Page 1 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Treasury Department 1
st Floor Treasury Building Bridge St., Bridgetown
Indoor Air Quality Assessment Report 1.0 Introduction
REA Envirohealth International was commissioned to execute a visual inspection and
empirical environmental assessments at The Treasury Building, located at Bridge Street,
Bridgetown, Barbados.
This was required in order to determine the status of the indoor air quality within the offices
located on the Ground, First, Fourth and Fifth Floors.
In order to fulfil these mandates, site visits were made on Friday 12th, Monday 15th and
Wednesday 17th January 2018.
This report outlines the methodologies, findings and conclusions of this project, along with our
recommendations.
2.0 Methodologies
The investigation was executed via:
i. a “walkthrough inspection” of the floors of the building with emphasis on the Ground,
First, Fourth and Fifth floors;
ii. an internal inspection of the air handling units situated on the Ground, First, Fourth and
Fifth floors;
iii. the taking of photographic images as deemed necessary;
iv. electronic “spot measurements” of basic physical environmental parameters, these
being: temperature (T/°C), relative humidity (RH/%) and dew point (Dew Pt./°C), using
a calibrated AQ Expert environmental monitor;
Page 2 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
v. “spot measurements” of basic chemical parameters, specifically - carbon monoxide
(CO), carbon dioxide (CO2), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), and sulphur dioxide (SO2). These
were executed by electronic detection at parts per million (ppm) levels using a
calibrated AQ Expert environmental monitor;
vi. “spot measurements” for formaldehyde (CH2O) and total Volatile Organic Compounds
(TVOCs) recorded with an AQ Expert environmental monitor, at parts per billion (ppb)
levels;
vii. “spot measurements” for particulate matter (PM) in two size ranges, these being ≥ 0.5
microns (0.5 µm) and ≥ 2.5 microns (2.5 µm) using a calibrated Dylos DC1700 air
quality monitor;
viii. sampling for airborne mould (fungal) spores and other particulate matter, using Air-O-
Cell® spore trap cassettes fitted onto a SKC QuickTake30® sampling pump operating
at a flow rate of 15 litres per minute (15 L/min). The Air-O-Cell® cassettes were
exposed for 10 minutes in each location to collect a total volume of 150 litres of air for
both indoor and outdoor reference samples, as detailed in Table 1. The exposed
cassettes were sealed, labelled and forwarded to Northeast Laboratory Services*
(NEL) in the USA, for analysis by optical microscopy;
*Northeast Laboratory Services is accredited under the American Industrial
Hygiene Association - Laboratory Accreditation Program (AIHA-LAP), the National
Environmental Laboratory Accreditation Conference (NELAC) and the American
Association for Laboratory Accreditation (A2LA).
ix. air sampling for the presence of bacteria and fungi using a SKC Biostage® viable
sampler and a selection of sterile agar plates. The Biostage® sampler was fitted onto a
SKC QuickTake30® sampling pump calibrated for a flow rate of 28.3 litres per minute
(28.3 L/min), to allow a total volume of 283.0 L of air to impact media plates over a
period of 10 minutes. The sampling location details are presented in Table 2. The
exposed plates were sealed, labelled and forwarded to a qualified microbiologist for
viable culturing and assessment by morphology using optical microscopy. The types
of media plates used were Malt Extract Agar, DG-18, Blood agar, and MacConkey
Page 3 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
agar, and these were incubated to permit the concurrent growth of viable bacteria and
fungi;
x. air sampling of total volatile organic compounds (TVOCs) using a SKC AirChek® 5000
Pump and thermal desorption tubes as presented in Table 3. For each location, a
thermal desorption tube was fitted to an AirChek® 5000 Pump and left to sample at a
flow rate of 100 millilitres per minute (100 mL/min) for a period of ninety minutes (90
minutes) according to the sampling instructions issued by CASSEN Testing
Laboratories**. The Thermal Desorption Tubes were forwarded to CASSEN Testing
Laboratories, #51 International Boulevard Toronto, Ontario, Canada, for “Open
Characterization” assessment by Thermal Desorption/ Gas Chromatography/ Mass
Spectroscopy (TD/GC/MS); and
** CASSEN Testing Laboratories is an American Industrial Hygiene Association
(AIHA) accredited laboratory and has participated in many proficiency schemes
such as the Industrial Hygiene Proficiency Analytical Testing (IHPAT)
Program, and the Workplace Analytical Scheme Proficiency (WASP) Program
which is administered by Health and Safety Laboratory (HSL) of the United
Kingdom.
xi. air sampling for a select number of gases by Colorimetric detection using a Gastec
GV-110 pump and appropriate detector tubes. Gastec detector tubes were used to
determine the presence of the following gases: Ammonia (NH3), Chlorine (Cl),
Hydrogen sulphide (H2S) and Total Mercaptans.
Page 4 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 1: Details of Monitoring Locations for Air-O-Cell® Spore/ Particulate Trap Cassettes samples collected on 12th January 2018
Cassette
Serial No. Location
Time
Commenced
OUTDOOR REFERENCE
2542 3581 BRA Public entrance 11:25 am
2542 3567 Balcony 4th Floor 3:44 pm
2542 3551 BRA Public entrance 4:36 pm
GROUND FLOOR
2542 3550 Vault area 11:48 am
2542 3573 Cashier Area 12:07 pm
2542 3585 BRA Customer Service Area 12:28 pm
2542 3562 BRA Customer Waiting Area 12:39 pm
FIRST FLOOR
2542 3564 Foyer (waiting area) 12:50 pm
2542 3537 Internal Audit 1:05 pm
2542 3574 Accounts near Air handling unit 1:13 pm
2542 3578 Accounts Payroll 1:18 pm
FOURTH FLOOR
2542 3575 Supervising Appraiser 2:59 pm
2542 3563 Assistant Appraiser 3:02 pm
2542 3582 Valuations Service Area (front) 3:18 pm
2542 3577 Project Area Evaluation 3:16 pm
FIFTH FLOOR
2542 3553 IT - BRA 4:04 pm
2542 3555 IT - Treasury 4:11 pm
2542 3597 IT Training room 4:21 pm
2542 3531 Director’s Office 4:27 pm
Page 5 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 2: Details of Sampling Locations for Viable Assessment of Airborne Fungi and
Bacteria via Agar Plates, conducted on 15th January 2018
Sample Location Time
Commenced
OUTDOOR REFERENCE
TB-OD-GL BRA Public entrance 11:25 am
TB-OD-BL Balcony 4th Floor 12:22 pm
GROUND FLOOR
TB-G-V Vault area 1:44 pm
TB-G-CAS Cashier Area 1:46 pm
FIRST FLOOR
TB-1-CA Foyer (waiting area) 12:48 pm
TB-1-AP Accounts Payroll 1:00 pm
FOURTH FLOOR
TB-4-VF Valuations Service Area (front) 11:35 am
TB-4-VB In front of Mr. Roach’s office 11:39 am
FIFTH FLOOR
TB-5-BI IT - BRA 4:04 pm
TB-5-TI Near to the AHU in IT - Treasury 4:11 pm
N.B. Malt Extract Agar, DG-18, Blood Agar and MacConkey plates were all used at each
location
Page 6 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 3: Details of Location for Thermal Tube samples collected on 12th January 2018
Tube
Serial No. Location
Time
Commenced
Mi023957 Field Blank -
Mi038245 First Floor 10:20 am
Mi034877 Fifth Floor 10:35 am
Mi023911 Fourth Floor 12:19 pm
Mi023950 Ground Floor 1:34 pm
Page 7 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
3.0 Observations, Findings and Results
3.1 Visual Inspection & Observations
i. There were some ceiling tiles on the Ground Floor that had water stains and
mould-like growth (Photo 1).
ii. Some ceiling tiles were missing on the Ground Floor, as construction in the area
was still on-going (Photo 2).
iii. The exhaust fan in the ladies’ sanitary conveniences on the Ground Floor had a
heavy build-up of dust (Photo 3).
iv. The Vault had several boxes and paper as well as old furnishings and pieces of
wiring (Photo 4).
v. The filter on one split unit on the Ground Floor had a heavy accumulation of dust
(Photo 5).
vi. Some chairs on the First Floor had mould like growth (Photo 6).
vii. The First Floor had some tiles missing and others had water stains (Photo 7).
viii. There was a lot of water condensation on the vents on the Fourth Floor (Photo 8).
ix. The Supervising Appraiser’s office has a dry wall partition which is adjacent to the
printing room.
x. There are no return vents in the Supervising Appraiser’s office.
xi. Some of the return vents had dust build-up (Photo 9).
xii. The room housing the air handling unit on the Fifth Floor had no door (Photo 10).
xiii. On the fifth floor some ceiling tiles were missing while others had water damage.
(Photo 11).
Page 8 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 1: Water Stain and Mould like Growth Photo 2: Missing Ceiling Tiles Ground Floor
Photo 3: Exhaust Fan with Dust Build up Photo 4: Old boxes and paper in Vault
Page 9 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 5: Split-unit Filter with Dust Accumulation
Photo 6: Chairs on First Floor with Mould like Growth
Page 10 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 7: Tiles with Water Stains First Floor Photo 8: Water Condensation on Vents
Photo 9: Return Vents with Dust Build-Up
Page 11 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 10: Missing Door to AHU on Fifth Floor
Photo 11: Missing Ceiling Tiles and Water Stained Tiles on Fifth Floor
Page 12 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
3.2 Employee Feedback
i. Some employees on the Fourth Floor complained of itchy throat and runny
nose.
ii. One person in the temporary Customer Service on the Fourth Floor complained
of itchy skin.
iii. Some employees on the Fifth Floor complained of a strange smell emanating
from near the air handling unit. One employee on the Fifth Floor complained of
having experienced sore throat, chest tightness and itchy eyes.
iv. Ground Floor staff complained of runny eyes and nose and sore throat.
v. The First Floor was not completely occupied therefore not many members of
staff were available. Nonetheless, available members of staff on the First floor
along with those relocated to the Fifth Floor provided feedback concerning their
symptoms. Some of the symptoms reported included a metallic taste on the
tongue; a pungent odour in the Pensions section which resulted in some
persons experiencing dizziness, nausea and a general feeling of malaise.
3.3 Air Conditioning/Ventilation System Inspection
3.3.1 Ground Floor – Carrier™ unit
i. The Ground floor is serviced by a Carrier™ unit which is housed in a plant
room located in close proximity to “Public Entrance” to the Cashier’s
department of the Treasury Building (Photo 12).
Page 13 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 12: Location of Ground Floor air conditioning unit
ii. Electrostatic filters were installed and were found to be clean. The
insulation at the base of the unit was also found to be damp to touch
(Photo 13).
iii. The evaporator coils had a slight build-up up of dirt. The condensate run-
off was also noted to be discoloured (Photo 14).
iv. The fibreglass duct board was exposed and was noted to be discoloured in
some areas (Photo 15).
v. The blower wheel was noted to have a slight build-up of dust (Photo 16).
vi. The plant room was found to be unkempt where a number of miscellaneous
items were observed. The room was also noted to be infested with
mosquitoes (Photo 17 & 18).
Page 14 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 13: Insulation at the bottom of the unit Photo 14: Discoloured condensate was damp to touch at the base of the evaporator
Photo 15: Return vent made of fibreglass duct board Photo 16: Blower wheel had a slight Duct board was noted to be discoloured build-up of dust
Page 15 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photos 17 & 18: Stored items in the Ground Floor plant room
3.3.2 First Floor –Trane™ unit (Western side)
i. This floor was served by three units. Two of the units were located behind the “back
wall” at the northern at end of the floor in close proximity to the back exit (Photo 19).
ii. “Fresh air” was supplied to the two units via a duct which was attached to an open
window on the western side of the building. The “fresh air” intake was covered with
metal wire mesh (Photos 20 & 21).
iii. The smaller Trane™ unit located on the western side was reported to service the
western perimeter of the floor (Photo 22). This unit when opened was noted to have
an odour similar to that of the Ladies’ sanitary conveniences having a combination of
an air freshener and uric scent. According to management, the Ladies’ sanitary
conveniences area has an extraction system which vents to the parapet roof on the
eastern side of the building. It could not be determined whether the extraction system
was working at the time of the inspection.
Page 16 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
iv. Electrostatic filters were installed and these along with the blower wheel, evaporator
and insulation were found to be free of any accumulated dust (Photo 23).
v. The internal view of the unit also revealed that some portions of the inner cabinet
insulation had become detached exposing the fibreglass insulation with some
fragments at the base of the unit (Photos 24 & 25).
Photo 19: Northern end of office showing the “back wall” which conceals two air handling
units
Back wall
Page 17 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photos 20 & 21: Location of “Fresh air” intake vent for the two air handling units located at the
northern end of the First Floor
Photo 22: Smaller unit located on the western side Photo 23: Blower wheel of the small of the First Floor unit located on western side of the First Floor
Ducted "Fresh air" Intake
Mesh wire covering "Fresh air" vent
Page 18 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 24: Exposed fibreglass insulation Photo 25: Fragments of fibreglass
insulation observed at the base of the unit
3.3.3 First Floor-Carrier™ Unit (Eastern side)
i. The larger Carrier™ unit which was situated adjacent to the Trane™ unit was found to
have a few anomalous conditions. A section of the inner cabinet fibreglass insulation
was exposed and discoloured (Photo 26).
ii. Other portions of the inner cabinet insulation were intact and clean in appearance.
The blower wheel (Photo 27) and evaporator coil were also clean in appearance.
iii. A gap was observed between electrostatic filters, and insulation at the base of the unit
showing signs of deterioration (Photo 28).
iv. A number of miscellaneous items were observed behind the units (Photos 29A& 29B).
Page 19 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 26: Discoloured inner cabinet fibreglass insulation Photo 27: View of inner cabinet
and blower wheel
Photo 28: Gap observed between electrostatic filters and insulation at the base of the unit showing signs of deterioration
Page 20 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photos 29A & 29B: Miscellaneous items observed behind the air handling units located on
the First Floor
3.3.4 First Floor-Unit Close to the Pensions Section
i. A third unit was inspected on the First Floor. This unit was located close to the
Pensions section (Photo 30).
ii. Fragments of fibreglass insulation were observed on the evaporator coil (Photo 31).
iii. The components of the inner cabinet were clean in appearance such as the insulation
that was intact, the blower wheel and evaporator coil. (Photo 32)
v. A gap was observed between the electrostatic filters, and the insulation at the base of
the unit was missing (Photo 33).
iv. A number of miscellaneous items were observed in the plant room such as a table and
empty drink bottles (Photo 34). A vent was also observed in the plant room which
communicates with the front portion of the office. This appeared to be part of the
return air pathway to the air handling unit.
v. It should be noted that there was reportedly a spill of a product used to treat the floor in
close proximity to this unit which reportedly resulted in a pungent odour. According to
management, the odour lingered mainly in the front section of the office.
Page 21 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 30: View of the plant room where the air handler unit is located which services the front
section of the First floor
Photo 31: Fragments of fibreglass insulation observed Photo 32: View of the blower wheel on the evaporator coil and inner cabinet insulation
Page 22 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 33: Missing Insulation and gap between filters Photo 34: View of the Plant Room
3.3.5 Fourth Floor- Unit (Eastern Perimeter)
i. A Trane™ air handling unit was located in a plant room on the eastern perimeter of the
floor.
ii. The unit was noted to have a number of filters missing from the filter bed (Photo 35).
iii. The insulation at the base of the unit showed signs of deterioration (Photo 36). In
addition, an unlabelled bottle containing a substance was observed at the base of the
air handling unit.
iv. The evaporator was clean in appearance (Photo 37).
v. The blower wheel had noticeable dust settled on the blower wheel (Photo 38).
vi. The fibreglass insulation was slightly damaged on a panel of the air handling unit
(Photo 39).
vii. The ceiling in the plant room was observed to have a number of missing ceiling tiles
and/or the tiles were not properly seated which could allow air to communicate
between the ceiling plenum and the plant room (Photo 40).
Empty drink bottle
Return air vent
Gap between filters
Missing insulation at the base of the unit
Page 23 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
viii. “Fresh air” was supplied to this plant room via a window on the eastern perimeter
which was kept ajar (Photo 41).
ix. “Return air” was supplied to the plant room via two transfer vents located in the office
(Photo 42). These vents were noted to have accumulated dust.
x. Miscellaneous items were stored in the plant room (Photo 43).
Photo 35: View of filter bed with missing filters Photo 36: Insulation at the base of unit
showing signs of deterioration. An unlabelled bottle with a substance located at the base of the unit
Photo 37: View of the evaporator coil which had Photo 38: Blower wheel with noticeable dust clean appearance accumulated on blades
Page 24 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 39: Slightly damaged insulation on a panel of the air handler unit on the Fourth Floor
Photo 40: View of ceiling in the air handling plant room where some ceiling tiles were missing
and/or not properly seated
Page 25 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photo 41: “Fresh air” intake vent via a window Photo 42: View of the transfer return vent on the eastern perimeter of the building located on the outside of the building
Photo 43: Miscellaneous items observed in the plant room on the Fourth Floor
Page 26 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
3.3.6 Fifth Floor- Unit (Western Perimeter)
i. A Carrier™ air handling unit which services the Fifth Floor was inspected. This unit
was located at the northern end of the floor on the western perimeter.
ii. A number of filters were missing from the filter bed (Photo 44).
iii. The inner cabinet insulation was slightly detached from the top (Photo 45).
iv. The ceiling tiles in the plant room were noted to be discoloured (Photo 46).
v. The plant room was cluttered with a range of items as shown in (Photos 47 - 50).
Photo 44: Filter bed with missing filters Photo 45: Portion of the inner cabinet insulation that was detached
Photo 46: Discoloured ceiling tiles observed in the plant room located on the Fifth Floor
Page 27 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Photos 47 & 48: View of miscellaneous items stored in the plant room located on the Fifth Floor
Photos 49 & 50: View of miscellaneous items stored in the plant room located on the Fifth
Floor
Page 28 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
3.4 Spore Trap Analysis (Non-Viable)
3.4.1 Airborne Mould Spores and Fragments
i. The total airborne mould spores and fragments for the various indoor locations ranged
from 80 Ct/m3 – 9,400 Ct/m3.
ii. Aspergillus/Penicillium-like spores were the dominant spore types identified in some of
the indoor samples. These spores were most dominant in the samples collected from
the BRA Customer Service area and Cashier area on the Ground Floor; the Customer
Waiting Area on the First Floor; the Assistant Appraiser’s office on the Fourth Floor;
and the I.T Director’s Office on the Fifth Floor.
iii. Aspergillus/Penicillium-like spores were not detected in any of the outdoor samples.
iv. The majority of the spores that were detected indoors were also present in the outdoor
samples.
v. The results are summarized in Table 4. Details of the mould detected are given in
APPENDIX II (Table A2) and the actual report is presented in APPENDIX I.
Page 29 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 4: Summary of Non-viable Assessment of Airborne Mould Spores and Fragments for Samples collected on 12th January 2018
Location/Lab ID# Types of Mould/Fragments Detected
Total Count of Fungal colonies
(Ct/m3)
Outdoor reference
BRA Public Entrance (Morning Session)
Ascospores Basidiospores Cladosporium*
Curvularia Myxomycetes/Smuts
Nigrospora Unknown Spores
1,300
Balcony 4th Floor
Ascospores* Basidiospores Cladosporium
Myxomycetes/Smuts Unknown spores
400
BRA Public Entrance (Evening Session)
Ascospores Basidiospores* Cladosporium
Curvularia Mycelial Fragments Myxomycetes/Smuts
Unknown Spores
960
*Most dominant spores detected
Page 30 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 4 Cont’d: Summary of Non-viable Assessment of Airborne Mould Spores and Fragments for Samples collected on 12th January 2018
Location/Lab ID# Types of Mould/Fragments Detected
Total Count of Fungal colonies
(Ct/m3)
Ground Floor
Vault Entrance Basidiospores
Unknown Spores 190
BRA Customer Service Area
Aspergillus/Penicillium* Myxomycetes/Smuts
Unknown Spores 9,400
BRA Customer Waiting Area
Ascospores Basidiospores
Unknown Spores 190
Cashier Area
Aspergillus/Penicillium* Basidiospores Chaetomium
Unknown spores
960
First Floor
Internal Audit Aspergillus/Penicillium
Unknown Spores 130
Customer Waiting Area
Aspergillus/Penicillium* Basidiospores
Unknown Spores 3,500
Accounts Payroll Aspergillus/Penicillium
Unknown Spores 80
Area next to AHU Aspergillus/Penicillium
Unknown Spores 130
Fourth Floor
Supervising Appraiser
Curvularia Pithomyces
Unknown Spores 130
Valuations Service Area (front)
Basidiospores Unknown Spores 110
Assistant Appraiser
Aspergillus/Penicillium* Curvularia Fusarium
Unknown Spores
400
Project Area Evaluation
Basidiospores Curvularia
Unknown Spores 210
*Most dominant spores detected
Page 31 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 4 Cont’d: Summary of Non-viable Assessment of Airborne Mould Spores and Fragments for Samples collected on 12th January 2018
Location/Lab ID# Types of Mould/Fragments Detected
Total Count of Fungal colonies
(Ct/m3)
Fifth Floor
IT Director’s Office (Treasury)
Aspergillus/Penicillium* 160
IT Training Room Ascospores
Aspergillus/Penicillium Basidiospores
370
IT- BRA (Open Office)
Aspergillus/Penicillium Unknown Spores 320
IT-Treasury Basidiospores Cladosporium 130
*Most dominant spores detected
3.4.2 Airborne Particulates
i. The main airborne particulates identified by light microscopy at the indoor
locations were “Black Opaque Particles”, “Miscellaneous Fibres” and “Skin Cell
Fragments”.
ii. The concentrations of the particulates for the various locations were well within
the recommended ranges as shown in Table 5.
iii. Other typical particulates that were screened for that were not detected include
Fiberglass fibers, Insect parts, and Pollen.
iv. The results are summarised in Table 5. Guidelines in parenthesis in Table 5
have been adapted from the Air-O-Cell Method Interpretation Guide from
Environmental Analysis Associates (APPENDIX III) and the actual laboratory
report is presented in APPENDIX I.
Page 32 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 5: Summary of Microscopic Examination of particulates for samples collected on 12th January 2018
LOCATION
Type of particulate Matter (Cts/m3)
*Black Opaque Particles
(500 – 5,000)
Miscellaneous Fibres
(100 – 1,000)
Skin cell fragments
(1,000 – 10, 000)
OUTSIDE REFERENCE
BRA Public entrance 1,500 - -
Balcony 4th Floor 670 - -
BRA Public entrance 800 6,000 -
Ground Floor
Vault area 690 53 1,500
Cashier Area 430 110 5,300
BRA Customer Service Area 190 80 1,200
BRA Customer Waiting Area 240 27 130
First Floor
Customer Waiting Area 160 - 930
Internal Audit 210 53 1,100
Accounts Payroll 53 - 80
Area next to AHU 80 - 210
Page 33 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 5 Cont’d: Summary of Microscopic Examination of particulates for samples collected on 12th January 2018
LOCATION
Type of particulate Matter (Cts/m3)
*Black Opaque Particles
(500 – 5,000)
Miscellaneous Fibres
(100 – 1,000)
Skin cell fragments
(1,000 – 10, 000)
Fourth Floor
Supervising Appraiser 240 190 4,700
Assistant Appraiser 210 - 1,200
Valuations Service Area (front) 930 130 5,300
Project Area Evaluation 270 80 6,000
Fifth Floor
IT Director’s Office - - 130
IT Training Room 110 - 80
IT- BRA 210 80 4,700
IT-Treasury 320 - 1,600
N.B:
- Values in parenthesis are based on levels that are considered to be “Low” as per Environmental Analysis Associates Guidelines (Appendix III).
- Black opaque particles: This category includes combustion emissions (primarily diesel), paint and binders from degrading sound liners in HVAC systems, biogenic debris (biological origin; i.e. insect droppings, decayed biological debris, etc) and rust from HVAC drip pans, rubber tyre particles, and copier and printer toner.
Page 34 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
3.5 Viable Air Analysis (Bacteria and Fungi)
3.5.1 Bacteria
i. Three types of bacteria were detected indoors and they were also present in the three
outdoor samples. The types of bacteria detected were Bacillus subtilis,
Staphylococcus species (coagulase negative) and Micrococcus sp.
ii. The concentrations of bacteria indoors fell within a similar range as the outdoor
concentrations. However, while Bacillus subtilis was the most dominant bacterium in
the outdoor samples. Staphylococcus (Coagulase negative) bacteria were more
prevalent indoors. Staphylococcus (Coagulase negative) is a bacterium that forms
part of the human flora. Therefore this bacterium would normally be present in
occupied spaces.
iii. The results are summarised in Table 6. Details of the various organisms found are
given in APPENDIX II (Table A2) and the actual laboratory report is presented in
APPENDIX IV.
Page 35 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 6: Summary of Viable Assessment of Bacteria for Samples collected on
15th January 2018
Location Types of Bacteria
detected
Total Concentration of
Bacterial Colony Forming
Units per Cubic Meter of air
(cfu/m3)
Outdoor Reference
BRA Public entrance Bacillus subtilis
Staphylococcus sp. Micrococcus sp.
93
Fourth Floor Balcony
Bacillus subtilis Staphylococcus sp.
Micrococcus sp. 50
Streptomyces 2
Ground Floor
Vault area
Bacillus subtilis Staphylococcus sp.
Micrococcus sp. 18
Cashiers Staphylococcus sp.
Micrococcus sp. 43
First Floor
Customer Waiting Area Bacillus subtilis
Staphylococcus sp. Micrococcus sp.
22
Accounts Payroll Bacillus subtilis
Staphylococcus sp. Micrococcus sp.
43
Page 36 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 6 Cont’d: Summary of Viable Assessment of Bacteria for Samples collected on
15th January 2018
Location Types of Bacteria
Detected
Total Concentration of
Bacterial Colony Forming
Units per Cubic Meter of Air
(cfu/m3)
Fourth Floor
Valuations Front Bacillus subtilis
Staphylococcus sp. Micrococcus sp.
86
Valuations back Bacillus subtilis
Staphylococcus sp. Micrococcus sp.
18
Fifth Floor
IT- Treasury Bacillus subtilis
Staphylococcus sp. Micrococcus sp.
115
IT- BRA Bacillus subtilis
Staphylococcus sp. Micrococcus sp.
61
3.5.2 Fungi
i. Seven genera of fungi were detected in the indoor samples and six of these were also
present in the outdoor samples. The types of fungi detected were Acremonium,
Aspergillus, Cladosporium, Fusarium, Gliocladium, Penicillium and Neurospora.
ii. Cladosporium and Penicillium species were the most dominant spores detected in this
assessment. Both types of fungi are known to thrive well under moist conditions.
iii. The results are summarized in Table 7. Details of the mould detected are given in
APPENDIX II (Table A2) and the actual report is presented in APPENDIX IV.
Page 37 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 7: Summary of Viable Assessment of Fungi for Samples collected on 15th January 2018
Location Types of Fungi Detected
Total Concentration of Fungal Colony Forming
Units per Cubic Meter of Air (cfu/m3)
Outdoor Reference
BRA Public Entrance
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus niger Aspergillus flavus
Cladosporium cladosporiodes Penicillium sp.* Gliocladium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum
119
Balcony Fourth Floor
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus niger Aspergillus flavus
Aspergillus nidulans Cladosporium
cladosporiodes* Penicillium sp. Gliocladium sp. Fusarium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum
117
Ground Floor
Vault area
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus niger
Aspergillus terreus Cladosporium cladosporiodes
Gliocladium sp Fusarium sp.
Penicillium sp.* Penicillium chrysogenum
Neurospora sp.
>38
Cashiers
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus niger Aspergillus flavus
Cladosporium cladosporiodes* Gliocladium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum
71
Page 38 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 7 Cont’d: Summary of Viable Assessment of Fungi for Samples collected on 15th January 2018
Location Types of Fungi Detected
Total Concentration of Fungal Colony Forming
Units per Cubic Meter of Air (cfu/m3)
First Floor
Customer Waiting Area
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus niger
Cladosporium cladosporiodes Penicillium sp.* Gliocladium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum
47
Accounts Payroll
Acremonium sp. Cladosporium cladosporiodes
Penicillium sp. Gliocladium sp. Fusarium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum Neurospora crassa
>66
Fourth Floor
Valuations
(Front section)
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus nidulans Aspergillus terreus
Cladosporium cladosporiodes* Penicillium sp. Gliocladium sp. Fusarium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum Neurospora crassa
>107
Valuations
(Back)
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus niger
Cladosporium cladosporiodes* Penicillium sp. Fusarium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum Neurospora sp.
>78
*Most dominant spores detected
Page 39 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 7 Cont’d: Summary of Viable Assessment of Fungi for Samples collected on 15th January 2018
Location Types of Fungi Detected
Total Concentration of Fungal Colony Forming Units per Cubic
Meter of Air (cfu/m3)
Fifth Floor
IT- Treasury
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus niger
Aspergillus nidulans Penicillium sp.* Gliocladium sp. Fusarium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum Neurospora crassa
>78
IT- BRA
Acremonium sp. Aspergillus sp.
Aspergillus flavus Cladosporium cladosporiodes
Penicillium sp.* Gliocladium sp. Fusarium sp.
Penicillium chrysogenum
92
*Most dominant spores detected
3.6 Air Quality Assessment of Physical & Gaseous Parameters
The results of the spot assessments conducted on Friday 12th and Monday 15th January 2018,
outdoors as well as various locations indoors, are summarised below in Tables 8 - 11. Values
in excess of the recommended guidelines are highlighted in red and are further discussed in
Section 4.
3.6.1 Physical Parameters
a. The temperature measurements ranged from: 23.2 – 26.2 °C for the Ground floor; 22.8
– 24.4 °C for the First Floor; 23.3 – 26.2 °C for the Fourth Floor; and 22.4 – 25.9 °C for
Fifth floor. It should be noted that at the time of the assessment the First floor was
partially occupied.
Page 40 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
b. Relative humidity measurements ranged from: 68.8 – 80.5% for the Ground Floor; 68.1
– 78.4% for the First Floor, 57.4 – 73.7% for the Fourth Floor; and 62.7 – 71.1% for the
Fifth Floor.
c. Dew point temperature recorded on the days of monitoring ranged from: 17.1 – 21.4
°C for the Ground Floor; 17.8 – 18.8 °C for the First Floor; 15.8 – 19.1 °C for the
Fourth Floor; and 16. 4 – 18.6 °C for the Fifth floor.
3.6.2 Gaseous Parameters
These parameters were collected on non-consecutive days. The ranges given are inclusive of
the measurements collected on both days.
The carbon dioxide measurements recorded were between: 408 and 533 parts per million
(ppm) for the Ground Floor; 487 and 579 ppm for the First Floor; 428 and 588 ppm for the
Fourth Floor; and 584 – 769 ppm for the Fifth Floor.
a. The carbon monoxide levels ranged from 0 – 0.8 ppm for both the Ground and first
floor and ranged from 0 – 1.5 ppm, and 0 – 0.4 ppm for the fourth and fifth floors
respectively.
b. Nitrogen dioxide (NO2) was recorded at levels ranging from: 0 – 0.1ppm on all the
floors assessed.
c. The sulphur dioxide (SO2) levels ranged from: 0 – 2 ppm for the Ground Floor; 0.3 – 2
ppm for the First Floor; 0.2 – 1.9 ppm for the Fourth Floor and 0.2 – 1.7 ppm for the
Fifth floor.
d. Formaldehyde (CH2O) was detected indoors at levels ranging from: 0 – 57 parts per
billion (ppb) for the Ground Floor; 0 – 29 ppb for the First Floor; 0 – 94 ppb for the
Fourth Floor and 0 – 97 ppb for the Fifth Floor.
e. The levels of total volatile organic compounds (TVOCs) ranged from: 246 – 1183 ppb
for the Ground Floor; 290 – 852 ppb for the First Floor; 171 – 569 ppb for the Fourth
Floor; and 185 – 443 ppb for the Fifth Floor.
Page 41 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 8: Summary of Results of Air Screening conducted on 12th January 2018
Location PARAMETERS
Time Temperature
(°C) Relative Humidity
(%) Dew Point
(°C)
Ground Floor
Vault Area 11:48 am 24.2 73.3 19.0
Cashier Area 12:07 pm 23.2 68.8 17.1
BRA- Customer Service 12:28 pm 23.2 69.9 17.3
BRA- Customer Waiting area 12:39 pm 25.3 75.4 20.5
First Floor
Foyer (Waiting Area) 12:50 pm 22.8 78.4 18.8
Internal Audit 1:05 pm 24.4 71.0 18.8
Accounts (near AHU) 1:13 pm 23.0 74.6 18.2
Accounts Payroll 1:18 pm 23.3 75.5 18.7
Fourth Floor
Supervising Appraiser 2:59 pm 26.2 57.4 17.1
Assistant Appraiser 3:08 pm 24.5 66.5 17.7
Valuations (Customer Area) 3.18 pm 24.1 68.6 18.0
Project Valuations 3:25 pm 24.0 73.7 19.1
Fifth Floor
IT- BRA 4:04 pm 25.9 62.7 18.2
IT-Treasury 4:11 pm 23.5 71.0 17.9
OUTDOOR REFERENCE
BRA Public Entrance 11:25 am 28.3 70.5
22.4
Fourth Floor Balcony 3:44 pm 26.5 72.7 21.4
BRA Public entrance 4:36 pm 27.6 73.2 22.2
Page 42 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 9: Summary of Results of Air Screening for Thermal Comfort Parameters conducted on 15th January 2018
Location
PARAMETERS
Time Temperature
(°C)
Relative Humidity
(%)
Dew Point (°C)
Ground Floor
Vault Area 1:42 pm 24.8 80.5 21.2
Cashier Area 2:03pm 23.4 74.8 18.7
BRA- Customer Service 2:10pm 25.7 75.8 21.1
BRA- Customer Waiting
area 2:20pm 26.2 75.5
21.4
First Floor
Foyer (waiting area) 12:55 pm
23.2 72.3 17.9
Internal audit 1:03 pm 24.3 68.1 18.0
Accounts near AHU 1:12 pm 23.9 70.8 18.3
Accounts Payroll 1:16 pm 23.5 71.1 17.8
Fourth Floor
Supervising Appraiser 12:03 pm
23.3 62.9 15.8
Assistant Appraiser 12:16 pm
23.4 69.7 17.6
Valuations customer area 12:10 pm
23.4 67.9 17.3
Project Area Valuations 12:22 pm
23.9 69.7 18.0
Fifth Floor
IT- BRA 11:30 am
24.2 71.1 18.6
IT-Treasury 11:16 am
23.5 70.9 18.0
IT- Training room 11:20 am
22.4 68.9 16.4
Director’s Office 11:11 am
23.5 67.2 17.0
OUTDOOR REFERENCE
BRA Public Entrance 11:25
am 26.8 67.0
20.2
N.B. ppm = parts per million ppb = parts per billion
Page 43 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 10: Results of Air Screening for Gaseous contaminants conducted on 12th
January 2018
Location
Parameters
Time CO2
(ppm) CO
(ppm) NO2
(ppm) SO2
(ppm) FMH (ppb)
TVOCs (ppb)
Ground Floor
Vault area 11:48 am 490 0 0 0 0 463
Cashiers 12:07 pm 533 0 0 0.5 0 246
BRA customer service
12:28 pm 488 0 0 0.9 0 442
BRA- Waiting area 12:39 pm 503 0 0.1 1.6 0 1183
First Floor
Foyer (waiting area)
12:50 pm 487 0 0.1 1.5 0 735
Internal Audit 1:05 pm 486 0 0 0.6 0 852
Accounts near AHU
1:13 pm 475 0 0 0.6 0 644
Accounts Payroll 1:16 pm 465 0 0 0.3 0 742
Fourth Floor
Supervising appraiser
2:59 pm 588 0 0.1 1.2 0 202
Assistant appraiser 3:08 pm 526 0 0 0.8 0 357
Valuations service area
3:18 pm 516 0 0.1 0.2 0 322
Project Evaluation area
3:25 pm 488 0 0 1.1 0 569
Fifth Floor
IT- BRA 4:04 pm 769 0 0 1.2 41 381
IT- Treasury 4:11 pm 638 0 0 0.2 41 284
Training room 4:21 pm 584 0 0 1.7 0 365
Director’s office 4:27 pm 624 0 0.1 2 0 192
OUTDOOR REFERENCE
BRA- Public entrance
11:25 am 430 0 0 0 74 1439
Fourth floor 3:44 pm 441 0 0 0.4 5 1141
BRA-Public entrance
4:36 pm 450 0.2 0 0 107 1074
Notes: ppm is parts per million; ppb is parts per billion
Page 44 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 11: Summary of Results of Air Screening for Gaseous Contaminants conducted on 15th January 2018
Location Parameters
Time CO2
(ppm) CO
(ppm) NO2
(ppm) SO2
(ppm) FMH (ppb)
TVOCs (ppb)
Ground Floor
Vault area 1:42 pm
425 0.8 0 0.9 57 1006
Cashiers 2:03 pm
497 0.8 0.1 2 0 427
BRA customer service
2:10 pm
421 0.3 0 1.0 0 779
BRA- Waiting area
2:20 pm
408 0 0 1.6 0 802
First Floor
Foyer (waiting area)
12:55 pm
573 0.8 0 0.9 29 366
Internal Audit 1:03 pm
557 0.2 0.1 2.0 0 325
Accounts near AHU
1:12 pm
561 0.4 0.1 2.0 0 334
Accounts Payroll 1:16 pm
579 0.4 0 0.7 0 290
Fourth Floor
Supervising appraiser
11:40 am
505 1.5 0 0.2 194 208
Assistant appraiser
11:55 am
467 0 0 0.2 0 225
Valuations service area
11:43 am
510 0 0.1 1.9 0 171
Project Evaluation area
12:00 pm
428 0 0 1.1 0 252
Fifth Floor
IT- BRA 11:30
am 615 0 0 0.5 0 443
IT- Treasury 11:16
am 634 0 0.1 1.0 0 309
Training room 11:20
am 616 0.4 0.1 0.7 97 202
Director’s office 11:11
am 609 0 0 1.0 20 185
Outdoor Reference
BRA- Public entrance
11:25 am
430 0 0 0 74 1439
Fourth floor 3:44 pm 441 0 0 0.4 5 1141
BRA-Public entrance
4:36 pm 450 0.2 0 0 107 1074
Notes: ppm is parts per million; ppb is parts per billion
Page 45 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
3.7 Open Characterisation of Total Volatile Organic Compounds (TVOC)
i. Open characterization of VOCs was undertaken in one location on each of the floors in
question (Ground, 1st, 4th and 5th).
ii. The concentration of TVOCs recovered from the samples ranged between 60 and 390
µg/m3 as summarized in Table 12.
iii. A full listing of the top 35 compounds for each sample is presented in the laboratory
report in APPENDIX V.
iv. With regards to the sample collected from the Ground Floor at the entrance to the
Vault, the compounds detected were largely related to emissions or off-gassing of
solvents found in paints and various coatings on furniture and building materials;
degradation products from old paper and other cellulose-based products; as well as
emissions from the metabolites of microbial organisms which may be attached to items
in the room such as furniture and paper. The microbial VOCs identified were 2-
Heptanone, 2-methyl, 2- Propanol and 2-Hexanone. These compounds were found in
low concentrations.
v. The sample collected from the First Floor also had a wide range of compounds that
are associated with floor polishes and scented products. These compounds most
likely originated from cleaning and personal care products. Also present were
compounds classified as volatile fatty acids (VFAs) that are very odourous and could
have been the likely cause of the odour that was similar to vinegar. Vinegar is often
used to clean and/or to neutralize some organic odours. VFAs are typically found in
products such as flooring materials, polishes, waxes and some cosmetics. The uric
odour detected in the back section of the office was likely from the ladies’ sanitary
conveniences which could be a combination of sewer odours, cleaning products and
air fresheners. Microbial VOCs were also identified in trace quantities in the sample
collected from this location indicating that there was active microbial growth albeit in
low concentrations.
vi. The TVOC profiles for the Fourth and Fifth Floors were similar. The majority of the
products are associated with personal care and cleaning products.
Page 46 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
vii. Aldehydes a class of VOCs were prevalent in the samples collected on the four floors
possibly derived from the “Malodour Destroyer”/ “Air Freshener” product with the
product name “Eternity”. Aldehydes could also originate from other sources such as
vehicle emissions, adhesive products, pressed wood products and degradation of solid
biological wastes.
viii. The overall TVOC matrix for Fourth and Fifth Floors were lower in concentration than
those of the Ground and First Floor.
Table 12: Summary of Results of Open Characterization of Total Volatile Organic
Compounds (TVOCs)
Sample Location/ Sample ID#
Total Concentration (µg/m3)
Top three Compounds per location
Ground Floor
Vault
(Mi023950)
390 µg/m3
1. Tetrahydrofuran
2. 4-tert-Butylcyclohexyl
acetate
3. 2-Butanone (Methyl
Ethyl Ketone)
First Floor
Customer Area/Pensions
(Mi038245) 270 µg/m3
1. decamethyl-
Cyclopentasiloxane
2. Ethanol
3. 2-Butoxyethanol
Fourth Floor
Valuations
(Mi023911) 60 µg/m3
1. decamethyl-
Cyclopentasiloxane
2. Benzoic acid
3. Ethanol
Fifth Floor
I.T. Treasury
(Mi034877) 160 µg/m3
1. decamethyl-
Cyclopentasiloxane
2. Ethanol
3. Benzoic acid
Page 47 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
3.8 Air sampling for Cl, H2S, NH3 and Total Mercaptans Air screening was conducted for the presence of inorganic gaseous contaminants that could
be present in cleaning products such as chlorine and ammonia, or that could have originated
from escaped sewer gases such as hydrogen sulphide and other odourous sulphur containing
compounds such as total mercaptans. However, none of these gases were present at or
above the detection limit of the instruments used.
3.9 Air Quality monitoring of Particulate Matter
i. Measurements of particulate matter at or above the small threshold of 0.5 microns
(µm), and large particulate threshold of 2.5 microns (µm) and above are presented in
Table 13.
ii. The measurements for small particles are used in conjunction with guideline ranges
which gauge how clean the air is (Table 14). However, the data does not indicate
which concentration is healthy or unhealthy.
iii. On the days of monitoring, the small particles (≥0.5 µm) ranged from 682 – 3209 for
the Ground Floor; 350 – 1046 for the First Floor, 553 – 2177 for the Fourth Floor and
416 - 2023 for the Fifth Floor.
iv. Based on the guidelines seen in Table 14, these results indicate that the dust levels
for the indoor locations varied between “fair” to “poor”.
Page 48 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 13: Air Quality Monitoring of Particulate Matter on 12th & 15th January 2018
Locations Particles)
≥0.5 microns ≥2.5 microns
12th January
2018 15th January
2018 12th January
2018 15th January
2018
Ground Floor
Vault area 758 1588 133 199
Cashier area 682 2271 91 329
BRA Customer Service Area 710 3209 140 483
BRA Customer Waiting area 1106 3157 189 423
First Floor
Foyer (waiting area) 350 745 45 94
Internal Audit 367 689 45 75
Accounts near AHU 577 1046 91 140
Accounts payroll 455 917 59 98
Fourth Floor
Supervising Appraiser 553 1533 31 161
Assistant Appraiser 959 2089 108 304
Valuations service area 955 2086 105 301
Project Area Evaluation 1071 2177 171 336
Fifth Floor
IT- BRA 669 2023 66 259
IT- Treasury 784 1908 83 276
Training room 745 1925 155 238
Director’s office 416 1589 17 168
OUTDOOR REFERENCE
BRA Public Entrance 1718 3215 224 378
Table 14: Air Quality Chart 0.5 microns – Small Count Reading
Measurement Range Status
3,000 + VERY POOR
1.050 - 3000 POOR
300 - 1,050 FAIR
150 - 300 GOOD
75 - 150 VERY GOOD
0 - 75 EXCELLENT
Page 49 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
3.10 Safety Data Sheet Review
i. Information concerning the cleaning products used in the building has been
summarized in Table 15. The information presented highlights the active ingredients
and hazardous decomposition products which could remain in the environment during
application of the products and/or following cleaning activity. Several methods were
used to screen for the presence of a range of gaseous contaminants consistent with
those found in the products utilized as outlined in Table 15. Regarding the
decomposition products from the various cleaning products, they consisted of carbon
oxides, aldehydes, sulphur compounds, acrylates and amines.
ii. It should be noted that cleaning of the office, sanitary conveniences and treatment of
the floors would have taken place prior to the assessment. However, some
decomposition products could have lingered considering that some sections of the
building were found to be odourous. In many instances the building occupants would
have reported that some of the odours were characteristic of cleaning products.
iii. It is unlikely that oxides of carbon such as carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide would
have remained in the environment. These compounds are known to be odourless and
when measured in this assessment were present at concentrations that fell within an
acceptable range.
iv. Odourous compounds tend to linger in the environment longer based on their adhesion
to surfaces and/or slow off-gassing from various sources such as building materials
and furnishings. Inadequate ventilation could also be a contributing factor.
v. Two of the products’ active ingredients consisted of glycol ethers (Eternity™- Air
Freshener and Brite Eyes™ - Floor polish) and these compounds were detected in the
TVOC scan. The decomposition products for these two chemicals were carbon oxides
and aldehydes. Several aldehyde compounds were detected on the four floors.
vi. Hydrochloric acid was listed as the active ingredient in two products (Hombre™ and
Wrangler™). Testing for chlorine gas was undertaken but it was not detected.
vii. Regarding sulphur compounds, these compounds were not reported in the laboratory
test results. In addition, neither hydrogen sulphide nor total mercaptans were
detected by direct reading instruments.
viii. Acrylates, a class of VOCs were not reported.
ix. Air screening was not undertaken for amines.
Page 50 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Table 15: Summary of Information contained in the Safety Data Sheets provided by the Manufacturer/Distributor
Product Name Chemical Name (Active Ingredient)
Purpose of Product (Listed as “Chemical Family” in Safety Data Sheet)
Hazardous Decomposition Product (HDP)
ETERNITY Air Freshener & Malodor Destroyer Concentrate Liquid
Polyethylene Mono (Nonylphenyl)Ether Glycols
Odor Control Agent
Carbon Oxides (e.g Carbon monoxide and Carbon dioxide)
Aldehydes
HOMBRE High Acid Emulsion Bowl Cleaner
Hydrochloric Acid Bowl Cleaner None Listed
WRANGLER Disinfectant Bowl & Porcelain Cleaner
Hydrochloric Acid Disinfectant Cleaner
None Listed
Sha-zyme Grease Attacking/Anti-slip Deodorizing Bio-Cleaner
None Listed Enzyme Cleaner Carbon Oxides (e.g Carbon monoxide and Carbon dioxide)
Sulphur compounds
BRITE EYES Wet Look Premium Grade Floor Finish
Diethylene Glycol Monomethyl Ether
Water Based Floor Dressing
Carbon oxides (e.g Carbon monoxide and Carbon dioxide)
Acrylates
Bare Bones No-Rinse No-Scrub Liquefying Stripper
2-Amino Ethanol 2-Butoxyethanol
Blended Alkaline Detergent
Carbon Oxides (e.g Carbon monoxide and Carbon dioxide)
Amines
Page 51 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
4.0 Discussion
Notwithstanding any requirements of the Safety and Health at Work Act 2005 (SHaW Act)
no legally binding Exposure Limits, Environmental Standards or Regulations have to
date been enacted by the Government of Barbados in respect of allowable workplace
exposures for physical and/or chemical parameters. Thus in the absence of specific local
statutory requirements and local guidelines, ‘international standards’ will be referenced for
the purposes of this investigation. It should therefore be noted that the standards and
guidelines cited in this document are not enforceable in Barbados. Thus monitoring was
not undertaken for purposes of verifying compliance with the guidelines cited, but rather to
identify and measure background levels of the selected contaminants if present; and to
determine whether potentially toxic or “unhealthy” levels existed in the workplace
environment. To this end, area monitoring and not personal monitoring was undertaken.
Personal monitoring is used primarily in industrial settings for compliance with published
standards/guidelines.
Published standards/guidelines referenced below were established primarily for industrial
settings where persons are exposed to known contaminants. These guidelines are not
directly applicable to non-industrial settings in every instance but are referenced as a
benchmark only since they are based on health factors that can affect people regardless
of their activities or geographical location. Health Canada (1995) makes reference to
ASHRAE Standard 62.1 1989 which recommends that for non-industrial settings 1/10th of
the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienist (ACGIH) threshold limit
value (TLV) should be used as a guide where comfort limits do not exist.
The measurements in this assessment reflect conditions at the time of testing. The data
recorded can therefore serve as baseline measurements if supplemented with further
testing.
4.1 Thermal Comfort Parameters: Temperature and Relative Humidity and Dew point
Most of the indoor temperature measurements recorded at the various locations fell within
the range suggested by ASHRAE Standard 55-2004 “Thermal Environmental Conditions
for Human Occupancy” which recommends that under summer conditions where the
relative humidity is 60%, temperatures should be maintained within the range of 20.0 °C
(68 °F) to 24.4 °C (76 °F). Slight deviations from the upper temperature limit were
Page 52 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
observed in several areas specifically the Vault Room 24.8 °C, BRA (Customer Service)
25.7 °C and BRA Customer Waiting Area 26.2 °C.
Apart from providing an acceptable thermal environment for humans to work in,
temperature once controlled within the recommended range may also reduce the risk of
evaporation/emission of any volatile substances present in the office.
As it relates to the relative humidity levels, ASHRAE Standard 55-2004 recommends that
during the summer months the relative humidity should be maintained between 30 % and
60 % in order to reduce thermal discomfort, microbial growth, condensation and water
damage in high humidity. Relative humidity levels exceeded the upper recommended limit
of 60% 29 out of 30 times which represents measurements for all of the floors tested. This
finding indicates that the air conditioning/ventilation was not capable of dehumidifying the
air adequately and/or that untreated/unconditioned air was impacting the building.
Dew point temperatures were deemed satisfactory since they did not closely approach
indoor ambient temperatures at any time during the assessment. Dew point is the
temperature at which dew (water droplets) forms. When the dew point is equal to the
ambient temperature occupants may be unable to adequately thermo-regulate their bodies
through sweating. In addition, when dew forms on surfaces, the water droplets may
provide a source of moisture that could support the growth of mould.
4.2 Carbon Dioxide (Ventilation)
Carbon dioxide (CO2) is often used as an indicator of the efficacy of ventilation within a
building environment, relative to indoor occupancy and metabolic activity. According to
American Society for Heating Refrigerating and Air conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE)
Standard 62.1-2010 “Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality”, it is recommended that
the differential between the indoor and outdoor levels does not exceed 700 ppm.
Additionally, the United States-Environmental Protection Agency (US-EPA) and the US
National Institution of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) state that:
“Carbon dioxide levels over 1,000 ppm indicate inadequate ventilation and
complaints such as headaches, fatigue, and eye and throat irritation will be more
widespread. 1,000 ppm should be used as an upper limit for indoor levels.”
Page 53 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
In all of the areas that were monitored within the Treasury Building, the levels of carbon
dioxide did not approach 1,000 ppm indicating that ventilation rates fell within the
recommended range.
4.3 Gaseous Contaminants
Air screening for potentially toxic gaseous contaminants on the 12th and 15th of January
2018 revealed the presence of carbon monoxide (CO), sulphur dioxide (SO2)
formaldehyde (CH2O) and Total Volatile Organic Compounds (TVOCs). Other gases
screened for, but NOT detected indoors, include nitrogen dioxide, hydrogen sulphide,
chlorine, ammonia and total mercaptans.
a. Carbon monoxide (CO) is a common by-product of combustion processes.
Common sources include vehicular exhaust and burning of fossil fuels. The
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienist (ACGIH) has
established a threshold limit value (TLV) based on an 8-hour time-weighted
average (TWA) of 25 ppm for CO. Other jurisdictions have established less
stringent guidelines such as the Occupational Safety and Health Administration
(OSHA) in the USA. OSHA recommends an 8-hr permissible exposure limit (PEL)
of 35 ppm. CO was only detected in trace amounts on the 15th of January and
ranged from 0.4 to 1.5 ppm. These measurements were significantly less than the
recommended guideline offered by ACGIH and therefore not a cause for concern.
The values obtained outdoors indicate that substantial quantities of this gas were
NOT accumulating in the immediate environs of the building.
b. Sulphur Dioxide (SO2) is a gas that is generated by combustion processes and
may be found in sources such as vehicle emissions and burning of fossil fuels.
The ACGIH recommends a threshold limit value (TLV) based on an 8-hour time-
weighted average of 0.25 ppm. However, OSHA recommends an 8-hr TWA of 2
ppm and a short-term exposure limit (STEL) 5 ppm. Sulphur dioxide ranged
between 0 and 2.0 ppm. The standards cited cannot be directly applied since
monitoring was not conducted over an 8-hr period. However, if the measurements
recorded were to persist in the environment for 8 hours then the ACGIH
recommendation would have been exceeded. Symptoms associated with Sulphur
Page 54 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
dioxide exposure include eye, nose and throat irritation, coughing, wheezing,
shortness of breath, chest pain, nausea and vomiting.
c. Formaldehyde (CH2O) is a volatile organic compound (VOC) that is a common
sensitizing agent that can cause a burning sensation of the eyes, nose and throat
and has been linked to breathing problems especially in children with asthma
Health Canada (1995). Indoor sources of formaldehyde may include the presence
of unsealed plywood, some foam insulations, fabrics, carpets, glues, furnishings,
paint, photocopy emissions and carbonless copy paper. Exposure limits
recommended by OSHA and ACGIH are 750 ppb and 300 ppb respectively.
However, Health Canada recommends a short-term (one hour) exposure limit of
100 parts per billion (ppb) to protect against irritation of the eyes, nose and throat.
Formaldehyde was recorded between 0 and 97 ppb and therefore is not a cause
for concern.
o Health Canada's recommended short-term exposure limit is 1/10th of
the lowest level at which symptoms have been observed, in order to
protect more sensitive individuals. Studies have shown that a
concentration of 1000 ppb can cause irritation of the eyes, nose and
throat.
d. Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) are organic compounds that easily become
vapours or gases. VOCs include all chemicals containing carbon (C) and
hydrogen (H) and are therefore referred to as hydrocarbons. VOCs are ubiquitous
in the indoor and outdoor environment. In office environments common sources
include emissions from copying and printing machines, off-gassing of building
materials, cleaning materials, personal care products. VOCs from the outdoors
may also become entrained in the “fresh air” or “outside air” intake of mechanically
ventilated buildings. Emissions from combustion sources such as vehicular
exhaust and smoke are common outdoor sources of VOCs. The term total volatile
organic compounds (TVOCs) refer to the concentration of a mixture of volatile
organic compounds (VOCs) that may be present in the atmosphere at a particular
time.
Page 55 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Altogether electronic monitoring indoors revealed the presence of trace quantities
of TVOCs ranging between 171 and 1,183 ppb.
Open characterization of VOCs by active monitoring revealed the presence of a
number of VOCs in notable quantities. The range of TVOC concentrations
reported for this method was 60 - 390 µg/m3 as shown in Section 3.7, Table 12.
A qualitative look at the TVOC profiles for the respective floors revealed that the
majority of the compounds were associated with several possible sources including
vehicle emissions; solvents used in paints and adhesives; off-gassing of building
materials; degrading materials especially in the Vault area; cleaning products and
floor finishes to a larger extent on the First Floor. Other possible contributions to
the odourous conditions on the First Floor also appear to be the combination of
sewer odours, cleaning products and air fresheners emanating from the sanitary
conveniences on the floor especially since a similar odour was detected in the air
handling unit. Although concentrations of TVOCs on the Fourth and Fifth Floors
were lower than those of the Ground and First Floor, the range of compounds
detected were similar albeit in varying concentrations. TVOCs may linger in
environments that are poorly ventilated. It should be noted that Carbon dioxide
concentrations were relatively low which coincided with below normal occupancy
on the Ground and First Floors in particular. Therefore, since typical conditions did
not exist at the time of the assessment in some areas, the carbon dioxide levels
are suspect for these locations. Microbial VOCs also made a contribution to the
environment being odourous particularly on the Ground Floor. This corresponds to
the presence of mouldy furniture and deteriorating materials that were present at
this location.
Although regulated indoor air quality guidelines do not currently exist for total
volatile organic compounds (TVOCs) levels for non-industrial settings, some
exposure limits have been recommended. According to The European
Collaborative Action (ECA) Report 11: 'Guidelines for Ventilation Requirements in
Buildings (CEC 1992)', the following are stated:
Page 56 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
a. Comfort range: < 200 µg/m3
b. Multi-factorial exposure range: 200 – 3,000 µg/m3
c. Discomfort range: (3,000 – 25,000 µg/m3), and the
d. Toxic range (> 25,000 µg/m3).
Based on the above guidelines the concentrations reported for the Fourth and Fifth
Floors fell within the Comfort range of <200 µg/m3. However, the measurements for
the Ground and First Floor fell within the multi-factorial range of 200 – 3,000 µg/m3.
Exposures in the ‘Multi-factorial range may result in persons experiencing discomfort
due to their level of tolerance, and how the individual VOCs interact with each other.
Nevertheless, Health Canada (1995) states that hypersensitive individuals can have
severe reactions to a variety of VOCs at very low concentrations. Furthermore, it is
stated that these reactions can occur following exposure to a single sensitizing dose or
sequence of doses, after which time a much lower dose can provoke symptoms.
Some of the symptoms of low TVOC exposure highlighted by Health Canada (1995)
include fatigue, headaches, drowsiness, dizziness, weakness, joint pains, peripheral
numbness or tingling, euphoria, tightness in the chest, unsteadiness, blurred vision,
and skin and eye irritation.
4.4 Air Analysis of Bio-aerosols (Bacteria and Fungi/Mould)
Bio-aerosols such as bacteria and fungi (mould) naturally exist in association with plant
matter and soil in the outdoors but may infiltrate buildings via natural ventilation and/or
may be tracked into buildings on the shoes and clothing of building occupants.
Some of the bacterial species detected specifically Micrococcus and Staphylococcus
(coagulase negative) are classified as commensal micro-organisms that form part of
the normal flora of humans and are therefore very prevalent in occupied spaces. On
the other hand, Bacillus subtilis species are spore-forming bacteria that are commonly
found outdoors but may exist indoors. None of the bacteria detected are classified as
faecal indicator bacteria or pathogenic bacteria.
Some fungi/moulds are well adapted to the indoor environment and may colonize
certain building materials particularly those materials with cellulose content which is a
Page 57 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
natural food source for fungi. Although some fungi such as Aspergillus can thrive well
under harsh conditions, most fungi require moist conditions, warm temperatures and a
suitable food source. While there was a wide range of fungi at the various locations,
only a few types were deemed to be elevated. Aspergillus/Penicillium-like spores in
particular were noted to be dominant in the Customer Waiting Area and Cashier
section on the Ground Floor; the Assistant Appraiser’s office on the Fourth Floor and
the Director’s office (IT –Treasury Department). The results also showed that
Aspergillus/Penicillium-like spores were not present in any of the three outdoor
samples. This finding is indicative of the existence of conditions that are conducive to
proliferation of mould in the areas highlighted. Aspergillus species usually emit a
characteristic musty odour as a result of their metabolic activity.
Moulds are usually harmless to the general population of healthy individuals who are
capable of fending off the allergens produced by moulds. Moulds are especially
problematic when found in large concentrations indoors. Some of the moulds detected
in this study are known to be allergenic therefore persons that are susceptible to the
allergens produced are likely to be affected. Microbial VOCs were only detected on
the Ground and First floors in trace concentrations. However, their presence indicate
that there was active growth of microbes.
4.5 Particulates
Particulates typically found indoors were detected in the samples and the
concentrations were also within the typical range for indoor environments. Skin cell
fragments, black opaque particles and miscellaneous fibres were identified in the
samples. Biologic and man-made fibres that are known irritants were absent, that is,
no measureable quantities of pollen, insect parts or fiberglass fibers were detected in
any of the samples.
Further assessment of dust levels was undertaken using a particle counter. This
assessment revealed that the concentration of dust was “fair” to “Poor” which indicates
that there was a notable quantity of airborne dust. This finding suggests that there
was inadequate air filtration at the air handling units as well as inadequate
housekeeping.
Page 58 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Indoor airborne particulate levels are expected to vary widely throughout the day,
dependent on both internal activities and outdoor influences. The highest dust levels
were observed on the 15th of January Ground Floor BRA Customer Service Area and
BRA Customer Waiting Area; for the First Floor it was the Accounts section in close
proximity to the air handling unit and it was all areas of the Fourth and Fifth floors
which falls within the range designated as “POOR”.
Airborne particulate matter (PM) comprises a complex mixture of organic and inorganic
substances. The main sources include aerosols, smoke, fumes, dust, ash and pollen.
In offices, photocopiers and printers are also potential sources. Particulate matter is
characterized according to size mainly because of the different health effects
associated with the particles of different diameters. Fine PM is particulate matter that
is 2.5 microns (µm) in diameter and less. It is also known as respirable particles
because it can penetrate the respiratory system further than larger particles which
have a diameter of 2.5 - 10 microns. The effects of particulate matter may include
aggravating pre-existing conditions like asthma, heart and lung disease as well as
causing bronchitis and lung cancer in adults and respiratory diseases in children.
The qualitative ratings (Excellent to Very poor) in Table 13 were provided by the
manufacturers of the Dylos 1700 DC and are based on their experiences in residential
and office environments. The quantitative values correlate with ISO 14644.1
Cleanroom standards. Furthermore, a Dylos rating of FAIR or better falls within the
EPA GOOD (green) Air Quality Index (AQI) for fine particulate matter PM 2.5.
Page 59 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
5.0 Conclusions and Recommendations
This section gives an overview of the conclusions drawn from the findings and our
recommendations.
1. The two main locations of concern which had odour complaints were the Vault area on the
Ground Floor and the First Floor of the building. Open characterization of total volatile
organic compounds (TVOCs) for the Vault area revealed the presence of compounds that
are largely associated with the emissions originating from the breakdown of paints,
coatings and other materials. Microbial VOCs were also present caused by emissions
from the metabolites produced by microbes from the degradation of materials contained in
the Vault. Some of the items include old paper, boxes, furniture and other cellulose
containing materials.
Recommendations:
Ground Floor - Vault
I. Remove all unnecessary items from the Vault. Any items with mould-like growth
should be discarded immediately. Care should be taken when removing these
items. They should be properly sealed to prevent cross-contamination.
II. All filing cabinets should be inspected for mould-like contamination on the items
contained therein as well as on the inner surfaces of the cabinets. If found to be
contaminated, the contents should be cleaned and/or discarded if necessary. The
filing cabinets should be cleaned with a suitable biocide.
III. The entire room should be industrially cleaned and allowed to ventilate until all
odours dissipate. Ensure that when this exercise is being undertaken that only
personnel associated with remedial activity is present. The Vault and other
surrounding areas should not be otherwise occupied.
First Floor
2. Regarding the odours detected on the First Floor, the compounds detected by open
characterization of TVOCs indicate that there were compounds that are associated with
floor polishes and scented products. These compounds most likely originated from the
Page 60 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
products used to strip and/or polish the floor as well as from cleaning and personal care
products. Also present were compounds classified as volatile fatty acids (VFAs) that are
very odourous and could have been the likely cause of the odour that was similar to
vinegar. None of the safety data sheets provided listed vinegar (acetic acid) as a
decomposition product. Since acetic acid was present it is possible that the product might
have been used to neutralize the odours. The uric odour detected in the back section of
the office was likely from the ladies’ sanitary conveniences which could be a combination
of sewer odours, cleaning products and air fresheners. The odour detected in the
bathroom was also detected in one of the air handling units on this floor. Therefore, it
appears that there is some communication between the sanitary conveniences and the air
conditioning system. It appears that the combination of compounds possibly from sewer
gases, cleaning products and air fresheners could have caused the complaints reported by
some members of staff.
Recommendations:
I. Further investigation is required to verify that the extraction system is working in
the sanitary conveniences located at the northern end of the First Floor. If the
system is not functioning properly then the pressure gradient in this location
relative to the offices may change causing odours to escape. Air from this location
will follow any path of least resistance.
II. Concerning the southern end of the First Floor it appears that the floor finishes
used could have been too potent causing VOCs to off-gas for some time after the
treatment was completed. It is plausible that vinegar odour originated from its use
to help neutralize the odour. Vinegar contains Acetic acid which is VOC, and if
used this may have contributed to the overall TVOC load. This area of the office
will need to be ventilated until the odours dissipate.
III. Conduct cleaning outside of typical office hours and ensure that enough time is
allowed to for linger odours to dissipate before the building is occupied again.
IV. In addition, the plant rooms associated with the three air handling units on this floor
were found to be unkempt and used for storing miscellaneous items. The plant
rooms should be properly cleaned and storage of items should cease.
V. This floor should remain unoccupied until corrective action has been taken.
Page 61 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
Relative Humidity
3. Measurement of atmospheric conditions revealed that relative humidity was poorly
regulated which may be a function of the maintenance and condition of the air conditioning
systems. High moisture levels may contribute to the degradation of building materials and
provide a suitable environment for mould to grow. Moisture-loving moulds were detected
in the assessment.
Recommendations:
I. The relative humidity should be properly regulated which require a thorough review
of the air conditioning/ventilation system by a qualified engineer.
II. Ensure that the units are properly insulated and that the evaporator coils are clear
of any debris. Ensure that sufficient return air is reaching the unit.
III. The respective systems should also be properly balanced.
Gaseous Contaminants
4. Some gaseous contaminants such as carbon monoxide, sulphur dioxide and
formaldehyde were detected but these were found to be at concentrations that fell within
an acceptable range. Some of these compounds could have originated from vehicular
exhaust.
Recommendations:
I. Given the location of the building, air filtration should be augmented with the
installation of carbon filters or pleated disposable filters with a MERV rating of no
less than 9.
II. In addition, portable air purifiers should be deployed to various sections of the floor.
To facilitate this recommendation management should enlist the services of a
reputable supplier.
Microbial Contamination
5. Microbial contamination was evident where Aspergillus/Penicillium-like spores were the
dominant spore types identified in some of the indoor samples. These spores were most
Page 62 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
prevalent in the samples collected from BRA Customer Service area and Cashier area on
the Ground Floor; on the First Floor in the Customer Waiting Area; on the Fourth Floor in
the Assistant Appraiser’s office; and on the Fifth Floor in the I.T Director’s Office.
Recommendations:
I. The areas mentioned above could be amplification sites for mould proliferation.
These areas especially should be misted with a suitable biocide.
II. Any building materials or furniture found to have mould-like growth should be
cleaned and/or discarded.
III. Proper regulation of the relative humidity in the building and upkeep of the plant
rooms would also help to keep microbial contamination at a minimum.
IV. Ensure that all ceiling tiles showing signs of water incursion and/or mould-like
growth are replaced.
Particulates (Dust)
6. Particulates (Dust) were found to be elevated especially in the Vault and Cashier sections
on the Ground Floor; the Accounts section close to the air handling units on the First Floor
and the Fourth and Fifth Floors. Elevated particulate levels could have been caused by the
absence of filters in some air handling units and the presence of gaps between the filters.
These conditions will allow air to by-pass the filtering stage of the system thus causing
untreated air to be conveyed through the air distribution system.
Recommendation:
I. Greater air filtration is required for the entire building.
II. All deteriorating materials should be replaced and filters should be properly
installed in the filter bed.
III. In addition, the plant rooms should be cleaned.
IV. The practice of using the plant room for storage especially of spent items should
cease and should be properly supervised.
V. Replace all missing ceiling tiles.
VI. The supply and return vents/grilles should be thoroughly cleaned.
VII. Ensure that all plant rooms are properly enclosed.
VIII. The inner cabinet insulation of the respective air handling units should be repaired
or replaced.
Page 63 of 63 REA Envirohealth International Project EHI-PF8501 Accountant General – Treasury Building
6.0 References
1. American Society of Heating Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE)
– ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2004: Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human
Occupancy.
2. American Society of Heating Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE)
– ANSI/ASHRAE 62, 1-2010: Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality.
3. Health Canada (1995) “Indoor Air Quality in Office Buildings: A Technical Guide”
www.hc-sc.gc.ca
4. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). 1987. Guidance for
Indoor Air Quality Investigations. Cincinnati: NIOSH
5. The European Collaborative Action (ECA) Report 11: 'Guidelines for Ventilation
Requirements in Buildings (CEC 1992).
6. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (US-EPA) / National Institute for Occupational
Safety and Health (NIOSH): Building Air Quality: A Guide for Building Owners and
Facility Managers 1991.
Respectfully submitted REA ENVIROHEALTH INTERNATIONAL
Electronic copy Lisa P Barrow BSc MSC (Occ Hyg) 28th February, 2018 Occupational Hygienist Date Electronic copy Sherry-Ann M. Allsopp BSc MPhil MSc 28th February, 2018 Occupational Safety and Hygiene Assistant Date Electronic copy Daderhie I. Best RPh MPH 28th February, 2018 Technical Assistant Date