Date post: | 30-Nov-2014 |
Category: |
Business |
Upload: | tapan-kamdar |
View: | 4,765 times |
Download: | 0 times |
PRICING STRATEGY WATERLESS WASHING MACHINE
- Amitabh Misra- Harshal Pimphalkhute- Shreyas Murthi - Tapan Kamdar
Context- There is growing awareness for ‘reduce-reuse-recycle’ of energy and water
¨ Energy¤ By 2030 electricity usage growth of 40%¤ Limited resources, cost will continue to rise in future¤ Washer-Drier units leading consumers of electricity at home
¨ Water¤ 22% of US water usage is for washing purposes1
¤ Typically 1.2B gallons a day is used for washing1
¨ Environment awareness for reduce-reuse-recycle¤ Waterless car washes, urinals, low water sprinklers¤ Energy star appliances
1 – American water works association estimates
Context
2
The waterless washing machine- New patented ‘nylon beads’ technology saves 90% water and 30% electricity
¨
¤ R&D partnership with University of Leeds (UK)
¤ Currently in stealth mode
¨ Key product features¤ No dryer unit required¤ 90% less water¤ 30% less electricity¤ Uses patented nylon beads – stains
get attracted and get diffused in nylon beads, beads are recycled
¤ Currently in prototype, first product available in end of 2010
Context
Note: See appendix for details on how the Xeros washer works
3
Context
Customers- Commercial cleaners & hotels will derive most benefit from Xeros’ offering
Custom
er Segments
à
Value driversà
Xeros Value proposition
Note: Quantification of these value drivers and market size for each segment done later in pricing and value creation sectionCommercial cleaners = professional dry cleaners who have significant volume of regular laundry cleaning
4
Traditional Washer/Dryer Air washers Dry Cleaning Natural Air
drying
Advantages
• Mature technology• Many strong
companies• Huge market share• Established
channels and manufacturing process
• New technology• Uses recycled
water• Can be used for
delicate washing
• Mature technology• High quality• Preserves delicate
fabric
• Very low total cost
Disadvantages
• Significant Energy consumption and water usage (~30% of utility bill)
• Uses ozone• Only removes bio-
degradable stains• Newer unproven
technology
• Expensive• Need special skills
and equipments• Use of abrasive
chemicals
• Time consuming
• Low quality
Context
Competitors- Key direct competitors are traditional washer/dryers and ‘air washers’
Primary Competition Secondary Competition
5
Context
Collaborators/Channels- Xeros should partner with some existing players like GE in both segments
Production Branding Promotion Distribution Channels
Commercial product
License technology for production to established player like GE
Brand as ‘XEROS’ washer
Use Direct Sales Force for promotion commercial outlets
Existing retail (e.g. Sears) and online (Amazon) channels
Residential product
License technology for production to established player like GE
Brand as GE washer + ‘Powered by XEROS’
Let GE take care of promotion
Existing retail (e.g. Sears) and online (Amazon) channels
Motivation / Decision Drivers
• Startup company needs good cash flow to sustain
• Xeros’ patent is on nylon beads technology, it can take advantage of GE’s expertise in production and distribution
• Xeros needs to maintain its brand recognition as innovation leader in commercial segment
• Residential customers are very fragmented and need a wide distribution network – requires deep pockets
• For commercial space, Xeros’ sales force is in best position to demonstrate the new technology and value proposition
This project is pricing only for the commercial washer product (not residential product) and will cover pricing for (1) washer unit (2)
nylon beads refills (3) service contracts
Note: The collaboration assumes that the license agreement drafted between GE and Xeros take care of no-compete clauses and restricts the freedom of use for certain allowed fields only (e.g. commercial, residential etc..)
6
Pricing strategy pyramid- Framework used for pricing the new washer units + beads
PriceLevel
Product value
Pricing Policy
Cash flow, Market Share
Value CreationEconomic Value, Offering Design, Segmentation
Value CommunicationEconomic Benefit, Positioning
Price StructureBundling, Fencing, Services
7
Value Creation- Savings come from lower operational costs, space reduction & lack of dryer unit
Operational cost reduction
Space savings due to lack of
dryer
Dryer machine Savings+ + =
Total value creation
(relative to current costs for customer)
Conventional cleaning
Xeros cleaning
8
9
Value Creation- The highest value add from Xeros’ washer is in Hotels segment
Loads Loads LoadsWeight (lbs) 10,000,000 Weight (lbs) 15,000,000 Weight (lbs) 5,000,000 / Weight/load 150 / Weight/load 150 / Weight/load 150= Annual Loads 66,667 = Annual Loads 100,000 = Annual Loads 33,333
Operational Savings Operational Savings Operational SavingsLabor 2.50 Labor 2.50 Labor 2.50+ Water 0.10 + Water 0.10 + Water 0.10+ Electricty 0.10 + Electricty 0.10 + Electricty 0.10+ Detergent 0.25 + Detergent 0.25 + Detergent 0.25- Beads (0.40) - Beads (0.40) - Beads (0.40)= VC/load 2.55 = VC/load 2.55 = VC/load 2.55* Annual Loads 66,667 * Annual Loads 100,000 * Annual Loads 33,333= Savings 170,001$ = Savings 255,000$ = Savings 84,999$
Space savings Space savings Space savingsLaundry (sq ft) 1000 Laundry (sq ft) 3000 Laundry (sq ft) 2000* Annual Rent $36 * Annual Rent $12 * Annual Rent $24* Utilization 25% * Utilization 80% * Utilization 80%= Savings 9,000$ = Savings 28,800$ = Savings 38,400$
Savings Savings SavingsOperational 170,001 Operational 255,000 Operational 84,999+ Space 9,000 + Space 28,800 + Space 38,400= Net Savings 179,001$ = Net Savings 283,800$ = Net Savings 123,399$ / # Machines 30 / # Machines 30 / # Machines 10= Value Created 5,967$ = Value Created 9,460$ = Value Created 12,340$
Commercial HotelsHopitals
+Dryer
machine Savings(~$15K)
Value created by Xeros washer is in addition to the savings from not buying the dryer
units
Note: Refer to appendix for more details on calculations, data sources and assumptions
Market Sizing and Targeting- The hotels and hospital segments also have the highest market potential
Commercial Hospitals Hotels
No. of cities in USA 100 100 100x No. of accounts/city 2 3 10= Total accounts 200 300 1,000
Value created per machine $5,967 $9,460 $12,340x No. of machine per account 30 30 10x Total accounts 200 300 1000 = Total value for segment 35,800,170$ 85,140,000$ 123,399,150$
Ease of converting to Xeros High Low HighFragmentation of segment DMU High Low LowExpected share 3% 6% 6%
Exp value 1,074,005$ 5,108,400$ 7,403,949$
Commercial segment has a lower expected
market potential
Expected share is a function of the Decision Making
Process by customers
Hotel segment is the best starting target segment with
highest expected market potential
10
Xeros should only look at targets in
cities/metros since sales/marketing
cost are significant in rural areas for a startup company
Note: Number of commercial accounts per city is assumed based on central cleaners who collect laundry from multiple locationsHotel segmented is assumed to be less fragmented due to centralized decision making by hotel chains / groups
11
Price Structure- Revenue will come from washer unit, beads and service are secondary sources
¨ Washer machine unit will be priced as per value provided to customer - see next section for price level
¨ Fences could potentially be created for Hospital segments by creating some product differentiation (e.g. anti-bacterial lining for washers etc..) – phase 2
Washer unit
¨ Beads will be sold at 10 % margin per load – sold in 20 pound packs
¨ Cost to customer = 40 cents (20 cents manufacturing cost + 10cents for distributors + 10 cents margin)
¨ For higher bead profits, warranty could be written such that Xeros beads are used exclusively
Beads
¨ Pricing based on industry benchmark for conventional washing systems – 10-20% machine of sale price
¨ A contract agreement based on hours of operation, would be an additional tool in endorsing product quality
¨ SLA structured to deliver service within promised period of request
Service
¨ Use ‘Economic Value Communication’ Strategyn Communication to focus on justifying price based on value of each
differentiating value driver.
Communication PositioningBenefits and Relative Cost to find Value
LowSimple “Search” Goods
HighComplex “Experience” Goods
Econ
omic
Ben
efit
Psyc
holo
gica
l B
enef
it
WaterlessWashingMachine
Positioning Factors
• Relatively Low cost to determine benefits because:• Hotels and Commercial cleaners
are EXPERT customers• Product expenditure is HIGH.• Purchases likely to be in BULK• Some benefits such as no water,
less power and no dryer are obvious
• Limited psychological benefits:• Less detergent, water and
electricity• But business has to be
competitive.
12
Value Communication Strategy- Justify price based on value of each differentiating value driver.
Traditional washers
Air Dryers
Dry Cleaners
Customer Economic Value Comparison• Create a customer economic value comparison
sheet for primary competition.• Include top differentiating value drivers – water
electricity, space and time.
Value Based Model• Create customizable value model software that
takes basic data from buyer as input and calculates net savings specific to customer.
• Include inputs such as area used, operation hours, labor, machine utilization & throughput.
• Calculate cost savings, new throughput, labor savings, reduced space requirements etc.
Address concerns about New Product and Switching Costs• Expert opinions from industry analysts such as
JD Powers in form of reports and videos• Customer testimonials• Demonstration videos focusing on simplicity of
use in washing and bead removal.• Offer free installation and trials
Other Promotional Material• Product demonstration video• Reports on impact of current processes on
environment.• Product warranty• Reference prices from all other alternative
washing products.
- Communicate Economic Value- Use Direct Sales medium
13
Value Communication Method- Use Direct Sales Force to communicate differentiation and value
¨ Give discounts for non-credit purchases (i.e. encourage shorter A/R period)
Manage cash flow effectively
Pricing Policy- Manage Cash flow and generate long term customers
¨ Allow for volume discounts for big accounts (this is required to manage customer expectations and can also be used as case studies for other customers)
¨ Appropriately incentivize sales force to target big accounts and give them 10% pricing flexibility
Win large volume from big accounts
¨ Bundle annual supply of beads (discounted price) with initial sale of washer unit
¨ Maintain 10% margin on beads sales later, once the customer is locked in
Promote beads sales with initial product
Objectives Tactics
14
15
Price Level- Skim the market (Hotels segment) with $34K, and allow hospitals to self select
PositiveDifferentiation
• Savings in labor and space
• Reduced operational costs
• Dryer machine costs
Reference Value
Conventional Conventional Washing m/c Washing m/c
Negative Diff•Cost of beads•User Training
Value returned to Customer
Dryer Cost + 25% of value created
Hotels – Price Skimming$52 K
$34 K
$25 K
PositiveDifferentiation
• Savings in labor and space
• Reduced operational costs
• Dryer machine costs
Reference Value
Conventional Conventional Washing m/c Washing m/c
Negative DiffNegative Diff•Cost of beads•User Training
Value returned to Customer
Dryer Cost + 25% of value created
Hospitals - Penetration
$49 K
$32 K
$25 K
Skimming
Price
TimePenetration Patent Expiry
$34K$32K
$25-28K
16
Price Timing Graph- Start with skimming and then move to penetration pricing
Skimming• Differentiated Product• Convey Long term value• Build Brand Image• Guard against competition• Consumer feedback and
buzz
Penetration• Price reduction to increase
adoption rates• Motivate volume purchases• Increase Market Share• Build Service revenue
stream
Patent Expiry• Price on par with
commercial washers• Value to customer = No
need for dryer• Launch non-commercial
model for residential market
$31K $29K $25-27K
17
Price Timing- Start with skimming and then move to penetration pricing
Appendix18
19
Illustration of washing
process using Xeros washer
Value Creation- Calculations, data sources and assumptions
Price/unit Usage /load Cost/load Savings (%)
Savingsper load
Water (gallons) $0.003 39 $0.11 90% $0.10
Detergent $0.27 1 $0.27 90% $0.25
Washer Energy (KwH) $0.25 0.12 $0.03 30% $0.01
Energy Dryer (KwH) $0.25 0.36 $0.09 100% $0.09
Sources and Assumptions:
http://michaelbluejay.com/electricity/laundry.html
http://timeswv.com/local/x681690753/WVUH-laundry-load-growing-to-15-million-pounds-annually
Xeros website and product specifications (for savings estimates)
Assumptions for space and operational savings informed through interviews with commercial washer owners
20