388
the sale outside the asylum of some of the gardenproduce is first deducted. Unfortunately, this itemis not stated separately, but is set down with moneyreceived from the sale of " articles and goods "(presumably manufactured) as well as garden produce.An important step towards realisation by the localauthorities of the importance of an adequate, varied,and fresh dietary would be a balance-sheet on whichthe garden produce is shown to be taken over at ’,market rates, or on which some other device is adoptedto ensure easy comparison between expenditure onfood at different hospitals. It does not follow, ofcourse, that the cost of food taken by itself is anindication even of quality or quantity, certainly notof variation. The patients’ milk bill or its equivalentin maintenance of cows would be no less if the medicalofficers enjoyed the cream therefrom, as alleged byDr. Lomax. The medical superintendent of one ofthe largest Poor-law infirmaries recentlv achieveda considerable improvement, combined with a
diminished expenditure, by the appointment ofan expert domestic economist as sister-housekeeperinstead of promoting a ward sister accordingto precedent. Still, though money spent is by nomeans an absolute sign, a comparison of costs indifferent mental hospitals in conjunction with theirrespective diet sheets, might afford valuable evidenceof efficiency, or, on the other hand, of carelessnessor leakage.
It is significant that among the proposals acceptedby the conference already referred to as desirable,many coincide with those put forward in thememorandum just issued by the Quaker MedicalSociety, and again with those emphatically cham-pioned by Dr. Lomax. This unanimity encouragesthe hope that certain of these reforms may be speedily.adopted, especially since the Board of Control appearsto agree that they are desirable. An innovationproposed by the Board itself, in a report, as yetunpublished, on the Lomax charges, will be welcomedon all sides. When examining Mr. Trevor, Dr. BedfordPierce quoted from this report a few lines expressingthe hope that, in the future, voluntary womenvisitors would be allowed freely to enter public mentalhospitals, with the double purpose of brightening thelives of the patients and forming a channel wherebythe conditions inside asylums might become betterknown to the general public. Mr. Trevor deniedthat this was a new scheme, saying that it had beenthe feeling of the Board for some time that suchvisitors should be allowed. This would be an
extension of the present system of visiting committeesin the sense that the new visitors would be selectedwith discretion from leisured members of the generalpublic and not from busy members of the local council.These appointments would involve no expense andmight lead to greater public confidence in asylumadministration, as well as to the comfort and happinessof the patients. ---
"ON THE EDGE OF THE PRIMÆVAL FOREST."
LIKE Arnold de Villanova, Dr. Albert Schweitzer isa doctor in three faculties-theology, medicine, andphilosophy. He is a professor at the University ofStrasburg and is also an accomplished organist,having been for some years the organist of the ParisBach Societv. Dr. Schweitzer had read much aboutthe condition of the natives in tropical Africa and wasstruck by the miseries which they had to undergofrom disease : so he made up his mind to studymedicine and to go out as a medical missionary to do ’,what he could to help. He graduated as M.D. in1913, and, accompanied by his wife, who was a qualifiednurse, left Europe for the Gaboon, under the auspicesof the Paris Evangelical Mission in the same year.The station to which he was appointed was Lambareneon the Ogowe, a little south of the Equator and inlongitude about 8° E. Here he and his wife workedfor four and a half years. In his book entitled " Onthe Edge of the Primaeval Forest " (London : A. and(’. Black, Ltd. 1922. Pp. 180. 6s.) Dr. Schweitzerrelates his experiences very simply, and it is evident
that he did excellent work. Among his most prizedpossessions was a pedal piano, specially constructedfor the tropics, with winch the Bach Society of Parishad presented him so that he could keep up hispractice even in Africa, and he tells us that in theintervals of his professional labonrs lie solaced himselfwith playing. It would be interesting to know whatthe natives thought of, let us say, the grept F majorToccata, that wonderful composition which soundsmajestic even on a pedal piano, and on a big organhas much of the feeling of a tropical forest. Sleep-ing sicknesss, malaria, various surgical affections,especially hernia, leprosy, and tropical phagedena,were the diseases which Dr. Schweitzer found mostcommon. After his wife, his chief helper was a
native named Joseph, who was extremely handy. Hehad started life as a cook and his anatomical knowledgewas derived from the kitchen. Thus he would bringup a patient saying,
’’ This woman has a pain in herleft upper cutlet," or "This man’s right ’gigot’hurts him." Among other matters Dr. Schweitzerwas struck by the knowledge of poisons which existsamong the native medicine-men, and of one in par-ticular which apparently produces mania, ending,after a more or less extended period of time, in death.Dr. Schweitzer’s remark as to general problems ofmissionary work and the relations of white to blackare illuminating ; he makes a shrewd observation asto the difference between Catholic and Protestantmissions : " The Protestant mission puts in the firstplace the building up of Christian personalities, whilethe Catholic has in mind before all else the establish-ment on solid foundations of a church." In 918Dr. Schweitzer came home to recruit his health, buthe tells us at the end of his book that he is going outagain. We congratulate him both on his book andon his work.
TWENTY YEARS OF ANTIRABIES INOCULATION.
I THE Bacteriological Institute of Lyons has recentlypublished the collected results of its antirabiesdepartment, from the date of its foundation in 1900up to the termination of its twentieth year ofexistence.l During this period a total of 12,886persons has been treated coming from some 15
departments. As in many institutes, the method oftreatment has been somewhat modified from thatoriginally devised by Pasteur in the direction ofgreater intensity and the earlier use of the morevirulent material. The course usually occupies25 days, but is varied according to the site and severityof the bites. Treatment is commenced bv theinoculation of rabbit’s cords which have been driedfor 7 days, the subsequent injections being madedaily with cords of increasing virulence. The leastattenuated virus in use is a cord which has been driedfor 2 days and this is reached on the fifteenth day oftreatment. In 11 of the 20 years covered by thereport the mortality in effectively treated cases wasnil ; the average mortality over the whole period is0-085 per cent. and the average number of personstreated 640 per annum. From the annual report ofthe Pasteur Institute of Paris2 for the year 1920 wealready know that during that year 1126 personswere treated with a mortality of 0’53 per cent. Itis to be noted that this is the highest mortality whichhas obtained since 1888, the third year of function ofthe Institute. It is also worthy of note that 86 ofthe treated persons belonged to Category
" -B. "-i.e.,persons bitten by a dog proved to have been rabid-and that none of the deaths which occurred were inthis class.Amongst other information furnished by the Lyons
report is evidence of the recrudescence of rabies whichhas occurred in France during and since the period ofthe war. This is attributable in the first place to thegeneral disturbance of civilian life in the early stagesof the combat, associated with the abandonment ofdogs, especially in the invaded areas, the mobilisation
1 Annales de l’Institut Pasteur, vol. xxxv., No. 12, December,1921. 2 Ibid., vol. xxxv., No. 9, September, 1921.
389
of veterinary surgeons, and the relaxation of municipalmuzzling regulations ; and, in the second place andmore latterly, to the importation of dogs by soldiersreturning from expeditionary units in the East-acondition analogous to that responsible for the recentreappearance of canine rabies in this country. Theresults of the Pasteur treatment obtained in theprovincial laboratory compare very favourably withthose of the parent institute in Paris, although thesame classification of patients is not in use, and hencedirect comparison is not possible. It is evident thata large number of persons undergoing treatmentat Lyons are in very slight danger of the disease,since about a third of the patients are persons whohave been licked by rabid animals and in whom thechances of developing the disease are presumablyslight. The figures for the mortality do not give us.an accurate picture of the death-rate in persons whohave been bitten by rabid animals, but rather of thatobtaining in persons in whom the Pasteur treatmenthas had full scope to do its best. Cases ending fatallyduring the treatment, or within 15 days of its termina-tion, are not included in the statistics, since it isrecognised that it is only some 15 days after the endof the treatment that immunity is fully established.If we take 20 days as the average duration of thecourse, and add to this the 15 days which mustsubsequently elapse before the patient enters into thestatistics of the Institute, we find that all cases inwhich the incubation period is less than 35 days, andin which the disease evolves normally in spite of thetreatment, are excluded.Trousseau tells us, in his vivid account of this
malady, that the average length of the incubationperiod is from one to three months, so that a certainnumber of cases evolving normally will not appear inthe results of the Institute, which thus come to excludeto a certain extent cases of short incubation. Thoughprobably more academically correct, this narrowedpresentation of the figures does not, therefore, satisfythe desire to know in a more general fashion whatare the chances of an individual who is bitten by amad dog of developing rabies when treated on modernlines. ____
ECONOMY AND RESIDENTIAL TREATMENTFOR TUBERCULOSIS.
ANYTHING would be a calamity that postponesindefinitely the resuscitation of a number of publichealth activities which had only begun to recover fromthe state of suspended animation imposed on them bythe war. It is a welcome relief to meet with oneproduct of the economy campaign which may havepositive constructive value to public health adminis-trat,ors and through them to the community at large.This pleasing phenomenon appears in the form ofa circular (No. 280) issued by the Ministry of Healthon Jan. 17th last to the authorities responsible forthe provision of residential treatment for tuberculosis.The circular discusses the general principles of economyin sanatorium administration.We would direct attention in particular to the second
portion of the circular, which brings under reviewthe cost of residential treatment. After comparisonof the claims received from local authorities in respectof their expenditure during 1920-21, the Ministry ofHealth has been struck by the wide variations in thecosts involved in residential treatment. In respect ofsalaries, for example, the cost per patient per weekvaried from less than 9s. to over ;S1 ; the cost of pro-visions per patient week from below 21s. to over 35s. ;that for drugs from less than ls. up to 3s. 6d. perpatient week. This information in itself, scantythough it be, is of real value to local authoritiesresponsible for the treatment of tuberculosis, in thatit gives them an opportunity of comparing theirexpenditure on certain definite items with that ofother authorities similarly placed. Allowing for thevariations dependent on the type of patient undertreatment, the geographical position and structure ofthe institution, and other local factors, the analysis of
expenditure on these few items is likely to throwunexpected light on avoidable waste in some areas.Obviously, this is only the first stage in a much moreintimate analysis, which can be rendered of value onlyby verifying the methods of tabulation of costs inpractice in the numerous areas concerned. It istherefore encouraging to find that the Ministry ofHealth proposes to submit a model form of summaryof accounts for consideration by representatives ofthe County Councils Association, the Association ofMunicipal Corporations, the Society of Superintendentsof Tuberculosis Institutions, the County AccountantsSociety, and the Institute of Municipal Treasurersand Accountants, in conjunction with officers of theMinistry. Having established a common basis ofstatement of accounts, the Ministry may publish anannual detailed analysis of the costs in the variousareas. There can be no question that such a procedurewould have a most beneficial effect in stimulatinginterest in the whole problem of residential treatment,and in concentrating attention on the essential whilediscouraging the non-essential features of such treat-ment. The overhauling of administrative machinerywould before long lead to a material improvement inthe methods and in the results of treatment.
HEALTH AND INDUSTRIAL OUTPUT.
THE study of human efficiency in industry promisesgreat returns in productivity, and yet 12 monthsago we narrowly escaped throwing away our lead inthis study, as may be read between the lines ofthe second annual report of the Industrial FatigueResearch Board which covers a period of 18 monthsending September, 1921. During this period, whenthe foundations of a new science were just begun, thecareer of the Board nearly terminated at short notice,but reconstruction has taken place and the Board hasnow become an integral part of the organisation ofthe Medical Research Council,who have also establishedfour allied committees to deal with industrial healthstatistics, with the physiology of muscular work, withthe physiology of the respiratory and cardio-vascularsystems, and with industrial psychology. The Board,in view of its financial restrictions, now appeals toindustries in their own interests to assume partialresponsibility for investigations. Every science musthave means of measurement and the Board, havingproved their value, has employed, as measures ofhuman efficiency, output (with regard to quantityand quality), sickness and mortality records, labourturnover, lost time, and accident frequency. Investi-gations have established that hours of work shouldvary for heavy, moderately heavy, and light labour,and that if hours are over-long output can be increasedby reducing them, but that this increase is only to beexpected where the human element, rather than themachine, rules the pace. Indications that spells ofwork are over-long are to be found in a fall of outputas the spell lengthens ; under good conditions outputshould rather improve up to the end of each spell,throughout the day, and from day to day throughoutthe week. Spells of work when too long ought to bebroken by organised rest pauses instead of allowingworkers to interpolate their own unorganised pauses.Seasonal influences due to temperature, humidity,and lighting are found to be considerable and to becontrollable by well-planned ventilation and illumina-tion. Attention to these principles, underlying humanefficiency, which are steadily emerging spells thedifference between profit or loss on the one hand, andpleasure in work or industrial discontent on the other.Even when everything has been done to make the
conditions of work with regard to hours of employ-ment and the environment of the worker satisfactory,still there remain other problems for inquiry.Vocational guidance to direct newcomers to work forwhich they are fitted, and vocational selection to pickout those suited for the work in hand are matters
1 Second Annual Report of the Industrial Fatigue ResearchBoard to September, 1921. H.M. Stationery Office. 1922. 1s. 6d.