VIE: Mong Duong 1 Thermal Power Project – Tranche 2 · Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant...

Internal Resettlement Monitoring Report Quarterly Report October – December 2014

VIE: Mong Duong 1 Thermal Power Project

– Tranche 2

Prepared by Viet Nam Electricity (EVN) GENCO 3 Thermal Power Projects Management Board 1.

EVN GENCO 3

Thermal Power Projects Management Board 1 (TPMB1)

MONG DUONG (2 x 500MW) THERMAL POWER PLANT PROJECT

INTERNAL RESETTLEMENT MONITORING QUARTERLY REPORT

Period 1st October to 31st December 2014

Contract No: TPMB1-EVN/ADB-2610L2MFF-Consulting-002

4th

Quarterly Internal Resettlement Mornitoring Report

Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant Project

Page 2 of 30

Table of Contents

ABBREVIATIONS ................................................................................................................. 31. GENERAL INFORMATION OF THE PROJECT ........................................................ 4

1.1. Mong duong Thermal Power Plant Project........................................................... 4

1.2. The Fresh Water Component .............................................................................. 4

1.3. The Scope of Land Acquisition and Resettlement................................................ 4

2. DETAILED RESETTLEMENT IMPLEMENTATION PROGRESS .............................. 52.1. Information Disclosure and Community Participation ........................................... 5

2.2. Detailed Measurement Survey............................................................................. 8

2.3. Compensation payment, assistance and resettlement ......................................... 8

2.4. Land Acquisition .................................................................................................. 9

2.5. Restoration of APs’ livelihoods and rehabilitation of APs’ lives .......................... 10

2.6. Issues concerning gender and ethnic minority ................................................... 12

3. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ........................................................ 143.1. Conclusions....................................................................................................... 14

3.2. Recommendations............................................................................................. 15

APPENDIX .......................................................................................................................... 16Appendix1 List of the affected Households .................................................................. 16

Appendix 2 Situation of Compensation Payment ................................................................. 24

4th



Page 3 of 30

ABBREVIATIONS

DCARB District compensation, Assistance, and Resettlement Board

DMS Detailed Measurement Survey

EVN Electricity of Viet Nam

FWC Freshwater Component

LFDC Land Fund Development Center

PAP Project Affected Person

PPC Provincial People’s Committee

RAP Resettlement Action Plan

TPP Thermal Power Plant

TPMB1 Thermal Power Plant Project Management Board No. 1

TRC Town Resettlement Committee

PC People’s Committee

RC Resettlement Committee

4th



Page 4 of 30

1. GENERAL INFORMATION OF THE PROJECT1.1. Mong duong Thermal Power Plant Project

Mong Duong Thermal Power Plant complex with a total combined capacity of 2’200 MW, is

located in the Mong Duong Ward (Cam Pha town, Quang Ninh province). It is situated along

Highway 18, 300 km northeast of Hanoi and 18 km from the Center of Cam Pha town. The

Project site is located at the mouth of the Mong Duong River and includes one ward (Mong

Duong) and one commune (Cam Hai). The objective of building this Plant is to increase the

capacity of the thermal electric power source and contribute to the stable supply of electricity

throughout the year and especially in the dry season when the hydro plants do not generate

much of their maximum capacity

1.2. The Fresh Water Component

The Mong Duong Thermal Generation Plant complex needs a large amount of fresh water from

4th Quarter, 2013. It is calculated that, the combined Plant needs 15.000 m3 of fresh water per

day. A fresh water supply system therefore must be constructed to serve the project. The system

consists of the reservoir, the pumping station, the 10 KV power supply to serve for the pumping

station, the water pipe line, and the access road.

Of which, only the Reservoir area and the Water Pineline area relates to land acquisition and

resettlement.

1.3. The Scope of Land Acquisition and Resettlement

Based on the detailed design, a total area of 1,849,411.39m2 with 192 households will be

permanently affected. Among the permanently affected land, 1,366,399.76m2 is affected by the

reservoir in Mong Duong Ward and 483,011.63m2 by the pipe-line and other works (access road,

powerhouse, etc) in Cong Hoa Commune and Cam Hai Commune (Cam Pha City). 34% of

affected area is productive forest land which is currently used for planting Acacia of 71

households (385 persons) in three communes/wards. FWC will also affect 8000.0m2 of residential

land of 37 households (182 persons) in Village 10, Mong Duong Ward. Cong Hoa and Cam Hai

communes will not have residential land affected by the FWCt. Area, number of households and

persons of affected land are shown detailed in Table 1 and Table 2. Beside, 17,756.5m2

temporary land is also acquired for the Project during construction phase and the compensation

was paid for the temporarily affected households.

In the pipeline, DMS also conducted in 2014 to analyze the road wideling. According to the

original design, pipeline will crossed over on road number 18, thus, the change in in alignment

should be done due to the wider road. Because of this change, 3 more households were affected

by this project.

The categories of permanently affected lands are as below:

4th



Page 5 of 30

Table 1: Affected Land Area Categorized by Communes until 31/12/2014

Reservoir Pipe line

NoCategories ofaffected land

MongDuong

Ward (m2)

Cong Hoa Commune

(m2)

Cam HaiCommune

(m2)

Sub-total(m

2)

Total (m2)

1 Residential land 8,000.0 - - - 8,000.0

2 Agricultural land 225,309.5 - - - 225,309.5

3 Forest land 305,863.50 195,251.53 129,451.60 324,703.13 955,626,76

4 Aquacultural area 13,872.65 269.00 12,687.80 12,956.80 39,786.25

5 Public land 813,354.16 98,304.20 47,047.50 145,351.70 958,705.86

Total 1,366,399.76 293,824.73 189,186.90 483,011.63 2,332,423.07

(Source: TPMB1, Updated in December 31st, 2014)

Table 2 Number of HHs and Persons whose land affected in each Commune til 31/12/2014

Mong Duong WardCong HoaCommune

Cam Hai CommuneTotal

NoCategoriesof affectedland

No. ofAHs (HH)

No. ofAPs

(person)

No. ofAHs (HH)

No. ofAPs

(person)

No. ofAHs (HH)

No. ofAPs

(person)

No. ofAHs (HH)

No. ofAPs

(person)

1Residentialland

37 182 0 0 0 0 37 182

2Agriculturalland

127 508 42 168 23 95 192 768

3Forest land(for acaciaplanting)

19 88 35 148 17 69 71 305

4Aquacultureland

7 41 1 4 1 4 9 49

(Source: TPMB1, Updated in December 31st, 2014)

2. DETAILED RESETTLEMENT IMPLEMENTATION PROGRESSDetailed on the progress of Resettlement Plan Implementation is in the Annex 2

2.1. Information Disclosure and Community Participation

The objectives of Information dissemination and community consultation include: (i) enhancing

the local people’s awareness of the project; (ii) Ensuring the design of a reasonable re-

resettlement and income restoration programe compared to the demands of the affected

households maximizing the socio-economic benefit of project; (iii) ensuring that the affected

people are able to participate and make proper selections of the issues which may directly impact

on their income and living standard; (iv) Ensuring the transparency of all activities related to land

withdrawal, displacement and economic restoration ; (v) Obtaining the co-operation participation

4th



Page 6 of 30

and contribution of ideas from the affected people to the activities to be done for the planning and

implementation of resettlement, preparation and carrying out of income restoration and livelihood

enlargement programs; (vi) Creating a continuous dialogue mechanism, addressing the

supervision and implementation issues; (vii) Creating a continous dialogue mechanism,

addressing the supervision and implementation issues; (viii) surveying the measures to control

the natural resource with the aim to achieve a suistainable use and preservation

During the preparation of draft resettlement plan in 2009,, the orientation meeting was conducted

by Thermal Power Project Management Unit No.1 (TPMB1) and DCARB of Cam Pha city with

relevant parties and affected households. Project information has been delivered to 100%

affected households (such as introduction of detailed technical design, scope of impacts on land

and asset upon on lands, entitlements for compensation, assistance and resettlement,

implementation schedule of land acquisition, compensation, assistance and resettlement and

grievance redress mechanism). The documents have also been placed in public places and in the

house of village leaders and head of mass-organization

During the implementation of Resettlement Plan, information disclosure activity was continuously

and regularly implemented through the implementation progress. This kind of activity is to

enhance local awareness, reduce grievance or complaints from AHs as well as speed up the

implementation of the project’s components. The information disclosure was mainly carried out

through: residential meetings, delivery of notices to each household, posting up notice at local

government’s offices, delivery of project leaflets and posters, direct meetings with AHs by

TPMB1’s, and local authorities. The disclosed information included; (i) information about the

compensation policy and the right of AHs; (ii) information about environmental impacts; (iii) issues

arising from the construction execution affecting local people.

From 1 th October to December 31 th 2014, many consultation meetings on the payment and

Income Restoration program and assistance among the affected households has arranged at the

headquarters of Communal People’s Committees. Besides, local were also informed of the

arrangements of the project compensation, responsibilities of relevant stakeholders and

grievence redress mechanism and result of grievance redress as well as newly arising issues

during the project implementations.

The results of the consultation show that most of the affected people have been aware of the

process of the project RP Implementation by listening or seeing. Some of the illiterate Project has

signed into the documents of compensation money transference by pressing their fingerprints

under the witness of a majority of attendees and with the confirmation of local authority to ensure

the explicitness. Both men and women from affected households are encouraged to attend, as

well as other interested community members. The list of public meetings for the Fresh Water

Component is provided in the following Table.

4th



Page 7 of 30

Table 3 Summary of consultations undertakenWard/commune Time Contents Participants Comments from participants

14/10/2014 Meeting at Mong duongward to implement theIncome RestorationProgram

Ward PC, TPMB1 Implement Vocational trainingfor affected households

25/11/2014 Public Consultationabout IncomeRestoration program

Cam Pha LFDC,CPC, head ofResident Area,TPMB1, affectedhouseholds No.10commune

The head of Resident Area andTPMB1 conduct the publicconsultation for affectedhouseholds

28/11/2014 Consultation for affectedhousehold about thesustainable livelihoodstrategy

Cam Pha LFDC,CPC, head ofResident Area,TPMB1, affectedhouseholds No.10commune

Communication programabout the appication thetraining course of IRP inproduct of local people

15/12/2014 Meeting at Mong duongward to check thelivelihood of affectedhouseholds after get thepayment

Ward PC, TPMB1 All the checked affectedhouseholds have restoredlivelihoods as the same levelor better than that prior to theproject, and they haveadaptable to their newconditions and improved theirincome

Cộ ng Hoàcommune

26/11/2014 Meeting at Cong HoaCommune to check thelivelihood situation ofaffected households


Cẩ m Hả i

commune26/11/2014 Meeting at Cam Hai

ward to implement theIncome RestorationProgram


The meetings were included all affected households, local authorities, head of mass-

organizations and village leaders. The total turns of participants are around 950 people, of whom

560 people are female (accounting for 55.4%).

Consultations continue to be deployed in the project area through community meetings. 100% of

affected households were consulted 3 times or more on the project’ policy of land acquisition,

compensation, support, and resettlement.

Affected people have been consulted on the needs of participating in the income restoration

program, however, many households are still not aware of the importance of the program,

therefore, they are not ready to participate in the program. Propaganda, information

disseminating to these households will be continuously performed during the implementation of

the income restoration program.

The consultation process has also paid its attention to the needs of women and vulnerable

groups such as the poor, single women headed household, elderly or some other policy objects.

4th



Page 8 of 30

Due to the Consultants providing information adequately and transparently on compensation

entitlements the complaints of affected people are not considerable in numbers.

2.2. Detailed Measurement Survey

The project mainly cover: (i) Mong duong ward where the reservoir has been constructed; (ii)

Cam Hai and Cong hoa Communes where the pipeline has been constructed. Detailed

Measurement Survey was completed before November 10th, 2012. Due to changes in technical

alternatives or some assets outside the project sites but is no longer valid for use left, some

added surveys was carry out in 2014 to compensate for the household

The Inventory of losses has been done with the participation of the relevant parties include: (i)

TPMB1 and Cam Pha Land Fund Development Center; (ii) Communal cadastral officer and

representatives of communal authorities; (iii) Representatives of affected hamlets and; (iv)

representatives of affected households (normally householders)

The Plan of compensation assistance and resettlement/relocation has been prepared based on

the Project Policy Framework ( as stated in RP) approved by ADB and the decision issued by

People’s Committee of Quang ninh Province. The Project Policy has considered that: the

household suffered from losses of plants, trees, structures have been compensated by cash with

assistances such as displacement fees, rewards for good progress in site-hand over, income

restoration and social benefits for Vulnerable Group

The discrepancies and omissions in the loss inventory process or other damages arising due to

changes in technical alternatives or some assets outside the project sites but is no longer valid for

use caused by land acquisition was timely inventory replenishment to ensure the entitlements of

the affected people, ensuring compliance RP framework of the project.

Need assessment survey was conducted in July 2013 to design and implement the measures for

income and livelihood restoration. Participants choosed the vocational training, Aacia’s Cultivating

and the breeding’s model. The Income Restoration Program has prepared by TPMB1 and

approved by ADB

In the pipeline, 3 more households were affected in DMS 2014 by this project After making the

DMS survey, the project prepared a summary table of DMS’s result then publicized at hamlet

community houses. Any complaints about affected assets such as land area, structures, trees

and other properties were checked and verified by members of Compensation Board. The records

of additional DMS (if any) will be made after reaching an agreement and having the signature of AHs

representatives. As a result, all that household got their payment and restored their income

2.3. Compensation payment, assistance and resettlement

As of December 31st, 2014, the project has basically completed payment of compensation and

support to affected households. In the freshwater pipeline and power line 65 affected households

have got payment with the amount of VND 17,059,295,200. In the Reservoir Area, the total 127

households affected households have paid with the amount 84,012,033,600. Timing of payments

from 2012 to May 10th 2014.

The total budget of approved compensation, assistance and resettlement is VND

103.837.805.600,and VND 103.837.805.600 has been paid for the affected people (including

budget for the DCARB), reached 100%.

In general, The Application Cost for the project was in compliance with the provisions of ADB

about the Compensation and Assistance will be based on the principle of replacement cost

(market value in normal conditions) at the time of The Compensation Implementation.The TPMB1

4th



Page 9 of 30

has many solutions to make sure that all the displaced Households in the project without having

any certificate of Land Use rights or any legal recognition of the acquired land are eligible to

receive compensation and resettlement assistance, non-land assets to support the replacement

cost of ABD and policies of Vietnam’s Law.

2.4. Land Acquisition

According to the implementation process of the project, land acquisition has been implemented

after project affected household Have received compensation, assistance and resettlement, at

least , in the time of 30 days

The land acquisition and resettlement has achieved good results in general for the Pipeline

Component (Cong Hoà and Cam Hai communes), and also in Resevoir. 127/127 affected

household in Resevoir got the payment. Site clearance rate for Reservoir Component has

completed 100%, the water has stored up in the Resevoir since January 2014, now has

integrated into the freshwater lake to fix with the design with construction depth of Dam 15m at

least metres of water

There are 117 land plots of households in the Resevoir which are recovered additional at

17.5metres depth of Dam to prevent the risk in case stream level rose high extraordinary by the

flood. The compensation step has been done based on the framework of project’s policy. TPMB1

and the local government implemented the compensation, all the affected households got the

payment and moved out of the resevoir to hand over the land for project

Of total 37 resettlement households, 12 households returned their fatherland in another province

such as Hai Phong, Lang Son, Bac Giang and Quang ninh because they migrated to this area 15

-25 years ago and now they come back the origin; 25 other households still stay inside the

commune but move near to the 329 road. The staying households situation as follows: (i) 25 HHs

completed repaired their facilities such as yard, roof, shed, workshop equipment; (ii) 12

househods have built the new house in the mainroad of the community, of which 8 households

finished build the brick houses and moved to their new houses, 7 households finished to build

the 2 floors house with shop/ restaurant, and 2 houses are under construction; (iii) 8/37 relocation

households bought a small truck to make the transportation service business. These households

have restored income by using the amount of compensation they received from the compensation

payment; (iv) 12/37 relocated households had opened a shop such as rice shop, grocery store or

small restaurants and other business related to be essential items for daily life of local people

All households have access to clean water and electricity, and some of households also have

accessed to potable water supply because they buy their own pumpling machine to collect the

water from streams. The Broadcasting Wave is being upgraded by Cam Pha city People’s

Committee, households in Mong duong may soom approach the Radio and Watch Tivi with better

with better quality

4th



Page 10 of 30

Table 4 Status of Relocation household until December 31th

, 2014

NoAffected Household

situation HHs Remarks

House

1 Repair the facilities 25

10 households repaired water tanks, , 5households repaired chicken pigsty10 other households repaired thegarden, electricity line, wells

2 Build a new house 128 households buit the brick house, 7households buit the 2-3 floors house

3 House is under construction 2They have finished construction and nowset up the water and electricity line

4 HHs has not build new house 0

Sell the house and move toother place

12

5 hhs to Hai Phong, 5 hhs to Lang son,and 2 hhs move to other village in Quangninh province (8 HHs are underconstruction and 4 HHs have not builtyet)

I.1.1.Land

1 Buy a new agriculture land 20

2

Buy a new resident land

25

3Not buy any kind of land

8They have their own land or they are tooold

Staying/Moving

1

Move to other place

12

10 of removed households built the newhouse, other have repaired orconstructed

2

Staying in Mong Duong ward

25

Other facilities

1Buy working tools (such assaws, sawmills, tractors etc) 15

2Buying buy trucks, pickuptrucks, cargo vehicles 8

3

Open the new shops such asrestaurant, beer’shop, ricesales’s shop, selling essentialsother facilities for local people 17

2.5. Restoration of APs’ livelihoods and rehabilitation of APs’ lives

Land acquisition for construction of the Project has caused certain impacts on the households in

the Project area. However, these impacts have been minimized at least by relevant parties since

the design stage of project

Besides compensation for affected land and property, the project has adopted many policies to

support affected households to ensure the progress of relief work as well as the interests of the

people and help them to restore stable life

4th



Page 11 of 30

All the affected households who get the payment received full assistances according to project

policies such as living stabilization assistance, occupation transmission assistance, and business

stabilization assistance.

To mitigate the risk for AHs, the income restoration has been prepared in RP and also in the

Updated RP approved by ADB

The project has complied with the policies which stipulated in the Resettlement Plan in which

clearly defined that all the severely affected household loss from 10% or more of productive land,

relocated households and the vulnerable households will not only get assistance fully from

project but also be participated in the Income Restoration Plan. The project has conducted

surveys for subsistence needs of households affected by the project . Based on the needs of

people affected , the income restoration program has been developed and approved by ADB and

TPMB1 and has implemented since 1/2014 .

Therefore, Income Restoration Plan (IRP) was prepared in order to (i) ensure entitlements for

Project affected persons (PAPs) are prepared in a transparent, consistent and equitable manner;

(ii) identify severe APs that require assistance other than cash compensation to restore their

livelihoods; (iii) design and implement the measures for income and livelihood restoration; and (iv)

establish monitoring and evaluation mechanisms on IRP implementation.

The aim of this IRP is to minimize the adverse impacts of the Project and to ensure that income

and livelihoods of AHs will be restored and improved better or at least equal pre-project levels.

As in December 2014, The Income restoration Programs have been implemented and included

the following steps: (1) Establish Management Program Committee (2) Organize the consultation

in 100% wards in the project area, (3) Cost Estimation has been prepared and approved by the

TPMB1 city; (4) Communications and dissemination of effective economic models in the project

wards by establishing material facilities and information channels for livelihood restoration

programs; (5) PMU has selected the center provide the agriculture technical training for the

income restoration program and began conducting training for farmers; (6) Deployed model

vocational training according to the Income restoration program which has been approved by

ADB; (7) Conducted community awareness programs in various forms such as through television

reports, through the training materials and integration in community activities

After the need assessment survey in participating in income restoration programs, an income

restoration plan was approved by ADB in March and have been implemented. As soon it is

approved by the ADB, icome restoration activities have been conducted immediately. The TPMB1

and the Land Fund Development Centre have coordinated to carry out the activities as follows:

1. Information dissemination Implementation included: (i) Conducted the Information

dissemination about Income Restoration Program and models livelihood restoration through

community meetings in Mong Duong ward, Cam Hai commune and Cong Hoa commune; (ii)

Selected and signed contract with Radio and TV Cam Pha town to implement the Disclosure of

information on policies and livelihood restoration programs through local information channels.

The main content of this activity is to communicate about effective economic models in the

region, in the country and other areas; provide technical guidance and production outputs,

communications through the local radio and Cam Pha province Television (each news from 15’-

20)’

2. Management and Training for Steering Committee conducted in 28th July 2014: (i) Established

the "Steering Committee of IRP Implementation” includes: Representatives from TPMB1,

Representative of the City’s leadership, City RC, the related agencies (Farmer’s Association,

Women’s Union, Agriculture Expansion Station,Economic Department); Representative of ward

or commune, Farmer’s Association, Women’s Union, Land Officials, village leaders. This

4th



Page 12 of 30

Committee is resposible for inspecting, supervising, monitoring to implement the IRP, to quarterly

report on the IRP implementation and to participate in solving the issues of implementation

process; (ii) held a meeting of Steering Commitee of IRP, to disseminate the content of IRP of the

Project and assign specific tasks for the members; (iii) TPMB1 coordinate with Consultant,

Agricultural extension center of the Province and city, Agricultural extension associations and

another organization to prepare the technical Support for training; (iv) Carried out the

Management Training

3. Acacia and Livestock Technique Training Implementation conducted: (i) TPMB1 coorperated

with the Agricultural Extension Centers and Department of Economics to set up the schedule for

the training courses on application of technics and the guidelines on capacity and productivity

improving, using the high quality Acacia trees; (ii) The training course carried out on 27 of June

2014 with 52 participants. At the monitoring’s survey, 95% the affected household was attended

and high appriciated about the result of the training and they thought that all the knowledge they

got from the course could be applied in their forestry activity. At the time of monitoring, 5

households have applied the model of Acacia planting in their forestry model which used high

quality Acacia auriculiformis as an intensive plantations model, primarily basal fertilizer inorganic

and microbial fertilizer. 5 other households who have a big garden remaining has applied the high

quality chicken modeling by using the steel mesh enclosure the garden and drop chicken inside

to feed. All the production models of the household is technical supported by the authorities and

Mong duong Department of Agriculture

4. Vocational Training Model Implementation: (i) signed the contract with Vocational Training

Centrer such include the Industrial and Construction Vocation College of Quang Ninh Province ,

Mining College Hữ u Nghị, Industrial College of Cam Pha, Vocational Center of Cam Pha

City,Provincial Women Union, Vocational College belong to Mining Company to support for the

affected household to attend; (ii) provided the information about available course and collected

the list of participants to support for basically vocational training such as automotive and

motorcycle repair, Mechanics, Electricity and Water Pluming Repair, Sewing Industry worker. The

Cooking vocational course was openned on 24th July 2014 with 12 members of affected

households attend. Other vocational course was openned on 24th July 2014 is motorcycle repair

with 10 people attending. Based on knowledge have been trained, 3 households have opened

their motorcycle-repair shops, 1 household opens stores offer repair and plumbing service, and

two other families are processing overlock clothing at home. According to the report of local

authorities, income from non-farm activities and forestry increased by 30% in 2014. The income

restoration programmes also facitilated the development of local economy in Mong duong

increased 10% on average

The local people in general are satisfied with the result of the lost inventory, compensation price

assistance and resettlement policies of the Project with the rate up to 100% people who was

intervied. With the loss of agricultural land household: They are highly appreciated with the

counting method, applying the replacement cost and compensation payments. As of

Resettlement Monitoring the household who lost some Item during DMS was additional

compensation.

In 2014, among 25 complaint letters from 25 affected household relates to misidentify the

acquired land and compensation rate. And all 25 of complaints had been solved. The 2

households have not been solved in the semi-annual report in July 2014 has agreed to get

payment and moved to the new place and restore their livelihood

2.6. Issues concerning gender and ethnic minority

Gender Issue: Gender equality is one of the important criteria to evaluate the development of a

community. Gender issues have been detailed in the RP that is being updated in term of the

4th



Page 13 of 30

socio-economic situation of females and gender strategy to ensure the effective integration of

gender related issues into such documents

Activities of RP implementation in the locality have been regconized by TPMB1 during the field of

monitoring such as community consultant, information dissemination through meeting with the

local people, answering questions arising during the meeting of community Consultation. The

Cam Pha Town Resettlement Committee (TRC) include women representatives from the Mong

Duong Ward and Women Union of the Residential Area No.10 to represent the interests of

women in the affected households. Capacity-building training were provided to the leaders of the

Women’s Union, by the social consultant of the TPMB1, to increase their participation in the TRC.

The participation of women in leadership and decision making in resettlement planning were

guaranteed through equal representation of men and women during the resettlement

implementation.Training program to enhance the awareness of the local people about the

HIV/AIDS was also mainstreamed inside the healthcar for the women.

During group discussions, it was mentioned that household members rely on men’s decision with

regard to business decisions while women are responsible for household chores. Men are more

likely affected because they are the primary income-earners in the households. In Mong duong

commune, when we asked about shifting to a new job most of the interviewed said that they are

old and cannot work as hired labour. They are relying on their children for support. Younger male

said they will shift to seasonal construction work. Women have to take care of their families, look

after their children.

By in-depth interview with women in the affected communities, the consultant found out women’s

awareness on environment sanitation in hamlet and healthcare for themselves. Because the

project is conducting in the urban area, the women understand clearly about the gender equity as

well as their society role. The women who are impacted by the project play an important role in

their family and also in the mass organizations. 95% ofinterviewed women attended the

community meetings. Most of women are confident to discuss about project activities and the

income restoration plan.

Land use rights certificates (LURC) for residential plots are registered under the namesof both

husband and wife. LURCs for plots at the resettlement site will also be registered under the

names of both husband and wife.However, with regard to agricultural lands LURCs in the area

are usually issued to women as they directly involved in agricultural production activities.During

discussions, DPs mentioned that household members rely on men’s decision with regard to

business decisions while women are responsible for household chores. Men are more likely

affected because they are the primary income-earners in the households.

Ethnic Minority Issue: The population of the commune mostly affected by the project, Ward No.

10, is inhabited predominantly by members of the two ethnic minorities living in this area, Dao

and Tay, while in the area affected by the pipeline, the majority is Kinh. The community

consultation, project information disclosure for all PAPs, including ethnic minorities have been

conducted in the project during the project implementation by TPMB1, People Committee of

Mong duong, and the Communes in the project regions. Seriously the Asian Development Bank

has provided affected households in the vulnerable group including minorities with a certain

amount to support their life and livelihood development in compliance with the updated RP and

legal framework

Together with the efforts in State governance reform at the macro level, local governance reform

plays an important role in poverty reduction for affected household. No10 Village institutions, both

official and unofficial, are the basis for local governance. Strong village institutions enhance

community assets and increase the effectiveness of external support. Forming and strengthening

village institutions contributes to local governance reform and to the development of rural civil

4th



Page 14 of 30

society. By the supporting from TPMB1 and Mong Duong People Committee have special

focused on conducting the assistance for local people, mainly the poverty, income, agriculture

production, housing conditions, and access to the basic public services

3. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS3.1. Conclusions

The dissemination of information about the project in general and the policy on Compensation,

support and Resettlement has been coordinated between TPMB1 and stakeholders with efforts.

Most of interviewees said that they had received information about the project as well as the

compensation policy of the implementing agencies. Information dissemination, community

consultation have witnessed the cooperation of DCARBs of Cam Pha city along with Mong Duong

ward in the project region and have basically conducted as per the regulated process resulting in

the certain efficiency. The policy priorities of the City support has been consulted dissemination to

affected households and communities, contributing relatively satisfactorily in resolving the

complaints and questions which still remain.

The site Clearance and Resettlement of the Project are now basically completed. The

Resettlement Policy has been implemented in a satisfactory way by TPMB1 that ensuring

meeting the objectives of the project. The problems happended in the implementation has been

solved in time by exchange and collaborate solution by stakeholders. The Resettlement Policy has

been implemented in a satisfactory way that ensure meeting the objectives of the project. The

problems happened in the implementation has been solved in timeby stakeholders through exchange

and collaborating solutions.

Implementing the activities on compensation, assistance and resettlement were delayed in

comparison with the approved resettlement plan. Progress on compensation and resettlement

implementation until December 31th, 2014 is 100%. The compensation payment completed

100% of total of anticipated compensation budget.

The dissemination of project information in general and the policy on compensation, support and

resettlement has been done with effort in the coordinationbetween MRB and stakeholders. Most

of interviewees said that they had received information about the project as well as the

compensation policy of the implementing agencies.

The resolution of questions and complaints feedback of the affected household has been doneby

TPMB1, local governments and related stakeholders. These questions raised in the construction

process such as the material gathering influence traffic, tunnel construction work was calculated by

TPMB1 to make sure that it will be solved to ensure the rights of the affected household.

In general, Compensation, Assistance and Resettlement of the project was carried out basedon the

Legal Framework of RAP, they followed up the scheduled in RAP and public for affected household

before payment. 100% affected people agreed with the Implementation steps of the project.

Granting land use right certificates (both resident land and production land) for relocated

households in Mong Duong is being submitted to CPC for approval, other land area have not

been implemented

At the monitoring time, 100% of relocated households moved out of the Resevoir, they repaired

the facilities and built the new house, some other households left Mong duong to their homeland

in another province. Among relocated households, 15 households have their new own business

such as transportation service and small business

4th



Page 15 of 30

Gender equity and ethnic minority activities have been effectively intergrated into the project

activities

The income restoration program have approved by ADB and implemented by TPMB1 with a good

results. The project has established the “Steering Committee, carried out the public consultation

and implemented the Vocational Training

3.2. Recommendations

The dissemination of information about the project operation need to continue to support

information to the community and policies as well as their interests in the Project. TPMB1 and

stakeholders should collaborate more in solving problems which could be arised in the Process of

Resettlement and Income Restoration of affected household in particular and the other affected

households in general.

The PC of Quang Ninh province, and DCARBs of Cam Pha city should pay its special attention

and put emphasis on households that have to move to another place and/or those are serverely

affected on their income source. The PC should approve, make decisions and create favorable

conditions for remaining households to move to the new place as well as the activities to restore

income of the affected households.

TPMB1 should closely cooperate with the PC of Quang Ninh province, Cam Pha city, and

DCARBs of city to support and create favorable conditions of compensation funds, to help the

locality to resolve shortcomings related to land acquisition and resettlement in an effective and

timely manner to ensure the planned implementation of the project

Quickly complete the granting of land use right-certificates for resettled households and prevent

the encroachment problem of agricultural and forestry land which has been handed over to

hamlet community

Income restoration activities should be conducted based on the approved IRP of ADB and that

program should calculate the vulnerable group and ethnic group in any stage. The TPMB1 should

closely with the PC of Quang ninh province, the PC of Cam Pha city to support the forestry land

for affected household by the land funding of The Cam Pha Forestry Company

It is necessary to enhance the participation of women in community activities and their ideas

sharing in meeting leaded by women union. Training course on gender equity should be held at

all the communesfor both men and women to increase the society on women’s equity.

4th



Page 16 of 30

APPENDIX

Appendix1 List of the affected Households

Cộ ng Hòa commune

Family member

Male Female Job situation of the hhs membersNo

Name of household

headEthnic

Under18

years

old

Above18

years

old

Under18

years

old

Above18

years

old

Employment Unempoyment

Primary

Income

Secondary

Income

1 Bàng Phư ơ ng Hùng Kinh 2 1 2 3 WorkerForestry planting

2 Bế Vă n Mít Tày 1 1 1 1 2Forestry planting Trader

3 Bế Vă n Việ n Tày 1 1 2 1 2 FarmerForestry planting

4 Bùi Hữ u Đ ài Kinh 2 1 1 2 FarmerForestry planting

5 Bùi Hữ u Luân Kinh 2 1 1 3 FarmerForestry planting

6 Bùi Đ ứ c Chinh Kinh 1 1 TraderForestry planting

7 Đ ào Xuân Tuy Kinh 1 1 3 1 TraderForestry planting

8 Đ ỗ Thành Minh Kinh 1 1 Worker Trader

9 Đ ỗ Thị Bả y Kinh 1 3 1 Farmer Worker

10 Hà Thị Thuỷ Tày 3 1 1 FarmerForestry planting

11 Hà Vă n Chung Kinh 1 1 1 1 1 FarmerForestry planting

12 Hà Vă n Lư ờ ng Tày 1 1Forestry planting farmer

13 Hà Vă n Lư u Kinh 1Forestry planting farmer

14 Hà Vă n Mùi Kinh 2 1 1 2 TraderForestry planting

15 Hà Vă n Nă m Kinh 1 1 2 FarmerForestryPlanting

16 Hà Vă n Tầ n Kinh 1 3 4 FarmerForestryPlanting

17 Hà Vă n Thuỵ Kinh 1 3 2 3 FarmerForestryPlanting

18 Hoàng Minh Thắ ng Kinh 1 1 Soldier Trader

19 Hoàng Thị Minh Tày 1 1 1 1 2Forestry planting

ForestryPlanting

20 Hoàng Vă n Toàn Tày 3 2 5 FarmerForestryPlanting

21 Lạ i Vă n Tòng Kinh 3 1 4 WorkerForestryPlanting

4th



Page 17 of 30

Family member

Male Female Job situation of the hhs membersNo

Name of household

headEthnic

Under18

years

old

Above18

years

old

Under18

years

old

Above18

years

old


Primary

Income

Secondary

Income

22 Mã Vă n Sáng Tày 1 2 1 1 3 FarmerForestryPlanting

23 Ngô Thị Vân Kinh 1 1 3 4 TraderForestryPlanting

24 Nguyễ n Đ ứ c Nhuầ n Kinh 3 2 5 TraderForestryPlanting

25 Nguyễ n Đ ứ c Thành Kinh 1 1 WorkerForestryPlanting

26 Nguyễ n Đ ứ c Tố t Kinh 1 1 SoldierForestryPlanting

27Nguyễ n Hữ uNhuyên Kinh 2 3 5 Farmer

ForestryPlanting

28 Nguyễ n Ngọ c Hiế n Kinh 1 1 SoldierForestryPlanting

29 Nguyễ n Thị Thuỷ Kinh 1 2 2 2Forestry planting

ForestryPlanting

30 Nguyễ n Thị Tình Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 TraderForestryPlanting

31 Nguyễ n Vă n Huế Kinh 1 1 SoldierForestryPlanting

32 Nguyễ n Vă n Phư ợ ng Kinh 2 2 4 FarmerForestryPlanting

33 Nguyễ n Vă n Thành Kinh 1 2 1 2 FarmerForestryPlanting

34 Nguyễ n Vă n Tớ i Kinh 1 1 SoldierForestryPlanting

35 Nông Vă n Lan Tày 2 1 1 3Forestry planting

ForestryPlanting

36 Phạ m Nam Hư ơ ng Kinh 1 1 SoldierForestry Planting

37 Phan Thị Nhậ t Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 TraderForestryPlanting

38 Tô Vă n Nà

SánDìu 1 1 1 2 3

Forestry planting

ForestryPlanting

39 Bùi Quố c Duy Kinh 1 1 3 4 TraderForestryPlanting

40 Hà Mạ nh Hùng Tày 1 2 1 1 3 FarmerForestryPlanting

41 Trầ n Thị Châu Kinh 1 1 FarmerForestryPlanting

42 Cong Hoa Commitee

4th



Page 18 of 30

Cam hai:

Family member

Male Female

Job situation of the hhs

membersNoName of household

headEthnic

Under

18

yearsold

Above

18

yearsold

Under

18

yearsold

Above

18 years

old


Primary

Income

Secondary

Income

1 Bùi Vă n Tay Kinh 3 1 2ForestryPlanting

trader

2 Đ ào Xuân Quang Kinh 1 1 2 2ForestryPlanting

farmer

3 Hà Vă n Dư ơ ng Kinh 1 1 Trader farmer

4 Hà Vă n Tình Kinh 1 1 WorkerForestryplanting

5 Hoàng Vă n Ngọ c Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

6 Lê Đ ứ c Tính Kinh 1 Trader farmer

7 Lư u Đ ứ c Oanh Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 WorkerForestryplanting

8 Đ ỗ Vă n Lỳ Kinh 2 1 1 3ForestryPlanting

famer

9 Mai Thị Việ t Kinh 1 1 2 1 3 WorkerForestry

planting

10 Hoàng Vă n Ngọ c Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

11 Nguyễ n Vă n Việ t Kinh 1 1Farmer Forestry

planting

12 Nguyễ n Vă n Tầ n Kinh 3 2 5Farmer Forestry

planting

13 Nông Thị Vấ n Tày 1 TraderForestry

planting

14 Phạ m Bá Quyế t Kinh 1 1 2 WorkerForestry

planting

15 Phạ m Thị Gái Kinh 2 2 3 2Aquaculture Forestry

planting

16 Trầ n Thị Thúy Nga Kinh 3 1 3Worker Forestry

planting

17 Phạ m Thị Thu Ánh Kinh 1 1 2Worker Forestry

planting

18 Trư ơ ng Thị Dịu Kinh 1 1 1 2 WorkerForestry

planting

19 Trư ơ ng Vă n Trò Kinh 2 1 AquacultureForestryplanting

20Trầ n Thị Bùng Kinh 1 1 1 1 Aquaculture

Forestryplanting

21Trầ n Thị Châu Kinh 1 1 Trader Farmer

22Từ Minh Ngọ c

SánDìu 1 2 1 2 Farrmer

Forestryplanting

23 Hoàng Vă n Nghiên Kinh 1 1 1 1 2 AquacultureForestryplanting

4th



Page 19 of 30

No10.ward

Sexual

Male Female


membersNo

Name of

household headEthnic

Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old

Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old


Primary

income

Secondary

income

1 Bàn Vă n Nă m Dao 1 1 12

FarmerForestryplanting

2 Bùi Quang Chiế n Kinh 1 3 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

3 Bùi Quang Chính Kinh 1 FarmerForestryplanting

4 Bùi Quang Cư ờ ng Kinh 1 1 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

5 Đ àm Vă n Ắ m Tày 1 2 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

6 Đ ặ ng A Sắ t Dao 1 1 2 2 FarmerForestryplanting

7 Đ ặ ng A Ử ng Dao 3 1 3 2 WorkerForestryplanting

8 Đ ặ ng Phúc Tiế n Dao 2 1 1 3 FarmerForestryplanting

9 Đ ặ ng Thị Loan Kinh 1 1 3 WorkerForestryplanting

10 Đ ặ ng Vă n Ba Dao 2 1 3 2 2 WorkerForestryplanting

11 Đ ặ ng Vă n Nguyên Dao 1 1 2 1 1 WorkerForestryplanting

12 Đ ặ ng Vă n Tư Dao 3 1 2 1 5 FarmerForestryplanting

13 Đ ặ ng Xuân Ba Dao 1 1 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

14 Đ ặ ng Xuân Cư ờ ng Dao 2 1 1 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

15 Đ ặ ng Xuân Lư ơ ng Dao 1 1 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

16 Đ ặ ng Xuân Minh Dao 1 3 FarmerForestryplanting

17 Đ ào Đ ứ c Thọ Kinh 1 1 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

18 Đ ào Vă n Chuỳ Kinh 1 1 1 2 WorkerForestryplanting

19 Đ ỗ Thị Hồ ng Kinh 2 1 1 RetirementForestryplanting

20 Đ ỗ Vă n Biên Kinh 1 1 1 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

21 Hà Vă n Hầ u Tày 1 1 1 3 1Forestryplanting farmer

22 Hồ Quay Phư ơ ng Dao 1 1 1 1 2 2 FarmerForestryplanting

23 Hồ Vă n Đ ứ c Dao 2 1 2 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

24 Hồ Vă n Phúc Dao 1 1 1 1 WorkerForestryplanting

25 Hồ Vă n Thanh 1 2 2 1 7 WorkerForestryplanting

26 Hoàng Thị Bé Tày 1 1 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

27 Hoàng Thị Kim Dao 2 1 2 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

28 Hoàng Thị Liên Tày 1 3 2 2Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

29 Hoàng Vă n Anh Kinh 1 1 1Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

4th



Page 20 of 30

Sexual

Male Female


membersNo

Name of


Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old

Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old


Primary

income

Secondary

income

30 Hoàng Vă n Khoa

Tày,Dao 1 1 1 1 1 Farmer

Forestryplanting

31 Hoàng Xuân Đ oàn Tày 1 1 1 1Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

32 La Vă n Bộ Tày 2 1 1 1Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

33 La Vă n Huấ n Tày 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

34 Lê Vă n Nam Kinh 1 2 2 2 FarmerForestryplanting

35 Lê Vă n Nhấ t Kinh 1 2 3 2 WorkerForestryplanting

36 Loan Vă n Phổ Tày 1Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

37 Loan Vă n Quang Tày 2 1Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

38 Loan Vă n Tô Tày 1 1 WorkerForestryplanting

39 Loan Vă n Tư ờ ngTày,Nùng 1 2 2 Worker

Forestryplanting

40 Loan Vă n Việ t Tày 1 2Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

41 Lộ c Vă n Vư ơ ng

Tày,Kinh 2 1 1

Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

42 Lụ c Vă n Hùng Tày 1 1Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

43 Lư ơ ng Vă n Cò Tày 1 1Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

44 Lư ơ ng Vă n Yên

Tày,Dao 1 1

Forestryplanting

Forestryplanting

45 Lý Minh Trọ ng Dao 1 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

46 Lý Minh Tuấ n Dao 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

47 Lý Thị Hai Dao 2 2 FarmerForestryplanting

48 Lý Thị Tư Dao 1 FarmerForestryplanting

49 Lý Vă n Hai Dao 2 1 2 1 FarmerForestry

planting

50 Lý Vă n Nă m Dao 2 1 2 1 2Forestryplanting Farmer

51 Lý Vă n Phúc Dao 2 1 2Forestryplanting farmer

52 Lý Vă n Sáu Dao 2 1 2 1 FarmerForestryplanting

53 Lý Vă n Tư Dao 2 2 1 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

54 Lý Vă n Việ t Dao 2 2 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

55 Lý Xuân Cả nh Dao 3 1 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

56 Lý Xuân Minh Dao 2 1 3 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

4th



Page 21 of 30

Sexual

Male Female


membersNo

Name of


Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old

Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old


Primary

income

Secondary

income

57Lý Xuân Thắ ng(Lý Xuân Hồ ng) Dao 1 1 2 1 3

Forestryplanting

58 Ngọ c Vă n Bẩ y Tày 1 1 1 1 2Forestryplanting Farmer

59 Ngọ c Vă n Chiề u Tày 4 1 1Forestryplanting Farmer

60 Ngọ c Vă n Miêu Tày 1 1 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

61 Nguyễ n Bả o LongKinh,Dao 1 1 1 1 Farmer

Forestryplanting

62 Nguyễ n Đ ứ c Thứ c Kinh 1 1 2 1 FarmerForestryplanting

63 Nguyễ n Như Đ ạ o Kinh 2 1 1 2 RetirementForestryplanting

64 Nguyễ n Quố c Đ ệ Kinh 1 1 2 1 RetirementForestryplanting

65 Nguyễ n Sỹ Nam Kinh 1 WorkerForestry

planting

66Nguyễ n ThanhCả nh Tày 1

Forestryplanting Farmer

67 Nguyễ n Thị Hoa Kinh 2 2Forestryplanting Farmer

68 Nguyễ n Thị Linh Kinh 1 1 2Forestryplanting Farmer

69 Nguyễ n Vă n Long Kinh 1 1 1 1 1 WorkerForestryplanting

70 Nguyễ n Vă n Luân Kinh 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

71 Nguyễ n Vă n Nứ c Kinh 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

72 Nguyễ n Vă n Sỹ

Kinh,Tày 1 2 1 Farmer

Forestryplanting

73 Nguyễ n Vă n Tá Tày 1 1 1 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

74Nguyễ n Vă n

Thanh Kinh 1 1 1 1 1 WorkerForestryplanting

75 Nguyễ n Vă n Thụ y Kinh 1 2 1 2 1 WorkerForestryplanting

76Nguyễ n Xuân Qúy(Qúy Ngà) Kinh 1 1 1 1 Trader

Forestryplanting

77 Nông Quố c Khánh Tày 2 4 1 WorkerForestryplanting

78 Nông Vă n Toả n Tày 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

79 Phạ m Huy Cư ờ ng Kinh 1 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

80 Phạ m Thị Giang Kinh 1 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

81 Phoòng Cắ m Công Dao 1 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

82 Phoòng Cắ m Tắ c Dao 2 1 1 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

83Phoòng Cắ mThành Dao 1 1 1 1 1

Forestryplanting

Farmer

4th



Page 22 of 30

Sexual

Male Female


membersNo

Name of


Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old

Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old


Primary

income

Secondary

income

84 Phoòng Đ ình Huy Dao 1 2 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

85 Phoòng Đ ình Phú Dao 1 2 FarmerForestryplanting

86Phoòng Đ ìnhThố ng Dao 3 1 1 1 Farmer

Forestryplanting

87 Phoòng Đ ình Vinh Dao 1 2 1 2 1Forestryplanting Worker

88 Phoòng Tắ c Qúy Dao 1 2 1 3 1Forestryplanting Worker

89 Phoòng Tài Múi Dao 1 1Forestryplanting Farmer

90 Phoòng Thị MaiDao,Kinh 1 1 1 1 Farmer

Forestryplanting

91 Phoòng Vă n Sinh Dao 3 1 1 2 1 FarmerForestryplanting

92 Phoòng Vă n Tư Dao 2 2 1 FarmerForestryplanting

93 Phùn A Hả i Dao 1 1 1 FarmerForestry

planting

94 Phùn A Phúc Dao 1 1 3 1 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

95 Phùn A Sơ n Dao 1 3Forestryplanting

Farmer

96Phùn Vă n Tư

(Phoòng Thị Mai) Dao 1 1 1 1 FarmerForestry

planting

97 Tạ Hữ u Hợ i Kinh 1 1 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

98 Triệ u Chă n Thố ng Dao 1 1 1 1 TraderForestryplanting

99 Triệ u Kim Tề Dao 5 4 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

100 Triệ u Quý Bình Dao 2 1 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

101 Triệ u Quý Dế nh Dao 2 1 2 1Forestryplanting

Farmer

102 Triệ u Quý Quân Dao 3 2 1 1 2Forestryplanting

Farmer

103 Triệ u Qúy Sáng Dao 3 1 4 1 1 WorkerForestryplanting

104 Triệ u Xuân Lợ iDao,Chiêm 1 1 4 Worker

Forestryplanting

105 Vi Vă n Đ ă ng

Tày,kinh 1 1 1 1 Farmer

Forestryplanting

106 Vi Xuân Lộ c Tày 1 1 3 1 FarmerForestryplanting

107 Vũ Vă n Tơ n Kinh 1 1 TraderForestryplanting

108 Phùn Thị Minh Dao 1 1 2 1 AquacultureForestryplanting

109 Vi Thị Hồ ng Tày 1 3 2 FarmerForestryplanting

110 Vi Thị Huệ Tày 1 3 FarmerForestryplanting

111 Vi Vă n Muộ i Tày 1 3 FarmerForestryplanting

4th



Page 23 of 30

Sexual

Male Female


membersNo

Name of


Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old

Under

18years

old

Above

18years

old


Primary

income

Secondary

income

112 Triệ u Quang Sáu FarmerForestryplanting

113 Vi Vă n Đ ă ng

Tày,kinh 1 1 1 1

Forestryplanting Farmer

114 Vi Xuân Lộ c Tày 1 1 3 1Forestryplanting Trader

115 Vũ Vă n Tơ n Kinh 1 1Forestryplanting Farmer

116 Đ ỗ Thị Hồ ng Kinh 2 1 TraderForestryplanting

117 Đ ỗ Vă n Biên Kinh 1 1 1 TraderForestryplanting

118 Triệ u Chă n Thố ng Dao 1 1 1 1 WorkerForestryplanting

119 Lý Vă n Việ t Dao 2 2 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

120 Triệ u Kim Tề Dao 5 4 1 Farmer

121 Lã Vă n Nàng Dao 1 1 3 1 Farmer

122 Vi Thị Liề u Tày 1 1 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

123 Phùng Vă n Tơ n Dao 2 2 1 1 FarmerForestryplanting

124 Phạ m Thị Luyế n Kinh 1 1 1 Trader

125Đ ong Mo High

School

126Mong duongCommittee

127Dong MoMedecine Center

4th



Page 24 of 30

Appendix 2 Situation of Compensation Payment

Annex 1: Situation of Compensation Payment until 31/12/2014

Date of projectimformation dessemination

Detailed MeasurementSurvey

Making compensation planVerify and approve the

compensation planSituation of Compensation

paymentSituation of Site

Clearance

No Component

Startingdate

Finishingdate

Startingdate

Finishingdate

Starting dateFinishing

dateSubmiting

dateApproval

Startingdate

Finishingdate

Startingdate

Finishingdate

Contractaward

1 Pineline 24/8/11 31/12/12 10/10/11 10/11/12 13/11/11 15/11/12 12/11/12 13/11/12 24/12/12 Finished 14/1/13 Finished 6/12/13

Cộ ng Hòa 24/8/11 31/12/12 10/10/11 10/11/12 13/11/11 15/11/12 12/11/12 13/11/12 24/12/12Finished

14/1/13Finished

6/12/13

Cẩ m Hả i 24/8/11 31/12/12 10/10/11 10/11/12 13/11/11 15/11/12 12/11/12 13/11/12 24/12/12Finished

14/1/13Finished

6/12/13

2 Resevoir 24/8/11 31/11/13 10/10/11 31/11/13 13/11/11 31/11/13 12/11/12 31/11/13 24/12/12

Finished

14/1/13 Finished 5/6/14MôngDư ơ ng 24/8/11 31/11/13 10/10/11 31/11/13 13/11/11 31/11/13 12/11/12 31/11/13 24/12/12

Finished31/3/14

Finished 5/6/14

4th



Page 25 of 30

Annex 2: Number of Affected Households until 31/12/2014

Long term affected households

No. Of Severe HHs HHs with Vulnerable People

Total Affected

HHs (both long

term and shortterm Affected HHs

No Component

Total

Lost from 10%

or more ofagricultural

land

Number of

resettledHHs

No. Of None-

severe HHs

Affected

BusinessHHs Poor HHs

Ethic

MinoritiesHHs

Single

Womanheaded HHs

Social

Policy HHs

1 Pineline 53 53 0 12 0 5 5 1 7 65

Cộ ng Hòa 36 36 0 6 0 3 4 0 5 42

Cẩ m Hả i 17 17 0 6 0 2 1 1 2 23

2 Resevoir 101 101 37 26 0 6 93 7 3 127

Mông Dư ơ ng 101 101 37 26 0 6 93 7 3 127

Total 154 154 37 38 0 11 98 8 10 192

4th



Page 26 of 30

Annex 3: Area of the acquired land until 31/12/2014

Permanently Acquired Land Area (m2) Temporarily Acquired Land Area (m2)

No. Components/

Packages AgriculturalLand

ResidentialLand

AquaculturalArea

Forest Land Other Land Total Forest Land Other Land Total

1 Pineline 0.0 0.0 12,956.80 324,703.13 145,351.70 483011.63 11460.7 6295.8 17756.5

Cộ ng Hòa 0.0 0.0 269.00 195,251.53 98,304.20 293824.73 0.0 1667.0 1667.0

Cẩ m Hả i 0.0 0.0 12,687.80 129,451.60 47,047.50 189186.90 11460.7 4628.8 16089.5

2 Resevoir 225,309.5 8,000.0 13,872.65 305,863.50 813,354.16 1366399.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Mông Dư ơ ng 225,309.5 8,000 13,872.65 305,863.50 813,354.16 1366399.76 0.0 0.0 0.0

Total 225,309.5 8,000.0 26,829.45 630,566.63 958,705.86 1849411.39 11460.7 6295.8 17756.5

4th



Page 27 of 30

Annex 4: Housing and other assets affected until 31/12/2014

No. Components/

Packages

Affected

Housing Area

(m2)

Affected Shop

Area (m2)

Affected

Factory Area

(m2)

Affected Rice

and crops area

(m2)

Affected Tree

(tree)

Affect Objects/

Architect Works

Relocated

Graves

(pcs)

Affected

Other

Assets

1 Pipeline 2,004.8 0.0 288.0 528.0 73,512.0

Cộ ng Hòa 1,198.0 0.0 288.0 310.0 46,232

Cẩ m Hả i 806.8 0.0 0.0 218.0 27,280

2 Resevoir 2,813.0 0.0 0.0 169,765.0 99,893

MôngDư ơ ng 2,813 0.0 0.0 169,765.0 96,791

Annex 4.1Annex

4.1

Total 4,817.8 0.0 288.0 170,293.0 173,405.0 0.0 -

Annex 4.1: Affected Other Assets until 31/12/2014

Toilet Kitchen Bathroom Well Barns Cement roofTư ờ ng rào/

Fence

Bể nư ớ c/Water

Tank

Đ ư ờ ng đ iệ n/

Electric LineNo.Components/

Packages(m2) (m2)/ (m2) (pcs) (m2) (m2) (m2) (m3) (m)

1 Pineline 16.92 144.27 2.79 1.00 329.20 130.56 8.40 372.76 4490.00

Cộ ng Hòa 0.00 10.63 2.79 1.00 35.60 0.00 0.00 50.19 1695.00

Cẩ m Hả i 16.92 133.64 0.00 0.00 293.60 130.56 8.40 322.57 2795.00

2 Resevoir 89.36 419.86 87.20 8.00 1,758.30 127.80 32.60 851.60 18537.70

Mông Dư ơ ng 89.36 419.86 87.20 8.00 1758.30 127.80 32.60 851.60 18537.70

Total 106.28 564.13 89.99 9.00 2087.50 258.36 41.00 1224.36 23027.70

4th



Page 28 of 30


Compensation Cost (VND)Paid and None-paid yet

(VND)Situation of Compensation Situation of Site Clearance

No. ComponentTotal of cost estimation

approved by 31/12/2014

Total of cost accoding to the

compensation planPaid until 31/12/2014

None-

paid

No. of HHs

receivedcompensation

No. of HHs

none-received

compensation

No. of HHs

handed overthe sites

No. of HHs

have notbeen handed

over the

sites

1 Pineline 17.059.295.200 17.059.295.200 17.059.295.200 0 65 0 65 0

Cộ ng Hòa 8.982.221.900 8.982.221.900 8.982.221.900 0 40 0 42 0

Cẩ m Hả i 6.396.697.700 6.396.697.700 6.396.697.700 0 20 0 23 0Pipeline(additionRecovery) 1.680.375.600 1.680.375.600 1.680.375.600 0 5 0 0

2 Resevoir 87.002.042.500 87.002.042.500 87.002.042.500 0 127 0 127 0

MôngDư ơ ng 87.002.042.500 87.002.042.500 87.002.042.500 0 127 0 127 0

Total 103.837.805.600 103.837.805.600 103.837.805.600 192 0 192 0

4th



Page 29 of 30


Communal Level Distric LevelCompensation

CommitteeProvincial PMU Provincial Level Court

Components/

Packages

No

. o

f

Co

mp

lain

ed H

HS

No

. o

f H

Hs

are

sati

sfa

cto

rily

reso

lved

No

. o

f

Co

mp

lain

ed H

HS

No

. o

f H

Hs

are

sati

sfa

cto

rily

reso

lved

No

. o

f C

om

pla

ined

HH

S

No

. o

f H

Hs

are

sati

sfa

cto

rily

reso

lved

No

. o

f C

om

pla

ined

HH

S

No

. o

f H

Hs

are

sati

sfa

cto

rily

reso

lved

No

. o

f C

om

pla

ined

HH

S

No

. o

f H

Hs

are

sati

sfa

cto

rily

reso

lved

No

. o

f

Co

mp

lain

ed H

HS

No

. o

f H

Hs

are

sati

sfa

cto

rily

reso

lved

Resevoir 17 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Pipeline 8 8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Total 25 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

4th



Page 30 of 30

Annex 7: Progress on compensation and resettlement implementaion till 31/12/2014

Component Pipeline ComponentResevoir

Component

Cộ ng Hòa Cẩ m Hả i Mông Dư ơ ng

Activities on compensation and resettlementCompletesituation Complete situation Complete situation

Information Dissemination and CommunityParticipation 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

Detailed Measure Survey (DMS)100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

Setting Compensation Plan100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

Consulting and Counseling with the APs oncompensation plan 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

Update the RP and approve by ADB100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

Finalized the compensation plan and submit forapproval 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

Verify and approve the compensation plan100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

Consultate the APs on the approvedcompensation plan (to the agricultural land) 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

Compensation Payment100% 100% 100%

Resettlement and Site Clearance100% 100% 100%

Independent Monitoring and Reporting100% 100% 100%

Compensation Progress by component100% 100% 100%

Compensation Progress of the Project100% 100% 100%

Date post:	06-Aug-2020
Category:	Documents
Upload:	others
View:	1 times
Download:	0 times

VIE: Mong Duong 1 Thermal Power Project – Tranche 2 · Mong Duong (2 x 500MW) Thermal Power Plant...

Documents