Date post: | 27-Mar-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | alexa-goodwin |
View: | 213 times |
Download: | 0 times |
What are they thinking?!
Mapping the Mindset of the Retirement Consumer—Exploring the Interconnected Emotional Pathways that Affect Investing
C11-0516-023R (05/11)
About the Presenter
ING 2
Must obtain Compliance approval of text to use this slide; alternately, simply delete this slideMust obtain Compliance approval of text to use this slide; alternately, simply delete this slide
Your Name
ING 3
MENU SLIDE
• MENU SLIDE
The Retirement Environment
The Retirement Environment
Psychology, Logic, Life & Investing
Psychology, Logic, Life & Investing
Using Behavioral Finance to Change Behavior
Using Behavioral Finance to Change Behavior
What’s it all mean?What’s it all mean?
Open ForumOpen Forum
I. II. III. IV. V.
THE RETIREMENT ENVIRONMENT
ING 4
SECTION I
How we think people think
MYTH:•Planning is rational
•Investment decisions are based in fact
ING 5
Planning and investment decisions are driven by emotions.
Planning and investment decisions are driven by emotions.
FACT:
The Retirement Environment
ING 6
17% decline in general public covered by a Pension Plan
Pensions have been cut.Pensions have been cut.
1979 to 1998:
12% increase in employees
offered DC Plan
ING 7
The Retirement Environment (cont.)
??WHY?
Personal savings plans grow•Defined Contribution (DC) Plans
•IRAs
ING 8
The Retirement Environment (cont.)
• Economic Crisis
• Headlines and Scrutiny
• Legislator Attention
• “New Normal”
??WHY?
ING 9
Behavioral Finance
Emotion and inclinations drive actions.
BEHAVIORAL
FINANCE
PSYCHOLOGY, LOGIC, LIFE & INVESTING
ING 10
SECTION II
ING 11
Hyperbolic Discounting
A show of hands…
ING 12
Hyperbolic Discounting (cont)
Get something now…
… at the expense having something else
in the future.
Procrastination.Procrastination.
RESULT:
ING 13
Procrastination
Common excuses to put off saving for retirement:• When I get a raise
• Retirement is too far away
• A few weeks or days, or even a year won’t make much difference
• I’ll catch up later
• I’ll sign up when I have time
• I can’t afford it right now
• I’m too busy
ING 14
Price of Procrastination
This chart is hypothetical and not intended to reflect the performance of any particular investment. It reflects the growth of an investment of $60 per month for 40 years, at 6% average annual return. If the investment were made in a tax-deferred vehicle such as an employer’s 401(k), 403(b) or 457 plan taxes would be due upon withdrawal at the investor’s current tax rate.
The $115,000 Coffee HabitHypothetical Tax-Deferred Growth
ING 15
Loss Aversion
The fear of losing:• Family
• Friends
• Health
• Home
• Physical attributes
• Status
• Possessions
• Freedom
ING 16
The fear of poverty
ING 17
Hierarchy of Fears
Source: “Imagine That” Affective Communications Study, co-sponsored by ING, not yet released. Data is based on a 2008 online Money Magazine survey.
I cannot afford to live in my house and must sell it to live somewhere less expensive
I cannot afford living expenses and need to ask my children for financial support
I cannot afford to pay for a very expensive medical procedure for myself or my spouse
I cannot afford living expenses and need to ask my children for financial support
49%
24%
17%
10%
ING 18
Familiarity Bias
ING 19
Familiarity Bias (cont)
• Inferior asset allocation
• Too much allocation to one or a few stocks
• Preferences for local stocks or industries
• Preferences for cultural proximity
• Preferences for professional proximity (i.e., a doctor investing in medical stocks)*
Source: “Mind on my Money,”
ING 20
Information and Change Overload
“The amount of information a human being consumed in the 18th century in his whole life –
is the same as a week of information in a regular newspaper.”
“The amount of information a human being consumed in the 18th century in his whole life –
is the same as a week of information in a regular newspaper.”
“Evolution and Information Overload,” wordpress.com, Design / Marketing / Philosophy, March 27, 2010
ING 21
Too Much Information
ING 22
Too Much Information (cont)
Another show of hands…
ING 23
Choice and Control
“too much choice
(can leave us)
bewildered and
depressed.”
ING 24
Lack of Control
“WORK STRESS AND HEALTH: the Whitehall II Study” Public and Commercial Services Union on behalf of the Council of Civil Service Unions / Cabinet Office, © 2004. Source of data: Bosma, H., Peter, R. Siegrist, J. and Marmot, M.G. (1998). Two alternative job stress models and the risk of coronary heart disease. Am. J. Publ. Hlth. 1998;88: 68-74.
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
High Job Control Intermediate Job Control
Low Job Control
Likelihood of Coronary Heart Disease
ING 25
Choice and Control offered by Retirement Plans
* “The Hearts and Minds of Retirement Investors,” ING North America Insurance Corporation, ©2009, Top-box score of “Very Important”
Relative Importance of Various Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plan Features*
ING 26
Self Comparison
{ AVERAGE }
DriverDriver
ING 27
Self-Comparison (cont)
DriverDriver
DriverDriver
DriverDriver
DriverDriverDriverDriver
DriverDriver
DriverDriver
AwareAware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
DriverDriver
ING 28
Self-Comparison (cont)
{ AVERAGE }DriverDriver
DriverDriver
DriverDriver
DriverDriver
DriverDriver
DriverDriver
DriverDriver
AwareAware
Aware
Aware
AwareAware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
Aware
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
SkillsSkills
ING 29
Optimism Bias
Most – if not all – individuals want to define themselves in favorable terms:
• People are more alike than they think
• What people believe about themselves, or what they would like to believe, doesn’t vary much from person to person
• Each person is convinced that he or she is unique
ING 30
Social Comparison
• 80% of drivers think they are above average drivers
• 94% of professors believe their work is above average
• 99% of students believe they’re above average in getting along with others
• Most Americans believe they’ll earn above average income in the future
• The majority of CEOs think their companies will thrive more than their average industry competitors
USING BEHAVIORAL FINANCE TOCHANGE BEHAVIOR
ING 31
SECTION III
ING 32
Using Behavioral Finance to Change Behavior
How can this
knowledge of human bias, behavior and impulses
help us to encourage consumers to take action to build a
more secure retirement for themselves?
ING 33
Automatic DC plan features
Auto enroll and contribution increases•Consumer retains control; can opt out
•Avoid conscious decision to sacrifice
•Reduces information overload
•Eliminates procrastination and inertia
•Provides immediate gain
ING 34
Information Design / Choice Architecture
• Design
• Information Layering
• Plain English
• Choice presentation
Helping investors navigate information, options and decisions
ING 35
Asset-allocated investment options
• Managed Accounts
• Target Date Funds
• Asset Allocation funds
Removes the burdens of information and choice overload
ING 36
Tools and engagement devices
• Risk assessment tools
• Calculators
• Online education and account access
Enable positive saving action
ING 37
Breakthrough
Using peer comparison to improve retirement behavior.Using peer comparison to
improve retirement behavior.
Breakthrough:
“Test” of Concept
ING 38
Resulting behavior - take action!
ING 39
Social Media
INGCompareMe.com
ING 40
The Personal Approach
Source: “Working with an Advisor: Improved Retirement Savings, Financial Knowledge and Retirement Confidence!” ING North America Insurance Corporation, © 2010
Have you spent time working with a financial advisor to discuss your investments or plan your financial future?*
ING 41
The Personal Approach (cont)
Source: “Working with an Advisor: Improved Retirement Savings, Financial Knowledge and Retirement Confidence!” ING North America Insurance Corporation, © 2010
People who spend time with an advisor have more saved for retirement
Spent time with advisor?Spent time with advisor?
NoYes, but onlyonce or twice
Yes, some timeYes, a lot
of time
3x
1.5x
2x
ING 42
The Personal Approach (cont)
Source: “Working with an Advisor: Improved Retirement Savings, Financial Knowledge and Retirement Confidence!” ING North America Insurance Corporation, © 2010
People who spend time with an advisor are more likely to be moderate investors *
People who spend less time with a financial advisor are more likely to be conservative investors
People who spend more time with a financial advisor are more likely to be moderate investors
There is little difference in aggressive investors
ING 43
The Personal Approach (cont)
Source: “Working with an Advisor: Improved Retirement Savings, Financial Knowledge and Retirement Confidence!” ING North America Insurance Corporation, © 2010
Increased time with an advisor increases financial knowledge and retirement confidence*
Investment Knowledge Compared to Peers
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
No time Once or twice Some time A lot of time
Less than
Same as
More than
ING 44
The Personal Approach (cont)
Source: “Working with an Advisor: Improved Retirement Savings, Financial Knowledge and Retirement Confidence!” ING North America Insurance Corporation, © 2010
Those with an advisor feel confident about retirement
No
34%
Yes, a lotof time
62%
Yes, but onlyonce or twice
39%
Yes, some time
50%
Confident About Enjoying Retirement Those who answered “very confident” or “extremely confident”
WHAT’S IT ALL MEAN?
ING 45
SECTION IV
ING 46
This is Just the Beginning
Sponsors have a desire to benchmark plans against plans of other similar companies •Is participation higher or lower?
•Do they offer loans?
•Automatic enrollment?
•Investment options, diversification?
•Managed account?
•Matches? How much?
ING 47
Using peer comparison to improve retirement
We want to know what other people are doing.
ING 48
More Information
INGRetirementResearch.com INGCompareMe.com
OPEN FORUM
ING 49
SECTION V
ING 50
Open Forum
Important Information
Nothing contained herein should be construed as (i) an offer to sell or solicitation of an offer to buy any security or (ii) a recommendation as to the advisability of investing in, purchasing or selling any security. Any opinions expressed herein reflect our judgment and are subject to change. Certain of the statements contained herein are statements of future expectations and other forward-looking statements that are based on management's current views and assumptions and involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results, performance or events to differ materially from those expressed or implied in such statements. Actual results, performance or events may differ materially from those in such statements due to, without limitation, (1) general economic conditions, (2) performance of financial markets, (3) interest rate levels, (4) increasing levels of loan defaults (5) changes in laws and regulations and (6) changes in the policies of governments and/or regulatory authorities.
The opinions, views and information expressed in this presentation are subject to change without notice based on market conditions and other factors. The information provided is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.
Products and services are offered through ING family of companies. Please log on to http://ing.us for information regarding other products and services offered through ING family of companies. Not all products are available in all states. © 2010 ING North America Insurance Corporation
ING 51