4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Workshop
„S/4 HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management“
22ND International SAP HERUG Conference – TU Berlin – 16 May 2019
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Speakers
Markus GRONERAD SCHEER – Management Consulting
3
Dirk SCHOSSIGSCHEER - HE&R
Michael WILMESTU BERLIN – Strategic SAP Initiatives
Julian WÖSTESCHEER – SAP Consulting
International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management 16 May 2016
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
4
14:00 16:00
StartWarm-Up Workout
Welcome
Intro
What is EAM?
EAM + S/4HANA
Scenario
Excercises
Summary
Q&A / next steps
Closing
Agenda
International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management 16 May 2016
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Stakeholder & IT-systems of universities
6 International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management 16 May 2016
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
SCHEER. Architect of future-proof SAP-solutions for HE&R
7 16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
SCHEER. S/4HANA-implementation methodology
8
✓ Define SAP- and S/4HANA-strategy
✓ Check & optimize IT / SAP, processes, organisation
✓ Define SAP-deployment (cloud / on-prem) &
S/4HANA-migration szenario (green, brown, blue)
✓ Plan S/4HANA-Roadmap / -project
✓ Execute S/4HANA-Migration
✓ Complete SAP-project (for all
migration szenarios) with project
plan, project organization, etc.,
✓ Average duration: 6 mths – 2 yts.
✓ S/4/HANA-
Operations
✓ S/4HANA
Application
Support
now Jan. 2026*
*31.12.2025 – current end of SAP ERP / ECC maintenance
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
S/4 HANA-Assessment / preliminary
study (HANA-Strategy, Business Case,
Analysis, Roadmap)
Conce
ption
Imple
mentat
ion
Change Management / Qualification
Project Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
SCHEER. Service offering for your S/4HANA-implementation
9
S/4 HANA-Assessment / preliminary
study (HANA-Strategy, Business Case,
Analysis, Roadmap)
Conce
ption
Imple
mentat
ion
Change Management / Qualification
Tried and tested Scheer modell: S/4 HANA preliminary study, S/4 HANA implementation & migration
Process driven Scheer university master: Preconfiguered SAP S/4 HANA reference system with university business processes
Documented Knowledge: Templates, SAP concepts, customizing / development doc., training material, test cases
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
Project Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
SCHEER. Process-driven SAP S/4HANA-master for HE&R
Reliability & acceleration for your SAP S/4HANA-implementation!
10
▪ Concept
▪ Documentation
▪ Templates
▪ PM-Tools
▪ Preconfigured SAP S/4 HANA
university reference system
▪ Extensive data bank with
university reference processes
▪ Scheer process-driven SAP:
Proven modell for process
driven SAP implementation
Professional Concept Migration concept Customizing documentation Test concept Training documents templates
University-reference-processes SAP S/4 HANA-university-reference-system
Scheer process-driven for SAP;
Integration of methods, content and tools
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
SCHEER. Process-driven SAP S/4HANA-master for HE&R
SAP S/4HANA HE&R reference-system
HE&R reference-process-architecture / models
Process-driven SAP Implementation methodology
Individual SAP
S/4HANA-solution
Templates, documents, blueprints, etc.
Fundament & guidance for your specific SAP S/4HANA-solution!
University-specific
SAP S/4HANA-system
11 16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
Scheer process-based SAP
implementation methodology
Scheer SAP S/4
HE-Master
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
13 16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Enterprise Architecture Management …
▪ ensures controled changes of the IT-architecture
▪ is a holistic approach
▪ is flexible: allows both - strategic proceeding and local optimisation
▪ allows an target-oriented change in the IT landscape (aligned to strategy and rules)
▪ provides transparency
▪ describes the interaction between business (processes) and IT = business-IT-alignment
EAM helps to achieve objectives, to keep the overview and to steer to the target.
14
Benefits of Enterprise Architecture Management
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
15
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
EAM procedere model – TOGAF* ADM
▪ The ADM (Architecture
Development Method) shows
how to proceed with
architecture changes
▪ It considers different layers,
governance, dependencies etc.
▪ But: It is not easy to
understand for a layperson
* TOGAF is the most common EAM framework.
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
16
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
EAM procedere model – lean SCHEER project approach
Input
• Key Success Factors
University
• Strategy University
• SWOT of EA – BU*
Result
• EA Objectives
• Analyse IT-layers
• SWOT of EA – by
IT Department
• Consider business
requirements
• Processes
• Data
• Applications
• Technology
• Consider EA governance / rules
• Consider crucial requirements
• Consider complete landscape /
dependencies
• EA Operations
• EA Support
• EA Change
Management
EAM-Strategy EAM-Analysis EAM-Design EAM-Realisation EAM-Operations
* Managers / Key Users of the Business Units do the SWOT analysis of the University‘ s EA
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
17
EA diagrams – examples (1/5) – University process map*
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
SCHEER SAP
S/4HANA-master
for HE&R
* The figure shows the first layer. Second layer shows all processes of process areas and layer three and four detailed processes with process steps.
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
18
EA diagrams* – examples (2/5) – Application landscape
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
* The diagrams help to better document, analyse and design the IT-architecture: „a picture is worth a thousand words”.
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
19
EA diagrams – examples (3/5) – Process support map
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
20
EA diagrams – examples (4/5) – data flow diagram
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
21
EA diagrams – examples (5/5) – IT infrastructure core components
What is Enterprise Architecture (Management)?
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Strong connection between EAM and S/4HANA!
23
EAM
SAP*
* The SAP procedure model fits into the general EAM model, which is more extensive and gives rules.
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
▪ Use a holistic approach and work lean
▪ Take care of Business-IT-alignment (consider strategy, crucial IT requirements…)
▪ Consider all layers of EA (Business processes … technology) and consider
dependencies
▪ Do process harmonisation / standardisation
▪ Optimize master data management
▪ Optimize research information and research data system
▪ Use full potential of SAP and non-SAP
24
Principles for effective S/4 migration:
Not just upgrade to S/4, make use of full EAM potential! Do an effective lean EAM to add value!
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
26
Workout-Scenario (1/2)
S/4HANA-Migration @ BIG CIVIC University (BCU)MISSION
BCU decided to migrate from SAP ECC to S/4HANA.
You, the BCU-S/4-Team, suggested not only to migrate the
current SAP to the new release S/4HANA one-to-one.
You follow an EAM-based approach and want to consider the
full range of HANA & also the non-SAP application landscape,
to do optimization, standardization and to expand a solution for
research management, which is existing only rudimentary today.
Additionally, you suggest to implement an Enterprise Service
Bus (SAP Process Orchestration) for better integration.
INITIAL
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
27
Workout-Scenario (2/2)
S/4HANA-Migration @ BIG CIVIC UniversityMISSION
Create project-plan for S/4HANA-Migration!
Consider a EAM-based approach!
Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
TASKs
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 1 / 2: Create EAM-based-project-plan for S/4HANA
28
Strategy Analysis Design Realisation Operation
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 3: Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
16 May 201629
Strategy Analysis Design Realisation Operation
EAM-Strategy
International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
30
Task 3: Results of phase “EAM-Strategy” - Example
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
Key Success Factors of University
• Good research
• Top reputation
Strategy of the University
• Attract more sponsors/funding
• Foster research data and information
EA objectives
• Standardised and centralised application landscape, e.g. use of
SAP
• Implement EA governance processes and EA board
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 3: Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
31
Strategy Analysis Design Realisation Operation
As-is IT-
Architecture
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
32
Task 3: Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
Document the as-is-IT-architecture
Prepare an application catalog of the as-is
IT- / SAP-application landscape and analyze it
Based on the catalog create additional diagrams of as-is
landscape (e.g. process support map)
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 3: Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
33
Create catalog of as-is application landscape
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
General Ledger Accounting, Accounts Payable
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 3: Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
34
Example for a university-as-is-IT-architecture (Teaching / Learning)
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 3: Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
35
Example for a university-as-is-IT-architecture (Reseacrh / Transfer)
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
36
SWOT analysis of the University‘ s EA from IT department‘ s point of view - Example
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
Strengths
• High stability of IT infrastructure
• Good automation by IT
Weaknesses
• „Zoo“ of applications
• Poor EA governance
(responsibilities, decision
making)
• Central solution for CRM missing
Opportunities
• Standardisation and
consolidation through strong
governance
• Value by doing digitalization
initiative
• Projects with high value by using
a lean and efficient EA method
Threats
• Zoo of applications getting even
worse over time
• Wrong EA decisions waste
resources
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 3: Analyse the as-is-IT-architecture!
37
Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
How is the situation regarding the IT application landscape
at your institution? Think of coverage of business needs,
automation, standardisation, stability, IT security etc.
• What is good?
• Where is need for action?*
Write your input on cards and discuss [15 min]
* The assessment what is good (strengths) and where is need for action (weaknesses) is part of the SWOT-analysis of the as-is EA.
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 3: Analyze the as-is-IT-architecture!
38
Exercise 1
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
39
Results of Exercise 1 at HERUG workshop
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
40
Strategy Analysis Design Realisation Operation
To-be IT-
Architecture
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
41
How to proceed to derive the target IT-architecture?
Input from phases strategy and analysis
• EAM strategy
• Key Success factors University
• Strategy of University
• Documentation of as-is IT-architecture
• SWOT of EA
• Results of documentation and analysis of
to-be IT-architecture
• Important business requirements
• EA governance
Design the to-be
IT-architecture
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
42
Derive the to-be landscape from as-is-IT-architecture
Design a sound to-be landscape by standardisation (reduce
number of sw providers) and expanding research
information and data solutions.
• Design to-be applications based on the as-is
IT- / SAP-application catalog [10 min]
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
43
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
Name Provider Functionality To be replaced by
SAP FI SAP SE General ledger accounting, accounts payable, … SAP S/4HANA Finance
DSpace Research Collection DuraSpace Research information and data solution Will not be replaced
Knowledge Portal Individual SW Knowledge base for students and other customers Will not be replaced
. . .
Template of an applications catalog
Instructions:
▪ On the far right column: this is the target application to be implemented during the migration project.
Please look for suitable application systems.
▪ “SAP S/4HANA Finance“ is the chosen to-be application for finance functionality.
▪ “DSpace Research Collection“ will not be replaced.
▪ „Knowledge Portal“ will not be replaced.
as-is to-be
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
44
Exercise 2.1
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
45
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
Name Provider Functionality To be replaced by
SAP FI SAP SE Hauptbuchhaltung, Kreditorenbuchhaltung, … SAP S/4HANA Finance
Grants Management SAP SE Grants management SAP S/4HANA Grant Mgt.
SAP BW SAP SE Reporting, Analysis SAP BW4HANA
SAP SLcM SAP SE Student-Lifecycle-Management SAP SLcM
Recruiting Faculty Non – individual system Recruiting employees SAP SuccessFactors
Payroll ADP Payroll management SAP SuccessFactors
Talent Management Oracle Talent management SAP SuccessFactors
Maximo Asset Management IBM Asset management SAP S/4HANA Asset Mgt.
CRM (Excel sheets) Microsoft Customer relationship management SAP C/4HANA
DSpace Research Collection DuraSpace Research information and data solution Will not be replaced
Knowledge Portal Individual SW Knowledge base for students and other customers Will not be replaced
Example: Solution: Application catalog*
as-is to-be
* The applications and providers in the catalog are illustrative. The purpose of the exercise is to show a few templates to do the design.
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
General Ledger Accounting, Accounts Payable
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
46
Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
Design a sound to-be landscape by standardization (reduce
number of sw providers) and expanding research information
and data solutions.
• Draft components of the to-be IT / SAP-landscape.
[10+ min]
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
47
Exercise 2.2
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
49
Example Solution: Components of the to-be application landscape*
* The applications in the diagram are illustrative. The purpose of the exercise is to show a few templates to do the design.
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
Functionalities are e.g.
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
50
Draft a data-flow-diagram!
Design a sound to-be landscape by standardization (reduce
number of sw providers) and expanding research information
and data solutions.
• Draft data flow diagram showing the major
interconnections between to-be-application systems and
focus on exchange of research data & information.
[10+ min]
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Task 4: Design the to-be-IT-/ SAP-landscape!
51
Exercise 2.3
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
52
Example Solution: Data flow diagram of the to-be application landscape*
* The applications in the diagram are illustrative. Only a few data flows with research information/data are shown to demonstrate the principle.
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Variant 1: Usual approach for S/4HANA migration
▪ Migrate existing SAP functionality one-by-one
▪ Focus on SAP and interfaces
Variant 2: Our recommandation
▪ Use a holistic approach based on Enterprise Architecture method
▪ Consider business-IT-alignment
▪ Analyse and design SAP and non-SAP application landscape
▪ Think of MDM and process harmonization also during the migration program
Benefits of variant 2: doing the right things + using full potential of the IT-architecture
54
Summary
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
56
Next steps
✓ Enterprise Architecture Management is increasingly becoming
a (critical) success factor for all universities that rely on SAP and
see digitization strategically
✓ We offer to establish appropriate EAM - S/4HANA-working
groups (within the German and the international HERUG)
✓ These groups should also enable further networking, for
example with the EAM Special Interest Group of EUNIS
✓ If you want to join, please contact us!
Let´s establish EAM @ HERUG!
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management
4.53
1.54
2.32
4.61
Scheer GmbH
Wendenstraße 130
20537 Hamburg
Germany
M +49 162 293 47 21
Dirk SchossigSENIOR MANAGER
HEAD OF HE&R @ SCHEER
Scheer GmbH supports companies in
their digital transformation. This includes
the development of new business
models, the optimisation of business
processes as well as the reliable
operation of IT.
57
Get in contact:
16 May 2016International SAP HERUG Conference 2019 – TU Berlin | Workshop : S/4HANA - Added Value by Enterprise Architecture Management