+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Tourism Management Perspectives - BGUyanivbel/s/TMP2.pdffor spiritual tourism Joseph M. Cheera, ⁎,...

Tourism Management Perspectives - BGUyanivbel/s/TMP2.pdffor spiritual tourism Joseph M. Cheera, ⁎,...

Date post: 21-Aug-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
5
The search for spirituality in tourism: Toward a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism Joseph M. Cheer a, , Yaniv Belhassen b , Joanna Kujawa c a Monash University, Australia b Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel c Kaplan Business School, Australia abstract article info Available online xxxx The geo-psychological separation from the everyday that is embedded in spiritual travel practices, can be seen as a laboratory in which individuals can examine, consider and practice spirituality in a way that is not always avail- able in daily life. This feature of the tourism experience is arguably the reason for the popularity of spiritual tour- ism experiences among novices to spirituality-driven endeavours, as well as to those who wish to develop and deepen their ongoing transcendent engagement through and during travel. If spirituality is the goal, traveling seems like an ideal setting within which it can be sought and, sometimes, even found. This Special Issue has iden- tied the emergence of a binary between spiritual tourism performance as intrinsically religious and conversely, as secular practice. Considering secular motivations rstly, it is clear that underlying the many specic drivers are deliberations focused on the self with motives like wellness, adventure or recreation predominant. Conversely, religious motivations for spiritual tourism largely leverage links to religion and are centred on specic drivers that are underlined by religious observance, ritualised practice, reafrmation of identity and cultural performance. © 2017 Published by Elsevier Ltd. The white tourist who doesthe chief cities and historical sights and then steams away with disgust at the backward civilization of India is doubtless justied in his depreciation of it. Yet a wiser kind of tourist shall one day arise who will seek out, not the crumbling ruins of useless temples, nor the marbled palaces of dissipated kings long dead, but the living sages who can reveal a wisdom untaught by our universities. [Paul Brunton, In a Search for Secret India] 1. Introduction In light of broader transformations in the way people are searching for transcendence in life, travel has become an important practice in the emerging spiritual marketplace (Heelas & Woodhead, 2005). Paul Brunton, holds the mantle as one of the pioneers in the West in the quest to understand spiritualities in the East, and in embarking on his journeys, he critically explores the work of gurus, mystics and spiritual teachers among others to elucidate their wisdoms. First published in 1934, Brunton's spiritual voyage not only foresaw the emergence of spirituality as a driver for tourism, and he in many ways inspired and paved the way for readers to expand their spiritual horizons while trav- eling. Brunton exemplies what Roof (2001) denes as reexive spiri- tualitybest described as a cultural movement or a contemporary attitude toward spirituality that promotes the use of reason while ex- ploring spiritualties. This reexive and critical examination of spiritual paths is considered one of the hallmarks of the contemporary spiritual movement, and spiritual tourism is one of its manifestations (Besecke, 2014). The papers in this volume demonstrate that the geo-psycholog- ical separation from the everyday that is embedded in spiritual travel practices, can be seen as a laboratory in which individuals can examine, consider and practice spirituality, like Brunton did, in a way that is not always available in daily life. Another way to comprehend the central role that travel plays in the contemporary spiritual movement is by focusing on its key characteris- tic as a tempo-spatial interruption from daily routine. This feature of the tourism experience is arguably the reason for the popularity of spir- itual tourism experiences among novices to spirituality-driven endeav- ours, as well as to those who wish to develop and deepen their ongoing transcendent engagement through and during travel. If spirituality is the goal, traveling seems like an ideal setting within which it can be sought and, sometimes, even found. If spirituality is a practice or an at- titude of connectivity then, again, travel offers many opportunities to experience our renewed connection with others, with life in general Tourism Management Perspectives xxx (2017) xxxxxx Corresponding author. E-mail addresses: [email protected] (J.M. Cheer), [email protected] (Y. Belhassen), [email protected] (J. Kujawa). TMP-00364; No of Pages 5 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2017.07.018 2211-9736/© 2017 Published by Elsevier Ltd. Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Tourism Management Perspectives journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/tmp Please cite this article as: Cheer, J.M., et al., The search for spirituality in tourism: Toward a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism, Tourism Management Perspectives (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2017.07.018
Transcript
Page 1: Tourism Management Perspectives - BGUyanivbel/s/TMP2.pdffor spiritual tourism Joseph M. Cheera, ⁎, Yaniv Belhassenb, Joanna Kujawac a Monash University, Australia b Ben-Gurion University

Tourism Management Perspectives xxx (2017) xxx–xxx

TMP-00364; No of Pages 5

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Tourism Management Perspectives

j ourna l homepage: www.e lsev ie r .com/ locate / tmp

The search for spirituality in tourism: Toward a conceptual frameworkfor spiritual tourism

Joseph M. Cheer a,⁎, Yaniv Belhassen b, Joanna Kujawa c

a Monash University, Australiab Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israelc Kaplan Business School, Australia

⁎ Corresponding author.E-mail addresses: [email protected] (J.M. Che

(Y. Belhassen), [email protected] (J. Kujawa).

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2017.07.0182211-9736/© 2017 Published by Elsevier Ltd.

Please cite this article as: Cheer, J.M., et al., TManagement Perspectives (2017), http://dx.d

a b s t r a c t

a r t i c l e i n f o

Available online xxxx

The geo-psychological separation from the everyday that is embedded in spiritual travel practices, can be seen asa laboratory inwhich individuals can examine, consider and practice spirituality in away that is not always avail-able in daily life. This feature of the tourism experience is arguably the reason for the popularity of spiritual tour-ism experiences among novices to spirituality-driven endeavours, as well as to those who wish to develop anddeepen their ongoing transcendent engagement through and during travel. If spirituality is the goal, travelingseems like an ideal settingwithinwhich it can be sought and, sometimes, even found. This Special Issue has iden-tified the emergence of a binary between spiritual tourism performance as intrinsically religious and conversely,as secular practice. Considering secularmotivationsfirstly, it is clear that underlying themany specific drivers aredeliberations focused on the self with motives like wellness, adventure or recreation predominant. Conversely,religious motivations for spiritual tourism largely leverage links to religion and are centred on specific driversthat are underlined by religious observance, ritualised practice, reaffirmation of identity and culturalperformance.

© 2017 Published by Elsevier Ltd.

The white tourist who “does” the chief cities and historical sights andthen steams away with disgust at the backward civilization of India isdoubtless justified in his depreciation of it. Yet a wiser kind of touristshall one day arise who will seek out, not the crumbling ruins of uselesstemples, nor the marbled palaces of dissipated kings long dead, but theliving sages who can reveal a wisdom untaught by our universities.

[Paul Brunton, In a Search for Secret India]

1. Introduction

In light of broader transformations in the way people are searchingfor transcendence in life, travel has become an important practice inthe emerging spiritual marketplace (Heelas & Woodhead, 2005). PaulBrunton, holds the mantle as one of the pioneers in the West in thequest to understand spiritualities in the East, and in embarking on hisjourneys, he critically explores the work of gurus, mystics and spiritualteachers among others to elucidate their wisdoms. First published in1934, Brunton's spiritual voyage not only foresaw the emergence of

er), [email protected]

he search for spirituality in tooi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2017.07

spirituality as a driver for tourism, and he in many ways inspired andpaved theway for readers to expand their spiritual horizons while trav-eling. Brunton exemplifies what Roof (2001) defines as ‘reflexive spiri-tuality’ best described as a cultural movement or a contemporaryattitude toward spirituality that promotes the use of reason while ex-ploring spiritualties. This reflexive and critical examination of spiritualpaths is considered one of the hallmarks of the contemporary spiritualmovement, and spiritual tourism is one of its manifestations (Besecke,2014). The papers in this volume demonstrate that the geo-psycholog-ical separation from the everyday that is embedded in spiritual travelpractices, can be seen as a laboratory in which individuals can examine,consider and practice spirituality, like Brunton did, in a way that is notalways available in daily life.

Another way to comprehend the central role that travel plays in thecontemporary spiritual movement is by focusing on its key characteris-tic – as a tempo-spatial interruption from daily routine. This feature ofthe tourism experience is arguably the reason for the popularity of spir-itual tourism experiences among novices to spirituality-driven endeav-ours, as well as to those whowish to develop and deepen their ongoingtranscendent engagement through and during travel. If spirituality isthe goal, traveling seems like an ideal setting within which it can besought and, sometimes, even found. If spirituality is a practice or an at-titude of connectivity then, again, travel offers many opportunities toexperience our renewed connection with others, with life in general

urism: Toward a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism, Tourism.018

Page 2: Tourism Management Perspectives - BGUyanivbel/s/TMP2.pdffor spiritual tourism Joseph M. Cheera, ⁎, Yaniv Belhassenb, Joanna Kujawac a Monash University, Australia b Ben-Gurion University

2 J.M. Cheer et al. / Tourism Management Perspectives xxx (2017) xxx–xxx

and, most importantly, with ourselves. Either way, spiritual tourism ap-pears to engage people onmany levels that other forms of tourism onlytouch upon. As in the past, the debate about the distinction between a‘traveller’ and a ‘tourist’ has preoccupied scholars, so now the numinousyet palpable distinction between a ‘religious’ and ‘spiritual’ touristemerges.

The search formeaningful and spiritual experiences in the theorisingof the tourist experience also goes far beyond the narrowwindow of re-ligious and/or spiritual tourism. In his pioneering and celebrated theo-retical model of the tourist experience, Cohen (1979) developed atypology of five modes of experiences which he anchors around theconcept of the ‘centre’. The centre in Cohen's conceptualisation is a cos-mological metaphor for the core values around which every society isorganised. In his model, tourism practices are viewed as conduitsthrough which people can manage tensions with the centres that gov-ern their home societies; therefore, they are powerful settings formean-ing-making engagements.

In the same vein, Norman (2011, 2012), Fedele (2012), Robledo(2015) and Stausberg (2014) attempt to define the ‘notoriously diffi-cult’ relationship between ‘spirituality and religion’ (Stausberg, 2014:355). Stausberg (2014: 355) argues that spirituality is ‘semantically’ lo-cated ‘bothwithin and beyond’ religion as it has the same inward direc-tion but it also strives to distance itself from religion. This desire todistance oneself from traditional religiosity amongmodern spiritual pil-grims is apparent in the new typologies for spiritual travel, notably byNorman (2011, 2012) and Robledo (2015), as well as in the number ofethnographic studies of spiritual pilgrims themselves. Fedele (2012),for example, in referring to the growing spiritual tourism traveller,coins the term ‘new pilgrims’ – that is, spiritual tourists who visit tradi-tional shrines for reasons unlike those of traditional religious pilgrims.Others refer to this as ‘unchurching’ (Wood, 2007), as ‘discursive shifts’(Fedele, 2012; Kujawa, 2012) or ‘subjective turns’ (Heelas &Woodhead,2005) from religion to a broadly defined spirituality.

The precursor for formal recognition of spiritual tourism as a catego-ry or genre of tourismwas the inaugural and so far only United NationsWorld Tourism Organisation (UNWTO) summit on the topic at NinhBinh City, Vietnam inNovember 2013. The conferencewas titled Spiritu-al Tourism for Sustainable Development outlining a specific focus on thecontributions that it canmake to the sustainable development of its var-ious communities including both hosts and guests. This all-encompassing approach moved beyond secular or religious demarca-tions emphasising that “the cultural exchange and dialogue evoked byspiritual tourism are the very cornerstones of mutual understanding,tolerance and respect, the fundamental building blocks of sustainabili-ty” (UNWTO, 2013: 2). TheUNWTO's utilitarian stance on spiritual tour-ism is unsurprising given the acknowledged potential that tourism ingeneral is seen to have, especially in countries of the Global South. Theunambiguous view put forward is that “the responsible and sustainableuse of natural and cultural assets in the development of spiritual tour-ism can create employment opportunities, generate income, alleviatepoverty, curb rural flight migration, prompt product diversification,and nurture a sense of pride among communities and destinations”(UNWTO, 2013: 2).

Our own journey in creating this volume was sparked by a sympo-sium on spiritual tourism in November 2015, initiated and organisedby Joseph Cheer at Monash University located in Melbourne Australia.This was conducted in conjunction with practitioners, World Weavers,an Australia-based organisation offering so called ‘Adventures of theSpirit’ including the unprecedented Monk for a Month experience – a24 day spiritual adventure at a traditional Tibetan Buddhist monasteryin India's Spiti Valley. The debates and ideas expounded on anddiscussed incited our curiosity, and we conceived of creating a SpecialIssue on this subject matter for Tourism Management Perspectives. Weare thankful to Chris Ryan for his trust and cooperation in enablingthis venture. As is often the case with academic initiatives that involvemultiple contributors across the globe, the final result is not necessarily

Please cite this article as: Cheer, J.M., et al., The search for spirituality in toManagement Perspectives (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2017.07

whatwe had envisaged at the beginning, andwe have ended upwith aneclectic and geographically diverse outcome that illuminates the multi-faceted manifestations and iterations of spirituality and tourism in con-temporary society.

2. Epistemic reflections on the special issue

Editing this Special Issues was a journey that started immediatelyafter the symposium on spiritual tourism held at Monash. In order toshare with our readers the essence of this process we have chosen toopen this special issue with a dialogue between Ben Bowler, CEO ofWorld Weavers and Yaniv Belhassen, a keynote speaker at the originalsymposium. The dialogue is entitled “A Conversation about Spiritualityand Tourism: Theory and Practice in Dialogue.” It provides an unusual ac-ademic stage to discuss theoretical and practical issues related to thespiritual tourism phenomenon. The non-mediated dialogue demon-strates the applicability and relevancy of Roof's reflexive spirituality(2001) among spiritual tourism entrepreneurs, andwe believe it exem-plifies an authentic and representative voice of this growing market.

Joanna Kujawa's work, “Spiritual Travel as a Quest,” provides an anal-ysis of the spiritual travel memoir genre, ranging from her own spiritualtourist experiences in Jerusalem and analogous to Paul Brunton's searchfor spiritual enlightenment in India and to what can be regarded as thenew-age spirituality of Elizabeth Gilbert's (2009) Eat, Pray, Love. Thispaper leverages Kujawa's longstanding interest in spirituality and her2012 best-selling book Jerusalem Diary: Searching for the Tomb andHouse of Jesus. In this book, Kujawa articulates a true story of a journeyin search of Jesus' house in Nazareth and his tomb in Jerusalem – spiri-tual tourism personified. Kujawa argues that spiritual travel memoirs aswell as recent ethnographic studies point to a significant discursive shiftfrom religiosity to spirituality and the demarcation between spiritualexperiences versus religious experiences, and spiritual tourism versusreligious tourism. This decisive delineation between ‘spiritual’ and ‘reli-gious’, Kujawa argues, opens a new door for both the conceptualisationand management of spiritual tourism.

In the next contribution, “Spiritual TourismatMeditation Retreats: Re-flexive and Reflective Well-Being Interventions,” Alex Norman andJennifer Pokornyoutline awider perspective on Buddhistmeditation re-treat practices in theWest. They highlight the social dimensions ofwell-being that characterise the Buddhist retreat segment often localised incommunity or permanent centres in the West. The contribution of thepaper to spiritual tourism lies in pointing out the new motivationalthemes in thefield, such as a growing interest among ‘WesternBuddhisttraditions’ in meditation retreats for the purpose of personal well-beingas a part of a larger wellness revolution in theWest. Notably, Norman isone of the pioneers in the development of spiritual tourism in the aca-demic community with his 2011 book Spiritual Tourism: Travel and Reli-gious Practice in Western Society having paved the way for this SpecialIssue.

HanaBowers and Joseph Cheer take a similar approach in the follow-ing paper: “Yoga Tourism: Commodification andWestern Embracement ofEastern Spiritual Practice.” Bowers and Cheer provide an inductive anal-ysis of Yoga retreats in India, while emphasising how body and spirit in-teract in the tourist motivation. In many ways, yoga offers is itsfollowers a gateway to spiritual practice. Indeed Bowers and Cheerargue that the practice of yoga has become largely alien from its genesissteeped in spirituality andmeditation, and in a contemporary sense hasbecome highly fashionable. Just as Norman and Pokorny looked at thegrowing interest in meditation retreats among Western Buddhists,Bowers and Cheer's focus was on spiritual tourism to India –more spe-cifically yoga-related travel by Western practitioners. However, unlikeNorman and Pokorny, Bowers and Cheers differentiate yoga tourismfromwellness tourism, and focus on the commodification of the originalyoga philosophy to accommodate Western practitioners and con-sumers. Bowers and Cheer assert that in the process of yoga's commod-ification, the original gatekeepers or custodians of yoga in the Indian

urism: Toward a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism, Tourism.018

Page 3: Tourism Management Perspectives - BGUyanivbel/s/TMP2.pdffor spiritual tourism Joseph M. Cheera, ⁎, Yaniv Belhassenb, Joanna Kujawac a Monash University, Australia b Ben-Gurion University

3J.M. Cheer et al. / Tourism Management Perspectives xxx (2017) xxx–xxx

subcontinent have appeared to have lost all sense of ownership of it.Thus, the links between spiritual tourism and the commodification ofspiritual practice is discernible in Bowers and Cheer's offering.

Darius Liutikas' “TheManifestation of Values and Identity in Travelling:The Social Engagement of Pilgrimage” analyses how spiritual tourism al-lows for themanifestation of tourists' values and creates a sense of iden-tity, both individual and social (what he terms ‘valuistic aspects ofspiritual tourism’). Liutikas looks into two travel diaries: one from a16th century Lithuanian nobleman Mikalojus Kristupas Radvila the Or-phan and the other from the recent pilgrimages of a Lithuanian youth toSiberia in honour of the thousands of exiled Lithuanians. In his paperLiutikas argues that, despite the different motivations and time spansfor the travel, both diaries reveal how spiritual tourism facilitates asense of identity and belonging. The key theme emerging from Liutikas'offering is that socio-cultural potential and importance of pilgrimagecan fulfil the spiritual needs of travellers or at least help to recognizethose needs.

The next two papers examine established pilgrimage trails (orroutes) by focusing on spiritual aspects in the experiences of contempo-rary tourists who walk on them. “Spiritual Tourism on The Way to St.James: Motivations and Feelings,” by Lucrezia Lopez, Rubén Gonzálezand Belén Fernández analyses the shift from religiosity to spiritualityin the famous Camino in Spain and in light of the emotional process dy-namics that characterised the tourists they interviewed. Indeed, TheWay to St James is an exemplification of the trajectory from what wassteeped in religiosity to what is now increasingly driven by non-secularmotivations. Their discussion elaborates on the longevity and the con-tinuing spiritual magnetism of ‘TheWay’. The variety of reasons spiritu-al tourists undertake the journey relates to three factors: the mobility(both physical and internal), the experiential value (authentic, uniqueand cathartic), and the inherent qualities of the tourists' route itself.Conceptually, the paper embraces the ‘polyvalent purpose of contempo-rary spirituality’which reconstructs the image and purpose of the tradi-tional tourist in a significant way.

Similarly, “Muslim perspectives on spiritual and religious travel beyondHajj: Toward understanding motivations for Umrah travel in Oman” byHamed Mohammed Almuhrzi and Abdulaziz Mohammed Alsawafi uti-lizes spirituality as a conceptual device with which they examine themotivations for Umrah travel in an Omani context. In articulating Mus-lim conceptualisations of spiritual tourism, Almuhrzi and Alsawafi drawon Umrah, the lesser known counterpart to the Hajj, both key rituals fordevout Muslims. Unlike the Hajj, Umrah is a pilgrimage that Muslimsundertake at any time of the year except during the time of Hajj.Almuhrzi and Alsawafi conclude that themain driver forMuslims to un-dertake Umrah travel is to be thankful to Allah. This paper is particularlyinsightful and timely given the contemporary global political landscapewhere adverse interpretations and reportage of Islamic faith have be-come increasingly commonplace.

In the last paper of the collection “Spiritual (Walking) Tourism as aFoundation for Sustainable Destination Management,” Kumi Kato andNicolas Progano focus on theNakahechi Kumano pilgrimage trail inWa-kayama, Japan as an example of ‘slow tourism’ and its connection to sus-tainability and engagement with local communities. The Kumano Kodois an exemplary case of an ancient pilgrimage trail that continues toarouse pilgrim interest in the pursuit of spiritual nourishment andKato and Pragono emphasise how thismode of walking leads to the cre-ation of communities of compassion. ‘Slow tourism’ is understood asthat undertaken ‘on foot’ or as walking tourism on natural trails associ-ated with spiritual qualities of serenity, natural beauty, sustainabilityand holistically understood wellness. As in other papers included inthis Special Issue, Kato and Progano separate these qualities fromother motivations associated with particular religions. The healing andcaring aspects of ‘slow tourism’ tap into the more positive aspects ofspiritual tourism, such as mindful engagement with nature, local com-munities and sustainability. Japan is also our next destination as the au-thors of this last article were kind enough to host a symposium in

Please cite this article as: Cheer, J.M., et al., The search for spirituality in toManagement Perspectives (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2017.07

Wakayama University Japan in 2017 signalling that the prospects forthe examination of Spiritual Tourism are bright.

3. Toward a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism

The development of a conceptual framework for spiritual tourismabides by the academic practice of integrating complex, multivalentand continually evolving concepts toward the development of under-pinning understandings that help guide scholarly discourse and furtherresearch. This Special Issue has identified the emergence of a binary be-tween spiritual tourism performance as intrinsically religious and con-versely, as secular practice. From a theoretical perspective thisunderlines the development of theory and guides the construction of aconceptual framework for further scrutiny of spiritual tourism.

In proposing a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism, outliningthe drivers that underline spiritual tourism practice is arguably a criticalfirst step (see Fig. 2). As evidenced in the emergent themes from papersin this Special Issue and as earlier emphasised by Norman (2011), thedemarcation between secular and religious drivers are foremost. A rea-sonable assessment is that the continuum of spiritual tourism motiva-tions presents the two drivers at distinct ends with an additionalacknowledgement that for some,motivations are predicated on both re-ligious and secular foundations. (See Fig. 1.)

Considering secular motivations firstly, it is clear that underlying themany specific drivers are deliberations focused on the self with motiveslike wellness, adventure or recreation predominant. Additionally, focustends to be on the attainment of some kind of spiritual benefit, such asgetting in touch with one's inner self or achieving an altered state ofconsciousness. Further, such opportunities are shaped by the commod-ification of spiritual tourism experiences either as a package of travelcomponents or payment for some facets (accommodation and food).In emphasising the self, secular drivers for spiritual tourism are con-sumptive by nature attributing beneficial outcomes to the traveller.

Conversely, religious motivations for spiritual tourism largely lever-age links to religion and are centred on specific drivers that areunderlined by religious observance, ritualised practice, reaffirmationof identity and cultural performance. Here, the purposes for spiritualtourism link to reverence and connectivity to a higher authority ordeity with the rewards underlined by religious practice predicated oninstitutionalised and genuine participation, with beneficial outcomesover and above the self. Indeed the focus is very much on the institu-tional or religious frameworks that govern travel for such purposes.

A conceptual framework of this type sets out to make generalisableassumptions in the full knowledge that in practice, some exceptionswill occur that fall outside or barely inside the characterisations made.Such frameworks are assumed to be evolutionary and will respond tofurther developments on the topic over time.

4. Conclusion

The papers in this volume echo previous attempts to conceptualiseshifts in the spiritual tourism market by collectively demonstratingthat the dynamic circumstances of modern life are not only a sourcefor the growing demand for spirituality, as emphasised bymany spiritu-ality scholars, but also that the realm of contemporary tourism is a cen-tral platform from which spirituality can be experienced and studied.Indeed, each one of the papers in this Special Issue illustrates that tour-ism can be viewed as a convenient setting within which one can exam-ine different forms of spirituality—whether it is the bubble-like settingthat givesmodern people the time and space to reflect on life, orwheth-er it is the safe environment to explore new formsof spiritualitywithoutthe risk of being labelled as ‘odd’. As reflected in this Special Issue, spir-itual tourism ismultivalent and comprised of diverse categories that caninclude practices, such as attendingNewAge andmusic festivals, partic-ipating in meditation and yoga retreats and in neopagan and shaman

urism: Toward a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism, Tourism.018

Page 4: Tourism Management Perspectives - BGUyanivbel/s/TMP2.pdffor spiritual tourism Joseph M. Cheera, ⁎, Yaniv Belhassenb, Joanna Kujawac a Monash University, Australia b Ben-Gurion University

Fig. 1. Spiritual tourism in motion:Monk for a Month participants.(Photo reproduced with permission from World Weavers/Ben Bowler).

4 J.M. Cheer et al. / Tourism Management Perspectives xxx (2017) xxx–xxx

ceremonies, as well as by following ancient pilgrimage trails such as theKumano Kodo in Japan or The Way of St James in Spain.

Taken as a whole, this special volume endeavours to further high-light the spiritual dimension of tourism practices around the world.The eight papers that comprise this Special Issue clearly demonstrate

Fig. 2. Conceptual framewo(Source: Authors).

Please cite this article as: Cheer, J.M., et al., The search for spirituality in toManagement Perspectives (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2017.07

the need for tourism researchers to lead the way in advancing a morenuanced understanding of the spiritual dimensions of tourism and con-comitantly the role of tourism in the spiritual movement. All of the au-thors have raised questions surrounding the blurring and demarcatingof boundaries between religiosity and spirituality in the context of

rk for spiritual tourism.

urism: Toward a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism, Tourism.018

Page 5: Tourism Management Perspectives - BGUyanivbel/s/TMP2.pdffor spiritual tourism Joseph M. Cheera, ⁎, Yaniv Belhassenb, Joanna Kujawac a Monash University, Australia b Ben-Gurion University

5J.M. Cheer et al. / Tourism Management Perspectives xxx (2017) xxx–xxx

modern tourism generally, and to spiritual tourism specifically. Wehope that this Special Issue will provide readers with the opportunityto deepen and extend their understandings of the spiritual tourism dis-course and to continue exploring the relationship between spiritualityand tourism, and to consider its implications for future research.

As a final point of our epistemic journey, it is important for us to ex-press gratitude to all the people who help us during this process. Firstly,to Chris Ryan for providing the platform for the publication of papers inthis Special Issue. We are conscious that it is always a gamble givingover responsibility to others for the delivery of a quality outcome andwe hope we have vindicated your decision. Thanks are due to the Na-tional Centre for Australian Studies (NCAS) and the Australia and Inter-national Tourism Research Unit (AITRU) at Monash University forhosting the symposium on Spiritual Tourism in November 2015 thatkick-started this Special Issue. Thanks are also due to Ben Bowler andHana Bowers at World Weavers for enabling the link between theoryand practice. DamienWilliams and Keir Reeves participated in the inau-gural symposium in 2015 and lent moral support to this endeavour.Bruce Scates and Natalie Nguyen at NCAS were also instrumental inlending institutional support via the Faculty of Arts at Monash Universi-ty. But most of all, we reserve our biggest thanks to the authors of thecollection of papers in this Special Issue. Lastly, we owe a great deal ofthanks to our family and friendswho, as is always the casewith endeav-ours of this nature, bear the brunt of our physical and mental absence.As a trio of guest editors based in different locations around the world,the development of this initiative required a great deal of patience, te-nacity, open-mindedness and most of all good humour. We now lookforward to the second symposium on Spiritual Tourism to be held atWakayama University in Japan in 2017.

Acknowledgment

As should be custom, especially befitting the spirit inherent in workof this nature in Australia, we wish to acknowledge the people of theKulin Nations, on whose land we gathered to conduct the formativestage of this research.We pay our respects to their Elders, past and pres-ent and acknowledge that this land ‘always has and always be will Ab-original land’.

References

Besecke, K. (2014). You can't put god in a box: Thoughtful spirituality in a rational age. Ox-ford University Press.

Brunton, P. (1934). A search in secret India. London: Rider.Cohen, E. (1979). A phenomenology of tourist experiences. Sociology, 13(2), 179–201.Fedele, A. (2012). Looking for Mary Magdalene: Alternative pilgrimage and ritual creativity

at Catholic shrines in France. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.Gilbert, E. (2009). Eat pray love: One woman's search for everything. Bloomsbury

Publishing.Heelas, P., & Woodhead, L. (2005). The spiritual revolution: Why religion is giving way to

spirituality. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.

Please cite this article as: Cheer, J.M., et al., The search for spirituality in toManagement Perspectives (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2017.07

Kujawa, J. (2012). Jerusalem diary: Searching for the tomb and house of Jesus. Bloomington,Indiana: Balboa Press.

Norman, A. (2011). Spiritual tourism: Travel and religious practice in western society. Lon-don, UK: Continuum.

Norman, A. (2012). The varieties of the spiritual tourist experience. Literature andAesthetics, 22(1).

Robledo, M. A. (2015). Tourism of spiritual growth as a voyage of discovery. In D.Chambers, & T. Rakić (Eds.), Tourism research frontiers: Beyond the boundaries ofknowledge. Tourism social science series, Volume 20. (pp. 71–86). Emerald.

Roof, W. C. (2001). Spiritual marketplace: Baby boomers and the remaking of American re-ligion. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press.

Stausberg, M. (2014). Religion and spirituality in tourism. In A. A. Lew, C. M. Hall, & A. M.Williams (Eds.), TheWiley Blackwell companion to tourism (pp. 349–360). New Jersey:Wiley.

UNWTO (2013). International conference: Spiritual tourism for sustainable development,Ninh Binh City, 21–2 November 2013. Madrid: UNWTO.

Wood, M. (2007). Possession, power and the new age. Belfast, UK: Ashgate.

JosephM. Cheer is based at the National Centre for AustraliaStudies (NCAS), Monash University, Melbourne Australia. Heis Senior Visiting Research Fellow at Wakayama University,Japan (2016–2017). Joseph's research draws fromhumange-ography and cultural anthropology mainly and he has pub-lished in Annals of Tourism Research, Journal of HeritageTourism, Pacific Economic Bulletin, Tourism Analysis and Tour-ism Planning and Development. He has two edited booksforthcomingwith Routledge in 2017 including Tourism Resil-ience and Sustainability: Adapting to Social, Political and Eco-nomic Change (Cheer & Lew, 2017) and Tourism Resilienceand Adaptation to Environmental Change (Lew & Cheer, 2017).

Yaniv Belhassen received his Ph.D. in 2007 from the Univer-sity of Illinois atUrbana-Champaign, in theUnited States, andthen joined the faculty at Ben-Gurion University of theNegevin Israel, where he now holds the post of Senior Lecturer. In2015–6 he spent his sabbatical leave at Monash Universityin Australia. His teaching and research interests include crit-ical analysis of tourism, epistemology, pedagogy, and socio-political aspects of tourism.

Joanna Kujawa is an Academic Head for Management Stud-ies at Kaplan Business School, Melbourne, Australia. She isthe author of a spiritual travel memoir, Jerusalem Diary:Searching for the Tomb and House of Jesus. An avid spiritualtourist herself, she pursues research related to spiritual tour-ism, spiritual travel-memoirs, spiritual experience, womentravellers andwomen and spirituality. Her previous academ-ic publications include contributions to Literature and Aes-thetics (vol. 22), Journeys and Destinations (2013) edited byAlexNorman. She is a regular contributor to the Religion Sec-tion of theAustralian Broadcasting Corporation and is inordi-nately passionate about her ‘Goddess News’ blog.

urism: Toward a conceptual framework for spiritual tourism, Tourism.018


Recommended