Date post: | 07-Jul-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | mail2agastaya7024 |
View: | 216 times |
Download: | 1 times |
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 1/11
Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality: A Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
Authors(s): Deborah KnightSource: The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, Vol. 57, No. 4 (Autumn, 1999), pp.
411-420
Published by: Wiley on behalf of The American Society for Aesthetics
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/432148
Accessed: 27-03-2016 15:08 UTC
R F R N S
Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article:
http://www.jstor.org/stable/432148?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents
You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted
digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about
JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
The American Society for Aesthetics, Wiley are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve andextend access to The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 2/11
DEBORAHKNGHT
Wh y W E n y C nd m n ng n m n y
A M A h P p v
n mn y n p nd dy d
w h n d m ng m n nd gn
ng u h p y n ymp hy ndn
n g nd mp n v n h m
u y xm n n h ph ph
u nd h u h h w n
mn y u u y d m ng
u wh h w h p w k
u n b h wn p
u k h b h
nd vdu w h p nd n m n y
h v n v yd y xp n m
n gh n h n un v nd mn n n
b g n d m n un xp d u Th C n
O x d D n y Cu n E ng h n y
n m n n w h b m g n
n Ox d u n d n n n b d
y m d n n d h u h w
w n nw my u n why
n m n y n v w d u h
k n m k d n w n m
h n b y nd d k n
m k p y h g d n n m y d
n n u b y m k n b udgm n
bu u m y d n n u v gn v
nd m g n
Ov nd b v h y d n n mgh
n h d m u d x p b n
n m n y T h m d g n
n m n y h ugh u y n n n n
m n h wh p d b p g mm d
p dg d Bu h m p d b p
mm d p d g d h v y n
d d yu d b u n m n y by h wh
d y T h m n d h m m
h m n mn y und Th n
d dv w n mn y mp
h m n pu v x mp h k
n yd u ky b m Bu g n h
h h g h nd d y
b u gh g n n m n y And d p h
n mp b y N wm n nd Rb C
m n m u kby h m ng mp
b y d nd ng n m n y Th n u
n h nk w mu h n mn y
nn b d nd d n n w k
w hn p u p h ph p p v
p h nk ph ph
nv nm n And h gh n y
u mu h bu u ph ph
n v nm n d b u n m n
w k h h wh n nd n y
h m
n mn y n n yb nd mn d
w h u b h n g h nk b u h p h ph
nv nm n h nd h b k g und
uh n d mn n h u wh n
v v d n p ng h nd d v w Bu wh
w wn b m w h n v nm n
nC n m d h w p d
n h d u n h h n u
w pp h n u nv nm n
h y C n gu w mu nd
d n y Ou n m w y nd ng
n u n un b u v b kg u nd
h b u w v k u ng n d n b
u n w hn h v nv n
mn h u n n W bg n
nd d n y w n m h un b u v
b kg u nd n n b u v g u nd By
u n ng b kg u nd n g u nd h m d
u d v u w n n d n h ph
ph n y n mn y T dp h
md w u dm n w wu d k h n
d d v w h h n h u gh And w w u d
d h v n h nd d v w h p h
p h p p v w h w d n y nd
u nu n ng y w k w hn n d v n w b
Th Ju n A h nd A C m F
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 3/11
v h d m y d bu
h p v n d ng v v u h n m u
h m nd py h g udgm n
My p p h n w h nd g w
n p u h nk ng b u K h n Hgg n
d h x m n n w k h Wh
gg n wn d n p h wh w h
p m y u d w h w k h
n w u p p p u b
n h w d h m k h b
R h H gg n gu h w k h u n
n p v k p n h n d
nwh nv v d n x p n n g m h ng
k h nd gn h u h n xp n
n b d by n nk h b u mu h
by k h b Th b h k h b
n d n n k h b n k h p n
n n yp b mm np b u
h nv n mn h upp u h xp n
H gg n m h h u p n n
p w k h wh h h d gn
n n m k ymb n u
u h yp wh h p v d h b kg u nd
u u b nd d b u h n O
Ou p n k h d n d p nd y n
n b nd m n p p bu m u
n u y n mm n uu n h
n d y p n d d b d K h
n d n h mm d b u
n n p u md nd ng W
n h v k h p n m hng
h m ny mgh k b n x m p y p
k h m u u un d by
n n d p n w d y d nd nn n
h d n u dd n g pu pp A nd w m g h x p
n k h p n n yp b
Hgg n pn h u u nv n mn h
m k n m n p n w k h p
b T h d u n n mn y p
w hn u u nv nm n n m y h
nv nm n n mp y p n
d m p h p hy F w ng H gg n m d
w k h w u d y h h u ph
p h p n n u nd d u n
n m n y m k y mb n
b kg und u u h u p d h m
ph ph v u Wh h k h n
nd n n h p m n ymy yn h
h h m nng g n ng u u h
n u h u u h yp h ph
ph p n n n mn y n d n
n n g u n hp h m nng g n ng
Th Ju n A h nd A C m
u u h n u h nd d ph ph
p p v wh h h v b n ng h
nd d v w Th v n h n m n
y p y n H gg n m d h n m n
y m nym yn d h n h
ph ph p p v u h bu n g
n n mn y un n m n ym
h n nph ph n n m nym
h ph ph C y h p u
n hp Bu H gg n m d h p y
why ph phy u u ud w d n
m n y n g v Wh m n b nv
g d w hy ph p hy n y nd mn ng
n m n y
Th pp h h n F k h
h nd d v w nd m mph m
p ng h nd d v wh n d nd ng
N x u n n d N wm n nd
m n d n n mn y Nwm n d
n h nd d v w un b u v
kg und nd p n n h n g
h b kg und nn v d n
n m n y m n n h h h nd
p p h nd d v w m v y ymp h
m n u n d m ny p n u
p n nv g Bu m h h m nd
n v gy nn w k w um
h y d h h d m n n ph
ph p p v g nd h m v h
ng v m n n mn y F n y
u n h p b m h ph ph nv
nm n n mn y N n yd h
nv n m nm k h d n n m n y
mp b bu m k h nd mn n
n mn y n n n n m n
y n n n n mn y nwh h n
m n y ugh n x n ph ph
u Th p u d v d m h
n d mn n n mn y p u y
ph ph n b u nd h u gh y
nd d Bu h u w h h n g y
w hH gg n m d k h h ud hv d
u n p
ENTMENTALTYTHETANDARDVEW
Wh h n h nd d v w n mn
y w k ng nd d v w why
n k nd d u g b k ng p h
phy H h y n m n d
ng Th C n Ox d n m n w
d m n ng g d W
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 4/11
K ngh W hy W En y C nd mn ng n m n y A M A h P p v
n m g und h Th u w h D vd
H um m d n n n O h nd d
T Hum w p n v m wh
m mn n h d b h v y wd d
n b w n u dg mn nd n m n A
d ng mm n n v n h w
hu nd p n n b u m n ub w
kn w h h n n d bu n h u
nd u nd h n yd u y x nd
n Bu n m n w d n Th
p b m mm n n h d w h n m n
h h yw u y gh b u n mn
h n n hng b y nd nd
w y Th h p u y m n
n g h y m b u d yn nd
u nd x d p n xp n
phy ng n n p n h
b w And hy m u
n g n d n g d ng h u
n A dy w h p n y
n m n un u y nd p b y v nu n
n b n h y p m g y un
b Ev nOx d n nd pp n y u
nu d n n p v d g und u n
n d k p m u h n y g h
m ph ph w p b by g h h
n h ng nh n y b n b b u h
mn ng n u n And y w
k h nd m n u p d gm h
d ub b n d d p bu
g d pp p d b h um n
u hw u ky m d n n Th u
u n b xp n p y n
nd h v n ng g nd h
h m n ng h n gn n
g v wy p g v up n u
m n nd p n n hng
x p n xp u h m n ng
ymp hy mp n d n n w h
n d u v h Bu u n h
h ng h d v w p n n b h
b d n d w h m n D n n
v n xmp n m d by n b n
m n nd w mgh n d h nv
b ng n m dby gn b up n m n
A h g h m ph ph n d h p
m g y mnd dph ph b h b m
n v u W h h p pn w h n kn w d g m
b nd h n d w h n u
n d by u m n g n y g d
h m n n udgm n nd hu y
nd d h h k y ph n d n n
v p n An h ny v p u
w hh p d g n n m n y
h ng n b nd d
n h nd d y m d n
m u n u y y b u m p m d udg
m n n m n un h kd by n b d
g u d h x mp d n n x n
mn y pu n k ubv n
n u udgm n b u b b u
u v y d by h v y m
n h g v h udgm n And wh n
u v w h ng u v n u
d by ng b u w y d by h m d
n n v n u b y m k n d nd
nb udgm n y k Th ng g
m bd w h ugh ndu g n u
m n p n b m mwk h m ud
n v ng u n m n n b k y
u h n d n n gh A u h un
h ppy p n Ox d n du n y n
h D n n n n u h n m n
n m n ng n v yd n
u Wh h n u b u h
m n ng nv y d w d Ox
d n y y m d n w ud
ym g n u n mn h nd n
d b d by n x m ud n m n
ng h nd w png v R mn H
y p h p v p n Ju hv
ng n m n pu u n h pp y p
w d n m n m And R b m n
m k n mn m nd n unh hy
nd m u nph ph p n h
ng v h d h dd n Th
n m n p b m h ph ph
Th ph ph xp n why h
n m n w h ng Rm nH d y
p n n h p p y
n h y h dy n n h gh Bu
h w n b d n ugh h p h ph
nn xp n why h n m n w h
ng h m h ump n h m n
why h w p ng v g n nd why h
n n dd w y hppy wh h w p
Th un ng y d by h nd
ph phy b u n mn y p y
mu h p w hOx d v n
n h n mn y w y pn
m H p n mgh b v d n
h m h h w y h nk ng b u
h n hp b w n n m n y n d h
m n w h wh h d
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 5/11
n n m n m ng h bu h
m d h ugh ng Th m
ph d m x v m v h n
m m n nd w u n h d n
m n y nn n w h x v y h
n d h p p Bu w n nu w h h
n d d ph ph y w n d h n
m n y n u u n m y d g u
Any pub x v d p y m n
h ud m m b u b ng bv
u y gn m b d Bu h
n w h n h J ph Kup m
xp y h n m n y v n
u m d v g n b h
n y wh d n d m k w
d mp n w hnk w h ng n m n
v n h N d ng K up n
mn y d p v d ng u v
n m n y w u n b v u
n p ud b h n p
h p h ng w u dn b b d Bu n m n
y h n u n u p n
N wm n g h d h d ub x n
dmn n wh nh n h n n
m b u n m n y ng
nd y p n n h
h w d wh ng ud h d
n d v du b h m v nd d
h gum n h h n h ng u h h
Kup m nd u n h v n h w h v
g n h n m n y h d
n u n h w H gu h
wh v h d b n m n y m
n m h d n u v p p h
h md d b n m n y
h n m n h n m n y
wy h ugh n u p u y bu h
And h n m n b m y
m pv h dTh n mn d p y
u h w h p v y nd
b p n W y u h b b d m
n p n n b u d by u
w k n h y n u n u
v yd yp n n m n d h ugh n d
ng by v ng u n h w y n m n
y Th h m n h
b v u h n m n n dv du k p
u n p n g h x p n x v
m ud n m n T h k m ny nk y
p v nd d h n d dv w m
n p y n n m n d d w d
n yp n b n m n
Th Ju n A h nd A C m
d mm d p v nd p v ng
p kng mm d g ng d
Hg gn p n dd x mp wh m n dd
h h d u yw u n n K M
Thu h v b n p ng n h n
d d v w Th p b m w h ng h
p bv u Th w h k ng
h ugh h nd d v w h h n p b
b yh pp y n g m n w h wh h b n
d Y n mn y ymp m m
d n Y n mn y udgm n
m b ng gn m b d
T h nd d ph ph v ww n y
h h u m h ng n b u h
w m n v h y ng h w h R m n
H dy h ph phy n n n u
wy y n hng b u h On m
n h dw h my d u n h nd d
v w nd hw ph phy n p n
n m n y n v y u h n n
h ym y w y h m gu y v m
n u n O u n
n n b m d k h nd dv w h
h n h u gh
DEFENDNGENTMENTALTY
Th wh h ng h nd d v w n
m n y hv m w u p n
h mOn d n d n m n y wh
m n ng g y w hn h nd d v w T
w h u gu w h N wm n h
n m n y n w y unwh m Th
h u gu h h m h ng
u y h m w h h nd d vw
n d n n mn y m v n h
d n
N wm nm k w m n m n h
mp u n m n y m g d
unwh m n Th m h h
n n v u v p p y d p v n
n m n y Th n y wh n
p p d n m n y u p m
n n y h nm p u y g n
y m B u n m n y n m
ny gn d n m g n y
m d n pp n m g n
n ud ng x mp g dy m dy m n
n y/ m n n N h pF y u k y
gn ng d h d n yg n u h
h W n G h h mu d m y y
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 6/11
K ngh W hy W En y C nd mn ng n m n y A M A h P p v
h nd h N h n m n y
gn d y k mp n m dd
nn m Th p y b u n
mn y m dum nu pp ng n p
y p h p n n nd h
n d n u b w n nd n n N
p d y n n Rm n u
nd b u p d y nd h d p
h h h m m x mp d dg d
p by Ang A m n ph ph h n
mn n v C h D k n y
d w h p h p d N
n mn y m w k h nn
h ugu h p y n v b m
h n mn n v d n b ng m
hng d h gn n mn y bu
h u n b y Th g d n m n
y V n u d ngu h b
m n n h L u n n A
n m n J u n yTh u gh F n nd y
Gu v F ub L Edu n n m n
h d un u n h mm M u hm w u d
n d b d h w h n mn y h
m y g n n h W w u d
n d y wh p y md h p pu
n v h V n n m n n w y
h n b u u y d n gu h d m n
n h n h h b
F ub h F n h n mp y u wn
x mp n m n n v n n
Th Y ung nd h R B v y H
A nd n w h d md h n y
d n n w w ud n d h w n ng
h d v u n u d p v m y
n m bu m gh b xp d
m d gn n g y b u nd n h n
v u v wy d gn ng ng d
ng n b y n h n h nd n dn
u y v u v n u d p bb y
y w h n w d n g n n
w n m ppu u u
hy ph ph d u n n m n
y n nu y u n D k n nd d n
p n d m m n m p pu x mp
nk y b ynd m dm H gg n n m
n ng g ng d u ph ph
n n bu h n d h b u h p
n h n n w k h Wh b u
h n mn y un y nd w n y
b u y p g n m p v n h O ym
p h W d W mb dn G dg
h b u h m n u g p m
b n ny h p m n b y Th
Th T n h un n k b nd h
h d ng n d h yw ud nv un
w n d n yw h h Eg Wh b u
h W Wh b u h n
m n ng h gh d u d by
n Th u y h h mp n
wh w k g m n u g ng
d bu p yng d nd d yb k
y w h nd ny numb
h b
T n d h x mp n h d h y
d v mgh d m h ng b u h n
nn n b w n h gh nd p pu
u u h h nd d v w m d p d
v k b k F n n m gh
v h p wh nv v d n u g n
pp n h gh d n un
h vng b n n m n d u nd
n w k h m d mp n b u
u m n nd n u gn v ng g
n w h And p k ng h w kw d n
ng h w k n m n
mn m nd u h n u u
n g n n k h my b n h v n
g d A u y h nk h g h d
n n w ng h n gn n v n
g d n n y b g n n k h
wh w d n w y pp h h
w k h v n g d w k n u d nd
n d h h n n mp y ud n m y
w n wb vn d h gh b u h y
hv b m k h wh m y b p
p xm n h b u w h v g wn
v h m W B n mn n dn h v b n
n n d b u h u h h u
p d w u d b h u h g m hn
p du n A h h v m k d m
h n p du n h n n d h u
nd h my u m ny p du d w k
h d p v n n v u v n
n m n y N wm n m A g ub yn
bu h h nd n d n T h n n n
h n m n y mgh h v u d b n n
m n y b n b u n h
k v w h nd mn n m n y u g h
An dh N wm n k n w d g h h
n x u n p n p ng wh
m nh u p n d w h p
m u wn n n h u u
n h p d w y p nd ng m n
y h gd u n m y n y u wn
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 7/11
un m y w h p y g m w y
pnd ng Th n y m u u
u n g n h b d m
n m n y Bu n n d
ng h p p p h n x
p n h w m gh h nk n mn
w n udg d b n mn n h u n
h n h n h g n m n y b
b ugh v w u dh d y n u h
v w And n d n n mn y
k n w dg h w m m g w ng
wh n w m h m w k p n
n mn
W h h n h p b y h h
ud b n n n mn y W h n h
nd d v w h d h w h u d b
h N wm n up wh u u
y n b u n m n y p
n n v y p y p y
mn h u h mgh p v
b m pug nn nd unb b y p nu n
v n u n N wm n b v h u h
v y u y w d d w h
m n y v p w n gn d n m wh h
dp d n h u g u m n d m gh
h w u n w yTh n n ng ug
g n Bu dub u n g vn h h
h n h m nng n mn y w hn
u ph ph nv n m n n w h v
n h h g n m n y u d n
v v h m n u d ng h
nd d v w w u d m h h w k
p n n m n n wh h
b m w hy n n m n n
wh h p v d n v d n h p
w h n n mn y Th h b
n Kup g n N wm n Nwm n
x mp ud b n m n y
Pu d h n D k n D mb y nd n
Kup p h n xmp
g d b u h w k nv v d n pp
ng Pu d h mp x nd nu u
n mn A Nwm npu pp
n g P u d h u n xp n m n
nd m n gy nv v n
nd A d ng h nd d v w uh
u pp n n n mn
Pu d h u n u n b ud b n
n n m n y n n
n xmp n mn y A uh h n
p y n d n n mn y A
b ugg h m p u n n
Th Ju n A h nd A C m
u u y d u p d gm n
mn y m y n b p d gm
m n d n n mn y n p
d gn h nd d vw nd nh n
b A h g u h h h p b m
n u p p n n h m n n g n
n d n p u h n m n
m n h n u y d p ud
g n n mn y h ph ph p
ud g n n mn p u y n h
n m n m n h y n d ng
h gn u u h b kg und
h hv n p d n u h n mn y
b d n h m nd p y
h g d M gn n y m n
gn ph ph p u d w h n
h nd d vw h n d p v h n v
b y n p n p p u y
n m p n p un v b v
d n d nd v b b h gum n
nd dm n n wh h n m n
u ub v n d n d nd d
n mp n m k h n d ng
h nd dv w p y h un m
n L w nd h ny hng d w h h
m n nd hn w h h n m n gn
y p v d h n h h n
m n d w n n h h
n h n d dv w h n p u
v b u y d b ng h n m n h
n m n nd n m n y v b u y
n nd d p v h p v g d n d
un m n n
n p u y k ng xmp u h w
ph ph y d d h nd d v w
mn u n h d h n mn m
n v h u n my h n d vdu
By p nd ng w h ng u n
w k u v n k h n
k n vu n b nd d n b m
mp n n w n m n b m
n pu d n g v w y m n h g
n wh n h u n n h x
h n d mn n n mn u u n
n h h du n u wh
w m gh y h v m w k ng
w n y d u h u v h
d n by p v k ng h u nw
m m n n u n n n n y h
nn b n d m n n h dub
n d dh W d n k bu v n
u n my wh n p n n dw h
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 8/11
K ngh W hy W En y C nd mn ng n m n y A M A h P p v
why d w d wh n h p p n
n bu m n H n nu Th p
ump n h u m n un k u
n n u y u wn n d h y hum
ng h h n nn b ng
mn d n gu h u w y d n ng
n mn y m nmum d n n n n
ng n h n d m n d d d n n
mph ng w kn d gn d n n
u ng n ndu gn nd n y n p
m g d n n n n d w h
k m n W hv dy n hw h
u v w m g g h p h n
d v w m n d nd n m n
y n h v u d h m n
m d n n n d hu d ngu h b w n
h g n ng nd h Bu u w w
w h h y d ng Th C n Ox d
v n m ng yn u p m y d n n
dy n m n d by h h h u b
u m n h m v m n
dw h u p n Wh m n
m ny w n d n d n y n m n
y bu h h n mn p y h
g n n ymp h w h h b v bu
d nd ng h n mn n n y g ng
h v h d n n m n y m
y h d n h n n dn h v
nd n dn b u nd k n n d h v
d n n m
THEENTMENTALTYOFTHE TANDARD
VEWOF ENTMENTALTY
h m h ng u h b d b u
h nd d vw A d ng h v w n
mn y b m w h y b u mp
h b u n n n mn y d p nd
u p n u k p d b nd m n
u h n m d h w
h d n dm v h yb m h b u
u n d n m n y mk n d m nd n
u u n ugg nv v n y n w
ng ng u n h ugh ng
bu h w d n d b h n b u nd
u pp d by g n u h m g n
n n m n y p h bv u nd
v d h m bgu u A n m n p n
m h wun p h d u n n d u nd
p nd n n wh p w h y nd
h u y n n mn w nv v m
x y u n nd d p h p n T h
m bn d mnd u p nn n w xp
n h un m mp ng p n
w N n nm n xp n nd p n
u h xp nd u n gy p y
mn n gy u h p w hy xp n
u u nd d m v u n w p
p v T h y nv v d u y k W
mu k u n p nd nd
h ugh ng n ng ng b h n
h g n u n nd n u p n
u n m n y k y d u wn
p n v u p u p dw h u v
w h h w h n n n n m n
p n m d un u n n w y
m u v w d b v u n
w d h
n h d ng h nd d v w n
mn y d u w y m v gn v
n g gm n w h h mb gu nd mp x
h h n u d b d y n ugh
n ud h p n n n n nd
u w h p n nd h w d
h w h h m w d h v mp d
h d d h d h n d h
n n mn y n u g m p n y
N n y w u m gn n b m y du
v d n x n w u v k y
b m p v C n y h m w n
du g n n m n y h m unp p d w
b m n n h w d nd h h ugh
g h m w w v d u n h
u d n n Y h v y p hw y
w d p v y nd n y d x
by p vd ng um h d p y u v
h ugh h w m n n h nd d
ng h nd d vw n m n y d n
n m h h n h n
h h b d ng g und wh K up
h v n n h wh
m n ng u h mp n py
n y mp hy n d h mgh n y h v
n k n v u by h m h n mn
h wn nd u vn d h m
p h p by h m h m n ng
d h n m n w w h n
n y h v y v u Wh m k
n m n y m y b mw h y m
h n m h v u u n h v u
n m n y v m u d ng v u
Th m bv u u h ph ph
nv nm n h nd mn n m n y
h n m n y k n d n
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 9/11
g n h n n h w h h y b ng
p u n h up n h w h h y n
v nm n A n g d h b k g und m
ph h nd mn n n mn y p y
u h m p h ph b n v
h m n n mn y mu b n
m y b m w hy d v
n w n p v n m h n u
n ng m n nd h n
w n m y m n
n p n w n p um h n
h u d d nd n n h m n P h
p hy d w h h n h d p h
mp x h v h h u Th
n p u h n n ny hng ph
p h y h y m y v np y h
g y p w h y On nn h n y
p h n h h w h mp h
p v h n d h n bu d
n w h n h nd d vw Th v b u
y g nd d p v g ng m d
w hd m u n y v yv p v y
n mn y w mn h nd h
n d h d y u h ud n du g n
h p h w b b d x v n m n
y dp d d u v h n n d
m nb p h W h n
Kup n n wh n h n n n
b w n n m n y n d d p n n
m n y p n u b u h dd n
d gu d d v n mn y mm
ny h w d n g n h h n
gu nM u d ng n nn n nd w k ng
n h n d h und ng h n
h v dy ugg d n w u n
h u n b u v b k g u nd h nd mn
n n mn y n b u v g und
w h u h g n ph ph nd m
n n n m n A nd n m n
n h y ph ph w y wn
d b h nd d d d
n m n y Th wh w d v h p
v y h nd d v wF d ng
h nd d v w wh m k n m n y
p v n h n h p u
d v d by h n m n n h n du gn
h w n m n T h p v y h
d dn h p n h d h wh
v h u n h p mp h p n
h p n h u p mp d n h ndu g
p h n m n Th wh v
v w h w hKup n mn
Th Ju n A h nd A C m
y m v u n d n b d d
w d n y hng h w u d d n y p mp n
d ng B u h nd d
x v d mn n n n b ng y p
u n wy p p y h d n
m n wh n v h nd mn n n
mn y ndu g n ng u y
nn d h p u ng h n
h p n wh gn h unw
h n h n m n h n h n b
nd d n mn p n
A h u d nw b b v u nd mn n
m n y u d v d m n
n wn ph ph v u
d n n m h wh h n nd mn
Bu h p u v u F n n
n v u h p b ng h n
m n w h ymp hy m p hy mp n
p n Th m b n n
n y ng h ng m h n m n
p p v n mu h k n
n d h w h w k b un ph
d h w h p un mb gu u m gh
h v v mp x y mb gu yw h
mn n ng G n d x p n m d h
np n n b p n d n x mp
h gh u w n h n n
d w d D k n Bu d ub h m ny
p h ph w ud b w ng v n n d
h p b y mp x y mb gu y n
n n n ub y xmp n
n d y m v n p p nd d
n hng h h p b nd u h p b y
h h nd mn n n mn y
n n n n mn y h ph
p h m g W d n u v u
wn nd d ph ph p n
n ph d un n d und p n d Y
v u n h nd d p n m y
hv n ph n nd y b
n mn y nn h
hu ugh n u p h Hum
d u n gg h ph ph nd mn
n n m n y m n v b
m y m ngu g A h b v Th
w d v u w h u v n n v y n gu
mp p h v d b m And
n n w h u h m bv u n dg
mp p y u d x p h m wh h
n g n p n und d n g d
n b w pp u wh h d m
u d pp b n T b m y m
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 10/11
Kn gh W hy W En y C nd mn ng n m n y A M A h P p v
ngu g b p h b kg u nd p
h p h ph nv n mn Bu u p u
n d wh h m un C y
m un m nng w hn u u p
nd b m h p d ng p b y
b n b h g n b y h
h h n m n h m n h
w m nh n d h un n d Fu h u h
pp n y g n n n u b u h m n
ng m n d h m u
m d m nd mn n p u
w k v d xp n
w u p n h m Y u y
h v p u h w h u d b
h ph y nd y ng gd
m h mp h ng h u h
bu y h p Hum ugg
nd h v y n h Wh w h u d
gu d g n h p ud ng v y
h ng h u d m v b d n
m n mp y unw h y u h h
n d n h n h m p n u h
un x mp H gg n g ng d
bu h mp n N wm n d n
D k n F w u m hng n m n
n d nd mn w k y n d
p ng gn h m p x y gn
n w k h w hv h y k n
b p d gm n m nym u p d
p h ph v u
Bu h n y p h m h y
Th h p n n h d d g dng
n ph ph m n y
u nd mn ng nd p n n
m n B w ugg h ph ph w h
nd mn n m n y F n n y u h
n d mn n k y m un n y m
p n h nd d y mpp d n
p u wh u h p n w
d n h m p d b y nd
d u v n u u y h ugh h h
p n nd b b ng d Cn d
h p u p u h u h n d mn n
m n L k h x v n m n
h n m n y n y w
v g y ng gn v v y T h
h p h n y h h w n v y
m u y w wu d n n nu
p du g um n h w ng h mp v h
n n m n y h w n p u
n h d ng h wv m h Bu h p h
p h k p u g y ng
g n v v y n gn ng h m h
h p n wh n d mn n
m n y Thu h p h ph b y nd mn
ng n mn y p n hm h
ph ph y v u u n dv du nd k
u m d ng Th ph ph
nd mn n n mn y n n h b
n m n v y nd d b u m
u d n d nd n b nd hu
n p n b b h g y ng
nd d v ng n mn y h m
v u
DEBORAHKNGHT
p m n Ph phy
Q u n Un v y
K n g n C n d K L N
N T E RN ET k n g h d@ p u n u
T h h w h h v w n h m
u An h ny v v w h n m n y m d
hugh ng n n m n h n n x
n ng g b n nd h n n mn
m nn h Th T T m An E y nPh ph
A h Ox d Ox d Un v y P pp
p n d n m n y nA gu ngAb u A
d A x N nd A n R d y N w Y k M G w H
pp M ny wh nn n mn y
h p y k h u d p pu p
h v b d n h n g h n n n m n
y h n n wh d h g n m n h
n m n p n m n by p k h n
x mp m n m n y h n nd
gn x mp h pp mb dn G
D K h Th W d B d T N wY k Un
v B k nd Cm n G n b g A v n G d
nd K h n h A n dCu u B n B n P
nd d u n h p mp n n
m n y nd k h n K h n H gg n w K h
n Ph phy h V u A d Ph p Ap n Nw
k Ox d Un v y P nd nR b C
m n On K h nd n m n y T h J un A
h nd A C m
A N wm n m k n T h A g d Unwh
m n n m n y n Agu ng Ab u A d N
n d R d y p
Th C n Ox d D n y Cu n Eng h h
d n mn
R h ng x p n n u d K h n Hgg n nd
R b C m n wh p m y n d n w
k h nd h d nd m n
N wm n Th A g d Unwh m n n m n
y
R b C m n n D n n m n y
P h phy nd L u
Th ugh u p C n wu dn h v n p d
h d p n h d h App n nd h
This content downloaded from 202.41.10.3 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 15:08:34 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
8/19/2019 Why We Enjoy Condemning Sentimentality a Meta-Aesthetic Perspective
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-we-enjoy-condemning-sentimentality-a-meta-aesthetic-perspective 11/11
Th Ju n A h nd A C m
N u Env n mn Th J un A h nd A
C m
H gg n w K h p
b d p Th p n m d by R b m n
n n D n n m n y n d On K h nd n
m n y bu h u d u yb m m u W
n nd d p nd n m n y u n h d n
p p n h n n n m n p n
Hgg n w K h p
bd p
bd p
D v dHum O h nd d T Th Ph
p hy A R d ng A n n n d M dm d A x N
n d A n Rd y Nw Y k MG w H p
v n m n y p
m n n D n n m n y p m
ph dd d
v n m n y p
m n nD n n mn y p
J ph Kup Th n m n C nd n J u
n Ph phy
N wm n Th A g d Unwh m n n
m n y p nd p m
Kup n m n p
M kJ n g h unwh m n n
m n y nh Wh W ng w h n mn y M nd
N wm n Th A g d Unwh m n n
m n y p
N h p Fy Th An m y C m P n n
Un v y P
m n O nK h nd n m n y p
N wm n Th A g d Unwh m n n
m n y p
bd
Kup n m n p
N wm n Th A g d Unwh m n n
mn y p u d by Kup n n m n
p
m n O nK h nd n m n y p
On n k h h u n m n p
n n On K h nd n m n y p p nd p
m nd n n D n n mn y pp nd
p m
m n nD n n mn y p
m n On K h nd n m n y p nd
nD n n m n y p
m n nD n n mn y p
m n O nK h nd n m n y p
m n nD n n m n y p
Kup n m n p
bd p
D v dHum O h nd d T Th Ph
phy A d N nd Rd y p
Th m N C nd pp n h d n
ub y n n Th P d x J unk F n
h phy nd L u d u
p p n A n n p dP d x
G n n h C n x C nm n F mTh y nd Ph
phy d M u y m h n d R h d A n Ox d O x
d Un v y P
T h n d by A xN nd A n R d y n h
n ng d u n u nF gn gum n n n
ng h p u g dy N nd R d y p u h
h nd d p n g dy h F g n d
nd m gh u b n m n p n A gu ngAb u
A p
My hnk h n nd Hum n R
h C un C n d h g n u u pp my
w k