DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Wetland restoration projects in the Danube Delta Biosphere
Reserve/Romania PAST, PRESENT, FUTURE
2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Danube River and Danube Basin 817,000 sq.km catchment basin – 8% of Europe surface
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
• Part of the Man
and Biosphere
Programme of
UNESCO since 1990
• Included in Ramsar
Convention List
since 1990
• Included in World
Heritage List since
1990
DANUBE DELTA -
BIOSPHERE RESERVE
Tulcea
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
HUMAN INDUCED CHANGES IN
DANUBE DELTA
BY
POLLUTION
AND
HABITAT
ALTERATIONS
DREDGING CHANNELS
HABITAT REDUCTIONS
BY
AND
BUILDING BARRAGES
AT KM 942 AND KM 863 FROM RIVER MOUTHS
DAMMING UPSTREAM FLOODPLAIN
AND 22% OF THE DELTA
B l a c k S e a
A
TULCEA
Pollution
LEGEND
Damming (22%)
New channels
Phosphorous: 45,000-60,000 t/year Oil: 45,000-50,000 t/year
DANUBE
Nitrogen: 300,000-400,000 t/year
(after Staras, 2000)
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DAMMING FLOODPLAIN UPSTREAM DELTA
Jiu
Olt
Arges
Ialomita
Calmatui
Siret
before 1960 1960-1965 1965-1970 after 1970
Damming period
Iron Gate II
Iron Gate I
Catch sizes in the Romanian Danube Delta and adjacent lakes
0 2000 4000 6000 8000
10000 12000 14000 16000 18000
1 9 4 8
1 9
5 0
1 9 5 2
1 9
5 4
1 9 5 6
1 9
5 8
1 9 6 0
1 9
6 1
1 9 6 4
1 9
6 6
1 9 6 8
1 9
7 0
1 9 7 2
1 9
7 4
t o n s
Cyprinus Carpio Total
Damming floodplain area of the Danube river
0
100
200
300
400
500
1949 1952 1956 1960 1962 1966 1975
x1,000 ha
(after Staras, 2000)
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013 26,000to
17,576to
16,548to
25,631to
25,340to
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DAMMING AND CHANNEL EXCAVATION
Danube
Legend
1903-1916
1952-1960> 19601941-19511930-19401880-1902
Excavation period Legend
1960-19701971-19801981-1989
Building period
Danube
(after Staras, 2000) DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Channels blocking
(after Staras, 2000)
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
CHANGES IN HYDROLOGY AND WATER CHEMISTRY
DANUBE RIVER
Water inflow (cm/s) P(PO4) (mg/l) N(NO3) (mg/l)
P(PO4) inflow tons/year
N(NO3) inflow tons/year
DELTA ECOSYSTEMS Before 1960 1971-1980 1980-1989
309 359 620 <0,01 0,06 0,07 0,4 1,5 1,5
100 700 1400
4000 17000 29300
2003-2005 700 0,05 0,6
1100
13500
(modified after Staras, 2000)
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
• Water (lacustrine) surface reduction
• Marsh or lacustrian areas changes into partial or total drained fields
DANUBE RIVER low water level has a major impact on DANUBE DELTA
CLIMATIC CHANGES AND THEIR IMPACT ON DANUBE DELTA
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Low water level impact on shoreline vegetation
• Macrophytes habitat reduction
• Bushes and reed expansion
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
• Eutrofication
• Reduction of aquatic species which consist basic food resource of birds
DANUBE RIVER low water level has a major impact on DANUBE DELTA
Migration from colonies
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
ECOLOGICAL RESTORATION MANAGEMENT OBJECTIVES
Ob.1. Protect and maintain population of species and habitats with ecological values
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Ob.2. Manage water circulation in order to improve the ecological conditions
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
THE RESTORATION PROGRAMME
• WETLAND RESTORATION - Research, design, monitoring - Civil works • HYDROLOGICAL SYSTEM
REHABILITATION -Research and design -Civil works
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
In 1994 - Babina (2,100 ha), - agricultural polder -
in 1996 - Cernovca(1,580 ha)- agricultural polder -
in 2000 - Popina(3,600 ha) - fishpond -
in 2002 - Fortuna (2,115 ha) -- agricultural polder -
in 2006 - SF. Gheorghe arm’s meanders (687 ha)
In 2008 - Holbina -Dunavat(5,630 ha)- fishponds -
Restoration Works in the Danube Delta
TOTAL: 15,712 haDANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
BABINA-CERNOVCA PILOT PROJECT
Babina(2,100 ha)
Cernovca(1,580 ha)
Research 1991 - 1994 1991 - 1996Design 1994 1996Implementation 1994 1996Monitoring 1995 - 2003 1997 - 2003
Project status
fullyimplementedreverted to
wetlandsince 1994
fullyimplementedreverted to
wetlandsince 1996
Present status
a mosaic of water types,clear to turbid water
systems, depending onthe connectivity to the
riverDANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013 DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
BEFORE FLOODING
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
2 YEARS AFTER FLOODING
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
AGRICULTURAL POLDER IN DANUBE DELTA
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Babina-Cernovca area (satellite images)
1993
1996
1993
1996
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Babina-Cernovca area (satellite images 2013)
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013 DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
40,4 ha
26,9 ha 20,4 ha
Lakes of Babina restored area
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
BIOLOGICAL FILTERING CAPACITY OF THE PALUSTRIAN AND AQUATIC VEGETATION
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
CONTACT OF CLEAN WATER FROM RESTORED AREA WITH DANUBE WATER RICH IN SEDIMENTS
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
CONTROL FISHING RESULTS IN RESTORED AREAS INDICATES THE PRESENCE OF BOTH REPRODUCERS AND YOUNG FISH
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
• S = 3,600 ha, fish ponds -Research: 1996-1999 -Implemented since 2000 -Status: permanent
wetland connected to the river
Canalul Cardon
Pop
ina
Ca
na
l
Cardon Canal
Musura
Branch
433283
8606
41
CH
ILIA A
rm
POPINA I
Dâmbei Road
Popina Br
ook
M o n k
O p e n in g
EC 22
EC 21
POPINA PROJECT
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
FORTUNA PROJECT
Fortuna Lake
Danube
S = 2,115 ha -Former polder for forestry -Research: 2000-2002 -Present status: implemented
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
HOLBINA-DUNAVAT PROJECT
S = 5,630 ha, former fish farms Research: 1993-1996 Result: Restoration strategy Implementation status:
investment funds available since 2003
Evolution: water system reverted from turbid plankton - dominated state to clear macrophytes - dominated one
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
3 islands - created as a result of rectification of Danube arm - were proposed to be connected to river
S= 687 ha
Hydrological connectivity restoration
MEANDERS PROJECT
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
50-100 EURO/HA/YEAR with low costs instead subsidies
FISH: 34 KG/HA/YEAR REED: 1-2 TONES/HA/YEAR PASTURE: 0,5 UVM/HA/YEAR
ECONOMICAL RESULTS
NUTRIENT REMOVAL - 15 KG PHOSPHORUS/HA/YEAR
- 335 KG NITROGEN/HA/YEAR
SEDIMENT RETENTION - 11 TONES/HA/YEAR
HABITAT FOR BIRDS AND FISHES AESTHETIC VALUES WATER STORAGE
ECOLOGICAL VALUES
WETLAND REHABILITATION
UNSUSTAINABLE / ABANDONED POLDERS
BENEFITS OF ECOLOGICAL RESTORATION BABINA&CERNOVCA PILOT PROJECTS - S=3,600HA
FILTERING
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
ECONOMICAL INDICATOR: MAXIMUM COST/BENEFIT RATIO BABINA&CERNOVCA PILOT PROJECTS - S=3,600HA
COSTS: RESEARCH, DESIGN & IMPLEMENTATION: 100,000 EURO
BENEFITS: FISH YIELD: 3,600HA x 34KG x 0.5EURO/KG = 60,000EURO/YEAR REED HARVEST: 3,600HA x 1T/HA x 16EURO/T = 60,000EURO/YEAR TOURISM: 10TURISTS x 100DAYS/YEAR x 10EURO/DAY = 10,000EURO/YEAR CATTLE: 100HA x 0.5UVM/HA x 100KG x 2EURO/KG = 10,000EURO/YEAR TOTAL VALUE : 140,000 EURO/YEAR at low labour costs
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
& DANUBE DELTA BIOSPHERE RESERVE AUTHORITY
AWARDS
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Objectives: 1. Reduce nutrients and sediments inflow to the delta by: -close or semi-close the artificial North-
South oriented canals
-reduce section of the (semi-)natural
West-East channels
2. Improve water circulation inside the delta and create refuge for fish at lower water level by: silt removal from natural canals
REHABILITATION OF HYDROLOGICAL SYSTEM
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Legend
Channels Blocking 8 channels Un-silting works L=329.5 km
Calibrated Channels 5 sections
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
CONSTRAINTS
LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
POLITICAL DECISION PUBLIC AWARENESS
GAPS IN KNOWLEDGEIRREVERSIBLE
MAN MADE CHANGES
WATER QUALITY
WETLAND RESTORATION
STAKEHOLDERS PARTICIPATION
FUNCTIONAL
INTEGRITY
(after Staras, 2000)
ECONOMIC INTEREST
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013 (after Staras, 2000)
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
ECOLOGICAL RESTORATION PROGRAMME 2005 – 2015
- part of the Master Plan for sustainable development of the Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve -
Foto: Erika Schneider WWF Germany
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
ECOLOGICAL RESTORATION PROGRAMME
2005 – 2015 Stage I - 2005 - 2008
1 2
4
3
ţ
Total S = 5,876 ha
Total S = 13,740 ha Civil works 1994 - 2004 Restored areas
1. A.A. Babina S= 2.100ha
2.A.A. Cernovca S= 1.580ha
3.A.A. Fortuna S= 2.115ha
4.A.P. Popina S= 3.600ha
Total S= 9.395ha
Polder
Fish Pond
1 2
4
3
ţ
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1.Carasuhat S= 2,863 ha 2. Murighiol-Dunavăţ S= 2,538 ha 3. Sulina S= 475 ha 4. Chilia I + II S= 2,950 ha 5. Murighiol S= 2,260 ha 6. Ceamurlia I S= 2,900 ha 7. Holbina-Dunavaţ S= 5,630 ha
Total Stage I : S= 19,616 ha
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
ECOLOGICAL RESTORATION PROGRAMME
2005 – 2015
Stage II – 2009 - 2015
Restored areas
1. A.P. Babina S= 2.100ha
2.A.P. Cernovca S= 1.580ha
3.A.P. Fortuna S= 2.115ha
4.F.P. Popina S= 3.600ha
Total S= 9.395ha
Task 1 Desiltation works L = 70 km Task 2 Wetland restoration
Polder
Fish Pond
Total S = 32,512 ha
Total S = 13,570 ha
1 2
4
3
ţ
PARDINA S=27.032 ha
SIREASA S=5.480 ha
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
Support from NATURE
SIREASA 2010
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
WETLANDS ECOLOGICAL
RESTORATION PROJECTS
TODAY
Zaghen 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
WETLANDS ECOLOGICAL
RESTORATION PROJECTS
TODAY
Carasuhat 2013
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
WETLANDS ECOLOGICAL
RESTORATION PROJECTS:
FUTURE?
DANUBE ENVIRONMENT FORUM, TULCEA, ROMANIA, JUNE 27-29, 2013
THANK YOU