+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï...

Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï...

Date post: 05-Aug-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
33
Transcript
Page 1: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

����������� ��������������������������������! #"��%$�&����' (�)�*+����$,���-

.0/21%32465�/�7�18:9<;>=@?BADC>EF=FGIHJC>KIL9<ADM7+3,N�OQPDRSRUTV7+W2W�PBXWYGIC>ADZ[=FK]\^A_?BADC>E`=[GaHbC>KaL

c�d[e�fhgai�jhdlk,m�n>o>fhgap:dlqsrtfhi+n>k�m�o>fhk,fhiFruqwv�i�jhrtn>dlixjbylo>o>p{z|dlgugIfhrIv�gIi�pl}^n>i�r�~ud0pIrIfhm�p��D��gapIr���y��wjho>dlpav�gIfb��fhiF�[n>�gadli`k,fhiFr�n>p�m�gadlm�fhgao>��n>i�pIrIylo>o>fhe�rId�m�gId��[n>e�f{yljhjhfbpIp�qwdlg�qsgIfbf���ylgan>yl�`o>fbp�n>i+rI��f�rtylga�lfhr�m�gadl�lgIylk�qwgayl�lk,fhi[r��pafhjhdli�eV�[rI��f�jhdli[rIgIdlo�n>p�rIgIyli�paqwfhgagafhe+rId�rI��f{rtylga�lfhr��F�xy��w�wv�k,m+~�n>rI��ylga�lv�k�fbi[rtp,z>dlg2gIfhpav�o>rtpl}t� ����o>dlpIv�gafjhdliF�lfhgIpan>dli���~���n>j���e�fhjhn>e�fhp�~���fhgIf,yli�e���d�~�rId�gafhm�gafhpIfbi[r{jho>dlpav�gIfhp{ylr{gav�i[rIn>k�fb��n>pQy�jhgav�jhn>yloYpartfbm�n>irt��f,jhdlk,m�n>o>ylrtn>dli%dlq:qsv�i`jbrtn>dli�yloYo>yli��lv�yl�lfhpl������n>p{m�ylm�fhg{m�gafhpafhi[rIp�y+i�fh~�ylo>�ldlgan>rt��k#rt��ylr{fh�Fm�o>dln>rtp�rI�`fv�pIf�dlq�jhdlk,m`n>o>fb��rIn>k,f�jbdli[rtgadloByli�e%e�ylrIy��`d�~(n>i�qwdlgak,ylrtn>dli�rtd dlm�rtn>k,n>¡hf�qwv�i�jhrIn>dli�jbylo>o>p��,¢B��fh�[rIfhi�pIn>�lfjho>dlpav�gIfBpa��ylgIn>i��Qyli�e�ylo>o>dFjhylrtn>i��{ylp£k�yliF��jho>dlpav�gIfbpYn>i�gIfh�ln>partfbgIp£ylpYm�dlpapIn>��o>fF�Jdlv�g:i`fb~�jho>dlpIv�gafh�¤jhdli[�lfbgIpan>dliylo>�ldlgan>rt��k#gafhe�v`jbfhp{��fhylm�ylo>o>dFjhylrtn>dli%�[� ¥l¦^§�yli�e�k,fhk,dlga��qsfhrtj���fhp�qsdlg�o>dFjhyloYyli�e%�lo>dl�`ylo£�Jylgan>yl��o>fhpQ�[�¨l¥^§,�Byli�e@n>k,m�gadJ�lfhp+rt��f�ylo>gIfbyle`��fb©�jbn>fhi[r�jhdFe�f��lfhi�fhgIylrIfhe-�[��yli�fhylgIo>n>fbg��lfhgIpan>dli�dlq{rI�`f�ªJrtyli�e�ylgaec�«�dlqu¬2fb~�­®fbgIpafh� jhdlk,m�n>o>fhg{�[� yl��dlv�r+¯l°l§�dli±y�²Q³Q��partylrIn>dli�´lµlµlµ^��c�dlgIfhd��lfhgl�<v�i�o>n>¶lf0k,dlparQdlrt��fhgylm�m�gIdlylj���fhpl��dlv�g�i�fh~·jho>dlpav�gIfb��ylo>o>dFjhylrtn>dli¸paja��fhk,f0pIylrIn>pI��fhp2rt��f�partgadli���¹�º�»�¼J½>»a¾®¿]½À¹sÁ�º®Â�¼J½ÀÂ�¾®Ã�ÁÅÄ ¼ÀÆ<ÇwȤÉQgav�o>fF�rt�Fv�p�ylj���n>fh�[n>i����ld[dFe�ylpa�[k,m�rtdlrIn>j�pam�yljhf{v�pIyl�lfF���ylrIfh�ldlgIn>fbp�yli�e)ªJv��Å�sfhjhr{²QfhpajhgIn>m�rIdlgIpl��²x� ¥^� ¥�Ê Ë{Ì�Í^Î�Ì�Ï<Ð%Ð�ÑsÒ�Î�ÓuÏ<Ò�Î�Ô�Ï<Î�ÕFÖt×t��«Dyli��lv�yl�lf���dli�partgav`jbrtpyli�e�Ø<fbylrtv�gIfbpI��ÁD¿À¾bÂ�¼�Ù®Ú`¿À¼J¹�Û�»�ÚFÜ<Â�ȤÇw¾®Ü<¹�Û£º®Ü<Ù�¹�Ú`ÝJ¿t¾®ÚFȤÇsÜ<¼J¹��F²x� ¥^� ¨ Ê Ë{Ì�Í�Î�Ì�Ï<Ð�Ð%Ñ�Ò�Î�ÓuÏ<Ò�Î�Ô�Ï<Î�ÕFÖt×t�ÅÞ£gadl�jhfhpapadlgIpa��Â�¾®Ã�ÁÅÇwÄ ¼J¿]¹�ß:¾�ÁÅȤÇwÃ�Çwà�º®È¤Çs¾®Ü<ßuÂJÄ ¾®¹�ÚF¿t¼�Âa¾[Ü<áJ¼�¿]¹�Çw¾®Üâ fhi�fhgaylo���fhgIk,pl��«�yli��lv`yl�lfbp��`ã�o>�ldlgIn>rI��k�pl�lÞYfhgIqsdlgIk,yli�jhfF�F����fhdlga�ã�e`e�n>rIn>dli`ylo�ä{fh��å±dlgIe�p£yli`e�Þ:�`gaylpafhp��^jho>dlpav�gIfBjhdliF�lfhgapIn>dliV��jho>dlpav�gIfBgafhm�gIfbpIfhiFrtylrIn>dli���jbdlk�m�n>o>fhg£dlm�rtn>k,n>¡hyl�rtn>dliV�Fpam`yljbf{pIylqsfhr��F�Fjhylo>o>fhfh�¤payJ�lf�gIfh�ln>partfbgIpl�®��d�~�yli�ylo>�[pan>p��[��fhylm�����ylpafhe jhdlk,m�n>o>ylrtn>dli

æ Tèçs32é¸O£1%N�?�ê2é ç 1�3ë�ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�ó�ô�ì^ò�õVï�ö^õVñFòJ÷aì^ò�øVñFò{ðsùÅúVö^ûVùÅö^ñFó�ü�ñ�ý öuýsþÅÿ��lõVñFí�ñDþ�����þ��+ùÅó��Åñ[ð�ð��Jù��Åñ+ö^ò�ñ[ù �{ñ��:ì^ò��bó�bì�ìÅî��bï�í�ï��Fñ¸ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú��Fù^ð�ðsó�ùÅúVø@ò�ñ��JûVòJúYó��:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ��bõVñ���ù^ò�ñ¸ô�ûVúVøVùÅí�ñFú��bù^ð��Fì^ú��bò�ì^ðuó��bò�û��[÷�bûYòJñFó�ý��,ñ[ô�ì^ò�ñ�ù�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú��[ù^ð�ð�ì����FûVòJó<þ��Fì^ú��bñ�� �Qï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��JïsìÅú%ï�ó{óJù"!Åñ[ø%ô�òJìÅí òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�óQïsú��bìù$#�ô�òJùÅí�ñDý %'&]ú@ù(�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò)�Vù^ó�ñ[ø�ìÅú ë�ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úV÷+*{ù^ó�ó�ïsúVö ÿ��,��ð�ñ�üJë-*�ÿ.Jþ��JõVï�ó�ô�ò�ù^í�ñ�ïsó�bõYñ/�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ¸ì^ô�ù��[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú)ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú10 ÿ2�bñ[ñFðsñ43658769�:]ý&]ú@ù�ë-*�ÿV÷+�Vù^ó�ñ[ø;�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò�þÅù<�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñxñ[ú�!�ïsò�ì^úYí�ñFú���ï�ó��Fì^úVó��bò�û����bñ[ø�ù��0ñ[ù��lõ�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úV÷

øVñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú�ó�ï>�bñ ?`ï>��îVòJì"!�ï�øVñ[ó2òJûYú �Jïsí�ñ0ù����Fñ[ó�ó��Jì@�Vï�úVøVï�úVö^ó�ì^ô�ô�ò�ñ[ñ)!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�ï�úA�JõVñ�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�:ìDø2�DýCB0ù��lõ-ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú��Fù^ð�ð�ï�ó@�bõYñ[ú·ï�í�îVðsñFí�ñ[ú��bñFø·ù^óD=VòJó��xï�úVó��bù^ð�ð�ïsúVö4�bõVñ(�[ì^ò�ò�ñ[ó�î£ìÅúVøVï�úVö�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ@ñFú !�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú��`þ�ó�ñ����bï�úVö_ûYîE�JõVñ�ùÅòJöÅûVí�ñ[ú��bó-ü�úVìÅòJí�ùÅðsð>��ïsú òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�Jþ�ù^úVø1�JõVñ[úîVùÅóJó�ïsúYö��bõVñF�[ìÅú��bò�ì^ðG�Jì'�JõVñ4�Jù^ò�ö^ñ��A� ��ùH#JIbûVí�î�%�ïsúVó��bò�û����bï�ì^ú2ý'KYûVú2���bï�ì^ú6òJñ��bûVò�úVó�ù^ò�ñ

ã�v`rI��dlgIpMLFyle`e�gafhpapIfhpl��N[��dli���ªJ��yld^�`²Qfhm�ylgIrIk,fhi[r2dlq2��dlk,m�v`rIfhg�ªJjhn>fbi`jbfF�POYylo>fRQ�i�n>�lfhgIpan>r��F�F´^¯2Þ£gadlpam�fhjhrªJrtgafhfhr��`¬2fh~'S2y��lfhiV�����·µl¦l´MTlµl�VUMTMUl´^��³:k,yln>ot��pa�`yldl�¤¡h��dli���W:jhpl� �lylo>fF� fhe�vV��ã�i`e�gafh~·å��[ã�m�m�fhot�`²Qfhm�ylgart�k,fhi[r+dlq���dlk�m�v�rtfbg%ªJjhn>fhi�jhfF��Þ£gan>i�jhfhrtdli�Q2i�n>�lfhgapan>r��F�:¥l´YX:o>e�fhi�ªJrtgafhfhr��BÞ£gan>i�jhfhrtdliV�:¬�­�µMUl´l¨l¨l�>TlµMU^°l�³:k�yln>ot�£ylm�m�fhoZW:jbp�� m�gan>i`jbfhrtdliV� fhe�vV�2Þ£gafho>n>k,n>i�ylgI�xm�gafhpafhi[rIylrtn>dli�p{dlq£rI��n>p2~udlga¶�ylm�m�fhylgafhe±n>i Þ:gIdFjhfhfhe�n>i��lpdlqurt��f±¯+[M[l¨ ã0��c ��dli�qsfhgIfbi`jbf�dli±«�n>pIm±yli�e%Ø<v`i�jhrIn>dli�ylo£Þ:gIdl�lgaylk,k,n>i`��Ê>ªJ�`yld¸yli�e�ã�m�m�fho�¯+[M[l¨l×:yli�en>i±rI�`f,��gapIrI��i�ylk,fhe±ylv�rI�`dlgML p{Þ:��� ²x��e�n>papIfbgIrIylrtn>dli)Ê>ªJ��yld�¯+[M[l¨l×t������n>p{gIfbpIfhylgaj��±~uylp{pIv�m�m�dlgartfhe%�[��rI�`f¬�ylrtn>dli�ylo�ªbjbn>fhi�jhf�Ø<dlv�i�e`ylrIn>dli â gIyliFrtp�����\��V[lµlµMT^°+Ul¦^������\2�V[MTlµlµ^°+[lµ^�`yli`e�����\2�V[l´lµ^¯a¦MTl¨^�

Page 2: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

] ^2_a` b"c�d�c�e"f�gh_8ghi"i�jlk

ï�í�îYðsñFí�ñFú��bñ[øUï�úm�bõVñ�ó�ù^í�ñYn�ù"�1�£ñ��[ùÅûVóJñY�JõVñ�� ù^ò�ñ)ñFóJó�ñ[ú��JïsùÅðsð>�1�[ùÅðsð�ó;�bì$�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó,ï�ô�ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jñ[ø�ï�ú ë-*�ÿ�ý�o úVìÅúV÷�ë-*0ÿV÷+�Vù^ó�ñ[ø;�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò0øVì�ñFó�úYì���ïsú��bò�ì�øVû��Fñ+ñ���÷îVð�ï��Fï��G�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úVó<þ"�Vû2��ï���òJñ�pDûYïsò�ñ[ó�ù�ó�ï�í�ï�ð�ù^ò�í�ñ��lõYù^úVï�óJíq�bì±í�ùÅúVù^öÅñ�ù^ð�ð��bõVñ@�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó�ýr õVñ+öÅì^ù^ð£ì^ôh�FðsìÅóJûYòJñs�Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ï�ì^ú�ïsó��bì(�lõVì�ì^ó�ñs�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñxò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^úVó)�bõVù ��í�ï�úVïsí�ï>�[ñ

ó��bì^ò�ñ[ó ü�ô�ìÅò)�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñs�FòJñFù��bï�ì^ú-bþ^ô�ñ��t�lõYñ[ó±üu�Jì�ù����[ñFóJó0ô�òJñFñ@!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó"bþ^ù^úVø�í�ñFí�ìÅò���ûVó�ñ�üÀô�ì^òò�ñ[ù��lõYù��Vð�ñxøVù �bù8Jý.v�ñFî£ñFúVøVï�úVö%ìÅúw�bõYñ�ò�ûVú��bï�í�ñ@�:ñ[õVù"!�ï�ì^ò�ì^ôBñ[ù �lõ�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú2þ �FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó)�[ùÅú�:ñ�ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jñ[ø ùÅó%øVù �bù ó��JòJû2���bûYòJñFó%ìÅôx!Dï�ò��bûVùÅðsð>�(ù^ú���óJõYù^î:ñ�y�ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bñFø ïsúE�bõVñ)õVñFù^î2þì^úz�JõVñ�ó��bù��M��ü�ï�ô�ùÅú���Jþ�ìÅò�ïsú(ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ý�ë�ð�ñ[ù^ò�ð>�Dþ��JõVñ�øVñ��[ï�óJï�ì^úVó�ì^ô�n�õVñ[ò�ñ�ù^úVø�õVì"n{�bìò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��C�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó�ù��+òJûVú��Jïsí�ñ/�[ùÅú-ö^ò�ñ[ù��Jð��@ù��:ñ����@�bõVñ|p�ûVùÅðsï>�,�@ìÅô2öÅñ[úVñFòJù �bñFø��FìDøYñDýRK£ì^òñ���ùÅí�îYðsñ�þ�}�ò�ù^ú2� ~ óF��ò��Vï��F0 }�ò�ù^ú��@ñ���ùÅð�ý)3M5 9��8?-}�ò�ù^ú2��3M5 987M:G�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�öÅñ[úVñFòJù �bñFó|!^ñFò��ô�ù^ó��@�Fì�øVñA���-õVù"!�ïsúYö�óJï>�-øVï>�£ñFòJñFú �D�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ±ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^ú�ó��bò�ù��Jñ[öÅïsñFó+ô�ì^ò¸øVï>�£ñFòJñFú��@��ïsúYøVó�ìÅôô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó"?-�bõYñw��& r ó��lõYñ[í�ñ;�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò40 �xì��Fù^ó�365�9 �8?��+ù^úYóJìÅúm365�5 ��:Qïsí�îVð�ñ[í�ñFú �JóA�Jù^ï�ðs÷ò�ñ��[ûYòJó�ï�!Åñ,îVòJì��Fñ[øVûVò�ñx�[ùÅðsð�ó�ùÅó�ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��Jð���ù^ó�í�ìÅó���ñ���îVðsï>�[ï>��ï>�bñFòJù �bï�ì^ú��[ìÅúVó��JòJû2���bóG� �%ûVó�ïsúVöó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ð��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ�òJñFîVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^úVó ù^úYø��Fù^ð�ðsï�úVöY�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ú��JïsìÅúVó�?h�bõVñ@ÿ��bùÅúVøVù^ò�ø����#ì^ô��+ñ�n� ñ[ò�óJñ��E�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò ü�ÿ2����� � � 40 o+îVî:ñ[ð ù^úYø��·ù�����ûVñ[ñFú�3M5 583�?so+îVî:ñ[ð ùÅúVø ÿVõVùÅì�3M5 5�� :ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bó��bõVñ�òJñ��bûVò�úV÷+�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úm�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ·ûVó�ï�úVö6ù ó�ñ��)ì^ô/�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ów�bìù��lõYïsñ�!^ñ4�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�ó�õVùÅòJï�úVö_ùÅúVø ô�ùÅó���ù����[ñ[ó�ó<�bì ô�òJñFñ4!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ4�Vï�úVøVï�úVö^ó<ý�&]ú6ìÅûVò<�[ûVò�òJñFú��n�ì^ò��Bþ"n0ñ�õVù"!Åñ,ïsú��bñFö^ò�ù��Jñ[ø�ù^ð�ðVì^ô8�bõVñFóJñ@�bñ��lõYúVï�p�ûVñFó�ï�ú �Jì�ù�ûVúVï>=Vñ[ø�ô�ò�ù^í�ñ�n0ìÅò��/�Jì�ù��lõVï�ñ�!Åññ����Fñ[ð�ðsñFú �C�FìDøYñ/pDûYù^ð�ï��,��ý� ñ�õVù"!Åñ�øVñ�!Åñ[ð�ì^î:ñ[ø ù�úVñ�n ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí ô�ìÅò|�lõVì�ì^ó�ï�úVö�öÅì�ìDø��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVó<ý

o+ó�ô�ùÅò�ù^ó�n�ñ<��úVì"n�þBì^ûVò úVñ�n��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ%ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bï�ì^ú_ó��lõVñFí�ñ�ï�ó/�bõVñ�=Vò�ó����Jì-óJù �bï�óJôu�·ùÅðsð{ìÅô�bõYñ�ô�ì^ð�ðsì"n�ï�úVö�ïsí�î:ì^ò��bùÅú �,îVò�ì^î:ñ[ò��bï�ñ[ó"�y��+úVð�ï��Åñ_ó��bù �M� ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú ù^úVø��bò�ù^øVï>�bï�ì^úVùÅð+ð�ïsú2�^ñ[ø��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó�þ�ìÅûVò)óJõVùÅòJñFøm�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ

ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^úVó�ù^ò�ñ-óJùÅô�ñ�ô�ìÅò�óJîYù��[ñY�Fì^í�îVð�ñ���ï��,� üÀóJñFñ�ÿVñ����bï�ì^ú��8�?�ù����bõVñ�ó�ù^í�ñF�bï�í�ñDþ�bõYñ��@ó��bï�ð�ð�ù^ð�ðsì"n ñ����bñFúVóJï>!^ñ��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ óJõYù^ò�ïsúVöuýy ��ûVò@�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ�ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú�ó��lõVñFí�ñ±ñ���îVð�ì^ï>�bó¸ñ����bñFúVó�ï�!Åñ±ûVó�ñ�ì^ô��Fì^í�îVï�ðsñF÷��Jïsí�ñA�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð

ù^úYø�øVù �bù;�Vì"n ïsúYô�ì^ò�í�ù �bï�ì^ú��bì�øVñ��bñ[ò�í�ïsúYñ/�bõVñ/�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ¸òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVó<ýy ÿVì^ûVò��[ñF÷Ið�ù^úYö^ûVùÅö^ñ·ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó��bõVù �-í�ù �^ñ�ó�ñ�!^ñFòJùÅð�ó�ñ�p�ûVñFú��bï�ù^ð�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú��[ùÅðsð�óY�[ùÅú

�VûVï�ð�ø�ìÅúVñ,óJõYù^ò�ñ[ø<�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�ô�ì^ò{ûYóJñx���±ùÅðsð��JõVñx�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úVó<þP�bù ��ïsúVö ùÅø�!�ù^ú��bùÅö^ñ�ì^ô8�[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷ó�ù"!^ñ¸òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�ýy���ñ��[ùÅûVóJñ�ù����bï>!`ù �bï�ì^ú�òJñ��[ì^ò�øVó0ù^ò�ñ+ù^ð�ó�ì%ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��Jñ[ø�ï�úF�bõVñ¸õVñ[ùÅî2þ �bõYñ��;�[ùÅú4�:ñ óJõVùÅòJñFø

n�ï>�bõ(ì��JõVñ[ò�õVñ[ùÅîV÷IùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ[ø��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó<ý r õVï�ó±ï�ó±ïsí�î:ì^ó�óJï>�Vð�ñ�ûVúVøYñ[ò±ó��bù �M�·ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^úz�:ñ[÷�[ùÅûVó�ñ¸ó��bù �M��ô�òJùÅí�ñ[ó�ì^ôu�Jñ[ú-õVù"!Åñ¸ó�õVìÅò��Jñ[ò,ðsï�ô�ñ��Jïsí�ñ/�JõVù^ú-õVñFù^îV÷aù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø4�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó<ýy r ùÅïsðDòJñ��[ûVò�ó�ï�!Åñ��[ùÅðsð�ó�y�n�õVï>�lõ±ù^ò�ñ�ìÅôu�bñ[ú(p�ûVï��Jñ)�JòJìÅû��Vð�ñ[ó�ì^í�ñG�Jì+ï�í�îVðsñFí�ñ[ú��.�Fì^ò�òJñ����Jð��

ì^ú)ù�ó��Jù��M��0 �+ùÅúVó�ì^ú$3M5�5 ��:>yE�Fù^úw�:ñ�ï�í�îYðsñFí�ñFú��bñ[ø�!Åñ[ò���ñ[ùÅóJï�ð���ýy�o+ð�ðYì^ôuìÅûVò��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsó{ùÅúVø�ì^î2�bï�í�ï>�[ù �bï�ì^úVóG�[ù^ú;�:ñs�FðsñFù^úVð>�%ò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú �Jñ[ø�ûVó�ïsúVö

�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úY÷IîVùÅóJó�ï�úVö@ùÅúVø'�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷aîVùÅóJó�ïsúYö@ó��,�Dð�ñ�0 o�îVî£ñFð�ù^úYø � ïsí�3M5�9 5�:�ù^ó��bõYñ�ïsú��bñFòJ÷í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ�ðsùÅúVö^ûYù^ö^ñ�ýy ��ú��[ñ�ùY�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�ï�ó/�[ò�ñ[ù �bñ[ø�þuúVì-ðsù �bñFò�n�ò�ï>�bñ[ó�ùÅòJñ�í�ù^øYñ<�Jì-ï���?h�JõVïsó�í�ù �^ñFó¸öÅñ[úVñFòJ÷

ù��JïsìÅúVù^ð2ö^ùÅò��VùÅö^ñ/�Fì^ð�ðsñ����bï�ì^ú�ùÅúVøE�l�� u  ¡��l��ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��`þ£ùÅúVø�ù^ð�óJì@òJñFøVû��[ñFó@�JõVñ%úYñ[ñ[ø_ô�ì^ò+ùÅðsï�ù^óù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�ó�ï�úY�bõVñ/�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò�ýy���ñ��[ùÅûVóJñ�ù^ð�ð��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó0ùÅòJñ�ñ[ï>�bõVñFò�ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø�ï�ú��JõVñ õVñ[ùÅî@ì^ò�ï�ú�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<þ¢=YòJó��)�FðsùÅóJó

�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úYó�üÀï�ý ñDý�þ.�l�  u  ¡8�l��Qù^ò�ñ�!^ñ[ò���ñ[ùÅó��4�bì�óJûYîVî£ìÅò���ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��bð>�Dý��ûVò+úVñ�n£�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bï�ì^ú)ó��lõYñ[í�ñ±øVì�ñ[ó�úVì��+ûVóJñ%ù^ú��)òJûVú��Jïsí�ñ±ó��bù �M�Bý�&]úYó��Jñ[ù^ø�þVùÅðsð

�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ñFú�!Dï�ò�ì^úVí�ñ[ú��Jó�ù^ò�ñ�ñFï��JõVñ[òxùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ[ø)ï�úF�JõVñ�õVñFù^î)ì^ò�ï�ú)ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ý r õVïsó�øYñ��[ï�ó�ïsìÅú

Page 3: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥D¦l§ jle"¨�c�e"f/` c�©>j�ª�©�d�« ª�` i"c ¦ jx¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�d�e�°�jl«¯­ § d�e ±

í�ù"��ó�ñ[ñFí²�Fì^ú��bò�ì"!^ñFòJó�ï�ù^ð]þ��:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ±ó��bù �M��ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú-ïsóDn�ïsøVñFð��Y�:ñ[ð�ïsñ�!^ñFø��bì�õVù"!Åñ/�£ñ��t�Jñ[òð�ì �Fù^ð�ï��,��ìÅô�ò�ñ[ô�ñ[ò�ñ[ú2�[ñDþÅùÅúVø@øVñFù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^ú�ì^ô�ó��bù �M��ô�òJùÅí�ñ[ó��[ù^ú��£ñ��lõVñFù^î:ñ[òC�bõYù^ú@öÅù^ò��Vù^öÅñ�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bï�ì^ú2ýs�·ì^ò�ñ[ì"!Åñ[ò<þ��:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ�õVñFù^î·ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��Jñ[ø��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó�ù^ò�ñ±úVì �D�Fì^ú��bï�ö^ûVìÅûVóxï�ú_í�ñ[í�÷ì^ò��DþVù^ú·ñ����bò�ù�í�ñFí�ì^ò���n�ò�ï��Jñ�ùÅúVø�òJñFù^ø6üÀì^ôR�bõYñ�ô�ò�ù^í�ñ±î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[ò"{ùÅòJñ�úVñ��[ñFóJó�ù^ò��@ù �+ñ[ù �lõô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú$�Fù^ð�ð�ý r õYñ[ó�ñ�ù^ó�óJûVí�î��JïsìÅúVó<þ�n�õVï�ðsñ;�JòJûYñDþ�ù^ò�ñ�úYì��±ùÅó�óJï�ö^úVï>=��Fù^ú���ù^ó�ìÅúVñ�í�ïsöÅõ ��bõYïsú���þ�ùÅúVø-ù^ò�ñ�ì �£ó�ñ��x���w�JõVñ�øVï�óJùÅø�!�ù^ú��bùÅö^ñFó�ìÅô�ó��bù �M��ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^ú-�y�o+ó<n0ñ�n�ïsð�ð0ó�õVì"n ï�ú ÿVñ����bï�ì^ú³�:þ-�:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ@í�ì^ó��±îVùÅò��Jó%ìÅôx�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú$�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó%ù^ò�ñù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bñFø@ï�ú��Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�0 o+îVî:ñ[ð�ù^úVø�ÿVõVù^ì�3M5 5�� :�þ��bõVñ ñ�� �JòJù%í�ñ[í�ì^ò��;n�òJï>�bñù^úVø�òJñFù^ø�ù��Qñ[ù �lõ(�Fù^ð�ð��[ùÅú�ìÅôu�bñFú(�:ñ�ù"!^ìÅïsøVñFø2ý � ï>�bõ��JõVñ�õVñ[ð�î�ì^ô8�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[÷+�bï�í�ñ��Fì^ú��bò�ì^ðù^úVø øVù��Jù��Vì"n ï�úVô�ìÅòJí�ù��JïsìÅú2þ��JõVñ��Fì^í(�VïsúYù��bï�ì^ú ì^ôxó�õVùÅòJñFø1�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó�ùÅúVø³�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!ÅñòJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó)�Fù^ú)ì^ôu�bñFú��:ñ/�[ìÅí�îVù^ò�ù��Vð�ñ@�Jì�ì^ò,ñ�!Åñ[ú4�:ñ����bñFòs�bõVùÅú�ó��bù �M��ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^úz0 o�îVî:ñ[ðù^úVø)ÿVõVùÅì�365�5 ��:]ý

y�&]ú·ùw�[ìÅí�îVù^úVï�ì^ú�îYù^î:ñ[ò<0 o+îYî£ñFð2ùÅúVø·ÿVõVùÅì�3M5 5�� :�þ�n�ñ±ó�õVì"n��bõVù �+ó��bù �M�Dó+øVì�úVì �+õVù"!Åñù�ó�ïsöÅúVï�=2�[ù^ú��Jð��<�£ñ��t�Jñ[ò,ðsì��Fù^ð�ï��,��ì^ôBò�ñ[ô�ñFòJñFú��[ñ@�bõVùÅú@õVñFù^îV÷aù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø�ù����bï>!`ù �bï�ì^ú�ò�ñ��Fì^ò�øVó<þñ�!^ñFú�ï�ú-ù�í�ì�øVñFòJúY�Fù��lõVñ¸í�ñ[í�ì^ò���õVï�ñ[ò�ù^ò��lõ��Dý�ÿ��bù �M�Dó�øYì�õYù"!^ñ ù�í�û��lõF�£ñ��t�Jñ[òsn�ò�ï��Jñ[÷í�ï�ó�ó�ò�ù��bï�ì:þ��Vû��2úVì���ùxí�û��lõ/�:ñ����bñFò2ò�ñ[ùÅøV÷Ií�ï�óJóBò�ù��Jïsìuý��,û���ìÅú�í�ù^ú���í�ì�øVñFòJú í�ù��lõVï�úVñFó�þ�bõVñ/n�ò�ï��Jñ[÷aí�ïsó�ó�î£ñFúVù^ð>�,��ï�óxù^îYîVòJì"��ï�í�ù��bñFð��;�Fñ[ò�ìY0 � ì^ûVîVîYïG3M5�5 ´8? v¸ï�n�ù^ú-ñ���ùÅð�ý�365�5 ��:]ý

y r õVñ%ùÅí�ì^ò��bï>�[ñ[ø��[ìÅó��¸ì^ô��Fì^ð�ðsñ����JïsìÅú��[ùÅú'�:ñ<!Åñ[ò��-ðsì"n²0 o+îYî£ñFð@3M5�9�7�?ao+îYî£ñFð{ù^úVø ÿVõVùÅì3M5�5 ��:]þÅñ[ó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ð�ð��;n�ï>�bõ-í�ì�øVñ[ò�ú�öÅñ[úVñFòJù �bï�ì^úVùÅðuö^ù^ò��VùÅö^ñ@�Fì^ð�ðsñ����JïsìÅú��Jñ��lõVúVï>p�ûVñ[óA0 �+úYö^ù^ò3M5�9 �8? �xñFîVî���3M5 5�´�:]ýr õVñ�í�ù^ï�ú<�Fì^ú��bò�ï>�Vû��bï�ì^ú�ì^ô8�bõYïsó�îYù^î:ñ[ò{ï�ó�ù^ú'µu¶��P·uµ�¸a¹Dù^úYø�ºl�»Pµ�¼ »P½ ¾M¼,ºZ¿����lµ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ��Fì^úV÷

!^ñFòJó�ï�ì^ú�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVíH�JõVù��{ï�ú��bñ[öÅòJù �bñFó�ùÅúVø�ïsí�îVò�ì"!^ñFó�í�ìÅó��{îVò�ñ�!�ï�ì^ûVó��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷aù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�ó.�Jñ��lõV÷úVï>p�ûVñ[ó�0 }�ò�ù^ú��w365�987 ?�o+îYî£ñFð�ù^úYø�ÿVõVù^ì'365�5 �8?Dÿ��Jñ[ñ[ð�ñ�36587M9�?��xì �[ù^óA365�9 �8?���ù^úVó�ì^ú13M5 5���?� ì^õVúVó�ó�ì^ú�3M5 9�À�:{ûYóJï�úVö·ù�ó�ïsí�îVð�ñ�ùÅúVø(ö^ñFúVñ[ò�ù^ð�ô�ò�ù^í�ñ�n0ìÅò��·ñ���îVòJñFóJó�ñ[ø�ï�ú$�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úV÷îVùÅóJó�ïsúYö ù^úVø��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñF÷IîYù^ó�óJï�úVö�ó��,��ð�ñ�0 o+îVî:ñ[ð ùÅúVø � ïsíÁ3M5 9�5�?xo+îYî£ñFð¸ùÅúVø#ÿVõYù^ì�365�5 ��:]ý��ûVò¸úVñ�n ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí ñ����bñFúVó�ï�!Åñ[ð>�)ñ���îVðsìÅï��JóD�JõVñ�ûVóJñ%ì^ô��Fì^í�îVï�ðsñF÷��Jïsí�ñ(�[ì^ú��JòJìÅð�ù^úYø_øVù �bù^÷�Vì"n ï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��JïsìÅú4�bì�ì^î2�bï�í�ï>�[ñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ+ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú�ó��bò�ù��bñFö^ï�ñ[ó0ù^úVø�òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVó<ý)��ûVòí�ñ[ùÅóJûVò�ñ[í�ñFú �Jó±ó�õVì"nq�JõVù��A�bõVñ�úYñ�n ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí òJñFøVû��Fñ[ó±õVñFù^î(ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú�����´��� ù^úYøí�ñ[í�ì^ò��¸ô�ñ��t�lõYñ[ó�ô�ì^ò�ð�ì��[ùÅð��Åö^ð�ì��VùÅð¢!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�������´8Â�?`ùÅúVø±ï�í�îYòJì"!Åñ[óh�JõVñ0ùÅðsò�ñ[ùÅø���÷Iñ����[ï�ñ[ú���[ì�øVñ%ö^ñFúVñ[ò�ù��Jñ[ø����-ù^ú·ñFù^ò�ðsï�ñ[òD!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú�ì^ôR�JõVñ%ÿ2����� � � �[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�� �-ù �£ìÅû��<3 7� ì^ú·ùv�B¸ë�ó��bù��JïsìÅú�À ��� �:ýà TèP�Ä2ÄYç ê�çsPB32ê�867+3,N 5�W�72ê�P@5V7@ÄYPDé08&,�,ïsó+øVï����FûVð��C�Jì�øYñ[ó�ïsöÅú�öÅìDì�øF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bï�ì^ú�ó��lõVñ[í�ñFóx�bõVù ��ùÅòJñ��:ì��bõY�Jïsí�ñ[÷añ����FïsñFú �ù^úYø óJîYù��[ñF÷Iñ����[ï�ñ[ú��`ý�&]ú ô�ù����`þQìÅî��bï�í�ï��Fù��bï�ì^ú6ì^ôx�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^úVó�ïsó�óJìÅí�ñ��bï�í�ñ[óøVùÅúVö^ñFòJìÅûVó�ù^úYø±ñ�!Åñ[ú±ûVúYóJùÅô�ñ�ô�ì^òsº�¿�� �lµsÅ�ºl�MÆ�µ0üÀï�ý ñDý�þP�bõYñ0í�ù���ï�í�ûVí ó�ï��Fñ�ìÅô�óJï�í�ûVð>�bùÅúVñ[ìÅûVó�ð��ð�ï�!Åñ�øYù��bù)øVûVò�ï�úVö-ñ���ñ��Fû��bï�ì^ú.Jý/&]ú�3M5 9�9uþ�ë�õYù^ó�ñY0>3M5 9�9�:�ì��YóJñFò�!Åñ[ø'�JõVù����Fñ[ò��bù^ï�ú_ó��bìÅòJùÅö^ñF÷ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú_ì^î2�bï�í�ï>�[ù �bï�ì^úVó�í�ù"���Fì^ú�!^ñFò��¸ù-îVò�ì^ö^ò�ù^íÇ�JõVù���ò�ûVúVó�ò�ì��VûYó��Jð���ï�ú��bì�ì^úYñ<�JõVù��øVì�ñ[ó+úVì���þ�øVûVñ/�Jì;�bõVñ�ò�ñ�p�ûVï�òJñFí�ñ[ú��,ì^ô�ù�ð�ù^ò�ö^ñFò,ô�òJù ���bï�ì^ú-ìÅô�í�ñ[í�ì^ò��4�JõVù^úY�JõVñ�îVò�ì^ö^ò�ù^íù����bûVùÅðsð>�)úVñ[ñFøVó�ý)o�îVî£ñFðC0>3M5 5�� :�ù^ð�óJì�úYì��bï>�[ñFø��bõVù �xîVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí�ó�ûYóJï�úVö�ð�ïsú2�^ñ[ø��FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó�È®þYì^òó��bù��M��÷aù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø�ù����bï>!`ù �bï�ì^ú±ò�ñ��Fì^ò�øVó<þ[í�ù"���[ùÅûVó�ñ�ù��[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ø�îYòJìÅö^ò�ù^í��Jì�ûYóJñ�í�û��lõ%í�ì^ò�ñí�ñ[í�ì^ò��DýÉ ã Ä ÇsÜ"ÊJ¼�Ù�ÂJÄ ¾®¹�Ú`¿À¼ Ê «Dyli�e�n>i_¯+[l¦l¨l×�n>p�y±gafhjhdlgae�rt��ylr,jhdli[rIyln>i`p,rI�`f¸��dlv�i�e���ylgIn>yl��o>fhp�dlq�rI�`f¸fhi�jho>dlpan>i��qwv�i�jhrIn>dli��FrIdl�lfhrt��fhg�~�n>rt�¸y,m�dln>i[rIfhg�rId,rt��f�fhi�jho>dlpan>i���qsv�i`jbrtn>dli�L p�jho>dlpav�gIf`�

Page 4: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

Ë ^2_a` b"c�d�c�e"f�gh_8ghi"i�jlk

ÌhÍ Ï�Î/Ï Í Í^ÖbÔ�Ì�Õ[Ö ÓuÑsÒ�Ð^Õ�Ñ4Ï Í Í�ÖbÔ�Ì�ÕFÖ Ò�Ï"Ó�Õ Í Ô Ó:Ñ�Ò�Ð�Õ�Ñ4Ï Í Í^ÖbÔ�Ì�Õ[Ö

ÕÕÕ

Ö×

Ø£ÙqÚÛÜ Ö²Ø£ÙqÚÝ£Þ

ß

à£á ֲأÙqÚ

ÕÕ âââ ã

ääå

ÚÕÛ

ÜÝ£Þ

ß

à× á ֲأÙÖæØ£Ù{Ú

ÕÕÛÕ

Õç ç ç-è

é é é é-êÜÝHÞà�á

ß

×

ØVn>�^�D¯l�Uã·jhdlk,m�ylgIn>padli¸dlq�rt��gIfbf�jho>dlpav`gafQgIfbm`gafhpafhi[rIylrtn>dli�p

ë6ì�í³ë�î+ï�ðZñ�ð�òhðZóhð+ô õ'ö÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�í1ú�î�õYö

÷�ø�ùzï�ûP÷�ì1ö'ü¢ý�î+ï�õë�ìPízü�î�õ�ö÷�ø�ù$ë�ìPíÿþ2î�õ�ö�ñ��Pò���ó���ô����þlí�îtþ2ð¯ì�õøMí�ý

þlízüøMí�ý

þlí$úøMí�ý

ë6ì�í���þ6ú'í1ö³þ�ë�í��Fù�ü øMízí�þ�÷zø�÷��Pø�í ������þMú�îZí���õë6ì�í�÷�������îZí.ð��¢ø��¢õ�öþ�ë'í���Fù�ü øMí���ø��ø�÷��Pø$÷Pø�ùzï�û�÷��'ö�ë8î���þ6ú�î���õ�ð���ð���ð���ð���õ�î�õ

þlí�÷�������îZí���ð��������¢ø��¢õølí�ý

ï¢û�÷ ��ø���ì ÷�ù1ö$÷!���"��î���ð¯í�þP÷�õ

ØVn>�^��T^�Uã�i+fh�Fylk�m�o>f�n>i�ªJrtyli�e�ylgIe c�«

ë�ì^úVó�ïsøYñ[òs�JõVñ±îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí ïsú�KQï�ö^ûVò�ñ/�;n�òJï>�t�Jñ[ú�ï�ú�ÿ��bùÅúVøVùÅòJøY��� üÀÿ�����D0 �_ïsð�úVñ[ò+ñ��xùÅð�ý3M5 5�� :�ý � ï>�bõÿ�Vù��;�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó$# ü�ó�ñ[ñ�KQï�ö^ûVò�ñ13�Jþ�ñFù��lõ�ñ�!�ù^ð�ûVù��JïsìÅú ìÅô&%('*)*)*),+-'.+4��ïsñFðsøVó�ù�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ@� ô�ì^ò�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú0/��JõVù����[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVóhIbûVó��,ù%ô�ñ�n#ï�ú��bñ[öÅñ[ò�ó21Bþ�3Bþ�4Bþ�5BþÅù^úVø76�? �JõVñD=YúVù^ðò�ñ[ó�ûVð��,ü�ï]ý ñ�ýsþ�8*9-:.1*;�<� �Fì^ú��bùÅïsúVó(=H�[ìÅîVï�ñ[ó�ì^ô��bõYñG�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ô�ì^ò>/Bþ��bõ�ûVóQï��2ûVó�ñ[ó�ù���í�ìÅó��(?�ü@=�ó�îVù��FñDý � ï>�bõ�ð�ï�ú��^ñFø(�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[óxüÀù^ð�óJì¸óJñFñCK�ï�ö^ûYòJñ|3�Jþ�ñ[ù �lõA�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ�ô�ì^òA//�Fì^ú��bùÅïsúVóQù î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[ò�bì��bõVñ(�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ±ô�ì^ò&Buþan�õVï>�lõ��Fì^ú��bùÅïsúVó�ù�ð�ïsó��DC)ì^ô{ó�ï>�[ñE= ý�ÿVï�ú��[ñ(�bõVñ(=VúVùÅð2ò�ñ[ó�ûVð>�@�^ñFñ[îVó=æ�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó0ô�ì^òF/�ó�ï�í�ûVð>�bùÅúVñ[ìÅûVóJð>�Dþ^ï>�0ûVó�ñ[ó&?�ü@= # �óJîVù �[ñ�ïsúVó��bñFù^ø�ìÅôG?�ü@=�Jý-o+îVîYù^ò�ñ[ú��bð>�Dþ�bõYïsó�ó�îVù��Fñ�ð�ñ[ù ��ï�óx�[ù^ûYóJñFø4����ïsúYù^îVîVò�ì^îYòJï�ù��Jñ[ð>��òJñ��bù^ï�úVï�úVö�óJìÅí�ñ'#aøYñ[ù^ø2%%ì ��Ibñ����bó±ü�ï]ý ñ�ýsþHC��bõYù���ó�õVì^ûVð�øF�£ñ�ò�ñ��FðsùÅïsí�ñ[ø)ñ[ùÅòJð�ï�ñ[òC���4�bõYñ�ö^ù^ò��VùÅö^ñ@�Fì^ð�ðsñ����Jì^ò<ý&]úm365�5 �:þ8n�ñ�ô�ì^ûVúVø�ó�ñ�!Åñ[ò�ù^ðQïsúYó��Jù^ú��Fñ[ó±ìÅô0ò�ñ[ùÅð�îYòJìÅö^ò�ù^í�ó�n�õVì^ó�ñ�ðsï>!^ñ�øVù �bù-ó�ï��Fñ_ü�ù^úYø

I ãEJuº®È�Â�Ä ¾®¹�Ú`¿À¼QÊ>��ylgae`fbo>o>n�¯+[MUl¨l×<n>pVy{gafhjhdlgae�rt��ylr£��dlo>e�pYdli�o>�0rt��f�qwgafhfB��ylgIn>yl��o>fhp£i�fhfhe�fhe��[�0rt��f�qsv`i�jhrIn>dliV�

Page 5: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥D¦l§ jle"¨�c�e"f/` c�©>j�ª�©�d�« ª�` i"c ¦ jx¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�d�e�°�jl«¯­ § d�e K

�bõYñ[ò�ñ[ô�ì^ò�ñ+í�ñFí�ìÅò���ûYóJñ�hn�ù^ó�ûVúVúVñ��[ñFóJó�ù^ò�ïsð>��ðsùÅòJöÅñ�ü¯n�ï��Jõ�ô�ù ���bìÅòJó�ì^ô��(�Jì(9 �8�n�õVñ[úF�[ìÅí�÷îVï�ðsñFøY� �@ñ[ù^ò�ð>�;!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅúVó,ì^ô�ìÅûVòx�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[òC�JõVù���ï�ú��bò�ìDøYû��[ñFø��JõVïsó@�Dï�úVø)ì^ô�óJîYù��[ñ¸ð�ñ[ù���ý.o+ð�ðò�ñ��[ñFú��R!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅúVóQì^ô:ÿ������ � � õYù"!^ñ,ì��:ñ��Åñ[ø<�bõVñY#�óJùÅô�ñ,ô�ì^ò�ó�îVù��FñC�[ì^í�îVð�ñ���ï>�,��%�üÀÿVÿ2ëxuò�ûVð�ñDþù^úYø@ûVó�ñ[ò�ó0ò�ñ[ùÅðsð>��øVï�ø@úVì �bï>�[ñ��bõVñ¸ïsí�îVò�ì"!^ñFí�ñ[ú��`ý r õVñ¸ÿVÿ2ë(ò�ûVð�ñ+ï�ó,ó��Jù��bñFø@ùÅó0ô�ìÅðsð�ì"n�ó��V��¸ML  ½P�l�� ONP��¾M·u��PP  µQPP·u¸SR�·u¸¢Æ7T<Å�ºl¹GP�µ(Å�¸2¾ µl� �.U ��PP  µA�»P¹�µP¾�·u¹�ºD  ��ºl¹�Å�ºlµWVR·u¹�U�·u¸�·u¹+º�º��l½6¿�µ!X�*0ðsñFù^ó�ñó�ñ[ñ�o+îVî:ñ[ðC0�365�5 ��:uô�ì^ò�ù�í�ì^ò�ñ ô�ì^ò�í�ùÅðuøVñ�=VúYï��JïsìÅú2ýr õVñ�ÿVÿ2ë_øVñ�=YúVï��JïsìÅú�ì^ôYò�ñ[ù �lõVù��Yïsð�ï��,��ïsó{ìÅôu�bñ[ú�!�ï�ñ�n�ñ[ø�ù^ó{ù^ú�ìÅî��bï�í�ï��Fù��bï�ì^ú<�bì�ñFðsï�í�ïsúYù��bñ

ñ[ú�!�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú��b÷aòJñFðsù �bñFø·óJîYù��[ñ�ð�ñ[ù �Dó<þ��Vû2�/n0ñ��:ñ[ð�ïsñ�!^ñ;�bõYù�� ï���ï�ó±ùY�[ò�û��FïsùÅð�îYòJìÅî£ñFò��,���JõVù��ù^ú��(ï�úVøVûVó��bò�ï�ù^ð�÷Ió��bò�ñ[úVö �bõ1�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò�ô�ì^ò�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVù^ð�ð�ù^úYö^ûVùÅö^ñ[ó%í�ûVó���óJù �bï�óJôu��ý#ë�ì^úYóJï�øVñ[ò�bõYñ�ô�ì^ð�ðsì"n�ï�úVö�����ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú-óJï�í�ûYðsù �bï�úVö�� îVõVù^ó�ñ[ó�ìÅô2ù��,��îVï>�[ùÅð��[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò"�

ë6ì�íZY!��[���þP÷�ø�î\Y.��ý¢ø�]lí�^.�Y¢õ�ö÷�ø�ùzï¢û�÷�Y!��ý"ø�]lí*]`_*'öa��ü û���ø�î\Y!��ý¢ø�]lí^,�Y¢õ

ï¢û�÷�Y!��ý"ø�]lí*]`_�b$öa��ü û���ø�baî\Y!��ý¢ø�]lí*]"_cPõd!d�d�d�d�dï¢û�÷�Y!��ý"ø�]lí*]`_!�Eöa��ü û���ø,��î\Y!��ý¢ø�]lí*]"_��,[MPõ

þlíeY.��ý¢ø�]lí�]`_��øMí�ý

&]ô2n�ñ�òJñ�n�òJï>�bñ)�bõVï�óR�[ì�øVñ�ïsú�ë�þ�n0ñ�n�ì^ûVð�ø�í�ù^ú�ûVùÅðsð>��ûVó�ñ)�JõVñ-»P¾ µlµ�ì^î:ñ[ò�ù��bï�ì^úYó.�Jì¸øYñ[ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��Jñù^ð�ð+ï�ú��bñFòJí�ñ[øYïsù �bñ·øVù �bù(ó��bò�û����JûVò�ñ[ó üÀñDý ö:ý�þ�ù^ôu�Jñ[ò@ù³�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ù��bï�ì^úUîVõYù^ó�ñ·ïsó�øVì^úYñ bý�&]ú ùö^ùÅò��Yù^ö^ñF÷��Fì^ð�ðsñ����Jñ[ø�ð�ù^úVöÅûVù^öÅñDþ^õVì"n0ñ�!^ñFò�þ¢n0ñ úVì�ðsìÅúVö^ñFò0õYù"!^ñ��bõVñ��[ùÅîVù��Vï�ð�ï��,�;�Jì�í�ùÅúDûYù^ð�ð��ô�ò�ñ[ñ�í�ñ[í�ì^ò��Dþ�óJï�ú��Fñ�í�ñFí�ì^ò�� í�ù^úVùÅö^ñ[í�ñFú ��ï�ó�úVì"n øVì^úVñ�ï�í�îVð�ï��Fï��Jð��E� �E�bõVñ�öÅù^ò��Vù^öÅñ�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bìÅò�ý1�+ù��JûVò�ù^ð�ð���þRn�ñFn�ì^ûYðsø�õVì^î:ñY�bõVù �;�bõVñY�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò;n0ìÅûVðsøE�£ñ�ò�ñ[ó�î:ì^úVó�ï��Yðsñ)ô�ì^òö^ñ��t�JïsúVö�ñ�!^ñ[ò����bõVï�úVö�ò�ïsöÅõ ��ý�+úVô�ìÅò��JûVúVù��Jñ[ð>�Dþ`í�ì^ó����Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFòJó.�bò�ñ[ù �h�bõVñWf.g*h�i-j.;*9�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úsIbûVó��2ðsï>�^ñ0ùxó�ïsí�îVð�ñ ë�÷að�ï��Åñ

ó�û��Vò�ì^û��JïsúVñ�ý���ì��Fù^ð-!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�ó�û��lõ ù^ókf,g*l*9-m.n�o*8-fDþpf.g*l*9Om.n-m.q-rÅþ2ýsý�ý�þ:ù^úVøsf,g*l*9-m.nOm.q*t yù^ó�ó�ûVí�ïsúVö��JõVñ��%ù^ò�ñ�ùÅðsðYî£ìÅïsú��bñFòJóR�Jì�óJìÅí�ñ�õYñ[ù^îY÷IùÅðsð�ì��[ù��Jñ[ø�ì���Ibñ����Jó�y�ù^ò�ñ0ùÅðsðYîVðsù �[ñFø%ï�ú��bõVñó�ù^í�ñ+ó��bù �M��ô�ò�ù^í�ñ�þ^ùÅúVøw�JõVñ���ùÅòJñD�[ì^úYóJï�øVñ[ò�ñ[ø4�bì<�£ñw  ·uNPµ0ûVú��bï�ð:ùÅôu�bñFò)n�ñ�ò�ñ��JûVò�ú�ô�òJìÅí �bõVñ�[ùÅðsð��Jìvi*/*w-:.9�t)ùÅúVø'n�õVñFú�n�ñ�î£ìÅî�ì �$�bõVñ�ó��bù �M��ô�òJùÅí�ñ�ô�ì^ò0f.g*h*i-j,;*9Bý r õVï�ó�ïsó/�FðsñFù^ò�ð��ûVúVù ���Fñ[î��Jù��Vð�ñD�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ ï��C�Åñ[ñ[îYó�ùÅðsðBï�ú��bñFòJí�ñ[øYïsù �bñ¸òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVó�óJï�í�ûVð>�bùÅúVñ[ìÅûVó�ð���ð�ï�!ÅñDþ�bõ�ûVó�òJñ�pDûYïsò�ñ[ó í�û2�lõ�í�ì^ò�ñ�í�ñ[í�ì^ò����bõYù^ú�òJñFù^ð�ð���úYñ��[ñFóJó�ù^ò��Dý(o ë îVòJìÅö^ò�ù^í�í�ñ[ò�n0ìÅûVð�øõVù"!Åñ�í�ùÅúDûYù^ð�ð��±ô�ò�ñ[ñFø(�JõVñxï�ú��bñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ,òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVóQô�òJìÅíH�bõYñxñ[ùÅòJð�ïsñFòQîVõVù^ó�ñ[óR�:ñ[ô�ìÅòJñí�ì"!�ïsúVö�ìÅú �Jì(�JõVñ�ð�ù��bñ�îYõVù^ó�ñ[ó<ý� ñ/�JõDûYóxù^ò�ö^ûVñ��bõYù���ö^ùÅò��Yù^ö^ñF÷��Fì^ð�ðsñ����Jñ[ø�ð�ù^úVöÅûVù^öÅñ[ó,í�ûYó���ó�ù��Jïsó�ôu�w�bõYñ�úVñ�n ÿVÿ2ë6ó��Fì^îV÷

ï�úVö�òJûVð�ñ ïsô-�bõYñ��@ûYóJñ ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó+î£ñFò�!�ù^ó�ï>!^ñ[ð>�Dý�B�ù �lõ�ð�ì��[ùÅð�!`ùÅòJï�ù��Yðsñ¸óJõYì^ûVð�ø��:ñ/�[ìÅúVó�ïsøVñFòJñFø#aøYñ[ù^ø2%¸ùÅôu�bñFò{ï��Jó�  ��ºl¹�ûVóJñ,ï�ú;�bõVñx�FûVò�òJñFú �Qô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú��:ì�ø��Dý.�C��øVñFù^ø2þ"n0ñ�ò�ñ[ùÅðsð>�±í�ñ[ùÅú<�JõVù��ï>��ï�ó�¸2½ ¹���½ ¸2¹+¾M·uP�Å�¹+·u¸"Æw¹+½�¹�U µ� J·uN�µP¸2µPºlº@½+»|¹�U µxR�� ¹���ºl¹�¾MÅ��P¹+Å�¾ µD¹�U�� ¹R·u¹a¿�½ ·u¸2¹+ºs¹�½^ý2ÿVûVîVî:ì^ò��b÷ï�úVöY�bõVñ�ÿVÿ2ë ò�ûVðsñ�ï�ó�ïsí�î:ì^ò��bùÅú ���:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúVó�óJû2�lõ�ùÅó0f,g*h*i-j.;�9�ù^ò�ñ<�[ì^í�í�ì^ú ï�úð�ù^ò�ö^ñ±ó�ì^ôu�,n�ù^ò�ñDý r õVñ�ÿVÿ2ë�ò�ûVð�ñ�ï�ó�úYì��+ùÅó�ï�í�î£ìÅò��Jù^ú��xô�ìÅò�ë�÷aðsï>�^ñ�ðsùÅúVö^ûVùÅö^ñFó@�:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ|n0ñ�[ùÅú�í�ùÅúDûYù^ð�ð���øYñ[ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��Jñ¸ï�ú��bñFòJí�ñ[øYïsù �bñ øVù��Jù�ó��JòJû����bûVò�ñ[ó�ï�úY�bõVñ�îYòJìÅö^ò�ù^í óJìÅûVò��[ñDýr ò�ù^øVï>�bï�ì^úYù^ðxó��bù �M�D÷aù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú�ó��lõVñFí�ñFó�ù^úYø#ðsï�ú��Åñ[øm�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó�ì���!�ïsìÅûVóJð>�³!�ï�ì^ð�ù��Jñ��bõVñ

ÿVÿ2ë(òJûVð�ñ@�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ¸ðsì��[ùÅða!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ@�YïsúVøYïsúVöÅóCn�ïsð�ð£ó��bù"��ìÅú4�bõYñ�ó��bù �M��ûYú �Jïsð��JõVñ���ñ��Dï>���bõVñFïsòó��[ì^î:ñDþ�óJìA�bõVñ��%í�ù"��ò�ñ[í�ùÅïsú�ð�ï�!Åñxñ�!Åñ[ú�ù^ôu�Jñ[òG�JõVñ[ï�ò�ð�ù^ó��{ûVó�ñDý.KQðsù ���[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó{øVì�óJù �bï�óJôu�(�bõVñÿVÿ2ë#òJûYðsñ�þ��Vû��/�JõVñ��·ò�ñ�p�ûVï�ò�ñ(�JõVù��/!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó��£ñ;�Fì^îVï�ñ[ø í�ù^ú����bï�í�ñ[ó±ô�ò�ì^í ìÅúVñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�bì�ùÅúVì��JõVñ[ò<ý.�·ù^ú���ìÅô.�JõVñ/�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ ó��JòJù �bñ[öÅïsñFó,øVñ[ó��[ò�ï��:ñ[øF���4o�îVî£ñFð�ùÅúVø � ï�í 0>3M5�9 9�:uù^ð�ó�ì!�ïsìÅðsù �bñ��bõYñ�ÿVÿ2ë6òJûVð�ñDý

���£ñ��Dï�úVö��JõVñ�ÿVÿ�ë ò�ûVð�ñw�[ùÅú(òJñ�p�ûVïsò�ñ�ñ����bò�ù��Fì^î���ïsúVö-ìÅô�î:ì^ï�ú��bñFòA!�ù^ð�ûVñ[ó%ô�òJìÅí ùÅú(ì^ð�ø�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ��bõVù �s�[ìÅú �Jù^ï�úVóx�bõYñ[íSüu�Vû��+ù^ð�óJì��[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVós!�ùÅðsûVñFó�úVì��+úVñ[ñFøVñ[ø-ï�ú�ù�úVñ�n��[ìÅú �Jñ����P

Page 6: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

y ^2_a` b"c�d�c�e"f�gh_8ghi"i�jlk

ï�ú �Jì�ù�úVñ�n³�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�ýG��úVñ��[ùÅúVúVì ��ó�ïsí�îVð>��#+�Fù^î�%D�bõVñ�ûVúVúVñFñ[øVñFø(!�ùÅðsûVñFó2ï�ú<�bõVñ�ì^ð�øA�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñDþó�ïsú��Fñ+ï>�0ï�ó�úVì����[ð�ñ[ùÅòGn�õVñ��bõVñFò)�JõVñ[ò�ñ�ùÅòJñ+ì��bõYñ[ò�òJñFô�ñ[ò�ñ[ú��Fñ[óG�JìA�JõVñ�ìÅðsø4�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�ý r õYñD�lõVùÅðs÷ð�ñ[úVöÅñ�ï�óC�bì�=VúVø)ñ����[ï�ñ[ú����[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ó��bò�ù��Jñ[ö^ï�ñ[ó��bõYù��,ì��:ñ��;�JõVñ ÿVÿ2ë(ò�ûVð�ñDn�õYïsð�ñ í�ï�úVï�í�ï��FïsúVö�[ìÅî��Dï�úVöuý

��ûVò�úVñ�n��FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú±ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí ûVó�ñ[ó�ºl�»Pµ� zL(  ·u¸S{Pµ�R���  ½ ºlÅ�¾ µ�º0üu�JõVñ@´ÅòJø��Fì^ð�ûVí�úï�ú�KQïsöÅûVòJñF3�R�JõVù��D�[ìÅú �Jù^ï�ú�ì^úVð>�F!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó+ù����bûVùÅðsð>�)úVñ[ñFøVñ[ø·ï�ú��JõVñ�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú'�Vû��+ù"!Åì^ï�ø�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñC�[ì^î���ï�úVö�� �%ö^ò�ì^ûVîYïsúVö�!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[óRn�ï>�bõ;�JõVñxó�ù^í�ñ(  · »PµP¹�·uT<µQï�ú��bì�ù�ó�õVù^ò�ù��Vð�ñ,òJñ��[ìÅòJø2ý&]ú'KQïsöÅûVò�ñ�3^þan�ñ�ûVó�ñE|�þ~} ùÅúVøv���bì�øVñ[úYì��bñ(�bõVñ<�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñDþYù^úVøa��þp�BþYùÅúVøv�xô�ì^ò��[ì�øVñ

î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[ò�ó�ý � ï��Jõ(�Yù����[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó<þ�!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó>3Bþ�4Bþ�5Bþ`ù^úVøQ6 í�ûVó��-�£ñC�[ìÅîVï�ñ[ø�ô�ò�ì^í£�JõVñC�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñì^ôMB�ïsú��JìD�JõVñC�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ0ì^ôS/Bþ�ùÅúVøA�JõVñ[ú�ï�ú �JìD�JõVñC�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ì^ôGjDþP�bõVï�ó{ïsó�!Åñ[ò���ñ���î£ñFúVó�ï�!ÅñDý � ï>�bõ�bò�ù^øYï��JïsìÅúVù^ð£ðsï�ú��^ñFø;�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó<þ"�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó0ô�ì^ò(/%ù^úYø�j�ùÅòJñ+ûVúVó�ù^ô�ñ[ð>��òJñF÷IûVó�ï�úVö|�bõYñ@�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ô�ì^òBBþ<ò�ñ��Jù^ï�úVïsúYö��JõVñs!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ�C|�JõVù��{ï�ó�úVì ��ô�òJñFñ�ïsúk/�ì^òDj ?^í�ìÅòJñFì"!^ñFò�þFù����[ñFóJó�ïsúYö�!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óA3Bþ4Bþ!5+ùÅúVø�6�ïsúVó�ï�øVñG� ïsó-p�ûVï��Jñ�ñ��Dî:ñ[úYóJï>!^ñ��:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ�ù ��ðsñFù^ó����,n�ìxð�ïsú���ó2úVñ[ñFøVó.�Jìs�:ñG�bò�ù"!^ñFòJó�ñ[ø�ý�C��úVì��Jï��FïsúYö4�bõYù��x3BþM4Bþ�5Bþ£ù^úVø�6-õVù"!^ñ%óJùÅí�ñ�ð�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ�þ��bõYñ%ó�ù^ô�ñFð���ð�ïsú2�^ñ[ø��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ô�ì^ò�BîVû��Jó��bõVñFíSïsú��bì�ù_ó�ñ[îVùÅòJù �bñ�ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø2þ.n�õVï>�lõ ïsó�ð�ù��bñFò%ó�õVùÅòJñFø$� �z�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó%ô�ì^òQ/ ù^úVø�jDý�+úYðsï>�^ñxð�ï�ú��^ñFø<�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó�þ��JõVñxúVñFó��JïsúYö�ðsñ�!^ñ[ðYì^ôuóJùÅô�ñ[ð>��ð�ïsú2�^ñ[ø��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó{úYñ�!^ñFò�ñ����Fñ[ñ[øYó�í�ì^ò�ñ�bõYù^úF�,n0ì�ü�ìÅúVñ�ð�ù"�^ñFò0ô�ìÅòC�bõVñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ï>�bó�ñ[ð�ôt?�ùÅúVì��JõVñ[ò�ô�ì^ò,ò�ñ��[ìÅòJøYó0ìÅô�øVï>�£ñFòJñFú���ð�ï�ô�ñ��Jïsí�ñ�bþó�ì<�JõVñ���ó��Jïsð�ð�ñFú�Ibì"�w!^ñFò���ô�ùÅó��x!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ¸ù����Fñ[ó�óx�bï�í�ñDýr ì%óJûVîYî£ìÅò��)�bõVñ�ÿVÿ2ë�ó��[ìÅîVïsúYö±òJûYðsñ�ô�ì^ò��[ù^ó�ñ[ó0ðsï>�^ñ@�bõVñkf.g�h*i-j.;*9�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú2þ n�ñs�bò�ñ[ù ��ùÅðsð

ù����bï>!�ù��bï�ì^ú ò�ñ��[ìÅòJøYó¸ùÅó/�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ñFú�!Dï�ò�ì^úVí�ñ[ú��Jó¸ô�ìÅò/�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó<ý<o+ó±ô�ìÅò/�Vù���[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó<þ�n�ñ�ï�úVó�ïsó��/�bõYù���ñ[ù �lõ�ó�û��lõ ñ[ú�!�ïsò�ì^úYí�ñFú����Fì^ú��bùÅïsú ì^úYð���!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ûYóJñFø�ï�úz�bõVñ�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú�ý r ì+ù"!^ìÅïsø�õVïsöÅõ|�[ìÅî��Dï�úVö�ì"!^ñ[ò�õVñFù^ø2þ�n0ñ�ûVó�ñ�ù��[ìÅíA�Vï�úVù��JïsìÅú±ì^ôYóJùÅô�ñ[ð>�¸ð�ï�ú��^ñFø�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó�ù^úVø��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñxò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó)�bì�ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú���ó�û��lõ�ñ[ú�!�ïsò�ì^úVí�ñFú ��? �bõVñ¸òJñFóJûYð��JïsúVö<�[ì�øVñúVì �xì^úVð>�)óJù �bï�ó�=VñFó@�JõVñ�ÿVÿ�ë6ò�ûVð�ñ�üu�Jõ�ûVó�í�ï�úVï�í�ï>�[ñ(�bõVñ%í�ñ[í�ì^ò��@ûVó�ñ ��Vû���ù^ð�óJì�ó�ûVîVî:ì^ò��bó!^ñFò���ô�ùÅó��x�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ��[ò�ñ[ù �bï�ì^ú)ù^úVø)ô�òJñFñ[÷+!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vðsñ¸ù����[ñFóJó<ýo+ú�ù^ð>�bñFòJúYù��bï>!^ñCn�ù"��ï�ó��bì�ó��Jï��M�(�bì/�bõYñxó��Jù^úVøYù^ò�ø�ó��bù �M��÷��VùÅóJñFø�ó��lõVñ[í�ñ�þ"n�õVï>�lõ;!�ïsìÅðsù �bñ[ó

�bõYñ ÿYÿ2ë ò�ûVð�ñ��:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ�øYñ[ù^ø ðsì��Fù^ð�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�ò�ñ[í�ùÅïsú ïsú �bõVñ�ó��bù��M� ô�ò�ù^í�ñ ûVú��bï�ð��bõVñô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�ò�ñ��JûVòJúYó�ý r õYïsóD�[ù^úY�:ñ�îVù^ò��bï�ù^ð�ð>�4=���ñ[øY���@ùÅóJó�ì��[ï�ù��JïsúVö�ù�øVñFó��FòJï�î��Jì^òxn�ï>�bõ�ñ[ù �lõò�ñ��bûYòJú�ù^øVøYòJñFóJó<þQó�õVì"n�ïsúYö'n�õVï>�lõE!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ùÅòJñ)ðsï>!^ñ-ï�úE�JõVñY�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú�0 o�îVî£ñFðxù^úYøÿVõVùÅì13M5�5 �8?ho+ûVöÅûVó��JóJó�ì^úÿ3M5 9�5�:,?��JõVñ�ö^ùÅò��Yù^ö^ñ(�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bì^ò/�JõVñ[úz=VúYøVó±ù^úYø ï�ú��bñFòJîVò�ñ��Jó��bõVñøVñFó��FòJï�î��bìÅò�øVûVò�ïsúYö�ñFù��lõF�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bï�ì^úF�bì�ïsöÅúVì^ò�ñ��bò�ù��FïsúVö��JõVì^ó�ñ�#aøVñFù^ø�%�ðsì��Fù^ðh!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó<ý.&]úù^øYøVï��JïsìÅú2þ£ô�òJñFñA!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó¸ïsúYóJï�øVñ�ù�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�í�ûVó��D�:ñA�Fì^îVï�ñ[ø�ô�òJìÅíÇ�bõVñ�õVñ[ùÅî��bì�bõYñ�ó��Jù��M�·ï�ú(ì^ò�øVñ[ò��Jì�ô�ûVðsð>� ì��:ñ����JõVñ�ÿVÿ2ë ò�ûVðsñ�ý�KYìÅò�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþ�ïsúz�JõVñ�ô�ì^ð�ð�ì"n�ïsúVöY���îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí��

ë6ì�í³ë�îZü�ð|ì.ð(ïhð/ñ�õ�ö÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�í1ú�î�õYö

÷�ø�ùzï�ûP÷'òzö'ühîZì.ð(ï�õï�ûP÷'ózö'ühî+òhð(ï�õï�ûP÷�ô�ö'ühî+óhðAñ�õ

þlí³ôøMí�ý

þlí$úøMí�ý

r õVñC�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ0ô�ìÅò{ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�B/�[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVóQô�ò�ñ[ñC!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFóG/uþ�1uþ�Cuþ<ù^úVøQ3Býh��úVøVñ[òR�JõVñ�ó��bù^úYøVù^ò�øó��bù��M�%ïsí�îVð�ñ[í�ñFú �Jù��JïsìÅú2þ�B�~ ó�ô�ò�ù^í�ñsn�ì^ûVð�ø;�[ìÅú��bù^ï�ú�ù�î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[ò)�bì�/�~ óG�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñDþ�ù^úVø�ùÅðsð£ô�ì^ûVòô�ò�ñ[ñx!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó{ì^ô�B±ùÅòJñx�Åñ[î��{ð�ï>!^ñ�ûVú��bï�ðMB�òJñ��bûVò�úVó<ýh�,û��R!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ�1±ò�ñ[ù �lõVñ[óQï>�bó0ðsùÅó��{ûVó�ñ�ù���bõYñ�=YòJó����[ù^ð�ð��bìx/�?"�Åñ[ñ[îYïsúVö¸ï>��ð�ï>!^ñ�n�ï��Jõ<�JõVñ,òJñFó���ì^ôa�bõVñC�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ�ïsóR�FðsñFù^ò�ð�� úVì ��ó�îVù �[ñ[÷aó�ù^ô�ñDý

Page 7: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥D¦l§ jle"¨�c�e"f/` c�©>j�ª�©�d�« ª�` i"c ¦ jx¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�d�e�°�jl«¯­ § d�e �

ë6ì�íÿþ6ù�ø`��î+òhð���ð+ë õ'ö÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�ízü�î ûað���õ�ö1þ6ë ��î û8ð���õ�ù�ü øMíEû

øP÷��Pø�ü�î+ë�î û�õ�ðû�õþlí�ühî+òhð�PõøMí�ý

ØVn>�^�[¥^�UØ<v�i�jhrtn>dliE�\�,����n>i�ªbrIyli�e`ylgae c�«

&]ú@ù±ò�ñ[ùÅða�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò�þ��bõVñ¸ó��bù��M��÷+�Vù^ó�ñ[ø�ó��lõVñ[í�ñ�í�ûVó��0ùÅðsó�ì±ï�ú��[ìÅòJî:ì^ò�ù��Jñxù|n�ï�øVñ¸òJùÅúVö^ñxìÅôì��JõVñ[ò,ñ�� �Jñ[úVó�ï�ì^úVóC�bì�ó�ûVîVî:ì^ò��)�Jù^ï�ðBòJñ��[ûVò�óJï�ì^ú�0 ��ù^úVó�ì^úz3M5�5 ��:]þ�öÅñ[úVñFòJù �bï�ì^úVùÅðYó��bù �M�;�[ì^ð�ð�ñ��[÷�bï�ì^ú$0�ë�õVñ[úVö�ñ��,ùÅð�ý�3M5 5�9 :�þ^ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��C�[ùÅðsð>������0�ë�ð�ïsúVöÅñ[ò�ñ��,ù^ð]ý�3M5 9�9�?¢��ïsñ���ñ���ùÅð�ý�365�5�� :�þ^ù^úYøñ����Fñ[î��JïsìÅú õYù^úVøVð�ï�úVö³0 �+ù^í�óJñ��_ùÅúVøz*{ñ����bìÅú � ì^úVñFó43M5 5�5�:]ý�B0ù��lõ ì^ô��bõVñFóJñ�í�ù"�_ò�ñ�p�ûVï�ò�ñúVìÅúV÷��JòJï>!�ïsùÅð��lõVùÅúVö^ñFó@�Jì4�bõYñ(�VùÅóJï>�±ó��lõVñ[í�ñ%óJû��lõ_ù^ó¸óJõVùÅòJï�úVö�ù ���bï>!�ù��JïsìÅú·òJñ��[ìÅòJøVó<þ�ï�úVó�ñ[ò��b÷ï�úVö�óJî:ñ��FïsùÅð�í�ù^ò��^ñFòJó�ï�ú$�bõVñ@í�ï�øVøVð�ñ�ìÅô0ù�ô�ò�ù^í�ñDþ�ù^úYø ò�ù^úYøVì^í�ð>�_ûVî:øVù��JïsúYö��bõVñ�ò�ñ��JûVò�úù^øYøVòJñFóJó<ý r õVñ í�ùÅïsúF�lõVùÅðsð�ñ[úVöÅñ+ô�ìÅò��JõVñ�ó��bù��M��÷+�Vù^ó�ñ[ø�ï�í�îVð�ñ[í�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^ú)ïsóx�Jõ�ûVó�ì^ú�õVì"n��bìí�ù^ï�ú��bù^ï�ú_ùÅúVø_ò�ñ[ùÅóJìÅú·ù��:ì^û2�D�JõVñ�ÿVÿ2ë îYòJìÅî£ñFò��,�-ï�ú��JõVñ%îYòJñFóJñFú��[ñ�ì^ô��JõVñ[ó�ñ�ñ����bñFúVó�ïsìÅúVó�ý� ñs�£ñFðsï�ñ�!Åñx�bõVï�ó�ï�ó�ù/!Åñ[ò��±øVï>�<�FûVð>��îVò�ì��Vð�ñ[í�?�ïsú�ô�ù ���`þ¢n0ñ�ùÅòJñ�úYì��{ù"n�ù^ò�ñ0ìÅô:ùÅú��A�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò�bõYù���ó�ûVîVî:ì^ò��bó�ù^ð�ðBì^ô-�bõYñ[ó�ñ�ñ����bñFúVóJï�ì^úYó�þÅúVì �x�bì�í�ñ[ú��bï�ì^ú)ñ[úYô�ì^ò��[ï�úVö��bõVñ�ÿVÿ�ë ò�ûVð�ñDý��ñ��[ùÅûVóJñ�ìÅô��bõVï�ó0øYï����[ûYð��,�<n�ï��Jõ�ó��bù��M��ó�ùÅúVø�ù^ð�ó�ì�ô�ì^ò�ò�ñ[ùÅóJìÅúVó{ö^ï>!^ñFú�ïsú;�JõVñ@�Fì^í�îVùÅúVïsìÅú

îVùÅî£ñFò<0 o+îVî:ñ[ð�ù^úVø�ÿYõVù^ì�365�5 ��:]þ�n0ñ�øVì�úVì �xûVó�ñ±ù^ú��)òJûVú��Jïsí�ñ±ó��bù �M�Bý)&]úVó��bñFù^ø2þ�n0ñA�bò�ñ[ù��ù^ð�ð�ù ���Jï�!�ù��JïsìÅú(òJñ��[ìÅòJøVó�ù^óA�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó±ô�ì^ò(�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó�ù^úVø(ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñw�JõVñ[í ï�úò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó�ì^ò�ïsú��bõVñ õVñFù^î2ý � ï>�bõVìÅû��C�bõVñ ó��bù��M��þÅó�ûVîVî:ì^ò��bï�úVöA�Jù^ï�ðBòJñ��[ûVò�óJï�ì^ú�þ�öÅñ[úVñFòJù �bï�ì^úVùÅðö^ùÅò��Yù^ö^ñ��[ìÅðsð�ñ����bï�ì^ú2þ�ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��R�Fù^ð�ð�� ���Dþ<ù^úVø�ñ�� �Fñ[î��JïsìÅú�õVù^úVøYðsï�úVö�ù^ð�ð��:ñ��Fì^í�ñ[ó�ó��bò�ù^ï�ö^õ��Jô�ì^ò�÷n�ù^ò�ø�0 o+îYî£ñFðR365�5 ��:]ý�&,��ï�ó�ùÅðsó�ì�ñ[ùÅó��<�bì�í�ùÅïsú��Jù^ï�ú;�bõVñ�ÿVÿ2ë îVò�ì^î:ñ[ò��,�A�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñxù^ð�ð2�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð�bò�ù^úYóJô�ñFòJó�ùÅòJñ¸úVì"n ïsí�îVð�ñ[í�ñ[ú��Jñ[ø-ù^ó�îVð�ù^ï�ú-ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úY�[ùÅðsð�ó�?�ù^ó�ð�ì^úVö�ù^ó�ñFù��lõF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ��Fì^úV÷�bùÅïsúYó@ì^úYð�� ô�òJñFñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFów�bõYù���ùÅòJñ�ð�ï�!Åñ�ïsúm�JõVñ'�Jù^ò�ö^ñ���ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúm�£ì�ø���þ�ù^úVø öÅù^ò��Vù^öÅñ�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bï�ì^ú ïsó�ìÅúVð>�·ïsú�!Åì��^ñFø_ù ���JõVñ;�:ñ[ö^ï�úVúVï�úVö-ì^ô�ñ�!Åñ[ò���ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úz�[ùÅðsð]þuù-ðsì��Fù^ðR!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ�Vï�úVøVï�úVö;n�ï�ðsðh�:ñ�ûVúVò�ñ[ù �lõVù��Yðsñ¸ù^ôu�Jñ[ò�ï>�bóxð�ù^ó��,ûVóJñ/n�ï>�bõYïsú-ï>�bóxó��[ìÅî£ñ�ýr õVñ�òJñFó��¸ì^ô)�bõVï�ó�îVù^î:ñ[ò�ï�ó�ì^ò�ö^ùÅúVï>�[ñ[ø_ù^ó ô�ì^ð�ðsì"n�ó<ý � ñ�=Vò�ó�� ûVó�ñ�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñ[ó��bì-ò�ñ�!�ï�ñ�n

�bõYñ;�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úV÷aîVù^ó�ó�ïsúVö)ù^úYø��FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷IîVùÅóJó�ï�úVö@ï�ú��bñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ�ðsùÅúVö^ûVùÅö^ñFó¸ùÅúVøz�bì�ó�õVì"nõVì"n ù ���bï>!�ù��JïsìÅú_ò�ñ��[ìÅòJøYó+í�ïsöÅõ��@�:ñ�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ[ø_ïsú��bõVñ�õVñ[ùÅî_ùÅúVø·ï�ú'�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�óü�ÿYñ����JïsìÅúw´8Jý � ñ@�JõVñ[ú@îVòJñFóJñFú���ì^ûVò�øVñ��Jù^ï�ðsñFøw�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷+�[ì^ú�!Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú±ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí üÀÿVñ����bï�ì^úw��bý� ñ�ù^îVîYð����bõVñ�ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí �bì·ó�ñ�!Åñ[ò�ù^ðR�Fì^í�í�ì^ú(îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí ô�òJùÅö^í�ñ[ú��Jó±ù^úVø(ó�õVì"n õVì"n ï��ù��lõYïsñ�!^ñ[óC�JõVñ�øVñ[ó�ï�òJù �Vðsñ ò�ñ[ó�ûVð>�bó�ü�ÿYñ����JïsìÅúYÀ8bý � ñ�ù^ð�ó�ì%öÅï�!Åñ¸ìÅûVò�í�ñ[ùÅóJûVò�ñ[í�ñFú �,øVù �bù�ù^úYøó�õVì"n õVì"nqn0ñFðsð�ì^ûVò�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí n0ìÅò���ó ì^ú�ò�ñ[ùÅðsï�ó��Jï����:ñ[ú��lõYí�ùÅò���ó�ü�ÿYñ����JïsìÅú$�8Jý<K�ï�úVùÅðsð>�Dþn�ñ¸øYïsó��[ûVó�óx�bõYñ�òJñFðsù �bñ[øFn�ì^ò���ù^úVøY�bõYñ[úY�[ìÅú��[ð�ûVøVñ�ý� T ê21%32é çs3,?B7:é¸ç 1%325)7+3�N6ê�X`1x52?�OQPD5&]ú��bõYïsó�óJñ����bï�ì^ú�þ�n�ñ±ïsð�ð�ûVó��JòJù �bñ/�JõVñ�ë-*�ÿY÷��VùÅóJñFøY�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ù��bï�ì^ú10 ÿ��bñFñ[ð�ñ�3M5�7M9�?�}�òJùÅú��43M5 987 ?o+îYî£ñFð@3M5�5 ��:,Qù^úYø_ì^ûYò�úVñ�nH�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsó+ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí ì^ú��bõVñ�ñ���ùÅí�îYðsñ�ïsú�KQïsöÅûVòJñ(´:ýr õVñ�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�j,<*9*8)ï��Jñ[ò�ù��Jï�!Åñ[ð>��ù^îVîVð�ï�ñ[ó¸ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú��'�bì-ù^ò�ö^ûVí�ñFú ��� ûVú��bï�ð{ï����[ìÅú !Åñ[ò�ö^ñFó�bì�ó�ù��Jïsó�ôu�@îVò�ñ[øYï��Fù��bñD��ý� ñ�ûVó�ñ�ë-*�ÿ�ù^óR�JõVñxï�ú��bñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ,ðsùÅúVö^ûVùÅö^ñ�ô�ì^ò��FðsìÅóJûYòJñ��[ìÅú !Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú(�£ñ��[ùÅûVóJñCn�ñxn0ùÅú��

�bì<�bò�ñ[ù ��ùÅðsðuù����bï>!�ù��bï�ì^ú@òJñ��[ì^ò�øVó0ù^ó��[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úw�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó<ý�o+ú@ùÅð��Jñ[ò�úVù��Jï�!Åñ+ï�ó)�Jì%ûYóJñD�bõVño+÷aúVìÅòJí�ù^ð^ô�ì^ò�í{0 K�ð�ù^úYù^ö^ùÅú�ñ���ù^ð]ý�365�5 ´�:<ñ����Jñ[úVøVñFø/n�ï��Jõ/�bõVñ�òJñ��bûVò�úV÷aù^øVøVò�ñ[ó�óuðsù �£ñFðsó"?P�bõYïsó2ïsóñ[ó�ó�ñ[ú��bï�ù^ð�ð��xIbûVó���ù�ó���ú��bù ���bï>�x!�ù^ò�ïsùÅú��{ì^ô{ë-*�ÿ2ý � ñxùÅòJñ,úVì ��ù^ø�!Åì��[ù��JïsúYö¸ûYóJï�úVö@ë-*�ÿ�ùÅóR�bõVñ

Page 8: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

� ^2_a` b"c�d�c�e"f�gh_8ghi"i�jlk

� �>��� á�º®¿]Çwº[ÝJÄ ¼� �>��� ÇsÜ<È�¼���¼J¿{Â�¾®Ü<¹�Ȥº®Ü<È� �>��� Ý�¾b¾[Ä ¼�º®Ü�Â�¾®Ü<¹�È�º[Ü<È� �>��� �"�����W��� � �$�,�

  �$¡G¢���£.�$� � É �"�,¤�� � I  ¢Dzz¢ É � ¢ I �z¥�¥�¥ � ¢�¦D}

¢ �>��� �   �   �§ �>��� ÁÅ¿]ÇwÃ�ÇwȤÇsáJ¼�¾�Á`¼�¿Àº®È¤¾®¿� �>��� ¡�¨"� � z � É � � I �z¥�¥�¥ � � ¦ }-� �  ©,ª � � ��¤��"�"�,«\�Fz � � ¢Å}

  ©,ª � � ��z¬¢ É � ¢ I �z¥�¥\¥ � ¢ ¦ }  ©,ª � � � § zz¢ É � ¢ I �z¥�¥�¥ � ¢�¦D}

ØVn>�^�[¨^�Uã���pIrIgIyljhr�pI�Fi[rtyl��dlq���Þ{ª

ë6ì�íÿþ6ù�ø`��î�­�ð�ò�ð��.ð+ë õ'ö÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�ízü�î�®�ð,û8ð���õ�ö

÷�ø�ù$ë�ìPíZ¯2îô õYö1þ�ëzô'ù�ü øMí°®�î û�õø�÷���øz÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�íe±aî���õ�ö'ü�î�®�ð��.ð,û�õ

þlí1ë8î�±8ð,û�õøMí�ý

þlí���î�¯að,û8ð�� õøMí�ý

þlí�ühî�­�ð�òhð$PõøMí�ý

ØVn>�^�[´^��Ø<v�i�jhrtn>dliE�\�,����ylqwrIfhg0��Þ{ª�jhdli[�lfhgapan>dli

ï�ú �Jñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ�ð�ù^úYö^ûVùÅö^ñ�ô�ìÅòQó��Jù^úVøVùÅòJø%øVù��Jù^÷+�Vì"n(ù^úYø(�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð�÷��Yì"n(ì^î��Jïsí�ï>�[ù��JïsìÅúVós0 o�îVî:ñ[ð3M5 5�� :�ýA&]ú�ô�ù ����þBò�ñ��[ñFú���!Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^úYó¸ìÅôG�JõVñ�ÿ����.��� � ùÅúVø�K-�.&,� r �[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò�ó40 ÿYõVù^ì13M5 5876:�lõVìÅóJñx�Jì�ûVó�ñs�bõYñ@o+÷aúVìÅòJí�ù^ðYô�ì^ò�í ùÅó��bõYñ+ï�ú �Jñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��JñxðsùÅúVö^ûYù^ö^ñ�ô�ìÅò�ìÅî��bï�í�ï��Fù��bï�ì^úYó�ù^úYø�bõYñ[úY�[ìÅú !Åñ[ò��0ï>��ï�ú �Jì_ë-*�ÿ)ô�ì^òx�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ��[ì^ú�!Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú2ý� T æ ê2\ÅAÅK]C>A�²D9<K]C>\^A�³�´D9<HbHJC>Aµ±HJKIL`;>=ë�ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úV÷aîVù^ó�ó�ïsúVö-ó��,��ðsñ�üJë-*�ÿ.xïsó%ù_ó�û��Vó�ñ��±ìÅôx¶Å÷+�[ùÅð��FûVð�ûVó�þ.�Vû2�An�õVï>�lõ$�[ð�ì^ó�ñ[ð>��ò�ñ[÷�Vñ����bó@�bõVñ|�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð�÷+�Vì"n ù^úVø-øVù �bùÅ÷��Vì"n ì^î:ñ[ò�ù��JïsìÅúVó�ì^ô�ù;!^ìÅú���ñ[ûVí�ù^úYú)í�ù �lõVïsúYñDý�o�ó+ï�ú¶D÷��Fù^ð>�[ûVð�ûVó<þ:ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVó�ù^ò�ñ�úYñ[ó��bñ[ø ù^úYø'!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó¸õVù"!^ñ%ðsñ��Dï>�[ùÅðQó��Fì^î:ñ ?��Vû2�¸ùÅó ì^ú_ùF!^ìÅú�+ñFûVí�ù^úVú)í�ù��lõVï�úVñ�þDì^ò�øVñ[ò,ì^ô2ñ�!�ù^ð�ûVù �bï�ì^ú)ïsó�îVò�ñ[÷aøVñ��bñ[ò�í�ïsúYñ[ø2ý.KYìÅòx�bõVñ îVûYòJî:ì^ó�ñ[ó,ì^ô-�bõYïsóîVùÅî£ñFò�þ�n0ñ%ñ���îVò�ñ[ó�ó%ë-*�ÿ�ûVó�ï�úVöw��� úYì��bù �bï�ì^ú2þYù^ð>�:ñ[ï>�+ó�ñ�!^ñFòJñFð��4�[ì^úYó��JòJùÅïsúVñFø�y!ó�ñ[ñ|KQï�ö^÷ûVò�ñ��:ý�o�ú)ù �bìÅí¸·|�Fù^úY�£ñ�ù;!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ¸ì^ò�ù;�[ìÅúVó��bù^ú���?Dù�¾ µl��½ ¾�RD�[ùÅú��:ñ|�Fì^úVó��bò�û����Jñ[ø)ì^û��ì^ô�ù�ó�ñ�p�ûVñ[ú2�[ñ@ü@· È`¹ · # ¹.º,º,º.¹ ·�»�QìÅô2ù �bì^í�ó<ý�&]ôp¼�ï�ó@�:ì^ûVúVøY�Jì�ù^ú0½�÷IñFðsñFí�ñ[ú���òJñ��[ìÅòJø2þ �JõVñ[ú�bõYñ���¾ Ý =Yñ[ð�ø@í�ù"���£ñ¸ô�ñ����lõVñ[ø�ûVóJï�úVöa:,9*;*9-f.<uü¿�Fþ ¼�bý r õVñ�ó���ú��bù���ô�ì^ò,ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø;�[ì^úYó��JòJû����bï�ì^ú2þ=VñFðsø óJñFðsñ����JïsìÅú2þ:îVò�ïsí�ï>�bï>!^ñ�ì^î:ñ[ò�ù��JïsìÅú2þ£ù^úVø ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú øVñ�=VúYï��JïsìÅú�í%ûVó����:ñ�ô�ì^ð�ðsì"n�ñ[ø�� ��ù�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú-ñ��DîYòJñFóJó�ïsìÅú�À�üu�JõVò�ì^ûVöÅõ��bõVñÁ;�9*<�ñ���îVòJñFóJó�ï�ì^ú.JýD��ú��JõVñ�ì �bõVñFòxõVù^úYø2þVô�ûYú��[÷�bï�ì^ú�ùÅîVîVð�ï��Fù��JïsìÅú7·Vü�· È ¹,º.º,º`¹ · » uøVì�ñ[ó0úVì���ó�î:ñ��[ï�ôu��ù|�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú�ñ���îVò�ñ[ó�ó�ïsìÅú(�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñxï�úë-*�ÿ�þDô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVóxúVñ�!^ñFò(¾ µ�¹+Å�¾M¸±ïsúY�bõYñ/�[ì^ú�!Åñ[ú��bï�ì^úVùÅðuóJñFúVóJñ�ý.&]úVó��Jñ[ùÅø2þDï���ï�óxñ��Dî:ñ����bñFøF�JõVù��ñ[ù �lõ ûVó�ñ[ò�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�n�ïsð�ðC�bù��Åñ@ù òJñ��bûVò�úV÷+�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú(ùÅó�ìÅúVñ@ìÅôxï>�bó�ù^ò�ö^ûVí�ñFú �Jó�ý r õVñ�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú(ï�ó�øYñ�=VúVñFø ï�ú$�bõVñ�ì^ò�øVïsúYù^ò��'n�ù"��ü�ûYóJï�úVöÂ%*1*n�bþ�ù^úVø$n�ï�ð�ð0îVò�ñ[ó�ûVí�ù��Yð����£ñï�ú !Åì��Åñ[ø4���w�JõVñ/�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñ ï�ú-ì^ò�øVñ[òx�Jì<�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVñ��bõVñ/�Fì^í�îVû��Jù��JïsìÅú2ýr ì)óJï�í�îVð�ïsôu���bõVñ�ó��Dú��Jù���ô�ûVò��bõVñFò�þ:ð�ù��Jñ[ò ï�ú��JõVñ�îVù^î:ñ[ò<þ�n�ñ%ûVó�ñ¸;*9*<�Ã È Ã # º,º,º Ã�»ej.n

º,º.º 9*n�læ�bì�øVñ[úYì��bñ¸ù�óJñ�p�ûVñ[ú��Fñ�ìÅôp;*9*<�ñ���îVò�ñ[ó�óJï�ì^úVó<þÅï�ý ñDý�þk;*9*<7Ã È j.n�;*9*<và # j.n º,º.º ;�9*<

Page 9: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥D¦l§ jle"¨�c�e"f/` c�©>j�ª�©�d�« ª�` i"c ¦ jx¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�d�e�°�jl«¯­ § d�e Ä

ë6ì�íÿþ6ù�ø`��î�­�ð�ò�ð��.ð+ë õ'ö÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�ízü�î ûað���õ�ö

÷�ø�ù$ë�ìPíZ¯2îô õYö1þ�ëzô'ù�ü øMí�­8î û�õø�÷���øz÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�íe±aî���õ�ö'ü�î���ð,û�õ

þlí1ë8î�±8ð,û�õøMí�ý

þlí���î�¯að,û8ð�� õøMí�ý

þlí�ühî+òhð�PõøMí�ý

ØVn>�^�[¦^�UØ<v�i`jbrtn>dliE�\�,����ylqwrIfhg0��Þ{ªJ����ylpafhe¸dlm`rIn>k,n>¡hylrtn>dli�p

à » j.n º,º,º 9�n*l º,º,º 9�n*lk9*n*lBý r ì;n�òJï>�bñ�ð�ñ[ó�ós!Åñ[ò��£ìÅóJñ��[ì�øVñ�þ�n�ñ�ì^ôu�Jñ[ú��[ìÅíA�Vï�úVñ�îVò�ï�í�ï>�bï>!^ñì^î:ñ[ò�ù��JïsìÅúVóCn�ï��Jõ-ì��bõYñ[ò�ñ���îVò�ñ[ó�ó�ïsìÅúVó±ü�ñDý ö:ý�þcÅ*Æ*Ç*Æ�È�ìÅòÉj,%Ê4*Ë�ÌÍ<�/*9*nÎ)*)*)�býK�ï�ö^ûYòJñCÀ�ó�õVì"n�óR�bõVñx�Fì�øVñ�ì^ô8�bõVñ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúÂj,<*9*8 ù^ôu�Jñ[ò��JòJùÅúVó�ðsù �bï�ì^ú�ïsú��bì�ë-*0ÿ2ý�KQïsöÅûVò�ñ��

ó�õVì"n�ó@�JõVñ(�Fì�øVñvj.<*9*8�ù^ôu�Jñ[ò��bõVñ<�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú�ùÅòJöÅûVí�ñ[ú��ÐÏ)ì^ôA/)õVùÅó@�:ñ[ñFú_õVìÅïsó��bñFø·ì^û��ì^ô��JõVñ·ð�ìDìÅîÿ�£ñ��[ù^ûYóJñ·ï>��ï�ó�ð�ìDìÅîV÷aïsú�!�ù^ò�ïsùÅú���üÀï���ïsó@ù^ð>n0ù"��ókÑ�bý�ÿVû��lõ ì^î2�bï�í�ï>�[ù �bï�ì^úVó@ù^ò�ñî:ñ[ò�ô�ì^ò�í�ñFø±ù^ôu�Jñ[ò,ë-*�ÿV÷+�[ìÅú !Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú�þM�Vû��-�:ñ[ô�ì^ò�ñ��JõVñ)�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�ùÅúVù^ð>��óJï�óhn�õVï>�lõ±ï�ó.�JõVñ�óJû���Ibñ����ì^ô-�bõYïsó�îVùÅî£ñFò�ýr ì�ñFù^ó�ñ/�bõVñ%îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^ú2þ�n�ñ±ûVó�ñ|�Fù^îVï>�bùÅð�ð�ñ��t�Jñ[ò�ó@�Jì�øVñ[úYì��bñA�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úVó�ü�ñDý ö:ý�þHÑBþÒ þ�ùÅúVøEÓ�bý � ñD�Fù^ð�ða�JõVì^ó�ñ+ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó0øVñ��[ð�ù^ò�ñ[ø�ï�úw�JõVñ�ó�ì^ûYò��FñxîVò�ì^ö^ò�ù^í ù^ó|Å�ºlµ�¾�»PÅ�¸2�P¹�·u½ ¸2ºü�ñ�ý öuýsþ~j.<�9*8Bþ*/�bþVù^úVøY�bõYì^ó�ñ�ïsú��bò�ì�øVû��Fñ[ø���� ë-*0ÿF�Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ï�ì^ú@ùÅó<�l½�¸a¹�·u¸aÅ���¹+·u½�¸/»PÅ�¸2�P¹�·u½ ¸2ºü�ñ�ý öuýsþ Ò þ!Ó�býpÔ.½ ¸2¹+·u¸2Å���¹+·u½�¸0N�� ¾M·u��PP  µPºBùÅòJñ0ù^ð�ð��bõVìÅóJñ�ô�ì^ò�í�ù^ð�îVù^ò�ù^í�ñ��bñ[ò�ó�ü�úVìÅòJí�ù^ð�ð>��îVðsù �[ñFøù^ó@�bõVñ|=YòJó���ù^ò�ö^ûVí�ñFú ��ìÅô2ù�ûYóJñFòxô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú.Qï�ú��bò�ì�øVû��[ñFø�ïsú6ë-*0ÿY�[ì^ú�!Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú��bì�ó�ñ[ò�!^ñ�ù^óò�ñ��bûYòJúY�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úYó%ü�ñ�ý öuýsþSÑ�Jý�KYûYú����JïsìÅúVó+ó�û��lõ�ù^óQj,<*9*8Bþ*i@ùÅúVøa%�ùÅòJñ/�Fù^ð�ðsñFøEµ�ºl�l�M¿�·u¸"Æ»PÅ�¸2�P¹+·u½�¸2º�þ��:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ<�bõVñ��·í�ù"���£ñ�îVùÅóJó�ñ[ø�ù^ó ù^ò�ö^ûYí�ñFú��bó¸ì^ò ó��Jì^ò�ñ[ø�ïsú øVù��Jù-ó��JòJû����bûVò�ñ[óó�ìA�bõYù��G�JõVñ��[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[òG�Fù^úVúYì���ï�øVñFú �Jïsôu��ùÅðsð:ì^ôh�JõVñ[ï�ò��[ù^ð�ðYó�ï>�bñ[ó<ý.o+ð�ðuô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVóC�bõVù ��øVì%úVì��ñ[ó��[ùÅî£ñ�ùÅòJñ/�Fù^ð�ðsñFø�{�¸a½�VR¸/»PÅ�¸2�P¹�·u½ ¸2º�ü�ñ�ý öuýsþM/�bý � ñA�[ù^ú�øYì�ñ����bñFúVóJï>!^ñ�ì^î��Jïsí�ï>�[ù��JïsìÅúVóxìÅú��úVì"n�ú)ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVóxó�ïsú2�[ñ�n0ñ���úVì"n ù^ð�ð�ì^ô.�bõVñFïsòs�Fù^ð�ðBóJï>�bñFó�ù��x�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñ��bï�í�ñDý� T à ê2;>\ÅH\²DGI=.³�´D9<HbHJC>Aµ�HbKaL`;>=ë�ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úV÷aîVù^ó�ó�ïsúVö-ó��,��ðsñ�ï�ó�í�ñFù^ú��|�Jì·ù^îVîYòJì"��ï�í�ù �bñ;�JõVñ@ìÅî£ñFòJù �bï�ì^ú(ì^ô,ù�!Åì^ú$��ñ[ûV÷í�ù^úVúE�[ìÅí�îYû��bñFò�?�ù£#�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú�% ïsú í�ù �lõVï�úVñ�ð�ù^úYö^ûVùÅö^ñ�ï�óDIbûVó���ù^ú ù^øVøYòJñFóJó�ïsúE�bõVñ)ñ���÷ñ��Fû��bù �Vð�ñ@îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí�þ�î:ñ[ò�õVù^îVó<n�ï>�bõ ó�ì^í�ñ4�Fì^ú�!^ñFú��bï�ì^ú(ù��:ì^û2�An�õVï>�lõ ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó±õVìÅðsø³�bõVñîVùÅòJùÅí�ñ��bñFòJó�yE!Åñ[ò��@í%û��lõ·ð�ï��Åñ�ùm#�IbûVí�î'n�ï>�bõ�ù^ò�ö^ûVí�ñ[ú��Jó�ý % r õVñ�úVì��JïsìÅú·ì^ô�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú_ï�úë-*�ÿ%ïsóQùÅðsí�ì^ó����JõVñ�óJùÅí�ñ�þ`ñ����[ñFî��-�bõVù �.�JõVñ��±õYù"!^ñ�úVñFó��Jñ[ø�ðsñ���ï��Fù^ðDó��Fì^î:ñ�ù^úYø�í�ù"�/�[ìÅú �Jù^ï�úô�ò�ñ[ñA!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó<ý r õYïsó¸îVò�ì��Vð�ñ[í ï�ó�ó�ì^ð>!^ñFø�� �-ùÅøVøVï�úVö@ù�#+�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�%;n�õVï>�lõ·í�ù��Åñ[ó¸ñ���îVð�ï��Fï���bõYñ�ù����Fñ[ó�óC�bì�ù^ð�ðBúVìÅúVðsì��Fù^ð�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó<ý}�òJùÅú��|0�365�9876:�ù^ò�ö^ûVñFø(�JõVù��{øYï��:ñ[ò�ñ[ú�����ï�úVøVó�ìÅô£ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó�ó�õVì^ûVð�ø�ûVó�ñ�øVï��:ñ[ò�ñ[ú��R�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷

ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú ó��bò�ù��Jñ[ö^ï�ñ[ó<ýÿK£ì^ò�ñ��DùÅí�îVðsñ�þ��JõVñ��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ-ô�ì^ò�ù$��úVì"n�úUô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú üÀñDý ö:ý�þ2/ ï�úKQïsöÅûVò�ñ��8��Fù^úm�:ñ_ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��Jñ[øUïsú ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<þ)�£ñ��[ùÅûVóJñ�n�ñ���úVì"n ù^ð�ð+ìÅô¸ï>�bó��[ùÅðsð�óJï>�bñFó@ù���[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ��bï�í�ñ,ùÅúVø(�Fù^ú%ðsñ��-�JõVñC�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ò�ù^ð>n0ù"��ó�îVù^ó�ó�ï��Jó{ô�òJñFñ)!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[óQù^óQñ�� �JòJù�ù^ò�ö^ûVí�ñFú �Jó�ýr õVñ/�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ¸ô�ì^ò�ù^ú-ñFó��Fù^îVï�úVö�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú2þ�ìÅú��JõVñ�ì��JõVñ[ò�õYù^úVø2þ�í�ù"�@õVù"!^ñ��bì;�:ñ�ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFøù^ó�ù¸õYñ[ù^î�ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø(n�õVï>�lõ��[ìÅú �Jù^ï�úVó��:ì��Jõ<�JõVñxí�ù��lõYïsúVñx�Fì�øVñ�ù^øVøYòJñFóJó{ìÅôa�JõVñxô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�îVð�ûVó�Vï�úVøVï�úVö^ó@�bì�ù^ð�ðBï��Jóxô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�ý

Page 10: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

Õ!Ö ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

� ë�ìPíÿþ6ù�ø,��î\]að�­��8ð�­*�ð�­�b8ð�­���ðZòhð��.ð+ë õ$ö��b ÷Pø�ù$ë�ì�í�ü�î û8ð��hð�­.×�ðu��õ'ö�!� ÷Pø�ù$ë�ì�íe¯.�8î\¯��ð�¯!b8ð�¯,��ð+ô õ'ö�,Ø þ6ëzô�ù�ü øMí�!Ù ÷�ø�ùzï�ûP÷­���öÚ�Pø�÷�ø�YMù�î@��ð�¯�Põ�!Û ï�ûP÷­*FöÚ�Pø�÷�ø�YMù�î��ð�¯�Põ�!Ü ï�ûP÷­�b'öÚ�Pø�÷�ø�YMù�î�b8ð�¯�Põ�!Ý ï�ûP÷­���öÚ�Pø�÷�ø�YMù�î@��ð�¯�Põ�!Þ þlí°­��aî�­*�ð�­�b8ð�­���ð@¯!b�õ�� øMí�ý! øP÷��Pø"b ÷�ø�ù$ë�ìPíe±!�8î�±��ð@±�b8ð�±!��ð���õ�� ö�ü�î��.ð@±�b8ð�±�ð@±!��õ$Ø ï�ûP÷�ë�ö°��ø�÷�ø�Y6ù�î�Øhð�­.×�õ�Ù ï�ûP÷�ë���öÚ�Pø�÷�ø�YMù�î@��ð+ë õ�Û þlí³ë��aîë�ð@±!�8ð�¯��ð�¯.b8ð�¯.��ð@¯!b�õ�Ü øMí�ý�Ý ï�û�÷v���ö°��ø�÷�ø�Y6ù�î@��ð���õ�Þ þlí���8î��.ð�¯.��ð�­.×�ð,û8ðu�.ð,û8ð�� õb.� ølí�ýb� ï�û�÷ß­.×1ö�î�­���ð�­*�ð�­�b8ð�­���ð+ë õb!b þlízü�î+ò�ð��ð�­.×hð���õb.� ølí�ý

ØVn>�^�D°l��Ø<v`i�jhrIn>dliE�\�,����ylqwrtfbg�jho>dlpav`gaf{jhdliF�lfhgIpan>dli

ë�ì^ú�!^ñFú �JïsìÅúVù^ðG�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�ó�ûVó�ñ��l�� u  µP¾M¼,ºl��NPµ%òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�þhn�õVï>�lõ í�ù"���:ñ@øVñFó��JòJì"�Åñ[øz����ùîVò�ì��[ñ[øYûVòJñx�Fù^ð�ð�þ�ù^úVø��l�  u  µlµ�¼,ºl��NPµ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�þ"n�õVï��lõ�ùÅòJñ�îYòJñFóJñFò�!Åñ[ø�ù��[ò�ì^ó�óR�[ùÅðsð�ó<ý-à{ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óúVì ��ð�ï>!^ñ ù^ôu�Jñ[òx�bõYñ/�[ù^ð�ðBí�ù"�;�£ñ�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ[ø��bì'�l�� u  µP¾M¼,ºl��NPµ,ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJóCn�õVï>�lõ��Fû��bó�øYì"n�ú�ìÅúò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�÷aóJù"!�ï�úVö|�bò�ù�����ý� ñsn�ù^ú��Jñ[ø<�bì�ù^øYù^î��R�JõVïsó0ïsøYñ[ù��bì±ìÅûVò+ë-*�ÿ�ï�ú��bñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ�òJñFîVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^ú2ý � ñxøVï�ø�ó�ì

ù^ó0ô�ì^ð�ðsì"n�ó�0 o�îVî:ñ[ðuù^úVø@ÿVõVù^ìF3M5�5 ��:,�BñFù��lõ_ë-*�ÿY÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFò��Jñ[ø�ûVóJñFò0ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúß��ïsó�îVùÅóJó�ñ[ø�ï>�bóì^ò�øVï�úVù^ò���ù^ò�ö^ûYí�ñFú��bó<þBù��[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úsá�â�þ�ùÅúVøZã-ñ����bò�ù-ù^ò�ö^ûVí�ñ[ú��Jó�á È ¹.ºäºåºä¹ á$æVýr õVñ0ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúz#aò�ñ��JûVò�úVó�%C��� ïsú�!Åì���ïsúYöxá â n�ï>�bõ±ùY#�òJñFóJûYð���%xù^ò�ö^ûVí�ñFú �èçxùÅúVø|�bõYñ�ù^øVøYï��JïsìÅúVù^ðù^ò�ö^ûYí�ñFú��bóQá È"¹.ºäºåºå¹ á æ ý r õ�ûVó�þ��bõVñE#+�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�%�ùÅòJöÅûVí�ñ[ú��bóÁá È`¹,ºåºäºå¹ á æ ù^ò�ñ�õVù^úVøYñ[ø��Vù��M��bì��bõVñ(�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú2ý � õYñ[ú'�JõVï�ó�ë-*0ÿ��[ì�øVñ�ï�ó@�JòJùÅúVó�ðsù �bñ[ø�ï�ú��bì�í�ù �lõVï�úVñ±ï�úVó��JòJû2���bï�ì^úYó�þá È`¹,ºåºäºå¹ á æ n�ï�ðsðYó��Jù"��ï�ú�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó��JõVòJìÅûVö^õYì^û��R�JõVñ�ñ���ñ��Fû��bï�ì^ú�ìÅôp��þ�ûVúVð�ñ[ó�ó���ò�ñ�p�ûVï�òJñFóR�bõVìÅóJñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó�ô�ì^ò{ì��JõVñ[ò{îYûVòJî:ì^ó�ñ[ó<þ`ï�ú<n�õYï��lõ<�[ùÅóJñ&��í%ûVó��Qó�ù"!^ñ�ù^úVø�ò�ñ[ó��bì^ò�ñ��bõVñFí�ý���úVñC�[ìÅûVð�øù^ð�ó�ì)ó�ù"���JõVù��/�JõVñ;�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú ïsó�òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bñ[ø�ïsúsãQé�3%ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó@ü@á â ¹,ºåºåºä¹ á æ �ï�úVó��Jñ[ùÅøì^ô�ïsú4IbûVó��¸ìÅúVñ�î£ìÅïsú��bñFò��bì)ù�í�ñ[í�ìÅò���÷aòJñFóJï�øVñ[ú��D�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�ý�&]ú_ìÅûVò îVòJñ�!�ïsìÅûVóDn�ì^ò��10 o�îVî:ñ[ðù^úYø�ÿVõVùÅì�3M5 5���:]þ�n�ñxì^û2�bð�ïsúVñFøw�bõYïsó�ô�òJùÅí�ñ�n�ì^ò���ù^úYø�øVñ[í�ìÅúVó��JòJù �bñFø;�bõVù ��ï>�G�[ìÅûVð�ø�òJñFøVû��[ñù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú6ù^úYø í�ñ[í�ìÅò��$�JòJù �<��ý1��ì"n0ñ�!^ñFò�þ�n�ñ)øVïsøUúVì ��õVù"!^ñ)ù^ú ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí �Jì ô�ûYðsð>�ñ���îVð�ì^ï>�C�bõVñ/�Yñ���ï��Yïsð�ï��,���bõVù �x�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�îYòJì"!�ï�øVñDýë�ðsìÅóJûVò�ñY�[ò�ñ[ù �bï�ì^úUù^úVøUûVó�ñ��[ùÅúUù^ð�óJìz�:ñ·òJñFîVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bñFø ûVó�ï�úVö$�bõVñ�ë-*�ÿUðsùÅúVö^ûYù^ö^ñ-ï>�b÷

ó�ñ[ð�ô/0 o+îYî£ñFð�ùÅúVø � ïsí 3M5 9�58?.}�ñFðsó�ñ���ù^úVø$��ûVøVù��m3M5 9�5 :�ý � ñ��[ùÅðsð��JõVï�ó��P  ½�ºlÅ�¾ µP¼>¿���ºlºl·u¸"ƺl¹�L" Jµ übë-���/Jý r õVñ¸í�ùÅïsú)øVï>�£ñFòJñFú��[ñ��:ñ��,n�ñ[ñFú ë-��� ù^úVø(ë-*�ÿ�ïsóx�JõVù��,ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó,ï�ú�ë-�C�øVì�úVì��)�[ìÅú �Jù^ï�ú�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�þ^óJì(�bõVñ��;�[ùÅúw�£ñ��JòJùÅúVóJð�ù��Jñ[ø�øYïsò�ñ����bð>��ï�ú��bì�í�ù��lõVï�úVñ@�Fì�øVñDý

Page 11: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe Õ!Õ

&]ú ë-����þ��JõVñ±ô�ìÅòJí�ù^ðBîYù^ò�ù^í�ñ��Jñ[ò�ó�ì^ô�ñ[ù��lõ-ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú��Fì^ò�òJñFóJî:ì^úYø4�bì;�JõVñ|�Jù^ò�ö^ñ��,í�ù��lõYïsúVñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<þ^ùÅúVø)õVñ[ùÅîV÷IùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ[øF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó,ù^ò�ñ¸òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bñ[ø)ù^ó�ë-*0ÿ�ò�ñ��Fì^ò�øVó<ýK�ï�ö^ûYòJñ(7�ð�ï�ó��Jó)�JõVñs�[ì�øVñ+ì^ôBô�ûVú����bï�ì^úÂj.<*9*8±ù^ôu�Jñ[ò)�bò�ù^úVó�ðsù �bï�ì^ú�ï�ú �Jì�ë-����ý£ë�ì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú

ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó�ù^úYø/!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�ü�ñ�ý öuýsþ!Ñ(ê Ò ê@Ó�DùÅòJñ{ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jñ[ø�ù^ó2ùxí�ù��lõVï�úVñ��Fì�øVñ�î:ì^ï�ú��bñ[ò,ü�ñ�ý öuýsþÑ*ÌBþ Ò ÌBþ*Ó*Ì�2îVðsûYós�bõVò�ñ[ñ ñ�� �JòJù��Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ+ù^ò�ö^ûYí�ñFú��bó±ü�ñ�ý öuýsþcÑ-r.ë*Ñ*Åuþ Ò r.ë Ò ÅBþ�Ó-r,ë*Ó*Å�býr õVñ@ìÅòJï�ö^ï�úVù^ð{ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú Ò ü�ï�ú1KQïsöÅûVòJñ;���õVùÅø(ô�òJñFñw!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[óÉÑ(ê�%(ê�w�ê�/() � ï��Jõ1�bõVò�ñ[ñ

�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ+òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�þÑ�ïsó�ò�ñ[îYðsù �[ñ[ø4� ��ô�ìÅûVò�úVñ�n�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó2Ñ*Ì(ê�Ñ-rOê�Ñ*ì(ê�Ñ�ÅBþ�ô�ìÅò,ù^ú@ñ��£ñ��[÷�bï>!^ñ@�bì��Jù^ð£ì^ôuóJñ�!^ñFú2ý � õYñ[ú Ò ïsó0îVù^ó�óJñFø��bì�i-ü�ð�ïsúYñ<3M5�bþ¢�bõVñFóJñxó�ñ�!Åñ[ú�ô�ò�ñ[ñs!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�y îYðsûVó�bõYñ%í�ù��lõYïsúVñ(�[ì�øVñ%î£ìÅïsú��bñFò�ô�ìÅò Ò ~ ó�ñFú��bò��)î:ì^ï�ú��ty�í�ûVó����£ñ%ó�p�ûVñFñ��[ñFø·ï�ú �Jì��JõVñ�ô�ìÅûVò¸îVù^÷ò�ù^í�ñ��Jñ[ò�ó Ò Ì*ë Ò Åuý)ë�ð�ñ[ù^ò�ð>�Dþuï�ô)�JõVñ[ò�ñ�ù^ò�ñ�í�ì^ò�ñ(�JõVù^úz�bõYòJñFñ�ô�òJñFñ<!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó<þuó�ì^í�ñ�ì^ô)�bõVñ�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ¸ù^ò�ö^ûYí�ñFú��bóxí%ûVó��@�£ñ|�:ì"��ñ[ø-ù^úYø�ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bñFø)ï�ú��bõYñ�õVñFù^î2ýGKYìÅòxì^ûVò+ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþn�ñ��YûVïsð�øY�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�Ñ*í;n�õYï��lõ)ïsó@�£ìÅûVúVøY�bì Ò r¸ï�úF�JõVñ/�[ùÅðsðBìÅú�ð�ï�úVñ43M5uý*�ò�ñ�!�ïsìÅûVó<�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ��[ìÅú !Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú(ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí�óY0 ÿ��Jñ[ñ[ð�ñ13M5�7M98?�}�òJùÅú��@ñ���ù^ð]ý�365�9 �8?Ro�îVî:ñ[ð

ù^úYø � ï�í 365�9�5 :�òJñ�p�ûVïsò�ñ�í�ñ[í�ì^ò���ó��bìÅòJñFó{ô�ì^ò�ñFù��lõ��[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�ý�o�ú�ïsí�î:ì^ò��bùÅú �ù^ø2!`ùÅú��[ñ�ï�ú�ìÅûVòQúVñ�nEn0ìÅò���ï�ó��bõVù �Rn0ñ�ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��Jñ�üÀïsú<�bõYïsó{ñ��DùÅí�îVðsñ�£ì^úVð>�±ì^úYñ�ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø�Ñ*í ô�ì^ò�bõYñ�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVó Ò ê�Ó(ê@/Bþ:ùÅúVøz�bõVï�ó±ò�ñ��[ìÅòJø�ïsóA�[ù^ò�ñ[ô�ûYðsð>���lõVìÅóJñFú��Jì��[ì^ú��Jù^ï�ú�ð�ì�ì^îV÷aïsú�!�ù^ò�ï�ù^ú���[ìÅí�î£ìÅúVñ[ú��bó<þDó�ì<�JõVù���ï>�x�[ùÅú��:ñ/�VûVï�ð>�xì^û��JóJï�øVñ��bõYñ�ðsì�ì^î�ýB�ó��[ù^îYïsúVö�ûVó�ñ[ò�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó ü$j.<*9*8�ê�i(ê�%��ù^ò�ñ�úVì"n ò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú �Jñ[ø ù^ó�ùÿ�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø

ü$m-ê�i(ê�%�Jþ,ñ[ù �lõ�n�ï>�bõ ï��Jó�� ¾ Ý =Vñ[ð�ø �:ñ[ï�úVö��bõVñ�í�ù��lõYïsúVñ��[ì�øVñ î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[ò ü$j.<*9*8(ê@i*Ì(ê�%*Ì�JýB�ó��[ùÅîVï�úVö%ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú��[ù^ð�ð�ó�ù^ò�ñ¸ï�í�îVð�ñ[í�ñ[ú��bñFø-ù^ós=Vò�ó���ó�ñ[ð�ñ����bï�úVö;�bõYñ/� ¾ Ý =Vñ[ð�ø2þ�îYðsù �[ï�úVö��bõVñ�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ï>�bó�ñ[ð�ôxïsú6ù_ó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ð�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ü¯�bõVñF=Vò�ó��%ô�ì^ò�í�ùÅð�îVùÅòJùÅí�ñ��bñFò�Jþ2ù^úVø1�JõVñ[ú øVì^ï�úVö·ù#JIbûYí�îYn�ï>�bõ-ù^ò�ö^ûYí�ñFú��bó�%-üÀðsï�úVñ[ó<3MÀ^÷M3M�uþa369^÷M3M5�býî T ê,X`1x5�?�OQP�ê�1%3pï+PBO£52ç 1�3r õVï�ó�óJñ����JïsìÅú6îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bó�ì^ûYò�úYñ�n �FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVíSûVó�ïsúYö��JõVñ-ô�òJùÅí�ñ�n0ìÅò��øVñ�=VúVñ[ø�ï�ú6ÿVñ����bï�ì^ú�´:ým��ûYò�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí �bù �^ñ[ó�ù��[ð�ì^ó�ñ[ø ë-*0ÿ6ñ��DîYòJñFóJó�ïsìÅú�À�ù^ó<�bõYñ)ï�úV÷îVû���þDøVñ��FïsøYñ[óC�bõVñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ+ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jù��bï�ì^ú@ô�ì^ò�ñ[ù��lõ@ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú�øYñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú�ü�ï�úÂÀ¢Jþ^ùÅúVø4�JõVñ[ú�bò�ù^úYóJô�ìÅòJí�ó�À+ï�ú��bì��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aîVù^ó�óJï�úVö%ó��,��ð�ñ�üJë-���/Jýo+ó�n0ñ�ù^ò�ö^ûVñFø�ù��G�JõVñ��£ñFö^ï�úVúVï�úVö�ìÅôBÿVñ����bï�ì^úw´uþ�n�ñ+ûYóJñ�ë-*�ÿ�ù^ó��bõYñ�ï�ú��bñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñxð�ù^úV÷

ö^ûYù^ö^ñ��:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ|n�ñ/n0ùÅú �x�Jìw�bò�ñ[ù ��ù����bï>!`ù �bï�ì^ú-ò�ñ��[ìÅòJøYó�ù^ós�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúF�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó�ý��+ó�ïsúVöë-*�ÿ�í�ù �^ñ[ó+ï��xñFù^ó�ïsñFòs�bì@ñ[úVô�ìÅò��Fñ|�bõVñ�ÿVÿ2ë�îVò�ì^î:ñ[ò��,�DýGKYìÅò+ñ���ùÅí�îYðsñ�þ��bì@õVù"!^ñ�ù;�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅú�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí óJù �bï�óJôu��ÿVÿ2ë�þ0ù^ð�ð�n0ñ·úYñ[ñ[ø ïsóF�bì6í�ù �^ñ�óJûVò�ñ��JõVù��F�bõVñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ññ[ú�!�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú�� ô�ì^ò�ñ[ù �lõ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú�yEn�õYñ��bõYñ[ò±ï>��ïsó�ù�ûYóJñFò�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú�ì^ò�ùY�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú�y÷aì^úVð>���[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVó�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó��bõVù ��ù^ò�ñ��bò�ûVð��_ô�òJñFñ�ï�úz�bõVñ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú��:ì�ø��Dý r õYïsó�ï�ó/�£ñ��[ùÅûVóJñù^ð�ðh�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ðh�JòJùÅúVó�ô�ñ[ò�ó�ïsú6ë-*0ÿ�ù^ò�ñ¸ò�ñ[ùÅðsï>�[ñFø-ù^óxô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú��Fù^ð�ðsó"?�ù �xù^ú���îYòJìÅö^ò�ù^í î:ì^ï�ú��`þ�ùð�ì �Fù^ð8!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vðsñ@�bõVù ��ï�ó0úVì%ðsìÅúVö^ñFò�ð�ï�!Åñ@�Fù^ú�úVì �)�:ñ+ô�ò�ñ[ñ�ïsúw�JõVñ��[ûVò�òJñFú����[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú2þ^ù^úYø!�ï��FñD!Åñ[ò�óJùuýh&]ô��bõVñ��[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[òC�Fù^ú@ìÅúVð>��ïsú�!^ì �^ñxöÅù^ò��Vù^öÅñs�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bï�ì^ú�ù����bõVñ��:ñ[ö^ï�úVúVï�úVö�ì^ô�ùô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú6ü¯n�õVï��lõ-ï�óx�bò�ûVñ�ô�ì^ò+ÿ������ � � 0 o+îVî:ñ[ðC3M5 5���:,bþ �JõVñ[ò�ñ ïsó+úVì�úVñ[ñFøY�bì�ï�í�î:ì^ó�ñ�ù^ú��ù^øYøVï��JïsìÅúVù^ðBò�ñ�p�ûVï�ò�ñ[í�ñ[ú��,ïsúYóJï�øVñ��bõVñ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú��£ì�ø���ýr õVñ�ó�ïsí�îVð�ñ[ó��/n0ù"���bì�ñFúVô�ì^ò��[ñ�ÿVÿ�ë ï�óA�Jì�ù^ð>n0ù"��ó�ûVó�ñ;�Vù �|�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó�ù^úYø��Jì·ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��Jñ

ñ�!Åñ[ò����bõVï�úVö_ìÅúE�JõVñ-õVñ[ùÅî2ý r õVï�ó�ï�ó<�FðsñFù^ò�ð��(ï�úVñ��<�FïsñFú��<�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñF�VûVï�ðsøVï�úVöz�Vù �(�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[óï�ú !Åì^ð>!^ñFó¸ñ����[ñ[ó�ó�ï�!Åñ<�Fì^î���ïsúYö:þuùÅúVø�í�ñFí�ì^ò��·ù����[ñ[ó�ó�ï�ó�í�û��lõ�ó�ðsì"n�ñ[ò��bõYù^ú�òJñFù^øVï�úVö-ô�ò�ì^íò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<ý���ûVò�í�ùÅïsú±ï�øVñFùxïsó-�bì�õVù"!^ñ{ñFù��lõ/�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ��Fì^ú��bùÅïsú/�JõVñ0ó�ù^í�ñ�ó�ñ��2ì^ô�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óü�ùÅó,ûVúVøVñFò��JõVñ��Vù��,ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jù��bï�ì^ú-��Vû��,ûVó�ñ¸ù%úVñ�n ð�ù"�^ìÅû��G�JõVù��,ô�ù��Fïsð�ï>�bù��Jñ[ó,ó�õVù^ò�ïsúYö�ù^úYø�bù �^ñFó{ù^ø�!�ù^ú��Jù^ö^ñ,ìÅô£ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ý���ûVò��Åñ��|�Jñ��lõVúYï�p�ûVñ�ï�ó��bì�ñ���îVðsìÅï��R�JõVñs�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñF÷��Jïsí�ñ�øVù �bù^÷�Vì"n ù^úVøm�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð�÷+�Vì"n ï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��bï�ì^úÿ�Jì$�VûVï�ðsø#ó�ù^ô�ñFð�� ðsï�ú��Åñ[øÿ�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó�üÀóJñFñ�ÿVñ����bï�ì^úm�8ù^úYøF�Jì�ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bñ��[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó,ï�úF�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ+ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó±ü�ó�ñ[ñ ÿVñ����JïsìÅúF´uý ��býx��ûVò

Page 12: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

ÕP] ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

Õ Õððððð ñòòòòòò ó

ô¬õ@ö�÷ ø ù

ú

ØVn>�^��U^������f{fh�[rIfhi�e`fbe@��ÞQª�jhylo>oD�lgIylm��¸qwdlg�qsv�i`jbrtn>dliE�\�,���ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí óJù �bï�ó�=Yñ[ó��JõVñ�ÿVÿ2ë�ò�ûVðsñx�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ�ò�ñ[ö^ùÅòJøYðsñFóJóQì^ô8n�õVù ��ì^î��Jïsí�ï>�[ù �bï�ì^úVóRn�ñ�øVì:þ¢n0ñï�úVóJï�ó��x�bõVù �x�bõVñ/�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ¸ô�ì^ò�ñ[ù �lõ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú)ìÅúVð>�w�[ìÅú �Jù^ï�ú�ï>�bó+ì"n�ú�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó<ý

��ûVò�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí øVì�ñ[ó)úVì��)ûVó�ñ_ù^ú��Uò�ûVú��bï�í�ñ�ó��Jù��M�ÿ�Vû��)ì^ûYò@í�ù^ï�ú��Jñ��lõVúVï>p�ûVñ�üÀï�ý ñDý�þûVó�ïsúYö�øVù��Jù^÷+�Vì"n ùÅúVø��[ìÅú �JòJìÅðs÷+�Vì"n#ï�úVô�ìÅòJí�ù��JïsìÅúY�bìw�VûYïsð�ø�óJùÅô�ñ[ð>�@ð�ïsú2�^ñ[øY�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó+ù^úVøY�bìù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JñD�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó�ï�ú�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó"�ï�ó�ù^ð�ó�ì�ù^îYîVðsï>�[ù �Vð�ñ��Jì%ó��bù �M��÷��VùÅóJñFø�ï�í�îYðsñFí�ñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVó<ý-&]úô�ù����`þ�ì^úVñF�[ùÅú6ó��bï�ðsð�ûVó�ñ(ë-*�ÿ6ùÅó��bõVñ-ï�ú �Jñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ�ð�ù^úVöÅûVù^öÅñ4n�õVï�ð�ñ)ó�ûVîVî:ì^ò��bï�úVö ó��Jù��M�ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅúz0 }�òJùÅú��;3M5�9�7�? �·ìÅòJò�ïsó�ñ����0ñ���ù^ð]ý�3M5 5�9�:]ý&]ú$�bõVñ�òJñFó��±ìÅôC�bõVï�ó�ó�ñ����bï�ì^ú2þ.n�ñ�îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú���ì^ûVò%úVñ�n �FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷+�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅú_ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí ï�ú

øVñ��bù^ï�ð]ý���ûVò�ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí �Fì^úVó�ïsó��bó�ìÅôxô�ì^ûVò�ó��bñFîVó�þ�ñ[ù �lõ ì^ôDn�õVï��lõ ïsó�ï�í�îVð�ñ[í�ñ[ú��bñFø ùÅó%ùó�ñ[îVùÅòJù �bñ¸îVù^ó�ó�ì"!^ñFò��JõVñ�ù��Yó��JòJù ����ó���ú��bù ��ì^òx�JõVñ/�[ùÅðsðBöÅòJùÅîVõ.�üt3 (�[ù^ð>�[ûYðsù �bñ��bõVñ/�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð�÷+�Vì"n ïsúYô�ì^ò�í�ù �bï�ì^úF���w�[ìÅúVó��JòJû2���bï�úVö��bõYñ/�[ù^ð�ðBö^ò�ù^îYõ.?üu��(=VúVøY�bõVñ�ó�ñ��,ìÅô2ò�ù"n#ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�ù^úVøF�bõYñ[ï�òxðsï�ô�ñ��Jïsí�ñ�ï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��JïsìÅú.?üu´�%òJûVúF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aó��JòJù �bñFö���ù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsóC�Jì�øYñ��bñFòJí�ï�úVñ/n�õVñFòJñ��bì�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ¸ñ[ù��lõF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ ?üu��%øVñ��FïsøVñ@�bõVñD�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ+ðsù"�Åì^û��{ùÅúVøw�bò�ù^úYóJô�ìÅòJíq�bõVñ�îVòJìÅö^ò�ù^í ïsú��bìA�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñF÷IîYù^ó�óJï�úVö ó��,��ð�ñDýo+í�ìÅúVöw�bõYñ[ó�ñ�øVï>�£ñFòJñFú��xîVò�ì �Fñ[øVûYòJñFó�þ��bõVñ%ì^úVð>���JõVï�úVöw�bõYù��+ù �£ñ����Jó@�bõYñ�ÿVÿ2ë�îYòJìÅî£ñFò��,��ïsón�õVñ��bõVñFòD�JõVñ(�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ±ô�ìÅò�ñFù��lõ·ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú_ì^úYð��Y�[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVó�ï��Jó¸ì"n�ú_ô�òJñFñA!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó<ýxBG!Åñ[ò���÷�bõYïsúVö_ñ[ð�óJñwn�ñ�øVìuþ2óJû��lõ(ùÅóA�Fù^ð>�[ûVð�ù��JïsúVö��JõVñ4�Fù^ð�ð�öÅòJùÅîVõ2þ�=VúVøVï�úVö��JõVñ4!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ�ðsï�ô�ñ��Jïsí�ñï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��bï�ì^ú�þuù^úVøz�JõVñ;�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aó��JòJù �bñ[ö �-ù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsó<þuù^ò�ñ�õVñ[ûVò�ï�ó��Jï��Fó±ô�ì^ò�ï�øVñ[ú��Jïsôu��ï�úVö�í�ì^ò�ñ�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ó�õVùÅòJï�úVö�ù^úVø)ô�ì^ò�í�ù �Dï�úVö��:ñ��t�Jñ[òxûYóJñ�ìÅô�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<ýî T æ P,û�K]=FAÅMD=[M�ê�WY5)ZF9<;>;SµÅGI9�´�üo �[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ@ô�ì^ò�ù_ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�í�ûVó��A�Fì^ú��bùÅïsú6ù^ð�ð0ìÅôxï��Jó�ô�òJñFñ4!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó<þ�õYì"n0ñ�!^ñ[ò<þ2øVï>�£ñFòJñFú �!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó�í�ïsöÅõ��x�£ñ±ûYóJñFø)ùÅðsìÅúVö�øVï>�£ñFòJñFú ��îYòJìÅö^ò�ù^í îVù �bõVó%üÀï�ý ñDý�þ��Fì^úVøYï��JïsìÅúVù^ðh�YòJùÅú��lõVñ[ó"bý�+ì"n ô�òJñ�p�ûVñ[ú��bð>�w�JõVñ[ó�ñ�îVù��JõVó�ù^ò�ñ ñ���ñ��Fû��bñFø-ù��,òJûYú �Jïsí�ñ/�Fù^ú)ù��:ñ����x�JõVñ�ì^î2�bï�í�ùÅð��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñð�ù"�^ì^û2�`ý�K£ì^òQñ���ùÅí�îYðsñ�þ��bõVñx�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú Ò ï�ú�K�ï�ö^ûYòJñ����[ì^ú��Jù^ï�úVó��,n0ì��Vò�ù^ú��lõVñFó��

ë6ì�íZ¯2îô õ�ö³þ�ë�ô�ù�ü øMíÚ­�î û�õø�÷���ø�ë�î�±8ð�û�õ

ë�ð�ñ[ù^ò�ð>�DþèÑ-ïsó ô�ò�ñ[ñ%ïsú��bõVñQ<*/*9�n��Vò�ù^ú��lõ�ù^úVøÂ%-ïsó ô�ò�ñ[ñ�ïsú��bõVñQ9*;O:.9F�Vò�ù^ú��lõ�ý@&]ô)n0ñ%ì^úVð>�õVù"!Åñ+ì^úYñ+ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò)�bì�óJîYù^ò�ñDþ�n0ñ�n0ìÅûVð�ø�ù����[ì^í�í�ì�øVù��JñD%<=Vò�ó����:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ@�bõYñ�9*;-:.9A�YòJùÅú��lõõVùÅîVî£ñFúVós�Jì<�:ñ�ï�úF�JõVñ�í�ïsøYøVðsñ�ìÅô2ù�ð�ì�ì^î2ý

��ûVò@=Vò�ó��xó��Jñ[î�ï�ó@�JõDûYóD�Jìw�[ùÅð��FûVðsù �bñ|�JõVñ|�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð�÷��Yì"n ï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��bï�ì^ú�ìÅô��bõVñ%ïsúVîYû��+îVò�ì^÷ö^ò�ù^í·ý � ñ�ùÅòJñ,ï�ú �Jñ[ò�ñ[ó��bñFø%ï�ú�ûVóJï�úVö ó�û��lõ�ïsúVô�ìÅòJí�ù �bï�ì^ú<�bì ïsøYñ[ú��bï�ôu�%ð�ì�ì^îVó{ùÅúVø<�bì�øVì ó��bù��Jï���Vò�ù^ú��lõ)îVò�ñ[øVï>���JïsìÅúz0 �,ù^ð�ðBù^úVøY�2ù^ò�ûVó|3M5�5 ´�:]ýBG!^ñFò�� ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�øVñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú�ï�ú�ë-*�ÿ�ñFúVøVóRn�ï>�bõ%ù�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú<�[ùÅðsð]ý � ñ,ó�ù"�Á�vR�·u¾ µl�P¹� zL/�l�  u  º

�)ï�ô{ï�ú��bõVñ(�£ì�ø��)ì^ôý��þ2�bõYñ[ò�ñ±ñ���ï�ó��Jó+ù�îVù �bõ��JõVù��+ñ[úVøVó�n�ï>�bõ·ùw�Fù^ð�ð��JìQ��ý�K£ì^ò�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþï�ú�KQï�ö^ûVò�ñD�uþ �[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú Ò øVïsò�ñ����bð>�;�[ùÅðsð�óýÑ�ù^úVø7%;�Vû��,úVì �ý/�ñ�!^ñFú4�JõVì^ûVöÅõ��JõVñ��[ùÅðsð��bì%;n�ì^ûVð�ø)ïsú�!^ì �^ñ�Ó�ùÅúVø��JõVñ[ú-ï�úVøVï�òJñ����Jð��7/�ù^óxn�ñ[ð�ð�ý

Page 13: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe ÕP±

þ�ï�!Åñ[ú-ù·ë-*�ÿ)ñ���îVò�ñ[ó�óJï�ì^ú�À�þDï��Jóxñ����bñFúVøVñFø(ë-*0ÿ��Fù^ð�ð�ö^ò�ù^îYõ@ï�óxù�øVïsò�ñ����bñFø)öÅòJùÅîVõ4n�ï>�bõ�bõYñ�óJñ���ì^ô�ï��Jóxô�ûVú����bï�ì^úV÷aøVñ�=YúVï��JïsìÅúY!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�ù^ó�úVì�øVñFó�ù^úVøYn�ï>�bõ-ñ[øVöÅñ[ó�ô�ò�ì^íÿ¼ È �bìÁ¼ # ï�ôüt3 ~¼ È øVïsò�ñ����bð>�Y�[ù^ð�ð�óý¼ # þ£ìÅò�üu��p¼ È øVïsò�ñ����bð>���Fù^ð�ðsó�óJìÅí�ñ±ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú'n�ï>�bõa¼ # ù^ó�ï��Jó�ò�ñ��JûVò�ú�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú�ý|K£ì^ò�ñ[ù �lõ_úVì�øVñɼ�þ�n�ñ�ù^ð�óJì)øVñ�=YúVñÁ¼h~ ó�îVò�ñ[øVñ��[ñFóJó�ì^ò¸óJñ��`þ�¿8¾ µ�R�ü¿¼hJþ�ùÅó��bõVñó�ñ��@ìÅô ù^ð�ð�úVì�øVñFó4�JõVù���õVù"!^ñ·ùÅú ñ[øVöÅñ·î:ì^ï�ú �JïsúYö³�bì�¼�ýHK�ï�ö^ûYòJñ�96ö^ï>!^ñ[ó��bõVñ�ñ����bñFúVøVñFøë-*�ÿ��[ùÅðsð{öÅòJùÅîVõ·ô�ì^ò��JõVñ�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúÍj,<*9*8Bý�o+ð>�bõVìÅûVö^õ Ò ï�ó�úVì�� øVï�òJñ����Jð����Fù^ð�ðsñFø'��� /Bþ8n0ñ�[ìÅúVó�ñ[ò�!`ù �bï>!^ñFð�� ùÅóJó�ûVí�ñ��bõYù��Ei³n�ïsð�ð+ñ�!^ñ[ú��JûVù^ð�ð��E�[ùÅðsðxï>�bó�òJñ��bûVò�úm�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú Ò ý r õVñîVò�ñ[øVñ��[ñFóJó�ì^ò,ó�ñ��,ì^ô>/;�[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVóx�,n�ì%ñFðsñFí�ñ[ú��bó<þ j.<*9�8�ùÅúVøvÓuýr õVñ�ñ����bñ[úYøVñ[ø(ë-*�ÿ��[ù^ð�ð:ö^ò�ù^îVõw�Fù^î��JûVò�ñ[ó,ù%ó�ï�í�îYðsñ¸óJñ��0ìÅôh�[ìÅú��bò�ì^ð�÷��Vì"nUï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��JïsìÅú2ý �

ë-���[ð�ñ[ó2ïsú|�JõVñ�öÅòJùÅîVõ�ï�í�îYð�� ð�ìDìÅîVó�ìÅò�ò�ñ��FûVòJó�ï�ì^úVó"?Fô�ì^ò�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþFô�ì^ò.�bõVñ0ö^ò�ù^îVõ�ï�ú|KQïsöÅûVò�ñ�9:þ�bõYñ�îVù��Jõ�ô�òJìÅí /��Jì Ò �JìßÓ·ù^úYø��Yù��M���Jìß/·ô�ì^ò�í�ó�ù�ðsì�ìÅî2ý r õVñ�úYñ[ó��bï�úVö�õVï�ñ[ò�ù^ò��lõ ��ìÅôð�ìDìÅîVóx�[ùÅúY�£ñ±ò�ñ�!Åñ[ùÅðsñFø4���@ò�ûVúVúVï�úVö;�JõVñ�ïsú��Jñ[ò�!`ùÅð�ù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�ó/0 �·û��lõYúVï��M�z3M5 587�? �s��øVñFòxù^úYø*{ù^ûYðsðh3M5 9���? r ùÅò¯IbùÅúF36587M� :�ýh&]ú��bûVï>�bï>!^ñFð���þ�ù^ú�ïsú��Jñ[ò�!`ùÅð�ïsó{ñFï��JõVñ[ò�ù¸úYù��bûYòJùÅðDð�ì�ì^î2þ<ù¸í�ù �Dï�í�ù^ðù������[ð�ï���ó�û��Vö^ò�ù^îYõ2þ:ì^ò�ù-í�ïsúYïsí�ù^ð{ï�ò�òJñFøVû��[ï>�Vð�ñ�òJñFö^ï�ì^ú.?h�bõVñ�ï�ú��bñ[ò�!�ù^ðQù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�ó�îVù^ò��bï>�bï�ì^úVó�bõYñ�óJñ���ìÅô£úYìDøYñ[ó{ï�ú �Jì øVïsóZIbì^ï�ú��{ïsú��Jñ[ò�!`ùÅðsó<þPn�ï>�bõ�ñ[ù �lõ%ï�ú��bñ[ò�!�ù^ð�ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��JïsúVö¸ù îVò�ì^î:ñ[òQðsì�ìÅîð�ù"�^ñ[ò,ìÅò�ù^ú)ïsò�òJñFøVû��Fï��Vð�ñ òJñFö^ï�ì^ú2ý&]ú �JûVï>�bï>!^ñ[ð>�DþBù^ú_ï�ú��bñFò�!�ù^ðQï�ó�ñ[ï>�bõVñFò ù�úVù �bûVò�ù^ðQð�ì�ì^î2þ:ù)í�ù���ïsí�ùÅð�ù �����[ð�ï>�%ó�û��VöÅòJùÅîVõ2þ:ì^ò

ù@í�ï�úVï�í�ùÅðQïsò�òJñFøVû��Fï��Vð�ñ�ò�ñ[öÅïsìÅú.?a�bõVñ�ï�ú �Jñ[ò�!�ù^ð�ù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsó�îVù^ò��bï>�bï�ì^úVó��bõYñ%ó�ñ��¸ì^ô�úYìDøYñ[ó¸ïsú��bìøVï�ó¯IbìÅïsú���ï�ú��bñ[ò�!�ù^ð�ó�þ n�ï>�bõ�ñFù��lõ@ï�ú��bñFò�!�ù^ðBò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú �JïsúYö�ù�îVò�ì^î:ñ[ò,ð�ì�ì^î-ðsù"�Åñ[ò<ýþ�ï�!Åñ[ú@ù%ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú)øVñ�=VúYï��JïsìÅú ��ï�ú@ù-ë-*�ÿ@îYòJìÅö^ò�ù^í À<þ n�ñ�øYñ�=VúVñÁ��~ ó/  ½P½M¿z  µ!N�µP >þ���ü���bþ

ù^óD�bõVñ�úVñ[ó��bï�úVö�øVñFî��bõ_ì^ôQï��Jó+ï�ú��bñ[ò�!�ù^ð2ïsú��JõVñ±ñ�� �Jñ[úVøYñ[ø ë-*0ÿF�Fù^ð�ð�öÅòJùÅîVõ-ì^ôFÀ�þVùÅóJó�ûVí�ïsúYö�bõYñ¸ìÅû��bí�ìÅó���ïsú��Jñ[ò�!`ùÅðuïsó�ù �0øVñFî��bõF�:ý.K£ì^ò,ù^ú��;!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñD�JõVù���øVì�ñ[ó�úVì �0øYïsò�ñ����bð>��øVñ�=VúYñ¸ùô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú ü�ñ�ý öuýsþ*Ñ(ê�%(ê�i�ïsúYKQïsöÅûVò�ñ���bþDï>�bóxð�ì�ì^î)ðsñ�!^ñFðBïsó�ùÅóJó�ïsöÅúVñ[ø��bì;�:ñ��:ý r õVñ ð�ìDìÅî�ð�ñ�!Åñ[ðì^ô�ñ[ù �lõ4�Fù^ð�ð�ô�òJìÅí �4�JìÁ�@ïsó�øYñ�=VúVñFø-ù^ó"�

��ü�� ¹ ���� T(·u¸�ü���ü@�� ¹ �,üå��tbýþ�ï>!^ñ[ú�ù ë-*�ÿ�ñ���îVò�ñ[ó�ó�ïsìÅú)øYñ�=VúVñFø·ï�úVóJï�øVñ|�JõVñA�:ì�ø��-ì^ôQô�ûVú����bï�ì^úÚ��þ�n0ñ�øVñ[øVû2�[ñ�ï>�bó�ðsì�ìÅîð�ñ�!^ñFð��Vù^ó�ñ[ø)ì^úF�bõYñ�ô�ì^ð�ðsì"n�ï�úVö�ïsúYøVû����Jï�!Åñ�îVò�ì �Fñ[øVûYòJñ��y���ü$j.%a·É<�/*9*nvÀ È 9*;O:.9vÀ # �� T(�{ü���ü�À È ¹ ��ü�À # t�?y���ü�;*9*<vÃ7j.naÀÐ9*n*l��� ��ü�À¢t?y���ü@·Vü�· È þ º.º,º þz· » ������ü���þz·�2ï�ô(·±ï�ó�ù��[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú.?DùÅúVøÚT(�Qü���ü���þè·�Jþ���ü���þè· È t�ï�ô(·�ïsóù�ûYóJñFò�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú-ù^úVø�· È ïsó�ï>�bó+òJñ��bûVò�ú��Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú2ýr õVñ0ð�ì�ì^îV÷að�ñ�!^ñFð^ú�ûVí(�£ñFò2ï�ó2ûYóJñFøA�bì�ù^ó�óJï�ö^ú�ù�îVò�ïsìÅòJï>�,�D�Jì+ñFù��lõ±îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí îVù �bõ�y�ù¸õVïsöÅõVñ[ò

ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�í�ñFù^úVó�ï>�±ï�ó�úVñ[ó��bñFø(øVñ[ñFî£ñFò�ïsúYóJï�øVñ�ð�ìDìÅîVó|�JõDûYó±ï��/�Fì^ûVð�øz�£ñ;�Jù��Åñ[ú í�ìÅòJñ�ìÅôu�bñFúù��+òJûVú��Jïsí�ñDý�K£ì^òxñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþYïsú�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úZj,<*9*8Bþ��bõYñ�ð�ìDìÅî�ðsñ�!^ñFð�ô�ì^òD!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFóÁj.<�9*8BþcÑBþH%Bþù^úYø�i�ï�ó/�8?h�bõVñ�ð�ì�ì^î ðsñ�!^ñFð{ô�ì^òW/Bþ Ò þ:ù^úVø�Ó�ï�ó43^ýA&]úz�bõVñ;�Fì^úVøVï>�bï�ì^úYù^ðQó��Jù��Jñ[í�ñ[ú��Ej.%Í6<*/*9�n )�)*) 9*;-:.9Î)*)�)�ï�úVó�ïsøVñ@�bõVñ¸øVñ�=YúVï��JïsìÅú�ì^ô Ò þ¢�bõVñ&<�/*9*n(�VòJùÅú��lõ;�[ùÅðsð�óG�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúÑ�ùÅúVøY�bõVñÉ9�;-:.9��Vò�ù^ú��lõF�[ùÅðsð�óÐ%@ù^úVøaÓBý��,ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ���ü Ò ¹ Ó��� T(·u¸�ü���ü��� ¹ ��ü��(t��{3¸ù^úYø��ü Ò ¹ Ñ���1�uþ^ó�ìA�JõVñx9*;O:.9(�Vò�ù^ú��lõ�ï�ó,í�ì^ò�ñ+ð�ï��Åñ[ð>�;�bì<�£ñ��bù �^ñ[ú�ý r õYñD=VúYù^ð��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ+ð�ù"�^ì^û2�ó�õVì^ûVð�ø)îVû��xù�õVï�ö^õVñFò�îVò�ïsìÅòJï>�,��ì^ú)í�ù���ïsúYö<�JõVñW9*;-:,9��YòJùÅú��lõ�ò�ûVú)ô�ù^ó��bñFò�ýî T à O£9�����Ga=[=�E`9FGaC>9��Å;>=FH���C>K@ü�;>C���=[K]C���=r ì_ï�í�îYðsñFí�ñFú��A�bõYñ@ó�ù^ô�ñ[ð>��÷Ið�ï�ú��^ñFø$�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó�þ�n�ñ4n�ù^ú��|�bì�ö^ò�ì^ûVî$!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ïsú��bì��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñò�ñ��[ìÅòJøYó�ï�ôG�JõVñ��·õYù"!^ñ�óJï�í�ïsð�ù^ò ð�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ�ý|&]ô)!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vðsñ�¼ È ïsó�øYñ�=VúVñFø�í%û��lõ_ð�ù��Jñ[ò��bõYù^ú ¼ # þ� ªJ��n>�lfhgIp{Ê>¯+[M[^¯a×�m�gafhpIfbi[rtfbexpIfb�lfhgIylo^rtfhj���i�n��[v�fhp�rI�`ylrujhyli+�`i�e�k,dlgaf�yljhjhv�gaylrtfQjhdli[rIgIdlo>�¤��d�~@n>i�qwdlgak,ylrtn>dliV�

Page 14: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

Õ Ë ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

��yl��o>f��b�ÿ\�y�~-qwgafhf{�Jylgan>yl��o>fhp�yli�e¸jho>dlpIv�gaf{pIrIgIylrIfh�ln>fhpÌ Ô�Ò! ,Î`Ñ�Í�Ò ÒPÎ`Ï<Î�Õ�"¸Ô�Ð$#YÕFÌ %xÏ�& Ì Ì�Õ[Õ�'xÏ<Ì�ÑsÏ�# Í Õ[Ö Ï Í Í�ÖbÔ�Ì�Õ�ÒPÎ`Ì�Ï�Î`ÕFÎ Ô�\�,��� ¯ ( ¯2pao>dlr£ T )lz+*�,VT-,VT^}.,Jz0/�,¤¥-,¤¥^}.,hz�¡1,¤¥-,¤¥^}.,hz¿£�,�¨-,�¨^}32 T,pao>dlrtp4 ¥ )lz5/1,¤¥-,¤¥^}.,Jzu¡�,¤¥-,¤¥^}.,hz ª ,¤¥-,¤¨^}.,hz¿£�,�¨-,�¨^}32 ¥,pao>dlrtp6 ¨ )lz ª ,¤¨-,¤¨^}.,hz¿£�,¤¨-,¤¨^}32 ¥,pao>dlrtp

¼ � þ:ùÅúVøv¼87�þ8�bõVñFú'n�ñ�í�ù"��úYì��¸õVù"!^ñ±ñFúVì^ûYö^õ·ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJós�Jì�õYì^ð�øv¼ # �Jì�¼87<n�õVï�ðsñ<n0ùÅï��JïsúYöô�ì^ò(¼ È ý.&]ô�n�ñ�ó�ù"!^ñм # �bì�¼87¸ï�ú��bì�ù<�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�þÅù^úVøk¼ # ~ ó�ðsùÅó���ûVó�ñ¸ï�ó,í�û��lõ)ñ[ùÅòJð�ï�ñ[ò��bõVùÅú�¼ � ~ óì^ò2¼87�~ ó<þ��JõVñ[ú-ó�õVù^ò�ïsúYö(�JõVïsó@�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ¸í�ïsöÅõ���úVì���ì �£ñ��w�bõVñ�ÿYÿ2ë ò�ûVð�ñDý�·ì^ó��@�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷+�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅú@ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí�ó�0 o�îVî:ñ[ðx3M5�5 �8?2}�òJùÅú���365�987 ?�ÿ��Jñ[ñFðsñY3M58769�:�ó��bùÅò��

���E�Fù^ð>�[ûVð�ù��JïsúYö1�bõVñ ó�ñ���ìÅô�ô�òJñFñ'!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó�ô�ìÅò@ñ[ù �lõ ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú øYñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú�ý r õVñFóJñ·ô�ò�ñ[ñ!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó�ùÅòJñ��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ø�¾t��V$»P¾ µlµaN�� ¾M·u��PP  µ�º/�£ñ��[ùÅûVóJñF�bõYñ���í�ù"���:ñ-óJû2�Vó��Jï��Jû��bñFø³���(ù_ó�ñ��ì^ô{ì �bõVñFòD!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�øVûVò�ïsúYö4�bõYñ(�JòJùÅúVóJð�ù��JïsìÅú2ýCK£ì^ò¸ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþ£ï�ô>�-ï�ó¸ô�òJñFñ�ï�úVóJï�øVñ0��þYùÅúVøv��[ìÅòJò�ñ[ó�î:ì^úVøVó-�bì¸ù���úVì"n�úV÷aô�ûVú����JïsìÅú�øVñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú2þ"�bõVñFú<�JõVñC�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ô�ì^òý��í�ûVó��Qù^ð�óJì��[ìÅú �Jù^ï�ú��~ ó�ô�òJñFñD!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó<ý � ñ¸ûVó�ñ;¹+¾MÅ�µ�»P¾ µlµ�NP��¾M·u�P�  µPº��Jì�øVñFúVì��JñD�JõVñ¸óJñ��0ìÅôh!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó)�JõVù���n�ï�ðsð�:ñ/=VúVù^ð�ð>��îVû��xï�ú��bì��bõYñ�ù����JûVù^ð��FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�ýr õVñ+ó�ñ��Fì^úVø�ó��bñFî�ì^ôBì^ûYò�ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí ï�óG�bõ�ûVó��bì(�[ùÅð��FûVðsù �bñx�JõVñ+ó�ñ��0ì^ôBò�ù"n ô�ò�ñ[ñs!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó

�bìÅö^ñ��bõVñFò;n�ï��JõE�JõVñ[ï�ò�ð�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ�ï�úVô�ìÅòJí�ù��JïsìÅú2ýEKYìÅò;�bõVñ�îVûYòJî:ì^ó�ñ�ìÅôD�FðsìÅóJûYòJñF�[ìÅú !Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú�þ!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó|�JõVù���ù^ò�ñ�ðsï>!^ñ�ïsú³�bõVñ�óJùÅí�ñ@óJñ���ì^ô�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúVó(�Fù^ú$�:ñ4�JòJñFù��bñFø ù^ó%õVù"!�ïsúYö��bõVñó�ù^í�ñ�ð�ï�ô�ñ��bï�í�ñDý � ñ ûVó�ñ;ºl¹+�MÆ�µA¸2ÅcTÁPlµ�¾R�bì�í�ñ[ù^ó�ûVò�ñ�ó�û��lõ�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúV÷aðsñ�!^ñ[ðBð�ï�ô�ñ��bï�í�ñDýýþ�ï>!^ñFúù�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú-øVñ�=YúVï��JïsìÅú���þ�ï��Jó�ó��Jù^öÅñ¸ú�ûVí(�£ñFò�þ:9<; ü@���ï�óxøVñ�=VúVñ[ø-ùÅó�ô�ì^ð�ðsì"n�ó"�y=9�; ü@�����3�ïsô2�@ï�ós�JõVñ�ì^û��Jí�ì^ó���ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú.?y=9�; ü@�����3ýé�9�; üå���ï�ô(��ïsóxù�ûVó�ñ[ò�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú)ùÅúVøE��ïsí�í�ñ[øYïsù �bñ[ð>��ñFú��[ð�ì^ó�ñ[óx��?y=9�; ü@�����3ýéZT(�?>@9�;(üå��BA��DCY¿�¾ µ�RBü@���E�ï�ô2�@øVñ�=VúVñ[ó+ù<�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú2ýþ�ï�!Åñ[ú(ù�ë-*0ÿ$�[ùÅðsð0ö^ò�ù^îVõZ|�þ-�:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñw�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú(ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó%ùÅòJñ�úVñ�!^ñFò�ò�ñ��[ûYòJó�ï�!Åñ

ì^ò�í�û��JûVù^ð�ð>��òJñ��[ûVò�óJï>!^ñ�þ��JõVñ(�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú�óJû2�Vö^ò�ù^îVõ�ìÅô�| ü�ï]ý ñDý�þ8� �-ï�ú��[ð�ûVøVï�úVö)ì^úVð>�F�bõVñ�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú�úVì�øVñFó��í%ûVó��|�£ñ@ô�òJñFñ�ì^ôC�����[ð�ñ[ó<ý r õYñ�ó��Jù^öÅñ�úDûYíA�:ñ[ò|�JõDûYóA�[ùÅî��bûYòJñFó/�bõVñì^ò�øVñFò�ì^ô¸ù^ð�ðxô�ûVú����bï�ì^úV÷aòJñ��bûVò�úUî£ìÅïsú��Jó�ïsúm�JõVñ�ì^ò�ï�ö^ï�úVù^ð�îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí·ý�&]ú�ùÅøVøVï>�bï�ì^ú2þ0ï>��ù^ð�ó�ì�[ùÅî��bûYòJñFóx�bõVñ�#�ñ[ú��FðsìÅóJï�úVö�%-ü�ìÅò�úVñ[ó��bï�úVö8�ò�ñ[ð�ù��JïsìÅúVó�õVïsî)ô�ì^ò�ùÅðsðBûYóJñFò�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVó<ý� ñ��[ùÅú_úVì"n øYñ�=VúVñ��JõVñ'Å�º�µ;¹+·uT<µ�ô�ì^ò ñ[ù �lõ·ûVó�ñ%ìÅô�ù4!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ�¼�ùÅóF9�; ü@��Gn�õVñFòJñ7�

ï�ó<�JõVñ)úVñ[ùÅòJñFó��%ñ[ú��FðsìÅóJï�úVö_ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú6øVñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú ü�ô�ì^ò<�bõYïsó�ûVó�ñ�ìÅôF¼�býsþ�ï>!^ñ[ú ù_ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úøVñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^úZ��þBï>�bó±ò�ù"n ô�ò�ñ[ñF÷�!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ�ïsúVô�ìÅòJí�ù �bï�ì^ú ïsó±ù-ó�ñ���ìÅô)�JòJï�îVð�ñ[ó@üå¼ ¹ »PÅ�¹ ¹   Å�¹l�n�õVñFòJñ¼·ïsó��bõYñ(!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñDþ¢»PÅ�¹Bï�ó��bõVñHGx¾Mºl¹�ûVóJñ(�bï�í�ñ%ìÅô~¼�øYñ[úVì �bï�úVö4�JõVñ%ó�í�ù^ð�ðsñFó���ó��Jù^öÅñ±ú�ûVíA�:ñ[òô�ì^ò,ùÅðsð:ûVó�ñ[ó,ì^ô�¼�ï�úVó�ïsøVñQ��þÅù^úYøz  Å�¹VïsóC�JõVñ4  ��ºl¹YûVó�ñD�Jïsí�ñ¸ì^ô�¼@øVñFúVì��JïsúYö(�JõVñ�ð�ù^ò�ö^ñFó��0ó��Jù^öÅñú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ìÅô2ùÅðsðBûYóJñFó�ì^ô ¼�ïsúYóJï�øVñ���ýr ì;�Jù��^ñ�ùÅø�!�ù^ú��bùÅö^ñ ì^ô��JõVñ|�[ìÅú��bò�ì^ð�÷��Vì"n ïsúVô�ìÅòJí�ù �bï�ì^ú ü�ó�ñ[ñ±ÿYñ����JïsìÅúY�:ý>3�bþ�n0ñ|�Fù^ú-ù^ð�ó�ì

ù^ø"IbûVó��.�bõVñ|  Å�¹<ù^úVøx»PÅ�¹�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ó���� ù^ó�ó�ïsöÅúVïsúYö�îVòJï�ì^ò�ï>�bï�ñ[ó��Jì+øVï>�:ñ[ò�ñ[ú���ûVó�ñ[ó�ù^ð�ì^úYöxøVï>�£ñFòJñFú �îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí îVù �bõVó<ýsK£ì^ò�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþ£ô�ì^ò¸ù ë-*0ÿ�ñ���îVò�ñ[ó�óJï�ì^ú�j.%�·�<*/�9*nÂÀ È 9*;-:,9 À # þan0ñ(�[ùÅúï�ö^úVìÅòJñ�ùÅðsðVûYóJñFó�ì^ôM¼�ïsúaÀ È ï�ôB��ü@À È ?IJ�,ü@À # bý r õVñ@�VïsùÅóG�Jì"n0ùÅòJøVóR�JõVñxð�ì�ì^î�ñ[øYö^ñ[óG�[ù^ú�ð�ñ[ùÅø�bì�í�ì^ò�ñ ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��x�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ¸òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVó,ù���ò�ûVú��bï�í�ñDýr ù �Vðsñ�&0ö^ï>!^ñ[óC�JõVñ�ó��Jù^öÅñ�ú�ûVí(�£ñFò�ù^úVøF�bõVñ�ó�ñ��,ìÅô�ò�ù"n#ô�òJñFñ�!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�ô�ìÅò�ù^ð�ðBô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó

øVñ�=VúVñ[ø�ïsú�KQïsöÅûVòJñ<�:ýD��ñ[ò�ñDþGj.<�9*8)ï�ó�ú�ûVí(�£ñFòJñFø_ù^ó¸ó��bù^öÅñF3|�£ñ��[ù^ûYóJñ�ï��¸ï�ó��JõVñ�ì^û��Jí�ìÅó��ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú.?H/�ïsó,úVñFó��Jñ[ø)ïsí�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ[ð>��ï�úVóJï�øVñ¸óJì�ï>��ï�ó�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ñ[ø�ù^óC�8? �JõVñ îVòJñFøVñ��Fñ[ó�óJìÅò0ó�ñ��ì^ô Ò �[ì^ú��Jù^ï�úVóÐ/�ì^úVð>�@ó�ì Ò ï�óxú�ûVí(�£ñFòJñFø�ù^ós´�?�ù^úYø�óJï�í�ïsð�ù^ò�ð���þcÓ�ïsó�úDûYíA�:ñ[ò�ñ[ø-ù^ós�uý�K£ì^ò

Page 15: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe Õ!K

ò�ù"n ô�òJñFñ(!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó<þ�Ó-ûVó�ñ[ó/�,n�ì�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�w�ù^úYøÂ/��:ì��Jõ�ù �¸ó��bùÅö^ñ<�8? Ò ûVóJñFóWÑBþM%Bþù^úYøßwuþ2�bõ�ûVóD�bõVñ(=Vò�ó��J÷IûVó�ñ�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ô�ì^ò&w@ï�ó@´wn�õYïsð�ñ|�bõYñ�ð�ù^ó��b÷aûVóJñ�ú�ûVí(�£ñFò+ï�ó@�uý�ë�ðsñFù^ò�ð���bõYñ�ó�ù^í�ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñA�[ùÅú�õYù"!^ñ�øVï��:ñ[ò�ñ[ú��w  Å�¹2ù^úYøw»PÅ�¹2ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ó ïsúYóJï�øVñ�øVï>�£ñFòJñFú � ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úøVñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^úVó%üÀñDý ö:ý�þ*w�ï�ú Ò !�ó�ý~w�ï�úaÓ�Jýî T � ê2;>\ÅH\²DGI=.³IHJK]GI9<K]=.µ^L�9<AD9<;>LFHJC>Hr õVñw�JõVï�òJø(ó��bñFî ìÅô,ì^ûVò±ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí·þBùÅðsó�ì��[ùÅðsð�ñ[øq#+�FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷Ió��bò�ù��Jñ[ö��-ùÅúVù^ð>��óJï�ó�þ %·ï�óA�Jì�øVñ[÷�bñFòJí�ï�úVñ/n�õVñFòJñ ï�ú��JõVñ�í�ù��lõVï�úVñ��bì�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��Jñ�ñFù��lõF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñDý.�,ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñDn�ñ�øVì�úVì��,ûVó�ñ�ù^ú��ò�ûVú��bï�í�ñ�ó��Jù��M��þÅù^ð�ðan�ñ+úYñ[ñ[ø�ïsó��bì%øVñ��FïsøYñ�õVì"n í�ùÅú �'ºl  ½ ¹�º,üÀï�ý ñDý�þÅòJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�uùÅòJñ�ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø�bì�ñFù��lõF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ ? �bõYïsóxú�ûVí(�£ñFòxï�óxøVñ[úYì��bñFø-ù^óLK0ü����ô�ì^òxñFù��lõ)ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú-øVñ�=VúYï��JïsìÅú���ý � ñ�[ùÅð��FûVð�ù��bñ�K0ü���2ûVóJï�úVö;�JõVñ�ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí øYñ[ó��[ò�ï��:ñ[øF�£ñFðsì"n�ý&]ô2��ïsó+ù^ú-ñ[ó��[ùÅîVïsúYö�ûYóJñFòxô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú2þ��bõVñFúMK�ü@��N��3^ý r õVïsó+ñ[ó�óJñFú �JïsùÅðsð>��í�ñ[ùÅúVós�JõVù���ùÅðsð

ï>�bó�ô�òJñFñs!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�í%ûVó��G�£ñ¸îVû��0ïsúw�JõVñ+õYñ[ù^î�ý r õVñD�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñxô�ì^òD��ï�ó�ù±î£ìÅïsú��Jñ[òG�Jì�ù±ð�ï�ú��^ñFøøVù �bù�ó��JòJû2���bûYòJñ ï�úF�JõVñ�õVñFù^î2ý&]ôp��ïsó{ùÅú�ñ[ó��[ù^îYïsúVö��Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú%ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�þ"�bõYñ[úOK0ü@����Íã�n�õVñ[ò�ñ�ã�ï�ó��JõVñ�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ìÅô

�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ý)��ñ��[ùÅûVóJñ/�JõVñ[ï�ò��[ù^ð�ð�ó�ï>�bñ[ó�ù^ò�ñ±úVì �s��úVì"n�ú�ù��s�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñ(�bï�í�ñDþYí�ìÅó���[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú)ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó+õVù"!^ñ��bì�ûYóJñ��bõYñ�ûVúVï�ô�ì^ò�í �[ìÅú�!^ñ[ú��JïsìÅú2þDï�ý ñDý�þ�ùÅð�n�ù"��ó�ï�ú�ã��[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷ó�ù"!^ñxò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJóD0 o+îYî£ñFðBù^úVø�ÿYõVù^ìY3M5�5 ��:]ý�&]ú�óJî:ñ��FïsùÅða�Fù^ó�ñ[ó<þ<ó�ì^í�ñ@�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó�[ùÅú��:ñ�ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bñFø�øYï��:ñ[ò�ñ[ú��bð>�h? n0ñ�n�ï�ðsð�øVïsó��[ûYóJóx�JõVïsó+í�ìÅòJñ ï�ú-ÿVñ����bï�ì^úYÀ:ý ´:ý&]ô&��ïsó�ù��DúYì"n�ú ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú2þh�JõVñ[ú�ï>�bó(�[ù^ð�ð{ó�ï��Jñ[ó±ùÅòJñ�ù^ð�ð�ñ��DîYðsï>�[ï>�bð>����úVì"n�ú ù��/�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñ

�bï�í�ñDý r õVñ<�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ±ñ[ú�!�ïsò�ì^úYí�ñFú��+ô�ì^òÁ���[ùÅú��:ñ%ùÅðsð�ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø·ï�ú_ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<ý r õVï�ó�ï�ó úVì��ù^ð>n�ù"�Dó�øVñ[ó�ïsò�ù��Yðsñw�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ ü�3�s�bõVñFòJñ�ùÅòJñ@ì^úVð>��ù·ðsï�í�ï��Jñ[ø úDûYíA�:ñ[ò�ì^ô�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó±ìÅú$�bõVñ�bùÅòJöÅñ��xí�ù �lõVïsúYñDþ£ù^úVø�üu�8�ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�úVö�ù^ð�ð2ô�ò�ñ[ñ(!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFóxïsú�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó@�Fù^ú�ù^øYø·îVò�ñ[ó�óJûVò�ñ[ó�bì�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVóG�JõVù��{õYù"!^ñx��ù^ó�ù�ô�ò�ñ[ñs!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñDýhB�ï>�bõVñFò�ìÅôa�JõVñ[ó�ñs�[ùÅú��[ò�ñ[ù��Jñ�í�ì^ò�ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�÷í�ñ[í�ì^ò����bò�ù�����ü�ó�ñ[ñ�ÿVñ����bï�ì^ú�À:ý �8Jý � ñ�ûVó�ñ<�bõVñ�ô�ì^ð�ð�ì"n�ïsúVö�ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí �Jì�ò�ñ[ó�ì^ð>!^ñ(�bõVñFóJñ�[ìÅú��Vï>���Jó��y�&]úVï��JïsùÅðsð>�Dþ`ñFù��lõ/��úVì"n�ú�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úE��ïsó�ù^ó�óJï�ö^úYñ[øHP ó�ð�ì��bó<þFï�ý ñDý�þQK0ü���?�RP6þPn�õVñ[ò�ñBP ïsó.�bõVñí�ù ��ïsí%ûVí ú�ûVí(�£ñFò�ìÅô:ù"!�ùÅïsð�ù��Vð�ñ�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó�ìÅú;�bõVñs�Jù^ò�ö^ñ��{í�ù �lõVï�úVñxí�ïsú�ûVó��bõYñxú�ûVíA�:ñ[òì^ô�ô�ì^ò�í�ùÅðuîVù^ò�ù^í�ñ��Jñ[ò�ó,ïsú-ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú��(ü�ù^ó�ó�ûVí�ïsúVö��JõVñ��wn�ï�ð�ðh�£ñ�îYù^ó�óJñFø�ï�ú-òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó��?

y r õVñ[ú2þ£ô�ìÅò+ñ[ù �lõ���úVì"n�ú�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úÚ��þ2n0ñ(=Vò�ó��s=YúVø·ù^ð�ð-�bõVìÅóJñ±ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúVóD�JõVù��¸úVì �xì^úVð>��[ù^ð�ðG�4�Yû��xù^ð�ó�ì%õVù"!ÅñQ�@ù^ó�ìÅúVñ ì^ô-�bõVñFïsò�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó"? �bõVï�óxó�ñ��,ï�óxøVñ[úYì��bñFø�ùÅóLS<�

ST�J>��DA��UC�¿�¾ µ�RBü@���ùÅúVø��@ï�ó�ô�òJñFñ�ïsúE�:E&]ôBô�ûVú����JïsìÅúQ�<�Fù^ð�ðsó0ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úß��ù^úYøß��ïsó0ô�òJñFñ+ï�úQ��þ¢�bõVñFúw�bõYñ+ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ì^ôuó�ðsì �bó0ù^ó�óJï�ö^úVñFø�bì �-ó�õVì^ûYðsø·úYì��@�:ñ�ð�ù^ò�ö^ñFòs�bõYù^ú��JõVñ�ú�ûVí(�£ñFò+ì^ô{ó�ð�ì��bó�ù"!�ù^ï�ðsù �Vðsñ�ïsúVó�ï�øVñx��þVì �bõVñFò�n�ï�ó�ñï��/n�ï�ðsð�ðsñFù^øz�bì-ó�îVïsð�ð�ïsúVöuý�ÿVûVîYî£ìÅóJñWV)ï�ó|�JõVñ�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò±ìÅôG!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó/�JõVù���ùÅòJñ�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�ïsúÂ��Vû��xúVì ��ïsú���?��bõVñFú�ï��xï�óxù�öÅìDì�ø-ï�øVñ[ù;�Jì�ù^ó�óJï�ö^ú��Yn�ï��JõMK�üå��YXZV�ó�ðsì �bó"?�n0ñ�ûYóJñ\[�üå���bì�øVñ[úYì��bñ/�JõVï�ós�[ìÅúVó��JòJùÅïsú����

[�üå����ÊT<�]{ü�3 ¹ K�üå��^X_Va� ñ/�JõVñ[ú-ò�ñ�=VúVñ��JõVñ�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[òxìÅô�ó�ðsì �bó�ùÅóJó�ïsöÅúVñ[øF�bìv��ù^ó"�

K�ü@���� T(·u¸2ü�>][�üå��?A��DCMS`E�aO><K0ü����E r õVïsó2îVò�ì �Fñ[øVûYòJñ{ï�ó2ò�ñ[î:ñ[ù �bñFø¸ûYú �Jïsð �bõYñ�ó�ðsì ��ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò2ù^ó�óJï�ö^úVñFø��bìxñ�!^ñ[ò��@��úVì"n�ú ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úúVì�ðsìÅúVö^ñFòx�lõVù^úVöÅñ[ó<ý

Page 16: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

Õ!y ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

r õVïsó,ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí ùÅð�n�ù"��ó��bñFòJí�ï�úVù��Jñ[ó,ù^úYø�òJñFù��lõVñFó�ù(=���î£ìÅïsú����£ñ��[ù^ûYóJñD�£ì �bõb[�üå��Bù^úYøK0ü���:ù^ò�ñ�ù^ð>n0ù"��óQî£ìÅóJï>�bï>!^ñ�ú�ûVí(�£ñFòJó<þ<ùÅúVø;�bõYñ�óJûVí ì^ô?K0ü���uô�ì^ò�ùÅðsð2�DúYì"n�ú�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúVó�ö^ñ��bóó�í�ùÅðsð�ñ[òQï�ú�ñ[ù��lõ%ï��Jñ[ò�ù��JïsìÅú2ýh&]ô?c ïsó��JõVñ,ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò{ìÅôYò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�óQì^ú<�bõVñx�Jù^ò�ö^ñ��2í�ù��lõYïsúVñ�þ�ù^úYø= ï�óD�JõVñ�úDûYíA�:ñ[ò¸ì^ô�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�øVñ�=YúVï��JïsìÅúVó<þ2�JõVñ�ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí �[ìÅûVðsø'�bù��ÅñE?�ü�c =��òJìÅûVúVøVó�bì�=VúVï�óJõ�ïsú��bõVñ<n�ì^ò�ó��s�Fù^ó�ñDý@&]ú·îVò�ù����bï>�[ñDþ£ï>�D�Jù��Åñ[ó+úYì4�bï�í�ñ%ùÅúVø_ò�ñ[ù �lõVñ[ó@�bõVñ<=���î:ì^ï�ú �ï�ú)ð�ñ[ó�óx�bõYù^úY�bõVò�ñ[ñ ò�ì^ûVúYøVó�ý� ñ��[ù^ú(ùÅö^ùÅïsúz�bù �^ñ�ùÅø�!�ù^ú��bùÅö^ñ�ìÅô��JõVñ4�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð�÷+�Vì"n ï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��JïsìÅú$n�õVñ[ú1�Fù^ð>�[ûVð�ù��JïsúYö

K0ü���bý.KYìÅò�ù^ð�ð:ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúVó2��ïsúF�bõVñ ù �£ì"!Åñ+ó�ñ��\S�þ n�ñD�Fù^ú�ö^ï>!^ñ¸ù%õVï�ö^õYñ[ò,îVò�ïsìÅòJï>�,�;�bì<�bõVìÅóJñô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVóAn�ï��Jõ õYïsöÅõVñ[òd�,üå� ¹ ��)!�ù^ð�ûVñ[ó/�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ�ùY�[ùÅðsðR�Jì��bõVñFóJñ�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó±õVù^îYî£ñFúVó|�bìô�ù^ð�ð�ï�úVó�ïsøVñ øVñFñ[î:ñ[òxð�ì�ì^îVó<ý��ñ���~ ó�ù^îVîYð��ÿ�bõYïsó�ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí��bì ìÅûVò@ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñ·ïsúmKQï�ö^ûVò�ñ��uý�KYûVú����bï�ì^ú j.<*9*8 ï�ó@ùÅú

ñ[ó��[ùÅîVï�úVö�ûVóJñFò�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú2þ�ó�ì�ï��@ïsó�ùÅóJó�ï�ö^úVñFø ìÅúVñ�óJð�ì���ý ÿVûYîVî£ìÅóJñ'n0ñ-ûVó�ñ��bõYòJñFñ��[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷ó�ù"!^ñ·ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<þ�ù^ð�ð�ñFó��Fù^îVï�úVöE�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úVó�ù^ò�ñ·ù^ó�óJï�ö^úYñ[ø��JõVòJñFñ_ó�ðsì �bó<þC�bõYù��)ïsó<þC�:ì��bõK0ü�Ó�{ù^úVøRK0ü Ò �óJõYì^ûVð�øY�£ñ%ñ�p�ûVù^ð��bìw´uýGK£ûVú����bï�ì^úß/�ïsó�ïsúVï>�bï�ù^ð�ð>��ùÅóJó�ïsöÅúVñ[øYn�ï>�bõ³36��óJð�ì��Jó�þù^ó�ó�ûVí�ïsúVöFn�ñ�õYù"!^ñ�3M�)ù"!`ùÅïsð�ù��Yðsñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�ìÅú��JõVñ��bùÅòJöÅñ��¸í�ù �lõVï�úVñ[ó<ý r õYñ�îYòJñFøVñ��Fñ[ó�óJìÅòó�ñ��¸ô�ì^ò�/��Fì^ú��bùÅïsúYóD�,n�ì@ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó�þAj.<*9*8@ùÅúVø ÓBþa�Vû���/�ï�ó úVì���ô�òJñFñ%ï�úZj.<*9*8BþVó�ì4�JõVñ%ó�ñ��S ô�ì^ò�/�ì^úYð��$�Fì^ú��bùÅïsúVó�ÓBý.�,ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñeK0ü�Ó8F�æ´uþQù^úVø�ì^úYð��(ìÅúVñ�!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñDþAwuþ�ïsó�ô�ò�ñ[ñ-ï�úÓ��Vû���úVì��%ïsúe/Bþ�óJìf[�ü�Ó�W� T(��ü�3 ¹ ´dX�3�g� �uý�K£ûVú����JïsìÅú°/�ï�ó(�JõDûYó%ùÅóJó�ïsöÅúVñ[ø$n�ï>�bõK0ü�/��� T<·u¸�ü+[�ü�Ó� ¹ 3M�8��1��óJð�ì��Jó�ü�ó�ñ[ñ r ù��Vð�ñ�&�bý&,��ï�ó%ï�í�î£ìÅò��Jù^ú��|�bì�úVì��Jñ4�JõVù��(� � ù^ó�ó�ïsöÅúVïsúYö��,n0ì·ó�ð�ì��bó<�bìÂ/uþ-n�ñ�ó�û����Fñ[ó�óJô�ûYðsð>��ù"!Åì^ï�ø

�VûVï�ð�øVïsúYö¸ùÅú����FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�ïsúYóJï�øVñ��bõVñ,ð�ìDìÅî)üÀóJñFñ�KQï�ö^ûVò�ñ/7^þ`ð�ïsúVñFó����^÷+����bý���ù^ï>!^ñ�ðsùÅíA�:øVù^÷að�ïsôu�JïsúVöù^úYøF�FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷IùÅúVù^ð>��óJï�ó,ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí�óA0 � ìÅõVúVó�óJìÅú$365�9 À8? o+îYî£ñFð�3M5 5�� :�n0ìÅûVðsø-õVù"!Åñ�ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFøù^ð�ð�ìÅô2/�~ ó�ô�òJñFñ;!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�ïsú��bì�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó"?��JõVï�ó|n0ìÅûVð�ø ô�ìÅò��Fñ��bõVñw�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú�Ó'�bì�ó�îVï�ðsðù^úYø�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��Jñ ù<�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ ï�úF�JõVñ�õVñFù^î)ñ�!^ñFò���ï>�bñFòJù �bï�ì^ú2ýî T î éBGI9<ADHb;>9<K]C>\ÅA�C>AÅK]\�Z[;>\ÅH\²DGI=.³�´D9<HbHJC>Aµ%HbKaLF;>=r õVñ�ð�ù^ó��,ó��Jñ[î-ì^ô2ì^ûVò�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí ïsó@�bì��bò�ù^úVó�ð�ù��bñ��JõVñ�ïsúYîVû���ë-*�ÿ)îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí ïsú��bì��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷îVùÅóJó�ïsúYö±ó��,��ð�ñDý.v¸ûVòJï�úVö(�bõVñ��bò�ù^úVó�ð�ù��bï�ì^ú�þ¢n�ñ+ò�ûVúw�JõVñD�FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷Iò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jù��bï�ì^ú�ù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�óG�bìøVñ��[ï�øVñA�JõVñ(=YúVù^ð�ðsù"�Åì^û��+ô�ì^ò¸ñ[ù��lõ'�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�ýC�·ìÅòJñ%óJî:ñ��Fï�=��Fù^ð�ð���þVöÅï�!Åñ[ú·ù�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú°��þYï�ô���[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVó�P ô�ò�ñ[ñ(!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó+ù^úYø·ïsó¸ù^ó�ó�ïsöÅúVñ[ø7½6ó�ðsì �bó<þ£õVì"n øVì4n�ñ�îVð�ù��FñA�JõVñ[ó�ñLP !�ù^ð�ûVñ[óï�ú �Jìɽ�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó�hþ�ï�!Åñ[ú ù�ë-*0ÿ�ñ��DîYòJñFóJó�ïsìÅúÚÀ�þ��bõYñ<�JòJùÅúVó�ðsù �bï�ì^ú_ï�ú��bìF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aîVù^ó�óJï�úVö�ó��,��ðsñ�ï�ó�øVì^úYñ(���

îVò�ì��[ñ[ó�ó�ïsúVö)ñ[ù �lõ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú øYñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú��bõYòJìÅûVö^õ ù-îVòJñFì^ò�øVñ[ò��JòJù"!Åñ[ò�óJùÅð2ìÅôÐÀ�ý(v�ûVò�ï�úVöY�bõVñ�bò�ù"!^ñFòJó�ù^ð]þ�n0ñ í�ù^ï�ú��bù^ï�ú)ù^úVø-ûVî:øVù��Jñ/�bõVñ�ô�ìÅðsð�ì"n�ï�úVö(�JõVò�ñ[ñ�ñ[ú�!�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú��0ó��bò�û����bûVò�ñ[ó"�VGU���¹jiY�M¿�Xso í�ùÅîVîVï�úVö�ô�òJìÅí ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVóxîYòJì��[ñFóJó�ñ[ø)ó�ì�ô�ùÅòx�bì��bõYñ[ï�òs�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ð�ù"�^ìÅû��`ýVGU�µP¾ µ�iY�6¿èX@o ðsï�ó���ì^ô��FûVò�òJñFú �Jð��4!Dï�ó�ï��Vð�ñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó�ù^úYø�!�ù^ð�ûVñFó�?P�� ºlµ�k�µZÆ�º�X r õVñ/�FûVò�òJñFú ���[ìÅú��bñ[ú��Jó�ì^ô-�[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷aó�ù"!^ñ+ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ý

� ñ�îVòJì��Fñ[ó�óJï�úVö�ñ[ù��lõ)ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú-øVñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú���þ n0ñ�ñ���ñ��[û2�bñ��bõVñ�ô�ìÅðsð�ì"n�ï�úVö��bù^ó���ó���:ý �:ý>3mls·u¸SR�·u¸¢Æz¹�U�µF¹+¾ ��¸aº�·u¹+·uNPµ��P  ½�ºlÅ�¾ µF½+»�¾ ��V'»P¾ µlµ7N�� ¾M·u��PP  µPº�X � ñ;�lõVñ��M��ïsô&� ïsó±ò�ñ[÷

�[ûYòJó�ï�!Åñ-ì^ò�í%û��bûVùÅðsð>�6ò�ñ��FûVò�óJï>!^ñFn�ï��Jõ ì��JõVñ[ò�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúVó�ýq��úVð>�6ûVó�ñ[ò�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúVó4�Fù^ú��£ñò�ñ��[ûYòJó�ï�!Åñ@ìÅò%í%û��bûVùÅðsð>�(ò�ñ��[ûYòJó�ï�!Åñ ?��[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó�ù^ò�ñ@úVñ�!^ñ[ò�ò�ñ��FûVòJó�ï>!^ñDý r õVñð�ù^úVöÅûVù^öÅñ�øYñ�=VúVñFø�ïsú;KQï�ö^ûVò�ñx��øVì�ñ[ó�úYì��{ó�ûVîVî:ì^ò��{í�û��JûVù^ðVò�ñ��FûVò�óJï�ì^ú�øVï�òJñ����bð>�Dþ¢�Vû���ï�ú�ò�ñ[ù^ðï�ú �Jñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ¸ð�ù^úYö^ûVùÅö^ñ[ó|0 o+îVî:ñ[ð�3M5�5 ��:]þ �bõVñ��@ù^ò�ñ¸ïsú��bò�ì�øVû��Fñ[øF!Dï�ù�ù�óJï�úVö^ð�ñx%*1�n�øVñ��FðsùÅòJùÅ÷�bï�ì^ú�ý�&]ú;�JõVï�ó)�Fù^ó�ñDþ<ù�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú�øVñ��[ð�ù^ò�ù��bï�ì^ú�ó�ïsí%ûVð>�bù^úYñ[ì^ûYóJð>��øVñ�=VúVñFóA½·ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVóD��þ���þS�uþ

Page 17: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe Õ!�

ý�ýsý>?¢�JõVñ���ùÅòJñ�îVò�ì��[ñFóJó�ñ[ø<�bìÅö^ñ��JõVñ[ò0ù^úVø�ñ�!^ñ[ú��JûVù^ð�ð��%óJõYù^ò�ñ�ì^úVñs�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�ý 7 &]ôG�<�[ùÅðsð�óG��ù^úVøÁ��[ùÅðsð�ó��uþ �JõVñ[úF�bõYñ¸ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ì^ô(��í�ûVó��,ù^ð�óJì(�[ìÅú �Jù^ï�ú4�JõVì^ó�ñ ô�ì^ò(��ù^úVø��uþDùÅúVø@ó�ì�ì^ú2ýKYìÅòx�bõVï�óxò�ñ[ùÅóJìÅú2þ n0ñ�úVñFñ[øY�bì��Fù^ð>�[ûVð�ù��Jñ/�bõVñ/�JòJùÅúVóJï>�bï>!^ñ��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ¸ì^ô-�bõVñ�ò�ù"n ô�ò�ñ[ñF÷�!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��bï�ì^ú�ý � ñ�ûVó�ñ/�bõVñ�ô�ìÅðsð�ì"n�ï�úVö%ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí��y�ÿVûVîVî:ì^ó�ñ(�JõVñ�óJñ�� ì^ô�ò�ù"n ô�òJñFñ(!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó ìÅô���yE�Fù^ð>�[ûVð�ù��Jñ[ø������JõVñ�ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí ï�ú_ÿVñ��[÷�bï�ì^úF�:ý ��y�ïsó,úVùÅí�ñFø�ùÅó�k�lWn�ü@���?�ù^ð�ó�ì%ó�ûVîVî:ì^ó�ñÉ��òJñ��[ûVò�ó�ï�!Åñ[ð>�<�Fù^ð�ðsó2��þ �bõVñFú_k�lWn�ü@��í�ûVó��C�[ì^ú��Jù^ï�ú@ù<�bò�ïsîVð�ñ�üå� ¹ »PÅ�¹�o ¹   Å�¹ o Jý � ñ��[ùÅð��FûVð�ù��bñ��bõYñ��JòJùÅúVó�ï��Jï�!Åñ@�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñD����í�ñ[ò�ö^÷ïsúVöbk�lWn�ü@��-n�ï>�bõY�bõVñ�ô�ìÅðsð�ì"n�ï�úVö�óJñ��P�

>Åü¿¼ ¹ »PÅ�¹�o ¹   Å�¹ o BA!¼_CDk�lWn�üå���E� õVñ[ú·í�ñFòJöÅïsúVö�ùÅðsð��bò�ïsîVð�ñ[ó�ô�ì^òD�bõVñ±ó�ù^í�ñ|!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñDþ�n0ñ|�Jù��Åñ/�bõVñ%í�ï�úVï�í�ûVí ìÅô�ùÅðsð��bõVñ»PÅ�¹£úDûYíA�:ñ[ò�ó�ù^úVøY�bõYñ�í�ù ��ïsí%ûVí ì^ô�ù^ð�ð��bõYñ�  Å�¹£ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ó�ý

y � ñ�ò�ñ[î:ñ[ù �<�JõVï�ó�îVò�ì �Fñ[øVûYòJñ)ûVú��bï�ðxï>��òJñFù��lõVñFó%ùz=�� î£ìÅïsú��`ý r õVï�ów�Fì^ûVð�øE�Jù��Åñ�?�ü¿½ # òJìÅûVúVøVó�ï�úY�bõVñ/n�ì^ò�ó����[ùÅóJñ�þ �Vû���ï>��ûVó�ûVù^ð�ð��4�bù��Åñ[óx�,n�ì��bì��bõVò�ñ[ñ�ò�ì^ûYúVøVó,ïsú-îVò�ù����bï>�[ñ�ý� ñ�ûVóJñek�lWn�p`ü@��/�Jì øVñFúVì��Jñ��bõVñ�=VúVùÅð@�bò�ù^úYóJï>�bï>!^ñ��FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�ô�ìÅò@ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú ��ý��2ñ���~ ó

ù^îYîVð����bõVï�óxùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVíæ�bì�ìÅûVòxñ���ùÅí�îYðsñ ï�úFKQï�ö^ûVò�ñ/�:ý-��ñ[ò�ñDþ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúv/@ïsó+òJñ��[ûVò�óJï>!^ñ¸ù^úYøù^ó�ó�õVì"n�ú)ïsú r ù��Vð�ñ�&[þ!k�lWn�ü�/��ï�óxï�úVï>�bï�ù^ð�ð���ñ�p�ûVù^ð��Jì8�

kql`n�ü�/���J>Åü�i ¹ � ¹ �� ¹ ü�Ñ ¹ ´ ¹ ´8 ¹ ü�% ¹ ´ ¹ ´8 ¹ ü�/ ¹ � ¹ ���E�,ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñx/;�[ùÅðsð�ó�ï��JóJñFðsôbþ�n0ñ í�ñ[ò�ö^ñ��bõYïsósn�ï>�bõY�JõVñ�óJñ��P�

>Dü�i ¹ � ¹ �8 ¹ ü�Ñ ¹ � ¹ �� ¹ ü�% ¹ � ¹ �8 ¹ ü�/ ¹ � ¹ �8�EÅýr õVñ/=VúYù^ð��bò�ù^úYóJï>�bï>!^ñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�kql`n p ü�/��ïsó�ñ�pDûYù^ðh�Jì8�

kql`n�p`ü�/8r�s>Åü�i ¹ � ¹ �8 ¹ ü�Ñ ¹ ´ ¹ �� ¹ ü�% ¹ ´ ¹ �8 ¹ ü�/ ¹ � ¹ �8�EÅý�,ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñG�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúVó2ùÅòJñ�úVñ�!^ñ[ò�ò�ñ��[ûYòJó�ï�!ÅñDþ��bõYñ)�JòJùÅúVóJï>�bï>!^ñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ô�ìÅò Ò ùÅúVøÉÓ ò�ñ[í�ùÅïsúVóó�ù^í�ñ ù^ó�ó�õVì"n�ú�ï�ú r ù �Vð�ñ�&��

k�lWnbpFü Ò ��tk�lWn�ü Ò ��u>Dü�Ñ ¹ ´ ¹ ´8 ¹ ü�% ¹ ´ ¹ ´� ¹ ü�w ¹ ´ ¹ �8 ¹ ü�/ ¹ � ¹ �8�E ?k�lWn p ü�Ó���tk�lWn�ü�Ó���u>Dü�w ¹ � ¹ �8 ¹ ü�/ ¹ � ¹ ���EÅý�:ý �:ý � Ô.��  �PÅ�  ��¹+·u¸"Æ�¹�U�µ<¹�¾MÅ�µ�»P¾ µlµÉNP��¾M·u�P�  µPº�X@�+ñ����xn�ñ�=VúVøY�bõVñ ó�ñ���ìÅôC¹+¾MÅ�µ-»P¾ µlµÁN�� ¾M·u¼

��PP  µPº�þDv!lWn�ü@��bþ���� ò�ñ[îYðsù �[ï�úVö�ñ[ù��lõÿ�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúE!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ-ïsúsk�lWngp�ü����� � ï��Jów�[ìÅòJ÷ò�ñ[ó�î£ìÅúVøVï�úVö��Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ|!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó<þ:ù^úVø�ñ[ù��lõ�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úV÷aøVñ�=YúVï��JïsìÅúz!`ùÅòJï�ù��Yðsñ-üun�õVñ��bõVñFò�ï��øVñ�=VúVñ[ó,ù�ûVó�ñ[ò,ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú@ìÅò,ù(�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú..����ï��JóC�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ��[ìÅú��bñ[ú��Jó üÀï�ý ñDý�þDóJð�ì��!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó"bý)KYìÅòxñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþYï�úfk�lWn�p`ü�/�R�JõVñ[ò�ñ±ï�ó+ì^úYñ|�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úY!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñWÑ@ùÅúVø�ì^úVñô�ûVú����bï�ì^úV÷aøVñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^úz!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vðsñ�/Bý � ñ�ò�ñ[í�ì"!ÅñÁ/��:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ�ï���ï�ó±ù"!�ù^ï�ð�ù��Vð�ñ%ï�úVó�ïsøYñ�ï��Jó±ì"n�ú�:ìDø2�Dý�ÿYûVîVî:ì^ó�ñ;n0ñ�ûVó�ñ;�bõVò�ñ[ñ;�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ%ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó"?�n�ñ�òJñFîVð�ù��[ñ�Ñ'� ��ùY�[ì�øVñ�î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[òÑ*Ì�ù^úYø)ï>�bó@�bõVò�ñ[ñ/�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ@!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó�Ñ-rDþ*Ñ�ìBþDùÅúVøaÑ�ÅBý r õVñ�ó�ñ���ìÅô.�JòJûYñ¸ô�ò�ñ[ñ/!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óvwlWn�ü�/8�ï�óxñ�p�ûVùÅð��bì��

vwlWn�ü�/���u>Dü�i ¹ � ¹ �8 ¹ ü�Ñ�Ì ¹ ´ ¹ �� ¹ ü�Ñ-r ¹ ´ ¹ �� ¹ ü�Ñ*ì ¹ ´ ¹ �� ¹ ü�Ñ*Å ¹ ´ ¹ �� ¹ ü�% ¹ ´ ¹ �8�EÅýx ����fYyljbrtv�ylo[n>k,m�o>fhk,fhi[rIylrtn>dli�~udlv�o>e{ylo>padBe`n>�Fn>e�fYrt��fhpaf^y0qsv�i`jbrtn>dli�p�n>i[rtd2fhpajhylm�n>i`��yli`e�¶[i�dJ~�i{qwv�i�jhrtn>dli�pl�ã�o>o`fbpIjhylm�n>i���qsv�i`jbrtn>dli�pupI��ylgaf�dli�f�jho>dlpav�gIfF�Dã�o>o�¶[i�d�~�ixqwv�i�jhrIn>dli`pujhyli�partn>o>o�ylo>o>dFjhylrtf2rt��fhn>gufhi[�Fn>gIdli�k,fhiFrtpn>i+rI��f�gIfb�ln>pIrIfhgIpl�

Page 18: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

Õ!� ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

�+ì �bï>�[ñ�õVñFòJñ ùÅðsð��Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ@!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó,úVù��JûVò�ù^ð�ð���ï�úVõVñFòJï>��Ñ�~ ó�»PÅ�¹£ùÅúVø³  Å�¹£ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ó<ý�����bõYñ4�bï�í�ñ4n�ñ@ò�ñ[ù �lõ��JõVñ4�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúVó Ò ù^úVø�Óuþhn0ñ@õVù"!^ñ�ùÅðsò�ñ[ùÅø��_øYñ��[ï�øVñFø$�bõVñ

ð�ù"�^ì^û2�xô�ì^ò¸ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úÂ/(üÀóJñFñA�bõYñ%ò�ñ[ó��+ìÅô��bõVñ%ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVíÇ�:ñ[ð�ì"nAbý@KYìÅòD�JõVñA�JòJùÅúVóJð�ù��JïsìÅú·ï�úKQïsöÅûVò�ñ<7^þÅô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú7/�ïsó,ùÅóJó�ïsöÅúVñ[ø;�,n�ì�ó�ð�ì��bó"�2ì^úVñ�óJð�ì����[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVó��bõVñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñDÑ*íBþ�ùÅúVì��JõVñ[ò�bõYñ<!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñQiuý±ÿVìYn0ñ�ò�ñ[îVð�ù��Fñ�ñFù��lõ_ì����[ûVò�òJñFú��[ñ�ì^ô2/-ïsúzk�lWn�p`ü Ò 0ù^úYøMk�lWnbpFü�Ó�)���ï>�bóxó�ðsì �C!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�ý r õVñ��bò�ûVñ�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[óUvwl`n�ü Ò �ùÅúVøuvwlWn�ü�Ó��ù^ò�ñ�ñ�p�ûVù^ð��Jì8�

v!lWn�ü Ò � >Dü�Ñ*Ì ¹ ´ ¹ ´8 ¹ ü�Ñ-r ¹ ´ ¹ ´8 ¹ ü�Ñ*ì ¹ ´ ¹ ´8 ¹ ü�Ñ*Å ¹ ´ ¹ ´8 ¹ü�% ¹ ´ ¹ ´8 ¹ ü�w ¹ ´ ¹ �� ¹ ü�Ñ*í ¹ � ¹ �8 ¹ ü�i ¹ � ¹ �8�E ?v!lWn�ü�Ó� � >Dü�w ¹ � ¹ �8 ¹ ü�Ñ*í ¹ � ¹ �8 ¹ ü�i ¹ � ¹ ���EDý�+ñFòJñxn�ñ,øVï�øVú.~ ��ïsú2�[ð�ûVøVñs�JõVñx�[ì�øVñ�î:ì^ï�ú��bñ[òA/A�£ñ��[ùÅûVóJñ�ï>�{ï�ó�ù^ð>n0ù"��óQù"!�ù^ï�ðsù �Vð�ñ��Jì�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVóï�ú'�bõYñ%ó�ù^í�ñ<�[ì�øVñ�ó�ñ[öÅí�ñ[ú��`ýDo+öÅù^ï�ú2þèÑ*Ì�ë*Ñ*Å�ïsúVõYñ[ò�ï����bõVñ�ð�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ%ô�ò�ì^í ÑBþYù^úVø��bõVñ�óJð�ì��!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[óýÑ*í�ù^úVøai�ï�úVõVñFòJï>��ô�ò�ì^íæ�JõVñ[ï�òx�[ìÅòJò�ñ[ó�î£ìÅúVøVï�úVö�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúa/uý�:ý �:ý ´ 9SU ��¾M·u¸"Æ�VR·u¹�U³�P  ½�ºlÅ�¾ µPº�·u¸�¹�U�µ��PÅ�¾M¾ µ�¸a¹(µP¸SNP·u¾ ½ ¸ST<µ�¸a¹�Xxþ�ï>!^ñFú ù ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú ��þ

ó�ûVîVî:ì^ó�ñsvwlWn�ü@��s�[ìÅú �Jù^ï�úVóLP !�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó<þ�ùÅúVøs�(ï�ó%ùÅóJó�ïsöÅúVñ[ø½ ó�ðsì �bó(� �z�JõVñ4�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷ó��bò�ù��bñFö���ù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsó@ïsú#ÿYñ����JïsìÅú��:ý ´:ý£&]ô�P|{ ½�þC�bõVñFú�n�ñ_ù^ò�ñ·øVìÅúVñDý ���bõVñFò�n�ï�óJñ�þ�n0ñó�ñ[ù^ò��lõ��bõVò�ì^ûVöÅõ��JõVñw�FûVòJò�ñ[ú�� ð�ïsó��±ì^ô�!�ïsó�ï>�Vðsñ;�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó�í�ùÅïsú��Jù^ï�úVñ[øz���'�JõVñO}�~��@���@�=�w�ñ[ú�!�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú��`þDùÅúVø�ó�ñ[ñ ï�ô.�JõVñ[ò�ñ ïsó+ù^ú��;�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ¸ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø4�JõVù��Cn�ñ��Fù^ú-ò�ñ[ûVó�ñDý r õVñ ó�õVù^ò�ïsúYöï�ó�ºl�+»Pµ.»P½ ¾Dº�¿����lµ�ù^ó0ðsìÅúVö±ù^óGn0ñ�ì^úVð>�%ò�ñ[ûYóJñs�JõVì^ó�ñs�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[óGn�õVì^ó�ñs�[ìÅú��bñ[ú��Jó�ù^ò�ñxù±ó�û��Vó�ñ��ì^ôHvwlWn�ü@���?�ï�ú�ì^ò�øVñ[òRn�ì^ò�øVó<þPn0ñ�ìÅúVð>�±òJñFûVó�ñ�ù��FðsìÅóJûYòJñ,ï�ô£ï>�{øVì�ñ[ó�úYì��R�Vò�ïsúYö¸ï�ú�ù^øVøYï��JïsìÅúVù^ðúVñ�n !�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó<ý-�,ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ/n0ñ ûVó�ñ�óJùÅô�ñ[ð>�@ð�ïsú2�^ñ[øY�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó<þ �[ñFò��Jù^ï�ú��FðsìÅóJûYòJñ ó�õVù^ò�ïsúYö^ó�õVù"!Åñù^ð�ò�ñ[ù^ø2�@�:ñ[ñ[ú�ù^ú��bï>�[ï�îVù��Jñ[ø|n�õYïsð�ñ�îVò�ì��[ñ[ó�ó�ïsúVö@�bõVñ0ñ[ú��FðsìÅóJï�úVö�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú%øVñ�=VúYï��JïsìÅúVó�ýh&]ô��bõVñFòJñù^ò�ñ±í%ûVð��JïsîYðsñ�óJõYù^ò�ù��Vð�ñ/�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó<þ�n�ñ�ûVó�ñA�JõVñ$#�£ñFó��D=��t%�õVñ[ûYòJï�ó��Jï��(�bì�øVñ��FïsøVñ(n�õVï>�lõ·ì^úVñ�bì�ò�ñ[ûVó�ñDý��ñ���~ ó�ð�ìDì ��ù ��ìÅûVò�ñ��DùÅí�îVðsñ�ì^ôÉj.<*9*8·ù^öÅù^ï�ú2ý � õVñFú³n�ñ�îVò�ì��[ñ[ó�ó�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú°/Bþ�ï��%õVù^ó

ó�ï��-ô�ò�ñ[ñ<!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó+ù^úYø·ïsó ùÅóJó�ïsöÅúVñ[ø��,n�ì@ó�ð�ì��bó<þa�Vû����bõVñFòJñ%ù^ò�ñ�úVì��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó+ù ���Fñ[ó�óJï>�Vð�ñ�ï�ú�bõYñw�[ûVò�ò�ñ[ú���ñ[ú�!�ïsò�ì^úYí�ñFú��`þ�óJì�úVì_óJõVùÅòJï�úVö-ï�ó�î:ì^ó�óJï>�Vð�ñDý4KYì^òA�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú Ò þBõVì"n�ñ�!Åñ[ò<þn�ñ+õVù"!Åñ+ù^ð�ò�ñ[ù^ø2�(�Fì^úVó��bò�û����Jñ[ø�ù(�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñDÑ*í�ô�ì^ò��bõVñ¸ñ[ú��FðsìÅóJï�úVö%ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú0/Bý.o+ó,ó�õVì"n�ú�ï�úKQïsöÅûVò�ñ�7^þ2�bõVñ(�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñWÑ�í��[ìÅú��bù^ï�úVóD!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFóDÑ*Ì*ë�Ñ*Å�ùÅúVø %BþYù^ð�ð�ì^ôRn�õYï��lõ�ùÅòJñ±ñFðsñFí�ñ[ú��bóì^ôgvwlWn�ü Ò Jý)��ñ��[ùÅûVóJñ Ò õVùÅóxñ[ï�ö^õ��xô�ò�ñ[ñ/!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[óxùÅúVø�ï�ó+ù^ó�ó�ïsöÅúVñ[øF�bõVò�ñ[ñ�óJð�ì��Jóxì^úVð>�Dþ�n0ñò�ñ[ûVó�ñ��bõVñ/�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ�Ñ�íBþDùÅúVø-òJñFóJñ��DvwlWn�ü Ò -�bì��£ñ��

vwlWn�ü Ò ��J>Åü�w ¹ ´ ¹ �8 ¹ ü�Ñ*í ¹ ´ ¹ �8 ¹ ü�i ¹ � ¹ ���EÅý�+ì �bï>�[ñw�JõVù��(n0ñ�ó�ñ��A�bõVñA»PÅ�¹Qú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ì^ô�Ñ*í��Jì��£ñ4´:þ.�£ñ��[ùÅûVóJñ;�JõVù��%ïsó(n�õVñ[ú$!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óÑ*Ì*ë�Ñ*Å�ùÅúVøk%±ùÅòJñx=YòJó���ûVó�ñ[ø2ý � ñxúVñFñ[ø;�bì�øVì�úVì��JõVï�úVö±ì^ú;�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú�ÓA�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ�ï���õVù^ó�bõYòJñFñ|!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFóxù^úYø�ïsó�ù^ó�óJï�ö^úVñFøY�bõVò�ñ[ñ±ó�ð�ì��bó<ý)&]ú��bõVñ%ñ[úVø�þ��JõVñ|�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñWÑ*í@ï�ó+ó�õVù^ò�ñ[øY���ù^ð�ð��bõYòJñFñ�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVó<þc/Bþ Ò þDùÅúVøaÓBý�:ý �:ý � �A u  ½P��� ¹�·u¸¢Æ1��  ½ ºlÅ�¾ µ�º�·u¸a¹�½�¾ µ�Æ�·uºl¹+µ�¾Mº�XCo�ôu�bñFòA�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�óJõYù^ò�ïsúVöuþBï�ôC�bõVñ�ó�ï>�[ñgP ìÅô

vwlWn�ü����ï�óxó��bï�ðsðBð�ù^ò�ö^ñFòC�bõVùÅúk½�þ�n�ñ õVù"!^ñ��bì�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ¸îVù^ò��bó�ìÅô��bõYñ/�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ ï�ú��JõVñ�õVñFù^î2ý� ñ�øVì(�bõVï�ó�� ��îYû��t�JïsúVö�½dXz3s!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�ï�ú��bì�ìÅúVñ+ó�ð�ì���ñFù��lõ�ùÅúVø�îVù �M��ïsúVöA�bõVñ¸òJñFí�ù^ï�úVïsúYöP�XQ½ké'3C!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ïsú��bìA�bõVñ�õVñ[ùÅîw�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñDý � ñ@�lõYìDìÅóJñx�JõVñ[ó�ñý½bX�3C!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óG�Vù^ó�ñ[ø�ìÅú�bõYñ%ô�ìÅðsð�ì"n�ïsúYö4�[ò�ï>�bñ[ò�ï�ù:ý@K�ï�ò�ó���þ8n0ñ%ô�ù"!^ì^òD�bõVìÅóJñ(!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFóDn�ï>�bõ��bõVñ�ó�í�ùÅðsð�ñ[òw  Å�¹�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ�îVû��t�JïsúYö��bõVñFí ï�ú(òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó��[ù^ú�ù"!Åì^ï�ø��Fì^úVó��bò�û����JïsúYö)ñ����bò�ù��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó�ý�ÿYñ��[ìÅúVø2þn�ñ�óJñFðsñ����;�bõYì^ó�ñ�!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó;n�ï��Jõm�bõVñ·ó�í�ù^ð�ðsñFò�»PÅ�¹�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò4�£ñ��[ù^ûYóJñ��JõVïsó�í�ù��^ñFó;�bõVñFíñ[ùÅóJï�ñ[òG�bì�ù ���Fñ[ó�ó�ý r õVï�òJø2þ�n�ñs�lõVñ��M��ï�ô��bõVñD!`ùÅòJï�ù��Yðsñxï�ó�ùÅðsò�ñ[ùÅø���ïsúw�JõVñ@�FûVò�òJñFú �R�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó�ü�ï]ý ñDý�þY�?�w�1�@�F�@�����ì^ò+úVì���?�n�ñ±ù^ð�ó�ì�ûVóJñA�bõVñ(�[ì^ú��Jñ[ú��bó�ì^ô��������@�F�@���D�bì@øVñ��FïsøVñ

Page 19: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe Õ!Ä

n�õVï>�lõY!`ùÅòJï�ù��Yðsñ¸ö^ì�ñ[óx�Jì�n�õVï��lõ-ó�ðsì �C�bì�ù"!^ìÅïsø�ûVúVúVñ��[ñFóJó�ù^ò���òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò,í�ì"!^ñFó�ý&]ú@ì^ûYò�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþÅô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú0/�ï�ó,ù^ó�óJï�ö^úYñ[øw�,n�ì�ó�ðsì �bóC�Vû��F/�õVùÅó�ó�ï>�<�JòJûYñ�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�þ

ó�ì�ìÅúVð��6ì^úVñ-ì^ô@�bõVñFí �[ùÅúE�:ñ-ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø6ï�úÿ�bõVñ-ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò<ý � ñ-îVû��;!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ7i�ï�ú��bõVñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò;�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ-ï��@õVù^ów�JõVñ�ó�í�ùÅðsð�ñ[ó���»PÅ�¹�ú�ûVí(�£ñFò_ü�ù^ð�ð@!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�õVù"!ÅñY�bõVñ·ó�ù^í�ñ³  Å�¹ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò"bý�:ý �:ý À Ô.¾ µl��¹+·u¸"Æ(ºl�+»PµP zL�  ·u¸M{�µ�R|�P  ½�ºlÅ�¾ µPº�XCKQï�úVù^ð�ð���þ�n0ñ0øVñ��FïsøVñ)�bõVñ0ðsù"�Åì^û���ô�ì^ò��JõVñ�óJîVï�ð�ðsñFø

õVñFù^î�ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø�yEn�õYï��lõ;�Fì^ú��bùÅïsúVó��bõYì^ó�ñ�P�XE½0éz3x!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�yE�Yù^ó�ñ[ø�ì^ú4�bõVñw  Å�¹VúDûYíA�:ñ[ò�ó�ýr õVñ�  Å�¹QúDûYíA�:ñ[ò±ï�úVøVï>�[ù �bñ[óAn�õVñ[ú�ù�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ�í%ûVó��/�£ñw�Fì^úVó�ï�øVñ[ò�ñ[ø ù^ó±øYñ[ù^ø�ý r ì�ùÅðsð�ì"nì��JõVñ[ò{ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúVóR�bì ó�õVù^ò�ñ)�JõVï�óR�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�n�õVï�ðsñ�úYì���!�ïsìÅðsù �bï�úVöD�JõVñ,ÿVÿ2ë_òJûYðsñ�þ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó.n�ï>�bõøVï�ó��Jïsú2���(  Å�¹£ú�ûVí(�£ñFòJó�ó�õVì^ûYðsøY�:ñ�îVû���ï�ú �Jì�ù�ó�ñ[îYù^ò�ù��bñ ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø2ýKYì^ò ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�/�ï�ú ì^ûVò ñ���ùÅí�îYðsñ�þuù^ð�ðR=�!^ñ�ô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó�Ñ�Ì*ë*Ñ*Å)ù^úVø�%�õVù"!Åñ(�JõVñ��bõVñ

ó�ù^í�ñE  Å�¹�ú�ûVí(�£ñFòJó<ý ÿVì$n�ñ��Fì^úVó��bò�û�����ù(ó�ï�úVö^ð�ñ�òJñ��[ìÅòJøZÑ*í ù^ó�ó�õVì"n�úUì^úÿ�2ïsúVñ'�83)ï�úKQïsöÅûVò�ñ�7^ý r õVñ4=YúVù^ð�ñ[ú�!�ïsò�ì^úYí�ñFú��±ðsù"�Åì^û���ô�ì^òQ/�ï�ó<�bõVñF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñEÑ*í_îVð�ûVó<�bõVñF!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñiBý � ñ�=VúVï�óJõ�îVò�ì �Fñ[ó�óJï�úVöÁ/(����ûVî:øVù �bï�úVö(�JõVñ`}g~?�w���=�w��þ�}g~?�@���Q�T�w�·ù^úVøO�?�w�1�@�F�@���ñ[ú�!�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú��bó,ù����[ìÅòJøVï�úVöÅð��;�VùÅóJñFø�ìÅú��JõVï�ós=VúVùÅð�òJñFîVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^ú2ý&]úw�bõVñ�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñ+ï�úwKQï�ö^ûVò�ñ(3^þ��bõYñ@�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñxô�ì^ò2B�í�ûVó���ó�îVð�ï��0ï��Jó0ô�ò�ñ[ñD!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�ïsú��JìA�,n�ì

ò�ñ��[ìÅòJøYó��:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñxC�~ ó(  Å�¹£ú�ûVí(�£ñFòsn�ù^ó,øVï>�£ñFòJñFú ��ô�ò�ì^í �bõVìÅóJñ ì^ô>3(ê�4�ê�5(ê�6Bý&,��ïsó�ï�í�î£ìÅò��Jù^ú����bì-úVì��Jñ��bõVù ���JõVñ�  Å�¹2ú�ûVí(�£ñFòJó ù^ò�ñ�úVì�� ñFóJó�ñ[ú��bï�ù^ðQô�ìÅò/�bõVñ�ÿVÿ�ë ò�ûVðsñ

ñ�!Åñ[úY�bõYì^ûVöÅõFn�ñ�ûVó�ñ/�bõVñFí²�Jì�øVñ��FïsøYñ|�bõVñ/�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ ð�ù"�^ì^û2�`ýs��ûVò+ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí ó�ù��Jïsó�=VñFóx�bõVñÿVÿ2ë òJûVð�ñA�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñAn�ñ�úYñ�!^ñFò�ò�ñ[ûYóJñ±ù��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñA�bõYù����VòJï�úVöÅó+ï�ú_ù^øYøVï��JïsìÅúVù^ð�ô�ò�ñ[ñA!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óü�ó�ñ[ñ�ÿYñ����JïsìÅú$�:ý �:ý ´8Jý�KYìÅò|�bõVñ@ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñ�ïsú$KQï�ö^ûVò�ñ'3^þ�ïsôCn�ñ�ù����[ï�øVñ[ú��bð>�_ùÅóJó�ï�ö^úVñFø�C'�bõVñó�ù^í�ñ� JÅ�¹2úDûYíA�:ñ[ò ù^óx3(ê�4�ê�5(ê�6Bþ��JõVñ;�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ô�ì^òWBYn�ì^ûYðsø îVû�� ù^ð�ðR=�!Åñ(!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó ï�ú �Jì�ùó�ïsúVöÅðsñ ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø2ý r õYïsósn�ï�ð�ðBîVòJñ�!^ñFú �ý/�ô�ò�ì^í òJñFûVóJï�úVö�B�~ óx�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�üu�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñxC�ï�ó�úVì��,ô�ò�ñ[ñ�ï�ú/�bþ��Yû���ï��xn�ì^ú-~ �,øVñFó��JòJì"�;�JõVñ�ÿVÿ2ë6îVò�ì^î:ñ[ò��,�Dý�:ý �:ý � ls·u¸SR�·u¸¢ÆA¹�U µx���l�lµ�ºlº8¿���¹�Uh»P½�¾G¸a½�¸a¼,  ½��l�  NP��¾M·u�P�  µPº�X � õVñ[ú/�JòJùÅúVóJð�ù��JïsúYöx�bõVñ��:ì�ø��

ì^ô2ñ[ù �lõ@ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú-ï�ú �Jì��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñF÷IîYù^ó�óJï�úVö±ó��,��ðsñ�þ n0ñ¸úVñ[ñFø��Jì�òJñFîVðsù �[ñ¸ñ[ù �lõ�ì����FûVò�òJñFú��[ñ�ì^ô�ùô�ò�ñ[ñ|!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ�¼�� �-ï>�bó¸ù����[ñ[ó�óxîVù �bõ2ý r õVï�ó@�[ùÅú��:ñA�[ùÅð��FûVð�ù��bñFø�����øVìÅïsúYö@ùw�Vò�ñ[ùÅø��bõY÷�=Vò�ó��ó�ñ[ù^ò��lõ�ì^ôG¼-ï�ú'�JõVñd}�~?�@�1�@�=���(ñFú�!Dï�ò�ì^úVí�ñ[ú���ý � ñ%ûYóJñ(�bõVñ³#að�ù����)øYïsó�îVð�ù"� %4�bñ��lõYúVï�p�ûVñûVó�ñ[øY���w}�ò�ù^ú��;0�365�9�7M:]þ^ó�ì��bõVù ��ðsìÅù^øVó�ìÅô��Fì^í�í�ì^ú)îVù��JõVós�[ùÅú��:ñ�ó�õVù^ò�ñ[ø2ý��ñ���~ ó@�bù��ÅñD�JõVñ�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�j¸ï�úYKQïsöÅûVòJñ���ù^ó�ùÅú�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñ �

ë6ì�íÿþ2î�õFö�ñ���ò���ó��zôr õVñ�óJùÅô�ñ[ð>�-ðsï�ú��^ñFø'�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ�ô�ìÅòEj±ï�ó óJõYì"n�ú·ïsú ï�ú'KQïsöÅûVò�ñF3�?:ï>���[ìÅú �Jù^ï�úVó¸ù4�[ì�øVñ�î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[òîVð�ûVóxù�î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[òs�Jì��bõVñ±ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø4�Fì^ú��bùÅïsúVï�úVö�3(ê�4�ê�5(ê�6Bý�o@���[ñFóJó�ïsúYö�ñ[ù��lõ)ì^ô.�bõVñFóJñ/!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óï�úVóJï�øVñWj�òJñ�pDûYïsò�ñ[ó�ô�ì^ð�ðsì"n�ï�úVöD�,n0ì�ðsï�ú���ó�þP�Yû��.n�ñ��[ù^úA=VòJó���ðsìÅù^ø|�JõVñ)�ÅúVøA=Yñ[ð�ø�ì^ô2�bõVñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñm�ï�ú��bì ù�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòpçYþ�ù^úVø<�bõYñ[ú�ù����Fñ[ó�óG3uþ�4uþ�5uþ<ù^úVøQ6 øVï�òJñ����bð>�±ô�ò�ì^í ç�!�ïsù¸ì^úVñ,ð�ì^ùÅø2ý r õVñFóJñï�ú �Jñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ/!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�üÀñDý ö:ý�þ�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFò�çaQí�ù"��ûVóJñ ûVî��JõVñ�ù"!�ù^ï�ðsù �Vð�ñ¸í�ù �lõVïsúYñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�óù^úYøE�Fù^ûVó�ñ�ûYúVúVñ��Fñ[ó�óJùÅò���ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFò%ó�îVï�ðsð�ïsúYö:þR�Yû����bõVï�ó;�[ùÅúE�:ñY=���ñ[ø�� �(ìÅúVð>�$�^ñ[ñFîVï�úVö�ùð�ïsí�ï>�bñ[ø-ú�ûVí(�£ñFòxì^ô2ïsú��bñFòJí�ñFøVïsù �bñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó�ï�úF�JõVñ�#að�ù�����øVï�óJîVð�ù"��%-üÀòJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�Jý

r ì�ó�ûVí�í�ù^ò�ï��FñDþ�n0ñ±ûYóJñFø��bõVñ(!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñF÷Ið�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ±ïsúYô�ì^ò�í�ù �bï�ì^úY�bì@øVñ��FïsøVñ(�bõVñA=VúVù^ð-�[ð�ì^÷ó�ûVòJñ�ðsù"�Åì^û���ý r õVï�ó2ï�ó�ìÅúVð�� ùÅú�ì^î��Jïsí�ï>�[ù��JïsìÅú|�bì+í�ù �^ñ��JõVñG�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ��FòJñFù��JïsìÅú¸ùÅúVø|�JõVñ�ù ���[ñFóJóô�ù^ó��bñFò�ý-�+ñ[ö^ùÅòJøYðsñFóJó�ì^ô-n�õVù��x!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[óCn�ñ îVû��xï�úY�bõVñ�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó,ù^úYø�n�õVñ��bõVñFòxì^ò�úYì��Cn0ñûVó�ñ%ó�ù^ô�ñFð��-ð�ïsú2�^ñ[ø'�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó�þ2�bõYñ%ù ���bûYù^ð�ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVíÇn�ì^ûVð�ø·ù^ð>n�ù"�Dó�óJù �bï�óJôu�Y�JõVñ%ÿYÿ2ëUò�ûVðsñù^ó�ð�ì^úYö�ùÅóxn0ñ úVñ�!^ñFò�óJõVùÅòJñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[óC�bõYù��x�Vò�ïsúYö�ï�ú-úVñ�n�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó±ü�ó�ñ[ñ ÿVñ����bï�ì^úY�uý �uý ´�bý

Page 20: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

]!Ö ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

KYì^ò�ì^ûYòxj.<*9*8�ñ��DùÅí�îVðsñ¸ï�ú4KQïsöÅûVò�ñ<7^þÅúVì �0ìÅúVð>�QÑ*í�ï�ó�ó�õVùÅòJñFø;� ��ùÅðsð8�bõYòJñFñ�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYóF/BþÒ þ`ù^úVø�ÓBþP�Vû��{ï>�bóG�[ò�ñ[ù��JïsìÅú%ï�ó{ì^û2�bó�ïsøVñx�JõVñ�/�ð�ì�ì^î2ý r õ�ûVó�þ<ñ[ù��lõ�ï>�bñ[ò�ù��JïsìÅú%ìÅôè/±í�ùÅúVù^öÅñ[ó��bì�[ùÅðsð-�,n�ì@ñ[ó��[ùÅîVï�úVö@ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó�n�ï>�bõYì^û��¸ù^ú��-í�ñ[í�ì^ò��Y�bò�ù����Dý r õVï�ó ïsó ù��lõYïsñ�!^ñ[ø�n�ï>�bõYì^û���bò�ñ[ù �bï�úVöA�Jù^ï�ðBòJñ��[ûVò�ó�ïsìÅú�ù^ó,ù%ó�î:ñ��[ï�ù^ð��Fù^ó�ñ�ü�ùÅóCn0ùÅó0øVìÅúVñ�� �;}�ò�ù^ú2�<0>3M5�9�7M:,bý�&]úVó��bñ[ùÅø2þ n0ñì^úYð���ûVó�ñ[øw�JõVñ+ó�ï�í�îYðsñD�[ù^ð�ð:ö^ò�ù^îVõ2þ¢�bõVñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñxðsï�ô�ñ[÷+�bï�í�ñ+ï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��JïsìÅú2þ�ùÅúVøw�JõVñ@�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷ó��bò�ù��bñFö���ù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�ó�þQùÅðsð,ìÅôsn�õVï>�lõ ùÅòJñ�ûVóJñFô�ûVð�ô�ì^ò�ì �bõVñFò�îYûVòJî:ì^ó�ñ[ó�ùÅú ��n�ù"�Dý r õVï�ó�ïsó�ùÅúï�í�î:ì^ò��bùÅú���ó��bò�ñ[úYö��bõ)ì^ô�ì^ûYò�úVñ�n ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí·ýî T � O£=��±9`G.�^Hþ�ò�ù^îVõV÷+�[ìÅðsìÅòJï�úVö�öÅðsì �Vù^ðQò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFò ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bï�ì^ú ù^úYø��Jù^ò�ö^ñ��JïsúYö:þ8n�õVï>�lõ�õYù"!^ñA�:ñ[ñFú�ïsí�îVð�ñ[÷í�ñ[ú��bñFø(���|�2ù^ð-þ�ñ[ìÅòJöÅñ�0>3M5 5���?�3M5�5 ��:]þ�n�ïsð�ð�ù����[ì^í�îVð�ï�óJõ%í�ìÅó����Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð �bò�ù^úVó�ô�ñ[ò�óxü�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�[ùÅðsð�ó"�ü�ó�û��lõ�ù^ó0ðsï�úVñ(36��ù^úVø�3M´�ï�úwKQï�ö^ûVò�ñA7��n�ï>�bõYì^û���ùÅú���ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�÷aòJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[òQí�ì"!^ñ[ó<ý r õYïsóù^ð�ð�ì"n�ó+ù@í�ìÅòJñ|�Yñ���ï��Yðsñ(�£ìÅûVúVøVùÅò��Y�:ñ��,n�ñ[ñ[ú'�[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷aó�ù"!^ñ�ù^úYø��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ò�÷Ió�ù"!^ñ ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJóD�bõVùÅúï�ó�úVì^ò�í�ù^ðBï�ú)í�ìÅó��C�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò�ó<ý*�ò�ì^ö^ò�ù^í�ó<þ�ï�ú-ì^ûVò+ó��lõVñFí�ñDþ �bñFúVø��bì�ù ���FûVí�ûVð�ù��Jñ�!`ùÅðsûYñ[ó�ï�ú�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�ùÅúVø-ì^úVð>��øVûYí�î

�bõYñ[í ïsú��bì�ù|�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ù ��ï�úVô�òJñ�p�ûVñ[ú���ï�ú��bñ[ò�!�ù^ð�ó�ý�&,��í�ù"�A�:ñ+ûYóJñFô�ûVð2�Jì±ûVó�ñ�í�ìÅòJñx�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñü�ùÅúVø-ô�ñ�n�ñ[òx�Fù^ð�ðsñFòJ÷aóJù"!Åñ �òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó��Jì�ì^î��Jïsí�ï>�[ñ/�bõYïsó<ý��ûVò.�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ0ó��lõVñFí�ñ�õVùÅúVøVð�ñ[ó��bùÅïsð��[ùÅðsð�ó-!^ñ[ò�� úVï>�[ñ[ð>�Dþ`ó�ï�í�îYð��/����ò�ñ[÷aù^ò�òJùÅúVö^ï�úVö�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<ý

�+ùÅúVó�ì^ú£0�365�5�� :,óJõVì"n�ó�õVì"n²�[ìÅí�îYðsï>�[ù �bñ[ø��bõYïsúVöÅów�:ñ��[ìÅí�ñFn�õYñ[úUï���~ ó@úVñ��Fñ[ó�óJùÅò��z�bì(ò�ñ[÷ù^ò�ò�ù^úVöÅñ+ù�ó��Jù��M��ô�ò�ù^í�ñ�ýo ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úF�bõYù����[ù^ð�ð�ó�ó�ñ�!Åñ[ò�ù^ð£ì��bõYñ[ò,ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó,ï�ú@ó�ñ�p�ûVñ[ú2�[ñ�n0ìÅûVðsø�þ^ï�ú@îYòJñ�!Dï�ì^ûYó ë-*0ÿ

�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò�ó@ü�ï�ú��FðsûVøYïsúVö_ì^ûVò±ì"n�ú-bþBùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ�ù��[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ô�ì^ò�ñFù��lõz�[ùÅðsð]ý r õVñ�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó,ù^úVø)óJùÅô�ñ[ð>��ð�ïsú��Åñ[øY�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó,ù^ð�ð�ì"n ûVóx�Jì�ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bñ¸ì^úVð>��ìÅú��[ñ�ýþ�ñ[úVñFòJùÅð�øVñ[ñFî(òJñ��[ûVò�ó�ïsìÅúVó�ù^ò�ñ�õVù^úYøVðsñFøz!^ñ[ò��_ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��bð>��ï�ú(ì^ûYò�ó��lõVñFí�ñDý4oæ�[ìÅú !Åñ[úV÷

�bï�ì^úYù^ð�ó��bù �M�_ï�í�îVðsñFí�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^ú1�Jñ[úVøVó<�bì_õVù"!^ñ�ù·õYïsöÅõ(óJîVù �[ñ�ì"!Åñ[ò�õVñ[ùÅø�î:ñ[ò�ô�ò�ù^í�ñDþ��Vû��ì^ûYò��FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó¸ùÅòJñ<p�ûVï>�bñ��[ìÅú��[ï�óJñ�ý r õ�ûVó/�Jì��bùÅð{í�ñ[í�ì^ò���ûVó�ù^ö^ñ-ü�ùÅúVøz�[ù��lõYñ(�Fì"!^ñ[ò�ù^öÅñ QìÅôò�ñ��[ûYòJó�ïsìÅúVó-n�ïsð�ð��£ñ,í%û��lõ%ð�ñ[ó�ó<ý�o ó��bù��M� ï�í�îVðsñFí�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^ú<�bõVù ��ûYóJñFó{úVì^úV÷aó��bù^úYøVù^ò�ø±ð�ù"�^ì^û2��[ùÅú-ù^ð�óJì�õVù"!Åñ�ù�ðsì"n î£ñFòJ÷aô�òJùÅí�ñ�ì"!^ñ[ò�õVñFù^ø2þ �Vû2�xï��+ó��Jïsð�ð�õVùÅós�bì�ò�ñ[ó�ñ[ò�!^ñ¸î:ñ[ò�÷Iô�ò�ù^í�ñ�ó�îVù��Fñô�ì^òA�  u �ð�ì��[ùÅð8!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ûVó�ñ[ø�ïsúF�bõVñ ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�ý r õVñ��bñ��lõYúVï�p�ûVñ¸ì^ô2ù^ó�óJì��Fïsù �bï�úVö|�bõYñ¸ò�ñ��JûVò�úù^øYøVòJñFóJó�n�ï>�bõ)ù%ð�ï�!Åñ[úVñFóJó,øVñFó��FòJï�î��Jì^ò�ü�ó�ñ[ñ¸ÿVñ����bï�ì^ú4��2ì^úVð>��ïsí�îVò�ì"!^ñFóG�JõVñ õVñ[ùÅîV÷Ió�îVù �[ñ+ûYóJ÷ù^öÅñ ?��JõVñ@øYñ[ù^ø6ñ[ú��bò�ïsñFó%ï�ú1�JõVñ@ô�ò�ù^í�ñ4n�ï�ð�ð0úVì �(�:ñ@ò�ñ��FðsùÅïsí�ñFø(ûVú��bï�ð�n�ñ@î:ì^î³�bõVñ�ô�òJùÅí�ñì��³�bõVñ�ó��bù �M�Bý r õYñ<�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú��FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�ï�ú ìÅûVò�ó��lõVñ[í�ñ��bñFúVøVó|�Jì��£ñ�í�ì^ò�ñ��[ìÅí�îYù�����:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ¸ï>��ì^úYð���õYì^ð�øVóxô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFóC�bõVù ��ù^ò�ñ¸ð�ï>!^ñ ïsúY�JõVñ�òJñFó��,ìÅô2ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úY�:ì�ø��Dý�:T ê27{52P�5Vé¸?0N�çsPD5o öÅì�ìDøUñFú !�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú���ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅúUó��lõVñFí�ñ·í�ûVó��@ï�í�îVð�ñ[í�ñ[ú��@ô�ò�ñ�p�ûVñFú��bð>� ûVó�ñ[øm�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ðó��bò�û����JûVòJñFó�!^ñ[ò��(ñ����FïsñFú �Jð���ý$�·ùÅú��1�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò�ó�ïsøVñFú��bï�ôu� óJî:ñ��FïsùÅðC�[ì^ú��JòJìÅð�ó��bò�û����bûVò�ñ[ó�ù���[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ@�Jïsí�ñ�þ^ùÅúVø�ùÅóJó�ïsöÅú�ñ[ù �lõ�ì^ô��JõVñ[í ù�ó�î:ñ��[ï�ù^ð8�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñxù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú�ó��JòJù �bñ[ö �Dý�KYìÅò�ñ���÷ù^í�îVð�ñDþ^ï�ú;}�òJùÅú�� ~ ó@��ò��Yï����Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFòD0 }�òJùÅú��A3M5 987M:]þ�ùÅðsð��Jù^ï�ðYò�ñ��FûVòJó�ï�ì^úVó�ùÅòJñ�ùÅóJó�ï�ö^úVñFø%ù±ó�ì^÷�[ùÅðsð�ñ[øzº�¹+���!{t¡8  ½P½M¿�ó��bò�ù��Jñ[ö���þ�ùÅúVø�ùÅðsð:ö^ñFúVñ[ò�ù^ð£òJñ��[ûVò�óJï�ì^úYó�ù^ò�ñ+ùÅóJó�ï�ö^úVñFø�ùYºl¹�� �.{t¡8¾tµ��PÅ�¾Mºl·u½�¸ó��bò�ù��bñFö���ý���ûYòxúVñ�n��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ|�Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú@ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí·þ�ì^ú��JõVñ�ì �bõVñFòxõVùÅúVø2þYûVúVï�ô�ì^ò�í�ð>�)øVñ[÷�[ï�øVñFós�bõVñA�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ�ó��bò�ù��Jñ[ö ��ü�ï]ý ñ�ýsþVú�ûVíA�:ñ[òxìÅôQóJð�ì��Jó��ùÅúVøY�bõVñ|�FðsìÅóJûYòJñ�ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jù��bï�ì^ú�ô�ì^òñ[ù �lõ�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�ó�ì^ð�ñ[ð>���Vù^ó�ñ[ø�ì^ú/�bõYñ0ð�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ0ï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��JïsìÅú±ì^ô�ï>�bóQô�ò�ñ[ñG!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó2ù^úVø�óJï�í�îVðsñ�[ìÅú��bò�ì^ð��Vì"n ï�úVô�ìÅòJí�ù��JïsìÅú2ý&]ú�ÿVñ����bï�ì^ú;´:ý �:þ¢n0ñ+õVù"!^ñ�ó�õVì"n�ú�õVì"n�ì^ûVò0ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí ï�í�îVð�ñ[í�ñ[ú��bó��bùÅïsð£òJñ��[ûVò�ó�ïsìÅúVóR!^ñFò��

ñ����FïsñFú �Jð��_üÀï�ý ñDý�þDô�ûVú����bï�ì^úÚj.<�9*8�bý�&]úF�bõVï�ó,óJñ����bï�ì^ú�þ n0ñ¸ûVó�ñ�í�ì^ò�ñ+ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñ[óC�bì�óJõYì"n#õVì"n�bõYñ)úYñ�n ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí øVñ[ùÅðsó�n�ï>�bõ�ì��bõYñ[ò<�[ì^í�í�ì^úE�[ìÅú �JòJìÅð0ó��bò�û����bûVò�ñ[ó�ó�û��lõ6ùÅó%ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú

Page 21: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe ]!Õ

ë6ì�íZ�Pø��8î+úhð¯ì.ðZïhðZñ�õ'ö÷�ø�ùzï¢û�÷'ò$ö'ú�îZì.ð�ï õ

ï¢û�÷'ó$ö'ú�î+òhðZñ�õï¢û�÷�ôzö'ú�î+óhð�ò õ

þlí$ò��Pó���ô���ï��*øMí�ý

ØVn>�^��[^�UØ<v�i`jbrtn>dliE¤����Qn>i�ªJrtyli�e�ylgIe c�«

ë6ì�í³ë�î�­�ð�úhð¯ì.ðZïhðZñ�õ'ö÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�íZ¯2î+ò õ�ö

÷�ø�ù$ë�ìPíÚ®�î+ó�õYö÷�ø�ù$ë�ìPíe±aîô õYö

÷Pø�ù�ï�ûP÷ �$ö�ò��Pó���ô���ï��*þlíÚ­�î���õølí�ý

þlí1ú�î@±8ð�óhð�ò õøMí�ý

þlí1ú�î�®hð�òhðZñ�õøMí�ý

þlí$ú�î\¯að¯ì.ðZï�õøMí�ý

ØVn>�^�D¯aµ^��Ø<v�i`jbrtn>dliE¤����{n>i���Þ{ª

ù^îYîVðsï>�[ù �bï�ì^ú)ïsú-ó�ñ�p�ûVñFú��[ñ�þ �DúYì"n�ú�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úY�Fù^ð�ð�þDùÅúVø-ö^ñ[úYñ[ò�ù^ðuòJñ��[ûVò�ó�ïsìÅú2ý�:T æ Ä!²ÅADZ[K]C>\ÅA�Z[9<;>;>H,C>A�Hb=��²D=[ADZ[=o��[ìÅí�í�ìÅú4�[ìÅú��bò�ì^ð:ó��JòJû����bûVò�ñ ïsú)ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVùÅðuîVòJìÅö^ò�ù^í�ó�ïsóC�bì�í�ù��Åñ�ù�ó�ñ�p�ûVñ[ú2�[ñ¸ì^ô�ô�ûYú��[÷�bï�ì^ú�ù^îYîVðsï>�[ù �bï�ì^úVóQùÅó�ó�õVì"n�ú(� �A�bõVñ,ñ���ùÅí�îYðsñ,ï�ú(KQï�ö^ûVò�ñ)5uýh��ñ[ò�ñDþ�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅúÁB y�n�õVï��lõ%ïsó{ùô�ì^ò�í�ù^ð£îVù^ò�ù^í�ñ��Jñ[ò0ì^ô(:.9@� y�ï�óG�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ø4�bõVò�ñ[ñD�bï�í�ñFó,ïsú�ù%òJì"n�ý��,ì��Jõw�bõVñ¸îVùÅòJùÅí�ñ��bñFòJó�üÀï�ý ñDý�þB(ê�1�ê�C(ê�3��ù^úVøE�bõVñ)ðsì��Fù^ð�!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó)ü�ï]ý ñDý�þA4(ê�5�ê�6�,ùÅòJñ�îVðsù �[ñFø ïsú òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�óA����øVñ[ô�ùÅûVð>�`ý&]ú·ù�ó��bù �M��÷��VùÅóJñFø-ó��lõVñFí�ñDþYù^ú�ù����bï>!�ù��bï�ì^ú�ò�ñ��Fì^ò�øYn�ïsð�ð.�:ñ�îYûVóJõYñ[ø·ìÅú �Jìw�bõYñ�ó��bù��M�Fn�õVñFúô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�%±ï�ó�ï�ú�!^ì��Åñ[ø.?"�bõVñFú�ñFù��lõ<�bï�í�ñs�£ñFô�ì^ò�ñ�B�ï�ó��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ø2þ"�[ñ[ò��bùÅïsú�!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[óQï�ú�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�óí�ûYó��|�:ñ�ó�ù"!^ñFø��Jì��bõVñ�ó��bù �M��ý;KYìÅò�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþ��:ñ[ô�ì^ò�ñ;�bõYñw=Vò�ó��/�Fù^ð�ðG�bìßBBþ��bõVñ@òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�óõVìÅðsøVï�úVö�B�ùÅúVøa3�í�ûVó��x�:ñ�óJù"!Åñ[ø@ó�ì��bõVù �x�bõVñ��4�Fù^ú)ó��Jïsð�ðh�:ñ�òJñ��bò�ïsñ�!^ñ[ø�ù^ôu�Jñ[ò�B�ò�ñ��JûVò�úVó�ý&]ô�ù����Jï�!�ù �bï�ì^ú(ò�ñ��[ìÅòJøYó±ù^ò�ñ�ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø(ì^ú$�JõVñ@õVñFù^î2þ.�JõVïsúYö^ó�öÅñ��±í%û��lõ1n�ì^ò�óJñ�ý�BG!^ñFò��

�bï�í�ñ�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó úVñ[ñFøz�bì��:ñ�óJù"!Åñ[ø��£ñFô�ì^ò�ñ�ù�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú$�[ùÅðsð]þBùY�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�òJñ��[ì^ò�ø õVù^ó/�Jì��£ñ�VûVï�ð>�+ì^úY�JõVñ±õVñFù^î2ý)�,ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ õVñ[ùÅî�ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bñFøF�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó�ù^ò�ñ�úVì��s�Fì^ú��bï�ö^ûYì^ûVó�ï�ú·í�ñ[í�ì^ò��Dþù^ú�ñ����bò�ù�í�ñFí�ì^ò��An�ò�ï��Jñ%ü�ùÅúVø�ðsù �bñFò�ù�í�ñ[í�ì^ò���òJñFù^ø.:ìÅô8�JõVñxô�ò�ù^í�ñxî:ì^ï�ú��bñ[ò0ïsó0úVñ��Fñ[ó�óJùÅò��ù��,ñFù��lõ)ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúY�[ù^ð�ð]ý� ï��Jõ|�bõVñ�úVñ�nz�bñ��lõVúVï>p�ûVñ�ì^ô�ûVó�ï�úVöx�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�þ®õVñ[ùÅî�ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^ú ìÅôÅù ���bï>!�ù��JïsìÅú

ò�ñ��[ìÅòJøYó��Fù^úF�£ñ�í�ùÅøVñ ù^ð�í�ìÅó��,ùÅó�ñ����[ï�ñ[ú���ù^ó�ó��bù �M��ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^ú$0 o+îVî:ñ[ð�ùÅúVø-ÿVõVùÅì�365�5 ��:]ýr õVñ�ïsøYñ[ù+ï�ó-�bõVù �.n�ñG�Fù^ú±ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��Jñ�í�ì^ó���îYù^ò��bó�ì^ô��bõYñ)�FûVòJò�ñ[ú��2ù����Jï�!�ù �bï�ì^ú±ò�ñ��Fì^ò�ø�ïsú(�[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷ó�ù"!^ñ+ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ý � ï��Jõ��Fù^ò�ñ[ô�ûVðuð�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ�ùÅúVù^ð>��óJï�ó<þ^ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFò0ó�ù"!^ñ��^ò�ñ[ó��bìÅòJñ�ùÅòJìÅûVúVø�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú�[ùÅðsð�ó/�[ùÅú�ì^ôu�bñFúz�£ñ�ñFðsï�í�ïsúYù��bñFø�ì^ò�ù^í�ùÅðsöÅù^í�ù��Jñ[ø2þuó�ì�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úz�[ùÅðsð�ó±ï�ú�óJñ�pDûYñ[ú��Fñ�úVñ[ñFø

Page 22: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

]P] ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

�Yë�ì�í³ë8î�­���ð�­��ð�­�b8ð�­���ð�úhðuì.ð�ïhðZñ�õzö��b ÷�ø6ù$ë�ì�íZ¯,�8î\¯��ð@¯!b8ð�¯.�8ð�ò�õ'ö�!� ÷�ø�ù�ë�ì�íÚ®��8î�®c�ð�®�b8ð�®��8ð�ó�õ�ö�,Ø ÷�ø�ùzë�ì�íe±!�aî�±�ð@±!b8ð@±!��ð�ô õ'ö�!Ù ÷�ø�ù�ï�û�÷'ï$ö��Pø�÷�ø�Y6ù�î�Øhð�±Põ�!Û ï�û�÷ �$ö�±!�!��±!b.��ô��Pï��*�!Ü ï�û�÷­���öÚ�Pø�÷Pø�Y6ù�î@�8ð@±Põ�!Ý ï�û�÷­*FöÚ�Pø�÷Pø�Y6ù�î��ð@±Põ�!Þ ï�û�÷­�b'öÚ�Pø�÷Pø�Y6ù�î�bað@±Põ�� ï�û�÷­���öÚ�Pø�÷Pø�Y6ù�î@�8ð@±Põ! þlíÚ­��8î�­*�ð�­�b8ð�­���ð���õ"b øMí�ý�� ï�û�÷'ú��'ö°�Pø�÷Pø�Y6ù�î@�8ð�®�b�õ$Ø þlí$ú��8î�®�bað@±!��ð�®*�ð�óhð�®���ð�óhð�®�b�õ�Ù øMí�ý�Û ï�û�÷'ú���öÚ�PøP÷�ø�Y6ù�î���ð�¯!b�õ�Ü þlízú��8î\¯.b8ð�®���ð@¯��ð�¯!bað�òhð�òhð@¯.� õ�Ý øMí�ý�Þ ï�û�÷­,×1ö�î�­���ð�­*�ð�­�b8ð�­��8ð�ï�õb.� ï�û�÷'ú���öÚ�PøP÷�ø�Y6ù�î���ð�ú�õb� þ�í1ú��8î+ú�ð�¯.��ð�­,×�ð�úhðZñhð¯ì.ð�ï�õb!b øMí¢ý

ØVn>�^�D¯l¯l��Ø<v`i�jhrIn>dliE¤����{ylqwrtfbg�jho>dlpav`gaf{jhdliF�lfhgIpan>dli

��yl�`o>f��.�b�ÿ\�y�~�qwgafhfQ��ylgIn>yl��o>fhp2yli`e¸jho>dlpav�gIf{partgaylrtfh�ln>fbp�qwdlg�qwv�i�jhrtn>dliE¤����Ì Ô�Ò! ,Î`Ñ�Í�Ò ÒPÎ`Ï<Î�Õ�"¸Ô�Ð$#YÕFÌ %xÏ�& Ì Ì�Õ[Õ�'xÏ<Ì�ÑsÏ�# Í Õ[Ö Ï Í Í�ÖbÔ�Ì�Õ�ÒPÎ`Ì�Ï�Î`ÕFÎ Ô¤���� ¯ ( ¯2pao>dlr4 T )lz5/1,¤¨-,¤¨^}.,Jz © ,¤¨-,¤¨^}.,hz0��,VT-,¤¥^}.,hz+��,>T-,uT^}32 ¥,pao>dlrtp� ¥ )lz5/1,¤¨-,¤¨^}.,Jz © ,¤¨-,¤¨^}.,hz0��,¤¥-,¤¥^}.,hz0��,�¥-,�¨^}32 ¥,pao>dlrtp6 ¨ )lz5/1,¤¨-,¤¨^}.,Jz © ,¤¨-,¤¨^}.,hz0��,¤¨-,¤¨^}.,hz0��,�¨-,�¨^}32 ¥,pao>dlrtp

ì^úYð���ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ ì^úVñ õVñFù^î)òJñ��[ìÅòJø2ýK�ï�ö^ûYòJñFó�3M��ùÅúVø'3�3�ðsï�ó��G�bõVñ�ë-*�ÿ�ù^úYø�ë-���³�[ì�øVñ�ô�ì^ò�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú�:.9Q�Bý r ù �Vðsñ@&t&{ð�ïsó��bó)�bõVñ

ó��bù^öÅñ+ú�ûVí(�£ñFòJó<þÅòJù"nUô�ò�ñ[ñ�!`ùÅòJï�ù��YðsñFó�þ^ù^úVø��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ+ó��bò�ù��bñFö^ï�ñ[ó0ô�ì^ò,ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú �@ù^úVøw�Fì^ú��bï�úV÷ûVù �bï�ì^úVó Ò þcÏBþ�ùÅúVøaÓBý�v�ûYòJï�úVöw�JõVñ/�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ/�[ì^ú�!Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú�ì^ô�:,9@�_üÀù^óxó�õVì"n�ú-ï�ú�K�ï�ö^ûYòJñw3�3 bþ�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úYóxù^ò�ñ�ó��Jïsð�ð�ò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú �Jñ[ø-ù^ó�ì^úVñ/�Fì�øVñ±î:ì^ï�ú �Jñ[ò�îVðsûYó@�bõYòJñFñ|�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ¸òJñFö^ï�óJ÷�bñFòJó<þ<ùÅðsðYøVñ[úVì �bñFø<���(�[ù^îYï��Jù^ð�ð�ñ��t�Jñ[ò�ó�ý.o�ó��£ñFô�ì^ò�ñDþ�ñ[ó��[ù^îYïsúVö ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú;�Fù^ð�ðsó+üÀï�ý ñDý�þ��[ù^ð�ð�óR�bìWBì^ú�ð�ï�úVñ<36�:þ>3�7^þ �83 £ù^ò�ñxïsí�îVð�ñ[í�ñFú �Jñ[ø�ùÅóG=Vò�ó���óJñFðsñ����JïsúVöA�bõVñD��¾ Ý =VñFðsø�þ�îVð�ù��FïsúYö|�bõVñD�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñï>�bó�ñ[ð�ô+ï�ú ù�ó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ð,òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�üu�JõVñ�=Vò�ó���ô�ì^ò�í�ù^ð,îVù^ò�ù^í�ñ��bñ[ò"bþ{ù^úVø��bõVñFú øYì^ï�úVö�ù�#JIbûYí�în�ï>�bõ�ù^ò�ö^ûVí�ñFú �Jó�%�ü�ð�ïsúYñ[ó43M´Å÷l36�:þ>3M�Å÷l3 7^þ ���^÷+�83�bý@��ñFô�ì^ò�ñ(�JõVñ;=Vò�ó����Fù^ð�ð-�JìaB6ü�ð�ïsúYñ;�83�Jþ8n0ñîVû��R!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó��JõVù��QõVù"!Åñ0ó�í�ù^ð�ðsñFòs JÅ�¹ÅúDûYíA�:ñ[ò�ó�üÀï�ý ñDý�þ�B(ê�3�Vï�ú��bì��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ0òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó,üÀï�ý ñDý�þÒ ì(ê Ò Å�bþ:ùÅúVø�óJîYïsð�ðR�bõVñ�ò�ñ[ó���ü�ï]ý ñ�ýsþpÑ*Ì*ë�Ñ*Å(ê�C�{ï�ú �Jì-ù)õYñ[ù^î ò�ñ��[ìÅòJø�Ñ*í ü�ð�ïsúYñ'3M58Jý<ox���bõVñó�ñ��[ìÅúVø�ù^úVøz�JõVñ;�bõVï�ò�ø��Fù^ð�ðsóA�bìßB üÀðsï�úVñ'3 7^þ>3M�8JþuúVì�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFò�óJù"!Åñ��^ò�ñ[ó��bìÅòJñ�ïsó±úYñ��[ñFóJó�ù^ò��Dýr õVï�óxï�ó@�:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ/�bõVñ�ð�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ[ó+ìÅôG3�ù^úYøv4 ü�ùÅðsó�ì�B�ù^úYøß5��øYì�úVì���ì"!Åñ[ò�ðsùÅî2þDóJì;�JõVñ����[ùÅúIbûVó���óJõYù^ò�ñ¸ìÅúVñ��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò±ü�ï]ý ñ�ýsþ Ò Å�ù^úVøvÏ*Åuþ*Ï*ì�ùÅúVøaÓ*ì�Jý

Page 23: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe ]P±

ë6ì�í�[�û"�hîë�ð,÷�õ�ö÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�í�[.îô õ�ö

þ�ë�îô�ö6í�þP÷�õYù�ü øMízí�þ�÷ø�÷��Pøz÷Pø�ùzï�û�÷�û'ö°YPû`�$ô

ï�û�÷ß�zö°Y�ý.�$ôþlí�îë1û¢õM����î�[Ú��õølí�ý

þlíÂ[�÷øMí�ý

ØVn>�^�D¯+T^�UØ<v�i�jhrtn>dli`� ª *�n>i�ªbrIyli�e`ylgae c�«

�:T à X`9��$��MD9%;>C���K]C>A�µ�\^Ab��AD\���A��u²DAÅZFK]C>\^ADH� ��TÁP�R �w  · »P¹+·u¸"Æ40 � ì^õVúVó�ó�ì^ú�365�9�À :Yï�ó�ù(n�ñ[ð�ð�÷���úVì"n�úw�JòJùÅúVó�ô�ì^ò�í�ù �bï�ì^ú;�JõVù��,ò�ñ�n�ò�ï��Jñ[ó�ù%îVò�ì^÷ö^ò�ù^í ïsú��bì�ùÅú�ñ�p�ûVï>!�ù^ð�ñ[ú��{ì^úVñ�ï�ú;n�õVï>�lõ�úVì�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�õVùÅó�ô�òJñFñx!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó�ýh��ùÅíA�:øVù�ðsï�ôu�bï�úVöì^ú'�DúYì"n�ú·ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó¸ñ[ó�óJñFú��bï�ù^ð�ð��Y�[ìÅòJò�ñ[ó�î:ì^úVøVó@�bì4�JõVñ�óJî:ñ��FïsùÅð.�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ±ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú·ó��bò�ù��b÷ñ[ö �Y�bõVù ��ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��Jñ[ó¸ù^ó¸í�ù^ú��-ô�òJñFñA!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó+ï�ú_ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó�ù^ó¸î£ìÅóJó�ï>�Vðsñ�ýD��û2�D�JõVïsó ó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ðó��bò�ù��bñFö���øYìDñFó�úVì���ùÅð�n�ù"��ó,ö^ñ[úYñ[ò�ù��bñ ñ��<�FïsñFú��x�[ì�øVñ40 }�òJùÅú��w3M5�9�7M:]ý.KYì^ò�ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþ�ï�úY�bõVñô�ì^ð�ð�ì"n�ïsúVö�îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí·þ^ùÅóJó�ûVí�ñ��bõVù ��%�ï�ó�ù;��úVì"n�ú�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú2þ�ùÅúVø7i(ê�3(ê�4�ê�5BþÅù^úVøv6�ùÅòJñ ï>�bóô�ò�ñ[ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó

ë6ì�í³ë�ì1ö�î��zì�ð|ì���ñ���ò��Pó���ô!�*Põë6ì�í1ú�î+ò�ð�ó�õ�ö�î��1òhð(ë�òhð(ë�ó õ

&]ô2�JõVñC�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ô�ì^òG% ï�óQù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bñFø�ï�ú�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<þ��JõVñ[ú<�:ñ[ô�ì^ò�ñ��bõVñC�[ùÅðsð��Jì&i ï�úVó�ïsøVñýBBþ`ó�ì^í�ñ0ìÅô%�~ ó0ô�òJñFñs!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó�í%ûVó��)�£ñ+óJù"!Åñ[ø�ïsú4�bõVñ�õVñ[ùÅî�ì^ò�ó��bù �M�-üÀù^ó�óJûVí�ï�úVö|�JõVñ[ò�ñxù^ò�ñ�ì^úYð��<�bõVò�ñ[ñ�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ+òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�Jý � õVñFúY�bõVñ��[ùÅðsð��JìQi�ò�ñ��JûVò�úVó�þ �JõVñ[ó�ñ�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó0í%ûVó����:ñ òJñFðsìÅù^øVñFø�Vù �M��ïsú��Jì�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�þDùÅúVø-îVù^ó�óJñFø��Jì�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úß%�?�ù^ôu�Jñ[òxñFú��bñ[ò�ï�úVök%Bþ�óJìÅí�ñ¸ìÅô.�JõVñ[í ù^öÅù^ï�úõVù"!Åñ/�bì;�:ñ�ó�ù"!^ñ[øFn�õVñFúß%w�[ùÅðsð�óDiBþ�ùÅúVø�ó�ì�ì^ú2ý ë�ð�ñ[ù^ò�ð>�Dþ�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsúYöQ%�~ ó+ñFú !�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú���ï�úò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó�øYòJùÅí�ù �bï>�[ùÅðsð>��ï�ú��FòJñFù^ó�ñ[óh�JõVñ0úYñ[ñ[ø%ô�ì^ò2í�ìÅòJñ)�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ{ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó�ï�úVó�ïsøYñ2BBý r õYïsóð�ñ[ù^øYóD�Jì@í�ì^ò�ñ�í�ñ[í�ìÅò��F�bò�ù����An�õYñ[ú'�JõVñ[ò�ñ�ùÅòJñ%ì^úVð>�-ù@ð�ïsí�ï>�bñFø_ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò¸ì^ôR�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<ýr õVñs�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aó��JòJù �bñFö���ù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�ó�øVñ[ó��[ò�ï>�£ñFø�ïsú�ÿYñ����JïsìÅú;�:ý ´�ûVó�ñ[ó�ùÅú�ï��Jñ[ò�ù��Jï�!Åñ�ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí

�bì�øVñ��[ï�øVñ��bõVñ ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ìÅô�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó�ù^ó�óJï�ö^úVñFøw�bì�ñFù��lõ4��úVì"n�ú�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú2ý r õVñ ú�ûVí(�£ñFò�ìÅôò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó+ùÅóJó�ï�ö^úVñFø��bì0%Fn�ï�ðsð��:ñ�ò�ñ[ó��bò�ï����bñFø����F�JõVì^ó�ñ�ìÅô{ï��Jó��[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ò�ó�þ2�bõVù ��ï�ó<þ2�JõVñ�ò�ñ��JûVò�ú�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú�ô�ìÅò2iÊ4�ù^úVø4�bõVñ�òJñ��bûVò�úw�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú@ô�ì^ò��bõVñD=VòJó����[ù^ð�ð8�bìÉ%Bý.o+ó�ù�ò�ñ[ó�ûVð>�`þ%�ï�óxì^úYð���ùÅóJó�ï�ö^úVñFø@ì^úYñ�óJð�ì���þDù^úVø)ï��Jós�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�n�ïsð�ð��£ñ�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ[ø)ï�úF�JõVñ�õVñFù^î2ý�:T � 4{=[AD=[Ga9<;£Ga=[Z.²ÅGaHbC>\ÅAr õVñC�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsó2ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí øVñFó��FòJï>�:ñ[ø�ïsú�ÿVñ����bï�ì^ú(�:ý ´D�Fì^úVó�ñ[ò�!�ù��bï>!^ñFð�� ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jó2ùÅðsð�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó�ûVóJï�úVö/�JõVñxó�ù^í�ñC=���ñ[ø�ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ìÅôa�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ý � ñx�[ùÅúò�ñ[ð�ù��|�JõVïsó�òJñFó��JòJï>���JïsìÅú(n�õVñFú�n0ñx��úVì"nE�bõVñx�Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð��Vì"n�ý�KYìÅò{ñ���ù^í�îVð�ñDþ"�bõVñs�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúîVùÅòJùÅí�ñ��bñFò�ìÅôYù���úVì"n�ú�ûYóJñFò{ô�ûVú����JïsìÅú��[ù^ú<�:ñ�ò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú �Jñ[ø%ïsú�ù^ú���ú�ûVí(�£ñFò{ì^ô2�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<ýso�ðsð�n�ñ%úVñFñ[ø�ïsó��bì�í�ù��^ñ%óJûYòJñ<�bõVù �D�JõVñ�ù����JûVù^ð-�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú_ïsó ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bñFøï�ú��bõVñ%óJùÅí�ñ/n�ù"�Dý r õVï�ó+ó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ð.�[ù^ð�ð�ïsúVö;�Fì^ú�!^ñFú��bï�ì^ú)ïsó�ñ[ó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ð�ð��)øVñ[ó�ï�òJù �Vðsñ�ô�ìÅòxö^ñFúVñ[ò�ù^ðò�ñ��[ûYòJó�ïsìÅú@ó�û��lõ)ù^óx�bõYñWh�w*i�ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú)ùÅó�óJõYì"n�ú�KQï�ö^ûVò�ñw3M�:ýK�ï�ö^ûYòJñ�36´·ö^ï>!^ñFó�ù�!Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú�ìÅôx�bõVñ7h�w*i�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú1n�ò�ï����bñFú ïsú ë-*�ÿ2ý��+ì �bï>�[ñw�JõVù��(�bõVñ

ò�ñ��[ûYòJó�ï�!Åñ�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú°h ï�ó��[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ø ìÅúVð�� ù��<�,n�ì·îVð�ù��[ñFó���ìÅúVñ4����ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úeh�w*i�n�ï��Jõ�Ñ ù^ó

Page 24: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

] Ë ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

ë6ì�í�[�û"�hî�­�ð+ë�ð÷�õ�ö÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�í�[.î\¯2ð+ô õ�ö

þ�ë�îô�ö6í�þP÷�õYù�ü øMíZ¯2î¯í�þP÷�õø�÷��Pøz÷Pø�ùzï�û�÷�û'ö°YPû`�$ô

ï�û�÷ß�zö°Y�ý.�$ôë�ì�í�®�î���õ�ö÷Pø�ù$ë�ì�í�±aî\�¢õ�ö

÷�ø6ùzï�û�÷'ó�öß�>�!���þ�íZ¯2î+ó�õøMí¢ý

þ�íÂ[.î�±að���õølí�ý

þlí³ë�î�®�ð,û�õølí�ý

þlíÂ[�î�­�ð,÷�õøMí�ý

ØVn>�^�D¯a¥^��Ø<v�i`jbrtn>dli`� ª *�n>i���Þ{ª

�bõYñ�òJñ��bûVò�ú��Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú2þ:ì^úYñ�ïsúVó�ï�øVñ�Ï�n�ï��Jõ�Ó�ù^ó/�JõVñ�òJñ��bûVò�ú��[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú2ýA�,ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ�bõYñ�óJñ��[ì^úYø'�[ùÅðsðR�Jìah�ïsó�ù)ò�ñ��FûVò�óJï>!^ñ(�[ù^ð�ð]þuï��/n�ï�ð�ð��£ñ�ñ��Dñ��[û��Jñ[ø�í�û2�lõ�í�ì^ò�ñ�ì^ôu�bñFúz�bõVùÅú�bõYñ;=VòJó��`ý � ñ;�Fù^ú òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��¸ùÅðsð�úVì^ò�í�ù^ð��[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó%ïsúz�bõYòJñFñ<�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<þP�Vû��{ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú����[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úVó Ò ù^úVø�Ó�ï�ú��,n0ì��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ0òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�ýhKQïsöÅûVòJñ|36�ð�ïsó��bó(�bõVñ;�FìDøYñ�ì^ô�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú°h*w*i�ù^ôu�Jñ[ò|�JòJùÅúVó�ðsù �bï�ì^ú ïsú��bì�ë-��� ûVóJï�úVö��JõVñ�ù��:ì"!^ñ�ó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ð�[ùÅðsð�ï�úVö��[ì^ú�!Åñ[ú��bï�ì^ú2ý�+ñ[ò�ñ0h�ï�ó�ù'��úVì"n�ú ô�ûYú����JïsìÅú2þ{ùÅúVø1�bõYñ�ñFú !�ï�òJìÅúVí�ñ[ú���ô�ìÅòÁh#üÀï�ý ñDý�þ��JõVñ�ô�ò�ñ[ñF!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ

%��ïsó%ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bñFø�ï�ú(ù�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò@üÀï�ý ñDý�þp%·ï�ó|�bò�ñ[ù �bñ[ø�ùÅó±ù^ú�ñ����JòJù-ù^ò�ö^ûYí�ñFú���ì^ôFhuþ�ó�ñ[ñ�ð�ïsúVñ5:þ �83Åþ � 98Jý¸ÿVïsú2�[ñ<�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úÂÑ-ó��bï�ð�ð{ûVóJñFó��bõVñ�úVìÅòJí�ù^ð-�[ùÅðsð�ï�úVö��Fì^ú�!^ñFú��bï�ì^ú2þan�õVñFú�ï>� ïsóîVùÅóJó�ñ[ø��JìY�bõVñ�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^ú�h ü�ð�ïsúVñ�� 98bþ£ù)úVñ�n #+�[ì�ñFò��FïsìÅú�%w�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úUü�ï]ý ñ�ýsþ�í*Ì-ìÅú_ð�ïsúVñ�^÷M7�+õVùÅó;�bìz�£ñY�VûYïsð>�;�bì�ù^ø"IbûVó��;�JõVñ-úVì^ò�í�ù^ðC�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ú��JïsìÅú üu�JõVò�ñ[ñY�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�óÑ*Ì*ë�Ñ*Å�{ï�ú��bìF�bõVñ�ó�î:ñ��[ï�ù^ð��Fì^ú�!^ñFú �JïsìÅú üu�,n�ìF�[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷aó�ù"!^ñ±ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó�í*Ì�ë*í*ì�bý��,ñ��[ù^ûYóJñ(�bõVñò�ñ��bûYòJú��[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú Ò ìÅô�h-ïsó ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jñ[ø·ï�ú'�,n�ì��Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�üÀï�ý ñDý�þ Ò Ì*ë Ò ì�Jþn�ñ��Fù^úF�VûVï�ðsø�ù�ó�í�ù^ð�ðsñFò�õYñ[ù^îY�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ�ü�ì^ô�ó�ï��Fñ�´uþ�ì^ú)ð�ïsúVñ/� ´82ô�ì^òx�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú0ÏBý&]ôx�£ì �bõ Ò ù^úVøÚÓ�ù^ò�ñ�òJñFîVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bñFø ï�ú$�bõYòJñFñw�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<þ��bõYñ�õVñ[ùÅî$�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ

ô�ì^òýÏ�n�ì^ûVð�ø)ù���ðsñFù^ó��)�:ñ ì^ô�ó�ï>�[ñ��:ý.�·ì^ò�ñ¸ö^ñ[úYñ[ò�ù^ð�ð���þ^ï�ô��JõVñ ó��Jù^úVøYù^ò�øw�[ùÅðsð�ïsúYö(�Fì^ú�!^ñFú �JïsìÅúûVó�ñ[ó�ãA�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñxò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó�ùÅúVø4�JõVñ òJñ��bûVò�ú4�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúEÓ�õVùÅó�½ ô�òJñFñD!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó<þ¢�JõVñ[úÓ;n�ï�ðsð��£ñFúVñ�=��+ô�òJìÅí ûVó�ïsúVö T<·u¸Vü�ã ¹ ½�-�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ+ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<ý  T¢¡�PD7{52?0OQPY¡�PB32é� ñ�õVù"!^ñ�ï�í�îVðsñFí�ñ[ú��bñFø(ì^ûVò�úVñ�nq�FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú·ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí ïsúz�JõVñ�ÿ��Jù^úVøVùÅòJøz���ì^ô-�+ñ�n � ñFòJó�ñ��w�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFòs!^ñFòJó�ï�ì^ú$3^ý ��´���ý�&]ú-ì^ò�øVñ[òx�Jìw=VúVø-ìÅû��xõVì"n í�û��lõ-î:ñ[ò�ô�ì^ò�í�ù^ú��Fñö^ùÅïsú�n0ñ��[ùÅú@öÅñ���ô�òJìÅí ì^ûVò,úVñ�n#ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí·þ n�ñ�õVù"!Åñ+í�ñ[ùÅóJûYòJñFø4�bõYñ�î:ñ[ò�ô�ì^ò�í�ù^ú��Fñ�ìÅô�óJï>�øVï>�£ñFòJñFú��x�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�ó�ìÅúY�bñ[ú-ÿ��'���:ñ[ú2�lõVí�ù^ò��Dó<ýr ù �VðsñY&�&t&�ö^ï>!^ñFó�ùÅú ì"!Åñ[ò�!�ïsñ�n ì^ôD�bõVñ��Jñ[úÿ�£ñFú��lõVí�ù^ò���ó�ýEK£ì^ò�ñ[ù �lõE�:ñ[ú2�lõVí�ù^ò��Bþ�n0ñ

ð�ïsó��w�bõYñ�óJï>�[ñ�ìÅô��JõVñ�ó�ì^ûVò��[ñ-îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí'ü�ï�ú ú�ûVíA�:ñ[ò�ìÅô�ð�ï�úVñ[ó" ù^úYø��YòJï�ñ���� øVñ[ó��[ò�ï>�£ñ�ï>�bóô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVùÅðsï>�,�Dýr õVñ±ó�ï��F�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò�ósn�ñ�ûVóJñ�ù^ò�ñ�ù^ð�ð�ó�ïsí�îVð�ñ|!�ù^ò�ïsù �bï�ì^úVó�ìÅô��bõVñ±ÿ2����� � � �Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFòs!^ñFòJ÷

Page 25: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe ]!K

�Yë�ì�í�[ û"��î�­��8ð�­*�ð�­�b8ð�­���ð�ë�ð,÷�õ�ö��b ÷�ø6ù$ë�ì�í�×��8î�×H�ð�×b8ð�ò�õ'ö�!� ÷�ø�ù�ï�û�÷­���öÚ�PøP÷�ø�Y6ù�î���ð�×HPõ�,Ø ï�û�÷­�YöÚ�PøP÷�ø�Y6ù�î��ð�×HPõ�!Ù ï�û�÷­���öÚ�PøP÷�ø�Y6ù�î@b8ð�×HPõ�!Û þlí�­��8î�­��ð�×b8ð�­���ð�ò�õ�!Ü øMí�ý�!Ý�!Þ ë�ì�í�[�î\¯.��ð�¯��ð�¯!b8ð�ô�ð+ë õ�ö�� þ�ë îô�ö�í�þ�÷�õ�ù�ü øMíe¯.�8î\¯��ð�¯!b8ð¯í þP÷�õ! ø�÷���øz÷�ø�ùzï¢û�÷�û�ö�YPû,�$ô"b ï¢û�÷ß�$ö�Y�ý!�$ô�� ë6ì�í�®��aî�®c�ð�®�b8ð�®���ðu��õ�ö$Ø ÷�ø�ù$ë6ì�íe±!�8î@±�ð@±�bað��¢õ'ö�Ù ÷�ø�ùzï¢û�÷'ó$ö�±�bO������Û ï¢û�÷�¯.��ö��Pø�÷�ø�Y6ù�î@��ð�±Põ�Ü ï¢û�÷�¯�Yö��Pø�÷�ø�Y6ù�î��ð�±Põ�Ý ï¢û�÷�¯!b�ö��Pø�÷�ø�Y6ù�î�b8ð�±Põ�Þ þlíe¯,�8î\¯��ð@¯!b8ð�ó�õb.� øMí�ýb� þlí�[�î�±!��ð�®*�ð��.ð�®�b8ð�®�� õb!b øMí�ýb.� ï¢û�÷ ­.×$ö�î\¯.��ð@¯��ð�¯!b¢õb`Ø ï¢û�÷'ë���ö°�Pø�÷�ø�Y6ù�î@��ð�ë õb.Ù þlí³ë��8îë�ð�®���ð�­.×�ð��hð+ë�ð,û¢õb.Û øMí�ýb.Ü ï�û�÷­!­zö�î�­���ð�­*�ð�­�� õb.Ý þ�í�[.î�×��8ð�­�­�ð�­�b8ð,÷8ð+ë õb.Þ øMí¢ý

ØVn>�^�D¯a¨^��Ø<v`i�jhrIn>dli`� ª *�ylqwrtfbg�jho>dlpav`gaf{jhdliF�lfhgIpan>dli

ó�ïsìÅúÿ3Åý � ´��Dý<o�ðsð�óJï>�'�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFòJó�ó�ù��Jïsó�ôu�'�JõVñ�#aó�ù^ô�ñ�ô�ì^ò�ó�îVù �[ñ;�[ìÅí�îVðsñ���ï��,��%)òJûVð�ñDþ�ù^úVø�ùÅðsðûVó�ñx�bõVñx�,��î:ñ[÷aøVï�òJñ����bñFø��[ì^í�îVï�ð�ù��bï�ì^ú<�bñ��lõVúVï>p�ûVñ[ó�øYñ[ó��[ò�ï��:ñ[ø�ï�ú�ù/�Fì^í�îVùÅúVïsìÅú%îYù^î:ñ[ò@0 ÿVõVù^ìù^úYø�o�îVî£ñFð)3M5 5�À :a�Jì�ùÅðsð�ì"n#ùÅòJöÅûVí�ñ[ú��bó��bì��:ñ¸îYù^ó�óJñFø�ï�ú�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó�ù^úYø��Jì�ó�ûVîVî:ì^ò��,í�ì^ò�ññ����FïsñFú �¸øVù �bù)òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVó<ý r õYñ1#�ðsù ���-øVï�óJîVð�ù"��%4�Jñ��lõVúVï>p�ûVñ�ïsó ï�í�îVðsñFí�ñ[ú��bñFø�ï�ú_ùÅðsðó�ï����[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�ó�þ��Yû��xï>�xïsó+ûVóJñFø�í�ì^ò�ñ¸ñ��£ñ����Jï�!Åñ[ð>�@ï�ú��[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�ós�bõVù ��ûVó�ñ|�bõVñ�úVñ�n��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅú�ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí·þ �:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñ ì^ô-�bõVñFïsò�í�ì^ò�ñ ñ����bñFúVó�ï�!Åñ¸ûYóJñ ì^ô�ó�õVù^ò�ñ[ø��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó�ý��£R¤.¥3¦:§-§8¥ r õYïsów!Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú�ûVó�ñ[ów�JõVñ·ìÅðsøÿ�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷+�[ìÅú !Åñ[ò�óJï�ì^ú(ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí 0 o+îVî:ñ[ð;3M5 5���?

o+îYî£ñFð{ù^úVø·ÿYõVù^ìz3M5�5 ��:]ýx�·ìÅòJñ%óJî:ñ��Fï�=2�[ù^ð�ð>�Dþ£ï��¸ûVó�ñ[ó��bõYñ%ð�ïsú2�^ñ[ø'�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ%òJñFîVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^úï�ô�ï>��ï�ó�ó�îVù �[ñ�ó�ù^ô�ñDþ�ì��JõVñ[ò�n�ï�óJñ�ï>�±ûVó�ñ[ó(�bõVñw�Yù��|�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ�ò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �bï�ì^ú2ý�ë�ì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó,ù^ò�ñ òJñFîVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bñFø@ûVó�ïsúYö<�JõVò�ñ[ñ/�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�ý��£R¤.¥3����¨�©3�1£R¤3¥.���?ª�©.��£R¤3¥3����«�©3�1£M¤.¥5����¬�¥ r õVñFóJñF�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò�ó�ù^ð�ð0ûVó�ñF�bõVñ-úVñ�næ�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ

�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅú�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí øVñ[ó��[ò�ï��:ñ[ø@ïsú�ÿYñ����JïsìÅú4�uý r õVñ���òJñFóJî:ñ����bï>!^ñ[ð>��ûVó�ñ+ì^úYñDþ��,n0ìuþ¢�JõVòJñFñDþì^ò�ô�ìÅûVò�ü�öÅñ[úVñFòJùÅðs÷aîVûVò�î:ì^ó�ñ ��[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷aó�ù"!^ñ+ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJóC�Jì�ò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú ���[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úF�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó<ý��£R¤.¥3­®��«�¥ r õVï�ó��[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò�ûVóJñFóD�JõVñ�úVñ�n£�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ|�Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú-ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí øVñFó��FòJï>�£ñFø·ï�ú

ÿVñ����bï�ì^ú<�:ý0ë�ì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúA�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[ó�ù^ò�ñ�òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bñ[ø�ûVóJï�úVö��bõVò�ñ[ñ,öÅñ[úVñFòJùÅðs÷aîVûVò�î£ìÅóJñG�[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷

Page 26: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

]!y ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

��yl�`o>f��.�3�b� â fbi`fbgIylo�n>i�qwdlgak,ylrtn>dli�yl��dlv�r�rt��f{��fbi`j���k,ylgI¶�m�gIdl�lgaylk,pË{Ì�Í�Î�Ì�Ï<Ð Ò�Ñ ¯ÅÕ °+ÕFÖ� ®Ì�Ѳ±PÎ`Ñ�Í�Ò³�´ ÔPÎ ¥lµl¥l¦ ¬��¤��d[e���m�gIdl��o>fhk�padlo>�lfhg��³ Í Ô ÕFÌ [^¯+[ ªJrtyli�e�ylgae�rI�`fbdlgIfhk,�¤m�gId��lfhg���fhi�j���k�ylga¶D�Ò�ÑsÕ�µ£Õ ¯a¥l´l¦ ��c�«%n>k,m`o>fbk�fbi[rtylrIn>dli dlq�m`gan>k,fQi[v�k���fbg��lfhi�fhgaylrtdlgl�¶\³ ¦l´l´ ����f{ä{iFv`rI����¢Bfbi`e�n>�xjbdlk�m�o>fhrIn>dli ylo>�ldlgIn>rI�`k±�ÓuÕ�·BÎ�Õ[Ò ¯l¯+Ul´ ã·o>fb�[n>jhylo>�¤yli�ylo>�[¡hfbg��lfhi�fhgaylrtdlgl�¸ Ï� °a¨l¥MT ã�i+n>k,m�o>fhk,fhi[rIylrtn>dli dlq�yli¸«Dã�«�\·m�ylgIpafhg��lfbi`fbgIylrIdlg��ÓuÑ�Ó�Õ ¯a¨MU ����f{�lylk,f{dlq�«�n>qwfQn>k,m�o>fhk,fhi[rIfhe v`pan>i��,o>n>pIrIp��Ò�ÑsÐg± Í Õ [M[lµ ã·pam���fhgIn>jbyloÅ��v�n>e���e��Fi`ylk,n>jhp2m�gIdl�lgaylk±�%xÏ Ô U^°a¨ ã·pan>k,m�o>f�gay���rtgayljhfhgl�'%Ó^¹²º ¥l¦l´MU ãf»�«@��å n>i�pIrIgIv�jhrIn>dli�paj���fhe�v`o>fbg��

��yl��o>f��0»���ã_jhdlk,m�ylgan>pIdli¸dlq�fh�[fbjhv�rtn>dli�rtn>k,fË{Ì�Í�Î�Ì�Ï<Ð ³ Ï<ÖJÑsÖ Í- � Î8±!¼ Î8±!½ Î8±!¾ Î<±!¿ Ó0±!¾z>pafhjhpl} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z|gIylrIn>d^}³�´ ÔPÎ ¥lµ^� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^�>°l° µ^�>°a¦ µ^�>°a¥ µ^�>°a´ µ^�>°a¦³ Í Ô Õ[Ì T^� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [MT µ^� [^¯ µ^� [lµ µ^� [lµ µ^� [l¦Ò�Ñ�Õ�µ£Õ ¥l´^� ¦ ¯l� µlµ µ^� Ul¨ µ^� Ul¦ µ^� Ul´ µ^� Ul¦ µ^� [MU¶\³ °l� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^� U^° µ^� Ul´ µ^� U^¯ µ^� U^¯ µ^� [MTÓuÕ�·BÎ�ÕFÒ ¯l¯l� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [^¯ µ^� UM[ µ^� [^¯ µ^� UMU µ^� [l¥¸ Ï� ¨^� ¨ ¯l� µlµ ¯l� µMT µ^� [^° µ^� [l´ µ^� [l¦ µ^� [MUÓuÑ>Ó�Õ ¯l� ¥ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [^¯ µ^� [MT µ^� [lµ µ^� UM[ µ^� UM[Ò�Ñ�ÐW± Í Õ TMT^� T ¯l� µlµ µ^� UMU µ^� Ul¨ µ^� Ul¥ µ^� [l¨ µ^� Ul¦%xÏ Ô Tlµ^� ¥ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [^° µ^� [M[ µ^� [MU µ^� [MU µ^� [^°'%Ó^¹²º ¯a¦^�>¯ ¯l� µlµ µ^� U^¯ µ^�>°l° µ^�>°a¦ µ^�>°a¦ µ^�>°a¦À µ:Õ[Ì�Ï<Î�Õ ¯l� µlµ µ^� UM[ µ^� UMU µ^� Ul¦ µ^� U^° µ^� [lµ

ó�ù"!^ñ¸òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�ùÅúVøF�bõVò�ñ[ñ/�VìÅù��JïsúVöÅ÷Iî:ì^ï�ú��)�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ+ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ýo+ð�ð£í�ñ[ùÅóJûYòJñFí�ñFú��bó�ùÅòJñ�øYì^úVñxìÅú�ù|v�B¸ë-À ����� ��� ���@n�ì^ò���ó��Jù��JïsìÅú<n�ï>�bõ�3M��9�í�ñFö^ù^÷+�����bñ[ó

ì^ô,í�ñ[í�ìÅò���ýw&]ú r ù��Yðsñ;&@à�þ�n�ñ�öÅï�!Åñ;�bõVñ�ñ���ñ��Fû��bï�ì^úz�bï�í�ñ@ìÅô�ò�ûVúVúYïsúVö��JõVñ4�:ñ[ú2�lõVí�ù^ò��DóûVúVøYñ[ò|�JõVñ�ù��:ì"!^ñ�ó�ï����[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò�ó<ý���úVð>�'�bõYñ�ñ���ñ��Fû��bï�ì^úz�Jïsí�ñ�üÀûVóJñFòA�Jïsí�ñ�îVð�ûVó±öÅù^ò��Vù^öÅñ�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bï�ì^ú$�Jïsí�ñ@îYðsûVó%ó���ó��bñFí �Jïsí�ñ�þ�ï�ú ó�ñ��Fì^úVøVó",ô�ìÅòA�bõYñO¦:§8§Y�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò%ïsó%óJõVì"n�ú-?-�bõVñî:ñ[ò�ô�ì^ò�í�ùÅú��[ñ¸ô�ì^ò�ì �bõVñFòx�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò�ó�ïsó�øYñ[úVì �bñ[ø)ù^ó�ù�ò�ù��Jïsì�òJñFðsù �bï>!^ñ��bì��JõVñg¦:§8§|�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò�ýr õVñ%ö^ù^ò��VùÅö^ñ[÷+�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bï�ì^ú��bï�í�ñ-üu�Fì^ò�òJñFóJî:ì^úVøYïsúVö;�Jì4�JõVñ�øVù �bù�ï�ú r ù��Vð�ñA&@à�{ï�ó+ð�ïsó��bñFø·ó�ñ[îV÷ù^ò�ù��Jñ[ð>��ïsú r ù��Vð�ñQà�ý%ÿVï�í�ï�ð�ù^ò�ð���þ r ù �Vð�ñÁàD&[þOàD&t&[þBùÅúVø à@&�&t&¸òJñFóJî:ñ����bï>!^ñFð����Fì^í�îVùÅòJñ(�bõVñõVñFù^î ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bï�ì^úUü�ï�ú í�ñFö^ù^÷+�����bñ[ó"bþ8�JõVñ;�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ù��JïsìÅú��Jïsí�ñ·ü�ï�ú�óJñ��[ìÅúVøVó"bþuùÅúVø��JõVñ;�[ì�øVñó�ï��Fñ�üÀïsúY��ï�ðsìÅ÷������bñFó�Jý&]ú r ù �Vðsñ/&�Á�þ�n�ñ�ðsï�ó��s�bõVñ�úDûYíA�:ñ[òxìÅô2í�ñ[í�ìÅò���ô�ñ��t�lõYñ[ó%üÀïsú·í�ï�ðsð�ï�ì^úVó"�ô�ì^òxð�ì��[ùÅð��Åö^ð�ì��VùÅð

!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó�ù^úYø��JõVñ�ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú îVò�ì�=Yðsñ-ì^ô�!�ù^ò�ïsìÅûVó;��ïsúYøVó�ì^ô��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó�ô�ìÅò;�bõVñz¦Â§8§_ù^úYø����«³�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFòJó<ý1��ñ[ò�ñDþ�#añ[ó��[ùÅî£ñ�%:þ�#+��úVì"n�ú�%uþQù^úVø #+�Fì^ú��t% ù^ò�ñ)òJñFóJî:ñ����bï>!^ñ[ð>�$�bõYñ��bì��Jù^ðó�ï��Fñ�ì^ôR�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó�ü�ï�ú_í�ñFö^ù^÷+n�ì^ò�øVó��ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bñ[ø�ô�ìÅò�ñFó��Fù^îVï�úVö�ûYóJñFò�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^úYó�þa��úVì"n�ú·ûVó�ñ[òô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó<þDù^úYø4�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú@ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVó"?�õVñ[ùÅî@ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú�ô�ì^ò,ì �bõVñFò0úVìÅúV÷+�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó0ï�ó,úVì��ð�ïsó��bñFø)ï�ú r ù �Vð�ñ�&�Á ü¯�Vû���ï�óxï�ú��[ð�ûVøVñFø)ï�ú r ù �Vð�ñ&àD&�bý� ñ/�Fù^ú)øVòJù"n �bõVñ�ô�ìÅðsð�ì"n�ï�úVö(�Fì^ú��FðsûYóJï�ì^úVó�ô�ò�ì^í �bõVñFóJñ/�Fì^í�îVù^ò�ï�óJìÅúVó��y r õVñH���?«A�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò{õVùÅó{ñ���ù����bð>�|�bõYñ�ó�ù^í�ñ,ó�ñ��bûYî�ùÅóR�bõVñ�¦Â§8§s�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò{ñ�� �Fñ[î��R�JõVù��

ì^úYñ�ûVó�ñ[ó-�bõVñ�úVñ�n1�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñG�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅú¸ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí·þFù^úVø|�JõVñ�ì��bõYñ[ò�ûVóJñFó��bõVñ�ì^ð�ø±ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí�ý

Page 27: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe ]!�

��yl��o>f�»,��ã�jhdlk,m`ylgan>padli�dlq��lylga��yl�lf�jhdlo>o>fhjhrIn>dli�rIn>k,fË{Ì�Í�Î�Ì�Ï<Ð ³ Ï<ÖJÑsÖ Í- � Î8±!¼ Î8±!½ Î8±!¾ Î<±!¿ Ó0±!¾z>pafhjhpl} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z|gIylrIn>d^}³�´ ÔPÎ ¯l� ¦^¯ ¯l� µlµ µ^� U^¯ µ^� Ul´ µ^�>°+U µ^� Ulµ µ^� Ul¥³ Í Ô Õ[Ì ¯l� µl¥ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [MU µ^� [^° µ^� [l¥ µ^� [l¥ ¯l� µ^¯Ò�Ñ�Õ�µ£Õ ¯l°l� [ ¯l� µlµ µ^�>°aµ µ^�>°+T µ^�>°+T µ^�>°a¥ µ^� Ul´¶\³ µ^� [l¨ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [MU µ^� [MU µ^� [MU µ^� [M[ µ^� [M[ÓuÕ�·BÎ�ÕFÒ µ^� Ul¥ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [lµ µ^� UM[ µ^� Ul¥ µ^� UMU µ^� [l¨¸ Ï� ¯l� µl´ ¯l� µlµ ¯l�>¯+T ¯l� µMT ¯l� µl¨ ¯l� µl¨ ¯l� µ^°ÓuÑ>Ó�Õ µ^� µMT ¯l� µlµ ¯l� µlµ ¯l� ´lµ µ^� µlµ ¯l� µlµ ¯l� µlµÒ�Ñ�ÐW± Í Õ ¥^� ¨l¥ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [lµ µ^� UM[ µ^� [lµ µ^� [^¯ µ^� [lµ%xÏ Ô µ^� µl´ ¯l� µlµ ¯l� Ulµ ¯l� ¦lµ T^� Tlµ T^� µlµ ¯l� Ulµ'%Ó^¹²º µ^� ´l¥ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [l¨ µ^� Ul¥ µ^� [l¦ µ^� [l¨ ¯l� µl¦

��yl��o>f�»��b��ã�jhdlk,m�ylgIn>padli�dlq�rIdlrtylo���fhylm¸ylo>o>d[jhylrIn>dliË{Ì�Í�Î�Ì�Ï<Ð ³ Ï<ÖJÑsÖ Í- � Î8±!¼ Î8±!½ Î8±!¾ Î<±!¿ Ó0±!¾z>c�¢�} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z|gIylrIn>d^}³�´ ÔPÎ ¦^¯+[^� µ ¯l� µlµ µ^� ´l´ µ^� ´lµ µ^� ¨l¨ µ^� ¨l¨ µ^� ¨l´³ Í Ô Õ[Ì ¥lµ^� U ¯l� µlµ µ^� Ul¦ µ^� Ulµ µ^�>°a´ µ^�>°a¥ µ^� UMUÒ�Ñ�Õ�µ£Õ Tl´l¥^� [ ¯l� µlµ µ^�>°+T µ^�>°+T µ^�>°aµ µ^�>°aµ µ^� Ul¥¶\³ ¯a´l¦^�>° ¯l� µlµ µ^�>°+[ µ^�>°aµ µ^� ´M[ µ^� ´^° µ^�>°+[ÓuÕ�·BÎ�ÕFÒ [l¦^� [ ¯l� µlµ µ^�>°+U µ^�>°l¯ µ^� ¦l¨ µ^� ¨M[ µ^� ¦M[¸ Ï� ´^°l� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^� UM[ µ^� U^¯ µ^�>°l° µ^�>°a´ µ^�>°+UÓuÑ>Ó�Õ ¯aµ^� T ¯l� µlµ µ^�>°l° µ^�>°a¥ µ^� ¦MU µ^� ¦l¥ µ^� ¦MUÒ�Ñ�ÐW± Í Õ ¥MTl¥^� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^� UMT µ^� ¦MU µ^� ¦l¨ µ^�>°aµ µ^� ´^°%xÏ Ô ¥l¥^¯l� ¦ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [MT µ^� [l¦ µ^� [l¥ µ^� [MT µ^� [l¥'%Ó^¹²º ¯a¦lµ^� U ¯l� µlµ µ^� Ulµ µ^�>°a´ µ^�>°aµ µ^�>°l¯ µ^�>°l¯À µ:Õ[Ì�Ï<Î�Õ ¯l� µlµ µ^�>°+[ µ^�>°a¨ µ^� ¦MU µ^� ¦l¦ µ^�>°a¥

��ú_ù"!Åñ[ò�ù^öÅñDþ��JõVñD���?«��[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò¸òJñFøVû��Fñ[ó õVñ[ùÅî_ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú�����´��� üu�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú���Y���8Â��ù^úVø�í�ñFí�ì^ò��)ô�ñ��t�lõVñFó�ô�ìÅò�ð�ì��[ùÅð��Åö^ð�ì��VùÅðh!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFóD���Y����Â�?YùÅúVø_ï�í�îVò�ì"!^ñ[ó@�bõVñù^ð�ò�ñ[ù^ø2�·ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��/�FìDøYñ�ö^ñ[úYñ[ò�ù��bñFø������bõVñU¦:§-§��[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò/���ÿ3M�8Â�ý r õYñU���?«��[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[òù^ð�ó�ì+ûVúVï�ô�ì^ò�í�ð���öÅñ[úVñFòJù �bñFó2í�ì^ò�ñG�Fì^í�îVù ���-�[ì�øVñDþ`ù �lõVï�ñ�!�ïsúYö+ù^ú%ù"!^ñFòJùÅö^ñ�ìÅô.3M5�Â6ò�ñ[øYû����JïsìÅúï�ú'�[ì�øVñ%óJï>�[ñ%ì"!^ñFòs�bõVñF¦:§-§��Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò�ý\ÃWÄ_Å?� ùÅúVøzÆDÇrÈÉ ù �lõVïsñ�!^ñ±ûYî'�bì�òJñFóJî:ñ����bï>!^ñFð���87 Â#ùÅúVø;����Â#ó�î:ñ[ñ[øYûVî�ï�ú�ñ���ñ��Fû��bï�ì^ú;�Jïsí�ñ�þ¢�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñs�bõYñ���ö^ñ���óJï�ö^úYï�=��Fù^ú����:ñ[úVñ�=��bó�ô�ò�ì^íûVó�ïsúYö�ó�ù^ô�ñFð��@ðsï�ú��^ñFøY�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó�ýy à{ù^ò��Dï�úVö(�bõVñ�ú�ûVí(�£ñFò�ì^ô��Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñxò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó�ûVúVøVñFòx�bõVñ úVñ�n��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñD�Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ï�ì^ú

ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí õVùÅó0ð�ï>�t�bð�ñ¸ñ��:ñ����0ì^úw�JõVñ¸ñ���ñ��Fû��bï�ì^ú;�Jïsí�ñ�üun�ï>�bõVï�ú4�� ò�ù^úYö^ñDþ�´8 ìÅú�ù"!^ñ[ò�ù^öÅñ Jþ�Vû���õVù^ó0ù�ðsùÅòJöÅñ�ñ��£ñ�����ìÅú;�bõVñ@�bì��Jù^ðVõYñ[ù^î�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bï�ì^ú2ý r õVñ\����«��[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�ï�ó�ù��:ì^û2��´^÷+�8Âô�ù^ó��bñFòx�bõVùÅúY�bõVñg����¨4�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò�þ �Yû���ï��Jós�bì �bùÅðBõVñ[ùÅî)ùÅðsð�ì��[ù �bï�ì^ú@ï�óxí�ì^ò�ñ��bõVùÅú$3 3� ð�ñ[ó�ó<ýy r õVñ%ñ��£ñ���� ì^ôG�bõVñ�úVñ�nH�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ�ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYí ì^ú'�JõVñ�ö^ù^ò��VùÅö^ñ|�Fì^ð�ðsñ����bï�ì^ú��bï�í�ñ�üÀö:ý �Dý

�bï�í�ñDþ0ó�ñ[ñ r ù �Vð�ñaà<�!�ù^ò�ïsñFó�øVò�ù^í�ù��Jï��Fù^ð�ð�� øYñ[î:ñ[úVøVï�úVö(ìÅúE�JõVñ��£ñFú��lõVí�ù^ò���ó�ý�B0ïsöÅõ���ìÅô�bõYñ��Jñ[úF�£ñFú��lõVí�ù^ò���óCn0ñ¸í�ñ[ù^ó�ûVò�ñ[ø�óJî:ñ[úVø)ð�ñ[ó�óx�bï�í�ñ ï�ú�öÅù^ò��Vù^öÅñs�[ìÅðsð�ñ����bï�ì^ú�üu�:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ¸ìÅôð�ñ[ó�ó±õVñ[ùÅî�ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bï�ì^ú.JþBõVì"n�ñ�!Åñ[ò<þ��bõYñ�ö:ý �Dýw�bï�í�ñ@ô�ì^ò��D�-Ê6ï�ó±ù^ð�í�ì^ó���øVì^û2�VðsñFø2ý r õVïsó�ïsóúVì ��ó�ûVò�îVòJï�ó�ïsúVö�óJï�ú��Fñ<�JõVñ�úVñ�nq�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ%ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí õVùÅó��[ì^í�îVð�ñ��Jñ[ð>��øVï>�£ñFòJñFú � ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú�:ñ[õVù"!�ï�ì^òxô�ò�ì^í²�bõVñ±ìÅðsø�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí·ýR��ù"!Dï�úVö�í�ì^ò�ñ/�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó�üÀñ[ó�î£ñ��[ï�ù^ð�ð����bõVñ­®��«Y�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò"Qö^ñFúVñ[ò�ù^ð�ð>�@ï�ú��[ò�ñ[ùÅóJñFós�bõVñ%ö:ý �Dý��Jïsí�ñDþ2n�õVï>�lõ·ó�ì^í�ñ�n�õVù ��òJñ��Vñ����bóD�bõVñ%õVñ[ùÅî

Page 28: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

]!� ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

��yl��o>f�»��.�b�Uã·jhdlk,m�ylgIn>padli¸dlq�jhdlk,m`n>o>ylrIn>dli rtn>k,fË{Ì�Í�Î�Ì�Ï<Ð ³ Ï<ÖJÑsÖ Í- � Î8±!¼ Î8±!½ Î8±!¾ Î<±!¿ Ó0±!¾z>pafhjhpl} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z|gIylrIn>d^}³�´ ÔPÎ ´M[^�>¯ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [M[ µ^� [MT µ^� [l¦ µ^� [l´ ¯l� µ^¯³ Í Ô Õ[Ì Tl¦^� ¨ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [M[ µ^� [l¦ µ^� [l¦ µ^� [MU ¯l� µ^¯Ò�Ñ�Õ�µ£Õ ¥^¯l� U ¯l� µlµ µ^� [M[ µ^� [MU µ^� [^° µ^� [M[ ¯l� µMT¶\³ ¯+[^� ¨ ¯l� µlµ ¯l� µl¥ µ^� [^° µ^� [MU ¯l� µ^¯ ¯l� µl¥ÓuÕ�·BÎ�ÕFÒ ¥^°l� U ¯l� µlµ µ^� [^¯ µ^� [MT µ^� Ul¦ µ^� UM[ µ^� [M[¸ Ï� ¯a¥MT^� T ¯l� µlµ µ^� [MU µ^� [l¥ µ^� [l´ µ^� [l´ ¯l� µ^¯ÓuÑ>Ó�Õ ¨^� U ¯l� µlµ ¯l� µl¨ ¯l� µ^¯ µ^� [MU ¯l� µMT ¯l� µl¨Ò�Ñ�ÐW± Í Õ ¦l¨^� ¦ ¯l� µlµ µ^� Ul´ µ^� Ul¥ µ^� UMT µ^�>°+U µ^� Ul¦%xÏ Ô ¯a´^� ´ ¯l� µlµ ¯l� µ^¯ µ^� [MU µ^� [^° µ^� [MU ¯l� µl¦'%Ó^¹²º ¯+Ul´^� [ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [MU µ^� [lµ µ^� [^¯ µ^� [^° µ^� [MUÀ µ:Õ[Ì�Ï<Î�Õ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [MU µ^� [l¨ µ^� [l¨ µ^� [l´ ¯l� µlµ

��yl��o>f�»��.�3�b�Uã_jhdlk,m`ylgan>padli�dlq�jhdFe�f�pIn>¡bfË{Ì�Í�Î�Ì�Ï<Ð ³ Ï<ÖJÑsÖ Í- � Î8±!¼ Î8±!½ Î8±!¾ Î<±!¿ Ó0±!¾z>ä{¢�} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z>gaylrtn>d^} z|gIylrIn>d^}³�´ ÔPÎ ¯aµl¥^�>¯ ¯l� µlµ µ^� Ul¥ µ^� U^¯ µ^� U^¯ µ^�>°a¦ µ^� Ul¥³ Í Ô Õ[Ì ¯aµ^°l� T ¯l� µlµ µ^� [l¥ µ^� [MT µ^� [MT µ^� [l¥ µ^� [MTÒ�Ñ�Õ�µ£Õ °a¨^�>¯ ¯l� µlµ µ^� Ul´ µ^� Ul¥ µ^� Ul¥ µ^� Ul¨ µ^� U^°¶\³ ¨^°l�>¯ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [^¯ µ^� Ul¦ µ^� Ul¦ µ^� UMU µ^� UMUÓuÕ�·BÎ�ÕFÒ ¯aµl´^� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^� Ul¥ µ^� Ulµ µ^�>°+[ µ^�>°+[ µ^� Ulµ¸ Ï� ¨^¯+U^� T ¯l� µlµ µ^� U^¯ µ^�>°a¦ µ^�>°a´ µ^�>°a´ µ^�>°a´ÓuÑ>Ó�Õ ¯a¨^� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^� [^¯ µ^� UMU µ^� UMU µ^� U^° µ^� UMUÒ�Ñ�ÐW± Í Õ ¯+Ul¥^�>¯ ¯l� µlµ µ^� ¦l¨ µ^� ¦^¯ µ^� ´M[ µ^� ´l¦ µ^� ´MU%xÏ Ô ´l¥^� ´ ¯l� µlµ µ^� U^° µ^� Ul¨ µ^� Ul´ µ^� Ul´ µ^� U^°'%Ó^¹²º ¨MTl¦^� [ ¯l� µlµ µ^� UMT µ^�>°+U µ^�>°+U µ^�>°+U µ^�>°+UÀ µ:Õ[Ì�Ï<Î�Õ ¯l� µlµ µ^� Ul¨ µ^� U^¯ µ^� U^¯ µ^� Ulµ µ^� UMT

ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú�øVù �bù�ï�ú r ù��Vð�ñxà@&[ýy�KYò�ì^íÇ�bõVñ�ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú·îVò�ì�=Vð�ï�úVö�øYù��bù)ï�ú r ù��Vð�ñ(&�Á�þ�n�ñ(�Fù^ú_ó�ñ[ñ<�bõYù��¸í�ìÅó��¸ì^ôG�bõVñ

ò�ñ[øVû����bï�ì^ú ïsú õVñ[ùÅî6ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��JïsìÅú6ï�ó�ô�ò�ì^í �JõVñF�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú³�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó�ýÿ��ú6ó�ì^í�ñF�£ñFú��lõV÷í�ù^ò���ó�þ��JõVñ�úVñ�n ó��bò�ù��Jñ[ö �w�VûVï�ðsøYó+í�ì^ò�ñ��DúYì"n�úV÷Iô�ûYú����JïsìÅúF�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFóx�£ñ��[ù^ûYóJñ�ï>�xúVì"n øVì�ñ[ó�[ìÅú��bò�ì^ð�ðsñFø@ð�ù^íA�:øVùÅ÷Ið�ïsôu�JïsúYö-üÀóJñFñ¸ÿYñ����JïsìÅú��uý ´%ù^úVøFÀ:ý �8Jý.KYì^ò,ñ��DùÅí�îVðsñ�þDô�ì^ò,ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úÚj.<�9*8ï�ú;K�ï�ö^ûYòJñ(7Åþ"�JõVñ+úVñ�nUó��JòJù �bñ[ö ��í�ù^úYù^ö^ñFóR�bì±ñFðsï�í�ïsúYù��bñ�ù^ð�ð2�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú<�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó+ü�ï�úVóJï�øVñ�bõYñ�ðsì�ì^î-������VûVï�ðsøVï�úVö�ìÅúVñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñ¸ô�ì^òx��úVì"n�ú)ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úa/�üÀì^û��JóJï�øVñ��bõYñ�ðsì�ì^î-býy r õVñ±úVñ�n��FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú@ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí ó�ûVò�îVòJï�ó�ïsúVöÅð���ïsí�îVò�ì"!^ñFós�bõYñ|�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ù��JïsìÅú

�bï�í�ñ(����úVñFù^ò�ð��F�8Â�ý r õVï�ó ïsó¸îVò�ì��Vù �Vð��Y�:ñ��Fù^ûVó�ñA�JõVñ%ìÅðsø_ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí ûVó�ñ[ø�ïsú˦:§8§;�[ìÅí�÷îVï�ðsñFò��[ì^ú��Jù^ï�úVó ñ���î£ñFúVó�ï�!Åñ�ù^øY÷IõVì���õVñ[ûYòJï�ó��Jï��Fó�þ8n�õYïsð�ñ��bõVñ�úVñ�n ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí ï�ó í�û��lõ í�ì^ò�ñó��Dó��bñFí�ù��bï>�Dý@o+úYì��bõYñ[ò¸òJñFù^ó�ì^ú-í�ïsöÅõ ���:ñA�bõYù����bõVñ�úVñ�n ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí ö^ñ[úYñ[ò�ù��bñFó+ð�ñ[ó�óD�Fì�øVñDþ�bõ�ûVó+òJñ�pDûYïsò�ñ[ó,ð�ñ[ó�ó�ïsúVó��bò�û����bï�ì^ú)ó��lõVñFøVûVð�ïsúYö<�Jïsí�ñ�ýy��+ó�ïsúVö'�bõVò�ñ[ñ��Vì^ù �bï�úVö^÷aî£ìÅïsú��|�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó�ü�ï]ý ñ�ýsþR�bõVñf­j�?«$�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò",øVì�ñ[ó

úVì ��ù �lõVïsñ�!^ñ±ùÅú��F�:ñ����bñFò�î£ñFòJô�ìÅòJí�ù^ú2�[ñ|�JõVù^ú�ûVóJï�úVö)úVì4�Yì^ù��JïsúYö^÷aî£ìÅïsú��@�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�òJñFö^ï�óJ÷�bñFòJó<ý r õVñ�óJð�ì"n�øVì"n�ú_í�ìÅó��Jð����Fì^í�ñ[ó�ô�ò�ì^í �:ñ[ú��lõYí�ùÅò���ó�ó�û��lõ_ùÅógÌ�Í.�@Î���ùÅúVøËÏ_à �JõVù��ô�ò�ñ�p�ûVñ[ú��Jð���ûVó�ñD=YòJó��b÷+�[ð�ù^ó�ó��[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úYó0ùÅúVø�ñ����Fñ[î��JïsìÅú�õVù^úYøVðsñFòJó<ý.KQïsò�ó��J÷��FðsùÅóJó)�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûV÷ù��JïsìÅúVó{ù^úYø%ñ�� �Fñ[î��JïsìÅúVóQí�ù"�|�£ñ,îVû2�{ïsú��bì ù ò�ñ��[ìÅòJø%ì^òQó��bì^ò�ñ[ø%ïsú��Jì¸ó�ì^í�ñ,ò�ñ[ô�ñ[ò�ñ[ú2�[ñ��[ñ[ð�ð]þ<ó�ì

Page 29: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe ]!Ä

��yl�`o>fr�0Ð,��¢Bgafhyl¶[e�d�~�i dlq�jho>dlpav`gaf{yljhjhfbpIp2yli`e¸ylo>o>d[jbylrtn>dliÏ Í Í�ÖJÔ�Ì�Õ À [Õ[ÖbÖ Ï Í Í�ÖJÔ�Ì�Õ À Í>Í ÍQ ®Ï�Î�ÑsÍ�Òz|k�fbk��¤gafhyle¸n>i+k,n>o>o>n>dli�p�} z>fhpajhylm�f�Ñ:¶Fi�dJ~�iwÑ:jhdliFrQn>i�k,fh�lyl�¤~udlgIe�pl}Ë{Ì�Í^Î�Ì�Ï<Ð ÍQ Î<±!¾ ÖbÏ�µuÑ�Ò�Î Í- � Î<±!¾ ÖbÏ�µBÑsÒ�γ�´ ÔPÎ U^°l� ¦ ¥^°l�>¯ ´^°l�>°l§ µ^� TMT8Ñ:µ^�>¯+U8Ñ{°a¦^� µ µ^�>¯+T8Ñ{¯l� ´M[8Ñ:¥l¦^� ¦ ¨M[^� [^¯l§³ Í Ô ÕFÌ ¨^� ´MU T^� ´MU ¨l¥^� ¦^§ ¯l� [^¯]Ñ:¨^� UMU8Ñ:µ^� [l´ ¯l�>¯+U8Ñ:µ^� ¨MU8Ñ:¥^�>¯+U ¥^°l� ´l¦^§Ò�ÑsÕ�µ£Õ ¨^°l� T T^°l� ´ ¨^¯l� U^§ °l� TMU8Ñ{¯l¯l� ¨8Ñ8Tl¦^� ´ °l� TMU8Ñ8U^� TM[8Ñ8[^� Ul¨ ¨l¥^�>°l¯l§¶�³ ¯a¦^� µ ¯a¥^� µ ¯+U^�>°l§ ¯+T^� ´8Ñ:µ^� µl¨8Ñ8Tl¨^� T ´^� [M[8Ñ{¯l� µ^°]Ñ{¯+T^� [ ¨l´^� ´^°l§Ó:Õ�·uÎ^Õ[Ò ¯a´^� [ °l� ´^° ´MT^� ¨^§ ¯l� ¨^°]Ñ:µ^�>¯+U8Ñ{¯l°l�>¯ µ^� ¨MU8Ñ:µ^� ¦^°]Ñ:¦^� [lµ ´l¦^� [MT^§¸ Ï� � [^�>°a´ ¨^� T^¯ ´l¦^� U^§ µ^�>¯aµ8Ñ8T^�>°l¯]Ñ8U^� µl¥ µ^� µM[8Ñ8T^� µ^°]Ñ:´^� ¥l¥ ¥lµ^� UM[^§Ó:Ñ>Ó�Õ ¯l� ´^° µ^� ¦l¦ ´MU^� µ^§ µ^� µl¦8Ñ:µ^� µlµ8Ñ{¯l� ´lµ µ^� µl¦8Ñ:µ^� µl¦8Ñ:µ^�>°a¥ ¨l¦^� µl´^§Ò�ÑsÐg± Í Õ °a¦^� ´ ¨l´^� U ¨lµ^�>¯l§ ¥^� ¨^°]Ñ:µ^� ´l´8Ñ:¦MT^� ¨ T^� ¦l¨8Ñ:¨^�>¯a¥8Ñ:¥l´^� ´ ¥l¦^� ¨l´^§%xÏ Ô Tlµ^� T ¯a¥^� ¦ ¥MT^� ´^§ µ^� µlµ8Ñ:µ^� µ^¯]Ñ{¯a´^� T µ^� µlµ8Ñ8T^�>¯l¯]Ñ{¯l¯l� ´ ¯aµ^� ¥l´^§'%Ó^¹²º ¨lµ^�>° ¯a¦^� U ´MU^�>°l§ °l� ¥MU8Ñ8T^� ¦lµ8Ñ:¥l¥^� ´ ¦^�>°+U8Ñ:¥^� µ^°]Ñ{¯a´^� U ¨lµ^� UM[^§À µ£Õ[Ì�Ï<Î�Õ ¨l¦^� µ^§ ¥M[^� Ul¥^§

�bõYñ���í�ûVó��G�:ñxò�ñ[îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��bù �Vð�ñ�ïsú�IbûVó���ìÅúVñsn�ì^ò�ø2þ�úVì ��ùÅó�ã�óJñFîVù^ò�ù��Jñx�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ,ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó"?n�õVñFú·ùw�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^ú�ï�ó��[ù^î2�bûVò�ñ[ø2þ2�bõYñEã�÷aòJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[òxò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú �Jù��JïsìÅú)õYù^ó@�Jì4�:ñ�îVù �M��ù^ö^ñFøï�ú �Jì�ù óJï�úVö^ð�ñxn�ì^ò�øA����í�ù���ï�úVö ù�òJñ��[ìÅòJø%ì^ú��bõVñ�õYñ[ù^î-?"n�õVñFú�ù/�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅú%ï�óR�bò�ï�ö^ö^ñFòJñFøüu���ß<*/*8*g�3�Jþ��JõVñ%ó�ï�úVö^ð�ñ[÷+n0ìÅòJø�ò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú �Jù��JïsìÅú�í�ûVó��D�:ñ�ûVúVîVù �M�`ùÅö^ñFø·ïsú��JìÂãw�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó<ý r õVï�óxì"!Åñ[ò�õVñ[ùÅø�ïsó+õVïsöÅõVñ[ò�ï�ô�í�ìÅòJñ��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�òJñFö^ï�ó��Jñ[ò�ó,ù^ò�ñ¸ûYóJñFø2ýÒ TèO�PBX`7:é¸PBN(R·1%OBÓ�xù ���Vï>�40 ÿ��Jñ[ñFðsñ�3658769�:QïsóA�bõVñ;=Vò�ó��/�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò/�bõYù��±ûVó�ñ[ó/�JõVñw�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúV÷IîYù^ó�óJï�úVö@ó��,��ðsñù^ó@�bõVñ�ï�ú��bñ[ò�í�ñ[øVï�ù��Jñ�ðsùÅúVö^ûYù^ö^ñ�?Dï��+ïsóxùÅðsó�ì��bõVñA=VòJó��x�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò@�bõVù ��òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bóx�bõYñ±ó��Jù��M�ô�ò�ù^í�ñ[ó±ùÅó/�[ìÅú �Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^ú��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó<ý��xì��Fù^ó"~ ó/�2ïsùÅò/�[ìÅí�îYïsð�ñ[ò40 �xì��Fù^ó4365�9�� :{ûVó�ñ[øz�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�ó.�Jì��lõYìDìÅóJñ0óJî:ñ��FïsùÅðsï>�[ñFø%ò�ñ[îYòJñFóJñFú �Jù��JïsìÅúVó2ô�ìÅòQøVï��:ñ[ò�ñ[ú�����ïsúYøVóQì^ô2�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó�?P}�ò�ù^ú���~ ó��ò��Vï��C�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFòA0 }�ò�ù^ú��¸ñ��,ùÅð�ý�365�9���? }�òJùÅú���365�9�7M::ûVóJñFó�óJï>��øVï>�:ñ[ò�ñ[ú��x�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bï�ì^úó��bò�ù��bñFö^ï�ñ[ó2ô�ì^ò�øVï��:ñ[ò�ñ[ú��.�Dï�úVøVóQìÅô�ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVó"?�o+îVî:ñ[ð�ùÅúVø � ïsíæ0>3M5 9�9�:Åïsú�!Åñ[ó��bï�ö^ù��Jñ[ø/�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷ó�õVù^ò�ïsúYö¸ó��bò�ù��Jñ[öÅïsñFó�ù^úVø�îVò�ì^î:ì^ó�ñ[ø�í�ù^ú��%ù^ð>�bñ[ò�úVù �bï>!^ñx�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ,òJñFîVòJñFóJñFú��bù��JïsìÅúVó<ý��+úYô�ì^ò��bûV÷úVù �bñ[ð>�DþDùÅðsð��JõVñ[ó�ñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsó)�bñ��lõYúVï�p�ûVñFóx!�ïsìÅðsù �bñ��bõVñ�#aó�ù^ô�ñ¸ô�ì^ò�ó�îVù �[ñ��[ì^í�îVð�ñ���ï>�,��%ü�ÿYÿ2ëx ò�ûVðsñ-øVûYñ��bì�ûVúVó�ù^ô�ñ��FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ)óJõVùÅòJï�úVöuý r õYñ��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ï�ì^ú(ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõYíSøVñ[÷ó��[ò�ï��:ñ[ø ïsú��bõYïsó±îYù^î:ñ[ò��[ìÅíA�Vï�úVñ[ó�ùÅðsðQìÅô)�JõVñ[ó�ñ�ù^úVùÅð���ó�ñ[ó�ü�ñ����Fñ[î���ó��bù �M��ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bï�ì^ú.�ù^úYøí�ì^ò�ñDþ n�õVï�ð�ñ�ó��Jïsð�ð�ó�ù��bï�ó�ôu�Dï�úVö<�bõVñ�ÿYÿ2ë ò�ûVð�ñDý�+ù^úYóJìÅú�0>3M5�5 ��:2óJõVì"n�ñ[ø'�bõVñ��[ìÅí�îVðsñ���ï��,�-ì^ô0ïsí�îVð�ñ[í�ñFú �JïsúYö��Jù^ï�ð-�Fù^ð�ðsó ñ��<�FïsñFú��bð>��ì^ú_ù

�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ú��JïsìÅúVù^ð{ó��bù �M�Bý;&]ú(ì^ûVò±õYñ[ù^îY÷��VùÅóJñFø�ó��lõVñFí�ñ�þh�JõVñw�Fì^ò�òJñ����búYñ[ó�ó¸ï�ó�ó��bò�ù^ï�ö^õ��Jô�ì^ò�n0ùÅòJø�:ñ��[ùÅûVó�ñ�øVñFù^ø ô�òJùÅí�ñFó�ùÅòJñ ù^û2�bì^í�ù �bï>�[ù^ð�ð>��ò�ñ��FðsùÅïsí�ñFø����m�bõVñ�ö^ùÅò��Yù^ö^ñ'�[ì^ð�ð�ñ����Jì^ò"?D�bõVññ����FïsñFú�����ïsó�ù��lõVï�ñ�!Åñ[øF� ��ûVó�ïsúVö;�JõVñ±ð�ì�ì^îV÷aõVñ[ùÅøVñ[òx�Jñ��lõVúYï�p�ûVñ40 o+îVî:ñ[ðC3M5 5���:��Jì�õVì^ï�ó��x�bõVñð�ìDìÅîV÷aïsú�!�ù^ò�ïsùÅú���ô�òJñFñ'!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ì^û���ì^ô|�JõVñ��Jù^ï�ð�ò�ñ��FûVò�óJï�ì^ú2þ�ùÅúVø#ûVó�ï�úVöE�JõVñ'�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó|0 o�îVî:ñ[ð�ùÅúVø-ÿVõVù^ì�365�5�� :��bì�óJï�í�ûYðsù �bñ��bõVñ/�Jì^î-ò�ñ[ûVó�ù��Vð�ñ¸ó��Jù��M��ô�ò�ù^í�ñ[ó<ý� ìÅõVúVó�óJìÅú'0�365�9�À :Vï�ú !Åñ[ú��bñFø�ðsùÅíA�:øVù�ð�ï�ôu�bï�úVö(n�õYñ[ò�ñxô�òJñFñ@!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ìÅôBùA��úVì"n�ú�ô�ûVú2���bï�ì^ú

�[ùÅú��:ñA�bò�ñ[ù �bñFø·ù^ó¸ñ����bò�ù�ùÅòJöÅûVí�ñ[ú��bó�üu�bõ�ûVó¸ù^ð�ð�ì �Fù��Jñ[ø·ï�ú·ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ó"bý � ù^úVø_ù^úVø·ÿ2�bñ��M��÷ð�ñ[ò�0�365�5�� :�îVò�ì^î:ì^ó�ñ[ø³�bõVñ)ïsøYñ[ù ì^ôxð�ïsöÅõ��b÷+n0ñFïsöÅõ �A�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó(n�õYï��lõ ðsñFù"!^ñ�ìÅû��(�Fñ[ò��bùÅïsú ô�ò�ñ[ñ!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ[ó,ïsô-�bõYñ��@ùÅòJñ ù ���[ñFóJó�ï>�Vðsñ¸ô�ò�ì^í ì �bõVñFò�îVð�ù��[ñFó�ýÿVì^í�ñ;�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò�ów0 ÿ2�bñ[ñFðsñ�3M587698?�}�ò�ù^ú2��ñ���ù^ð]ýR3M5 9��8?0ë�ù^ò�øVñ[ð�ð�ï@3M5�9 ��:Qî:ñ[ò�ô�ì^ò�í �[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ

�[ìÅú�!^ñ[ò�ó�ïsìÅú�ù^úVø��[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ%ùÅúVù^ð>��óJñFó�ùÅó¸îYù^ò���ìÅôG�bõYñ[ï�ò/�bò�ù^úVó�ðsù �bï�ì^ú�ô�òJìÅí ðsùÅíA�:øVù��Fù^ð>�[ûVð�ûVóì^òA�[ì^ú��Jïsú�ûVù �bï�ì^úV÷aîVù^ó�ó�ïsúVö-ó��,��ðsñ�ï�ú��bì·í�ù��lõYïsúVñ4�[ì�øVñDý��,û��±ï>��ï�ó�ûYóJñFô�ûVðG�Jì·óJñFîVù^ò�ù��Jñ��bõVñ�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ@ï�ú��bò�ìDøYû����JïsìÅú ô�òJìÅíSí�ù��lõVï�úVñF�[ì�øVñ@öÅñ[úVñFòJù �bï�ì^ú ó�ì'�JõVù��<�bõYñF�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFò%ï�ó�í�ì^ò�ñ

Page 30: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

±!Ö ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

í�ì�øVûVð�ù^ò"?-�bõVï�ó�õVùÅóA�:ñ[ñFú(øVì^úVñ@ïsú1�Fì^í�îVï�ðsñFòJóA�Vù^ó�ñ[ø�ì^ú(ìÅòJøYïsúVùÅò���¶Å÷+�[ùÅð��FûVð�ûVó�üu�JõVò�ì^ûVöÅõð�ù^íA�:øVù±ð�ï�ôu�bï�úVö8�0së�ìÅûVó�ïsúVñFù^û�ñ��0ù^ð]ýa365�9 À8? � ì^õVúYóJó�ì^ú'365�9�À :Vù^úYø�ì^ú;�[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úY÷IîVùÅóJó�ï�úVöó��,�Dð�ñ�ü�ûVó�ï�úVö;�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aîVù^ó�óJï�úVö%ó��,��ð�ñ C0 o�îVî:ñ[ð�ùÅúVø � ï�í 365�9�5�?¢}�ñFðsó�ñ��@ù^úVøY�+ûYøVù���365�9 5�:]ý��ì �bõ�ë�õYì"nm0>3M5 9�9 :�ù^úVø�ÿ2�bñ[ñFðsñ0ù^úVø�ÿVûVó�óJí�ù^ú40>3M5 9�� :�ì��Vó�ñ[ò�!^ñFø��bõVù ��øVù �bù^÷+�Vì"n ù^úVùÅð���ó�ïsó

�[ùÅú-õVñ[ð�î-øVñ��FïsøVñ/n�õYñ��bõYñ[òs�Jì�îVû��x!�ù^ò�ï�ù��Vð�ñ[ó�ï�ú��[ùÅðsð�ñ[ò�÷Ió�ù"!^ñ�ì^òx�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<ý � ñù^ò�ñ|�JõVñA=Vò�ó��s�bì�óJõVì"n õVì"n��bì�òJñFîVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��x�[ùÅðsð�ñ[ñF÷Ió�ù"!^ñ ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�óxï�ú��[ìÅú��bï�úDûYù��bï�ì^úY÷IîVùÅóJó�ï�úVöó��,�Dð�ñ�0 o+îYî£ñFð�ù^úVø ÿYõVù^ìÿ3M5�5 �8?�o�îVî:ñ[ð|3M5 5���:0ù^úVø õVì"n �bì�ûVó�ñ��Fì^í�îVï�ðsñF÷��Jïsí�ñ4!�ùÅòJï�ù��Vð�ñ[÷ð�ïsô�ñ��bï�í�ñ�ï�úVô�ìÅòJí�ù��JïsìÅú��Jì�øVì�ù�í�û��lõY�:ñ��t�Jñ[ò�Ibì ��ìÅô2ï>��üu�JõVï�óxîVù^î:ñ[ò"bý��ì��[ùÅð�!�ù^ò�ïsù �VðsñFó{ì^ô:øVï>�£ñFòJñFú ��ô�ûVú����JïsìÅúVóGn�ï>�bõ�úYì^úVì"!Åñ[ò�ðsùÅîVîVï�úVö�ð�ï>!^ñ�ò�ù^úVöÅñ[óR�[ùÅú��£ñxùÅðsð�ì^÷

�[ù �bñFøw�bì(�bõVñ¸óJùÅí�ñ+ò�ñ[ö^ï�ó��bñ[ò�ì^ò�ö^ð�ì��VùÅð2n�ï>�bõVìÅû��0ùÅú��%ó�ù"!^ñ��^ò�ñ[ó��bì^ò�ñ|0së�õYì"n�3M5�9 98?Mþ�ì^í�ù^ò�øù^úYø(ÿVñ[ó��bìÅôu��3M5 583M:]ý � ñ�ù��lõYïsñ�!^ñ;�bõYïsó(� ��ù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�úVö�îVùÅò���ìÅôC�bõVñw�FðsìÅóJûYòJñFó@ü�ô�ì^ò(��úVì"n�úô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVó�ù^úVøY�Fì^ú��bï�ú�ûVù��JïsìÅúVó�2ï�ú��£ì �bõ��Fù^ð�ðsñFòJ÷{ùÅúVøY�[ù^ð�ð�ñ[ñ[÷aó�ù"!^ñ+ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó<þDù^úYøF�JõVñ[ú�ûYóJ÷ï�úVöw�bõYñ±ö^ò�ù^îVõY÷��Fì^ð�ì^ò�ïsúVö�ö^ð�ì��Yù^ð�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòxù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^ú-ùÅúVø��bùÅòJöÅñ��bï�úVö�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí�ó(0së�õYù^ï>�bï�ú3M5 9���?��,ò�ïsöÅö^ó,ñ��,ùÅð�ýh365�9 58?�þ�ñ[ìÅòJöÅñ�ñ���ù^ð]ý�3M5�5 �8?�þ�ñ[ìÅòJöÅñ�ùÅúVøFo+îVî:ñ[ðC3M5�5 ��:]ý�xñ��Fñ[ú��bð>�Dþ�ë�ð�ïsúVöÅñ[ò)0>3M5 5�9 :�ö^ù"!Åñ�ù+ô�ì^ò�í�ùÅð�ù^úYø�ïsí�îVð�ñ[í�ñ[ú��Jù��bï�ì^úY÷Iï�úVøVñFî£ñFúVøVñ[ú���øYñ�=VúVï>�bï�ì^ú

ì^ôC�JõVñ@îVò�ì^î:ñ[òA�bù^ï�ð�ò�ñ��FûVò�óJï�ì^ú�ù^úYø$�bõVñ�ÿYÿ2ë òJûYðsñ�ý���ûYò|�[ûVò�ò�ñ[ú��±îVùÅî£ñFò±ù^ò�ö^ûVñFó±ô�ì^òA�bõVñï�í�î:ì^ò��bùÅú��[ñ ìÅô��bõYñ¸ÿYÿ2ë ò�ûVð�ñ�ü�ï�ú)ï�í�îVð�ñ[í�ñ[ú��bï�úVö�ô�ûVú����bï�ì^úVùÅðBðsùÅúVö^ûYù^ö^ñFó��ù^úYø�îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jó�ù�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[÷aù^ð�ðsì��Fù��bï�ì^ú@ó��lõVñFí�ñ��JõVù���ï�óx�:ì��bõ-ñ��<�FïsñFú���ù^úVø-ó�ù^ô�ñ ô�ì^ò�ó�îVù��FñDýÔ T ê21%32ê�X�?B52ç 1%325� ñ+õVù"!Åñ�îVòJñFóJñFú��bñ[ø@ù^ú�ñ����FïsñFú �0ù^úVø�ó�ù^ô�ñF÷Iô�ìÅòJ÷aó�îVù��Fñ��FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú�ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVíq�JõVù��ï�ú �Jñ[öÅòJù �bñ[ó¸ù^úYø�ï�í�îVòJì"!Åñ[ó¸îVò�ñ�!�ïsìÅûVó��[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñF÷IùÅúVù^ð>��óJï�ó@�Jñ��lõVúYï�p�ûVñFó�ý���ûVò ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí ûVó�ñ[óó�ïsí�îVð�ñ_ùÅúVø ñ��:ñ����bï>!^ñ_õYñ[ûVò�ïsó��bï>�[ó�üu�VùÅóJñFø ì^ú��Fì^í�îVï�ðsñF÷��Jïsí�ñ��Fì^ú��bò�ì^ð�÷+�Vì"n ùÅúVø�!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñð�ïsô�ñF÷��Jïsí�ñ·ï�úVô�ì^ò�í�ù��JïsìÅú.��bì ñ���îVðsìÅï��;�Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ�ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó�ùÅúVøÿ�[ìÅúVó��JòJû2����ó�ù^ô�ñ[ð>�6ð�ï�ú��^ñFø�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[ó<ý��+úYðsï>�^ñ�ù^ú���îVò�ñ�!�ï�ì^ûVó ó��lõVñ[í�ñFó�þ:ìÅûVò ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí ó�ù��Jïsó�=Vñ[ó��JõVñE#aó�ù^ô�ñ�ô�ì^ò�ó�îVù��Fñ�[ìÅí�îVðsñ���ï��,��%�ó��[ìÅîVï�úVö�ò�ûVð�ñDn�õVï�ð�ñ¸ó��bï�ð�ð:ó�ûVîVî:ì^ò��bï�úVö<!^ñFò���ñ����FïsñFú ���[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ+ùÅðsð�ì��[ù��JïsìÅú�ù^úYø!�ù^ò�ïsù �Vð�ñ¸ù ���Fñ[ó�ó�ý

��ûVò2í�ñFù^ó�ûVòJñFí�ñ[ú��2ó�õVì"n�ó-�bõVù �.�JõVñ�úVñ�nE�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ï�ì^ú¸ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVí ï�ó�ù�ö^ò�ñ[ù ��ó�û��[÷�[ñFóJó<ý r õVñ|�FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú@ùÅðsöÅì^ò�ï��JõVí ï>�bó�ñ[ð�ô{ïsó¸ô�ù^ó��bñFòs�bõYù^ú·ìÅûVò+îVò�ñ�!�ï�ì^ûVó+ù^ð�ö^ì^ò�ï>�bõVíü�ó�ñ[ñ r ù��YðsñxàD&t&�bý�&,�xí�ù��Åñ[ó�îVò�ì^öÅòJùÅí�ó�ó�í�ùÅðsð�ñ[ò�üu���@ùÅú�ù"!Åñ[ò�ù^ö^ñ¸ì^ôx3M5�Â��ùÅúVø-ô�ù^ó��bñFò%üu���ù^ú�ù"!^ñFòJùÅö^ñ�ìÅô-36�8Â�bý�&,�QøVñ��FòJñFù^ó�ñ[ó��bõVñ,ò�ù��Jñ0ìÅôYõVñFù^î�ù^ð�ðsì��[ù �bï�ì^ú(� �A´��8Â�þ�ùÅúVø<� ��ì �£ñ���ïsúVö�bõYñ�#�óJùÅô�ñ+ô�ì^ò�ó�îVù��Fñ@�[ìÅí�îVðsñ���ï��,��%�ò�ûVð�ñ+ùÅúVøw�^ñFñ[îVï�úVö(�[ð�ì^ó�ûVòJñFó0ó�í�ù^ð�ð�þ^ï>��õYñ[ð�îVó0ò�ñ[øYû��[ñD�bõVñù^í�ìÅûVú���ìÅô2ð�ï>!^ñ øVù��Jù�îVòJñFóJñFò�!Åñ[ø�� �@ö^ù^ò��VùÅö^ñ@�Fì^ð�ðsñ����JïsìÅú2ýr õVñ4�FðsìÅóJûVò�ñ[÷aù^úYù^ð>�Dó�ï�ó/�bñ��lõYúVï�p�ûVñFó�îVò�ñ[ó�ñ[ú��Jñ[ø(ï�ú³�bõYïsó�îVù^î:ñ[ò(�[ùÅú(ù^ð�óJì��:ñ@ùÅîVîVð�ïsñFø1�bì

�[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò�ó@�JõVù��+øVì@úVì �xûVó�ñ)ë-*0ÿ�ù^ó@�JõVñ[ï�ò+ï�ú��bñFòJí�ñ[øYïsù �bñ�ð�ù^úYö^ûVùÅö^ñDý)�,ì��Jõ�óJùÅô�ñ[ð>��ð�ï�ú��^ñFø�[ð�ì^ó�ûVò�ñ[óxùÅúVø�ö^ì�ì�ø�ûVó�ñ±ì^ô��Fù^ð�ðsñFñ[÷aóJù"!Åñ¸ò�ñ[öÅïsó��bñFòJó�ùÅòJñ�ñFóJó�ñ[ú��JïsùÅð�ï�ú��VûVï�ðsøVï�úVö�õVïsöÅõV÷+pDûYù^ð�ï��,��[ìÅí�îVïsð�ñ[ò�ó��bõVù �D�Fù^ú·öÅñ[úVñFòJù �bñ�ñ����[ï�ñ[ú��D�Fì�øVñAn�õVï�ð�ñ%ó��bï�ðsðQó�ù��Jïsó�ôu��ïsúVö��bõVñ³#aó�ù^ô�ñ%ô�ì^ò ó�îVù��Fñ�[ìÅí�îVðsñ���ï��,��%�òJûYðsñ�ýÕ T 7Hï£7+ç�X`7qÖ{ç�X�ç é08r õVñ�úVñ�n �FðsìÅóJûYòJñF÷��Fì^ú�!^ñFòJó�ïsìÅú�ù^ð�ö^ìÅòJï>�bõVí îVòJñFóJñFú��bñ[ø)ï�úF�JõVï�ó+îVùÅî£ñFò�ïsóxúYì"n ï�í�îYðsñFí�ñFú��bñ[øù^úYø6ò�ñ[ð�ñ[ù^ó�ñ[ø³n�ï��JõE�JõVñ-ÿ��bùÅúVøVù^ò�ø1��� ìÅôs�+ñ�n � ñFòJó�ñ��#üÀÿ������ � � D�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò�ù^úVøE�bõVñK���&,� r �����E�[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò;0 ÿVõYù^ì�365�5876:�ý�ÿ������ � � ïsó¸ù/IbìÅïsú��Dn0ìÅò��F���F�2û��[ñFú��`þa*�ò�ïsú2�[ñ��Jì^ú2þù^úYøW×{ùÅðsñ�ý�K��.&,� r ïsó{ù í�ì�øVñ[ò�ú��[ì^í�îVï�ð�ñ[ò{ï�úVô�òJùÅó��JòJû2���bûYòJñ�øVñ�!Åñ[ð�ì^î:ñ[ø�ù��B×{ùÅðsñx��úVï�!Åñ[ò�óJï>�,�Dý�,ì��Jõ�K���&,� r ùÅúVø-ÿ����.��� � ùÅòJñ ù"!�ù^ï�ð�ù��Vð�ñ�ù �C�bõVñ�ô�ìÅðsð�ì"n�ïsúYö<n�ñ��)ó�ï��Jñ �

/*<*<*irØ�Ù@Ù*%*;Oj.n*<().f�:-)�5�w�;�9()�9l*1

Page 31: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe ±!Õ

Ú!Û!Ü^ÝYÞQßUà1á8â:ã�á8äHá8ÝYå�æ� ñ@n�ì^ûVð�ø�ð�ï��Åñ@�bì(�bõVùÅú�� r ò�ñ�!Åì^ò � ï�í�þ8Á+ù"!�ï�ñ[ò)��ñ[ò�ì"�Dþ � ìÅõVúw�xñFîVî��Dþ � ñFù^úV÷+*�ï�ñ[ò�ò�ñ r ùÅðsîVï�ú2þù^úYø��JõVñ�ù^úVìÅú��Dí�ìÅûVó,òJñFô�ñ[ò�ñ[ñ[ó�ô�ìÅòx�[ìÅí�í�ñFú �Jó�ì^ú)ù^ú-ñ[ùÅòJð>�;!^ñFòJó�ï�ì^ú@ìÅô.�JõVï�óxîVù^î:ñ[ò<ýçwá-è�á8çwá-ÝYÛ!á8æéBê�ê�ë�ì�í�é�î�ïRî ¯+[MU^°l� â ylgI��yl�lfujhdlo>o>fhjhrIn>dli�jhyli���f£qsylpIrIfhg�rt��yli�partylj�¶{ylo>o>dFjhylrtn>dliV��ðtÜ�»�¾®¿]Ã�º®È¤Çw¾®Ü�ñ:¿À¾bÂ�¼�¹�¹aÇsÜ��ò�¼�ȤȤ¼J¿�óô®Û�¨^�6T^°a´]õMT^°+[^�

éBê�ê�ë�ì�í�é�î�ïRî ¯+[M[MT^�Âö�¾[Ã�ÁÅÇsÄ ÇsÜ���÷YÇsȲøHö�¾®Ü<ȤÇwÜ<Ú`º®È¤Çw¾[Ü<¹a����ylk���gan>e`�lfRQ�i�n>�lfhgapIn>r��xÞ:gafhpIpl�l¬�fh~�O£dlgI¶��éBê�ê�ë�ì�íBé�î�ïRî ¯+[M[l¨^��«�d[dlm���fhyle�fhgap,n>idù<�¤jhylo>jhv�o>v�p�dlg���Þ{ª��Dò�Çs¹wÁ�º®Ü<Ù�ú<ÉlÃ�Ýa¾[Ä ÇsÂ$ö�¾®Ã�ÁÅÚ`È�º[È�Çs¾®ÜMû®�¥l¥^°jõl¥l¨l¥^�Vã2o>pad,yJ��yln>o>yl��o>f{ylp�Þ£gan>i�jhfhrIdli�Q�i�n>�lfhgapIn>r�����fhj���\�fbm�dlgIr���ªJ����\��¤¨l¦lµl�V[l¨^�éBê�ê�ë�ì�í:é�î!ïRîQü<ý<þ�ÿ����Yí���î ¯+[MUMU^�(X:m`rIn>k,n>¡hn>i���jho>dlpav�gIf�fbi[�[n>gadli�k,fhi[r�gafhm�gafhpIfbi[rtylrIn>dli�p��+��fhj��V��\2fhmV�¯a¦MU^�F²Qfhm�r��Fdlq���dlk,m�v�rtfhg,ªbjbn>fhi�jhfF�`Þ:gIn>i�jhfhrIdliDQ�i�n>�lfhgapIn>r��F�FÞ:gIn>i�jhfbrtdliV�F¬2­Å�éBê�ê�ë�ì�í�é�î�ïRî1ü<ý<þLÿ����Yí���î ¯+[MUM[^�2��dliFrtn>iFv`ylrIn>dli���m�ylpapIn>i��^�`jho>dlpav�gIfb��m�ylpapIn>i��,par��[o>fF�w��i�ú<Ç Æ�Ȥ¼�¼JÜ<È+ø��:ö�ú<ÉlÃ�Á�Y¾[Ü$ñ£¿]ÇsÜ<ÂJÇ ÁÅÄ ¼J¹{¾�»�ñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ã�Ã0ÇsÜ���ò�º®Ü���Ú`º`�J¼�¹��Fã0��c Þ£gafhpap��[¬2fb~�OYdlga¶D��TM[l¥]õl¥lµMT^�

éBê�ê�ë�ì�í^é�î8ïRî�ü<ý<þ �$ü������<ë�ë�ý<í��qî���î ¯+[M[^¯l�0ªJrIyli`e�ylgae±c�«�dlqY¬�fh~_­[fhgIpafh�F�:��i��@ø®Çs¿ÀÙLðtÜ<È�� Ä!ú<ÉlÃ�Á�¾®ÜHñ£¿t¾\��!ò�º®Ü���QðIÃ�ÁDÄ ¼�Ã0¼�Ü<Ȥº®È¤Çw¾®Ü¸º®Ü<Ù�ò�¾\��ÇwÂ�ñ:¿À¾$�J¿Àº[Ã0Ã�ÇwÜ����lc@�bå@n>gapIn>i��^�J³:e���ªJm�gIn>i��lfhga�+»Yfhgao>yl�^�J¬2fb~O£dlgI¶��ůjõ^¯a¥^�

éBê�ê�ë�ì�í^é�î-ïRî<ü8ý<þ ���8ü��8í� Yî ¯+[M[MT^����ylo>o>fhfb��pay��lf�gafh�ln>pIrIfhgap�n>i�jbdli[rtn>iFv�ylrtn>dli��¤m`ylpapan>i`�¸par��[o>fF��ò�Çs¹wÁ�º®Ü<Ùú<ÉlÃ�Ý�¾®Ä ÇsÂ�ö�¾®Ã�ÁÅÚFȤº®È¤Çs¾®Übô®Û�¥^�D¯+[^¯jõMTMT^¯l�

éBê�ê�ë�ì�íÂé�î@ïRî@ü<ý<þ!���8ü��8í" :î ¯+[M[l¦^��³:k,m�n>gIn>jhylo:yli�e%yli�ylo>�Frtn>jxpartv�e���dlqBpartylj�¶��lfbgIpav�p���fhylm�jhdlpar�qwdlgo>yli��lv�yl�lfhp�~�n>rt�¸jho>dlpIv�gafhpl��#[¾®Ú`¿]Ü<º®Ä�¾�»%$�Ú`Ü<ÂJȤÇs¾®Ü<º®Ä!ñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ã�Ã0ÇsÜ��'&®ÛV¯,z>­®yliFv�ylgI��}t�`¨^°jõ^°a¨^�é(�*)���+-,�+-+-�-ý<í/.Âî ¯+[MUM[^� â ylga��yl�lf0jhdlo>o>fbjhrtn>dli±n>i�rI��f10328,54 6£�¤k,ylj��`n>i�fF����fhj��V�"\2fhmV��Þ£c â k�fbk�d�°a¥^�²Qfhm�r���dlqB��dlk,m�v�rtfhg�ªJjhn>fhi�jhfhpl������ylo>k,fhgapaQ�i�n>�lfhgapIn>r��0dlq^��fhj���i�dlo>dl�l�F� â dlrIfh��dlga�^�^ªJ~ufhe�fhiV��²Qfhjhfhk0��fhgl��:ü<ì�ì�í7��î�ü<ý<þ�.!ü�8���+�í!ÿ!î:9�î ¯+[M[l¥^�^¢Bgayli�j��xm�gIfhe�n>jhrIn>dli+qsdlg:qsgIfbfF�<��igñ£¿À¾JÂ;<�:ö��ú�ð>=�ñ�ò7�@?A� BDCqö�¾®Ü�»E¾®Ü`ñ£¿À¾$�;�ò�º®Ü����F�¼�¹�Ǭ��Ü�º®Ü<ÙqðIÃ�ÁDÄ ¼�Ã0¼�Ü<Ȥº®È¤Çw¾®Ü<�`ã���c Þ:gafhpIpl�[¬2fh~YO£dlgI¶��[¥lµlµ]õl¥^¯a¥^���8���)G)�+�í*H�î �JI �*�8ê�ë:8�í�KHîL�qî � KNë�ý<ý<ë�þ�M8í�KHî � ü<ý<þN�(��8���O��8ý8í�.Âî ¯+[MUM[^����dlo>dlgIn>i�����fhv�gIn>partn>jhpYqwdlgVgafh�ln>partfhgylo>o>dFjhylrtn>dliV����i_ñ:¿À¾bÂ�@�Âö� ú�ð>=�ñ�ò7�@?P� Q:B`ö�¾®Ü�»R2¾[Üdñ£¿t¾\���ò�º[Ü��;SFQ¼J¹�Ǭ��Ü�º®Ü<ÙgðtÃ�ÁÅÄ ¼�Ã�¼JÜ<Ȥº®È¤Çw¾[Ü<�ã0��c Þ:gIfbpIpl�l¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D��T^°a´]õMTMUl¨^�I ü*8�þ<ë�ì�ìJ��í<.Âî ¯+[MUl¨^�{��dlk,m�n>o>n>i`��y�qsv�i`jbrtn>dli�ylo�o>yli��lv`yl�lf`�^��iFñ£¿t¾bÂ�B¾�»�Ȳø[¼UT:BDQRVW�:ö� ö�¾®Ü�»a¼�¿À¼�Ü<Âa¼�¾[Üò�Çs¹wÁ�º®Ü<Ù�$^ÚFÜ<Â�ȤÇw¾®Ü<º®Ä@ñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ã�Ã�ÇwÜ�����ã0��c Þ£gafhpap��®¬2fb~�OYdlga¶D��TlµMU]õMT^¯l°l�

I �8ü���,���ý<íYX\î^ÿ@î ¯+[MUMT^��\2fh�ln>partfhg�ylo>o>d[jhylrIn>dli)yli�e-pam`n>o>o>n>i����[n>y��lgaylm��)jbdlo>dlgIn>i��^�Z��iRú<ÉlÃ�Á`¾[¹aÇsÚFà ¾[Üö�¾[Ã�ÁÅÇsÄ ¼�¿Nö�¾[Ü<¹aȤ¿]Ú`ÂJȤÇs¾®Ü<�Fã0��c ªbn>�lm�o>yliV�[¬2fh~�O£dlgI¶��6[MU]õ^¯aµl´^�

I �8ü�+�ë�í@�qî79�î ¯+[MUMU^��ªJylqwfhr��%jhdli�pIn>e�fhgaylrtn>dli�p,qwdlg0pIrIdlgIyl�lfxylo>o>dFjhylrtn>dli�dlm�rtn>k,n>¡hylrIn>dli�p�����ifñ:¿À¾bÂ�Z�:ö�ú�ð[=�ñ�ò7�S?A� QDQqö�¾®Ü�»E£¾®ÜLñ£¿t¾\���ò^º®Ü��;<FQ¼J¹�Ǭ��Ü º®Ü<ÙqðIÃ�ÁDÄ ¼�Ã0¼�Ü<Ȥº®È¤Çw¾®Ü<�Fã0��c Þ:gIfbpIpl�l¬�fh~YOYdlga¶D�ůjõM[^�

I �8ë�ý�)Qí�HNî ��\ ü�8�ê�ë]8�í�9�î � ü8ý<þ^.!ë�ë�íYHNî ¯+[M[MU^� â fhi�fhgIylrIn>dli�ylo{pIrIylja¶�jhdlo>o>fhjhrIn>dli-yli`e-m�gadl�`o>fb��e�gan>�lfhim�gafhrtfhiFv�gIn>i��^����iFñ£¿t¾bÂ���Âö� ú�ð>=�ñ�ò7�@?_� BDQ�ö�¾®Ü�»Eu¾®ÜWñ£¿t¾\��Yò�º®Ü���<FQ¼�¹aÇä�JÜ�º®Ü<Ù\ðtÃ�ÁÅÄ ¼�Ã�¼JÜ<Ȥº®È¤Çw¾[Ü<�ã0��c Þ:gIfbpIpl�l¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D�D¯a¦MT]õ^¯l°a¥^�I �*��`�í�a?î I î ¯+[MUMU^�[c�n>i`n>k,n>¡hn>i��2gIfh�ln>partfbg�v`payl�lfBm�fhi�ylo>r��0ylr�m`gad[jbfhe�v`gafBjhylo>o>pl�]��iLñ£¿t¾bÂ���:ö( ú�ð[=�ñ�ò7�S?� QDQqö�¾[Ü�»E:¾®Ü$ñ:¿À¾\���ò^º®Ü��;�FQ¼J¹�Çä�JÜ�º®Ü<ÙHðtÃ�ÁÅÄ ¼JÃ�¼JÜ<Ȥº®È¤Çs¾®Ü<�`ã0��c Þ£gafhpap��[¬�fh~YOYdlga¶D��Ul´]õM[l¨^�

I ìJ��ý�)Që:8�í�ïRî*�qî ¯+[M[MU^�2Þ£gadlm�fhg�rtyln>oYgIfhjbv`gapan>dli�yli`e�pIm�yljhf�fh©,jhn>fhi�jh�F����iFñ:¿À¾bÂ���:ö(Tú�ð>=�ñ�ò7�S?b� BDQö�¾[Ü�»EY¾[Ü$ñ£¿t¾\���ò^º®Ü��;�FQ¼J¹�Çä�JÜ�º®Ü<ÙHðtÃ�ÁÅÄ ¼JÃ�¼JÜ<Ȥº®È¤Çs¾®Ü<�`ã0��c Þ£gafhpap��®¬2fb~�OYdlga¶D�D¯l°a¨]õ^¯+Ul´^�

I ìJ��ý�)Që:8�írïzî��qî ��\ ü*8D,��<ë:���Yë]8�í�é�î \ î � ü8ý<þ^c�+-,�íYdNî"�Uî ¯+[MUMU^�Z��k,m�o>fhk,fhi[rIylrtn>dli�partgaylrtfh�ln>fhp�qwdlgjhdliFrtn>iFv`ylrIn>dli�p�����i^TDBDQDQe�:ö� ö�¾®Ü�»�¼J¿À¼�Ü<Â�¼�¾[Übò�Çw¹sÁ�º®Ü<Ùf$^ÚFÜ<Â�ȤÇw¾®Ü<º®Ä�ñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ã�Ã0ÇsÜ��J�Dã���c Þ:gafhpIpl�¬�fh~YOYdlga¶D�D¯+Tl¨]õ^¯a¥^¯l�I ����+-��ý<ë�ü��<í�X�î �LI ��8���ë�ý8í�HNîL.Âî � ü<ý<þN�`ü��<ý�M<í��Dî ¯+[MUl´^�`���`fBjbylrtfh�ldlgan>jhylo�yl��partgayljhrYk,ylj���n>i`f`�1��i'$�Ú`Ü<Â�½È¤Çw¾[Ü<º®Äwñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ã�Ã0ÇsÜ��qò�º[Ü��JÚ`º`��¼J¹�º®Ü<Ù\ö�¾®Ã�ÁÅÚ`È�¼�¿U��¿À ø®ÇwȤ¼�ÂJȤÚ`¿À¼�ÛYò7?�ö:úhg�¾[Ä!óDiDT®��­Å�`Þ:�`­®dlv�yli�i�ylv�e��³:eV�ŪJm�gIn>i��lfhga�+»Yfhgao>yl�^�l¬�fh~�O£dlgI¶��®´lµ]õl¦l¨^��%��`^ü<ý<í!é�î � �wü�8�þ���,���í��qî � ü<ý<þ'�f��+-+�í7d�î ¯+[M[l¨^�Dc�fhk,dlga�,pIv���pI�FpIrIfhk6m^fhgIqsdlgIk,yli�jhfQdlq�m�gIdl�lgaylk,pBv`pan>i��jhdlmF�[n>i��,�lylgI��yl�lf�jbdlo>o>fhjhrtn>dliV�w��i�ñ:¿À¾bÂ�^óDT®¹�È"��Ü<Ü<Ú`º®Ä7�:ö� ú�ð[=�ñ�ò7�S?2½3ú�ð>=%�:öj�dú<ÉlÃ�ÁG£¾®Ü`ñ£¿]ÇsÜ<ÂJÇs½ÁÅÄ ¼�¹{¾�»?ñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ã�Ã�ÇwÜ��qò^º®Ü��JÚ`º`��¼J¹��[ã0��c Þ£gafhpap��[¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D�D¯jõ^¯a¨^�a�ì�ü<ý8ü�)-ü<ý8í I î � �<ü�k�8DM8í8é�î � �%�*k1ü8í���î]aBî � ü<ý8þla�ë�ì�ì ë]��+�ë�ý<í7�Uî ¯+[M[l¥^�^����f2fbpIpafhi�jhfQdlqÅjbdlk�m�n>o>n>i���~�n>rt�jhdliFrtn>iFv`ylrIn>dli�p��<��iLñ:¿À¾JÂ;7�:ö(sú�ð>=�ñ�ò7�@?m� BDC�ö�¾®Ü�»R�¾®ÜHñ:¿À¾$�;!ò�º[Ü��;nFQ¼J¹�Çä�JÜ�º®Ü<Ù�ðtÃ�ÁÅÄ ¼�Ã�¼JÜ<Ȥº®È¤Çw¾[Ü<�ã0��c Þ:gIfbpIpl�l¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D��Tl¥^°jõMTl¨^°l�

Page 32: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

±P] ^2_a` b"c�dDc�e"f/gh_2ghi"i jlk

Xrë]�*8�)Që�í7.Âî�ü<ý<þ\éBê�ê�ë�ì�í�é�î1ïRî ¯+[M[l¦^�@��rtfhgaylrtfbe¸gafh�ln>partfhg�jhdlylo>fhpajhn>i��^�!��igñ:¿À¾JÂ;��@÷£¼JÜ<ȤÉl½ÀÈ+ø®Çs¿ÀÙo��Ü<Ü<Ú`º®Ä�:ö( ú�ð>=�ñ�ò7�@?�½5ú�ð>=%�Âöj�bú<ÉlÃ�Á�:¾®Ü`ñ:¿]ÇwÜ<Â�Ç ÁÅÄ ¼�¹�¾�»�ñ£¿À¾$�J¿tº®Ã0Ã�ÇwÜ��qò�º®Ü���ÚFº`��¼�¹a�`ã���c Þ:gafhpIpl�F¬2fb~O£dlgI¶��6TlµMU]õMT^¯+U^�

Xrë]�*8�)Që�í".Âî � XY����ì�ì�ü����Yë�í"a?î � ü<ý<þ!9?ë�ê�ê]M<í:ÿ!î ¯+[M[l¨^�,ã m�dlgartyl��o>f�yli�e%dlm�rIn>k�n>¡bn>i`� ��ylj�¶lfhi�e�qwdlg�rI�`fªJc�«�pa¬2­Qjhdlk,m�n>o>fhgl���iLñ:¿À¾bÂ�¼�¼�Ù®ÇwÜ���¹�¾�»BÈ+ø®¼ZTDBDBRV$ðIÜ<È�¼�¿]Ü<º®È¤Çw¾[Ü<º®Ä�ö�¾®Ü�»�¼J¿À¼�Ü<Â�¼Q¾®Üqö�¾[Ã�ÁÅÇsÄ ¼�¿Âö�¾®Ü<¹�È�¿]Ú`Â�½È¤Çw¾[Ü<�ŪJm�gIn>i��lfhga�+»Yfhgao>yl�^�l¬�fh~�O£dlgI¶��6Ul¥]õM[^°l�XY���Yü�8�þ<í I îGK�î<ü<ý8þe�<ë]+-,��*qD,�í"HNî ¯+[M[^¯l� â o>dl��ylo>n>¡hylrtn>dli%yli�e�o>n>�lf��Jylgan>yl��o>fhp�����iUñ:¿À¾bÂ�¼�¼�Ù®ÇwÜ���¹�¾�»0È+ø®¼TDB:BDTdú<ÉlÃ�Á`¾®¹�ÇwÚ`à ¾®ÜOñ£º[¿]È�Çsº®ÄSr£á�º®Ä ÚFº®È¤Çs¾®Ü�º®Ü<Ùdú<¼�Ã0º[Ü<È�ÇsÂJ¹�½tsBº[¹a¼�Ùbñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ãu º®Ü<Ç ÁÅÚ`Ä º®È¤Çs¾®Ü<�Vã���cÞ:gIfbpIpl�l¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D�D¯a¦l¦]õ^¯l°l°l�

\ ü<ý�+-�-ý<í I î ¯+[M[lµ^��³:©,jhn>fhi[r:partylj�¶0ylo>o>dFjhylrtn>dli,qsdlg£rIyln>o>��gafhjhv�gapIn>�lfBo>yli��lv�yl�lfhpl����i TDBDB:iU�Âö�sö�¾®Ü�»�¼J¿t¼JÜ<Â�¼¾®Ü`ò�Çw¹sÁ%º®Ü<Ùv$�Ú`Ü<ÂJȤÇw¾[Ü<º®Ä@ñ£¿À¾$�J¿tº®Ã0Ã�ÇwÜ�����ã0��c Þ:gIfbpIpl�l¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D�D¯aµl¦]õ^¯l¯+U^�\ ��ë:k�í(9�î � �SM�k�w���)Qí�9�î�KHî � ü<ý<þx��8���)G)Që:�Yü<ý<í I î ¯+[M[lµ^��\2fhm�gIfbpIfhiFrtn>i���jbdli[rtgadlo�n>i�rt��f�m`gafhpafhi�jhf+dlq��gapIrI��jbo>ylpIp�jhdli[rIn>i[v�ylrtn>dli�pl����iDñ:¿À¾JÂ;��Âö�Tú�ð[=�ñ�ò7�S?b� B:iLö�¾®Ü�»E�¾®ÜWñ:¿À¾$�;�ò�º®Ü���"F�¼�¹�Ǭ��Ü%º[Ü<ÙLðtÃ�½ÁÅÄ ¼�Ã0¼�Ü<Ȥº®È¤Çw¾®Ü<�Fã0��c Þ:gIfhpapl�l¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D�[¦l¦]õ^°l°l�ÿ��*�<ý�+-+-�-ý<íS��î ¯+[MUl´^� «�ylk0��e�y±«�n>qwrtn>i��^�Å��gayli`paqwdlgak,n>i��¸Þ:gadl�lgIylk,p�rId|\�fbjhv�gIpan>�lfx³��[v�ylrtn>dli�pl�\��im�@ø®¼ú<¼�Â�¾®Ü<Ù�ðtÜ<Ȥ¼�¿]Ü<º®È¤Çw¾®Ü<º®Ä-ö�¾®Ü�»�¼J¿À¼�Ü<Â�¼�¾®Üv$�Ú`Ü<ÂJȤÇw¾[Ü<º®Ä<ñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ã�Ã0ÇsÜ���ò^º®Ü��JÚ`º`��¼J¹�º®Ü<Ù�ö�¾®Ã�ÁÅÚ`Ȥ¼J¿Z��¿À ø®Çs½È¤¼�ÂJȤÚ`¿À¼��^ªJm�gIn>i��lfhga�+»Yfhgao>yl�^�®¬�fh~�O£dlgI¶��ů+[lµ]õMTlµl¥^�

ÿ��*�<ê�ê:��í�y�îGHNî ¯+[M[l¥^����ylj���fx~�gan>rtf�m�dlo>n>jhn>fhp�yli�e�m�fhgaqwdlgak,yli`jbfF����iUñ:¿À¾bÂ�¼�¼�Ù®ÇwÜ���¹x¾�»,È+ø®¼Hó:i®È+ø ��Ü<Ü<Ú`º®ÄðIÜ<È�¼�¿]Ü<º®È¤Çw¾[Ü<º®Ä@ú<ÉlÃ�Á�¾®¹�ÇwÚ`Ã#¾®Ü$ö�¾[Ã�ÁÅÚ`Ȥ¼J¿Y��¿À ø®ÇwȤ¼�ÂJȤÚ`¿À¼��[ã���c Þ:gafhpIpl�l¬�fh~�O£dlgI¶��ů+[^¯jõMTlµ^¯l�

KNë�ì�+�ë]M<í79�î�ü8ý<þ \ �<þ�ü*z8í7HNî ¯+[MUM[^� \�fhylo>n>partn>j�jhdlk,m�n>o>ylrtn>dli+�F��m�gIdl�lgaylk rtgayli�pIqsdlgIk,ylrIn>dli��-��i�ú<Ç Æ<È�¼�¼�Ü<È+ø�:ö(�ú<ÉlÃ�Á�:¾®Ü$ñ:¿]ÇwÜ<Â�Ç ÁÅÄ ¼�¹{¾�»Bñ:¿À¾$�J¿Àº[Ã0Ã�ÇwÜ���ò^º®Ü��JÚ`º`��¼J¹��Fã0��c Þ:gIfhpapl�l¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D��TMU^¯jõMTM[MT^�

K�8�ü<ý*O íG�qî ¯+[MU^°l�8X8\�¢Y���0��ã�i�dlm�rtn>k,n>¡hn>i���jhdlk,m�n>o>fhg:qwdlg{ªJja��fhk,fF�^Þ:��� ²x��rI�`fbpIn>pl��OYylo>f.Q2i�n>�lfhgapIn>r��`��¬2fb~S�yJ�lfbi��������

K�8�ü<ý*O í"�qî � KNë�ì�+�ë]M<í�9�î � 9?ë�ë]+�í:ÿ!î �n\ �<þ�ü*z8í"HNî � H��*��ì�k���ý<íYÿ!î � ü<ý<þgé?þ�ü*�"+�í�y�î ¯+[MUl¦^��X8\2¢Y���0��ã�idlm�rtn>k,n>¡hn>i��%jhdlk,m`n>o>fbg�qsdlg�ªJja��fhk,fF�eú�ð>=�ñ�ò7�@?_?2¾®È¤ÇsÂa¼�¹|{ ñ:¿À¾JÂ;Nú<Çä�ÀÁDÄ º®Ü}� QD&bú<ÉlÃ�ÁG�¾®ÜOö�¾®Ã�ÁÅÇwÄ ¼�¿ö�¾[Ü<¹aȤ¿]Ú`ÂJȤÇs¾®Ü�~qóDT®ÛV°,z|­®v�o>�D}t��T^¯+[]õMTl¥l¥^�

.!ü<ý<þ*��ý<í�HNî�ÿ!î ¯+[l¦l¨^�V����fQk�fbja��yli�n>jhylo�fh��ylo>v�ylrtn>dli¸dlq�fh�[m�gafhpapIn>dli�pl�:ö�¾®Ã�ÁÅÚ`È�¼�¿�#F¾®ÚF¿]Ü<º[Ä"&®Û`¨^�®¥lµMU]õl¥MTlµ^��f��ì�ý<ë]8�í(9�î � �(�*q:,1ë�í(�Dî � ü8ý<þ \ ü�8�ê�ë]8�í�9�î ¯+[M[lµ^�^�!ø®¼'F�¼>�YÜ<ÇwȤÇs¾®Ü�¾�»�ú<È�º[Ü<Ù®º®¿ÀÙ!\ò���cL��� Þ:gafhpIpl���ylk0��gIn>e��lfF�[c�ylpIpaylj��[v�pafhrtrIp���f��8�8���+�ë:,�,�íYX�î �/I 8�ü�8DM<í%KHî � X�ì ë]`�íYy�î � ü<ý<þOïLü<ìJz8ë]8�íY�qî ¯+[M[MU^� ªJrIylja¶F�¤�`ylpafhe�r��Fm�fhe-ylpIpafhk0�`o>�o>yli��lv�yl�lfF����iUñ:¿À¾JÂ;STDBDBDQWðtÜ<Ȥ¼�¿]Ü<º®È¤Çw¾®Ü<º®Ä�� ¾[¿,ÊJ¹®ø®¾�Á�¾®Ü���ÉaÁ�¼J¹�ÇwÜ�ö�¾[Ã�ÁÅÇsÄ º[È�Çs¾®Ü��Bò7?�öÂú^g^¾®Ä<TRV-ûDC®�Ð��®«�fhgad��xyli�e�ã�� X:��dlgant�l³:e�p���ªJm�gIn>i��lfhga�+»Yfhgao>yl�^�lä{�ldlrId^�[­[ylm`yliV�PTMU]õl´MT^�

�f�����<ý*����z-í%��î���î ¯+[M[^°l���uÙ®á�º®Ü<Â�¼aÙDö�¾®Ã�ÁÅÇwÄ ¼�¿1F�¼�¹�Ǭ��Ü-º®Ü<ÙdðtÃ�ÁÅÄ ¼JÃ�¼�Ü<È�º[È�Çs¾®Ü<�)c�dlga�lyli@ä{ylv�qwk,yli�iÞ:v��`o>n>pa��fhgap��Ūbyli¸Ø<gayli`jbn>pIjhd^����ylo>n>qsdlgIi�n>y^�9?ü��"+�ë:M<í7y�î�ü<ý<þ'H^ë:M*,��-ýLÿ]�-ý<ë:+�í���î ¯+[M[M[^��ã�pIn>i��lo>fQn>i[rIfhgIk,fhe�n>ylrIf{o>yli`�lv�yl�lf{rI�`ylr�pIv�m�m�dlgartp�k0v`o>rIn>m�o>fn>k,m�o>fhk,fhi[rIylrtn>dli�p�dlqYfh�[jhfbm`rIn>dli�p��V��fhj��`i�n>jhylo�m�ylm�fbg��lfhr2rtd,��f{m�v��`o>n>pa��fheV�9?ë�ê�ê]M<í!ÿ!î \ î ¯+[M[l¥^�Dã·��n>�l���¤m�fhgaqwdlgak�yli�jhf��lylga�`yl�lf{jbdlo>o>fhjhrtdlg�qwdlg�ªJrtyli�e�ylgIe¸c�«��^��fbja��i�n>jhyloDk,fhk,dlgIyli��e�v�k±�®ã£���{�-¢Bfho>oÅ«�yl��dlgaylrtdlgan>fhpl�Fc�v`gagayJ�xS�n>o>ot�l¬�­Å�[­®yli[v�ylga�F�9���O ü�+�í<X�î�ÿ!î ¯+[MUl¨^��«�n>ylgl�®yli¸ã�o>�ldlo>��o>n>¶lfQjhdlk,m�n>o>fhg2qwdlg�paj��`fbk�f`��ª�� ¢��®rI��fhpIn>pl�FcL���-²�fbm`r��Fdlq2��dlk,m�v`rIfhgªJjhn>fhi�jhf�yli`e¸³:o>fhjhrtgan>jhyloD³£i��ln>i�fhfhgan>i��^�9�M8þ<ë:8�í%��î<X\î!ü<ý<þ�HQü��<ì�ì íZ�Dî I î ¯+[MUl¦^��³:o>n>k,n>i`ylrIn>dli�ylo>�ldlgIn>rI��k�p�qsdlg,e`ylrIy���d�~ yli�ylo>�[pan>pl�^�:ö�ö�¾[Ã�ÁÅÚ`ȤÇwÜ���ú<Ú`¿]áJ¼�Él¹jT:Q®Û�¥±ztªJfhm�rtfbk���fhgl}t�PT^°l°jõl¥^¯a¦^�

���<ü��-í* :î ¯+[M[l¨^�Y��dlk,m`n>o>n>i��+ªJrtyli�e�ylgae�c�«¸qsdlg£fb©�jbn>fhi[r:fh�[fbjhv�rtn>dlixdli�k,d[e�fhgai,k,ylja��n>i�fhpl��Þ:��� ²x��rI�`fbpIn>pl�Þ:gIn>i�jhfbrtdli�Q2i�n>�lfhgapIn>r��`�®Þ:gIn>i�jhfbrtdliV�F¬2­Å����fhj���\2fhm�dlgar0��ªJ�¤�h\��¤¨^°a´l�V[l¨^����<ü��-í/ Yî ¯+[M[^°l��ØVo>fh�Fn>�`o>f�gafhm�gIfhpafhiFrtylrtn>dli�yli�ylo>�[pan>p��N��iUñ:¿À¾bÂ�(T:BDBû �Âö��ú�ð[=�ñ�ò7�S? ðIÜ<Ȥ¼J¿]Ü<º®È¤Çs¾®Ü<º®Äö�¾[Ü�»a¼�¿À¼JÜ<Â�¼U¾®Üf$^ÚFÜ<Â�ȤÇw¾®Ü<º®Ä@ñ:¿À¾\��¿Àº®Ã�Ã�ÇwÜ��e{ ð3ö($wñZ� BûR~®��ã0��c Þ:gIfbpIpl�l¬�fh~�OYdlga¶D��Ul´]õM[MU^�

���<ü��-ín Yî�ü<ý8þ�éBê�ê�ë�ì�íwé�î1ïRî ¯+[M[l¨^��ªJm`yljbfh�¤fh©,jhn>fhi[r�jho>dlpIv�gafQgIfhm�gafhpafhi[rIylrtn>dli�p��!��i�TDBDB-V��:ö� ö�¾[Ü�»a¼�¿]½¼�Ü<Â�¼0¾®Ü`ò�Çw¹sÁ�º®Ü<Ù�$�Ú`Ü<ÂJȤÇw¾[Ü<º®Ä@ñ£¿À¾$�J¿tº®Ã0Ã�ÇwÜ�����ã0��c Þ:gIfbpIpl�®¬�fh~YOYdlga¶D��¯a´lµ]õ^¯a¦^¯l����<ü��-í@ :î�ü<ý<þDéBê�ê�ë�ì�í�é�î�ïRî ¯+[M[l´^��ã r��[m�fb����ylpafhe@jbdlk�m�n>o>fhg�qsdlg±ªbrIyli�e`ylgae@c�«��g��izñ£¿À¾JÂ;Y�:ö�ú�ð[=�ñ�ò7�S?m� Bô�ö�¾®Ü�»RV¾®ÜLñ:¿À¾\���ò�º[Ü��;�FQ¼�¹�Ǭ��Ü�º®Ü<ÙqðtÃ�ÁÅÄ ¼�Ã�¼JÜ<Ȥº®È¤Çw¾[Ü<�lã0��c Þ£gafhpap���¬�fh~FOYdlga¶D�ůl¯a¦]õ¯+TM[^�

������w8ë:8�+�íncHî ¯+[M[^¯l�:��dli[rtgadlo>�¤��dJ~)yli�ylo>�[pan>pBdlqÅ��n>�l��fhga��dlgae�fhguo>yli��lv`yl�lfbp��ÅÞ:��� ²x��rI��fhpIn>pl�^��ylgIi�fh�ln>f�c�fho>o>dliQ�i�n>�D�>�lÞ:n>rtrIpI��v�ga�l���FÞVfbi`i�pa�[o>��yli�n>y^����c/Q��h��ªJ�>[^¯a�h¯a¨l´^�

Page 33: Welcome | Computer Scienceflint.cs.yale.edu/flint/publications/escc.pdfb"c d c e"f gh_8ghi"ijlk ï í îYðsñFí ñFú bñ[øUï ú m bõVñ ó ù^í ñ Yn ù " 1 £ñ [ùÅûVóJñ

¤�¥@¦l§ j�e"¨�c�e"f/` c�©�j�ª�©>d6« ª�` i"c ¦ jC¬�k dP­®"«¯js¬�dPe�°�j�«Z­ § dPe ±P±

��,�ë�ë�ì�ë�í�X\îG.Âî ¯+[^°+U^��\2yl���`n>r���y¸jhdlk,m�n>o>fhg�qsdlg+ªbj���fhk,fF����fhj��V� \�fhmV�^ã����¤�h\2�¤¨^°a¨^�<cL���0�:��ylk���gan>e��lfF�c�ã����,�ë�ë�ì�ë�í�X\î�.Âî�ü8ý<þ'����+-+-�Yü<ý<í7X\î1ÿ@î ¯+[MUlµ^�D����f{e�gafhylk6dlq�y,o>n>qwfhrIn>k,fF��ã·o>yl¡h����ylgan>yl�`o>fQfh�FrtfhiFr�k,fhj���yl�i�n>pak��Q��ibñ:¿À¾bÂ�¼�¼�Ù®ÇwÜ���¹�¾�»{È+ø®¼UTDBDQDi�ò!ð3ú�ñOö�¾®Ü�»�¼J¿t¼JÜ<Â�¼��[ã���c Þ:gafhpIpl�DªbrIyli�qwdlgae��D¯a¦l¥]õ^¯l°+T^��wü�8��jü<ý<í�9�î�dNî ¯+[^°a¨^�l��fhpIrIn>i�����dJ~��lgaylm���gIfbe`v�jhn>��n>o>n>r��F��#F¾®Ú`¿]Ü<º®Ä�¾�»�ö�¾[Ã�ÁÅÚ`Ȥ¼J¿Bº[Ü<ÙNú<Él¹�È�¼�ÃZú<Â�Çw¼�Ü<Â�¼ZB®Û�¥z|²�fbjhfhk��^fhg�}I�F¥l´l´]õl¥l¦l´^�� ý�)Qü�8�í��qî]�Dî ¯+[MUl¦^���@ø®¼�FQ¼�¹aÇä�Jܸº®Ü<Ùor:á�º®Ä Ú`º®È¤Çw¾[Ü�¾�»(����Ǭ� ø�ñ£¼�¿�»a¾®¿]Ã�º®Ü<Â�¼�ú<Ã0º®ÄsÄ È¤º®Ä Êrú<Él¹�Ȥ¼�Ã0��cL���Þ:gIfbpIpl�^��ylk0��gIn>e��lfF� c�ã��ïLü<ý<þ8í��Dî ü<ý<þ���,�ë:��z-ì ë]8�í*HNî ¯+[M[l¨^�ŪJfho>fbjhrtn>�lf�yli�e�o>n>�l�[r�~ufhn>�l�FrVjho>dlpav`gafujhdli[�lfbgIpan>dliV���i\ñ£¿À¾JÂ;@óDT[¹aÈ7��Ü<½Ü<Ú`º®Ä7�:ö� ú�ð[=�ñ�ò7�S?�½5ú�ð>=%�:öU�bú<ÉlÃ�Á�u¾®Ü$ñ:¿]ÇwÜ<Â�Ç ÁÅÄ ¼J¹�¾�»Bñ:¿À¾$�J¿Àº[Ã0Ã�ÇwÜ��Hò�º®Ü���ÚFº`��¼�¹a�Fã0��c Þ:gafhpIpl�¬�fh~YOYdlga¶D�[¨l¥l´]õl¨l¨l´^�

\�fbjhfhn>�lfhe�ªJfhm�rtfhk0��fhg�¯+[M[MU^�FgIfh�Fn>pIfbe�X:jhrIdl��fhg,¯+[M[M[^�`yljhjhfhm�rtfbe�²�fbjhfhk��^fhg�¯+[M[M[


Recommended