Information Session for Living Annuitants
29 November 2017
Agenda1. WHAT is a living annuity
2. RISKS
1. INVESTMENTS
2. DRAWDOWNS
3. EXITING the living annuity
1. UCRTRF vs COMMERCIAL living annuity
2. LIFE vs LIVING ANNUITY
4. What happens when I DIE
5. Admin fee increase March 2018
6. Information Resources
7. Disclaimer
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
BASICALLY like a BANK account
You control how much goes in (initially)
You control where invested
You control how much you take out
NO GUARANTEES If it runs out it runs out
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
LET’S TALK ABOUT RISK
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY CAPITAL
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
INVESTMENTRISK
DRAWDOWN RISK
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY CAPITAL
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
INVESTMENTRISK
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY CAPITAL
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsPension paid Fees
YOU CHOOSE the investment portfolio
RISK (volatility) vs REWARD (return)Income
Market linkedSmooth Bonus
Shari’ah
so you have controland the risk
INVESTMENTRISK
Investment options
9
A
B
C
D
Income Fund: Inflation + 1% target, Low Risk
(0-2 year time horizon)
Smooth Bonus Fund: Inflation + 3% target, Medium Risk
(3-5 year time horizon)
Balanced Fund: Inflation + 5% target, Higher Risk
(7 year time horizon)
Shari’ah Fund: Inflation + 4% target, Medium-High Risk
(5-7 year horizon)
2017 SUMMARY OF INVESTMENT RETURNS
The Shari’ah Fund, Portfolio D, was introduced on 1 April 2010 and does not yet have a 7-year track record.
* inception date is 1 April 2010 for Portfolio D, 1 January 1995 for the other portfolios.
Below is an example of the differences between the long-term actual returns overthe different portfolios achieved over a 22- year period.
Note the short-term fluctuations (gains and losses) in the all share index, but also look at the long-term returns.
Below is an example of the differences between the actual returns over the different portfolios achieved over a 6-year period.
Monthly Performance
As you would expect, the Balanced Fund (Portfolio C) shows the largest variation in monthly returns, reflecting the riskier nature of this portfolio, but with the highest returns since inception.
• Monthly returns for the four portfolios during 2016. These figures are shown after investment manager fees.
• Note: inception date is 1 April 2010 for Portfolio D, 1 January 1995 for the other portfolios.
Investment Choice
YOUR CHOICECan switch portfolios
ANYTIME
Switch forms with benefit statement documents
Switches will be confirmed with you
Within 2 days
ONLINE switching
Processed within 5 days
MMI MVA adjustment process
Switch Turnaround Times
Normal switches including switches to MMI· Acknowledge receipt of switch instruction to member within 2 days.· Switch will be processed within 5 days and certificate send to the member
Full disinvestments from MMI· Obtain MVA quote from MMI within 2 days· If no MVA proceed with disinvestment request to MMI· Acknowledge receipt to member and confirm that we will proceed with switch.· If MVA applicable, acknowledge receipt and inform member of MVA (process included in the 2 days SLA)· Also request confirmation from member to proceed with switch. (Member to confirm within 2 days)· As soon as member confirms we send disinvestment request to MMI· Payment to be received within 3 working days· Switch to be processed on the day that money is received in bank account and certificate send to the member
Members with partial fund values invested in MMI· Internal investment portfolio’s to be switched within 5 days· Switch certificate and confirmation regarding MVA to the member.· For MMI disinvestments, the same process as above will apply
Investment Choice
INFORMED DECISION
UCTRF websitewww.uctrf.co.za
UCTRF investment guideToolkit – pension purchase
RISK vs VOLATILITYAbility to absorb shocks VS need
for real growth
COMMON ERROR 1Choosing too
conservative a strategy
COMMON ERROR 2Trying to time the market
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY CAPITAL
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
DRAWDOWN RISK
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
YOU CHOOSEthe drawdown
AnnuallyWithin limits
(min 2.5% and 17.5%)
So again, you have controland the risk
DRAWDOWN INFLATION LONGEVITY
RISK
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
YOU CHOOSEthe drawdown
AnnuallyWithin limits
(min 2.5% and 17.5%)
So again, you have control
DRAWDOWN INFLATION LONGEVITY
RISK
Drawdown = % of capital you want to draw
as a pension for the year. Can be paid
monthly / quarterly / biannually / annually
EG Living annuity capital = R1 mil
5% drawdown = pension of R50,000 per year
i.e. R4,167 per month
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
YOU CHOOSEthe drawdown
AnnuallyWithin limits
(min 2.5% and 17.5%)
So again, you have control
DRAWDOWN INFLATION LONGEVITY
RISK
Drawdown = % of capital you want to draw
as a pension for the year. Can be paid
monthly / quarterly / biannually / annually
EG Living annuity capital = R1 mil
5% drawdown = pension of R50,000 per year
i.e. R4,167 per month
ANNUAL INCOME CHANGE FORM
2 months from election
If you do NOT return this form, stay on the same % as previously
THIS IS A RISK
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
YOU CHOOSEthe drawdown
AnnuallyWithin limits
(min 2.5% and 17.5%)
So again, you have control
DRAWDOWN INFLATION LONGEVITY
RISK
Drawdown = % of capital you want to draw
as a pension for the year. Can be paid
monthly / quarterly / biannually / annually
EG Living annuity capital = R1 mil
5% drawdown = pension of R50,000 per year
i.e. R4,167 per month
MUST MANAGE DRAWDOWN IN RELATION TO CAPITAL AVAILABLE
If markets run, keep pension increase to inflation to bank the good performance for the bad years
If markets fall, will need to adjust income (same proportion of a lower capital value at best case)
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
YOU CHOOSEthe drawdown
AnnuallyWithin limits
(min 2.5% and 17.5%)
So again, you have control
DRAWDOWN INFLATION LONGEVITY
RISK
Drawdown = % of capital you want to draw
as a pension for the year. Can be paid
monthly / quarterly / biannually / annually
EG Living annuity capital = R1 mil
5% drawdown = pension of R50,000 per year
i.e. R4,167 per month
MUST MANAGE DRAWDOWN IN RELATION TO CAPITAL AVAILABLE
If markets run, keep pension increase to inflation to bank the good performance for the bad years
If markets fall, will need to adjust income (same proportion of a lower capital value)
TRUSTEES TRY TO ASSIST in ANNUAL INCOME CHANGE FORMSR1 million = pmMinimum (2.5%) = R2 083Maximum (17.5%)= R14 583
Max Recommended (Single) = expect for life CPI linkedMax Recommended (Dependants) = expect for life CPI linked with provision for spouse pension of 75% on deathActuary’s Maximum = expect for life no increases no spouse pension
What is a Living Annuity?
LIVING ANNUITY ACCOUNT
RETIREMENT CAPITAL
Positive investment
returns
Negative investment
returnsDrawdown =
pension Fees
YOU CHOOSEthe drawdown
AnnuallyWithin limits
(min 2.5% and 17.5%)
So again, you have control
DRAWDOWN INFLATION LONGEVITY
RISK
Drawdown = % of capital you want to draw
as a pension for the year. Can be paid
monthly / quarterly / biannually / annually
EG Living annuity capital = R1 mil
5% drawdown = pension of R50,000 per year
i.e. R4,167 per month
MUST MANAGE DRAWDOWN IN RELATION TO CAPITAL AVAILABLE
If markets run, keep pension increase to inflation to bank the good performance for the bad years
If markets fall, will need to adjust income (same proportion of a lower capital value)
TRUSTEES TRY TO ASSIST in ANNUAL INCOME CHANGE FORMSR1 million = pmMinimum (2.5%) = R2 083Maximum (17.5%)= R14 583
Max Recommended (Single) = expect for life CPI linkedMax Recommended (Dependants) = expect for life CPI linked with provision for spouse pension of 75% on deathActuary’s Maximum = expect for life no increases no spouse pension
Based on insurer rates
Ie the insurer’s mortality and investment
expectation
UNDERSTANDING YOUR DRAWDOWN FORMANNUAL UNIVERSITY OF CAPE TOWN RETIREMENT FUND (UCTRF) LIVING
ANNUITY DRAWDOWN FORM
As you are aware, a living annuitant must elect his or her pension level annually. Your living annuity
anniversary date is July of each year. You now have the opportunity to revise the income you draw for the
period 1 January 2018 to 31 December 2018.
The purpose of an annuity is to provide you with an income for life. This of course is dependent on
variables that we are unable to predict, e.g. earnings on the underlying investment and longevity, but
clearly the amount you draw from your annuity is one of the primary factors which is under your control
and will determine how long your UCTRF living annuity will last. The less you draw down, given the
investment return achieved, the more likely it is that your living annuity will be able to provide for a
sustainable retirement income.
The table here gives a range of drawdown rates which are explained
Your personal details
Name: Dr XX Membership No: 0000000
Date of Birth: Date of Purchasing Living Annuity: 01/01/2017
Fund value on 01/10/2017:
Summary of drawdown rates
SARS Your Trustee’s max
Minimum Current recommended
(single)
8.59 %
Trustee’s max
recommended
(dependants)
7.61%
Actuary’s
maximum
SARS
Maximum
2.50% 3.50% 12.43% 17.50%
UNDERSTANDING YOUR DRAWDOWN FORMThe table here gives a range of drawdown rates which are explained below.
With respect to each of the draw down rates in the table above:
SARS legislated limits
The percentage annual level of drawdown may not be less than the minimum or more than the maximum
percentage prescribed by the Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service in this regard, which
are currently between 2.5% and 17.5%.
Current drawdown rate
You are currently drawing income at a drawdown rate of 2.50%
Trustee’s maximum recommended drawdown rate is determined to be no more than 8.59% (or, if your
living annuity is intended to provide an income to a spouse, partner or other surviving dependants in the
event of your death, no more than 7.61%). Note that this is not a recommended drawdown rate, and
as long as you are able to do so, you should aim to draw less than this; the Trustees strongly
recommend that the applicable one of these two rates (depending on whether your living annuity should
make provision for a spouse or other dependants as well as for you) should be used as an upper limit to
your drawdown choice.
Summary of drawdown rates
SARS Your Trustee’s max
Minimum Current recommended
(single)
8.59 %
Trustee’s max
recommended
(dependants)
7.61%
Actuary’s
maximum
SARS
Maximum
2.50% 3.50% 12.43% 17.50%
UNDERSTANDING YOUR DRAWDOWN FORMActuary’s maximum rate is calculated to be the absolute maximum you should draw in order to maintain a sustainable retirement income under set assumptions (which include the assumption that your living
annuity does not have to provide for a spouse or other dependants). The Rules of the Fund1
require the
Actuary to stipulate a maximum drawdown rate for each living annuitant, beyond which there is a serious risk of depletion of funds in the short- to medium-term. In your case the Actuary’s maximum drawdown
percentage is 12.43% per annum.
To guide you in your decision we have provided you with the two limits within the legislated
limits: the Trustee’s maximum recommended drawdowns (one for a single person, and one
inclusive of dependants), and
The Actuary’s maximum.
If you feel it is necessary to draw more than the Trustee’s maximum recommended drawdown to meet
your current income needs, bearing in mind that we recommend you draw less than this, we recommend
that you take financial advice to help you understand the implications of your choices and, if necessary,
make changes to your lifestyle to ensure the sustainability of your living annuity.
However, you should only under exceptional circumstances be considering drawing more than the
Actuary’s maximum rate. As indicated in the section above, the UCTRF Trustees strongly recommend
that you draw down considerably less than this maximum: the less you draw, the more retirement capital
will be left. If you decide to do so, you will, in terms of the Rules of the Fund, be required to declare that you
have taken financial advice on this matter and understand the implications of your choice.
If you wish to draw down at a greater rate than the Actuary’s maximum, you MUST complete section 3 of
the attached declaration form, certifying that you acknowledge the risks of this strategy, have taken financial
advice on this issue and take responsibility for the likely consequences. If you are in this position, we
strongly recommend that before committing to a higher drawdown rate, you contact the UCTRF Office
(email: uctrf- [email protected] or call 021 650 2934) who will help you to understand the potential
consequences of an excessively high drawdown rate, and/or discuss the matter with your financial advisor.
Please note that it is not “safe” to draw at a rate that is close to but lower than the
Actuary’s maximum. It is not even necessarily “safe” to draw close to the Trustees’
maximum rate applicable to you (i.e. depending on whether your living annuity must also
provide for dependants or not). Even if you choose a lower drawdown rate, your
retirement capital could still be insufficient for your lifetime needs (and those of your
spouse and dependants, if applicable) if you or your dependants live too long or if the
investment returns are poor.
UNDERSTANDING YOUR DRAWDOWN FORM
EXITING THE LIVING ANNUITY
CAN I TRANSFER to another living annuity?
YES (S14 process – approval by FSB)Full amount
Split transfer allowed
CAN I TRANSFER to a life annuity?
YES (S14 process – approval by FSB)Full amount
Split transfer allowed
CAN I ENCASH my benefit
NOUnless the capital value falls below the amount prescribed by SARS (currently
R50,000 if any part was previously commuted, or R75,000 otherwise)
EXITING THE LIVING ANNUITY
CAN I TRANSFER to another living annuity?
YES (S14 process – approval by FSB)Full amount
Split transfer allowed
LIVING Annuity
Commercial provider UCTRF
Cost Commercial Provider* UCTRF
Initial fee 1% of assets R508
Ongoing
administration
0.75% first R250k
0.5% next R500k
0.25% above R750k
R71 pm
First-year comparison
based on R1m
R15,000 R1,184
Stay invested in the UCTRF
Lower fees
Reg 28 compliant
S37C distribution
Cannot mix
Can transfer to external later
Wide choice
Higher fees
Not Reg 28 compliant
No S37C distribution
Can mix
Cannot transfer back to UCTRF later
* Best-case scenario example
EXITING THE LIVING ANNUITY
CAN I TRANSFER to a life annuity?
YES (S14 process – approval by FSB)Full amount
Split transfer allowed
WHAT IS A LIFE ANNUITY?
LIFE AnnuityExternal
LIVING AnnuityExternal or in UCTRF
• Insurance Policy• Income as long as you live• No decision making after purchase• No inheritability• BUT guarantee period and• Spouse pension options• Can’t change mind
• “Bank Account”• Withdraw money each month
until it’s gone• Must decide on portfolio and pension• Inheritability• Investment risk and • Risk of outliving your capital• Can change later
WHAT IS A LIFE ANNUITY?
LIFE AnnuityExternal
LIVING AnnuityExternal or in UCTRF
• Insurance Policy• Income as long as you live• No decision making after purchase• No inheritability• BUT guarantee period and• Spouse pension options• Can’t change mind
• “Bank Account”• Withdraw money each month
until it’s gone• Must decide on portfolio and pension• Inheritability• Investment risk and • Risk of outliving your capital• Can change later
DON’T be surprised
For the same capital:Older person will get a higher pension amountMales will get a higher
pension amount
They are expected to live shorter
LIFE Annuity
Increases:
None Fixed % pa Inflation linked With-Profit
The lower the increases, the
higher the starting pension…
but inflation catches up!
https://www.uctrf.co.za/40/E/Monthly-Pension-Indicator
R1 million = pmLevel = R10 604Fixed 5% = R7 370With profit = R 6 424 Infl linked = R6 100
(Single Male age 65)
LIFE Annuity Guarantee period: typically 5 years
How many years after retirement the pension gets paid for regardless of when you die.
Spouse’s pension: typically 75%
You can choose for your spouse to geta % of your pension after you die.
The LONGER, the lower the pension overall.
• Do you have a spouse?• Do they have any pension?• How much extra would they need if you were gone?
The more spouse’s pension, the lower the pension overall.
When is a living annuity inappropriate?
You want your pension to be guaranteed to last you for
life (without decreasing ever)
You don’t want to make the investment and drawdown
decisions anymore
To summarise briefly the key features of the different types of annuities available:
MUST REVIEW PERIODICALLYIt may be that your review of your circumstances leads you to the conclusion that your living annuity remains the vehicle best suited to meet your needs in retirement.
LIVING ANNUITY
You make decisions- where to invest
- how much pension to takeMost flexibilityInheritability
Least guaranteeInvestment risk
Risk of outliving capital
Inflation linkedLIFE ANNUITY
Insurer determines pension upfront
Pension guaranteed for life and to increase with inflation
No flexibilityNo inheritability
Most guaranteeNo investment risk
No risk of outliving capital
With profitsLIFE ANNUITY
Insurer determines pension upfront
Pension guaranteed for life and to increase depending on
investment performanceNo flexibility
No inheritability
Most guaranteeLittle investment risk
No risk of outliving capital
What happens to my living annuity in the event of my death?
Inherit balance
Continued pension payment
Purchase another annuity
Cash
Section 37 C allocation – Trustees decide allocation of
capital to beneficiaries
Financial dependants
Nominees
Estate
Nomination of Beneficiaries
You MUST complete the recommendation of beneficiaries under the UCTRF: complete and return form HR151
You MUST complete the nomination of beneficiaries under the separate Group Life Assurance Scheme (if you are under NRA and elected this cover on early retirement):
complete and return form HR155
Admin price increase
The current administration fee is R71.00 per month and the payment fee for eachpayment made to you is R12.76. The next review date for the payment fee is 1 July2018.
As previously advised, in order to reduce the level of cross subsidisation ofadministration fees between contributing members and Living Annuitants, theBoard of the UCTRF have agreed that the monthly administration fee for livingannuitants (excluding the payment fee) will be increased to R112.00 per month inMarch 2018. Thereafter the Board expects the administration fees to increase inline with the Administrator’s annual increase in fees.
R71 per month R112 per month
Information Resources
• UCTRF website www.uctrf.co.za
• AGM (held in the third quarter)
• Information session (held in the fourth quarter)
• Drawdown forms (fourth quarter)
• Benefit statements (first quarter)
DisclaimerThis presentation is for information purposes only.
The information contained herein is not intended to be, and must not be regarded as, financial advice or advice as defined in the Financial Advice and Intermediary Services Act (37 of 2002).
The University of Cape Town Retirement Fund (the ‘Fund’), the Fund’s Trustees, the Principal Officer and staff of the Fund, together with the Fund’s service providers, shall not be liable for any loss or harm or damage which may be suffered by any person as a result of the use or reliance upon the information presented herein, or any discussions between the aforementioned and any person arising from the presentation.
In the event of any discrepancy between the presentation and either the Rules of the Fund or the Fund’s Insurance Policies, the Rules and Policies will prevail. The Pension Funds Act 25 of 1956 overrides all Rules and Insurance Policies.
Thank you
Any Questions?