Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adultsFrans Thissen
Department of Geography, Planning and International Development Studies
OutlinePart 1 Introduction Concepts Results: the cumulative
character of vulnerability (a demanding environment)
Possibilities of (in)formal care (a supportive environment)
Conclusions
Part 2 Questions
The conceptualisation and measurement of person-environment fit
Research project in Eastern Gelderland villages
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
2
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
3
Introduction “WHEN I'M SIXTY-FOUR” When I get older losing my hair,Many years from nowWill you still be sending me the Valentine,Birthday greetings, bottle of wine
Paul McCartney (1967)
THE EXPERIENCE OF BEING OLD(Young) Adults have not ‘been there’. ‘Being old’ creates the potential of empathy, recognition, sharing and understanding.
Chris Pilo (2003), however about the study of youth. GROWING OLD: LOSS
Loss of health (biological) Loss of social roles (social-cultural) Loss of social capital (functional social
resources) Theo van Tilburg (2005)
UvA research about older people
Older people in villages Zeeland, Drenthe, Gelderland (1995 &
2009), Noord-Holland Old People in Europe’s Rural Areas
(OPERA) Clare Wenger: types of social support
networks European study of Adult Well-being
(ESAW) Clare Wenger, Thomas Scharf, Vanessa
Burholt PhD Marieke van der Meer
Multiple disadvantage of older immigrants and non-migrants in deprived neighbourhoods in Amsterdam
PhD Sabine van der Greft
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
4
Concepts Vulnerability Environment / Neighbourhood (demanding / supporting) Environmental stress Environmental docility hypothesis Person-environment fit
Literature: Meer, M. van der, J. Droogleever Fortuijn & F. Thissen (2008), Vulnerability and environmental
stress of older adults in deprived neighbourhoods in The Netherlands. Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, Vol 99, 1, p. 53-64.
Droogleever Fortuijn, J.C., M.J. van der Meer & F. Thissen (2006). Kwetsbare ouderen en de kwaliteit van de buurt. Rooilijn, 39 (5): 245-250.
Meer, M. Van der (2006), Older adults and their socio-spatial integration in the Netherlands, Netherlands Geographical Studies 345, KNAG / UvA, Utrecht / Amsterdam, Chapter 6
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
5
Vulnerability (1) Definition: “aggregate of all
factors that negatively affect independent functioning in daily life”
Multidimensional concept with cumulative effects
Balance between burden vs. bearing capacity (Deeg)
Views on vulnerability / frailty (SCP)
Result of irreversible developments (health, social networks)
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
6
Vulnerability (2) Dimensions: Individual: personal functional
dependency Personal health status Behavioural consequences (Instrumental) activities of daily
living: (I)ADL, measures of independent functioning
Household: resources Presence of other people Adequacy of household income
Environmental context
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
7
Environment / Neighbourhood
Work of environmental psychology (Lawton) and environmental gerontology (Phillipson, Scharf)
Environment: Demanding vs. supportive
character of the environment Changing character of the (local)
community (Phillipson)‘Elected’ and ‘Excluded’
Person-environment fit (Keaton) Older people as active agents Temporal dimension: place
connectivity (Burholt)
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
8
Neighbourhood deprivation
Neighbourhood deprivation: multidimensional concept (Musterd)
1. Low income2. Non-participation and non-integration
(social security payments) Relevant characteristics for social
mobility of (young) adults
Neighbourhood deprivation dimensions for older people
Housing and care: quality dwellings, public domain and access to services Self reliance
Wellbeing (social climate) Belonging and identity
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
9
Environmental stress
Definition: “process in which people experience emotional distress in relationship to environmental exposures” (Baum et al 1982; Dupéré & Perkins 2007)
‘Being out of place’ (Rowles & Walkins, 2007)
Measuring environmental stress1. Dissatisfaction with the
neighbourhood2. Feelings of safety
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
10
Environmental docility hypothesis (Lawton 1982) “the less competent the individual, the greater is the impact
of environmental factors on that individual”
Older adults without functional limitations and with adequate household resources are able to live satisfying lives in a variety of not only favourable, but also unfavourable environments.
Frail older adults with few resources are hypothesised to experience high levels of environmental stress in terms of neighbourhood dissatisfaction and feelings of unsafety in deprived neighbourhoods, while feeling satisfied and safe in non-deprived neighbourhoods.
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
11
Data and methods ESAW NL Dutch ESAW dataset 2002-2003, structured face-to-face
interview with 1939 older people (50-90 years, non-institutional)
Stratified random sample (12 geographical strata) Three regions: central, peri-urban, peripheral Urban / rural Deprived / non-deprived
Sample proportionate to national distribution of eight age / gender groups
Response rate 43 percent Descriptive analyses and logistic regression analyses
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
12
Older adults in The NetherlandsDeprived neighbourhood 36 % functional dependent 45 % low income 28 % lives alone
30 % Lives whole life in current settlement
Access to dwelling by stairs: 14 %
Non-deprived neighbourhood 25 % functional dependent 22 % low income 24 % lives alone
18 % lives whole life in current settlement
Access to dwelling by stairs 9 %
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
13
Source: Esaw-NL 2002-2003
Cumulative character of vulnerability (1)
14Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
Source: Esaw-NL 2002-2003
15Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
Cumulative character of vulnerability (2)
Source: Esaw-NL 2002-2003
Possibilities of (in)formal care (a supportive environment)Dependent older people in deprived neighbourhoods receiving informal care experience less environmental stress than older people receiving formal care
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
16
Conclusions
Most older people: self reliant, feel at home, active agents
Vulnerable people are more likely to experience negative effects from environmental deprivation
Risks of socialisation of care Accumulation of personal, household and
environmental vulnerability results in environmental stress (cumulative character of vulnerability)
The importance of the quality of the neighbourhood
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
17
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
18
Questions: the conceptualization and measurement of person-environment fit of older adultsMake a list or scheme of concepts that represents the concept of person-environment fit of older people in a village
Develop some ideas for ‘measurement’: topic list or questions in questionnaire
Research design – conceptual model
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
19
Dependent variables:
Person-environment fit
Explanatory variables:
Life history characteristics
Individual characteristics
Contextual characteristics
Self-reliance (housing, care)
Feeling at home (belonging, identity)
Research region: Eastern Gelderland
20Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
Research region: Eastern Gelderland
21Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
22
Data Women and men > 55 years 1995 survey 285 women, 230 men 1995 interviews 15 women, 10 men 2009 survey 285 women, 230 men 2009 interviews 15 women, 8 men
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
23
Indicators of modernity and person-environment fit
Driving license Car availability Experience with
paid work Educational level
Satisfaction with dwelling
Satisfaction with village Feelings of safety locally Attachment to village Active outside home
Traditional-Modern Vulnerable-successful
Traditional / Modern
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
24
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
25
Four situations of person-environment fit
vulnerable successfultraditional 2 1modern 3 4
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
26
Traditional successful: Nel 75 years Lives 50 years in small village M. Married with farmer Active in community life (choir, noaberschap, dialect) Feels perfectly at home Feels safe
“I leave the keys in my car and everybody could take the car and I let all the doors open and there is always coffee for anybody who drops in”
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
27
Traditional vulnerable: Corrie 86 years Wheelchair 45 years in industrial village B. Low involvement in community life Knows less and less people Feels unsafe
“The tight community is still there but has gone underground”
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
28
Modern vulnerable: Anna
68 years 34 years in small village L. Active in social activities outside village (tennis,
classical music) Few contacts in village Feels not at home Feels unsafe
“L. does not feel as ‘my’ village”
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
29
Modern successful: Marjan 68 years Born in large village K., but lived longtime outside village Active in aqua fitness, badminton and voluntary work (Third
World shop, Red Cross, local crafts) in village Helps people, knows many people in village Feels at home Feels safe Actively anticipates on later life in village
“I have spotted my future house in the village”
Person environment fit: Vulnerable older women / type of village
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
30
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
31
Critical human ecology viewpoint on ageing“ …older adults are not passive recipients of the environments in which they live, but have varying capacities to make choices and to act on and adapt their environments” (Keating and Phillips, 2008, p. 4)
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adults
32
Conceptualization and measurement of person-environment fit of older people in small villages
Self
reliance
General opinion about self-reliance Own contribution:Housing Opinion about dwelling
Opinion about residential environment Opinion about characteristics of the
residential environment (facilities, safety, inhabitants, attractiveness)
Recent activities aimed at better person-environment fit: Moving, changes to dwelling, activities aimed at better fit with respect to residential environment
Care Opinion about formal care Opinion about informal care of family Opinion about informal care of neighbours Opinion about informal care of friends
Recent activities with respect to self-care, informal care, volunteering, helping family, friends and neighbours
Feeling at home
General opinion about feeling at home Own contribution:Well-being
Loneliness Place attachment:
o Social (social integration)o Physical (esthetical and emotional)o Historical (relation developed in time)
Identification: relation between own lifestyle and place identity
Recent activities with respect to social integration, the physical quality of the village, historical consciousness, attuning lifestyle and place
Vulnerability and the person-environment fit of older adultsFrans Thissen
Department of Geography, Planning and International Development Studies