Working Together toReduce Exposure to Pesticides
City of Prince George
Presented by: Justin Sandhu, Dr. Marie Hay, and Kerensa Medhurst
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Our Mission
The eradication eradication
of cancerof cancer and the
enhancement of enhancement of
the quality of lifethe quality of life
of people living
with cancer.
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Evidence-Based Positions
Providing Canadians with important cancer information based on high-quality evidence is a cornerstone of the Canadian Cancer Society’s (CCS) work.
– Considerable evidence supports a link between between pesticides and cancer.
– The CCS continues to assess new research as it becomes available.
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Pesticides- Cosmetic Use
Pesticides: substances or devices used to kill, suppress or repel target insects, weeds, fungi or other pests. This includes:
• Herbicides (weeds and plants)• Insecticides (insects)• Rodenticides (animals)• Fungicides (fungal)
“Pesticides are poisons, otherwise they wouldn’t wor k”.-Environment Canada
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Pesticides- Cosmetic Use
Cosmetic Use:When pesticides are used to enhance the appearance of private lawns and gardens as well as parks and recreational facilities
•No benefit to human health
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Pesticides & Cancer
Studies have found a 2-3 times increased risk of childhood leukemia associated with childhood or pre-natal exposure to household or garden pesticides.Source: Belson, M., Kingsley, B., and Holmes, A. (2007) Risk factors for acute leukemia in children: A review. Environmental Health Perspectives, 115 (1)
“The adverse effects of pesticides on human and ecosystem health are undeniable. -Warren Bell, MD, Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Distribution of sprayed pesticide :• 50-100% in soil• 0-30% in atmosphere• 1-10% on plant• 0-0.3% on target insect, disease, etc.
Source: Environmental Protection Agency - D. Pimentel
Pesticides & the EnvironmentCanadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Precautionary Principle
It’s better to be safe
than sorry.
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
We are not alone…Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
CU ft,W a ~tt1n Canadian Union of Postal Workers ' a:.=..:..=.:.:.- Syndicat des travailleurs et trava,illeuses des postes e ----,- ~ -~-·r-·"'-" ~
, , I J I l '• .. ~ . .. ' ., , 4 t,' ~ ~·-- ----.---,,-.-..-. • - .- . :;-- • .' •· , I ., ,' (J.
-..::::_..... ~ .... ~
P'IJBLIC HEALTH A S SO CIA TIO N CANADIENNE DE SANTE PUS'L/QUE
1 110 .-earn ing D1sa· 1 1t11es · ssociati1on of 1Ca.nada
BCSPCA SP~NG FOR ANIMA 5·
~~
ldabc•Lea1ming Disabilities Association of British Columbia
David Suzuki Founda1t1ion
ASSO~IA~ION [I;. I M.EDICALE l'
CANADI EN NE ..
CANADIAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
first· ca 11 · Et;: d1 l: i.:1.J Y:.-J 11 ~.J,'!JUl'.r ::~~..: 1
Society Promotlns Environmental
, Con ~rvauon toxic free! Canada
BHITIHI COIJUM• IA t;:::::;;::~
wilds:m , t: ,;'.i.~ lll\Dl:\r~
~ RICA_~- C:AIKCR FOU ND.t;,TIOW F0Hr}IJiT•ll1rJ
C.M,AC,trn [ DU c;.xCE~ DU 5Drl'
:•"1.i.-:11
{i/" ·.> S lt ',H. HA · . ( ~I.UR . . BC
PHABC
Interior Health ~ WliDERNESS ~ COMMITIEIE
MEDICAL SSOCIJIT OH
Community Action
Over 185 Canadian municipalities, including 36 in BC, have adopted pesticide bylaws
Over 23.8 million or 79.6% of Canadians are benefiting from enhanced protection from unwanted exposure to synthetic lawn and garden pesticides
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Success Stories
"The bylaw is working very well, costs us very little to maintain and grass is still growing in Hudson"
-Michael Elliott, former Hudson, Que., mayor, November 22, 2002, The Ottawa Sun
"There is definitely a better way of maintaining lawns and yards than by soaking them with pesticides” –Mark Shmigelsky, former Invermere mayor, March 12, 2008, Invermere Valley Echo
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Alternatives
• There are many alternatives to pesticides.
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Pesticide Bylaws: Best Practices
• All ‘cides’
• All private and public lands
• No infestation clause
• No exceptions except public health
• Permitted, less-toxic pesticides are specified
• + an educational campaign
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Pesticide Free
• On a complaint basis, as with other “nuisance”by-laws (i.e. noise, smoking)
• It can be easy !
• phased-in approach
• Educate and then restrict
• Complaint and then fine
EnforcementCanadian Cancer Society
Societe canadienne du cancer
Isn’t Education Enough?
“Only those communities that passed a by-law and supported it with education or made a community agreement were successful in reducing the use of pesticides by a high degree (51-90%). Education and outreach programs alone, while more popular than by-laws, are far less effective. We could find none that have achieved more than a low reduction (10-24%) in pesticide use to date.”From The Impact of By-Laws and Public Education Programs on Reducing the Cosmetic/Non-essential, Residential Use of Pesticides: A Best Practices Review Jointly prepared by the Canadian Centre for Pollution Prevention and Cullbridge Marketing and Communications
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
What will be the economic impact?
•Bylaws do not harm business
•The number and variety of alternative lawn and gardenproducts is growing
•Development of green economy
•Many businesses are voluntarily shifting away fromsynthetic pesticides
•The economic impact argument should not deter fromthe importance of safeguarding health
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
•It shows leadership, and is the right thing to do from a publichealth perspective
•It will raise the community’s profile as a place that cares aboutthe health of its citizens and theenvironment, and is a safe andhealthy place to raise children
•Fits with sustainability planning, water reduction priorities, and provides strong northern leadership.
Benefits to Prince George Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer
Let’s work together to make a difference
Thank you
Canadian Societe Cancer canadienne Society du cancer