Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
WIL Plus
I don‟t know what your destiny will be, but one
thing I do know; the only ones among you who
will be really happy are those who have sought
and found how to serve.
Albert Schweitzer
Carol-joy Patrick Coordinator, Service Learning
Senior Lecturer
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Transformation testimonials
“Community Internship was THE best thing I’ve done in my life! It broadened my
social conscience; I saw how my actions can make a real impact on a child’s life; and
it influenced my career. It opened my eyes to inclusive practice which is now a life-
long commitment for my personal and professional life.” Phillip Poulton, Bachelor
of Music (Southbank)
“My internship with Student LINX greatly improved my English, and my engagement
with Australian people. I did something of value for the environment and I also helped
other international students socialise with Australians. My internship is one of the key
reasons I recently won a graduate internship with one of the world’s leading
banks.” Kang Sik Jo, Bachelor of Business (Gold Coast) International Student
“I expected to learn and I expected to grow in my Community Internship but it was
much more than I expected. I wasn’t expecting to see that my internship would make
such an impact on a whole family’s circumstances and future. That impact has
continued way past my internship. It was just fantastic. The internship also gave me
an insight into how I want to operate as a professional in the future.” Liz Wigan,
Bachelor of Social Work (Logan)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Today
1. Role of the University
2. On the same page: Service-learning (SL) definitions and alignment of SL
with WIL
3. Growth of SL and WIL in the North American and Australian contexts
4. Research from the literature that demonstrates students‟ personal and
professional development through SL
5. The Griffith University experience - Community Internship
6. Encore: But wait … there‟s more …
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Role of the university
“The sole purpose of the university is to pursue academic
research and to train future researchers. Any attempt to
concern ourselves with students‟ lives outside the classroom
amounts to discipleship and indoctrination.”
Kiss, E, Euben, J.P. (2010) Aim high: A response to Stanley Fish in Kiss, E, Euben, J. P. Eds.
Debating Moral Education: Rethinking the Role of the Modern University)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Role of the university
”... attempts to prescribe a single overriding aim or to limit the
purposes of college to the realm of intellectual development take too
narrow a view of the undergraduate experience and threaten to
impose a moratorium on efforts to nurture some extremely important
human qualities during four formative years of students‟ lives.
Instead, colleges should pursue a variety of purposes,
including a carefully circumscribed effort to foster generally
accepted values and behaviours, such as honesty and racial
tolerance...
Bok, Derek (2006) Our underachieving colleges. A candid look at how much students learn and why they should
be learning more. Princeton University Press, New Jersey
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Role of the university
“Educating citizens is one of the oldest aims of liberal learning
in the Western tradition, but it has not always coexisted
peaceably or on a par with other goals that higher education
also serves. Now, after a longish lull, “citizenship” is back on
the agenda, and a large and diverse group of educators have
signed on.”
Huber, M. T. & Hutchings, P. (2010) Civic Learning: Intersections and Interactions in Eds Smith,
M. B., Nowacek, R. S. & Bernstein, J. Citizenship across the Curriculum. Indiana University
Press. Bloomington Indiana
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Role of the university
“...no one is born a citizen. Citizens have to be made. We become not
merely rights-bearing humans but public selves through a complex
socialization that endows us with the knowledge , capacities, values, and
habits that we need for the reflective practice of democratic life.. „[w]e
must learn to be free,‟ argues the political theorist Benjamin Barber:
The literacy required to live in civil society, the competence to
participate in democratic communities, the ability to think critically
and act deliberately in a pluralistic world, the empathy that permits
us to hear and accommodate others, all involve skills that must be
acquired.
...there is no citizenship without education for citizenship.”
Scobey , D. (2010) Across: The Heterogeneity of Civic Education in Smith, M. B., Nowacek, R. S.
& Bernstein, J. Citizenship across the Curriculum. Indiana University Press. Bloomington Indiana)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Role of the university
“In 1996 Ernest Boyer exalted American colleges and universities as
“one of the greatest hopes for intellectual and civic progress in this
country.” But, he went on to say, “...for this hope to be fulfilled, the
academy must become a more vigorous partner in the search for
answers to our most pressing social, civil, economic and moral
problems, and must reaffirm its historic commitment to what I call the
scholarship of engagement.”
Sandman, L. R, Thornton, C. H & Jaeger, A. J. Eds. (2009) New Directions for Higher Education: Institutionalizing Community
Engagement in Higher Education: The First Wave of Carnegie Classified Institutions. Jossey-Bass
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Role of the university
“[W]hat universities … are mandated to make or to help to make is
human beings in the fullest sense of those words – not just trained
workers or knowledgeable citizens but responsible heirs and
members of human culture … Underlying the idea of a university –
the bringing together, the combining into one, of all the disciplines –
is the idea that good work and good citizenship are the inevitable by-
products of the making of a good – that is, a fully developed – human
being.”
Palmer, P., Zajonc, A., with M. Scribner. (2010) The Heart of Higher Education: A Call to Renewal: Transforming the Academy through
Collegial Conversations. Jossey-Bass. San Francisco. P 3. Quoting “Wendell Berry - The Loss of the University.” Home economics.
San Francisco: North Point Press, 1987. P. 77
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Role of the university
“One of the central problems facing the academy is how
disconnected many students feel their classroom learning is from
what so many of them refer to as “the real world.” The problem for
these students is ... a sense that their education is unfolding in
isolation from the world beyond the boundaries of their
campuses. If students feel their learning is often disconnected, if
they are not sufficiently engaged in the world with a fully developed
sense of agency, faculty bear some responsibility for this.”
Smith, M., Nowacek, R. S., and Bernstein, J. L. (2010 ) Introduction: Ending the Solitude of Citizenship Education in Smith, M. B.,
Nowacek, R. S. & Bernstein, J. Citizenship across the Curriculum. Indiana University Press. Bloomington Indiana
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Role of the university
“The moral climate on campus today is not healthy. Students face
more complex and perplexing ethical challenges than ever, but they
receive scarcely any guidance from the adults with whom they
interact each day on how to cope with them. ... The new treatments
offered by our culture are no more effective. Student needs for
direction are not well served by a narrow construal of ethics as
following the rules of a profession or by seat-of the pants newspaper
advice columns. We need stronger medicine than this.”
Hoekema, D. (2010) Is there an ethicist in the house? How can we tell? in Kiss, E, Euben, J. P. Eds. 2010 Debating Moral Education:
Rethinking the Role of the Modern University
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Service-learning is ...
WIL: an umbrella term
a range of approaches and strategies
integrates discipline theory with the practice of work
within a purposefully designed curriculum
(Patrick, Peach, Pocknee, 2008)
Academic service-learning
a pedagogical model
intentionally integrates
academic learning and relevant community service
(Howard, 2003)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Service-learning is ...
“..an active, creative ...[pedagogy] that integrates community service
with academic study in order to enhance a student‟s capacity to think
critically, solve problems practically , and function as a life-long
moral, democratic citizen in a democratic society.”
In most cases, service-learning takes place within an academic
course ....Service-learning also involves student reflection on the
service experience, an emphasis on providing genuine service to the
community, and the development of democratic, mutually beneficial,
and respectful relationships between the students and the community
members with whom they work.”
Benson, L., & Harkavy, I. (2003) Service-learring. In K. Christian & D. Levinson (Eds.), Encyclopaedia of community: From the village to the
virtual world (p. 1223). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Service-learning is ...
“Real” work – not just shadowing or observation
Conducted in not-for-profit organisations
Students are not paid
Is not “just” work-integrated learning
Reciprocal – benefit to student and to community
Learning is structured
Reflection is central
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Service-learning is ...
Service-LEARNING: Learning goals primary; service outcomes
secondary
SERVICE-Learning: Service outcomes primary; learning goals
secondary
service learning: Service and learning goals completely
separate [- sic]
SERVICE-LEARNING Service and learning goals of equal weight
and each enhances the other for all
participants.
Sigmon, R. (1994). Serving to Learn, Learning to Serve. Linking Service with Learning. Council for Independent
Colleges Report.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Service-learning is ...
Internships
Practicum
Clinical practice
Cooperative education
Fieldwork education
Service Learning
Real world learning
Placements
Experiential learning
Work experience
Industry experience
Professional practice Academic service learning, adult learning,
clinical attachments, clinical experience, competency assessment, corporate business management, employment experience, engaged learning, experiential placements, faculty internships, field placements, industry experience, industry links, industry placement, learning in the workplace, operational performance, practical projects, practical training, practice based education, practice-based learning, problem-based learning, professional experience, professional learning, sandwich, site visits, structured workplace learning, student employability, volunteering...
•
Patrick, Cj, Peach, D., Pocknee., Webb, F., Fletcher, M., & Pretto, G. (2008). The WIL Report: A National scoping
study. Brisbane Australia; Australian Learning & Teaching Council
WIL typology
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Growth of WIL & SL: North America
Extra-curricular and curricular service
Dewey‟s experiential education notions
Wisconson Idea – early 19thC – to improve society & democracy
Cooperative education – developing at the same time and really taking off
Engineering Coop – 1972)
1960‟s & 70‟s - – Political and social upheaval. Kennedy Peace Corp.
1964 - VISTA. 70‟s National Centre for Service-Learning.
1990‟s – National and community service act passed by congress – funding to
support service - National SL Clearing house, Americorp, etc
1985 Campus Compact established
Proliferation of SL activities on college campuses from the late 80‟s, early 90‟s
onward – ie – 25 year history
1993 – National Service Learning Clearinghouse and combined services –
Americorps, VISTA, Learn and Serve America into one agency.
NOW – WIL-type curriculum when class-based SL (missing WIL literature)
Some taken from Chapter 1: Understanding Service-Learning: History, Pedagogy, Philosophy.
http://nlu.nl.edu/cec/upload/Chapter-1.pdf
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Growth of WIL & SL: Australia
1983 - World Council and Assembly on Cooperative Education Conference in Melbourne.
At that time, Coop being used by predecessors to VU and Swinburne – then UTS and RMIT.
1987 Bob Laslett – WACE award to look at coop worldwide
1990 first Australian Coop conference in Melbourne – ACE
NZACE established 1991
Disincentives to academics to engage in scholarship of Coop
Late 1990‟s & early 2000‟s – Generic Skills agenda – demand for work-ready graduates;
growing use of “new” WIL – not just “old” WIL – i.e. Eng, Nursing, Teaching.
2005 – DEST CGS requirements for WIL experiences
2005– discussions with WACE – launch of ACEN in 2006
2008 – Macquarie introduces compulsory volunteering and other unis start thinking about
service institutionally (UWA, Griffith, QUT, UWS, Newcastle etc)
Increasing use as an institutional & secondary school strategy
2010 - Launch of SL chapter of ACEN and EA
2011 – Griffith first SL Summit
2013 – Griffith second SL Summit
Some taken from Patrick, C-j, & Kay, J. (2004) Establishing a New Nationwide Network for Promoting Cooperative and Work-
Integrated Education. In (Coll, R (eds)2004, International handbook for cooperative education: an international perspective of the
theory, research and practice of work-integrated learning, WACE, Boston.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
WIL: an umbrella term
a range of approaches and strategies
integrates discipline theory with the practice of work
within a purposefully designed curriculum
(Patrick, Peach, Pocknee, 2008)
Academic service-learning
a pedagogical model
intentionally integrates
academic learning and relevant community service
(Howard, 2003)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
Challenges of WIL
Ensuring equity and access
Managing expectations and competing demands
Improving communication & coordination
Ensuring worthwhile WIL (SL) placement experiences
Adequately resourcing WIL (SL)
Patrick, Peach, Pocknee, 2008
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
VOLUNTEERISM
Doing something altruistic
INTERNSHIP
Structured for student
learning benefit
SERVICE-LEARNING
Equal reciprocity.
Integrated within a
course.
COMMUNITY SERVICE
Structured Volunteerism
FIELD EDUCATION
Specific learning
acquisition in a field of
study
Furco, Andrew. “Service-Learning: A Balanced Approach to Experiential education.” Expanding Boundaries: Service Learning.
Washington DC: Corporation for National Service, 1996. 2-6.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
Some goals and outcomes are similar:
Learning through application of content
Work place skills and attributes
Team/group work is common
Communication and Reflection skills
Self confidence and identity
Respect for others; cross cultural competence
Value of education as door to opportunity (self and society)
Barbara Holland
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
Some goals and outcomes are different:
WIL is focussed on
Development of student as future professional
Practice of professional skills and culture
„Practical skills‟ – techniques, practices
SL is focused on
Development of student as a future member of local/global
community
Practice of personal and professional values
„Affective‟ skills – ethics, social responsibility, diversity, culture,
equality
Barbara Holland
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
Flinders – Work-Integrated Learning (Service-learning) is an
intentional, organized, supervised and assessed educational
activity that integrates theoretical learning with its applications
in the workplace (community).
Canberra - Work Integrated Learning (Service-learning) is a
deliberate and intentional learning in work (community),
supported by appropriate induction for students and
supervisors, and imaginatively embedded assessment.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
Purdue – Service learning (WIL) is an educational methodology
which combines community service (workplace experience) with
explicit academic learning objectives, preparation for community
(delete community) work, and deliberate reflection.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
RMIT - “Work integrated learning (WIL) is the umbrella term used at RMIT
to describe all educational programs, major learning activities and
assessments which combine and integrate learning and its workplace
application, regardless of whether this integration occurs in industry, in
the community or in the university and whether it is real or simulated.”
WIL can occur in the classroom. Can Service Learning?
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Alignment of WIL and SL
UWS Definition
Community-engaged or work-integrated learning:
A unit or component of a unit that enables a student to participate
in an approved learning activity that involves an interactive
learning partnership with external community organisations
(business, industry, government, not-for-profit or educational
sectors). The learning activity can be done individually or in
groups, must provide a clear knowledge benefit to student(s) and
the partner(s), and is linked to specific learning objectives
including the demonstration of academic knowledge/professional
skills related to the course of study.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Citizenship)
“... the findings of researchers indicate that colleges do produce
significant results in preparing students as citizens. ... studies
“almost invariably indicate changes during the college years in
students‟ political attitudes and values toward ... greater interest in
social and political issues and greater interest in and involvement in
the political process. ... More precisely... “net of other factors,
including prior levels of involvement, individuals with a bachelor‟s
degree (compared to those with only a high school diploma) were 1.8
times more likely to be frequently involved in political activities, 2.4
times more likely to be involved in community welfare groups, 1.5
times more likely to be highly committed to community leadership,
and 2.5 times more likely to vote in a national, state, or local election.”
Hoekema, D. (2010) Is there an ethicist in the house? How can we tell? in Kiss, E, Euben, J. P. Eds. 2010
Debating Moral Education: Rethinking the Role of the Modern University
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Citizenship)
“... researchers have shown that college graduates are much more
active civically and politically than those who have not attended
college (even after controlling for differences in intelligence, parental
education, and socio-economic background). In fact, political
scientists find that formal education is the most important factor in
explaining who does or does not go to the polls. Several studies
also suggest that certain courses and concentrations, notably in the
social sciences, and certain outside activities, such as
community service programs, have a positive effect on students‟
willingness to vote or to work to improve their communities following
graduation.”
Bok, Derek (2006) Our underachieving colleges. A candid look at how much students learn and why they should be learning more.
Princeton University Press, New Jersey
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Citizenship)
“Higher education benefits the public in other ways, such as higher
volunteering rates, more civic behaviour, and greater cultural
acceptance.”
“The increase comes primarily from people with degrees in
education, social sciences, agriculture or health.”
Graduate Winners: Assessing the public and private benefits of higher education. Grattan Institute.)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Citizenship)
“... we contend that service-learning provides the most important vehicle
of community engagement because „when service-learning is
institutionalized, then it is part of the academic culture of the institution, aligns
with the mission, becomes an enduring aspect of the curriculum that is
supported by more than a few faculty, improves other forms of pedagogy,
leads to other forms of civic scholarship, includes faculty roles and rewards,
is part of the experience of most students, and has widespread support,
understanding, and involvement of students, faculty, administration, and the
community. This leads us to the conclusion that service-learning, is, thus,
a necessary component of effective civic engagement and, if one cannot
measure and evaluate every aspect of civic engagement, then service-
learning is the most important critical indicator of a campus‟s civic
engagement.”
Bingle, Hatcher, Hamilton & Young quoted in Sandman, L. R, Thornton, C. H & Jaeger, A. J. Eds. (2009) New Directions for Higher
Education: Institutionalizing Community Engagement in Higher Education: The First Wave of Carnegie Classified Institutions. Jossey-Bass
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Range of developments)
“Among other things, the study found that service participation
positively affects students‟ commitment to their communities, to
helping others in difficulty, to promoting racial understanding, and to
influencing social values. In addition, service participation directly
influences the development of important life skills, such as
leadership ability, social self-confidence, critical thinking skills, and
conflict resolution skills. Service participation also has unique
positive effects on academic development, including knowledge
gained, grades earned, degrees sought after, and time devoted to
academic endeavours.
.
Astin, A W, Sax, L J and Avalos, J. (2003). Long-Term Effects of Volunteerism during the Undergraduate Years in Campus Compact
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Skill development)
“...controlling for students‟ pre-college disposition toward service,
students who spend time volunteering during college, compared
to those who do not volunteer, become more convinced that
individuals can change society, feel more committed to personally
affecting social change, and develop stronger leadership skills.”
Quoting Sax & Astin, Hoekema, D. (2010) Is there an ethicist in the house? How can we tell? in Kiss, E, Euben, J. P. Eds. 2010
Debating Moral Education: Rethinking the Role of the Modern University
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Contextual learning)
Learning Course Content:
“As long as faculty members related the service learning experience
directly to the course curriculum, service learning aided students in
learning more than in courses without service learning. Students
repeatedly mentioned the benefits of relevancy, enthusiasm, and
application of textbook material.”
Student voice: Service learning is different because “when you‟re
doing a project like simulations or case studies, you don‟t have to
worry about an end result” in terms of impact on real people.
American Association of Community Colleges. 2010. Improving Student Outcomes with Service Learning.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Increased learning)
Learning skills and knowledge:
“Students mentioned increases in reasoning, logic, leadership, and
confidence.”
Student voice: “I really think that people don‟t realize until they‟ve
done something like this what they‟re capable of doing.”
American Association of Community Colleges. 2010. Improving Student Outcomes with Service Learning.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Increased learning)
Benefits of service learning:
Student comments revealed that service learning increased retention
of academic content because it provided students with experiences
that had real-life consequences. Students enjoy “group-based”
learning in service-learning.
American Association of Community Colleges. 2010. Improving Student Outcomes with Service Learning.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research
Value of service learning:
Student voice: “Service learning is important for the benefit of
society in the long run because it builds character in us. It gets us
out there and makes us realize the difference between the teachings
and the potential that we have.”
American Association of Community Colleges. 2010. Improving Student Outcomes with Service Learning.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research (Retention)
Retention and persistence:
Student voice: ”It‟s helped me want to pursue my education in
that field and move on and get as high as I can.” Student voice:
“I‟ve seen them change their mind from merely wanting a two-
year degree to wanting a four-year degree, and from only
wanting a four-year degree to wanting a doctorate. And it‟s all
because of certain aspects of service learning we‟ve done. They
would sit there and they‟d say, „Wow! That is really cool! I want
to know more about that.‟”
American Association of Community Colleges. 2010. Improving Student Outcomes with Service Learning.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Community Internship (3002GIH)
Multi-disciplinary
10 Credit Point
Free-choice elective
Discipline-based or not – depends on student choice
People or planet (equalise disadvantage)
50 hrs (minimum) volunteering activity (Project, role, research)
Alignment with a personal Academic Advisor
Enrolments – GBS, Psych, International (30-40%), Masters (5%),
Overload (5%+)
2012 - 230 students; Circa 12,000+ hours volunteering; 70% of
students self-report continued volunteering
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Community Internship (3002GIH)
Assessment:
Assessment - Internship Plan, Peer Discussion, Internship Report
Focus on personal and professional development
Assessment aligned with and supported by 3 Lectures, 3 tutorials,
4 self-paced modules and Academic Advisor consultations.
Modules that support student development
Reflections and discussion central to the course
Transformative learning results
Future Plans:
a) Ist semester 1st year group unit; b) led by senior year students
working as Teaching Assistants in a Civic Leadership unit; and c)
Overseas development aid unit, and/or service study tours.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Encore
“Community service and community service-learning also offers
valuable spaces for college students to engage in identity
exploration. Erikson (1965, 1968) famously characterized
adolescence as the period in the lifespan in which individuals move
beyond a blind adherence to the beliefs, values, and worldview of
their parents and mentors and begin to seek out their own
understandings of the world around them. Erikson labelled this
exploration the adolescent “identity crisis” and characterized this
process as crucial to an individual‟s development of a mature adult
identity.
Seider, S., & Butin D. W. (2012) Introduction to Special Issue on “The Future of Community Engagement in Higher Education”. Journal
of College & Character. Vol 13, No 1, Feb 2012.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Encore
“More recently, Arnett (2000, 2004) has asserted that the period of
primary identity exploration for many individuals has shifted from
adolescence to emerging adulthood - the period in the lifespan from
approximately 18 to 26 years old. According to Arnett and
colleagues, it is this period of emerging adulthood “during which
youth are[most] free to explore potential identify alternatives without
having to assume permanent adult commitments” (Schwartz, Cote,
& Arnett, 2005, p. 204).
Seider, S., & Butin D. W. (2012) Introduction to Special Issue on “The Future of Community Engagement in Higher Education”. Journal
of College & Character. Vol 13, No 1, Feb 2012.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Encore
“Community service and community service-learning experiences
represent some of the most important spaces for college students to
encounter new and different understandings of the world. ... These
experiences offer emerging adults powerful „participatory
experiences‟ with both the recipients of the service as well as the
professionals organizing the service experiences. These
experiences „can promote a heightened and broadened sense of
connection to other people ...[and] encourage reflections on moral
and political questions‟ (Yates & Younnis, 1996, p. 87)
Seider, S., & Butin D. W. (2012) Introductin to Special Issue on “The Future of Community Engagemen tin Higher Education”. Journal of
College & Character. Vol 13, No 1, Feb 2012.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Encore
“Transformative learning involves experiencing a deep, structural
shift in the basic premises of thought, feelings, and actions. It is a
shift of consciousness that dramatically and irreversibly alters our
way of being in the world. Such a shift involves our understanding of
ourselves and our self-locations; our relationships with other humans
and with the natural world; our understanding of relations of power in
interlocking structures of class, race and gender; our body
awareness, our visions of alternative approaches to living; and our
sense of possibilities for social justice and peace and personal joy.”
O‟Sullivan, E. (2003). “Bringing a perspective of transformative learning to globalized consumption.” International Journal of Consumer
Studies, 27 (4), 326-330.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Encore
Nicolas
Hemal
Extended family volunteering
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
SL Student outcomes research
LOW SES SL impacts
Increases aspirational goals to attend university
Increases gpa for university participants
Increases retention at university
Increases graduation rates
A promising connection: Increasing College Access and Success. Cress et al. (2010) Campus Compact. www.compact.org.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Encore
“More recently it has emerged that high-quality civic engagement
also increases access and student success ... Many colleges and
universities are responding by deliberately tying civic engagement
activities into access and success initiatives.
“Findings from these and similar programs show that intentionally
designed and well-executed efforts result in increased student
learning, retention, and graduation rates. In short, civic engagement
works.”
Cress, C., Burack, C, Giles, D., Elkins, J. & Stevens, M. (2010),. A promising Connection: Increasing College access and success
through civic engagement. Campus compact.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Encore
“Community Internship was THE best thing I’ve done in my life! It broadened my
social conscience; I saw how my actions can make a real impact on a child’s life; and
it influenced my career. It opened my eyes to inclusive practice which is now a
life-long commitment for my personal and professional life.” Phillip Poulton,
Bachelor of Music (Southbank)
“My internship with (please insert name of org/activity) greatly improved my English,
and my engagement with Australian people. I did something of value for the
environment and I also helped other international students socialise with
Australians. My internship is one of the key reasons I recently won a graduate
internship with one of the world’s leading banks.” Kang Sik Jo, Bachelor of
Business (Gold Coast) International Student
“I expected to learn and I expected to grow in my Community Internship but it was
much more than I expected. I wasn’t expecting to see that my internship would make
such an impact on a whole family’s circumstances and future. That impact has
continued way past my internship. It was just fantastic. The internship also gave
me an insight into how I want to operate as a professional in the future.” Liz
Wigan, Bachelor of Social Work (Logan)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Encore
...”service-learning [is] an important tool in the development of
employment choices and civic leadership. Alumni with a history of
high-quality service-learning experiences were more likely to accept
employment in service-related fields. In addition, alumni with a
history of service-learning did increasingly more volunteer service as
they got older.
Warchal, J & Ruiz, A. (2004). The long-term effects of undergraduate service-learning programs on postgraduate
employment choices, community engagement, and civic leadership. In Service-Learning: Research to advance the field
(Eds Welch, M & Billig, S. IAP, Greenwich, Connecticut.(p104)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
WIL and SL alignment
In their extensive review of the literature on service-learning, Eyler, Giles, Stenson,
and Gray (2001) found a range of benefits for students:
As noted by both students and faculty, service-learning has a positive impact on students‟
academic learning and on their ability to apply what they have learned in the “real world.”
Service-learning improves student satisfaction with college, and students engaged in service-
learning are more likely to graduate.
Service-learning has a positive effect on students sense of personal efficacy, personal
identify, interpersonal development, ability to work well with others, spiritual and moral
development, and leadership and communication skills.
Service-learning has a positive effect on reducing stereotypes and facilitating cultural
and racial understanding.
Service-learning has a positive effect on social responsibility and citizenship skills.
Finally, work in the community [volunteering] can give students a leg up in gaining
employment after graduation.
Cress, C., Burack, C, Giles, D., Elkins, J. & Stevens, M. (2010),. A promising Connection: Increasing College
access and success through civic engagement. Campus Compact.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Resources
1. Campus Compact www.compact.org (An association of 1200 University and College
Presidents in the U.S.A. to promote service learning. A huge range of resources on service
learning including books, and syullabus (unit/subject) outlines.)
2. National Service Learning Clearinghouse www.servicelearning.org (Covers service learning
from primary school through university and a range of resources available here.)
3. Service Learning Handbook (Diana Whitton and Catherine Walbank) Pearson. 2011. (A very
good book for use by students, but also a great “how to” book for practicalities of service
learning.)
4. Yorio, P., & Feifei, Y. (2012). A Meta-Analysis on the Effects of Service-Learning on the Social,
Personal, and Cognitive Outcomes. Vol 11, No 1, 9-27 (A good recent compilation of service
learning outcomes.)
5. A promising connection: Increasing College access and success through civic engagement.
Campus Compact 2010 (A document originating from a President’s council at Campus
Compact which demonstrates the power of service in positively impacting aspirations and
retention of low SES college/university students.)
6. At a Glance: What we Know about the effects of service-learning on college students, faculty,
Institutions and communities, 1993-2000: Third Edition (NCLLLL clearing house source.A
national study of college students‟ search for meaning and purpose. (2006?)Principal
researchers – Astin W, and Astin H.
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)
Resources
7. Simonet, D. (2008) Service-Learning and academic success: The links to retention research.
Minnesota Campus Compact.
8. Zlotkowski, E., Longo, N., & Williams, J. (Eds) 2006) Students as Colleagues. Campus
Compact Boston (A fantastic book that promotes the idea of thinking of students as colleagues
in the design and delivery of service learning activities.)
9. Brewis, G., Russell, J & Holdsworth, C. (2010) Bursting the Bubble: Students, Volunteering and
the Community. Institute for Volunteering Research
10. Atelier Learning Solutions PL. (2006) A national role for further development of service
learning in Australia. Final Report. Prepared for DEST. (A report commissioned by the
Australian Government to explore how service learning might be applied in Australia.)
Griffith University Service Learning. EM: [email protected] PH: 07 3382 1781)