Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Transmission and Clean Energy in the Western US
Dave OlsenGovernors Wind Energy Coalition
November 3, 2011
Seattle • Salt Lake City • Denver • Helena • Phoenix • Sacramento • Portland • Las Vegas
Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Agenda
• Regional Cooperation– WREZ Development Zones– Renewable Energy Exports-Imports– Regional Transmission Expansion Plan– Importance for Governors
• Clean Energy Vision for the West
• System Planning and Public Consent
2
Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Western Grid Group• 200 years state regulatory experience
Former chairmen, staff of 8 western PSCs
• 50 years experience as wind, solar, geothermal, hydroelectric power developers
• Non-profit NGO; works with Governors, utilities, regulators, agencies, advocates
• Formed 2003 to develop policies to accelerate transition to sustainable electricity, win transmission access for clean resources
Connecting Clean Energy in the West4
Moves Toward Regional Cooperation
Connecting Clean Energy in the West5
Limitations on Transmission Development
• RPS-driven procurement• Projects target coastal markets
– One-way flow to West coast– CA >50% western demand; limits imports
• In-state only energy development– Every state wants economic benefits– States reluctant to import—even lower cost power– Narrow view of opportunities
Connecting Clean Energy in the West6
But: Regional Cooperation Opportunities
• Develop renewables in zones– Western Renewable Energy Zones (WREZ)
• Retire coal, use freed-up transmission for renewables
• Every state an exporter and importer• Coordinate system operation to reduce
costs, improve reliability– Optimize siting to reduce variability
Connecting Clean Energy in the West7
WREZ• WGA initiative, funded by DOE• Zone development minimizes transmission
need, economic and environmental cost• Zones of common interest to utilities • Facilitates transmission development
– Combined procurement justifies interstate tx– Basis for cost allocation decisions– Planners discount remote, lower-cost power
because transmission development uncertain
Connecting Clean Energy in the West8
WREZ areas of highest renewable resource supply potential
Connecting Clean Energy in the West9
Add: New Ways to Optimize Wind Siting• Reduce aggregate variability, integration
costs; maximize output– Northrop Grumman-MORE Power; LS Power
• Dispersed renewables help keep system balanced
• Smart from the Start environmental siting• Every state an exporter and importer• Requires new transmission infrastructure
Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Exports from All RegionsRetiring old coal creates new demand
Supports project, supply chain investments across the region
=> Regional transmission topology
Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Regional Cooperation Priorities• Energy Imbalance Market• Balancing Area coordination• Faster schedules, dispatch• Improved forecasting• WECC Regional Transmission
Expansion Plan (RTEP)• Regional markets
Connecting Clean Energy in the West12
Importance for Governors
• Regional development creates larger markets, to economic benefit of all states
• Improved reliability• Lower costs
– Shared reserves– Most efficient units run more, less efficient less– Least-cost system balancing
Connecting Clean Energy in the West13
Clean Energy Vision for the West
Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Western Grid 2050• Compare Business as Usual (BAU) and
Clean Energy Vision (CEV) trajectories
• $200 billion investment next 20 years
• Choices today determine infrastructure in 2030, 2050
• Begin west-wide discussion of goals for electric system performance
Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Clean Energy Economy Goals for Electric System Performance
• Drive job creation, economic development, competitiveness
• More secure, sustainable• More reliable• Less expensive• Reduce emissions, water use• Improve public and ecosystem health
Connecting Clean Energy in the West16
Modernizing Electric Service• More reliable
– More diverse, much more decentralized– Wind, solar higher mechanical availabilities– Modern communications, control technologies
• Less expensive– No/low fuel costs pay back investment in
clean resources, reduce system cost• More secure, lower risk, higher quality
Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Sustained, Orderly Transition• Build on Energy Efficiency, Renewables
policies now in place• Add Distributed Generation, Demand
Resources to decentralize, diversify• Schedule coal retirement years ahead
• Don’t invest in upgrading old plants• Compensate remaining book value• Incentives for utilities to diversify; use freed-up
transmission for renewables
• Regional markets and cooperation
Connecting Clean Energy in the West18
Earning Public Consent: New Principles for System
Planning
Connecting Clean Energy in the West19
Earning Public Consent• Infrastructure development contentious
– History of major planning failures by experts– Skepticism re: social need vs. private interests
• Address public concerns:– Jobs, economic development– Security; Health; Local, environmental impacts
• Key to better-planned projects, faster approvals, less litigation
• Builds broader appreciation of benefits
Connecting Clean Energy in the West20
System Planning Principles• Planning the system, not just transmission• Expands NWCC 2004 Transmission
Planning Principles• Builds on FERC Orders 890, 1000
– Stakeholder involvement produces better plans
– Planning identifies project beneficiaries, builds record cost recovery can be based on
Connecting Clean Energy in the West21
New Planning MetricsEconomics• Job creation; economic development• Protection from fuel price risk, volatility• Efficient utilization of existing grid• Comparable treatment of demand and supply resourcesLocal and Environmental Concerns• Emissions; Water Use• Protection of Wildlife, Habitat and Ecosystem Integrity• Robust Stakeholder Participation
Energy Security• System vulnerabilities, risks
– Reliance on indigenous, inexhaustible resources– Vehicle electrification
Connecting Clean Energy in the West22
Planning Principles—Next Steps
• Can public interest System Planning Principles facilitate wind project siting, transmission development?
• Are they politically feasible?
• What entities should sponsor discussions to develop and promulgate them?
Connecting Clean Energy in the West
Dave [email protected]
(805) 653-6881
Clean Energy Vision Report, MaterialsWestern Clean Energy Advocates,
Western Grid Group, at:
www.westerngrid.net
Seattle • Salt Lake City • Denver • Helena • Phoenix • Sacramento • Portland • Las Vegas