C M Y K Nxxx,2016-11-03,A,001,Bs-4C,E2_+
The roster of retired military of-ficers endorsing Hillary Clinton inSeptember glittered with decora-tion and rank. One former generalled the American surge in Anbar,one of the most violent provincesin Iraq. Another commandedAmerican-led allied forces bat-tling the Taliban in Afghanistan.Yet another trained the first Iraqisto combat Islamic insurgents intheir own country.
But as Election Day ap-proaches, many veterans are in-stead turning to Donald J. Trump,a businessman who avoided theVietnam draft and has boasted ofgathering foreign policy wisdomby watching television shows.
Even as other voters abandonMr. Trump, veterans remainamong his most loyal supporters,an unlikely connection forged bythe widening gulf they feel fromother Americans.
After 15 years at war, many whoserved in Iraq or Afghanistan areproud of their service but ex-hausted by its burdens. They dis-trust the political class that re-shaped their lives and are frus-trated by how little their fellow cit-izens seem to understand abouttheir experience.
Perhaps most strikingly, theywelcome Mr. Trump’s blunt at-tacks on America’s entangle-ments overseas.
“When we jump into wars with-out having a real plan, things likeVietnam and things like Iraq andAfghanistan happen,” saidWilliam Hansen, a former Marinewho served two National Guardtours in Iraq. “This is 16 years.This is longer than Vietnam.”
In small military towns in Cali-fornia and North Carolina, veter-ans of all eras cheer Mr. Trump’spromises to fire officials at the De-partment of Veterans Affairs. Hisattacks on political correctnessevoke their frustrations with tor-tured rules of engagement craftedto serve political, not military,ends. In Mr. Trump’s forceful as-sertion of strength, they find abalm for wounds that left thembroken and torn.
“He calls it out,” said JoshuaMacias, a former Navy petty offi-cer and fifth-generation veteran
Trump HoldsStrong AppealWith Veterans
Praised for His BluntTalk on War’s Costs
By NICHOLAS CONFESSORE
Continued on Page A18
U(D54G1D)y+&!,!&!=!]
The internet was supposed to be a boonto democracy, but when confronted withinformation choices, people often re-treat to the echo chamber of their ownbeliefs, Farhad Manjoo writes. PAGE B1
BUSINESS DAY B1-9
Digital’s Loose Grip on TruthA new exhibitioncounters the no-tion that thepainter’s late,dark-hued worksreflect an innerangst, and hisbrighter onesoptimism. PAGE C1
ARTS C1-8
Rothko’s Palette, Illuminated
CASA GRANDE, Ariz. — Sincemoving to Arizona 15 years ago,Nieves Lorenzo watched as His-panics grew in numbers but onlyhaltingly asserted themselves asa political force. Then came Don-ald J. Trump’s presidential candi-dacy.
“He has woken up the sleepinggiant,” Ms. Lorenzo, a native ofVenezuela, said as she stood in alocal Democratic campaign head-quarters here in the desert be-tween Phoenix and Tucson.
By driving women, educatedwhite voters and, most signifi-cantly, growing blocs of minoritiesaway from the Republican Party,Mr. Trump has hastened socialand political changes already wellunderway in two key regions, theinterior West and the upper South,that not long ago tilted to the right.
Now, even as Hillary Clinton
contends with inflamed Demo-cratic anxiety over renewed scru-tiny of her private email server,these once-red areas are provid-ing an unexpected firewall for hercampaign.
Democrats are already stronglyconfident of victory in three ofthem — Colorado, Nevada andVirginia — and believe that afourth, North Carolina, is likely tobreak their way as well. Added tothe party’s daunting advantage inthe Electoral College, these stateshave impeded Mr. Trump’s path toamassing the 270 electoral votesneeded to win, limiting his abilityto exploit Mrs. Clinton’s late vul-nerabilities and forcing him toscrounge for unlikely support insolidly Democratic places likeMichigan and New Mexico.
The shift is stark enough that
In Changing Regions, TrumpMakes Inroads for Democrats
By JONATHAN MARTIN and ALEXANDER BURNS
Continued on Page A17
Tim Arango entered the city ofMosul, Iraq, on Wednesday withIraqi special forces soldiers.
For the first time in more thantwo years, residents of easternMosul enjoyed a day without theIslamic State. As Iraqi securityforces drove the muddy streets of
the neighborhood, familiesstepped from the gates of theirdriveways, waving, flashing two-fingered victory signs and yelling,“Heroes!” Others held whiteflags.
Some men, in ankle-length Arabgowns in the jihadist-regulationstyle, were smoking cigarettes,while others had them tucked be-hind their ears. They were cele-
brating the Iraqi forces’ victoryover the Islamic State in their areaby savoring some of the smallpleasures banned under morethan two years of militant rule.
“We are very, very happy,” saidone man, Qais Hassan, 46, sur-rounded by soldiers. “Now wehave our freedom.” The IslamicState, he said, had “asked us to im-plement religion. But they had
nothing to do with religion.”Iraqi soldiers were seeing first-
hand what life in Mosul had beenlike under Islamic State rule im-posed in 2014. But they were alsocatching a glimpse of some of thechallenges ahead, simultaneouslypressing the fight toward the citycenter and going about the messybusiness of re-establishing gov-
As Forces Start Clearing Mosul, Iraqis Cheer, Shave and SmokeBy TIM ARANGO
Continued on Page A12
MAULVIWALA, India — Des-perate to reduce the pollution thathas made New Delhi’s air qualityamong the worst in the world, thecity has banned private cars fortwo-week periods and cam-paigned to reduce its ubiquitousfireworks during holiday celebra-tions.
But one thing India has not seri-ously tried could make the mostdifference: curtailing the fires setto rice fields by hundreds of thou-sands of farmers in the nearbystates of Punjab and Haryana,where much of the nation’s wheatand rice is grown.
Although India’s environmentalcourt, the National Green Tri-bunal, told the government lastyear to stop farmers from burningthe straw left over from their riceharvests, NASA satellite images
in recent weeks have shownvirtually no abatement. Farmersare continuing to burn most of theleftover straw — an estimated 32million tons — to make room toplant their winter wheat crop.
While fireworks associatedwith the Hindu holiday of Diwaliwere blamed for a particularlybad smog problem in recent days,smoke from the crop fires blowingacross the northern plains intoNew Delhi accounts for about one-quarter of the most dangerous airpollution in the winter months. Inthe growing metropolis of nearly20 million people, pollution soared
well above hazardous levels in thepast week.
Farmers 100 miles north in Pun-jab were well aware that theywere contaminating the capital’sair, they said in interviews, andwere willing to consider otherways to dispose of the excessstraw, but could not afford the op-tions offered by the government.
“We are smart, and we haveadopted new technology in thepast,” said Jaswant Singh, 53, ashe watched a fire sweep across a20-acre field near his village,Maulviwala, about 140 milesnorthwest of New Delhi.
He planned to set his own sev-en-and-a-half-acre rice paddyablaze in a couple of days, he said,“because we can’t afford to pay forthe new technology ourselves.”
The air was thick with smokethat evening as I drove the twohours back to Punjab’s capital,
Outlawed Crop Fires Fuel India’s Air PollutionBy GEETA ANAND
A farmer burned a harvested wheat field last month on the outskirts of Jalandhar, India.SHAMMI MEHRA/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE — GETTY IMAGES
Known Cause, KnownCure but Continuing
Health Hazard
Continued on Page A6
CHAPEL HILL, N.C. — Presi-dent Obama threw the power ofthe White House behind HillaryClinton on Wednesday. He faultedhow the F.B.I. director, James B.Comey, handled new emails relat-ed to the investigation into Mrs.Clinton’s private server, and thenshouted out to college studentshere in a pivotal battlegroundstate that it was crucial that theyvote because the “fate of the worldis teetering.”
Mr. Obama’s comments aboutMr. Comey, broadcast early in theday as recent polls showed a tight-ening race, were striking for apresident who has insisted hedoes not comment on F.B.I. inves-tigations. But Mr. Obama ap-peared to be doing exactly that inimplicitly criticizing Mr. Comey’sdecision to send a vague letter lastweek to Congress — and by exten-sion, the public — informing law-makers about a discovery of newemails related to Mrs. Clinton’suse of a private server as secre-tary of state.
“We don’t operate on incom-plete information,” Mr. Obamasaid in an interview with NowThisNews. “We don’t operate on leaks.We operate based on concrete de-cisions that are made.”
Without mentioning Mr. Comeyby name — although it was clearwhom he meant — Mr. Obamasuggested that the F.B.I. had vio-lated investigative guidelines andtrafficked in innuendo by alertingCongress last week. Mr. Obama’sremarks, which followed searingcriticism of the F.B.I. director from
PRESIDENT FAULTSF.B.I. AND FIRES UPCLINTON FAITHFUL
CRITICIZES EMAIL ‘LEAKS’
Obama Tells Crowd inNorth Carolina Vote
Hinges on Them
This article is by Jonathan Mar-tin, Adam Goldman and GardinerHarris.
President Obama in ChapelHill, N.C., on Wednesday.
AL DRAGO/THE NEW YORK TIMES
Continued on Page A16
TUNED IN Jay Z and other musi-cians are going on the road tosupport Hillary Clinton. PAGE C1
SEXUAL HARASSMENT At its core,it is about power, and politics is apower profession. PAGE A14
An Iowa man described as a troubledloner was in custody in the deaths oftwo officers near Des Moines who weregunned down in the driver’s seats oftheir patrol cars. PAGE A15
Surrender in Officers’ Killings
A warming planetis responsible forthe bright colors offall lasting so latein the year, scien-tists say. What willhappen over thelong term is lesscertain. PAGE A20
NATIONAL A14-20
Longer Lasting Color in Fall
An Australian nurse offering free carefor battered and overworked horses inthe shadows of the Pyramids faceshostility from their owners. PAGE A4
Healing Cairo’s Horses
The United States’ alliances are feelingstrained over the South China Sea, afterthe Philippines agreed to a deal withChina on fishing. PAGE A13
Churning Alliances in Asia
Volkswagen, a pioneer in revealing itshistory of using forced labor in WorldWar II, has set off anger by partingways with a company historian. PAGE A4
INTERNATIONAL A4-13
Volkswagen’s Nazi Past
James Burke, head of the SuffolkCounty police, drew officials’ attentionafter his reaction to a theft. PAGE A22
NEW YORK A22-25
Sentence for Ex-Police Chief
Microsoft has unveiled MicrosoftTeams, a real-time communicationsservice that resembles Slack but addsfeatures like threaded conversationsand videoconferencing. PAGE B3
Microsoft Challenges Slack
Gail Collins PAGE A27
EDITORIAL, OP-ED A26-27
From Vogue Arabia toNew York FashionWeek, Muslim con-sumers and designers
are demandingglobal recogni-
tion andrespect oftheir cul-
tural andcommercial
clout. PAGE D1
THURSDAY STYLES D1-10
A Muslim Fashion Identity
CLEVELAND — If you are go-ing to endure years — no, genera-tions — of futility and heartbreak,then when you do finally win achampionship, you might as wellmake it a memorable one.
The Chicago Cubs did just that,shattering their 108-year champi-onship drought in epic fashion:with an 8-7, 10-inning victory overthe Cleveland Indians in Game 7of the World Series that began onWednesday night, carried intoThursday morning and seemed toend all too soon.
After the Indians rallied withthree runs in the eighth inning, in-cluding a two-run thunderbolt of ahome run by Rajai Davis off closerAroldis Chapman, and then a briefrain delay, the Cubs pushed tworuns across in the 10th on Ben Zo-brist’s double and Miguel Mon-tero’s single.
The Indians got a run back inthe bottom of the inning when Da-vis singled home Brandon Guyer,who had walked with two outagainst Carl Edwards Jr. But MikeMontgomery, the Cubs’ fifthpitcher of the night, got MichaelMartinez to hit a slow roller tothird base. Kris Bryant scooped itup and threw to first baseman An-thony Rizzo, and the Cubs pouredout of the dugout and mobbed oneanother in the center of the dia-mond.
The heart-stopping end to theseries was the Cubs’ third straightvictory over the Indians, allowingthem to become the first team torally from a three-games-to-onedeficit in the Series since KansasCity in 1985, and the first to do it onthe road since Pittsburgh in 1979.
But they did not so much beatthe Indians as survive them.
In this matchup of long-suffer-ing franchises who shared the
More Torment, Then Cubs End
108-Year Wait
By BILLY WITZ
Cubs players after scratching out a win in an epic game that ended early Thursday in Cleveland. Chicago last won a title in 1908.GREGORY SHAMUS/GETTY IMAGES
Continued on Page B13
VOL. CLXVI . . . No. 57,405 + © 2016 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 3, 2016
Late Edition
$2.50
Today, becoming cloudy, afternoonand evening showers or heavy thun-derstorms, high 74. Tonight, cloudy,low 47. Tomorrow, sunny, high 56.Weather map appears on Page A24.