+ All Categories
Home > Documents > WHAT DETERMINES POLIOMYELITIS EPIDEMICS?

WHAT DETERMINES POLIOMYELITIS EPIDEMICS?

Date post: 05-Jan-2017
Category:
Upload: hoangdien
View: 215 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
2
216 as it does after intravenous and intramuscular injection, but the peak level was less than 10% of that attained by parenteral -injection; only 16%’ of the penicillin given was recovered in the urine, whereas the recovery after intravenous or intramuscular injection was never less than 37%, and usually much more. The same workers observed in another in- vestigation ’17 in which excretion was slowed by dio- drast, and also in two patients with renal failure,15 that less penicillin was recovered from the urine when excretion was delayed, suggesting that there was slow destruction in the body. Similar observations were made in the dog by BBYBR et al 18 RAMMELKAMP and KEEPER also confirmed 15 that after rectal administra- tion a bacteriostatic level was not reached in the blood-serum. Recently another group of workers in the United States" have administered penicillin in large doses (100,000 units) to " normal " subjects by mouth, and demonstrated its ’excretion in the urine for some hours; from 8% to 33% was recovered. The simultaneous administration of sodium bicarbonate reduced the amount recovered, instead of increasing it as had been expected; but it is to be noted that penicillin is even more rapidly inactivated by alkali than by acid so that a check on the purity of the bicarbonate is highly desirable. Unfortunately this work is incomplete, since no study was made of the acidity of the gastric juice or of the penicillin levels reached in the blood-serum. Now on another page LITTLE and LUMB produce more data. Some of their findings, such as the high proportion of the drug excreted in the urine after oral administration, conflict with previous reports. Others, such as the use of egg albumin as a vehicle for oral administration, are new, and their scientific basis has yet to be elucidated. In view of the promise of easier and more comfortable therapy which these investigations hold out, they deserve repetition and expansion, using the most refined methods of assay available. But as long as the supply of penicillin falls far short of potential demand, as it does today, no-one will wish to intro- duce a new method of use without complete assurance that it is economical as well as effective. A MEDICAL PRINCIPAL IT is perhaps one sign of the Oxford medical renais- sance of the last twenty years that Somerville College should have broken with precedent by appointing a woman doctor to be its next principal. Dr. Janet Vaughan’s qualities and experience abundantly justify the innovation. She has a scholastic and literary back- ground as the daughter of the late William Vaughan, headmaster of Wellington and Rugby, and- grand- daughter of John Addington Symonds ; her investiga- tions at University College Hospital and the British Postgraduate Medical School brought her into the first rank of haematologists ; during the war she has adminis- tered a large blood-supply depot ; she is the first woman counsellor of the Royal College of Physicians, and serves on its committee on social and preventive medicine ; she is one of the seven trustees of the Numeld Founda- tion ; and her other public work includes membership of the Goodenough Committee, the Royal Commission on Equal Pay, and the small body of experts who have recently been in India advising the Bhore Committee about medical education. Forty-five years of age, she married in 1930 Mr. David Gourla,y, and they have two daughters. 17. Rammelkamp, C. H., Bradley, S. E. Ibid, 1943, 53, 30. 18. Beyer, K. H., et al. Science, 1944, 100, 107. 19. Free, A. H., Leonards, J. R., McCullagh, D. R., Biro, B. E. Ibid, 1944, 100, 431. Annotations DRUGS FOR MALARIA WRITING under this title on Nov. 18 last we remarked that " although malaria has always been of immense importance to the British Empire, we owe our escape from a dangerous position to the enterprise of the German chemical industry supplemented by American energy in applying the product to military purposes." All will agree that the Allies are indebted to,the German workers who invented mepacrine (’Atebrin’) before the main quinine-producing areas were taken by the Japanese ; but it has been pointed out that our comment does less than justice to the precautions taken by the British Government to build up a reserve stock of quinine, or to the success achieved by British manu- facturers in producing mepacrine. Since the war of 1914-18, when quinine supplies were secured only by delicate negotiation, the possibility of a shortage in war-time has, we are informed, been fully appreciated! by the authorities in this country. In 1938 arrange. ments were made to ensure that as much quinine as possible was held throughout the Empire: a considerable national reserve was purchased, and in addition at least two years’ supply was obtained and held by most of the Dominions and Colonies. The manufacture of synthetic antimalarials is a complex process, and mepacrine was not made completely in the United Kingdom on any large scale till 1941, when intermediate substances were no longer obtainable from France. Thenceforward, how- ever, progress was rapid. It was in, March, 1942, that the Japanese overran Java, which provided over 90% of the world’s supply of quinine, and by that time mepacrine production here was already considerable. Officers of the Ministry of Supply at once visited the USA to arrange a joint programme for further production, and this was fulfilled as successfully here as in America. In 1943 the output was 40 tons, and this amount was more than trebled in 1944, when at least 150 tons was produced. Each ton provides about 10 million tablets, and in 1943 over 395 million tablets made by three British firms were allocated to the Services, Dominions, Colonies, -and certain Allied and neutral countries. The 1944 pro- duction will satisfy demands approaching 1500 million tablets, and it is already evident that such demands will be exceeded and met in 1945. WHAT DETERMINES POLIOMYELITIS EPIDEMICS? LABORATORY mice sometimes contract a virus disease, often called Theiler’s disease after its discoverer. This resembles poliomyelitis in man so closely that many have hoped to learn more of the human disease by study of its murine counterpart. A first exciting step was the discovery that Theiler’s virus is to be found in the faeces, and (less abundantly) in the intestinal walls, of almost every young mouse. Nevertheless, naturally’ occurring paralysis was extremely rare. This fitted in with the current tendency of students of human polio- myelitis to pay more attention to the intestine and less to the nose as a portal of entry. Poliomyelitis virus was recovered from stools more readily than from throat washings ; it was found in sewage ; it turned up in flies caught in the wild state. Theiler’s virus is often of low neurotropic tendency ; so suggestions were made that human poliomyelitis virus was, like it, ubiquitous, but not always sufficiently strongly neurotropic to be demonstrable by inoculation into monkeys. Why should a ubiquitous denizen of the intestines reveal its presence by causing epidemics of nervous disease ? Sven Gard 1 of Uppsala has made some obser- vations on the mouse disease which may afrord a clue. In his stock of mice, producing 6000 animals a year, Theiler’s virus was regularly present in the .stools of 1. Gard, S. Yale J. Biol. Med. 1944, 16, 467.
Transcript
Page 1: WHAT DETERMINES POLIOMYELITIS EPIDEMICS?

216

as it does after intravenous and intramuscularinjection, but the peak level was less than 10% of thatattained by parenteral -injection; only 16%’ of thepenicillin given was recovered in the urine, whereasthe recovery after intravenous or intramuscularinjection was never less than 37%, and usually muchmore. The same workers observed in another in-

vestigation ’17 in which excretion was slowed by dio-drast, and also in two patients with renal failure,15that less penicillin was recovered from the urine whenexcretion was delayed, suggesting that there was slowdestruction in the body. Similar observations weremade in the dog by BBYBR et al 18 RAMMELKAMP andKEEPER also confirmed 15 that after rectal administra-tion a bacteriostatic level was not reached in theblood-serum.Recently another group of workers in the United

States" have administered penicillin in large doses(100,000 units) to

" normal " subjects by mouth, anddemonstrated its ’excretion in the urine for somehours; from 8% to 33% was recovered. Thesimultaneous administration of sodium bicarbonatereduced the amount recovered, instead of increasingit as had been expected; but it is to be noted thatpenicillin is even more rapidly inactivated by alkalithan by acid so that a check on the purity of thebicarbonate is highly desirable. Unfortunately thiswork is incomplete, since no study was made of theacidity of the gastric juice or of the penicillin levelsreached in the blood-serum. Now on another pageLITTLE and LUMB produce more data. Some of their

findings, such as the high proportion of the drugexcreted in the urine after oral administration, conflictwith previous reports. Others, such as the use of eggalbumin as a vehicle for oral administration, are new,and their scientific basis has yet to be elucidated.In view of the promise of easier and more comfortabletherapy which these investigations hold out, theydeserve repetition and expansion, using the mostrefined methods of assay available. But as long asthe supply of penicillin falls far short of potentialdemand, as it does today, no-one will wish to intro-duce a new method of use without complete assurancethat it is economical as well as effective.

A MEDICAL PRINCIPALIT is perhaps one sign of the Oxford medical renais-

sance of the last twenty years that Somerville Collegeshould have broken with precedent by appointinga woman doctor to be its next principal. Dr. JanetVaughan’s qualities and experience abundantly justifythe innovation. She has a scholastic and literary back-ground as the daughter of the late William Vaughan,headmaster of Wellington and Rugby, and- grand-daughter of John Addington Symonds ; her investiga-tions at University College Hospital and the BritishPostgraduate Medical School brought her into the firstrank of haematologists ; during the war she has adminis-tered a large blood-supply depot ; she is the first womancounsellor of the Royal College of Physicians, and serveson its committee on social and preventive medicine ;she is one of the seven trustees of the Numeld Founda-tion ; and her other public work includes membershipof the Goodenough Committee, the Royal Commissionon Equal Pay, and the small body of experts who haverecently been in India advising the Bhore Committeeabout medical education. Forty-five years of age, shemarried in 1930 Mr. David Gourla,y, and they have twodaughters.17. Rammelkamp, C. H., Bradley, S. E. Ibid, 1943, 53, 30.18. Beyer, K. H., et al. Science, 1944, 100, 107.19. Free, A. H., Leonards, J. R., McCullagh, D. R., Biro, B. E.

Ibid, 1944, 100, 431.

Annotations

DRUGS FOR MALARIA

WRITING under this title on Nov. 18 last we remarkedthat " although malaria has always been of immenseimportance to the British Empire, we owe our escapefrom a dangerous position to the enterprise of the

German chemical industry supplemented by Americanenergy in applying the product to military purposes."All will agree that the Allies are indebted to,the Germanworkers who invented mepacrine (’Atebrin’) beforethe main quinine-producing areas were taken by theJapanese ; but it has been pointed out that our commentdoes less than justice to the precautions taken by theBritish Government to build up a reserve stock ofquinine, or to the success achieved by British manu-facturers in producing mepacrine. Since the war of1914-18, when quinine supplies were secured only bydelicate negotiation, the possibility of a shortage inwar-time has, we are informed, been fully appreciated!by the authorities in this country. In 1938 arrange.ments were made to ensure that as much quinine aspossible was held throughout the Empire: a considerablenational reserve was purchased, and in addition at leasttwo years’ supply was obtained and held by most of theDominions and Colonies. The manufacture of syntheticantimalarials is a complex process, and mepacrine wasnot made completely in the United Kingdom on anylarge scale till 1941, when intermediate substances wereno longer obtainable from France. Thenceforward, how-ever, progress was rapid. It was in, March, 1942, that theJapanese overran Java, which provided over 90% ofthe world’s supply of quinine, and by that time mepacrineproduction here was already considerable. Officers ofthe Ministry of Supply at once visited the USA to arrangea joint programme for further production, and this wasfulfilled as successfully here as in America. In 1943 theoutput was 40 tons, and this amount was more thantrebled in 1944, when at least 150 tons was produced.Each ton provides about 10 million tablets, and in 1943over 395 million tablets made by three British firms wereallocated to the Services, Dominions, Colonies, -andcertain Allied and neutral countries. The 1944 pro-duction will satisfy demands approaching 1500 milliontablets, and it is already evident that such demands willbe exceeded and met in 1945.

WHAT DETERMINES POLIOMYELITIS EPIDEMICS?

LABORATORY mice sometimes contract a virus disease,often called Theiler’s disease after its discoverer. Thisresembles poliomyelitis in man so closely that many havehoped to learn more of the human disease by study of itsmurine counterpart. A first exciting step was the

discovery that Theiler’s virus is to be found in thefaeces, and (less abundantly) in the intestinal walls, ofalmost every young mouse. Nevertheless, naturally’occurring paralysis was extremely rare. This fitted inwith the current tendency of students of human polio-myelitis to pay more attention to the intestine and lessto the nose as a portal of entry. Poliomyelitis virus wasrecovered from stools more readily than from throatwashings ; it was found in sewage ; it turned up in flies

caught in the wild state. Theiler’s virus is often of low

neurotropic tendency ; so suggestions were made thathuman poliomyelitis virus was, like it, ubiquitous, butnot always sufficiently strongly neurotropic to bedemonstrable by inoculation into monkeys.Why should a ubiquitous denizen of the intestines

reveal its presence by causing epidemics of nervousdisease ? Sven Gard 1 of Uppsala has made some obser-vations on the mouse disease which may afrord a clue.In his stock of mice, producing 6000 animals a year,Theiler’s virus was regularly present in the .stools of

1. Gard, S. Yale J. Biol. Med. 1944, 16, 467.

Page 2: WHAT DETERMINES POLIOMYELITIS EPIDEMICS?

217

young mice, but paralysis appeared only sporadically-it. 2 animals during more than three years. There were’also; however, two "minor outbreaks," involving 4 and5 cases. First, in July, 1941, there was an outbreak ofinfection by Salmonella enteritidis (Gaertner’s -bacillus).While this was at its height in the two following months,4 cases of paralysis occurred and histological studyshowed the typical picture of Theiler’s disease. Thevirus was recovered from the central nervous systemand lymph-nodes of one mouse, but difficulty in obtainingmice of a clean stock prevented exhaustive studies.The second " minor outbreak " also coincided with an

epizootic in young mice which was characterised byprofuse diarrhoea. Necrotic spots in the livers of affectedanimals, showed thread-like organisms which could notbe cultivated, but were fdentified as the !3acilluff pili-formis of Tyzzer. A batch of 100 mice affected with thedisease was set aside for study, and after three weeks allbut 16 had died. Of these survivors, 5 had flaccidparalysis of the hind legs. Strains-of Theiler’s virus wererecovered from the central nervous system and intestinallymph-nodes, but could not be continuously propagatedby intracerebral inoculations.

In these observations Gard sees a possible clue to theepidemiology of poliomyelitis in man. May not anintestinal bacterial invasion open up the way for ourubiquitous virus to reach the lymph-nodes, where it isat least one stage on the road to the central nervous-system. ’May not - the minor illnesses’ associated with-poliomyelitis epidemics be, after all, not abortive casesof the disease, but rather instances of an associatedinfection which, in the unlucky, opens the way to anattack by the virus A biphasic or

"

dromedary "

type of fever curve is said to occur in 60% of cases insome epidemics. (To be zoologically correct we shouldcall it a Bactrian-camel curve.) May not the first wavebe due, not to a systemic invasion with poliomyelitisvirus, but to the associated infection ? May not theseasonal incidence of poliomyelitis have more to do withthe spread of intestinal infections than of the virus

itself These suggestions may prove right or wrong :they at least open up an interesting line of thought.We are accustomed-to the idea that virus infections

pave the way for secondary bacterial invaders. Thenotion that bacteria may pave the way for viruses isnot new, for we know of herpes simplex activated bypneumococcal and other infections, and we may yetlearn that there is a rheumatic-fever virus activated bystreptococci. But the way of the epidemiologist ishard if in seeking the cause of epidemics of disease

immediately due to organism A he has to look for factorsfavouring the spread of organism B.

DELAYED AMERICAN JOURNALS

THE irregularity and delay in the arrival of medicaland scientific journals from America are still almost asbad as in the worst’days of the battle of the Atlantic.The journals, it is true, do arrive in due course-wholeissues are no longer irrecoverably torpedoed or pagesobliterated by a too-zealous censor, misfortunes whichwere cheerfully borne in 1941-but they lose much oftheir interest from being two months or so out of date.Some allowance must no doubt be made for the condi-tions of publication in the United States, where thoughpaper is plentiful printing may be held up by prioritieswhich do not extend to scientific publications. Thus amonthly journal may appear long after its nominaldate, and its final arrival here be correspondingly late.But this cannot apply to such a regular and importantweekly as the Journal of the AmericanMedical Association.It is bad enough that this should always reach us atleast six weeks after publication without two consecutiveissues being delivered together, one six and the otherseven weeks old. A Gilbertian touch is added by aBoard of Trade notice that parcels of scientific journals

from the United States are liable to seizure by theBritish Customs unless an import licence has previouslybeen obtained by the importer, even when the journalsare unanticipated gifts. How is one to apply beforehandfor a licence to import a gift of which one knows nothingtill told that it is impounded by the Customs Once ?But the regular issues of the journals can hardly be beingdelayed by the Customs. Where the delay does ariseis a matter of some public concern. When news canarrive hot by radio or cable, scientific and medicalinformation should be available from our closest alliesas regularly as war conditions allow and at least aspromptly as ordinary mail. Medical research surelydeserves some privilege and priority.

PLASTIC ARTIFICIAL EYES

Fop some years British and American investigatorshave been examining the possibilities of the acrylicresins for making artificial eyes. The glass eye hasdone admirable service in the past, and a well-made glasseye in a good socket can have a very lifelike appearance.But all glass eyes suffer from disadvantages. Theybreak when dropped-no unlikely occurrence in the

daily manipulations’required to insert and remove them-and they have a life of two years at most, for thechemical action of the tears causes corrosion and roughensthe smooth surface of the glass, and this in turn 1’adsto a sore and inflamed socket. Suitable acrylic resinshave been devised which are more durable and lighterthan glass, and can be trodden on ’without breaking.Being more workable than glass they permit of a moreexact fit to the socket, and an -elaborate technique formaking them is now employed by the United StatesArmy medical service. By using a plastic material oflow melting-point which just sets at body temperaturea cast of the eye socket is taken. From this original,successive positive and negative moulds are taken untilfinally a negative mould of the. eye socket is obtainedinto which liquid resin can be poured. The iris has

previously been painted on a fine celluloid disc,;and thisis incorporated in the plastic eye, together with con-junctival vessels made of rayon threads, the whole

being finished off in a clear plastic solution which givesan appearance of moistness. The results, both in

cpmfort and-appearance, are said to be well worth thetrouble. Later modifications will no doubt shortenand simplify the technique.

PENICILLIN AND SUBACUTE BACTERIALENDOCARDITIS

SUBACUTE bacterial endocarditis is among the moredistressing tragedies of human illness. Usually seen inyoung people, it is a threat to all those with a rheumaticor congenitally deformed heart. The discovery of

penicillin has raised hopes that here at last might be acure, though reports from America have so far beenno more than suggestive.i No investigation will beconvincing unless it is based upon a reasonably large

series of cases, and our readers will be glad to see theannouncement on another page by the Penicillin ClinicalTrials Committee of the Medical Research Council thatthey are establishing ten centres to which physiciansare invited to send their cases. The patients will begiven penicillin according to an orderly plan,- andfollowed by clinical and bacteriological studies, so we

should soon learn whether there is an immediate response.The ultimate effect cannot be judged without observationover several years, but even a successful immediateresponse would be an advance on present results andwould justify further investigation. On the other.hand,initial failure would enable us to change our tactics andseek some other line.

1. See Lancet, 1944, ii, 117. J. Amer. med. Ass. 1944, 126, 233. Amer.Heart J. 1944, 28, 669. Nav. med. Bull., Wash. 1944, 43,1010.


Recommended