+ All Categories
Home > Documents > UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady...

UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady...

Date post: 23-May-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 2 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
99
UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 DEFENSE DOCUMENTATION CENTER FOR SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL INFORMATION CAMERON STATION. ALEXANDRIA, VIRGINIA UNCLASSIFIED
Transcript
Page 1: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

UNCLASSIFIED

AD 445924

DEFENSE DOCUMENTATION CENTERFOR

SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL INFORMATION

CAMERON STATION. ALEXANDRIA, VIRGINIA

UNCLASSIFIED

Page 2: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

NOTICE: When government or other dravings, speci-fications or other data are used for any purposeother than in connection with a definitely relatedgovernment procurement operation, the U. S.Government thereby incurs no responsibility, nor anyobligation whatsoever; and the fact that the Govern-ment may have foralated, furnished, or in any waysupplied the said drawings, specifications, or otherdata is not to be regarded by implication or other-wise as in any manner licensing the holder or anyother person or corporation, or conveying any rightsor pezrission to manufacture, use or sell anypatented invention that may in any way be relatedthereto.

Page 3: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

REPORT NO.

SD-TDR-62-75 TDR-1 69(3230-11 )TN-2

-AC

91

Aerodynamic Influence Coefficients

from Piston Theory:

Analytical Development

and Computational Procedure

15 AUGUST 1962

Prepared by WILLIAM P RODDEN and EDITH F FARKAS

Aeromechanics Department

Aerodynamics and Propulsion Research Laboratory

and

cy.. , HEATHER A. MALCOM and ADAM M. KLISZEWSKI

C Computation and Data Processing Center

Laboratories Division

Prepared for COMMANDER SPACE SYSTEMS DIVISION

UNITED STATES AIR FORCE

Inglewood, California

LABORATORIES DIVISION * \ )>I'\(I ( ' )1I1 \ 1,,DDC CONTRACT NO. AF 04(695)-169

Page 4: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

Report No.SSD-TDR-62-75 TDR- 169(3230- 11 )TN-Z

AERODYNAMIC INFLUENCE COEFFICIENTS FROM

PISTON THEORY: ANALYTICAL DEVELOPMENT

AND COMPUTATIONAL PROCEDURE

Prepared by

William P. Rodden and Edith F. FarkasAeromechanics Department

Aerodynamics and Propulsion Research Laboratory

and

Heather A. Malcom and Adam M. KliszewskiComputation and Data Processing Center

Laboratories Division

I

AEROSPACE CORPORATIONEl Segundo, California

Contract No. AF 04(695)-169

15 August 196Z

Prepared for

COMMANDER SPACE SYSTEMS DIVISIONUNITED STATES AIR FORCE

Inglewood, California

J

2 730

Page 5: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

Report No.

SSD-TDR-6Z-75 TDR-169(3z30-11)TN-z

AERODYNAMIC INFLUENCE COEFFICIENTS FROM

PISTON THEORY: ANALYTICAL DEVELOPMENT

AND COMPUTATIONAL PROCEDURE

Approved by /

J. 9' Logan, Di'rect6rA rodynamics and PropulsionResearch Laboratory

B.A. TroeschDepartment Head,Computation and DataProcessing Center

AEROSPACE CORPORATIONEl Segundo, California

Page 6: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

ABSTRACT

In this report we present method for calculating the aerodynamic

influence coefficients (AICs) based on third-order piston theory with an

optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order

theory. The AICs are computed assuming the airfoil to have a rigid chord

with or without a (rigid chord) control surface. The influence coefficients

relate the surface deflections to the aerodynamic forces rough the following

definitions.'Inthe oscillatory case,

IF1 = w-ZbZs[C1f[ ] r r h i

and in the steady case,

1Ff (1/2)PV 2 (S/) [Chs] h/

The piston theory is limited to high Mach number (or high reduced frequency),

but Van Dyke's quasi-steady correction extends the validity to some lower

supersonic Mach number at low reduced frequency.K.

/The Acrospace IBM 7090 Computer Program umber HMll provides

the AICs from this theory in both a printed and an optional punched-card

output format. The program capacity is 25 surface strips, 15 Mach numbers,

and 20 reduced velocities for each Mach numberI -

iii

Page 7: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

!CONTENTS

ABSTRA CT ....................................... 1ii

SYM BO LS . ... ... ... ... . ..... ... .. ... ... ... .. .... .

I. FORMULATION OF PROBLEM ..................... 1

A . Introduction ............................... 1B. Sign Convention ............................. 1C. Derivation of Equations ....... 1 . ............... 2D . References ... ...................... ...... 20

II. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF INPUT ................... 21

A . U nits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . 21

B. Classes of Numerical Data and Limitations ............ 21

III. DATA DECK SETUP ............................. 24

A. Loading Order ............................. 24B. Input Data Description ......................... 25C. Example Keypunch Forms ..................... 28

IV. PROGRAM OUTPUT . . ................................ 2

A. Printed Output ............................. 32B. Punched Output ............................ 47

V. PROCESSING INFORMATION ....................... 48

A . Operation ................ ............... 48B. Estimated Machine Time ........................ 48C. Machine Components Used ..................... 48

VI. PROGRAM NOTES . .............................. 49

A . Subroutines ............................... 49B. Generalized Tapes'........................... 49

VII. FLOW DIAGRAM ............................... 50

VIII. SYMBOLIC LISTING ............................. 51

iv

Page 8: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

ISYMBOLS

a Ambient speed of sound0

b Local semichord

b Reference semichordr

Ch Element of oscillatory aerodynamic influence coefficientmatrix

Chs Element of steady aerodynamic influence coefficient matrix

C Coefficients in expressions for pressure coefficientn

C Pressure coefficientP

c Local chord

c Control surface chorda

c Mean aerodynamic chord

d Distance between forward and aft control points

F Cont::ol point force

g Airfc U1 semithickness

gx SloF, of airfoil, gx = dg/dx

h Vertical deflection

I ,i JThickness integralsn n C

K Coefficients in expressions for oscillatory aerodynamicn coefficients

k Local reduced frequency, k = wb/V

k Reference reduced frequencyr

L h , L a , LPo Oscillatory leading edge lift coefficients

hv

0 ~o

V9

Page 9: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

IL Lift referred to leading edge motion

0

M Free stream Mach number

M h 0M ,MPo Oscillatory leading edge pitching moment coefficientso o 0

M Pitching moment about leading edge referred to leading edge. 0 motion

p -Surface pressure; p0 is ambient pressure

q Free stream dynamic pressure

rh, rt Ratios of hinge-line and trailing-edge thicknesses tomaximum thickness, respectively

S Wing area

s Wing semispan

Th ,T ,T Oscillatory leading edge hinge moment coefficientsO 0

To Hinge moment referred to leading edge motion

t Airfoil maximum thicknessmax

V Free stream velocity

V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

v Unsteady component of downwash velocity

w Downwash velocity

x Chordwise coordinate; x 0 is coordinate of pitching axis; xmis coordinate of maximum thickness point; xh is coordinateof hinge line

a Angle of attack; a is initial angle of attack0

P Control surface incidence; also, p = (M 2 - 1)1/2

y Specific heat ratio of air, y = 1. 400

Ay Strip width

vi

Page 10: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

!A Leading edge sweep angle

Dimensionless chordwise coordinate, = x/c

p Free stream density

T,Th T t Airfoil thickness ratios at point of maximum thickness,hinge line, and trailing edge, respectively

Circular frequency

(-) Bar denotes term depends on flow characteristics normal toleading edge

[ ] Square matrix

Column matrix

vii

Page 11: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

ISECTION I

FORMULATION OF THE PROBLEM

A. Introduction

The pressure on a lifting surface is normally given by a surface

functional relationship. However, in the limit of a high Mach number (or

high reduced frequency), this relationship becomes a point function. As a

consequence of this limit, aerodynamic influence coefficients (AICs) may be

specilied exactly by a strip theory, and control surface and camber effects

may be determined in a straightforward manner.

The present formulation derives the AICs from third-order piston

theory for a lifting surface with control surface (both assumed rigid in the

chordwise direction; i. e. , no camber is presently considered). The deriva-

tion differs only slightly from that of Ashley and Zartarian in that in the

present case the third-order pressure coefficient is generalized to account

for sweep and steady angle of attack, and, following a suggestion of Morgan,2

Huckel, and Runyan, a correction (optional) is suggested to give agreement3.-

with the second-order quasi-steady supersonic theory of Van Dyke. This

quasi-steady correction should extend the validity of the piston theory to

lower supersonic Mach numbers at low reduced frequencies. The derivation

given here is taken from Ref. 4; further, the computational aspects of the

present report are an extension of the computing procedure of Ref. 4.

B. Sign Convention

The flutter sign convention is used in the oscillatory case: forces and

deflections are positive down; rotations are positive with leading edge up.

The aerodynamic sign convention is used in the steady case: forces and

deflections are positive up; rotations are positive with leading edge up.

Page 12: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

C. Derivation of EquationsS 5

We quote here the development of Miles 5in obtaining the piston theory

pressure coefficient There are t _A=noLinterest. Th firs assumes

that the angle of attack is small enough that there are pressu perturbations

on the expansion side of the surface. The( second assumes that the angle of

attack is large, and that the expansion pressure approaches a vacuum and is

ineffective-in producing perturbations. Because of the difficulty in specifying

the transition from low to high angle of attack, we shall restrict the present

consideration to the first case, the low angle of attack.

'Hayes' hypersonic approximation states that any plane slab of fluid

initially perpendicular to the undisturbed flow may be assumed to remain so2

as it is swept downstream and to move in its own plane under the laws of

one-dimensional, unsteady motion. Thus, the problem of a wing haygn

arbires -otion ngrmal to its surface may be reduced to the

consideration of the ope,.direinlal motion of a piston into an otherwise

undisturbed flq~w. This problem is relatively simple if the disturbances

produced by the piston are treated as simple waves, for then the pressure

on the piston depends only on the instantaneous velocity there, w. and is

given by

P/P [ + (1/2) (y-l) (W/ao)] Z0/(N-i) (1)

where p0 and a are the values of pressure and sonic velocity in the

undisturbed flow.

"The result, Eq. (1), is exact for an expansion, but the presence of a

shock front(and consequent departure from isentropic flow) renders it only ap-

proximate for a compression. Lighthill has suggested a cubic approximation

Page 13: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

Ito be adequate for practical application if lw/a 0 < 1. The series expansion

yields

P/po = 1+ -y(w/a 0 ) + (1/4) y(-y + 1) (w/a 0 )2

3+ (1112) -y(-y + 1)(w/a o) (2)

Lighthill has shown that this expression, Eq. (2), is within six percent of the

value given by either Eq. (1) or the exact solution with the shock at maximum

permissible strength. ,5

The pressure coefficient C = (p - Po)/q is found from Eq. (2) after2

noting that q = (-/Z) p 0 M

Cp = (2/M) [(w/a) + (1/4) (-y + 1) (w/a)2

+ (1)y( + 1) (w/ao) ] (3)

Following a suggestion of Morgan, Huckel, and Runyan, 2 we may generalize

this result, Eq. (3), by writing

Cp = (Z/M ) [ C1 (w/ao) + C 2 (w/ao)2 + C 3 (w/a ) 3 (4)

in which for piston theory

C 1 = 1, C 2 = (-Y + 1)/4, C 3 = (Y + 1)/1Z (5)

and for the quasi-steady theory of Van Dyke 3

C1 - Mfp, C2 [M 4 (Y.+ l)-4p ]/4P4 , C 3 = (+ 1)/1 (6)

3

Page 14: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

IVan Dyke gives only the second-order solution so that the value of C 3 is

taken from the piston theory result. The use of the modified coefficients C

and C 2 could extend the lower Mach number limit of piston theory.

We may now calculate the lifting pressure coefficient from Eq. (4) and

the local piston velocity. The normal velocity (positive away from the

surface) on the upper and lower surfaces of a symmetrical thin airfoil having

thickness distribution Zg(x) and angle of attack a is given by

Wu = V (gx - a0 - v) , (7a)

w I = V (gx +a 0 +V) (7b)

where v is the unsteady component of the dimensionless downwash.

For the case of small angles of attack, the lifting pressure (positive

down) is

Cp = CPU - = -( 4/M) [(C1 + 2c2Mgx

+ 3C3M E ) (a° + v) + C3M (a° + v)3 (8)

If, consistent with the small perturbation assumptions of aeroelastic analysis,

only the terms linear in v are retained, Eq. (8) becomes

C =-(4v/M) [C + ZC Mg + 3c MZ(g2 + a (9)p 2Mg, 3 3

2 g x )]

Before discussing the swept wing transformation, it is appropriate to

review the limitations of Eq. (9). Ashley and Zartarian I have shown that the

piston theory is applicable if any of the conditions M > > 1, Mk >> 1, or

4

Page 15: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

9k > > I is met. We see that for low reduced frequency the Mach number

necessarily must be high. However, if the reduced frequency is large the

Mach number is not necessarily large; in fact it could be transonic or even

subsonic. At this point it is apparent that any sweep correction introduced

to bring piston theory into line with linearized supersonic theory must be

considered as a low frequency approximation.

The result, Eq. (9), applies to the swept wing case if all quantities are

determined by the flow characteristics normal to the leading edge. The

expressions may be rewritten in the form

(4V/Vi) [" 1 + ?,r Ni- + 3M + vo)]Z (10)

The transformation from the normal values to the free stream values are the

following:

the Mach number

= M cos A (Ila)

the geometryx = x cos A (lib)

'G= b cos A (llc)

the angles of attack and slope

a = a /cos A (lId)

= p/cos A (Ile)

9- = gx/cosA (lf)

the dynamic pressure

- 2q = q cos A (llg)

5

Page 16: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

!and the pressure coefficient

C C Cos A (llh)P P

We note that h and k are invariant. From the dimensionless downwash

v = (I/V) 1+ va + (x - Xo) a

+ [VP + (x - x h)PI 1(x - Xh) (12)

whic4 for harmonic motion becomes

v = ikh/b + [ 1 + i(k/b) (x - x ) a

+ 1 + i(k/b) (x - Xh)] (x -xh) (13)

we find the transformed value

v = ikh/S + [1 + i(k/'S) (x - ox .

+ [1 + i(k/) (x - Xh)]l (x - (14a)

= ikh/b cos A + [1 + i(k/b) (x - x ) c/cos A

+ [1 + i(k/b) (x - x h) (pIcos A) I(x -x h ) (14b)

= v/cos A (14c)

Page 17: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

The transformed pressure coefficient becomes

C p p cos 2 A = [-4(v/cos A) cos 2 A /M cos A]p p

X T 1 + 2Zz(M cos A) (gx/cos A)

+ 3C 3 (M cosA) 2 (gz + a)/cos A] (15a)

-(4v/M)[[ +2 2Mg + 3 2CM (gx + a2 (15b)1 2 x 3 3 g+ 0 )

We note that the sweep effect shows up only in the coefficients C and _C 2

'for piston theory, there is no effect

S-C = 1, U z = c = (y + 1)/4 , (16)

and for the quasi-steady supersonic theory

I = M/(M - sec ZA)I/

2 = [M4 (- + l)-4 sec 2 A(M? - sec 2 A)]I[4(M - sec z A) z (17)

Equation (17) is seen to be the most general result. If sec A is taken

as zero then the piston theory results, Eqs. (16), are obtained; and if sec A

is taken as unity the sweep correction is not made in the quasi-steady super-

sonic result.

We next consider the integration of the pressure coefficients obtained

above. The oscillatory aerodynamic coefficients referred to the leading edge

are defined by the following equations,

7

Page 18: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

9dL/dy = 4pw b 3Lh ho/b + Lao a + Lpo (18a)

dM/dy= 4pw b4(Mhoho/b +M ao a+ Mo (18b)

dT/dy= 4p2 b (Th o h 0 /b + T a * a+ T PO (18c)

The lift, moment, and hinge moment are found from the pressure coefficient

2bdL/dy = q f C dx (19a)

0 p

2bdM/dy= q f x C dx (19b)

0p

ZbdT/dy =q f (X - Xh) C dx (19c)o p

where the pressure coefficient is given by Eq. (15b).

C -- -(4/M) [ 1 + ZC 2 Mg + 3C 3 M (g2 + a2)

x likho/b + [l + ikx/b] a + [1 + ikx xh)/b P I(x xh)) (ZO)

and we have taken the pitch axis at the leading edge x ° = 0. We define the

following dimensionless thickness integrals

I1- (l/Zb) f gx dx (Zla)0

8

Page 19: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

12 (1/4b 2) f b g dx (2ib)0

13 = (1/8b 3 ) Zbx gxdx (Z1c)

14 = (I/Zb) 2b dx (Zld)

2b 2 22e0

IS = (1/4b 2 ) f2 x g2xdx Ze

Zb= (1/8b 3 ) xg dx (22a)

2b(1/2b) J gx dx (22a)

xh33 (118/42) f Zb 2xd (22b)

J 3 = (1/8b 3) fbx' gx dx (22c)

xh

2b

34 = (1/ 2b) f gx dx (22d)xh

Page 20: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

9 = 1/4b 2 ) 2b x g2dx (22e)xb h

xh

J= (1/8b 3 ) x b ~ gx . (2Zf)

,%

These thickness integrals are evaluated at the end of this section for a

typical airfoil. If we substitute Eq. (20) into Eqs. (19), make use of the

definitions Eqs. (21) and (22). of the thickness integrals, and identify the

resulting expressions with Eqs. (18), we obtain the oscillatory aerodynamic

coefficients

Lh = - iKI/k (23a)0

L a = - KI/k2 - iK2/k (23b)0

L = - K 4/k 2 - i(K5 - ZK 4 h)/k (23c)

0p4Y

Mh = - iK /k (23d)0

Ma = - Kz/k2 - iK 3 /k (23e)0

M~o = - K5/k 2 _ i(K 6 2K 5 h)/k (23f)0

T - i (K5 2K )/k (23g)

T1 = -(K 5 - ZK4 th)/k 2 - i(K6 - 2Ksh)/k (23h)

10

Page 21: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

T o =-(K - 2K4 h)/kZ - i(K- 4 K5 h + 4K 4 Z)/k (3i)

where

gh = Xh/2b (24a)

K = (l/M) [-C + 2r MI I + 3C 3 M2 (1 4 + C) (24b)

* = (1/M) [C + 4- 2 MI2 +

3 C3 MZ( 2 15 + a 2 )] (24c)

* (4/3M) [ I + 6-CMI 3 + 3C3M2 (31 + a)2 (24d)

4 (/M) I?1( - h) + 2 2MJI+ 3c 3 M [J 4 + ao(l- h (24e)

K5 (I/M) l(1 - z ) + 4r 2MJ 2 + 3C3 M Z2J5 + a2(l - 9h) (24f)

5 1 h 2 3 5 0

K6 (4/3M) i(I - 93) + 6C 2 MJ 3 + 3C 3 M 2 [3J 6 + a2 _ -h) ] (2 4 g)

To conclude the derivation of the oscillatory aerodynamic coefficients,

we calculate the thickness integrals for the typical airfoil of Fig. 1. We

approximate the airfoil by two parabolas and a line. The equation of the

forward parabola that goes through the leading edge and is horizontal at

the point of the maximum thickness is

g 1 (X)/C = (T/2) (X/Xm) (2 - X/XM) (25)

The approximation by a sharp leading edge is consistent with the theoryhaving ruled out detached shock waves.

11

Page 22: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

POINT OF MAXIMUM THICKNESS

HINGE LINE

g X

t/2 th /2

-X h Ch

C: 2b, C I

Fig. 1. Typical Airfoil Cross Section.

where T = t max/c. The second parabola, horizontal at the point of maximum

thickness and going through the hinge line, is

g 2 (x)/c = (T/Z) 1- 1 - rh) [(x - Xm)/(xh - xm)]21 (26)

where rh Th/T and Th = th/c. The line connecting the hinge line and blunt

trailing edge is given by

g 3 (x)/c = (ThlZ) [1 - (I - rt) (x - xh)/(c - Xh)] (Z7)

12

Page 23: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

where rt = t/T h and T t = ti/c. By differentiating we find the desired slopes

g'(x)/c = (T/XM) (I - x/x m ) (28a)

gZ(x)/c = - T(1 - rh) (x - Xm)/(xh - XM) (28b)

g (x)Ic - (Th/2) (1 - rt)/(c - xh) (28c)

From the slopes, the thickness integrals follow immediately. Computing the

control surface integrals first yields

Id = -gd (liz) (-rh - Tt) (29a)

J2 = f t = -(1/4) (h - rt) (1 + th) (29b)h

3 = 2 =gd -(1/6) ( - (I + h + t (Z9c)3= f (h t) ~h hth

3 4 f I g d. = (1/4)(-h -Tt) ( - th ) (Z9d)

35 = f gd = (1/8) ('h - wt ) Z (I + h/(l - th ) (?9e)

J, =fIg( Tt) (

=~ + th~d + (112 t h) (29f)

13

Page 24: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

The complete airfoil. integrals become

hf gtdc + J1 = Th/Z + Jl (30a)0

ahI f 2g d + J2 ('T/3 % + (T h/ 6 ) (zah + am) + (3 Ob)

0

14 = ah 2 + =[ + (1/3) (T -h)/(2 - m + J4(30d)t5fh .2

1 f g d + 3T h0

= T/I2 + ( J/) ( - Th) (3 ah + m)/ (h - am) + (30e)

ah16 t tgd + J"5

1+ 112(T - -( h+ )% -t)+J 3e

(T /30)Cm + (1/30) (T - Th) z (6 ' + 3 ahar n + am)/(ah am) + f 6 (30f)

where a = x/c, aM = xm/c, and ah = xh/c'

14

Page 25: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

Having obtained the oscillatory aerodynamic coefficients, we are

now in a position to derive the AICs. We consider the given and equivalent

force systems in Fig. 2. The equivalent forces are arbitrarily placed at

the quarter-chord, the control surface hinge line, and the trailing edge.

The derivation must relate the forces F I , F 2, F 3 to the deflections h,

h 2 , h 3 through the given leading edge aerodynamic coefficients and deflec-

tions h, a, . We begin with the force equivalence.

0, L

b/2 (b/2 +-d) 2b F 2 M o 0 1)

0 '0 ca T

The loads and deflections are related through the definitions of the oscillatory

coefficients.

L 1 0 0 L h L La 0 h "

M 0 4p2b2y 0 b 0 Mh Mao M PO ba . (32)

T 0 0 b Th 0o T P b

The equivalence in the deflections is given by

h (1 + b/Zd) -b/Zd h 1

ba = -b/d bid 0 h2 (33)

b6 b/d -(b/ri + b/c b0c h 3a

15

Page 26: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

1Lo T

(b) h

FD h3

F2 I F3

- 2b -

Fig. 2. Original (a) and Equivalent (b) Force

Systems and Geometry for Oscillatory Case.

16

Page 27: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

SSubstituting Eq. (33) into (32), Eq. (32) into (31), and solving for the forces yields

F (1 + b/Zd) -b/d (b/Ca) (3b/Zd - 1)

F2 = 4pwzb 2 ~y 1 -b/Zd b/d -(b/ca) (3b/ Zd)

F3L o o b/ca

Lho Lao LPO (1 + b/2d) -b/ad 0

X Mh M MPO -b/d b/d 0 (34)o 0

Th Ta0 T b/d -(b/d + b/ca) b/Caj

From the definition of the AIC matrix

IFI pw-b 2 s [C hijh (35)

and by identity with Eq. (34), we find the AICs for a single strip.

(1 + b/Zd) -b/d (b/ca) (3bl2d - 1)

[Ch] 4(b/br) 2 (Ay/s) -b/d b/d -(b/ca) (3b/Zd)

0 0 b/c a

Lh L LL0 ° (1 + b/Zd) -b/2d 0

X Mh Ma MPO -b/d b/d 0 (36)o 0

Th T TPO b/d -(b/d + b/ca) b/ca a

17

Page 28: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

IIn the absence of a control surface Eq.(36) reduces to

(I + b/2d) -b/d][C h I 4(b/brd2 (A Y/S)[ -b/ 2d b/dI

Lh L] ( /d -b/ 2d

j) (37)Mho Ma -b/d b/d

The complete AIC matrix for a surface of N strips appears in the partitioned

form

I_ _ I o I ..0 0 00

o C hl 0 ICrh' 0 l C tT (38)

--- 0

.1 I. .1I. I.I I III I I.

_ I I I. h

L IhN]

in which the first null partition is reserved for control points at which the

aerodynamic forces are negligible (e. g. , external stores) and in which the

remaining partitions are of the size 3 x 3 or 2 x 2 according to whether or

not the strip has a control surface.

18

Page 29: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

The steady AIC matrix follows from the oscillatory solution as a

limiting case. If we compare the definition of the steady matrix

(1/Z)p V 2 (S/c [Chi thI (39)

with the oscillatory definition Eq. (35), we observe

[Ch] Z(sc/S) lim k 2[C h (40)Sk -0r h

r

From the previous section we find the limiting values of the oscillatory

coefficients to be

lim kk2Lh k 2M k h) 0 (41)k -0 o r ho rh0r

lim kL =- K(b /b)Z (4Za)r a 1 r

a00Zrr

limkr = - (K 5 - ZK 4 h) (brb) 2 (4 2c)

rk -0 ro

r

limkL = - K 4 (b/b) 2 (4 3a)k-0r 4 rk -0 0

r

19

Page 30: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

Ilir k2 M K5(br/b) 2 (43b)

k -0 r Por5r

lim krT - (K - ZK 4 h) (br/b)2 (43c)k -0 r 03

r

D. References

1. H. Ashley and G. Zartarian. "Piston Theory--A New Aero-dynamic Tool for the Aeroelastician. " Journal of the Aeronautical Sciences,23 (1956), 1109.

2. H. G. Morgan, V. Huckel, and H. L. Runyan. "Procedure forCalculating Flutter at High Supersonic Speed Including Camber Deflections,and Comparison with Experimental Results. " NACA TN 4335, September1958.

3. M. D. Van Dyke. "A Study of Second-Order Supersonic FlowTheory." NACA Report 1081, 1952.

4. W. P. Rodden, E. F. Farlas, P. E. Williams, and F. C. Slack."Aerodynan Inuence Coefficients /)y Piston Theory: Analytical Develop-

ment afid'i 5r edure for- the-1-M- 7-090-Gem p+Aer. " Northrop CorporationReport NOR-61-57, 14 April 1961.

5. J. W. Miles. The Potential Theory of Unsteady Supersonic Flow.London: Cambridge University Press, 1959, pp. 184-185.

20

Page 31: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

SECTION II

GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF INPUT

A. Units

Since all dimensional input is geometrical and the aerodynamic matrix

is dimensionless, only a consistent set of length units is necessary--inches or

feet.

B. Classes of Numerical Data and Limitations

The data required by the program are control and option indicators,

geometry, Mach numbers, and a set of reduced velocities for each Mach

number. The example problem illustrates their use.

I. Example Problem

We consider the four-strip wing shown in Fig. 3 at Mach numbers

1. 8 and 2. 5. We use reduced velocities of 4. 0 and 8. 0 for both Mach num-

bers, and compute the steady case for Mach 2. 5. The aerodynamic matrices

will be computed by piston theory and by Van Dyke's quasi-steady variation.

Strips 2 and 3 are considered to have control surfaces. The thickness

integrals will be computed for an assumed airfoil (constant across the span)

having 10 percent thickness, maximum thickness at 40 percent chord, and a

blunt trailing edge having 1. 5 percent thickness.

2. Program Restrictions and Options

a. The number of strips into which a wing may be subdivided

must be < Z5.

b. The number of Mach numbers must be < 15.

c. The number of reduced velocities used with any one Mach

number must be < 20.

21

Page 32: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

IA

2b

low S

Fig. 3. Example of Four-Strip Wing.

Strip No. Ay(ft) b(ft) Ca(ft) d(ft)

1 4.7 12. 28120 0 11.9

2 4. 2 9. 50000 5. 25000 9. 0

3 3. 6 7. 06250 3. 99375 6. 6

4 3. 1 4. 96875 0 4. 5

Strip No. am ah T Th Tt

1 0. 4 (not used) 0. 1 0. 015 (not used)

2 0. 4 0. 72368421 0. 1 0. 050 0. 015

3 0.4 0. 71725664 0. 1 0. 050 0. 015

4 0.4 (not used) 0. 1 0. 015 (not used)

sec A = 1. 25 S = 554.0 sq ft

b = 6.5 ft c = 21.0 ftr

s = 15. 6 ft a 's (constant) = 5. 00

*N. B. The trailing edge thickness is listed as the hinge line thickness

in the case of no control surface.

22

Page 33: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

d. If it is desired to compute the steady matrix [ Chs I , a zero

or negative value of V/br w must be supplied to the program. (S and c must

also be provided. )

e. Thickness integrals may be given or computed. If given

.they may be given only once with each deck and are considered constant with

strips, a 's may be constant or vary with strips (for each Mach number).0

(T, Tht Tt)'s may be constant or vary with strips. m and h may be

constant or vary with strips.

f. The control surface strips must be a continuation of the

main surface strips; e. g. , in the case of a partial span control surface the

inboard and outboard span statiois should be used as boundaries of the main

surface strips.

g. As many complete sets (decks) of input data may be

supplied as desired (one following the other).

23

Page 34: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

SECTION III

DATA DECK SETUP

A. Loading Order

Input decks punched from keypunch forms are loaded behind column

binary deck HMll. The data for each deck should be in the following order:

(1) Heading Card 1

(2) Heading Card Z

(3) NTHRY, NTHICK, NALPHA, NTAUS, NZETAS

(4) ISZ, MSZ, NO PUNJ, JSZ 1 , JSZ;), .. J~zMS

(5) sec A, b, s, 5, c

(6) Ayl, Ay, 'S

(7) bit b 2 , . . . ,bis z

(8) c al' ,ca 2 ' . . ISZ

(9) dip d2 , . . . dr.z

(10) Mach1 , Mah. . . . Mach MSZ

(Ila) If thickness integrals are given:

(a) When all c ai= 0 tabulate only IV~ 12t t v s 1 6.

(b) Any c ai f 0 then include J' ,2 f - v , J 6 t and

t fl I thZ' * *. - hISZ (if NZETAS I only t hl is needed).

(11b) If thickness integrals are computed:

[ if NTAUS = Ilonly T I, T hit and T tl are needed; if c .i=0(.e

no control surface), the trailing edge thickness (T ti) is listed as

Thand the locationfor Tt may be left blank for these strips].

*Please, no remarks about our Greek!

24

Page 35: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

(b) "m 1,h I ; m 2 h; . ; mISZ, hISZ [if NZETA = 1

only ml and ahl are needed; if Cai = 0, the program

uses h = 1. 0 (t for trailing edge), and the location

for ahi may be left blank for these strips].

(IZa) If alphas do not vary with strips:

1 a2' ' CLMSZ

(12b) If alphas vary with strips:

(a) al, a2 ' . . aIS Z for first Mach number

(b) al, az, , a S Z for second Mach number

(c) al, a2, a iS z for MSZ Mach number

(13) V/b w series

(a) (V/b r)l, (V/b r0)z, , (V/bro)JSZ for first Mach

numbe r

(b) (V/b r)l, (V/b W) 2 , (V/b )S for second Mach

number

(c) (V/b r )l, (V/br w) 2 , (V/b r) jSZ for MSZ Mach

number

B. Input Data Description

(1), (2) Heading Card I and Heading Card 2 may contain any characters

desired in Columns 2 through 72. These cards are convenient for

identifying the vehicie, surface, date, engineer, etc. Both cards

may be blank but must be included in the data deck.

(3) Control card: FORMAT (1814)

(a) NTHRY = 0, piston theory is used to compute CI and. 'C

25

Page 36: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

INTHRY € 0, Van Dyke's theory is used to compute 1 and

C2 (If sec A = 0, then with either theory 1 and

-C are the same)

(b) NTHICK = 0, when thickness integrals are computed

NTHICK # 0, when thickness integrals are given (in this

case they are constant for the surface)

(c) NALPHA = 1, the alphas are constant (do not vary with

each strip)

NALPHA = ISZ, the alphas vary with each strip

(d) NTAUS = 1, the T, T h , and Tt are constant for all strips

NTAUS = ISZ, the T, T ho and T t vary with each strip

(e) NZETAS = 1, tm and th are constant for all strips

NZETAS = ISZ. m and th vary with each strip

(4) Control card: FORMAT (1814)

(a) ISZ = number of strips, < 25

(b) MSZ = number of Mach numbers, < 15

(c) NO PUNJ = 0, or blank, when punched card output is

desired

NO PUNJ 0, no punched output is desired

(d) JSZ 1 number of (V/br w)'s for first Mach number, < 20

JSZz - number of (V/br w)'s for second Mach number,

< Z0

JSZMsz = number of (V/b r)'s for last Mach number, < 20

(5) Single parameters: FORMAT (6EIZ. 8)

(a) sec A, secant of leading edge sweep angle

(b) b, reference semichord

26

Page 37: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

B(c) s, wing semispan

(d) S, wing area.

(e) , mean aerodynamic chord

(6) Ay, series: FORMAT (6E12.8)

AYl " . AyIs z , strip widths

(7) b. series: FORMAT (6E12.8)1

b . b is z , local semichords

(8) c . series: FORMAT (6EI2.8)

cal c . caISZ' control surface chords; in the absence of a

control surface, c ai may be zero or blank, but a sufficient

number of cards must be included

(9) d. series: FORMAT (6El2.8)

d1 . . disZ, distance between forward and aft control points

(10) Mach number series: FORMAT (6E12.8)

Mach 1 MachMSZ , in any order desired, but the number

listed must agree with MSZ

(Ila) Thickness integrals given: FORMAT (6E12.8)

(a) . 1 , I , ..... 16 the complete airfoil thickness

integrals

(b) Jl' J 2. I6 the control surface thickness

integrals, use only when c ai 1 0

ghl' h ' . ' hISZ' dimensionless chordwise

coordinate (xh/.c) for the control surface hinge line

(lIb) Thickness integrals are computed: FORMAT (6E12.8)

(a) Tit Thit and Tti' airfbil thickness ratios (t/c) at point of max-

imum thickness, hinge line, and trailing edge, respectively

27

Page 38: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

(b) mi and ahi' dimensionless chordwise coordinates for

point of maximum thickness and hinge line

(Ia) Alphas do not vary with strips (alpha is a , the initial angle of

attack). FORMAT (6E12. 8)

al1' CL 2 " MSZ (degrees) are tabulated in order for each Mach

number

(1Zb) Alphas vary with strips: FORMAT (6E1Z. 8)

a 1 , a, 2 .P lSZ (degrees) are tabulated for each Mach

number. The series for each Mach number, starts on a new line

(card).

(13) V/b w series, reference reduced velocity: FORMAT (6EI2.8)

There is a reduced velocity series for each Mach number;

each series starts on a new line (card), and the number

of V/b w's must agree with the JSZ for the respectiver

Mach number.

C. Example Keypunch Forms

Example keypunch forms are given on the following pages. Columns

73 through 80 are reserved for data deck identification. This space rilay be

used in any fashion; however, it is suggested that the last three columns be

used for sequencing. Only the cards with sequencing in Columns 73 through

80 are to be used in the sample data deck; the lines (cards) with Columns

73 through 80 blank are for clarification of input.

28

Page 39: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

1-

0~It

29

Page 40: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

fl _OD00 N W() a

00 0 00 __ ----

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 it00 0 0_ 0 0 0 _ 0 0 cz

x x - - -

2 2 2 ___ 2 2lit

z __ _ __ ___ II I _ to

0D r-n 4&-

0 - -

r-

A- ca * - __

40 3n

Page 41: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

o 00 0 0 0 ~ 0- _

I1 1

-Aft0 f

131

Page 42: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

SECTION IV

PROGRAM OUTPUT

A. Printed Output

1. All input data

2. Thickness integrals (Is and J's)

3. Each group of aerodynamics influence coefficients (comprising

a complete aerodynamic matrix), associated Mach number,

and V/br w

4. Sequencing numbers (Columns 73 through 80) of the first and

last punched cards (output) for each group (one V/br W) of

influence coefficients

5. Example problem printed output is shown on the following pages

32

Page 43: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

0

0% a4010% 0n

11-4OD %

0 0% ON%*

0000

ii 0 0CO

wuJ 1D00 000 0000%00 0

- ~ ~ ~ L N NI00- 400 * 000 000zV 000

00U. m 0000

I -J 4z0 0 00 0 0cz 0 U-0ixcc ccczol00 L

L) LU 0 r -4 00 00

U. 00 0%0

0tf0

~~00

LU~~ QU00U. 0 0 0

0000

0 LU L LU30

Page 44: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

# Ity NN

N LM

N

'00

00

N

0 00

VNN~00

-4

w. u

f 0-

- - y

at.

* *34

Page 45: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

10

N

0 L0x 00p DO

Go NO NO W% 0,0 y -.4 4

m. P.-401

oj 1." C4z ULJu CI da U

(" 00 10 0I

P.- r O

U.1

44

0j I4 0

4 00

~~0.cc NyW-4. f

f4.Y

03

Page 46: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

LU

0 -*

-t g-z 10

-- 0000

0 w~ N f

UNF-?U. co.4..4fn4.

-Lf -I UL 4"a.c .co f4N0

z c

z c 0m

0O I I

08 0

0- N

tnp

N .4

36

Page 47: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

000

00

0 00

00

LL w0-. 0lu

0U 0

- 0

-4~ 000 u 0

0-

U, 000

LU-4c

LzU.

37

Page 48: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

0 1

I.,

Ce00 0D w. I

0r-4 000

2 0

00 If 0

U.1 0 0

W W%0 f ~ N

0. 0 0 N0

0 N0 0

0U I' I - X-.-

W0 Q

U.)U

LL '0 U L-4p-

9 NN I

0

4 0LU'U

0% -4

II,

00 0 0

.. ....

38

Page 49: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

0

u~j w

Zq 0

- 00 - 0 to CDO

00f I N

-j t-

-4 040 00 V

LL. WIz e

U)N'

2 00

Page 50: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

001 00uj0U

uj ui000-0 00~00 000-0 00

000

0 000ll

.4 0O cy 0

0 0%0%'- 0' 0'

aLI- 0 0I

ON 4 44 0

0 i

U. -9 ui U0- 0% 0%

>.0P 0 0 0 6 00

-~0 000 mCh 0

.4 z 0 0 0% 00 w 0 V ( M 1

D cp% ON

LU O uj i 00 -

I- u o 00 0 c40

Page 51: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

Go

0

'CY

000

000

o

N

uJ J 0N Ir

'441

Page 52: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 0CI0 0

UUJI

m 00-4 IUN u0 It

0- 00 0

of -900C U. Lw Lu NvLU LU w4 0rCDP

N-0 I .00 li 4.

z .J .1 0 .0 0

!0 m0N0IN

L -. 00 II ;c0 00

CD 0

1:1 0 ou14CY

V)0 0 00 0 c0 0 1LU z 0UJ u L LU c

aD 0 t In1111

0 10 LA U0 f" 1

0 0Wf

0- N 00 0

LU 0

z u CKw C7 4 - -4 00 x -

Z 39 Q .0.j in u w0LLL. U LAJUJI t MN

ry 00 uP% .4

z 0 0 el 142

Page 53: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

wwLf 0 OD

0

0

00 N

0 U. W I

- Do N

0-I-- 00 0 c00

0W 0of O . yN

- US 0 0 j.Lr0z x 0 a

It 00 0' 3

0 If Ln I'U.- o00 00 01.0 0iu 0 0 oL

oo

LU UY o

UUN LULA 0 t-' U.1L

-000

4> N 00r

00 0000

in- N ry N4 00 00 0

LW LUW

40m? .

4.L -P

NN3

Page 54: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 000 0

mw w

000

00

4*

U 00 0c- - -

0 (n(In 00 0P-

w ww 0 4It.M 0 -

- Itu 1010 .0

c-o-

uN N q- 0 N0 0 0 0 00 0 c

0 N 00 M 0 INr N0 0 '0- -1

03 -- 11-f00L

LUpqP-N D N .0

0~~~ IA-oM ' 4P01 1 M 0 0 0* NA -4

Mi -M t

LLJ~~ ~ ~ a 0x-d0 0 0x -

z 3 P-4 0 0ON-4L

Z a - -4.0 f

.4> 10 c oz tn

01-

w-. -- 04 00 0

N.NIN

'CM N

IQ 4

00 00

-44

Page 55: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 000 0

4 U.%

co 0

00 0;

00

00 0000 ; I w -

410 LM

1200 00 0a

-4n

U. . .0 c

- l- -44 0

0 00 g A

0il 110C

0: W I 4 -N -40 0oN0 0 00 0

Q0 0 L LL .1

U.41 !-440

00 00 0oA W,

ODt -t

00

Ug

0I- 0

0-.1

44

Page 56: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

I ' C

0000 0

= 0 -4

00 0 0T

A Z 0 00 N N 0

a~~0 W * 4 4

0 ,,' 00 0

0 Q

0 N.O N NAD UI )-

z. C- -

U. tLJ U0I 0 L

U. ' f I -4 m 0 4

-j 0 -9 -J WiQo -4 X4

LA. W 0

0 .ry Z

C;.

0-

LU 0

44

Page 57: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

I

B. Punched Output

1. A deck of punched cards (output) from this program is suitable

as an input deck to other programs requiring the use of AICs.

2. All punched output is sequenced in order on Columns 73 through

80 starting with HMI 10000. The data is punched in the following

order:

a. Card I contains (V/b rW) I and M FORMAT (6E12. 8)

b. Card 2 contains the size (number of control points) of the

AIC matrix and the number of strips:, FORMAT (1814)

c. The AIC matrix punched in column binary form and its TRA

card make up the remainder of the punched output for

(V/b r W) 1

3. The order of Statement 2 above is repeated for all reduced

velocities and associated Mach numbers per input deck.

4. Each AIC matrix is punched by columns. Column 1 starts in

Origin 1 and Column 2 in Location (1 + matrix size).

5. The oscillatory AIC matrix is punched in the order -- Column 1

(real), Column 1 (imaginary), Column 2 (real), Column 2

(imaginary), . , , Column N (real), Column N (imaginary).

In the steady case all columns are real and are punched in order.

47

Page 58: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

ISECTION V

PROCESSING INFORMATION

A. 2e ration

STANDARD FORTRAN MONITOR system

B. Estimated Machine Time

T = time in minutes

ISZ = number of strips

JSZM = total number of reduced velocities

MSZ = number of Mach numbers

n = number of sets (decks) of input data

T = 1. 0 + .02 [(ISZ MSZ • JSZM)1 + (ISZ • MSZ JSZM) 2

+ + (ISZ • MSZ JSZM)n ]

C. Machine Components Used

Core storage, about 5300

Standard FORTRAN input tape (NTAPE Z)

Standard FORTRAN output print tape (NTAPE 3)

Standard FORTRAN output punch tape (NTAPE 7)

48

Page 59: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

ISECTION VI

PROGRAM NOTES

A. Subroutines Used

RDLN, reads and prints title cards

AEROP4, punch AIC matrix

BINPU, column binary punch

All other subroutines are on library tapes

B. Generalized Tapes ,

Input, print,and punch tapes in this coding are defined as Units 2, 3,

and 12, respectively; however, these may be altered by placing the desired

units on symbolic cards HMll0060, HM1l0061, and HM110062.

49

Page 60: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

tB A

w 50

Page 61: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

SECTION VIII

SYMBOLIC LISTING

Some of the symbols used in the program are defined as follows:

FORTRAN Symbols Definition

NTHRY Option--theory used for CV C 2

NTHICK Option--thickness integrals given orcomputed

NALPHA Option--a's constant or vary

NTAUS Option--T's constant or vary

NZETAS Option--t's constant or vary

NO PUNJ Option- -punching or no punching

ISZ Number of strips

MSZ Number of Mach numbers

J SIZE (M) Number of reduced velocities forMach number

JSZ Number of reduced velocities for aMach number

SEC LAM sec A

BR br

S s

CAP S S

C BAR

*Please, no remarks about our Greek!

51

Page 62: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

ISYMBOLIC LISTING (continued)

FORTRAN Symbols De finition

C BAR 1

C BAR 2 2

RAD DEG w/180. 0 (program constant)

DELTA Y(I) Ay for strip i

B (I) b for strip i

CA (1) ca for strip i

D (I) d for strip i

EMACH (M) m'th Mach number

EKR(J, M) 1/kr =(V/br w) for reduced velocity J,

for m'th Mach number

El (N) I series (thickness integrals)

EJ (N) J series (thickness integrals)

Al (I, N) I series for strip i

AJ (I, N) J series for strip i

ZETA H (I). th for strip i

ZETA M (1) m for strip i

TAU (1) T for strip i

TAU H (I) Th for strip i

TAUT (1) Tt for strip i

ALPHA (I, M) n for strip i, for m'th Mach number

EK (I, N) K series for strip i

52

Page 63: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

SYMBOLIC LISTING (continued)

FORTRAN Symbols Definition

CONST (I) 4(b/br)2 Ay/s for strip i

A (I, N, K) Premultiplying matrix in oscillatory

coefficients matrix equation

G (N, K) Real, oscillatory leading edge

coefficient matrix

GI (N, K) Imaginary matrix

H (N, K) Postmultiplying matrix in oscillatory

coefficients matrix equation

Q (N, K) Working array

QI (N, K) Working array

P (N, K) AIG matrix, complex

The symbolic listing of the program is shown on the following pages.

53

Page 64: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

0E l~ l,0oal 4 - 4l l 4INN NN m ne00 0 0 !CC0 1ISZ000Z 0 0 0 0-N 0N

0 01 3 000 1C1000 01l!HQ0 011 000 0 00 00

Z -M o

D0% 0

W.1-4 W N

I.- LL--U- QI -4 It Iz wU wi LA'

- LU U -9-4 --) a -. 1

N -. z t It

-i U. 04

:1!LU m - xNN C)- 0 101--n M Lu

u 4 z - -

I0- C;. L) r- Lu Z-. LU

HZC X- LA1

-4j -4 z

V)A It x .D CC - W

.- ~ ca * f/0-I xU x 10I

N z -. ) -4 -0o '0

10 NY Z LU N

U0~ cc - 4

LI, -I 0 x xO 0-

x 4 z fl IX44 x

M0 .NM D tIM(0 NI.

ft 1.U x( -0 -

Ln fn x 54

Page 65: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 i1 10' . O ,I

oog 4: 00 000 00.00 00 000 000 000

1-4.4 -r4 4 r 1 11 4

-4-' a. " ~ HZH ZH 2:nx 3E

-~ cer Xj

4 0 -n -

X P4 CID

Z-0. --- I r 4A N

C.D P2 -

N 4

-0 II W

zU JJ 4Z - '

'2~~ t. S4uIt> _j- 4Ul

O t. x CC NN'a I .1O0~ V? I owU

Q'%. ' - -

0. - 4 .4* -. CDN Ny

£00. w t - -- riI m O C0

S) V)& 1-40 * - -4 NNN

cLO - '0 r4-N -. L aa0 CL

NIN .- X- WW144

Lx- enf a, 2.1 ZU .

if)) In CL' 'Ww

S- Nof l 0fI f w1)O C L m 0 0 L. C L

-~1 V) -4 -4 I - 0

-o X : : C 0 0 43 a-I0

ot a 4 -a 4 Q

00 000I .1 .1 . 0.

0 U. -- U. - owCCccc o -T~-

U.U U. U-

-4 .4~ I 4 NNNIj

55

Page 66: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

P. 00 (V Cca, 0 n 00 000 t c00 0-(D00 000oc m 0 0.

0 000 00 0 00 0 00 Z000 000

x xz 3E3Exz z i c !1z

4-AUJ -

U.1,

- - 40 Luz

I CA11U.

CA

4. -dU.

- I

U-. U,:

44 U. We

O W 1- 0.4 rp

-, < , II LU (AA

tA1- CL 1 L -

LU L

00 0 N4 0N N N qC 1 y

LL'I -9000'-A .u

0 .40-LU0 LU -iL 2 IL N

56

Page 67: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

M :2

00 00 0C)00C 0 00 0 00 000o 0001o1

Ni at ifiit

-4 n

-4

-c x

LUN- -I

-9- LU L

LU a LWCL N m 49i9IL d-

I4 Z

4 LCL I.- CLC

f9 4 : .1.- 4

ry 0 L z )0Q Ve

toI- 00 aJ 0-I

I.-0 0-" 0 49 -9-

0 90 0Uwc

v ON fm

NN N NY

57

Page 68: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

co l o - 0 o 0-N 10r c N("s c0kA kn% 01 -P oc o c o0

aK ZZZ .4 . 4 4- 4 4Z * 4.00 00 00 C) 00 X Z Cc0 0 0

z

0 wU

z 010

-a I.

ON

z~ dc

I .- 4

II PQ 9 -9U.

z +

z 14

44W

z z zCL 0Cc .&- - .00

ui -zZm - - CYw If

02. Q0.0.U U. N w

Z II b.- (a- U

N-- 't I~ vs -eg cy cm r

- 44 WW WN W 58

Page 69: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

N - 10 NO t c0 4u inN 10 C00 N N N N NN NJ (I iN NOo0 0 0 0 0 0 000!

0- I)

4) -4 Ijx

.0 nI WUJU

X4 V4

We+

- WW U. U.4U liWU M 0.0.L N I *W 1 IP!*~~I I. 4-IC7 ~ HFI -

-Nj I 4 1Z 1U' 1i1 ,J

4-~~ -<4 -j N---Ij I' .(AN% N L I U. U.1- xI~ . 040I1-T-I~ 4% C 0 1 .. > 4) X.) - Li X

o il, 11. 1- .- II(

Izwu 111. 1 W W:)D 1 4 )XiL ON 3z z~ %AI.;1 L

1- - I.-I 1 .111 V c

59

Page 70: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 'tU1 Oo I 0 4N 'o - D M - c -0 .uo

NN N NN N NN N NN N NN N N N (i N04N0 00 00000 000 000 000

,4 - -4 -.. .4 .4- .4.44 . 4 -4 .

4-

P-4 CL

-u-

+0'0

ccW W 4

c. -01

4% U +

ZE - -c.

* * 0-

-NN

-1CL0 g

W 0- 10

Page 71: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

NN NNt yre yN N f N ,IN N Nf (00 00 000 000 000 !1000 .0001-4 -4 -4 -d~ -4W-4 .44- W .44 w444 1--

.4 # *- d - -- "4 ..d .d .- 444.i-.-

Xmz xr1 Ix ZZZ'xx xx

-4 3d -

.4 .9 4

I.- k" 0-wj pq P4 WN

Ld **4/ 0 0 * -

*~i -- .

N 'N -

Ir.'j f"L -0 . JN "I *w I*

N~ ~ -4 - - : a -

39 u fn -N

t*I zN l N 4-44fE 6m N #- C

N N N

61

Page 72: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 1 -4- .- 4. NN N

4.-4 - 4 q -4 4-4

IX six sr si 3rs S 1111 i3c zx X

If I

z-4- -4

--

U.1 N M

So- uJ 0. ff-~C aI .

z N 4L CL N z0 Z 0. Uu a .

0 00

I 62

Page 73: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

9 0 00

00 ie a 0

.4

Li

m

cz

0~0

az'oil

06

Page 74: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

I.-0 n 2Y%

,A 1) IN4A6w1

.OO 9- N- cc G %

C7 0 ^2 W 0 )w00 000Ln CL9

4~ ~ z ~ ~ iL

0 0(

2: 0 -. 1 I -1:N Coe0I I K1. 0 0m 0 FP.

0LC:N- y t 4 0 1 N2:P

4- 10 %- r It III tI

4A4 IOI 0 N tvNN :

LU 000 0 00 cmLU. IIIo I" JE 0 L-Cc

0 4i 09 1:1 1 cc~E -f

IA A t 0 NEI c cc

LU I p0 0 w

9-A ~4u 9Kn IAI-

0 CL WU0. '0 %- 0 tNi

49 1 %U.1 n 41

4o 11 02tI 4

o 00

IA LU j YeIA 0. ca

0e X'-.- 4A N- 0.' 14 .- a

4U 0J 000 0 2 00

0LL

10 P- 0 91

4% Nf U U1,1 in

00

0 19 x III- ca

64

Page 75: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

ii

'I

I i fJ~ii

I Ii

liii',''I' ,iIIIjIIi~I

I ijII~IIPI~II

I! ~i~III~

65

Page 76: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

000 c00 0 I- 000 000

0 1wN~ w p- N CO0

0!3 mmm ~ -N NI

w 0 0 11 (fl F-11 1 ID I N O

z

0. 000 000 0 0 00C 000C.

-r 000 00010 0 i.L 000 00D

Z @-e N 0 c U .4~ uw NN NiN -- 0I-j

01 L00 M UN -4U ? I

u 000 U.

LU4

00 000 ItI 1 ".0 0 000 000 -

ULL 0 0 co 00 coo0@m M W -.C"NIt4 D f

0 " n M 0Q -LU -.4- 04

4 t 0 00 ofUNz 0%A-4 c 1ca 000 l"0 10 0 NNN NNNr

4 - It 9%0NC m y

-d CY ' y0 a -4C

10 - -# 40, I u0 z 1 0 On '0 - 66

Page 77: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

PI

I0 0

NN

CID0 A0 ~OD

NN'Y t Lii

'010 N P.N~

'0 0

CID r 0'00 1

INUvCYCNf

&A PICVY CY e

Nco

umCI 0 O

N'CY

00 c0o

N'0 GIDa0ON'

67

Page 78: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

in -, V, o 'a 'a

000

.401-z0

4

w

z a.-

cc K 20do cc S:

-w a cccc W A0

Page 79: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

0z

IL cc0

cc -j

00 z

C0 00 0

4 0y

n2 00: 0 UL

4 0

U.

2:44

0-

0.

w LU LU

0 0

UU0) - t-

0 0

C,

o

26

Page 80: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

O'OO' O'0 000iBP0 i o 04 0,az pz z r-f-C O m ,7 '

en mmVw0 o 000 co.o M

at

CL.T

0 o

.4 L4 CQ

x M4

Z) I. -I CID0 . 00O

*~L .4' U. a

.e4

a70

Page 81: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 -44 4 4 N Nt4+ I4t 4 4 I r -

00 000 000 0

LILa-a

0 LU

t3 4) 0

i 4~ ac

GO - I

cc z 0

N0 J.9 0A.

- Q a

- 0 *70

Page 82: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

Iz

z z

44 Ci0- U co

4fl ccl U

0 0U U

z z L2

9 0 .

cc~~~I wULi 1-0c A 1M 0 0 C

>. 0 0. LC

0 z u 2 z

L0 0 2 A 99 1..

- 0 W) 0 az x 0 0.

LU0 CA L- W

0 0c 0 A

-A 00- U1 Id4 KU0 4o 4A

>U 0. 40

U) t" 0 U)4A w - 0Z cc. cc I.. LU

u. 0

4 U 0

2 72

Page 83: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

z

00

00-

U.

U.

00

("-0

zU-

00

U

73

Page 84: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

CO 0I 0-4N 00r 0 o - km'n PWO-

00 0003 000 000 001IM0001

x z 3z z zxxxx1,zx x x I xx ZIx x Ix I

*Cie

*c D

m of

3c C., I I M Uz 0

of w

**U LM

000

z ry

Su 4

ccC x ccx x xq 1.)01. t .9 .1 :

I 1V 1x z 4 -M 1 *0I

*iSjI

0 4.4 0 0 P.

)cv10Qfm0 0

-4( 00 1in*'o- t t0*

f"1 1 "iW tI 01 A1

74

Page 85: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 0 .01 f nL op NM p oa nrV

4 * - rI *I I It I -t. tI K tI00 000 000 00 000 000 00

'o. 4-44 4o4 4 . o.4 .4 .. 4 -4 - 4 .4 - -

CIDIX

z Ij- I. ! .

> x 0

r * 00 5 0 u4.

z. *. wNj 0 *j 0iCNj 3 W Q c*fc

C-i Ii, * 0w wu.i

.4 1- W -i z

0I

-44 I-O I.- J NN -.- 4

00 000 00 00 00 0

00 00-jC 00 000 t Z 0

00 ~ ~ u 00 0 0 0

000 ~ C 00 00 0.u'I

4A00 0d I S4 l 00 V00 00CL 4)0- V9906

00 000

00 0 00 000 0 00 4000 0P-0

C 0 0 0Q0040 ri

0 0 00 0 0 0 000 0 P- 70

Page 86: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

't Ln Ln o r-N VSn In 000 100 Lmt n % N N N L %I00 00 000 000 000 000 0

-4--4 4-44 ~ ~ 44 04 .4dX X3 Zn Xn Xn II M!CC 3 Z3 X3

MESm *UviSUY.U.Ou

*UL*LL

* ~ &*

U.LUcx*

*

a(*-C-

*U

Q L0

*u

* * U.* * w

*0

* U

Cc -4e4ri

0 04 _j4g

* mw

Z

10 01 %NI

N O IryC --. 4

476

Page 87: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 00 00000 000 00

Is x- L

U- z

z CQ* *0

3 0. - JI x

-JJ* 3C

* 0

II 00 0* 0rI0 00 I- 00l

1 0 .4 N IIIt ~0 0 r 0 0 11 0 0

0 0 0

r-r - - 0

r4/

-4 . 000 000 000

0000 0o p00 000 000 10Ij

000

77

Page 88: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

OLM L10 1-

00 000 000 00 00 00 0

mE LLII.u0 0ZZ ;Z -; I

* S S

S SU li

SL CID

0

S IU

* ci0 *1*U L

*0

z X; 0* I itI.

x I d0P x aj-

*K I. Il z 0-axcowjcx

00 0W % C 4 't -LU :~:il'1 4

0co aw2 r.-f- fc"*

(400 0 N

0 004 0 0l

in : In11 00t-4 I4

I44? f

co I0 GO:0 00 o0 IQ c co 0

S 78

Page 89: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

10 NN NNN

Qo O ~ .40 .-2 3c

00~ 000m 00 00 0

zz

III IO

ill IISc

z do cui N u

*g

acCV

>**S*ISj

coc

4L

w-4

0 0 0 u

*0 0N0U o

00 0 00 0 0

**Y U. 0

u.4Uu

* MIR

lA79

Page 90: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

04-4 - -N~ r4fiy U N

00 00 000 0 0 0 000 0- - -4 -0 . -0 4 -4 -

044

~zz Kiin 4i iM 0%i 0 0

*rSc

0 L*z1.

0 L*

ca

0 04 CLacU I-L

U.. xV*iL

ccc49r

94 r kn 1*yt

0 C 0 00 00 000 N00 00 00QQI 00

ry- #00 r 00 0 00 00

wo uf00 0 0 0uQ aPoo 0 o 0 00r

0 0

oo 0 00 1 0 W

00 0

o* 0 LI

C, c4JF 0,

* 01

Page 91: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

4.'000 '0 t

- 00 0 '000

0 0

-4 -- 4004 - -

0 0

0 I II

00 rN

a -CIV I ) 0 z 01 0

00 It Ir st Q~!i~I0 ' 0

I N Ooo Q - I ;U 0 00U or I 0

00 Q ~ C)'4 ' 00 0 0 C2 N j N- ; 0 000 040~)li'4 0~fU o, ~0 0'0Q o 000 'Dr

06 0000 00 000< Coo

IY , I Q - 0-rin -

Cc> o

Page 92: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

00 000 00.4 -4 .

-4 -1 44 .-

z0I-

0

0

z0I-,

00oo00

N 0

0 0

o N0Cc

LU c0- z a

LU -Q >-

g 0 0

Ii ' 0 0 00 000

00 000 0 000

00 coo 0i00 ill'0-0 0

00 Quo QO 081

Page 93: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

0.0

>. rN

uiN

&M' I'(AN

-9 D N

ccNn

Q N

00

in 04 N -

4- 1- y 1

0 -j a

1A N 1 n r .

UU "_

IA to It O--M nQI mry 1M ry 11A II--- - I n - 1 M

in M -Vo4 f 44 Cr 11 t. (

~J82

Page 94: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

-9Y

0f

ILI.

-U 4 -0. -

f^ '0 MU 0 z0-i u - '0z aw

I- -j -9c Uu jN 0

ty 0" '0'- Nfm fn N

-V

38

Page 95: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

'3 0 000

S00a

C.,

-0V) 4 0zwJ

'000 Zj

.4 c.4 0Kz

00wJ '-

.j

Z 000

'no0.4

0-cc

0 jn4000

U. .-4 Iof of

xof

ie )FE. 1-nU

Jan 060004.4 U 4n

En 1-6- 'rwU C)-

1-1

49 0 LP. - x L f

9 u4Li En -4 944

KK

84

Page 96: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

14-

0 00 1

N~~ 4) ee d~J

4) 0 0 0

Z, o0 0 4) I

0 k , . , 'd ow ' V

!5~~~ V d0'

En U-14 -1 04 k ~~4 '

~~2o~_5 7 4)444O ) b.0 >, l w

L).. p~ W 1 405

'~f-i ~E 0 bD 4)~a U

0 0.d 0>

0' ui124~ U-&' So ce b No P. o 0 0 u 0

.d~~ ~~~ 0 m .,414 i4- o l-

d z M -.o ub

Page 97: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

14 um

So 0 ~ p, 4

u,

-d 142t Vo 0 -:,4 uA 0 . u)0)_ _ ,

u u )J 0 0 U oo w)U > 0U0A. 'X. I. -" 4 ; -. 0

go 14 * O 4 - * 14'

N i 0A..0' 0~ kj _. 0 440

").. 04

U .0pa 0 u ', .

C) * k.A .4)n u00

In .'A 44 V~0a~a54~)40 ~0- .0 o 4'~05

o~~~~~~ m. ,$4~Q.44U . W-- 0

0 '0 0 4 j u. O

0'd.0 0.U) cc Q

N MU .r N 0.

>- w00 0. ' 40j. u j

-~C III,)~~. r- ad'0 *O U A OA

v J- 3, .0 12. N.U u. a1.4.I

Page 98: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

z

tn M U0 14 .U )4- VU.

00 'd 14 C '*,.. .

0~ 0040 )o 0

C;Id u00 "d u.0 Isd

D4*40 Id 00 e'd 0

W ', -U) 0 -'4d' j)

0 -a4 cp0 -< E. '04O' I'0d0 L'

"D 0 W 4

0 4.4 0l-o v 4.. 'u0X , z -1 P. iI. 4. ,

0 Z 00 45 a' ',' U u -0 2

1,~~~~0~4 400 6- 1:,v

Z c 0 . -5. a 0 4.d. Z

0 0 V 1

(d:1 11 0 . b

20 QV 0 0 0 0

WI~ 0*.~ .oo 'N)UO MU8

4V 44 .04

w. C, 0UH0U4 -5.4' v Z_ uU 0

U 0 .U

C; 4 i , V> 1-0

Page 99: UNCLASSIFIED AD 445924 - DTIC · optional correction to agree with Van Dyke's quasi-steady second-order ... V Free stream velocity V/b r w Reference reduced velocity, V/br w = 1/kr

"a'

I.U 4 cr 0 0

, ' G 0

0

: go.0 14~or UW'

m u

ua

0 t4

U 0.) :0 14 0 -

.0 0 0 uu'

u~ 04 P,~ a.' L P

14

V'O

0. -01 U0-.. §"93 w L) 4.

A -, 0 m 0.u S.


Recommended