LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012
UV LED charge control at 255 nm
John Conklin for the UV-LED Team Hansen Experimental Physics Labs
Stanford University
Stanford
University
King Abdulaziz City for
Science and Technology
NASA Ames
Research Center
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Science
– Special/General Relativity
– Gravitational waves
– Earth Geodesy/Aeronomy
Science & Technology Implementation on Small Satellites
Education
Grad, Undergrad
3-5 year projects
Student led tasks
Technology
Gravitational Reference Sensors
Ultra-stable optics
Precision Navigation
formation flying Science & Technology on Small Satellites
Education driven
International collaborations
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
MGRS System Overview
Grating Displacement Sensor
• Picometer sensing for science signal • High sensitivity, low dynamic range • In work
Grating Angular Sensor
• Nanoradian level angular sensing • Completed lab demo
Differential Optical Shadow Sensor
• Nanometer sensing for drag free signal • Lower resolution, high dynamic range • 2014 Launch
UV LED Charge Management
• Solid state 255nm light source • Charge control of proof mass and housing • 2013 Launch
Proof Mass Caging
Full Drag-Free System
• 70-30 Au-Pt sphere • Silicone Carbide coating • 2015 Launch
•Model of the test mass caging system
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Drag Free Control and MGRS
MGRS: Modular Gravitational Reference Sensor:
– DOSS: Differential optical shadow sensor • Nanometer level displacement sensitivity
– Grating angular sensor • Nanoradian level angular sensitivity
– Grating displacement sensor • Picometer level displacement sensitivity
– Launch lock mechanism
– UV-LED charge management
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
GRACE follow-on
Geodesy, Aeronomy
STAR
Gravitational Science
Small Sats Technology Demo Program
LAGRANGE
Gravitational Waves
UV LED Sat - 2013
(funded)
Shadow Sat - 2014
(partially-funded)
Optical Sat – 2016
(in lab)
Drag-free CubeSat – 2015
(in lab)
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Charging Sources and Effects
• Many disturbance forces:
– Solar, atmospheric, micrometeoroids…
– Charging
• Charging mechanisms:
– Direct: charged particles accumulate on either proof mass or housing
– Secondary: charged particles interact with spacecraft, knocking off electrons which then accumulate on the proof mass or housing
• Potential imbalance leads to an electrostatic force
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
UV LED Properties
• UV LEDs are:
– Now commercially available, space qualification w/ Stanford
– AlGaN based wide-bandgap (4.86eV) device with 255 nm line (12 nm FWHM)
– >10 uW output power possible
– High dynamic range (> 1 kHz modulation is possible) • Operate CM outside the science band
4 4.5 5 5.5 6 6.50
2
4
6
8
10TFW1 - V-I during functional testing
Voltage (V)
LE
D C
urr
en
t (m
A)
Pre Test
Post Thermal
Post Shake
4 4.5 5 5.5 6 6.50
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3x 10
-7 TFW1 - V-P during functional testing
Voltage (V)
LE
D O
ptica
l P
ow
er
(W)
Pre Test
Post Thermal
Post Shake
-2 0 2 4 6 8 100
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1x 10
-9 TFW1 - LED Response I-I
PD
Re
sp
on
se
Cu
rre
nt
(mA
)
LED Drive Current (mA)
Pre Test
Post Thermal
Post Shake
200 220 240 260 280 300 3200
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1TFW1 - Post Fact Spectra
Wavelength (nm)
Inte
nsity (
norm
aliz
ed)
Voltage-Current Voltage-Power Current (L)-Current(P) Spectrum
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
UV LED Charge Control
• Charge control by UV photoemission using 254 nm line of an rf mercury source successfully demonstrated on GP-B
• LAGRANGE: Newer commercial UV LEDs (240-255 nm) – Fast-switchable (> 100 MHz) allowing ac charge management through
synchronization with bias electrode
– 10 mW 10 μW at 252 nm
• Passive charge management possible for LAGRANGE – Virtual wire between TM and S/C (~5 pF capacitance)
• Space qualification complete – Lifetime: >5 years
– Radiation
– Shake, bake, shock
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
AC Charge Management Overview
“Positive Charge Transfer” “Negative Charge Transfer” “Positive Charge Transfer” “Negative Charge Transfer”
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Charge Management Experimental Setup
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Charge Management Results
System capacitance to ground is 17 pF
10 W incident UV power (255 nm), modulated at 100hz, 50% duty cycle, 3.0 Vpp bias
Sphere potential was measured using floating probe relative to surrounding housing
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
TRL 4
TRL 5
Collaboration: Stanford – ARC – KACST
Flight hardware, management
TAA with KACST
I&T, operations
Ames
Research
Center
Basic research supports
Basic research at KACST
Flight program at ARC
Stanford
University
S/C, Launch, basic res.
TAA with ARC
I&T, operations
Basic research with SU
KACST Flight data
Flight payload
“Non Conventional Collaboration” on UV-LED SAT
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Small Satellite Demonstration
• 16 total LEDs • Four bias plates • Gold coated sphere (e-beam dep’n) • Contact probe • Gold coated Ultem tubes - shielding
Scheduled for launch in 2013
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
UV LED Small Sat Components
Payload completion: May 2012
Spacecraft CDR: Aug 2012
Payload Integration: Dec 2012
Russian launch: Sep 2013
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012
Kelvin Probe for Measurements of Patch Effects
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012
Kelvin Probe Results for Au and TiC Au – Nb – Alumina 11-03-04 TiC – Alumina 11-03-04
Kelvin probe measurements: investigations of the patch effect with applications to ST-7 and LISA N. A. Robertson et al Class. Quantum Grav. 23(7) pp. 2665-2680 (2006) http://iopscience.iop.org/0264-9381/23/7/026
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Coatings Tested at Stanford
Nb MoC Au SiC
TaC ZrC TiC Nb
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Proof Mass Coatings
• Gold is soft and prone to sticking and scratching
– Alternatives: carbide coatings
– Very tough, wide bandgap (close to AlGaN)
• Test: carbide pellets coated on to Aluminum substrates via e-beam deposition
– Measured: reflectivity, quantum efficiency, surface resistivity
– Carbides are an attractive alternative for the traditional gold proof mass coatings
Material QE R (255 nm) φ (eV)*
Au 3.40E-07 0.17 4.57
Nb 5.64E-07 0.17 4.30 SiC 4.34E-07 0.12 4.80
TiC 4.48E-07 0.15 3.80
ZrC 3.85E-07 0.11 3.70 MoC 6.82E-07 0.15 4.74
TaC 6.35E-07 0.13 5.0
Ir -- 0.6 --
Top row (from left): Au, Nb, Ir, SiC Bottom row (from left): TiC, Mo2C, ZrC, TaC
QE measurement setup
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012
Material
Current Source
Drive Voltage
(mV)
LED
Current
(mA)
Sphere
Voltage
Sample
Voltage
Sample
Current
(LED off)
Sample
Current
(LED on)
Vacuum
Pressure
(torr)
Sample
current
(net)
#
electrons # photons QE mean
QE,
relative
to Au
Au 53 10 5 -5 -4.5E-13 3.15E-12 2.1E-03 3.60E-12 2.25E+07 6.41E+13
53 10 5 -5 -1.5E-13 3.45E-12 6.5E-04 3.60E-12 2.25E+07 6.41E+13 3.40E-07 1.00
Nb 53 10 5 -5 -4.3E-13 4.71E-12 2.1E-03 5.14E-12 3.21E+07 6.41E+13
53 10 5 -5 -3.4E-13 5.80E-12 5.7E-04 6.14E-12 3.84E+07 6.41E+13 5.64E-07 1.66
SiC 53 10 5 -5 -4.4E-13 3.56E-12 1.8E-03 4.00E-12 2.50E+07 6.41E+13
53 10 5 -5 -3.5E-13 4.25E-12 5.8E-04 4.60E-12 2.88E+07 6.41E+13 4.26E-07 1.25
TiC 53 10 5 -5 -1.1E-12 3.60E-12 2.0E-03 4.72E-12 2.95E+07 6.41E+13
53 10 5 -5 -2.0E-13 4.70E-12 4.7E-04 4.90E-12 3.06E+07 6.41E+13 4.51E-07 1.32
ZrC 53 10 5 -5 -6.7E-13 3.65E-12 2.0E-03 4.32E-12 2.70E+07 6.41E+13
53 10 5 -5 -3.5E-13 3.52E-12 5.1E-04 3.87E-12 2.42E+07 6.41E+13 3.92E-07 1.15
Mo2C 53 10 5 -5 5.0E-13 5.75E-12 2.0E-03 5.25E-12 3.28E+07 6.41E+13
53 10 5 -5 -2.5E-13 6.83E-12 5.5E-04 7.08E-12 4.43E+07 6.41E+13 6.48E-07 1.90
TaC 53 10 5 -5 -7.0E-13 5.42E-12 1.7E-03 6.12E-12 3.83E+07 6.41E+13
53 10 5 -5 1.0E-13 6.75E-12 5.2E-04 6.65E-12 4.16E+07 6.41E+13 6.27E-07 1.84
Photoemission Efficiency of Carbide Films
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
UV LED Small Satellite
Technology Objectives
Raise TRL levels (4/5 8/9) for
Deep UV LEDs
ac charge control
Beneficiaries:
LISA
GRACE follow-on
Drag-free CubeSat
Payload
Isolated “test mass”
16 UV LEDs & photodiodes
Charge amp
Voltage bias plates
ac charge control
electronics
Mission Design
Spacecraft: Saudi Sat
Russian launch in 2013
2 month mission
Fully funded ($1.5M)
Management
NASA ARC: Flight payload,
PM, SE, SMA
Stanford: Payload design, SOC
KACST: Spacecraft, Launch, MOC
Demonstrates unconventional
international collaboration
55 kg
50 W
Saudi Sat 3
222277180 mm
6.5 kg
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Differential Optical Shadow Sensor (DOSS)
Technology Objectives
Raise TRL level for miniature high-
sensitivity displacement sensor
nm/Hz1/2 sensitivity
No forcing
Non-contact
Payload
Light source:
SLED, 1545 nm
InGaAs quad-photodiode
Ultra-low current Difet amp
Mission Design
2U CubeSat
Any orbit
Launch ~ 2014
1 month ops
Payload funded
Management
Stanford & KACST:
Payload, CubeSat structure
I&T & Launch: pending
2 kg
4 W
2U Cube
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
The Drag-free CubeSat
Science
Earth Aeronomy, space weather
Demo < 10–12 m/sec2 for future
Geodesy
Earth observation
Gravity science
Gravity-waves
Mission Design
3U CubeSat
Secondary launch via P-POD
Launch ~ 2015
1-2 month drag-free ops in LEO
Target program: Franklin/Edison
Payload
Drag-free sensor + micro-thrusters
Management
NASA ARC: PM, SE, SMA,
mission operations
Stanford: Payload design,
drag-free control, data analysis
4 kg
6 W
3U Cube
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Fiber-coupled Optical Cavity Small Sat
Technology Objectives
Raise TRL levels for:
Frequency stabilized laser
Fiber coupled optical train
Beneficiaries:
STAR, GRACE follow-on, LISA
Mission Design
Saudi-sat compatible secondary
Any orbit, slow tumble OK
Launch ~ 2015
1 month mission lifetime
Payload
High-finesse Optical cavity
Optical fiber coupling
Low-cost laser
Modulator
photodiodes
Management
NASA ARC: PM, SE, SMA, ops
Stanford: Payload design, science
KACST: Spacecraft
55 kg
50 W
Saudi Sat 3
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Space-Time Asymmetry Research (STAR)
Science
STAR will measure:
Isotropy of speed of light to 10–17
The direction of anisotropy
Dependence on boost velocity
Mission Design
ESPA compatible on EELV
Circular sun-sync 650 km orbit
Launch ~ 2016
2-year lifetime
Class D mission
Payload
Molecular clocks
Orthogonal
optical cavities
Low-noise
comparator
Multi-layer thermal enclosure
“Deviations from Einstein’s predictions would
cause us to rethink one of the foundational
pillars of all of physical science” – Astro2010
decadal
Management
NASA ARC: PM, SE, SMA, ops
Stanford: Payload design, science
KACST: Spacecraft & Launch
DLR: molecular clocks
180 kg
150 W
ESPA
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
UV LED Small Sat Integration and Test
Construction of engineering model
ongoing at Ames, March 21, 2011
Thermovac chamber
testing
LISA 9 Symposium, May 2012 Information contained herein is not subject to Export Control or ITAR
Questions?
arXiv:1202.0585v1