feature Commercial scale hemp construction
facility to reduce energy consumption The key areas for
consideration were airtightness thermal mass and high
levels of insulation
Construction The architects first became aware of Tradical Hemcrete at
the concept design stage while researching alternatives to
the initial suggestions of either in situ or precast concrete
as the primary walling element Hemcrete is manufactured
from locally grown hemp shiv - the woody core of the
plant - which is mixed with a lime-based binder to form
a composite material which is carbon negative and has a
high thermal inertia giving it excellent thermal and acoustic
properties but the suitability of the product for a large
scale commercial project was untested
Hemp spraying had been used extensively on domestic
projects but not before on a building the size of the Wine
Societys warehouse project where calculations had
suggested that to accommodate the required volume of
wine (about 3500000 bottles) within the 3250m 2 floor
area the building would have to be up to 21 m high
A visit to the recently completed Adnams brewery
warehouse in Southwold confirmed the benefits of hemp
in terms of thermal performance and carbon emissions
but did not resolve the design teams concerns that this
product which had previously been used in a domestic
capacity had no track record as part of a large scale
commercial development
Winner oftwo awards and recently short-listed for
the national RICS Sustainability Award The Wine
Society Warehouse Stevenage is a fine example
of a simple green industrial building It uses a
combination of insulating external envelope and
interior thermal mass - the wine - to achieve an
impressively low energy consumption avoiding all
forms of bolt-on bling Olwyn Pritchard and Geoff
Yeates report
In 2007 the Wine Society realised it needed a fourth
wine warehouse at its main Stevenage site and appointed
local arcllitects and town planners Vincent and Gorbing
Associates to lead their selected design team which
included MLM Consultants as both structural and services
engineers and project managers Millbridge With ever-inshy
creasing energy costs a major concern the society was
keen to limit as far as possible the additional burden that a
new building would impose on the site s running costs and
the g rowing need for an energy efficient building became a
fJr llT1ary feature of the design brief
Green Building bull
The Wine Society is a non profit making wine organisation
owned by its members It was established in 1874 for the
purpose of sourcing importing storing and distributing
wine to its members all of whom are shareholders
Most of its operations are located in Steven age
Hertfordshire from where it provides over seven million
bottles of wine a year to its 100000 members across the
country
Vincent and Gorbing has been actively involved in
sustainable architecture since 1999 when the practices
first passively ventilated office building the headquarters
of an expanding housing association was commissioned
Once completed the newly occupied office building became
the focus of a long-term exercise in modelling the diurnal
and nocturnal airflows in naturally ventilated buildings which
was carried out by the Cambridge University-based BP
Institute for Multiphase Flow Building on this experience
the practice has put sustainability at the core of its design
philosophy for all new projects
The initial design team meetings with The Wine Society
involved discussions about sustainability and the need to
retain a steady-state environment within the new storage
16 Winter 2010 Green Building 17
Top far left the outside of the finished building Here can be seen the final cladding over the hemcrete panels and also the external aspect of the Kalwall insulated walling system
Above the Kalwall wall insulating glazing system allows light to enter the building and thus help to save on artificial lighting
Left and insets The hemcrete panels being constructed distributed and installed
Nevertheless the unique properties of Hemcrete shy
thermal mass carbon negative air permeability etc - made
it the first choice for the external envelope Vincent and
Gorbing and the design team developed the idea of using
the sprayed form of Hemcrete in large pre-fabricated
wooden cassettes measuring 24m high 36m wide and
300mm thick
The cassettes were framed up using standard TJI
joists with the backing made from Samox board which
is both breathable and vapour permeable like Hemcrete
and which forms the visible inside face of the external
wall construction The cassettes were then transported
to a disused airfield in Suffolk where they were sprayed
and cured before delivery to the site in Stevenage Here
they were stacked up and tied back to a structural steel
frame for both support and stability Between the walling
Winter 2010
Feature Commercial scale hemp construction
cassettes and the external cladding (a composite metal
panelling system) is a void quite literally a breath ing space
which provides natural ventilation for the Hemcrete
Extensive discussions followed with the structural
engineers to see if the Hemcrete cassette system could be
adapted for the roof construction Unfortunately structural
limitations and cost constraints precluded the use of this
approach and a more conventional roof construction was
adopted
From an ea rl y stage in the monitoring process it was
clea r that the building was demonstrating remarkable
temperature stability with very little use of the MampE
insta llations notwithstanding significant daily external
temperature variations and extended periods of sub-zero
temperatures during the winter of 2009 20 10 The table
below indicates the actual recorded end-of-year energy
usage figu res compared to the projected f igures from the
thermal model and the savings both in terms o f kWh per
ann um and in terms of CO per annum
- - ~ -~~
Project ed energy usage 384948kWh 358961kWh
Recorded energy usage 52628kWh 295490kWh
Saving
kWh - kg CO2
conversion factors
Saving in CO2
pa
332320kWh
0192
63805kg (638 tonnes)
63471kWh
0422
26784kg (2678 tonnes)
All flgures per annum
Another design innovation was the use of a Ka lwa ll
translucen l wa lling sys lem to the whole of the north
elevation of the warehouse Kalwall has good thermal
insulation properties but also allows a high level of daylight
penetration and its northerly aspect meant that there was
little or no risk of solar heat gain throughout the year
At the time of its construction the internal ra ck ing
system for the pa llets hold ing t he wine was at 18m the
highest insta lled anywhere in the world In its own way this
was quite an achievement but the compact nature of t he
wine storage was t o be a significant part of the energy
saving t hat was a fundamenta l briefing requirement Wine
has a si milar density t o water and a similar t hermal mass
the presence of over 2500m3 of wine would both provide
the thermoI moss ond be an essential element in stabilising
the internal temperature a key factor not only in energy
efficiency but also in the storage of wine in its optimum
condition
The building was completed by Morgan As hurst now
Morgan Sindall in the autumn of 2008 and over the
following months the Wine Societys staff began stocking
the building and familiarising themselves wi th its operating
requirements Once thi s initial period was complete the
projects services engineers MLM Consulting Engineers
and the Wine Society monitored the internal and external
temperatures for a full year along with the building s
consumption of both gas for heating and electricity for
lighting
Monitoring of energy use MLM and The Wine Society closely monitored the energy
costs against th e projections of a thermal model that MLM
had developed at the design stage t o enable evaluati ons of
al ternate construction systems
Green Building bull
These figures are some 65 better than expected
from the thermal model in effect quantify ing the dynamic
component of the Hemcrete and translating into a
significant reduction in an nual running costs of
Electricity at 73pkWh = pound 13854
Gas at 27pkWh = pound8972
Taking the two CO savings which total 905 tonnes
of CO per an num the total carbon reduction ove r the
projected 40-year life of the bu ilding is over 3600 tonnes
of CO2
Some 730m3 of Hemcrete was used on this development
As a ca rbon negative mat erial wit h an embodied carbon
figure of 130kg COi m3 this equates to an additional
contribution of 949 tonnes of CO ~
The existing warehouses on the site have been
constructed to various different standard s and have
different levels and ages of equipment However it is
interesting to make a comparison between t he new and the
old warehouses by comparing the energy usage in terms
of kWh used per m of warehouse space This exercise
indicated t hat the new warehouse is operating in the order
of 70 more efficiently than the existing warehouses
There is little doubt that this building is a success
story for the Wine Society Its design teams innovative
concept has been able to exceed the societys dual green
aspirations for a highly sustainable building and radical
reductions in its energy costs as well as demonstrating
convincingly that sustainable design techniques are now as
applicable to commercial high bay warehousing as they are
to smaller sca le developments
Oliver Johnson ch ief executive of the Wine Society
18 Winter 2010
I ommented Our priority is providing members wit h high
( IIJa lity wines and services so we have to take a practical
Ipproach projects must make sense commercially as well
lt1$ environmentally Temperature contro l is important in the
long term storage of wine so clearly good insulation helped
ltlchieve both goals We used an alternative material called
Hemcrete Not only does thi s have exce llent insulation
properties but it is also carbon negative Somewhat more
xpensive to construct perhaps but it brought good
avings in equipment and energy
Furthermore the energy reductions arise solely from
Ihe design of the bu ild ing and wi ll be fully ach ievab le for
the whole life of the building without further interventions
Keith Laid law Project Technica l Director of consulting
engineers MLM said Each project needs to be considered
on its own merits but this particu lar project has
dem onstrated how with an environmentally aware client
and an innovative design team modern green technology
can be integrated into buildings where their use would not
normally have been considered with dramatic effects on
energy usage and long term benefits to the environment
Mark Chandler Vincent and Gorbings Project Director
sa id We firmly believe that the design team s principal idea
o f capturing Hemcrete in prefabricated walling units has
ope ned up a world of new opportunities in the sustainable
(Jesign and construct ion of large sca le industrial buildings
Being able to achieve long t erm carbon reduc tions and
energy savings
)ur most signifi
ust ainability
in
cant
such
con
an innovative
tribution yet to
way
the
makes
concept of
this
Awards The awards wh ich the building has so far gained are first
prize in the susta inability category of the RICS 2010 East
o f England Awards in May this year and in December 2009
Vincent amp Gorbing was awarded the Herfordshire based
Building Futures Award for Outstand ing Commitment to
Adapt to a Changing Climate Judges we re impressed at the
use of innovative technologies such as Hemcrete within
its construction They sa id The Wine Society Warehouse
points the way forward for bu ildings that are traditionally
unsustainable and vulnerable to a changing c limate
Geoff Yeates and Olwyn Pritchard
The team
Client The Wine Society Stevenage
Architect Vincent and Gorbing Associates
Structural engineer MLM Consul ting Engineers
Build ing services engi neer MLM Consulting Engineers
Project manager Millbridge
Cost cons ultant RLF Stevenage
DampB contracto r Morgan Ashurst (now Morgan Sindall)
Hemcrete Lime Tech no logy Ltd
Kalwall Stoakes Systems Ltd (advert below)
Geoff Yeate s i6 a ch ar~rt d arc hi t ect now work inlj
part~timc a ll a consu ltant for Yincent and Garbing
hay ing fe cent-Iy retired j5 tt director of the pra ct ice In
h ie ~ pa re t ime he monltorSo the pf rfoman ce of t he Wine
Soc jttl~ P1 C1 Ww~re hOu ge in formally by sampling it e
COrltents on an occa ~ i o n al bS5is
G[OFFnATpoundSVINCEIIIIT-(iQR8INC COaUK
Olwyn Prltchard is on ~l ine t1C W5 cdi tor for t he Green
Bui ld ing Press and poundI regu la r contr ib utor to the
m agazin e She hae a 1Il ri e a bZlckg ro und I n c ludin~ 9 0me
t ime pent exp er ienc ing 50cial hou8ing comm un ity 1ill ig
low Impac t living and a lon g ~til nd i ng intere9 t In green
ieeue5
OlWVH GREEH9UILDINGPIUSCOUK
KALWALLreg
Energy saving Kalwall is green because it reduces dependence on artificial light
It diffuses calming restful light for the worker which increases productivity
For cladding and roofing it creates a perfect ambience for all building types including
this Wine Society warehouse (right)
Stoakes Systems Ltd Tel 0208 660 7667
wwwstoakescouk
Green Building bull 19 Winter 2010
Feature Commercial scale hemp construction
cassettes and the external cladding (a composite metal
panelling system) is a void quite literally a breath ing space
which provides natural ventilation for the Hemcrete
Extensive discussions followed with the structural
engineers to see if the Hemcrete cassette system could be
adapted for the roof construction Unfortunately structural
limitations and cost constraints precluded the use of this
approach and a more conventional roof construction was
adopted
From an ea rl y stage in the monitoring process it was
clea r that the building was demonstrating remarkable
temperature stability with very little use of the MampE
insta llations notwithstanding significant daily external
temperature variations and extended periods of sub-zero
temperatures during the winter of 2009 20 10 The table
below indicates the actual recorded end-of-year energy
usage figu res compared to the projected f igures from the
thermal model and the savings both in terms o f kWh per
ann um and in terms of CO per annum
- - ~ -~~
Project ed energy usage 384948kWh 358961kWh
Recorded energy usage 52628kWh 295490kWh
Saving
kWh - kg CO2
conversion factors
Saving in CO2
pa
332320kWh
0192
63805kg (638 tonnes)
63471kWh
0422
26784kg (2678 tonnes)
All flgures per annum
Another design innovation was the use of a Ka lwa ll
translucen l wa lling sys lem to the whole of the north
elevation of the warehouse Kalwall has good thermal
insulation properties but also allows a high level of daylight
penetration and its northerly aspect meant that there was
little or no risk of solar heat gain throughout the year
At the time of its construction the internal ra ck ing
system for the pa llets hold ing t he wine was at 18m the
highest insta lled anywhere in the world In its own way this
was quite an achievement but the compact nature of t he
wine storage was t o be a significant part of the energy
saving t hat was a fundamenta l briefing requirement Wine
has a si milar density t o water and a similar t hermal mass
the presence of over 2500m3 of wine would both provide
the thermoI moss ond be an essential element in stabilising
the internal temperature a key factor not only in energy
efficiency but also in the storage of wine in its optimum
condition
The building was completed by Morgan As hurst now
Morgan Sindall in the autumn of 2008 and over the
following months the Wine Societys staff began stocking
the building and familiarising themselves wi th its operating
requirements Once thi s initial period was complete the
projects services engineers MLM Consulting Engineers
and the Wine Society monitored the internal and external
temperatures for a full year along with the building s
consumption of both gas for heating and electricity for
lighting
Monitoring of energy use MLM and The Wine Society closely monitored the energy
costs against th e projections of a thermal model that MLM
had developed at the design stage t o enable evaluati ons of
al ternate construction systems
Green Building bull
These figures are some 65 better than expected
from the thermal model in effect quantify ing the dynamic
component of the Hemcrete and translating into a
significant reduction in an nual running costs of
Electricity at 73pkWh = pound 13854
Gas at 27pkWh = pound8972
Taking the two CO savings which total 905 tonnes
of CO per an num the total carbon reduction ove r the
projected 40-year life of the bu ilding is over 3600 tonnes
of CO2
Some 730m3 of Hemcrete was used on this development
As a ca rbon negative mat erial wit h an embodied carbon
figure of 130kg COi m3 this equates to an additional
contribution of 949 tonnes of CO ~
The existing warehouses on the site have been
constructed to various different standard s and have
different levels and ages of equipment However it is
interesting to make a comparison between t he new and the
old warehouses by comparing the energy usage in terms
of kWh used per m of warehouse space This exercise
indicated t hat the new warehouse is operating in the order
of 70 more efficiently than the existing warehouses
There is little doubt that this building is a success
story for the Wine Society Its design teams innovative
concept has been able to exceed the societys dual green
aspirations for a highly sustainable building and radical
reductions in its energy costs as well as demonstrating
convincingly that sustainable design techniques are now as
applicable to commercial high bay warehousing as they are
to smaller sca le developments
Oliver Johnson ch ief executive of the Wine Society
18 Winter 2010
I ommented Our priority is providing members wit h high
( IIJa lity wines and services so we have to take a practical
Ipproach projects must make sense commercially as well
lt1$ environmentally Temperature contro l is important in the
long term storage of wine so clearly good insulation helped
ltlchieve both goals We used an alternative material called
Hemcrete Not only does thi s have exce llent insulation
properties but it is also carbon negative Somewhat more
xpensive to construct perhaps but it brought good
avings in equipment and energy
Furthermore the energy reductions arise solely from
Ihe design of the bu ild ing and wi ll be fully ach ievab le for
the whole life of the building without further interventions
Keith Laid law Project Technica l Director of consulting
engineers MLM said Each project needs to be considered
on its own merits but this particu lar project has
dem onstrated how with an environmentally aware client
and an innovative design team modern green technology
can be integrated into buildings where their use would not
normally have been considered with dramatic effects on
energy usage and long term benefits to the environment
Mark Chandler Vincent and Gorbings Project Director
sa id We firmly believe that the design team s principal idea
o f capturing Hemcrete in prefabricated walling units has
ope ned up a world of new opportunities in the sustainable
(Jesign and construct ion of large sca le industrial buildings
Being able to achieve long t erm carbon reduc tions and
energy savings
)ur most signifi
ust ainability
in
cant
such
con
an innovative
tribution yet to
way
the
makes
concept of
this
Awards The awards wh ich the building has so far gained are first
prize in the susta inability category of the RICS 2010 East
o f England Awards in May this year and in December 2009
Vincent amp Gorbing was awarded the Herfordshire based
Building Futures Award for Outstand ing Commitment to
Adapt to a Changing Climate Judges we re impressed at the
use of innovative technologies such as Hemcrete within
its construction They sa id The Wine Society Warehouse
points the way forward for bu ildings that are traditionally
unsustainable and vulnerable to a changing c limate
Geoff Yeates and Olwyn Pritchard
The team
Client The Wine Society Stevenage
Architect Vincent and Gorbing Associates
Structural engineer MLM Consul ting Engineers
Build ing services engi neer MLM Consulting Engineers
Project manager Millbridge
Cost cons ultant RLF Stevenage
DampB contracto r Morgan Ashurst (now Morgan Sindall)
Hemcrete Lime Tech no logy Ltd
Kalwall Stoakes Systems Ltd (advert below)
Geoff Yeate s i6 a ch ar~rt d arc hi t ect now work inlj
part~timc a ll a consu ltant for Yincent and Garbing
hay ing fe cent-Iy retired j5 tt director of the pra ct ice In
h ie ~ pa re t ime he monltorSo the pf rfoman ce of t he Wine
Soc jttl~ P1 C1 Ww~re hOu ge in formally by sampling it e
COrltents on an occa ~ i o n al bS5is
G[OFFnATpoundSVINCEIIIIT-(iQR8INC COaUK
Olwyn Prltchard is on ~l ine t1C W5 cdi tor for t he Green
Bui ld ing Press and poundI regu la r contr ib utor to the
m agazin e She hae a 1Il ri e a bZlckg ro und I n c ludin~ 9 0me
t ime pent exp er ienc ing 50cial hou8ing comm un ity 1ill ig
low Impac t living and a lon g ~til nd i ng intere9 t In green
ieeue5
OlWVH GREEH9UILDINGPIUSCOUK
KALWALLreg
Energy saving Kalwall is green because it reduces dependence on artificial light
It diffuses calming restful light for the worker which increases productivity
For cladding and roofing it creates a perfect ambience for all building types including
this Wine Society warehouse (right)
Stoakes Systems Ltd Tel 0208 660 7667
wwwstoakescouk
Green Building bull 19 Winter 2010