3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 3

- . -1, , - . - , - .

, , , . .

,

- , - , , - , . - : , . - , . , - 2, , , -

1. ? 1 // . 2008. 4 (18). . . ? 2 // . 2008. 5 (19). .

2RawlsJ. The Idea of Public Reason Revisited // The University of Chicago Law Review. Sum-mer. 1997. Vol. 64. No. 3. P. 765 807.

4

, - , - ?3.

, , , - , - , -, . , . - - - : , - , , - . , - : -, . -, , (, - ) . , - , 4. , - .

, - . - -. , - 5. : , - -; - , ; - 6. -

3. ? 1.4HabermasJ. Religion in the Public Sphere // European Journal of Philosophy. 2006. Vol. 14.

No. 1. P. 16.5Ibid. P. 14.6Ibid.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 5

, , - , ; , , , - . , -, -, .

. -, . - , -. , , . : , -7. - , - , - , . , - . , , - , . , 8. , - : - , - 9. , - . - , . - .

. - ( ), - ,

7MeillassouxQ. After Finitude: An Essay on the Necessity of Contingency. L.: Continu-um, 2008. P. 45.

8Ibid. P. 47.9Ibid. P. 45 56.

6

, , -- , - 10.

-, , - , -. , . , , -, - , - . , , , - : , . . , , .

. , - - , - , , . , - : - , - - , 11. - . , -, - 12. , , . - ,

10 - .: HabermasJ. The Boundary between Faith and Knowledge: On the Reception and Contemporary Importance of Kants Philosophy of Religion // HabermasJ. Between Naturalism and Religion. Polity, 2008. P. 209 248.

11HabermasJ. Religion in the Public Sphere P. 19.12Ibid. P. 19.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 7

, - (, , ) - . - , , .

-, . , - . , , - . -, , . , , , - 13, . , - , , --: , - , , , , - . , -, - .

- - : - 14. , : - -. : -, - -, , , - , . : , , 15.

13JanicaudD. Le Tournant thologique de la phnomnologie franaise. Combas: d. de lclat, 1991.

14After the Postsecular and the Postmodern: New Essays in Continental Philosophy of Reli-gion (ed. A. P. Smith, D. Whistler). Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2010.

15SmithA.P.,WhistlerD. What is continental philosophy of religion now? // After the Post-secular and the Postmodern P. 2.

8

, , , , . - , - , - , , , , . , , -, .

- 16, 17 18. , - .

, , . , - . , , : - , . - , , , , 19 ( - , ). - . -, , . , , 20. - , . - . ,

16iekS. On belief. L., N. Y.: Routledge, 2001; . , - / . . . . .: - , 2003; . . . .: , 2009.

17. . / . . . . .: ; .: , 1999.

18AgambenG.The Time That Remains: A Commentary on the Letter to the Romans. Stan-ford, Stanford University Press, 2005; . . .: -, 2008.

19. . . .: , 2009. . 5 6.

20 . . 12.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 9

- - . -, , - 21, - -, 22.

- , : - - , . , , , . , , : -, -, . -, , - ! -, , - !23

- , . - : , -. ? - . , - . ( - ) ( , ) , . , , , - 24. , - , , - , . , , / -. , , , , , 25. , , : -, 26. .

21. . 397.22 . . 402 403.23 . . 402.24iekS.,MilbankJ.The Monstrosity of Christ: Paradox or Dialectic? / Creston Davis (Ed.).

Cambridge: MIT Press, 2009. P. 60.25Ibid. P. 55.26Ibid. P. 61.

10

: . , . .

, - -, , - , , - , , .

, - . - -, , , . , , , - , , . , - . .

, , - . - , - .

: - , - . , - , . . - / , -, .

, , - , / - . : -, . , , : , , .

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 11

: , , , ?27. ( - ), -, .

, , . , - 28. , , , .

, . . - , , . saeculum - , . , , - Ludisaecularis , . - saeculum - (, ). - : , , ( hocsaeculum (2 . 4:10) ). saeculum - . . , - . saeculum. XVI . - (weltliche christliche Gewalt)29. , , - , , .

27MilbankJ. Faith, Reason and Imagination: the Study of Theology and Philosophy in the 21st Century // MilbankJ. Future of love: essays in political theology. Eugene, Oregon: Cascade books, 2009. P. 320.

28SmithA.P.,WhistlerD. What is continental philosophy of religion now? P. 14.29.95 / ., . , . . . . .:

, 2002. . 23.

12

-. - , . - , - , .

, , , , . - , , .

, , . . , , -, . , - , . , , . . . , , , - : , , - . , 30. , , , - , . , : -, , ? - , ? - ? , , , , - 31. , - / , , , . , , , .

30SmithJ.Z. Religion. Religions, Religious // Critical terms for religious studies (ed. VM. Taylor). Chicago, L.: The University of Chicago press, 1998. P. 281.

31HanegraafW. New Age Spiritualities as Secular Religion: a Historians Perspective // Social Compass. 1999. June. Vol. 46. No. 2.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 13

, (- ), ?

, , , , - , . - - . , : , 32 , 33. - . -, - , , - , . -, / , - - . - - , , - , 34. - , , -35. , , - 1960- ., -, , , - .

, - , - . , , , , , - -. , ?

- -

32HolyoakeG.J.English secularism: a confession of belief. Chicago: The open court pub-lishing company, 1896. P. 35.

33Ibid. P. 36.34WallisR.The Elementary Forms of the New Religious Life. L.: Routledge and Kegan

Paul, 1984.35. : MilbankJ.Materialism and transcendence // Theology and the Political:

The New Debate / C. Davis, J. Milbank, S. iek (Eds.). Durham, L.: Duke University Press, 2005. P. 393 426.

14

. -, - - . , . - , - -36. ? - . -, , , , , , , , . -, - .

. , -, , . , , - . -, - , , , , , , , ( - ). -, , , - . . -, - , 37.

, -, , , 38. , . -, , , , , - , , - : , -

36PickstockC. Modernity and scholasticism: A Critique of Recent Invocations of Univoci-ty // Antonianum. LXXVIII. P. 5.

37BlondPh. Introduction: Theology before philosophy // Post-secular philosophy: Between philosophy and theology. Routledge, 1998. P. 3 4.

38MilbankJ., PickstockC. Truth in Aquinas. L.: Routledge, 2001.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 15

39. - , : , , , - . . - , . - 40.

. , , , , , 41. -42 naturapura . , , . -, . , . , - , , , . , , , . , , - . , , finisnaturalis, 43.

-, . , -, . . - : , . , - . -

39MilbankJ.Faith, Reason, Imagination: the Study of Theology and Philosophy in the XXI Century P. 307.

40Ibid. P. 307.41. DepoortereF. The Death of God: An Investigation into the History of the Western Con-

cept of God. T. &T. Clark Ltd., 2008. P. 12642Ibid. P. 130 131.43DuprL. Passage to Modernity: an Essay in the Hermeneutics of Nature and Culture.

New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993. P. 172.

16

: - , . , . : , , - , , - . , , , - . XVI . 44.

, , , , , : - , , , , , , -. - , , - . - - . : , - - , - , 45. , - . , . , , - 46 - , - , - 47.

, , , , -- 48.

44DepoortereF. The Death of God P. 135.45MilbankJ. Faith, Reason, Imagination: the Study of Theology and Philosophy in the XXI

Century P. 325.46. CunninghamC. Genealogy of Nihilism. L., N. Y.: Routledge, 2002.47 .: Radical Orthodoxy: A New Theology (eds. J. Milbank, C. Pickstock,

G. Ward). L.: Routledge, 1999.48AsadT.Formations of the secular. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2003.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 17

, - , , - , , , - . - , , . , , , - 49, , , , - , - , 50. , , , , , , , . -, .

: , , - - : - , , , (. . ), - (. . , , ). , , - 51. - , - : , -, . , - , : , , , , , 52. - - , , - . . , , - 53. ,

49. . / . . . . . . . . -cad, 1994. . 35.

50AllenA. Foucault and Enlightenment: A Critical Reappraisal // Constellations. 2003. Vol. 10. No 2. P. 188.

51AsadT.Formations of the secular P. 25.52Ibid. P. 23.53AsadT.Thinking about agency and pain // AsadT.Formations of the secular P. 67 99.

AsadT.Reflections on Cruelty and Torture // AsadT.Formations of the secular P. 100 126.

18

-. , , 54.

- 55. - - , , , , , , , -, , . - - , - , , - . 56. , , - - , , - , 57. . , , , -, .

-. . - , , - . , , - - . , - , , , - 58. -, , , , , , , .

- ,

54AsadT.Formations of the secular P. 25 26.55TaylorCh. A secular age. Cambridge, L.: Belknap press of Harvard university press, 2007.56Ibid. P. 3.57Ibid. P. 13.58Ibid. P. 15.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 19

(), , . , , . -, , , - , , - 59. ( ) ( ), - , .

, - : - , , [ . ..].

, -. , , , - , .

- , -, . , , , , - , - (- ). - : ( - , ) , , , - .

, , -, - (Christendom)60. , , , , , , .

59Ibid. P. 18.60Ibid. P. 514.

20

, (-, , spirituality), - 61.

, , , - , . , , , 62, -, . - , .

, , , - - . : - , - , - ?

: --, , - , ; -, - - : , , -, , - , .

. , , , , ( -) , - 63.

61 .: Ibid. P. 505 535.62. // . ., 1994. .

115.63WallersteinI.Unthinking social science: the limits of nineteenth-century paradigms.

Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 2001. P. 241.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 21

. , - , ; , , , - , , .

, - -64. 1) - 2) , 65. , ( - ) - - , , - - . , , - .

, 66 - , . - ( , ), , , 67. , . : - . . - - (1686): , -

64. : . .: Nota Bene, 1998. . 9.65 . . 9.66. // . . . 3. .: , 1988.

. 205.67. // . 95 -

/ ., . , . . . . .: , 2002. . 19 28.

22

68. : , - , - , , , 69.

- , 70. ( - ). - , , , - , . .

, , 71. , - , 72. religio73 , - , , - ; religio (, ). , religio , . Religio

68. // . 2- .. .: , 1968. . 2. . 267.

69 . . 271.70HarrisonP. The Book of Nature and Early Modern Science // The Book of Nature in Early

Modern and Modern History (ed. R. van Berkel, A. Vanderjagt). Peeters, 2006.71 . ,

. 72 (. . : -

// . 2008. 4) , , -, , , -. , , , . ( ) - , . . AsadT. Genealogies of Religion. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993; FeilE. Religio. Bd. 1 4. Gttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht, 1986 2007; HarrisonP.Religion and the Religions in the English Enlightenment. Cam-bridge University Press, 1990; FitzgeraldT.Discourse on Civility and Barbarity: A Criti-cal History of Religion and Related Categories. Oxford, N. Y.: Oxford University Press, 2007; MasuzawaT.The Invention of World Religions, or, How European Universalism Was Preserved in the Language of Pluralism. Chicago, L.: University of Chicago Press, 2005; SmithW.C. The Meaning and End of Religion. N. Y.: Macmillan, 1962. - .

73 .: . - / . . .: -, 1995. . 2. . 3.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 23

, ; - . ( ) , - 74. religio .

, - religio ( , , - ):

-, religio , - . religio, -, - - .

-, religio . , , . religio , - .

-, religio , - . religio -, .

-, religio , . Religio - , - . Religio , 75.

, , , - 76.

74 . NockA.D.Conversion: The Old and the New in Religion from Alexander the Great to Augusine of Hippo. Oxford, 1933. : ; (P. 163). - , - .

75CavanaughW. T. The Myth of Religious Violence. Secular Ideology and the Roots of Mod-ern Conflict. Oxford University Press, 2009. P. 76 79.

76, : - , . -, , .

24

, . , - , , - XVII .: - (16171688); XVIII . Religionsphilosophie , 77.

- . - 1818 .: , , - 78. -: , , , 79. , , -, .

, - , , , - . , -: , - , , 80.

- . , - . . - , , , , , 81. , , .

, . - . , , -

, , - .

77New dictionary of the history of ideas / Maryanne Cline Horowitz (Ed.). Thomson Gale, 2005. P. 1804.

78... . .: , 1975. . 1. . 80.79 . . 8380. // . . -

. .: : , 2010. . 44.81. // . 8 . .: ,

1994. . 6. . 114.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 25

, , , - , . , -, - , 82. : , -, , -, 83.

, , , . . - . , , XVIII . , -: , . , , , -, , - , ?

, : , . - .

. , -, . - -. -, , , , . - , , . , - . , , - - . - , , 84.

82... // ... . 2- . .: , 1977. . 2. . 200 333.

83. . 168 180.84 // 4 . .: , 2000.

26

: , , ; - . - , , , - 85. , , - - ( ), -, , , 86.

, - , - . , .

, , -, , , .

, - , , , - - -, , . , , , , - . , - , , - .

, - , , -, -. , , , . : , , - 87 ( ). : . , -

85CaputoJ.On Religion. L., N. Y.: Routledge, 2001. P. 63.86Ibid. P. 64.87... . .: , 1975. . 1. . 145.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 27

. -. , -, , - . , 88. - , ? - , ?

, , , . , , . - , , -, . - , , - ( )89 , , -, , . . , , , , , , , , , -. XXI . , - , .

- , , . - , . - , , . - , - . , - , , , , , , -

88... // . . . . 2- . .: , 1976. . 1. . 225.

89MilbankJ. Faith, Reason, Imagination: the Study of Theology and Philosophy in the XXI Century P. 321.

28

, 90. - , , , , . ., . , , , , , -, , -, , -, 91.

: - , - , , , .

- , , , , - . , . , , , XX ., : , , -, , , . -. , , , . - , , 92. - , , , 93.

, , ,

90CaputoJ. On Religion P. 42 43.91Ibid. P. 46.92On the Power of the Powerless: Dialogue with John D. Caputo // After the Death of God

(ed. J. W. Robbins). N. Y.: Columbia University Press, 2007. P. 133.93. On the Power of the Powerless: Dialogue with John D. Caputo P. 142 144.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 29

, , , - , . .94

- . , , . , , - : - , . , , , . - -, , , -. -, . - , -, . 95. , , , , - , , , , - 96.

- . - , , , , . - , : , - ; - , , - ; , - , , .

, , , ,

94CaputoJ. On Religion P. 2.95On the Power of the Powerless: Dialogue with John D. Caputo P. 119.96Ibid. P. 118.

30

-, - , , - , 97. - . -, -, , (, , ), , (-, , . .). - , , , - . , . - 98 , , . - ( - ). , , , -, . - - -99. , - - . , 100.

, , ( - ). , - -

97, : - , : - , . , , , , , - - , , , , , , (MilbankJ. Faith, Rea-son, Imagination: the Study of Theology and Philosophy in the XXI Century P. 320).

98. . ., .: , 2005.99. // . -

. ., .: , 2005. . 275 277.100. . ,

1981 / 1982 . / . . . . . .: , 2007. C. 40 44.

3 ( 8 2 ) 2 0 1 1 31

, . . , , , , , , , - . -, , , , , -, . , . - , , - .

?101 , - , - 102, 103. -, , , - , , - 104. - .

, , -, ( - , , - ). : ? ? - , , , - , , , , - . - , , , , , - .

, - , - . -

101. ? // . .. .: -, 2002. . 1

102 . . 348 349.103 . . 353.104 . . 353.

32

, - , -105, -. , , . : , - , , , -, , . - , , , -, 106. - .

105 . . 354.106CaputoJ.On Religion P. 60 61.

, , - .