Water and WastewaterCapital Charge Update
Utilities Department
Orange County Board of County Commissioners
February 26, 2013
• Background
• Level of Service Study
• Capital Charge Update
• Customer Impact
• Next Steps
Presentation Outline
2
• Background
• Level of Service StudyLevel of Service Study
• Capital Charge UpdateCapital Charge Update
• Customer ImpactCustomer Impact
• Next StepsNext Steps
Presentation Outline
3
Background
• Charges are paid by new development for water and wastewater capacity
• Capital charges are calculated for the amount of water or wastewater capacity needed to serve one home (LOS)
• Current Charges: $1,950 per home (water) $3,668 per home (wastewater)
4
• BackgroundBackground
• Level of Service Study
• Capital Charge UpdateCapital Charge Update
• Customer ImpactCustomer Impact
• Next StepsNext Steps
Presentation Outline
5
Level of Service Study
• Determined actual Level of Service for single family homes
• Recommend changing level of service for new single family homes Water: 350 to 275 gpd Wastewater: 300 to 225 gpd
6
LOS Study
7
LOS Study
8
Level of Service Study
9
Level of Service Study
10
Level of Service Study
• Commercial Factors
Factors convert commercial demands to equivalent number of single family homes
• OCU has 61 commercial factors No Change:44 Decrease: 12 Modify: 4 Increase: 1
11
Level of Service Study
• Small Restaurants
Restaurants are charged per seat– Consistent with most utilities in Florida
Restaurants with more than 200 seats– Use 25% more water per seat
Propose reducing per seat factor– Factor for first 100 seats set at 75% of full value– Smaller restaurants get a full 25% reduction– All restaurants benefit
12
• BackgroundBackground
• Level of Service StudyLevel of Service Study
• Capital Charge Update
• Customer ImpactCustomer Impact
• Next StepsNext Steps
Presentation Outline
13
Capital Charge Update
• Per resolution, reviewed and updated every 4 years
Based on cost of existing and future capacity
Growth to “pay its own way”
Cannot exceed full recovery cost
Based on new Level of Service
14
Capital Charge Update
• Cost per home
Water Wastewater Total
Current $1,950 $3,668 $5,618
Proposed $1,791 $3,346 $5,137
$ Change -$159 -$322 -$481
% Change -8.2% -8.8% -8.6%
15
Capital Charge Update
16
Capital Charge Update
17
Capital Charge Update
18
• BackgroundBackground
• Level of Service StudyLevel of Service Study
• Capital Charge UpdateCapital Charge Update
• Customer Impact
• Next StepsNext Steps
Presentation Outline
19
Customer Impact
• Typical reductions in capital charges
Customer Type Reduction ($) Reduction (%)
One Single Family Residence
-$481 -8.6%
Hotel 200 Rooms
-$48,100 -8.6%
Multi-Family 33 one bedroom units 33
two bedroom units 34 three bedroom units
-$82,068 -18.1%
20
Customer Impact
• Typical reductions in capital charges
Customer Type Reduction ($) Reduction (%)
Small Restaurant100 seats
-$17,653 -31.4%
Large Restaurant350 seats
-$29,678 -15.1%
Retail Space2 bathrooms
-$581 -8.6%
Office20,000 sq. ft.
-$3,213 -8.6%
21
• BackgroundBackground
• Level of Service StudyLevel of Service Study
• Capital Charge UpdateCapital Charge Update
• Customer ImpactCustomer Impact
• Next Steps
Presentation Outline
22
Next Steps
• BCC Workshop 02-26-13• DAB Workshop 03-06-13• DAB Recommendation 03-20-13• LPA Workshop 04-18-13• BCC Comp Plan Adoption 05-14-13• LPA Recommendation 05-16-13• BCC Public Hearing June 2013
23
24
Water and WastewaterCapital Charge Update
Utilities Department
Orange County Board of County Commissioners
February 26, 2013
Factors That Decrease
25
Use Type Current Factor Proposed Factor
Multi-Family - 1 bedroom 0.583/unit 0.500/unit
Multi-Family - 3 bedrooms 1.000/unit 0.833/unit
Restaurant/Cafeteria - First 100 seats
0.100/seat 0.075/seat
Restaurant 24 hours - First 100 seats
0.167/seat 0.125/seat
Bar/Cocktail Lounge - First 100 seats
0.067/seat 0.050/seat
Warehouse OfficeOffice SF plus all bathrooms
plus Warehouse Fixture Units
Office SF plus 1 bathroom plus Warehouse Fixture
Units
Factors That Decrease
26
Use Type Current Factor Proposed Factor
College or Technical School Outside of Typical Campus
0.067/student seat 0.025/student seat
Student Housing – 1 bedroom
0.583/unit 0.500/unit
Student Housing – 3 bedrooms
1.000/unit 0.833/unit
Hotel – 1 bedroom suite 0.583/unit 0.500/unit
Hotel – 3 bedroom suite 1.000/unit 0.833/unit
Animal Care 0.160/Kennel Run 0.091/Kennel, Cage or Stall
Modified Factors
27
Use Type Current Factor Proposed Factor
Dentist 0.833/dentist 0.650/wet chair
Medical Office 0.833/doctor Fixture Units
Vehicle Fueling Stations 1.000/toilet room Fixture Units
Hair SalonEngineering Study to
determine per pedicure station flow
0.300/pedicure station
Factors That Increase
28
Use Type Current Factor Proposed Factor
Irrigation 0.125/1000 SF 0.159/1000 SF
Residential Factors
29
Establishment Unit ERC Factor
Single family home, detached or townhome, with water meter less than 1 inch
Home 1.000
Single family home, with water meter 1 inch or larger By fixture units N/A
Duplex, 1 or 2 bedrooms Each half of duplex 0.833
Duplex, 3 or more bedrooms Each half of duplex 1.000
Multi-family, efficiency or 1 bedroom Apartment 0.500
Multi-family, 2 or more bedrooms Apartment 0.833
Mobile home, 1 or 2 bedrooms Home 0.667
Mobile home, 3 or more bedrooms Home 0.833
Non-Residential Factors
30
Establishment Unit ERC Factor
Animal care facility/veterinary clinicKennel, cage, or
stall0.091
Bowling alley (add for restaurant and bar seats that are separated)
Bowling lane 0.333
Church (add for residences, weekday schools, and daycare facilities)
Seat 0.017
Hair salon (add 0.3 ERCs for each pedicure station) Operator station 0.300
Hotel room or one-bedroom hotel suite (add for food service, meeting and banquet rooms, self-service laundries, and major facilities attracting non-guests)
Room orsuite
0.500
Hotel suite, two or more bedrooms (add for food service, meeting and banquet rooms, self-service laundries, and major facilities attracting non-guests)
Suite 0.833
Industrial/production facility, without showers (add for food service and industrial/production process demands)
Employee 0.050
Industrial/production facility, with showers (emergency showers not included, add for food service and industrial/production process demands)
Employee 0.117
Non-Residential Factors
31
Establishment Unit ERC Factor
Irrigation1,000 sq. ft. of irrigable area
0.159
Laundry, self-service Washing machine 1.333
Office building (add for food service)1,000 sq. ft. gross
floor area0.334
Retail space By fixture units N/A
Shell building (unfinished space) with fixtures present (Exception: if building is multi-unit with fixtures located in common areas, apply “office building” factor instead of fixtures)
By fixture units N/A
Trailer park (overnight) Each space 0.333
Warehouse/office, 3,000 sq. ft. or less By fixture units N/A
Warehouse/office, larger than 3,000 sq. ft.
By “office building” factor for office area. Warehouse area by
bathroom fixture units as required by Plumbing Code (2 WC, 2 Lav, & 1 D.F.) plus any
non-bathroom fixtures located in warehouse area
Non-Residential Factors
32
Establishment Unit ERC Factor
FOOD SERVICE FACTORS•If a restaurant eligible for a 25% capital charge reduction for the first 100 seats has mixed bar/restaurant seating, the reduction will apply to restaurant seats first, then to bar seats•Fast food classification applies to facilities with no table service, glassware, or washable plates and utensils
Restaurant, any type, less than 20 seats By fixture units N/A
Restaurant/cafeteria, per seat, first 100 seats Seat 0.075
Restaurant/cafeteria, per seat, seats other than first 100
Seat 0.100
Restaurant, twenty-four hour, per seat, first 100 seats Seat 0.125
Restaurant, twenty-four hour, per seat, seats other than first 100
Seat 0.167
Restaurant, fast food, per seat Seat 0.050
Bar/cocktail lounge, per seat, first 100 seats Seat 0.050
Bar/cocktail lounge, per seat, seats other than first 100 Seat 0.067
Non-Residential Factors
33
Establishment Unit ERC Factor
Dentist office Wet chair 0.650
Medical office By fixture units N/A
Hospital Per bed 0.833
Nursing home Per bed 0.417
Extended care facility, efficiency or one bedroom (no additional charge for staff-operated facilities supporting residents’ daily living activities)
Housing unit 0.500
Extended care facility, two or more bedrooms (no additional charge for staff-operated facilities supporting residents’ daily living activities)
Housing unit 0.833
Meeting and/or banquet rooms (seats = total sq. ft./15 sq. ft.)
Seat 0.017
Theater Seat 0.010
Theater (dinner) Seat 0.067
Non-Residential Factors
34
Establishment Unit ERC Factor
Daycare or preschoolChild, per permitted occupancy
0.025
Elementary school or kindergarten Student seat 0.025
Middle and high schools Student seat 0.067
College or technical school Student seat 0.067
College or technical school outside of a typical campus Student seat 0.025
Student housing, one bed (add for food service) Housing unit 0.500
Student housing, two beds (add for food service) Housing unit 0.583
Student housing, three beds (add for food service) Housing unit 0.833
Student housing, four or more beds (add for food service)
Housing unit 1.000
Non-Residential Factors
35
Establishment Unit ERC Factor
Vehicle fueling station/convenience store (add for vehicle wash and repair bays)
By fixture units N/A
Vehicle repair/maintenance facility (add for additional uses)
Repair bay 0.250
Vehicle wash facility (or by engineer’s estimate if wash water recycle system is proposed)
Wash bay 3.200
Rates Comparison
36
Rates Comparison
37
Melbourne $124.61Cocoa $112.92
Casselberry $88.53Sanford $85.73Oviedo $85.26
Winter Park $82.95Seminole County $80.76
Orlando (OUC) $73.66Altamonte Springs $70.59
Maitland $69.67Orange County $67.69
Mt. Dora $66.21Ocoee $64.40
Winter Garden $59.99Lake Mary $57.70
Apopka $57.63
Combined Water & Sewer Bill Survey at 10,000 Gallons per Month
Rates Comparison
38
Collier County $112.77Columbia County $111.09
Volusia County (East) $108.12Lee County $105.66
Pinellas County $102.98Hillsborough County $100.75
Polk County $98.33Pasco County $97.64
Brevard County $97.48Broward County $97.22
Volusia County (West) $90.37Okaloosa County $89.78
Marion County $88.79Manatee County $87.85Seminole County $80.76
Toho Water Authority $75.58Miami-Dade County $73.54Palm Beach County $72.19
Orange County $67.69
Combined Water & Sewer Bill Survey at 10,000 Gallons per Month