DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
TWR-49:Long Term Retention of Product Model Data
Paul J. RakowNaval Surface Warfare Center
Carderock Division
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
2
Project Description
Project accomplishments
2009-2011 Objectives
Group Discussion
Close-out
Agenda
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
3
Why product model information?
• As DOD acquisition contracts transition from electronic drawing based archive data sets to digital product model data, the respective agencies need to ensure that future users have access to the required data to support the lifecycle of their weapon system.
• This includes the requirements and issues involved with the:– Transition to 3-D geometry in numerous forms and quantities.– Aggregation of product models and related data from individual
components to complete weapons systems– Long-term accessibility and interpretability of the archived digital
data by future generations.
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
4
Shipbuilderinvolvement
Core data
Concept
30
-70
years
Design & Construction
Evaluations & applications of
core data
Retirement
In-service
Commissioning
Origination of the dataThe design spiral is actually a convoluted path
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
5
What types of data?Long Term Data Retention of Weapon System
• 3-D Geometry• engineering properties• associative relations• analysis data
• process definition• logistics definition• manufacturing data• work breakdown structure • product structure
• links to M&S• links to documentation
• drawings• models• photographs• manuals
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
6
Product model data: Multiple data typesPiping
Images
2D Drawings
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
7
3D model
Product model data: Multiple data typesPiping
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
8
What will we do with it?
Research and evaluate through objective measurement, issues related to long-term data retention of large amounts of structured weapons system product data in native and neutral formats.
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
9
• National Archives and Records Administration (NARA)R&D - Long Term Knowledge retention of product model data for historical data retrieval and governmental reconstitution
• JEDMICS / NESDRStorage and retrieval of engineering drawings and product model data
• Defense Logistics Agency (DLA)Use of product model data for weapons system support
• NAVSEAuse of product model data for ships and ships systems evaluation and support
StakeholdersPrimary Interest
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
10
• New Ship DesignsEven when revolutionary, large portions are based upon extension of existing designs
• In-serviceOperational and Logistical support
• RepairsUSS Cole, USS Intrepid, USS New Orleans and SSN Hartford, etc
• Decommissioning: Identification of hazardous materials if scrapped, Live Fire Test & Evaluation (LFT & E) analysis and documentation,National Defense Reserve Fleet
NavyUses for Long Term Retention of Data
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
11
Use CasesAssist in the definition of data requirements
User case # 001 002 003 004 005
User case name Repair Ship Design new ship Analyze ship Cost analysis of ship Decommission ship
Description
Designer - @ Navy repair yard / commercial repair yardNeeds existing ship data to facilitate repair
Designer - new ship classNeeds legacy data to derive new design
Analyst - Uses Asset/LEAPS to perform Analysis of AlternativesArchived ship becomes parent ship for future class
- Compare estimate to actual cost of ship- Use baseline costs to estimate $ of new ship
Scrap yard is decommissioning ship
Types of Query needed
CompartmentDisciplineSystemZone
CompartmentDisciplineSystemZone
CompartmentDisciplineSystemZone
EWBS Materials
Originator NSWC NSWC NSWC NSWC RD-NAVAIR
User case # 006 007 008 009 010
User case name Historical User Bid for Construction Logistical Support Operation Deployment
Description
A private citizen wants to review the info in the National Achieves for historical purposes
Shipyard "A" designed the lead ship in the class.Shipyard A, B & C will bid on Construction of follow ships
Long Term Support - complete technical specifications for open procurement of all components for the weapon system. This is to include process specifications, material designations and up to date drawings.
Operation - operational manuals; operational and periodic maintenance manualsrepair parts listing
Deployment - requirements for docking, operation, crew stand down, housing, special facilities and any other equipment, structure of operator needs for the ship to be fully operational at a forward deployed port.
Types of Query needed
CompartmentDisciplineSystemZone
EWBSCompartmentDisciplineSystemZone
Part NumberManufactureMaterialCriticality CodeCostShelf Life/Time ChangeCompartmentSystemZoneDiscipline
Time ChangeRepair PartsCompartmentSystemZoneDisciplineTechnical manuals
StructuresEquipmentOperational SuppliesTechnical ManualsFacilitiesCrew RequirementsCriticality CodesClassified Needs
Originator NSWC NSWC DLA DLA DLA
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
12
Why the TWR 841?
This ship is used to assist in sonar tests & locate and retrieve torpedoes and missile drones.
This ship was selected for our project because it is in-service, has a complete set of drawings available for distribution, and is:
Approved for Public Release:
Distribution Unlimited.
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
13
What is the TWR 841?Torpedo Weapons Retriever Characteristics
Fuel Capacity 8,700 gal.
Potable Water Capacity
1,300 gal.
Missile Washdown Water Capacity
1,100 gal.
Range 1700 nm
Electrical 450 VAC three phase 60 Hz.120 VAC single phase 60Hz.24 VDC.
Crew 18
Construction Welded steel construction with plates welded over transverse and longitudinal bulkheads and transverse frames
120 Foot Torpedo Weapons Retriever
The Torpedo Weapons Retriever is utilized in support of underwater acoustic submarine operations and torpedo exercises. It is designed to launch and retrieve acoustic devices as well as retrieve missiles and torpedoes in the ocean. The TWR 841 is based out of the Naval Undersea Warfare Center located in Newport Rhode Island.
Length overall 120 ft
Beam, Max 25 ft.
Draft (full load) 7 ft. 5 in.
Displacement (full load)
248 LT
Displacement (minimum operating load)
221.75 LT
Speed 14.7 knots.
Engines Two (2) Caterpillar Model 3512 V12
Power 1140 shp at 1800 rpm.
Propellers Two (2) manganese bronze, 54 in diameter, 46.8 in pitch, 4 blade
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
14
Path to TWR-49
Archived TWRNavy Common Product Model
CM controlled native source data
Hull/molded formsRhino
Deckhouse StructureSolidWorks
Sensors/AntennasSolidWorks
Hull Structure/ER MachineryShipConstructor
Data contentData format
Attributes/Analysis results/ requirements
Project IDE / Native DB
Archived Ship Product ModelLEAPSTEPNative
Supplies data
References data
ShipLEAPS
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
15
Common Product Model Data Environmentas directed by COMNAVSEA on 04 Feb 2008
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
16
Leading Edge Architecture for Prototyping Systems (LEAPS)
• LEAPS is a framework developed to support virtual prototyping in the context of conceptual and preliminary ship design and analysis.
• Navy Common Product Model
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
17
Feasibility study/ConceptDesign
PreliminaryDesign
Detail Design & Construction(DD & C)
O & S activitiesContractDesign
Tools usage from DDG-1000 program
DDG-1000 image from http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/ship/dd-x-schem.htm
CA
D T
oo
lsAutoCAD, CATIA & UGS (CAD)
AutoCAD- FASTship, Rhino, UGS, Pro-E,
CATIA V4 & 5, (CAD)CATIA V5 &
ShipConstructor (CAD)AutoCAD? CATIA? (CAD)
Des
ign
Use
cas
eUC1 UC5UC4
UC8 UC9 UC10 UC7UC6
UC2
UC3
One Program, Many CAD systemsDDG 1000
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
18
Data Sources : TWR 841Native systems
ShipConstructor - AutoCAD based- Equipment below main deck- Structure below main deck- Distribution Systems below
main deck
RhinoCAD - Molded Forms- Compartmentation- Equipment
SolidWorks - Deckhouse Structure
LEAPS - NAVSEA Product Model
Repository- Integration tool
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
19
Modeling ToolShipConstructor
ShipConstructor was selected as our product modeling tool as it is relevant to NARA, NAVAIR and DLA because it is AutoCAD based. It is also relevant to NAVSEA due to the following shipbuilding projects.•Deepwater – National Security Cutter (NGSS Avondale) •LCS – both variants (Gibbs & Cox on Lockheed Martin program, Austal on General Dynamics program)•CVN – 21 deckhouse (NGSS Avondale for Newport News)•ONR E-Craft (Guido Perla for Alaska Ship & Drydock)•ONR X-Craft (Sea Fighter) – Nichols Brothers
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
20
Secondary Modeling ToolsTool Selection
• SoldiWorks was chosen due to current Navy Ship Design program usage
• Rhinoceros CAD: Used for Hullform, molded surfaces, compartmentation, HVAC.
• LEAPS (Leading Edge Architecture for Prototyping Systems).
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
21
TWR 841 : Test DataCompartmentation/ Rhino
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
22
TWR 841 : Test caseHVAC / Rhino
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
23
TWR 841 : Test caseShips Structure / ShipConstructor
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
24
TWR 841 : Test caseShip’s Piping / ShipConstructor
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
25
TWR 841 : Test caseShip’s Piping / ShipConstructor
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
26
Test Data : TWR 841ShipConstructor Product Model
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
27
Test Data : TWR 841SolidWorks Geometry
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
28
Test Data : TWR 841LEAPS Product Model
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
29
11102110
2210
2310
3110ASSY_003 A
SS
Y_0
01
AS
SY
_001
AS
SY
_001
AS
SY
_002
AS
SY
_002
ASSY_002ASSY_004
ASSY_003
ASSY_003
Retention of Data : TWR 841Construction Units
Life cycle support requires
•production hierarchy (interim products)
•and design hierarchy (system)
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
30
Product StructureProduct Model Based
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
31
Product structures are relatedProduction / Design hierarchy
A collection of parts that are used together as portion of a functional system
A single component that is fabricated or purchased
A fully operational weapon system that is comprised of multiple functional systems to complete the intended mission
A collection of parts & sub-assemblies that operate together to accomplish a specific task
Part Functional SystemSubassembly Weapon System
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
32
Files stored on Data GridTWR Builders Drawings
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
33
Data stored on Data GridTransverse Bulkhead at Frame 11
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
34
Accomplishments
• Created product model
• Research and Development of required Product Model Data to support engineering analysis
• Implemented a second native product modeling environment
• Developed, implemented, and testing STEP AP203 / AP214 for use in archiving Ship Product Model Data
• Transitioned the SolidWorks model to LEAPS
• Initiate the use of the Data Grid for storing native CAD models, STEP files, and the TWR source drawings.
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
35
Ongoing activities
• Developing, implementing, and testing additional STEP AP’s for use in archiving Ship Product Model Data
• Transitioning ShipConstructor model to LEAPS
• Transitioning the SolidWorks model to LEAPS
• Develop the product model repository architecture incorporating native CAD, the NAVSEA product modeling system, STEP, and ad-hoc neutral file formats using the Data Grid.
• Develop more automated methods for increasing our efficiency in populating the Data Grid.
• Develop a structural model of the engine room having enough detail to perform a stress analysis so that we can demonstrate the relationship between CAD models, FEM, analysis data, results, and documentation.
• Perform a topside analysis of the C4N equipment on the TWR and relate the LEAPS data, analysis data, results, and documentation.
• Perform intact and damage stability analyses using SHCP and capture results
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A : Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited
36
QUESTIONS?
COMMENTS