8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 1/12

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 2/12

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 3/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

!"#$%&#'()*#!%+,-*,.%*,,*%/#0*,1+%#2*3)4%*%/#5+%,*66#037++6#+-#8,94:)%1(6#(,9#2(.+%#;*6()1+,:#(,9##

$%&#$+%1(,#<(%%*,/#=::1:)(,)#>%+-*::+%/# >+61)13(6#031*,3*#(,9#037++6# +-# 8,)*%,()1+,(6#(,9#>4.613# =--(1%:/#

5+64?.1(#@,1A*%:1)"1#

!

!

"#$! %&! '($! )%#*! ($)+! ,$-&%-./#0$! %12$0'34$5! %&! '($! 6/'3%#/)! 7/1%-! 8$)/'3%#5! 9%/-+! :6789;! (/5! 1$$#! '%!

-$+<0$! '($! '3.$!,$-3%+! 1$'=$$#! '($! &3)3#*! %&!'($!,$'3'3%#!/#+!<#3%#!0$-'3&30/'3%#!$)$0'3%#5>!?(35!@$/-! '($!

6789A5!BCDC!E$-&%-./#0$!F00%<#'/13)3'@!8$,%-'!0)/3.$+!'(/'!GH>I!,$-0$#'!%&! /))!6789!$)$0'3%#5!=$-$!($)+!

=3'(3#!DCC!+/@5!%&!'($!,$'3'3%#!1$3#*!&3)$+!/#+!JK>D!,$-0$#'!%&!/))!3#3'3/)!$)$0'3%#5!=$-$!($)+!=3'(3#!KH!+/@5!%&!

'($!,$'3'3%#5!1$3#*!&3)$+>B!"<-!/#/)@535!%&!9<-$/<!%&!6/'3%#/)!F&&/3-5!:96F;!+/'/!&-%.!DJJJLBCCJ!&%<#+!'(/'!3#!

'($! )/5'! '=%! @$/-5!'($-$! (/5! 1$$#!/! 5)3*('! 3#0-$/5$! 3#!'($!#<.1$-! %&!-$,-$5$#'/'3%#! $)$0'3%#5! 1$3#*!($)+!

1$'=$$#!BDLIC!+/@5!/&'$-!'($!,$'3'3%#>!9<'!'(-%<*(%<'!'($!+$0/+$!'($-$!(/4$!1$$#!43-'</))@!#%!$)$0'3%#!+/'$5!

3#!'($!&3-5'!BC!+/@5!/&'$-!'($!,$'3'3%#!35!&3)$+!:5$$!M3*<-$!D;>!?(<5N!=(3)$!'($!6789!(/5!./+$!5%.$!,-%*-$55!3#!

.$$'3#*!'($3-!,$-&%-./#0$!%12$0'34$5N!/5!&%-.$-!6789!O$#$-/)!P%<#5$)!M-$+!M$3#5'$3#!$Q,)/3#5N!R'($!,-%1)$.!

(/5! 1$$#! '(/'! /!,/-'@!3#! /#@! $)$0'3%#!0/5$!(/5! '($! /13)3'@! '%!<#+$-.3#$! '($! $Q,-$553%#!%&!$.,)%@$$! &-$$!

0(%30$!1@!./#3,<)/'3#*!'($!9%/-+!,-%0$+<-$5!'%!0-$/'$!+$)/@>S!I!

!

?($5$!+/'/!%#!'($!'3.3#*!%&!,$'3'3%#!/#+!$)$0'3%#!+/'$5!./''$-!1$0/<5$!'($!#<.1$-!%&!+/@5!1$'=$$#!'($!

,$'3'3%#!/#+!'($!$)$0'3%#!./@!./T$!/!*-$/'!+$/)!%&!+3&&$-$#0$!/5!'%!=($'($-!%-!#%'!/!*-%<,!%&!=%-T$-5!*$'!

<#3%#!-$,-$5$#'/'3%#!%-!/!&3-5'!0%#'-/0'>!?($!'3.$!1$'=$$#!'($!,$'3'3%#!/#+!'($!$)$0'3%#!/)5%!./@!./T$!/!

+3&&$-$#0$!/5!'%!=($'($-!/#!3#+343+</)!=%-T$-!*$'5!&3-$+!%-!*$'5!(35!%-!($-!=/*$5!%-!1$#$&3'5!0<'!3#!-$'/)3/'3%#!

&%-!<#3%#!/0'343'@N!%-!$#+5!<,! )$/43#*!/! 2%1N!=3'(!%-!=3'(%<'!/! 5$'')$.$#'N!1$0/<5$!%&! '($!0%$-03%#N!'(-$/'5N!

/#+U%-! (/-/55.$#'! 5<&&$-$+!'(-%<*(%<'! '($!$.,)%@$-A5! 0/.,/3*#>!"4$-! '($! )/5'! '(-$$! +$0/+$5! '($-$! (/5!

1$$#! /! =$/)'(! %&! 50(%)/-)@! -$5$/-0(! '(/'! (/5! +%0<.$#'$+! '($! */<#')$'! %&! '(-$/'5N! &$/-N! -$'/)3/'3%#N!

.353#&%-./'3%#N! /#+! (/-/55.$#'! =%-T$-5! (/4$! '%! $#+<-$! 3#! %-+$-! '%! $Q$-035$! '($3-! -3*('! '%! <#3%#!

-$,-$5$#'/'3%#!/#+!0%))$0'34$!1/-*/3#3#*>V!

!

W%=$4$-N!#%#$!%&! '($!-$0$#'!6789!0$-'3&30/'3%#!$)$0'3%#! -$5$/-0(!(/5! $Q/.3#$+!'($! -$)/'3%#5(3,!1$'=$$#!$.,)%@$-!%,,%53'3%#!/#+!'($!'3.3#*!%&!'($!$)$0'3%#>5!?(35!35!1$0/<5$!&%-!'($!&$=!-$5$/-0($-5!=(%!(/4$!+%#$!

'($!(/-+!=%-T!%&!0%##$0'3#*!$)$0'3%#!'%!<#&/3-!)/1%-!,-/0'30$!:X7E;!+/'/N!'($!%#)@!'3.3#*!4/-3/1)$!'($@!(/+!'%!

<5$!&%-!$.,)%@$-!1$(/43%-!=/5!'($!+/'$!X7E5!=$-$!&3)$+>!9<'!53#0$!X7E!0(/-*$5!0/#!1$!&3)$+!/5!.<0(!/5!53Q!

.%#'(5!/&'$-!'($!/))$*/'3%#!%00<--$+N!R+/'$!&3)$+S!*-%55)@!<#+$-$5'3./'$5!=($#!$.,)%@$-!%,,%53'3%#!1$*3#5>!

Y'! 35! &%-! '(35! -$/5%#! =$! =$-$! /5T$+! '%! &%))%=! <,! %#! %<-! BCCJ! 5'<+@! %#! $.,)%@$-! %,,%53'3%#! /#+! '($!

1-$/T+%=#! %&! '($! <#&/3-! )/1%-! ,-/0'30$! ,-%0$55! :5$$! !"# $"%&# '())*&+# ,-*# ./0*/12324(02"/# "3# 567%"8*)#

977"1202"/#0"#9):(/2;2/: ;H!'%!$Q/.3#$!'($!-$)/'3%#5(3,!1$'=$$#!'($!,$'3'3%#!+/'$N!$)$0'3%#!+/'$N!/#+!=($#!

'($!.%5'! 5$-3%<5! $.,)%@$-! %,,%53'3%#! %00<-5! +<-3#*! -$,-$5$#'/'3%#! 0/.,/3*#5>! X,%#! 0%.,)$'3%#! %&! '(35!

/#/)@535!=$!=%<)+!1$!/1)$!'%!+$'$-.3#$!=($'($-!%<-!+/'/!,-%43+$!$.,3-30/)!5<,,%-'!&%-!53*#3&30/#')@!-$+<03#*!

'($!#<.1$-!%&!+/@5!1$'=$$#!,$'3'3%#!/#+!$)$0'3%#!3#!6789!0$-'3&30/'3%#!$)$0'3%#5>!!

!

!!

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 4/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

B!

!

!96F!E)<5>0%.!6789!-$,-$5$#'/'3%#!$)$0'3%#!+/'/N!DJJJLBCCJ!!

!

!

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 5/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

I!

!

"<-! BCCJ! -$,%-'! -$5<)'$+! &-%.! /! -$Z<$5'! 3#!BCCH! 1@! '($! [$#/'$! /#+! W%<5$! W$/)'(N! \+<0/'3%#N! 7/1%-N! ]!

E$#53%#5!:W\7E;!0%..3''$$5!'%!/55$55!'($!$&&$0'34$#$55!%&!0<--$#'!)/=!/#+!9%/-+!,-/0'30$!3#!,-%'$0'3#*!/#+!

$#&%-03#*!=%-T$-5A!-3*('5!3#!'($!6789!$)$0'3%#!,-%0$55>!?($!*%/)!=/5!'%!,-%43+$!-3*%-%<5!/0/+$.30!-$5$/-0(!'%!

3#&%-.!'($!+$1/'$!%#!)/1%-!)/=!-$&%-.>!?($!+/'/!&%-!1%'(!'(/'!%-3*3#/)!-$5$/-0(!/#+!'(35!.%-$!-$0$#'!/#/)@535!

%-3*3#/'$! &-%.! /! '(%-%<*(! -$43$=! %&! ,-3./-@! 6789! +%0<.$#'5! &-%.! /! -/#+%.! 5/.,)$! %&! DNCCC! 6789!

0$-'3&30/'3%#!$)$0'3%#5! '(/'!'%%T! ,)/0$! 1$'=$$#! ^/#</-@!DN! DJJJ! /#+!_$0$.1$-!IDN!BCCIN!/#+! &-%.!/#! 3#L

+$,'(!5<-4$@!%&!KHB!0/.,/3*#5!0%.3#*!%<'!%&!'(/'!5/.$!5/.,)$>!"<-!&3-5'!&3#+3#*5!&-%.!'(35!-$5$/-0(!=$-$!-$)$/5$+!3#!`/@!BCCJ!/#+!(/4$!1$0%.$!%#$!%&!'($!,-3./-@!+/'/!5%<-0$5!&%-!*%4$-#.$#'N!.$+3/N!/0/+$.305N!

/#+!)/1%-!%#!1%'(!$.,)%@$-!%,,%53'3%#!/#+!0<--$#'!9%/-+!,-/0'30$!+<-3#*!6789!$)$0'3%#5>!

!

"<-!.$'(%+!%&!.$/5<-$.$#'!&%-!'(35!5'<+@!35!'($!'3.$!1$'=$$#!'($!+/'$!%&!%00<--$#0$!%&!5$-3%<5!<#&/3-!)/1%-!

,-/0'30$!/))$*/'3%#5!/#+!'($!+/'$!'($!,$'3'3%#!=/5!&3)$+!/#+U%-!'($!+/'$!'($!$)$0'3%#!=/5!&3)$+>!9$0/<5$!$/0(!

<#&/3-!)/1%-!,-/0'30$!0(/-*$!5($$'!0/#!3#0)<+$!&-%.!%#$!'%!/5!./#@!/5!'(3-'@!+3&&$-$#'!/))$*/'3%#5N!$/0(!=3'(!/!

+3&&$-$#'!+/'$!%&!%00<--$#0$N!.%5'!%&!=(30(!/-$!#%'!5,$03&3$+!%#!'($!0(/-*$!5($$'N!'(35!35!.<0(!.%-$!'3.$!

0%#5<.3#*!+/'/!'%!0%))$0'>!Y#!5%.$!0/5$5!3'!-$Z<3-$+!-$/+3#*!'(-%<*(!$#'3-$!X7E!+%0<.$#'!&3)$5N!3#0)<+3#*!

$.,)%@$-!-$5,%#5$5N!5$'')$.$#'!/*-$$.$#'5N!0%.,)/3#'5N!+35.355/)5N!=3'(+-/=/)5N!'$5'3.%#@N!/&&3+/43'5N!/#+!

9%/-+!/#+!P%<-'!+$0353%#5!<#'3)!'($!5,$03&30!+/'$!&%-!$/0(!5$-3%<5!43%)/'3%#!3#!'($!0(/-*$!=/5!&%<#+>!M%-!'(35!

-$/5%#!=$!%#)@!<5$+!0(/-*$5!&3)$+!+<-3#*!'($!)/5'!@$/-!%&!%<-!5/.,)$aBCCI>b!!

!

B(.6*#CD#;(,E*#+-#B1?1,E#.*)F**,#G334%%*,3*#+-#0*%1+4:#@2>#=66*E()1+,:#(,9#H161,E#+-#>*)1)1+,/#@2>#=66*E()1+,:#-%+?#IJJK#L6*3)1+,:##

$(":#.*-+%*#M*)1)1+,#-16*9# $(":#(-)*%#M*)1)1+,#-16*9#

! CNJ#

M64:# COPQRN# ROQKJ# IPQCJ# PQJ# CQCJ# CCQIJ# KCQNJ# OCQNJ# NCQRN# RS#M64:#

T#IJJK

0(?M6*

F5535'/#0$!%-!+%.3#/'3%#! C>Cc! C>Cc! BK>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! KC>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! BK>Cc! D>bc!

P%$-034$!5'/'$.$#'5N!

3#0)<+3#*!'(-$/'5! DC>Gc! DC>Gc! K>Vc! DC>Gc! DH>Bc! DC>Gc! DI>Kc! DI>Kc! B>bc! K>Vc! C>Cc! DK>Vc!

_350(/-*$!&%-!<#3%#!

/0'343'@! DC>Jc! H>Kc! H>Kc! DI>Cc! B>Bc! C>Cc! G>bc! DK>Bc! BI>Jc! G>bc! V>Ic! DJ>Kc!

_3503,)3#$!&%-!<#3%#!

/0'343'@! H>Dc! J>Dc! J>Dc! I>Cc! I>Cc! I>Cc! DK>Bc! J>Dc! J>Dc! BD>Bc! DB>Dc! DI>bc!

W/-/55.$#'! DI>Ic! DI>Ic! DI>Ic! H>bc! DI>Ic! C>Cc! DI>Ic! H>bc! H>bc! H>bc! H>bc! H>Bc!

Y#'$--%*/'3%#! BK>Cc! DC>Cc! DC>Cc! K>Cc! DC>Cc! DK>Cc! DK>Cc! K>Cc! K>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! G>Ic!

7/@%&&!&%-!<#3%#!/0'343'@! DH>bc! DH>bc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! DH>bc! DH>bc! II>Ic! C>Cc! B>Kc!

E-%.35$!%&!1$#$&3'5! DB>Kc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! BK>Cc! DB>Kc! DB>Kc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! C>Cc! I>Ic!

8$'/)3/'3%#!&%-!9%/-+!

,/-'303,/'3%#! DV>Ic! DV>Ic! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! VB>Jc! C>Cc! C>Cc! BG>Hc! C>Cc! B>Jc!

[%)303'/'3%#U!+35'-31<'3%#!

-<)$5! BK>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! BK>Cc! DB>Kc! DB>Kc! DB>Kc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! I>Ic!

[<-4$3))/#0$! DB>Kc! DB>Kc! DB>Kc! BK>Cc! C>Cc! DG>Gc! DG>Gc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! H>Hc!

d/*$5N!1$#$&3'5N!%-!

0%#+3'3%#5!/)'$-$+! C>Cc! J>Dc! DI>Hc! DI>Hc! V>Kc! DG>Bc! J>Dc! V>Kc! J>Dc! V>Kc! DI>Hc! J>Dc!

?%'/)!5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5! DD>Cc! J>Bc! G>bc! J>Hc! b>Ic! G>Ic! DB>Gc! DC>Hc! G>Ic! J>Bc! K>Cc! JC>Kc!

[$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5!=%#!DC>bc! DC>Cc! DC>bc! G>Hc! b>Dc! J>Ic! DB>Jc! G>Hc! H>Vc! DC>bc! K>Cc!

BK>bc!

?%'/)!/))$*/'3%#5! DB>Cc! G>bc! J>Dc! J>Dc! G>Ic! G>bc! DB>V!c! J>Kc! G>bc! G>bc! V>H!c! DCC>Cc

[%<-0$e!!9-%#&$#1-$##$-!/#+!d/--$#N!6789!_%0<.$#'!_/'/1/5$!%&!X7E!+%0<.$#'5!&-%.!5/.,)$!%&!DCCC!0$-'3&30/'3%#!$)$0'3%#5!&-%.!DJJJLBCCI!

=3'(!/!JJ!,$-0$#'!M"YF!-$5,%#5$!-/'$!&-%.!'($!6789>!

!

!

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 6/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

V!

!

?/1)$!D! ,-$5$#'5!5$-3%<5!<#&/3-!)/1%-!,-/0'30$!/))$*/'3%#5!&-%.!/))! '($!BCCI!$)$0'3%#5!3#!%<-!5/.,)$N!1-%T$#!

+%=#!1@!'($!'3.$!1$'=$$#!+/'$!%&!%00<--$#0$!%&!5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5!/#+!'($!,$'3'3%#N!=(3)$!?/1)$!B!1-$/T5!

'($!+/'/!+%=#!1@!'($!'3.$!1$'=$$#!+/'$!%&!5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5!/#+!'($!$)$0'3%#>!?($!.%5'!53*#3&30/#'!&3#+3#*!

3#!%<-!5'<+@!0/#!1$!&%<#+!3#!'($!1%''%.!-%=5!%&!?/1)$!D>!?(3-'@L%#$!,$-0$#'!%&!5$-3%<5!43%)/'3%#5!%00<--$+!IC!

+/@5!1$&%-$!'($!,$'3'3%#!=/5!&3)$+!/#+!Vb!,$-0$#'!%&!/))!5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5!%00<--$+!1$&%-$!'($!,$'3'3%#!=/5!

&3)$+>! [3.3)/-)@!Vb!,$-0$#'!%&! /))! 5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5!=%#!'(-%<*(!9%/-+!%-! P%<-'! +$0353%#5! %-! 5$'')$.$#'5!

%00<--$+!1$&%-$!'($!,$'3'3%#!=/5!&3)$+>!?($!5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5!&3#+3#*5!3#!1%'(!?/1)$5!D!/#+!B!/)5%!-$4$/)!'($!,$-4/534$#$55N! 0%#535'$#0@N! /#+! 3#'$#53'@! %&! $.,)%@$-!%,,%53'3%#! '%!=%-T$-5!$Q$-0353#*! '($3-! -3*('5! '%! 1$!

-$,-$5$#'$+!1@!/!<#3%#!/#+!'%!1/-*/3#!0%))$0'34$)@>!?(35!%,,%53'3%#!5'/-'5!)%#*!1$&%-$!'($!&3)3#*!%&!'($!,$'3'3%#!

/#+!0%#'3#<$5!%#!/&'$-!'($!,$'3'3%#!35! &3)$+!=(3)$!=%-T$-5!=/3'! &%-!'($! $)$0'3%#N!/#+!,$-535'5!5'3))!/&'$-! '($!

$)$0'3%#>!!

!

?(35!.3553%#! 35! /00%.,)35($+! '(-%<*(!.<)'3,)$! '/0'305! /'! '($! $.,)%@$-A5! +35,%5/)>! ?/1)$5! D! /#+! B! )35'! '($!

1<3)+3#*!1)%0T5!%&!$.,)%@$-!0/.,/3*#5>8!Y'!35!#%!/003+$#'!'(/'!'($@!/-$!/)5%!/))!5$-3%<5!X7E!43%)/'3%#5N!'(%5$!

.%5'!)3T$)@!'%!*/3#!/!5$'')$.$#'!&/4%-/1)$!'%!'($!<#3%#N!,-$!%-!,%5'!0%.,)/3#'!%-!/!9%/-+!%-!P%<-'!%-+$-!=3#>!

?($5$! 3#0)<+$! '(-$/'5N! 3#'$--%*/'3%#N! 5<-4$3))/#0$N! &$/-N! 0%$-03%#N!43%)$#0$N! -$'/)3/'3%#! /#+!(/-/55.$#'! &%-!

<#3%#! /0'343'@N!,-%.35$5!/#+!1-31$5N! /#+!$)$0'3%#!/#+!<#3%#! 3#'$-&$-$#0$5>! \.,)%@$-5!,$#/)3f$!=%-T$-5! 3#!

./#@!=/@5g!1@! '-/#5&$--3#*! '($.! '%!.%-$! %#$-%<5!=%-T! /553*#.$#'5N! 0<''3#*!=/*$5!%-!1$#$&3'5N! )/@%&&5N!

0%#'-/0'3#*!%<'N!/#+N!.%5'!$*-$*3%<5)@N!+350(/-*3#*!=%-T$-5!%-!5(<''3#*!+%=#N!0%#'-/0'3#*!%<'N!%-!%<'5%<-03#*!

/))!%-!,/-'!%&!'($!&/03)3'@>!!

!

!

!

[%<-0$e!!9-%#&$#1-$##$-!/#+!d/--$#N!6789!_%0<.$#'!_/'/1/5$!%&!X7E!+%0<.$#'5!&-%.!5/.,)$!%&!DCCC!0$-'3&30/'3%#!$)$0'3%#5!&-%.!DJJJLBCCI!

=3'(!/!JJ!,$-0$#'!M"YF!-$5,%#5$!-/'$!&-%.!'($!6789>!

B(.6*# ID# ;(,E*# +-# B1?1,E#.*)F**,# G334%%*,3*# +-# 0*%1+4:# @2># =66*E()1+,:# (,9# )7*# L6*3)1+,# 9()*# U1,# ,4?.*%# +-#9(":# .*-+%*#

*6*3)1+,V/##@2>#=66*E()1+,:#-%+?#IJJK#L6*3)1+,:#

!!"#$

 %&'($

)*+($

!,-./"$

)*+($

/,.0#$

)*+($

"-."#$

)*+($

,-.,#$

)*+($

1-.1#$

)*+($

2-.2#$

)*+($

!-.!#$$$

)*+($

-.#$

)*+($

 34567$

8&695:;<$$

=$ 2##1$

>*?%&6$

F5535'/#0$!%-!+%.3#/'3%#! KC>Cc! C>Cc! KC>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! D>bc!

P%$-034$!5'/'$.$#'5N!3#0)<+3#*!'(-$/'5! DH>Bc! BD>Hc! G>Dc! G>Dc! G>Dc! DI>Kc! G>Dc! G>Dc! G>Dc! C>Cc! DK>Vc!

_350(/-*$!&%-!<#3%#!/0'343'@! Db>Vc! DC>Jc! DC>Jc! DI>Cc! V>Ic! C>Cc! B>Bc! DI>Cc! V>Ic! BI>Jc! DJ>Kc!

_3503,)3#$!&%-!<#3%#!/0'343'@! DB>Dc! DG>Bc! DK>Bc! J>Dc! C>Cc! C>Cc! H>Dc! C>Cc! H>Dc! II>Ic! DI>bc!

W/-/55.$#'! BC>Cc! BH>bc! H>bc! DI>Ic! C>Cc! DI>Ic! H>bc! C>Cc! H>bc! H>bc! H>Bc!

Y#'$--%*/'3%#! VC>Cc! BK>Cc! C>Cc! K>Cc! C>Cc! DK>Cc! DC>Cc! K>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! G>Ic!

7/@%&&!&%-!<#3%#!/0'343'@! II>Ic! DH>bc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! DH>bc! C>Cc! II>Ic! B>Kc!

E-%.35$!%&!1$#$&3'5! BK>Cc! BK>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! DB>Kc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! I>Ic!

8$'/)3/'3%#!&%-!9%/-+!

,/-'303,/'3%#! DV>Ic! DV>Ic! DV>Ic! DV>Ic! C>Cc! DV>Ic! DV>Ic! C>Cc! C>Cc! DV>Ic! B>Jc!

[%)303'/'3%#U!+35'-31<'3%#!-<)$5! BK>Cc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! BK>Cc! DB>Kc! DB>Kc! C>Cc! C>Cc! DB>Kc! C>Cc! I>Ic!

[<-4$3))/#0$! DB>Kc! BK>Cc! BK>Cc! C>Cc! H>Ic! C>Cc! ID>Ic! C>Cc! C>Cc! C>Cc! H>Hc!d/*$5N!1$#$&3'5N!%-!0%#+3'3%#5!

/)'$-$+! V>Kc! Bb>Ic! DI>Hc! J>Dc! J>Dc! J>Dc! V>Kc! C>Cc! V>Kc! DG>Bc! J>Dc!

?%'/)!5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5! DG>Ic! DJ>Ic! DD>Kc! G>bc! V>Hc! H>Jc! b>Ic! K>Kc! V>Dc! DI>Gc! JC>Kc!

[$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#5!=%#! Db>Dc! BC>bc! DC>Cc! DD>Vc! V>Ic! DC>Cc! K>Cc! H>Vc! V>Ic! DC>bc! BK>bc!

?%'/)!/))$*/'3%#5! DG>bc! DJ>Dc! DD>Hc! b>Jc! V>Hc! b>Kc! b>Jc! K>Cc! K>Cc! DB>Jc! DCC>Cc!

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 7/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

K!

!

?($-$!/-$!5$4$-/)!+35'3#0'!5'/*$5!'%!/!<#3%#!%-*/#3f3#*!0/.,/3*#!'(/'!/-$!3.,%-'/#'!'%!<#+$-5'/#+!3#!%-+$-!'%!

3#'$-,-$'!'($!53*#3&30/#0$!%&!'($!+/'/!,-$5$#'$+!/1%4$>!M3-5'!'($-$!35!'($!3#3'3/)!,$-3%+!=($-$!'($!&3-5'!0%#'/0'!

35! ./+$! 1$'=$$#! '($! =%-T$-5! /#+! '($! <#3%#N! )$/+$-5! /-$! 3+$#'3&3$+! /#+! /#! %-*/#3f3#*! 0%..3''$$! 35!

$5'/1)35($+>! ?($!5$0%#+!,(/5$! 35!=($#! '($!<#3%#N! '(-%<*(! '($!%-*/#3f3#*! 0%..3''$$N! -$/0($5!%<'! '%! '($!

1/-*/3#3#*! <#3'!.$.1$-5! /#+! *-/+</))@! 1<3)+5! <,! 5<,,%-'! <#'3)! '($! =%-T$-5! /-$! -$/+@! '%! ,$'3'3%#! &%-! /#!

$)$0'3%#>9!?($!'(3-+!,(/5$!35!'($!,$-3%+!1$'=$$#!'($!+/'$!'($!,$'3'3%#!35!&3)$+!/#+!'($!$)$0'3%#!+/'$>!?(35!35!

=($#!1%'(!'($!<#3%#!/#+!$.,)%@$-!0/.,/3*#5!/-$!.%5'!%<'!3#!'($!%,$#N!1<'!/5!%<-!+/'/!5(%=!'(35!35!#%'!

=($#!'($!$.,)%@$-!0/.,/3*#5!1$*3#>!M3#/))@!'($!&%<-'(!,(/5$!35!'($!,$-3%+!1$'=$$#!'($!+/'$!%&!$)$0'3%#!/#+!

'($!+/'$!%&!0$-'3&30/'3%#N!=(30(!0/#!3#0)<+$!=/3'3#*!&%-!$)$0'3%#!%12$0'3%#5N!X7E5N!/#+!,%5531)$!-$-<#!$)$0'3%#5!

'%!1$!-$5%)4$+>10!!

!

"<-! &3#+3#*5! 5(%=! '(/'! 5$-3%<5! 43%)/'3%#5! %00<--$+! /0-%55! $/0(! %&! '($5$! '3.$! ,$-3%+5N! &-%.! +350(/-*3#*N!

'(-$/'$#3#*N! /#+! (/-/553#*! )$/+$-5! 3#! '($! $/-)3$5'! 5'/*$5! %&! 1<3)+3#*! '($! %-*/#3f3#*! 0%..3''$$g! '%! <53#*!

5<-4$3))/#0$N!3#'$--%*/'3%#N!/#+!'(-$/'5!'%!'-@!'%!+355</+$!=%-T$-5!&-%.!/''$#+3#*!<#3%#!.$$'3#*5!%-!5,$/T3#*!

=3'(!%-*/#3f3#*!0%..3''$$!.$.1$-5!,-3%-!'%!5<1.3''3#*!'($!,$'3'3%#g!/))!'($!=/@!'%!-$'/)3/'3#*!/*/3#5'!'($!

.%5'!%<'5,%T$#!<#3%#!/0'3435'5!/'!'($!4$-@!$#+!%&!'($!$)$0'3%#!0/.,/3*#>!M3#/))@!%#!'($!+/@!%&!'($!$)$0'3%#!

/#+! '(%5$! 3..$+3/'$)@! &%))%=3#*! =$! &%<#+!./#@! 0/5$5!%&! $.,)%@$-5! '/-*$'3#*! '(%5$!=(%! =$-$! $)$0'3%#!

%15$-4$-5!%-!=3'#$55$5!3#!6789!($/-3#*5>!

!

"#$!-$,-$5$#'/'34$!$Q/.,)$!%&!$.,)%@$-5A!,/''$-#!%&!$/-)@N!,$-535'$#'N!/#+!<#-$)$#'3#*!%,,%53'3%#!'(/'!=$!

-$0%-+$+!3#!%<-!6789!X7E!_%0<.$#'!_/'/1/5$!0%.$5!&-%.!W3))53+$!F0-$5!3#!d3))/-+N!"(3%>!?($!X#3'$+!M%%+!

/#+! P%..$-03/)! d%-T$-5! :XMPd;! )/<#0($+! /#! %-*/#3f3#*! 0/.,/3*#! 3#! )/'$! BCCB>! F00%-+3#*! '%! '($!

P%#5%)3+/'$+!P%.,)/3#'! 355<$+!%#!_$0$.1$-!HN! BCCBN!HB!+/@5!1$&%-$! '($!,$'3'3%#!=/5! $4$#!&3)$+N!W3))53+$!

3#3'3/'$+!3'5!/#'3L<#3%#!0/.,/3*#!1@!./T3#*!/#!$Q/.,)$!%&!%#$!%&!'($!<#3%#!/0'3435'5!3#!'($!$/-)3$5'!,(/5$!%&!

'($!0/.,/3*#N!5'/-'3#*!=3'(!/!=-3''$#!=/-#3#*>DD!W3))53+$!+3503,)3#$+!'(/'!5/.$!$.,)%@$$!/*/3#!%#!_$0$.1$-!

JN!5<5,$#+$+!($-!'($!#$Q'!+/@N!/#+!&3-$+!($-!/!=$$T!/&'$-!'(/'>!?($!0%.,/#@!/)5%!+35,/-/'$)@!$#&%-0$+!3'5!

5%)303'/'3%#!,%)30@>!?(-%<*(%<'!'($!#$Q'!'=%!=$$T5!'($!$.,)%@$-!0/.,/3*#!$Q,/#+$+!'%!%'($-!$.,)%@$$5!/#+!

3#0)<+$+! 43%)/'3%#5! 5<0(! /5! 3#'$--%*/'3%#N! 1-31$5N! %#$-%<5! /553*#.$#'5! &%-! <#3%#! /0'343'@N! /#+! /#%'($-!

+3503,)3#$!/#+!+350(/-*$>! ?(35!/))! =/5!1$&%-$! '($!$#+! %&!_$0$.1$-N! VD!+/@5!1$&%-$! '($!,$'3'3%#!=/5! &3)$+>!

['/-'3#*!.3+L̂ /#</-@N! '($!0%.,/#@!1$*/#! 5<-4$3))/#0$!/#+!'(-$/'$#$+!=%-T$-5!=3'(!=/*$! -$+<0'3%#5! /#+!

&/03)3'@!0)%5<-$>!

!

?($! XMPd! &3)$+!'($! ,$'3'3%#!&%-! /#!$)$0'3%#!%#!M$1-</-@! H>!F00%-+3#*! '%!'($! P%.,)/3#'N! %#!M$1-</-@!BHN!

W3))53+$N! +350(/-*$+! %#$! $.,)%@$$! /#+! +3503,)3#$+! /#%'($-! 3#! -$'/)3/'3%#! &%-! '($3-! ,/-'303,/'3%#! 3#! 6789!

,-%0$$+3#*5>!"#! '($!&%))%=3#*! +/@N!#%=! BD!+/@5!/&'$-! '($!,$'3'3%#N! '($!$.,)%@$-!./+$!.%-$!'(-$/'5!/#+!

,-%.35$5! /#+! 3#! '($! &%))%=3#*! '=%! .%#'(5! ,-3%-! '%! '($! $)$0'3%#N! +3503,)3#$+! /#+! (/-/55$+! '(-$$! .%-$!

$.,)%@$$5!=(%!=$-$!'($#!/))!&3-$+!/&'$-!'($!$)$0'3%#>!?($!'(-$/'5N!3#'$--%*/'3%#5N!5<-4$3))/#0$N!/#+!+35,/-/'$!

$#&%-0$.$#'!%&!5%)303'/'3%#!-<)$5!/)5%!0%#'3#<$+!3#!'($!+/@5!/#+!=$$T5!/&'$-!'($!,$'3'3%#!=/5!&3)$+>!9@!'($!

'3.$!%&!'($!$)$0'3%#!%#!F,-3)!BDN!BCCIN!3'!(/+!1$$#!#$/-)@!&34$!.%#'(5!53#0$!'($!&3-5'!5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#!%#!

_$0$.1$-!HN!BCCB>!?($!0(/-*$!5($$'5N!0%.,)/3#'!/#+!5$'')$.$#'5!/))!'$))!/!5'%-@!'(/'!35!-$,$/'$+!%4$-!/#+!

%4$-!3#!#<.$-%<5!%'($-!0/.,/3*#5a'($!3#'$#53'@!/#+!0%#5'/#0@!%&!'($!$.,)%@$-!0/.,/3*#!/#+!'($!&/0'!'(/'!

3'!1$*3#5!)%#*!1$&%-$!'($!,$'3'3%#!35!&3)$+>!!

!

?(35!,/''$-#!%&!/**-$5534$!$.,)%@$-!%,,%53'3%#!35!#%'!35%)/'$+!'%!<#3'5!5<0(!/5!W3))53+$!=($-$!'($!<#3%#!-/#!/!

=3##3#*! 0/.,/3*#>! F5! 3#! '($! W3))53+$! 0/5$!=$! &%<#+!/! 0%#535'$#'! ,/''$-#! %&! $.,)%@$-! '/0'305! 1$3#*!<5$+!

-$,$/'$+)@!/#+!3#!0%.13#/'3%#!'(-%<*(%<'!%<-!5/.,)$>!?(35!35!=($-$!%<-!5<-4$@!+/'/!%#!$.,)%@$-!'/0'305!0/#!

1$!4$-@!3#5'-<0'34$>DB!!?/1)$!I!<5$5!1%'(!%<-!5<-4$@!+/'/!%#!$.,)%@$-!1$(/43%-!&%-!BCCI!:5<../-3f$+!3#!'($!

)/5'! 0%)<.#! %&!?/1)$!I;! /#+! #<.1$-! %&!+/@5!1$'=$$#! '($! $/-)3$5'! 5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#!/#+! '($! +/'$!%&! '($!

$)$0'3%#!&-%.!%<-!X7E!5/.,)$!&%-!BCCI>!

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 8/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

H!

!

!

!

![%<-0$e! 9-%#&$#1-$##$-!/#+!d/--$#N!5<-4$@! &3#+3#*5!&-%.! '($!R?($! P(/#*3#*!P)3./'$!&%-! X#3%#!"-*/#3f3#*!/'! '($!?<-#! %&! '($!`3))$##3<.N!E/-'!De!!!!!!!!!!!!!

6789!P/.,/3*#5SN!M$1-</-@!BCDD>!

!

7%%T3#*!/'!'($!5<../-@!+/'/!%#!$.,)%@$-!1$(/43%-N!&%-!$Q/.,)$N!3#!GJ!,$-0$#'!%&!/))!0/.,/3*#5!5<-4$@$+!

$.,)%@$-5!-$Z<3-$!=%-T$-5!'%!/''$#+!0/,'34$!/<+3$#0$!.$$'3#*5!=3'(!'%,!./#/*$.$#'!+<-3#*!=%-T!'3.$>!?($!

./2%-3'@! %&! $.,)%@$$5! /''$#+! /'! )$/5'! &34$! %&! '($5$! +<-3#*! '($! 0%<-5$! %&! /! 0/.,/3*#>! Y#! HH! ,$-0$#'! %&!

B(.6*#KD#$1--*%*,3*:#1,#*?M6+"*%#+MM+:1)1+,#9*M*,91,E#+,#,4?.*%#+-#9(":#.*-+%*#)7*#*6*3)1+,#)7()#)7*#*(%61*:)#:*%1+4:#@2>#

(66*E()1+,#+334%%*9&##W2;!#04%A*"#$()(/#IJJK#(,9#W2;!#0(?M6*/#IJJK#

!

!"#$

 %&'($

)*+($

!,-./"$

)*+($

/,.,#$

)*+($

1-.2#$

)*+($

!-.!#$$$

)*+($

-.#$$$

)*+($

 34567$

8&695:;<$$

=$

>'7@6+$

>*?%&6$

6<.1$-!%&!0/,'34$!/<+3$#0$!.$$'3#*5! DK>bG! I>HC! DI>II! b>CC! BC>CC! V>C! DK>KC! DC>IV!

6<.1$-!%&!)$''$-5!! H>GH! V>BC! V>CC! IB>Hb! H>CC! V>C! G>Hb! H>KI!

6<.1$-!%&!)$/&)$'5! DI>CC! D>CC! G>KC! IH>CC! G>CC! V>C! J>CC! DH>BD!

6<.1$-!+350(/-*$+! D>VC! D>bK! B>HI! D>CC! D>II! >CC! V>CC! B>KJ!

6<.1$-!%&!=%-T$-5!)/3+!%&&! >CC! >CC! >CC! D>CC! >CC! >CC! >CC! IB>KG!

6<.1$-!%&!/**-$5534$!$.,)%@$-!'/0'305! DB>JC! DV>VC! DI>JC! DC>BK! DC>Hb! H>KC! DH>VC! DC>GG!

! ! ! ! ! ! !! ! !

`%-$!'(/#!K!0/,'34$!/<+3$#0$!.$$'3#*5! >Hb! >BC! >bG! >KC! D>CC! >CC! >bK! >KI!

`%-$!'(/#!K!$.,)%@$-!)$''$-5! >Kb! >V>CC! >BJ! >Hb! D>CC! >CC! D>CC! >BG!

`%-$!'(/#!K!$.,)%@$-!)$/&)$'5! >GH! >CC! >GC! >Hb! >KC! >CC! D>CC! >HD!

! ! ! ! ! ! !! ! !

[<,$-435%-!($)+!%#$L%#L%#$5!/'!)$/5'!=$$T)@! >JC! >HC! >bC! >bK! D>CC! >CC! >HC! >HH!

X5$+!5<,$-435%-!%#$L%#L%#$5!'%!3#'$--%*/'$!! >HC! >GC! >bC! >bK! >II! >CC! >GC! >HI!

X5$+!5<,$-435%-!%#$L%#L%#$5!'%!'(-$/'$#!=%-T$-5! >bC! >GC! >bC! >KC! >Hb! >KC! >HC! >KV!

?(-$/'$#$+!)%55$5!%&!=/*$5!/#+!1$#$&3'5! >KC! D>CC! >HC! >KC! >II! >CC! D>CC! >Vb!

_350(/-*$+!=%-T$-5!&%-!<#3%#!/0'343'@! >KC! >GC! >GC! >BK! D>CC! >CC! >BC! >IV!

F)'$-/'3%#!%&!1$#$&3'5!%-!0%#+3'3%#5! >BC! >HC! >BC! >BK! >II! >KC! >BC! >BB!

E-%.35$5!%&!3.,-%4$.$#'5! >VC! >GC! >HC! >KC! >II! >KC! >HC! >VH!

X#50($+<)$+!-/35$5! >KC! >BC! >BC! >CC! >II! >CC! >VC! >DG!

?(-$/'5!%&!,)/#'!0)%53#*! >bG! >HC! >bC! >CC! >CC! >CC! D>CC! >KG!

9-31$5!%-!5,$03/)!&/4%-5! >IC! >BC! >VC! >KC! >CC! >KC! >HC! >BI!

[<-4$3))/#0$! >CC! >CC! >IC! >CC! >Hb! >CC! >VC! >DV!

9-3#*3#*!3#!$Q'-/!5$0<-3'@!/#+U%-!,<''3#*!<,!

&$#03#*! >IC! >BC! >DC! >CC! >CC! >CC! >VC! >DV!

?(-$/'$#$+!%-!(/-/55$+!<#3%#!/0'3435'5!! >HC! >GC! >VC! >KC! >CC! >KC! >HC! >VD!

9-%<*('!3#!,%)30$!! >BC! >VC! >BC! >CC! >II! >KC! >HC! >BD!

F5535'$+!/#'3L<#3%#!0%..3''$$! >VC! >HC! >IC! >CC! >II! >CC! >GC! >IC!

8/#!.$+3/!0/.,/3*#! >CC! >CC! >DC! >BK! >CC! >CC! >BC! >DB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

DC!%-!.%-$!$.,)%@$-!'/0'305! >HC! >GC! >bC! >KC! >II! >CC! >GC! >VJ!

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 9/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

b!

!

0/.,/3*#5!=%-T$-5!/-$!-$Z<3-$+!'%!.$$'!/)%#$!=3'(!'($3-!5<,$-435%-5!/'!)$/5'!=$$T)@N!=($-$!.%5'!'(-$/'5!

/#+!3#'$--%*/'3%#5!%00<->!d%-T$-5!/-$!'(-$/'$#$+!=3'(!,)/#'!0)%53#*5!3#! Kb!,$-0$#'!%&!0/.,/3*#5!/#+!=3'(!

)%55!%&!=/*$5!/#+!1$#$&3'5!3#!Vb!,$-0$#'>!Y#!HV!,$-0$#'!%&!0/.,/3*#5!=%-T$-5!/-$!3#'$--%*/'$+!/1%<'!(%=!

'($@! /#+! %'($-! =%-T$-5! /-$! *%3#*! '%! 4%'$N! .%5')@! 1@! 5<,$-435%-5! :KI! ,$-0$#';N! =(3)$! $.,)%@$-5! <5$!

5<-4$3))/#0$!3#!DV!,$-0$#'!%&!$)$0'3%#5>DI!!

!

\.,)%@$-5!/)5%! 3#0-$/53#*)@! <5$!&$/-!/#+!43%)$#0$>!?=$#'@L%#$!,$-0$#'! +%!,%)30$!=/)TL'(-%<*(5!=3'(! )$55!

'(/#! D! ,$-0$#'! -$)/'3#*! '%!/#@! /--$5'! %-! 3#4$5'3*/'3%#! /#+! DV!,$-0$#'! 1-3#*! 3#! 5$0<-3'@! *</-+5! %-!,<'! <,!

5$0<-3'@!&$#03#*>!`%5'!$*-$*3%<5N!=%-T$-5!/-$!+350(/-*$+!3#!IV!,$-0$#'!%&!0/.,/3*#5>!F5!5(%=#!3#!?/1)$!IN!/!

53*#3&30/#'! 3#0-$/5$! 3#!+350(/-*$5!1$*3#5! /'!+/@! BD!/#+! 0%#'3#<$5! %4$-! '3.$>!M3#/))@N! /5! 5(%=#! 3#!'($! )/5'!

0%)<.#!%&!?/1)$!DN!'($5$!5<-4$@!&3#+3#*5!/-$!/))!5<,,%-'$+!1@!'($!X7E!+/'/!3#+30/'3#*!'(/'!<#3%#5!/-$!&3)3#*!

X7E!0(/-*$5!%#!'($!5/.$!355<$5!'(/'!'($@!-$,%-'$+!'%!<5!=$-$!'($!.%5'!/**-$5534$!1$(/43%-!1@!$.,)%@$-5>!

!

9<'!'($!&3#+3#*!'(/'!35!.%5'!-$)$4/#'!'%!'($!355<$!%&!'($!'3.3#*!%&!$)$0'3%#5!35!'(35e!$.,)%@$-!%,,%53'3%#!'%!

<#3%#5!35!0%#5'/#'!/#+!0<.<)/'34$>!Y'!1$*3#5!1$&%-$!'($!,$'3'3%#!35!&3)$+!/#+!0%#'3#<$5!5'$/+3)@!'(-%<*(%<'!'($!

0/.,/3*#>!F5!-$,%-'$+N!=$!&%<#+!'(/'!HH!,$-0$#'!%&!$.,)%@$-5!($)+!=$$T)@!5<,$-435%-!%#$L%#L%#$!.$$'3#*5!

=3'(!=%-T$-5!'(-%<*(%<'!'($!0/.,/3*#>!Y'!1$/-5!#%'3#*!'(/'!'(35!=/5!3#!/!5/.,)$!=($-$!'($!/4$-/*$!0/.,/3*#!

)$#*'(!=/5!/5!(3*(!/5!DK!=$$T5>!F5!5(%=#!3#!?/1)$!IN!/'!)$/5'!JC!,$-0$#'!%&!/))!0/.,/3*#5!3#!%<-!5/.,)$!'(/'!

(/+!/!5$-3%<5!43%)/'3%#!%00<-!.%-$!'(/#!DKC!+/@5!%-!.%-$!1$&%-$!'($!$)$0'3%#!(/+!5<,$-435%-!%#$L%#L%#$5!/'!

)$/5'!=$$T)@>!F#+!&%-!'(%5$!'(/'!(/+!/'!)$/5'!%#$!5$-3%<5!X7E!43%)/'3%#!/&'$-!'($!$)$0'3%#!'($!-/'$!=/5!5'3))!HC!

,$-0$#'!%&!0/.,/3*#5>!!

!

?/1)$!I!5(%=5!'(/'!'(35!0%#5'/#0@!35!'-<$!&%-!'($!&<))!-/#*$!%&!%'($-!/**-$5534$!'/0'305!/5!=$))N!=3'(!+350(/-*$5N!

'(-$/'5N!,-%.35$5N!/#+!5<-4$3))/#0$!(%)+3#*!5'$/+@!/0-%55!'($!./#@!=$$T5!/#+!.%#'(5!1$&%-$!'($!+/'$!%&!'($!

$)$0'3%#! 3#! '($5$! 0/.,/3*#5>! Y#! /++3'3%#N!$.,)%@$-5! -/-$)@! <5$!%#$! %,,%53'3%#! '/0'30! 3#! 35%)/'3%#g!.<)'3,)$!

'/0'305! /-$! <5$+! 3#! 0%.13#/'3%#!/#+! 5'$/+3)@! '%! 0%$-0$! =%-T$-5! '%! 4%'$! /*/3#5'! <#3%#! -$,-$5$#'/'3%#N! /5!

3#+30/'$+! 1@!'($! )/5'! -%=! 3#!?/1)$! IN!=(30(! +$50-31$5! '($! ,$-0$#'/*$!%&!$.,)%@$-5!=(%! <5$! '$#! %-!.%-$!

/**-$5534$!'/0'305>!!M%-!'(%5$!0/.,/3*#5!=($-$!/'!)$/5'!%#$!X7E!%00<--$+!VC!%-!.%-$!+/@5!1$&%-$!'($!$)$0'3%#N!

/'!)$/5'!HC!,$-0$#'!%&!$.,)%@$-5!<5$+!'$#!%-!.%-$!/**-$5534$!'/0'305>!

!

!d($#!=$! '-/0T$+! %<-! X7E! +/'/! .%-$! 0)%5$)@N! -$/+3#*! %4$-! $/0(! 0/5$! '%! 5$$! =($'($-! 0(/-*$5! %00<-! 3#!

+3&&$-$#'! '3.$5! 3#! +3&&$-$#'! 0/.,/3*#5N! =$! &3#+! '(/'! 3#! 0/5$5! =3'(! )/-*$! #<.1$-5! %&! 5$-3%<5! X7E5N! '($!

/))$*/'3%#5!'$#+!'%! 1$!.%-$!)3T$)@! '%!1$! 5,-$/+! /0-%55! '($! $#'3-$! 0/.,/3*#N! -/'($-! '(/#! 0)<5'$-$+! 3#!%#$!

5,$03&30!'3.$!,$-3%+N!/#+!'(/'! &3)3#*!0(/-*$5!+%$5!#%'!5'%,! '($!$.,)%@$-! &-%.!0%#'3#<3#*!'%! 0%..3'!.%-$!

5$-3%<5! 43%)/'3%#5!%&!'($! 5/.$!%-!$50/)/'3#*!#/'<-$>!['3))! 0$-'/3#! T3#+5!%&! 0(/-*$5!+%!'$#+!'%! 1$!0)<5'$-$+!

+<-3#*! +3&&$-$#'! ,$-3%+5! %&! '($! 0/.,/3*#>! Y#! ,/-'30<)/-N! 3#'$--%*/'3%#N! 5<-4$3))/#0$! /#+! (/-/55.$#'! /-$!

$5,$03/))@! 0%#0$#'-/'$+! 3#! '($! =$$T5!1$&%-$! '($! ,$'3'3%#! 35! &3)$+N! =(3)$!+350-3.3#/'3%#!/#+! -$'/)3/'3%#! &%-!

<#3%#!/0'343'@N!/)'(%<*(!,-$5$#'!'(-%<*(%<'N!5$$.!'%!/)5%!5'/-'!%<'!4$-@!(3*(!/#+!'($#!,$/T!/*/3#!2<5'!1$&%-$!

'($!$)$0'3%#>!Y&!'($-$!=$-$!/#@!,$-3%+!=(30(!(/5!/!)%=$-!/.%<#'!%&!/0'343'@!3'!=%<)+!1$!'($!'=$#'@!+/@5!/&'$-!

'($!,$'3'3%#!=/5!&3)$+>!9<'!'($-$!35!5%!)3'')$!+/'/!&-%.!'(/'!,$-3%+!3'!35!+3&&30<)'!'%!/#/)@f$>!!Y#!/++3'3%#N!'($-$!

53.,)@!/-$!#%!+/'/!%#!0/.,/3*#5!=3'(!'$#!+/@!0$-'3&30/'3%#!,$-3%+5!53#0$!'($@!%00<-!3#!)$55!'(/#!D!,$-0$#'!%&!

$)$0'3%#5>!?=$#'@!+/@!0$-'3&30/'3%#!,$-3%+5!/-$!5<0(!/!#$=!,($#%.$#%#N!/,,$/-3#*!2<5'!53#0$!BCCGN!'(/'!'($@!

(/4$!@$'!'%!1$!-$5$/-0($+!:[$$!M3*<-$!D;>!!

!

"<-!BCCI!X7E!/#+!5<-4$@!&3#+3#*5N!3#!0%.13#/'3%#!=3'(!'($!)/-*$-!&3#+3#*5!&%-!%<-!'%'/)!5/.,)$!3#!%<-!6789!

X7E!_%0<.$#'!_/'/1/5$!/1%<'!'($!'3.3#*!/#+!'3.$!5,/#!%&!$.,)%@$-!1$(/43%-N!'$))!<5!/!*-$/'!+$/)!/1%<'!'($!

3.,%-'/#'!-%)$!%&! '3.3#*! 3#! '($!6789!$)$0'3%#!,-%0$55N!3#! ,/-'30<)/-!'($! '3.$!1$'=$$#!'($! +/'$!$.,)%@$-!

%,,%53'3%#!1$*3#5N!'($!+/'$!'($!,$'3'3%#!35!&3)$+N!/#+!'($!+/'$!'($!$)$0'3%#!35!($)+>DV!"<-!X7E!+%0<.$#'5!5(%=!

'(/'!5%.$!%&!'($!.%5'!$*-$*3%<5!$.,)%@$-!%,,%53'3%#!5'/-'5!)%#*!1$&%-$!'($!<#3%#!(/5!$4$#!&3)$+!'($!,$'3'3%#>!

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 10/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

G!

!

M%-'@L5$4$#!,$-0$#'!%&!5$-3%<5!X7E5!/-$!&3)$+!1$&%-$!'($!,$'3'3%#N!3#0)<+3#*!HC!,$-0$#'!&%-!3#'$--%*/'3%#!/#+!

(/-/55.$#'N!/#+!IJ!,$-0$#'!&%-!+350(/-*$5!&%-!<#3%#!/0'343'@!/#+!KV!,$-0$#'!&%-!0%$-03%#!/#+!'(-$/'5>!!F#+!

$.,)%@$-!%,,%53'3%#!0%#'3#<$5!<#/1/'$+!&-%.!'($!&3-5'!.%.$#'!'($!<#3%#!0/.,/3*#!*%$5!/1%4$!*-%<#+N!+/@!

/&'$-!+/@!/#+!=$$T!/&'$-!=$$T!)$/+3#*!<,!'%!'($!$)$0'3%#N!/#+!+%$5!#%'!5'%,!<#'3)!'($!<#3%#!(/5!$3'($-!)%5'!

'($!$)$0'3%#!%-!=%#!/!&3-5'!0%#'-/0'>!?($!0<.<)/'34$!$&&$0'!%&!'($!5'$/+@N!,$-4/534$N!/#+!3#'$#5$!$.,)%@$-!

%,,%53'3%#! <#+$-.3#$5! =%-T$-5A! /''$.,'5! '%! $Q$-035$! '($3-! -3*('5! '%! 0(%%5$! <#3%#! -$,-$5$#'/'3%#! &-$$! %&!

0%$-03%#!/#+!3#'3.3+/'3%#>!!!!

!

X,!<#'3)! #%=!5'<+3$5!$Q/.3#3#*!'($! 3.,/0'! %&!+$)/@! 3#!<#+$-.3#3#*!=%-T$-5!$Q$-0353#*! &-$$! 0(%30$! 3#! '($!

$)$0'3%#!,-%0$55! (/4$! -$)3$+! %#! '($! '3.$!+3&&$-$#0$! 1$'=$$#! '($! &3)3#*! %&!X7E5! /#+! '($! ,$'3'3%#!/#+! '($!

$)$0'3%#! +/'$5>! 9@! <53#*! /! .<0(! .%-$! -$)3/1)$! /#+! /00<-/'$! '3.3#*! .$/5<-$a'($! +/'$! X7E! /))$*/'3%#5!

%00<-a=$!(/4$!1$$#!/1)$!'%!5(%=!#%'!%#)@!'(/'!.%5'!$.,)%@$-!0/.,/3*#5!1$*3#!.<0(!$/-)3$-!'(/#!$Q,$0'$+!

1<'! /)5%! '(/'! '($-$! 35! /! 5'$/+@! ,/''$-#! %&! 5$-3%<5! /))$*/'3%#5! 5'/-'3#*! 4$-@! $/-)@! 3#!.%5'! 0/.,/3*#5! /#+!

0%#'3#<3#*! %#! '(-%<*(!'%! '($!$)$0'3%#>! Y#!0%.13#/'3%#!%<-! &3#+3#*5!./T$! /! 5'-%#*!$.,3-30/)!/-*<.$#'! &%-!

5'-$/.)3#3#*!'($!6789!0$-'3&30/'3%#!,-%0$55!'%!-$+<0$!'($!,$-3%+!1$'=$$#!'($!,$'3'3%#!/#+!'($!$)$0'3%#!'%!'($!

5(%-'$5'!#<.1$-!%&!+/@5!,%5531)$>!!!

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 11/12

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !

J!

!

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 ?($!/<'(%-5!=%<)+!)3T$!'%!'(/#T!%<-!-$5$/-0(!'$/.!?$-$5/!9%+/N!F)$Q/#+$-!9%-$5N!^%(#!\-')N!?($%+-30!M3*<-/53#N!630(%)/5!

7/=-3$N!F)35%#!7<,30%N!^$5530/!h<3/5%#N!^<+3'(!8%+-3*<$fN!P(-35'3/#!i/./--%#N!/#+!F<5'3#!i=30T>!?(35!5'<+@!35!1/5$+!%#!$/-)3$-!

+/'/!0%))$0'$+!/5!,/-'!%&!/!)/-*$-!5'<+@!%#!,-*#<-(/:2/:#<%26(0*#3")#=/2"/#9):(/2;2/:#(0#0-*#,>)/#"3#0-*#?2%%*//2>6!=(30(!=/5!

&<#+$+!1@!'($!E<1)30!d$)&/-$!M%<#+/'3%#N!E/#'/!8($/!M%<#+/'3%#N!F.$-30/!83*('5!/'!d%-T!:F8Fd;N!_350%<#'!M%<#+/'3%#N!E%4$-'@!/#+!8/0$!F0'3%#!P$#'$-N!9$-*$-!`/-T5!M%<#+/'3%#N!'($!FM7LPY"N!P?d!/#+!BI!/&&3)3/'$5>!?(35!,%-'3%#!%&!'($!-$5$/-0(!=/5!

&<#+$+!1@!F8FdN![\YXN!/#+!'($!FM7LPY">!!B!6789>!BCDC>!M350/)!j$/-!BCDC!E$-&%-./#0$!F00%<#'/13)3'@!8$,%-'!('',eUU===>#)-1>*%4U,$-&%-./#0$L/#+L/00%<#'/13)3'@!I!M-$+!M$3#5'$3#>!DJJV>!,*1026"/8#"3#@)*&*)24A#BC#@*2/10*2/#D*3")*#0-*#<"662112"/#"/#0-*#@>0>)*#"3#E")A*)F?(/(:*6*/0#

G*%(02"/1C!8$'-3$4$+!M$1-</-@!bN!BCDD!('',eUU+3*3'/)0%..%#5>3)->0%-#$))>$+<UT$@k=%-T,)/0$UIVD!V[$$!E/<)!d$3)$-!DJGI>!lE-%.35$5!'%!m$$,e![$0<-3#*!d%-T$-5n!83*('5!'%![$)&L"-*/#3f/'3%#!X#+$-!'($!

678FNl!$()H()&#B(I#G*H2*I N!4%)>!JHN!#%>!G!:^<#$;N!,,>!DbHJLDGBbg!m/'$!9-%#&$#1-$##$->!DJJV>!R\.,)%@$-!9$(/43%-!3#!

P$-'3&30/'3%#!\)$0'3%#5!/#+!M3-5'LP%#'-/0'!P/.,/3*#5e!Y.,)30/'3%#5!&%-!7/1%-!7/=!8$&%-.NS!3#!M-3$+./#N![($)+%#!$'!/)>!:$+5>;N#

G*10")2/:#0-*#J)"621*#"3#K6*)24(/#B(D")#B(I >!!Y'(/0/N!6j>!!Y78!E-$55N!bKLGJ>!

^%(#![0(.3''!/#+!9$#!i3,,$-$->!BCCJ>!R_-%,,3#*!'($!FQ$e!Y))$*/)!M3-3#*5!_<-3#*!X#3%#!"-*/#3f3#*!P/.,/3*#5N!DJKDLBCCbS>!

P$#'$-!&%-!\0%#%.30!/#+!E%)30@!8$5$/-0(>!d/5(3#*'%#N!_P>N!`/-0(!BCCJg!7/#0$!P%.,/>!BCCV>!=/3(2)#K&H(/0(:*+#E")A*)1L#

@)**&"6#"3#K11"42(02"/#2/#0-*#=/20*&#M0(0*1#>/&*)#./0*)/(02"/(%#$>6(/#G2:-01#M0(/&()&1>!Y'(/0/N!6$=!j%-Te!P%-#$))!X#34$-53'@!

E-$55g!m/'$!9-%#&$#1-$##$->!BCCC>!RX#$/5@!?$--/3#e!?($!Y.,/0'!%&!P/,3'/)!`%13)3'@!%#!d%-T$-5N!d/*$5N!/#+!X#3%#!"-*/#3f3#*>S!!

P%..3553%#$+!8$5$/-0(!E/,$-!/#+![<,,)$.$#'!'%!,-*#=M#,)(&*#N*32420+#<(>1*1O#<"/1*P>*/4*1#(/&#G*4"66*/&(02"/1#3")# K402"/!1@!'($!X[!?-/+$!_$&303'!8$43$=!P%..3553%#>!d/5(3#*'%#N!_Pe!X[!?-/+$!_$&303'!8$43$=!P%..3553%#g!M$-*<5%#N!^%(#LE/<)>!

BCCG>!oo?($!\@$5!%&!'($!6$$+)$5e!F![$Z<$#'3/)!`%+$)!%&!X#3%#!"-*/#3f3#*!_-34$5N!

DJJJpBCCV>AA!Y#+<5'-3/)!/#+!7/1%-!8$)/'3%#5!8$43$=!HB:D;e!IpBD>!5 ?($-$!(/4$!1$$#!5'<+3$5!%#!$.,)%@$-!1$(/43%-!/#+!0$-'3&30/'3%#!$)$0'3%#!'3.3#*!3#!P/#/+/!=(30(!&%<#+!/#@!3#0-$/5$!3#!'($!

#<.1$-!%&!+/@5!1$@%#+!0/-+!0($0T!+$0-$/5$5!'($!)3T$)3(%%+!%&!/!<#3%#!=3#>!:[$$N!&%-!$Q/.,)$N!P(-35!83++$))>!BCDC>!R?($!P/<5/)!

\&&$0'!%&!\)$0'3%#!_$)/@!%#!X#3%#!d3#!8/'$5e!Y#5'-<.$#'/)!q/-3/1)$!\5'3./'$5!&-%.!?=%!6/'<-/)!\Q,$-3.$#'5S!./&>10)2(%#

G*%(02"/1N!q%)>!VJN!6%>!I!:^<)@;N!IbDLIGH!/#+!`30($)$!P/.,%)3$'3N!P(-35!83++$))N!/#+![/-/![)3##>!BCCb>!oo7/1%-!7/=!8$&%-.!/#+!'($!

8%)$!%&!_$)/@!3#!X#3%#!"-*/#3f3#*e!\.,3-30/)!\43+$#0$!&-%.!P/#/+/>AA!./&>10)2(%#(/&#B(D")#G*%(02"/1#G*H2*I !HD:D;e!

IBpKG>!H!m/'$!9-%#&$#1-$##$-!!"#$"%&1#'())*&+#,-*#./0*/12324(02"/#"3#567%"8*)#977"1202"/#0"#9):(/2;2/:!\0%#%.30!E%)30@!Y#5'3'<'$!

9-3$&3#*!E/,$-!rBIK>!`/@!BCN!BCCJ!('',eUU=%-T5>1$,-$55>0%.UT/'$k1-%#&$#1-$##$-UVCU!b!"<-!BCCI!5/.,)$!(/+!DKV!$)$0'3%#5!=3'(!BIH!X7E!/))$*/'3%#5>!Y'!35!/)5%!3.,%-'/#'!'%!#%'$!'(/'!%<-!,/5'!-$5$/-0(!(/5!&%<#+!'(/'!

<#3%#5!&3)$!0(/-*$5!3#!&$=$-!'(/#!(/)&!'($!0/5$5!=($-$!X7E!0/5$5!%00<-!1%'(!1$0/<5$!%&!'($3-!&-<5'-/'3%#5!=3'(!'($!9%/-+!,-%0$55!

/#+!1$0/<5$!3'!35!#%'!3#!'($3-!3#'$-$5'!'%!&3)$!0(/-*$5!3&!3'!35!)3T$)@!'($!<#3%#!35!*%3#*!'%!=3#!'($!$)$0'3%#!53#0$!'($!0(/-*$!0%<)+!1)%0T!'($!$)$0'3%#!.%43#*!&%-=/-+>!G![$$!d$3)$-!DJGIg!9-%#&$#1-$##$-!DJJVg!BCCCg!BCCJg![0(.3''!/#+!i3,,$-$-!BCCJg!/#+!P%.,/!BCCJ>!

9 F)'(%<*(!<#+$-!'($!)/=!<#3%#5!%#)@!#$$+!'%!&3)$!=3'(!/!.3#3.<.!%&!IC!,$-0$#'!%&!'($!1/-*/3#3#*!<#3'!%#!0/-+5!'%!Z</)3&@!&%-!/#!

$)$0'3%#!'%+/@!HC!,$-0$#'!%&!/))!<#3%#5!&3)3#*!&%-!6789!$)$0'3%#5!&3)$!=3'(!/'!)$/5'!HC!,$-0$#'!%&!'($!<#3'!%#!0/-+5> 10 m/'$!9-%#&$#1-$##$-!/#+!8%1$-'!W30T$@>!BCCV>!RP(/#*3#*!'%!"-*/#3f$e!F!6/'3%#/)!F55$55.$#'!%&!X#3%#!"-*/#3f3#*!['-/'$*3$5NS!

3#!8<'(!`3)T./#!/#+!m3.!q%55N!$+5>N!G*D>2%&2/:#B(D")Q#9):(/2;2/:#(/&#9):(/2;*)1#2/#0-*#!*I#=/2"/#?"H*6*/0 >!>!!Y'(/0/N!6j>!!

Y78!E-$55!&%-!.%-$!%#!'($!#/'<-$!%&!<#3%#!%-*/#3f3#*!0/.,/3*#5>!!DD!W3))53+$!F0-$5!Y#0>!!+U1U/!731$-'@!W3))53+$!%&!d3))/-+!Y#0>!/#+!X#3'$+!M%%+!/#+!P%..$-03/)!d%-T$-5!X#3%#N!)%0/)!JDDN!FM7LPY"N!

P7P>!!BG'#9)&*)#<"/1"%2&(02/:#<(1*1#<"/1"%2&(0*&#<"67%(2/0#(/&#!"024*#"3#$*()2/:>!P(/-*$![($$'5e!P/5$!6%5>!GLPFLIVCDDN!GL

PFLIVBDbNLGPFLIVIIDN!GLPFLIVIIBg!P%#&3+$#'3/)!5$'')$.$#'!/*-$$.$#'5!&%-!+350(/-*$+!/#+!+3503,)3#$+!$.,)%@$$5>!!DB!?($!)/5'!0%)<.#!%&!?/1)$!I!35!1/5$+!%#!%<-!&<))!5/.,)$!%&!KKG!0/5$5>!!?($!-$5'!%&!'($!'/1)$!%#)@!3#0)<+$5!'($!0/5$5!&%-!'($!DCB!

BCCI!$)$0'3%#5!3#!'($!5<-4$@!&3)$!=3'(!'($!+/'/!5%-'$+!1@!'3.$!1$'=$$#!+/'$!%&!&3-5'!5$-3%<5!/))$*/'3%#!/#+!$)$0'3%#!+/'$>!?($5$!

+/'/!3#0)<+$!/))!$.,)%@$-!43%)/'3%#5!-$,%-'$+!1@!%-*/#3f$-5!3#0)<+3#*!'(%5$!=($-$!#%!X7E!0(/-*$!=/5!&3)$+!1$0/<5$!$3'($-!'($!

$)$0'3%#!=/5!*%3#*!'%!1$!=%#N!%-!'($!=3'#$55$5!=$-$!'%%!/&-/3+!'%!0%.$!&%-=/-+N!%-!'($!-$.$+3$5!=$-$!#%'!5$$#!/5!=%-'(!'($!'3.$!/#+!-35T>!!DI!?(35!,$-0$#'/*$!,-%1/1)@!<#+$-!$5'3./'$5!5<-4$3))/#0$!53#0$!.%5'!%&!3'!35!$)$0'-%#30!/#+!3#43531)$!'%!'($!=%-T$-5>!

DV!6789!_%0<.$#'!_/'/1/5$!%&!X7E!+%0<.$#'5!3#0)<+$5!/))!%&!'($!M"YF!X7E!+%0<.$#'5!&-%.!%<-!5/.,)$!%&!DCCC!6789!

0$-'3&30/'3%#!$)$0'3%#5!&-%.!DJJJ!'%!BCCI!=3'(!/!JJ!,$-0$#'!M"YF!-$5,%#5$!-/'$!&-%.!'($!6789>!!

 

8/6/2019 Working Paper Cover 2011-01-Final

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/working-paper-cover-2011-01-final 12/12