8/11/2019 UMC order

1/21

RENDERED: OCTOBER 3, 2014; 10:00 A.M.

TO BE PUBLISHED

Commonwealth of Kentucky

Court of Appeals

NO. 2013-CA-000446-MR

UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER, INC. APPELLANT

APPEAL FROM EFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT

!. HONORABLE AN"ELA MCCORMIC# BISI", UD"EACTION NO. 11-CI-00$21%

AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION

OF #ENTUC#Y, INC.; THE COURIER-

OURNAL, INC.; PATRIC# HO&IN"TON;

BELO #ENTUC#Y, INC. D'B'A' &HAS-TV;

ADAM &ALSER; AND OHN #EITH SMITH APPELLEES

OPINION

AFFIRMIN" AND REMANDIN"

(( (( (( (( ((

BEFORE: CLAYTON, COMBS, AND NIC#ELL, UD"ES.

NIC#ELL, UD"E: T)* +*/ ** / 5)*)* U/!*/ M*7/89

C**, I8. ?@*9 U/!*/ L/!/* H@/9 97 *9*7

8/11/2019 UMC order

2/21

98///* 1?/ 9 @/8 9*8 5/)/ )* 8@* #*8 O@*

R*87 A8 .2 T5 @9) )9!* ** **7 887* UMC is9

@/8 9*8. &* 9 5 )* *97 )* O/8* )* A* "**9

61.$0 et seq.

-2-

8/11/2019 UMC order

3/21

7**/9/ 5)*)* )* *+**7 *87 9* )*5/* **@

7/8* 7* #RS 61.$.

FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

&)*)* UMC / 9 @/8 9*8 @@* )* A8 9/* / )*

8* )* 7*/9 *@99* @* *87 *+*?)* A*/89 C/!/

L/*/* U/ #*8, I8. 97 P9/8 H5/, 9 *@*

The Courier-Journal, ) ) /9/ 9 9 @@*7 ** *5**

ULH, C9)/8 H*9)89* I//9/!*, 97 *5/)'S. M9 H@/9 S*

8*9* 9 9*5/7* *5 )*9)89* @!/7*; &HAS *@* A79 &9*

) /9/ 9 UMC *-*@/ 9 !/9/ 7* )* A/-

#/898 S9*, 42 U.S.C. K 13209-$, S9 L95, 42 U.S.C. K 13%; 97

#*/) S/) ) /9/ 9 8)9* / UMC // @98/8*. C//

9 2006 OA" @//?#. O@. A. "*. 06-ORD-210?UMC 7*/*7 9

*+* 89// / 59 9 @/8 9*8, 97 )***, 59 *8 )*

A8, *89* / 7/7 7*/!* G)* 7

*@*7*7 / / )* C5*9) #*8 9* 89 9)/

7.= #RS 61.$01>)>. I 7*/ )* *+*, UMC 7/7 9* 9

**@/ 9/ 7/8* 7* #RS 61.$.

P9 #RS 61.0, &HAS, The Courier-Journal97 )*

ACLU, 9 9@@*9*7 )* OA"; UMC 9@@*9*7 )* S/)3*+*. O O8*

6, 2011, )* OA" *7**7 9 @// )* ACLU 9@@*9?#. O@. A. "*.

3 S/) 7/7 9@@*9 / )* 9@@*9.

-3-

8/11/2019 UMC order

4/21

11-ORD-1$?)7/ UMC / 9 @/8 9*8 7* #RS 61.$01>> *89* /

59 )> 7* / 7/ 8*. D**/ 11-ORD-1$ *

7/@//!*, )* OA" /*7/9* /*7 @// / )* )** )* 9@@*9

*98)/ )* 9* 88/?UMC is9 @/8 9*8 7* / /*9*. #.

O@. A. "*. 11-ORD-1; #. O@. A. "*. 11-ORD-1%; 97, #. O@. A.

"*. 11-ORD-160.

T)**9*, UMC /*7 9 8/79*7 9@@*9 9 2011 OA"

@// / )* ** C/8/ C. C-/ 9 7*

5** /*7. C// #RS 61.0>9>, )* 8/8/ 8 887*7 7* )* @*

*87 *+*, UMC * )* 7* @!/ / 59 9 @/8 9*8,

9*9/!*, )* *+**7 78* 5** **@ @78/ 7* )*

A8.

A 9 9*, )* 8/8/ 8 @*8//89 /+/*7 )5

C/ D/*84*!/ UMC B97 D/*8 57 * *@98*7 /

4 B*5** /* 97 5*!* C/ D/*8, /9* **8*7 9 9/ UMC

*/* 97, *!* 9**7, **59* )**-*9 *. UL *@**, ** 97 /8*

-4-

8/11/2019 UMC order

5/21

)* *!* 9 ?5)/8), 9* 9 89 7/*8/!* / UMC A/8* I8@9/

?57 95 *9// 7/*8, *!* )) )* 7/7 8/* 9 +,

/ 9 7/*8 !9898/* 9/ !*?) 95/ UL 9@@/ 9

89 *!* 9 C/ D/*8, 89

8/11/2019 UMC order

6/21

)* C/ D/*8 / / 7/8*/. A77//9, )* 8/8/ 8 *7

UL 87 /* 9 97 98/ 8/ )* // 9 /* C/

D/*8 !9898, )** /*/ #RS 2$1B.-1001>8> 97 *9/ UL

9* 9 C/ D/*8 / 8)/8*.

&)/* 7**// UMC 59 8*9*7 97 *9/)*7 9 @/8

9*8 9 9 7* #RS 61.$01>>? 9)* 59 8*9*7 5 @/!9*

)*9)89* @!/7*?)* 8/8/ 8 )*7 UMC / *)** 9 @/8 9*8

7* #RS 61.$01>/>, *89* 8/ )* /9/ @8* 97

9@@/* C/ D/*8, UL?/* 9 @/8 9*8 7* #RS

#RS C)9@* 2$1 @*9/ @/!9* 8@9/ 97 98/9/, 5)/8) UMC 9/9/89 9@@ / /8* / / 9 @/ 8@9/. A)) */*7 )* /9 8,

#RS 2$3.2131> 9)/J* )* 9* * / )* 8* 9 @/ 8@9/.

-6-

8/11/2019 UMC order

7/21

61.$01>>?8 9@@/* UMC */* B97 D/*8.6 I

*@9// / /, )* 8/8/ 8 5*,

UL 8 !* )* **8/ C/

D/*8 9 de facto@5* 9@@/* !*

)* C/ D/*8. &)* 8/*7 5/) UL

+*/*7 @5* 9@@/* )* U/!*/

D/*8, )/ *9 )9 )* 9/ 97 / 98

6 &* +* 9/* @/ UMC *!***-@9* 9*7*7 95 9 9@@!*7 99

2%, 200.

ARTICLE IV

BOARD OF DIRECTORS

S*8/ 4.01 P5* 97 N* D/*8. A 8@9*

@5* )9 * **8/*7 7* )* 9)/ , 97 )*/* 97 99/ )* C@9/ )9 * 99*7 7* )*7/*8/ , )* B97 D/*8, *8 9 //9/ *

) / )* C@9/ A/8* I8@9/. U@ )*

97@/ )** A*7*7 97 R*9*7 B95, )* B97 )98/ *!*** 1$> !/ 7/*8.

S*8/ 4.02 C@// 97 9//89/.

9> T)* C)9/9 )* B97 )* )9 * )*

@* **8*7 97 *!/ 9 P*/7* )* U/!*/

L/!/* )* )/ 7*/**. T)* C)9/9)9 * 9 * /8/, !/ ** )* B97 D/*8

97 )9 9@@/ 9 // 4> 97 9 9/

*!* $> 977//9 7/*8, * 5) )9 * )* D*9 )* U/!*/ M*7/89 S8), 9)* 5) )9 *

)* U/!*/ E*8/!* V/8* P*/7* H*9) A9/,

9)* 5) )9 * )* 8)9/ * )* 8//897*@9* )* U/!*/ M*7/89 S8), 97 9)*

5) )9 * 9 ** )* U/!*/ L/!/* B97

T** )* . T)* *9//

7/*8 )* )9 8/ *)9 /* %> 97 * )9 5*!* 12> 8/ *97*

5) )9!* 7*9*7 9 /** / )*9) 89* /*,

@!/7*7 )9 * 8) C/ D/*8 /> )9 */8*, 7/*8 *@** 9 */ 5)/8) 8@**

5/) )* 8@9/ 5/)/ )* L/!/* M*@/9

S9//89 A*9 , //> )9 * 9 **, /8* *@** )* U/!*/ L/!/*. T)* 7**/9/

5)*)* 9 /** C/ D/*8

8/11/2019 UMC order

8/21

*/*> UMC !*/ 7 / 9@@/*7 9

@/8 9*8. U7* #RS K 61.$01>/>, )/ 9*

UMC 9 @/8 9*8 *8 )* O@* R*87 A8.

T)* *879 +*/?5)*)* )* *+**7 *87 9* **@

7/8*?59 * 95**7 / UMC 9 9 9 @/8 9*8 )9 **

*!*7. T)* 8/8/ 8 /@*7 98/ UMC 97 9597*7

)* D/*8, 5)* 7*8// )9 * /9 97 *8

9@@*9. D/*8 **7 * */7* )* C5*9)

#*8. T)* N/9/ C/** )9 *7*9! *8*7 )* D/*8 897/79* C/

D/*8 5) *@** )* 97 9* 7/!*/ 5/)/

)* 8/. T)* U/!*/ D/*8 97 )* C/

D/*8 9* */* *98) ***7 9 9 .

> T)* * /8* )* C)9/9 / )* / )* P*/7* )*U/!*/> )9 * 8**/!* 5/) )/ * 9 P*/7*

)* U/!*/. I )* C)9/9 / ** )* )9 )*

P*/7* )* U/!*/, )* )* )9 *!* 9 )* @*9* )* P*/7* )* U/!*/. T)* *9// 16 **

)* B97 D/*8 )9 * 7/!/7*7 / )** @,

7*/9*7 9 "@ I, "@ II 97 "@ III. E98) "@)9 8@/* 9 8/9/ C/ D/*8 97

U/!*/ D/*8, / */ @!/7*7 )9 C/

D/*8 )9 8/* 9 9/ *98) "@. D/*8

)9 * /7*//*7 9 "@ )* C)9/9. "@ I7/*8 )9 * 9@@/*7 9 ///9 * 5 *9 97,

9 )* *@/9/ )* ///9 *, "@ I 7/*8 )9 *

**8*7 9@@/*7 88*/!* )** *9 *. "@ II7/*8 )9 * 9@@/*7 9 ///9 * )** *9

97, 9 )* *@/9/ )* ///9 *, "@ II 7/*8

)9 * **8*7 9@@/*7 88*/!* )** *9 *."@ III 7/*8 )9 * 9@@/*7 9 ///9 *

*9 97, 9 )* *@/9/ )* ///9 *, "@ III

7/*8 )9 * **8*7 9@@/*7 88*/!* )** *9

*.

. . .

S*8/ 4.04 R*!9 D/*8. A D/*8, )* )9 )*

C)9/9 97 9 *-/8/ **, 9 9 9 /* * *!*7

/8*, 5/) 5/) 89*, 9 9/ !* )*U/!*/ D/*8 97 )* C/ D/*8, !/

89, @ 5/* /8* 7*/!**7 )* 7/*8 97 )*

C@9/. . . .

--

8/11/2019 UMC order

9/21

9* **, /7/ UMC */*7 / 7 9/) )* OA" @/ )7/ )9

UMC 59 9 @/8 9*8 97 )** 59 /7/89/ 97 9/) / UMC

7*/9 )* @* *87 *+*.

T)* 8/8/ 8 7**7 UMC @!/7* )* *+**7 *87 )*

8 in camera /@*8/ 9 5/) 9 /* *@99/ 9 9@@/89*

S*8/ 4.06 V9898/*. I )* *!* 9 !9898 88 / )*

/8* 9 7/*8 7* 7*9), */9/, *!9 )*5/*,)* !9898 )9 * /*7, / )* 89* 9 U/!*/ D/*8,

)* P*/7* )* U/!*/, / )* 89* 9 C/

D/*8, )* B97 D/*8 * * 897/79*

/9*7 )* N/9/ C/**G. . . .

S*8/ 4.10 . A 9/ )* B97 *87/A7!/ D/*8>, * )9 )9 5) 9* C/D/*8, )9 8/* 9 + )* B97. I 9 + /

@** 9 9 **/ )* B97, 9 98/ 9* 9 8) **/

)9 * )* 98 )* B97. I )* 9*8* 9 +, )*B97 ** @**, 9 9/ !*, 9 97 )*

**/ 9)* 79*, /* 97 @98*. . . .

S*8/ 4.1 C)/* E*8/!* O/8* U/!*/ L/!/*

H@/9. T)* C)/* E*8/!* O/8* U/!*/ L/!/*

H@/9 )9 * )* P*/7* )* C@9/ 97 9 *-

/8/, -!/ ** )* B97. . . .

ARTICLE VI

COMMITTEES

S*8/ 6.01 C/** "**9.

A. T)* B97 9 8*9* 8/**, *98) 8// )**

3> * !/ 7/*8 97 8) )* @* 9 )*

B97 9 7**/*, *!* 9 )* @*9* )* B97;@!/7*7 )9 * )9 )9 )* 8/** **)/@

8@*7 !/ B97 ** )9 * C/

D/*8. E8*@ 9 )*5/* @!/7*7 / )** B95,9@@/* 8) 8/** )9 * )* C)9/9.

. . .

D. A 9/ )* ** 9 8/** 5) 9*

C/ D/*8 )9 8/* 9 + )*

998/ /* 9 9 **/ 8) 8/**.

-%-

8/11/2019 UMC order

10/21

**@/ 7* )* A8. I F*9 2013, )* 8/8/ 8 9*7*7 )*

F/7/ F98, C8/ L95 97 O7* ***7 N!** 21, 2012,

/87* )* **8*, 8/ )* C)9/9, * U/!*/ D/*8 97)** C/ D/*8. T)* E*8/!* C/** )9 )9!*

97 9 **8/* 9 )* 9)/ )* B97, )9 )9!* )* 9)/ )* B97 / ***8* 9*7/, 9*/, *@*9/ )* B-L95; **8/, 9*/ *!/ 9

** )9 C/** 9 7/*8 /8* )*

C@9/; 9*7/ *9/ )* A/8* I8@9/;97@/ 9 @9 **, 97@/ 9 @9 8/79/,

5/) 9)* C@9/; 9)/J/ )* 9*, *9*, *8)9*

9* 9/9 9 )* @@* 97 9* )*C@9/; 9)/J/ )* !9 7// )*

C@9/, *!/ @8**7/ )***; 97@/ 9 @9

)* 7/// )* 9* )* C@9/ 9*7/,

9*/, *@*9/ 9 R*/ )* B97 5)/8) /* @!/7* )9 / )9 * 9*7*7, 9**7 *@*9*7

8) C/**; 7/ 9 )* 98 /77* 95 )*

A/8* I8@9/.

S*8/ 6.03 N/9/ C/**. T)* N/9/ C/**

)9 8/ )* C)9/9, 5) )9 *!* 9 C)9/9 )*C/**, * U/!*/ D/*8 97 5 C/

D/*8. T)* N/9/ C/** )9 **8 97

*8*7 )* D/*8 897/79* **8/ 9 C/

D/*8 97 // !9898/* / 9 D/*8)/@ 97 /8* )* B97 )* )9 )* C)9/9> 97 )*

C@9/.

ARTICLE VII

OFFICERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS

. . .

-10-

8/11/2019 UMC order

11/21

I )* /** 89/ 97 8@***, 5* @!/7* 9 /*

)//89 @*@*8/!* )5 UMC 89* / */. F 1%3 / 1%%, ULH

59 99*7 H99 V///9, I8. . &)* H99 **7

5/) C/9'H@/9 A*/89, 97 !*7 / )*97+9* N9)!/*,

T****, UL 97 )* C5*9) #*8?/ * 1%%?8)*

*/9* H99 *9* 97 9//9/ 9*** 97 ** 9 *5

@*9'99* ULH.

I 9/8/@9/ UL 97 )* C5*9) // 9 *+*

@@9 9 */ @*9* 97 99* ULH, )* P*/7*

S*8/ $.03 C)9/9 )* B97 D/*8. T)* C)9/9)9:

A. B*, 9 9 /*, )* // P*/7* )* U/!*/ )/7*/**;

B. S*!* 9 9 *-/8/, !/ 7/*8 )* B97;

C. P*/7* 9 9 **/ )* B97;

D. P!/7* *97*)/@ )* B97 97 / 8/** /

9/ 7*!*@/, 97 *!99/ 8@9* @/8/*97 9 97 ** 8) @/8/* 97 9 9* 8/*

5/) )* A/8* I8@9/;

E. E* )9 )** / 9@@@/9* 8/89/ *5**

)* B97 97 8@9* 9, )* B97 D/*8 97**8/!* 9, @)/8/9 97 97//9/!* 97 )*

@**;

F. C9 @*8/9 **/ )* B97;

". E9/) )* 9*79 9 B97 **/; 97

H. P* 8) )* 7/* 9 9* 89 9 B97

C)9/9 9/*7 )* B97 97 /8/*

5/) )* A/8*, )** B95, )* A//9/A***.

. . .

-11-

8/11/2019 UMC order

12/21

*5/) H@/9 H*9)89* S*!/8* 97 A/9 H*9) S*, I8.

5 5 9 N H*9)89* 97 ***7 )**/ 9 98)*7

UMC. T)/ *5 @/ #*8 */ 59 /8@9*7 * 2$, 1%%, /

)@* */ 8)* @*9* 97 99* ULH; @!/7* *7/89 89* @*@*

/ **7;

8/11/2019 UMC order

13/21

I 2006, )* OA" 59 9*7 5)*)* UMC )97 !/9*7 )* A8

7*/ 9 @* *87 *+* 9 @9/* /* 5/ 9 9 988/7*. O

O8* 20, 2006, 99J/ UMC 8* 7* #RS 61.$01>)>, )* OA"

/*7 9 @// /7/ UMC 59 not 9 @/8 9*8 *89* / 7/7 *8*/!*

9 *9 5*-/!* @*8* )* 7/ / @* / #*8 9* 97 89

9)/ 7. 06-ORD-210. T)* @// 59 9@@*9*7. T)***, 7*

#RS 61.0>>, / )97

8/11/2019 UMC order

14/21

95. T )9!* 9 +, 9 9/ )* 7/*8 * @**, 97 )*

9/ )* @** * C/ D/*8. A 7/*8?*8*@ )*

8)9/?9 * *!*7 = 8/9/ 97 /*9 +9/ 9 /*7>. S@*8//89,

)* OA" */*!* UL *9/)*7, 8*9*7 97 8 UMC. B9*7 )*

)/ UMC, 5* 7/9**.

I / 7/@*7 )9 )* P*/7* *5/) 97 N?5 @/!9*

/7/!/79 *97/ 5 @/!9* )*9)89* @!/7*?8*9*7 UMC. T)*/ !//

/ */9/J*7 / )* A/8* I8@9/ )* 9* **8*7 * 22,

-14-

8/11/2019 UMC order

15/21

1%%. T)* *

)9!* *7 U/!*/ M*7/89 C**, I8. UMC>, 9

--@/ / !**, @*9* )* U/!*/

L/!/* H@/9 97 *9*7 98///* ULH>.

A9/, )* 98 */*7 9* *5/) 97 A/9, N @*7*8*.

T)* 98 )9 *5/) 97 N 98*7 9 UL / 97 / **/, 7*

9* UL * UMC 8*9.

I /*@*/ 9 9* *9/, 5* 9@@ )*

8/11/2019 UMC order

16/21

G9 97, 8//, 8/**, 8/**, 97

)8 8/**, 97!/ 8/**, 88/, 9*8,

*8*@ 9 8/** 9 )@/9 *7/89 9,

established created and controlled by a public a%ency

9 7*/*7 / @999@) 9>, >, 8>, 7>, *>, >, >, )>,

/>, > )/ *8/G.

GE@)9/ 977*7. &)/* / / !/ UL 59 /*9 / UMC 8*9/,

/ * 59 9 9 //9 97 **/8/9, */)* 5)/8) 9* UMC 9

@/8 9*8. UL 7/7 *8* 9 ** UMC / afterUMC )97 **

/8@9*7 97 59 99/ ULH.

T * *, )** / @* *!/7*8*UL 8 ULH, UMC

@*9* 97 99* ULH. T)9 / @// /9@@@/9* /8* ULH

59 7**7*7 UL / 1%$%. A 9 7 *597 )/ 8//89 @/8 9*?

5)/8) )9@@* * UL @/* *7/89 *98)/ 7?/ / 88/9 )9

UL )9!* ///89 /@ / ULH 8/ 97 @*9/. T)* OA" *+9*

)/

8/11/2019 UMC order

17/21

T @@ / @*/*, )* A* "**9 */* )*9!/

&niversity of 'ouisville #oundation Inc. v. Cape (ublications Inc. 2003 &L

22$426 #. A@@. 2003> 2002-CA-001%0-MR>, 9 @/)*7 7*8//

7*89/ )* UL F79/ * 9 @/8 9*8 *89* / 59 8*9*7 97

*9/)*7 UL B97 T**, 98/ / )*/ /8/9 89@98//* 5)/*

UL 59 9 /8/@9 /!*/ @*@9/ *8* 9 9* ///. A

@9* )/ C 887*7 )* 7*/// > 59 97 *) *8@9 9 /8/@9 /!*/.

&* *9/ 7///) 8*9/ 97 *9/)* )* UL

F79/ 8*9/ 97 *9/)* UMC. T)* F79/ 59 8*9*7

97 *9/)*7 ** UL B97 T**

8/11/2019 UMC order

18/21

&* 5 )* /9 8 88/?)9 UMC / 9 @/8

9*8 7* #RS 61.$01>/> *89* UL, /* 9 @/8 9*8, 9@@/ 9

9/ UMC B97 D/*8. U7* )* 8* 95, )* B97 )9 9

9/ *!***%!/ 7/*8, 5) * )9 *!* 9 *

U/!*/ D/*8 9@@/*7 UL P*/7*, 97 9 9/ 5*!*

9 * C/ D/*8 **8*7 )* B97 9* /9/ 9 -

** N/9/ C/**. UL?5 UMC * ** /8* / 9*7

*5/) 97 N *!* /* 5/) UMC / 200$?)9 8@** 8 !*

5) *!* 9 9 U/!*/ D/*8 *89* )* 9@@/* 9* 97*

UL P*/7*.

T)* 9 /* 5/) )* 9@@/* U/!*/ D/*8,

5/) )* * )* N/9/ C/** 97 / 8 5) 5/ *

8/7**7 **8/ 9 9 C/ D/*8. UL P*/7* 8)9/ )*

N/9/ C/**. H* 8)* * U/!*/ D/*8 97 5 C/

D/*8 *!* )* N/9/ C/**. I / )/) /* UL

P*/7* 57 95 ** 9!9* UL * /9*7 9 9

C/ D/*8. I 98, UL P*/7* 89 ** 9!9*

897/79* / *!* 8/7**7 *89* )* 8 )* B97 9*79 97 )97@/8

)* ** )* N/9/ C/**. &)/* C/ D/*8 9*

7/*8 9@@/*7 UL, / 9 @*/9 897/79* 89 * 8/7**7 97

% T)* 8/8/ 8 @// 9* )* 97 )9 9 9/ /** 7/*8, )/ //8/* 5/) )* 95 @!/7*7 5)/8) 9*, !/ 7/*8.=

-1-

8/11/2019 UMC order

19/21

/9* @@*7 )* B97 )* N/9/ C/**, )*')* 89 *

**8*7 )* */* B97. T), 5)/* UL 9 8 )* 9 , /

8*9 8 )* @9) )* 9. A 9*7 )* 8/8/ 8,

G*89* )* 8/** )9 ** 97

*+/* 9 9/ 9@@!9 @** 9 /** )*UMC 97, 97 *89* UL 9* 8 5

)* !*, 897/79* 9 C/ 7/*8

!9898 9 * @***7 )* UMC 97 5/) )*

9@@!9 U L.

&* /7 )/ 99/ * @*9/!* 97 7/8* *. Medley 16

S.&.37 3%.

&)/* 5* 9* //*7 )* 8/8/ 8 *@9/ )5 *5

C/ D/*8 57 * 9*7 / )* *!* 9

8/11/2019 UMC order

20/21

)* *5 C/ D/*8 57 * ?*!* ))

)* 57 8*9 * )97@/8*7 UL. T), 5* 7 7** )* 8/8/

8

8/11/2019 UMC order

21/21

BRIEFS FOR APPELLANT:

P)//@ &. C/*

B*)9 A. B**J

L/!/*, #*8

M9 R. O!***

F9, #*8

BRIEF FOR APPELLEE,

AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES

UNION OF #ENTUC#Y:

&//9 E. S)9@

L/!/*, #*8

BRIEF FOR APPELLEES, THE

COURIER-OURNAL, INC.,

PATRIC# HO&IN"TON, BELO

#ENTUC#Y, INC. AND ADAM

&ALSER:

L. F*/8)9*

** S. R*

L/!/*, #*8

BRIEF FOR APPELLEE, OHN#EITH SMITH:

N /* /*7.