particularly a mother)
experiencing a mental illness and/or alcohol/drug abuse problem
A father who has identified his health as ‘very poor’
* Vietnam Veterans Counselling Service Vietnam Veterans Sons and Daughters Project Plan
18
T-G TRAUMA - NOT ‘MENTAL’T-G TRAUMA - NOT ‘MENTAL’
Psychobiology / Body memory of
trauma – Bessel van der Kolk Psychoneurobiology / Developing brain
& trauma – Bruce Perry, Alan Schore Trauma and Psychosis – John Read
19
STATES BECOME TRAITS STATES BECOME TRAITS
Dissociation (‘freeze’) If a child dissociates in response to severe
trauma and stays in that … state for … sufficient … time, [they] will alter the homeostasis of the systems [involved]…
↑ dissociative/somatoform disorders, anxiety, major depression
* Bruce Perry, 2001
20
STATES BECOME TRAITSSTATES BECOME TRAITS
Hyper-arousal (‘fight’ or ‘flight’) If the child exposed to violence uses a …
hyper-arousal response, the altered homeostasis will be in different neuro-chemical systems
↑ persisting hyper-arousal symptoms / disorders: PTSD, ADHD, conduct disorder
* Bruce Perry, 2001
21
PREGY. / EARLY YEARS - PREGY. / EARLY YEARS - SUPPORT CRITICAL SUPPORT CRITICAL Exposure to violence or trauma alters the
developing brain Consistent, moderate stress → resilience Unpredictable or chronic stress → deficits
in function / vulnerability to future stressors*: ‘Living barefoot … surrounded by broken glass’
* Bruce Perry, 2001
22
EFFECTS OF RACISMEFFECTS OF RACISM
Racism is a major determinant of health
and a driver of inequalities in health*
* Ricci Harris et al, 2006
23
EFFECTS OF RACISMEFFECTS OF RACISM
Consistent relationships [have been found] between self-reported discrimination and … poorer mental health outcomes*
The literature suggests a robust link between self-perceived discrimination and mental health**
* Ricci Harris et al, 2006** Gee, 2002
24
25
EFFECTS OF RACISMEFFECTS OF RACISM
26
COMBATTING RACISMCOMBATTING RACISM
27
‘‘CLAYTON’S’ APARTHEIDCLAYTON’S’ APARTHEID
What are the contemporary effects of
keeping Aboriginal Australia side-lined
for generations?
28
EFFECTS ON IDENTITYEFFECTS ON IDENTITY
29
PERMISSION TO MARRYPERMISSION TO MARRY
30
CEASE TO BE AN ABORIGINECEASE TO BE AN ABORIGINE
31
32
THE HOW …THE HOW …
How can service providers and
organisations make a difference?
33
AN INTEGRATED APPROACHAN INTEGRATED APPROACH
Cultural Competence
Cultural Ease
Cultural Awareness
CulturalSafety
34
UNSAFE CULTURAL PRACTICEUNSAFE CULTURAL PRACTICE
… comprises any action that diminishes, demeans or disempowers the cultural identity or well-being of an individual.*
* Nursing Council of New Zealand, 2005
35
CULTURAL SAFETYCULTURAL SAFETY
More than simply having some cultural
awareness/sensitivity* Requires the service provider to let go
some ‘power’ in the relationship with the
client**
* New Zealand Psychologists Registration Board, 2006
** Aekins, 2006
36
CULTURAL SAFETYCULTURAL SAFETY
The client determines what’s comfortable
– the service provider looks for guidance
as to how to provide the service The service provider professional is
encouraged to reflect on their own cultural
identity and how this plays out in the way
they work with the client
37
CULTURAL EASECULTURAL EASE
38
NOTNOT CULTURAL EASE CULTURAL EASE
39
HOW TO MAKE A DIFFERENCEHOW TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE
Strengthen resilience – personal and cultural Keep a de-Othering perspective Cultural safety – make it a service priority Cultural ease - use Aboriginal protocols/ways Build environments for change – develop real
engagement with local community Extended advocacy – Political is the
Clinical
40
STRENGTHEN RESILIENCESTRENGTHEN RESILIENCE
Culture and health Connection to culture, language, land
‘protective’ of well-being* Notion of cultural resilience**
* Jane McKendrick
** Iris HeavyRunner and Kathy Marshall / Tracy Westerman
41
STRENGTHEN RESILIENCESTRENGTHEN RESILIENCE
Enculturation is a resiliency factor in development …
Spirituality reported by adolescent students was related to competence …
[Other studies show] links between spirituality and/or enculturation and wellness and/or resilience
* Joyce Strand and Thomas Peacock, 2002
42
Being Being ootherther
43
Being Being OOtherther
44
BEYOND THE PALEBEYOND THE PALE
45
INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIAN INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIAN APPROACHES TO LISTENINGAPPROACHES TO LISTENING
Dadirri
“Inner, deep listening and quiet, still awareness … something like what you call contemplation.” (Miriam-Rose Ungunmerr-Baumann)
46
Indigenous Australian Indigenous Australian Approaches to ListeningApproaches to Listening
Dadirri
Listening with your ears and heart*
* Judy Atkinson, after Miriam-Rose Ungunmerr-Baumann
47
INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIAN INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIAN APPROACHES TO LISTENINGAPPROACHES TO LISTENING
Ngara“Listen, hear, think … (Eora, the Sydney language) to listen is simultaneously to reflect and become self-aware.”*
* Paul Carter
48
Indigenous Australian Indigenous Australian Approaches to ListeningApproaches to Listening
Ngara Listening requires something of you … you need to complete the circle. Hearing should lead to action.*
* Koori Peak Organisation Board Member
49
INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIAN INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIAN APPROACHES TO LISTENINGAPPROACHES TO LISTENING
Binang Goonj
“They hear, but they don’t listen.” (Bidjara language, south-west Queensland)
50
INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIAN INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIAN APPROACHES TO LISTENINGAPPROACHES TO LISTENING
The Role of Silence
"If you cannot understand an Aboriginal person's silence, then you will never understand their words" (Uncle George Tongerie, Elder from South Australia)
51
FOR US, FOR US, LISTENINGLISTENING INVOLVES INVOLVES
More than ‘hearing’- includes self-
reflection /contemplation
‘Listening’ to the silence … to what’s
not being said … to what’s being
said non-verbally
52
INDIGENOUS LISTENING IS INDIGENOUS LISTENING IS CONNECTION CONNECTION →→ RELATION RELATION Indigenous cultures built on kinship Everyone’s connected - somehow Through ‘deep listening’, and appropriate
self-disclosure, you become part of that
person’s / or community’s universe Now people can deal with you – safely –
and you with them
53
CULTURAL SAFETY / EASECULTURAL SAFETY / EASE
↑ training in Koorie child/family well-
being Prioritise cultural safety Build a service that’s comfortable with
Aboriginal protocols and at home with
Aboriginal ways
54
BUILDING ENVIRONMENTS BUILDING ENVIRONMENTS FOR CHANGEFOR CHANGE
Improving Koorie well-being means Building environments for change,
cooperatively, with communities Consultation beyond lip service – that involves
full community participation in planning Ready-made / one-size-fits-all solutions fail
- flexibility offers more chance of success … have your ‘cloth’ at hand, but cut it to fit
55
REAL COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENTREAL COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Little ‘r’ respect What do I know about the people I am
working with? How can I find out more? Meeting people in their own reality builds
trust and confidence
56
KOORIE WAY - COMMITKOORIE WAY - COMMIT
Take time to build real relationships – the
‘slow road’ may be the fastest way to get
there So … get involved for the long haul Koorie people/ communities want a
partner who’s ‘clued-in’ and committed
57
BUT … ALL THIS IMPLIESBUT … ALL THIS IMPLIES
Personal challenge
To existing comfort zone Professional challenge
To models of professional distance and
non- disclosure
58
BUT … ALL THIS IMPLIESBUT … ALL THIS IMPLIES
Organizational Challenge
Mandates organisational change Political Challenge
Strong advocacy is politically risky
59
The Political The Political IsIs The Clinical The Clinical
Australian Govtl. denial of contemporary
consequences of past practices leads to: inequitable, ineffective policy under-funding of services mainstreaming of services / lack of
culturally-safe services
60
The Political The Political IsIs The Clinical The Clinical
History of inadequate govt. action
mandates new forms of proactive action Considered, sustained lobbying on behalf
of child/family need is part of duty of care
- importance of extended advocacy
61
The Political The Political IsIs The Clinical The Clinical
Extended Advocacy – be informed and bold Insist government policy founded-on
contemporary effects of loss and TGT Insist initiatives be funded according to
need, are sustainable Insist anything else is a violation of our
duty of care