+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Using the Google Custom Search Engine to Search Selected ... · Thirty (52%) websites failed the...

Using the Google Custom Search Engine to Search Selected ... · Thirty (52%) websites failed the...

Date post: 06-Aug-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
1
Using the Google Custom Search Engine to Search Selected Grey Literature Websites Using the Google Custom Search Engine to Search Selected Grey Literature Websites Emmanuel Nkansah, BE, MLS; Nina Frey, MLS; Caitlyn Ford, MLIS, Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada . PURPOSE In support of the Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health (CADTH) Rapid Response service, CADTH’s Information Services department routinely searches 73 websites for grey literature. Our objective was to evaluate the reliability of the Google Custom Search Engine (GCSE) when used as a tool to optimize these searches. METHODS Evaluating the reliability of GCSE involved a three-step process: • Since website URLs are changeable entities, each URL had to be authenticated for accuracy. This phase was handled by a free FireFox browser add-on, Link Checker. Link Checker authenticated a list of URLs saved in HTML format. www.cadth.ca Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health Any website requiring a password was excluded because it is not possible to submit passwords using the GCSE interface. The remaining website URLs were collectively saved on GCSE as a test database. Using Microsoft Internet Explorer, each website in the GCSE test database was searched to retrieve a specified document. Keywords from the title of this document were used as the search terms in GCSE. If GCSE retrieved the specified document, then the website was deemed to be verified. If GCSE did not retrieve the document, then the website was said to have failed the verification test. RESULTS Fifty-eight of the 73 websites routinely searched by CADTH’s Information Services staff for grey literature (which excludes the 15 websites requiring a password to access) were tested in GCSE. Twenty-eight (48%) websites passed the verification test and were included in the GCSE. Thirty (52%) websites failed the verification test and were excluded, including one website that was excluded because it was being redesigned. Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health. Grey matters: a practical search tool for evidence-based medicine [Internet]. Ottawa: The Agency; 2008 Apr. [cited 2012 Jan 4]. Available from: http://www.cadth.ca/media/pdf/Grey-Matters_ A-Practical-Search-Tool-for-Evidence-Based-Medicine.doc Updated 2011 Jan. REFERENCES The use of GCSE significantly reduces the time required by CADTH Information Services staff to search the collection of grey literature websites for the Rapid Response service. GCSE performs these searches without compromising the quality of retrieval and without cost. GCSE is a viable solution for efficient grey literature searching in all subject areas. DISCUSSION Note: The numbers illustrated in this graph do not include the 15 websites that were screened out because they required a password. 48% 52% Screened out 15 websites requiring a password to access 21% Included 28 websites that passed verification test 38% Excluded 30 websites that failed verification test 41% Results of the GCSE Reliability Test Included 28 websites that passed verification test Excluded 30 websites that failed verification test Pass and Failure Rates of Websites Tested in GCSE
Transcript
Page 1: Using the Google Custom Search Engine to Search Selected ... · Thirty (52%) websites failed the veri˜cation test and were excluded, including one website that was excluded because

Using the Google Custom Search Engine to Search Selected Grey Literature Websites Using the Google Custom Search Engine to Search Selected Grey Literature Websites

Emmanuel Nkansah, BE, MLS; Nina Frey, MLS; Caitlyn Ford, MLIS, Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.

PURPOSEIn support of the Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health (CADTH) Rapid Response service, CADTH’s Information Services department routinely searches 73 websites for grey literature. Our objective was to evaluate the reliability of the Google Custom Search Engine (GCSE) when used as a tool to optimize these searches.

METHODSEvaluating the reliability of GCSE involved a three-step process: • Since website URLs are changeable entities, each URL had to be authenticated for accuracy. This phase was handled by a free FireFox browser add-on, Link Checker. Link Checker authenticated a list of URLs saved in HTML format.

www.cadth.caCanadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health

• Any website requiring a password was excluded because it is not possible to submit passwords using the GCSE interface. • The remaining website URLs were collectively saved on GCSE as a test database. Using Microsoft Internet Explorer, each website in the GCSE test database was searched to retrieve a speci�ed document. Keywords from the title of this document were used as the search terms in GCSE. If GCSE retrieved the speci�ed document, then the website was deemed to be veri�ed. If GCSE did not retrieve the document, then the website was said to have failed the veri�cation test.

RESULTSFifty-eight of the 73 websites routinely searched by CADTH’s Information Services sta� for grey literature (which excludes the 15 websites requiring a password to access) weretested in GCSE. Twenty-eight (48%) websites passed the veri�cation test and were included in the GCSE. Thirty (52%) websites failed the veri�cation test and were excluded, including one website that was excluded because it was being redesigned.

Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health. Grey matters: a practical search tool for evidence-based medicine [Internet]. Ottawa: The Agency; 2008 Apr. [cited 2012 Jan 4]. Available from: http://www.cadth.ca/media/pdf/Grey-Matters_A-Practical-Search-Tool-for-Evidence-Based-Medicine.doc Updated 2011 Jan.

REFERENCES

The use of GCSE signi�cantly reduces the time required by CADTH Information Services sta� to search the collection of grey literature websites for the Rapid Response service. GCSE performs these searches without compromising the quality of retrieval and without cost. GCSE is a viable solution for e�cient grey literature searching in all subject areas.

DISCUSSION

Note: The numbers illustrated in this graph do not include the 15 websites that were screened out because they required a password.

48%52%

Screened out 15 websites requiring a password to

access 21%

Included 28 websites that passed verification test

38%

Excluded 30 websites that failed verification test

41%

Results of the GCSE Reliability Test

Included 28 websites that passed verification test

Excluded 30 websites that failed verification test

Pass and Failure Rates of Websites Tested in GCSE

Recommended