US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 1
WBS 5 - Forward Pixels
Bruno Gobbi
DOE/NSF Review
May 8, 2001
WBS 5 - Forward PixelsWBS 5 - Forward PixelsWBS 5 - Forward PixelsWBS 5 - Forward Pixels
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 2
OutlineOutlineOutlineOutline
• Status of the US CMS Pixel project
• System overview
• Accomplishments of last year’s goals
• Status and technical progress
• Scope change and contingency use since
last review
• Committee concerns and issues
• Plans for the next six months
• Summary and conclusions
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 3
The FPix project is nearing the completion of a 3 year R&D phase. All the major components have now been defined, allowing for a more realistic estimate of cost and schedule.
The project is now shifting into prototyping of components, carrying out system tests, and studying how to assemble the detector. The installation date has been delayed by one year (to April 06), permitting us to start the final assembly in ‘04 rather than ‘03.
Status of the Forward PixelStatus of the Forward PixelStatus of the Forward PixelStatus of the Forward Pixel
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 4
FPix System OverviewFPix System Overview
Barrel
CMS Pixel Detector
FPix Disks
EuropeanGroup
Responsibility of US CMS
Service Cylinder
Space Cylinder
FPix Full Size Model of 1/2-Disk 2.4m
Power, Cooling, Optical Fibers
FPix:• US delivers 4 ‘disks’ (“stand alone” system)
• No changes in scope since last year
Disks’ Mechanics
IR
FPIX System OverviewFPIX System OverviewFPIX System OverviewFPIX System Overview
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 5
Blade Butterfly
HDI
Plaquette
SensorsROC
VHDI
Si Plate
FPix Scope and DeliverablesFPix Scope and Deliverables
FECVMEBoard
Token Bit Manager
Comm. Network Hub
NEW
FPIX Scope and DeliverablesFPIX Scope and DeliverablesFPIX Scope and DeliverablesFPIX Scope and Deliverables
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 6
Last YearGoals and Accomplishments
Last YearLast YearPlans and AccomplishmentsPlans and Accomplishments
Last YearLast YearPlans and AccomplishmentsPlans and Accomplishments
• Beam test: Carried out.
• Prototype TBM/CNH, HDI, and FEC: TBM/CNH, and FEC being tested (FPGA), HDI is now two components a Very-HDI (first prototype) and the HDI
• Submission of second prototype sensors: In progress
• Submission of Multiple Chips Placement: Parts just returned. Good results.
• Procure first 1/2-Disk made of Be: Delayed by lack of engineers. Effort is resuming now.
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 7
FPix Technical Progress in FPix Technical Progress in FY01FY01
FPix Technical Progress in FPix Technical Progress in FY01FY01
• Preparing for a new Sensor Submission
• Bump Bonding submission for multiple chips being evaluated
• First Prototypes of the TBM and FEC
• First prototype of VHDI
• Started tooling for assembly of detectors
• Results from Test Beam at CERN
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 8
1.E-07
1.E-06
1.E-05
1.E-04
1.E-03
0 100 200 300 400 500Reverse Bias (V)
Lea
kag
e C
urr
en t
(A) Pixel Current
Guard Ring Current
After = 1x1014 p/cm2
increase in current after 300V(2-8)% noisy channels (PSI)With = 6x1014 p/cm2
same I with pixels at -100C
FPix. Sensors, 1st Subm.
Guard Ring: Design hold 1000V. Very good!
p-Stop: double open ring. OK but no safety margin
Before irradiation90% of pixels have Vbrkdwn >300V
FPIX Sensors - First SubmissionFPIX Sensors - First SubmissionFPIX Sensors - First SubmissionFPIX Sensors - First Submission
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 9
Conclusions (first submission):
• Baseline design is adequate for CMS! - Would like to understand and correct the increase in current for irradiated sensors - the cause of 10% noisy channels (test PSI)
FPix. Sensor 2nd SubmissionFPix. Sensor 2nd Submission
Second submission
• Is in preparation. Goals:- finalize the two-double ring p-stop design - produce sensors to test the FPix readout
FPIX Sensor - Second SubmissionFPIX Sensor - Second SubmissionFPIX Sensor - Second SubmissionFPIX Sensor - Second Submission
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 10
FPix, Bump BondingFPix, Bump Bonding
D;/cms/Lehman/Lehman 2001/Presentations/Plenary Presentations\Bump-Bonding..ppt
• Bump bonding with industry
• Single Chip Placement
• status: parts returned.
• submission with MCNC for bump bonding (Blank Chips) for all the sensors required for 3 Blades [135 ROC, 21 sensors of 5 different sizes, SnPb]
• In house bump bonding
• at UCD (In) for R&D detectors and read-out electronics
• yield per bump 0.9998 0.0001
FPIX - Bump BondingFPIX - Bump BondingFPIX - Bump BondingFPIX - Bump Bonding
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 11
Z, B
X
Y
20o
Row
Beam
}
Double Column
Charge Sharing
Pixels150 x150 m2
D:\LHM\2001\Presentations\Plenary Presentations\For Dan \Geometry Pixels.ppt 8mm
ROC, PSI36:11 double columns x 30 rows
Vienna Repeater
FPix. Test Beam at CERNFPIX - Test Beam at CERNFPIX - Test Beam at CERNFPIX - Test Beam at CERNFPIX - Test Beam at CERN
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 12
150 m
= 14 mover pixel
Pixels at 20o to beam
150 m / 12 = 43 m
FPix. CERN’s Test Results
= 46 mover pixel
Charge sharing vs position
Charge sharing vs position
Pixels normal to beam
150 m
D:\LHM\2001\Presentations\Plenary Presentations\For Dan \Cern Test Result.ppt
CERN Test ResultsCERN Test ResultsCERN Test ResultsCERN Test Results
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 13
FPix, Readout ElectronicsFPix, Readout Electronics
Front End Controller, FECSingle Channel Prototype
FPGAToken Bit Manger, TBM
and Control Network Hub
FEDDetetor
FPIX Readout ElectronicsFPIX Readout ElectronicsFPIX Readout ElectronicsFPIX Readout Electronics
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 14
Very Hight Densityes. Interc.Very Hight Densityes. Interc.
VHDI for Row of 5 ROCs
Test Station
Very High Density InterconnectVery High Density InterconnectVery High Density InterconnectVery High Density Interconnect
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 15
FPix, R&D Assembly. SiDetFPix, R&D Assembly. SiDet
Assembly of Detectors;NIKON measurementstation. Need 672 units
Assembly of Butterflies;OMIS II measurementstation. Need 96 units
FPIX - R&D Assembly - SiDetFPIX - R&D Assembly - SiDetFPIX - R&D Assembly - SiDetFPIX - R&D Assembly - SiDet
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 16
FPix, R&D SurveyFPix, R&D Survey
Survey BladesZeiss 500 measurement station.Need 8 units (1/2-Disk)
Components
FPIX R&D - SurveyFPIX R&D - SurveyFPIX R&D - SurveyFPIX R&D - Survey
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 17
US CMS FPIXUS CMS FPIXBCWS, BCWP & ACWPBCWS, BCWP & ACWP
US CMS FPIXUS CMS FPIXBCWS, BCWP & ACWPBCWS, BCWP & ACWP
$0
$500
$1,000
$1,500
$2,000
$2,500
AY
K$ BCWS (K$)
BCWP (K$)
ACWP (K$)
W. Scheduled
W. Performed
ACW. Performed
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 18
FPIX - BCWS ProfileFPIX - BCWS ProfileFPIX - BCWS ProfileFPIX - BCWS Profile
FPIX BCWS by Fiscal Year
0
500,000
1,000,000
1,500,000
2,000,000
2,500,000
FY96 FY97 FY98 FY99 FY00 FY01 FY02 FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06
W. Scheduled vs. Year
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 19
US CMS FPIXUS CMS FPIXSch. & Cost PerformanceSch. & Cost Performance
US CMS FPIXUS CMS FPIXSch. & Cost PerformanceSch. & Cost Performance
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
0.90
1.00
1.10
1.20
BCWP/BCWS
ACWP/BCWP
Scheduled Performance
Cost Performance
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 20
US CMS FPIX US CMS FPIX (% Comp., Cont. Use)(% Comp., Cont. Use)US CMS FPIX US CMS FPIX (% Comp., Cont. Use)(% Comp., Cont. Use)
0.000
0.100
0.200
0.300
0.400
0.500
0.600
BCWP/EAC
(EAC-Base)/Base(Contingency Use)
% W. Completed
% Cont. Use
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 21
FPIX - ETCFPIX - ETCFPIX - ETCFPIX - ETC
FPIX - ETC 5.6 AYM$
EDIA (k$)
M&S (k$)
Mfg Labor (k$)
EDIA
Mfg
M&S
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 22
SOW 01 - FPIXSOW 01 - FPIXSOW 01 - FPIXSOW 01 - FPIX
FPIX SOWs FY01 -- $.36M
University of California-Davis
Fermilab
Johns Hopkins University
University of Mississippi
Northwestern University
Purdue University
Rutgers University
Fnal
Rutgers
Purdue
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 23
US CMS FPIXUS CMS FPIXL2 & L3 Milestone PerformanceL2 & L3 Milestone Performance
US CMS FPIXUS CMS FPIXL2 & L3 Milestone PerformanceL2 & L3 Milestone Performance
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 24
FPix Critical Path
PanelsDisks
Space Cylinders
VHDI & HDI
SensorsReadout Chip
Bump Bonding
Assembly PlaquettesAssembly Butterflies
Assembly 1/2-DisksInstall Disks in 1/2-Cyl.
Shipment to LHCCommissioning completed
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 25
Critical Path AnalysisCritical Path AnalysisCritical Path AnalysisCritical Path AnalysisCritical Path Analysis
• The read-out chip development sets the critical path. [responsibility of PSI]
• Development of the TBM, VHDI and HDI depends on the design of the ROC.
• Bump Bonding is the next most critical task.
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 26
Last Review ConcernsLast Review ConcernsLast Review ConcernsLast Review Concerns
Concerns from last time have been addressed:
• Increase engineering support for HDI, (VHDI). Done
• Update the near term plan with specific milestones. Done
• Devote manpower immediately to the evaluation /of a new preproduction of sensors. Done
• Increase manpower on bump-bonding task.
Request was made to the funding agencies but it
has not been awarded yet.
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 27
Issues
• Additional manpower for bump bonding remains a pressing issue.
• Mechanical engineering must be made available (from US CMS) now to prevent this task from becoming a critical one.
IssuesIssuesIssuesIssues
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 28
What we plan for the next 6 monthsWhat we plan for the next 6 monthsWhat we plan for the next 6 monthsWhat we plan for the next 6 months
• Submission of second prototype sensors
• Testing of the first prototype TBM/CNH and FEC (FPGA), … then with FED and new sensors with final chip in Dmill
• Layout of VHDI and HDI
• Continue tooling for the assembly
• Procure prototypes PSS for 1/2-Disk
US CMS DOE/NSF Review: May 8-10, 2001 29
Summary and Conclusions
• FPix effort is now moving from R&D to prototyping.
• Results from a test beam at CERN confirm the expected position resolution.
• Evaluation of first sensor’s submissions completed. Second submission is being prepared.
• A submissions for bump bonding of blank multiple chips is being evaluated and gives promising results.
• Submission TBM/CNH chip to take place this month.
• Testing of prototypes TBM and FEC (FPGA) … has started; will allow a Full System test (sensors, ROC, FED, OL, ...)
Summary and ConclusionsSummary and ConclusionsSummary and ConclusionsSummary and Conclusions