Weather ing Instruct ional Case: A ser ies of s tudent-centeredsc ience lessons
Lesson1
SmokeyMountainsSource:NationalParkService
SuggestedTimeline45minutes
Materials
• Copiesofthe“MountainAge”probefoundinVol1:UncoveringStudentIdeasinScience(Keeley,p.169)
• Copiesore-versionofresearchcollectionsheet.
• Picturesoflocal/familiarmountainranges
• Butcherpaperandstickynotes• Researchmaterials:computersorbooksonmountainranges
Preparation1. Oneprobeperstudent2. Printouttheresearchcollection
sheetORhavestudentsenterinformationontheelectronicversionofthedocument.
3. Writedownsentenceframesandsentencestartersonbutcherpaperandpostinfrontofclassroom.
4. Findpicturesandvideofootageofmountainrangesandplacetheminsheetprotectorsforthestudentstomakeobservations.
IntroductiontoWeathering
SummaryThislessonisanintroductionintoamulti-dayunitaboutweathering.Inthisinstructionalcase,studentswilllearnaboutthenatureofchemicalandmechanicalweatheringandhowtheyaffectthesurfaceofourplanetandtospecificallyanswerthebigquestions:“Whatmakeslargerockschangeintosmallrocks?”Tointroduceconceptsofweatheringhowrocksmaychangeovertime--studentswillsharetheirinitialunderstandingthroughPageKeeley’s“"MountainAge"formativeassessmentprobe.Thestudentworksheetandteacherbackgroundfromtheprobeisincluded(usedwithpermission).ThisprobebeginstheinvestigationoftheweatheringofrocksbyaskingstudentstoconsidertheresultsofweatheringanderosiononEarth’ssurfacefeaturessuchasmountains.
Objectives
• Studentsdemonstratetheirpriorknowledgeonweatheringanderosion.
• Studentswillusereasoningbasedonpriorknowledgeorexperiencewithrockstodeterminetheageofamountain.
TeacherBackgroundKnowledgeAlthoughthisprobedoesnotdirectlydealwiththeweatheringofrocks,itprobesstudents’understandingoftheroleofweatheringanderosiononthedevelopmentofdifferentlandscapes.Activemountainbuildingprocessesareshort-termevents(millionsofyears)ingeologictimecomparedtotheslowerandmoregradualweatheringanderosionofrocksattheEarth’ssurface(hundredsofmillionsofyears).Youngmountainstendtohavemorejaggedorirregularshapesduetotheupliftingprocessesthatformthem.Whenweatheringanderosionoutpacemountainbuildingprocesses,oldermountainsgenerallydevelopamoreroundedshapewithlesstopographicrelief.Althoughtheweatheringanderosionofrocksmayseemlikeordinaryprocess,theireffectovergeologictimeisverysignificantandcanbringdownhighmountains.Thekeytostudents’understandingoftheroleofweatheringanderosioninthedevelopmentoflandscapesistheimmensityofgeologictime..
Page2of3
Lesson1 IntroductiontoWeathering
Standards12
NGSSPerformanceExpectations:ThislessonsupportsstudentsinprogressingtowardtheNGSSPerformanceExpectation.MS-ESS2-1.DevelopamodeltodescribethecyclingofEarth'smaterialsandtheflowofenergythatdrivesthisprocess.[ClarificationStatement:Emphasisisontheprocessesofmelting,crystallization,weathering,deformation,andsedimentation,whichacttogethertoformmineralsandrocksthroughthecyclingofEarth’smaterials.]MS-ESS2-2.ConstructanexplanationbasedonevidenceforhowgeoscienceprocesseshavechangedEarth'ssurfaceatvaryingtimeandspatialscales.[ClarificationStatement:EmphasisisonhowprocesseschangeEarth’ssurfaceattimeandspatialscalesthatcanbelarge(suchasslowplatemotionsortheupliftoflargemountainranges)orsmall(suchasrapidlandslidesormicroscopicgeochemicalreactions),andhowmanygeoscienceprocesses(suchasearthquakes,volcanoes,andmeteorimpacts)usuallybehavegraduallybutarepunctuatedbycatastrophicevents.Examplesofgeoscienceprocessesincludesurfaceweatheringanddepositionbythemovementsofwater,ice,andwind.Emphasisisongeoscienceprocessesthatshapelocalgeographicfeatures,whereappropriate.] AssessmentBoundaries:Assessmentislimitedtotheinteractionsoftwosystemsatatime.Inthislesson…ScienceandEngineeringPractices DisciplinaryCoreIdeas CrossCuttingConcepts
ConstructingExplanationsandDesigningSolutionsStudentswillconstructascientificexplanationbasedonvalidandreliableevidenceobtainedfromoutsideresearchandthePageKeeleyMountainAgeprobereadingwiththeassumptionthattheoriesandlawsthatdescribenatureoperatetodayastheydidinthepastandwillcontinuetodosointhefuture.StudentswillusetheClaim-Evidence-Reasoningprotocoltoconstructtheirexplanationbasedonobservationsandevidencegathered.
ESS2.A:Earth’sMaterialsandSystemsTheplanet’ssystemsinteractoverscalesthatrangefrommicroscopictoglobalinsize,andtheyoperateoverfractionsofasecondtobillionsofyears.TheseinteractionshaveshapedEarth’shistoryandwilldetermineitsfuture.ESS2.C:TheRolesofWaterinEarth'sSurfaceProcessesWater’smovements—bothonthelandandunderground—causeweatheringanderosion,whichchangetheland’ssurfacefeaturesandcreateundergroundformations.
StabilityandChangeExplanationsofstabilityandchangeinnaturalordesignedsystemscanbeconstructedbyexaminingthechangesovertimeandprocessesatdifferentscales,includingtheatomicscale.Studentsinvestigatetheageofmountainsbasedonobservationsandresearchofmountainelevation,sizeandarea.Studentsalsorecognizetheroleofweatheringanderosionwhendiscussingmountaingrowth.
Inthislesson…CCSSMathematics CCSSEnglish-LanguageArtsn/a
ELA-LITERACY.W.6.1Writeargumentstosupportclaimswithclearreasonsandrelevantevidence.CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.6.1Citetextualevidencetosupportanalysisofwhatthetextsaysexplicitlyaswellasinferencesdrawnfromthetext.
1NGSSLeadStates.2013.NextGenerationScienceStandards:ForStates,ByStates.Washington,D.C.:TheNationalAcademiesPress.2NationalGovernorsAssociationCenterforBestPractices,CouncilofChiefStateSchoolOfficersTitle:CommonCoreStateStandards(insertspecificcontentareaifyouareusingonlyone)Publisher:NationalGovernorsAssociationCenterforBestPractices,CouncilofChiefStateSchoolOfficers,WashingtonD.C.CopyrightDate:2010
Page3of3
Lesson1 IntroductiontoWeathering
PriorKnowledgeInpreviousgrades,studentshavelearnedthatwindandwaterchangetheshapeoftheland.Thisprobewilldeterminewhattheirreasoningisbasedontheirpriorknowledgeorexperienceofrocks.Itisassumedthatstudentsalreadyunderstandmajorconceptsofthe“rockcycle,”andiftheydonot,theprobemayhelptheirmisunderstandingssurface.
Lesson1. AdministertheprobeaccordingtoPageKeeley’sSuggestionsforInstructionandAssessment.When
administeringtheprobe,youcanalsowanttoincludeactualphotosofmountainswithdifferentages.2. Thisprobewilldeterminewhattheirreasoningisbasedontheirpriorknowledgeorexperienceofrocks.
OldRagMountain(A)
MountEverest(B)
Source:NationalParkService Source:NationalGeographicPhotographbyJodiCobb
3. CollecttheassessmentstoinformyourteachingoftherestoftheWeatheringunitlessons.Youmayalso
havestudentsposttheiranswersonstickynotesandgenerateasurveyofwheretheclassstands(AversusBorA/Barethesameage).
4. Introducepicturesoflocalorfamiliarmountainranges.Haveaclassdiscussiononnearbymountainrangesandtheirgeneralobservationsofmountains.Thiswouldbeagoodtimetointroducemountainsrangesovertimeandthegeologicaltimescale.
PotentialPitfallsSeePageKeeley’s“TeacherNotes”forpossiblemisconceptions.Notethatthereisnosinglecorrectanswertothisprobebecauseshapeandheightalonecannotbeusedtodeterminetheageofmountains.Studentsmayrevealthattheyconceptualizedifferentshapedandsizedrocksasjustbeingthatway,andhavenotmadeconnectionstothekeyconceptthatrocksarepartoftheEarth’scrust,andhavechangedovertime,chemicallyand/ormechanically.Theprobeassesseswhetherstudentshaveconsideredweatheringfactorsintotheirclaimoriftheyarebasingtheirreasoningonthebeliefthattallermountainsareolder.