+ All Categories
Home > Documents > University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t...

University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t...

Date post: 03-Jul-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
56
Transcript
Page 1: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � ! " # � $ % � " % � & ' � % ( " � � % � ) � * + % � % � � % � ) � � , - � � # � % " $ + ) � " ) "

. � / " $ � � % 0 � & 1 2 2 � � � � � % - ( � ) � 3 �4 5 6 + � � % ( ' � $ 3 � + % $ " " %

- ( � ) � 3 � * 1 � * 7 8 7 8 9 : 9 8 ; 5' � $ ) ( 6 8 * < 8 8 =

> ? � � � � � � � � � �@ A B C D E D F G B C E H F I D E H J F J K F G C B L H L M N O P Q E H J N R S Q T A F G F U A F G F B C D G F C F H U F J E HB H U G L J V W U B L H U L E D L B H U L M K B F T M L G J B C W G F U F M L V H J E U B L H C L M D A X C B W C Y Z H U E [ B H \E J B C W G F U F C U E H W F ] T F ^ H J U A E U U A F B H B U B E _ F I D G F C C B L H L M D A X C B W E _ L ` C F G K E U B L HH E U V G E _ _ X L W W V G C B H E W L H U F I U L M H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F E _ \ F ` G E Y Z H U A B C T E X EM L G b E _ B C b C B b B _ E G U L c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C L W W V G C ^ G C U ] ` V U H L U H F W F C C E G B _ X T B U A

U A F V C V E _ B H U F G D G F U E U B L H C Y d X M L _ _ L T B H \ U A B C _ B H F T F C A L T A L T U A F L V U _ B H F C L MU A F T F _ _ a [ H L T H M L G b C L M D A X C B W E _ U A F L G X E G B C F ^ G C U B H H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F M L G b Y

@ A F F I E W U G F _ E U B L H L M W L b b V U E U B K F E H J H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F U A F L G B F C G E B C F C EA L C U L M D G L ` _ F b C Y

@ A F C U E G U B H \ D L B H U M L G U A B C B H K F C U B \ E U B L H B C U A F G F D G F C F H U E U B L H L M W E _ W V _ V CB H E H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F M G E b F T L G [ Y Z H C V W A E M G E b F T L G [ J F G B K E U B K F C E G F G F D G F aC F H U F J ` X W L b b V U E U L G C ] L G b L G F \ F H F G E _ _ X ` X D G L J V W U C U A E U C E U B C M X U A F e E W L ` BB J F H U B U X E H J U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F Y Z M T F U E [ F W L b b V U E U L G C N h i j Q k h j l j hB H E H E ` C U G E W U E _ \ F ` G E E H J J F ^ H F m h k N h i n Q M L G E ^ I F J F _ F b F H U n ] U A F Hm E W U C _ B [ F E J F G B K E U B K F B H U A F C F H C F U A E U m o h j p k m o h p j q h m o j p o U A F

f F B ` H B g G V _ F p Y r C C L L H E C T F A E K F W E _ W V _ V C B H C V W A E M G E b F T L G [ ] W L H W F D U C L M\ F L b F U G X E G F B b b F J B E U F _ X E K E B _ E ` _ F Y s L G F I E b D _ F ] B M T F A E K F U T L J F G B K E U B K F Ct u h k N h i n Q E H J t v h k N h i w Q ] U A F H T F W E H W L H C B J F G U A F W L b b V U E U L G L M

Page 2: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

U A F C F J F G B K E U B K F C N t u i t v Q h k t u t v h l t v t u h k N N n i w Q i h Q x @ A F H L H aW L b b V U E U B L H L M J F G B K E U B L H C W L G G F C D L H J C U L W V G K E U V G F B H \ F L b F U G X ] E H J B H J F F J

T F C A E _ _ C F F U A E U U A F F E G _ B F C U F b F G \ F H W F L M W V G K E U V G F B H U A B C W L H U F I U B C U A FM L G b E _ E H E _ L \ L M U A F W V G K E U V G F L M E \ E V \ F W L H H F W U B L H y

s L G b V _ U B K E G B E ` _ F W E _ W V _ V C T F H F F J K E G B E ` _ F C z { i z | i } } } i z ~ E H J F _ F b F H U C� { i � | i x x x i � ~ C V W A U A E U � � h k � h � � z � k N h i � � Q x s L G E C B b D _ F C U G F D G F C F H U E a

U B L H T F C A E _ _ E C C V b F U A F U A F z � W L b b V U F T B U A L H F E H L U A F G ] E H J U A E U U A F � �W L b b V U F T B U A L H F E H L U A F G Y � B H W F T F T E H U � � z � k � � � o U A F � G L H F W [ F G J F _ U E� � � B C F c V E _ U L L H F B M � E H J � E G F F c V E _ E H J B C g F G L L U A F G T B C F p ] T F b V C U A E K F

U A F W L b b V U E U L G F c V E U B L H N z � i � � Q k � � � x @ A V C b V _ U B K E G B E ` _ F W E _ W V _ V C B H U A B CH L H a W L b b V U E U B K F G F D G F C F H U E U B L H J F b E H J C U A F W L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H C

N z � i z � Q k SN � � i � � Q k S

N z � i � � Q k � � �@ A F C F F c V E U B L H C E G F U A F � � E U ` E W [ \ G L V H J � M L G L V G H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W E _ W V a_ V C Y @ A F G F E J F G T B _ _ H L U F U A E U U A B C � E U ` E W [ \ G L V H J A E C U A F C E b F D E U U F G H L MW L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H C E C E ` E G F M L G b L M c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C T A F H U A F z

K E G B E ` _ F C E G F B H U F G D G F U F J E C D L C B U B L H E H J U A F � K E G B E ` _ F C E G F B H U F G D G F U F J E Cb L b F H U E Y Z H E W F G U E B H C F H C F U A B C b F E H C U A E U L V G W L H C B J F G E U B L H C C U E G U B H U A Fc V E H U V b J L b E B H Y � L U F U A E U � E U B C E W L G G F W U E J � F W U B K F ] C B H W F U A F J F G B K E U B K F C� � E _ _ W L b b V U F T B U A L H F E H L U A F G Y

f F U h � ` F E W L _ _ F W U B L H L M F _ F b F H U C L M U A B C E _ \ F ` G E Y � F ^ H F � W L K E G B E H UJ F G B K E U B K F C � T B U A � � k � � l h � ` X U A F M L G b V _ E

t � � k N � i � � Q k � � � l N � i h � Q x� L b D V U B H \ U A F W V G K E U V G F ] L H F ^ H J C

N t � i t � Q � k N N � � i � � Q i � QE H J

N � � i � � Q k � � h � l � � h � q N h � i h � Q x@ A F G F E J F G T B _ _ G F W L \ H B g F U A B C _ E C U F I D G F C C B L H E C U A F M L G b V _ E M L G U A F W V G K E U V G FL M E \ E V \ F W L H H F W U B L H Y

O

Page 3: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

Z H B H U F G M E W B H \ U A B C M L G b E _ B C b T B U A D A X C B W C T F E J L D U U A F W L V D _ B H \ F c V E U B L H� z � � � � k � � k � � l h � x

@ A F G F E J F G T B _ _ G F W L \ H B C F U A B C E C U A F b B H B b E _ W L V D _ B H \ D L C U V _ E U F B H U A F W L H aU F I U L M � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C Y � F G F T F U E [ F B U B H U A F W L H U F I U L M W L b b V U E U L G C L G

� L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C ] L G E b L G F \ F H F G E _ D G L J V W U C E U B C M X B H \ U A F e E W L ` B B J F H U B U X E H JU A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F E C J F C W G B ` F J E ` L K F Y � H F G F U G B F K F C U A F D A X C B W C L M E \ E V \ F ^ F _ J

B H U A B C M L G b E _ B C b Y @ A B C B C U A F F C C F H W F L M U A F D E U U F G H ` F A B H J U A F s F X H b E H a� X C L H J F G B K E U B L H L M F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b M G L b W L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H C N O � ] O � Q ]E H J B U C B b D L G U B C b L G F \ F H F G E _ Y d F W E V C F U A F ` G E W [ F U C W E H ` F B H U F G D G F U F JE C W L b b V U E U L G C L G E C � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C T B U A C D F W B E _ C U G V W U V G F ] U A F M L G b E _ B C bW E H ` F C F F H B H E b V _ U B D _ B W B U X L M W L H U F I U C Y � F F D F G G F _ E U B L H C A B D C T B U A W V G K E U V G FE H J b F U G B W E G F G F _ E U F J U L U A B C C A B M U B H \ L M W L H U F I U C E C E G F G F _ E U B L H C A B D C T B U Ac V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C T A F G F U A F c V E H U V b M L G b E _ B C b B C L ` U E B H F J ` X U A F � B G E WD G F C W G B D U B L H L M G F D _ E W B H \ � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C ` X W L b b V U E U L G C Y � F T B _ _ J B C W V C C

U A F C F B C C V F C B H � F W U B L H � L M U A B C D E D F G Y @ A F L G \ E H B g E U B L H L M U A F D E D F G B C E CM L _ _ L T C Y

� F W U B L H O L M U A B C D E D F G T F J B C W V C C U A F D G L D F G U B F C L M U A F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K FJ B C W G F U F W E _ W V _ V C U A E U V H J F G _ B F C L V G T L G [ Y � F G F T F ` F \ B H T B U A U A F W L H C B J F G E a

U B L H L M E U F b D L G E _ L D F G E U L G n T B U A U A F D G L D F G U X U A E U � n k n � � M L G E � U B b FC F G B F C � z i z � i z � � i } } } x @ A V C z n k n z � i z � n k n z � � i } } } x @ A B C M L G b E _ B C bM L G U B b F C F G B F C \ B K F C G B C F U L U A F U B b F J F G B K E U B K F m h k N h i n Q k h n l n h kn h � l n h k n o h � l h p i E W L b b V U E U L G G F D G F C F H U B H \ E J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B K F Y

� L U F U A E U m h C E U B C ^ F C U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F ] E D G B K B _ F \ F H L U C A E G F J ` X U A F V C V E _W L b b V U E U B K F J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B K F Y @ A B C C F W U B L H J B C W V C C F C U A F J B C W G F U F L G J F G F JW E _ W V _ V C o � � � p U A E U E G B C F C M G L b U A B C B J F E E H J E D D _ B F C U A F C F B J F E C U L E H V b a` F G L M C B U V E U B L H C Y Z H D E G U B W V _ E G ] T F W L H C B J F G U A F L H F K E G B E ` _ F W E C F L M U A FW L b b V U E U L G F c V E U B L H N z i m z Q k n � E H J C A L T U A E U B U _ F E J C U L E d G L T H B E H

T E _ [ ] E H J U A E U B M T F U E [ F U A F C B g F L M U A F U B b F C U F D B H U L E W W L V H U ] U A F H U A FJ B � V C B L H W L H C U E H U M L G E d G L T H B E H D G L W F C C E G B C F C H E U V G E _ _ X E C � � O x � F W L b aD E G F U A B C T B U A U A F V C V E _ J F G B K E U B L H L M U A F J B � V C B L H W L H C U E H U E H J U A F J B � V C B L HJ B � F G F H U B E _ F c V E U B L H Y � F U A F H W L b D E G F U A B C C B U V E U B L H T B U A U A F L H F J B b F H aC B L H E _ � W A G �L J B H \ F G F c V E U B L H ] b L J F _ B H \ B U B H G F _ E U B L H U L E J B � V C B L H D G L W F C C

T B U A W L b D _ F I E b D _ B U V J F C Y Z H U A B C K B F T D L B H U L H F C F F C U A E U U A F C U F D _ F H \ U A L MU A F J B � V C B L H D G L W F C C B C U A F � L b D U L H T E K F _ F H \ U A E C C L W B E U F J T B U A U A F b E C C

M L G U A F D E G U B W _ F ] E H J U A F U B b F B C U A F � L b D U L H U B b F Y s L G U A F � _ E H W [ b E C C U A B C\ B K F C E C U F D F c V E _ U L U A F � _ E H W [ _ F H \ U A E H J E U B b F B H U F G K E _ F c V E _ U L U A F � _ E H W [

R

Page 4: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

U B b F Y � F C D F W V _ E U F L H U A F G F _ E U B L H C A B D L M U A B C G F C V _ U U L � L B H U T L G [ T B U A � B F G G F� L X F C E H J L U A F G C N R � Q Y � F W L H C B J F G L U A F G U B b F C F G B F C U A E U W E H ` F G F \ E G J F J E CC L _ V U B L H C U L U A B C � F B C F H ` F G \ G F _ E U B L H ] U A F D G L ` _ F b L M V C B H \ b L G F K E G B E ` _ F C E H JE b L J F _ U A E U B C G F _ E U F J U L E J B C W G F U F K F G C B L H L M U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L HL M F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B W M L G b E _ B C b Y

� F W U B L H R F I E b B H F C U A F W L H C F c V F H W F C M L G E D E G U B W _ F T A L C F D L C B U B L H a b L ab F H U V b W L b b V U E U L G B C F c V E U F J U L E b F U G B W ^ F _ J Y � F G F T F C F F A L T U A Ff F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H o E H J B b D _ B W B U _ X J B � F G F H U B E _ \ F L b F U G B W C U G V W U V G F p W L b F CH E U V G E _ _ X M G L b U A F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W E _ W V _ V C Y @ A B C B C E K F G X \ F H F G E _ G F C V _ UE H J B H C F W U B L H � T F J B C W V C C B U B H E b L G F E I B L b E U B W W L H U F I U E C J F C W G B ` F J B H U A B CB H U G L J V W U B L H Y @ A B C C F W U B L H J B C W V C C F C U A F B H U B b E U F G F _ E U B L H C A B D ` F U T F F H U A E Uf F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H E H J U A F e E W L ` B E H J f F B ` H B g B J F H U B U B F C U A E U B C G F K F E _ F J` X L V G H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W E _ W V _ V C Y Z H C F W U B L H � L V G C U E H W F _ F E J C U L E H B H K F G aC B L H L M U A F V C V E _ � B G E W b E I B b � G F D _ E W F � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C T B U A W L b b V U E U L G C � YZ M T F G F D _ E W F W L b b V U E U L G C T B U A � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C U A E U L ` F X E f F B ` H B g G V _ FC E U B C ^ F J ` X U A F W L b b V U E U L G C ] U A F H U A F J X H E b B W E _ K E G B E ` _ F C T B _ _ L ` F X � E b B _ a

U L H   C F c V E U B L H C Y @ A V C T F W E H U E [ F � E b B _ U L H   C F c V E U B L H C E C E W _ E C C B W B g E U B L H L ML V G U A F L G X Y r b L H \ L U A F G U A B H \ C ] U A B C D L B H U L M K B F T F I D _ E B H C U A F E D D F E G E H W FL M U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H B H U A F E ` C U G E W U M L G b E _ B C b Y Z H U F G D G F U B H \ T B U A� L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C ] T F L ` U E B H E H F T D G L L M o K B E e E W L ` B B J F H U B U X p L M U A F W _ E C C B W E _G F C V _ U U A E U E � F T U L H B E H D E G U B W _ F b L K B H \ B H \ F H F G E _ B g F J W L L G J B H E U F C E W W L G J B H \

U L f E \ G E H \ F   C F c V E U B L H C J F C W G B ` F C E \ F L J F C B W B H U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H Y� F W U B L H ¡ J B C W V C C F C U A F G F _ E U B L H C A B D L M U A F J B C W G F U F L G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C T B U A ¢ aJ F M L G b E U B L H C E H J c V E H U V b \ G L V D C Y � F C A L T U A E U B H E c V E H U V b \ G L V D T B U AE C D F W B E _ \ G L V D _ B [ F F _ F b F H U G F D G F C F H U B H \ U A F C c V E G F L M U A F E H U B D L J F ] U A F G F B C EG F D G F C F H U E U B L H L M U A F J B C W G F U F L G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C Y Z H U A B C W E _ W V _ V C L H E c V E H U V b\ G L V D U A F C c V E G F L M U A F E H U B D L J F W E H G F D G F C F H U L H F U B W [ L M U A F W _ L W [ Y @ A F HM L _ _ L T C C F W U B L H � L H H F U T L G [ C E H J J B C W G F U F C D E W F U B b F Y @ A B C C F W U B L H B C E H F I D L aC B U B L H L M B J F E C G F _ E U F J U L C D B H H F U T L G [ C E H J U L D L _ L \ B W E _ c V E H U V b ^ F _ J U A F L G X Yr C E H F E G _ X F I E b D _ F T F J B C W V C C U A F J B C W G F U B g E U B L H L M U A F � B G E W F c V E U B L H B H

£ q £ J B b F H C B L H E _ C D E W F U B b F Y Z U B C L V G C D F W V _ E U B L H U A E U U A F E D D G L E W A F C U LJ B C W G F U F D A X C B W C B H A F G F H U B H J B C W G F U F W E _ W V _ V C E H J B H U L D L _ L \ B W E _ ^ F _ J U A F L G XE G F J F F D _ X B H U F G G F _ E U F J Y r U U A F F H J L M U A B C C F W U B L H T F L V U _ B H F U A B C G F _ E U B L H C A B DB H U A F W E C F L M E b L J F _ M L G c V E H U V b \ G E K B U X J V F U L f L V B C � G E H F Y � F W U B L H PB C E H E D D F H J B I L H U A F B U F G E H U E D D G L E W A U L b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E Y � F B H W _ V J F U A B CE D D F H J B I U L C A L T A L T L H F W E H W L H W F D U V E _ B g F b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E M G L b D L B H U L M

K B F T L M U A F J B C W G F U F Y � F W U B L H ¤ B C E D A B _ L C L D A B W E _ E D D F H J B I J B C W V C C B H \ U A F�

Page 5: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

H E U V G F L M M L V H J E U B L H C B H b E U A F b E U B W C E H J B H D A X C B W C Y¥ ¦ § ¨ © ª « @ A F M L _ _ L T B H \ G F M F G F H W F C B H G F _ E U B L H U L H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W E _ W V _ V CE G F V C F M V _ B H W L b D E G B H \ T B U A L V G E D D G L E W A N � ] £ S ] £ R ] R � Q Y ¬ V W A L M U A F D G F C F H U

T L G [ B C U A F M G V B U L M E _ L H \ C F G B F C L M J B C W V C C B L H C T B U A � B F G G F � L X F C ] E H J T F T B _ _` F D G F D E G B H \ W L _ _ E ` L G E U B K F D E D F G C L H B U Y @ A F D G F C F H U D E D F G B C E C V b b E G XM L G U A F D G L W F F J B H \ C L M U A F r � � r � L H M F G F H W F A F _ J B H � E b ` G B J \ F ] ­ H \ _ E H JB H U A F C V b b F G L M O S S O Y Z D E G U B W V _ E G _ X U A E H [ ­ J J B F � C A B H C M L G D L B H U B H \ L V U

U A F G F _ F K E H W F L M b B H B b E _ W L V D _ B H \ Y @ A F D E D F G N R � Q E _ C L T L G [ C T B U A b B H B b E _W L V D _ B H \ M L G U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H Y @ A F ^ G C U G F b E G [ E ` L V U U A Fb B H B b E _ W L V D _ B H \ L W W V G C B H U A F L G B \ B H E _ D E D F G ` X � X C L H N � Q ] B H U A F W L H U F I UL M � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C Y @ A F D E D F G N £ � Q B C T L G U A G F E J B H \ E C E W L b D E H B L H U L� X C L H Y Z H U A F D G F C F H U D E D F G T F \ F H F G E _ B g F U A F b B H B b E _ W L V D _ B H \ U L W L H U F I U CB H W _ V J B H \ ` L U A W L b b V U E U L G C E H J � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C Y @ A F G F E J F G W E H C F F U A FM V _ _ \ F H F G E _ B U X L M L V G E D D G L E W A ` X ^ G C U G F E J B H \ U A B C B H U G L J V W U B L H E H J U A F H\ L B H \ J B G F W U _ X U L C F W U B L H C � E H J � Y Z U B C U A F D V G D L C F L M U A B C D E D F G U L B H J B W E U FA L T H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W E _ W V _ V C W E H ` F V C F J B H M L V H J E U B L H C Y

® ¯ ª ° ± ² ³ ¦ ´ µ ¦ § ¦ ° ¶ « ¬ L C U L M U A B C F � L G U T E C C D L H C L G F J ` X U A F � F M F H C F r J aK E H W F J · F C F E G W A � G L � F W U C r \ F H W X o � r · � r p E H J r B G s L G W F · F C F E G W A f E ` L a

G E U L G X ] r B G s L G W F ¬ E U F G B F _ � L b b E H J ] ¸ � r s ] V H J F G E \ G F F b F H U s R S ¡ S O a S £ a O aS � S O O Y � L b F L M U A B C F � L G U T E C E _ C L C D L H C L G F J ` X U A F � E U B L H E _ Z H C U B U V U F M L G� U E H J E G J C E H J @ F W A H L _ L \ X o � Z � @ p Y @ A F ¸ Y � Y ¹ L K F G H b F H U B C E V U A L G B g F J U LG F D G L J V W F E H J J B C U G B ` V U F G F D G B H U C M L G ¹ L K F G H b F H U D V G D L C F C H L U T B U A C U E H J B H \E H X W L D X G B \ A U E H H L U E U B L H C U A F G F L H Y @ A F K B F T C E H J W L H W _ V C B L H C W L H U E B H F JA F G F B H E G F U A L C F L M U A F E V U A L G E H J C A L V _ J H L U ` F B H U F G D G F U F J E C H F W F C C E G B _ XG F D G F C F H U B H \ U A F L º W B E _ D L _ B W B F C L G F H J L G C F b F H U C ] F B U A F G F I D G F C C F J L G B b D _ B F J ]L M U A F � F M F H C F r J K E H W F J · F C F E G W A � G L � F W U C r \ F H W X ] U A F r B G s L G W F · F C F E G W Af E ` L G E U L G X ] L G U A F ¸ Y � Y ¹ L K F G H b F H U Y o � L D X G B \ A U O S S R Y p Z U \ B K F C U A F E V U A L GD _ F E C V G F U L U A E H [ � B F G G F � L X F C ] � _ B K F � B _ b B C U F G ] @ F J d E C U B H ] @ L H X � F E [ B H ]­ J J B F � C A B H C ] d E C B _ � B _ F X ] � F B U A d L T J F H ] r G _ F U E ¹ B � L G ] r C A L [ ¹ E H \ E J F E H ]f X H H W _ E B G F � F H H B C ] f L V B C f B W A U E H J � E b f L b L H E W L M L G b E H X W L H K F G C E U B L H CJ V G B H \ U A F W L V G C F L M U A B C T L G [ ] E H J U A F @ A F L G X ¹ G L V D L M U A F � U E H M L G J f B H F E Gr W W F _ F G E U L G f E ` L G E U L G X M L G A L C D B U E _ B U X J V G B H \ U A F D G F D E G E U B L H L M D E G U C L M U A FD G F C F H U D E D F G Y

Page 6: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

» � � � � � � � ¼ � � � � � � � � � � � �Z H U A B C C F W U B L H T F G F W E _ _ U A F W L H C U G V W U B L H L M E H L G J F G F J K F G C B L H L M U A F W E _ W V a_ V C L M ^ H B U F J B � F G F H W F C m ½ ¾ N O � Q ] N O P Q Y Z H U A B C W E _ W V _ V C U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F B CC E U B C ^ F J ] E H J C L U A F W E _ W V _ V C W E H ` F V C F J B H E K E G B F U X L M E D D _ B W E U B L H C Y

Z H U A F E ` C U G E W U M G E b F T L G [ L M U A B C W E _ W V _ V C ] U A F G F E G F K E G B E ` _ F C z ] F E W A L MT A B W A W L H H L U F C E U B b F C F G B F C

z i z � i z � � i x x x x� B C W G F U F V H B U U B b F C U F D C E G F B H J B W E U F J ` X U A F D G B b F C E D D F H J F J U L U A F z Yr \ F H F G E _ D L B H U B H U A F U B b F C F G B F C E U U B b F � T B _ _ ` F J F H L U F J ` X z ¿ Y d XW L H K F H U B L H _ F U U A F U B b F C U F D ` F U T F F H C V W W F C C B K F D L B H U C B H U A F C F G B F C ` F F c V E _

U L £ À Á� k £ x

@ A F H T F W E H J F ^ H F U A F K F _ L W B U X E U U B b F � ` X U A F M L G b V _ E ÀÂ o � p k z ¿ Ã { l z ¿ x

¬ L G F \ F H F G E _ _ X ] B M z J F H L U F C D L C B U B L H E U E \ B K F H U B b F ] U A F H z � l z J F H L U F CU A F K F _ L W B U X Ä Å Å Æ Ä Å Å Ç È É ] T A F G F U A F D A G E C F � E U U A E U U B b F � b V C U B H K L _ K F U A F

H F I U U B b F E C T F _ _ Y Z H E J B C W G F U F W L H U F I U U A F G F B C H L H L U B L H L M B H C U E H U E H F L V CK F _ L W B U X Y

¬ F E C V G F D L C B U B L H ] E H J X L V ^ H J z Y @ A F H b F E C V G F K F _ L W B U X ] E H J X L V \ F Uz � l z Y � L T b F E C V G F D L C B U B L H ] E H J X L V \ F U z � ` F W E V C F U A F U B b F A E C C A B M U F JU L U A F H F I U U B b F B H L G J F G U L E _ _ L T U A F K F _ L W B U X b F E C V G F b F H U Y Z H L G J F G U L

b F E C V G F K F _ L W B U X U A F D L C B U B L H B C H F W F C C E G B _ X C A B M U F J U L B U C K E _ V F E U U A F H F I UU B b F C U F D Y Z H U A B C C F H C F ] Ê Ë Ì Ç Å Ç Ë Í Ä Í Î Ï É Ð Ë Ñ Ç Å Ò È É Ä Ì Ó Ô É È É Í Å Ì Ñ Ä Í Í Ë Å Ñ Ë È È Ó Å É

Ç Í Ä Î Ç Ì Ñ Ô É Å É Õ Ô Ä È É Ö Ë Ô × Ø @ A B C B C U A F [ F X D A X C B W E _ B J F E U A E U b L U B K E U F C L V GW L H C U G V W U B L H C Y Z U T E C U A B C B J F E ] U L _ J U L U A F E V U A L G ` X � B F G G F � L X F C ] U A E U _ F J

U L L V G D E D F G C E H J D E G U B W V _ E G _ X U L N O � Q Y@ A F C B b D _ F C U B H U F G D G F U E U B L H L M U A F K E G B E ` _ F z B C U A E U U A F U B b F C F G B F C K E _ V F C

E G F H V b F G B W E _ K E _ V F C ] W L b b V U B H \ T B U A L H F E H L U A F G E H J T B U A E H X L D F G E U L G CU A E U b B \ A U ` F D G F C F H U B H U A F E C C L W B E U F J b E U A F b E U B W C L G D A X C B W C Y Z H M E W U ] T FT B _ _ L M U F H J F E _ T B U A C B U V E U B L H C T A F G F U A F z E H J U A F F _ F b F H U C L M U A F U B b F

C F G B F C E G F B H M E W U L D F G E U L G C ] H L U H F W F C C E G B _ X W L b b V U B H \ T B U A L H F E H L U A F G Y r U

¡

Page 7: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

U A F K F G X _ F E C U T F T B _ _ W L H C U G V W U E H E _ \ F ` G E U A E U b B G G L G C U A F J B C W G F U F H L H aW L b b V U E U B K B U X L M U A F L D F G E U B L H C L M D L C B U B L H E H J K F _ L W B U X b F E C V G F b F H U Y

� V G D G L � F W U B C U L U E [ F U A B C ` E C B W H L H W L b b V U E U B K B U X E U M E W F K E _ V F E H JM L _ _ L T L V U B U C W L H C F c V F H W F C Y @ L U A B C F H J T F T B _ _ M L G b V _ E U F E W E _ W V _ V C L M^ H B U F J B � F G F H W F C U A E U U E [ F C U A F L G J F G L M L ` C F G K E U B L H C B H U L E W W L V H U Y @ A B CM L G b E _ B g E U B L H B C F I D _ E B H F J ` F _ L T Y

@ L C F F b L C U W _ F E G _ X U A F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K B U X U A E U B C E U U A F ` E C F L M L V GW L H C B J F G E U B L H C ] _ F U n J F H L U F U A F L D F G E U B L H L M C A B M U B H \ U B b F ` X L H F B H W G F b F H U Y@ A V C T F W E H F H K B C E \ F E H E _ \ F ` G E L M L D F G E U B L H C U A E U W L H C B C U C B H W L b b E H J C_ B [ F n z o b F E C V G F Ù ] U A F H U B W [ U A F W _ L W [ p Y Ú Ë Å É Å Æ Ä Å Ö É Ö Ç Ð Ð Ä Û Ô É É Å Ë Å Ä × É

Å Æ É Ì É Ü Ó É Í Ñ É Ë Õ Ë Ê É Ô Ä Å Ç Ë Í Ì Õ Ô Ë È Ô Ç Û Æ Å Å Ë Ð É Õ Å Ø f F U Ý n z Ý J F H L U F U A F � C D E U B E _F K E _ V E U B L H � L M U A B C C F c V F H W F L M L D F G E U B L H C ] L ` U E B H F J B H \ F H F G E _ ` X D F G M L G b B H \E _ _ U A F B H C U G V W U B L H C E H J U A F H F K E _ V E U B H \ U A F C D E U B E _ D L C B U B L H Y @ A V C

Ý n z Ý k zT A B _ F

Ý z n Ý k z �C B H W F T A F H U A F W _ L W [ U B W [ C ] U A F D L C B U B L H C A B M U C U L U A F D L C B U B L H E U U A F H F I U

U B b F Y � F C F F U A F G F M L G F ] U A E U z n Þk n z x @ A B C B C U A F ^ G C U B H C U E H W F L M H L H aW L b b V U E U B K B U X B H U A F D A X C B W C L M J B C W G F U F C D E W F E H J U B b F Y s G L b U A F D L B H U L M

K B F T L M C D E U B E _ F K E _ V E U B L H B U B C b L C U W L H K F H B F H U U L J F W _ E G F U A F F c V E U B L Hz n k n z �

C B H W F U A F C F U T L F I D G F C C B L H C A E K F B J F H U B W E _ C D E U B E _ F K E _ V E U B L H C Y� F W E H U A F H J F ^ H F U A F � � � J F G B K E U B K F ` X U A F F c V E U B L H

m z k N z i n Q k z n l n z k n z � l n z k n o z � l z p k n � zT A F G F � z J F H L U F C U A F W _ E C C B W E _ J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B K F T B U A V H B U U B b F C U F D Y @ A F

[ F X D L B H U E ` L V U U A F � � � J F G B K E U B K F B C U A E U B U B C E W L b b V U E U L G ] E H J W L H C F ac V F H U _ X C E U B C ^ F C U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F

m o z � p k m o z p � q z m o � p x@ A B C b E [ F C B U D L C C B ` _ F U L J L J B C W G F U F W E _ W V _ V C B H E T E X U A E U B C M L G b E _ _ X C B b B _ E G

U L W _ E C C B W E _ W E _ W V _ V C Y � F T B _ _ G F D F E U U A B C C U G V W U V G F b L G F C _ L T _ X H L T ] ^ G C UG F W E _ _ B H \ U A F D G L D F G U B F C L M W _ E C C B W E _ J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B K F C Y

Page 8: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� F ` F \ B H ` X G F W E _ _ B H \ U A F V C V E _ J F G B K E U B K F B H U A F W E _ W V _ V C L M ^ H B U F J B � F G aF H W F C ] \ F H F G E _ B C F J U L E o D L C C B ` _ X p H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W L H U F I U Y

ß ¦ à ° á ¶ á ± ° « f F U� z k z � l z

J F ^ H F U A F ^ H B U F J B � F G F H W F J F G B K E U B K F L M E K E G B E ` _ F z T A L C F C V W W F C C B K F K E _ V F CB H J B C W G F U F U B b F E G F

z i z � i z � � i x x x x@ A B C � z B C E W _ E C C B W E _ J F G B K E U B K F B H U A F W E _ W V _ V C L M ^ H B U F J B � F G F H W F C Y Z U B CC U B _ _ J F ^ H F J F K F H B M U A F c V E H U B U B F C F _ F b F H U C L M U A F U B b F C F G B F C E G F B H E H L H aW L b b V U E U B K F E _ \ F ` G E Y � F C A E _ _ E C C V b F U A E U U A F K E _ V F C L M U A F U B b F C F G B F CE G F B H E D L C C B ` _ X H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F G B H \ â T B U A V H B U Y o @ A V C U A F K E _ V F C W L V _ J` F G F E _ H V b ` F G C ] W L b D _ F I H V b ` F G C ] b E U G B W F C ] _ B H F E G L D F G E U L G C L H E � B _ ` F G UC D E W F ] L G F _ F b F H U C L M E H E D D G L D G B E U F E ` C U G E W U E _ \ F ` G E Y p @ A B C b F E H C U A E UM L G F K F G X F _ F b F H U h L M U A F G B H \ â U A F G F B C E T F _ _ a J F ^ H F J C V W W F C C L G F _ F b F H Uh � ] U A F H F I U U F G b B H U A F U B b F C F G B F C Y Z U B C W L H K F H B F H U U L E C C V b F U A E U U A F

G B H \ B U C F _ M A E C U A B C U F b D L G E _ C U G V W U V G F Y Z H D G E W U B W F ] L H F B C W L H W F G H F J T B U A ED E G U B W V _ E G U B b F C F G B F C E H J H L U U A F C U G V W U V G F L M U A F F H U B G F G B H \ Y ¬ L G F L K F G ] T FC A E _ _ E C C V b F U A E U U A F H F I U a U B b F L D F G E U L G J B C U G B ` V U F C L K F G ` L U A E J J B U B L H E H Jb V _ U B D _ B W E U B L H B H U A F C F H C F U A E U

o h q j p � k h � q j �E H J

o h j p � k h � j � xr H F _ F b F H U ã L M U A F G B H \ â B C C E B J U L ` F E ã ä å æ � ç å � B M ã � k ã x

è ¦ § § ¨ é «� o z � p k z � � o � p q � o z p � x

ê © ± ± ë «� o z � p k z � � � l z �

k z � � � l z � � q z � � l z �k z � o � � l � p q o z � l z p �

k z � � o � p q � o z p � x

P

Page 9: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

@ A B C M L G b V _ E B C Î Ç ì É Ô É Í Å M G L b U A F V C V E _ M L G b V _ E B H � F T U L H B E H W E _ W V _ V C ` XU A F U B b F C A B M U L M z U L z � B H U A F ^ G C U U F G b Y � F H L T W L G G F W U U A B C J B C W G F D E H W X B HU A F W E _ W V _ V C L M ^ H B U F J B � F G F H W F C ` X U E [ B H \ E Í É Ö J F G B K E U B K F m E C E H Ç Í Ì Å Ô Ó Ñ Å Ç Ë Í

Å Ë Ì Æ Ç Õ Å Å Æ É Å Ç È É Å Ë Å Æ É Ð É Õ Å Ë Õ Å Æ É Ë Ê É Ô Ä Å Ë Ô m Ø @ A E U B C ] T F U E [ F z m o � p c V B U F_ B U F G E _ _ X E C E H B H C U G V W U B L H U L í Ô Ì Å í Í Î � � Ä Í Î Å Æ É Í í Í Î Å Æ É Ï Ä Ð Ó É Ë Õ z xZ H L G J F G U L ^ H J � � U A F W _ L W [ b V C U E J K E H W F L H F H L U W A Y @ A F G F M L G F z A E CE J K E H W F J U L z � E H J T F A E K F U A E U U A F F K E _ V E U B L H L M z m o � p B C

z � o � � l � p x

Z H L G J F G U L [ F F D U G E W [ L M U A B C H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F U B b F a C A B M U B H \ ] T F T B _ _ T G B U Fm z k n o z � l z p

T A F G F U A F F _ F b F H U n B C E C D F W B E _ U B b F a C A B M U L D F G E U L G C E U B C M X B H \� n k n � �

M L G E H X � B H U A F G B H \ â Y @ A F U B b F a C A B M U F G ] n ] E W U C U L E V U L b E U B W E _ _ X F K E _ V E U FF I D G F C C B L H C B H U A F G F C V _ U B H \ H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W E _ W V _ V C L M ^ H B U F J B � F G F H W F C Y

� F W E _ _ U A B C W E _ W V _ V C m ½ ¾ o M L G J B C W G F U F L G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C p Y � L U F U A E U n M L G ab E _ B g F C U A F L D F G E U B L H E _ L G J F G B H \ B H A F G F H U B H L V G B H B U B E _ J B C W V C C B L H L M K F _ L W B U XE H J D L C B U B L H b F E C V G F b F H U C Y r H L D F G E U L G W L H U E B H B H \ n W E V C F C E U B b F C A B M U B H

U A F K E G B E ` _ F C L G L D F G E U L G C U L U A F _ F M U L M n B H U A F C F c V F H W F L G J F G Ys L G b E _ _ X ] T F F I U F H J U A F G B H \ L M K E _ V F C â o C F F U A F J F ^ H B U B L H L M � E ` L K F p

` X E J J B H \ E H F T C X b ` L _ n T B U A U A F D G L D F G U X U A E U h n k n h � M L G F K F G X hB H â Y Z U B C E C C V b F J U A E U U A F F I U F H J F J G B H \ â B C E C C L W B E U B K F E H J C E U B C ^ F C U A FJ B C U G B ` V U B K F _ E T C L U A E U n o h q j p k n h q n j E H J n o h j p k o n h p j M L G E _ _h E H J j B H U A F G B H \ Y � F E _ C L E C C V b F U A E U n B U C F _ M B C E W L H C U E H U B H U A F C F H C F

U A E U n � k n Y@ A F [ F X G F C V _ U B H m ½ ¾ B C U A F M L _ _ L T B H \ E J � V C U F J J B � F G F H W F M L G b V _ E À

è ¦ § § ¨ î «m o z � p k z m o � p q m o � p z x

¤

Page 10: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

ê © ± ± ë «m o z � p

k n o z � � � l z � pk n o z � � � l z � � q z � � l z � p

k n o z � o � � l � p q o z � l z p �k n z � o � � l � p q n o z � l z p �

k z n o � � l � p q n o z � l z p �k z m o � p q m o z p � x

@ A F V D C A L U B C U A E U m ½ ¾ ` F A E K F C M L G b E _ _ X _ B [ F B H ^ H B U F C B b E _ W E _ W V _ V C E H JW E H ` F V C F J E C E W E _ W V _ V C B H U A B C K F G C B L H L M J B C W G F U F D A X C B W C Y Z H N O � Q � B F G G F� L X F C E H J U A F E V U A L G V C F U A B C M L V H J E U B L H U L ` V B _ J E J F G B K E U B L H L M E H L H aW L b b V U E U B K F K F G C B L H L M F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b Y r H L U A F G K F G C B L H L M U A B C J F G B K E a

U B L H W E H ` F M L V H J B H N O � Q Y Z H ` L U A W E C F C U A F J F G B K E U B L H B C E U G E H C _ E U B L H U LU A B C W L H U F I U L M U A F T F _ _ a [ H L T H s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H L M F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B W

M L G b E _ B C b M G L b W L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H C L M D L C B U B L H E H J K F _ L W B U X Y� L U F U A E U U A F J F ^ H B U B L H L M U A F J F G B K E U B K F B H m ½ ¾ B C E W U V E _ _ X E W L b b V a

U E U L G Àm z k n o z � l z p k n z � l n z k z n l n z k N z i n Q x

@ A F L D F G E U L G n W E H ` F G F \ E G J F J E C E J B C W G F U B C F J U B b F a F K L _ V U B L H L D F G E U L G B HU A F � F B C F H ` F G \ M L G b V _ E U B L H L M c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C Y Z H M E W U T F W E H T G B U F

M L G b E _ _ X U A E Uz � k n ï { z n

C B H W F n z � k z n o E C C V b B H \ M L G U A B C B H U F G D G F U E U B L H U A E U U A F L D F G E U L G n B CB H K F G U B ` _ F p Y � V U U B H \ U A F U B b F K E G B E ` _ F ` E W [ B H U L U A F F c V E U B L H ] T F \ F U U A FF K L _ V U B L H

z ¿ Ã ð ¿ k n ï { z ¿ n x@ A B C E C D F W U W E H ` F W L b D E G F J U L U A F M L G b E _ B C b L M r _ E B H � L H H F C   U A F L G X L MH L H a W L b b V U E U B K F \ F L b F U G X N � Q Y

Z H m ½ ¾ ] z E H J m z A E K F H L G F E C L H U L W L b b V U F ÀN z i m z Q k z n o z � l z p l n o z � l z p z k n o z � o z � l z p l o z � l z p z p

£ S

Page 11: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� F H W FN z i m z Q k n o z � z � l O z � z q z z p x

@ A B C B C H L H a g F G L F K F H B H U A F W E C F T A F G F z E H J z � W L b b V U F T B U A L H F E H L U A F G Y� L H C F c V F H U _ X ] T F W E H W L H C B J F G D A X C B W E _ _ E T C B H U A F M L G b

N z � i m z � Q k ñ � �T A F G F ñ � � B C E M V H W U B L H U A E U B C C V B U E ` _ F U L U A F \ B K F H E D D _ B W E U B L H Y Z H N O � QT F C A L T A L T U A F M L G b E _ B C b L M F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b E G B C F C T A F H ñ � � B C � � � ] U A F

� G L H F W [ F G J F _ U E Y Z H N O ¡ Q T F T B _ _ C A L T A L T U A F \ F H F G E _ W E C F W L G G F C D L H J C U LE � D E G U B W _ F � b L K B H \ B H E H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F \ E V \ F ^ F _ J W L V D _ F J T B U A \ F L J F C B Wb L U B L H G F _ E U B K F U L U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H E C C L W B E U F J T B U A U A F ñ � � x @ A B CG F C V _ U W E H ` F V C F J U L D _ E W F U A F T L G [ L M @ E H B b V G E N � O Q B H E J B C W G F U F W L H U F I U Y

Z U C A L V _ J ` F F b D A E C B g F J U A E U E _ _ D A X C B W C U A E U T F J F G B K F B H U A B C T E X B CM L G b V _ E U F J B H E W L H U F I U L M H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F L D F G E U L G C E H J K E G B E ` _ F C Y � FJ L H L U J F G B K F F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b ] ` V U G E U A F G E H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F E H E _ L \ Y Z UB C H L U X F U W _ F E G � V C U T A E U U A F C F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F D A X C B W E _ U A F L G B F C G F E _ _ Xb F E H Y � V G B H B U B E _ B J F E _ B C E U B L H L M b F E C V G F b F H U B C H L U U A F L H _ X b L J F _ M L Gb F E C V G F b F H U U A E U W L G G F C D L H J C U L E W U V E _ L ` C F G K E U B L H C Y � F G U E B H _ X U A F B J F E

U A E U T F W E H b F E C V G F U B b F B H E T E X U A E U A E C � C U F D C ` F U T F F H U A F C U F D C L MU B b F � B C E H B J F E _ B C E U B L H Y Z U A E D D F H C U L ` F E H B J F E _ B C E U B L H U A E U ^ U C E b L J F _ L MU A F V H B K F G C F E C E W F _ _ V _ E G E V U L b E U L H Y Z H E W F _ _ V _ E G E V U L b E U L H E H L ` C F G K E U B L H

B C T A E U E H L D F G E U L G L M U A F E V U L b E U L H b B \ A U ` F E ` _ F U L J L Y Z U B C H L U H F W F C C E G B _ XT A E U U A F � B H A E ` B U E H U C � L M U A F E V U L b E U L H W E H D F G M L G b Y � F G F B C U A F W G V I L M U A F

b E U U F G Y @ A F B H A E ` B U E H U C W E H A E K F L H _ X _ B b B U F J L ` C F G K E U B L H C L M U A F G V H H B H \ L MU A F E V U L b E U L H ] J V F U L U A F M E W U U A E U U A F X U A F b C F _ K F C E G F D G L W F C C F C G V H H B H \ L HU A F E V U L b E U L H Y @ A F U A F L G B F C T F ` V B _ J L H U A F ` E C B C L M m ½ ¾ W E H ` F U A F L G B F C

Ä ò Ë Ó Å U A F C U G V W U V G F L M U A F C F E V U L b E U E Y @ A F X T B _ _ F K F H U V E _ _ X _ F E J U L U A F L G B F CL M T A E U W E H ` F L ` C F G K F J ` X U A F D G L W F C C F C U A E U G V H L H C V W A E V U L b E U E Y Z UB C D L C C B ` _ F U A E U U A F T F _ _ [ H L T H D A F H L b F H E L M c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C T B _ _ E G B C FH E U V G E _ _ X B H C V W A E W L H U F I U Y @ A F C F D L B H U C L M K B F T C A L V _ J ` F W L b D E G F J T B U A

N £ � Q Y

ó ô õ ö ÷ ø ù ú û ü ú ý ü þ ÿ � ü ú � � � � � û � � � û ø ú � � ü � û ø ú@ L G F U V G H U L ` E C B W C ] W L H C B J F G U A F W L b b V U E U L G F c V E U B L H B H L H F C D E W F K E G B E ` _ F

z x£ £

Page 12: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

N z i m z Q k n �M L G E C B H \ _ F K E G B E ` _ F z x � G B U U F H L V U ] U A B C F c V E U B L H ` F W L b F C

n � k N z i n o z � l z p Q k z n o z � l z p l n o z � l z p z k n o z � o z � l z p l o z � l z p z p xZ M � E H J U A F F _ F b F H U C L M U A F U B b F C F G B F C z i z � i z � � i x x x � E G F E _ _ W L b b V U B H \C W E _ E G C U A F H U A B C F c V E U B L H G F J V W F C U L

� k o z � l z p | x@ A V C

z � k z � � { | iE d G L T H B E H G E H J L b T E _ [ ] B C E C L _ V U B L H U L U A F C B b D _ F C U L H F a J B b F H C B L H E _ W L b ab V U E U L G F c V E U B L H Y

� L T _ F U C F I E b B H F U A B C d G L T H B E H T E _ [ b L G F W _ L C F _ X ` X c V E H U B M X B H \ U A FU B b F C U F D E C T F _ _ E C U A F C D E W F C U F D Y � F U E [ FÁ

� k �C L U A E U

m z k n o z � l z p � �T A F G F B U B C E C C V b F J U A E U � B C E C W E _ E G ] W L b b V U B H \ T B U A E _ _ F _ F b F H U C L M U A FU B b F C F G B F C E H J W L b b V U B H \ T B U A U A F L D F G E U L G n o U A E U B C ] � J L F C H L U W A E H \ FT B U A U B b F p Y � L T F I E b B H F L H W F E \ E B H U A F F c V E U B L H

N z i m z Q k n � xf F U Ý z � l z Ý k

Áx @ A F H ] G F D F E U B H \ U A F W E _ W V _ E U B L H ] T F ^ H J

� k o z � l z p | � � kÁ | � � x

� F H W F Á | � � k � x@ A B C U F _ _ C V C U A E U B M � B C U L ` F W L H C U E H U U A F H U A F G F b V C U ` F E W L H C U E H U G F _ E a

U B L H C A B D ` F U T F F H U A F C c V E G F L M U A F C D E W F B H U F G K E _ M L G U A F d G L T H B E H T E _ [ E H JU A F C B g F L M U A F U B b F B H U F G K E _ Y @ A F G F b E G [ E ` _ F D L B H U A F G F B C U A E U B U B C � V C U U A B C

£ O

Page 13: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

W L H C U E H U G F _ E U B L H C A B D U A E U B C G F c V B G F J M L G E d G L T H B E H D G L W F C C U L ` F J F C W G B ` F J` X U A F J B � V C B L H F c V E U B L H

� � o � i � p � � � k ¾ � | � o � i � p � � � |T A F G F U A F J B � V C B L H W L H C U E H U ¾ B C \ B K F H ` X U A F M L G b V _ E

¾ kÁ | � O � k � � O x

@ A F J B � V C B L H W L H C U E H U W L b F C J B G F W U _ X M G L b L V G W L H C B J F G E U B L H B H K L _ K B H \ U A F� � � W L b b V U E U L G T B U A L V U E H X L M U A F V C V E _ W L H W F D U V E _ E D D E G E U V C E ` L V U E D aD G L I B b E U B H \ E J B � F G F H U B E _ F c V E U B L H Y

@ L b E [ F U A B C W L b D E G B C L H ] _ F U C G F W E _ _ A L T U A F J B � V C B L H F c V E U B L H V C V E _ _ XE G B C F C B H J B C W V C C B H \ d G L T H B E H b L U B L H Y � F E G F \ B K F H E d G L T H B E H D G L W F C C

T A F G F� o � q � p k � o � p �

ÁC L U A E U U A F U B b F C U F D B C � E H J U A F C D E W F C U F D B C L M E ` C L _ V U F K E _ V F

Áx � F G F \ E G J

U A F D G L ` E ` B _ B U X L M _ F M U L G G B \ A U C U F D C E C F c V E _ ] C L U A E U B M � o � i � p J F H L U F C U A FD G L ` E ` B _ B U X U A E U U A F d G L T H B E H D E G U B W _ F B C E U D L B H U � E U U B b F � U A F H

� o � i � q � p k � o � lÁ

i � p � O q � o � qÁ

p � O xs G L b U A B C F c V E U B L H M L G U A F D G L ` E ` B _ B U X T F W E H T G B U F E J B � F G F H W F F c V E U B L H M L G

U A F D E G U B E _ J F G B K E U B K F L M U A F D G L ` E ` B _ B U X T B U A G F C D F W U U L U B b F ÀN o � o � i � q � p l � o � i � p p � � Q k o � | � O � p N o � o � l

Ái � p l O � o � i � p q � o � q

Áp p �

Á | Q@ A F F I D G F C C B L H B H ` G E W [ F U C L H U A F G B \ A U A E H J C B J F B C E J B C W G F U F E D D G L I B b E U B L H

U L U A F C F W L H J D E G U B E _ L M � o � i � p T B U A G F C D F W U U L � x @ A V C B M U A F G E U B L ¾ kÁ | � O �

G F b E B H C W L H C U E H U E C U A F C D E W F E H J U B b F B H U F G K E _ C E D D G L E W A g F G L ] U A F H U A B CF c V E U B L H \ L F C B H U A F _ B b B U U L U A F J B � V C B L H F c V E U B L H

� � o � i � p � � � k ¾ � | � o � i � p � � � | xZ U B C b L C U W V G B L V C A L T U A F J B � V C B L H W L H C U E H U W L b F C V D B H U A F C F U T L W L H a

U F I U C Y f F U C U G X U L U A B H [ E ` L V U U A F W L b D E G B C L H ` F U T F F H U A F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K FL ` C F G K E U B L H E _ C U E G U B H \ D L B H U E H J U A F b L G F C U E H J E G J J B � F G F H U B E _ E D D G L I B b E a

U B L H Y Z H U A F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W L H U F I U T F \ F UÁ | M G L b U A F E D D F E G E H W F L M U A F

C c V E G F L M U A F J B � F G F H W F L M z � E H J z B H U A F W E _ W V _ E U B L H L M U A F W L b b V U E U L GL M z E H J m z x Z H U A F J B � F G F H U B E _ E D D G L I B b E U B L H ] T F \ F U U A F

Á | M G L b U A F E D aD G L I B b E U B L H L M U A F C F W L H J J F G B K E U B K F L M U A F D G L ` E ` B _ B U X � o � i � p T B U A G F C D F W U

U L � x @ A F W L H W F D U L M D G L ` E ` B _ B U X J L F C H L U E D D F E G B H U A F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K FW L H U F I U Y � _ F E G _ X U A B C C V ` � F W U H F F J C b L G F U A L V \ A U Y

£ R

Page 14: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

ó ô ó � þ ü ú � ÿ � � � � � � � ÷ � � � � � ÷ �ø � û ú � � ÷ � � � � ü � û ø ú ü ú � � � �� û � � � û ø ú � � ü � û ø ú

s B G C U G F W E _ _ U A F � _ E H W [ � V b ` F G C Y �� B C � _ E H W [   C W L H C U E H U J B K B J F J ` X O � x ã B CU A F C D F F J L M _ B \ A U Y � B C � F T U L H   C \ G E K B U E U B L H E _ W L H C U E H U Y @ A F � _ E H W [ _ F H \ U AT B _ _ ` F J F H L U F J ` X � ] U A F � _ E H W [ U B b F ` X � E H J U A F � _ E H W [ b E C C ` X x @ A F B G

M L G b V _ E C E G F k �� ã � �

� k �� � ã� k �� � ã | x

@ A F C F E b L V H U C L M b E C C ] _ F H \ U A E H J U B b F A E K F � V C U U A F C F J B b F H C B L H C E H J E G FW L H C U G V W U F J M G L b U A F K E _ V F C L M M V H J E b F H U E _ D A X C B W E _ W L H C U E H U C Y @ A F X A E K FG L _ F C B H D A X C B W C U A E U D L B H U U L J F F D F G G F E C L H C U A E H U A F M L G b E _ M L G B H U G L J V W B H \

U A F b Y � F G F T F C A E _ _ C F F A L T U A F X E G F G F _ E U F J U L U A F � W A G �L J B H \ F G F c V E U B L H Y· F W E _ _ U A E U � W A G �L J B H \ F G   C F c V E U B L H W E H ` F G F \ E G J F J E C U A F J B � V C B L H F c V E a

U B L H T B U A E H B b E \ B H E G X J B � V C B L H W L H C U E H U Y · F W E _ _ A L T U A B C T L G [ C Y @ A F� W A G �L J B H \ F G F c V E U B L H B C

� �� � ! � � � k " !T A F G F U A F � E b B _ U L H B E H " B C \ B K F H ` X U A F F c V E U B L H " k # | � O $ q % T A F G F

% o � i � p B C U A F D L U F H U B E _ F H F G \ X E H J # k �� � � � � � � B C U A F b L b F H U V b L D F G E U L G Y� B U A U A B C T F A E K F # | � O $ k o l �� | � O $ p � | � � � | x @ A V C T B U A % o � i � p k S ] U A F

F c V E U B L H ` F W L b F C � �� � ! � � � k o l �� | � O $ p � | ! � � � | T A B W A C B b D _ B ^ F C U L� ! � � � k o � �� � O $ p � | ! � � � | x

@ A V C T F A E K F E G G B K F J E U U A F M L G b L M U A F J B � V C B L H F c V E U B L H T B U A E H B b E \ B aH E G X W L H C U E H U ] E H J B U B C D L C C B ` _ F U L b E [ F U A F B J F H U B ^ W E U B L H T B U A U A F J B � V C B L HF c V E U B L H ` X C F U U B H \

�� � $ kÁ | � �

T A F G FÁ

J F H L U F C E C D E W F B H U F G K E _ ] E H J � J F H L U F C E U B b F B H U F G K E _ E C F I D _ E B H F JB H U A F _ E C U C F W U B L H E ` L V U U A F d G L T H B E H T E _ [ Y � B U A U A B C T F W E H E C [ T A E UC D E W F B H U F G K E _ E H J U B b F B H U F G K E _ T B _ _ C E U B C M X U A B C G F _ E U B L H C A B D T B U A E b E C C E H J� _ E H W [   C W L H C U E H U & ' É È Ä Ô × Ä ò Ð Ò ( Å Æ É Ä Í Ì Ö É Ô Ç Ì Å Æ Ä Å Å Æ Ç Ì É Ü Ó Ä Å Ç Ë Í Ç Ì Ì Ä Å Ç Ì í É ÎÖ Æ É Í $ Ç Ì Å Æ É ) Ð Ä Í Ñ × È Ä Ì Ì (

ÁÇ Ì Å Æ É ) Ð Ä Í Ñ × Ð É Í Û Å Æ Ä Í Î � Ç Ì Å Æ É ) Ð Ä Í Ñ × Å Ç È É * *

s L G H L U F U A E U� | � � k o �� � ã p | � o �� � ã | p k �� � x

£ �

Page 15: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

Z H L T c V L U F E H F b E B _ W L b b F H U L M � B F G G F � L X F C À � � B U A G F \ E G J U L X L V G� � � J F G B K E U B L H L M U A F J B � V C B L H F c V E U B L H ] E H J T B U A E H B b E \ B H E G X J B � V C B L HW L F º W B F H U ] U A F � W A G �L J B H \ F G F c V E U B L H ] H L U F U A E U U A F G F _ E U B L H �� � $ k � | � �B C C E U B C ^ F J M L G Ä Í Ò b E C C $ D G L K B J F J T F U E [ F � k � L b D U L H T E K F _ F H \ U A k�� � $ ã E H J � k � L b D U L H U B b F k �� � $ ã | + T A B W A B C C B b D _ X U A F U B b F L M E C U F D_ F H \ U A L M U A B C _ F H \ U A U E [ F H E U U A F K F _ L W B U X L M _ B \ A U Y Z A E K F E K E \ V F B J F E U A E U ZA F E G J L M U A B C G F _ E U B L H T A F H Z T E C E \ G E J V E U F C U V J F H U Y Z H E H X W E C F Z E b C V G Fs F X H b E H A E J B U B H b B H J T A F H A F V C F J E G E H J L b T E _ [ L H U A F _ B \ A U W L H F U LJ F G B K F U A F £ q £ � B G E W F c V E U B L H ] E H J W L V H U F J C U F D C V C B H \ � y � L ] B H E C F H C F ] X L V G� � � J F G B K E U B L H L M U A F J B � V C B L H F c V E U B L H J L F C W L H H F W U U A F ¬ E I T F _ _ F c V E U B L H CJ F G B K E U B L H K B E � � � ] U L U A F � B G E W F c V E U B L H J F G B K E U B L H + T A B W A B H E K E \ V FC F H C F T E C T A E U Z A L D F J T F T L V _ J ` F E ` _ F U L J L U A B C C D G B H \ o O S S O p Y � M W L V G C F

U A B C \ F H F G E _ G F C V _ U E D D _ B F C B H D E G U B W V _ E G U L U A F � _ E H W [ b E C C ] T A B W A T E C X L V G^ G C U L ` C F G K E U B L H Y Z U B C B H U G B \ V B H \ U A E U B M U A F b E C C C W E _ F B C $ N U A F � _ E H W [ b E C C Q ]

U A F H T F W E H V C F F B U A F G U A F � L b D U L H T E K F _ F H \ U A L G U A F � W A T E G g W A B _ J G E J B V CE U U A E U b E C C C W E _ F E C U A F C U F D _ F H \ U A B H � � � Y @ A B C G F B H M L G W F C b X W L H K B W U B L H

o F I D G F C C F J _ L H \ E \ L p U A E U F _ F b F H U E G X D E G U B W _ F C E G F C b E _ _ ` _ E W [ A L _ F C Y �@ A F _ E C U D E G U L M � L X F C   G F b E G [ E ` L V U U A F � W A T E G g W A B _ J G E J B V C G F M F G C U L

L V G T L G [ N R � Q F I D _ E B H B H \ ­ J e L H F C   b B W G L W L C b L _ L \ X Y e L H F C L ` C F G K F J U A E U B M ]M L G E D E G U B W _ F L M b E C C $ T F C F U U A F � W A T E G g W A B _ J G E J B V C o â , k O $ � � ã | p F c V E _

U L U A F � L b D U L H G E J B V C o â - k �� � O $ ã p ] U A F H U A F G F C V _ U B H \ b E C C $ B C F c V E _ U LL H F A E _ M U A F � _ E H W [ b E C C y

â , k â -O $ � � ã | k �� � O $ ã

$ k o £ � O p �� ã � � k � O@ A B C B C A B \ A _ X C V \ \ F C U B K F L M _ B b B U B H \ W L H J B U B L H C L H b E U U F G o � � _ E H W [ U L H B W b E U a

U F G � p D G B L G U L U A F d B \ d E H \ E H J _ F E J C B H U A B C T E X U L C D F W B ^ W W L C b L _ L \ B W E _D G F J B W U B L H C Y Z U E _ C L \ B K F C E H B H U G B \ V B H \ D A X C B W E _ b F E H B H \ U L U A F � _ E H W [ b E C C Y

� A E U J L F C E _ _ U A B C C E X E ` L V U U A F H E U V G F L M U A F � W A G �L J B H \ F G F c V E U B L H B U aC F _ M & Z H U F G D G F U B H \ B U E C E J B � V C B L H F c V E U B L H T B U A B b E \ B H E G X W L H C U E H U C V \ \ F C U CW L b D E G B H \ T B U A U A F � � � F c V E U B L H

N z i m z Q k n � ¾M L G E G F E _ W L H C U E H U ¾ Y @ A B C F c V E U B L H B b D _ B W E U F C E d G L T H B E H D G L W F C C T A F G F

z � k z � � T A F G F � | � � k � ¾ x � F W E H U E [ F � k . � � T A F G F � B C E G F E _ C U F D a_ F H \ U A Y @ A B C \ B K F C E d G L T H B E H T E _ [ B H U A F W L b D _ F I D _ E H F T B U A U A F W L G G F W U

£ �

Page 16: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� � � J B � V C B L H W L H C U E H U Y � L T F K F G ] U A F G F _ E U B L H C A B D L M U A B C T E _ [ T B U A U A F� W A G �L J B H \ F G F c V E U B L H B C _ F C C W _ F E G ` F W E V C F U A F ! B H U A E U F c V E U B L H B C H L U U A FD G L ` E ` B _ B U X M L G U A F d G L T H B E H D G L W F C C Y @ L C F F E W _ L C F G G F _ E U B L H C A B D T F T B _ _

U E [ F E J B � F G F H U U E W [ Y� L H C B J F G E J B C W G F U F M V H W U B L H ! o � i � p J F ^ H F J o G F W V G C B K F _ X p ` X U A F M L _ _ L T B H \

F c V E U B L H! o � i � q � p k o � � O p ! o � l

Ái � p q o £ l � p ! o � i � p q o � � O p ! o � q

Ái � p

Z H L U A F G T L G J C ] T F E G F U A B H [ B H \ A F G F L M E G E H J L b � c V E H U V b T E _ [ � T A F G F U A FE b D _ B U V J F M L G C U F D D B H \ G B \ A U L G C U F D D B H \ _ F M U B C D G L D L G U B L H E _ U L � T A B _ F U A FE b D _ B U V J F M L G H L U b L K B H \ E U E _ _ B C D G L D L G U B L H E _ U L o £ l � p x Z U B C U A F H F E C X U LC F F U A E U ! B C E J B C W G F U B g E U B L H L M

� ! � � � k o �Á | � O � p � | ! � � � | x

e V C U H L U F U A E U ! C E U B C ^ F C U A F J B � F G F H W F F c V E U B L Ho ! o � i � q � p l ! o � i � p p � � k o �

Á | � O � p o ! o � lÁ

i � p l O ! o � i � p q ! o � qÁ

i � p p �Á |

@ A B C \ B K F C E J B G F W U B H U F G D G F U E U B L H L M U A F C L _ V U B L H U L U A F � W A G �L J B H \ F G F c V E aU B L H E C E _ B b B U L M E C V b L K F G \ F H F G E _ B g F J d G L T H B E H D E U A C T B U A W L b D _ F I

E b D _ B U V J F C Y � F W E H U A F H G F B H U F G D G F U U A B C B H � � � U F G b C ` X U A F F c V E U B L HN z i m z Q k n o

Á | � � p L G N z i m z Q k S ] F E W A L M U A F C F W L H U B H \ B H W B F C A E D D F H B H \D G L ` E ` B _ B C U B W E _ _ X Y Z U G F b E B H C U L ` F C F F H T A F U A F G U A F G F B C M V G U A F G B H C B \ A U U L` F \ E B H F J B H U L U A F � W A G �L J B H \ F G F c V E U B L H K B E U A B C W L b ` B H E U B L H L M U A F � � �E D D G L E W A E H J U A F C U L W A E C U B W E D D G L E W A Y

ó ô / � 0 1 1 � ü ø �r _ L H \ T B U A U A F C B b D _ F d G L T H B E H b L U B L H C L _ V U B L H U L U A F L H F J B b F H C B L H E _ W L b ab V U E U L G F c V E U B L H ] U A F G F B C E A F B G E G W A X L M U B b F C F G B F C U A E U C L _ K F U A B C F c V E U B L H ]

T B U A D F G B L J B W E H J W A E L U B W ` F A E K B L V G Y @ A F C F C L _ V U B L H C W E H ` F L ` U E B H F J ` XU E [ B H \

z k n ~ �T A F G F 2 B C E H V b F G B W E _ C W E _ E G ] E H J U E [ B H \ U A F W L b b V U E U L G F c V E U B L H U L ` F

N z i m z Q k n | ~ à { �£ ¡

Page 17: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

T A F G F � B C E C W E _ E G Y ­ I D E H J B H \ U A B C F c V E U B L H ] T F ^ H Jz n o z � l z p l n o z � l z p z k n | ~ Ã { �

n ~ � n o n ~ � � l n ~ � p l n o n ~ � � l n ~ � p n ~ � k n | ~ Ã { �n | ~ Ã { � ~ Ã { o � � l � p l n | ~ Ã { o � ~ Ã { l � ~ p � k n | ~ Ã { �

� ~ à { o � � l � p l o � ~ à { l � ~ p � k �� ~ à { o � � l O � p k � l � ~ �

� ~ Ã { k o � l � ~ � p � o � � l O � p x@ A B C _ E C U F c V E U B L H F I D G F C C F C U A F U B b F C F G B F C G F W V G C B K F _ X T A F G F � G F M F G C U L U A F

K E _ V F L M U A F C F G B F C U A E U B C å U B b F C U F D C ` E W [ M G L b � ~ x @ A F ^ G C U W E C F L M U A B CG F W V G C B L H B C

� � � k o � l � � � p � o � � l O � p x� F I U W E C F B C

� � � � k o � l � � � � p � o � � l O � p x@ A F C F G F W V G C B L H C J F D F H J W G B U B W E _ _ X L H U A F K E _ V F L M U A F D E G E b F U F G � x Z H U A F ^ G C UW E C F L H F C F F C D F G B L J B W L C W B _ _ E U B L H C U A E U o M L G E D D G L D G B E U F K E _ V F C L M � p J F C U E ` B _ B g FE H J ` _ L T V D ] E _ U F G H E U B H \ ` F U T F F H E H V H ` L V H J F J D A E C F E H J E ` L V H J F J C F b B aD F G B L J B W D A E C F Y � F T B _ _ B H K F C U B \ E U F U A F C F U B b F C F G B F C B H E C F D E G E U F D E D F G Y

ó ô 3 4 ø ÷ � 5 ü ÷ û ü � þ � �Z H U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H L M F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B W M L G b E _ B C b M G L b W L b ab V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H C N O � Q L H F V C F C U A F G F _ E U B L H C

N z � i z � Q k SN z � i m z � Q k � � � �

T A F G F � B C E C W E _ E G Y � F G F T F C A E _ _ V C FN z � i z � Q k S

N z � i m z � Q k n � � � �E C T F J B J B H E H E _ X g B H \ U A F L H F a J B b F H C B L H E _ W E C F Y @ A B C E _ _ L T C V C U L A E K FC W E _ E G F K L _ V U B L H L M U A F U B b F C F G B F C ] ` V U W A E H \ F C C L b F L M U A F B C C V F C B H U A F

£ �

Page 18: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H Y @ A F C F E G F B H M E W U A E H J _ F J ` X U A F b L G F \ F H F G E _M L G b E _ B C b U A E U T F J B C W V C C B H U A F H F I U U T L C F W U B L H C Y @ A V C T F C A E _ _ E B b B H U A B CC F W U B L H U L C F F U L T A E U F I U F H U L H F W E H b E [ F C B b D _ F b L J F _ C M L G U A B C K F G C B L HL M U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L H G F _ E U B L H C Y ¬ L J F _ C L M U A B C C L G U T B _ _ ` F E H L U A F G _ F K F _ L ME D D G L I B b E U B L H U L J B C W G F U F F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b Y

� G B U B H \ L V U U A F W L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H N z i m z Q k n � ] E H J H L U b E [ B H \E H X E C C V b D U B L H U A E U z � W L b b V U F C T B U A z ] T F ^ H J

n ï { N z i m z Q k z � o z � l z p l o z � l z p zk z � o z � l z p l z o z � l z p q z o z � l z p l o z � l z p z

k o z � l z p | q o z z � l z � z p k o z � l z p | q N z i z � Q x@ A V C U A F W L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H N z i m z Q k n � ` F W L b F C U A F F c V E U B L H

o z � l z p | q N z i z � Q k � xd X E C B b B _ E G W E _ W V _ E U B L H ] U A F F c V E U B L H N z i m � Q k S ` F W L b F C U A F F c V E U B L H

o z � l z p o � � l � p q N z i � � Q k S x@ A F C F F c V E U B L H C E G F B b D L C C B ` _ F U L C E U B C M X C B b V _ U E H F L V C _ X M L G � Þk S B M T F

E C C V b F U A E U z E H J z � W L b b V U F E H J U A E U z E H J � � W L b b V U F E H J U A E UN � i m � Q k n � Y s L G U A F H T F T L V _ J H F F J U L C L _ K F À

o z � l z p | k � xo � � l � p | k � x

o z � l z p o � � l � p k S xT B U A U A F ^ G C U U T L F c V E U B L H C B b D _ X B H \ U A E U o z l z � p E H J o � l � � p E G F F E W A

H L H a g F G L ] E H J U A F U A B G J B b D _ X B H \ U A E U U A F B G D G L J V W U B C F c V E _ U L g F G L Y Z H L U A F GT L G J C ] U A F F c V E U B L H C ` F _ L T W E H H L U ` F C E U B C ^ F J B M U A F U B b F C F G B F C E G F W L b D L C F J

L M W L b b V U B H \ C W E _ E G C YN z i m z Q k n �

N � i m � Q k n �N z i � Q k S

Z H L G J F G U L b E [ F C V W A b L J F _ C T F C A E _ _ A E K F U L B H U G L J V W F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K B U XB H U L U A F U B b F C F G B F C U A F b C F _ K F C Y Z H E W F G U E B H C F H C F U A B C B C E H E _ L \ V L V C U L

U A F B H U G L J V W U B L H L M H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F E _ \ F ` G E B H U A F � B G E W F c V E U B L H B H R q£ J B b F H C B L H C ] E H J U L U A F B H U G L J V W U B L H L M H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F ^ F _ J C B H \ E V \ F

U A F L G X Y£ P

Page 19: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� F G F B C E H F I E b D _ F L M C V W A E b L J F _ Y· F U V G H U L U A F F c V E U B L H C

o z � l z p | q N z i z � Q k � xo z � l z p o � � l � p q N z i � � Q k S

F I D G F C C B H \ U A F ` F A E K B L V G M L G U T L J B C U B H W U K E G B E ` _ F C z E H J � x Z M N z i z � Q k S ]U A F H T F A E K F o z � l z p | k � C L U A E U

z � k z � . � xZ H L G J F G M L G U A F C F W L H J F c V E U B L H U L ` F C E U B C ^ F J ] T F H F F J U A E U

N z i � � Q k � �T A F G F U A F E b ` B \ V B U X L M C B \ H B C _ B H [ F J T B U A U A F K E G X B H \ C B \ H C B H U A F U F b D L G E _

` F A E K B L V G L M z E H J � x � F T B _ _ b E [ F U A F C B \ H b L G F D G F W B C F B H E b L b F H U ] ` V UU A F G E J B W E _ D E G U L M U A B C C V \ \ F C U B L H B C U A E U M L G U T L J B C U B H W U C D E U B E _ K E G B E ` _ F C z

E H J � ] U A F G F T B _ _ ` F E W L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H ` F U T F F H L H F E H J E U B b F C A B M U L MU A F L U A F G Y

Z M U A F C D E W F K E G B E ` _ F C E G F _ E ` F _ F J z � ] U A F H T F W E H T G B U Fz ¿ à {� k z ¿� q 6 ¿� �

T A F G F 6 ~� B C D _ V C L H F L G b B H V C L H F Y @ A V C F E W A C D E W F K E G B E ` _ F D F G M L G b C E T E _ [T B U A U A F ^ I F J C U F D a _ F H \ U A � x � F C A E _ _ T G B U F B H M L G b E _ _ X

z �� k z � q 6 � �T A F G F B U B C V H J F G C U L L J U A E U U A F F D C B _ L H T B U A L V U U A F C V D F G C W G B D U W L H H L U F C U A F

C B \ H W A E H \ F U A E U L W W V G C B H U A B C � V H W U V G F L M U A F D G L W F C C Y � F U A F H J F b E H J U A FW L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H C

N z �� i z � Q k N z �� i z � Q k 6 � 6 � � x­ E W A z � B C E C W E _ E G B H B U C L T H J L b E B H ] ` V U J L F C H L U W L b b V U F T B U A U A F U B b FC A B M U C L M U A F L U A F G J B G F W U B L H C Y � F U A F H W E H A E K F U A F M V _ _ C F U L M W L b b V U E U B L HG F _ E U B L H C À

N z �� i z � Q k N z �� i z � Q k 6 � 6 � � x£ ¤

Page 20: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

N z � i z � Q k SN z � i m z � Q k n � � � �

C L U A E U U A F C X C U F b T B _ _ C E U B C M X U A F E C C V b D U B L H C C V D D L G U B H \ U A F s F X H b E H a� X C L H J F G B K E U B L H Y Z H U A B C C X C U F b ] U A F F _ F b F H U C L M E \ B K F H U B b F C F G B F C z � i z �� i z � �� i } } }W L b b V U F T B U A L H F E H L U A F G Y @ A F ` E C B W ^ F _ J F _ F b F H U B H U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L HC F U V D B C U A F b E \ H F U B W ^ F _ J j J F ^ H F J ` X U A F o H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F p K F W U L G W G L C CD G L J V W U

j k o £ � � p m z 7 m z x� F G F T F A E K F

m z � k n o z �� l z � p k n 6 � . � x@ A V C

j k n | 6 � 7 6T A F G F 6 k o 6 { i 6 | i 6 8 p o E C C V b B H \ U A G F F C D E U B E _ W L L G J B H E U F C p E H J 6 � J F H L U F C U A B CK F W U L G L M C B \ H C E U U A F H F I U U B b F C U F D Y Z H U A B C T E X T F C F F U A E U T F W E H U A B H [

L M F E W A C D E U B E _ W L L G J B H E U F E C D G L K B J B H \ E _ L H \ U F b D L G E _ ` B U C U G B H \ E H J U A FU A G F F W L L G J B H E U F C U L \ F U A F G \ B K F U A F ^ F _ J B H U F G b C L M U A F K F W U L G W G L C C D G L J V W U

L M U A F B G U F b D L G E _ W G L C C C F W U B L H C E U H F B \ A ` L G B H \ B H C U E H U C Y Z U B C B H U F G F C U B H \ U LW L b D E G F U A B C b L J F _ T B U A U A F W L _ L G E _ \ F ` G E B H U A F M L _ _ L T B H \ D E D F G ` X � F H F

N � R Q Y

ó ô 9 � û � � ÷ � � � 1 þ ü � � û � ü þ � þ � � � ÷ ø � ü � ú � � û � �Z U B C L M B H U F G F C U U L W L b D E G F U A F C F G F C V _ U C T B U A E J B G F W U J B C W G F U B g E U B L H L M W _ E C C B W E _F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b Y � V D D L C F U A E U z i z � i z � � i z � � � i } } } B C E U B b F C F G B F C L M K F W U L G CB H â 8 o T A F G F â J F H L U F C U A F G F E _ H V b ` F G C p Y f F U � z k z � l z ` F U A F V C V E _J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B K F o T B U A U B b F C U F D F c V E _ U L L H F M L G W L H K F H B F H W F p Y f F U h : jJ F H L U F U A F V C V E _ B H H F G D G L J V W U L M K F W U L G C B H U A G F F J B b F C B L H C Y r C C V b F U A E U

U A F G F E G F ^ F _ J C ; E H J j C V W A U A E U� | z k ; q � z 7 j

o U A F f L G F H U g M L G W F _ E T p Y r C C V b F E _ C L U A E U ; E H J j E G F D F G D F H J B W V _ E G U L U A FK F _ L W B U X K F W U L G � z ] E H J U A E U ; B C D F G D F H J B W V _ E G U L j x @ A F H T F A E K F

� z � 7 � z k o � z � l � z p 7 � z k o � | z p 7 o � z p

O S

Page 21: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

k ; 7 � z q o � z 7 j p 7 � zk ; 7 � z l � z o j : � z p q o � z : � z p j x

� B H W F ; B C D F G D F H J B W V _ E G U L � z T F [ H L T U A F G F B C E < C V W A U A E U ; 7 � z k < jE H J T F A E K F j : � z k S C B H W F j B C D F G D F H J B W V _ E G U L � z x @ A F G F M L G F

� z � 7 � z k < j q Ý Ý � z Ý Ý | jC L U A E U

j k � z � 7 � z � o < q Ý Ý � z Ý Ý | p x¸ D U L U A F M E W U L G B H U A F J F H L b B H E U L G ] U A B C M L G b V _ E B C B H F I E W U _ X U A F C E b FD E U U F G H E C U A F M L G b V _ E B H L V G J B C W G F U F b L J F _ M L G � � � F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b E CJ F C W G B ` F J B H U A F D G F K B L V C C V ` C F W U B L H Y @ L C F F U A B C ] H L U F U A E U U A F j ^ F _ J B H

U A F � � � b L J F _ B C D G L D L G U B L H E _ U L m z 7 m z E H J U A E U m z k n � z C L U A E Um z 7 m z k n � z 7 n � z k n | � z � 7 � z x ¸ D U L U A F U B b F a C A B M U B H \ E _ \ F ` G E E H J

E D G L D L G U B L H E _ B U X W L H C U E H U ] U A F F I D G F C C B L H C E G F U A F C E b F y � _ F E G _ X b L G F T L G [B C H F F J F J B H W L b D E G B H \ W _ E C C B W E _ J B C W G F U F F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b T B U A U A F G F C V _ U CL M E J B C W G F U F E H E _ X C B C L M U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H Y

= > � � ? � @ � � � � � � � A � � � � � � > � � � � � � �f F U U B H \ z � o � k £ i O i x x x i � p J F H L U F E C F U L M C D E U B E _ K E G B E ` _ F C o H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F

U B b F C F G B F C B H U A F C F H C F L M L V G J B C W G F U F L G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C p ] T F T B _ _ _ L L [ E UE W L _ _ F W U B L H L M ` E C B W E C C V b D U B L H C E ` L V U U A F W L b b V U E U B L H L M U A F C F K E G B E ` _ F CE H J L M U A F B G J F G B K E U B K F C Y Z U B C H E U V G E _ M G L b U A F D L B H U L M K B F T L M U A F J B C W G F U FL G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C U L A E K F

N z � i z � Q k SM L G E _ _ � E H J � Y @ A F G F E G F H L L U A F G H E U V G E _ W L b b V U E U B L H C M G L b U A F D L B H U L M

K B F T L M U A B C W E _ W V _ V C Y� F C A E _ _ J F ^ H F ñ � � ` X U A F F c V E U B L H

N z � i Bz � Q k ñ � � x� F G F Bz � B C C A L G U A E H J M L G m z � E H J

N h i j Q k h j l j h xO £

Page 22: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

r _ L H \ T B U A U A B C W L b b V U E U L G F c V E U B L H ] T F T B _ _ E C C V b F U A E UN z � i z � Q k S i

N z � i ñ � C Q k SE H J

N ñ D E i ñ � C Q k S x� F G F B U B C E C C V b F J U A E U ñ � � B C H L H a J F \ F H F G E U F B H U A F C F H C F U A E U U A F G F F I B C U C

ñ � � C L U A E Uñ � � ñ � C k � �C

E H J U A E Uñ � � ñ � C k � C� x

� F G F T F E G F V C B H \ U A F ­ B H C U F B H C V b b E U B L H W L H K F H U B L H U A E U B b D _ B W B U _ X E C C V b F CU A E U T F C V b L K F G G F D F E U F J B H J B W F C B H E H F I D G F C C B L H Y � X b ` L _ � �� B C E � G L H F W [ F G

J F _ U E ] F c V E _ U L £ T A F H � F c V E _ C � E H J S L U A F G T B C F Y@ A F ^ G C U G F C V _ U U A E U B C E J B G F W U W L H C F c V F H W F L M U A F C F E C C V b D U B L H C B C U A F

C X b b F U G X L M U A F � b F U G B W � W L F º W B F H U C ñ � � x @ A E U B C ] T F C A E _ _ C A L T U A E Uñ � � k ñ � � x

è ¦ § § ¨ F « ñ � � k ñ � � xê © ± ± ë «

ñ � � l ñ � �k N z � i Bz � Q l N z � i Bz � Qk N z � i Bz � Q q N Bz � i z � Q

k m N z � i z � Qk S x

s L G U A F D V G D L C F L M J L B H \ W E _ W V _ V C B H U A B C C B U V E U B L H T F J F ^ H F Bz � ` X U A FF c V E U B L H

O O

Page 23: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

Bz � k ñ � C Bz C x@ A F L D F G E U L G Bz � B C C B b D _ X U A F B H J F I C A B M U L M U A F W L G G F C D L H J B H \ Bz � x � F J LH L U J F ^ H F E W L G G F C D L H J B H \ z � x Z U B C F E C X U L W A F W [ U A F F c V E U B L H

N z � i Bz � Q k � �� x� L H C F c V F H U _ X ] T F J F ^ H F U A F J F G B K E U B K F L M E H L D F G E U L G G T B U A G F C D F W U U L z �` X U A F F c V E U B L H

� � G k N G i Bz � QE H J U A F W L G G F C D L H J B H \ _ L T F G F J J F G B K E U B K F ` X U A F M L G b V _ E

� � G k N G i Bz � Q x� L U F U A E U T F A E K F

� � z � k ñ � � x� F E _ C L J F ^ H F H

� � G k N z � i G Q iU A F J F G B K E U B K F L M G T B U A G F C D F W U U L U A F W L H � V \ E U F K E G B E ` _ F Bz � x� B U A U A F C F D E G U B E _ J F G B K E U B K F C B H A E H J ] T F J F ^ H F BG ` X U A F M L G b V _ E

BG k � C G Bz C xZ M G W L b b V U F C T B U A ñ � � U A F H B U B C F E C X U L C F F U A E U

BG k � C G Bz C x@ A F C F M L G b V _ E C F I U F H J o B b D _ B W B U _ X p U A F J F ^ H B U B L H L M U A F U B b F C F G B F C U L F H U B U B F CL U A F G U A E H U A F L D F G E U L G C z � C B H W F

BG k m G k n o G � l G p x

r C U G F E b L M W L H C F c V F H W F C U A F H M L _ _ L T C ` X J B � F G F H U B E U B H \ ` L U A C B J F C L M U A FF c V E U B L H

O R

Page 24: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

ñ � � k N z � i Bz � Q x� L U F U A E U

Bñ � � k N Bz � i Bz � Q q N z � i m | z � Q` X U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F

m N h i j Q k N m h x j Q q N h i m j Q x� L U F E _ C L U A E U T F W E H M G F F _ X V C F U A F e E W L ` B B J F H U B U X

N h i N j i ¾ Q Q q N ¾ i N h i j Q Q q N j i N ¾ i h Q Q k S xZ H D E G U B W V _ E G ] U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H

I � � C k o £ � O p o � � ñ � C q � � ñ � C l � C ñ � � pE C C L W B E U F J T B U A U A F ñ � � W L b F C V D E _ b L C U E U L H W F M G L b U A F J B � F G F H U B E U B L H D G L aW F C C J F C W G B ` F J E ` L K F Y @ L C F F A L T U A B C A E D D F H C ] K B F T U A F M L _ _ L T B H \ W E _ W V _ E U B L H

T A F G F H� �

H� � G k N z � i N z � i G Q Q x

� F E D D _ X U A F L D F G E U L GH

� �H

� � U L U A F C F W L H J m ½ ¾ J F G B K E U B K F L M z C xè ¦ § § ¨ J « I � � C k o £ � O p

H� �

H� � m | z C

ê © ± ± ë «H

� �H

� � m | z C k N z � i N z � i m | z C Q Q

k N z � i Bñ � C l N Bz � i Bz C Q Q

k N z � i Bñ � C Q l N z � i N Bz � i Bz C Q Q

k N z � i Bñ � C Q q N Bz C i N z � i Bz � Q Q q N Bz � i N Bz C i z � Q

O �

Page 25: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

k N ñ � C i Bz � Q q N Bz C i ñ � � Q q N Bz � i l ñ � C Q

k � � ñ � C l � C ñ � � q � � ñ � C

k O I C � � xZ U B C G F b E G [ E ` _ F U A E U U A F M L G b L M U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H W L b F C V D J B G F W U _ XM G L b U A B C H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W E _ W V _ V C T B U A L V U E H X E D G B L G B \ F L b F U G B W B H U F G D G F a

U E U B L H Y � F C A E _ _ J B C W V C C U A F W L H U F I U L M U A B C G F C V _ U B H U A F H F I U U T L C F W U B L H C L MU A F D E D F G Y

� H F ^ H J C U A E Um | z � k � � q ñ � D ñ � E G D E Bz � q I � � C Bz � Bz C

T A F G FG D E k N Bz D i Bz E Q x

Z U M L _ _ L T C M G L b U A F e E W L ` B B J F H U B U X U A E UG � � k ñ � D ñ � E G D E

C E U B C ^ F C U A F F c V E U B L H� � G � C q � � G C � q � C G � � k S i

B J F H U B M X B H \ G � � E C E H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F E H E _ L \ L M E \ E V \ F ^ F _ J Y � � B C E H L H aW L b b V U E U B K F E H E _ L \ L M E C W E _ E G ^ F _ J Y @ A F J F U E B _ C L M U A F C F W E _ W V _ E U B L H C T B _ _` F M L V H J B H N O ¡ Q Y

@ A B C J F C W G B D U B L H L M U A F F c V E U B L H C M L G E H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F D E G U B W _ F B H Eb F U G B W ^ F _ J B _ _ V C U G E U F C U A F G L _ F L M U A F ` E W [ \ G L V H J J B C W G F U F U B b F B H U A B C U A F L G X YZ H U F G b C L M U A F ` E W [ \ G L V H J U B b F U A F b F U G B W W L F º W B F H U C E G F H L U W L H C U E H U Y Z UB C U A G L V \ A U A B C K E G B E U B L H U A E U U A F C D E W F U B b F J F G B K E U B K F C L M U A F U A F L G X E G FE G U B W V _ E U F J Y @ A F ` E W [ \ G L V H J B C E D G L W F C C T B U A B U C L T H M L G b L M J B C W G F U F U B b F ]` V U H L C D E W F U B b F C U G V W U V G F E C T F [ H L T E H J L ` C F G K F B U Y � V G L ` C F G K E U B L H L MC D E W F U B b F C U G V W U V G F E D D F E G C E C E G L V \ A o W L b b V U E U B K F p E D D G L I B b E U B L H U L U A FD G L W F C C F C J F C W G B ` F J E C W L H C F c V F H W F C L M U A F ` E C B W H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F F c V E U B L H CL M U A F J B C W G F U F L G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C Y

O �

Page 26: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

K � � � � � � � � L M � � � N ? � � � � � � � � � � � � O � �� � � � � � � � � � � �

Z H U A B C C F W U B L H ] T F \ L ` E W [ U L ` E C B W C E H J F I E b B H F U A F W L H U F I U L M W E _ W V _ V CJ F ^ H F J K B E W L b b V U E U L G C Y � F C A E _ _ V C F E D E G U B E _ _ X B H J F I a M G F F H L U E U B L H Y Z H

U A B C H L U E U B L H ] T F E K L B J H F C U F J C V ` C W G B D U C ` X V C B H \ J B � F G F H U K E G B E ` _ F H E b F CE H J U A F H V C B H \ U A F C F H E b F C E C C V ` C W G B D U C U L G F M F G U L U A F G F _ F K E H U K E G B E ` _ F C Y@ A V C T F T G B U F z E H J � B H C U F E J L M z � E H J z � ] E H J T F T G B U F ñ P Q B H C U F E JL M ñ � � x Z U B C E C C V b F J U A E U U A F J F G B K E U B L H m z A E C U A F M L G b m z k N z i n Q M L GC L b F n x

@ A F ` G E W [ F U N h i j Q B C H L U E C C V b F J U L ` F E W L b b V U E U L G Y Z U B C E C C V b F J U LC E U B C M X U A F e E W L ` B B J F H U B U X ] ` B _ B H F E G B U X B H F E W A K E G B E ` _ F ] E H J U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ FM L G E _ _ M V H W U B L H C L M U A F M L G b � v o h p k N h i w Q x @ A E U B C T F E C C V b F U A E U

� v o h j p k � v o h p j q h � v o j p x· F W E _ _ U A E U B H W _ E C C B W E _ J B � F G F H U B E _ \ F L b F U G X L H F A E C U A F H L U B L H L M E W L a

K E G B E H U J F G K E U B K F ] J F ^ H F J ` X U E [ B H \ E J B � F G F H W F c V L U B F H U V C B H \ D E G E _ _ F _ U G E H C a_ E U B L H K B E E W L H H F W U B L H Y � L K E G B E H U J F G B K E U B K F C B H J B � F G F H U J B G F W U B L H C J L H L UH F W F C C E G B _ X W L b b V U F Y @ A F W L b b V U E U L G L M W L K E G B E H U J F G B K E U B K F C \ B K F C G B C F U L

U A F W V G K E U V G F U F H C L G B H U A F M L G bN t � i t � Q z C k â CR � � z R x

Z M J F G B K E U B K F C J L H L U W L b b V U F U A F H T F G F \ E G J U A F B G W L b b V U E U L G E C F I D G F C C aB H \ E W V G K E U V G F Y Z H L V G H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F W L H U F I U U A B C b F E H C U A E U W V G K E U V G FE G B C F C Ê Ô Ç Ë Ô U L E H X H L U B L H L M W L K E G B E H U J F G B K E U B K F C C B H W F É Ï É Í Å Æ É ò Ä Ì Ç Ñ Î É Ô Ç Ï Ä S

Å Ç Ï É Ì Î Ë Í Ë Å Ñ Ë È È Ó Å É Ø� F C A E _ _ W L H C B J F G J F G B K E U B K F C B H U A F M L G b

t P o h p k N h i � P Q x­ I E b B H F U A F M L _ _ L T B H \ W L b D V U E U B L H À

t P t Q G k N N G i � Q Q i � P Q k l N N � P i G Q i � Q Q l N N � Q i � P Q i G Qk N N G i � P Q i � Q Q q N N � P i � Q Q i G Q

O ¡

Page 27: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

k t Q t P G q N N � P i � Q Q i G Q x@ A V C

N t P i t Q Q G k â P Q GT A F G F

â P Q G k N N � P i � Q Q i G Q x� F W E H G F \ E G J â P Q E C E W V G K E U V G F L D F G E U L G Y

@ A F E H E _ L \ B H U A B C W L H U F I U L M � E U C D E W F B C E ` C U G E W U c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C y@ A E U B C ] T F E C C V b F D L C B U B L H K E G B E ` _ F C o L D F G E U L G C p z ] � ] } } } E H J b L b F H U V b

K E G B E ` _ F C o L D F G E U L G C p � P ] � Q ] } } } C E U B C M X B H \ U A F F c V E U B L H C ` F _ L T YN z i � Q k S

N � P i � Q Q k SN z i � Q Q k � P Q

T A F G F � P Q B C F c V E _ U L L H F B M z F c V E _ C � E H J B C g F G L L U A F G T B C F Y � F J F ^ H F� P G k N G i � P Q

E H J� T U G k N z i G Q x

Z H U A F W L H U F I U L M U A F E ` L K F W L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H C ] H L U F U A E U U A F C F J F G B K E U B K F C` F A E K F W L G G F W U _ X B H U A E U

� P o � p k � P QE H J

� T U o � Q p k � P Q� T U o � p k S k � P o � Q p

T B U A U A F _ E C U F c V E U B L H C K E _ B J F K F H B M z k � x � L U F E _ C L U A E U B U F G E U F J D E G aU B E _ J F G B K E U B K F C C V W A E C � P � Q W L b b V U F Y � F H W F U A F W V G K E U V G F â P Q B C F c V E _U L g F G L Y � F C A E _ _ G F \ E G J U A F C F D L C B U B L H E H J b L b F H U V b L D F G E U L G C E H J U A F

W L G G F C D L H J B H \ D E G U B E _ J F G B K E U B K F C E C E H E ` C U G E W U E _ \ F ` G E B W C V ` C U B U V U F M L G � E UC D E W F Y

O �

Page 28: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� B U A U A B C G F M F G F H W F D L B H U L M o E _ \ F ` G E B W ] c V E H U V b p � E U C D E W F T F W E H J F ^ H FH� P k � P l h P

M L G E H E G ` B U G E G X E _ \ F ` G E a K E _ V F J M V H W U B L H L M U A F K E G B E ` _ F z x Z H B H J B W F C U A B CT L V _ J G F E J H

� � k � � l h � iE H J T B U A G F C D F W U U L U A B C J F M L G b F J b L b F H U V b T F A E K F U A F W L K E G B E H U J F G B K E a

U B K Ft P G k N G i

H� Q Q k N G i � Q q h Q Q k � Q G q N G i h Q Q x

@ A F W V G K E U V G F M L G U A B C W L K E G B E H U J F G B K E U B K F B C \ B K F H ` X U A F M L G b V _ Eâ P Q G k N t P i t Q Q G k N N < P i < Q Q i G Q

T A F G F < P k � P l h P x � F H W Fâ P Q k N � P l h P i � Q l h Q Q k l N � P i h Q Q l N h P i � Q Q q N h P i h Q Q

k � P h Q l � Q h P q N h P i h Q Q x� B U A B H J B W F C U A B C G F E J C

â � � k � � h � l � � h � q N h � i h � Q xE H J U A F G F E J F G T B _ _ H L U F U A E U U A B C A E C U A F E ` C U G E W U M L G b L M U A F W V G K E U V G F L M E

2 E H \ a ¬ B _ _ C \ E V \ F ^ F _ J ] E H J C D F W B ^ W E _ _ X U A F M L G b L M U A F F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B W ^ F _ JT A F H U A F D L U F H U B E _ C h � E H J h � W L b b V U F T B U A L H F E H L U A F G Y

� L H U B H V B H \ T B U A U A B C F I E b D _ F ] T F W L b D V U FN z i

H� Q Q k N z i � Q l h Q Q k � P Q l N z i h Q Q x

f F Uñ P Q k � P Q l N z i h Q Q

C L U A E UN z i

H� Q Q k ñ P Q x

� F T B _ _ C A L G U _ X W L H C B J F G U A F M L G b L M U A B C \ F H F G E _ W E C F ] ` V U ^ G C U B U B C V C F M V _ U LG F C U G B W U U L U A F W E C F T A F G F N z i h Q Q k S C L U A E U ñ P Q k � P Q x @ A B C B C U A F J L b E B H

O P

Page 29: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

U L T A B W A U A F L G B \ B H E _ s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H E D D _ B F C Y Z H L G J F G U L F H U F GU A B C J L b E B H ] T F C F U

Bz k m z kH

� P k � P l h P x� F U A F H A E K F

N z � i z � Q k SN z � i Bz � Q k � � �

E H Jâ � � k N Bz � i Bz � Q k � � h � l � � h � q N h � i h � Q x

� L U F U A E U F K F H V H J F G U A F C F G F C U G B W U B L H C T F E G F C U B _ _ _ L L [ B H \ E U U A F D L C C B ` B _ B U XL M E H L H a E ` F _ B E H \ E V \ F ^ F _ J Y @ A F D V G F F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B W W E C F B C T A F H U A FW L b b V U E U L G L M h � E H J h � K E H B C A F C Y d V U T A X J L T F C F U Bz k

H� P & @ A F

E H C T F G U L U A B C B C U A F [ F X U L U A F \ E V \ F B H U F G D G F U E U B L H L M F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b ]M L G T B U A U A B C B H U F G D G F U E U B L H T F ^ H J U A E U Bz C E U B C ^ F C U A F f L G F H U g M L G W F _ E T�z k ; q Bz 7 j T A F G F j G F D G F C F H U C U A F b E \ H F U B W ^ F _ J E H J ; U A F F _ F W U G B W^ F _ J o B H U A F W E C F L M U A G F F C D E W F K E G B E ` _ F C z � T B U A � k £ i O i R x p @ L C F F A L T U A B C

T L G [ C ] C V D D L C F U A E U �z � k ; � q G � � Bz � E H J C V D D L C F U A E U ; � E H J G � � W L b b V U FT B U A z C x @ A F H T F W E H W L b D V U F

N z � i �z � Q k N z � i ; � q G � C Bz C Qk G � C N z � i Bz C Q k G � C � � C k G � � x

@ A B C B b D _ B F C U A E UG � � k N Bz � i Bz � Q k â � � k � � h � l � � h � q N h � i h � Q

C B H W F N z � i �z � Q q N Bz � i Bz � Q k m N z � i Bz � Q k S x Z U B C U A F H F E C X U L K F G B M X U A E U U A Ff L G F H U g M L G W F F c V E U B L H B C C E U B C ^ F J T B U A j C k 6 � � C â � � E H J U A E U B H U A F W E C F L M

N h � i h � Q k S U A B C _ F E J C J B G F W U _ X U L C U E H J E G J F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B W U A F L G X T A F H U A F` G E W [ F U B C E � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U o C F F U A F H F I U C F W U B L H M L G E J B C W V C C B L H L M � L B C C L H` G E W [ F U C p Y � A F H U A B C ` G E W [ F U B C H L U g F G L ` V U U A F D L U F H U B E _ C h � E G F M V H W U B L H CL H _ X L M U A F z � T F W E H _ L L [ E U E \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H L M \ E V \ F U A F L G X T A F G F U A F H L H aW L b b V U E U B K B U X W L b F C M G L b B H U F G H E _ f B F E _ \ F ` G E D E G E b F U F G C Y @ A B C C A L T C U A E U

U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H C V D D L G U C W F G U E B H \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H C L M W _ E C C B W E _F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b ] E H J U A B C T B _ _ ` F U A F C V ` � F W U L M E b L G F F I D E H J F J K F G C B L HL M U A B C D E D F G Y

O ¤

Page 30: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

Z H G F \ E G J U L U A B C _ E C U G F b E G [ ] U A F G F E J F G C A L V _ J H L U F U A E U B H L V G N O P ]O � Q E _ \ F ` G E B W E H J J B C W G F U F K F G C B L H L M U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H B U T E CE W U V E _ _ X E H E J J B U B L H E _ E C C V b D U B L H U A E U j 7 j k S T A F G F j 7 j J F H L U F C U A F

o H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F p K F W U L G W G L C C D G L J V W U L M j T B U A B U C F _ M Y o � L U F U A E U j ko £ � O p Bz 7 Bz x p Z H U A F L G B \ B H E _ � X C L H D E D F G U A B C W G L C C D G L J V W U K E H B C A F J ` F W E V C F

L M E C C V b D U B L H C E ` L V U U A F L D F G E U L G C E H J U A F B G � B _ ` F G U C D E W F G F D G F C F H U E U B L H C Y� B U A j 7 j E C E H F I U G E U F G b ] U A F s F X H b E H a � X C L H J F G B K E U B L H B C B H J F F J E

H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H L M F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b E H J B H W _ V J F C M L G b C L M\ E V \ F U A F L G B F C E b L H \ B U C b L J F _ C Y

¹ F H F G E _ B g B H \ ] T F T B C A U L F I E b B H F U A F C U G V W U V G F L M U A F M L _ _ L T B H \ C D F W B E _E I B L b C M L G E ` G E W [ F U Y

N z i m � Q k ñ P QN z i � Q k S

N � i ñ P Q Q k SN ñ P Q i ñ V W Q k S

� L U F U A E Um ñ Q V k m N � i m � Q k N m � i m � Q q N � i m | � Q x

E H J U A E U m N z i ñ P Q Q k S B b D _ B F C U A E UN ñ P Q i m � Q k N � i m ñ P Q Q x

� F ^ H F U T L U X D F C L M J F G B K E U B L H C E C M L _ _ L T Ct P o G p k N G i m z Q

E H Jt X P o G p k N z i G Q x

@ A F C F E G F J V E _ T B U A G F C D F W U U L ñ P Q E H J T B _ _ E W U _ B [ F D E G U B E _ C T B U A G F C D F W U U LU A F C F K E G B E ` _ F C B H U A F C D F W B E _ W E C F T A F H ñ P Q B C E � G L H F W [ F G J F _ U E ] � P Q x Z M U A F

M L G b ñ P Q B C B H K F G U B ` _ F ] U A F H T F W E H G F T G B U F U A F C F J F G B K E U B L H C ` X W L H U G E W U B H \U A F B H K F G C F L M ñ U L L ` U E B H C U E H J E G J M L G b E _ D E G U B E _ C Y

R S

Page 31: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

t X P t X Q m | � k N z i N � i m | � Q Qk N z i m ñ Q V l N m � i m � Q Q k N z i m ñ Q V Q l N z i N m � i m � Q Q

k N ñ Q V i m z Q l N z i N m � i m � Q Qk t P o ñ Q V p l N z i N m � i m � Q Q x

� L T V C F U A F e E W L ` B B J F H U B U X L H U A F C F W L H J U F G b E H J L ` U E B Ht X P t X Q m | � k t P o ñ Q V p q N m � i N z i m � Q Q q N m � i N m � i z Q Q

k t P o ñ Q V p l t V o ñ P Q p q t Q o ñ P V p x@ A B C B C U A F M L G b E _ f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H Y

r U U A B C C U E \ F T F M E W F L H W F E \ E B H U A F b X C U F G X L M U A F E D D F E G E H W F L M U A Ff F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H Y @ A F G F B C E T E X U L C F F U A E U U A F E D D F E G E H W F L M U A B CW L H H F W U B L H B C H L U E H E W W B J F H U ] ` V U G E U A F G c V B U F H E U V G E _ Y � F C A E _ _ F I D _ E B H

U A B C D L B H U L M K B F T B H U A F H F I U C F W U B L H T A F G F T F J B C W V C C � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U CE H J U A F W L H H F W U B L H L M U A B C M L G b E _ B C b T B U A W _ E C C B W E _ D A X C B W C Y � H U A F L U A F GA E H J ] T F A E K F C F F H B H U A B C C F W U B L H U A E U B U B C c V B U F H E U V G E _ M L G W V G K E U V G F B H

U A F M L G b L M U A F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K B U X L M J F G B K E U B L H C U L E D D F E G E U U A F L V U C F UB H E H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F M L G b E _ B C b Y � F A E K F E _ C L C F F U A E U U A B C W V G K E U V G F E H JW L H H F W U B L H W E H ` F V H J F G C U L L J E C E b F E C V G F b F H U L M U A F J F K B E U B L H L M U A F U A F aL G X M G L b U A F � � E U � W L b b V U E U B L H G F _ E U B L H C L M L G J B H E G X c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C Y­ _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b E H J 2 E H \ a ¬ B _ _ C U A F L G X W E H ` F C F F H E C U A F U A F L G X L M U A FW V G K E U V G F B H U G L J V W F J ` X C V W A E J F K B E U B L H Y � H U A F L U A F G A E H J ] M G L b U A FD L B H U L M K B F T L M b F U G B W J B � F G F H U B E _ \ F L b F U G X ] U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H B C

U A F V H B c V F W L H H F W U B L H U A E U D G F C F G K F C U A F B H H F G D G L J V W U J F ^ H F J ` X U A F b F U G B WV H J F G U A F D E G E _ _ F _ U G E H C _ E U B L H J F ^ H F J ` X U A F W L H H F W U B L H Y � F T L V _ J _ B [ F U LC F F U A E U U A F M L G b E _ f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H D G L J V W F J A F G F A E C U A B C D G L D F G U XE C T F _ _ Y

@ L U A B C F H J _ F U C G F W E _ _ U A F M L G b E _ B C b L M D E G E _ _ F _ U G E H C _ E U B L H Y @ A F B H ^ H B U F C aB b E _ D E G E _ _ F _ U G E H C _ E U F L M h B C J F H L U F J ` X h � k h q � h T A F G F

� h C k l I C� � h � � z �T A F G F A F G F T F E G F T G B U B H \ B H U A F V C V E _ _ E H \ V E \ F L M K F W U L G C E H J J B � F G F H U B E _ CT B U A U A F ­ B H C U F B H C V b b E U B L H W L H K F H U B L H M L G G F D F E U F J B H J B W F C Y � F E C C V b F

R £

Page 32: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

U A E U U A F � A G B C U L � F _ C X b ` L _ C C E U B C M X U A F C X b b F U G X W L H J B U B L H I C� � k I C� � x @ A FB H H F G D G L J V W U B C \ B K F H ` X U A F M L G b V _ E

Y h i j Z k ñ � � h � j �� L U F U A E U A F G F U A F ` E G F C X b ` L _ C J F H L U F K F W U L G C T A L C F W L L G J B H E U F C b E X ` FB H J B W E U F J ` X B H J B W F C Y @ A F G F c V B G F b F H U U A E U U A B C B H H F G D G L J V W U ` F B H K E G B E H UV H J F G D E G E _ _ F _ J B C D _ E W F b F H U B C U A F G F c V B G F b F H U U A E U � o ñ � � h � h � p k S x � E _ W V a_ E U B H \ ] L H F ^ H J C

� o ñ � � h � h � p k o � C ñ � � p h � h � � z C q ñ � � � o h � p h � q ñ � � h � � o h � p

k o � C ñ � � p h � h � � z C l ñ � � I �D E h D � z E h � l ñ � � h � I �D E h D � z E

k o � C ñ � � p h � h � � z C l ñ � � I �D E h D h � � z E l ñ � � I �D E h � h D � z E

k o � C ñ � � p h � h � � z C l ñ E � I E� C h � h � � z C l ñ � E I E� C h � h � � z C� F H W F

o � C ñ � � p k ñ E � I E� C q ñ � E I E� C xs G L b U A B C B U M L _ _ L T C U A E U

I � � C k ñ � E I E� C k o £ � O p o � C ñ � � l � � ñ � C q � � o ñ � C p p x� F G U E B H _ X U A F C F H L U B L H C L M K E G B E U B L H W E H ` F B b D L G U F J B H U L L V G E ` C U G E W U W L H a

U F I U Y @ A F c V F C U B L H G F b E B H C A L T U L B H U F G D G F U U A F H F T W L H H F W U B L H U A E U E G B C F C Y� F H L T A E K F E H F T W L K E G B E H U J F G B K E U B K F B H U A F M L G b

Ht � z � k � � z � q I �C � z C x

@ A F c V F C U B L H B C A L T U A F W V G K E U V G F L M U A B C W L H H F W U B L H B H U F G M E W F C T B U A U A F\ E V \ F D L U F H U B E _ C U A E U \ E K F G B C F U L U A F b F U G B W B H U A F ^ G C U D _ E W F Y @ A F U A F b FL M U A B C B H K F C U B \ E U B L H A E C U A F � E K L G L M \ G E K B U X U A F L G B F C T B U A E c E V \ F U A F L G F U B W` E W [ \ G L V H J Y � F T B _ _ B H K F C U B \ E U F U A F C F G F _ E U B L H C A B D C B H J F U E B _ B H E C F c V F _ U L

U A B C D E D F G Y

R O

Page 33: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

[ � � � � � � \ � � � ] � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � \ � � � ] �� � �

� B G E W N £ £ Q B H U G L J V W F J E M V H J E b F H U E _ G F _ E U B L H C A B D ` F U T F F H c V E H U V b b F W A E H aB W C E H J W _ E C C B W E _ b F W A E H B W C U A E U B C C V b b E G B g F J ` X U A F b E I B b Ô É Ê Ð Ä Ñ É ) Ë Ç Ì Ì Ë Í

ò Ô Ä Ñ × É Å Ì ò Ò Ñ Ë È È Ó Å Ä Å Ë Ô ò Ô Ä Ñ × É Å Ì Ø · F W E _ _ U A E U U A F � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U h i j � B CJ F ^ H F J ` X U A F M L G b V _ E

h i j � k o � h � � ¢ p o � j � � # p l o � h � � # p o � j � � ¢ p iT A F G F ¢ E H J # J F H L U F W _ E C C B W E _ D L C B U B L H E H J b L b F H U V b K E G B E ` _ F C G F C D F W U B K F _ X Y

Z H L V G K F G C B L H L M J B C W G F U F D A X C B W C U A F H L H W L b b V U B H \ K E G B E ` _ F C E G F M V H W aU B L H C L M J B C W G F U F U B b F ] T B U A E m ½ ¾ J F G B K E U B K F m E C J F C W G B ` F J B H U A F ^ G C U

C F W U B L H Y � B H W F m z k z n l n z k N z i n Q B C B U C F _ M E W L b b V U E U L G ] B U M L _ _ L T CU A E U

m o N h i j Q p k N m h i j Q q N h i m j QM L G E H X F I D G F C C B L H C h ] j B H L V G G B H \ â Y r W L G G F C D L H J B H \ f F B ` H B g G V _ F M L G� L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C T L V _ J G F E J

o � � � � p h i j � k � h � � � i j � q h i � j � � � � x

� L T F K F G ] A F G F U A F G F B C E H F E C B _ X K F G B ^ F J F I E W U M L G b V _ E Ào � � � � p h i j � k � h � � � i j � q h i � j � � � � l h i j � o � B¢ � � ¢ q � B# � � # p x

@ A B C b F E H C U A E U U A F f F B ` H B g M L G b V _ E T B _ _ A L _ J M L G U A F � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U F I E W U _ XT A F H

o � B¢ � � ¢ q � B# � � # p k S x

@ A B C B C E H B H U F \ G E ` B _ B U X W L H J B U B L H U A E U T B _ _ ` F C E U B C ^ F J B M # E H J ¢ C E U B C M X� E b B _ U L H   C F c V E U B L H C

B¢ k � " � � # iB# k l � " � � ¢ x

R R

Page 34: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

@ A B C ] L M W L V G C F ] b F E H C U A E U ¢ E H J # E G F M L _ _ L T B H \ E D G B H W B D _ F L M _ F E C U E W aU B L H T B U A G F C D F W U U L U A F � E b B _ U L H B E H " Y @ A V C T F W E H B H U F G D G F U U A F Õ Ä Ñ Å

m o N h i j Q p k N m h i j Q q N h i m j Q B H U A F J B C W G F U F o W L b b V U E U L G p W L H U F I U E C E HE H E _ L \ L M U A F D G B H W B D _ F L M _ F E C U E W U B L H Y @ E [ B H \ U A F J B C W G F U F W L H U F I U E C M V H J E ab F H U E _ ] T F C E X U A E U � E b B _ U L H   C F c V E U B L H C E G F È Ë Å Ç Ï Ä Å É Î ` X U A F D G F C F H W F L M

U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F M L G U A F J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B K F L M E W L b b V U E U L G Y @ A F W _ E C C B W E __ E T C E G F L ` U E B H F J ` X M L _ _ L T B H \ � B G E W   C b E I B b B H U A F L D D L C B U F J B G F W U B L H y � _ E C aC B W E _ D A X C B W C B C D G L J V W F J ` X M L _ _ L T B H \ U A F W L G G F C D L H J F H W F D G B H W B D _ F V D T E G J CM G L b U A F J B C W G F U F Y

@ E [ B H \ U A F _ E C U D E G E \ G E D A C F G B L V C _ X ] T F b V C U G F F K E _ V E U F U A F b F E H B H \ L M� B G E W   C b E I B b Y @ A F b F E H B H \ L M c V E H U B g E U B L H A E C _ L H \ ` F F H E ` E C B W b X C U F G XL M c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C Y d X U G E K F G C B H \ U A B C U F G G B U L G X B H G F K F G C F ] C U E G U B H \ M G L b

U A F H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F T L G _ J ] T F ` F \ B H U A F C F c V F C U B L H C E H F T YZ H b E [ B H \ U A B C ` E W [ T E G J C � L V G H F X U L W _ E C C B W E _ D A X C B W C T F C F F A L T L V G F E G a

_ B F G E C C F G U B L H U A E U ` E G F c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C L M W L b b V U E U L G C W E H ` F G F \ E G J F JE C U A F ` E W [ \ G L V H J M L G U A F W L V D _ B H \ T B U A L U A F G ^ F _ J C o E C B H U A F J F C W G B D U B L H L MM L G b E _ \ E V \ F U A F L G X B H U A F _ E C U C F W U B L H p ] ^ U C T B U A � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C Y @ A F ` E G F� L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C C E U B C M X

¢ � i ¢ � � k S # � i # � � k S

¢ � i # � � k � � � xZ H L V G D G F K B L V C M L G b E _ B C b ] T F T L V _ J B J F H U B M X z � E C U A F W L G G F C D L H J F H U T B U A ¢ �E H J � � E C U A F W L G G F C D L H J F H U L M # � x r H J ] \ B K F H E W _ E C C B W E _ K F W U L G D L U F H U B E _ h ]

T F W L V _ J T G B U F U A F W L V D _ B H \ � ¢ � � � � k # � l h � U L J F C W G B ` F U A F b L U B L H L M E D E G aU B W _ F B H U A F D G F C F H W F L M E H F _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B W ^ F _ J Y @ A F E H E _ L \ L M U A F s F X H b E H

� X C L H J F G B K E U B L H B C U A F H F I D G F C C F J W _ E C C B W E _ _ X B H U F G b C L M U A F � L B C C L H ` G E W [ aF U C Y � B b B _ E G G F b E G [ C E D D _ X U L U A F E H E _ L \ C M L G \ E V \ F U A F L G X E H J W V G K E U V G F YZ H D E G U B W V _ E G B U B C L M B H U F G F C U U L C F F U A E U L V G J F G B K E U B L H L M U A F f F K B a � B K B U EW L H H F W U B L H W L G G F C D L H J C U L U A F b L U B L H L M E D E G U B W _ F B H \ F H F G E _ B g F J W L L G J B H E U F C

U A E U C E U B C ^ F C � E b B _ U L H   C F c V E U B L H C Y @ A F M E W U U A E U C V W A E D E G U B W _ F b L K F C B H E\ F L J F C B W E W W L G J B H \ U L U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H B C E W _ E C C B W E _ M E W U U A E U T E CC V G F _ X L H F L M U A F b L U B K E U B L H C M L G U A F J F K F _ L D b F H U L M J B � F G F H U B E _ \ F L b F U G X Y� V G J F G B K E U B L H L M U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H ] B H U F G D G F U F J B H � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C ]G F D G L J V W F C U A B C G F C V _ U Y

R �

Page 35: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

@ L C F F A L T U A B C T L G [ C ] _ F U � æ | k ñ � � � � � � � � J F H L U F U A F b F U G B W B H U A F\ F H F G E _ B g F J W L L G J B H E U F C � C x @ A F H U A F K F _ L W B U X L M U A F D E G U B W _ F A E C C c V E G F Â | k

o � æ � � � p | k ñ � � B� � B� � x @ A F f E \ G E H \ B E H M L G U A F C X C U F b B C U A F [ B H F U B W F H F G \ X� k $ Â | � O k $ ñ � � B� � B� � � O x @ A F H U A F W E H L H B W E _ b L b F H U V b B C # � k � � � � B� � i

E H J T B U A ¢ � k � � T F A E K F U A F � L B C C L H ` G E [ F U C� � � k ¢ � i # � � k � � i � � � � B� � � k � � i $ ñ � C B� C � x

@ E [ B H \ $ k £ M L G C B b D _ B W B U X ] T F W E H G F T G B U F U A B C ` G E W [ F U E C � � i B� � � k ñ � � x

@ A B C ] B H � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C ] B C L V G \ F H F G E _ B g F J F c V E U B L H L M b L U B L H Y@ A F W _ E C C B W E _ J F G B K E U B L H E D D _ B F C f E \ G E H \ F   C F c V E U B L H L M b L U B L H U L U A F C X C a

U F b Y f E \ G E H \ F   C F c V E U B L H G F E J C� � � � o � � � � B� � p k � � � � � � x

� B H W F U A B C F c V E U B L H B C F c V B K E _ F H U U L � E b B _ U L H   C F c V E U B L H L M b L U B L H ] B U M L _ _ L T CU A E U U A F � L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C C E U B C M X U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F Y � B U A U A B C ] T F W E H D G L W F F JT B U A L V G J F G B K E U B L H L M U A F f F K B a � B K B U E W L H H F W U B L H B H G F _ E U B L H U L U A F E W W F _ F G E aU B L H L M U A F D E G U B W _ F Y Z H U A F W _ E C C B W E _ J F G B K E U B L H ] L H F T G B U F C L V U U A F f E \ G E H \ F

F c V E U B L H E H J C L _ K F C M L G U A F E W W F _ F G E U B L H Y @ A F E J K E H U E \ F L M V C B H \ L H _ X U A F� L B C C L H ` G E W [ F U C B C U A E U B U C A L T C U A F G F _ E U B L H C A B D L M U A F W L H H F W U B L H T B U A U A Fe E W L ` B B J F H U B U X E H J U A F f F B ` H B g G V _ F Y

@ A B C J B C W V C C B L H G E B C F C M V G U A F G c V F C U B L H C E ` L V U U A F H E U V G F L M U A F \ F H F G E _ aB g E U B L H U A E U T F A E K F b E J F Y � G B \ B H E _ _ X � F G b E H H � F X _ N � � Q \ F H F G E _ B g F J W _ E C C B aW E _ J B � F G F H U B E _ \ F L b F U G X E H J J B C W L K F G F J \ E V \ F U A F L G X ` X E _ _ L T B H \ W A E H \ F C L M_ F H \ U A E C T F _ _ E C W A E H \ F C L M E H \ _ F U L E D D F E G B H U A F A L _ L H L b X Y � F G F T F E G G B K FE U E K F G X C B b B _ E G C B U V E U B L H K B E U A F D G L D F G U B F C L M E H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F J B C W G F U FW E _ W V _ V C L M L ` C F G K E U B L H C Y r W _ L C F G W L b D E G B C L H T B U A U A F \ F L b F U G X L M \ E V \ F

U A F L G B F C B C W E _ _ F J M L G Y

^ � � � � � � � � � � _ � � � ` � � � � � � �@ A F J B G F W U G F _ E U B L H ` F U T F F H U A F W L H U F H U L M _ L W E _ D A X C B W E _ J F C W G B D U B L H C ` E C F J L H

U A F m ½ ¾ W E _ W V _ V C E H J b L G F \ _ L ` E _ W L H C B J F G E U B L H C E G F E b E U U F G L M C D F W V _ E U B L H YR �

Page 36: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� H F C U G L H \ A B H U B C W L H U E B H F J B H U A F D G L D F G U B F C L M U A F J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B K F U A E UA E C U A F M L G b

m a b o � p k o b o ¢ � p l b o � p p � o ¢ � l � p x@ A F W _ E C C B W E _ J F G B K E U B K F L W W V G C B H U A F _ B b B U E C ¢ E D D G L E W A F C L H F Y

Z H U A F C F U U B H \ L M ¢ H L U F c V E _ U L L H F ] U A F J F G B K E U B K F m a B C J B G F W U _ X G F _ E U F JU L M V H J E b F H U E _ H L H W L b b V U E U B K B U X Y � L H C B J F G K E G B E ` _ F C � E H J c C V W A U A E Uc � k ¢ � c T A F G F ¢ B C E W L b b V U B H \ C W E _ E G Y @ A F H U A F F I D E H C B L H L M o � q c p ~

\ F H F G E U F C E ¢ a ` B H L b B E _ U A F L G F b T B U A ¢ a W A L B W F W L F º W B F H U C W L b D L C F J B H ¢ aM E W U L G B E _ C L M ¢ a B H U F \ F G C N å Q a T A F G F

N å Q a k £ q ¢ q ¢ | q x x x q ¢ d ~ ï { e x@ A F J F G B K E U B K F m a B C J B G F W U _ X G F _ E U F J U L U A F ¢ a B H U F \ F G C K B E U A F M L G b V _ E

m a o � ~ p k N å Q a � ~ ï { x

Z H U A F W L H U F I U L M U A B C D E D F G ] T F A E K F W L H C B J F G F J J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B K F C B HU A F M L G b

� ð b o � p k o b o � qÁ

p l b o � p p �Á

x@ A B C T B _ _ W L H K F G U U L U A F ¢ a J F G B K E U B K F B M � q

Ák ¢ � Y @ A V C T F H F F J

¢ k o � qÁ

p � � x@ A B C b F E H C U A E U E J B G F W U U G E H C _ E U B L H M G L b m ½ ¾ U L ¢ a J F G B K E U B L H C W L V _ J ` FF � F W U F J B M T F E _ _ L T F J ¢ U L K E G X E C E M V H W U B L H L M � E H J B H U G L J V W F J U A F U F b D L G E _L D F G E U L G n B H U L U A F W E _ W V _ V C L M ¢ a J F G B K E U B K F C Y

Z H \ F H F G E _ ] b E H X ¢ a J F M L G b F J C U G V W U V G F C C V W A E C U A F c V E H U V b \ G L V D C E C aC L W B E U F J T B U A U A F W _ E C C B W E _ f B F E _ \ F ` G E C E D D F E G U L ` F F H U T B H F J T B U A U A F J B C aW G F U B g E U B L H B H A F G F H U B H m a x @ A F c V E H U V b \ G L V D C A E K F U V G H F J L V U U L ` F J F F D _ XW L H H F W U F J T B U A U L D L _ L \ B W E _ E b D _ B U V J F C M L G H F U T L G [ C J F C W G B ` B H \ [ H L U C E H J

U A G F F J B b F H C B L H E _ C D E W F C Y o � F F U A F H F I U C F W U B L H L M U A B C D E D F G Y p @ A F E H E a_ L \ M L G U A F c V E H U V b \ G L V D C B H J B b F H C B L H M L V G B C ` F B H \ C L V \ A U Y Z M U A F G F B CE W L H H F W U B L H ` F U T F F H U A F _ L W E _ E H J U A F \ _ L ` E _ D E G U C L M L V G F C C E X B U b E X _ B FB H A B J J F H W L H H F W U B L H C ` F U T F F H J B C W G F U B g E U B L H E H J c V E H U V b \ G L V D C Y � _ F E G _ X

U A F G F B C b V W A T L G [ U L ` F J L H F B H U A B C ^ F _ J Y

R ¡

Page 37: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

@ A F G F B C E W _ V F E ` L V U U A F b F E H B H \ L M U A F L D F G E U L G n o m G k N G i n Q B HU A F J B C W G F U F L G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C p B H U A F W L H U F I U L M c V E H U V b \ G L V D C Y f V E H U V b

\ G L V D C E G F � L D M E _ \ F ` G E C Y r c V E H U V b \ G L V D C V W A E C � k g a o h g o O p p B CE W U V E _ _ X E H E _ \ F ` G E L K F G E ^ F _ J � T B U A E H E H U B D L J F

h À � l i �E H J E W L D G L J V W U Á

À � l i � j � iE V H B U £ E H J E W L V B H B U

6 À � l i � x@ A F W L D G L J V W U B C E b E D L M E _ \ F ` G E C Y @ A F E H U B D L J F B C E H E H U B b L G D A B C b ]h o � c p k h o c p h o � p i E H J \ F H F G E _ B g F C U A F B H K F G C F B H E \ G L V D B H U A F C F H C F U A E U

k h o � { p � | k 6 o � p £ E H J k � { h o � | p k 6 o � p £ T A F G FÁ

o � p k k � { j � | xr H F _ F b F H U ñ B H E c V E H U V b \ G L V D � B C C E B J U L ` F E Û Ô Ë Ó Ê Ð Ç × É É Ð É È É Í Å

B MÁ

o ñ p k ñ j ñ E H J h o ñ p k ñ ï { x Z H b E H X c V E H U V b \ G L V D C o C V W A E C � kg a o h g o O p p p U A F C c V E G F L M U A F E H U B D L J F B C G F D G F C F H U F J K B E W L H � V \ E U B L H ` X E

C D F W B E _ \ G L V D _ B [ F F _ F b F H U U A E U T F C A E _ _ J F H L U F ` X n Y @ A V Ch | o � p k n ï { � n

M L G E _ _ � B H � x @ A B C b F E H C U A E U B U B C D L C C B ` _ F U L J F ^ H F U A F J B C W G F U F L G J F G F JW E _ W V _ V C B H U A F W L H U F I U L M E c V E H U V b \ G L V D � o E C E ` L K F p ` X U E [ B H \ n U L ` F

U A F C D F W B E _ \ G L V D _ B [ F F _ F b F H U Y @ A F H T F A E K Fm z k N z i n Q k z n l n z k n o n ï { z n l z p k n o h | o z p l z p x

� L H � V \ E U B L H ` X U A F C D F W B E _ \ G L V D _ B [ F F _ F b F H U B H U A F c V E H U V b \ G L V D W L H C U B aU V U F C U A F U B b F F K L _ V U B L H L D F G E U L G B H U A B C E _ \ F ` G E Y

@ A F G F E G F E H V b ` F G L M W V G B L V C E C D F W U C U L U A B C V C F L M U A F J B C W G F U F L G J F G F JW E _ W V _ V C B H E c V E H U V b \ G L V D Y s B G C U L M E _ _ ] B U B C U A F W E C F U A E U B H C L b F c V E H U V b\ G L V D C o M L G F I E b D _ F T B U A V H J F M L G b F J W _ E C C B W E _ f B F E _ \ F ` G E C p U A F C c V E G F L M U A FE H U B D L J F B C F c V E _ U L U A F B J F H U B U X b E D D B H \ Y s G L b U A F D L B H U L M K B F T L M m ½ ¾ ]

U B b F J L F C H L U F I B C U B H U A F C F E _ \ F ` G E C Y d V U B H U A F ¢ a J F M L G b E U B L H C C V W A E Cg a o h g o O p p ] U A F C c V E G F L M U A F E H U B D L J F B C c V B U F H L H a U G B K B E _ E H J W E H C F G K F T F _ _

E C U A F U B W [ L M U A F W _ L W [ Y Z H U A B C T E X ] ¢ a J F M L G b E U B L H C J L D G L K B J F E W L H U F I U M L GU B b F Y Z H D E G U B W V _ E G ] U A B C C V \ \ F C U C U A E U U A F ¢ a J F M L G b E U B L H C L M W _ E C C B W E _ C D B H

R �

Page 38: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

H F U T L G [ C N R P Q C A L V _ J ` F E ` _ F U L E W W L b b L J E U F U B b F Y r C V \ \ F C U B L H J B G F W U _ XG F _ E U F J U L U A B C G F b E G [ L W W V G C B H N ¤ Q ] E H J T F C A E _ _ U E [ F U A B C V D E U U A F F H J L M

U A F H F I U C F W U B L H L M U A B C D E D F G Y

l � � � m � � ] � L � � � � � � � n o � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �p q � � � � �

� H F W E H W L H C B J F G G F D _ E W B H \ W L H U B H V L V C C D E W F o C V W A E C ­ V W _ B J F E H C D E W F T B U AU A F V C V E _ U L D L _ L \ X p ` X E J B C W G F U F C U G V W U V G F L M G F _ E U B L H C A B D C Y @ A F \ F L b F U G X L MU A F ¹ G F F [ C A F _ J E J B C W G F U F T F ` L M G F _ E U B L H C A B D C B H U A F W L H U F I U L M W L H U B H V L V C

C D E W F Y @ A E U C D E W F T E C H L U W L L G J B H E U B g F J B H L V G T E X ] H L G T E C B U A F _ J E C E HB H ^ H B U F E \ \ G F \ E U F L M D L B H U C Y Z H \ F H F G E _ U L D L _ L \ X U A F G F B C E T B J F W A L B W F M L GD L C C B ` _ F C D E U B E _ C U G V W U V G F C o T A F G F T F b F E H ` X E C D E W F E U L D L _ L \ X L H C L b FC F U p Y

� B C W G F U B g E U B L H L M C D E W F E H J U B b F B b D _ B W E U F C U A F G F D _ E W F b F H U L M C D E W F U B b F` X E H F U T L G [ ] \ G E D A L G W L b D _ F I U A E U A E C H L J F C M L G U A F D L B H U C E H J F J \ F C U LB H J B W E U F C B \ H B ^ W E H U G F _ E U B L H C A B D C E b L H \ U A F D L B H U C Y

­ V _ F G   C T L G [ B H U A F F B \ A U F F H U A W F H U V G X ` G L V \ A U M L G U A U A F V C F L M E ` C U G E W U\ G E D A C E C A L _ J F G C L M C D E U B E _ C U G V W U V G F Y r M U F G ­ V _ F G B U T E C D L C C B ` _ F U L ^ H J U A FW _ E C C B ^ W E U B L H L M U A F ¹ G F F [ G F \ V _ E G C L _ B J C B H U A F U A F o T B J F G p W _ E C C B ^ W E U B L H L M

U A F G F \ V _ E G \ G E D A C L H U A F C V G M E W F L M U A F C D A F G F Y ¬ F U G B W W E H J B C E D D F E G B H U LG F _ E U B L H C A B D V H J F G U A F U L D L _ L \ B W E _ W L H C U G E B H U L M ­ V _ F G   C M L G b V _ E % l ; q G k O ]

T A F G F % J F H L U F C U A F H V b ` F G L M K F G U B W F C ] ; U A F H V b ` F G L M F J \ F C E H J G U A FH V b ` F G L M M E W F C M L G U A F W L H H F W U F J \ G E D A � L H U A F C D A F G F Y

r H F U T L G [ B U C F _ M W E H G F D G F C F H U E H E ` C U G E W U C D E W F Y ­ b ` F J J B H \ C L M U A E UH F U T L G [ B H U L E \ B K F H C D E W F o C V W A E C \ G E D A C L H U A F U T L J B b F H C B L H E _ C D A F G F pW L G G F C D L H J U L \ _ L ` E _ W L H C U G E B H U C L H U A F C U G V W U V G F L M U A F E ` C U G E W U \ G E D A Y

� L T E H F T U A F b F E G B C F C ] b L U B K E U F J ` X E W L H � V H W U B L H L M W L b ` B H E U L G B W C E H JD A X C B W C Y Z b E \ B H F _ E ` F _ _ B H \ U A F F J \ F C L M U A F H F U T L G [ M G L b C L b F C F U L M � W L _ L G C � Y@ A F C F W L _ L G C W E H G F D G F C F H U U A F ` E C B W C U E U F C L M E D A X C B W E _ C X C U F b ] L G U A F X W E H` F E H E ` C U G E W U C F U L M J B C U B H W U b E G [ F G C M L G D V G F _ X b E U A F b E U B W E _ D V G D L C F C Y� H W F U A F H F U T L G [ B C _ E ` F _ _ F J ] F E W A K F G U F I B C E H F H U B U X T B U A E W L _ _ F W U B L H L M_ E ` F _ C B H W B J F H U U L B U Y f F U U A F G F ` F \ B K F H E M V H W U B L H U A E U E C C L W B E U F C E H V b ` F G

o L G E _ \ F ` G E F _ F b F H U p U L F E W A C V W A _ E ` F _ _ F J K F G U F I Y � E _ _ U A B C H V b ` F G U A F Ï É Ô Å É rR P

Page 39: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

Ö É Ç Û Æ Å E U U A E U K F G U F I Y f F U ¾ J F H L U F E C D F W B ^ W W L _ L G B H \ L M U A F H F U T L G [ s E H JW L H C B J F G U A F D G L J V W U ] L K F G E _ _ U A F K F G U B W F C L M s L M U A F K E _ V F C L M U A F K F G U F I

T F B \ A U C Y s B H E _ _ X _ F U � o s p ] U A F Ä È Ê Ð Ç Å Ó Î É L M U A F H F U T L G [ ] ` F J F ^ H F J E C U A FC V b b E U B L H L M U A F D G L J V W U L M U A F K F G U F I T F B \ A U C L K F G E _ _ W L _ L G B H \ C L M U A F H F U Y� o s p B C E _ C L W E _ _ F J U A F Ê Ä Ô Å Ç Å Ç Ë Í Õ Ó Í Ñ Å Ç Ë Í L M U A F H F U T L G [ Y

r b D _ B U V J F C L M U A B C C L G U E G F F I E W U _ X T A E U L H F W L b D V U F C B H ^ H J B H \ U A F D E G aU B U B L H M V H W U B L H L M E D A X C B W E _ C X C U F b L G U A F c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W E _ E b D _ B U V J F

M L G E J B C W G F U F D G L W F C C Y Z H E _ _ U A F C F W E C F C U A F H F U T L G [ B C B H U F G T L K F H T B U A U A FE _ \ F ` G E B W C U G V W U V G F L M U A F K F G U F I T F B \ A U C Y Z U B C L H _ X G F W F H U _ X U A E U U L D L _ L \ B W E _D G L D F G U B F C L M H F U T L G [ C B H U A G F F J B b F H C B L H E _ C D E W F A E K F W L b F U L ` F V H J F G aC U L L J B H U A B C T E X N O O Q ] N £ Q ] N � � Q Y @ A B C A E C _ F J U L H F T B H M L G b E U B L H E ` L V U U A F

U L D L _ L \ X L M _ L T J B b F H C B L H E _ C D E W F C ] E H J H F T G F _ E U B L H C A B D C ` F U T F F H D A X C B W CE H J U L D L _ L \ X Y

r W _ E C C B W E _ F I E b D _ F L M C V W A E H E b D _ B U V J F T E C J B C W L K F G F J ` X · L \ F G � F H G L C FN � Q B H F _ V W B J E U B H \ C D F W B E _ W L _ L G B H \ C L M R a G F \ V _ E G \ G E D A C B H U A F D _ E H F Y r R a

G F \ V _ E G \ G E D A � A E C U A G F F F J \ F C B H W B J F H U U L F E W A K F G U F I Y � A F H F b ` F J J F J B HU A F D _ E H F ] U A F C F F J \ F C E W c V B G F E C D F W B ^ W W X W _ B W L G J F G Y @ A G F F W L _ L G C E G F V C F J Y

� H F E C C L W B E U F C U L F E W A K F G U F I U A F T F B \ A U. l £ 6 t u v

T A F G F ç ] w ] ã J F H L U F U A F F J \ F C b F F U B H \ U A F K F G U F I B H U A B C W X W _ B W L G J F G ] E H JU A F F D C B _ L H B C F c V E _ U L £ ] l £ E W W L G J B H \ E C U A F F J \ F C A E K F J B C U B H W U _ E ` F _ C B HU A F \ B K F H L G G F K F G C F W X W _ B W L G J F G ] L G S B M U A F G F B C E G F D F U B U B L H L M _ E ` F _ C Y @ A F

G F C V _ U B H \ E b D _ B U V J F W L V H U C U A F H V b ` F G L M T E X C U L W L _ L G U A F H F U T L G [ T B U AU A G F F W L _ L G C C L U A E U U A G F F J B C U B H W U W L _ L G C E G F B H W B J F H U U L F E W A K F G U F I Y @ A B C

G F C V _ U B C E D F G C D B W V L V C \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H L M U A F W _ E C C B W E _ M L V G W L _ L G D G L ` _ F b L MW L _ L G B H \ b E D C B H U A F D _ E H F T B U A M L V G W L _ L G C C L U A E U E J � E W F H U G F \ B L H C G F W F B K FJ B � F G F H U W L _ L G C Y

@ A F � F H G L C F F I E b D _ F \ F H F G E _ B g F C U L H F U T L G [ C T A L C F E b D _ B U V J F C F b ` L J X\ F L b F U G B W E _ D G L D F G U B F C L M ­ V W _ B J F E H U A G F F J B b F H C B L H E _ C D E W F o E H \ _ F C E H J U A F B GJ F D F H J F H W F p Y ¹ F L b F U G X ` F \ B H C U L F b F G \ F B H U F G b C L M U A F E K F G E \ F C L M D G L D aF G U B F C L M E H E ` C U G E W U E H J J B C W G F U F H F U T L G [ L M G F _ E U B L H C A B D C Y @ L D L _ L \ B W E _ D G L D aF G U B F C F b F G \ F B H U A F C E b F T E X Y @ A F B J F E L M C D E W F b E X W A E H \ F U L U A F B J F E L ME H F U T L G [ T B U A \ _ L ` E _ C U E U F C E H J E M V H W U L G U A E U E C C L W B E U F C U A B C H F U T L G [ E H JB U C C U E U F C U L U A F b L G F M E b B _ B E G D G L D F G U B F C U A E U E W _ E C C B W E _ L ` C F G K F G b B \ A U C F F Y

R ¤

Page 40: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

x ô õ y � � ü ÷ ÿ � ø ú z � ü ú � � � 4 � � � ü ú û � �� F C A L V _ J G F b E G [ L H U A F ` E C B W M L G b E _ B C b M L G E b D _ B U V J F C B H c V E H U V b b F a

W A E H B W C Y @ A F � B G E W H L U E U B L H { h Ý j | N £ £ Q J F H L U F C U A F D G L ` E ` B _ B U X E b D _ B U V J FM L G E U G E H C B U B L H M G L b h U L j Y � F G F h E H J j W L V _ J ` F D L B H U C B H C D E W F o M L G

U A F D E U A L M E D E G U B W _ F p ] ^ F _ J C o M L G c V E H U V b ^ F _ J U A F L G X p ] L G \ F L b F U G B F C L HC D E W F U B b F o M L G c V E H U V b \ G E K B U X p Y @ A F D G L ` E ` B _ B U X E b D _ B U V J F B C E W L b D _ F IH V b ` F G Y @ A F E W U V E _ D G L ` E ` B _ B U X L M E H F K F H U B C U A F E ` C L _ V U F C c V E G F L M U A FE b D _ B U V J F Y Z M E W L b D _ F U F C F U L M B H U F G b F J B E U F C U E U F C ¾ { i ¾ | i x x x ¾ ~ B C [ H L T H ]

U A F H U A F E b D _ B U V J F W E H ` F F I D E H J F J U L E C V b b E U B L H{ h Ý j | k k ~� } { { h Ý ¾ � | { ¾ � Ý j | x

@ A B C M L G b V _ E M L _ _ L T C U A F M L G b E _ B C b L M U A F V C V E _ G V _ F C M L G D G L ` E ` B _ B U X ] E H J B UE _ _ L T C M L G U A F W L H C U G V W U B K F E H J J F C U G V W U B K F B H U F G M F G F H W F L M U A F E b D _ B U V J F C Y Z UB C U A F C B b D _ F C U W E C F L M E c V E H U V b H F U T L G [ L M U A F M L G b

h l l l ~ l l l ¾ l l l ~ l l l jT A F G F U A F W L _ L G C E U h E H J j E G F ^ I F J E H J T F G V H U A G L V \ A E _ _ W A L B W F C L M

W L _ L G C M L G M L G U A F b B J J _ F F J \ F Y @ A F K F G U F I T F B \ A U C E U U A F K F G U B W F C _ E ` F _ _ F J~ E G F { h Ý ¾ | E H J { ¾ Ý j | G F C D F W U B K F _ X Y r b F E C V G F b F H U E U U A F ¾ F J \ F G F J V W F C

U A F ` B \ C V b b E U B L H U L E C B H \ _ F K E _ V F Y� L H C B J F G U A F \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H L M U A F D G F K B L V C F I E b D _ F U L U A F \ G E D A

h l l l ~ l l l ¾ { l l l ~ l l l ¾ | l l l ~ l l l x x x l l l ~ l l l ¾ � l l l j� B U A r E H J d ^ I F J U A F E b D _ B U V J F M L G U A F H F U B C

Y h Ý j Z k k { � � � � � � � � � � � ~ Y h Ý ¾ {� � Z Y ¾ |� � Ý ¾ 8� � Z x x x Y ¾ �� � Ý j Z� H F W E H U A B H [ L M U A B C E C U A F C V b L K F G E _ _ U A F D L C C B ` _ F D E U A C M G L b h U L

j x Z H M E W U B H U A F W E C F L M E � D E G U B W _ F � U G E K F _ _ B H \ ` F U T F F H U T L D L B H U C B H C D E W F ]U A B C B C F I E W U _ X T A E U b V C U ` F J L H F U L W L b D V U F E H E b D _ B U V J F a B H U F \ G E U F L K F G

E _ _ U A F D E U A C ` F U T F F H U A F U T L D L B H U C T B U A E D D G L D G B E U F T F B \ A U B H \ C Y Z H U A FJ B C W G F U F W E C F U A B C C L G U L M C V b b E U B L H b E [ F C D F G M F W U C F H C F Y Z H U A F W E C F L ME W L H U B H V V b U A F G F B C H L [ H L T H T E X U L b E [ F G B \ L G L V C b E U A F b E U B W E _ C F H C FL V U L M E _ _ W E C F C L M C V W A B H U F \ G E _ C Y � F K F G U A F _ F C C ] U A F D G B H W B D _ F C L M c V E H U V b

� S

Page 41: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

b F W A E H B W C b V C U ` F A F _ J M L G F b L C U M L G D A X C B W E _ D V G D L C F C E H J C L C V W A � D E U AB H U F \ G E _ C � E H J U A F B G \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H C U L c V E H U V b ^ F _ J C E G F B H W L H C U E H U V C F ` X

U A F L G F U B W E _ D A X C B W B C U C N £ ¡ Q T A L U E [ F U A F D L B H U L M K B F T U A E U U A F D G L L M L M EU F W A H B c V F B C B H U A F W L H C B C U F H W X L M U A F G F C V _ U C T B U A U A F F I D F G B b F H U C Y � A F HU A F L ` C F G K E U B L H C U A F b C F _ K F C E G F b E U A F b E U B W E _ o C V W A E C ^ H J B H \ B H K E G B E H U C L M

[ H L U C E H J _ B H [ C p ] U A F B C C V F E W c V B G F C E H F T U F I U V G F Y� L T W L H C B J F G U A F C V b b E U B L H J B C W V C C F J E ` L K F B H U A F W E C F T A F G F å k O x

@ A E U B C ] T F C A E _ _ E C C V b F U A E U F E W A ¾ C W E H U E [ F U T L K E _ V F C ] W E _ _ U A F C F K E _ V F C� E H J â x s V G U A F G b L G F _ F U V C C V D D L C F U A E U Y � Ý â Z k Y â Ý � Z k . l £ T A B _ FY � Ý � Z k Y â Ý â Z k £ x @ A F E b D _ B U V J F C U A E U L H F W L b D V U F C B H U A B C W E C F

W L G G F C D L H J U L C L _ V U B L H C U L U A F � B G E W F c V E U B L H N £ £ Q B H L H F C D E W F K E G B E ` _ F E H JL H F U B b F K E G B E ` _ F Y @ A B C F I E b D _ F B C G F _ E U F J U L E H L ` C F G K E U B L H L M · B W A E G Js F X H b E H N £ ¡ Q Y Z H N O � Q T F \ B K F E K F G X F _ F b F H U E G X J F G B K E U B L H L M U A B C G F C V _ UE H J T F C A L T A L T U A F C F E b D _ B U V J F C \ B K F C L _ V U B L H C U L U A F J B C W G F U B g F J � B G E WF c V E U B L H ] C L F K F G X U A B H \ B C G F E _ _ X c V B U F F I E W U E H J L H F W E H V H J F G C U E H J � V C U T A E UA E D D F H C B H U E [ B H \ U A F _ B b B U U L U A F W L H U B H V V b Y Z H U A B C F I E b D _ F E C U E U F L M U A FH F U T L G [ W L H C B C U C B H E C F c V F H W F L M W A L B W F C L M � L G â Y @ A F C F W E H ` F B H U F G D G F U F JE C W A L B W F C U L b L K F _ F M U L G G B \ A U E _ L H \ U A F _ B \ A U a W L H F B H E ¬ B H [ L T C [ B D _ E H F YZ U B C B H C V b b B H \ L K F G C V W A D E U A C B H C D E W F U B b F U A E U U A F C L _ V U B L H U L U A F � B G E WF c V E U B L H E D D F E G C Y Z H U A B C W E C F ] U B b F A E C ` F F H B H U G L J V W F J B H U L U A F H F U ` XB H U F G D G F U B H \ U A F C F c V F H W F L M H L J F C B H U A F H F U T L G [ E C E U F b D L G E _ J B G F W U B L H Y

¬ L G F C D F W B ^ W E _ _ X ] _ F U o ç i w p J F H L U F E D L B H U B H J B C W G F U F ¬ B H [ L T C [ B C D E W F U B b FB H _ B \ A U W L H F W L L G J B H E U F C Y @ A B C b F E H C U A E U ç J F H L U F C U A F H V b ` F G L M C U F D C

U E [ F H U L U A F _ F M U E H J w J F H L U F C U A F H V b ` F G L M C U F D C U E [ F H U L U A F G B \ A U Y � F_ F U ! � o ç i w p J F H L U F U A F C V b L K F G U A F D E U A C U A E U F H U F G U A F D L B H U o ç i w p M G L b

U A F _ F M U E H J ! � o ç i w p U A F C V b L K F G U A F D E U A C U A E U F H U F G o ç i w p M G L b U A F G B \ A U Y­ E W A D E U A � W L H U G B ` V U F C � v d T T A F G F ã o � p J F H L U F C U A F H V b ` F G L M W L G H F G C B H

U A F D E U A Y � B F T U A F J B E \ G E b ` F _ L T Y� � � � � � �

� � � � ���� �

� � � �

� � � � �

� £

Page 42: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

Z U B C W _ F E G M G L b U A F J B E \ G E b U A E U! � o ç i w q £ p k ! � o ç i w p q � ! � o ç i w p x

@ A V C T F A E K F U A E U� ! � � � â k � ! �

E H J C B b B _ E G _ X� ! � � � � k � ! � x

@ A B C D E B G L M F c V E U B L H C B C U A F � B G E W F c V E U B L H B H _ B \ A U W L H F W L L G J B H E U F C Y@ A B C J B C W G F U F J F G B K E U B L H L M U A F � B G E W F c V E U B L H B C C B b D _ F G U A E H U A F b F U A L J

V C F J B H N O � Q Y Z E b B H J F ` U F J U L � A E G _ F C d _ L L b N R Q M L G D L B H U B H \ U A B C L V U U Lb F Y Z H M E W U ] U A B C M L G b L M U A F J B C W G F U B g E U B L H B C F C C F H U B E _ _ X s F X H b E H   C L G B \ B H E _b F U A L J E C B C F K B J F H U M G L b U A F G F D G L J V W U B L H L M s F X H b E H   C A E H J T G B U U F H H L U F CB H s B \ V G F P L M U A F G F K B F T D E D F G N R ¤ Q ` X � W A T F ` F G Y s L G L H F E D D G L E W A ] K F G XW _ L C F B H C D B G B U ] U A E U \ F H F G E _ B g F C U A B C F I F G W B C F L M s F X H b E H U L M L V G J B b F H C B L H E _J B C W G F U F C D E W F U B b F C F F N � S Q Y

r C B H U A F � B G E W F c V E U B L H F I E b D _ F ] L H F T E X U L B H W L G D L G E U F C D E W F U B b F B CU L B H U G L J V W F E U F b D L G E _ J B G F W U B L H B H U L U A F H F U Y r U E K F G U F I ] L H F b V C U C D F W B M X

_ E ` F _ C L M ò É Õ Ë Ô É E H J Ä Õ Å É Ô U L F E W A F J \ F L M U A F H F U U A E U B C B H W B J F H U U L U A E UK F G U F I Y Z M U A F G F B C E C V º W B F H U _ X W L A F G F H U E C C B \ H b F H U L M C V W A _ L W E _ U B b F C ] U A F H

E \ _ L ` E _ U B b F J B G F W U B L H W E H F b F G \ F M L G U A F F H U B G F H F U T L G [ Y � F U T L G [ C F H J L T F JT B U A U F b D L G E _ J B G F W U B L H C A E K F U A F C U G V W U V G F L M b L G D A B C b C B H E W E U F \ L G X T A F G F

F E W A b L G D A B C b D L B H U C M G L b D E C U U L M V U V G F Y r W E U F \ L G X L M c V E H U V b H F U T L G [ CF b F G \ F C F c V B D D F J T B U A E M V H W U L G o K B E U A F E _ \ F ` G E L M U A F K F G U F I T F B \ A U C p

U L b L G D A B C b C L M K F W U L G C D E W F C E H J G F D G F C F H U E U B L H C L M \ F H F G E _ B g F J C X b b F U G X\ G L V D C Y r D D G L D G B E U F U G E W F C L M U A F C F b L G D A B C b C D G L J V W F U A F E b D _ B U V J F C Y

f V E H U V b H L H a _ L W E _ B U X B C ` V B _ U B H U L U A F H F U T L G [ D B W U V G F Y r H X L ` C F G K F GU E [ B H \ E b F E C V G F b F H U B H U A F H F U A E C E H F � F W U L H U A F \ _ L ` E _ C F U L M C U E U F C

E K E B _ E ` _ F M L G C V b b E U B L H E H J A F H W F E � F W U C U A F D L C C B ` B _ B U B F C L M L ` C F G K E U B L H C E UE _ _ L U A F G H L J F C B H U A F H F U T L G [ Y d X G F D _ E W B H \ C D E W F T B U A E H F U T L G [ T F L ` U E B HE D G F W V G C L G U L C D E W F U B b F B H T A B W A c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C B C ` V B _ U B H U L U A F B H B U B E _C U G V W U V G F Y

¥ ¦ § ¨ © ª « r C U G B [ B H \ D E G E _ _ F _ U L U A F K B F T C F I D G F C C F J B H U A B C C F W U B L H W E H ` FM L V H J B H N £ O Q Y � L H W F D U C L M U B b F E H J W E U F \ L G X E G F J B C W V C C F J ` X f L V B C � G E H F

N P Q ] N ¤ Q B H G F _ E U B L H U L U L D L _ L \ B W E _ c V E H U V b ^ F _ J U A F L G X Y Z H U A F W E C F L M � G E H F   C� O

Page 43: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

T L G [ U A F G F B C E J F F D F G W L H H F W U B L H T B U A U A F b F U A L J C L M U A B C D E D F G ] E C Z C A E _ _F I D _ E B H ` F _ L T Y

x ô ó � � � � ø ÷ ü þ û � � ü ú � � � � 1 ÷ ü ú � 4 ø � � þ � ø ÷ z � ü ú � � �� ÷ ü � û � �

� G E H F V C F C E D E G U B U B L H M V H W U B L H J F ^ H F J M L G E U G B E H \ V _ E U F J M L V G a b E H B M L _ J Y f F UV C J F H L U F U A F D E G U B U B L H M V H W U B L H ` X � o � i h i j p k Y h Ý j Z � T A F G F �B C E M L V G a b E H B M L _ J E H J h E H J j E G F o W L _ L G F J a C F F U A F H F I U C F H U F H W F p U A G F FJ B b F H C B L H E _ C V ` b E H B M L _ J C B H U A F ` L V H J E G X L M Y @ A F D E G U B U B L H M V H W U B L H B CW L H C U G V W U F J ` X C V b b B H \ L K F G E _ _ W L _ L G B H \ C L M U A F F J \ F C L M E J V E _ W L b D _ F I

U L U A B C U G B E H \ V _ E U B L H M G L b E ^ H B U F C F U L M W L _ L G C U A E U W L G G F C D L H J U L W F G U E B HG F D G F C F H U E U B L H C L M U A F U A F c V E H U V b \ G L V D g a o h g o O p p T A F G F ¢ B C E G L L U L MV H B U X Y @ A F C V b B C L K F G D G L J V W U C L M £ � n a C X b ` L _ C o H E U V G E _ \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H C L M

U A F ¡ n C X b ` L _ C B H E H \ V _ E G b L b F H U V b U A F L G X p F K E _ V E U F J T B U A G F C D F W U U L U A FW L _ L G B H \ C Y @ A F C D F W B ^ W M L G b L M U A F D E G U B U B L H M V H W U B L H o A F G F T G B U U F H B H U A FW E C F T A F G F h E H J j E G F F b D U X p B C

� o � p k s � ï � k � �   � � $ a o < o ¡ p p � ¢ � � $ ï {a o < o � p p � £ £ � n a o < o ¤ p p x� F G F < J F H L U F C U A F _ E ` F _ _ B H \ M V H W U B L H ] E C C B \ H B H \ W L _ L G C U L U A F M E W F C E H J

U F U G E A F J G E L M � E H J Â l ¥ B C U A F J B � F G F H W F L M U A F H V b ` F G L M K F G U B W F C E H JU A F H V b ` F G L M F J \ F C B H � x s E W F C E G F J F H L U F J ` X ¡ ] U F U G E A F J G E ` X � E H J

� a C B b D _ B W F C ` X ¤ x � F G F M F G U A F G F E J F G U L N ¡ Q M L G M V G U A F G J F U E B _ C YZ H W L b D V U B H \ � o � i h i j p k Y h Ý j Z � L H F ^ I F C U A F W A L B W F L M W L _ L G E U B L H

L H U A F ` L V H J E G X D E G U C h E H J j Y @ A F E H E _ L \ T B U A c V E H U V b \ G E K B U X B C U A E U EW L _ L G F J U A G F F b E H B M L _ J h W E H ` F G F \ E G J F J E C E U A G F F b E H B M L _ J T B U A E W A L B W FL M o W L b ` B H E U L G B E _ p b F U G B W Y @ A F W L _ L G B H \ B C U A F W L b ` B H E U L G B E _ C V ` C U B U V U F M L G

U A F b F U G B W Y Z H U A F U A G F F b E H B M L _ J W E C F U A B C B C c V B U F C D F W B ^ W E _ _ X C L ] C B H W F U A FW L _ L G C W E H ` F G F \ E G J F J E C E º I F J U L U A F F J \ F C L M U A F C B b D _ B W F C Y @ A F W L _ L G L HE \ B K F H F J \ F B C B H U F G D G F U F J E C U A F \ F H F G E _ B g F J J B C U E H W F ` F U T F F H U A F F H J D L B H U CL M U A F F J \ F Y @ A V C Y h Ý j Z � B C E C V b b E U B L H L K F G � E _ _ D L C C B ` _ F b F U G B W C �L H � U A E U W E H F I U F H J U A F \ B K F H b F U G B W C L H h E H J j Y Y h Ý j Z � B C E HE b D _ B U V J F M L G U A F b F U G B W o W L _ L G B H \ p L H h U L F K L _ K F B H U A F C D E W F U B b F � U L

U A F b F U G B W o W L _ L G B H \ p L H j Y

� R

Page 44: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

@ A F D E G U B U B L H M V H W U B L H � o � i h i j p k Y h Ý j Z � B C E U L D L _ L \ B W E _ B H aK E G B E H U L M U A F M L V G b E H B M L _ J � Y Z H D E G U B W V _ E G ] B M h E H J j E G F F b D U X o EK E W V V b a K E W V V b E b D _ B U V J F p ] U A F H U A F � G E H F a 2 F U U F G B H K E G B E H U ] � o � p ] B C E

M V H W U B L H L M U A F C B \ H E U V G F E H J ­ V _ F G W A E G E W U F G B C U B W L M U A F M L V G a b E H B M L _ J N ¡ Q Y� H U A F b E U A F b E U B W E _ C B J F L M U A F D B W U V G F U A B C B C E _ G F E J X C B \ H B ^ W E H U C B H W F B UD G L K B J F C E H F T T E X U L F I D G F C C U A F C B \ H E U V G F L M E M L V G a b E H B M L _ J B H U F G b C L M_ L W E _ W L b ` B H E U L G B E _ J E U E Y

s G L b U A F D L B H U L M K B F T L M E U A F L G X L M c V E H U V b \ G E K B U X ] � o � i h i j p k Yh Ý j Z � ] E C T F A E K F J F C W G B ` F J B U C L M E G ] B C _ E W [ B H \ B H E H L U B L H L M U B b F E H JJ X H E b B W E _ F K L _ V U B L H L H U A F M L V G b E H B M L _ J � Y � H F W E H U A B H [ L M h E H J jE C b E H B M L _ J C E U U A F B H B U B E _ E H J ^ H E _ U B b F C ] ` V U T F A E K F H L U X F U J F C W G B ` F J EH L U B L H L M U B b F T B U A B H � B U C F _ M Y

� G E H F D G L D L C F C U L B H U G L J V W F U B b F B H U L � E H J B H U L U A F D E G U B U B L H M V H W U B L HY h Ý j Z � ` X _ E ` F _ _ B H \ W F G U E B H U A G F F J B b F H C B L H E _ C V ` b E H B M L _ J C L M � T B U A

C D F W B E _ \ G L V D _ B [ F F _ F b F H U C M G L b U A F c V E H U V b \ G L V D g a o h g o O p p E H J F I U F H J B H \U A F D E G U B U B L H M V H W U B L H U L B H W _ V J F U A B C _ E ` F _ _ B H \ Y ¬ L K F b F H U E W G L C C C V W A E _ E a

` F _ _ F J A X D F G C V G M E W F B C G F \ E G J F J E C L H F U B W [ L M U A F W _ L W [ Y @ A F C D F W B E _ \ G L V D _ B [ FF _ F b F H U C E W U L H U A F G F D G F C F H U E U B L H C B H C V W A E T E X U A E U U A F D E G U B U B L H M V H W a

U B L H W E H ` F F I U F H J F J U L B H W _ V J F U A F F I U G E _ E ` F _ C Y @ A F H L H F A E C U A F D G L � F W UU L V H J F G C U E H J U A F H F T D E G U B U B L H M V H W U B L H E H J B U C G F _ E U B L H C A B D T B U A J B C W G F U F

J X H E b B W C M L G U A B C b L J F _ L M c V E H U V b \ G E K B U X Yf F U C J F H L U F U A F C D F W B E _ \ G L V D _ B [ F F _ F b F H U B H U A F � L D M E _ \ F ` G E � k g a o h g o O p p

` X U A F C X b ` L _ n x @ A F H ] E C J B C W V C C F J E U U A F F H J L M U A F D G F K B L V C C F W U B L H ] L H FA E C U A E U U A F C c V E G F L M U A F E H U B D L J F h À � l i � B C \ B K F H ` X U A F M L G b V _ Eh | o � p k n ï { � n x @ A B C B C U A F U B W [ L M U A F W _ L W [ Y @ A F m ½ ¾ J F G B K E U B K F B H U A F

c V E H U V b \ G L V D B C \ B K F H ` X U A F M L G b V _ E m z k N z i n Q k n o h | o z p l z p x Z D G L aD L C F U L \ F H F G E _ B g F U A F J B C W G F U F L G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C L H U A F c V E H U V b \ G L V D U L EJ B C W G F U F L G J F G F J W E _ W V _ V C L H U A F M L V G b E H B M L _ J � T B U A B U C A X D F G U A G F F C D E W F C_ E ` F _ _ F J T B U A C D F W B E _ \ G L V D _ B [ F C Y @ A B C \ F H F G E _ B C F J W E _ W V _ V C T B _ _ ` F E V C F M V _

U L L _ B H F _ V W B J E U B H \ U A F J X H E b B W C L M � G E H F   C b L J F _ Y ¬ V W A b L G F T L G [ H F F J CU L ` F J L H F B H U A B C J L b E B H Y

� �

Page 45: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

¦ § o o � � � ¨ � � ? � � � � � � �@ A F D G B b B U B K F B J F E ` F A B H J E H B U F G E H U B C E D F G B L J B W U B b F C F G B F C L G � T E K F M L G b �

} } } ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w } } } x@ A F F _ F b F H U C L M U A F T E K F M L G b W E H ` F E H X b E U A F b E U B W E _ _ X L G F b D B G B W E _ _ X

T F _ _ a J F ^ H F J L ` � F W U C Y � F W E H G F \ E G J U A F L G J F G F J D E B G C N ç i w Q E H J N w i ç Q E C E ` a` G F K B E U B L H C M L G U A F T E K F M L G b L G E C U T L D L B H U C L M K B F T E ` L V U U A F T E K F M L G b o ç^ G C U L G w ^ G C U p Y � E _ _ N ç i w Q E H Ç Å É Ô Ä Í Å Y � H F A E C U A F W L _ _ F W U B L H L M U G E H C M L G b E U B L H CL M U A F M L G b � N ç i w Q k N � ç i � ï { w Q _ F E K B H \ U A F D G L J V W U ç w B H K E G B E H U Y @ A B C U B H Xb L J F _ W L H U E B H C U A F C F F J C L M C D F W B E _ G F _ E U B K B U X ] E H J U A F B U F G E H U C W L H U E B H U A FC F F J C L M \ F H F G E _ b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E y � B H W F U A B C D E D F G A E C ` F F H E W L b ` B H E U B L H L MJ B C W V C C B L H C L M H L H a W L b b V U E U B K B U X E H J U B b F C F G B F C ] T F B H W _ V J F U A B C E D D F H J B IL H B U F G E H U C Y r b L G F W L b D _ F U F J B C W V C C B L H T B _ _ E D D F E G F _ C F T A F G F Y s L G G F _ E U F JJ B C W V C C B L H C F F N £ P ] £ ¤ ] O S ] O £ ] O R ] R £ ] R O ] � £ Q Y

� F ^ H F D G L J V W U C E H J C V b C L M B U F G E H U C E C M L _ _ L T CN ç i w Q N ã i � Q k N ç ã i w � Q

E H JN ç i w Q q N ã i � Q k N ç q ã i w q � Q x

@ A F L D F G E U B L H L M � V I U E D L C U B L H B C b V _ U B D _ B W E U B L H T A B _ F q J F H L U F C L G J B H E G XE J J B U B L H B H E W E U F \ L G X E D D G L D G B E U F U L U A F C F F H U B U B F C Y @ A F C F L D F G E U B L H C E G FH E U V G E _ T B U A G F C D F W U U L U A F C U G V W U V G E _ � V I U E D L C B U B L H L M B U F G E H U C À

x x x ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w x x xx x x ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � x x x

� U G V W U V G F C W L b ` B H F E U U A F D L B H U C T A F G F U A F X W L G G F C D L H J Y � E K F M L G b C W L b ` B H FE U U A F U B b F C T A F G F U A F X W L G G F C D L H J Y Z U F G E H U C W L H b ` B H F B H � V I U E D L C B U B L H Y

Z M : J F H L U F C E H X M L G b L M ` B H E G X W L b D L C B U L H M L G U A F B H \ G F J B F H U C o ç ] w ] Y Y Y p L MB U F G E H U C ] U A F H T F W E H F I U F H J : U L U A F B U F G E H U C U A F b C F _ K F C ` X U A F J F ^ H B U B L H

N ç i w Q : N ã i � Q k N ç : ã i w : � Q Y Z H U A B C C F W U B L H T F C A E _ _ ^ G C U E D D _ X U A B C B J F E U Lf L G F H U g U G E H C M L G b E U B L H C ] E H J U A F H \ F H F G E _ B g F B U U L L U A F G W L H U F I U C Y

� L ] U L T L G [ À � F A E K FN � l � i � q � Q k N � i � Q q N l � i � Q k � N £ i £ Q q � N l £ i £ Q x

� �

Page 46: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� B H W F N £ i £ Q N ç i w Q k N £ ç i £ w Q k N ç i w Q E H J N S i S Q N ç i w Q k N S i S Q ] T F C A E _ _ T G B U F£ k N £ i £ Q

E H JS k N S i S Q x

f F U¡ k N l £ i £ Q x

¡ B C E C B \ H B ^ W E H U B U F G E H U U A E U T F C A E _ _ G F M F G U L E C E Ê Ë Ð Ä Ô Ç Å Ò Y � L U F U A E U¡ ¡ k £ x

� L U F E _ C L U A E UN � l � i � q � Q k � q � ¡ x

@ A V C U A F D L B H U C L M C D E W F U B b F M L G b E H E _ \ F ` G E E H E _ L \ L V C U L U A F W L b D _ F IH V b ` F G C T A L C F F _ F b F H U C E G F L M U A F M L G b � q � ¡ T B U A ¡ ¡ k £ C L U A E U

o � q � ¡ p o � � q � � ¡ p k � � � q � � � q o � � � q � � � p ¡ xZ H U A F W E C F L M U A F f L G F H U g U G E H C M L G b E U B L H B U B C F E C X U L C F F U A F F _ F b F H U C L M U A FM L G b N � i � ï { Q U G E H C _ E U F B H U L F _ F b F H U C L M U A F M L G b

� o  p k N o £ q  p � o £ l  | p i o £ l  p � o £ l  | p Q k N � i � ï { Q xs V G U A F G E H E _ X C B C C A L T C U A E U  B C U A F G F _ E U B K F K F _ L W B U X L M U A F U T L G F M F G F H W F

M G E b F C B H U A F D A X C B W E _ W L H U F I U Y ¬ V _ U B D _ B W E U B L H H L T X B F _ J C U A F V C V E _ M L G b L MU A F f L G F H U g U G E H C M L G b

� C o � q � ¡ p k � o  p o � q � ¡ pk o £ � o £ l  | p l  ¡ � o £ l  | p p o � q � ¡ p

k o � l �  p � o £ l  | p q o � l  � p ¡ � o £ l  | pk � � q � � ¡ x

@ A F E _ \ F ` G E U A E U V H J F G _ B F C U A B C B U F G E H U D G F C F H U E U B L H L M C D F W B E _ G F _ E U B K B U XB C E G F _ E U B K F L M U A F W L b D _ F I H V b ` F G C T B U A E C D F W B E _ F _ F b F H U ¡ L M C c V E G F L H FG E U A F G U A E H b B H V C L H F o � | k l £ B H U A F W L b D _ F I H V b ` F G C p Y

� ¡

Page 47: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

@ A F E D D F E G E H W F L M E C c V E G F G L L U L M b B H V C L H F V H M L _ J C H E U V G E _ _ X M G L bB U F G E H U W L H C B J F G E U B L H C Y � F ^ H F U A F � C A B M U � L D F G E U L G m L H B U F G E H U C ` X U A FF c V E U B L H

m N ç i w Q k N w i ç Q x� L b F U B b F C B U B C W L H K F H B F H U U L U A B H [ L M m E C E J F _ E X L D F E U L G ] C B H W F B U C A B M U C

U A F T E K F M L G b x x x ç w ç w ç w x x x ` X L H F B H U F G H E _ U B b F C U F D Y � L T J F ^ H F� N ç i w Q k ¡ m N ç i w Q k N l £ i £ Q N w i ç Q k N l w i ç Q x

� F C F F E U L H W F U A E U� � N ç i w Q k N l ç i l w Q k N l £ i l £ Q N ç i w Q k o l £ p N ç i w Q x

@ A V C� � k l £ x

@ A B C B C U A F U G E J B U B L H E _ W L H C U G V W U B L H L M U A F C c V E G F G L L U L M b B H V C L H F B H U F G b CL M L D F G E U B L H C L H L G J F G F J D E B G C Y � F G F T F A E K F J F C W G B ` F J � N ç i w Q B H E Í É Ö T E XE C U A F C V D F G D L C B U B L H L M U A F T E K F M L G b C ¡ k N l £ i £ Q E H J m N ç i w Q T A F G F m N ç i w QB C U A F J F _ E X C A B M U L M U A F T E K F M L G b N ç i w Q Y

© ô õ 4 ª � y « ¬ ª ­ � � ö y ª 5 « ª « � � y ª � � �¬ E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E A E C C L b F C U G E H \ F T B C J L b ` V B _ U B H U L B U C K F G X ` L H F C Y � L H C B J F GE U T L J B b F H C B L H E _ D F G B L J B W D E U U F G H L G � T E K F M L G b Y �

x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x xx x x ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w x x xx x x ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � x x xx x x ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w x x xx x x ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � ã � x x xx x x ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w ç w x x x

x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x xç w

ã � i w ç� ã i ã �

ç w i � ãw ç

� �

Page 48: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

r ` L K F E G F C L b F L M U A F b E U G B W F C E D D E G F H U B H U A B C E G G E X Y � L b D E G F U A F b E U G B IT B U A U A F � U T L J B b F H C B L H E _ T E K F M L G b � C A L T H E ` L K F Y r \ B K F H b E U G B I M G F F g F C

L V U E T E X U L K B F T U A F B H ^ H B U F T E K F M L G b Y Z H L G J F G U L [ F F D U G E W [ L M U A B CD E U U F G H B H \ ] _ F U C T G B U F

N ç i � Q q N w i ã Q ® k ç wã � x

T A F G FN � i c Q k � S

S c xE H J

® k S ££ S x

@ A F M L V G b E U G B W F C U A E U W E H ` F M G E b F J B H U A F U T L a J B b F H C B L H E _ T E K F M L G b E G FE _ _ L ` U E B H F J M G L b U A F U T L B U F G E H U C N ç i � Q E H J N w i ã Q K B E U A F J F _ E X C A B M U L D F G E U B L Hm N � i c Q k N c i � Q T A B W A T F C A E _ _ J F H L U F ` X E H L K F G ` E G E C C A L T H ` F _ L T

m N � i c Q k N � i c Q k N c i � Q xf F U U B H \ h k N ç i � Q E H J j k N w i ã Q ] T F C F F U A E U U A F M L V G b E U G B W F C C F F H B H U A F\ G B J E G F

h q j ® i j q h ® i j q h ® i h q j ® x@ A F L D F G E U L G ® A E C U A F F � F W U L M G L U E U B H \ E H B U F G E H U ` X H B H F U X J F \ G F F C B H U A FM L G b E _ D _ E H F Y � G J B H E G X b E U G B I b V _ U B D _ B W E U B L H W E H ` F T G B U U F H B H E W L H W B C FM L G b V C B H \ U A F M L _ _ L T B H \ G V _ F C À

® ® k £® ¯ k ¯ ®

T A F G F f B C E H X U T L F _ F b F H U B U F G E H U Ys L G F I E b D _ F ] _ F U 6 k N l £ i £ Q C L U A E U 6 k l 6 E H J 6 6 k N £ i £ Q k £ x f F U

� k 6 ® x@ A F H

� � k 6 ® 6 ® k 6 6 ® ® k 6 o l 6 p k l 6 6 k l £ x� F A E K F G F W L H C U G V W U F J U A F C c V E G F G L L U L M b B H V C L H F B H U A F M L G b L M U A F b E U G B I

� P

Page 49: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

� k 6 ® k N l £ i £ Q ® k S l ££ S x

¬ L G F \ F H F G E _ _ X ] T F C F F U A E Uo h q j ® p o ¾ q m ® p k o h ¾ q j m p q o h m q j ¾ p ®

T G B U B H \ U A F O 7 O b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E E C E C X C U F b L M A X D F G W L b D _ F I H V b ` F G C Y � L U FU A E U

o h q j ® p o h l j ® p k h h l j j@ A F M L G b V _ E L H U A F G B \ A U W L G G F C D L H J C U L U A F J F U F G b B H E H U L M U A F b E U G B I Y @ A V C

T F J F ^ H F U A F Ñ Ë Í ° Ó Û Ä Å É L M h q j ® ` X U A F M L G b V _ Eh q j ® k h l j ® x

@ A F C F D E U U F G H C \ F H F G E _ B g F U L A B \ A F G J B b F H C B L H E _ b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E YZ U B C T L G U A D L B H U B H \ L V U U A F ^ G C U D G F W V G C L G U L U A F c V E U F G H B L H C À @ A B C D G F a

W V G C L G B C U A F C X C U F b � £ i � 6 i � ® i � � � x

� F G F 6 6 k £ k ® ® T A B _ F � k 6 ® C L U A E U � � k l £ Y @ A F ` E C B W L D F G E U B L H C B HU A B C E _ \ F ` G E E G F U A L C F L M F D C B _ L H E H J F U E Y ­ U E B C U A F J F _ E X C A B M U L D F G E U L GU A E U G F K F G C F C U A F W L b D L H F H U C L M U A F B U F G E H U Y ­ D C B _ L H H F \ E U F C L H F L M U A F

W L b D L H F H U C ] E H J _ F E K F C U A F L G J F G V H W A E H \ F J Y @ A F c V E U F G H B L H C E G B C F J B G F W U _ XM G L b U A F C F U T L L D F G E U B L H C L H W F T F W L H C U G V W U E H F I U G E C c V E G F G L L U L M b B H V CL H F U A E U W L b b V U F C T B U A U A F b Y � E _ _ U A B C F I U G E G L L U L M b B H V C L H F . l £ Y @ A F H

U A F c V E U F G H B L H C E G F \ F H F G E U F J ` X � k 6 ® i � k . l £ 6 i � k . l £ ® �

T B U A� | k � | k � | k � � � k l £ x

@ A F � G B \ A U � T E X U L \ F H F G E U F U A F c V E U F G H B L H C B C U L C U E G U E U U A F ` L U U L b B U F G E H U_ F K F _ T B U A ` L L _ F E H K E _ V F C L M S E H J £ E H J U A F L D F G E U B L H ­ Ù � · o F I W _ V C B K F L G p Yd V B _ J B U F G E H U C L H U A B C ] E H J b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E M G L b U A F C F B U F G E H U C Y @ A B C \ B K F C U A FC c V E G F G L L U L M H F \ E U B L H Y � L T U E [ F D E B G C L M K E _ V F C M G L b U A B C H F T E _ \ F ` G E E H J` V B _ J O 7 O b E U G B W F C E \ E B H Y @ A F W L F º W B F H U C B H W _ V J F C c V E G F G L L U C L M H F \ E U B L H

U A E U W L b b V U F T B U A W L H C U G V W U B L H C E U U A F H F I U _ F K F _ E H J C L c V E U F G H B L H C E D D F E GB H U A F U A B G J _ F K F _ L M U A B C A B F G E G W A X Y

� ¤

Page 50: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

© ô ó 4 ü � ÷ û ± ª þ � � � ÷ ü û ú � � ú � ÷ ü þ� L H C U G V W U B L H L M b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E B H \ F H F G E _ D G L W F F J C E C M L _ _ L T C Y f F U ` F E H

å 7 å b E U G B I L K F G E G B H \ â x f F U k o $ � � p J F H L U F U A F b E U G B I F H U G B F C Y f F U � ` FE H F _ F b F H U L M U A F C X b b F U G B W \ G L V D h ~ C L U A E U � { i � | i } } } i � ~ B C E D F G b V E U B L HL M £ i O i } } } i å x f F U  k o  { i  | i } } } i  ~ p J F H L U F E K F W U L G T B U A U A F C F W L b D L H F H U C Yf F U

Áo  p J F H L U F U A F J B E \ L H E _ b E U G B I T A L C F � l � � J B E \ L H E _ F H U G X B C  � x f F U

 ² k o  ² � i } } } i  ² ³ p x f F UÁ

² o  p kÁ

o  ² p x f F UÁ

J F H L U F E H X J B E \ L H E _ b E U G B IE H J

Á² J F H L U F U A F W L G G F C D L H J B H \ D F G b V U F J J B E \ L H E _ b E U G B I E C � V C U J F C W G B ` F J Y

f F U N � Q J F H L U F U A F D F G b V U E U B L H b E U G B I L ` U E B H F J ` X U E [ B H \ U A F � l � � G L T L MN � Q U L ` F U A F � � l � � G L T L M U A F B J F H U B U X b E U G B I Y � L U F U A E U N � Q

Ák

Á² N � Q x s L G

F E W A F _ F b F H U � L M h ~ J F ^ H F U A F K F W U L G Â o i � p k o $ { ² � i } } } i $ ~ ² ³ p E H J U A FJ B E \ L H E _ b E U G B I

ÁN Q ² k

Áo  o i � p p x

´ µ ¦ ± © ¦ § « k o £ � o å l £ p y p k ² ¶ , ³Á

N Q ² N � Q x@ A F D G L L M L M U A B C U A F L G F b B C L b B U U F J A F G F Y � L U F U A E U U A F U A F L G F b F I D G F C C F CE H X C c V E G F b E U G B I E C E C V b L M D G L J V W U C L M J B E \ L H E _ b E U G B W F C E H J D F G b V a

U E U B L H b E U G B W F C Y � B E \ L H E _ b E U G B W F C E J J E H J b V _ U B D _ X ` X E J J B H \ E H J b V _ U B aD _ X B H \ U A F B G W L G G F C D L H J B H \ F H U G B F C Y @ A F X E G F E W U F J V D L H ` X D F G b V U E U B L H C E CJ F C W G B ` F J E ` L K F Y @ A B C b F E H C U A E U E H X b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E W E H ` F F b ` F J J F J B HE H E _ \ F ` G E U A E U A E C U A F C U G V W U V G F L M E \ G L V D G B H \ L M U A F D F G b V U E U B L H \ G L V D

T B U A W L F º W B F H U CÁ

B H E H E _ \ F ` G E o A F G F U A F J B E \ L H E _ b E U G B W F C p U A E U E G F E W U F JV D L H ` X U A F D F G b V U E U B L H \ G L V D ] E H J M L _ _ L T B H \ U A F G V _ F N � Q

Ák

Á² N � Q x @ A B C

B C E M V _ _ \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H L M U A F W E C F å k O J F C W G B ` F J B H U A F _ E C U C F W U B L H YZ U B C E b V C B H \ U L H L U F U A E U U A B C U A F L G F b U F _ _ C V C U A E U V D U L U A F M E W U L G L M

£ � o å l £ p y E V H B U E G X b E U G B I U A E U A E C V H B U W L b D _ F I H V b ` F G C E C B U C F H U G B F C B CE C V b L M C B b D _ F G V H B U E G X U G E H C M L G b E U B L H C M E W U L G F J B H U L J B E \ L H E _ E H J D F G b V a

U E U B L H b E U G B W F C Y Z H c V E H U V b W L b D V U B H \ D E G _ E H W F ] C V W A E V H B U E G X b E U G B I B CE C V b L M D G L J V W U C L M D A E C F \ E U F C E H J D G L J V W U C L M C T E D \ E U F C o M L G b B H \ U A FD F G b V U E U B L H C p Y

r G F E C L H M L G J B C W V C C B H \ U A F C F M L G b V _ E U B L H C L M b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E B H U A F D G F C F H UW L H U F I U B C U A E U L H F C F F C U A E U b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E B C \ F H F G E U F J ` X U A F C B b D _ F L D aF G E U B L H C L M � V I U E D L C F J E J J B U B L H E H J b V _ U B D _ B W E U B L H ] E H J ` X U A F V C F L M D F G ab V U E U B L H C E C L D F G E U L G C Y @ A F C F E G F V H E K L B J E ` _ F J B C W G F U F F _ F b F H U C ] E H J C L U A FL D F G E U B L H C L M b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E W E H ` F b L U B K E U F J L H U A F ` E C B C L M J B C W G F U F D A X C aB W E _ B J F E C E H J H L H a W L b b V U E U B K B U X Y @ A F G B W A H F C C L M W L H U B H V V b M L G b V _ E U B L H C ]

� S

Page 51: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

B H ^ H B U F b E U G B I E _ \ F ` G E ] E H J C X b b F U G X \ G L T C H E U V G E _ _ X L V U L M ^ H B U F b E U G B IE _ \ F ` G E E H J A F H W F L V U L M U A F J B C W G F U F Y

· � � � � � o � � � § o o � � � ¨@ A F D V G D L C F L M U A B C E D D F H J B I B C U L D L B H U U L E T E X L M U A B H [ B H \ E ` L V U U A FG F _ E U B L H C A B D L M b E U A F b E U B W C ] D A X C B W C ] D F G C L H C ] E H J L ` C F G K E U B L H C U A E U V H J F G a_ B F C U A F E D D G L E W A U E [ F H B H U A B C D E D F G Y � F ` F \ E H W L H C U G V W U B L H C b L U B K E U B H \H L H a W L b b V U E U B K B U X ` X W L H C B J F G B H \ C F c V F H W F C L M E W U B L H C } } } m ¾ j h T G B U U F HM G L b G B \ A U U L _ F M U C L U A E U U A F X W L V _ J ` F E D D _ B F J U L E H E W U E H U z B H U A F L G J F G} } } m ¾ j h z k } } } o m o ¾ o j o h z p p p } } } x @ A F C F c V F H W F L M F K F H U C h i j i ¾ i m i } } }

T E C W L H W F D U V E _ B g F J E C E U F b D L G E _ L G J F G ] T B U A U A F F K F H U C U A F b C F _ K F C A E D D F H aB H \ E U _ F K F _ C L G M G E b F C L M C V W W F C C B K F � C D E W F � Y ¸ Æ É Ô É Ç Ì Í Ë Ä È ò Ç É Í Å Ñ Ë Ë Ô Î Ç SÍ Ä Å É Ì Ê Ä Ñ É ( Í Ë Ô Ç Ì Å Æ É Ô É Ä Í Ò Ñ Ë Í Å Ç Í Ó Ó È Ë Õ Å Ç È É Ø r _ _ U A E U B C \ B K F H B C U A FD L C C B ` B _ B U X L M C U G V W U V G F E U E H X \ B K F H b L b F H U ] E H J U A F D L C C B ` B _ B U X L M J B C U B H a\ V B C A B H \ C U G V W U V G F C M G L b L H F b L b F H U U L U A F H F I U Y Z H U A B C _ B \ A U U A F M L G b V _ Em z k N z i n Q k z n l n z k n o z � l z p W L H H L U F C E C X b ` L _ B W G F D G F C F H U E U B L H

L M U A F b F E C V G b F H U L M E J B � F G F H W F E W G L C C L H F U B b F B H U F G K E _ ] H L U A B H \ b L G F YZ H L U A F G T L G J C m z G F D G F C F H U C E J B � F G F H W F U E [ F H E W G L C C E ` E W [ \ G L V H J J B � F G aF H W F o U A F U B b F C U F D p Y � H W F U A F D E H J L G E   C ` L I L M b F E C V G B H \ C V W A J B � F G F H W F CA E C ` F F H L D F H F J ] T F E G F C V ` � F W U U L U A F b V _ U B D _ B W B U B F C L M M L G b C L M J B � F G F H W Ft v z k N z i w Q ] U A F B G H L H a W L b b V U E U B K B U X E b L H \ U A F b C F _ K F C ] U A F H L U B L H L M E

� E U ` E W [ \ G L V H J U A E U A E C U A F M L G b E _ E D D F E G E H W F L M c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C ] U A FF b F G \ F H W F L M E ` C U G E W U W V G K E U V G F E H J M L G b E _ \ E V \ F ^ F _ J C Y r _ _ U A B C L W W V G C B H

U A F C F W E _ W V _ B L M J B � F G F H W F C Ê Ô Ç Ë Ô U L U A F F b F G \ F H W F L M J B � F G F H U B E _ \ F L b F U G X L GU L D L _ L \ X L G F K F H U A F H L U B L H L M _ B H F E G C V D F G D L C B U B L H L M C U E U F C o C L B b D L G U E H UU L c V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C p Y � L U F U A E U B H U A B C E _ \ F ` G E B W D E U U F G H B H \ F E W A E _ \ F ` G E

F _ F b F H U z B C E H E W U E H U o W E H ` F E W U F J V D L H p E H J E H E W U L G o K B E U A F L D F G E U L Gt P p Y Z H f B F E _ \ F ` G E C ] U A B C B C U A F G F _ E U B L H C A B D ` F U T F F H U A F E _ \ F ` G E E H J B U C

E J � L B H U G F D G F C F H U E U B L H U A E U b E [ F C F E W A F _ F b F H U L M U A F E _ \ F ` G E B H U L E G F D G F aC F H U L G M L G U A E U E _ \ F ` G E ` X F I E W U _ X U A F M L G b V _ E ç � � ¹ o z p k N h i z Q k l t ¹ o z p

U A E U T F A E K F B J F H U B ^ F J E C E M L G b E _ J B � F G F H W F L G J F G B K E U B K F ] E \ F H F G E U L G M L G EW E _ W V _ V C L M J B � F G F H W F C Y

@ A F D G F W V G C L G E H J W L H W F D U V E _ ` E W [ \ G L V H J L M L V G D E G U B W V _ E G M L G b E _ B C bB C U A F G F M L G F U A F W L H W F D U L M J B C W G B b B H E U B L H ] U A F B J F E L M E J B C U B H W U B L H Y r [ F X

� £

Page 52: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

T L G [ B H G F _ E U B L H U L U A E U W L H W F D U B C U A F ` L L [ � f E T C L M s L G b � ` X ¹ Y � D F H W F G ad G L T H N � £ Q B H T A B W A B C C F U L V U E W E _ W V _ V C L M J B C U B H W U B L H L M b E I B b E _ C B b D _ B W B U XE H J \ F H F G E _ B U X Y Z H U A E U W E _ W V _ V C E b E G [ o J F H L U F J A F G F ` X E ` G E W [ F U Y Z pG F D G F C F H U C E J B C U B H W U B L H E H J B C C F F H U L ` F E J B C U B H W U B L H ` F U T F F H B H C B J F E H JL V U C B J F Y Z H U A B C F _ F b F H U E _ b E U A F b E U B W C U A F G F B C H L J B C U B H W U B L H F I W F D U U A FL H F U A E U T F J G E T ` F U T F F H U A F b E U A F b E U B W B E H E H J U A F L D F G E U L G B H U A F M L G ab E _ C X C U F b E C C B \ H º C X b ` L _ º B H U F G D G F U E H U Y @ A B C \ B K F C M V _ _ G F C D L H C B ` B _ B U X U L U A Fb E U A F b E U B W B E H U L J G E T U A F ` L V H J E G B F C ` F U T F F H U A F M L G b E _ C X C U F b E C D A X C aB W E _ B H U F G E W U B L H E H J U A F M L G b E _ C X C U F b E C C X b ` L _ B W F H U B U X E H J U A F M L G b E _C X C U F b E C � _ E U L H B W W L H W F D U V E _ M L G b Y Z H b E [ B H \ E b E U A F b E U B W C L M J B C U B H W a

U B L H ] U A F b E U A F b E U B W B E H U F _ _ C E C U L G X U L A B b C F _ M º A F G C F _ M E ` L V U U A F W G F E U B L HL M E T L G _ J Y � D F H W F G a d G L T H   C B W L H B W b E U A F b E U B W C W E H ` F F I U F H J F J U L W L H U E W UE H X b E U A F b E U B W C ] E H J T A F H U A B C A E D D F H C U A E U b E U A F b E U B W C B C U G E H C M L G b F JB H U L E D F G C L H E _ W G F E U B L H L M U A F b E U A F b E U B W B E H T A L V C F C B U Y Z H E C B b B _ E G o ` V U

U L E b E U A F b E U B W B E H p J E G [ F G T E X ] U A F D A X C B W B C U B C B H U B b E U F _ X ` L V H J U L U A FD A X C B W E _ G F E _ B U X U A E U A F C U V J B F C Y

� F W L V _ J A E K F ` F \ V H U A B C D E D F G T B U A U A F U A F � D F H W F G a d G L T H b E G [ E C` G E W [ F U À Y Z x @ A B C F b D U X ` G E W [ F U B C C F F H U L b E [ F E J B C U B H W U B L H ` F U T F F HB H C B J F E H J L V U C B J F Y Z H L G J F G M L G U A E U U L L W W V G U A F ` G E W [ F U A E C U L ` F W L b FE D G L W F C C B H U A F D F G W F D U B L H L M C L b F L H F Y Z U A E C U L _ F E K F T A E U F K F G L ` � F W U B K FF I B C U F H W F L G D L U F H U B E _ B U X B U A E C E _ L H F o E _ _ L H F p E H J ` F W L b F U A F _ L W V C L G H F I V CL M E H B J F E B H E D F G W F B K B H \ b B H J Y r C C V W A B U B C C U E ` B _ B g F J ` X U A E U D F G W F D a

U B L H º W G F E U B L H E H J ` F W L b F C G F E _ _ X E C L _ V U B L H U L Y Z � k Y Z T A F G F U A FW V G _ X ` G E W [ F U o U A F M L G b L M D F G W F D U B L H p B C B H U A F ^ G C U D _ E W F B J F H U B W E _ U L U A Fb E G [ Y Z i E H J U A F H J B C U B H \ V B C A F J M G L b B U ` X U A F E W U L M J B C U B H \ V B C A B H \ T L G _ JE H J D F G W F B K F G Y Z U B C T B U A B H U A B C W _ F M U L M U A F B H ^ H B U F G F W V G C B K F E H J U A F ^ H B U F

Y Z k Y Z � k Y Z � � k Y Z � � � k } } } k } } } � � � � � �U A E U U A F L ` � F W U B K B U X L M b E U A F b E U B W C º D A X C B W C o U A F X E G F H L U J B � F G F H U B H U A F

W _ F M U p E G B C F C Y r _ _ U A F G F C U L M b E U A F b E U B W C L G W E _ W V _ V C L M ` G E W [ F U C H F F J C W L b FM L G U A M L G U A F L ` C F G K F G B H U A F C E b F T E X Y @ A G L V \ A U A E U B H U F G E W U B L H U A F G F B C

U A F D L C C B ` B _ B U X L M E J F F D J B E _ L \ V F L M b E H X _ F K F _ C ] E J B E _ L \ V F T A F G F B U B C C F F HU A E U b E U A F b E U B W C E H J D A X C B W C J F K F _ L D B H D E G E _ _ F _ ] F E W A J F C W G B ` B H \ U A F C E b F

` L V H J E G X M G L b L D D L C B U F C B J F C Y @ A E U ` L V H J E G X B C U A F B b E \ B H E G X ` L V H J E G X` F U T F F H U A F B H H F G E H J L V U F G T L G _ J C L M E H B H J B K B J V E _ Y

� O

Page 53: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

» � ` � � � � � � �N £ Q ¬ Y s Y r U B X E A N £ ¤ ¤ S Q ] ¸ Æ É ¼ É Ë È É Å Ô Ò Ä Í Î ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ì Ë Õ ½ Í Ë Å Ì ( � E b ` G B J \ F

¸ H B K F G C B U X � G F C C YN O Q d E C U B H ] @ Y E H J � B _ b B C U F G � Y N £ ¤ ¤ � Q ] ¾ Ë È ò Ç Í Ä Å Ë Ô Ç Ä Ð ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ì ] � L G _ J � W B a

F H U B ^ W � V ` Y � L YN R Q d _ L L b ] � A E G _ F C N £ ¤ ¤ P Q ] o D G B K E U F W L b b V H B W E U B L H pN � Q � X C L H ] s Y e Y N £ ¤ ¤ S Q ] s F X H b E H   C D G L L M L M U A F ¬ E I T F _ _ ­ c V E U B L H C ] ¿ È Ø À Ø

) Æ Ò Ì Ø � P o R p ] ¬ E G W A £ ¤ ¤ S ] O S ¤ a O £ £ YN � Q · Y � F H G L C F N £ ¤ � £ Q ] r D D _ B W E U B L H C L M H F \ E U B K F J B b F H C B L H E _ U F H C L G C ] Z H ¾ Ë È S

ò Ç Í Ä Å Ë Ô Ç Ä Ð Á Ä Å Æ É È Ä Å Ç Ñ Ì Ä Í Î Â Å Ì ¿ Ê Ê Ð Ç Ñ Ä Å Ç Ë Í Ì ] F J B U F J ` X � Y e Y r Y � F _ C A ]r W E J F b B W � G F C C Y

N ¡ Q � G E H F ] f L V B C ] � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y ] 2 F U U F G ] � E K B J � Y N £ ¤ ¤ � Q ] � U E U F C V bB H K E G B E H U C L M � a b E H B M L _ J C ] À Ë Ó Ô Í Ä Ð Ë Õ ½ Í Ë Å ¸ Æ É Ë Ô Ò Ä Í Î Â Å Ì ' Ä È Ç í Ñ Ä Å Ç Ë Í Ì

N � Q � L H H F C ] r _ E B H N £ ¤ ¤ S Q ] Ú Ë Í S Ñ Ë È È Ó Å Ä Å Ç Ï É ¼ É Ë È É Å Ô Ò r W E J F b B W � G F C C YN P Q � G E H F ] f L V B C N £ ¤ ¤ ¡ Q ] � _ L W [ E H J W E U F \ L G X À Z C c V E H U V b \ G E K B U X E _ \ F ` G E B W & ]

À Ø Á Ä Å Æ Ø ) Æ Ò Ì Ø F Ã o £ £ p ] � L K F b ` F G o £ ¤ ¤ ¡ p ] D D Y ¡ £ P S a ¡ £ ¤ R YN ¤ Q � G E H F ] f L V B C N £ ¤ ¤ � Q ] r D G L D L C E _ M L G U A F c V E H U V b U A F L G X L M \ G E K B U X ]

E G Ù B K À \ G a c W º ¤ � S � S � � K O O R r D G ¤ � YN £ S Q � B b E [ B C ] r Y E H J ¬ �V _ _ F G a � L B C C F H N £ ¤ ¤ O Q ] s Y ] f V E H U V b b F W A E H B W C L H E

_ E U U B W F E H J c a J F M L G b E U B L H C ] ) Æ Ò Ì Ø Ä É Å Å Ø O ¤ � d ] D Y O � O YN £ £ Q � B G E W ] � Y r Y ¬ Y N £ ¤ ¡ P Q ] ) Ô Ç Í Ñ Ç Ê Ð É Ì Ë Õ Å Ó Ä Í Å Ó È Á É Ñ Æ Ä Í Ç Ñ Ì ( � I M L G J ¸ H B a

K F G C B U X � G F C C YN £ O Q ­ U U F G ] @ Y E H J � L X F C ] � B F G G F N O S S £ Q ] � G L W F C C ] � X C U F b ] � E V C E _ B U X E H J

f V E H U V b ¬ F W A E H B W C ] Æ Ç Å Ç Å Ô Ç Í Û ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ì ] F J B U F J ` X � Y � B F G G F � L X F C E H Je Y � Y K E H J F H d F G \ ] � L G _ J � W B F H U B ^ W � V ` Y � L Y ] � P P a � R � Y

N £ R Q s L G \ X ] ­ G B W r Y N O S S O Q � B � F G F H U B E _ \ F L b F U G X B H W L b D V U E U B L H E _ F _ F W U G L b E \ aH F U B W C ] � A � @ A F C B C ] ¸ Z ¸ � Y

N £ � Q ­ Y s G F J [ B H N £ ¤ ¤ S Q ] � B \ B U E _ ¬ F W A E H B W C ] ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ä È J É ] D D Y O � � a O � S Y� R

Page 54: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

N £ � Q r C A U F [ E G ] r ` A E X ] · L K F _ _ B ] � E G _ L E H J � b L _ B H ] f F F N £ ¤ ¤ O Q ] � � F E K B H \ E � _ E C aC B W E _ ¹ F L b F U G X T B U A f V E H U V b @ A G F E J C � ] ) Æ Ò Ì Ø ' É Ï Ø Ä É Å Å Ø ] K L _ Y ¡ ¤ ] D YO R � Y

N £ ¡ Q · Y � Y s F X H b E H E H J r Y · Y � B ` ` C N £ ¤ ¡ � Q ] Å Ó Ä Í Å Ó È Á É Ñ Æ Ä Í Ç Ñ Ì Ä Í Î ) Ä Å ÆÂ Í Å É Û Ô Ä Ð Ì ( ¬ W ¹ G E T � B _ _ d L L [ � L b D E H X Y

N £ � Q � V \ A F C ] · Y e Y N £ ¤ ¤ O Q ] � H s F X H b E H   C D G L L M L M U A F ¬ E I T F _ _ ­ c V E U B L H C ]¿ È Ø À Ø ) Æ Ò Ì Ø ¡ S ] o � p ] r D G B _ £ ¤ ¤ O ] R S £ a R S ¡ Y

N £ P Q � E V � b E H ] f Y N £ ¤ P � Q ] � B \ H E H J � D E W F ] Z H · F _ B \ B L V C ­ I D F G B F H W F E H J � W B aF H U B ^ W � E G E J B \ b C Y � G L W F F J B H \ C L M U A F £ ¤ P O Z r � � · � L H M F G F H W F ] � U L H Xd G L L [ ] � F T 2 L G [ À Z H C U B U V U F L M r J K E H W F J � U V J X L M � L G _ J · F _ B \ B L H C ]

o £ ¤ P � p ] £ £ P a £ ¡ � YN £ ¤ Q � E V � b E H ] f Y N £ ¤ P � Q ] � F _ M a G F M F G F H W F E H J G F W V G C B K F M L G b C ] e L V G H E _ L M � L W B E _

E H J d B L _ L \ B W E _ � U G V W U V G F C o £ ¤ P � p ] � R a � O YN O S Q � E V � b E H ] f Y N £ ¤ P � Q ] � D F W B E _ G F _ E U B K B U X E H J E W E _ W V _ V C L M J B C U B H W U B L H C Y

� G L W F F J B H \ C L M U A F ¤ U A r H H V E _ Z H U _ Y ¬ F F U B H \ L M r � � r ] � E b ` G B J \ F ] ­ H \ a_ E H J o £ ¤ P � p Y � V ` Y ` X r � � r � F C U ] D D Y O ¤ S a R £ £ Y

N O £ Q � E V � b E H ] f Y N £ ¤ P � Q ] Z b E \ B H E G X K E _ V F C B H b E U A F b E U B W E _ _ L \ B W Y � G L W F F J aB H \ C L M U A F � F K F H U F F H U A Z H U F G H E U B L H E _ � L H M F G F H W F L H ¬ V _ U B D _ F � E _ V F Jf L \ B W ] ¬ E X O ¡ a O P o £ ¤ P � p ] d L C U L H ¬ r ] Z ­ ­ ­ � L b D V U F G � L W B F U X � G F C C ]O P O a O P ¤ Y

N O O Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y N £ ¤ ¤ £ ] £ ¤ ¤ � Q ] ½ Í Ë Å Ì Ä Í Î ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ì ( � L G _ J � W B F H U B ^ W � V ` YN O R Q f Y � Y � E V � b E H ] � H L U f L \ B W ] Z H ½ Í Ë Å Ì Ä Í Î ¿ Ê Ê Ð Ç Ñ Ä Å Ç Ë Í Ì F J Y ` X f Y � E V � a

b E H ] � L G _ J � W B F H U B ^ W � V ` Y � L Y ] o £ ¤ ¤ � p ] £ a £ £ S YN O � Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y E H J � L X F C ] � Y � B F G G F N £ ¤ ¤ ¡ Q ] � B C W G F U F � A X C B W C E H J

U A F � F G B K E U B L H L M ­ _ F W U G L b E \ H F U B C b M G L b U A F M L G b E _ B C b L M f V E H U V b¬ F W A E H B W C ] ) Ô Ë Ñ Ø Ë Õ Å Æ É ' Ë Ò Ä Ð Ç Ë Ñ Ø Ä Ë Í Î Ø ¿ ] J É î ] D D Y P £ a ¤ � Y

N O � Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y E H J � L X F C ] � Y � B F G G F N £ ¤ ¤ ¡ Q ] � B C W G F U F � A X C B W C E H J U A F� B G E W ­ c V E U B L H ] ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ì Ä É Å Å É Ô Ì ¿ ] O £ P ] D D Y £ R ¤ a £ � ¡ Y

N O ¡ Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y E H J � L X F C ] � Y � B F G G F o Z H D G F D E G E U B L H p

� �

Page 55: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

N O � Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y N £ ¤ ¤ ¡ Q ] f V E H U V b F _ F W U G L J X H E b B W ` B G J U G E W [ C ] ¸ Ö Ç Ì Å Ë ÔÚ É Ö Ì Ð É Å Å É Ô Ú Ó È ò É Ô Ê Ë

N O P Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y N £ ¤ ¤ P Q ] � L H W L b b V U E U B K B U X E H J J B C W G F U F D A X C B W C ]) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ä È £ O S o £ ¤ ¤ P p ] £ O � a £ R P Y

N O ¤ Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y N £ ¤ ¤ P Q ] � D E W F E H J U B b F B H J B C W G F U F D A X C B W C ] Â Í Å Ð Ø À ؼ É Í Ø Ç Ò Ì Å Ø � L _ Y O � ] � L C Y £ a R ] O � £ a O � R Y

N R S Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y N £ ¤ ¤ ¤ Q ] r H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F E D D G L E W A U L J B C W G F U FD A X C B W C ] B H ¿ Ì Ê É Ñ Å Ì Â Â S ) Ô Ë Ñ É É Î Ç Í Û Ì Ë Õ ¿ Ú ) ¿ Ì Í ] O £ � a O R P Y

N R £ Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y N O S S O Q ] d B L _ L \ B W Y ¿ Á Ç ¾ Ë Í Å É È Ê Ë Ô Ä Ô Ò Á Ä Å Æ É È Ä Å Ç Ñ ÌÇ É Ô Ç É Ì ] � L _ Y R S � ] o O S S O p ] D D Y R £ R a R � S Y

N R O Q � E V � b E H ] f L V B C � Y N O S S O Q ] @ B b F B b E \ B H E G X K E _ V F ] D E G E J L I C B \ H E H JC D E W F ] B H ¾ Ë È Ê Ó Å Ç Í Û ¿ Í Å Ç Ñ Ç Ê Ä Å Ë Ô Ò Ç Ò Ì Å É È Ì ( ¾ ¿ Ç Î Ç S Ï Ç Õ Å Æ Â Í Å É Ô Í Ä Å Ç Ë Í Ä Ð

¾ Ë Í Õ É Ô É Í Ñ É ] f B F \ F ] d F _ \ B V b o O S S £ p F J Y ` X � E H B F _ � V ` L B C ] r Z � � L H M F G aF H W F � G L W F F J B H \ C � L _ V b F ¡ O � o O S S O p Y

N R R Q ¬ E H U A F X ] ¬ Y N £ ¤ ¤ ¤ Q ] r W L b ` B H E U L G B E _ ` B U a ` E H \ _ F E J B H \ U L U A F c V E U F G aH B L H C ] r C D F W U C Z Z a � G L W F F J B H \ C L M r � � r O S ] F J Y ` X � F B U A d L T J F H ]O R a � � Y

N R � Q ¬ L H U F C B H L C ] ¬ Y E H J � F G F g a f L G F H g E H E ] r Y ] N £ ¤ ¤ ¤ Q ] ¬ B H B b E _ W L V D _ B H \ E H Js F X H b E H   C D G L L M ] E G Ù B K À c V E H U a D A X º ¤ P £ S S P P K O £ � � F D £ ¤ ¤ ¤ Y

N R � Q ¬ �V _ _ F G a � L B C C F H ] s L _ [ F G U N £ ¤ ¤ P Q ] Z H U G L J V W U B L H U L H L H a W L b b V U E U B K F \ F aL b F U G X L M W L b b V U E U B K F E _ \ F ` G E C E H J E D D _ B W E U B L H C B H D A X C B W C ]B H ) Ô Ë Ñ É É Î Ç Í Û Ì Ë Õ Å Æ É Ì Í Î Á É r Ç Ñ Ä Í Ç Ñ Æ Ë Ë Ð Ë Í ¼ Ô Ä Ï Ç Å Ä Å Ç Ë Í Ä Í ÎÁ Ä Å Æ É È Ä Å Ç Ñ Ä Ð ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ì ] � L C U E H g o £ ¤ ¤ P p Ð A U U D À º º [ E _ V g E Y D A X C B [ Y V H B a[ L H C U E H g Y J F º O ¬ � º b A º b A Y A U b _ Ñ Y

N R ¡ Q � L X F C ] � B F G G F N O S S £ Q ] Æ Ç Å Ç Å Ô Ç Í Û ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ì ] F J B U F J ` X � Y � B F G G F � L X F C E H Je Y � Y K E H J F H d F G \ ] � L G _ J � W B F H U B ^ W � V ` Y � L Y

N R � Q � L X F C ] � Y � Y ] � E V � b E H ] f Y � Y ] f B H J C E X ] e Y � Y ] f E b ` ] � Y · Y N O S S R Q ] � H­ Y � Y e L H F C   b B W G L W L C b L _ L \ X ] � f r � a � ¸ d a ¤ ¡ O S ] e E H Y O S S R ] E G Ù B K À E C U G L aD A º S R S £ £ � ¡ K £ £ S e E H O S S R Y

� �

Page 56: University of Illinois at Chicagohomepages.math.uic.edu/~kauffman/NCP.pdf · u a f c j g b k e n t u i v q h k l n w x @ h l a w l b v u e b h m j f g k c d \ x] t f c a e _ u g b

N R P Q � F H G L C F ] · L \ F G N £ ¤ � £ Q ] r H \ V _ E G ¬ L b F H U V b a r H r D D G L E W A U L � L b ` B H E aU L G B E _ � D E W F U B b F ] Z H Å Ó Ä Í Å Ó È ¸ Æ É Ë Ô Ò Ä Í Î Æ É Ò Ë Í Î ] ­ J B U F J ` X @ F J d E C U B H

� E b ` G B J \ F ¸ H B K F G C B U X � G F C C ] D D Y £ � £ a £ P S YN R ¤ Q � W A T F ` F G ] � B _ K E H � Y N £ ¤ P ¡ Q ] s F X H b E H E H J U A F K B C V E _ B g E U B L H L M C D E W F a U B b F

D G L W F C C F C ] ' É Ï Ø Á Ë Î Ø ) Æ Ò Ì Ø � L _ Y � P ] � L Y O ] r D G B _ £ ¤ P ¡ ] � � ¤ a � S P YN � S Q � b B U A ] @ Y ] N £ ¤ ¤ � Q s G L b C F U C U L c V E G [ C ] A F D a D A º ¤ � S P R � ¤ £ � r V \ £ ¤ ¤ � K B E

A U U D À º º T T T Y B H H F G I Y H F U º D F G C L H E _ º U C b B U A º @ � A L b F Y A U b _N � £ Q ¹ Y � D F H W F G a d G L T H ] Ä Ä Ö Ì Ë Õ Ï Ë Ô È ( e V _ B E H � G F C C ] � F T 2 L G [ o £ ¤ ¡ ¤ p YN � O Q @ E H B b V G E ] � A L \ L N £ ¤ ¤ O Q ] · F _ E U B K B C U B W \ F H F G E _ B g E U B L H E H J F I U F H C B L H U L U A F

H L H a r ` F _ B E H \ E V \ F U A F L G X L M s F X H b E H   C D G L L M L M U A F ¬ E I T F _ _ F c V E U B L H C ]¿ Í Í Ä Ð Ì Ë Õ ) Æ Ò Ì Ç Ñ Ì ( Ï Ë Ð Ø Ì Ì Í ] D D Y O O ¤ a O � � Y

N � R Q � F H F ] ¹ Y � Y N £ ¤ P O Q ] r _ B U U _ F W L _ L G B H E ` C U G E W U E _ \ F ` G E ] ¿ È É Ô Ø Á Ä Å Æ ØÁ Ë Í Å Æ Ð Ò ] � L _ Y P ¤ � L Y ¡ o e V H F a e V _ X £ ¤ P O p ] � £ � a � £ ¤ Y

N � � Q � F X _ ] � F G b E H H N £ ¤ O O Q ] Ç Ê Ä Ñ É Ò ¸ Ç È É Ò Á Ä Å Å É Ô ] ¬ F U A V F H ] f L H J L H o £ ¤ O O p YN � � Q � B U U F H ] ­ J T E G J N £ ¤ P ¤ Q ] f V E H U V b ^ F _ J @ A F L G X E H J U A F e L H F C � L _ X H L b B E _ ]

¾ Ë È È Ó Í Ø Á Ä Å Æ Ø ) Æ Ò Ì Ø ] K L _ Y £ O £ ] D D Y R � £ a R ¤ ¤ Y

� ¡


Recommended