Volume Information

Volume InformationSource: Columbia Law Review, Vol. 2, No. 1 (Jan., 1902), pp. i-xvPublished by: Columbia Law Review Association, Inc.Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1109068 .

Accessed: 24/05/2014 03:04

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

.

Columbia Law Review Association, Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access toColumbia Law Review.

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 193.104.110.112 on Sat, 24 May 2014 03:04:28 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=clra

http://www.jstor.org/stable/1109068?origin=JSTOR-pdf

http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp


COLUMBIA

LAW REVIEW

VOL. I-1902

NEW YORK

THE COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY PRESS

THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, AGENTS

1902.



COPYRIGHT, 1902

BY THE COLUMBIA LAW REVIEW



CONTENTS.

ARTICLES.

PAGE

AMENDMENTS, PROPOSED, TO THE FEDERAL BANKRUPTCY ACT.

S. Whitney Dunscombe. 313 ATTORNEY'S LIEN, ENFORCEMENT OF...........Henry S. Redfield 449 AVERAGE, GENERAL, LIABILITY WITH CARGO FOR SUCCESSIVE

PORTS ................................arringon Putnam. 275 CORPORATIONS AT HOME AND ABROAD ........Thomas Thatcher. 351 CRIMINAL LAW AND ITS ADMINISTRATION IN THE STATE OF

NEW YORK ....................................Robert Earl I44 FARQUHARSON v. KING ..........................John S. Ewart. 223 FORMATION OF CONTRACT INTER ABSENTES.

Clarence D. Ashley I INCORPORATION BY REFERENCE .. .............Stewart Chaplin. 148 INSULAR DECISIONS, DECEMBER, I90I, THE.

Edward B. Whitney 79 INSURANCE RISK, EXPERT OPINION AS TO.....John H. Wigmore. 67 INTERNATIONAL LAW, THE SOURCES OF.

Sir Frederick Pollock, Bart 5II JUDICIAL ACTION BY THE PROVINCIAL LEGISLATURE OF MASSA-

CHUSETTS BAY ........................ Melville M. Bigelow 536 LAW MERCHANT, WHAT IS ,...... .........Francis M. Burdick. 470 LAW OF NATURE, THE HISTORY OF. A PRELIMINARY STUDY. II.

Sir Frederick Pollock, Bart. 131 LEGISLATION, DELIBERATE ................ Carman F. Randolph. 92 LIABILITY OF A BANK TO THE MAKER OF A CHECK FOR THE

WRONGFUL DISHONOR THEREOF ......... Ernest M. Hufcut. I93 LIVINGSTON, EDWARD, AND THE LOUISIANA CODES.

Eugene Smith. 24 NUISANCES, SUMMARY ABATEMENT OF, BY BOARDS OF HEALTH.

Frank J. Goodnow. 203 "PER MY ET PER TOUT," A PERPLEXITY OF.

W. A. Purrington. 385 PRIVACY, THE RIGHT OF .........................Denis O'Brien. 437 SHIP SUBSIDIES AND SUGAR BOUNTY STATUTES; THEIR CONSTI-

TUTIONALITY .............................. F. Robinson, 525 SUITS BETWEEN STATES, NOTES ON: KANSAS V. COLORADO, I. & II.

Carman F. Randolph. 283, 364 THAYER, JAMES BRADLEY .............. Charles Sherman Haight 238 USES, CHARITABLE, IN NEW YORK ........Robert Ludlow Fowler IO



iv COLUMBIA LA W RE VIEW.

NOTES AND RECENT DECISIONS.

Page numbers in heavy-faced type refer to NOTES; others to RECENT DECISIONS.

PAGE.

ADMINISTRATION. See Wills. ADMINISTRATIVE LAW. Mandamus............................ 256

Mandamus against governor of a State . ....................... 496 ADMIRALTY. Duty of master to injured seaman . .................. 556 AGENCY. Apparent authority: fraud.......................... 44, 49

Apparent authority: trade custom .......................... 178 Ratification .3......... .......... ................. 336 Usurious contract ................... ...................... 256

BAILMENTS. Action by bailee: measure of damages.......... 324, 336 Bailee as plaintiff; measure of damages . ..................... 324 Bailee for hire: damages ..................................... 49 Pledge ................................................... 178 Pledge: necessity of delivery ....... .................... 496

BANKRUPTCY. Lunatics ............................. 556 M istake of law............................................. 257 Preference: attacliment................................. 249, 256 Preference, set-off ................................ .... . 256

BILLS AND NOTES. See Negotiable Paper. CARRIERS. Contracts of carriage........................... 160, 178

Duty of carrier to protect passenger from ill treatment by its servants ................................................... 488

Duty of conductor to demand tickets ........................ 414 Duty to protect passengers against the carrier's servants... 488, 497 Duty to provide safe depot facilities......................... 414 Ejection from train: form of action ........................... 15 Liability beyond terminus of line .............................. 414 Liability for loss of mail................................ 410, 414 Liability of railroads to owners of mail and express ............. 410 Limitation of carrier's liability and failure.to stop in transitu: ship-

per's assent to terms ........... ........................... 330 Limitation of liabilities: stoppage in transitu .............. 330, 336 Pleading: conversion ........ ............................. 115 Statutory penalties: separate offences......................... 115 Tickets: ejection from train .................................. 336

CONFLICT OF LAWS. Contracts of carriage.................. 160, 178 Negotiable instruments ................................ 253, 257

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW. Delegation of legislative powers to the courts. .................................................. 337 courts .. 5 , , , 337

Direct taxes: War Revenue Act of I898 ....................... 556 Due process of law: gaming instruments ......................179 Due process of law: power of legislature to make evidence con-

clusive. ......................................... 493, 497



NOTES AND RECENT DECISIONS.

Eleventh amendment: suit against state officers ................ 416 Eminent domain........................................... 337 Eminent domain: compensation ........................ 333, 337 Eminent domain: rights under restrictions in deeds........... 333 Equal protection of the laws: classification for taxation.......... 257 Equal protection of the laws: medical practice: osteopathy.. 251, 257 Federal and state courts: receivers, injunction: contempt: rail-

roads: highways ......4.... . ........ 415 Impairment of contract: power of municipalities to regulate street

railways fares: equity . .............. ......... 487, 497 Inheritance tax: discrimination: fourteenth amendment ......... 45 Interstate commerce: "Wilson Act" ................... i6

Municipal regulation of street railway rates .................... 487 Police power: delegation of legislative powers .................. 337 Police power: limitation upon right of contract ................ 16 Police power: patent rights ..................... .......... 49 Police power: regulation of trust: equity jurisdiction....... 168, 179 Regulation of medical practice under the fourteenth amendment. 251 State regulation of interstate commerce: long and short haul 402, 416 State regulation of foreign commerce: police power .......... 557 State regulation of long and short haul ........................ 402 Taxation: public purpose .................................... 497 Territorial application of treaty as a judicial question ........... 557

CONTRACTS. Accord and satisfaction ............ ................ 557 Agreements for re-organization of a railroad: conversion........ 497 Anticipatory breach of agreement to hold stock: measure of

damage ................................... 46 Anticipatory breach: installment contract ...................... 416 Bonds of indemnity ............................ . 498 Conditions: dependent promises ......................... 179 Conflict of laws: illegality under law of place of performance.... 558 Consideration: novation ..................................... 80 Construction, time of performance ........................... 5o Damages: future profits ................................... 6 Extension of mortgage debt: usury . ......................... 258 Illegality: fictitious suits..................................... 258 Installment: failure to pay ................................... 4I7 Limitation as to area in contracts in restraint of trade ........... 166 Public policy: securing nomination for office............... 558 Restraint of trade ................................... 166, I8o Revocation of offer........................................ 417 Savings banks: payment to holder of deposit book............. 558

CORPORATIONS. Amendment of by-laws: effect on right of members ..................................................... 258

Banks: liability of individual directors to creditors .............. 498 Beneficial associations: effect of change of by-laws on insane

member ... ............................... 417 Building and loan association: status of members ........... 498

v



vi COLUMBIA LA W REVIEW.

Calls . ............................................. 418 Duty of directors: breach of trust ............................ 117 Electric light companies: power to mortgage franchises........ 418 Liability of stockholders: rights of creditors .................. 338 National banks: shareholder's liability: statute of limitations.... 418 Quo warranto: pleading .................................... 50 Removal of causes: effect of statute . ................ 499

CRIMINAL LAW. Contempt: conspiracy to defeat injunction....... I17 Conviction after acquittal of joint defendant . .................. 559 Double jeopardy ................. ......................... 559 Evidence . ............................... 3......9, 52 False pretences .................... ..................... 259 Former jeopardy ......................... .............. 117, I 18 Indictment for obstruction of justice .......................246, 259 Penal code: commitment warrant ............................ 338 Procedure: incomplete verdict............................... 259 Unlawful assemblies........................................ 419

DAMAGES. Contract of service: burden of proof ................... 499 DOMESTIC RELATIONS. Divorce: alimony: wife as creditor of hus-

band ..... .............................................. 259 Divorce: curtesy ............ ............................... 80 Husband as wife's agent ..................................... 260

EQUITY. Assignment: priority: purchaser for value........... 164, I8I Bills of peace .............................................. i 8 Constructive trusts ...........................5........ ... Equitable interest, conflicting, and purchaser for value .......... 164 Extension of the rule protecting trade names .................. 245 Fraudulent conveyance ..................................4I9, 559 Injunction: determination of title ............................. 5 Injunction: jurisdiction over parties .......................... 51 Injunction: laches ...................................... 4 9, 559 Injunction: mistake of law .................................. 420 Injunction: strikes: right of action ........................ 552, 560 Jurisdiction over criminal proceedings ....................550, 560 Jurisdiction over public officers ............................... I8 M istake ................................ ............ .... . 260

M istake of fact ............................................. 1 8 Power to restrain a libel .................................175, I18 Property: exchange quotations ...........................549, 560 Protection of trade marks: words in common use...........406, 420 Publication of photograph as advertisement................... 486 R es judicata ...................................... ........ 420 Restraint of trade: libel ..................................... 500 Right of privacy: publication of photograph as an advertise-

ment .......................................486, 500 Right to exclusive use of name ...........................245, 260 Specific performance by enforcing an implied negative covenant.. 162 Specific performance: injunction ..................... 162, i8i, 338



NOTES AND RECE?NT DECISIONS. vii

Trusts ..................... .................. ........... 500 Trusts: accounting: parties ................................. 56o Trusts: claims of creditors: defaulting trustee ................. 344 Trusts: deposit of trust funds in bank ...................... 500 Trusts: gift of bankbook . ............................. 110, II9

EVIDENCE. Admissions of former occupant of land ................ 561 Attempt to incriminate defendant ............................ 339 Criminal law: admissibility of evidence of other crimes: compari-

son of handwritings ....................................39, 52 Confessions: inducements .................................. 182

Expert testimony . ....................................... 182

Hearsay: dying declarations ................................. 339 Hearsay in cases of pedigree ............................... 170 Hearsay : pedigree ............ .....................170, 182, 501 New York rule as to admissions by the assignor of personal prop-

erty ..................................................... 326 Privileged communications .................................. 52 Public records: parish register ............................... 501 Res gestc ..................................... ......... 182, 183

FRAUD, WHERE AN AGENT COMMITS, AND ONE OF TWO INNOCENT

PERSONS MUST SUFFER ................................... 44

GENERIC WORDS AS TRADE MARKS ........................... 406

GIFT, ATTEMPTED, OF AN ACCOUNT IN A SAVINGS BANK, TO TAKE

EFFECT UPON DEATH OF SUPPOSED DONOR.............. 110

INSOLVENCY. Conveyance in fraud of creditors.... ............ 421

Mortgage to secure creditors . . ................... 119 Preference . ............................................. 1-9

INSURANCE. Agency clauses in insurance policies ............. 334

Agent's knowledge of breach of restrictions of an insurance policy at its inception ........................................... 243

Construction of indemnity policy ............................. 261 Fire policy: amount of loss ................................ 421 Insurable interest: right to proceeds .......................... 501 Location of chattels as a term in an insurance policy............ 108 Re-instatement clause in fire policy. ......................... 261 Restrictions upon liability for the agent's acts ..............331, 339 Waiver of condition by agent: evidence ...................243, 26r W arranty ................................................ 120

Warranty: domestic relations: infancy ....................... 61

Warranty: location of property .......................... 108, 1I9 INTERFERENCE WITH BUSINESS OR EMPLOYMENT: BOYCOTT ..... 37

INTERNATIONAL LAW. Interpretation of treaty: consular administration of estate of foreign intestate ........................... 501

JURISDICTION OF EQUITY IN CASES OF LIBEL, THE .............. 175

LIABILITY TO THIRD PERSONS FOR INJURIES FROM A BREACH

OF CONTRACT ............................................ 105

MORTGAGES. After required property: future increase............. 183 Covenants in restraint of redemption ......................331, 339



viii COL UMBIA LA W REVIEW.

Execution sale: redemption; statute of frauds ................. 262 Limitation of action: suspension of the statute ................. 262 Limitations within which a mortgagee may stipulate for collateral

advantages .............................................. 331 MUNICIPAL CORPORATIONS. Defective incorporation: estoppel.... 263

Highways: interest of abutting owners ....................... 492

Highways: rights of abutting owners ...................... 492, 502 Liability of ................................................. 411

Liability for salaries ............................ ..... . 263 Taxation ........................... ...................... 267 Torts: master and servant ...............................411, 421

NEBRASKA ANTI-TRUST ACTS, THE .1........... ........6... 168

NEGOTIABLE PAPER. Bank checks as affected by the drawer's death 171

Banking: duty of depositor to verify accounts .................. 502 Checks: revocation by death ............................ .171, I84 Duty of depositor to examine pass-book ..................... 490

NEWSPAPER PUBLICATIONS IN CONTEMPT OF COURT ........... 246

PARTNERSHIP. Dissolution: liability for tort .................... 263

Insolvency: special partner as creditor ....................247, 264

Property: shares in joint-stock associations ................403, 421 Release of partner by judgment creditor ..................... 264 Sale of good will: right to solicit old customers ............... 264 Shares in joint stock associations ............................ 403

PEOPLE V. MOLINEUX ................................... 89

PLEADING AND PRACTICE. Appealable interest ........ ........ I20 Cause of action ..................... .................. .. 34? Examination before trial under the N. Y. code ................. 502 Original jurisdiction of the U. S. courts ........................ 422 Plea in abatement .............................. ........... 34? Plea of resjudicata under the N. Y. code .................... 422, Real party in interest .................................... 328, 340 Real party in interest under the codes ....................... 328 Removal of causes: State as real party ....................... I20

Resjudicata: collateral attack on judgment ................... 340 Setting aside verdict ....................................... 502 Single cause of action ................. ................... 184 Variance ............................................ . 84

QUASI CONTRACT. Payment by mistake: forged bills of lading..... 561 REAL PROPERTY. Additional burdens to highways ................ 422

Adverse possession: interruption by submergence .............. 562 Adverse possession: tenant's denial of landlord ................ 52 Attachment of chattels to the freehold .................... ... 407 Boundaries: accretion ..................................... . 422

Contingent and vested interests ............................. 53 Co-tenants: adverse title ............. ......... .,.. 34I Covenants: construction .................................... 121

Covenants running with' incorporeal rights ................ 554, 562 Covenants running with the land: re-assignment ............34I, 423



NOTES AND RECENT DECISIONS. ix

Diversion of an interstate watercourse ........................ 47 Dower: purchase money: mortgage ......................... 503 Easements ................................................. 265 Equitable estate: rule in Shelley's case ........................ 53 Fixtures .... ....................................... 121, 407, 423 Fixtures: new lease ........................................ 423 Highway easements: elevation of railroad tracks .............. 158 Highway easements: elevated railroads ...................., 85 Ineffective grant: implied trusts.............................. 562 Landlord and tenant: landlord's liability for nuisances of tenant. 503 License: transfer of theatre tickets ........................... 503 Navigable waters: legislative authority........................ 54 Party wall easement ........................................ 54 Re-entry: summary proceedings .........................250, 265 Reservations: exceptions .................................... 265 Reserved easements: covenants against incumbrances ........ 562 Right of re-entry . . ........................... 250 Riparian rights: compensation . .......................... . .. 265 Riparian rights: diversion of an interstate water-course .......47, 55 Seat in stock exchange ...................................... 84 Special power: appointment: ademption ....................... 266 Subjacent support: limitation of actions ....................... I2

Sub-letting: occupation by servant ............................ 266 Surface water .............................................. 341 Surface water: discharge upon highway ....................... 504 Water: rights in gross.... . 563

SALES. Fraud................................................. 423 Interest in land: revocation of license ......................... 342 Warranty: option of exchange ............................342, 424

STATUTES. Anti-trust act: combination in restraint of interstate com- m erce ................................................. 504

Construction: foreign corporations: non-compliance with statutes I85 Exemption of homesteads.................................... 122

Failure of testamentary witness to give address ................ 55 Interpretation: mandamus................................... 55 Intersecting railroads ........................................ 504 Limitations upon judgment creditor's bill . .............. 342 Limitations: waiver......................................... I86 New York Code Civil Procedure: foreign corporations ......... 266 New York Code Civil Procedure: probate practice . .122

New York Code Civil Procedure: right of testator's creditors

against devisees ....................................... 55 New York Penal Code....................................... 122

W aiver..................................... .. .. ........... 424 SURETYSHIP. Discharge of surety: indulgence to the principal ...... 123

Parol promise of indemnity ..... 104 Statute of Frauds: promise of indemnity .................. 104, 123

TAXATION. Assessment of corporate franchise ................43, 56



x COLUMBIA LA W RE VIEW.

Corporate franchise, taxation of .............................. 43 Exemption of charitable and literary institutions ............... 123 Municipal corporation: estoppel .............................. 267 Purchase under tax sales .......................... ...... .... 343 Remedy of certiorari in New York ............................ 56 Special assessments: estimating benefits ................... 241, 267 Shares of stock............................................. 424

TORTS. Assault: consent ....................................... I86 Conspiracy: boycott: trade union ...........................37, 57 Conspiracy interference with business ........................ 124 Damages: prospective medical services ........ ............... I86 Duty to trespasser: voluntary risk ............... 563 Independent contractors, liability for acts of ................... 112 Independent contractor: obstruction of public streets .......112, 124 Injury causing death on high seas: jurisdiction ................ 563 Interference with business or employment ..................... 400 Libel; privilege ............................................. 57 Malicious injury: trade union: strikes. ..................... 400, 424 Malicious prosecution: civil suits ............................. 24 Master and servant: assumed risk ......... ................... I87 Master and servant: disobedience of orders: proximate cause.... 343 Master and servant: fellow servant .......................... 57 Master and servant: municipal corporations ................ 411, 42I Master and servant: release ................................. 343 Master and servant: safe place to work ................ ........ 125 Master and servant: scope of authority ........................ 57 Negligence: care due to children ............. ............. 564 Negligence: failure to deliver telegram . ............... 267 Negligence: implied invitation .............................. 564 Negligence: manufacturer's liability for defects in the articles.... 58 Negligence: privity of contract .......................105, 125, 268 Negligence: Res ipsa loquitur ........... ................. ... 125 Nuisance: action by lessee ...............................547, 564 Nuisance: maintenance of explosives .......................... 565 Release: Joint Tortfeasors ................................. 565 Vicarious negligence ............. ........................ 87

TRUSTS. See Equity. WILLS. Attorney's lien ................. ..................... 344

Construction of statute: military service . ...................... 425 Construction: " survivor " as " other " .................... 187 Devise to unincorporated society: charitable trust............... 58 Execution: order of signing ................................. I88 Powers of executor: profit from fiduciary relation ............ 88 Revival by codicil .......................................... 425 Undue influence: confidential relations ........................ 268



BOOK REVIEWS.

ABBOTT: Trial Brief. New Mode of Proving Facts ............... 127 ALDEN: A Handbook on the Code of Civil Procedure .............. 63 BATES: A Treatise on the Procedure in Suits in Equity in the Circuit

Courts of the United States ... ....... .................. 62 BRYCE: Studies in History and Jurisprudence ..................... 398 CRAWFORD: 'Negotiable Instruments Law. Annotated ............ 273 DUNNING: A History of Political Theories, Ancient and Mediaeval .. 431 FACULTY YALE LAW SCHOOL: Two Centuries' Growth of American

Law ................................................. 127 FOSTER: A Treatise on Federal Practice . ........................ 28 FREEMAN: The Law of Void Judicial Sales....................... 568 FROST: A Treatise on Guaranty Insurance ........................ 433 HALL: Crime and Social Progress...................... ......... 507 HARRIMAN: The Law of Contracts. Second Edition. ........... 59 HEPBURN: A Selection of Cases and Statutes on the Principles of

Code Pleading, with Notes ............................... 88 HUGHES: Handbook on Admiralty Law .......................... 347 KERR: On Fraud and Mistake. Third Edition .................... 566 MECHEM: Cases on the Law of Damages. Third Edition .......... 271 NICHOLS: BRITTON: An English Translation and Notes.......... 34 PAGE: A Concise Treatise on the Law of Wills.................... 426 PAINE: Bailments .............................................. 126 PASSOS: Commercial Trusts; The Growth and Rights of Aggregate

Capital ................................................ 271 ROOD: A Treatise on the Law of Attachments, Garnishments, Judg-

ments and Execution .................................... 434 RUSSEL: The Police Power of the State and Decisions Thereon as

Illustrating the Development and Value of Case Law........ 65 SIBLEY: The Right To and Cause for Action...................... 506 SMITH: A Treatise on the Law of Master and Servant ............. 505 SPELLING: Injunctions and Other Extraordinary Remedies ......... 88

TAYLOR: A Treatise on International Public Law ................. I9I THOMPSON: Commentaries on the Law of Negligence ............. 505 WAIT: Pleading and Practice ................................... 569 WAPLES: A Handbook of Parliamentary Procedure. Second Edition 65 WASHBURN: A Treatise on the American Law of Real Property.

Sixth Edition. W urts Ed ..... .......................... 567 WATSON : A Treatise on the Law of Damages for Personal Property. 272 WHITE: A Treatise on the Canadian Company Law............... 64 WILGUS: A Study of the United States Steel Corporation in Its In-

dustrial and Legal Aspect .............................. .. 269 WILLIAMS: The Liability of Municipal Corporations for Torts ...... 126

WILSON and TUCKER: International Law ........................ 349 WOODRUFF: A Selection of Cases on the Law of Insurance ........ 432



TABLE OF RECENT CASES.

PAGE

Abb v. Northern Pac. R. Co... 565 Ackerman v. True........... 559 American Alkali Co. v. Camp-

bell ...................... 418 American Bible Society v.

American Tract Society.... 58 American Loan and Trust Co.

v. General Electric Co...... 58 Anglo-American Provision Co.

v. Davis Provision Co....... 266

Backes v. Curran............ 338 Baldwin v. Tucker ........... 78 Barney v. Indiana Ry. Co..... 50 Battle Creek Valley Bank v.

First Nat. Bank of Madison. 183 Bell v. Mills ............342, 424 Bell v. Town of Sullivan...... 424 Bender v. King.............. 121 Bent v. Heilberg ............. 182 Bernheimer v. Adams........ 423 Blackv. State ............... 415 Blackburn v. Thompson...... 260 Bloomingdale v, Weil....... Blue Jacket Copper Co. v.

Scherr .................. . 257 Bly v. Edison Electric Illumi-

nating Co .............547, 564 Bracher's Will, In re.......... 344 Brown v. Wadsworth......... 53 Burrows v. Lang............ 265 Butler v. W. U. Tel. Co...... 267

Callen v. Columbus Edison Electric Light Co ..... 492, 502

Calvert v. Southern Ry. Co.... 499 Carpenter v. Pocasset Mnfg.

Co .................. I2I

Carpenter v. Ry. Co.......... I15 Cartwright v. Adair .......... 54 Cassidy v. Uhlmann.......... 498 Cedar Canon Mining Co. v. Yar-

wood.. .................... 341 Central Trust Co. v. West

India Improvement Co.. 164, i8I Chapman v. Cheney.......... 53 Chicago Board of Trade v.

Christie Grain and Stock Co. 549, 560

PAGE

Clark, In re................. 122

Cohen v. Bryant .............. 265 Collister v. Hayman.......... 503 Coltrand v. Blake ............ 499 Colwell v. Waterbury.....411, 421 Cor. Union Assn. v. Rubber

Co .... . ................ 420 Compagnie Francaise v. La.

State Board of Health...... 557 Conkey Co. v. Russel; In re

Bessette .................. I17 Cook & Cobb Co. v. Miller .406, 420 Coughlin v. McElroy ......... 263 Critten v. Chem. Nat. Bank

490, 502 Crittenden & Cowler v. Cowler. 117

Davis v. Farnham Manf. Co. v. Los Angeles ...........550, 560

Davis v. Ramage............ I80 DeLancey v. Wellbrock....... 423 Delaware Surety Co. v. Layton. I18 Deming v. Term. Ry. of Buf-

falo .................... 12, 124 Denman v. Mentz............ 562 Dennison Univ. v. Manning... 123 DeReiter v. DeReiter........ 260 Detroit v. Detroit Cit. St. Ry.

Co..... ........... 487, 497 Dickson, In re ............. 256 Dodge v. Cornelius .......... 55 Doremus v. City of Paterson.. 563 Doyle v. Rolwing............ I80 Drum v. New England Cotton

Yarn Co .............. 125 Dunbar v. Charleston and W.

C. Ry. Co .. ........... 414

Eisenberg, In the matter of.... 556 Erie Ry. Co. v. Salisbury.... 58

Farquharson Bros. & Co. v. King & Co..............44, 49

Fleming v. McCutcheon ...... 88 Foster v. Commissioners of

Lyon Co ................. 49 Foster v. Portland Gold Mining

Co........................ 564 Frank v. Herold .......... 552, 560




PAGE

Frazier v. Jenkins ........... 419 Fries v. New York & Harlem

R. R. Co ..............158, I85 Frith, In re ................. 344 Frost v. People.............. 179

Gantz v. Lancaster ......... 258 Gardner v. Rhodes .......... 503 Garner v. Mahoney.......... 342 Gattward v. Knee............ 425 Gaylord, In re .............. 185 Genet v. The President, etc., of

the Del. & ?1. Canal Co..... 422 George v. Butler............. 262 German Bank v. Ry. Co..410, 414 Glaskell v. City of Jamestown. 337 Groce v. Ponder............. 503 Goodwin v. Smith............ 263 Green v. Brainerd & N. M. Ry.

Co........... ............ 343 Greenwood v. Moore......... 52 Grossmayer v. No. I Indep.

Order of B'nai B'rith.... 417 Groveno v. Signor ............ 86 Guaranty Trust Co. v. Grotrian. 561

Hahl v. Sugo................ 84 Hallett v. Metropolitan Mes-

senger Co ................. 338 Hancock v. Sup. Council Cath.

Ben. Legion............. 501 Harper v. State.............. 339 Harris v. Larsen............. 122 Harter v. Shull.............. 340 Hartley v. Sanford ........ 104, 123 Hawarden v. Youghiogheny

and Lehigh Coal Co........ I24 Heilman Brewing Co. v. Pie-

meisl ..................... 85 Hermann v. Great Northern

Ry. Co.................... 414 Herring v. Sutton............ 5 Hetcher v. State ............ 259 Hicks, Matter of... ....... 500 Higlister v. French........... 339 Hoboken Bank for Savings v.

Schwoon ..............110, II9 Hull Coke and Coal Co. v. Em-

pire Coal and Coke Co...... 417 Hunt v. Bode ............... 496 Hunt v. Tolles............... 562 Hunter v. Hunter............ 264

Inderwick v. Tatchell......... Indianapolis St. Ry. v. Robin-

son ....................... Industrial and General Trust

v. Tod....................

I88

I86

498

PAGE

International Comn. Y. W. C. A. Young Woman's C. A. of C ............. 245, 260

Iroquois, The............. 556

Jessup v. Bamford Bros. Co... 34I Johnson Forge Co. v. Leonard. 416 Jones, Matter of ..........403, 421 Jordon v. Indianapolis Water

Co ..................... 554, 562

Keith v. Brewster........... 18 Kensington, The.......160, 178 King v. Tibbits and Windust

246, 259 Kleebauer v. Western Fuse and

Explosive Co ............ 565 Knight v. People............. 52 Knoxville Iron Co. v. Harbison 116

Lacey v. Dobbs.............. 88 Ladd v. Augusta Savings Bank. 558 Ladd v. Kuhn.... ....... 120 Lander v. Burke ............. 424 Leawright v. Love............ 256 Leigh v. Taylor ...... .. 407, 423 Lindsley v. Mining Co........ 5 Lindstrom v. International Na-

vigation Co................ 563 Livingston v. Page........... 558 Lobrasciano, Matter of...... 502 Los Angeles Traction Co. v.

W ilshire .................. 417 L. & N. R. R. Co. v. Eubank.

402, 416 Luby v. Bennett.............. 124 Lund v. Tyler ............... 86 Lunn v. Guthrie ......... 336

Mackay v. Smith............. 420 Magar v. Hammond.......... 563 Marlin Fire Arms Co. v.

Shields............175, i8i, 500 Maxon v. Gates .............. 179 McBeathe v. Rawle ......... 125 McCann v. N. Y. & Q. C. Ry.

Co ............. .......... 502 McClusky v. Garfield & Proctor

Coal Co................... 187 McCormick v. Gross ......... 340 McDonald v. Thompson...... 418 McEacham v. Colten...... 341, 423 McLeod v. N. Y. C. & St. L.

Ry. Co ................488, 497 McQueen v. Wilson.......... 268 Merkle v. Beidleman.......... 327 Metropolitan Supply Co. v.

Ginder ...........169, I82, 339

xiii



COLUMBIA LA W REVIEW.

PAGE

Michael v. Fishel .........250, 265 Michael v. Hart & Co......... 416 Miller v. Melone............. 343 Milwaukee Mech. Ins. Co. v.

Russell ..... ............. 261 Minneapolis v. Janney........ 497 Minnosota v. Northern Securi-

ties Co ...... ............ 422 M. K. & T. Ry. Co. v. Hickman. 120 Missouri, K. & T. Ry. Co. v.

Simonson .............493, 497 Montague & Co. v. Lowry.... 504 Moore v. Central Foundry Co. 499 Moses, In re ............... 266 Murray v. Boston Ice Co...... 187

National Protective Ass'n. v. Cumming.......... 408,425, 554

Niagara Falls v. N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. Co ............. 51

Niagara Fire Ins. v. Cornell . 168, I79

New York v. Baird .......... 498 Noakes & Co., Ltd. v. Rice 331, 340 Noonan v. Pardee............ 122 Northern Assurance Co. v.

Grand View Building Ass'n. 243, 26I

Officer v. Officer............. 500 Ohio Farmer's Ins. Co. v. Bur-

get ...................108, 120 Ohio Farmer's Ins. Co. v.

W aters ......... .... ... 120

O'Leary v. Erie Ry. Co....... 268 O'Rourke v. Hancock Ins. Co. 262 Orr v. Leathers.............. 184

Parish et al. v. N. Y. Produce Exchange............. 258

Peck v. Schenectady Ry. Co.. 422 Penn. Co. v. Philadelphia Con-

tributorship, etc....... 421 People v. Central Union Tel.

C o... . . ............... 5I People v. Howard............ 259 People v. McDaniels......... 559 People v. Molineux .........39, 52 People v. Most .............. 22 People, ex rel., etc., v. N. Y. C.

& H. R. Co................ 55 People, ex rel. Allen v. Hagan. 338 People, ex re. Society of Church

of St. Mary v. Feit .......... 23 People, ex rel. Thompson v.

Feitner .................... 57 Peterson v. Wilmington...411, 421 Philadelphia Mortgage and

Trust Co. v. City of Omaha. 267

PAGE

Pierson v. Metropolitan Bank. 178 Pine et al. v. City of New York. 419 Pine et al. v. Mayor, etc., of

City of N. Y .............47, 55 Porter v. Cook ............... 557 Presby v. Benjamin .......... 266 Price McCormick & Co., Mat-

ter of, In re. Claim of Crocker ...............247, 264

Quinn v. Leathem ..........37, 57

Rauh v. Waterman ........... 423 Reade, In the Goods of....... 425 Reagan v. Nat. Bank ......... I9 Rex v. Plummer............. 559 Reynolds & Reynolds Co. v.

Eacock... .. ............. 19 Richmond, In the Matter of... 55 Roberson v. Folding Box Co.

486, 500 Robinson v. Sims............ 256 Rosenthal v. Weir........330, 336 Royal Trust Co. v. Washburn

B. & I. R.Ry.Co .......... 415

Salt Lake City Water and Elec- tric Power Co. v. City of Salt Lake City ........... ..... 337

Schaezlein v. Cabaniss........ 337 Schenkein & Coney, In re.249, 256 Schoeller, Matter of.......... 502 Scofield v. Penn. Co......... 336 Sears v. Board of St. Commis-

sioners .......... .. ..242, 267 Secretary of State v.Krisnamoni 562 Simmons v. Territory......... Sicilian Asphalt Paving Co. v.

Reilly .................... 340 Slingerland v. International

Contracting Co............ 266 Smith v. Patton............ 421 Snyder v. Holt Mf'g. Co....... 58 So. Express Co. v. State..... II6 So. Pacific Ry. Co. v. Arnett.. I82 So. Ry. Co. v. Wood......... I15 Spiers & Union Drop Forge Co. I6 Standard Inv. Co. v. Freeman.. 343 State v. Carter ............... 183 State v. Cook .............. . 49 State v. Gravette .........251, 258 State v. Goddard ............ 118 State v. Muir ................ 117 State v. School District No. 108,

Dakota Co................ 263 State v. Sunapee Dam Co..... 54 State Board of Equalization v.

People, ex rel. Goggin ....43, 56 Steinmeyer v. Steinmeyer.... 501

xiv




PAGE

Sternaman v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co ...............334, 339

Stewart v. Price .......... 30S, 340 Stillwater, etc., St. Ry. Co. v.

Boston & Maine Ry. Co ... 504 Sutton v. Belo............... 57 Swift, In Re................. 257

Tarbell v. Rutland Ry. Co.... 343 Tartar Chemical Co. v. United

States........... ......... 557 Teal v. American Mining Co.

et al .............107, I25, 268 Trauger, State ex rel. v. Nash. 496 Travell v. Bannerman ........ 564 Tremblay v. Harmony Mills... 504 Turpie v. Lowe .............. 262 Tweedie Trading Co. v. James

P. McDonald Co.......... 558

Union National Bank of Chi- cago v. Chapman.......253, 257

Union Pac. R. R. Co. v. Alex- ander..................... 4 6

Union Strawboard Co. v. Bon- field ................... 166, I8o

United Rys. & Electric Co. v. Hardesty .................. 414

PAGE

United States v. Certain Lands. 333, 337

United States v. Thomas .... 556 United States, ex rel. Guar-

anty Trust Co. v. Haggarty. 552, 560

Van Horn v. Kittitas County.. 258

Walsh v. Wheelwright ....... 56 Wamsley v. Atlas Steamship

Co....................... 115 Washington v. Bank for Sav-

ings..............170, I82, 501 Washington Co. v. Williams.. 181 Webster v. Webster.......... 264 Weiand's Adm'r. v. State Na-

tional Bank of Maysville. 171, 184 Welston Coal Co. v. Smith.... 57 W hite v. State ............ .. I82 Wilcox v. Chicago & N. W. Ry.

Co................... . 260 Winkfield, The...........324, 336 Wise v. Dunning............. 419 Woodbridge v. Bockes........ 560 Worcester, etc., St. Ry. Co v.

Travellers Ins. Co......... 261

XV



Date post:	09-Jan-2017
Category:	Documents
Upload:	ngonhi
View:	212 times
Download:	0 times

Volume Information

Documents