Optimal algorithm
for nearest drop
detection
Effects of electric fields on
multiple drops with
simultaneous tracking of all
drops
Experimental
observations
Computed
forces Compact separation
technology for oil,
water, and gas
Understanding of electro-coalescence
for enhancing oil-in-water separation
General Introduction
The oil extracted from offshore
reservoirs will normally contain a large
and during the reservoir lifetime,
increasing percentage of water in oil.
When the water-oil mixture is passed
through the pressure relief valve an
emulsion with high percentage of small
water droplets is formed.
Before the oil is pumped onshore or into
tankers it is desirable to extract the
water from this emulsion.
The separation tanks are mainly built or
operated as gravity separator with low
flow rates and long residence times.
The residence time mainly depends on
the sedimentation velocity of the
smallest droplets (d<100µm)
The electric fields are to some extent
used to help smaller droplets to coalesce
in to larger droplets that sediment
quicker.
The sedimentation velocity increases
proportionally to the square of the
diameter and therefore one wishes to get
the smallest water droplets to coalesce
General Introduction
A multidisciplinary investigation
Surface chemistry
Surface/interface characteristics
Chemistry
Electrochemistry
Continuum mechanics and Multiphase flow
Drop-drop interaction
Electrostatic forces
Systems with multiple droplets
Turbulence
Electrical Engineering
Critical field strength
Effect of frequency AC vs. DC fields
Coalescence efficiency
Industrial application
Industrial prototypes
Novel separation philosophy
Oil
Water
The Stability of Water in Oil emulsion is due to:
Production history
Oil characteristics
Water characteristics
Crude oil composition and characteristics play a role in stabilizing water-in-oil emulsion:
Asphaltenes and Resins natural emulsifying agents
Brief overview on how does chemical and electrostatic emulsion resolution methods work
My contribution:
Hypothesis on how external field applied to emulsion influences the aggregation
properties of natural emulsifying agents and thereby the emulsion stability
Apparatus for measuring the effect of an electrostatic field on crude oil, inline at an
offshore installation. (Patent owned by Aibel)
The importance of surface chemistry
Short overviews
Emulsion stability due to production history
A blend of oil and water is forced to the surface through vertical
casing. The resulting shear energy and pressure decline produces a
“tight” oil/water emulsion once at the surface.
To enroute the blend into the production equipment, where primary
separation and dehydration takes place may require that many
emulsions are heated, pressurized, pumped, and pushed through
pipelines.
Once at the production facility, the emulsion is generally a
homogenized blend of oil, water, gas and contaminants. An
understanding of the production history can provide an insight into
the nature of the emulsion.
Consider:
Different lift techniques
Pressure in the reservoir
Pressure cycles
The mixture is often heated
Injection of the optimum de-emulsifier
Varying water content
1
10
100
1000
10000
100000
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Temperature (oC)
Vis
co
sity (
mP
as)
0,915
0,925
0,935
0,945
0,955
0,965
0,975
De
nsity (
g/m
l)
viscosity
shear rheology (100/s)
shear rheology (100/s)
density
T [C]
Vis
cosi
ty [
mP
a]
Den
sity
[g/m
l]
Emulsion stability due to oil characteristic
Oil specific gravity and viscosity are traditionally the fundamental
physical properties used to evaluate emulsion stability. They are
principally responsible for the separation rates of a water-in-oil
emulsion.
Interfacial tension and conductivity are equally important.
Crude oils, in addition to a mixture of hydrocarbon fractions, also
contain a non-homogeneous blend of a variety of compounds, such
as surfactants, anions, cations, clay, sand, silt, and bacteria.
The degree of emulsion stability depends on most of the following
factors:
The size of the dispersed water droplets
The age of the emulsion
The viscosity of the oil
The difference in the density of the two liquids
The volume percentage of the water cut
The interfacial tension
The asphaltenes, paraffin and suspended solids content.
Wavelength (nm)
Ap
pa
ren
t ab
so
rban
ce
2200 12001700
Wavelength (nm)
Ap
pa
ren
t ab
so
rban
ce
2200 12001700
Near-Infrared spectroscopy
Wavelength (nm)
Appar
ent A
bso
rban
ce
Production history and oil characteristics
In order to increase the sedimentation velocity and
enhance oil waterseparation one can:
A water droplet falling in oil can be in first approximation
considered as a sphere. In a very conservative way the
sedimentation velocity is used to design a separtion vessel.
Maximise the density difference
Decrease viscosity
Increase the droplet size
The viscosity varies exponentially.
The greatest effect is experienced for
temperatures below 80º C
One can observe that the curves
become more flat at higher
temperature
1
10
100
1000
10000
100000
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Temperature (oC)
Vis
co
sity (
mP
as)
0,915
0,925
0,935
0,945
0,955
0,965
0,975
De
nsity (
g/m
l)
viscosity
shear rheology (100/s)
shear rheology (100/s)
density
Emulsion stability due to water characteristic
Low water pH neutralizes the naturally occurring
basic surfactants so that better water quality can be
achieved
Low brine pH may contribute to the stability of the
emulsion by chemically altering the water droplet
interface.
Generally, produced water salinity varies directly
with oil gravity and inversely with oil viscosity:
low salinity brines accompany heavy, high
viscosity oils
high salinity brines accompany light, low
viscosity oils
Generally, water wet solids should not interfere with
the coalescence and separation processes.
Oil-wetted solids tend to hinder separation by
accumulating at the droplet interface.
Asphaltenes and Resins:
natural emulsifying agents
Emulsion stability is governed primarily by the state
of solubility of the asphaltenes in the crude oil.
Asphaltenes at or near the point of precipitation are
more surface-active than those which are sufficiently
solvated or molecularly dispersed.
The characteristics of the crude oil which should play
a role in determining the solubility state of the
asphaltenes include:
The resin-to-asphaltene ratio,
The aromaticity ratios of the crude medium and
resins with respect to the asphaltenes
The concentration of polar functional groups in
the
Cartoon from Kilpatrick
Asphaltenes and Resins
natural emulsifying agents
Resin-asphaltene association to form a colloidal aggregate.
Asphaltenes interact through hydrogen bonding and -bond
overlap.
Resins solvate asphaltene aggregates through polar functional
group interactions.
Resin-asphaltene colloidal aggregate association to form an
interfacial film.
Primary asphaltene aggregates cross-link to form a rigid,
viscoelastic structure at the oil-water interface
Cartoon from Kilpatrick
Chemical resolution methods
Asphaltene
”molecuke
”
Resin
molecuke
Oil
Water
Oil –Water interface
Resin-solavated
asphaltene aggregate
Resin-solavated
asphaltene aggregate
+
Properly designed chemicals react with the interfacial
film in an orderly way to promote complete
coalescence.
These chemical blends are designed to neutralize the
effect of natural emulsifying agents that stabilize the
emulsion.
Demulsifiers are surfice-active compounds, and when
added to the emulsion, they migrate to the oil/water
interface, rupture or weaken the rigid film, and enhace
coalescence of water droplets.
A properly selected chemical for the given emulsion
Adequate quantity of this chemical
Adequate mixing of the chemical in the emulsion
Sufficient retention time
Additional heat
Optimum emulsion breaking with a demulsifier requires:
Electrostatic resolution methods
A variety of electrostatic treatment techniques are available to
the designer and operator. They include AC, DC, AC/DC,
modulated and pulsed fields.
AC field Water Dipole
The driving force for droplet coalescence is based on the
dipole of the water drop.
The water molecules are aligned creating a chain of water
droplets with positive and negative poles.
Droplets that are close together will migrate towards each
other and coalesce.
At 50 Hz AC field alters polarity up to 100 times per second
and the droplet interface is most probably not charged.
DC field Charging
The DC field transfers a charge to dispersed water droplet
proportional to the voltage gradient and the oil conductivity.
The charge at the interface promotes coalescence.
The DC field promotes droplet stretching that ruptures the
outer film and enhances the droplet coalescence rate.
Oil
Oil –Water interface
Resin-solavated
asphaltene aggregate Resin-solavated
asphaltene aggregate
Water
Asphaltene
”molecuke
”
Resin
molecuke
+
Electrostatic resolution methods
E
E
Asphaltene
”molecuke
”
Resin
molecuke
+
Preliminary results show that resin-asphaltene association
form a colloidal aggregate somewhat influenced by the
presence of the electric field.
The viscoelastic properties of the film formed by cross link of
primary aggregates are dependent on the presence of the
electric field.
This suggests that electric field can be favorable for enhancing
separation and should be applied as far upstream as possible
Significance of my contribution :
Literature: Chiesa M., Ingebrigtsen S, .Melheim J.A., Hemmingsen P.V. and Hansen B.E.:“The role of viscosity on electrically induced coalescence
of water drops in oil”. Separation and Purification Technology, Volume 50, Issue 2, 2006, pp 267-277
Oil
Oil –Water
interface
Resin-solavated
asphaltene aggregate Resin-solavated
asphaltene aggregate
Water
Combined Chemical and Electrostatic
resolution methods
The chemical selection and evaluations are typically based
on widely accepted “bottle test” methods
This technique may fail to select the proper chemical
demulsifier for electrostatic coalescence and separation.
Just as the chemical demulsifier acts at the water droplet
interface, so does electrostatic coalescence.
If not properly selected, the applied electrostatic field may
interfere with the demulsifier action.
However, when properly selected, the electrostatic field can
significantly augment the chemical activity and ultimately
separation
E
E
Significance of my contribution :
Apparatus for inline measuring the effect of
electrostatic fields on crude oil, offshore.
The apparatus is to be connected to a sample point
upstream a separator. The stream is ported through a
pipe section with electrodes on each side.
After electrodes, a three-way valve is installed so that
one can choose either to port the treated oil back to the
separator inlet or to a measuring device.
The batch test device allows for variation in:
Electric field
Temperature
Chemicals
Flow conditions
Laminar
Turbulent
The data obtain using the apparatus take into account of
production history issues and physiochemical properties
of the crude.
Patent application: Erik Hansen, Matteo Chiesa and Pål Jahre Nilsen “An apparatus for measuring the effect of an electrostatic field on crude
oil, inline at an offshore installation.”. Patent application number at Oslo Patentkontor AS: 2007 3231
Significance of my contribution :
VIEC batch test for Ofon
10% WC, 80degC, no chemicals
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0 10 20 30 40 50
Time (min)
Re
ma
inin
g w
ate
r in
oil W
iO (
%)
WiO(%) OFF
WiO(%) ON
Settling curves for real crude oil, 80°C (176 ° F)
A multidisciplinary investigation
Surface chemistry
Surface/interface characteristics
Chemistry
Electrochemistry
Continuum mechanics and Multiphase flow
Drop-drop interaction
Electrostatic forces
Systems with multiple droplets
Turbulence
Electrical Engineering
Critical field strength
Effect of frequency AC vs. DC fields
Coalescence efficiency
Industrial application
Industrial prototypes
Novel separation philosophy
Oil
Water
The water drops motion is due to different
forces. A framework that takes into
account such forces is proposed.
The framework is tested on two drops
system and semi-stationary multi drops
system
The development of efficient data
structure and numerical algorithms is
necessary to describe dynamic system.
Turbulent electro-coalescence is
described and the results resemble
qualitatively the results obtained
experimentally
Continuum mechanics & Multiphase flow
Modelling and experimental efford to describe
Turbulent electro-coalescence
Experiments are performed to observe the behavior of a droplet falling
towards a stationary one.
Mathematical models for these forces are presented and discussed with
respect to the implementation in a multi-droplet Lagrangian framework.
The droplet motion is mainly due to buoyancy, drag, film-drainage, and
dipole-dipole forces. Attention is paid to internal circulations, non-ideal
dipoles, and the effects of surface tension gradients.
The optical observations are compared with the results from numerical
simulations.
Drop-drop interaction
Literature: Chiesa M., Melheim J., Pedersen A., Ingebrigtsen S. and Berg G: “ Forces acting on two water droplets in oil under the influence of an electric
field: numerical predictions versus experimental observations”. European Journal of Mechanics B/Fluids, Vol. 24 717-732 2005.
h
2r
Experimental setup
Experimental set-up designed for visual
observation of the behavior of water
droplets in oil, exposed to an electric field.
A movable 15 mm electrode-gap
arrangement is placed vertically inside a
cubic test cell.
The cell is placed in an optical bench to
obtain a shadow-graphic representation
of the water droplets as shown.
FIRST STEP: A TWO DROPLET SYSTEM
The forces acting on each droplet
determine its motion:
Fext (external forces on the
droplet)
Ffluid (forces from the fluid on
the droplet)
Fd-d (inter-droplets forces)
ii
dt
du
x
dd-extfluidi
idt
dm FFF
u
E=0 V/mm E=400 V/mm
MODELLING FRAMEWORK
In the Lagrangian formulation of the
droplet motion, the best results is
obtained with:
Drag force of LeVan [1]
Film-thinning force of Vinogradova [2]
Analytical expression of the electric force of Davis [3]
Literature: Chiesa M., Melheim J., Pedersen A., Ingebrigtsen S. and Berg G: “ Forces acting on two water droplets in oil under the influence of an electric
field: numerical predictions versus experimental observations”. European Journal of Mechanics B/Fluids, Vol. 24 717-732 2005.
THE EFFECT OF INTERNAL
RECIRCULATION ON THE DRAG FORCE
LeVan formula:
1
1
1
1
d)(233
|)|(3/2)(223
Re
24
r
rC
c
cc
vu N/m 10 5
1
0
vuvuF ACdcd 2
1
E = 300 V/mm, r = 110 μm
THE EFFECT OF FILM THINNING
rrr
f fh
ae
ev *2
c )(6
F
The model of Vinogradova:
1
61ln
61
6
2*
h
b
b
h
b
hf
E = 300 V/mm, r = 110 μm
where are complicated series depending on and
DIPOLE-DIPOLE FORCE
The analytical expression of Davis:
Dipole induced dipole model (DID) of Siu et al
1cos312 2
1
43
1
3
2
22
KrrF or dE
2sin12 2
43
1
3
2
22 KrrF ot
dE
2
2
2
1
2
2
2sinFcosF4 rF or E
2sinF4 3
2
2
2rF ot E
31 - FF / 2rd / 21 rr
42
2
2
1
2
2
2
2
1
23
2
3
1
2
42
1
2
53
2
42
2
2
53
1
1
331
rr
rrrr
r
r
r
rK
d
d
d
d
d
d
32
2
2
1
2
3
2
3
1
2
32
1
2
33
2
32
2
2
33
1
2
3
221
rr
rr
r
r
r
rK
dd
d
d
d
E = 300 V/mm, r = 110 μm
WATER DROPS FALLING UNDER THE
INFLUENCE OF AN ELECTRIC FIELD
t = 0s
t = 0.56s E
t = 0s
t = 0.56s E
t = 0.8s t = 0.808s
Experimental observation Numerical prediction
Literature: Chiesa M., Melheim J., Pedersen A., Ingebrigtsen S. and Berg G: “ Forces acting on two water droplets in oil under the influence of an electric
field: numerical predictions versus experimental observations”. European Journal of Mechanics B/Fluids, Vol. 24 717-732 2005.
In a stagnant water-in-oil emulsion subjected to an
external AC electrical field adjacent drops will
attract each other.
The discrete drop model of the emulsion presented
earlier is used to calculate the two-dimensional
motion of the individual, spherical water drops
directly from the forces acting on them.
The hydrodynamic interaction between the drops
and the interstitial oil phase is taken into account,
together with the effect of the electrical field.
Coalescence is assumed to occur when two drops
collide.
DIRECT ELEMENT METHOD SIMULATION OF
A STATIONARY MULTI DROPLET SYSTEM
DIRECT ELEMENT METHOD SIMULATION OF
A STATIONARY MULTI DROPLET SYSTEM
Literature: Chiesa M., Norheim S., Pedersen A.:“Predicted and measured droplet growth in an electrostatic field”. To be submitted to “European Journal of
Mechanical Engineering B/Fluids” 2006.
Predicted and measured droplet growth due to the electrical field
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1 5 9 13 17 21 25 29 33 37
Droplet diameter (px=6.67e-6m)
Acc.
vo
lum
etr
ic d
rop
let
dis
trib
utio
n
Fig 9c
Fig 9d
Fig 9b
Fig 9a
Fig 11a
Fig 11b
Fig 11c
Fig 11d
CELL STRUCTURE FOR THE DETECTION OF
NEIGHBOURING PARTICLES
A separate particle cell structure
A priority list for events to handle
Events are for instance collisions and transfer
between particle cells
Adaptive cell structure
Literature: Melheim J. and Chiesa M.: “Formulation and numerical performance of an adaptive algorithm for efficient
collision detection.” ASME Fluids Engineering Summer Conference USA 2005
THE CLUSTER INTEGRATION METHOD FOR
THE EFFICIENT CALCULATION
Literature: Melheim J. and Chiesa M.: “Formulation and numerical performance of an adaptive algorithm for efficient
collision detection.” ASME Fluids Engineering Summer Conference USA 2005
Virtual radius for each drop.
A test move (hard-sphere algorithm) is
employed to search for droplets with
overlapping virtual radii during the next global
time step.
The clusters are integrated separately using an
embedded Runge-Kutta scheme.
After a local time step is successfully
performed, the fluctuating velocities and the
turbulence frequency of those droplets are
updated using a Runge-Kutta scheme for
stochastic differential equations.
CORRELATED DROP MOTION
The instantaneous velocity ``seen'' by the droplets is needed to calculate the forces.
A model for the fluctuating fluid velocity, that correlates the fluid velocities seen by close droplets is used.
The model is based on a stochastic differential equations, Langevin Eq.
We obtain correlated fluctuating velocity for each drop
Un-correlated
Correlated
Literature: Melheim J. A..:“Correlated motion of inertial particles in turbulent flows”. Submitted to “Physics of Fluids” 2006.
Simulation of turbulent electro-coalescene
E=250 V/mm
1000
2.2
cP4
kg/m1000
kg/m800
wE,
oilE,
oil
3
3
oil
w
m20
sm216.0
sm05.0
m/s3.0
%2
3-2
2-2
d
k
U
In
In
w
3cm
Literature: Melheim J. and Chiesa M.: “Simulation of
turbulent electrocoalescence ” Chemical Engineering
Science, Volume 61, Issue 14, 2006, pp 4540 - 4549
SIGNIFICANCE OF MY CONTRIBUTION
A numerical framework able to describe
turbulence electro-coalescence
Big step forward to provide process
engineers a design tool for separation
equipment
Possibility to take into account for the
presence of electrostatic internals.
Modelling and experimental efford to describe
Turbulent electro-coalescence
A multidisciplinary investigation
Surface chemistry
Surface/interface characteristics
Chemistry
Electrochemistry
Continuum mechanics and Multiphase flow
Drop-drop interaction
Electrostatic forces
Systems with multiple droplets
Turbulence
Electrical Engineering
Critical field strength
Effect of frequency AC vs. DC fields
Coalescence efficiency
Industrial application
Industrial prototypes
Novel separation philosophy
Oil
Water
WATER DROPLET INSTABILITY
• A water drop will elongate due to the electric stress on its
surface
• Above a critical field strength the drop becomes unstable
and breaks up
– : surface tension
– : permittivity
• Defines the maximum applicable field in an
electrocoalescer
rEcrit
2648.0
FORCES ON THE DROPLET
• Capillary pressure due to the
surface tension
• Electrostatic pressure
• Shape close to a rotational
ellipsoid
x
(0,b) (a,0)
y
1 2
E
21
11rrcP
2
21 EPe
SOME EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
• Critical field increases with
decreasing drop size
• Excellent fit to theory
5.00
10.00
15.00
20.00
25.00
30.00
35.00
0 100 200 300 400
Drop radius [mm]
Ele
ctri
c fi
eld
[kV
/cm
]
Theory, IFT=40.04
No surfactant
0.025 % surf.
0.1 % surf.
Theory, IFT=20
Breakup modes depends on
voltage waveform and
frequency:
50 Hz square wave voltage
2000 Hz sine wave voltage
EFFECT OF FREQUENCY AC vs. DC FIELDS
• Insulating barriers are used to – prevent breakdown due to water
bridges (conductive water drops)
– limit charge injection from electrodes
• Local electric field determined by – conductivity of oil and barrier
– permittivity of oil and barrier
– frequency of applied voltage
• DC voltage: Resisitive voltage
distribution, Eoil 0 (red line)
• AC voltage: Capacitive voltage
distribution (blue line)
A multidisciplinary investigation
Surface chemistry
Surface/interface characteristics
Chemistry
Electrochemistry
Continuum mechanics and Multiphase flow
Drop-drop interaction
Electrostatic forces
Systems with multiple droplets
Turbulence
Electrical Engineering
Critical field strength
Effect of frequency AC vs. DC fields
Coalescence efficiency
Industrial application
Industrial prototypes
Novel separation philosophy
Oil
Water
Electro-coalescence
Compact coalescers -> Turbulent flow and electrostatic fields
HV
AC •The turbulence causes collisions between droplets.
•The electric field enhances the chance of
coalescence when drops collide.
The evolution equation
• The continuous equation (PBE);
• The discrete equation;
• The proportionality coefficient;
00
),(),(),(),(),(),(2
1
d
),(dvdtvnvvQtvnvdtvntvvnvvvQ
t
tvnv
max
3 33
00
)(
0
),(),(d
d im
m mmii
il
l
liIntm
m
mmlli nddQnnddQnt
n
),(),(),( mieffmiturbmi ddQddQddQ
MODELLING COMPACT COALESCERS
The collision frequency
32
37
31
1
)(2
)(8
),(
ji
ji
jiturb
rrC
rrC
ddQ
RL
RL
MODELLING COMPACT COALESCERS–1D
The collision efficiency
The collision efficiency is a measure of the probability of
coalescence when two droplets collide.
The probability of coalescence is determined by the time
required for the film to rupture and the interaction time of
the droplets.
Predicted and measured droplet growth in coalescer
0
0,1
0,2
0,3
0,4
0,5
0,6
0,7
0,8
0,9
1
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
Droplet diameter (m)
Acc. vo
lum
etr
ic d
rop
let
dis
trib
uti
on
inlet
6kV experiments
6kV simulation
12kV experiments
12kV simulation
MODELLING COMPACT COALESCERS–1D
A multidisciplinary investigation
Surface chemistry
Surface/interface characteristics
Chemistry
Electrochemistry
Inter-droplet interaction
Drop-drop interaction
Electrostatic forces
Coalescence efficiency
Multiphase flow
Systems with multiple droplets
Turbulence
Industrial application
Industrial prototypes
Novel separation philosophy
Oil
Water