5/18/2016
1
Win-Win Co-Tenancy Provisions for
Landlords and Tenants
Chris Ressa
Sr. VP of Leasing, Northeast & Midwest
Table of ContentsI. Co-Tenancy Definitions
II. Co-Tenancy Purpose
III. How does a Co-Tenancy Failure Occur?
IV. How is a Co-Tenancy Enforced?
V. How are the Landlord & Tenant Protected?
VI. How is the Co-Tenancy Cured?
VII. Case Studies
VIII.Solutions for the Future
What is a Co-Tenancy Provision?
3
I. Co-Tenancy Definitions
5/18/2016
2
The term “co-tenancy clause” refers to one or more clauses in a typical shopping
center lease that conditions a tenant’s obligation to start construction, open and
operate its store upon the commencement of construction, opening and/or continued
operation of other specified “co-tenants” in the shopping center.
I. Co-Tenancy Definitions
Two (2) primary types of Co-Tenancy
• Named Co-Tenancy– Specifies tenants that need to be open
and operating.
• Occupancy Threshold– Specifies a minimum percentage of the
center’s gross leasable area that must be leased.
Example A:
• TJ Maxx must be open and operating or a Co-Tenancy failure shall be deemed to have occured.
I. Co-Tenancy Definitions
Example B:
The center must be at least 70% occupied or a co-tenancy failure shall be
deemed to have occurred.
I. Co-Tenancy Definitions
5/18/2016
3
• Execution Co-Tenancy: – Before the center is built the Landlord must
show a certain amount of leases have been executed. This can lead to delays for the Landlord, as penalties and delays might come before the project gets off the ground even if it is going well. However, this provision gives a tenant assurances the center will be built.
• Delivery Co-Tenancy:– This is similar to execution co-tenancy,
however, it requires that the Landlord has delivered space to tenants and construction has started when the lessee’s space is delivered. Similar problems can occur for landlords, as with the execution co-tenancy. Again, this is an important provision because most tenants don’t want to be the only ones under construction and opened.
Stages of Co-Tenancy
I. Co-Tenancy Definitions
• Opening Co-Tenancy– This provision requires a certain percentage
of tenants to be open or certain named Tenants to be open before lessee opens. landlords want tenants to open regardless. If multiple tenants have opening co-tenancy provisions it could set off a domino effect that could impact financials and delay the project. Tenants want assurance they are not the only ones open in a shopping center.
• Operating Co-Tenancy– This provision is what most people think of
when they think of co-tenancy. It is the provision that states certain tenants or certain percentage/number of tenants are open and operating throughout the term of the lease.
Stages of Co-Tenancy cont’d
I. Co-Tenancy Definitions
Some Key Points of
Consideration:
• What constitutes a Co-Tenancy
failure?
• How does the failure get enforced?
• What are the penalties/damages?
• How does the Landlord cure the Co-
Tenancy failure?
Hmmm…
I. Co-Tenancy Definitions
5/18/2016
4
Crafting a fair clause that clearly defines a failure
Let’s do this together
II. Co-Tenancy Purpose
Leverage, Fairness, Protection, & Committees
II. Co-Tenancy Purpose
• Balanced merchandising mix
• Protection for the tenant
• Non-punitive action for the
Landlord
• What else?
What are we trying to accomplish?
II. Co-Tenancy Purpose
5/18/2016
5
When is Co-Tenancy a deal breaker for the Landlord?
II. Co-Tenancy Purpose
• Potential Lender issues
• Landlord doesn’t “need” the deal – Occupancy is high
– Tenant demand is high
• Cost risks
• Partner issues
• Terms of Co-Tenancy do not work ******
• What else?
Landlord Deal Breaker Cont’d
II. Co-Tenancy Purpose
When is Co-Tenancy a deal breaker for the Tenant?
II. Co-Tenancy Purpose
5/18/2016
6
• Terms of Co-Tenancy do not work *****
• Committee requires something no matter what
• Tenant has multiple options in a market
• What else?
Tenant Deal Breaker Cont’d
II. Co-Tenancy Purpose
Time to Create an Anchor or Named on-going Co-Tenancy Provision
III. How does a Co-Tenancy Failure Happen?
“Landlord agrees that after the delivery date Shop-Rite, Christmas Tree Shops, Bob’s
Furniture, Ashley Furniture, Burlington Stores, K-Mart, and Hobby Lobby shall remain
open and operating or a Co-Tenancy failure shall be deemed to have occurred.”
Why won’t this work for the
Landlord?
A Strong Tenant PerspectiveIII. How does a Co-Tenancy Failure Happen?
5/18/2016
7
There has to be a better way to satisfy both
party’s concerns
III. How does a Co-Tenancy failure Happen?
“Landlord agrees that after the rent
commencement date that four (4) of the
seven (7) anchors shall remain open and
operating or a Co-Tenancy Failure shall
be deemed to have occurred. The
anchors are as follows: K-Mart, Ashley
Furniture, Shop-Rite, Burlington Stores,
K-Mart, Hobby Lobby, Christmas Tree
Shops, and Bob’s Furniture.”
Is this a reasonable compromise?
III. How does a Co-Tenancy failure Happen?
How can we improve the compromise position that enables less ambiguity and protects each side?
• Using a certain square footage to define an anchor vs. named tenants? Better or worse, and for whom?
• Add that, no matter what, a certain tenant(s) must be open? Better or worse, and for whom?
• What else?
III. How does a Co-Tenancy failure Happen?
5/18/2016
8
“Landlord agrees that during (a) this lease, Shop-Rite (or its Replacement Tenant(s)) shall be open and operating from its respective premises, fully stocked and staffed, except due to casualty, condemnation, force majeure, and temporary closures for remodeling and restocking, and (b) three (3) of the following six (6) anchors, Bob’s Furniture, Christmas Tree Shops, Ashley Furniture, Burlington Stores, and K-Mart, must be open and operating from their respective premises, fully stocked and staffed, except due to casualty, condemnation, force majeure and temporary closures for remodeling and restocking (the “Ongoing Co-Tenancy Requirement”)”
Does this seem fair to both parties?
III. How does a Co-Tenancy failure Happen?
When, EXACTLY, does the Co-Tenancy Failure take place?
IV. How is Co-Tenancy Enforced?
A Tenant Has Gone Dark
• One party should notify another party upon a co-tenancy failure by sending written notice to
the other party.
• Penalties should be incurred after a certain period when the receiving party gets notice.
• What happens if the party who bares the responsibility of notifying does not notify the other
party?
IV. How is Co-Tenancy Enforced?
5/18/2016
9
“If a co-tenancy failure has occurred, Tenant
shall notify Landlord of such a failure within
ninety (90) days following such failure by
sending written notice. Thirty (30) days after
Landlord has received such notice Tenant shall
be allowed to use remedies set forth below. If
Landlord does not receive notice within ninety
(90) days of such failure, then the co-tenancy
failure shall be null and void”
Is this a fairly written provision? How can we make this provision fair, clear and non-
punitive?
IV. How is Co-Tenancy Enforced?
What do we have thus far?
“Landlord agrees that during (a) this lease, Shop-Rite (or its Replacement Tenant(s)) shall be open and
operating from its respective premises, fully stocked and staffed, except due to casualty, condemnation,
force majeure, and temporary closures for remodeling and restocking, and (b) three (3) of the following six
(6) anchors, Bob’s Furniture, Christmas Tree Shops, Ashley Furniture, Burlington Stores, and K-Mart, must be
open and operating from their respective premises, fully stocked and staffed, except due to casualty,
condemnation, force majeure and temporary closures for remodeling and restocking (the “Ongoing Co-
Tenancy Requirement”)
If a co-tenancy failure has occurred, Tenant shall notify Landlord within ninety (90) days following such
failure. If Landlord receives written notice within ninety (90) days, then Tenant shall have all rights and
remedies set forth below with regard to co-tenancy failure starting on the date of which the co-tenancy
failure actually occurred. If Landlord has not received a notice within three hundred sixty five (365) days
following the date on which such co-tenancy failure occurred, then such co-tenancy failure shall be deemed
not to have occurred.”
IV. How is Co-Tenancy Enforced?
IV. How is Co-Tenancy Enforced?
5/18/2016
10
What is the appropriate penalty for the Landlord in the event of a
Co-Tenancy failure?
PenaltiesV. How are Landlord & Tenant Protected?
Common Industry ThemesV. How are Landlord & Tenant Protected?
Crafting the Penalty Language
“If at any time during the Lease Term there is a co-tenancy failure (except due to casualty,
condemnation, force majeure, and temporary closures for remodeling and restocking), Tenant shall
have the right to pay 50% of base rent. If Tenant shall have paid 50% of base rent for a period of
twelve (12) consecutive months and the Ongoing Co-Tenancy requirement remains unsatisfied,
Tenant shall either (i) terminate the Lease by providing written notice thereof to Landlord within ten
(10) days after the expiration of such twelve (12) month period and thereafter the Lease shall expire
on the thirtieth (30th) day following Landlord’s receipt of such notice, or (ii) waive the then existing
failure of the ongoing Co-Tenancy requirement and resume payment of full base rent on the first day
of the immediately succeeding calendar month. In the event Tenant does not terminate the Lease
within the aforesaid ten (10) day period, Tenant shall be deemed to have elected to waive the failure
as set forth in clause (ii).”
V. How are Landlord & Tenant Protected?
5/18/2016
11
• Tenant has protection if a failure occurs
• Tenant can go to reduced rent and after a certain amount of time can terminate
• Landlord has protection from long term reduced rent. Tenant has to go back to full rent
or terminate after a certain period of time.
• Timeline for notice, termination, and reduced rent are outlined
V. How are Landlord & Tenant Protected?
Where do we stand?“Landlord agrees that during the term of the lease, Shop-Rite (or its suitable replacement(s)) shall be open and operating from its respective
premises, fully stocked and staffed, except due to casualty, condemnation, force majeure, and temporary closures for remodeling and
restocking. In addition, three (3) of the following six (6) anchors, Bob’s Furniture, Christmas Tree Shops, Ashley Furniture, Burlington Stores,
and K-Mart, must be open and operating from their respective premises, fully stocked and staffed, except due to casualty, condemnation,
force majeure and temporary closures for remodeling and restocking.
If a co-tenancy failure has occurred, Tenant shall notify Landlord within ninety (90) days following such failure. If Landlord receives written
notice within ninety (90) days, then Tenant shall have all rights and remedies set forth below with regard to co-tenancy failure starting on
the date of which the co-tenancy failure actually occurred. If Landlord has not received a notice within three hundred sixty five (365) days
following such failure that a co-tenancy failure has occurred, then the Co-Tenancy failure for that specific co-tenancy failure shall be deemed
not to have occurred.
If at any time during the this Lease there is a co-tenancy failure (except due to casualty, condemnation, force majeure, and temporary
closures for remodeling and restocking), Tenant shall have the right to pay 50% of base rent next due and payable. If Tenant shall have paid
50% of base rent for a period of twelve (12) consecutive months and the Ongoing Co-Tenancy Requirement remains unsatisfied, Tenant shall
either (i) terminate the Lease by providing written notice thereof to Landlord within ten (10) days after the expiration of such twelve (12)
month period, and thereafter the Lease shall expire on the thirtieth (30th) day following Landlord’s receipt of such notice, or (ii) waive such
co-tenancy failure and resume payment of full base rent on the first day of the immediately succeeding calendar month. In the event
Tenant does not terminate the Lease within the aforesaid ten (10) day period, Tenant shall be deemed to have elected to waive such co-
tenancy failure as set forth in clause (ii). “
V. How are Landlord & Tenant Protected?
How does the Landlord actually cure a Co-Tenancy failure?
VI. How is the Co-Tenancy Cured?
5/18/2016
12
Key points of consideration:
• Who is an acceptable replacement Tenant(s)?
• Where can the replacement Tenant(s) be located in the shopping center?
• What percentage of GLA of named co-tenant must be replaced?
How to Remedy a Co-Tenancy
THIS IS ONE OF THE LARGEST REASONS FOR CO-TENANCY LITIGATION. BE SURE TO
CLEARLY ARTICULATE HOW A CO-TENANCY IS CURED IF A FAILURE OCCURS!
VI. How is the Co-Tenancy Cured?
VI. How is the Co-Tenancy Cured?
Is the below reasonable?
“To cure a Co-Tenancy failure, Landlord must
replace an anchor with a national retailer. A
national retailer is defined as a Tenant that
has at least 100 stores in more than 26
states in the United States of America.”
VI. How is the Co-Tenancy Cured?
5/18/2016
13
“As used herein, a “Replacement Tenant” shall mean a tenant with at least two (2)
other locations whose use is typically found in first class shopping centers, medical
tenants, health clubs, and other tenants typically found in first class shopping
centers.
Replacement Tenants shall occupy at least 80% of the floor area previously occupied
by the co-tenant being replaced. For the K-Mart and Burlington spaces (shown as
space 1 and space 40 on the site plan), 80% of the floor area may be occupied by up
to three (3) different tenants to cure the co-tenancy failure so long as each of the
three (3) tenants qualifies as a Replacement Tenant as set forth above. For all other
anchor spaces, 80% of the floor area may be occupied by up to two (2) different
tenants to cure the co-tenancy failure, so long as each of the two (2) Tenants
qualifies as a Replacement Tenant as set forth above.
Notwithstanding the forgoing, if during this Lease one of the anchors’ space changes
in size, then the new square footage of such space will be deemed the new anchor
size, provided, however, at no time shall the size of the anchor be less than 90% of
the size as of the effective date of this Lease.”
VI. How is the Co-Tenancy Cured?
VI. How is the Co-Tenancy Cured?
“Landlord agrees that during (a) this lease, Shop-Rite (or its Replacement
Tenant(s)) shall be open and operating from its respective premises, fully
stocked and staffed, except due to casualty, condemnation, force majeure,
and temporary closures for remodeling and restocking, and (b) three (3) of
the following six (6) anchors, Bob’s Furniture, Christmas Tree Shops, Ashley
Furniture, Burlington Stores, and K-Mart, must be open and operating from
their respective premises, fully stocked and staffed, except due to casualty,
condemnation, force majeure and temporary closures for remodeling and
restocking (the “Ongoing Co-Tenancy Requirement”)
If a co-tenancy failure has occurred, Tenant shall notify Landlord within
ninety (90) days following such failure. If Landlord receives written notice
within ninety (90) days, then Tenant shall have all rights and remedies set
forth below with regard to co-tenancy failure starting on the date of which
the co-tenancy failure actually occurred. If Landlord has not received a
notice within three hundred sixty five (365) days following the date on
which such co-tenancy failure occurred, then such co-tenancy failure shall
be deemed not to have occurred.
If at any time during the this Lease there is a co-tenancy failure (except due
to casualty, condemnation, force majeure, and temporary closures for
remodeling and restocking), Tenant shall have the right to pay 50% of base
rent next due and payable. If Tenant shall have paid 50% of base rent for a
period of twelve (12) consecutive months and the Ongoing Co-Tenancy
Requirement remains unsatisfied, Tenant shall either (i) terminate the Lease
by providing written notice thereof to Landlord within ten (10) days after
the expiration of such twelve (12) month period, and thereafter the Lease shall
expire on the thirtieth (30th) day following Landlord’s receipt of such notice, or (ii)
waive such co-tenancy failure and resume payment of full base rent on the first day
of the immediately succeeding calendar month. In the event Tenant does not
terminate the Lease within the aforesaid ten (10) day period, Tenant shall be
deemed to have elected to waive such co-tenancy failure as set forth in clause (ii).
As used herein, a “Replacement Tenant” shall mean a tenant with at least two (2)
other locations whose use is typically found in first class shopping centers, medical
tenants, health clubs, and other tenants typically found in first class shopping
centers.
Replacement Tenants shall occupy at least 80% of the floor area previously occupied
by the co-tenant being replaced. For the K-Mart and Burlington spaces (shown as
space 1 and space 40 on the site plan), 80% of the floor area may be occupied by up
to three (3) different tenants to cure the co-tenancy failure so long as each of the
three (3) tenants qualifies as a Replacement Tenant as set forth above. For all other
anchor spaces, 80% of the floor area may be occupied by up to two (2) different
tenants to cure the co-tenancy failure, so long as each of the two (2) Tenants
qualifies as a Replacement Tenant as set forth above.
Notwithstanding the forgoing, if during this Lease one of the anchors’ space changes
in size, then the new square footage of such space will be deemed the new anchor
size, provided, however, at no time shall the size of the anchor be less than 90% of
the size as of the effective date of this Lease.”
VI. How is the Co-Tenancy Cured?
5/18/2016
14
• Grand Prospect Partners v. Ross Dress for Less, Inc.
• Kleban Holding co. LLC v. Ann Taylor Retail, Inc.
• Old Navy, LLC v. Center Developments Oreg., LLC
Case Studies
VII. Case Studies
A Solution for the Future?VIII. Solutions for the Future
Using tenant sales as our guide? No harm, foul? Can we focus on protecting the Tenant rather than punishing the Landlord?
• Tenant has to show some sort of meaningful decrease in sales before it gets to enforce penalties on the Landlord?
• If there is no decrease in sales then the circumstances could prove to be non-harmful?
• Have alternate rent be based on a tenant’s occupancy cost?
• What else?
Can Co-Tenancy provisions be fair, but non-punitive?
VIII. Solutions for the Future
5/18/2016
15
One Size Doesn’t Fit All
• When the Co-Tenancy event consequences affect intrinsic value. For example, a Tenant might feel it dilutes their brand?
• When Co-Tenancy can’t be quantified in one event, rather the erosion of sales happens over time?
• What else?
VIII. Solutions for the Future
Questions?
CHRIS RESSA, CLS
SR. VICE PRESIDENT – LEASING,
NORTHEAST & MIDWEST
DLC MANAGEMENT CORP.
580 WHITE PLAINS ROAD, 3rd Floor
TARRYTOWN, NY 10591
D 914.304.5642 | T 914.631.3131
C 914.760.3145 | F 914.560.2280 E [email protected]
Please Complete Your Evaluation Now.
1. Take Out Your Smartphone or Tablet
2. Go to survey.icsc.org/2016RECON
3. Select this course:
Win-Win Co-Tenancy Provisions
for Tenants and Landlords
Course Evaluation