+ All Categories
Home > Documents > users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ;...

users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ;...

Date post: 01-Feb-2018
Category:
Upload: dinhquynh
View: 222 times
Download: 4 times
Share this document with a friend
25
Transcript
Page 1: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

������������� ������������������ �����������! "�����#���$%�&��'�(��) �+*, -��$.���/$.��0,1

24365798�:�;<84=?>@<AB>�CEDGFIHJHLKNM<OQPSRUTWVYXZR\[]7YXE^LR`_a8.XE^Jb�><8.X�=�[]7c[]XE:Y[ 8LX�><8LXd:QeI7Y7f[]Xd:QgihjTS[f8.7]g.kljmQnQofpSqfm�r�sutLofm�r�vw3yx�tLz?{ZpSofm]qu|In�vwm�3Sn�mJ}d|I{Sqfvw3S~JmQqc���<mQqf���L~S}d�L�L�J�N�

���,���/�,�����`�9�d�����m�{d��qcofz?m�3�otL�<x�tLz?{ZpIofmQq��<3S~Jvw3ZmQmQqfvw3Z~S}Z��x�|S�.3�oY�Bx�qfpZ�L}Z��|S 

¡W¢¤£�¥�¦�§d¨J¥J© lªv�3Sm��.qc�aofvwz?m<{SqftJ{Em]qcofv�mQr¤�L3Z«�r9¬Sz®­EtJ�wvwn<�L�w~Jt.qfvwof¯Sz?r°{Iqft.±Nv�«Sm��#²�v�«Sm��³¬�pSrcm�«�UqY�.z?mQ²#t.qf´��µt.q�r9¬Ir9ofm�z¶rc{Em�n�v³·dn��.ofvwtJ3+�L3Z«6±¸mQqfv³·dn��.ofvwtJ3ª�E243�of¯Svwru�UqY�.z?mQ²#t.qf´E}Zof¯Zm�±¸m]qfvw�·dn���ofvwtJ3&�L3d«�n�tL3NocqftL�,¹�pZm�r9ofvwtJ3Sr��.qfm®{Z¯IqY�Lrcm�«+�Lr?ºf8�8Jb�[c^LX/¹NpSm�r9ofvwtJ3Sr�»ª�Wr9¬Ir9ofm�z�m�v³of¯ZmQqrf�.ofvwr9·dmQrW¼`t.q�n��.3&­EmBz��L«Sm�oft�rf��ofvwr9�U¬Z½��W{IqftJ{EmQqco\¬�}¾tLq�v³o¿«St�mQr�3Zt.o��°À#¯Sm�rcm?¹�pZmQr9ofv�tL3Zrn��L3®­Em�L3Sr9²#mQqfm�«®­�¬�r9¬Iz ­EtL��vwn�.�w~JtLqfv³of¯Sz?rÁmQÂI{Sqfm�rcrcm�«¿vw3¿of¯Sm�þ�\n��L�wn�pZ�wpSr��.Äim#vw�w��pSr9ocqY�.ofm¯Zt�²Åof¯Zmuê��n��.�wn�pZ�wpZr��.�wrctB{Sqft�±Nv�«Sm�r#of¯Sm�­d�.rcvwr��UtLq�o4²�tB¹�pd�.3�ofvwoY��ofvw±¸m�mQÂNofm�3SrcvwtJ3Zrt.�¤of¯Zvwr�L{S{Sqft¸�.n]¯ª»j�WÆd798¸ºf^¸ºQ_`b _µÇfR`_a: m]ÂIofmQ3ZrcvwtJ3ª}ª²�¯SmQqfm of¯Sm ±¸mQqfv³·Zn��.ofvwtJ3&�L3Z«+nQtJ3�ocqftJ�,{SqftL­Z�wm�z?r�.qfm¿�L3Sr9²#mQqfm�«�vw3�ofm]qfz?r�t.�Áof¯Zm�{SqftL­d�.­Zvw�wvwo\¬�²�v³of¯6²�¯Sv�nY¯6of¯Zm�rc{EmQn�v³·dn���ofv�tL3�¯ZtJ��«Ir�}E�L3Z«�ÉÈL_µÇ]:f8LeNXZR\[cÈÊm]ÂIofmQ3ZrcvwtJ3ª}�vw3ʲ�¯Svwn]¯Ëm�±¸m�3�ofr?vw3Ëof¯Sm63Zm���q��µpSofpIqfmy�.qfm6²�m�vw~J¯�ofm�«Ìz?tLqfm¯Zm���±Nvw�³¬�of¯Z�L3�mQ±¸m�3�ofrvw3�of¯Zm��µ�.qu��²��¬W�µpSofpIqfmJ�

Í ÎSÏuÐEѾÒ�ӿԿհоÖYÒ�Ï

��×�ØÁ�N�d��ÙfÚ�×aÛ/�?Ü<���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ��EØ,��Ý�Þ°Û&ß#�¾�a×a�B�E�`àE�E�.×`Ú�á<Û�Ý�Ü,���Sâ°×��Á���yãW×a�,�N�`Þ&�E�Á�EÜ<Ú��N���4�.�EÛ/�¸Ùã �E��ä��4�E�?Ú�áÁ��Ý�Ü��N��×aå<���dÚ�×`�¾ØÊ�EØ,�ÊâE���.×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾ØÊ�E��Ý�Þ°Ý�Ú��NÛÌÝ�æ¤çQØÊÚ�á,×aÝ®�4�.�EÛ/��ã �E��ä�èÁ��é�ê�ëLé�ìí ê¸î9ïË×�Ý?��Ý���Ú?�E���a×aØÁ�N�d��Ý��Nð°�Á�NØ,�¸�NÝ��E��Ý�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛñÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�æ#ò �¾ÛÌÛ/�¾ØÅ�.áÁ�¾×��¸�NÝ��4�E��Ú�áÁ��Ý�Ü#�N��×µÙå<���dÚ�×`�¾Øó�E�¿Ý�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛ'Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×a�NÝW�d���Éî í¸ô é¤ëdê�õdö�ö`ë�÷¾ø9ùÅú³ûóü®ý¤þ¸ÿ��EØ,���?ì]ê í ÷��¤öµõdê�õ��Áîfë ô õEîfõú �B���Eý¤è�WáÁ�ªý�dÿfæ��WáÁ� � í êLø �®ù.õ¾î9ø9ë������ í�� î9ø9ë��G�EÝ�ä¤Ý�ã�áÁ��Ú�áÁ�����ÌÝ�Þ°Ý�Ú��NÛ�Ý��dÚ�×�Ý�å,�NÝ��ÌÜ,���EÜÁÙ����Ú]ÞEè�Ú�á,�dÚ/×aÝ�è�ã�áÁ��Ú�áÁ���/�E�a�®Ú�áÁ�ÅÝ��Nðj�,�NØ,�¸�NÝi�E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�Ú�á,�dÚ/���EØ ß#�ÊÜ,���¤�,�,�¸�N� �<�Á�.×aØÁàÚ�áÁ�y�E�¸Ú�×`â¤×`ÚYÞÊ�E��Ú�áÁ�yÝ�Þ°Ý�Ú��NÛ ß��N�a�¾ØÁà�Ú��/Ú�áÁ�6Ü,���EÜ#����ÚYÞEæ��¤×�Û�×a�a�d�.�aÞEèªÚ�áÁ��ù.ë��<î9ê�ëEö���� í�� î9øcë���EÝ�ä¤Ý�ãWá,��Ú�áÁ���+×`Ú�×aÝ�Ü��¾Ý.Ý�×`ß<�`��Ú��%�LáÁ�°�¾Ý����9��Ý.�Áß<Ý���Ú��E���6Ú�áÁ�Ì×aØÁÜ��ÁÚ�Ý6Ú���Ú�áÁ�ÌÝ�Þ°Ý�Ú��NÛ Ú���NØ,Ý��,���6Ú�á,�dÚ?Ú�áÁ��Ý�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛñÝ��dÚ�×�Ý�å,�NÝ?��Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]ÞEæ���áÁ�NÝ���ð°�Á�NÝ�Ú�×a�¾Ø,ÝB���EØÅß#���EØ,Ý�ã �����N�ÉßjÞ�E�`àE�E�.×aÚ�á,Û�ÝyÚ�á,�dÚ&�EÜ#���.�dÚ��Ì�¾Ø Ý���Ú�Ý��E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�è��EØ<� Ú�á,�dÚi�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�GÚ��óÚ�áÁ�Ë×aÚ����.�dÚ�×`âE���âd�E�a�,�dÚ�×`�¾Ø �E� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ýyå�!°Ü#�¾×aØjÚy�\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝÌú "y��#%$�&Zß�è'®��$��¤è��ò?ý��dÿfæ���á,×�Ý��dÜ,Ü,���¾�E�Lá×aÝi�E�4Ú��Nض���E�a�`�N� Ú�áÁ� � ï ô)( ëdö øcù��dÜ<Ü,���¾�E�.á¶Ú��GâE���.×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø �EØ<� �¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�cè�Ý.×aØ,�¸�ÉÚ�áÁ�Å�E�µÙàE�E�.×`Ú�á<Û�Ý��d���Å�E�\Ú��NØ �dß��`�ÉÚ��GÚ��däE���E�ÁâZ�EØjÚ��dàE���E���¸�¾Û/Ü<�E�¸Ú�����Ü<���NÝ��NØjÚ��dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý��4�E��Ý���Ú�Ý�E�®Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�èÚ�áj�<Ý6Ü,���Iâ¤×a�,×�ØÁàÌ�EØ ��*Ì��×`�NØjÚ6ã �IÞóÚ��Å�EØ,Ý�ã®���yÚ�áÁ��âE���.×aå<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø �EØ,�G�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�ð°�Á�NÝ�Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý¿�¾ØÌÝ�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛ�Ý®ãW×`Ú�áÌ�a�d��àE�+�9�EØ<�èj�,Ø<�Á���¿Ý��¾Û/���¸�¾Ø,�,×`Ú�×a�¾Ø,ÝWú ,6û-�<èw�,�.,6û�Áþ¸ß,ÿfè×aØÁå�Ø,×`Ú��/� Ý�Ú��dÚ��/Ý�Ü<�E�¸�NÝNæ0��á,�&�dÜ,Ü,�.�¾�E�.á ×aÝ��¸�¾Û�Ü<�`��Ú��N�óßjÞÅÜ,�.�EÜ����.ÚYÞjÙfÜ,���NÝ�����â¤×aØÁàÌ�Nðj�,×aâªÙ�E�`�NØ,�¸�É���N���dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý�è�Ý��,�.á �EÝ�ß<×�Ý�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø ú³ûó×a��ý�Zÿ1�4�4�E�/âE���.×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø0���EØ,� �E�`Ú����.Ø<�dÚ�×aØÁàß<×aÝ.×aÛ&�<�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø ú �.,2"43yý�$dÿ5�4�4�E���¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�6�Læ

7G�&�����\����Ú��ÌÚ�á,×�Ý��dÜ,Ü,���¾�E�Lá%�EÝ�Ú�áÁ� ( ëNëdö í õ�� Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØÁà��4�E�WâE���.×aå<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø%�EØ<���¸�¾ØªÚ��.�¾�cæç�Ø,�Á���N�èSÚ�áÁ�®âE���L×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾Øiðj�,�NÝ�Ú�×`�¾Øi×aÝ��EØ,Ý�ã®�����N�i×aØi�Wß#�°�¾�`�N�EØ��9�EÝ�á,×a�¾Ø8�4�N×`Ú�á,������Ý�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛÝ��dÚ�×aÝ�å,�NÝ&�%Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]ÞEè��E��×`Ú&�Á�°�NÝiØÁ�EÚ��Læ�ò �E�.���NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,×aØ,à¾�`ÞEèÚ�áÁ�ËÝ�Þ°Û&ß#�¾�a×a��âE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø�E�`àE�E�.×aÚ�á,Û�Ý��d���?ß#�j�¾�a�N�EØ/×aØ�Ø,�dÚ��Á����9dÚ�áÁ��Ý��,ß<Ý���Ú�Ý��E�#Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��¾Ø/ãWá<×a�.áiÚ�áÁ��Þi�EÜ#���.�dÚ������EØ: À#¯Zvwr�qfm�rcm���qfn]¯&²�Lr�rcpS{Z{Et.qcofm�«&vw3+{d�.qco�­�¬yof¯Sm s�|%;Åx# �<u�<��< ��²��qY«/xx0<��\�>=��¸��?�@L�I}°of¯SmBs�|%;~LqY�.3No�xx0<��\�¸�L�BA�C�DJ�I}E�L3d«Wof¯ZmFE�s�<ó~.qY�L3�o�s��L�J�%=GAL�\�¸���H=Q�\��C�?>=J�

Page 2: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

ß#� �9�EØ<��âE����Þ+�E�4Ú��NØ/�d����ú � ��Þ $��Eÿ ������Ü,���NÝ��NØjÚ��N��ß°Þ�Ú�áÁ�N×`���.á<�d�.�E�¸Ú����.×aÝ�Ú�×��B�4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý�èSÚ�á,�dÚ�d���ÌÛÌ�dÜ,Ü<×aØÁà¾Ý��4���¾Û Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ+Ú�� � ��Nþ��¾æ � ×�Ý�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø ×`Ú�Ý��N�a�®���EØ ß#�/Ý����NØ �EÝ��Åß<×aØ<�d��Þ�,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸���9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Øè��EÝ�Ý��¤��×a�dÚ�×aØÁàÌ�<×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸� ÌÚ��ËÚ]ã®�ÉÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�×`��Ú�áÁ��Þ��d���&ß<×aÝ�×aÛÌ×a�a�d�Nè¤�EØ,��,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸�óþÊ×`�BÚ�áÁ��Þ �d���ÉØÁ�EÚ�æ�çQØ Ú�á,×aÝ+Ü<�dÜ#���Nè�ã �É×a�a�a�,Ý�Ú��.�dÚ���áÁ�Iã �E�a�¿Ú�áÁ�Ê�N�`�NÛ/�NØjÚ�Ý&�E�Ú�á,×aÝi�dÜ,Ü,�.�¾�E�.áè�Ø,�EÛ/�N�`ÞEè��a×aØÁ�N�d�&Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝNèuÝ�Þ¤Û+ß#�¾�a×����E�`àE�E�.×`Ú�á<Û�Ý�è��EØ,� �Nð°�,×`âd�E�`�NØ,�¸����N�a�dÚ�×a�¾Ø,Ý�èÁ���EØ�ß#�6��!°Ú��NØ<�Á�N�ÅÚ��Ì�-�>�,õ��<î9ø9îfõEî9ø6� í Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØÁà¾Ý�èÁã�áÁ�����yÚ�áÁ���¸�¾ØjÚ����¾���EØ<�ÉâE����Ù×`å<���dÚ�×a�¾ØÅðj�Á�NÝ�Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý?�d����à¾×aâE�NØ�ðj�<�EتÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×aâE�+�EØ,Ý�ã ���.Ý�èÁãWá,�����6Ú�áÁ���E�`àE�E�.×`Ú�á<Û�ÝB�EÜ#���.�dÚ���¾Ø ÛÌ�dÜ,Ü<×aØÁà¾Ý��\���¾Û Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ&Ú��%���N�E�®Øj�,Û&ß#���.Ý�è��EØ,� ãWáÁ�����ÌÚ�áÁ���Nð°�,×`âd�E�`�NØ,�¸�����N���dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü��¾Ø<�GÚ��ó�.�N�E�µÙfâZ�E���Á�N� �,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸�NÝËú ,2"+ý��°è�� �ªü®ýEýÁè³â � 7 Áþ¸ßuè� '¿ü ��Eÿfæ 7G�Ê�¸�¾Ø¤ÙÝ�×a�,����Ú]ã®�&Ý��,�.áÌðj�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE��Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØÁà¾Ý�9¾��é�ê�ë ( õ ( ø4ö ø � î9øcù�Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàÁèEã�áÁ�����BÚ�áÁ�?âE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø�EØ,� �¸�¾ØjÚ����¾��ðj�,�NÝ�Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý��d���/�EØ,Ý�ã �����N� ×aØ Ú����.Û�Ý��E��Ú�áÁ��Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×aÚYÞÉÚ�á,�dÚ6Ú�áÁ�/Ý�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛ��!Áá,×`ß<×`Ú�Ý¿Ú�áÁ�y�Á�NÝ�×`�.�N�ÌÜ,�.�EÜ����.ÚYÞEè¤�EØ,�É���Eø � ù.ë�� �<î í �ÉÝ���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàÁè¤ãWáÁ���.����âE�NØjÚ�Ý?×aØÊÚ�áÁ�6ØÁ�N�d��9�ÁÚ��Á���/�d���/ã �N×`à¾ájÚ��N� Û/�E���/Ú�á,�EØ Ú�áÁ�¾Ý���×aØ Ú�áÁ���,×�Ý�Ú��EتÚy�9�ÁÚ��Á�.�Eæ��y�Á�y��!°Ú��NØ<Ý�×`�¾Ø,Ý6���N�aÞ�¾Ø ���,õ���î9ø4îfõEî9ø � í âE���.Ý�×a�¾Ø,Ýi�E�WÚ�áÁ� �#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ýi�\�E�/Ý��¾�`â¤×aØÁà Ú�áÁ�ÉâE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø �EØ,� �¸�¾Ø¤ÙÚ����¾�Ü<���Eß<�`�NÛ�ÝB�EØ,��è,×aØÉÚ�áÁ���,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�ÅÝ���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàÁè,��âE�NØÅ�4�E����!¤Ü,���NÝ�Ý.×aØÁà�Ú�áÁ���a×aØ,�N�d��ÙfÚ�×aÛ/��9�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�0� Ý�Ü#�N��×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø,ÝNæ

����� ���������

7G� �Á��âE�N�a�EÜ Ú�áÁ� Ú�áÁ���E��Þ �4�E� Ú�áÁ� ���EÝ�� �E� Ú]ã®�dÙfÜ<���NÞE��� Ý�Ú��°�Lá,�EÝ�Ú�×a� à¾�EÛ��NÝú�¤á,�� �&Áè'�âE�! ��°è"�3yý��Zÿfè¤�E�aÝ��&���E���`�N� ùLë���ù>�°êJê í �<î�é�ê�ë ( õ ( ø4öUø � î9ø9ù6÷ªõ ô�í�� ú �<�.,2�dÿfèj�EØ<�Ì�4�E��¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�6àE�¾�E�aÝ�æB� � îfëNù$#°õ � î9øcùó÷jõ ôÌí ×aÝËÜ<�a�IÞE�N�-�IâE���%� Ý�Ú��dÚ�� Ý�Ü<�E�¸�Eæ?�BÚÉ�N�E�.á Ý�Ú��dÚ��EèÜ<�a�IÞE����þ�Ý��N�`�N�¸Ú�Ý �+Û/�SâE�Eè°�EØ,�ËÝ�×aÛi�,�`Ú��EØÁ���¾�<Ý��`Þ&�EØ<�Ì×aØ,�,��Ü��NØ<�Á�NتÚ��aÞEèZÜ��a�NÞE���%��Ý��N�`�N�¸Ú�Ý �Û/�SâE�'&EÚ�áÁ�Bà¾�EÛ/�?Ú�áÁ�NØiÜ,���¤�¸���N�,Ý�Ú��y�6Ý��,���¸�NÝ�Ý��E��Ý�Ú��dÚ����E���¸�E�.�,×aØÁà6Ú��y��Ú��.�EØ,Ý�×aÚ�×`�¾ØiÜ,���EßÁÙ�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞ��Á��Ú����LÛ�×aØÁ�N�&ßjÞ+Ú�áÁ�?���Á�����NØjÚ�Ý�Ú��dÚ����EØ,�ißjÞ�Ú�á,�BÝ��N�`�N�¸Ú��N�/Û/�IâE�NÝNæ¾��Øi�¾�ÁÚ��¸�¾Û/�?�E��&à¾�EÛ/�Eè,���E�a�`�N� î9ê�õªù í)( �¸�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ý®×aØËÚ�áÁ�6×aØÁå<Ø<×`Ú��WÝ��Nð°�Á�NØ,�¸���E�uÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝBÚ�á<�dÚ �d���6â¤×aÝ�×`Ú��N�Ë×aØÚ�áÁ�?�¸�¾�Á�.Ý��®�E��Ú�áÁ�Bà¾�EÛ/�Eæ�7G�?Ý��NÞiÚ�á,�dÚ��6�a×aØÁ�N�d��Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ+áÁ�¾�a�,Ýu�4�E����Ú��.�E�¸��×a�ÁÚ�áÁ�BÚ��.�E�¸�ß#�N�`�¾ØÁà¾ÝBÚ���Ú�á,�yÜ,���EÜ#����ÚYÞEæ,��Ý�×aÛ�Ü<�`����!¤�EÛ/Ü��`�y�E�uà¾�EÛ��+×aÝBÚ�áÁ�yà¾�EÛ/�+*-,�.0/21�3546.�æ���áÁ�à¾�EÛ/�7*-,�.0/21�3546.ó���EØ�ß#��×aØÉ�¾ØÁ���E��Ú]ã®�ÊÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�è28�9;:�<��E�=8�>@?BADCcæ,ç�Ø�Ý�Ú��dÚ��+8�9;:�<Eè,Ü<�a�IÞE���&þ�.á,�j�¾Ý��NÝ+�Ëß�×`ÚFE!GIH � ��Nþ��¾è��EØ,� Ü<�a�IÞE���I�Ë�LáÁ�°�¾Ý��NÝ��Êß<×`Ú E)JKH � ��Nþ��¾æ�çQ�LE!GFMNE)Jdè#Ú�áÁ�à¾�EÛ/��Ü,���¤�¸���N�,Ý6Ú��ÅÝ�Ú��dÚ��O8�>@?BADC�&#�EÚ�áÁ����ãW×aÝ��Eè�Ú�áÁ��à¾�EÛ/�/Ý�Ú��IÞ°Ý+×aØóÝ�Ú��dÚ��O8'9;:�<Eæ ��áÁ��Ý�Ú��dÚ��8�>@?BADC�×aÝ�õ (�� ëdê ( ø �j÷QP��¾Ø<�¸���NتÚ����.�N�%×`Ú�èÁÚ�áÁ�yà¾�EÛ��&ØÁ��âE���W�a�N�NâE�NÝ�×`Ú�æ

6�EÛ��NÝu�d���®��Ý�Ú��EØ,�,�d�L��Û/�¤�Á�N�E�4�E���¸�¾ØªÚ��.�¾�ªÜ,�.�Eß<�`�NÛ�Ý�9¸Ú�áÁ�®Û/�IâE�NÝu�E�¤Ü<�a�NÞE��� þ�Û/�¤�Á�N�Ú�áÁ��×aØ,Ü<�ÁÚ�Ý �\�.�¾Û Ú�áÁ���¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�a�`���NèÁã�á,×a�`��Ú�áÁ��Û/�SâE�NÝW�E��Ü<�a�IÞE���R�/Û/�¤�Á�N�#Ú�áÁ�y���NÛÌ�E×aØ,×aØÁà×aØÁÜ��ÁÚ�Ý��E�`�¾ØÁàËãW×`Ú�á%Ú�áÁ�&×aØjÚ����.Ø,�E�uØÁ�¾Ø,�Á��Ú����LÛ�×aØ,×aÝ.Û �E��Ú�áÁ�&Ý�Þ°Ý�Ú��NÛ�æ �°Ú��¤�.á<�EÝ�Ú�×a��à¾�EÛ��NÝàE�NØÁ���.�E��× #���Ú��.�EØ,Ý.×`Ú�×`�¾Ø�Ý�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛ�ÝNèjû%�d�.äE�IâÌ�Lá,�E×aØ,Ý�è°û%�d��äE�Sâ��Á�N��×aÝ�×a�¾Ø/Ü,���¤�¸�NÝ�Ý��NÝ�ú �®���Jý' dÿfè�EØ,� Ú��Á�LؤÙfß<�EÝ��N� à¾�EÛ/�NÝ�æ G �WáÁ�ÉâE���.×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàG���EØ ß#�É���N�¸�IâE�����N���EÝ�� Ý�Ü#�N��×a�E����EÝ��&�E��Ú�áÁ�+�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�uÝ���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàÁè��¸�E�.���NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,×aØ,àiÚ��Ëà¾�EÛ/�NÝ�ãWáÁ�������¾Ø<�`ÞÉ�¾ØÁ��Ü<�a�IÞE����á<�EÝW��.á,�¾×a�¸���E��Û/�IâE�NÝNæ

S ;ZtLq�z��L3�¬®tL�¾of¯Zm�rcm�rc{Em�n�v��.�En����Lrcrcm�r#t.�°r9¬Ir9ofm�z?r�}Lof¯ZmQqfmu�.qfmu�L�w~LtLqfv³of¯Zz?r<�µtLq#rctJ�w±Nv�3S~�±¸mQqfv³·dn���ofvwtJ3W�L3Z«n�tJ3�ocqftL�#{SqftL­Z�wm�z?r�of¯d��o ¯Z��±JmW­Em]ocofmQq�²#tLqfr9oc��n��.rcm�n�tLz?{Z�wmQÂIv³o4¬+of¯d�.3iof¯ZtLrcmWof¯Z�.o®n��L3/­Em�tJ­IoY�Lvw3Zm�«­�¬�rc{Em�n�v��.��vw��vw3S~&of¯ZmW�.��~LtLqfv³of¯Zz?r®�µtLqBr9oft�n]¯Z�Lr9ofvwn�~J�Lz?m�r��,  qfmQ±IvwmQ² tL��of¯Zm�z?tJr9o®mUT?n�vwm�3�o ´I3St�²�3�L�w~Jt.qfv³of¯Zz?r�µt.quof¯Sm�rcm�r9ocqfpZn]ofpSqfm�r�vwr�­EmQ¬�tJ3Z«Wof¯Sm�rcn�tJ{Em�t.�¤of¯Zvwr�{d�.{EmQq��

Page 3: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

����� ������� ��� � ��������2����������������� �������������� ���ç�Ø Ý�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛ�Ý&ãW×`Ú�á Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×aÝ�Ú�×a�&Ú��.�EØ,Ý.×`Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý�èuÝ��,�.á �EÝ�û%�d��äE�Sâ �.á<�E×aØ,Ý�è�×`Ú+×aÝ+Ü��¾Ý.Ý�×`ß<�`�Ú�á,�dÚ����a×aØÁ�N�d�Ü<���EÜ#����ÚYÞ6�Á�°�NÝ�ØÁ�EÚ�á,�¾�a�y�4�E���E�a�EÚ��.�E�¸�NÝNèIß<�ÁÚuØÁ��âE����Ú�áÁ�N�`�NÝ.Ý�áÁ�¾�a�,Ý�ãW×`Ú�á6Ü#�¾Ý�Ù×`Ú�×`âE�WÜ,���Eß<�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞEæ¾�u×`äE��ãW×aÝ��Eè¾��âE�NØÉ×aØ/à¾�EÛ/�NÝ ãW×`Ú�áÌ�Á��Ú����.Û�×aØ<×aÝ�Ú�×a� Ú��.�EØ,Ý.×`Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý�èªÜ<�a�NÞE���6þÛ��IÞ Ø,�EÚyß����dß��`��Ú����NØ,Ý��Á�.�iÚ�á<�dÚ+�ÅÜ,���EÜ#����Ú]ÞóáÁ�¾���,Ý6�¾Ø �E�a��Ú��.�E�¸�NÝNè�ß<�ÁÚ�Û��IÞ Ø,��âE����ÙÚ�áÁ�N�`�NÝ.Ý®ß#�6�dß<�`��Ú��/�NØ,Ý��Á�.��Ú�á,�dÚ?×`ÚBáÁ�¾�a�<Ý¿ãW×aÚ�áÊÝ��¾Û/�6Ü��¾Ý.×`Ú�×`âE��Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞ�ú �,�2,2"+ý�$Zÿfæ"Á�E�Ë��!¤�EÛ/Ü��`�Eè¿�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×��Á�����dà¾�E×aØ Ú�áÁ�%à¾�EÛ/� *R,�.0/51 3�4 .è�Ú��EàE��Ú�áÁ���ÊãW×`Ú�á Ú�á,��Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ�E�����N�E�Lá,×aØÁà 8�>@?BADC �9�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ú�×�ØÁàÌ�E� �E�a��Ú��L�E�¸�NÝ6Ú�á,�dÚy�¸�¾ØªÚ��E×aØ 8�> ? ADC6�Læ �°Ú��d��Ú�×aØ,àË�4���¾Û 8'9;:�<EèÜ<�a�IÞE���ÊþË×aÝ+Ø,�EÚ&�dß<�`�ÌÚ��%�NØ,Ý��,����Ú�á,�dÚ��E�a��Ú��.�E�¸�NÝi���N�E�Lá 8 > ? ADC 9uãWá,�dÚ���âE���/Ý��Nð°�Á�NØ,�¸�Ì�E�ß<×`Ú�Ý&Ü<�a�IÞE���ÅþË�LáÁ�j�¾Ý��NÝ�è�Ú�áÁ�����Å×aÝi�E�`ã �IÞ°ÝiÚ�áÁ�ÊÜ#�¾Ý�Ý�×`ß�×a�a×`Ú]ÞóÚ�á,�dÚiÜ<�a�IÞE���O�%�LáÁ�°�¾Ý��NÝ�Ú�áÁ��¸�¾Û/Ü<�a�NÛ/�NتÚ��d�.Þ Ý��Nð°�Á�NØ,�¸�Eè��¸�¾Ø,å<Ø,×aØÁà Ú�áÁ�Åà¾�EÛ/�%Ú�� 8'9;:�<Eæ"!W��âE���.Ú�áÁ�N�`�NÝ�Ý�è�×a�WÜ<�a�IÞE���%þ�.á,�j�¾Ý��NÝ+�N�E�.á ß<×`Ú4��EØ,� þ�ãW×`Ú�á �Nð°�,�E��Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×`Ú]ÞEè×aØ �N�E�.á ���¾�,Ø,�GáÁ�ÌãW×a�a�uÜ,���¤�¸���N�Ú��K8 > ? ADC�ãW×`Ú�á�Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞÉþ�# �°è°Ý��&Ú�á,�dÚ%8 > ? A@C�×aÝ¿���N�E�.áÁ�N�ÊãW×aÚ�á�Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×`Ú]ÞËþdæ¤��Ø,�EÚ�áÁ�����!Á�EÛ/Ü<�`�+×�ÝBÜ,���Iâ¤×a�Á�N��ßjÞÉÚ�áÁ��à¾�EÛ��+*R,�. /21%$�&('�è<�/âd�d�.×a�EØjÚ��E� *R,�. /21�3546.%ãWáÁ���.��Ú�áÁ�ß<×`Ú�Ý ���EØÊß#���.á,�¾Ý��NØÊ�¾Ø,�¸���¾Ø<�`ÞEæ �WáÁ�Wà¾�EÛ/��*R,�.0/51�$%&('����EØËß#�6×aØ��¾Ø,���E��Ú�á,������Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ8�9 :�<Eè 8 > ? ADCfè��EØ,��8*)�A,+ Ccæu�BÚK8'9;:�<dèuÜ��a�NÞE���.ÝËþË�EØ<�����LáÁ�°�¾Ý��Ëß�×`Ú�Ý E G �EØ,� E J &u×`� E G M E J èÚ�áÁ��à¾�EÛ/�6Ü,���¤�¸���N�,Ý Ú�� 8 > ? ADCcè¤�EÚ�áÁ����ã�×aÝ���×aÚ®Ü,�.�°�¸���N�,Ý®Ú�� 8-) A.+ Ccæ � �EÚ�á 8 > ? ADC#�EØ,� 8-) A.+ C#�d����dß<Ý��E�.ß<×aØÁàÊÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�æç�ØóÚ�á,�ià¾�EÛ��O*-,�.0/21%$�&('�è�Ú�á,��ÛÌ� !¤×aÛÌ�E�uÜ<���Eß<�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞÉãW×`Ú�áóãWá,×��.áÜ<�a�IÞE���+þ����EØ%�NØ,Ý��Á���6���N�E�Lá,×aØÁà�8 > ? ADC�×�Ýyþ�# �°æ

,��NØ,�¸�Eè,×`ÚB×aÝ®�E�\Ú��NØÉ�E��×aتÚ����.�NÝ�Ú®Ú����¸�¾Ø<Ý�×a�Á���B�iÜ,���Eß<�dß<×��a×aÝ�Ú�×a�BâE���LÝ�×`�¾ØÊ�E��âE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø�EØ,� �¸�¾ØjÚ����¾��Ü,���Eß��`�NÛ�Ý�è�Ú�á,�dÚ��EÝ�ä%Ú�á,��ÛÌ� !¤×aÛÌ�E�uÜ<���Eß<�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞÉãW×`Ú�á ãWá<×a�.á �ÉÜ,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ���EØ ß#�Ëà¾�<�d�.�EتÚ����N�¶Ú�� áÁ�¾�a�æ�7G���d���ÅÚ�áj�<Ýi�a�N� Ú��GÚ�á,�ÊÜ<���Eß<�`�NÛ �E���¸�¾Û/Ü��ÁÚ�×aØÁà Ú�áÁ�Û�� !Á×aÛ��E�Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞ�ã�×`Ú�áÅãWá,×��.áÅÜ<���NÞE���&þ+���EØ%�NØ,Ý.�Á���yÚ�á,�dÚW�EØ-��Ùf����à¾�,�a�d��Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]ÞáÁ�¾�a�<ÝÌ×aض� Ý�Ú��¤�.á,�EÝ�Ú�×a�%à¾�EÛ��Eæ ��á<×aÝ/Ü,���Eß��`�NÛ ���EØ�ß#�%Ý��¾�`âE�N��ãW×`Ú�á�ðj�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE���#Ù���E�a���,���,Ý¿�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ Ú�á,�dÚ?�d���y�,×`�.�N�¸Ú��`Þ��Á���.×`âE�N�Ê�4���¾Û Ú�áÁ�N×`� ß#�j�¾�`�N�EØÉ�¸�¾�,ØjÚ�����Ü<�d�.Ú�Ý?�,Ý��N�Ú��ÌÝ��¾�aâE��ß#�j�¾�`�N�EØÅ�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾��Ü,���Eß<�`�NÛÌÝ�æ

�°Ü#�N��×`å����E�a�`ÞEèªú 'L�jý¤þ¸ÿÁÝ�áÁ�Iã �N�&Ú�á,�dÚu�4�E��Ú��Á�.ؤÙfß<�EÝ��N��à¾�EÛ/�NÝ�ãW×aÚ�á+�Á��Ú����.ÛÌ×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×���Ú��.�EؤÙÝ�×`Ú�×a�¾Ø,Ý�èdÚ�áÁ�WÝ���Ú¿�E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ®�4���¾Û ãWá,×��.á�Ü<�a�IÞE����þ����EØ��NØ,Ý��Á���?Ú�á<�dÚ¿�EØ ��Ùf����à¾�,���d�¿Ý�Ü#�N��×`åÁÙ���dÚ�×`�¾Ø�áÁ�¾�a�<Ýu���EØiß#�®�¸�¾Û/Ü��ÁÚ��N��×aØ+�.�#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý�ß<�EÝ��N�&�¾Ø&Ú�áÁ�BÝ���Ú�ÙfÚ�áÁ���E����Ú�×��B�EÜ����L�dÚ��E�.Ý/ �-0 �EØ,�Ì�¾ØÌÚ�áÁ�iùLë��<î9ê�ëdö4öµõ ( ö í é�ê í � í ù í��B� ëdê&�EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�21<é�ê í æ�"Á�E�B�iÝ���Ú"3-�E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�è¤Ú�áÁ�Ý���Ú41<é�ê í ��3 �¿�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ý �E�uÚ�áÁ��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ?�\�.�¾Û ãWá<×a�.áÊÜ<�a�IÞE���yþ����EØÊ�NØ,Ý.�Á���6�+Ú��.�EØ<Ý�×`Ú�×`�¾ØËÚ��3 ×aØÊ�¾ØÁ��Ý�Ú���Ü�æ,��Ý��EØÉ��!Á�EÛ/Ü<�a�Eè,�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×a�Á���BÚ�áÁ�/ê í õªù$#°õ ( ø\öUø9î9ïÊÜ<���EÜ#����ÚYÞ6573+èÁ�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×�Ý�Ú�×aØÁà�E���E�a�#Ú�áÁ�yÚ��.�E�¸�NÝ�Ú�á,�dÚ��¸�¾ØjÚ��E×aØ%�/Ý�Ú��dÚ��i×aØ83+æ���áÁ��Ý���Ú?�E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��4���¾Û ãWá,×��.áÊÜ<�a�IÞE���&þ���EØ �NØ<Ý��Á����Ú�á,�dÚ+�E����Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ&�d�.��×aØ 5 3 ���EØ ß#���¸�¾Û/Ü<�ÁÚ��N�Gß°Þ �`��Ú�Ú�×aØÁà�9;:KM<3&è��EØ,��4�E�>= M ��Nþ � � ��?�?�?9è#ß°Þó�`��Ú�Ú�×aØ,à@9;A�B G MC3 / 1<é�ê í � 9;A��Læ ��áÁ�/Ý���Ú�9;AË�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ý��E� Ú�áÁ�Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝË�\�.�¾Û ãWá,×a�Lá Ü<�a�IÞE���óþ����EØ �\�E�L�¸��Ú�áÁ��à¾�EÛ/�óÚ��D3�×�ض�dÚÌÛ/�¾Ý�ÚE= Ý�Ú���Ü<Ý &®×aض�å<Ø,×aÚ��ià¾�EÛ��Eè�Ú�áÁ��Ý��¾�a�,Ú�×`�¾Ø ×aÝ6Ú�áj�<Ýyà¾×`âE�NØGß°Þó�a×�Û2AGF>HI9;Aªæuò �¾Û/Ü<�ÁÚ�×�ØÁàÉÚ�áÁ��Ý��Nð°�Á�NØ,�¸�9;:��,9 G �,9 J ��?�?�?��E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��¸�E�.���NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,Ý?Ú��Ë��âZ�E���,�dÚ�×aØÁà�ß°ÞÅ×`Ú����.�dÚ�×`�¾Ø%Ú�áÁ�+�`�N�EÝ�Ú�å !¤Ü��¾×�تÚ�E�J9 MK3 / 1<é�ê í � 9 �Lè�ãWá,×a�Lá ×�Ý��Á�NØÁ�EÚ��N� ×�Ø �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý6�EÝ �ML%? ��3 / 1<é�ê í � 9 � ��9�Ú�á,×aÝ�4�E�.Û&�<�a��×aÝWÚ�áj�,Ý�� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ý�Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø��\�E�.Ûi�,�a���\�E�����N�E�.á<�dß<×a�a×`Ú]ÞEæ �°�¾���ÁÚ�×`�¾ØÅ�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ�d���Bä¤ØÁ�IãWØi�4�E��àE�NØÁ���.�E�¤Ü<�d�.×aÚYÞ+�¸�¾Ø,�<×`Ú�×`�¾Ø,ÝBú 'L�jý¤þ¸ÿfèE�EØ,�iÚ�á,×aÝ�Ý�� *Ì�¸�NÝ��4�E��Ý��¾�`â¤×aØÁàWà¾�EÛ��NÝãW×`Ú�áÉ�.�NÝ�Ü#�N�¸Ú?Ú��Ë�d��ß<×aÚ��.�d��Þ)��Ùf�.��à¾�,�a�d�?Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×a�NÝ�æ

��á,�ÉÝ��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø �4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝi�\�E�/Ú�áÁ�ÉÜ,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×�Ý�Ú�×a��Ý���Ú�Ú�×�ØÁà ���EØ ß#�Ê�Eß<Ú��E×aØÁ�N� Ý�×aÛ/Ü��`Þß°Þ/à¾×`â°×�ØÁà&� ���,õ��<î9ø9îfõEî9ø � í ×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØËÚ��&Ú�á,��Ý��¾���ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø��4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ®�E�¿ú 'L�jý¤þ¸ÿfæjç�ØËÚ�á,×aÝ

&

Page 4: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

ð°�,�EتÚ�×aÚ��dÚ�×`âE� ×�تÚ�����Ü<����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØèZÝ��Áß<Ý���Ú�Ýu�E�,Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��d��� ����Ü<�a�E�¸�N�&ß°Þ � îfõEî í �Zõdö �,õEî9øcë�� � Ú�á,�dÚ�EÝ�Ý��¤��×a�dÚ��ËãW×`Ú�á �N�E�.á Ý�Ú��dÚ��Ê�Å���N�E�¿Ø°�,Û&ß#����×aØGÚ�áÁ�Ì×�تÚ�����âd�E�Wú ��NþJÿ &�Ú�áÁ��Ý���Ú&�EÜ����L�dÚ��E�.Ý/ è 0 �d�.� ����Ü<�a�E�¸�N� ßjÞ-Ú�áÁ� Ü#�¾×aØjÚYãW×�Ý��GÛ�� !¤×�Û&�,Û �EØ<� Û�×aØ,×�Û&�,Û �EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�.Ý � è��ú ���N×6$�Áè" ,2$'�¤è"���#%$�&d�<è"Á�N�6$�&Zÿfæ���áÁ�y�EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�E1<é�ê í ×�Ý?����Ü<�a�E�¸�N��ßjÞÉ�EØÅ�EÜ#���.�dÚ��E���ué�ê íÚ�á,�dÚ�èdà¾×`âE�NØ��6Ý�Ú��dÚ��BâZ�E���,�dÚ�×`�¾Ø���èSà¾×`âE�NÝ�Ú�á,� Ý�Ú��dÚ��Bâd�E�a�,�dÚ�×`�¾Ø�ué�ê í �� ���EÝ.Ý��°��×��dÚ�×aØÁà�ãW×`Ú�á�N�E�.á Ý�Ú��dÚ���Ú�á,�+Û�� !Á×aÛ��E�#��!¤Ü��N�¸Ú��dÚ�×a�¾Ø��E��� Ú�á,�dÚ�Ü<�a�IÞE���+þ����EØó�E�.á,×`��âE�i×aØÉ�¾ØÁ��Ý�Ú���Ü�æ

��Ýu�EØ&��!Á�EÛ/Ü<�`�EèZ�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×a�Á�����dà¾�E×aØiÚ�áÁ�¿àE�¾�E� 5 3+æ ���NØÁ�EÚ�� ßjÞ � ��3 ��Ú�áÁ�®�Lá,�d�.�E�¸Ú����.×aÝ�Ú�×a��9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø �E� 3+è#Ú�á,�dÚ��EÝ�Ý�×`à¾Ø<Ý6âZ�E�a�,�ÉþiÚ��%Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�×aØ 3 �EØ,� âd�E�a�Á� ÉÚ���Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��¾�,Ú�Ý�×a�Á�3+æ 7G�+���EØ��¸�¾Û�Ü<�ÁÚ��yÚ�áÁ��Û�� !Á×aÛ��E��Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×aÚYÞ/�E�����N�E�.á,×�ØÁà 3 ßjÞÊ�`��Ú�Ú�×aØÁà���: M�� ��3 ��EØ,�è��4�E�8= M ��Nþ � � ��?�?�?9è�ßjÞ �`��Ú�Ú�×aØÁà���A�B G M�� ��3 � � �ué�ê í ���A��Læ�çQÚÌ×aÝ/ØÁ�EÚ��<× *Ì���,�`ÚÚ��GÝ����ÉÚ�á,�dÚ���A ��8��+×aÝiÚ�áÁ�ÅÛ�� !¤×�Û��E�¿Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞ ãW×`Ú�á ãWá,×��.á Ü<�a�IÞE���ÉþÉ���EØ ���N�E�Lá 3�4���¾Û Ý�Ú��dÚ�� 8ªæ ��áÁ�y�a×aÛ�×aÚ¿�E����Ay�\�E�7=����-èÁãWá,×��.áÉ�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�<Ý®Ú��/Ú�á,���`�N�EÝ�ÚBå !¤Ü��¾×�تÚ�ML%? ��� ��3 � � �ué�ê í ��L � �Lè��EÝ.Ý��°��×��dÚ��NÝ�ãW×`Ú�á �N�E�.á¶Ý�Ú��dÚ��ÅÚ�á,�ÊÛ�� !Á×aÛ��E�®Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×`Ú]Þ ãW×`Ú�áãWá,×��.áÅÜ<���NÞE����þ&���EØó�NØ,Ý��Á�.� 5 3+æ���Ý��EØ%��!Á�EÛ/Ü<�a�Eè�×aØÅÚ�á,�+à¾�EÛ/�K*-,�.0/21�3546.óã �iá,�IâE���:���8'9;:�</� M Ë�EØ,�è<�4�E�7=�� ¤è���A ��8'9;:�</�LM þ�� ��� A &�Ú�áÁ�&�a×�Û�×`Ú��a×aÛ A�F�H-þ�� ��� A M þ&×aÝ×aØ,�,���N�óÚ�á,�/Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞÅã�×`Ú�á ãWá,×a�Lá Ü<�a�NÞE����þ/���EØ �NØ,Ý��Á�������N�E�Lá,×aØÁà 8�> ? ADC��4���¾Û 8'9;:�<Eæ7G��ØÁ�EÚ��6Ú�á,�dÚ?Ú�áÁ�y���EÝ��6�4�E�?���N�E�.á<�dß<×a�a×`Ú]Þ�à¾�EÛ/�NÝ�×�Ý®×aØÊ�9�E�¸Ú?ã®�N���<ä¤ØÁ�Iã�ØÉ�\���¾Û ���a�EÝ.Ý�×a���E�à¾�EÛ/��Ú�á,���E��Þ �9Ý����Eè<�Eæ³àÁæ`èuú "�3yý��Zÿ �Læ�,��Iã ��âE���Nè�Ú�á,×aÝ?ð°�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE�+×aØjÚ�����Ü,�.��Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØÅ�E��Ú�áÁ��#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý6Þ°×a�N�a�,ÝyÝ��¾�a�,Ú�×`�¾Ø �\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝ6�\�E�&Ú�áÁ���¸�¾Û/Ü<�`��Ú��ËÝ���Ú��E� ��Ùf����à¾�,�a�d�+Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝú �,�6û-Áþ�ÿfæ�û��E�����SâE���Nè���âE�NØG�4�E�y���N�E�Lá,�dß<×a�a×aÚYÞ%à¾�EÛ��NÝ�èÚ�áÁ� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý��dÜ<Ü,���¾�E�.á �`�N�E�,ÝÚ��ÌÝ�×�Û/Ü<�`�����¸�E���.�N�¸Ú�ØÁ�NÝ�ÝW�d�.à¾�,Û/�NØjÚ�Ý��4�E�WÚ�áÁ�+Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾ØÉ�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�¤è<Ý�×�Ø,�¸��×`Ú�×aÝ?Ü#�¾Ý�Ý.×`ß<�`��Ú����!¤Ü<�`�¾×`ÚuÚ�áÁ� �¸�¾Û�Ü<�`�NÛ/�NØjÚ��dÚ�×`�¾Øi�E���#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ýu�EØ<�+Ú�áÁ�?�¸�¾Ø,Ø,�N�¸Ú�×`�¾Øiß���Ú]ã®���NØ+�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝ?�EØ,�ÅãW×�Ø,Ø,×aØÁà�Ý�Ú��.�dÚ���à¾×a�NÝW×aØÉÚ�áÁ�&�¸�¾Ø,Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú�×a�¾ØÉ�E��Ú�á,�+�d��à¾�,Û/�NØjÚ�Ý+ú �,�6û�Áþ¸ÿfæ

����� �6�����"!����!� ���2��������Q� ������ ���� ��������� ���

��áÁ� Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×a�ÅÝ���Ú�Ú�×aØÁà ×aÝÉð°�,�EتÚ�×aÚ��dÚ�×`âE� ãW×`Ú�á����NÝ�Ü#�N�¸ÚÉÚ�� Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�è?ß<�ÁÚÉØÁ�EÚÊãW×`Ú�á���NÝ�Ü#�N�¸Ú?Ú��/Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ>9<ãWá,×��`��Ý�Ú��dÚ���âZ�E���,�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý?�d����ð°�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE�Eè,�N�E�Lá�Ú��.�E�¸�&×aÝ?Ý�Ú�×a�a����âd�E�µÙ�,�dÚ��N� ×aØ �%ß��°�¾�`�N�EØ ã �IÞ�9u�N×`Ú�áÁ���&×aÚ+×aÝ+×�ØGÚ�áÁ�ÌÜ<���EÜ#����ÚYÞEèu�E�&×`Ú+×�Ý+ØÁ�EÚ�æ���á,×aÝyß#�°�¾�`�N�EØ��âd�E�a�,�dÚ�×`�¾ØG�E�BÚ��.�E�¸�NÝi�Á�°�NÝ�ØÁ�EÚ��NØ<�dß<�`���,ÝyÚ��óÝ�Ü#�N��×`�\Þ�#�áÁ�Iã ã®�N����$Å��Ý�Ü#�N��×`å<���dÚ�×a�¾Ø ×aÝÛ/��Ú�æ "Á�E�/×aØ,Ý�Ú��EØ<�¸�Eèu��Ú��L�E�¸�ÉÝ.�dÚ�×aÝ�å,�NÝ 5 3 �EÝ&�`�¾Ø,àó�EÝiÚ�áÁ�ËÝ���Ú>3 �E�?Ú��d��àE��Ú/Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�×aÝ���N�E�LáÁ�N�è#ØÁ�ÊÛÌ�dÚ�Ú����6á,�Iã �`�¾ØÁàÊ×`ÚWÚ��däE�NÝ6Ú��Ê���N�E�.á ×`Ú�9�ØÁ�ÊÜ,�.× #��+×�ÝWÜ<���E�¸�N�%�¾Øó���N�E�.á<×aØÁà3 Ý��j�¾Ø,���&Ú�á,�EØ �a�dÚ����Nè��EØ,� ��âE�NØ ×a� 3 ×aÝ+���N�E�.áÁ�N� ×aØ �óÛi�,�Lá �`�¾Ø,àE���&Ú�×aÛ��ÌÚ�á,�EØ Ú�áÁ����N�EÝ��¾Ø<�dß<�`���a×`�4����!°Ü#�N�¸Ú��EØ,�¸ÞG�E� Ú�áÁ�ÌÝ�Þ°Ý�Ú��NÛ�è�Ú�áÁ�/Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ Ø,��âE����Ú�áÁ�N�`�NÝ�Ý&áÁ�¾�a�,ÝNæ "<�Á��ÙÚ�áÁ���.Û��E���Eè,×`�u��Ü,���EÜ#����ÚYÞ �¾ë í�� ��ëEîBáÁ�¾�a��è°Ú�á,�yß��°�¾�`�N�EØÉ��âd�E�a�,�dÚ�×`�¾Ø��E�uÚ��.�E�¸�NÝ��Á�°�NÝ�ØÁ�EÚÜ,���Sâ°×��Á�Ë� ØÁ�EÚ�×`�¾Ø �E�WÜ<���EÜ#����ÚYÞ �dÜ,Ü<���>!Á×aÛ��dÚ�×`�¾Ø�æ "Á�E�/��!Á�EÛ/Ü<�a�EèuÚ�áÁ�ÉÝ��d�4��ÚYÞ Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ% 3 ×aÝ?â¤×`�¾�a�dÚ��N��×a����Ý�Ú��dÚ��+�¾�ÁÚ�Ý�×��Á�;3 ×aÝ?��âE�������N�E�.á,�N� 9�ØÁ�ÌÜ,�.× #��y×aÝ?Ü��a�E�¸�N�Å�¾Ø%Ý�Ú��NÞ¤×aØÁà×aØI3ñ�EÝ/�`�¾ØÁàG�EÝ�Ü#�¾Ý�Ý�×`ß��`�Eèu�EØ,� Ú�áÁ�ÉÜ,�.�EÜ����.ÚYÞ �9�E×a�aÝ&��âE�Nض×`�WÚ�áÁ�ÅÝ�Þ°Ý�Ú��NÛ Ý�Ú��NÞ¤Ý�×aØ 3�4�E�6�EØ ��!¤Ü#�N�¸Ú��N�óÚ�×�Û/�iÛi�,�Lá ���d��àE����Ú�á<�EØóÚ�á,�iÝ�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛ'&wÝ��SãWØ ��!°Ü#�N�¸Ú��N�G�a×`�4��Ú�×aÛ��Eæ���ÝÚ�áÁ�NÝ�����!¤�EÛ�Ü<�`�NÝ ×a�a�a�,Ý�Ú��.�dÚ��Eè¾Ú�áÁ��ß��°�¾�`�N�EØÌ��âZ�E�a�<�dÚ�×`�¾Ø��E��Ú��L�E�¸�NÝ ×�Ý¿Ý��NØ,Ý.×`Ú�×`âE��Ú����.á,�EØ,àE�NÝ×aØ ß#�Ná,�Iâ°×`�E�yÚ�á<�dÚ��°�����,�+�d��ß<×`Ú��L�d�.×a�`Þ%���dÚ���9�×aØ Ú��N�.á,Ø<×a���E��Ú����.ÛÌÝ�è ��Ùf����à¾�,�a�d�+Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ�d���+Ø,�EÚW�¸�¾ØªÚ�×�Øj�Á�¾�<ÝW×aØÉÚ�áÁ��òB�EتÚ��E��Ú��EÜ#�¾�`�EàEÞEè<ã�á,×a�.áÅ�EÝ.Ý�×`à¾Ø,Ý��<×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸� � � A Ú��ÌÚ��L�E�¸�NÝÚ�á,�dÚ��d���/×a�,�NتÚ�×a���E���ÁÜ Ú��ÉÜ#�¾Ý�×`Ú�×`�¾Ø =���þdè��EØ,� �,×)(����y�dÚ>=�æ0�6×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�G�¸�¾ØªÚ��.�¾���EØ,�âE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø Ü<���EÜ#�¾Ý��NÝ�Ú�� ���NÛ/�N�ÁÞ Ú�á,×�ÝÌÝ�×`Ú��<�dÚ�×`�¾Ø¶ß°Þ ã®�N×aà¾áªÚ�×aØ,à ��âE�NتÚ�ÝÉÚ�á<�dÚÌ�¤�����Á�

*

Page 5: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

×aØ Ú�áÁ�ÉØÁ�N�d�&�9�ÁÚ��Á�.�ËÛ/�E���ÉáÁ�N�Iâ°×a�aÞGÚ�á,�EØ ��âE�NتÚ�Ý�Ú�á,�dÚ��¤�����Á��×aØ Ú�á,�Ë�9�d��ÙY�NãB�NÞ �9�ÁÚ��Á���ú �,�2,�û��&Zÿfæ

�6×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ�×aØ,à �.�N�E�.á,�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞ �EØ,� Ý��d�4��ÚYÞ Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×a�NÝi×�Ý��N�EÝ�ÞEæ "Á�E���.�N�E�.á,�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞEè�ã ��EÝ�Ý�×aà¾Ø/Ú�áÁ�Wâd�E�a�Á��� A Ú��+Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ®Ú�á,�dÚ®���N�E�.áËÚ�áÁ��Ú��d��àE��ÚBÝ���Ú¿�d�4Ú���� =/Ý�Ú���Ü<Ý�èj�\�E����H ú ��NþJÿ &�4�E��Ý.�d�\��Ú]ÞEèEã®�?�EÝ�Ý�×aà¾Ø&Ú�á,�®âd�E�a�Á�6þ ��� A Ú��6Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ�Ú�á<�dÚ�Ý�Ú��NÞ&×�Ø+Ú�áÁ�?Ý��d�4�BÝ���Ú��E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��4�E�=/Ý�Ú���Ü�Ý�æ�"Á�E�BÛ/�E�����¸�¾Û/Ü<�`��!/Ú��NÛ/Ü#�E�.�E�µÙY�a�Eà¾×a�?Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×a�NÝ�è¾áÁ�Iã ��âE���Nè¤Û��EØjÞ��,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ�×aØÁàÝ��LáÁ�NÛ/�NÝÌ�d�.�ÅÜ��¾Ý.Ý�×`ß<�`�Eæ "Á�E�Ë��!¤�EÛ�Ü<�`�Eè�� ����,�.á<×?Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ % 5�� �¸�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ý/�E�y�E�a�BÚ�áÁ�Ú��.�E�¸�NÝÅÚ�á<�dÚÅâ°×aÝ.×`ÚÊ� Ý.�Áß<Ý���Ú�� �E�&Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝó×aØÁå<Ø,×aÚ��N�`Þ Û��EتÞ-Ú�×aÛ/�NÝ ú³ûóü®ý¤þ�ÿfæ 7G� ���EØ�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,ØªÚ Ú�áÁ�6Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ % 5�� ×�ØËÝ���âE���L�E�#ã �IÞ°Ý�9Á�¾ØÊÚ�áÁ�6ß<�EÝ.×aÝ¿�E�uÚ�áÁ�6Ú�×aÛ/�����Nð°�,×`���N�ËÚ�����N�E�Lá��Êè��E���¾Ø Ú�áÁ��ß<�EÝ�×�Ý6�E� Ú�á,�ÌØj�<Û+ß#���y�E�Bâ°×�Ý�×`Ú�Ý6Ú���Êè�E�+�¾Ø Ú�áÁ�/ß<�EÝ�×�Ýy�E�?Ý��¾Û/�Û/�E�����¸�¾Û/Ü<�`��!Ì�¸�L×`Ú����.×`�¾Ø �4�\�E�B×aØ,Ý�Ú��EØ,�¸�EèªÚ�áÁ��Ú�×aÛ/�����Nð°�,×`���N�/Ú��iâ¤×aÝ�×`Ú� ÚYãW×a�¸�/�Læ��6ØËÚ�áÁ��EÚ�áÁ����á,�EØ<�è<Ú�áÁ��Ü,�.�N�Á�N�¸�NÝ�Ý��E�6�EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�.Ý��E�¿Ú�á,� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�Ü,���Iâ¤×a�Á���ÉØ,�dÚ��Á�.�E���`�¤���,Ý�4�E�&�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ�×�ØÁàÉÚ�áÁ�ÌØÁ��!¤Ú�ÙYÝ�Ú���Ü �9�ÁÚ��Á�.�Eæ���×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý6����Ü<�a�E�¸�NÝ��ué�ê í ãW×`Ú�áÚYã �y�,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N�&âE���.Ý�×`�¾Ø<Ý�è�� �ué�ê í �EØ,� ��þ ��� �� �� �ué�ê í èZãWáÁ��������H ú ��NþJÿÁ×�Ýu���,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ�9�E�¸Ú��E�Næ���Ý�×aØ,àWÚ�áÁ�NÝ��®�EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�.Ý�èZã®� ���EØ+ãW�.×`Ú��¿Ú�á,�®Ý��¾�a�,Ú�×`�¾Ø�Ú����,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�&���N�E�.á,�dß�×a�a×`Ú]Þà¾�EÛ/�NÝ��EÝ������ :�� A����IM �ML�? ��� ��3 � � � �ué�ê í ��L �Lè<�EØ,�ÅÚ�áÁ��Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾ØÉÚ��Ì�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N��Ý��d�4��ÚYÞà¾�EÛ/�NÝ��EÝ���������A�) �B9;< M! L�? ��� ��3 � ����þ �����" #� �ué�ê í ��L � �Læ

7G�&Ü,���EÜ#�¾Ý���Ú��Ê�,Ý��+�,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý��EÝ�Ú�áÁ�i�¸�¾Û�Û/�¾Ø%ß<�EÝ�×aÝ?�4�E�WÚ�á,�&Ý�Ü#�N��×µÙå<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø�è,âE���.×`å<���dÚ�×a�¾Øè<�EØ,�ó�¸�¾ØªÚ����¾���E���,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N��Ü<���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ�æ 7G���Á��å<ØÁ�O�dø � ùLë�� �<î í �é�ê�ëLé í êJî9ø í�� �EÝ�Ú�áÁ�/öUø6� í õdê ��í¸ô õ���î9ø9ù � �E�u�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ?�E��Ú�áÁ�+�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý�æ ��áÁ����NÝ��<�`Ú�×aØÁàÅÝ���Ú�Ú�×aØ,à%×aÝ��¸�¾ØjÚ�×aØ°�Á�¾�,Ý+×�ØGÚ�áÁ�ÊòB�EØjÚ��E�iÚ��EÜ��¾�a�EàEÞEèu�EØ,�GÜ<���Iâ¤×a�Á�NÝ�Ø,�EÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý��E�Ý��dÚ�×aÝ��4�E�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø%ðj�,�E��×`ÚYÞÉ�EØ,���dÜ,Ü<���>!Á×aÛ��dÚ�×`�¾ØÉ�4�E�W�a×�ØÁ�N�d�?Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝNæ

���%$ & � �����������������%�('���*) �!� �����������,+ ��8�-' �/.0 ������ !�� ! �6×`âE�NØÉ�&�\�E�LÛ&�,���1�Å�E��Ú�áÁ�2�#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,ÝNèªã �6���EØÉ�EÝ�Ý��°��×a�dÚ��y�ÊöUø6� í õdê ��í�ô õ��<î9øcù � Ú��,�ÅßjÞ��âd�E�a�,�dÚ�×aØÁà�×aÚ�¾Ø��a×aØÁ�N�d�Ú��L�E�¸�NÝ�èS�EØ,��ßjÞ�Ú��dä°×�ØÁà?Ú�áÁ��âd�E�a�Á���¾ØyÚ�á,��å,�.Ý�Ú�Ý�Ú��dÚ��Eæ/��á,×�Ý�a×aØÁ�N�d�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý&×aÝy�E�4Ú��NØè�ß<�ÁÚ�Ø,�EÚ+�E�`ãB�NÞ¤Ý�è����N�a�dÚ��N� Ú���Ú�áÁ����âd�E�a�,�dÚ�×a�¾ØG�E�BÚ�áÁ���4�E�.Û&�<�a�É�¾ØÚ�áÁ�yà¾�EÛ/�EèÁã�á,×a�.áÊã �����E�a�#Ú�áÁ� ( ê�õ���ù$#ªø �j÷ ��í�ô õ��<î9øcù �32 ��Ý?�EØÅ��!¤�EÛ�Ü<�`�EèÁ×`��ã �y��âZ�E���,�dÚ��Ú�áÁ��å�!°Ü#�¾×aØjÚ4� :�� A����+M �ML%? ��3 / 1<é�ê í � 9 � ���¾Ø��yÚ��.�E�¸�F8�:�� 8 G � 8 J ��?�?�?aè¾ã ��á,�IâE�WÚ�á,�dÚL8�:FH� :�� A����Ê×`��Ú�áÁ������×aÝ = H65 Ý��,�Lá Ú�á,�dÚ�8�A�H 3+æ ,W�NØ<�¸�Eè�Ú�á,����×aØÁ�N�d�6Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý��E��� :�� A����¤è�Á�NØÁ�EÚ��N�"ú7� :�� A����Zÿ�839;:;<jè��¸�¾×aØ,��×��Á�NÝ�ãW×aÚ�á 5 3+èuçQØ Ú�á,×aÝ&���EÝ��Eè�ã®�Éá,�NâE�ÊÚ�á,�dÚiÚ�áÁ�Ì�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�� :�� A����¤è<��âd�E�a�,�dÚ��N�ó�¾Ø ��à¾�EÛ/�Eè�����Ú��Á�.Ø<Ý?��!¤�E�¸Ú��aÞ�Ú�áÁ�&Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��4���¾Û ãWá,×a�Lá�Ü<�a�IÞE���iþ&���EØ�NØ,Ý��,���Êú7� :�� A����Zÿ�839;:;<°æ �Wá,×aÝW�¸�¾Ø<ØÁ�N�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø �Á�°�NÝ�Ø,�EÚ�áÁ�¾�����4�E�6�E�����4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ�æ2"Á�E�y��!¤�EÛ�Ü<�`�Eè�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×��Á���yÚ�áÁ���4�E�.Ûi�,�a�>= M �ML%? ��1<é�ê í ��L � / @?�? ��3 0 1<é�ê í �A? � � �Læ�çQ� ã®����âd�E�a�,�dÚ��ÌÚ�á,×aÝ�4�E�.Û&�<�a���¾Ø �ÊÚ��.�E�¸� 8 : � 8�G � 8!J���?�?�?aè#ã �i���EØGÝ.áÁ�Iã Ú�á,�dÚ 8�A H� @?�? ��3 0 1<é�ê í �A? � ��× ( ã �á,�IâE��8CB H 3 �4�E�+�E�a�"D�� =�æ ,��NØ,�¸�Eè�ã �Ëá<�NâE��8�:�H#=�×)( Ú�áÁ���.�Ì×aÝ>= HE5 Ý��,�.á Ú�á,�dÚ8CB H@3¶�4�E���E���(D�� =09E×aØ&�EÚ�áÁ����ã �E�.�,Ý�èdÚ�áÁ�?�a×aØ,�N�d��Ý��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��Ý�ú =¿ÿ 839;:;< �¸�¾×aØ<��×a�Á�NÝuãW×`Ú�áiÚ�áÁ��¸�dÙ ����,�.á<×�Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ 5 % 3'ú �WáÁ�ªý�dÿfæ �6Ø Ú�á,���EÚ�áÁ���&á<�EØ,�è#Ú�áÁ���4�E�.Ûi�,�a�F��è���âZ�E���,�dÚ��N��¾Ø �%à¾�EÛ��Eè��,�j�NÝ ��ëEî&�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,� Ú��óÚ�á,�ÊÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��4���¾Û ãWá,×a�Lá Ü��a�NÞE���ÅþÊ���EØ �NØ<Ý��Á���5 % 3 �9Ý���� ' !Á�EÛ/Ü<�`��þ�×�Ø-�°�N�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø-&��Læ

ç�Ø Ú�áÁ��ß#�°�¾�`�N�EØ Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØ,àÁè�Ú�áÁ�%�a×�ØÁ�N�d���EØ,� ß,�L�EØ,�.á,×�ØÁàGÝ��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��ÝÌ�d���%���N�a�dÚ��N� �4�E��E�a� � î9ê�ë��j÷EöUï � í î í ê ô ø �,ø � î9øcùÌ�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝÊú �,�.,6û�Áþ��Eÿfèu�óÝ���Ú+�E�?�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ+Ú�á,�dÚ&×aØ<���a�,�Á�NÝÚ�áÁ�+Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾ØÊ�4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝ?�4�E��à¾�EÛ/�NÝ�ã�×`Ú�áÉ���NÝ�Ü#�N�¸Ú�Ú�� ��Ùf�.��à¾�,�a�d�?Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×a�NÝ�ú 'L�ªý¤þ�ÿfæ�7G�Ý�áÁ�Sã Ú�á<�dÚ�Ú�á,×aÝu�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,�NØ,�¸�®���d���L×`�NÝ�Ú�áÁ�.�¾�Áà¾á�Ú���Ú�áÁ�¿Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×aÝ�Ú�×a���EØ,�i�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�

Page 6: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØ,à¾Ý�æ<ç�Ø,�Á���N�è�×aØ�ß#�EÚ�á�Ú�á,�+Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×a�6�EØ,��Ú�áÁ�i�,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N� Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØÁà¾ÝNè<ã �&Ý�áÁ�SãÚ�á,�dÚ�Ú�á,�GâZ�E�a�,�NÝ��¸�¾Û/Ü<�ÁÚ��N� ßjÞ"Ý�Ú����¾ØÁà¾�aÞ-�Á��Ú����LÛ�×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×a�%�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ�×�ÝÉ�Nðj�,�E��Ú��¶Ú�áÁ�Û�� !Á×aÛ��E�#��!¤Ü#�N�¸Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø��E��Ú�áÁ�N×`����×aØÁ�N�d��Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý?Ú�á<�dÚ�Ü<�a�IÞE���&þ����EØÅ�NØ<Ý��Á���Eæ

ç�Ø�Ú�áÁ�i�,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N�óÝ���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàÁè�Ú�áÁ�&�a×�ØÁ�N�d�WÝ��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý��E���,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N�-�#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý�Ü,���dÙâ¤×a�Á�NÝBÚ�áÁ�+Ý�Ü��N��×aå<���dÚ�×`�¾ØÅ�a�EØÁà¾�<�dàE�Eè<�EØ,�ÅÚ�áÁ�yß<�.�EØ,�.á<×aØÁà/Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý�Ü<���Iâ¤×a�Á�NÝBÚ�áÁ�+âE���.×µÙå<���dÚ�×`�¾ØÊ�E�`àE�E�.×aÚ�á,Û�Ý�æ "Á�E�B��!¤�EÛ/Ü��`�EèªÚ�áÁ��âd�E�a�Á�W�E�Ú�á,���,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N���4�E�.Û&�<�a� ����� :�� A����+�¾ØÚ�áÁ��å<�.Ý�Ú�Ý�Ú��dÚ��®�E�,�?Ú��.�E�¸� 8 : � 8'G � 8 J ��?�?�?S×aÝ*� A èNãWáÁ���.� = M"Û�×aØ � D H�5 � 8 B H63��¾æ%,��NØ,�¸�EèÚ�áÁ���a×aØÁ�N�d�6Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý/ú7����� :�� A����Zÿ�839;:;<� �EÝ�Ý��°��×a�dÚ��NÝ6Ú�á,�&âd�E�a�Á�1� A Ú��ÉÚ��.�E�¸�NÝ6Ú�á<�dÚ��.�N�E�.á 3×aØ =ÌÝ�Ú���Ü<Ý�æ ��áÁ�WÝ.�EÛ/���4�E�.Ûi�,�a������� : � A � �°èj��âZ�E���,�dÚ��N�Ì�¾ØÊ��à¾�EÛ��EèjÞ¤×`�N�a�,Ý�Ú�áÁ��Û�� !Á×aÛi�,Ûâd�E�a�Á�?�E�¿ú7����� :�� A����Zÿ�839;:;<� Ú�á,�dÚ�Ü<���NÞE����þ����EØÌ�E�Lá,×`��âE�Eæ��¤×aÛ�×a���d�.�`ÞEèZÚ�áÁ��âd�E�a�Á�?�E�*��������A�) �B9;< �¾ØÚ�áÁ�&å,�.Ý�ÚWÝ�Ú��dÚ��&�E���ÌÚ��.�E�¸�78�:�� 8 G � 8 J ��?�?�?�×�Ý+þ � � A è<ã�áÁ����� =�M ÛÌ×aØ � D�H/5 � 8 B��H 3��¾æ,��NØ,�¸�Eè�Ú�áÁ�Å�a×aØÁ�N�d��Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý�ú7��������A�) � 9;< ÿ�839;:;<� �EÝ�Ý��¤��×a�dÚ��NÝ/Ú�á,�Êâd�E�a�Á� þ � � A Ú��GÚ��L�E�¸�NÝÚ�á,�dÚÌÝ�Ú��NÞ¶×aØ 3'�\�E�E= Ý�Ú���Ü<Ý�æ5��áÁ�%Ý��EÛ����\�E�LÛ&�,����� ����� A�) �B9 < è¿��âZ�E�a�<�dÚ��N�¶�¾Ø¶� à¾�EÛ/�EèÞ¤×`�N�a�,Ý Ú�áÁ��Û�� !Á×aÛi�,Û âZ�E���Á�6�E�Bú7��������A�) � 9;< ÿ 839;:;<� Ú�á,�dÚWÜ<�a�NÞE����þy���EØ%�E�.á,×`��âE�Eæ��Wà¾�E×aØ�èÁÚ�á,×aÝ�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü��¾Ø<�Á�NØ,�¸�6áÁ�¾�a�,Ý®�\�E�?��Ý���Ú?�E���4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ Ú�á,�dÚ?×aØ,�����,�Á�NÝ�Ú�á,�6Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾ØË�\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝ®�E�à¾�EÛ/�NÝWãW×`Ú�áÉÜ<�d�.×aÚYÞÉ�¸�¾Ø,�,×`Ú�×`�¾Ø<Ý�æ

����� ��! �������!������5� ��� !��� �� � �%�Q� ��� � � � ���� �

��áÁ�&�\�L�EÛ/��ã®�E�.ä°Ý��4�E��Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×aÝ�Ú�×a�y�EØ,� �,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�óâE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø �d���i�¸�¾Û�Ü<�`�NÛ/�NØjÚ��N�ß°Þ ð°�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE�Ì�Nð°�,×`âd�E�`�NØ,�¸�/�.�N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,ÝÌú ,2"+ý��°è�� �ªü®ýEý¤è³â � 7 Áþ¸ß�ÿfæ 7G�ÊÝ�áÁ�Iã Ú�á,�dÚ�è��,Ý�Ú®�EÝ?ò ��� �EØ,�Éò ������.á<�d�.�E�¸Ú����.× #��6�E�.�,×�Ø,�d��Þ�ß<×aÝ�×�Û&�,���dÚ�×`�¾Ø�ú³û%×���ý�Zÿfè°Ý��+Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×aÝ�ÙÚ�×a�/�EØ,�G�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ýy�.á,�d�.�E�¸Ú����L× #���Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×a�+�EØ,�G�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� ß<×aÝ�×�Û&�¤Ù�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø ú �,�.,6û��&Zÿfæ

1�ê í �dø9î �32 ��á,×aÝuÜ<�dÜ#����×aÝ�ß��EÝ��N�i�¾Ø���¾×aØjÚ�ã �E��ä+ã�×`Ú�á ��á,�¾Û��EÝ��+æ�,W�NØ�#N×aØÁàE�����EØ,���W�ÁÜ��däûó� ��,ÛÌ�,�d�+�¾Ø Ú�áÁ�Ì�¸�¾Ø,ØÁ�N�¸Ú�×a�¾Ø ß#��ÚYã ���NØ à¾�EÛ��NÝ�è �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�è��EØ,� �a×aØÁ�N�d�+Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝú �,�2,�û�Áþ��,èw�<��û�ÁþEèw�,�2,�û��&Zÿfæ�ç�ã �¾�,�a� �a×`äE�ÌÚ�� Ú�á,�EØÁä ûó�d�.�¸� ",�d�N�a���¤è ���ÁÜ<�dä ûó�ZÙ��,Û��,�d�NèZû%�d�.× ��N���`� �¤Ú��j�N�a×�ØÁà¾�¤èS�EØ,�i�EØi�EØÁ�¾ØªÞ¤Û/�¾�,Ý�����â¤×`��ã ���u�4�E�����N�E�,×aØ,àW�WÜ<���N�a×aÛ�×�Ø,�d��ÞâE���.Ý�×a�¾ØÅ�E�uÚ�á<×aÝ?ã �E��äÊ�EØ<�Å�\�E�WÜ,���Iâ¤×a�,×�ØÁàiÛÌ�EتÞÅáÁ�N�`Ü<�4�,���¸�¾Û�Û/�NØjÚ�Ý��EØ,�ÅÝ��ÁàEàE�NÝ�Ú�×a�¾Ø,Ý�æ

� �ÌÑ����]Ö��"ÖYÏ��#ѪÖ����

� ��� ��' �/.0 ��������!�� ! �

� ï��<îfõ�� 2 ����Ú�� ß#���GÝ���Ú��E�6Ü,�.�N�,×a���dÚ���Ý�Þ¤Û+ß#�¾�aÝNè! ß#��� Ý���ÚÌ�E��âd�d�.×a�dß<�a�NÝ�è��EØ,�#"ß#�Ë�óÝ���Ú&�E�?�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×a�¾Ø Ý�Þ¤Û+ß#�¾�aÝNæ ��áÁ�Ë�\�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ+�E� �#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý+�d���ËàE�NØÁ���.�dÚ��N� ß°ÞGÚ�áÁ�àE�.�EÛ�ÛÌ�d�

�-9 9 M%$ � L �'& � � �)(F� � �)*F� � � ��� � � �ML�? � � L%? � � ��þ%��4�E��Ü,���N�,×����dÚ��NÝ+$ H,�/èjâZ�d�.×��dß<�`�NÝ L�è¾�EØ<�/�4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý � H-"Åæ¾ç�Ø�Ú�áÁ��Ú]ã®�iðj�<�EتÚ�×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý�ML%? ���EØ,�� L%? ��è¤ã �����Nð°�,×`�.�WÚ�á,�dÚ?�E�a���¤�����Á�����NØ,�¸�NÝ �E�(Ló×aØ ��á,�NâE�y��âE�NØÉÜ#�¾�a�d�L×`ÚYÞEèjÚ�á,�dÚ×aÝ�èIÚ�áÁ��Þ6�°�����Á��×aØyÚ�áÁ� Ý��¸�EÜ#�¿�E�Á�EØ���âE�NØiØ°�,Û+ß#���u�E�¤Ø,��à¾�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý � & �Læ>7G�B�EÝ�Ý��,Û/�¿Ú�á,�dÚ��4�E��N�E�.á&�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø � H-" Ú�á,�����¿×aÝ ���,õdö¤�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾ØI���<�E�H�� �%H-"ÅèNãW×`Ú�á �6�,�E� � ���<�E� �� � � M ��æ

Page 7: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

6×`âE�NØ �Ê���`�¾Ý��N�ó�\�E�.Ûi�,�a� � �E�F�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�è,Ú�á,�+�4�¾�a�`�Iã�×aØÁà�Ú��.�EØ<Ý��\�E�LÛ��dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý��NØ,�dß<�`�i�,ÝÚ���Ü<�<Ý�áÅ�E�a�ØÁ��à¾�dÚ�×`�¾Ø<Ý�Ú���Ú�áÁ�yÜ<���N�,×a���dÚ��NÝ�9

& ����G (F�5J>� � � & ��G�� * � & ��J%� & � �ML%? � � � L%? & ��ú & L���L,ÿ �����& ��� G *F� J � � � & � G � ( � & � J � & � L%? � � � �ML%? & ��ú & L���L,ÿ � &��

& � ��� � � �6�,�E� �� ��� & �0� � ��* �

ãWáÁ���.� ��ú & L���L,ÿ<�Á�NØ,�EÚ��NÝ�Ú�áÁ�B�\�E�LÛ&�,����×�Ø&ã�á,×a�.á��E�a�°�4�����?�¤�����Á�����NØ,�¸�NÝ��E��LË�d���?�.��Ü<�a�E�¸�N�ß°Þ & Luæ07G�ÌãW×a�a�uß#�&Ü<�d�.Ú�×a���,�a�d�.�aÞ�×aتÚ����.�NÝ�Ú��N� ×aØ Ú�áÁ���E� �\�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ6×aØ����jì�¸ëEê ô,2 �WáÁ�NÝ���4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝ6Ú��däE�ÌÚ�áÁ�N×a��Ø,�EÛ/���4���¾Û Ú�áÁ�Ì�E�,Ú�áÁ�E�.Ýy�E�yú 'L�jý¤þ¸ÿfè�ãWáÁ���.��×aÚyã �EÝ&Ý�áÁ�Iã�Ø Ú�á,�dÚÚ�áÁ��Þ Ý�� *Ì�¸�i�\�E�yÝ��¾�aâ°×aØ,àËÚ��Á�LؤÙfß<�EÝ��N�óà¾�EÛ/�NÝ &��EÝ6ã ��ãW×a�a�uÝ����Eè#Ú�áÁ�NÝ����\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝ����EØ ß#��,Ø,×a�\�E�.ÛÌ�`Þ��,Ý��N�G�4�E�+Ý��¾�aâ°×aØ,àÊß#�°�¾�`�N�EØèÜ,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×�Ý�Ú�×a�dè��EØ<� �,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N� �¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�¿Ü,���EßÁÙ�`�NÛ�Ý�ãW×`Ú�á%���NÝ�Ü#�N�¸ÚWÚ��ÊÜ<�d�.×aÚYÞ��¸�¾Ø,�,×aÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý�æ2"Á�E� � H "Åè��Ë�4�E�.Û&�<�a�>� ×�Ý�×aØ���°ì���ëdê ô ×a�×`Ú����EØ%ß��6ã��L×`Ú�Ú��NØ��EÝ

�-9 9 M� �� L��? �� � G.L�� � G������� : L : ?����� :��� � *'� ��L � � � �

� 9 9 M#$ �'& � � �-( � � �-* �L�

ãWáÁ���.� �4�E� ������! �èBã � á,�NâE� L � H �è?�EØ,�"ã�áÁ����� � H " �EØ,� $ H �/æ ",�E�"�#�$�% �è�Ú�áÁ�Åå�!°Ü#�¾×aØjÚið°�,�EØjÚ�×`å,���& � ×aÝ, ×`�'�+×aÝ���âE�NØè��EØ<�¶×aÝ+� ×`�(�+×�Ý��°�,��æ��å !¤Ü#�¾×aتÚ?�4�E�.Ûi�,�a� �G×aÝW×aØ � î9ê�ë��j÷EöUï � í î í ê ô ø �,ø � î9øcù���ëdê ô ú �,�2,6û-Áþ��¾ÿ�× ( � �¸�¾Ø,Ý.×aÝ�Ú�Ý��E��ÌÝ�Ú��.×aØÁà/�E��å !¤Ü#�¾×aØjÚ�ðj�,�EØjÚ�×`å,���LÝ��4�¾�a�`�Iã �N��ß°ÞÅ�Ìð°�,�EØjÚ�×`å,����Ùf�4������Ü<�d�.Ú�="àE�NØÁ���.�dÚ��N�óßjÞÚ�áÁ���4�¾�a�`�SãW×aØÁàiàE�.�EÛ�ÛÌ�d�>9

= 9 9 M $ ��& $ � = ( = � $)* = ��& $ *>= � � ��� � �� 9 9 M L � �,( � ?

� í�ô õ��<î9ø9ù �32 �WáÁ�&Ý��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��Ý��E�F�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�×aÝ��Á��å<ØÁ�N�ó×aØ�Ú����LÛ�ÝW�E�����dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�NÝ�æ#� öµõEîcî9øcù í) M �+*O�-,.� �¸�¾Ø,Ý�×�Ý�Ú�ÝB�E����Ý���Ú(* �E�u�N�a�NÛ/�NتÚ�Ý?�EØ<�É�E����Ü<�d�.Ú�×a�E���E�.�Á���.,"�IâE���'*�è,Ý��,�LáÚ�á,�dÚ?��âE����ÞÊÜ<�E×`�?�E�u�N�`�NÛ/�NØjÚ�Ý�/ G ��/ J H0* á,�EÝ����,Ø<×aðj�,��àE���N�dÚ��NÝ�ÚW�`�Iã ����ß#�¾�,Ø,�1/ G �2/ J�EØ,�&�`�N�EÝ�Ú��ÁÜ,Ü#����ß#�¾�,Ø,�3/ G � / J æZ� �a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�B×aÝ®ùLë ô é�ö í î í ×a�°��âE���.Þ �9ØÁ�EÚ�ØÁ�N�¸�NÝ�Ý��d�.×��`Þ6å<Ø,×`Ú��/�ØÁ�¾Ø¤Ùf�NÛ�Ü,ÚYÞ Ý��Áß<Ý���Ú��E�4* á,�EÝy�ÊàE���N�dÚ��NÝ�Ú+�`�Sã®���yß#�¾�,Ø<�ó�EØ,� �É�`�N�EÝ�Ú��,Ü,Ü#���Wß#�¾�,Ø,� ×aØ*�æ®� �dõdö � í ö`õEîcî9øcù í ×aÝ�� �¸�¾Û/Ü<�`��Ú��%���dÚ�Ú�×a�¸��Ú��EàE��Ú�áÁ���ÊãW×`Ú�á � � í ÷ªõ¾î9ø9ë�� �EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�65ièÝ��dÚ�×aÝ��\Þ¤×aØÁà05357/ M8/��4�E���E�a�9/ H:*�è�EØ,��5 �;*=< M?> � 57/ � / H@*=< ���4�E�y�E�a�A*.<CBD*ú ���¾ÝLý�Áè,�.á,�dÜ<Ú����.�Sÿfæ<� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ý6ø �<î í êYé�ê í îfõEî9øcë�� �E) �Iú ú�³ÿ ÿ �6�¸�¾Ø<Ý�×aÝ�Ú�ÝB�E����âZ�E���Á�y�a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�) M �+*O�-,.���EØ,� �E�y�EØ�×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø ú ú� ÿ ÿ�Ú�á<�dÚÌÛ��dÜ<Ý/��âE���.Þ Ü,���N�,×a���dÚ��)$NH � Ú��� �a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�Ì�N�a�NÛ/�NتÚÅú ú $,ÿ ÿ7HF*�è��EØ,� Ú�á,�dÚ�Û��dÜ<Ý&��âE����Þ �9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø � H " Ú�� �%�4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Øú ú ��ÿ ÿ H �+*HG�I*+�Læ 7G�6���Nð°�,×`����Ú�á,�dÚB�\�E�?�E�a� � H-" �EØ,�Ê�E�a��/�H0*Ìè°ã �yá,�NâE�=5/ú ú ��ÿ ÿB�J/ � Mú ú �6�,�E� �� �Yÿ ÿB�K5L/ �Læ�� �dõdêJø9õ ( ö íÊí ���Iø4ê�ë�� ô�í �<îW×�Ý��Ì�4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾ØNM 9� OG�P* Ú�á,�dÚ��EÝ.Ý��°��×��dÚ��NÝ� �a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�É�N�`�NÛ/�NØjÚ2M ��L ��HO* Ú�� �N�E�.á âd�d�.×a�dß<�a�8L H �æ "Á�E�4L H �è9/ H�*�è��EØ,� �âd�d�.×a�dß<�`���Nتâ¤×`���¾Ø<Û/�NتÚ(M¾è°ã �y�Á�NØÁ�EÚ��6ß°Þ1Mªú L�9 M�/ªÿ#Ú�á,��âd�d�.×a�dß��`�W�NØjâ°×a���¾Ø,Û/�NØjÚ �,��å<ØÁ�N�ß°ÞQMªú L 9 M8/¾ÿ ��L � MD/�è��EØ<�NMjú L 9 MD/¾ÿ �A?�� M8M �A?��W�\�E�7L �M ?�æ y×`âE�NØ �EØ ×�تÚ�����Ü<����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØR M �E) �Iú úS� ÿ ÿ �Jè��EØ,� �Ëâd�d�.×a�dß��`�+�NØjâ°×a���¾Ø,Û/�NØjÚ.MEè#��âE����Þ-�#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ý��\�E�LÛ&�,��� � Ý�Ü#�N��×`å,�NÝ

Page 8: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

�/�a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�y�N�a�NÛ/�NتÚ+ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ�� ��H0*�è,�,��å<ØÁ�N�É×aØ,�,�<�¸Ú�×`âE�N�`Þ��EÝ?�4�¾�a�`�SãWÝ�è¤�\�E� $ H,�/è � H-"Åè,�EØ,�L H .9

ú ú $,ÿ ÿ � � M ú ú $,ÿ ÿ ú ú7��G (F�5JLÿ ÿ � �KM ú ú7��G�ÿ ÿ � � � ú ú7�5JJÿ ÿ � �ú ú & $Áÿ ÿ � � M 5�ú ú $,ÿ ÿ � � ú ú7� G *F� J ÿ ÿ � �KM ú ú7� G ÿ ÿ � � � ú ú7� J ÿ ÿ � �ú ú L,ÿ ÿ � � MOM ��L � ú ú �ML%? �,ÿ ÿ � � M � � /�H0* � /KM ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ � ��� ��� ��� �

ú ú � ��� �Yÿ ÿ � � M ú ú ��ÿ ÿB��ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ � ��� ú ú; L%? �,ÿ ÿ � �KM � � /�H0* � /KM ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ � ��� ��� ��� ��?���a�Á�.×`à¾ájÚ�ÙYá,�EØ,�ÁÙYÝ�×a�Á� �9Ý��NÛ��EتÚ�×��%���EÜ#���.�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý �d����Ü����.�\�E�.Û��N�/�IâE���BÚ�áÁ��âZ�E���Á�W�a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸� )�æçQÚi×aÝ&�N�EÝ�Þ Ú�� Ý.áÁ�Iã Ú�á,�dÚ�×`� � � � < ß°Þ ����� �0��* �Lè�Ú�á,�NØ"ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ�� ��M ú ú7� < ÿ ÿ�� �<æ�� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�4�E�.Û&�<�a� � ×aÝËù�ö`ë ��í � ×a� �E�a�®×`Ú�Ý�âd�d�.×a�dß��`�NÝ��d���Ëß��¾�<Ø,�Gß°Þ �¾Ø,�Ì�E�?Ú�áÁ� � �E� å !¤Ü��¾×�تÚð°�,�EتÚ�×aå,���.Ý�ædçQ� �Ê×aÝ����a�¾Ý��N�èEÚ�áÁ�NØ/Ú�á,��âZ�E���Á�+ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ � � �Á�°�NÝ�ØÁ�EÚ®�Á��Ü#�NØ,�i�¾Ø MEèª�EØ<�/ã®�Wã��.×`Ú��Ý�×aÛ�Ü<�`Þóú ú7�,ÿ ÿ � æ

� ��� ������� ����� !�� � !�� � �7G� �Á��âE�N�`�EÜ"Ú�áÁ�%Ú�á,���E��Þ¶�4�E�ÊÝ�Ú��¤�.á<�EÝ�Ú�×a�óà¾�EÛ/� Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á���NÝNæL"Á�E�Å� å<Ø,×`Ú��%Ý���Ú��&è®ã ��Á�NØÁ�EÚ��óßjÞ �6×aÝ�Ú��%���4��Ú�á,�%Ý���ÚÌ�E�6Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×aÚYÞ �<×aÝ�Ú��.×`ß��ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý&�IâE�����+æ � �4ÚYã �dÙfÜ<�a�NÞE���Ý�Ú��¤�.á,�EÝ�Ú�×a�%� ÷ªõ ôÌí2� î9ê��,ùIî �°ê í�� M�� � ��� ��� G ����J �����¿�¸�¾Ø<Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ý®�E��Ú�áÁ���\�¾���`�IãW×�ØÁà+�¸�¾Û/Ü#�dÙØÁ�NØjÚ�Ý+ú �2,."1��,èw�,�2,."+ý�$SÿH9

� ��å<Ø,×aÚ��6Ý���Ú�� �E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�æ� ��å<Ø,×aÚ��6Ý���Ú�� �E��Û��IâE�NÝ�æ� �?ã �óÛ��IâE�É�EÝ�Ý�×`à¾Ø,Û��NتÚ�Ý�� G ��� J 9�� G� �! #"�$°æ "Á�E� �IH � þ � ���¾è�Ú�áÁ�Ë�EÝ.Ý�×`à¾Ø,Û/�NØjÚ� � �EÝ�Ý��°��×a�dÚ��NÝ+ãW×`Ú�á �N�E�Lá Ý�Ú��dÚ���8 H%�"Ú�á,�ÌØÁ�¾ØÁ�NÛ/Ü<ÚYÞ Ý���Ú&� � ��8 �&B'� �E�?Û/�SâE�NÝ�IâZ�E×a���dß<�`�yÚ���Ü<���NÞE���(� �dÚWÝ�Ú��dÚ��+8ªæ

� � Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×�Ý�Ú�×a�ËÚ��.�EØ,Ý�×`Ú�×a�¾Ø �4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø(� 9)�+*,� J G� �6×aÝ�Ú��%� �F�Lè®Ú�á<�dÚÌà¾×`âE�NÝËÚ�áÁ�Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×aÚYÞ�� ��8���- G ��- J ���/. ���E���+Ú��.�EØ,Ý�×aÚ�×`�¾Ø��\�.�¾Û 8�Ú���.�ãWáÁ�NØ�Ü<�a�IÞE����þ?Ü��a�NÞ¤Ý�Û/�SâE�- G �EØ,�ÅÜ<���NÞE���R��Ü��a�NÞ¤Ý�Û/�SâE��- J æ

�BÚ���âE����ÞiÝ�Ú��dÚ��-8IH0� èdÜ<�a�NÞE����þB�LáÁ�j�¾Ý��NÝ��6Û/�IâE�1- G H2� G ��8��Lè¾�EØ,��Ý�×aÛi�,�`Ú��EØÁ���¾�,Ý.�`Þ��EØ,�×aØ,�,��Ü��NØ<�Á�NتÚ��aÞWÜ<�a�IÞE��� �W�.áÁ�°�¾Ý��NÝ��WÛ��IâE�3- J H2� J ��8��Læ/�WáÁ�¿à¾�EÛ/�®Ú�áÁ�NØ&Ü,���¤�¸���N�,Ý�Ú���Ú�áÁ�Ý��,���¸�NÝ.Ý��E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��4.%H5� ãW×`Ú�áÊÜ,���Eß��dß<×a�a×`Ú]Þ6� ��8Q��- G ��- J ���/. �Læ 7G���Á�NØÁ�EÚ��6ß°Þ87 ��8Q��- G ��- J � M� .RH9� � � ��8���- G ��- J ���/. �;: ��Ú�áÁ�iÝ���Ú��E�-� í�� î9ø ��õEî9øcë�� � îfõEî í�� ãWá,�NØ%�E�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý<- G ��- J �d����.á,�¾Ý��Nض�dÚ 8ªæ�çQØ àE�NØÁ���L�E�cè�Ú�áÁ�ÅÜ<�a�IÞE���.Ý/���EØ �.�EØ<�Á�¾Û�× #��ÉÚ�áÁ�N×`���LáÁ�¾×a�¸�Å�E�6Û/�IâE�NÝË�dÚÌ�Ý�Ú��dÚ��Eæ 7G���Á�NØ,�EÚ���ß°Þ6= � ��8 ��B �6×aÝ�Ú��%��� �®Ú�áÁ�6Ý���ÚB�E�uÛ/�SâE���,×aÝ�Ú��.×aß<�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý��IâZ�E×��a�dß<�`��Ú��Ü<�a�IÞE���(�LH � þ � ���i�dÚR8 H5� è<�,��å<ØÁ�N�Éß°Þ

= � ��8�� M �!> H �6×aÝ�Ú��/��� � ��> ��- �3: %ø ô é�ö ø í�� -�H2� � ��8 � ��?"Á�E�K8 H?� �EØ,� > G H@=7G/��8��Lè > J�H@=�J���8 �Lè�ã®�Ê�Á�NØÁ�EÚ���ß°ÞBA� ��8Q� > G � > J>�6Ú�áÁ�ËØÁ��!°Ú�ÙYÝ�Ú��dÚ��Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×`Ú]ÞÌ�,×aÝ�Ú��.×`ß<�ÁÚ�×a�¾Øèj�Á��å�ØÁ�N�É�\�E���E�a�C. H0� ß°Þ

A� ��8Q� > G � > J ���/. � M DE SGFIHQSKJMLON

DEQP FIH P JMLON

� ��8���- G ��- J ���/. � > G ��- G � > J ��- J �-?

$

Page 9: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

� �4�.�EØ,�,�¾Û�× #��N��� � î9ê�õEî í ÷¾ï�� � �4�E�uÜ��a�NÞE���9� H � þ � ����×aÝ��WÛ��dÜ<Ü<×aØÁà�� � 9 � B G� �6×aÝ�Ú��%��� �Ú�á,�dÚ��EÝ�Ý��°��×a�dÚ��NÝBã�×`Ú�áÊ��âE����ÞÊÝ��Nðj�Á�NØ<�¸���E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ 8 H5� B Ú�áÁ�yÛ/�IâE���<×aÝ�Ú��.×`ß��ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø�� � � 8���,Ý��N�Ëß°Þ�Ü<�a�IÞE��� ��ãWá,�NØÌÚ�áÁ��Ü<�EÝ�ÚBá,×aÝ�Ú��E��Þ/�E��Ú�áÁ��à¾�EÛ/�y×aÝ 8�&°ã®�����Nð°�,×`����Ú�á,�dÚ�� � � 8 8�� H= � ��8 ���\�E�6�E�a� 8KH ���+�EØ,� 8 H � æ�7G��×aØ,�<×a���dÚ��+ãW×aÚ�á�� � Ú�á,�&Ý���Ú��E�¿�E�a��Ý�Ú��.�dÚ���à¾×`�NÝ��4�E�Ü<�a�IÞE���(�LH � þ � ���¾æ

6×aâE�NØ �EØ ×aØ,×aÚ�×a�E��Ý�Ú��dÚ�� 8 H � �EØ<� Ú]ã®�GÝ�Ú��.�dÚ���à¾×a�NÝ� G H� G �EØ,��� J H�� J èuã ��Á��å<Ø,�+Ú�áÁ��Ý���Ú� �¤îfùLë ôÌí�� ��8Q���0G ���5J%�7BB��� Ú��É�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×�Ý�Ú��E�®�E�a��Ú�á,�iÝ��Nð°�Á�NØ,�¸�NÝ��E�¿Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ8�: � 8 G � 8 J ��?�?�?�Ý��,�.á Ú�á,�dÚ 8�: M 8 �EØ,� Ý��,�Lá Ú�á,�dÚÅ�4�E�%�E�a��= � Ú�áÁ���.� �d��� Û/�SâE�NÝ- A G ��- AJ H0� Ý��,�Lá%Ú�á,�dÚ�� G ��8�:���?�?�?!� 8�A ����- A G ��: ¤è�� J ��8�: ��?�?�? � 8�A�����- AJ ��: ¤è#�EØ,� 8�A�B G H7 ��8�AQ��- A G ��- AJ �Læ�6×`âE�NØË��Ú��.�E�¸��� M 8�: � 8 G � 8 J ��?�?�?5H5� � èjã®���Á�NØÁ�EÚ���ßjÞ���A�×aÚ�Ý =jÙfÚ�áÊÝ�Ú��dÚ��8�A¾æ

��Ø ×aØ,×`Ú�×��E�®Ý�Ú��dÚ�� 8�H ���EØ,� ÚYã � Ý�Ú��.�dÚ���à¾×a�NÝ��0G H���G��EØ,����J H��OJÊ�<Ø,×að°�Á�N�`Þ�Á��Ú����.ÛÌ×aØÁ�G�¶Ý�Ú��¤�.á,�EÝ�Ú�×a�GÜ,���¤�¸�NÝ�Ý � � � ���K��ü���� S�� � PL �Êã�áÁ������� B � �"!"×�ÝÉÚ�áÁ� Ý���Ú��E�Û/�N�EÝ��,�.�dß<�`�ÅÝ���Ú�Ý�è��EØ<� ãWáÁ�����Åü��#� S � � PL 9���G� ú ��NþJÿ��EÝ.Ý�×`à¾Ø,Ý/� Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×aÚYÞGÚ�� �N�E�LáÛ/�N�EÝ��,�.�dß<�`��Ý���Ú�ú " � " ���°è"�3yý��Sÿfæ<ç�ØÅÜ<�d�.Ú�×a���,�a�d�NèÁ�4�E���ÌÛ/�N�EÝ��Á�.�dß��`��Ý���ÚW�E��Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ�� H�/è¿ã � �Á�NØÁ�EÚ�� ßjÞ¶ü¿��� S � � PL ��� ��Ú�áÁ� Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞ Ú�á,�dÚÊÚ�áÁ�%à¾�EÛ��ó�4�¾�a�`�SãWÝË� Ú��.�E�¸� ×aØ�&è��EØ,� à¾×`âE�NØ � Û/�N�EÝ��Á�.�dß��`�Ì�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø � 9 � � G� ç ��è�ã �Ê�Á�NØ,�EÚ��Ëß°Þ '$� S�� � PL �� ��Ú�áÁ���!¤Ü��N�¸Ú��dÚ�×a�¾Ø��E��� ×aØ � ��� ���K��ü¿��� S%� � PL �Læ

7G�y�Á�NØÁ�EÚ���ß°Þ��'&�è �(&#è � &G è � &J è°�EØ<���)&ÌÚ�áÁ��×�Ø,�,×`â¤×a�,�,�E�¤�¸�¾Û/Ü#�¾ØÁ�NØjÚ�Ý �E���&à¾�EÛ/�Ý�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á��� � æ� é í ù�øcõdö�ù�ö`õ �B�Ní�� ë �i÷jõ ôÌí8� î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í��32 �u�.�EØ,Ý�×aÚ�×`�¾Ø Ý�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛ�Ý�è�Ú��Á�.ØÁÙfß<�EÝ��N� à¾�EÛ/�NÝ�è��EØ,�ûó�d��äE�Iâ"�Á�N��×aÝ�×a�¾Ø Ü,�.�°�¸�NÝ�Ý��NÝÊ�d�.� Ý�Ü��N��×��E�����EÝ��NÝ��E�&�Á��Ú����.ÛÌ×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×��Åà¾�EÛ/�GÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,���NÝ�æ� à¾�EÛ/� Ý�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á��� � ×aÝ � í î í ê ô ø6�<ø � î9ø9ùG×a���4�E�É�E�a��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�8Q�G. H � & �EØ<���E�a��Û/�SâE�NÝ- G ��- J H � & ã ��á,�NâE��� & ��8Q��- G ��- J ���/. �%H � ��Nþ��¾æ0��áÁ�yÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,��� � ×�Ý�î �¤ê��,ì ( õ �Ní ��×a���dÚ��âE����Þ�Ý�Ú��dÚ����dÚ�Û/�¾Ý�Ú��¾ØÁ�BÜ<���NÞE�������EØ��LáÁ�j�¾Ý����EÛ/�¾ØÁàyÛ&�<�`Ú�×`Ü<�`� Û/�IâE�NÝ &¾Ú�á,�dÚ�×aÝ�èd×`�,�4�E���E�a�Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ 8IH0� & èNÚ�áÁ��������!Á×aÝ�Ú�Ýu�dÚ�Û/�¾Ý�Ú��¾ØÁ�C�LH � þ � ���®ãW×`Ú�á � � &� ��8�� � : þdæ ��áÁ��Ú��Á�.ØÁÙfß<�EÝ��N��Á��Ú����.ÛÌ×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×���à¾�EÛ/��Ý�Ú��L�,�¸Ú��Á���NÝ6�¸�¾×aØ,��×��Á�&ã�×`Ú�á Ú�áÁ��à¾�EÛ/�NÝy�E��ú �B���Eý¤è ò �¾Ø<ý'�¤è�WáÁ�ªý' Zÿfæ"Á�E�C� H � þ � ���¾è¾Ú�áÁ��Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á��� � ×aÝ�é�ö`õdï í êJìE��×`�<�dÚ���âE���.ÞiÝ�Ú��dÚ��?�¾Ø<�`Þ+Ü<���NÞE���C�����EØ��LáÁ�°�¾Ý���EÛ/�¾ØÁà Û&�,�aÚ�×`Ü<�`�ÊÛ/�IâE�NÝ &®Ú�á,�dÚÌ×aÝNè�×a� � � &* � � ��8�� � M þÉ�4�E�Ì�E�a�?Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ 8 H'�Bæ�ü¿�a�IÞE����Ù.þ�EØ,� Ü<�a�IÞE����ÙB�ÊÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,���NÝ+�9���E���`�N� �¸�¾�a�`�N�¸Ú�×`âE�N�`Þ ë�� í ì�é�ö`õdï í êÊÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á�.�NÝ����¸�¾×�Ø,��×a�Á�&ãW×`Ú�áûó�d��äE�Iâ �Á�N��×aÝ�×a�¾Ø Ü,���¤�¸�NÝ�Ý��NÝÅú �����)� ¾ÿfæ���á,�ËÜ<���NÞE����ÙK���Á��Ú����LÛ�×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×a�/à¾�EÛ/�ÅÝ�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á���NÝ�¸�¾×aØ,��×��Á��ãW×`Ú�áóÚ��.�EØ,Ý.×`Ú�×`�¾Ø%Ý�Þ°Ý�Ú��NÛÌÝ�9�×aØ%��âE����Þ%Ý�Ú��dÚ��Eè#�N�E�LáG�Nâd�E×a�a�dß<�`�iÛ/�IâE���E��Ü<���NÞE���L��Á��Ú����.ÛÌ×aØÁ�NÝ?���,Ø<×aðj�,�6Ý.�,���¸�NÝ�Ý��E�WÝ�Ú��dÚ��Eæ

+ ,ÉÒ�Ò ��� �Ï.- �,ѪÖ0/ Õ ��оÖfÒ�Ï �Ï¿Ó21ËÒuÏ�ÐEÑ¾Ò �

6×`âE�NØ �Ëà¾�EÛ/�/Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á�.� � M � � ��� ��� G ��� J �����Lè#�óöUø6� í õdê�é�ê�ëLé í ê¸î9ï%�E� � ×aÝ��ËÝ.�Áß<Ý���Ú3FB?� � �E��×aÚ�Ý�Ý�Ú��dÚ��&Ý��Nðj�Á�NØ<�¸�NÝ�æ56×`âE�NØó�/�a×aØÁ�N�d�?Ü,�.�EÜ����.ÚYÞ43FB?� � è,ã �+�`��Ú

��þ � 8 & 3 M � 8 H5� �65 � G H7� G ? 8�� J H9� J ?0 �Áîfù.ë ôÌí�� ��8Q��� G ��� J ��B�3 � �� ����� � 8 & 3 M � 8 H5� �65 ��JFH7� J�? 8���G H9��G�?0 �Áîfù.ë ôÌí�� ��8Q���0G ���5J>��B�3 ��? � ���

��áÁ��Ý���Ú���þ � 8 & 3 ×aÝBÚ�á,�+Ý���Ú��E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��\���¾ÛñãWá,×a�LáÉÜ<�a�NÞE���&þ����EØ��NØ,Ý.�Á���6Ú�á,�dÚ�Ú�áÁ�+à¾�EÛ/��¾�ÁÚ��¸�¾Û/�G×aÝË×aØ:3-&¿Ú�áÁ� Ý���Ú0��� � 8 & 3 ×aÝËÚ�áÁ� Ý�Þ°ÛÌÛ/��Ú��.×a���E�a�aÞ �,��å<ØÁ�N� Ý���ÚË�4�E�ËÜ��a�NÞE��� �°æ

ý

Page 10: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

7G�Å�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×a�,���&Ú�áÁ�É�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾� Ü,���Eß<�`�NÛÌÝ��E�W�¸�¾Û/Ü��ÁÚ�×aØÁàóÚ�áÁ�ÊÝ���Ú�Ý �� ��&�EØ,� � ���Læ 7G�ÅØÁ�EÚ��Ú�á,�dÚ/�4�E��Ü<�a�NÞE����Ù.þÅ�Á��Ú����.Û�×aØ<×aÝ�Ú�×a�Ìà¾�EÛ/��Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,���NÝ�è��¸�¾Û/Ü<�ÁÚ�×aØ,à �� ��i�¸�E�.���NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,Ý&Ú��Ý��¾�`â¤×aØÁà Ú�áÁ� í �Eø � î í �<î9ø9õEö&âE���.×aå<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø Ü,�.�Eß<�`�NÛ #�×aÝÉÚ�áÁ����� � Ú��.�E�¸� ×aØ�3�� $¤è��EØ,�"�4�E�Ü<�a�IÞE����ÙB� à¾�EÛ/� Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,���NÝÅ�¸�¾Û/Ü<�ÁÚ�×�ØÁà �� ��Å�¸�E���.�NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,ÝÉÚ�� Ý��¾�aâ°×aØ,à Ú�á,� � �<ø6� í ê � õdöâE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾ØÌÜ<���Eß<�`�NÛ�#��d�.���E�a�<Ú��.�E�¸�NÝB×aØ�3�� $¤æ 7G���.��â°×`��ã�Ú�áÁ�Wã �N�a�µÙfä¤ØÁ�SãWØÌÝ��¾���ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø��E�Ú�áÁ�NÝ����¸�¾ØªÚ��.�¾�,Ü,���Eß��`�NÛ�Ý��4�E�¿Ú�áÁ�����EÝ���×aØ�ãWá,×a�Lá3 ×aÝ¿�y���N�E�.á<�dß<×a�a×`Ú]Þ�Ü,���EÜ#����ÚYÞEèj�+Ý��d�4��ÚYÞÜ,���EÜ#����Ú]ÞEèE�EØ,�/�6Ü<�d�.×`Ú]Þ+Ü,�.�EÜ����.ÚYÞEæ�"Á�E�¿�yÝ.�Áß<Ý���Ú�3DB?�ó�E�#Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�èªÚ�áÁ� � õ � í î9ïiÜ,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ% 3 M � 8�: � 8 G � 8 J ��?�?�?2H5� � � 8M=�? 8�A H@3��?�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ýu�E�,�E�a�jÚ��.�E�¸�NÝ�Ú�á,�dÚ�Ý�Ú��NÞi�E�`ã �IÞ°Ý�×aØ�3+è�EØ,�%Ú�áÁ�Ëê í õªù$#°õ ( ø\öUø9î9ï�Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ�5;3 M � 8�: � 8 G � 8 J ��?�?�?0H � � � 5 =�? 8�A H�3I�i�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×�Ý�Ú�ÝW�E��E�a�¤Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ¿Ú�á,�dÚ¿�¸�¾ØjÚ��E×aØ���Ý�Ú��dÚ��W×aØ 3+æjò �¾Ø<Ý�×a�Á�����EØjÞ&Ú��ÁÜ��`��� M ��3 G � 3 J ��?�?�?!� 3��<��Ý��,�LáÚ�á,�dÚ;3 G � 3 J ��?�?�? � 3�� �4�E�.Û �ÉÜ<�d��Ú�×aÚ�×`�¾Ø �E�3�-×aØjÚ��� : ÅÛi�ÁÚ��,�E�a�aÞ��,×aÝ ��¾×aØjÚ�Ý��Áß�Ý���Ú�Ý�æ6×`âE�NØ � Ú��.�E�¸� � M 8 : � 8�G � 8!J���?�?�?KH ����èBã®�G�Á�NØÁ�EÚ��Gß°Þ���5� í � � � ��� �ËÚ�á,� ���d��àE�NÝ�Ú�OH � þ ��?�?�? ��� �%Ý��,�.á Ú�á,�dÚO8�A H 3 � �4�E��×aØÁå�Ø,×`Ú��N�`Þ Û��EØjÞ = H 5?æ ��áÁ�NØ�èuÚ�áÁ�Ëé¤õEêLø9î9ïÜ,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ� �õdêJø4î9ï ��� �y×aÝi�Á��å<ØÁ�N� �EÝ� WõdêJø4î9ï ��� �IM � � H ��� � ��5� í ��� � ��� �B×aÝ���âE�NØ �¾æ��áÁ�����N�`��âd�EØ,�¸���E��Ü<�d�L×`ÚYÞ�Ü<���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ¿×�Ý �<�Á��Ú���Ú�áÁ���9�E�¸Ú Ú�á<�dÚB�EØjÞ)��Ùf�.��à¾�,�a�d�BÜ,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ���EØ&ß���Ý�Ü��N��×aå,�N�yãW×`Ú�á+�W�Á��Ú����.ÛÌ×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×����E�,Ú��¾Û��dÚ��¾ØiãW×`Ú�á��?Ü��d�.×`ÚYÞy�E���¸��Ü,Ú�×�ØÁà��¸�¾Ø,�<×`Ú�×`�¾Øú ��áÁ�ªý�Eÿfæ ,��NØ,�¸�Eèjã �����EØËÚ��.�EØ,Ý��\�E�.Û �EتÞ/âE���L×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾ØÌÜ,���Eß<�`�NÛ ãW×`Ú�á/�.�NÝ�Ü#�N�¸Ú¿Ú��&�EØ ��Ù����à¾�,���d���¸�¾Ø,�<×`Ú�×`�¾Øi×aتÚ�����âE���.×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾Ø&Ü,���Eß��`�NÛ ã�×`Ú�á����NÝ�Ü��N�¸Ú�Ú��y�WÜ��d�.×`ÚYÞ&�¸�¾Ø,�,×`Ú�×`�¾Ø+ßjÞÛ/�N�EØ,Ýu�E�,�WÝ.×aÛ/Ü<�`���E�,Ú��¾Û��dÚ��¾ØiÜ,���¤�,�,�¸Ú��¸�¾Ø,Ý�Ú��L�,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø �9Ý����¿�4�E��×�Ø,Ý�Ú��EØ,�¸��ú �<�.,6û-Áþ��¾ÿ �Læ

�0��� � �M��� ���� .0 ������ !�� ! �"Á�E�¿�E���jÚ�á,�����?���a�EÝ�Ý��NÝ��E��Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ �9Ý��d�4��ÚYÞEè¾�.�N�E�.á,�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞEèE�EØ,��Ü��d�.×`ÚYÞ��LèdÚ�áÁ�?Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×a�¾Ø&�E�Ú�áÁ��ß#�°�¾�`�N�EØ��¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�¾Ü<���Eß<�`�NÛ�ÝF�� �� �0� ���u���EØ+ß���ãW�.×`Ú�Ú��NØ�×aØ1�#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý×�تÚ�����Ü<����Ú��N���SâE���Ú�áÁ�i�a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�i�E��Ý��Áß<Ý���Ú�Ý��E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�æü¿���N��×aÝ��N�`ÞEè<à¾×`âE�NØó�ÊÝ���Ú�� �E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�è#Ú�áÁ�&Ý���Ú�� ��� ��E� ( ëNëEö í õ��)��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � � �\�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ¿�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ý¿�E��E�a� �#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý��4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝ��Á��å<Ø,�N���IâE���BÚ�áÁ�Ý���Ú��E�<Ü<���N�,×a���dÚ��NÝ � � M � � �EØ,�iÚ�áÁ�BÝ���Ú��E�<�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø<Ý "�� M � é�ê í G �!�Lé�ê í G �Qé�ê í J �!�Lé�ê í J �¾èãWáÁ���.�F�6�,�E�H��é�ê í G � M �Lé�ê í G �EØ<���6�,�E� ��é�ê í J � M �Lé�ê í J æ�y×`âE�NØ��ià¾�EÛ/�+Ý�Ú��L�,�¸Ú��Á��� � M� � ��� ��� G ��� J �����LèÁã ��×aØjÚ�����Ü,�.��Ú¿Ú�áÁ���\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝ¿�E��� ��� � �IâE���?Ú�á,���a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�7) ���"� �-B.���E�Ý��Áß�Ý���Ú�Ý��E�C� èS�E�L�Á�����N�i�E���¸�E�.�,×aØÁà�Ú��yÝ���Ú�×�Ø,���a�,Ý�×a�¾Øæ !W��à¾�dÚ�×a�¾Ø/×aÝ�Ý���Ú��¸�¾Û/Ü<�a�NÛ/�NتÚ��dÚ�×a�¾Ø 9�4�E���E�a� 38B � è<ã®�+�a��Ú75 3 M+�2" 3&æ���áÁ��Ü,�.�N�,×a���dÚ��NÝW�d�.�+×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��N���EÝ�Ú�áÁ�NÛ�Ý��N�`âE�NÝ�9�4�E�i�E�a� $ H �/è�ã �Ë�`��ÚÉú ú $,ÿ ÿ 8 & M $uæ���áÁ�Ì�4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý�é�ê í G è �Jé�ê í G è�é�ê í J è��EØ,� �Jé�ê í J �d������E�a�`�N�Éé�ê í � í ù í���� ëdê/ëLé í ê�õEîfëEê � ( �EØ,�ÅÚ�á,��ÞÊ�d���&×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��N���EÝ?�4�¾�a�`�SãWÝ�9

ú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ 8 & ��� � M � 8IH5� �"5 - G H � G ��8 �-? 8- J H2� J ��8��-? 7 ��8���- G ��- J � B�� � � ���ú ú �Lé�ê í G ÿ ÿ 8 & ��� � M � 8IH5� � 8- G H � G ��8 �-? 5 - J H2� J ��8��-? 7 ��8���- G ��- J �M0�� �M $�� � $��

ú ú é�ê í J ÿ ÿ 8 & ��� � M � 8IH5� �"5 - J H � J ��8 �-? 8- G H2� G ��8��-? 7 ��8���- G ��- J � B�� � �cý��ú ú �Lé�ê í J ÿ ÿ 8 & ��� � M � 8IH5� � 8- J H � J ��8 �-? 5 - G H2� G ��8��-? 7 ��8���- G ��- J �M0�� �M $���? ��þ� �

ç�تÚ��,×aÚ�×`âE�N�`ÞEè�ú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ 8 & ��� �¿×aÝ�Ú�áÁ��Ý���Ú¿�E�Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ �4���¾Û ã�á,×a�.á�Ü<�a�NÞE���6þ����EØË�\�E�L�¸����Ú��L�EØ,Ý�×µÙÚ�×`�¾Ø/Ú����'×aØ � èª�EØ<�%ú ú �Lé�ê í G ÿ ÿ�8 & ��� ��×�Ý�Ú�áÁ�WÝ���Ú��E�Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ®�4���¾Û ãWá,×��.á�Ü<�a�IÞE���Wþ�×aÝ��<Ø,�dß<�`�Ú�� �NâE�¾×a� ��Ú��L�EØ,Ý�×`Ú�×`�¾Ø Ú���� ×aØ � æ���á,�Ì�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý6é�ê í J �EØ,� �Jé�ê í J �d���É×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��N�Ý�Þ¤Û�Û/��Ú��.×����E�a�`ÞEæ�7G���,�NØÁ�EÚ���ßjÞ ( ø6� � � �-M �E)5��� � �-B.� �Iú ú� ÿ ÿ�8 & �WÚ�áÁ�i���NÝ��<�`Ú�×aØÁàÊ×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��ZÙÚ�×`�¾Øó�\�E�2�#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý�æ�"Á�E���Ë���`�¾Ý��N� �4�E�.Û&�<�a� � H�� ��� � è<ã �&ã��L×`Ú��Êú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & �.�dÚ�áÁ����Ú�á,�EØ

þ�

Page 11: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ�� +�� J & N è��EØ,� ã®���¾ÛÌ×`Ú � ãWáÁ�NØ ���`�N�d�+�4���¾Û Ú�áÁ�Ë�¸�¾ØªÚ���!¤Ú�æ ",�E�i�Åà¾�EÛ�� � è��%Ý.�Áß<Ý���Ú3DB?� & �E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��EØ,�ÅÜ��a�NÞE���(� H � þ � ���¾è<ã �+á,�IâE�+Ú�áÁ�NØ

�J�K� 8 & 5 3 M ú ú �ML%? ��3 (�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ 8 & ? ��þEþ%���á,×�Ý/�\�E�LÛ&�,��� ���EØ-ß��ó�,Ø,�Á���.Ý�Ú��j�¤� ß°Þ¶�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×a�Á���L×aØÁà ×`Ú�ÝÊ×`Ú����.�dÚ�×`âE� �¸�¾Û/Ü<�ÁÚ��dÚ�×a�¾Ø 9®ã �á,�IâE�WÚ�á,�dÚ�ú ú �ML�? ��3,(�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ�8 & M"�a×aÛ A�F�H �4AªèªãWáÁ�������4:-M $��EØ,�èE�4�E� =�H�5?è,ã�áÁ������4A�B G M 3 / ú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ 8 & ���4A���9�×`Ú+×aÝ��N�EÝ�Þ Ú��óÝ�áÁ�Sã ß°ÞG×aØ,�,�,�¸Ú�×a�¾ØóÚ�á<�dÚ+Ú�áÁ�ÌÝ���Ú+Ú�á,�dÚ �4A�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×�Ý�Ú�Ý��E�#Ú�áÁ�WÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ®�E� � �4���¾Û ãWá<×a�.á/Ü��a�NÞE���C�����EØÌ�4�E�.�¸��Ú�á,��à¾�EÛ/�WÚ���3-×aØ/�dÚ Û/�¾Ý�Ú=GÝ�Ú���Ü�Ý�æ ��áÁ�Ì�Nðj�,�dÚ�×a�¾Ø ��þEþ%��Ú�áÁ�NØ �4�¾�a�`�SãWÝyß°Þ Ú��dä¤×aØÁà%Ú�áÁ�Ì�a×aÛÌ×`Ú�= � �-æ��¤×�Û�×a�a�d�.�aÞEè�4�E�WÝ��d�4��ÚYÞÅÜ,���EÜ#����Ú�×a�NÝ®ã �+á,�IâE�Eè<�4�E�(�LH � þ � ����9

�J�O� 8 & % 3 M ú ú; L%? ��3 *�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ 8 & ? ��þ �����à¾�E×aØè¤Ú��/�,Ø,�Á���.Ý�Ú��EØ,�ÌÚ�á<×aÝ �\�E�.Ûi�,�a�i×`ÚBáÁ�N�`Ü<Ý®Ú����¸�¾Ø,Ý�×��Á��� ×aÚ�Ý?×`Ú����.�dÚ�×`âE�y�¸�¾Û/Ü<�,Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Øæ7G�6á,�NâE��ú ú; L�? ��3 *�é�ê í G ��L � �Yÿ ÿ 8 & M"�a×aÛ A�F�H �4AjèªãWáÁ���.���4:-M � �EØ,�è¾�4�E� = H�5Bè�ã�áÁ������4A�B G M�3�0Ëú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ 8 & ���4A�� &°×`Ú¿×aÝ��N�EÝ�Þ/Ú��+Ý����WÚ�á<�dÚ �4A6�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ý��E�#Ú�áÁ�WÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ �E� � �4���¾ÛãWá,×��.áÉÜ<�a�IÞE���&þ����EØ%à¾�,�d�.�EØjÚ����&Ú�á<�dÚ�Ú�áÁ��à¾�EÛ/�&Ý�Ú��NÞ¤Ý�×�ØE3 �4�E�W�dÚ��`�N�EÝ�Ú =ÅÝ�Ú���Ü<ÝNæ���áÁ��Nð°�,�dÚ�×`�¾Ø ��þ ���yÚ�áÁ�NØ �\�¾���`�IãWÝ�ßjÞ Ú��dä°×�ØÁàÅÚ�áÁ���a×aÛÌ×`Ú;= � �-æ ��á,��Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø �E�?�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾��EØ,�ÅâE���L×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾ØÅÜ<���Eß<�`�NÛ�Ý �4�E��Ü<�d�.×aÚYÞÊÜ,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ?×aÝ�à¾×`âE�NØÅß°ÞËÚ�áÁ�+�\�¾�a�a�IãW×aØ,ài�.�NÝ��,�`Ú�æ� ' � ���� � � ú 'L�ªý¤þ�ÿ���ëdê�õdö4ö,÷ªõ ôÌí � î9ê��ÁùIî �¤ê í��)� ( õdö\öjé¤õEêJî9ø9î9ø9ë�� � ��3 G � 3 J ��?�?�? � 3��<�yë ��'& ( õ��2�Åõdö\ö�� H � þ � ��� (��®í #¤õ�� í

�J�O� 8 & �õdêJø4î9ï �G��3 G ��?�?�? � 3��4� � M ú ú � L �@������ G L G ?��B � G

��3 B *Ìé�ê í � ��L�B � �Yÿ ÿ 8 & ��þ>&��

6×`âE�NØ �EØ ' �dÙf�4�E�.Û �#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ýi�\�E�.Ûi�,�a�6� M � L � ����� �G,L�G�?� �B � G ��3 B *óé�ê í G ��L B � �Lèã � �Á��å<Ø,� Ú�áÁ� Ü��d�.×`ÚYÞ"Ü,�.�EÜ����.ÚYÞ ?î9ï ����� ���¸�E�����NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,×�ØÁà Ú�� ��ß°Þ ?î9ï ����� � M �õEêLø9î9ï �G��3 G ��?�?�?!� 3��<� �Læ�7-×`Ú�á�Ú�á,×aÝ?ØÁ�EÚ��dÚ�×`�¾Ø�è,ã®�&���EØÅ���NÝ�Ú��dÚ�� ��þ>&��?�EÝ��4�¾�a�`�SãWÝ�æ ��������� ����� � ��ëdêÌõdö4ö÷jõ ôÌí+� î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í��&� ( õdö\ö �-H � þ � ���Gõ��2�%õdö4ö�ù�ö`ë ��í �1���jì�¸ëEê ô��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � � ��ëdê ô �¤ö`õ � � H � ��� �� ù.ë���îfõdø6�<ø6�j÷ ë��<ö ï î # í ��� ��ùNî9øcë�� � ï ô)( ëdö�é�ê í � (��®í#°õ�� í �J�O� 8 & �î9ï � ��� � M ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & 2��õªù���ë�� � í î í ê ô ø6��õ¾ù�ï 2 ç�ØËß��°�¾�`�N�EØ �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý�è¾Ú�áÁ���EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�.Ý¿é�ê í G �EØ,��é�ê í J �d���6ØÁ�EÚÚ�áÁ�É�,�,�E�¿�¾ØÁ�Ì�E��Ú�á,�Ë�EÚ�áÁ���Iæ���á<×aÝ�×aÛ/Ü��a×`�NÝyÚ�á,�dÚiß#�j�¾�a�N�EØ �¸�¾ØjÚ����¾� Ü,���Eß<�`�NÛÌÝ+�d���ÉØÁ�EÚ�Á��Ú����.ÛÌ×aØÁ�N� 9°�\�E� 3 B(� � è¤Ú�áÁ�6�Nðj�<�E�a×`ÚYÞ �8";��þ � 8 & 3 M���� � 8 & � � � "�3 ���Á�°�NÝ ��ëEîBáÁ�¾���Ì�4�E��E�a�uà¾�EÛ/��Ý�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á���NÝ � �EØ<� �E����Ü,�.�EÜ����.Ú�×`�NÝ 3Wæ�ç�تÚ��<×`Ú�×`âE�N�`ÞEè�Ú�áÁ���4�E�¸Ú6Ú�á,�dÚ6Ü<���NÞE����þ�×aÝ�,Ø,�dß��`�BÚ��+�NØ,Ý��,���?Ú�áÁ���¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�<àE�¾�E� 3 �,�j�NÝ®ØÁ�EÚ��NØjÚ��E×a�,Ú�á,�dÚ¿Ü<�a�NÞE���%�y×aÝ®�dß<�`�?Ú��+�NØ<Ý��Á���Ú�áÁ���¸�¾ØjÚ����¾��àE�¾�E� & 3�æ0"Á�E����!Á�EÛ/Ü<�`�EèÚ�á,�������d���/à¾�EÛ/�ÌÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á���NÝ � ã�áÁ�������\�E�&Ý��¾Û/�3DB?� & ã®�+á<�NâE�

� & "�����þ � 8 & 5 3��RM ú ú & �ML%? ��3#(Ìé�ê í G ��L � �Yÿ ÿ 8 & M ú ú; L%? � & 3#* �Lé�ê í G ��L � �Yÿ ÿ 8 &�M ú ú; L%? � & 3#*Ëé�ê í J ��L � �Yÿ ÿ 8 & M ��� � 8 & % � & 3 �-?

��Ø ��!¤�EÛ/Ü��`��×aÝ6Ú�áÁ�/à¾�EÛ/��Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á���O*R,�.0/21�3�4 . 9��EÝy��!¤Ü<�a�E×�ØÁ�N� ×aØ Ú�áÁ��×aØjÚ����¤�,�,�¸Ú�×`�¾Øã �+á,�NâE�+8'9;:�<��H ��þ � 8 5 � 8�>@?BADC���&,�¾ØÅÚ�á,���EÚ�áÁ���Wá,�EØ<�èÁ×`Ú����EØÅß#�y�N�EÝ�×a�`ÞÊÝ����NØÅÚ�á,�dÚ=8'9;:�<��H��� � 8 % � 8�9;:�<'�¾æ

þEþ

Page 12: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

�0��� ��' � � � ����� � ��� ���� ��Q�4� + �"�M��� � �� .0 ��������!�� ! ���áÁ���E�.�NÛ þ/�NÝ�Ú��dß��a×aÝ�áÁ�NÝy�%ß<�EÝ�×a�/�¸�¾Ø<ØÁ�N�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø ß#��Ú]ã®���NØ �a×aØÁ�N�d�yÜ��d�.×`ÚYÞ Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×a�NÝ��EØ,�âE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø��E�aàE�E�.×`Ú�á,Û�ÝË��!¤Ü,���NÝ�Ý��N�-×aØ �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý�æ5,������Eè ã®� Ý�á,�E�a���Á��âE�N�`�EÜ � �¸�¾Ø¤ÙØÁ�N�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø ß#��ÚYã ���NØG�a×aØ,�N�d��Ü,�.�EÜ����.Ú�×`�NÝ í �Jé�ê í�����í ��ø � ��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � � ( �EØ,� Ú�áÁ�N×`��âE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø�E�`àE�E�.×aÚ�á,Û�Ý��E�aÝ��W��!¤Ü,���NÝ�Ý��N�&×aØ4�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�æ>�u�WÚ�á,×�Ý�NØ,�èNã �¿Ü<���Iâ¤×a�Á�¿���a×aØÁ�N�d�uÝ��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý�4�E� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý�è¤�Eß,Ú��E×aØÁ�N�Åß°ÞÊ��âZ�E�a�<�dÚ�×aØÁà �#ÙY���E�a���,���,ÝB�¾Ø%�a×�ØÁ�N�d�BÚ��.�E�¸�NÝ�æ

� Ú��L�E�¸��� H � � à¾×aâE�NÝ&�L×aÝ��ÌÚ�� �EØ ×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØQR ��M �E)5�����L�-B.� �Iú ú� ÿ ÿ�8

����\�E� �#Ù

���E�a���,���,Ý�è¿ã�áÁ�����0) � � � �-B.�Ë×aÝÌÚ�áÁ� ���dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�ó�E�&Ý��Áß<Ý���Ú�ÝË�E�+Ø,�dÚ��,�.�E��Ø°�,Û&ß#���.ÝÌ�E�L�Á�����N��E���¸�E�.�,×�ØÁà&Ú���Ý���ÚB×aØ,���a�<Ý�×`�¾Øè¾�EØ,�ËãWáÁ���.���E�a�<Ü,���N�,×a���dÚ��NÝ $ H � � �d���6×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��N�Ê�EÝ Ú�áÁ�Ý���Ú�Ý��E�<×aØ<�,×a�¸�NÝ�E�<Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�×aØ $�èZ×cæ³�Eæ`èÁú ú $,ÿ ÿ�8

�M � = H�5 � ��A H)$ �¾æ ��á,�®�Á��å<Ø<×`Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý � ��� �0��þ� �

���EØ�ß#��Ý�×�Û/Ü<�a×`å<�N�è°Ý.×aØ,�¸�y��âE����ÞÅ�`�¤���dÚ�×`�¾Ø��E��Ú�áÁ�+Ú��.�E�¸�&á,�EÝW�ÌÝ�×aØ,à¾�`�yÝ��,���¸�NÝ�Ý��E�%9,�\�E���E�a��LH � þ � ���6�EØ,�/�E�a� �IB#5 ã ���`��ÚWú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ�8 � ��� � M ú ú �Lé�ê í � ÿ ÿ�8 � ��� � M � = H�5 � =4 þ�H � �¾æ7G���Á��å<Ø,��Ú�áÁ� ( ëNëdö í õ�� öUø6� í õdê ��í�ô õ��<î9øcù � ú7�,ÿ 8C9;:;<�

�IâE���WÚ�áÁ��Ý���Ú?�E�uÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ;� �E���i���a�¾Ý��N��#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý��4�E�.Ûi�,�a�>� H � ��� � Ú��Å�¸�¾Ø,Ý.×aÝ�ÚW�E�®�E�a��Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ6ã�áÁ�¾Ý��+å<�.Ý�Ú�Ý�Ú��dÚ���×�Ý�×aØ%Ú�áÁ�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý��E� � 9�Ý�Ü��N��×aå<���E�a�`ÞEèuú7�,ÿ 839;:;<

�M � � H9��� � �:7H ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ ���� �¾æ�çQØ �¸�¾ØªÚ��L�EÝ�Ú�è#ã®�����E�a�

Ú�áÁ��Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý�ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & �,��å<ØÁ�N�ó�IâE�����Êà¾�EÛ/�/Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,��� � Ú�áÁ� ( ê�õ���ù$#jø6�j÷ Ý��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��Ý6�E�Ú�áÁ� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ýy�4�E�.Ûi�,�a���æ��WáÁ�/�\�¾���`�IãW×�ØÁà��`�NÛ�Û��ÅÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ&Ú�á<�dÚ��\�E�&�\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝ�×aØ ' �dÙ�4�E�.ÛÅè°Ú�áÁ�6Ü<�d�.×`Ú]Þ�Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ��¸�E�����NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,×�ØÁà+Ú���Ú�áÁ���\�E�LÛ&�,���&�¸�¾×aØ<��×a�Á�NÝ®ãW×`Ú�áËÚ�áÁ�y�a×aØÁ�N�d�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��ÝW�E�uÚ�áÁ�+�\�E�.Ûi�,�a�¤æ& � � � � � ��ëdê�õdö4ö �Ní î � ë � � îfõEî í�� � ( õEö\öA� H � þ � ��� õ��5� õdö\ö�ùNöµë �Ní �N���°ì���ëdê ô ��ìù.õEöµù>�°ö � � ��ëdê ô �¤ö`õ � � H�� ��� � ù.ë��<îfõEø6�,ø �j÷óë��,öUïÉî # í ��� ��ùIî9ø9ë�� � ï ô)( ëdö<é�ê í � ( �®í #°õ�� í ?î9ï � ���0� M ú7�,ÿ 8C9;:;<

� 2��á,×�ÝW�`�N�E�,Ý��N�EÝ�×a�aÞÅÚ��ËÚ�áÁ�i�4�¾�a�`�Iã�×aØÁà����NÝ.�,�`Ú�è<ã�á,×a�.á%���N�a�dÚ��NÝ�Ú�áÁ���a×aØÁ�N�d���EØ,�óß,�.�EØ,�Lá,×aØÁàÝ��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��ÝW�E��' �dÙf�4�E�.Û �4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝ�æ ��������� ������� ��ëdêÌõdö4ö÷jõ ôÌí+� î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í��&� ( õdö\ö �-H � þ � ���Gõ��2�%õdö4ö�ù�ö`ë ��í �1���jì�¸ëEê ô��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � � ��ëdê ô �¤ö`õ � � H � ��� � ù.ë���îfõdø6�<ø6�j÷ ë��<ö ï î # í ��� ��ùNî9øcë�� � ï ô)( ëdö�é�ê í � (��®í#°õ�� í ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ�8 & M �J�O� 8 & �î9ï ����� � M �J�O� 8 & ú7�Áÿ�839;:;<�� 2ç�Ø��9�E�¸Ú�èjÚ�áÁ�W���N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý.á,×`Ü/ß#��ÚYã ���NØÊÚ�áÁ�W�a×aØ,�N�d�¿�EØ,��ß<�.�EØ,�.á<×aØÁà+Ý��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��Ý áÁ�¾�a�<Ý��\�E� �E�a��#ÙY���E�a���,���,ÝB�\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝ?×aØÅÝ�Ú����¾ØÁà¾�aÞÊ�Á��Ú����LÛ�×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×a�W�4�E�.ÛÅæ� ' � ���� � � ú �,�.,6û�Áþ��Eÿ ��ëdê�õdö4ö�÷jõ ôÌí � î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í��6� ( õdö4ö�ù�ö`ë ��í � ��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � � ��ëdêLìô �¤öµõ � � H�� ��� �� ( õ��2� õEö\ö#é�öµõdï í ê � � H � þ � ��� ( ø ���-ø � ø � � î9ê�ë��j÷EöUï � í î í ê ô ø �,ø � î9ø9ù��ëdê ô õ��5�ÉùLë��<îfõdø � � ë��<ö ïÉî # í ��� ��ùNî9øcë�� � ï ô ( ëdöÁé�ê í � ( î # í � ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & M �J�O� 8 & ú7�Áÿ 839;:;<� 27G� ãW×a�a�EÝ����®Ú�á,�dÚ�Ú�á,�®�a×aØ,�N�d���EØ,��ß,�L�EØ,�.á,×�ØÁà�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ýu�E�,Ý�Ú����¾ØÁà¾�`Þy�Á��Ú����LÛ�×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×a� �9�EØ,�×aØÊÜ<�d��Ú�×����,�a�d�Nè 'L�dÙf�4�E�.Û �¿�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝB�d���y���N�a�dÚ��N�Å×�ØË�E�a��Ú�áÁ�yÝ���Ú�Ú�×�ØÁà¾Ý?�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×a�,�����N�É×aØÊÚ�á,×aÝÜ<�dÜ#���Nè¤Ø,�EÛ/�N�`ÞEèÁ×aØÊÚ�áÁ�6ß#�°�¾�`�N�EØè°Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×aÝ�Ú�×a�dèj�EØ,�É�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�ÉÝ���Ú�Ú�×aØÁà¾ÝNæ �WáÁ�y�a×aØÁ�N�d��EØ,��ß,�.�EØ,�Lá,×aØÁà Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��ÝÌ�E�+�\�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝË�d��� ØÁ�EÚË�E�`ãB�NÞ¤ÝÊ���N�a�dÚ��N�è �EÝÊÚ�áÁ�ó�4�¾�a�`�SãW×aØÁà��!Á�EÛ/Ü<�`���Á�NÛ��¾Ø,Ý�Ú��.�dÚ��NÝ�æ��� ����� � � ú �,�2,6û-Áþ��¾ÿ òB�¾Ø,Ý�×a�Á��� Ú�áÁ� �4�E�.Ûi�,�a� � M �ML%? ��é�ê í G ��L � (! ?�? � � *é�ê í G �A? � � �Lè�ãWáÁ������� B?� ×aÝ?�/Ý���Ú?�E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�æ���áÁ�y�a×�ØÁ�N�d��Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý+ú7�,ÿ 839;:;<

��¸�¾Ø<Ý�×aÝ�Ú�Ý?�E�

þ �

Page 13: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

�E�a��Ú�áÁ��Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ � M 8�: � 8 G � 8 J ��?�?�?¤�4�E�BãWá,×a�Lá�Ú�áÁ�����6×aÝ �2=�H�5-Ý.�,�.áÊÚ�á,�dÚ 8 � HF� �4�E�?�E�a�� � =�èÁÚ�á<�dÚ�×aÝ�è¤�E���E����Ú�á,��Ú��L�E�¸�NÝ�Ú�á,�dÚ?��âE�NØjÚ��,�E�a�`ÞË�NتÚ���� �ËèÁ�EØ,�ÅØ,��âE���W�`�N�NâE�&×`Ú?�dà¾�E×aØ0&�,Ý�×�ØÁà�Ú��NÛ/Ü#�E�.�E�µÙY�`�Eà¾×a�6ØÁ�EÚ��dÚ�×a�¾Øè,ã ��×aØ,�,×a���dÚ��6Ú�á,×�Ý?Ý���Ú��E��Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ�ß°Þ ú 5 % �+ÿ � æÁç�ØÅ�9�E�¸Ú�èã �+á,�NâE�78�A7H ú ú; ?�? � � *Ìé�ê í G �A? � �Qÿ ÿ � �� �¾Ø,�`ÞÉ×`� 8 � HF� �4�E���E�a��� ��=�è<�EØ<�Åã®�&á,�NâE�&Ú�á,�dÚ8�:�H ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ�� �� × (GÚ�áÁ�����&×�Ý = H 5 Ý.�,�.áóÚ�á,�dÚ=8�AKH ú ú; ?�? � � *�é�ê í G �A?�� �]ÿ ÿ�� �� æ�,��Iã ��âE���Nè�¸�¾Ø¤ÙÝ�×a�,�����Ê�Á��Ú����.Û�×�Ø,×aÝ�Ú�×a��Ü<�a�NÞE����ÙB�ËÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á��� � M � � ��� ��� G ��� J �����WãW×`Ú�á � M � 8Q�G. ��� �¾è� M � -�� E ���Q�¾è��EØ,� � J ��8�� M � -�� E!�¾è � J �/. � M'� J ��� � M � -��¾è�EØ,�óÚ��.�EØ,Ý�×aÚ�×`�¾Ø%�.�N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Øà¾×`âE�NØËßjÞ87 ��8�������- � M � 8��¾è 7 ��8������ E�� M � . �¾è 7 �/. ������- � M � ���¾è 7 ��� ������- � M � � �¾èjã�áÁ������Ê×aÝ6Ú�áÁ�/Ý�×�ØÁà¾�`��Û/�IâE�Ê�Nâd�E×a�a�dß<�`�iÚ���Ü<���NÞE����þdæ "Á�E��� M � 8Q�����Ì×aÚ6×�Ý6�N�EÝ�ÞóÚ���Ý����/Ú�á,�dÚ��þ � 8 & ú7�,ÿ 839;:;<�

M ��þ � 8 & ú 5 % �&ÿ 839;:;<�M � 8Q�G.)�����¾è,ãWá<×a�`��ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & M � .)�����¾æ

ç�Ø ú �<�.,6û-Áþ��¾ÿfè°×aÚ ×aÝBÝ�á,�IãWØÊÚ�á,�dÚ?×aØËàE�NØÁ���.�E�#Ú�áÁ�6�a×aØ,�N�d� �EØ,�Êß,�L�EØ,�.á,×�ØÁà&Ý��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��ÝB�E��#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý?�4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝ��d���&���N�a�dÚ��N���¾Øó�E�a�à¾�EÛ/�iÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,���NÝW× ( Ú�áÁ��ÞÅ�d���&���N�a�dÚ��N���¾Øó�E�a�Ü<�a�IÞE����Ù.þ��EØ,�%�E�a�#Ü<�a�IÞE����ÙB��à¾�EÛ/�iÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á�.�NÝ�æ

� �ÌѾÒ�� ���®Ö��]Ö��SоÖYÕ - �,ÑjÖ / Õ ��оÖfÒuÏ �Ï¿Ó 1ÊÒ�ÏuÐdÑªÒ �

��áÁ�&ß#�j�¾�`�N�EØ �¸�¾ØjÚ����¾��Ü,���Eß<�`�NÛ��EÝ�ä¤ÝWãWá,��Ú�áÁ�����ËÜ<�a�IÞE���y���EØóà¾�<�d�.�EتÚ�����Ú�á,�dÚ6�E�a���¾�ÁÚ�Ù�¸�¾Û/�NÝ��d�.��×aØ �G�Á�NÝ�×`�.�N� ��×aØÁ�N�d��Ü,���EÜ#����Ú]ÞEæF��áÁ�Ëé�ê�ë ( õ ( ø\öUø � î9øcùó�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�?Ü<���Eß<�`�NÛ �EÝ�ä¤ÝãWá,�dÚB×aÝ®Ú�áÁ� ô õ��Eø ô õdö°é�ê�ë ( õ ( ø\öUø9î9ïËãW×aÚ�á�ãWá,×��.áÊ�&Ü��a�NÞE���?���EØÉà¾�,�d�.�EØjÚ����6Ú�á,�dÚBÚ�áÁ���¾�ÁÚ�Ù�¸�¾Û/���E��Ú�áÁ��à¾�EÛ/��ß#�N�`�¾Ø,à¾Ý�Ú��iÚ�áÁ���,�NÝ�×`���N�Ë�a×aØÁ�N�d��Ü<���EÜ#����ÚYÞEæ 6×`âE�NØÉ��à¾�EÛ/�6Ý�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á���� M � � ��� ��� G ��� J ���I�6�EØ<�G�ÅÜ,���EÜ#����Ú]Þ�38B'���uèã®���¸�¾Ø,Ý.×a�Á���yÚ�áÁ�/Ú]ã®�Éé�ê�ë ( õ ( ø4öUø � î9ø9ùù.ë��<î9ê�ëEö,é�ê�ë ( ö í�ô � �¸�¾Ø,Ý�×�Ý�Ú�×aØÁà�×aØÅ�¸�¾Û�Ü<�ÁÚ�×aØÁà/Ú�á,�+�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý���þ � & 3 � ��� � & 3 9 �@G� ú ��NþJÿ�Á��å<Ø,�N�ÉßjÞ09

��þ � & 3 M���8 H5��?/Ý��ÁÜ� SKF� S

×aØÁ�� P F� P ü¿� � S%� �

PL � 3 � ��þ * �

��� � & 3 M���8 H5��?/Ý��ÁÜ� P F� P

×aØÁ�� SGF� S ü¿� � S � �

PL � 3 �-? ��þ ��

ãWáÁ���.���58IH5� ? � ��8 ��×aÝ�Ú�áÁ�6�,Ý��<�E���ÁÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý®ØÁ�EÚ��dÚ�×`�¾ØÊ�4�E� �&�4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø�Ú�á<�dÚ Û��dÜ�Ý¿�N�E�Lá8 H5� ×aØjÚ���� ��8 �Læ

$���� ������� ��� � ������ .0 ������ !�� ! �"Á�E��Ú�á,�����EÝ���×aØÊãWá,×a�Lá43¶×aÝB�����N�E�.á,�dß�×a�a×`Ú]ÞEè¤Ý.�d�\��Ú]ÞEè,�E��Ü<�d�.×aÚYÞ�Ü,�.�EÜ����.ÚYÞEèÁã �����EØÅ�¸�¾Û�ÙÜ<�ÁÚ��%Ú�áÁ���9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý���þ * �Lè ��þ ����,Ý�×aØÁà � é�ê�ë ( õ ( ø\öUø � î9ø9ù ×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø �E� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ýú �,�6û-Áþ�ÿfæ®ü��.�N��×aÝ��N�`ÞEè�à¾×`âE�NØ�� Ý���Ú�� �E�yÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�è Ú�áÁ�%Ý���Ú������ � �E�Wé�ê�ë ( õ ( ø4öUø � î9ø9ù ��ìù.õEöµù>�°ö � � �4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝB�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×�Ý�Ú�Ý �E���E�a���#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý®�4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝB�Á��å<ØÁ�N�Ë�IâE����Ú�á,��Ý���ÚB�E�uÜ,���N�¤Ù×a���dÚ��NÝ � � M � � �EØ,�óÚ�áÁ��Ý���Ú6�E�¿�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý�"��FM � é�ê í G �Qé�ê í J �¾è#ãWáÁ�����7�6�,�E� ��é�ê í G � Mé�ê í J æ y×`âE�NØ � à¾�EÛ/��Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,��� � M � � ��� ��� G!����J����I�Lè¿ã®�Å×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú�Ú�áÁ�NÝ��Ê�4�E�.Ûi�¤Ù�a�EÝy�SâE����Ú�áÁ�Ì�a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�2)F� � G� ú ��NþJÿ �-�.���E�B�4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý&� G� ú ��NþJÿfè��E�.�Á�����N� Ü��¾×�تÚ]ãW×aÝ���9�4�E� �2��� 9�� G� ú ��NþJÿ&�EØ,� 8 H �Bè?ã®� á,�IâE� �� � � ����8 � M Û�� ! � � ��8�� ���0��8 � � �EØ,������ ����8�� M Û�×aØ � � ��8�� ���0��8 � �¾æ !���à¾�dÚ�×`�¾Ø-×aÝÌ�Á��å�ØÁ�N� ß°Þ 5�� M��58 H ��?aþ ��� ��8��Læ��áÁ�ÅÜ<���N�,×a���dÚ��NÝ��d�.�ó×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��N� �EÝ ù$#°õEê�õ¾ùIî í êJø � î9ø9ù ��� ��ùIî9ø9ë�� � P��4�E�Ì�E�a� $NH � � è�ã �

þ>&

Page 14: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

�`��Ú�ú ú $,ÿ ÿ & M � � $ �Lè�ãWáÁ���.��� � $ �i×aÝ��Á��å<ØÁ�N� �4�E���E�a� 8 H+� ß°Þ�� � $ ����8�� M þÅ×`�R8�H%$�è�EØ,�� � $ ����8 �RM É�EÚ�áÁ���.ãW×aÝ��Eæ ��áÁ�/×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×a�¾Ø,Ý6�E��é�ê í G �EØ,�óé�ê í J �d�����,��å<ØÁ�N� �EÝ�4�¾�a�`�Iã�Ý�èÁ�\�E��� 9 ��G� ú ��NþJÿH9

ú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ & ��� � M ��8 H5��? Ý��ÁÜ� SGF�� SKJMLON

×aØ,�� P F�� P JMLON

'������ � 8Q� > G � > J � ��þ>���

ú ú é�ê í J ÿ ÿ & ��� � M ��8 H5��? Ý��ÁÜ� P F�� P JMLON

×aØ,�� SGF�� SKJMLON

'������ � 8Q� > G � > J � ��þ!���

ãWáÁ���.�1'������ � 8�� > G � > J � M�� F � A� ��8�� > G � > J ���/. � ���/. �?×�ÝBÚ�áÁ�+ØÁ��!¤Ú�ÙYÝ�Ú���Ü%��!¤Ü#�N�¸Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø��E�� èªà¾×`âE�NØ/Ú�á,�dÚ�Ü<���NÞE���Wþ��EØ<��Ü<�a�NÞE��� �y�.áÁ�°�¾Ý���Ú�á,�N×`��Û/�IâE�NÝ®�E���¸�E�.�,×aØ,àyÚ��+�,×aÝ�Ú��L×`ß<�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø<Ý> G �EØ,� > J èI���NÝ�Ü��N�¸Ú�×aâE�N�`ÞEæIç�تÚ��<×`Ú�×`âE�N�`ÞEèjú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ & ��� ��×aÝ�Ú�áÁ�¿�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×a�¾Ø�Ú�á,�dÚ��EÝ�Ý��¤��×a�dÚ��NÝ�ãW×`Ú�á�N�E�.á 8IH � Ú�áÁ�yÛ�� !¤×�Û��E����!°Ü#�N�¸Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØÉ�E� � Ú�á,�dÚBÜ<�a�IÞE����þ6���EØ��E�.á,×a��âE��×aØÌ�¾Ø,��Ý�Ú���Ü�æç�ØGÜ<�d��Ú�×a���<�a�d�Nè�4�E��3#B � è ú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & ��� ��3 � �y×aÝ�Ú�áÁ�ÌÛ�� !Á×aÛ��E��Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞ�ã�×`Ú�áGãWá,×��.áÜ<�a�IÞE���$�����EØ��\�E�.�¸� � Ú��.�EØ<Ý�×`Ú�×`�¾Ø Ú��D3 ×aØ �¾ØÁ� Ý�Ú���Ü�æ 7G� ØÁ�EÚ�� Ú�á,�dÚ�è®�<Ø,�a×`äE��×aØ Ú�áÁ�ß#�j�¾�a�N�EØÌ���EÝ��EèÁ×aØÌÜ,���Eß<�dß<×��a×aÝ�Ú�×a� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�Ú�á,���EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�.Ý¿é�ê í G �EØ,��é�ê í J �d�����,�,�E�cè°Ý��Ú�á,�dÚ?Ú�áÁ�����E�����,�a�,ÝB���Nð°�,×`�.�NÝ®�¾Ø<�`ÞÌÚ]ã®��Ü<���N�Á�N�¸�NÝ�Ý��E�W�EÜ����L�dÚ��E�.Ý�èÁ�.�dÚ�áÁ���WÚ�á,�EØÉ�\�¾�,�Næ ��áÁ��,�,�E��×`ÚYÞÊ�\�¾���`�IãWÝW�,×`���N�¸Ú��`ÞË�\�.�¾ÛñÚ�áÁ�+ÛÌ×aØ,×aÛ�� !ÊÚ�áÁ���E���NÛ ú â !F��$dÿH9,�4�E���E��� � 9 �@G� ú ��NþJÿ�EØ,���E����8IH5�BèÁã®�+á<�NâE�

þ ��ú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ & ��� ����8 �LM þ � Ý��,Ü � SGF�� SKJMLON ×�ØÁ� � P F�� P JMLON '������ � 8Q� > G � > J �M"×aØÁ� � SGF�� SOJ L N Ý��ÁÜ � P F�� P JMLON þ � '������ � 8Q� > G � > J �M"Ý��ÁÜ � P F�� P JMLON ×aØÁ� � SGF�� SKJMLON '����K5 � � 8Q� > G � > J �M ú ú é�ê í J ÿ ÿ & �K5�� ����8��-?

7G�Ë�,�NØÁ�EÚ��Ìß°Þóé�ê ( � � ��M �E)5� � G� ú ��NþJÿ �-�.� �Iú ú� ÿ ÿ & ��Ú�áÁ�Ì�.�NÝ��,�`Ú�×aØ,àÉ×�تÚ�����Ü<����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØG�4�E��#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý�æQ"Á�E���i���`�¾Ý��N�Ë�4�E�.Û&�<�a� � H � ��� � è°ã®��ã��.×aÚ��iú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & �L�dÚ�áÁ���®Ú�á<�EØ ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ � : � J & N è�EØ,�iã � �¾ÛÌ×`Ú � ãWáÁ�NØ����`�N�d���4���¾Û�Ú�áÁ� �¸�¾ØjÚ���!¤Ú�æ ��áÁ�BÝ��¾�a�ÁÚ�×a�¾Ø,Ý�Ú��6Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×�Ý�Ú�×a���¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�Ü,���Eß��`�NÛ�Ý�ã�×`Ú�á����NÝ�Ü��N�¸Ú�Ú��Ë�.�N�E�.á,�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞEè#Ý��d�4��ÚYÞEè�EØ,�óÜ<�d�.×`Ú]ÞÅÜ,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ����EØ%Ú�á,�NØóß#�ã��.×aÚ�Ú��NØÅ×aØ �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý?�EÝWÝ�Ú��dÚ��N�%ßjÞÉÚ�áÁ�y�4�¾�a�`�SãW×aØÁà�Ú�áÁ���E���NÛ�æ

� ' � ���� � � ú �,��û�Áþ¸ÿ ��ëEê&õdö4ö<÷ªõ ôÌí1� î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í��;� ( õdö\ö�� H � þ � ��� ( õEö\ö 3�B?�'& õ��2�õdö4ö¤é¤õdê¸î9ø9î9ø9ë�� � � M ��3 G � 3 J ��?�?�? � 3��4�+ë ��� & ( �®í #¤õ�� í P

�J�K� & 573 M ú ú �ML%? ��3 (Ëé�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & ��þ>$��

�J�K� & % 3 M ú ú; L%? ��3 *Ìé�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & ��þNý��

�J�O� & �õdêJø4î9ï��G��3 G ��?�?�? � 3��<� � M ú ú � L �@������ G L G ?����� G��3 � *�é�ê í � ��L � � �Yÿ ÿ & ? ���� �

��áÁ�G�dß#�IâE� Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø-�4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝÅ�d���GÚ�áÁ�G�EØ,�E�`�EàE�¾�<ÝÅÚ�� ��þEþ%�Lè ��þ ���LèW�EØ,� ��þ>&��LèW��âE�NØÚ�áÁ�¾�Áà¾á�Ú�áÁ�?Ü,���°�E���E��Ú�áÁ�N×`���¸�E�.���N�¸Ú�ØÁ�NÝ�Ý®���Nð°�,×`���NÝ��,× (#�����NØjÚ��d��à¾�,Û/�NØjÚ�Ý�æ �WáÁ���d��à¾�,Û/�NØjÚ�4�E���.�N�E�.á,�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞyà¾�EÛ��NÝ�×aÝu�EÝ��4�¾�a�`�SãWÝ�æ���áÁ�¿å�!°Ü#�¾×aØjÚ ��þ>$������EØiß#�®�¸�¾Û/Ü��ÁÚ��N��×`Ú����.�dÚ�×`âE�N�`Þ

þ *

Page 15: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

ß°Þ ú ú �ML�? ��3 (�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & M �a×aÛ A�F�H �4Aªè�ãWáÁ����� �4: M �58�?%�EØ,�è��4�E� = H#5Bè¿ã�áÁ������4A�B G M � ��3 � � ú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & ���4A��Læ�çQÚ6×�ÝWÚ�áÁ�NØó�N�EÝ�ÞóÚ��ÉÝ.áÁ�Iã ß°Þ�×aØ,�,�,�¸Ú�×a�¾Ø�Ú�á,�dÚ��4A ��8 �W×aÝÚ�áÁ�WÛÌ� !¤×aÛÌ�E�¤Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×`ÚYÞ+ãW×`Ú�á�ãWá,×��.á�Ü<�a�IÞE���C�u���EØÌ���N�E�.á43 �4���¾Û 8 H5� ×aØ/�dÚ¿Û��¾Ý�Ú =Ý�Ú���Ü<ÝNæNçQØ��4�E�¸Ú�è ��þ>$���×aÝ�Ý�×aÛ/Ü<�aÞW�����NÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÛ/�NتÚ�×aØ4�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�E�¤Ú�áÁ��ã �N�a�µÙfä¤ØÁ�SãWØ6å !¤Ü��¾×�تÚ�.á<�d�.�E�¸Ú����.× #N�dÚ�×`�¾Ø �E�¿Ú�áÁ�/Ý��¾���ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø �E�®Ü#�¾Ý�×aÚ�×`âE�iÝ�Ú��°�Lá,�EÝ�Ú�×a��à¾�EÛ/�NÝ �9Ý����Eè��Eæ³àÁæ`è¿ú "�36ý��dÿ �Læ��áÁ�&Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø ��þNý��W���EØ �E�aÝ���ß#���,Ø,�,���.Ý�Ú��°�°��×�ØÅÚ����.Û�ÝW�E��Ú�á,�+×`Ú����.�dÚ�×`âE�&��âZ�E���,�dÚ�×`�¾Ø��E�Ú�áÁ�iå !¤Ü��¾×�تÚ�æ�7G�/á,�IâE��ú ú; L%? ��3 *Ëé�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & M��a×aÛ A�F�H �4Ajè�ãWá,������� : M ��8 ?aþdè�EØ,��4�E� L H 5?èãWáÁ���.� �4A�B G M�� ��3 ���Åú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & ���4A��Læ¤ç]Ú?���EØÉß#��Ý.áÁ�IãWØÊß°ÞË×aØ<�,�,�¸Ú�×`�¾ØÌÚ�á,�dÚ�4A ��8 �+×aÝ&�Nðj�,�E�®Ú�� Ú�áÁ�ÉÛ�� !¤×�Û��E�¿Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞ �E�WÝ�Ú��IÞ°×aØ,à ×aØ 3 �\�E���dÚ/�`�N�EÝ�Ú2= Ý�Ú���Ü<ÝÚ�á,�dÚ�Ü��a�NÞE���.�����EØ �E�.á<×`��âE�Ì�4���¾Û 8 H%� æ �WáÁ�/�Á��Ú��E×a�`�N� �d�.à¾�,Û/�NØjÚ�Ý����EØ ß#���\�¾�<Ø,�G×aØú �,�6û-Áþ�ÿfæ

7G�yØÁ�EÚ���Ú�á,�dÚ �¾ØË�Á��Ú����LÛ�×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×a�?Ú��Á�.ØÁÙfß<�EÝ��N�ÌÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á���NÝ �9�EØ,�ËÚ�áÁ�N×`�BÝ�Ü#�N��×a�E�<���EÝ��NÝ�èÝ��,�Lá �EÝ6Ú��.�EØ,Ý�×`Ú�×a�¾ØóÝ�Þ¤Ý�Ú��NÛ�Ý��Lè�Ú�á,�iß#�°�¾�`�N�EØ �EØ,� Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×aÝ�Ú�×a�y�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾��Ü,�.�Eß<�`�NÛ�Ý��d����Nð°�,×`âd�E�`�NتÚ�è�EÝ��d�.�/Ú�áÁ��ß��°�¾�`�N�EØG�EØ,� Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×aÝ�Ú�×a�4�#ÙY���E�����,�a×cæ�çQØ<�Á���N�è#�\�E���E�����,��Ú�����ÙÛ�×aØ<×aÝ�Ú�×a� Ú��Á�.ØÁÙfß<�EÝ��N��à¾�EÛ���Ý�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á���NÝ � ãW×`Ú�á�Ý���Ú �E�Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ1� èj�EØ<���4�E�®�E�a�<Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ3�B ����èB�E�a� � H � þ � ���¾èW�EØ<���E�a�����`�¾Ý��N� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý��4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ�� �¸�¾ØjÚ��E×aØ,×aØ,à �¾Ø,�aÞ�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý®é�ê í G �EØ,�Êé�ê í J è,ã �+á,�IâE��Ú�á,�dÚ�� �G�J�O� 8 & 35� M��J�O� & 3 �EØ,� � ��ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & � M ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & æ

� í î í ê ô ø ��õ¾ù�ï 2 ��Ý��Ì�¸�¾Ø,Ý��Nð°�Á�NØ,�¸�+�E��Ú�á,�&�,�,�E��×`ÚYÞÊß#��ÚYã ���NØ%Ú�áÁ�yé�ê í G �EØ,�Éé�ê í J �EÜ#����Ù�dÚ��E�.Ý�è�Ü,���Eß<�dß�×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×����¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�uÜ,���Eß<�`�NÛÌÝ?�d���&�Á��Ú����LÛ�×aØÁ�N�è,�<Ø,�a×`äE�6Ú�áÁ�N×`��ß#�j�¾�`�N�EØ%�¸�¾�,ؤÙÚ�����Ü<�d�.Ú�Ý�9¾×aØ�Ü<�d��Ú�×����,�a�d�NèÁú³û%�d�Jý�$Zÿ,Ü,���SâE�NÝ�Ú�á,�dÚ��4�E�¿�E�a�°à¾�EÛ/�NÝ � èj�E�a�¤Ý���Ú�Ý�3FB?� �& ×aØ�Ú�áÁ�� �E���N�¤á,×`���.�d�L�.ájÞEèd�EØ<�i�E��� 8 H5� & èdã®�Bá,�IâE��þ �8��þ � & 32��8 � M'��� � & � � � " 3 ����8 �Læ�7"á,×a�`�®Ú�áÁ�Ü,���°�E���E�uÚ�á,×aÝ ���NÝ��,�aÚ®���Nð°�,×`�.�NÝ �E�,âZ�EØ,�¸�N�Å�d�.à¾�,Û/�NØjÚ�Ý�èÁÚ�áÁ�y���EÝ���×aØÊãWá,×��.á 3¶×aÝB�&Ü��d�.×`ÚYÞÜ,���EÜ#����Ú]Þy�\�¾���`�IãWÝu�N�`�NÛ/�NØjÚ��d�.×a�aÞ��4���¾Û��¾�Á���#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý�Ý��¾�a�,Ú�×`�¾Ø��4�E�.Ûi�,�a� ���� �LèE�EØ,�&�4���¾ÛÚ�áÁ���,�,�E�a×`Ú]Þ��E��é�ê í G �EØ,�/é�ê í J æªç�ØË�4�E�¸Ú�è¤�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×a�,���®��Ü��d��Ú�×`Ú�×`�¾Ø �NM ��3 G � 3 J ��?�?�? � 3��4���E�� æ<����Ú�Ú�×aØÁà��LG M $��EØ,��� � B G M 3 � �\�E�iþ3� �4� �GèÁã®�+á<�NâE��9

þ��(��þ � & WõdêJø4î9ï �G��3 G ��?�?�?!� 3���� � M þ � ú ú � L �@������ G L G ?� �B � G ��3 B *Ëé�ê í G ��L@B/� �Yÿ ÿ &M ú ú � B G L �@����� J L G ? � �B � G ��3 B *�é�ê í J ��L�B/� �Yÿ ÿ &M ��� � & WõdêJø4î9ï �G��� G!��?�?�? ��� � B GQ� �M ��� � & � � � "� �õdêJø9î9ï �G��3 G ��?�?�?!� 3��<� � �-?

$���� ��' � � � ����� � ��� ���� ��Q�4� + �� �� ��� �� ������/. 0 �Q���� !�� ! �

��áÁ� Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×a�¾Ø8���� ���E�,Ü<�d�L×`ÚYÞ+�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�°Ü,���Eß��`�NÛ�Ý����EØiß#�¿�.�NÝ�Ú��dÚ��N�/�EÝ��\�¾�a�a�IãWÝ�æ�"Á�E��Ü<�a�IÞE����LH � þ � ���¾è,�E���<à¾�EÛ/�yÝ�Ú��L�,�¸Ú��Á���NÝ � è°�EØ,�Ê�E�a��'L�dÙf�4�E�.Û �\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝ����¸�¾ØªÚ��E×aØ<×aØÁà+�¾Ø<�`Þ/Ú�áÁ��9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø Ý�Þ¤Û+ß#�¾��é�ê í � è�ã ��á,�NâE� ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & M �J�O� & ?î9ï ����� �Læ ��Ý.×aØÁàG���NÛ�ÛÌ� þdè�ã �����EØÚ�áÁ�������4�E�����.�N�a�dÚ���Ú�áÁ���a×�ØÁ�N�d���EØ,�Åß,�L�EØ,�.á,×�ØÁà/Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý?�E��ó�EÝ��4�¾�a�`�Iã�Ý�æ

� ' � ���� � $ ��ëdê�õdö4ö,÷ªõ ôÌí � î9ê��ÁùIî �¤ê í��)� ( õdö\ö��LH � þ � ��� ( õ��5�ÌõEö\öù�ö`ë ��í �4��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � ���ëdê ô �¤ö`õ � � H ����� � ø ����jì�¸ëEê ô ùLë��<îfõdø �,ø �j÷Gë��,öUï%î # í ��� ��ùIî9ø9ë�� � ï ô)( ëEö#é�ê í � ( �®í#°õ�� í î #°õEî?ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & M �J�O� & ú7�Áÿ 839;:;<�� 2

þ

Page 16: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

��á,×�ÝÚ�áÁ���E���NÛ ���N�a�dÚ��NÝ�Ú�áÁ�¿ß,�L�EØ,�.á,×�ØÁà�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��ÝBú ú7�Áÿ ÿ & �E�jé�ê�ë ( õ ( ø\öUø � î9ø9ù �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý�ãW×`Ú�áÚ�áÁ���a×�ØÁ�N�d��Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý%ú7�,ÿ 839;:;<

�� �E� ( ëIëdö í õ�� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�æ�ç�Ø �E�.�Á���/Ú�� ���N���dÚ��Åß,�.�EØ,�Lá,×aØÁà�EØ,� ��×aØÁ�N�d��Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ýy�E�®é�ê�ë ( õ ( ø4ö ø � î9øcù8�#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý�è#ã®�Ë�Á��å<ØÁ���ÅÜ<���Eß<�dß<×a��×aÝ�Ú�×a�&�a×aØÁ�N�d�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ýiú� ÿ 9;:;<

��E��Ü,���Eß<�dß�×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×�� �#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý�æ

� Ú��.�E�¸��� H@���Gà¾×`âE�NÝy�.×�Ý��&Ú����EØG×�تÚ�����Ü<����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø R���M �E)5��� G� ú ��NþJÿ �-�.� �Iú ú� ÿ ÿ

��

�4�E� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý�èuã�áÁ����� �E)5��� G� ú ��NþJÿ �-�2�/×aÝ�Ú�áÁ�����dÚ�Ú�×a�¸���E���4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý 5 G� � ��Nþ���E�.�Á���.�N�GÜ#�¾×aتÚ]ãW×aÝ��Eèã�áÁ�������ÅÜ,�.�N�,×a���dÚ�� $ H � � ×�Ý�×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��N� �EÝ&×`Ú�Ý��Lá,�d�.�E�¸Ú����.×aÝ�Ú�×a��9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Øèu×cæ³�Eæ`èu�4�E���E�a� = � óã®�Éá,�IâE�Gú ú $<ÿ ÿ

�� =��+M þÊ×`� �A H $�èu�EØ,�"ú ú $,ÿ ÿ

�� =��IM ó×a�

�A �H)$�æ �¤×aÛ�×��a�d�.�`Þ�Ú��&Ú�áÁ��ß��°�¾�`�N�EØË���EÝ��EèjÚ�á,���Á��å<Ø<×`Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý ��þ>��� �0��þ!���B���EØËß#�WÝ�×aÛ�Ü<�a×`å,�N��èÝ�×aØ<�¸�i��âE���.Þ Ý�Ú��dÚ��/�E� Ú�áÁ��Ú��.�E�¸�Ìá<�EÝy�ÊÝ.×aØÁà¾�`��Ý��,���¸�NÝ�Ý��E�Næ�"Á�E�+�E�a� � 9 5 G� ú ��NþJÿ®�EØ,���H � þ � ���Ëã �Ì�`��ÚÌú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ � ��� � M ��=�? ��� =, þ%�Læ 6×aâE�NØ �����`�¾Ý��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý6�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�� H ����� � è<ã �+�Á��å�ØÁ�yÚ�áÁ�6é�ê�ë ( õ ( ø4ö ø � î9øcù/öUø � í õdê ��í�ô õ��<î9ø9ù � ú7�,ÿ 9;:;<�

9 � � G� ú ��NþJÿ��E���IâE����Ú�áÁ��Ý���Ú��E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ<� ßjÞÊÚ��dä¤×aØÁà/Ú�áÁ�yâd�E�a�Á�y�E� �%�IâE���WÚ�á,��å,�.Ý�Ú?Ý�Ú��dÚ��+�E�uÚ�áÁ�+Ú��.�E�¸��9Ý�Ü#�N��×`å<���E���`ÞEè¤ã®�+�a��Ú+ú7�Áÿ 9;:;<

�� � � M ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ����� � �Læ

ç�Ø�Ú�áÁ�6�Á��å<Ø<×`Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý ��þ * �Lè ��þ ��¿�E�Ú�áÁ�WÜ<���Eß<�dß<×a��×aÝ�Ú�×a�B�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�#�EØ,��âE���.×aå<���dÚ�×`�¾ØËÜ,���EßÁÙ�`�NÛ�ÝNè�Ú�áÁ�%Ü,�.�EÜ����.ÚYÞ 3 ×aÝ�� Ý���ÚÌ�E�6Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ�æ ��� �¸�¾Û/Ü<�`��Ú��%�¾�Á�Ë�¸�¾Ø,Ø,�N�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø¶ãW×aÚ�á Ú�áÁ�Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×a�y�a×aØÁ�N�d�6Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý/ú� ÿ 9;:;<

�è�ã �/ØÁ���N� Ú��É�,��å<ØÁ�&�ÊÜ,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×�Ý�Ú�×a�6âE���.Ý�×a�¾Øó�E�

Ú�áÁ�NÝ�� Ü,���Eß��`�NÛ�Ý�æ¿����Ú�� 9����HG � ú ��NþJÿyß�� � �9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×a�¾Ø¶Ú�á,�dÚÉ×aÝÊÛ/�N�EÝ��Á�.�dß��`�ó×aØ Ú�áÁ�Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×`Ú]ÞÌÝ�Ü<�E�¸�8� ��� ���K��ü�� � S%� � PL �LèÁ�4�E���E��� �0G H9��GW�EØ,�7�5J H9� JZæ 7G�&�,��å<ØÁ��9

��þ �� & � M���8 H5� ? Ý��,Ü� S F� S

×aØÁ�� P F� P ' � S%� �

PL ����

��� �� & � M���8 H5� ? ��,� P F� P

×aØÁ�� SOF� S ' � S%� � PL ����-?

��áÁ�®���N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø<Ý�á,×`Ü&ß���Ú]ã®���NØ�Ú�á,�®Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×�Ý�Ú�×a���a×aØÁ�N�d���EØ,�&ß,�.�EØ,�Lá,×aØÁà�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý�×aÝuÚ�áÁ�NØ��!¤Ü,���NÝ�Ý��N��ßjÞÊÚ�áÁ���4�¾�a�`�SãW×aØÁàiÚ�áÁ���E���NÛÅæ

� ' � ���� � � ��ëdê�õdö\ö�÷ªõ ôÌí � î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í4� ( õdö4ö�� H � þ � ��� ( õ��5�Åõdö4ö�ùNöµë �Ní �+��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � ���ëdê ô �¤ö`õ � � H ����� � ø6� � î9ê�ë��j÷EöUï � í î í ê ô ø6�,ø � î9øcù �¸ëdê ô õ��5�-ù.ë��<îfõdø �,ø6�°÷�ë��<ö ï î # í��� ��ùNî9øcë�� � ï ô)( ëdö,é�ê í � ( �®í #°õ�� í î #¤õEî?ú ú7�Áÿ ÿ & M �J�O�� & ú7�,ÿ 9;:;<�� 2"Á�E��Ü<�a�NÞE���iþdè,Ú�áÁ���dß#�IâE�&Ú�áÁ���E���NÛñÝ�Ú��dÚ��NÝWÚ�á,�dÚW�\�E�W�E����8IH5� & è

ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & ��8�� M Ý��ÁÜ� SKF� S

×aØÁ�� P F� P ' � S � �

PL ��ú7�,ÿ 9;:;<�� �-? ���¤þ%�

��á,×�Ý��Nð°�,�dÚ�×`�¾ØG���EØ ß������N�E�G�EÝ��\�¾�a�a�IãWÝ�9#Ú�áÁ�/âd�E�a�Á���E�B�Å�¸�¾ØªÚ��.�¾� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý��4�E�.Ûi�,�a�ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & ×�Ý��Nð°�,�E�ªÚ���Ú�áÁ� Û�� !¤×�Û��E�¾��!¤Ü#�N�¸Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØiÚ�á,�dÚ�Ü<���NÞE���?þ¿���EØià¾�,�d�.�EØjÚ���� �\�E��Ú�áÁ�BÝ��EÛ/��4�E�.Û&�<�a�¤èÁ��âZ�E���,�dÚ��N�Å�¾Ø��a×�ØÁ�N�d�?Ú��.�E�¸�NÝ�æ��WáÁ�yÚ�áÁ���E���NÛ ���N�a�dÚ��NÝ�ØÁ�EÚW�¾Ø,�`ÞÌÚ�á,�yß,�.�EØ,�Lá,×aØÁà�EØ,�ËÚ�áÁ����×aØÁ�N�d�¿Ü<���Eß<�dß<×a��×aÝ�Ú�×a�BÝ��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý�è°ß<�ÁÚ �E�aÝ��i�+à¾�`�Eß��E�<�EÜ,Ú�×�Û�× #N�dÚ�×`�¾ØÌÜ,���Eß<�`�NÛ Ú�����`�¤���E�Á�¾ØÁ�EæjçQØ����¤þ%��Ú�áÁ���L×`à¾áªÚ�ÙYá<�EØ,��Ý�×a�,�?����Ü,���NÝ��NØjÚ�Ý��yà¾�a�Eß<�E�,�EÜ,Ú�×�Û�× #N�dÚ�×`�¾Ø�Ü,�.�Eß<�`�NÛ 9Ü<�a�IÞE����þ�×aÝ�Ú���Þ°×�ØÁàËÚ���ÛÌ� !¤×aÛÌ× #��&Ú�á,�iâd�E�a�Á���E�®Ú�áÁ���4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø ú7�Áÿ 9;:;<

��IâE����Ú��.�E�¸�NÝNè��EØ,�

Ü<�a�IÞE�����Ë×�Ý�Ú��.Þ°×aØ,àÌÚ��Å�EÜ,Ü#�¾Ý��iÚ�á,×aÝ�æ0�6Ø Ú�áÁ���`���\Ú�ÙYá<�EØ,� Ý�×a�Á�Eè��¾Ø Ú�áÁ�&�EÚ�á,����á,�EØ,�è�Ú�áÁ��EÜ,Ú�×aÛÌ× #N�dÚ�×`�¾Ø ×aÝ/�`�¤���E�cè�ß#�N×aØÁà Ü#�����4�E�.Û/�N� Ú�áÁ���¾�Áà¾á Ú�á,�Å��âZ�E�a�<�dÚ�×`�¾Ø �E��Ú�áÁ�Å�EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�ú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ & �dÚW�E�a�Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ��E� � æ

þ>�

Page 17: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

� � Ö��dÕ¤Ò�Ô®Ï�Ð'�<Ó.- �<ÑªÖ /BÕ ��оÖYÒ�Ï �Ï¿Ó 1ËÒ�ÏuÐEÑ¾Ò �

ç�Ø Ú�áÁ�Éß#�°�¾�`�N�EØ �EØ<� Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×�Ý�Ú�×a�/Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØ,à¾Ý�è�Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ&�d���ÅÝ�Ü#�N��×`å,�N� �EÝ ��Ùf�.��à¾�,�a�d��a�EØÁà¾�<�dàE�NÝ�è,�EØ,�Å�E�`àE�E�.×aÚ�á,Û�Ý?�d���y�NØ,�¸�¤�Á�N�Å�EÝ?å�!°Ü#�¾×aØjÚ®��!¤Ü,���NÝ.Ý�×`�¾Ø,ÝB×aØÊÚ�áÁ�4�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�æ��áÁ��Û��E×aØÌÚ�áÁ���E���NÛ�Ý�è¤Ý��,�LáË�EÝ ��á,���E���NÛ�þ��EØ,�8��áÁ���E���NÛ &°èj��!¤Ü,���NÝ.Ý¿Ú�áÁ�����N�a�dÚ�×a�¾Ø,Ý�á,×`Üß#��ÚYã ���NØ Ú�áÁ�ÉÜ,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ��EØ,� Ú�áÁ� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ýiå !¤Ü��¾×�تÚ�Ý&Ú�á,�dÚ/Ý��¾�`âE�ÉÚ�áÁ�ÉâE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Ø�EØ,�"�¸�¾ØjÚ����¾�yÜ,���Eß��`�NÛ�Ý�æ ��áÁ�G�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü#�¾Ø,�,�NØ,�¸�óß#��Ú]ã®���NØ Ú�á,� ß<�.�EØ,�.á<×aØÁà �EØ<� �a×aØÁ�N�d�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý&Ý�����âE�NÝiÛ��E×aØ,�`ÞóÚ��%���a�d�.×a�\Þ Ú�áÁ�����N���dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý�á,×aÜ ß#��Ú]ã®���NØ Ú�áÁ�Ì�`�¤���E���EÜ,Ú�×�Û�× #N�ZÙÚ�×`�¾Ø Ú�á,�dÚ/Ú��däE�NÝ�Ü<�a�E�¸�Å×aØ Ú�áÁ�Åß,�.�EØ<�.á,×aØ,à Ý��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��ÝNè��EØ<� Ú�áÁ�Éà¾�`�Eß<�E�B�EÜ,Ú�×aÛÌ× #N�dÚ�×`�¾ØÚ�á,�dÚ�Ú��däE�NÝ6Ü<�a�E�¸�+×aØ%Ú�áÁ�&��×aØÁ�N�d�WÝ��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��ÝNæ<ç�Ø�Ú�áÁ�i�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�%Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàÁè<�¾ØóÚ�áÁ�&�EÚ�áÁ���á,�EØ,��èjã ���LáÁ�°�¾Ý���ØÁ�EÚ?á,�NâE�y�EØÅ×aØ<�Á��Ü#�NØ,�Á�NØjÚ¿ØÁ�EÚ�×`�¾ØÊ�E���,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�ËÜ<���EÜ#����ÚYÞ09j�L�dÚ�áÁ���Nè�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�¶Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ��d�.�óÝ�Ü#�N��×`å,�N� ß°Þ Ú�áÁ�%��×aØÁ�N�d�ÌÝ��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��ÝÌ�E�y�\�E�LÛ&�,���EÝ/�E�yÚ�áÁ��,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,ÝNæ���áÁ�+ÛÌ�E×aØÅ���NÝ��<�`Ú�Ý?�4�E�WÚ�áÁ�i�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N��Ý���Ú�Ú�×�ØÁàË�¸�¾Ø,�¸���LØ�Ú�á°�,ÝÚ�áÁ�Ë���N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý.á,×`ÜGß#��ÚYã ���NØ Ú�áÁ�Ë�a×�ØÁ�N�d�+Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý �9�,Ý��N� Ú��ó��!¤Ü,���NÝ�Ý+Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ��6�EØ,�Ú�áÁ�6ß,�.�EØ<�.á,×aØ,àiÝ��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��Ý1�4ã�á,×a�.áÊ����Ü<���NÝ��NØjÚ�Ý?�E�`àE�E�.×`Ú�á,ÛÌÝ��¿�E�u�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�8�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�è�EÝ?ã �N�a��EÝ?Ú�áÁ�y�.�N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý�á<×`ÜÉß���Ú]ã®���NØ�Ú�áÁ���,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N�ÅÝ���Ú�Ú�×�ØÁà��EØ,�ÅÚ�áÁ���<Ø,�,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N��¾ØÁ�Eæ���Ý�ß#�EÚ�áGÜ<���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ��EØ,� �E�`àE�E�.×`Ú�á,ÛÌÝ��d���Ì�Á��å�ØÁ�N� ×aØ Ú����.ÛÌÝ��E�BÚ�áÁ� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�èã ��ß#��à¾×aØÉßjÞÉ×aØjÚ����¤�,�,��×aØÁà��,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,ÝNæ

� ��� �6�����"!����!� � .0 ��������!�� ! �6×`âE�NØ"� Ý���Ú � �E�+Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ%�EØ,�"� Ý���Ú�� �E� �Eø � ù.ë�� �<î���õ¾ùIîfëdê � ( Ú�á,� Ý���Ú�= ��� � � � �E��,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ý6�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝy�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×�Ý�Ú�Ýy�E�B�E�a��Ú�áÁ���4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝy�Á��å<Ø,�N� �IâE���+Ú�á,��Ý���Ú�E��Ü,���N�,×a���dÚ��NÝ � � M � �Å�EØ,�ÅÚ�á,�+Ý���Ú��E���4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý

"�M � �#é�ê í � �.��þ�� � �" E�é�ê í � � � H � þ � ����� � H�� ���

ãWáÁ���.� �6�,�E�H� �é�ê í G � M ��þ � ��� �é�ê í J �EØ,� ���<�E� � �#é�ê í J � M ��þ � � � �#é�ê í G æ��Ý/×aØ Ú�áÁ�ÉÜ,���Eß<�dß�×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×��Ì���EÝ��Eè�à¾×`âE�NØ � à¾�EÛ/��Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,��� � M � � ��� ��� G ��� J �����Lè¿ã �×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú?Ú�á,�NÝ����4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝB�IâE����Ú�áÁ���a�dÚ�Ú�×a�¸�.)5� �FG� ú ��NþJÿ �-�.���E���4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý���G� ú ��NþJÿfè�E�.�Á���.�N� Ü#�¾×aتÚ]ãW×aÝ��Eæ���à¾�E×aØè�ã �%�Á��å�ØÁ�ÅØÁ��à¾�dÚ�×`�¾Ø¶ß°ÞF5�� M ��8 H ��?aþ � � ��8��LæF��áÁ�×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×a�¾Ø��E��Ü,���N�<×a���dÚ��NÝ��EØ<���9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý�×aÝ�Ü��d�.�EÛ/��Ú����.× #��N�óß°ÞÉ� �dø � ùLë�� �<î �¸õªùNîfëdêø �<î í êYé�ê í îfõEî9øcë���� 9�� G� ú ��NþJÿfèÁÚ�á,�dÚ��EÝ.Ý�×`à¾Ø,Ý Ú����N�E�.á��<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ®�9�E�¸Ú��E� � H� ×`Ú�Ý âd�E�a�Á�� � ��� H ú ��NþJÿfæ°��Ý ×aØ/Ú�áÁ��Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×aÝ�Ú�×a�BÝ��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��ÝNèªã ��×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú¿Ú�áÁ�WÜ,�.�N�,×a���dÚ��NÝ $ H,��EÝ6Ú�áÁ�N×`�y�Lá,�d�.�E�¸Ú����.×aÝ�Ú�×a���4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Øè#×cæ³�Eæ`è�ú ú $,ÿ ÿ� & � � M � � $ �Læ0"Á�E�+�E�a� � H ���8G� ú ��NþJÿ ���EØ,��E�a� � H � þ � ���¾è<ã �+�`��Ú�9

ú ú;�#é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & � � ��� � M �58 H5��?�� � ���¸ú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & ��� ����8�� ���'���ú ú ��þ ��� � E�#é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & � � ��� � M �58 H5��? ��þ���� � � � �" �� � ���¸ú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & ��� ����8 �-? ����&��

��á°�,Ý�è Ú�áÁ� �,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�"×aØjÚ�����Ü,�.��Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø-�E�1�é�ê í � ×aÝÊ�Nð°�,�E�6Ú�� Ú�áÁ� Ü,���Eß<�dß�×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×���×aؤÙÚ�����Ü,�.��Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø �E�®é�ê í � èu�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� ß°Þ ���4�E�¸Ú��E��� &�Ú�áÁ�Ì�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N� ×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØG�E���þ �/���� �é�ê í � ×aÝ®�Nðj�<�E��Ú���Ú�áÁ�6Ü,�.�Eß<�dß<×a�a×�Ý�Ú�×a�?×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×a�¾ØÌ�E��é�ê í � èÁ�,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N�ËßjÞ�Å�9�E�¸Ú��E�&�E���¿è��EØ,� ãW×`Ú�á þ � �-�E�,�Á�N� Ú��ó×`Ú�æ 7G�Ê�Á�NØÁ�EÚ��ËßjÞ �dø � ù � � �����IM �E)5� � G�ú ��NþJÿ �-�.� �Iú ú� ÿ ÿ & � � ��Ú�áÁ�W���NÝ.�,�`Ú�×aØÁàyÝ��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��Ý¿�\�E�®Ú�áÁ� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�è¾�EØ,�Ìã®��ã��.×`Ú��+ú ú� ÿ ÿ & � � �4�E�ú ú�³ÿ ÿ�� + � � J & � �QN èÁ�¾ÛÌ×`Ú�Ú�×aØÁà � ãWá,�NØÅ���`�N�d�W�4���¾Û Ú�áÁ���¸�¾ØjÚ���!¤Ú�æ

þ!�

Page 18: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

7"á,×a�`� ���'���6×aÝ�Ú�áÁ�/��!¤Ü#�N�¸Ú��N�G�Á��å<Ø,×aÚ�×`�¾Øè ����&������Nðj�<×`���NÝ6Ý��¾Û/� ��,Ý�Ú�×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Øæ�ò �¾Ø¤ÙÝ�×a�,����� à¾�EÛ/�%Ý�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á��� � M#� � ��� ��� G ��� J ���I�Læ "�×`�.Ý�Ú�è�ØÁ�EÚ�×��¸�ÅÚ�á,�dÚ/Ú�á,×aÝ/�Á��å�Ø,×`Ú�×`�¾Ø�NØ,Ý��,���NÝBÚ�á,�dÚBé�ê í G �EØ,� ��þ �����" #�#é�ê í J �d�����<�,�E� 9,×aØÉ�9�E�¸Ú�è,�4�E�R8IH0� ã®�&á,�NâE�

þ�� ú ú;�é�ê í G ÿ ÿ � ��� ����8 �LM þ���� � � �¸ú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ ��� ����8 �M þ���� � � �" � � ��� ��� � � �¸ú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ ��� ����8��M ��þ���� � � � �" �� � ��� � þ ��ú ú é�ê í G ÿ ÿ ��� ����8 ���M ��þ���� � � � �" �� � ���¸ú ú é�ê í J ÿ ÿ �K5 � ����8 �M ú ú ��þ � � � #�é�ê í J ÿ ÿ � �K5 � ����8��-?

��áÁ���,��å<Ø,×`Ú�×`�¾Ø<Ý ���'�����EØ,� ����&������EØ��E�aÝ���ß#� ��,Ý�Ú�×`å,�N�Éß°ÞÉÝ�áÁ�Iã�×aØÁà�áÁ�Sã Ú�áÁ�����NÝ.�,�`Ú�×aØÁàÜ,���N�,�N�¸�NÝ�Ý��E���EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�.ÝË���Eضß#���,Ý��N�¶Ú�� Ý��¾�`âE�%�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� ���N�E�Lá,�dß<×a�a×aÚYÞ �EØ,�¶Ý��d�4��ÚYÞà¾�EÛ/�NÝ�×aØÅ�/ãB�NÞ��EØ,�E�a�EàE�¾�,Ý�Ú�����þ>$����EØ,� ��þNý��Læ�����Ú 38B?� ß#����Ý���Ú��E��Ú��d��àE��Ú�Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�è�EØ,� å ! �óÜ��a�NÞE��� ��H � þ � ���¾æ ò �¾Ø,Ý�×��Á���/� �Eø � ù.ë�� �<î í � ê í õ¾ù #°õ ( ø\öUø4î9ï ÷ªõ ôÌí$( ×aØ ãWá,×��.áÜ<�a�IÞE���4��àE��Ú�Ý Ú�áÁ�WÜ��NÞE� ( � � ��� A ãWáÁ�NØ�Ú�á,�WÚ��d��àE��Ú 3"×�Ý����N�E�LáÁ�N�Ë�d�4Ú���� =�Ý�Ú���Ü�Ý�èj�EØ,�ÌÚ�áÁ�Ü<�IÞE� ( �×`�%3 ×aÝBØÁ�EÚ?���N�E�LáÁ�N�æ���áÁ�yÛ�� !Á×aÛi�,Û Ü<�NÞE� (GÚ�á,�dÚ?Ü��a�NÞE���(�����EØ�à¾�,�d�.�EØjÚ����+×aÝà¾×`âE�NØÅß°Þ

ú ú �ML�? ��3#(��é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ � ? ��� * ���Ý��EØ"��!¤�EÛ�Ü<�`�Eè��¸�¾Ø,Ý�×��Á�����dà¾�E×aØ"Ú�áÁ�Gà¾�EÛ/� *-,�.0/21�3546.�è��E�`�¾ØÁà ãW×`Ú�á"Ú�áÁ�G�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�ú ú �ML%? � � 8�> ? ADC � ( �#é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ�� è�EØ,� �`��Ú�� M � � � �Læ�����Ú �4:+M ��8 ?É�EØ,�è#�4�E� = H65?è��`��Ú�4A�B G M � � � 8�>@?BADC � � � ú ú;�#é�ê í G ÿ ÿ � ���4A��Læ�7G�i���EØóâE���.×`�4ÞÉÚ�á,�dÚ��4:���8�9;:�</�LM ¤è � G ��8�9 :�< �LM��� GJ �% GJ �jþ%� M��J è � J ��8�9;:�</� M���� GJ ��J GJ �¾þ%� M��J � P� è<�EØ<���a×aÛ A�F�H �4A ��8�9;:�</� M� � ��� ��� � M ú ú �ML�? � � 8 > ? ADC � (��#é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ�� ��8�9;:�< �Læò �¾Ø<Ý�×a�Á���ÊØÁ�Iã � �dø � ùLë�� �<î í � � õ � í î9ïG÷ªõ ô�í$( ×aضã�á,×a�.á Ü<�a�IÞE���1�iàE��Ú�ÝÊÚ�áÁ� Ü<�NÞE� (þ ��� � � � A ×`��Ú�áÁ�yà¾�EÛ���Ý�Ú��NÞ¤ÝW×aØ83 �4�E� =É�¸�¾Ø,Ý��N���,Ú�×`âE��Ý�Ú���Ü<Ý�è,�EØ<�ÉÚ�áÁ�yÜ<�NÞE� (¶þy×`�%3 ×aÝØÁ��âE�����`���\Ú�æ��WáÁ��Û�� !Á×aÛ&�<Û Ü<�NÞE� ( Ú�á,�dÚWÜ<�a�NÞE��� �®���EØÅà¾�,�d�L�EتÚ����i×aÝ?à¾×`âE�NØÅß°Þ

ú ú; L�? ��3 * ��þ�� � � #�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ � ? ���' ��

ç�Ø,�Á���N�èÁ�¾ØÁ�����EØ%âE���.×`�4ÞËÚ�á<�dÚ��\�E���E�a��8IH0� èÁã®�&á,�NâE�þ � ú ú �ML%? ��3 ( �#é�ê í G ��L � �Yÿ ÿ � ��8�� M ú ú; L�? � & 3 * ��þ �����" #�#é�ê í J ��L � �Yÿ ÿ � ��8 � �������

×aØ,�<×a���dÚ�×aØÁàiÚ�á,�dÚWÚ�á,�yÜ<�NÞE� ( Ü<���NÞE���&þ+���EØ�à¾�,�d�.�EØjÚ����&×�ØÅ���,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N�@3WÙf���N�E�.á,�dß�×a�a×`Ú]Þà¾�EÛ/�B×aÝu�Nðj�,�E�jÚ���þ¿Û�×aØ°�,Ý�Ú�áÁ�®Ü��NÞE� (ÌÚ�á,�dÚ�Ü<�a�IÞE��� �W���EØ&à¾�,�d�.�EØjÚ����B�\�E��Ú�áÁ�B�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�& 3�ÙYÝ.�d�\��Ú]ÞÊà¾�EÛ��Eæ

��ß#�IâE�Eè6ã®� á,�IâE� ×�ØÁ�\�E�LÛ��E�a�`Þ"×aØjÚ����°�<�,�¸�N� �,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� ���N�E�Lá,�dß<×a��×`ÚYÞ �EØ,��Ý��d�4��ÚYÞà¾�EÛ/�NÝó×aØ"Ú����.Û�Ý%�E�&Ü<�IÞE� (#Ý �EÝ�Ý��¤��×a�dÚ��N� ãW×`Ú�á"Ú�áÁ�GÚ��.�E�¸�NÝNæ.,��Iã �d�.� Ú�áÁ�NÝ�� Ü��NÞE� (Ý�Á��å<Ø,�N�è¤�\�E��Û/�E���yàE�NØÁ���.�E��àE�¾�E�aÝ �+��Ø<�ÅãWá,�dÚ�×aÝ�Ú�áÁ�yÜ,���N��×aÝ����Á��å<Ø,×`Ú�×a�¾ØË�E��Ú�áÁ�yà¾�EÛ��NÝÚ�á,�dÚ ��� * ���EØ,� ���' ���Ý��¾�`âE� � ���Ë�EØ,Ý�ã ����Ú�áÁ�NÝ��+ð°�Á�NÝ�Ú�×a�¾Ø,Ý�èÁã �+×aØjÚ����°�<�,�¸�yÚ�áÁ�+�a×�ØÁ�N�d�?Ý��¸ÙÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý��E�®�,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N���#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ý�è��EØ,� ã®���¾Ø,�¸�/Û/�E�.�&���N���dÚ��iÚ�á,����×aØÁ�N�d�6Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��ÝÚ���Ú�áÁ�+ß,�.�EØ,�Lá,×aØÁà��¾ØÁ�Eæ

þ>$

Page 19: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

� ��� ��' � � � ����� � ��� ���� ��Q�4� + �� � ����!���� ���!.0 ������ !�� ! �� �dø � ùLë�� �<î í �Åé�ê�ëLé í êJî9ï ×aÝ&Ú�áÁ�Å×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø �E��� �,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N���#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý+�4�E�.Ûi�,�a��IâE���ó�a×aØÁ�N�d�ÊÚ��.�E�¸�NÝ�æ.�¤×�Û�×a�a�d�.�aÞ Ú�� Ú�áÁ� Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×a�Å���EÝ��Eè?Ú�áÁ�G�a×aØ,�N�d�ÊÝ��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��ÝÉ�E��,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ýy�EÝ�Ý��°��×a�dÚ��NÝ+ãW×`Ú�á �N�E�.á Ú��.�E�¸�Ì�ÅØ°�,Û&ß#����×aØ Ú�áÁ��×aØjÚ�����âd�E��ú ��NþJÿ�Eß,Ú��E×aØ,�N�¶ß°Þ ��âZ�E�a�<�dÚ�×aØÁà Ú�áÁ���#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý��4�E�.Û&�<�a�G�IâE���ÉÚ�áÁ�óÚ��.�E�¸�Eè?�EØ,�¶Ú��dä¤×aØÁà Ú�áÁ�âd�E�a�Á���dÚ�Ú�áÁ��×�Ø,×`Ú�×a�E�#Ý�Ú��dÚ��&�E�uÚ�áÁ�+Ú��.�E�¸�Eæ

ò �¾Ø<Ý�×a�Á������Ý���Ú�� �E�/�,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚÅ�4�E�¸Ú��E�.ÝNè��E�`�¾ØÁà ãW×`Ú�á �¶�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚÅ�4�E�¸Ú��E� ×aØjÚ�����ÙÜ,����Ú��dÚ�×a�¾Ø � 9� G� ú ��NþJÿfæ�� Ú��.�E�¸�� H � � à¾×`âE�NÝ �.×aÝ�� Ú����EØ ×�تÚ�����Ü<����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØR ��M �E)5�� G� ú ��NþJÿ �-�.� �Iú ú� ÿ ÿ

� � ��#�4�E��Ú�á,�®�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�<Ý��4�E�.Û&�<�a�EÝ�×aØ&= ��� � � � æ��Ý®×aØÌÚ�áÁ�WÜ<���Eß<�dß<×a��×aÝ�Ú�×a�B���EÝ��Eè¤�E�a�,Ü<���N�,×a���dÚ��NÝ $ H � �Ë�d���6×aتÚ����.Ü,����Ú��N�Ì�EÝ®Ú�áÁ�N×`� �.á,�d�L�E�JÙ

Ú����.×aÝ�Ú�×a�?�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Øèj×cæ³�Eæ`èª�4�E� �E����= � +ã®�6á,�NâE�/ú ú $,ÿ ÿ �� =�� M þ�×`����A H $�èj�EØ,� ú ú $,ÿ ÿ

�� =��LM

×`� �A �H)$�æ���áÁ���,��å<Ø,×`Ú�×`�¾Ø<Ý ���'�����EØ,� ����&������EØÅß#��Ý�×aÛ/Ü<��×`å,�N�è°Ý�×aØ,�¸��×aØÅ��Ú��L�E�¸�Eè<��âE����Þ�`�¤���dÚ�×`�¾Ø�á,�EÝW��Ý�×aØÁà¾�a�6Ý.�,���¸�NÝ�Ý��E�Næ5"Á�E���E�a��� 9 5 G� ú ��NþJÿ��EØ,� � H � þ � ���&ã �+�`��Ú

ú ú;�#é�ê í � ÿ ÿ � � � ��� �LM ��=�? � � � ��� � � = þ%� �ú ú ��þ �����" #�#é�ê í � ÿ ÿ � � � ��� �LM ��=�? � ��þ�� � � � � �" �� � � � ��� =1 "þ%� � ?

6×`âE�NØ � ���`�¾Ý��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý+�\�E�LÛ&�,���/� H(= ��� � � � è�ã®�ÊÚ�áÁ�NØ �Á��å<ØÁ�Ì×aÚ�Ý��dø � ùLë�� �<î í �öUø6� í õdê ��í�ô õ��<î9øcù � ú7�,ÿ�39;:;<

� � �9�� � G� ú ��NþJÿißjÞ ú7�,ÿ�39;:;<

� � �� � � M ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ����� � �Læ�� �dø � ùLë�� �<î í �

é�ê�ëLé í êJî9ïG×aÝ�Ú�áÁ�/Û��dÜ,Ü�×aØÁà�� � G� ú ��NþJÿ �Á��å<ØÁ�N� ß°Þ�Ú�áÁ���a×aØ,�N�d��Ý��NÛÌ�EتÚ�×a��Ý�ú7�,ÿ 39;:;<� � �

�E�B����`�¾Ý��N�%�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,ÝB�4�E�.Û&�<�a�,� H = ��� � � � æ��ÝW�EØ%��!¤�EÛ/Ü��`�Eè<�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×��Á���W�dà¾�E×aØó��Ý��Áß<Ý���ÚJ3�B � �E��Ú��d��àE��Ú�Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ�è��EØ,�ó�/Ü<�a�IÞE����LH � þ � ���¾æ0��á,�yÜ<�NÞE� ( �E��Ú�áÁ�+�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�Å���N�E�Lá,�dß<×a�a×aÚYÞÊà¾�EÛ/�+�¸�¾Ø,Ý�×��Á�����N��×aØ,�\�E�.ÛÌ�E�a�`Þ×aØ-�°�N�¸Ú�×a�¾Ø °æaþ+���EØÅß#���Á��å�ØÁ�N�ÉßjÞGú �ML%? ��3 (��é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ�39;:;<� � �

9<×aØ<�Á���N�è

ú �ML%? ��3#(F�#é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ 39;:;<� � �� � � M � � ��� A �

ãWáÁ���.�E= MñÛ�×aØ � D H 5 � � B H 3I�¾æ���á,���4�E�¸ÚiÚ�á,�dÚ ��� * �+����Ü,���NÝ��NØjÚ�Ý&Ú�áÁ�ËÛ�� !Á×aÛi�,ÛÜ<�IÞE� ( Ú�á,�dÚ�Ü<�a�IÞE���+þ����EØ��E�Lá,×`��âE�i×aØÅ�/à¾�EÛ/�+Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á��� � ���EØ%ß#���4�E�.Û��E��× #��N���EÝ

��þ � � & ú �ML�? ��3 ( �é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ 39;:;<� � �M ú ú �ML%? ��3 (F�#é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & � � ? �������

�¤×aÛÌ×a�a�d�.�`ÞEèªÚ�áÁ�6Ü<�NÞE� ( �E��Ú�áÁ�y�,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�ÊÝ.�d�\��Ú]ÞËà¾�EÛ/���¸�¾Ø<Ý�×a�Á�����N�É×aØ,�\�E�.ÛÌ�E�a�`Þ/×aØ �°�N�JÙÚ�×`�¾Ø °æaþ+���EØ�ß#���Á��å<ØÁ�N�Éß°ÞGú; L%? ��3 * ��þ���� � #�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ�C9;:;<� � �

9,×aØ<�Á���N�è

ú; L%? ��3 * ��þ���� � #�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ 39;:;<� � �� � � M þ���� � ��� A �

ãWáÁ���.� = M Û�×aØ � D H 5 � � B �H 3��¾æ#����Ý��Ë×aØ%Ú�á,×aÝ����EÝ��Eè#�\�E�6�E�a�uà¾�EÛ/�iÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á���NÝ � ã �á,�IâE��9

��þ � � & ú; L%? ��3 * ��þ���� � #�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ C9;:;<� � �M ú ú; L%? ��3 * ��þ���� � #�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & � � ? ����$��

��áÁ�%���N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý��������Ë�EØ,� ����$��Ì�d��� ��,Ý�ÚËÚYã � Ý�Ü��N��×��E�����EÝ��NÝÊ�E�yÚ�áÁ�%àE�NØ,���.�E�W�.�N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Øß#��ÚYã ���NØ%Ú�á,�&�a×aØ,�N�d�W�EØ,��ß<�.�EØ,�.á<×aØÁà�Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý��E���,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ý�è<��!°Ü,�.�NÝ�Ý��N�ß°ÞËÚ�áÁ�+�\�¾�a�a�IãW×aØ,àiÚ�á,���E���NÛÅæ

þNý

Page 20: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

� ' � ���� ��� ��ëdêóõdö4ö¿÷ªõ ôÌí-� î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í�� � ( õdö4ö�é�ö`õdï í ê � ��H � þ � ��� ( õdö4ö ��í î � � ë ��dø � ùLë�� �<î���õ¾ùNîfëdê � ( õdö4ö �dø � ù.ë�� ��î��¸õªùNîfëdê í �dõdö �Áõ¾î9ø9ë�� � � H ����G � ú ��NþJÿ � ( õ��2�%õdö4ö�ù�ö`ë ��í ���ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � � ��ëdê ô �°ö`õ � � H'= ��� � � � ø6� � î9ê�ë��°÷EöUï � í î í ê ô ø6�<ø � î9ø9ù ��ëdê ô î #°õEî�ù.ë��<îfõdø �ë��,öUï î # í ��� ��ùIî9ø9ë�� � ï ô)( ëEö � �é�ê í � õ��5� ��þ � � � �#é�ê í � ��ëdê,� H � (��®í #°õ�� í î #¤õEîú ú7�,ÿ ÿ� & � � M��J�O� � & ú7�,ÿ�39;:;<� � � 2��á,×�Ý?Ú�áÁ���E���NÛ'×aÝ�Ú�á,�&Û��E×aØ����NÝ��,�`Ú��dß��¾�,Ú�Ú�áÁ�+âE���L×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾Øó�E���,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N��Ü<���EÜ#����Ú�×`�NÝ�è�EÝi×`Ú+���N���dÚ��NÝ&� �,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N� Ü,���EÜ#����ÚYÞ¶ú7�,ÿ 39;:;<

� � �Ú�� Ú�áÁ�Ìâd�E�a�,�dÚ�×`�¾Ø-ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & � � �¸�¾Û/Ü<�ÁÚ��N� ßjÞ

Ú�áÁ��âE���L×`å<���dÚ�×`�¾ØÅ�E�`àE�E�L×`Ú�á,Û �%�IâE����Ú�áÁ��à¾�EÛ��+Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,��� � æ� í î í ê ô ø ��õ¾ù�ï 2 �Á×aØ,�¸�+�,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N��Ü,���EÜ#����Ú�×a�NÝ��d���&�,��å<ØÁ�NÝW�EÝ�Ú�áÁ�i�a×aØÁ�N�d��Ý��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��ÝW�E��,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ý6�4�E�.Ûi�,�a�EÝ�è#Ú�áÁ���,�<�E�a×`ÚYÞó�E� �<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�G�¸�¾ØªÚ��.�¾��Ü,���Eß<�a�NÛ�Ýy���EØß#��Ý�Ú��dÚ��N�%�EÝW�\�¾���`�IãWÝNæ� ' � ���� ��� ��ëdê/õdö4ö#÷jõ ôÌí � î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í��<� ( õEö\ö ��í î � � ë �+�dø � ùLë�� �<î ��õ¾ùNîfëdê � ( õdö4ö �dø � ìù.ë�� ��î4��õ¾ùIîfëdê í �Zõdö �,õEî9øcë�� � � H ���!G� ú ��NþJÿ � ( õ��2� õdö\ö6ù�ö`ë ��í � ��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � � ��ëdê ô �°ö`õ �� H = ��� � � � ø � � î9ê�ë��j÷EöUï � í î í ê ô ø �,ø � î9ø9ù �¸ëdê ô î #°õEî�ù.ë��<îfõdø �óë��,öUïiî # í ��� ��ùIî9ø9ë�� � ï ô ì( ëEö � �é�ê í G õ��5� ��þ�� � � #�é�ê í G ��ëdê � H� ( �®í #°õ�� í î #°õEî

þ��%��þ � � & ú7�,ÿ 39;:;<�� � � M ��� � &� ú & �Áÿ 39;:;<�� � � ?

� ��� � � � � �������� �����7��� � � � ����!����!� � ���� ������ ��� � ������ .0 ������ !�� ! �6×`âE�NØ � H ú ��NþJÿfè?�Á�NØÁ�EÚ�� ßjÞ � � ���2� 9 ��G� ú �� �Zÿ�Ú�áÁ� Ý���ÚË�E�+�E�a�W�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��9�E�¸Ú��E�×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×a�¾Ø,Ý?ß#�¾�,Ø,�Êß°Þ �¤æÁçQ� � HQ� � ��� � �\�E� ��� þdè,ã �+Ý��NÞÉÚ�á,�dÚ �É×�Ý+ù.ë���î9ê�õ¾ùIî9ø6� í 2�-å !¤Ü��¾×�تÚ�ð°�,�EتÚ�×aå,��� �MLÌ�E�� LÌ�¤�����Á�.Ý¿÷��,õdê � í �Ë×aØ/�y�4�E�.Û&�<�a���Ê×`�����4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø/Ý�Þ¤Û+ß#�¾�é�ê í �¤�����Á�.Ý��¾ØË��âE����Þ�Ý�Þ¤ØjÚ��E�¸Ú�×a��Ü<�dÚ�áÌ�\�.�¾Û Ú�áÁ��ðj�,�EØjÚ�×`å,���¿Ú��i��ð°�,�EØjÚ�×`å,�N�Ì�°�����Á�.���NØ,�¸��E��Ú�áÁ��âd�d�.×a�dß<�`�@Luæ "Á�E�Ì��!Á�EÛ/Ü<�`�Eè�×�Ø Ú�áÁ�Å�\�E�LÛ&�,�����ML�? ��3 ( �é�ê í � ��L � ��Ú�áÁ�Åå !¤Ü��¾×�تÚð°�,�EتÚ�×aå,���¿�¤�����Á�.Ý¿à¾�,�d�.�Á�N�0&j×aØ�Ú�áÁ�W�\�E�.Ûi�,�a� ��þ ��� � /�é�ê í � � �ML�? ��3 (>L � ��×`Ú¿�,�j�NÝ®ØÁ�EÚ�æ��Ø,�Á����� �¸�¾ØjÚ��.�E�¸Ú�×`âE� �,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚÊ�9�E�¸Ú��E�ó×�تÚ�����Ü<����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾ØèB��âE����Þ"à¾�,�d�.�,�N�"�°�����Á�.���NØ,�¸��E���Åå !¤Ü#�¾×aØjÚ�ðj�,�EØjÚ�×`å,���i�Á��å<ØÁ�NÝ+�%�¸�¾ØjÚ��.�E�¸Ú�×`âE�É�EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�&�¾Ø Ú�áÁ�Ìâd�E�a�Á�NÝ+�E�BÚ�áÁ�Ì�4�����âd�d�.×a�dß<�`�NÝ�Ú�á,�dÚ6�d����×aØ%Ú�á,�iÝ��¸�EÜ#�i�E��Ú�áÁ��ðj�<�EتÚ�×`å<���Næ�,��NØ,�¸�Eè#ßjÞ%Ú�áÁ�+�B�EØ,�E�Lá å !¤Ü��¾×�تÚÚ�áÁ���E���NÛ�è�Ú�áÁ�iå !¤Ü#�¾×aتÚ�×aÝW�,Ø<×aðj�,�Eæ,çQØ Ý��,�Láó���EÝ��NÝ�è#ã®��ØÁ���N� ØÁ�EÚ��<×aÝ�Ú�×aØÁà¾�<×aÝ�áÊß#��ÚYã ���NØ� �EØ,� �ðj�,�EØjÚ�×`å,���LÝ�èÁ�EØ,�Åã �+�Á�NØÁ�EÚ���ß#�EÚ�áÉß°Þæ

çQ� � � � � M þdè¿Ú�á,�NØ ß#�EÚ�á ú ú;�é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & � � �EØ<� ú ú ��þ�� � �� �é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & � � �.�N�,�,�¸��Ú�� Ú�áÁ��,Ø,�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�¶�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø ú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & è �4�E�1� H � þ � ���¾æ �WáÁ�%�4�¾�a�`�SãW×aØÁà Ú�áÁ���E���NÛ ��!°Ú��NØ<�,ÝÚ�á,×aÝ+�Eß<Ý�����âd�dÚ�×`�¾Ø Ú��%Ú�áÁ�Ê�¸�¾Û/Ü<�`��Ú�� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,ÝNè�Ý�áÁ�SãW×aØÁà%á,�Iã Ú�á,�ËÝ��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý&�E�?Ú�áÁ��,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�8�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,ÝB�¸�¾ØªâE���.àE�NÝ�Ú��/Ú�áÁ�yÝ��NÛ��EØjÚ�×a��Ý?�E�uÚ�áÁ�y�,Ø,�,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�)�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�EÝ�Ú�áÁ�®�<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��9�E�¸Ú��E�.Ý��dÜ,Ü,���¾�E�LáÉþdæ �u��Ý�Ú��dÚ��BÚ�áÁ� ���NÝ��<�`Ú�èNã �®��!¤Ú��NØ,�iÚ�áÁ�®Ý��NÛ��EتÚ�×���Ýu�E��,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�1�#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,Ý#Ú���×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��E�aÝ��?Ú�áÁ���9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý#é�ê í G è¸é�ê í J èI�`��Ú�Ú�×�ØÁà+ú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & � � Mú ú é�ê í � ÿ ÿ & �\�E�u�E�a� �LH � þ � ���¾èSà¾�EÛ/�BÝ�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á���NÝ � èS�EØ<���E�a�¾�,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ�×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×`�¾Ø<Ý ��æ/7G��E�aÝ����`��Ú �#ú;��9 M -¾ÿªß#��Ú�áÁ�®�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ�9�E�¸Ú��E�u×aØjÚ�����Ü,����Ú��dÚ�×a�¾Ø+�Á��å<Ø,�N�6ßjÞ �ú;� 9 M -¾ÿ � � � M -�EØ,��ú;� 9 M -ªÿ � ��<6� M � � � <6� �\�E��� �M!� <9æ� ' � ���� ��� ú �,�.,6û��&Zÿ ��ëEê õdö4ö ÷jõ ôÌí�� î9ê��,ùNî �¤ê í���� ( � í î�����L � H�= ��� � � � (Líõ)��ì�ùLõdöµù>�¤ö � � �¸ëdê ô �¤öµõ � ø9î # �Jê í.í �ZõdêJøcõ ( ö í L ( õ��5� �dø � ùLë�� �<î ��õ¾ùIîfëdê�� 2 � # í ��ëdö4öµë � ø6�j÷õ ����í ê¸î9øcë�� � #°ëEö;��P

��

Page 21: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

� 2 E� L õ��5���"õdö � õdï � õ��5�Ëë��,öUïÌëNù.ù>�°êyø �%î # í ù.ë��<î í �ªî*�é�ê í � ��L � ( �¸ëEê � H � þ � ��� ( î # í �

�a×aÛE F G ú ú ��L%? ��� �#é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & � � � � � � E � � M ú ú �ML%? ����é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & � � � � ?� 2 E� L¶õ��2��� õdö � õdï � õ��5�Åë��<ö ïÉëNù.ù>�°ê&ø6� î # í ùLë��<î í �ªî ��þ���� � #�é�ê í � ��L � ( î # í �

�a×aÛE F G ú ú � L�? ��� ��þ ��� � #�é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & � � � � � � E � � M ú ú; L�? ����é�ê í � ��L � �Yÿ ÿ & � � � � ?��áÁ�Ë���NÛ��d��äd�dß<�`�Ë�4�E�¸Ú�×aÝ&Ú�á,�dÚiÚ�áÁ�Ë�E�L�Á���&�E��ðj�,�EØjÚ�×`å,���LÝ+×aØ Ü,���Eß<�dß<×��a×aÝ�Ú�×a�+�#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü��¾Ø<�,Ý?Ú���Ú�áÁ�&�E�.�Á���W×�ØÅãWá,×a�LáÅÚ�áÁ�+��×aÛ�×`Ú�Ý?�d���+Ú��däE�NØó×aØ%�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���<�a�,Ý�æ"Á�E��×aØ,Ý�Ú��EØ<�¸�EèN�\�E����à¾�EÛ/� Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,��� � �EØ,��3DB?� & èZ�`��Ú � M � ?�? ��L%? � � & 3 * �#é�ê í � ��L � � (��3#* ��þ ����� ��é�ê í � �A?�� � �Læ�7G�+á,�IâE�+Ú�á,�dÚ

�a×aÛE F G �a×aÛ� F G ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & � � � � � � E � � � � � M ú ú �ML%? @?�? � � & 3 *Ëé�ê í � ��L � � ( ��3#*Ìé�ê í � �A? � � �Yÿ ÿ & ���Eý��

��×aÛ� F G �a×�ÛE F G ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & � � � � � � E � � � � � M ú ú; @?�? �ML�? � � & 3 *Ëé�ê í � ��L � � ( ��3#*Ìé�ê í � �A? � � �Yÿ ÿ & ? � &� �

"Á�E�.Ûi�,�a� ���Eý���×�Ý�Ú�áÁ� Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø �E�yÜ,���Eß<�dß�×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×��Ë�¸�dÙ � ��,�Lá,×�à¾�EÛ/�NÝÌã�×`Ú�á¶àE�¾�E� 5 % 3+èãWá,×��`� � &� ��×aÝ?Ú�áÁ��Ý��¾�a�ÁÚ�×`�¾ØÉ�E��Ü,���Eß��dß<×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×a� � ��,�Lá,×à¾�EÛ/�NÝWãW×`Ú�áÉàE�¾�E� % 5 3&æ

� ���Ô®Ö�+�+���<Ï¿Õ ��� �ÁÐEѪÖ]Õ �

�u���¸�¾Û/Ü<�`��Ú���Ú�á,�/��!°Ú��NØ,Ý.×`�¾ØG�E� Ú�áÁ�����a�EÝ�Ý�×����E��ß��°�¾�`�N�EØ �4�.�EÛ/��ã �E��ä �\�E�+Ý�Ü��N��×aå<���dÚ�×`�¾ØèâE���.×`å����dÚ�×`�¾Øè<�EØ,� �¸�¾ØjÚ����¾��Ú��ËÚ�áÁ�&ð°�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE�����EÝ��Eè�ã®�iÝ�áÁ�Iã�áÁ�Iã�Ú�áÁ�i���a�EÝ�Ý�×a���E�uØÁ�dÙÚ�×`�¾Ø �E��ß<×aÝ.×aÛ&�<�a�dÚ�×`�¾ØG���EØ ß#�Ì��!¤Ú��NØ,�Á�N� Ú��óÚ�áÁ�Éð°�,�EتÚ�×aÚ��dÚ�×`âE�ÊÝ���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàÁè��EØ,� á,�Iã �¾�Á�ð°�,�EتÚ�×aÚ��dÚ�×`âE�.�#ÙY���E�����,�a×��.á,�d�.�E�¸Ú����L× #��yðj�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE�6ß<×�Ý�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Øè ��,Ý�Ú �EÝ Ú�áÁ��ß#�°�¾�`�N�EØ�#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý�èÁ�a×`äE�&ò �W��è,�.á<�d�.�E�¸Ú����.× #��NÝWß<×aÝ�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×a�¾Øæ

�0��� E���!� ��� � � ��*) � �� � !�� � � ����ç�Ø�Ú�áÁ� ß#�j�¾�`�N�EØ&Ý���Ú�Ú�×aØÁàÁèZ�EØ,�&�\�E���Á��Ú����.Û�×�Ø,×aÝ�Ú�×a��à¾�EÛ�� Ý�Ú��L�,�¸Ú��Á���NÝ�èSÚ�áÁ�®Ø,�EÚ�×`�¾Ø+�E�Áß�×aÝ�×aÛ�Ù�,�a�dÚ�×a�¾Ø/�\�E� à¾�EÛ/�NÝ ×aÝ����E�a�a�N�óõdöµî í ê���õEî9ø �j÷ � ø ô �¤ö`õEî9øcë�� ú �2,."43yý�$Zÿfæ "�× !/�&�Á��Ú����.Û�×�Ø,×aÝ�Ú�×a�à¾�EÛ/� Ý�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á�.� � M � � ��� ��� G ��� J �����Lè®�E�`�¾ØÁà ãW×`Ú�á � Ý���Ú � B � � �E�6Ü,���N�<×a���dÚ��NÝ�æ� ���N�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø 9 B�� *9�"×aÝ��Éé�öµõEï í êLì � õdöµî í ê���õEî9ø �j÷ ( ø � ø ô �¤öµõEî9øcë��¶×`�Qè#�\�E�i�E�a� 8Q�G.IH(� è��8Q�G. �%H 9 ×aÛ/Ü<�a×a�NÝ¿Ú�á,�dÚ=8IH)$�� . H $%�\�E���E�a��$ H,�/è��EØ,��×`� ��8��G. �%H�9�èÁÚ�áÁ�NØ

8C- G H2� G ��8��-? 5 E G H2� G �/. �-? 8 E J H2� J �/. �-? 5 - J H � J ��8 �-? A9 ��7 ��8Q��- G ��- J � ��7 ��8Q� E G � E J � � �80E G H2� G �/. �-? 5 - G H2� G ��8��-? 8- J H � J ��8 �-? 5 E J H � J �/. �-? A9 ��7 ��8Q��- G ��- J � ��7 ��8Q� E G � E J � � �

ãWáÁ���.� A9 � � . G ��� � . J � �B× ( �/. G �G. J �%H�9�è,�4�E�W�E�a�C. G �G. J H0� æ���áÁ���,��å<Ø,×`Ú�×`�¾ØÊ�E���ié�ö`õdï í êJì �õdöµî í ê���õEî9ø �j÷ ( ø � ø ô �¤ö`õEî9øcë���×aÝi�Eß,Ú��E×�ØÁ�N� ß°Þ ��!Á�.á,�EØ,à¾×aØÁàG×aØ Ú�á,�É�dß#�SâE�É�,��å<Ø,×`Ú�×`�¾Ø Ú�áÁ����¾�`�NÝW�E��Ü<�a�NÞE���LÝ+þ+�EØ<� �°æ������N�a�dÚ�×a�¾Ø 9 ×aÝ��EØ õdöµî í ê���õEî9ø �j÷ ( ø � ø ô �¤öµõ¾î9ø9ë�� ×`��×aÚW×aÝ?ß#�EÚ�á�/Ü<���NÞE����Ù.þ��EØ<����Ü<�a�IÞE����ÙB���E�`Ú����LØ,�dÚ�×aØÁà/ß<×�Ý�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Øæ

�u�Ë�Eß<Ú��E×aØ Ú�áÁ�i�¸�¾�d�LÝ��NÝ�Ú6Ü<�a�IÞE����þ��E�`Ú����LØ,�dÚ�×aØÁàËß<×aÝ�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×a�¾Øè,×cæ³�Eæ`è�Ú�áÁ�i���d��àE�NÝ�Ú6���¸Ù�a�dÚ�×`�¾ØÊÚ�á,�dÚ?×aÝ �iÜ<�a�IÞE����Ù.þy�E�`Ú����.Ø,�dÚ�×�ØÁà&ß�×aÝ�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø�èEã®�����EØÉ�,Ý��y��Ý�Þ¤Û+ß#�¾�a×��?å !¤Ü��¾×�تÚ

�¤þ

Page 22: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

�dÜ,Ü,�.�¾�E�.á ú³ûó×a��ý�Zÿfè�ãWá,×��.á ×aØ â°×a��ã �E���¾�Á�/��!¤Ú��NØ,Ý�×`�¾Ø Ú��GÚ�áÁ�Åð°�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE�����EÝ��Eè�ã �Ý�Ú��dÚ����EÝB�4�¾�a�`�SãWÝ�æÁ� ( ø6��õEêLïO�dø � îfõ���ù í ��� ��ùNî9øcë��ó×�Ý �i�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø��)9 �9* ��G� � ��Nþ��&Ú�á,�dÚÛ��dÜ<Ý��N�E�.áóÜ<�E×`���E��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝF8��G. H5� Ú���Ú�áÁ�N×`�W�<×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸���0��8��G. �%H � ��Nþ��¾è��EØ,�%Ý��,�.á�Ú�á,�dÚ�4�E���E�a� 8��G.)��� H+� è�ã ��á,�NâE���0��8��G. � M��0�/. � 8����EØ,���0��8��G. � ������8Q��� � ������ �G. �Læ ",�E��,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸���9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý����� < ã®�W�a��Ú� ��� < × (�����8Q�G. ��� � < ��8Q�G. ���\�E� �E�a�58Q�G. H0� æ�7G�6�Á��å<ØÁ�Ú�áÁ�i�4�<Ø,�¸Ú��E��� G Û��dÜ,Ü<×�ØÁà�ß<×aØ<�d��ÞÅ�,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸�i�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,ÝWÚ��Éß<×aØ,�d��ÞÅ�,×�Ý�Ú��EØ,�¸�i�4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý�9�4�E�W�E�a�#ß<×aØ<�d��ÞË�,×�Ý�Ú��EØ,�¸�y�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý��Ê�EØ,���E�a��8Q�G.%H5� èÁã �+�`��Ú�� G/��� ����8Q�G. �LM þ�×`�uÚ�áÁ�����×aÝ $ H � Ý��,�LáÅÚ�á,�dÚR8 H)$ �� .%H)$�è,�EØ<�Åã®�&�`��Ú

� G ��� ����8��G. � M"ÛÌ� !���� Û�� !E S FIH S JMLON

Û�×�Ø� S F�H S J NÛÌ� !� P F�H P J N

Û�×aØE P FIH P JMLONA�0��7 ��8���-�G ��-�J%� ��7 ��8Q� E!G!� E)J%� � �

Û�� !� SGFIHQSOJ NÛ�×aØE SGFIHQSKJMLON

Û�� !EQP FIH P JMLONÛ�×aØ� P F�H P J N

A�0��7 ��8���- G ��- J � ��7 ��8Q� E G � E J � �������EÚ�áÁ����ã�×aÝ��Eè°ãWáÁ�����%A��� � . G ��� � . J � � M����/. G �G. J ���4�E�B�E��� . G �G. J H � æÁ� Ü��a�NÞE����Ù.þ��E�`Ú����.Ø<�dÚ�×aØÁàß<×aÝ.×aÛ&�<�a�dÚ�×`�¾ØE9 ×aÝ�Ý�×aÛ�Ü<�`ÞÌ�/�.�N�a�dÚ�×`�¾ØÉãWáÁ�¾Ý����.á,�d�.�E�¸Ú����L×aÝ�Ú�×a�+�4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾ØÅ×aÝ?�/å !¤Ü#�¾×aØjÚ �E�� G èd×fæ³�Eæ`è¾×`Ú�×aÝ��yÝ��Áß<Ý���Ú 9HB?�8*�� Ý��,�Lá�Ú�á,�dÚ�� � 9 � M�� G ��� � 9 � �LèEãWáÁ����� � � 9 ����8��G. ��×aÝ ×`� ��8��G. �%H�9�èÁ�EØ,��×�Ýyþ6�EÚ�áÁ����ãW×aÝ��EæÁçQØÉÜ<�d�.Ú�×a���,�a�d�Nè¤Ú�áÁ���¸�¾�d�LÝ��NÝ�Ú�Ü<���NÞE����Ù.þyß�×aÝ�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø� 83:;<G ×aÝ�à¾×`âE�NØ ßjÞ�� � G M � � � 83:;<G �Lè#ãWáÁ������� � G ×aÝ6�`�N�EÝ�Ú�å !°Ü#�¾×aØjÚW�E�®Ú�áÁ�i�4�,Ø<�¸Ú��E��� GNè×cæ³�Eæ`èÚ�áÁ� �`�N�EÝ�ÚË�<×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸���9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×a�¾Ø Ú�á,�dÚËÝ.�dÚ�×aÝ�å,�NÝ�� � G M�� G ��� � G �Læ 7G� �Á��å<ØÁ�%Ú�áÁ�ó�¸�¾�d�.Ý��NÝ�ÚÜ<�a�IÞE����ÙB�Å�E�`Ú����LØ,�dÚ�×aØÁàÅß<×�Ý�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø � 83:;<J ×aØG�EØ �EØ,�E�a�EàE�¾�,Ýy�9�EÝ�á,×`�¾Øè#ãW×aÚ�á ���NÝ�Ü#�N�¸ÚyÚ���/�9�,Ø,�¸Ú��E� � J �Eß<Ú��E×aØÁ�N�Åß°ÞÅÝ�ã �dÜ<Ü<×aØÁà/Ú�áÁ�+���¾�`�NÝ?�E��Ü<�a�IÞE���.Ý+þ&�EØ,� �/×�ØÅÚ�áÁ�+�Á��å�Ø,×`Ú�×`�¾Ø�E�� G æ "�×�Ø,�E�a�`ÞEè�Ú�áÁ�/�¸�¾�d�.Ý��NÝ�Ú��E�aÚ����.Ø,�dÚ�×aØÁàÊß<×aÝ.×aÛ&�<�a�dÚ�×`�¾ØF� 83:;< ×aÝ�à¾×`âE�NØ ß°Þ � � � 83:;< � M� � è�ãWáÁ�����!� � ×aÝyÚ�á,�Ë�`�N�EÝ�Ú&�,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸�Ì�4�,Ø<�¸Ú�×`�¾ØGÚ�á,�dÚiÝ��dÚ�×aÝ�å,�NÝ+ß#�EÚ�á"� � M#� G ��� � ���EØ,�� � M$� J ��� �>�Læ 7"áÁ�NØÉã �6ãW×aÝ�áËÚ���Û��däE�y��!¤Ü<�a×a��×`Ú®Ú�áÁ�y�Á��Ü#�NØ,�Á�NØ,�¸���E��Ú�á,��ß�×aÝ�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø���N�a�dÚ�×a�¾Ø,Ý��¾Ø�Ú�áÁ�Bà¾�EÛ/���EØ,���¾Ø)�/èEã � ãW�.×`Ú�� � 8C:;<& � % è � 83:;<G � & � % è¾�EØ,�1� 8C:;<J � & � % �4�E� � 8C:;< è � 8C:;<G è�EØ,�#� 83:;<J æF�WáÁ�É�\�¾�a�a�IãW×aØ,àóÚ�áÁ���E�.�NÛÅè��Á���.×`âE�N� �4���¾Û ú �2,."136ý�$Zÿfè¿���N�a�dÚ��NÝ/�E�`Ú����.Ø<�dÚ�×aØÁàß<×aÝ.×aÛ&�<�a�dÚ�×`�¾ØÊ�EØ,�Åß#�j�¾�a�N�EØ �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,ÝNæ

� ' � ���� �'& ��ëdêGõ � í î í ê ô ø �,ø � î9øcù�÷ªõ ôÌí�� î9ê��,ùIî �°ê í2� ( î # í ��ëdö\ö`ë � ø �j÷¶õ ����í êJî9øcë�� �#°ëdö ��P� 2 ��ëdê¶õdö\öL� H � þ � ��� ( �®í #°õ�� í î #°õEî���8��G. � �H � 8C:;<� � & � % ø ( î # í ê í ø � õ ù�ö`ë �Ní � ��ì

ùLõdöµù>�¤ö � � �¸ëdê ô �¤öµõ>� H�� ��� � ù.ë��<îfõEø6�,ø �j÷ ë��,öUïié�ê í �døcù.õEî í�� ø6� � õ��5�.��� ��ùIî9ø9ë�� �ø � � é�ê í � �!�Lé�ê í � � � �,ù$#�î #°õEî 8 H ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & õ��5��. �H ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & 2

� 2 ��8Q�G. � �H6� 83:;<& � % ø ( î # í ê í ø � õóù�ö`ë ��í � ��ì�ù.õdö`ù��¤ö � � �¸ëEê ô �¤öµõ � H � ��� � ù.ë���îfõdø6�<ø6�j÷ë��<ö ï+é�ê í �døcù.õEî í�� ø ��� � �,ù #Åî #¤õEî 8IH ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & õ��5� . �H ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ 8 & 2

�0��� ������� � �� � !�� � ������ � 6� �!�������u���Eß,Ú��E×aØË��ðj�<�EتÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×aâE�WâE���.Ý�×a�¾Ø/�E��E�`Ú����.Ø,�dÚ�×aØ,à�ß<×aÝ�×�Û&�,���dÚ�×`�¾ØèZã®�W�E�<�dÜ,Ú�Ú�áÁ���Á��å<Ø,×µÙÚ�×`�¾ØÅ�E�)� � Ú��ÌÚ�áÁ�+���EÝ��+�E��Ü,���Eß<�dß�×a�a×aÝ�Ú�×���à¾�EÛ/�iÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á�.�NÝ��EØ,��ð°�,�EØjÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×`âE�+�,×�Ý�Ú��EØ,�¸��9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,ÝÊú �,�2,�û��&Zÿfæ "�× ! �%à¾�EÛ/�ÉÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��Á�.� � M � � ��� ��� G ��� J �����Lè��E�a�¾ØÁà%ãW×aÚ�á �Ý���Ú ��B � �G�E�BÜ,���N�,×����dÚ��NÝ�æ�� �dø � îfõ���ù í ��� ��ùNî9øcë�� ×aÝ��%ÛÌ�dÜ,Ü<×aØÁà*� 9 � * � G� ú ��NþJÿÝ��,�LáÌÚ�á<�dÚ �4�E�B�E�a�28Q�G.)��� H5� ã®�yá,�IâE� �0��8��G. � M$���/.)� 8 �¿�EØ,������8Q�G. ��������8Q��� � +�0��� �G. �Læ7G�Å�Á��å<ØÁ� �dø � ù.ë�� ��î í �%÷jõ ôÌí-( ø � ø ô �¤öµõ¾î9ø9ë�� ú �,�2,�û��&dÿBãW×`Ú�á ���NÝ�Ü#�N�¸Ú&Ú��G� �,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ

�'�

Page 23: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

�9�E�¸Ú��E� �7H ú ��NþJÿ &ÁÚ�áÁ�y�,Ø,�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N�Ê���EÝ��y�¸�E�����NÝ�Ü��¾Ø<�,Ý¿Ú�� �IM þdæ�6×`âE�NØ �KH ú ��NþJÿfè,ã ��Á��å<Ø,�?Ú�áÁ�?�4�<Ø,�¸Ú��E��� � Û��dÜ,Ü�×aØÁà6�,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸�?�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×a�¾Ø,Ý�Ú��+�,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸�?�4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø,Ý�9d�4�E����âE����Þ�,×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸�/�4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø � �EØ,�G�E�a��Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ+8��G.+H%� èã®�Ë�Á��å<ØÁ��� � ��� ����8Q�G. � M þÌ×`�¿Ú�áÁ���.�Ì×aÝ$ H,� Ý��,�.á�Ú�á,�dÚR8 H)$ �� .%H)$�è,�EØ,�

� � ��� ����8Q�G. � M�L�N�� !

����� Ý��ÁÜ� SGF�� SKJMLON

×aØÁ�� SKF�� SGJ NÝ��ÁÜ

� P F�� P J N×�ØÁ�

� P F�� P JMLON� ��� ��� A� ��8Q� > G � > J � � A� �/. ��� G ��� J � � �

Ý��ÁÜ� SKF�� SGJ N

×aØÁ�� SGF�� SKJMLON

Ý��ÁÜ� P F�� P JMLON

×aØÁ�� P F�� P J N� ��� ��� A� ��8Q� > G � > J � � A� �/.)��� G ��� J � � � ����

�EÚ�áÁ����ã�×aÝ��Eæ "Á�E� � �,×�Ý�Ú��EØ,�¸� �4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø�� �EØ,� �<×aÝ�Ú��.×`ß��ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý > G"�EØ,� > JZèÅã � �`��Ú� ��� ��� > G � > J �óß#� Ú�áÁ� ��!°Ú��NØ<Ý�×`�¾Ø �E�ÊÚ�áÁ� �4�<Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø � �4���¾Û Ý�Ú��dÚ��NÝ Ú�� �,×aÝ�Ú��L×`ß<�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø<Ýú â �57 Áþ��Eÿ,à¾×aâE�NØ/ßjÞiÚ�áÁ��Ý��¾���ÁÚ�×`�¾ØiÚ���Ú�áÁ���a×�ØÁ�N�d��Ü,���EàE�.�EÛ ÛÌ� ! � L�F� � > G ��8���� > J ��8�� � = LãWáÁ���.�/Ú�áÁ��âd�d�.×a�dß<�`�NÝ � = L � L�F� �d�.�ÌÝ��Áß ��N�¸ÚyÚ�� = L � = � ����8Q�G. �6�EØ,� = L � Å�4�E�+�E�a�8Q�G. H�/æ���áÁ�?�`�N�EÝ�Ú��<×aÝ�Ú��EØ,�¸�?�9�,Ø,�¸Ú�×`�¾Ø�Ú�á<�dÚ�×aÝ��6å !¤Ü��¾×�تÚ��E��� � ×�Ý����E�a�`�N� �¤ì �Eø � ù.ë�� �<î í �÷ªõ ô�í-( ø � ø ô ø4ö`õdêLø9î9ï ( �EØ,� �Á�NØÁ�EÚ��N� � 3:� ��� æ �6Ø û �6ü®Ý8�4�¾ØÁ�¸ÙfÜ��a�NÞE����à¾�EÛ/�ÉÝ�Ú��.�,�¸Ú��,���NÝ��Lè�4�E��� � þdè�,×aÝ��¸�¾�<تÚ��N�óà¾�EÛ/��ß<×aÝ�×�Û&�,���dÚ�×`�¾Ø��¸�¾×aØ,��×��Á�NÝWã�×`Ú�á%Ú�á,�i�,×�Ý��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�ó�,×�Ý�Ú��EØ,�¸�Û/��Ú��.×���Ý?�E�Bú â � 7 Áþ��¾ÿfæ<��à¾�E×aØèÁã �yã��.×`Ú���� 3:� ��� � & � % ãWáÁ�NØÉã �yãW×aÝ�áÉÚ���Û��däE�+��!°Ü<��×a��×`ÚBÚ�áÁ��Á��Ü#�NØ,�Á�NØ<�¸ÞÌ�E� � 3:� ��� �\�.�¾Û Ú�áÁ��à¾�EÛ/� � �EØ,�Å�4���¾Û Ú�áÁ��Ý��,ß<Ý���Ú?�E��Ü,���N�,×����dÚ��NÝ �/æ

� Þ Ú�áÁ��Û�×aØ<×aÛ�� !%Ú�áÁ���E�.�NÛ ú â !F��$dÿfèã �Ì���EØG��!Á�.á<�EØÁàE�ÌÚ�áÁ�/Ú]ã®� Û�×a�,�<�`�iÝ.�ÁÜ �EØ,�×aØÁ�u�EÜ#���.�dÚ��E�.ÝW×�ØÅÚ�áÁ�+�Á��å�Ø,×`Ú�×`�¾ØÉ�E��� � &��EÝ����¸�¾Ø,Ý��Nð°�Á�NØ,�¸�Eè�×`Ú�×aÝ?�N�EÝ�ÞÅÚ��ÊÝ�����Ú�á,�dÚ�Ú�áÁ��Á��å<Ø<×`Ú�×`�¾Ø ×aÝ/Ý�Þ¤Û�Û/��Ú��.×a���E�Bã�×`Ú�á ���NÝ�Ü#�N�¸Ú/Ú��GÜ<�a�IÞE���.Ý�þÅ�EØ,� �°æ5��áj�<Ý�è�Ú�áÁ������×aÝ��¾Ø,�aÞ�¾ØÁ�yâE���.Ý.×`�¾ØÉ�E� �9�,Ø0�Q�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N�Éà¾�EÛ/�yß<×�Ý�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Øè°×aØÉ�¸�¾ØªÚ��L�EÝ�Ú�Ú��/Ú�áÁ�yÚ]ã®�Ì�<×aÝ�Ú�×aØ,�¸ÚÜ<�a�IÞE����Ù.þ��EØ,��Ü<�a�NÞE����ÙB���E�`Ú����.Ø<�dÚ�×aØÁàyß<×aÝ.×aÛ&�<�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý�æSçQØ<�Á���N�è¾�¸�¾Û/Ü<�d�L×aØÁàyÚ�áÁ���Á��å�Ø,×`Ú�×`�¾Ø�E� � � �EØ<��� � è�ã �óÝ����óÚ�á,�dÚË�E�aÚ����.Ø,�dÚ�×aØÁà ß<×aÝ�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×a�¾Ø ×�ÝÌ�Á��å<Ø,�N� ãW×`Ú�á �.�NÝ�Ü#�N�¸Ú�Ú��� í î í ê ô ø �,ø � î9øcù Û/�SâE� �,×aÝ�Ú��.×`ß<�ÁÚ�×a�¾Ø,Ý�è¿�EØ,�"Ú�á,� Û�×aØ,×aÛÌ� !¶Ú�áÁ���E���NÛ �Á�°�NÝÅØÁ�EÚ�áÁ�¾���-×a�Ú�áÁ�&Ü<�a�NÞE���LÝ��d�.�+�4�E�.�¸�N� Ú��Ê�,Ý��&�Á��Ú����.ÛÌ×aØ,×aÝ�Ú�×��y�,×aÝ�Ú��.×aß<�ÁÚ�×`�¾Ø,ÝNæ �WáÁ�+�4�¾�a�`�SãW×aØÁà�Ú�á,���E���NÛ���N�a�dÚ��NÝWà¾�EÛ/��ß<×�Ý�×aÛ�×a���d�.×`ÚYÞ/ã�×`Ú�áÅðj�<�EتÚ�×`Ú��dÚ�×aâE�+�EØ,�Å�,×aÝ.�¸�¾�,تÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,�a�,ÝNæ� ' � ���� � ��� ú �,�2,�û��&dÿ � # í �¸ëEö\ö`ë � ø �j÷óõ �B��í êJî9øcë�� � #°ëdö �3��ëdêiõEö\ö÷ªõ ôÌí � î9ê��,ùIî �°ê í����2� 2 � í î ����� � � % (Lí î # í ��í î�ë �Wù�ö`ë �Ní �.��ì�ùLõdö`ù��¤ö � � �¸ëEê ô �¤öµõ � ø6� ����� �� î #°õEî�ù.ë��<îfõdø �ë��<ö ï+é�ê í �døcù.õEî í�� ø ��� 2 ��ëdê�õdö\ö28��G.%H5� & �®í #°õ�� í

� 3:� ��G � & � % ��8Q�G. � M Ý��ÁÜ� F % ���� �� �

�� ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & ��8�� � ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & �/. � �� ?� 2 � í î;= ��� � � � � % (.í î # í���í î�ë �óùNöµë ��í � ��ì�ùLõdöµù>�¤ö � � ��ëdê ô �¤ö`õ � ø �,= ��� �� � � î #¤õEî

ùLë��<îfõdø � ë��,öUïyé�ê í �Eø9ùLõEî í�� ø6� � 2 ��ëdêiõdö4ö58Q�G. H0� & õ��2�Åõdö\ö �7H ú ��NþJÿ (��®í #°õ�� í� C:� ��� � & � % ��8Q�G. � M Ý��,Ü

� F�� ���� � �Ý��ÁÜ

� F �"!QJ � N�� ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & � � ��8�� � ú ú7�,ÿ ÿ & � � �/. � �� ?

çQÚ ×aÝ¿Ü#�¾Ý�Ý�×`ß<�a�?Ú��i��!¤Ú��NØ,�ËÚ�áÁ�6�¸�¾Ø,ØÁ�N�¸Ú�×`�¾ØÊß#��ÚYã ���NØÉ�,×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�����,�a�,Ý �EØ,�Ë�Nðj�,×aâªÙ�E�`�NØ,�¸� ���N�a�dÚ�×a�¾Ø,Ý��9�Á��Ú�áÁ���IèW×aØ,���a�<�,×aØÁà ���NÝ��<�`Ú�Ý%�dß#�¾�ÁÚóÚ�áÁ� Ý�Ú��dß�×a�a×`Ú]Þ-�E�/ß�×aÝ�×aÛi�,�a�dÚ�×`�¾Ø�EØ,� �<×aÝ��¸�¾�,ØjÚ��N� �#ÙY���E�a���,���,Ý6ãW×`Ú�áG�.�NÝ�Ü#�N�¸ÚyÚ��%Ü#����Ú��Á��ß��dÚ�×`�¾Ø,Ý6×aØGÚ�áÁ�Ìà¾�EÛ/�ÌÝ�Ú��.�<�¸Ú��Á���ú �� �¾ü5��¤èw�,�2,�û��&dÿfæ

��&

Page 24: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

� ��� �,Ñ��<Ï®Õ ���

�  ������¸���.<��¤ ���pIq�}ÁÀ��  ¿���m�3S��vw3Z~LmQq�}Á�.3d« E®���pZ{S�UmQqfz��L3ª�6 ��³ofmQqf3d��ofv�3S~6ofvwz?mBofm�z?{EtLqY�.���wtJ~LvwnJ��I;� > �}/A�DI» C�?J���>?>=��I}°�L�L�¸�N�

�  ������ D�@�� <¿�¾ ��wpSq�}¾À��  ¿����m�3S��vw3Z~Jm]q�} E®����pZ{I�µmQqfz��.3j}E�.3d«��&� � �¾���.qY«Iv`�� ��wofm]qf3d�.ofvw3S~�qfm]·d3ZmQz?m�3�oqfm����.ofvwtJ3Sr���2\3Ì>@<AB>�CED����LM#><8.XE:QeN7]7c[]XE:Qg+hjTZ[c8L7Yg�;��JRUTWVYXZR\;�><8LX�=�;�}N±¸tL��pSz?m5=GA�C�CBt.���¤[c:QR\;A�8.R\[]Ç�_µX/><8���ƾ; �d:Q_�;�}S{d�.~Jm�r = CL��� = ?�@N�j|I{Iqfv�3S~JmQqc���<mQqf���L~I} = D�D�@N�

� ! x D�C��#"®� ! ¯d��o�.3d« <¿��x��wm���±¸m����L3Z«ª�°��T?nQv�mQ3No�z?tN«Sm��Zn]¯Sm�n]´Nvw3Z~�±Nv���of¯Zm�m�¹�pd��ofv�tL3d�.�dê��n��.�wn�pZ�wpZr��j2435798�:�;�OJO.RUT�V%$�$&$'�Zg(��ƪ;)�°8+*L_a:�_µX/><8��uƪ;�E:Q_�;�}S{d�.~Jm�r��L��A(���%=��N} = D�D�CN�

� ! mQq D-,�� � � .¤� ! mQqcofrcm�´L�Lr���/�g.XE^��®_a:�5798+*L7c^��0� _µX1*W^LXdÈ�@¤ÆdR`_2�B^Jb¤><8LXSR`7c8Jb �¤ of¯Sm�3d�¿|Nn�vwm�3�ofvw·ZnJ}�= D�D3,����tL�wpZz?m�r2��L3d«�2c2]�

� ! l C�D(�54S� <¿� !76pZnY¯ZvN�.3d«�l,� �¿��l°�.3d«N²#m�­EmQq��¸|ItL�w±Ivw3S~rcm�¹�pZm�3�ofv��L�¸nQtJ3d«Iv³ofv�tL3Zrj­N¬u·d3Svwofm]�\r9oY��ofm,r9ocqY�.ofm�~Lv�mQr��hZ7c^.XZÇQ; � �?[]7�;8 &^LRUTS; �d8�:�;�} =���@N» �BD3,9�N�%=�=J}�= D�C�DN�

� ! qc¬/@�C�� <¿� �� ! qc¬N�L3�o��:"uqY�.{Z¯S��­Z�Lrcm�«¿�L�w~Jt.qfv³of¯Zz?r¤�µt.q,­Et�tJ�wm��.3 �µpS3ZnQofvwtJ3¿z��L3Svw{ZpZ����ofv�tL3j�ZV%$�$&$�hZ7c^.XZÇ<;^¸:QR`_a8LXSÇ¿8LX�><8���ÆZeIR\[]7YÇf}¾x��\�3,N¼ @¸½]» C�?�?���C�D%=L}�= D�@�CI�

� x�tJ3 D¸���6 ¿�ux�tL3d«StL3j�¶À#¯Smin�tLz?{Z�wmQÂIv³o4¬ÊtL�®r9oft�n]¯Z�Lr9ofvwn�~¸�.z?m�r���VYX�=�8L7<�?^LR`_a8.XG^LXdÈ%><8��uÆdeNR�^LR`_a8LXS}D�CN» �.�J���I�J� AS}�= D�D¸���

� «Z =���J���6l,�Á«Im� u�³�`��qft&�.3d«�À��  �� ��mQ3Z��vw3Z~LmQq��+x�tL3Zn�pIqcqfm�3�o®tLz?m�~¸���aqfm�~JpS� ��qB~J�Lz?m�r���243�5#7c8�:�;uO->LRUTV%$&$�$?�Sg��uƪ;8�j8+*L_a:¿_µX/><8(��ƪ;�E:Q_a;�}I{d�L~Lm�rF= A/=<��=�,BAS}¾�L�J�L�I�

� «Z =�@�FD�@���l<�J«Sm# ��³�`�.qftI}�À��  ¿����mQ3Z��vw3Z~LmQq�}L�L3Z« E®�(��pZ{I�µmQqfz��.3j�Sx�tJ3Sn�pSqcqfmQ3NoÁqfm��LnY¯d�L­Svw��v³o\¬®~J�Lz?m�r��S2435798�:�;ªK1�.RUT V%$�$&$A�Sg��uƪ;CB°8LeNXEÈ�;¾89=�><8���ƾ;��d:Q_�;�}L{d�.~Jm�r&,�CBA(��,�?-,��N29�<���ix�tJz?{SpSofmQq�|Nt�n�vwmQo4¬.,qfmQrcr�} = D�D�@N�

� «Z =�D�6�%=��(��l<��«Sm� u�³�`��qftS}�À��  ¿����m�3S��vw3Z~LmQq�}��L3d« <��&�6��E4pZz�«Z��q�� ;SqftJz ±JmQqfv³·dn���ofv�tL3Ìoft&n�tJ3�ocqftL�a»��¬I3d�.z?v�n�{IqftJ~.qY�Lz?ru�UtLq�tJz?m�~J�.�aqfm�~JpS���.q�tL­CE4m�nQofvw±¸m�r���2\3�5798�:�;#O3F.RUT�V%$&$�$G�Zg(��ƪ;8�°8+*L_a:®_UX><8���ƾ; �d:Q_�;�}S{d�.~Jm�ru��?BD��N��DJ�N�¾29�<���H.,qfmQrcr�}¾�L�L�%=L�

� «Z =�D�6�%=Q­:��l<�N«Im� u�³�`��qftS}SÀ��  ¿�1�um�3Z��vw3S~JmQq�}N�.3d« <����6��E9pZz�«S�.q��°|N¬Iz®­EtJ�wvwnu�.�w~JtLqfv³of¯Sz?r��µt.qvw3S·Z3Zv³ofmQ�r9oY�.ofm®~¸�Lz?mQr���243Å>@�A >�CED H¸O¸M�><8LXd:QeN7]7c[]XE:Qg/hjTZ[c8L7Yg¸;#O.F¸RUTyVYXSR\;�><8LX�=�;�}d±¸tL�wpZz?m®�>=�,BA�t.��¤[c:QR\;¤A�8LR\[]Ç�_µX�><8��uƪ;�E:Q_�;w}S{Z�L~Lm�r�,L��C��C,�,L�I�j|N{Sqfvw3Z~LmQqc����m]qf� �.~S}d�L�L�%=J�

� «Z =�D�6�J���6l,�N«Smu u�³�µ�.qftS}IÀ��  �����m�3S��vw3Z~Jm]q�}N�L3Z« <¿�C�6��E9pSz�«Z��q��j��v�rcnQtJpZ3�ofvw3Z~�of¯Sm��UpSofpIqfmuvw3�r9¬Ir9ofm�z?rof¯Zm�t.qc¬��I243 5798�:�;¾KNH�RUT VYXZR\;°><8JbUbw8�I�; � eNR\;��°^LX1*�;S5#7c8+*�;w}¸lªm�nQo��Ls�tLofmQrÁv�3Bx�tJz?{ª�¸|Nn�v`�J|I{Sqfvw3S~JmQqc���m]qf� �.~S}E�L�J�L�I�

� «Z @�6�%=J�6l<�°«Sm� ��w�µ�.qft��.3d«+<����6��E9pSz�«Z��q��LK�pZ�L3�ofv³oY�.ofvw±¸m?rctL��pIofvwtJ3/tL��tLz?m�~¸���aqfm�~JpS� ��q ~J�Lz?m�r���2435798�:�;,KJKJ7cÈ � > M�Sg��uƪ;#hjTZ[c8L7Yg�84=?><8(��ƪ;�}S{d�.~Jm�r C�?-,���C�@L�I�ª �xN�O.,qfm�rcr�}E�L�L�%=J�

� ����.��J���P4I�Z��mQrc¯d�.qf3Z�Lvwr�}E ��d�<«Z�.���.o�}E�.3d«Q.Á�R.Á�L3Z�L3S~¸�J«Im�3j� ! vwrcvwz pS���.ofvwtJ36�UtLq����L­Em��w�wm�«6z��.qf´Jt.±?{IqftL�n�m�rcrcm�r��VYX�=Q8L7S�B^LR`_a8LX&^LXdÈ�><8(��ÆdeNR�^LR`_a8.XZ} = ?�DI¼��J½]»= CL����= DJ�N}¤�.�J�J�N�

� ��mQq ?.�(� xu�d��m]qfz��L3j��B�_µXZ_µR\[D�ZR�^LR\[T &^L7VUJ8�W�_a^LXL/®[c:Q_µÇf_a8.X65#7c8�:Y[]ÇfÇQ[]Çf� un��J«SmQz?v�nT.,qfm�rcr�} = D�?L�I�� �7"T43.�D�D���4S�¾��m�rc¯Z�.qf3Z�Lvwr�}°�¿�X"�pZ{IoY�I} <��)4¸�L~J�J«Im�m�rf�L3ª}Á�.3d«Y.Á�X.Á�.3d�.3Z~¸�L«Sm�3ª�Z��mQocqfvwn�r��µt.q�� �.­Em��w�wm�«

z��.qf´¸t�±Br9¬Ir9ofm�z?r��°243/>@�A >�C¾D\[ �-��M�><8LXE:QeN7Y7f[]Xd:Qg�hjTZ[c8L7]g¸;,O¸H.RUTWVYXZR\;<><8.X�=�;�}N±JtJ�wpZz?mF= C�C�AtL�&�¤[c:QR\;jA�8.R\[]Ç�_µX/><8���ƾ; �d:Q_�;�}I{d�.~Jm�r��-,B@��N��?L�N�j|I{Iqfv�3S~JmQq�}�= D�D�DN�

� �7"T43.<�¸����4S�S��m�rc¯d��qf3d�.v�r�}Z�®��"�pZ{IoY�I}/<¿�R4¸�L~J�J«Im�m�rf�L3ª}¾�L3Z«L.¤��.Á�.3d�.3Z~¸�L«Sm�3ª�#À#¯Sm�z?mQocqfvwn��L3Z�L�wtJ~LpZmtL��²#m��.´+­Svwrcv�z®pZ���.ofvwtL3&�µt.q�{SqftL­d�L­Svw��vwr9ofvwnB{Iqft�n�m�rcrcm�r�� 243i5798�:�;O1��RUT�V%$&$�$]�Zg(��ƪ;��°8+*L_`:?_UX><8���ƾ; �d:Q_�;�}S{d�.~Jm�r A/=�����A��J��}j�L�L�¸�N�

� �&4�D%=J� ���  ����,z?mQqfrctJ3?�.3d«?xu� |E�14JpIof� �N�EÀjqfmQmu�.pSoftLz��.oY�I}Lz pI��n��L�wn�pS��pSr,�L3Z«B«SmQofm]qfz?v�3Z�LnQ¬W¼`mQÂNofm�3Z«Sm�«�L­Sr9ocqY�LnQo]½]�/2\3Ì5798�:�;uKJF¸XdÈ�V%$�$&$^�Zg(��ƾ;_B°8LeNXdÈ�;�89=�><8���ƪ;N�E:Q_�;w}¤{d�.~Jm�rB��C�@��N��?�?N��29�<���x�tJz?{SpSofmQqu|Nt�n�vwmQo4¬\.,qfmQrcr�} = D�D%=L�

� ��l @�C��ñ���  ��N�<z?m]qfrctJ3?�.3d«�xu� l<�Nlªm�v`�¾� T?n�vwm�3�o�z?tN«Im��ZnY¯ZmQn]´Nvw3Z~�vw3B� qY�L~Jz?mQ3Nofr<tL�¾of¯Sm{SqftJ{EtLrcv³ofv�tL3d�.�þ�\n��L�wn�pZ�wpSr���2\3y5#7c8�:�;XB�_µ7]ÇfR,V%$&$�$?�Zg(��ƾ;X�j8+*L_a:¿_µX/><8(��ƪ;�E:Q_a;�}Z{Z�L~Lm�ru��C�?9�I��?�@I} = D�@�CI�

� �<±Jm�,�?��`�®�I�,±¸mQqfmQoco�� <�m�n�pIqfrcv�±Jmu~J�Lz?m�r��ª243/><8LXSR`7]_`ºQeIR`_`8LXZÇuR�8 RUTZ[BhjTZ[c8L7]g?89=0a�^��?[]Ç�VcVcVY}J±¸tJ�wpSz?mu��DtL� � XSXE^Jb Ç�84=@ +^LRUTZ[S�?^.R`_a:f^Jb8�SR`eZÈ._�[]Çf}E{d�.~Jm�r A�?9�%?B@I} = D3,�?��

� ;Zm�� @J���b� �  ¿� ;ZmQ� «Iz��L3ª�B  «Sm�n�v�«S�L­Z�wmB{IqftJ{EtLrcvwofvwtL3d�L��{SqftL­d�L­Svw��vwr9ofvwn�«I¬I3Z�Lz?vwn �wtJ~LvwnJ��243i5798�:�;�O->LRUT� > c�Sg��uƪ;#hjTZ[c8L7YgW89=�><8(��ƪ;�}I{Z�L~JmQr��BD�@����J��DI} = D�@J�N�

� ; � @J���d� �  ¿��;Zm���«Sz��.3?�L3Z«��®�1����qfm��`�° É{IqftJ­Z�L­Zvw�wvwr9ofvwn�«I¬I3Z�Lz?vwn�wtJ~JvwnJ�°243W5#7c8�:�;¤O]PSRUT � > O�Sg��uƪ;hjTZ[c8L7Yg�84=?><8(��ƪ;�}S{d�.~Jm�r = @%=S� = D-,N} = D�@¸���

� ;¤� D�?��#4S�>;¤vw���.q��L3Z«e�B�J�,qfvwm���mJ�#><8(��ÆS[]R`_µR`_2WL[f +^L7+UJ8(W@/®[c:Q_µÇf_a8LXB5798�:Y[]ÇYÇQ[]Çf�°|I{Iqfv�3S~JmQqc���<mQqf���L~I} = D�D�?��

� *

Page 25: users.soe.ucsc.eduluca/papers/03/concur03quant.pdf · ! " # $% & ' ( ) +*, -$. /$.0,1 24365 798 : ; @ CEDGFIHJHLKNM

� �@�FD�?��^�&��upSof¯&�L3Z« �&�8��²�v��.of´¸t�²�rc´L�I� K�pZ�L3�ofv³oY�.ofvw±¸m?�.3d�L�³¬Ircvwr¿�L3d«+z?tN«Sm��ÁnY¯ZmQn]´Nvw3Z~I�B243i5#7c8�:�;O.F¸RUT�V%$&$�$?�Zg(��ƾ;X�j8+*L_a:¿_µX/><8(��ƪ;�E:Q_a;�}Z{Z�L~Lm�r =�=�=<��=��J�N} = D�D�?N�

� �D�6�L�(�ËÀ��  ¿�:��m�3S��vw3Z~Jm]q��L3d« <����6��E9pSz�«Z��q��< %n����.rcrcvw·Zn��.ofvwtL3ytL�Ár9¬Iz ­EtL�wv�n�ocqY�L3SrcvwofvwtL36r9¬Ir9ofm�z?r��Á2435798�:�;°89=�O1��RUT � XZXSeS^JbR�Zg(��ƾ;j8LXihjTZ[c8L7�; � Çaƪ;ª89=¿><8��uƪ;)�d:Q_�;�}J±¸tJ�wpZz?m = ?�?.�¿t.� �°[f:QR\;dA�8LR\[]Ç_µX/><8��uƪ;�E:Q_�;�}S{d�.~Jm�r =����N�BAS�ª|N{Sqfvw3Z~LmQqc����m]qf� �.~S}d�L�L�J�I�

� ��tJ� @L�J���y� �:��tJ��m�3ª��  {IqftJ­d�.­Zvw�wvwr9ofv�n0.,��l<��243�5#7c8�:�;�O->LRUT � > M�Zg(��ƪ;hjTZ[c8L7Yg684=�><8��uƪ;�}S{d�.~Jm�r��D>=S�I�BD�?�} = D�@L�I�

� ��tJ� @L�L­C�6� �8��tJ��mQ3j� <�m�rcpS�wofr�tL3�of¯Zm?{SqftL{EtJrcv³ofvwtJ3Z�L��þ��n��L�wn�pS�wpZr��ÉhjTS[f8.7f[]R`_a:f^Jb�><8��uÆdeNR\[]7 �E:Q_�[]Xd:][]}��?N¼a�¸½]» �J�L���N�-,BAI}�= D�@L�I�

� �¿|C�FC�C(�\4S� "®����m�z?m�3�¬�}84S� l<�<|N3Zm��w�`},�L3Z«/ ¿� Ä ���3d�L{S{j� /¿[]XZe���[]79^¸º�b�[ &^L7VUJ8�W/>°TS^._µXZÇf�+� �¤���L3s�tLr9ocqY�L3d«6x�tJz?{d�.3�¬�}�= D�C�CI�

� �6�.q D�@(�y� �  �� �6��qcofvw3j��À#¯Sm?«SmQofm]qfz?v�3Z�LnQ¬�t.� ! ���LnY´�²#m��w�<~¸�.z?m�r��/hjTZ[ N8LeN7]Xd^Jb�89=e�Zg(�?ºf8Jb _a: �°8+*L_a:Q}CJ�I¼ A�½]»=�,BC3,�� =�,B@%=J}�= D�D�@N�

� ��vw� DL�(� <¿����v��w3SmQq��)E�{EmQqY��ofv�tL3d�.���L3d«��.��~Lm�­SqY�.vwn6rcm�z��L3�ofvwn�r®tL�un�tJ3Sn�pSqcqfm�3�o®{Sqft�n�mQrcrcm�r��/243A4S�,±L�L3ljm�mQpN²�m�3j}ªm�«Iv³oftLq�}���^LXdȸºf8�8�U+84=6hjTZ[c8L7f[]R`_a:f^Jb�><8���ÆZeIR\[]7Z�E:Q_�[]Xd:][]}j±¸tL��pSz?m ! }ª{Z�L~JmQr =��L�J���=�� A��N�E�<�wrcm�±NvwmQq�|In�vwm�3Sn�mD.,pZ­Z�wvwrc¯Zm]qfr®¼`sutLqcof¯S� �utJ�w���L3d«Z½]}S uz?r9ofmQqY«S�Lz6}�= D�DJ�N�

� �L.�D>=J���Á� �6�L3S3d���L3d«& ¿�8.,3IpSm��wv`��hjTZ[�hE[S��ÆI8L79^Jb �j8+*L_a:�84= D�[c^¸:QR`_2WL[W^LXEÈ�><8LXd:QeI7Y7f[]XSRT�Zg.ÇfR\[S� ÇQM�JÆS[c:Q_ ��:Y^.R`_a8LXZ�#|I{Iqfvw3Z~Jm]qc�\�<mQqf���L~I}ZsumQ²'��t.qf´E} = D�D>=J�

� <umQv @L�(� 4S� �®��<�m�v³�4�#ljtL~Jvwn¿�UtLqu{SqftL­d�L­Svw��vwr9ofvwn¿{SqftJ~.qY�Lz?z?vw3Z~I��2\3�5#7c8�:�;�O�F¸RUT � > M�Zg(��ƪ;hjTZ[c8L7Yg�89=><8���ƾ;�}Z{Z�L~Lm�r @���=��I} = D�@L�I�

� <utLrHDJ���`�B� 2]� <�tJrcm�3�of¯Z�L�`���#eS^LXSR�^Jb�[]Ç�^LXEÈËhjTZ[]_µ7 � ƸÆdb _a:f^LR`_a8LXSÇY},±JtJ�wpZz?m��L�BA&t.��5#_µR �B^LX�D�[]ÇQ[c^L7c:YTA�8.R\[]Ç�_µX\ &^LRUTZ[S�B^LR`_a:QÇD�E[]7]_�[]Çf��ljtL3Z~Jz��.3y|Nn�vwm�3�ofvw·Zn�GÀ°m�nY¯Z3Svwn��L�`}����.qf�wt�²�} = D�DJ�N�

� |I¯Z�3,L���%l<� |¾�d|I¯Z�L{S��m]¬���|Noft�nY¯d�Lr9ofvwn�~J�Lz?m�r���5#7c8�:�;jA�^LR\; � :Y^JÈ�;��d:Q_�;�C8� � }Z��DN»=���D-,�� =�=��L�I}�= D-,L�I�� À#¯Zt�DJ�(��Ä �°À#¯ZtJz��.r��� upSoftLz��.oY�WtJ3�vw3S·Z3Zv³ofmBtL­CE4m�nQofr���243 4I�¤±L�L3�lªm�m�p�²#mQ3j}jm�«Sv³oftLq�}���^LXEȸºf8�8�U+89=

hjTZ[c8L7f[]R`_`:Y^Lbu><8��uÆdeNR\[]7e�E:Q_�[]Xd:Y[]}°±¸tL�wpZz?m ! }ªn]¯Z�L{Sofm]q AS}j{d�.~Jm�r =��3,�� = D>=J�Á�,�wrcm�±NvwmQq |In�vwm�3Sn�m.<pS­Z�wvwrc¯ZmQqfr¿¼`s�t.qcof¯S� ��tL�w� �.3d«Z½]}Z �z?r9ofmQqY«Z�.z6}�= D�DJ�I�

� À#¯Zt�D3,���Ä �ZÀ#¯ZtJz��.r���E�3�of¯Sm�r9¬I3�of¯Zm�rcvwrtL�¤r9ocqY�.ofm�~Lv�mQr�vw36vw3I·d3Zv³ofmu~¸�Lz?mQr��,243y5#7c8�:�;Á89=¿O.FJRUT � XSXZeS^Jb�Zg(��ƪ;Á8LXÌhjTZ[c8L7�; � Çaƪ;Á89=B><8��uƪ;�E:Q_�;�}I±¸tL�wpZz?m DL�J�Bt.���¤[c:QR\;°A�8LR\[]Ç�_UX/><8���ƪ;�d:Q_�;�}I{d�.~Jm�r=S� =��I�¾|I{Sqfvw3S~JmQqc���<mQqf���L~S} = D�D3,��

� ± ! Ä��%=��(� ;��°±L�L3 ! qfm�pZ~Lm����L3d« 4S�ªÄ�tLqcqfmQ�a�W �3��.��~LtLqfv³of¯Zz �UtLq®¹�pd�L3�ofv³oY�.ofvw±¸m ±¸mQqfv³·dn���ofvwtJ3it.��{SqftL­S��L­Sv��wvwr9ofvwnWocqY�.3Zrcv³ofvwtJ3/r9¬Ir9ofm�z?r��W243%>@�A >�C¾D H¸O¸M�><8LXE:QeN7Y7f[]XE:QgËhjTZ[c8L7Yg�;�O.F¸RUT+VYXZR\;�><8LX�=�;�}±¸tJ�wpSz?m��>=�,BA?tL�&�°[f:QR\;jA�8LR\[]Ç�_µX/><8��uƪ;�E:Q_�;�}I{Z�L~JmQr��L��C����3,.�I}ª�.�J�%=L�

� ± ! Ä��%=Q­:�2;���±L�L3 ! qfm�pS~Jm��u�L3Z« 4S�<Ä�t.qcqfm��`��À°t�²��qY«SrW¹�pd�L3�ofv³oY�.ofvw±¸m�±¸mQqfv³·dn���ofvwtJ3Ét.��{SqftL­d�L­Svw��vwr9ofvwnr9¬Ir9ofm�z?r��?243i5#7c8�:�;�F1�JRUT+VYXZR\;u><8JbUbw8�I�; � eIR\;��°^.X�*�;,5798+*�;�}j±¸tJ�wpZz?mB�L��?�C6tL�f�¤[c:QR\;�A�8LR\[]ÇB_UX><8���ƾ; �d:Q_�;�}S{d�.~Jm�r A���=S��A¸�¸���j|I{Iqfv�3S~JmQqc���<mQqf���L~I}E�.�J�%=L�

� ±Ns���@�� 4S�L±¸tJ3¿s�m�pSz��L3S3j��EpSq,À#¯Sm�tLqfvwm�«ImQq&"�m�rcm��w�wrcn]¯Z�.� ofrcrc{Zvwm��wmJ�8 &^.RUTZ; � XSXE^Jb }>=��J�I» �BD3,����¸�.�I}�= DJ��@N�

�'


Recommended