Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
WÄRTSILÄ CORPORATION MARINE SOLUTIONS ENGINES RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT
USE OF LPG IN WÄRTSILÄ INTERNAL COMBUSTION ENGINES : ALTERNATIVE FUEL AND EXPERIMENTAL PURPOSES
Paolo ManganoWartsila Italia R&D Laboratory
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
Why WÄRTSILÄ at GTC and at WLPGA Forum
Because :
1. GAS is the FUTURE FUEL for Internal Combution Engines
2. WÄRTSILÄ has long and successful history in gas engines design
and production, and its R&D departments invested in LPG
storage, vaporization and internal distribution plants
3. LPG usage for experimental purposes is important for
technological reasons, gases mixtures combustion studies and
for designing environmental friendly solutions
4. Validation of W-products with LPG, Ethane and other gases
supports our portfolio development and future applications with
«associated gases» (available from oil fields and refining
processes), and opens market opportunities
CH4 C2H6 C3H8 C4H10
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
Fully owned sites
Sites with R&D
Joint Venture sites
Licensee sites
QMD (Qingdao, China)2-stroke engines
WQDC (Shanghai, China)4-stroke engines
Wärtsilä CME (Zhenjiang, China)Propulsion
WHEC (Mokpo, South Korea)4-stroke engines
Khopoli, IndiaGensets,
Auxiliary modules,Ecotech modules
Wuxi, ChinaPropulsion,
seals & bearings
Gothenburg, SwedenWater treatment, seals & bearings
Stord, NorwayElectrical & automation systems
Santander, SpainPropulsion
Hull, Reading Newcastle, UK Valves
Poole, UKWater systems
Aalborg, Denmark Deepwell pumps and seawater lift pumps
Singapore, Engine room pumps, pump room systems and Fi-Fi pumps
Suzhou, ChinaAssembly & sourcing
Geestacht, Germany Fresh water generation & condensation plants
Moss, NorwayInert gas and exhaust gas
scrubber systems
Trondheim, NorwayFrequency converters
Trieste, Italy4-stroke engines,propulsion, R&D
Vaasa, Finland4-stroke engines, R&D
Bermeo, SpainR&D
Winterthur, Switzerland2-stroke engines Services
WinGD, Winterthur, Switzerland
Helsinki & Espoo, FinlandR&D
Turku, FinlandR&D
Drunen, the NetherlandsR&D, Propulsion
Açu Superport, Brazil
4-stroke gensets,propulsion,
WÄRTSILÄ in the World
Toyama, JapanSeals & bearings
Havant, UK; Slough, UK
Seals & bearings
Vigo, SpainSeals & bearings
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
WÄRTSILÄ GROWTH AREAS
Environmental
solutions
Gas as a fuel
Environmental regulation and
increased focus on optimised lifecycle
efficiency create demand in the marine
industry.
Emission reduction and control are
key focus areas in Marine Solutions
Engines R&D
Economic and environmental reasons
increase the growth potential for gas
solutions in “Marine Solutions” and in
“Energy Solutions” end markets.
We continue to be the leading 4-
stroke engines provider for
• gas fuelled vessels in all
segments
• gas power plants
Smart Power
Generation
The transition to sustainable and
contemporary energy systems drives
the demand for smart power
generation.
Our engines are a core part of
«Energy Solutions» business,
supporting this transition with
• fuel flexibility
• efficiency
• operational flexibility
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
WÄRTSILÄ : focus and core competence areas
RELIABILITY
OPERATIONAL
FLEXIBILITY
=
Various fuels
ENERGY EFFICIENCY &
EMISSIONS
=
Various fuels
Core
technologies
and core
components
Power
systems
Air and Exhaust
systems
Fuel
systems
Automation
systems
Exhaust treatment
systems
Core
Competence
areas
Combustion &
chemistryProduct design Controls
Validation and integration
Effective
design
9.1.2015
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
WÄRTSILÄ : Medium Speed Engines Portfolio
Engine output (MW)
0 5 10 15 20 25
Wärtsilä 38
Wärtsilä 26
Wärtsilä 34DF
Wärtsilä 20
Wärtsilä 32
Wärtsilä 46/46F/46DF
Wärtsilä 50DF
Wärtsilä 34SG
Wärtsilä 50SG
Wärtsilä 20DF
Auxpac 16
Wärtsilä W31DF, W31SG
Wärtsilä 31 Diesel
Ethane (gas mode, «pilot» production)
LPG (gas mode, «pilot» production)
LPG (liquid mode,«pilot» production)
Gas
Diesel
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
WÄRTSILÄ Gas Technologies
******** ***
******** ***
*********
* *
GAS INJECTION
GAS INJECTION
GAS INJECTION
DUAL-FUEL (DF)
Low gas pressure
LFO pilot fuel
SPARK-IGNITION GAS (SG)
Low gas pressure
Pure gas engine
GAS-DIESEL (GD)High gas pressure
LFO pilot fuel
9.1.2015
1987 1992 1995
DUAL-FUEL (DF)GAS-DIESEL (GD) SPARK-IGNITION GAS (SG)
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
Otto or Diesel ideal cycles: effects on NOX
Big temperature
difference
NOx formation!
Diesel, max flame temp.
Otto, max flame temp.
CO2
NOx
SOx
Particulates
Dual-Fuel engine
in gas mode
Diesel
engine
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Emission
values [%]
Environmental benefits moving from liquid to gas fuels!
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
WÄRTSILÄ Engines Research & Development locations
Trieste, Italy• Technology
Development Programs
• Design, Analysis and
Expertise
• Performance, Testing &
Validation
Bermeo, Spain
• Performance, Testing
& Validation
Finland• Technology Development Programs
• Product Development Programs
• Research & Innovation Management
• Design, Analysis and Expertise
• Performance, Testing & Validation
• Environmental Products &
Technologies
• Automation & Controls
Espoo, Finland
Vaasa, Finland
Turku, Finland
• Marine Solutions Engines R&D ~480
• Strong emphasis on technology
leadership and innovation
• Long-term co-operation with research
institutes and partners
~ 200 employees
4 sites and laboratories
22 test engines
~ 20 test rigs
2 Single Cylinder Engines
2 Gas Mixing Stations
WÄRTSILÄ R&D laboratories
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
W6L20DFCRW10V31SG W6L34 DF W9L20DF
W6L32EW10V31DF
W6L50SG W8L46DF
W6L50DFW16V34SG W6L20DF W20V32SG
WÄRTSILÄ R&D LABS : ”gas technology” engines
RTX-5
Ethane
LPG in gas mode (Exp)
LPG + NG (Exp)
LPG in liq.mode (Exp)
NG or Dual Fuel (*)
(*) NG + LFO
(**) = in «pilot» production
Exp = Experimental
(**)
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
Gas Mixing Station : why
• It needs to study how gas composition affects anti-knocking properties
• Knocking is sharp sound caused by premature combustion of part of the
compressed air-fuel mixture in the cylinder
• Several mixtures of gases in various compositions can be prepared and tested, to
simulate customers conditions and study knocking characteristics
• Generally CH4 and inert gases have high anti-knock properties
• Long hydrocarbon chains e.g. n-C6H14 cause knocking, even if their amount is low
in gas fuel mixture
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
Motor Octane Number (MON)
• Octane system is used mainly for liquid fuels (i.e. petrol, gasoline); it has been suggested
also for gaseous fuels, but it is not really suitable for them
• MON method was applied to small bore test engines with a stoichiometric mixture : the
conditions in large bore engines cylinder are totally different ones
• CH4 MON is out of range, about 130…140
KNOCKING SENSITIVITY 1
N-Butane Number (NBN)
• NBN system uses n-butane as a pro-knock component instead of Hydrogen, based on
engine tests done in 1980’s on large bore lean burn engines (bore 228 and 450 mm).
• Other non-methane hydrocarbons are “reduced” to n-butane with correction factors; if a
gas mixture has NBN 5, it means that the mixture knocks as easily as mixture of 95% CH4
and 5% n-C4H10
There is no universally accepted standard for determining knock sensitivity of gaseous
fuels.
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
• MN conventionally represents gas knocking properties; GMS aims at preparing and
studying gas mixtures knocking effects
• Methane (CH4) as anti-knocking element MN = 100
• Hydrogen (H2) as knocking element MN = 0
• Propane (C3H8) MN = approx. 35
In early 1970’s a “MN model” was developed based on tests on small engines and
stoichiometric mixture with Hydrogen as a reference fuel and no heavier hydrocarbons
than butane
• Heavier hydrocarbons decrease MN
• Inert gases increase MN
Correction factors are introduced by engine manufacturers to adjust the model
Examples of natural gases MN (just indicative data) : Russian 92, North Sea 73,
Algeria 71, Japan 63, Canada 91, The Netherland 90
KNOCKING SENSITIVITY 2
Methane Number (MN)
Tests results show that gaseous fuel sensitivity to knocking saturates when
the share of pro-knocking component gets very high
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
Methane Number (MN) systems
BLEND 1 BLEND 2 BLEND 3
Methane 68 80 90
Ethane 13 8 5
Propane 14 5 3
Iso-Butane 0 2 1
N-Butane 3 2 1
lso-Pentane 0 1 0
N-Pentane 0 1 0
Hexane 2 0 0
Heptane 0 1 0
C/H ratio 0.29 0.27 0.26
H/C ratio 3.61 3.74 3.88
Waukesha 51 56.1 77.3
MN (AVL-meth) 47.4 50.1 67.2
MN Wärts Corr 45 43.8 67.2
MN CAT 25.7 26.3 67.6
Binary CH4 mixtures
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
vol-% in CH4
MN
H2
C2H6
C3H8
C4H10
1:1
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
Gas combustion, knocking & Methane Number
Knock
margin
Change in knock margin due to various parametersGas engine output derating due to MN
(indicative graph)
Gas Engine Combustion map; BMEP = Brake Mean Effective Pressure (proportional to engine power)
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
LPG and Gas Mixing Station in WÄRTSILÄ Italy, TriesteLPG liquid to
vaporizer
LPG liquid to «GD» type engine;
technology & plant not yet released
LPG gaseous or LPG + NG mixture
13 bar stream
NG stream to GMS
LPG gaseous or LPG + NG mixture
8 bar stream
Draft-.13Doc.ID: Revision: Status:© Wärtsilä Internal
Conclusion : LPG and Gas Mixing Station in WÄRTSILÄ
1. LPG & GMS plant for experimental purposes in WÄRTSILÄ Italy:
capacity up to 2000 kg/h
2. GMS plant ready for upgrades to inert gases (N2, CO2) and other fuels
3. Experimental gas engines power with LPG fuel : 2100 - 6000 kW
LPG gas engines portfolio : 3000 - 7500 kW, with LPG composition : C3H8 min.
97%, C4 + heavier alkanes max. 3%, alkenes max 2%
GAS is the future fuel for Internal Combustion Engines, but natural gas / LNG
are not the only winning gaseous fuels :
1. Combustion processes are to be simulated and variables influence studied
by altering NGs composition, to fine-tune gas engines setup &
performances;
2. As «associated gases» from oil fields or crude oil refining, other mixtures
of gases and LPG are important energy sources for future energy
solutions!