CO-ORDINATOR:
CA. SUNIL G. KHANDELWAL
SPEAKERS:
SHRI R.S. GOYAL
CA. KRISHAN GARG
CA. PRAKHAR GOYAL
Friday, 05 April 2019
CHAIRMAN CA. PANKAJ SHAH
PRESIDENT CA. VIKRAM GUPTE
4/5/2019
1
GST ‐ REAL ESTATE
TAXABILITY on NEW PROJECTS w.e.f. 01.04.2019(CONCEPTS & CONDITIONS)
NEW PROJECT???“Project that commences onor after 1st April , 2019” shall bein
epe
sm
sda
ble
te
classified under the category of NEWPROJECT.
defi
typ
term
affo
rdrat
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
ine
pes
ms
dabl
ete
TYPES OF CONSTRUCTION IN A
PROJECT
defi
typ
term
affo
rdrat
Affordable Residential apartment in RREP/REP
Residential apartment Other than Affordable in RREP/REP
Commercial Apartments in
an RREP
Commercial Apartments in project other than RREP.
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
4/5/2019
2
ine
pems
able
te
IMPORTANT TERMS & DEFINITIONS
Real Estate Project (REP)
Residential apartment
defityp
term
affo
rdrat
Residential Real Estate Project
(RREP)
Carpet Area
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
ine
pems
able
te
IMPORTANT TERMS & DEFINITIONS“Real Estate Project (REP)” : It
shall have the same meaningas assigned to it in clause (zn)of Sec. 2 of RERA Act, 2016
"real estate project" means the developmentof a building or a building consisting of
Real Estate Project (REP)
Residential apartment
defityp
term
affo
rdrat
apartments, or converting an existing buildingor a part thereof into apartments, or thedevelopment of land into plots or apartment,as the case may be, for the purpose of sellingall or some of the said apartments or plots orbuilding, as the case may be, and includes thecommon areas, the development works, allimprovements and structures thereon, and alleasement, rights and appurtenancesbelonging thereto;
Residential Real Estate Project
(RREP)
Carpet Area
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
ine
pems
able
te
IMPORTANT TERMS & DEFINITIONS
Real Estate Project (REP)
Residential apartment
“Residential apartment”shall mean apartmentintended for residential useas declared to the RERAA th it t t
defityp
term
affo
rdrat
Residential Real Estate Project
(RREP)
Carpet Area
Authority or competentauthority
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
4/5/2019
3
ine
pems
able
te
IMPORTANT TERMS & DEFINITIONS
Real Estate Project (REP)
Residential apartment
“Residential Real EstateProject (RREP)” : It shallmean a REP in which thecarpet area of the
i l t t i t
defityp
term
affo
rdrat
Residential Real Estate Project
(RREP)
Carpet Area
commercial apartments is notmore than 15 percent of thetotal carpet area of all theapartments in the REP.
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
ine
pems
able
te
IMPORTANT TERMS & DEFINITIONS
Real Estate Project (REP)
Residential apartment
“ Carpet Area” shall have thesame meaning as assignedin clause (k) of Sec. 2 ofRERA Act, 2016.
It means Net usable floor area,excluding
defityp
term
affo
rdrat
Residential Real Estate Project
(RREP)
Carpet Area
excluding
Area covered by external walls
Areas under service shaft
Exclusive balcony or verandaharea
Exclusive open terrace area
But includes area covered bythe internal partition walls ofthe apartment ‐CA. Prakhar Goyal
(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
ine
pes
msable
te
AFFORDABLE RESIDENTIAL APARTMENT for NEW PROJECT???
A residential apartment having…
Carpet area not di 60 S Mt
Carpet area not exceeding 90 Sq. Mtrs
defi
typ
term
affo
rdrat exceeding 60 Sq. Mtrs
in a metropolitan city and gross amount charged for which is not more than 45.00
Lakhs Rupees.
g qin a city/town other than a metropolitan city and gross amount charged for which is not more than 45.00
Lakhs Rupees.
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
4/5/2019
4
ine
pes
ms
able
te
Metropolitan Cities
DELHI NCR (DELHI, NOIDA, GREATER NOIDA, GHAZIABAD, GURGAON, FARIDABAD)
KOLKATA
defi
typ
term
affo
rdrat
BANGALORE
CHENNAI
HYDERABAD
MUMBAI (whole MMR)
KOLKATA
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
ine
pes
ms
able
te
Gross Amount???
Consideration charged for construction ofaffordable residential apartment;
Amount charged for transfer of land orundivided share of land, as the case maybe including by way of lease or sub lease;
defi
typ
term
affo
rdrat be including by way of lease or sub lease;
Any other amount charged by thepromoter from the buyer of the apartmentincluding preferential location charges,development charges, parking charges,common facility charges etc.
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
ine
pes
ms
dabl
e
te
Effective GST Rates for NEW PROJECT
1% 5% 5% 12%
defi
typ
term
affo
rdrat
Affordable Residential Apartment
in RREP/REP
Residential Apartment other than Affordable Residential apartment in RREP/REP
Commercial Apartment in
RREP
Commercial Apartment in project other than RREP
NO ITC NO ITCNO ITC ITC AVAILABLE
4/5/2019
5
ine
pes
ms
dabl
e
te
CONDITIONS for NEW EFFECTIVE GST RATES OF 1% & 5% !!!
1No INPUT TAX
CREDIT
280% of
VALUE of
defi
typ
term
affo
rdrat
*[other than services by way of grant of development rights, long termlease of land (against upfront payment in the form of premium, salami,development charges etc.) or FSI (including additional FSI), electricity,high speed diesel, motor spirit, natural gas], used in supplying the service
shall be received from registered supplier ONLY.
CREDIT available
VALUE of INPUT & INPUT
SERVICES
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
ine
pes
ms
dabl
e
te
• PROVIDED THAT...• inputs & input services on which tax is paid on reversecharge basis shall be deemed to have been purchasedfrom registered person;
• when such inputs & input services falls short of saidthreshold of 80%, tax shall be paid on value of suchshortfall at the rate of 18% on reverse charge basis.
defi
typ
term
affo
rdrat
PROVIDED ALSO THAT NOTWITHSTANDING
ANYTHING SAID ABOVE, IF CEMENT IS RECEIVEDFROM URP, TAX SHALL BE PAID BY PROMOTER ONRCM BASIS@ rate applicable to cement. (28%)
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
SlNo.
Name of Input goods and services
% of input goods &services receivedduring thefinancial year
Whetherinputs fromregisteredperson (Y/N)
1 Sand 10 Y
2 Cement 15 N
3 Steel 20 Y
4 Bricks 15 Y
ILLUSTRATIONS
4 Bricks 15 Y
5 Flooring tiles 10 Y
6 Paints 5 Y
7 Architect/ designing/ CAD drawing etc.
10 Y
8 Aluminium windows, Ply,commercial wood
15 Y
4/5/2019
6
SlNo.
Name of Input goods and services
% of input goods &services receivedduring thefinancial year
Whetherinputs fromregisteredperson (Y/N)
1 Sand 10 Y
2 Cement 15 Y
3 Steel 20 Y
4 Bricks 15 Y
ILLUSTRATIONS
4 Bricks 15 Y
5 Flooring tiles 10 Y
6 Paints 5 N
7 Architect/ designing/ CAD drawing etc.
10 Y
8 Aluminium windows, Ply,commercial wood
15 N
ILLUSTRATIONSSlNo.
Name of Input goods and services
% of input goods& servicesreceived duringthe financial year
Whether inputsfrom registeredperson (Y/N)
1 Sand 10 N
2 Cement 15 N
3 Steel 15 Y
4 Bricks 10 Y
5 Flooring tiles 10 Y
6 Paints 5 Y
7 Architect/ designing/ CAD drawing etc.
10 N
8 Aluminium windows 15 N
9 Ply, commercial wood 10 N
# Important Explanations:
i. Project wise account of inward supplies from registered& unregistered supplier shall be maintained.
ii. Tax on shortfall to be calculated at end of FY & taxliability on shortfall shall be added to output tax liability
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
in the month not later than the month of june followingthe end of FY.
iii. However, tax on cement from URP shall be paid underRCM in the month in which cement is received.
iv. ITC not availed shall be reported every month in 3Breturn as ineligible credit.
4/5/2019
7
# Other Important Changes:
Description of service Rate (%)
Conditions for applicability
Composite supply ofworks contract suppliedby way of construction,erection, commissioning,
12 • carpet area of affordable residential apartment isnot less than 50% of total carpet area of allapartment in a project.• to decide value for determining affordable
‐CA. Prakhar Goyal(SatyanarayanGoyal & Co.)
installation, completion,fitting out, repair,maintenance, renovationor alteration ofaffordable residentialapartment in new projector ongoing project (withnew rates)
apartment: value shall be value of similar apartmentbooked nearest to date of signing of contract forsuch services.• in case finally, carpet area of affordableresidential is less than 50% of total carpet area:The recipient shall be liable to pay tax on RCMbasis as is equal to difference between the tax atapplicable rate & the tax actually paid.
05-04-2019
1
1
R.S. Goyal, Tax Practitionerswebsite : www.rsgoyal.com
e-mail : [email protected]
2
Supply of TDR or FSI by land owner
• Supply of TDR or FSI by land owner to developer• for construction of Residential apartment
Project/Period On or after 01.04.19
Residential apartment sold before CC
No liability of tax on supply of TDR or FSI for residentialprojects
Liability of tax on Builder under RCM No liability of RCM on TDR received by builders
Liability of tax on Builder/ land owner on
the residential apartment sold by them
• At effective rate of 1% in case of affordableResidential house &
• At effective rate of 5% in case of other thanaffordable Residential house 5%
SUPPLY OF TDR OR FSI SUPPLIED ON OR AFTER 01.04.2019 &
CASE 1 – SUPPLY OF RESIDENTIAL APARTMENT BEFORE CC
3
Supply of TDR or FSI by land owner
• Supply of TDR by land owner for construction ofcommercial apartment –
• Liability for tax on supply of TDR for Comm. Apartment
Commercial apartment sold before
CC
Liable for tax on supply of TDR for commercialprojects
Liability of tax on Builder under RCM
No exemption to builder for depositing tax under RCMon TDR received by him. He shall be liable to deposittax on Value of TDR supplied by Land Owner.
Liability of tax on Builder/ land owner on
the commercial apartment sold by them
At effective rate of 12% on supply of commercialapartments
SUPPLY OF TDR OR FSI SUPPLIED ON OR AFTER 01.04.2019 &
CASE 2 – SUPPLY OF COMMERCIAL APARTMENT BEFORE CC
05-04-2019
2
4
Supply of TDR or FSI by land owner
• Supply of TDR by land owner in the residential & comm.apartment
• If TDR given for construction of both resi. & comm.apartment
• – Liability of tax on pro-rata basis
Residential/commercial apartment sold
before CC
• Liability of tax on Pro-rata basis• on supply of TDR related to commercial apartment only
SUPPLY OF TDR OR FSI SUPPLIED ON OR AFTER 01.04.2019 &
CASE 3 – SUPPLY OF RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL APARTMENT BEFORE CC
5
Residential/commercial apartment sold
before CC
Exemption available for construction of residentialapartment as per formula (#1)
GST Payable on TDR or FSI (including additional FSI)
or both for construction of the project X
(carpet area of the residential apartments in the project
Total carpet area of the residential & commercial apartments in the project.
(#1)
SUPPLY OF TDR OR FSI SUPPLIED ON OR AFTER 01.04.2019 &
CASE 3 – SUPPLY OF RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL APARTMENT BEFORE CC
Liability of tax on Builder under RCM
• No liability of RCM on builders for residential aprt. if sold before CC• but liable for RCM on Comm. Aprt. Irrespective of issuance of CC
6
GST Payable on TDR or FSI for construction of the project
Xcarpet area of the residential apartments in
the project
Total carpet area of the residential & commercial apartments in the project.
SUPPLY OF TDR OR FSI SUPPLIED ON OR AFTER 01.04.2019 &CASE 3 – SUPPLY OF RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL APARTMENT BEFORE CC Example
3,50,000.00 x 50,000.00 =
Value of Exempted RCM if all the Residential Flats sold before CC
87,500.00 2,00,000.00
Calculation of exempted value of RCMGST on supply of TDR or FSI 3,50,000.00 Carpet Area Residential Apartment 50,000.00 Carpet Area Commercial Apartment 1,50,000.00 Total carpet area 2,00,000.00 Residential apartments remaining un- booked on the date of issuance of completion certificate or first occupation 20,000.00
RCM Payable on the Portion of commercial Property = 2,62,500.00 Total = 3,50,000.00
05-04-2019
3
7SUPPLY OF TDR OR FSI SUPPLIED ON OR AFTER 01.04.2019 &
CASE 3 – SUPPLY OF RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL APARTMENT BEFORE CC
Liability of tax on Builder/ land owner on
the residential/ commercial apartment
sold by them
• At effective rate of 1% in case of affordableresidential house
• At effective rate of 5% in case of other thanaffordable residential house
• At effective rate of 12% on supply of comm.Apartments
8
Supply of TDR or FSI by land owner
• Supply of TDR or FSI by land owner to Developer forconstruction of Residential apartment –
• if flat remained un-booked on the date of issuance ofCC or First Occupation whichever is earlier
SUPPLY OF TDR OR FSI AFTER ISSUANCE OF CC OR FIRST OCCUPATION – PROVISO
CASE 4 – RESIDENTIAL PROJECT
9
Liability of tax on Builder under RCM
Liability of RCM on Pro-rata basis on such proportion ofvalue of development rights for residential apartmentsremained un-booked on the date of issuance of CC as perthe formula (#2) provided in Noti No. 4 dt 29.03.19 but in anycase the tax under RCM shall not exceed 1% in case ofaffordable resi. houses & 5% in case of other resi. house
05-04-2019
4
10
GST Payable on TDR or FSI for construction of the residential apartments in the project but for the
exemption contained hereinX
carpet area of the residential apartments in the project which remain un-booked on the date of
issuance of completion certificate or first occupation
Total carpet area of the residential apartments in the project.
(#2) SUPPLY OF RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL APARTMENT AFTER CC Example
Amount to be paid at the time of issuance of completion certificate or first occupation GST on supply of TDR or FSI 3,50,000.00 Carpet Area Residential Apartment 50,000.00 Carpet Area Commercial Apartment 1,50,000.00 Total carpet area 2,00,000.00
Residential apartments remaining un- booked on the date of issuance of completion certificate or first occupation 20,000.00
87,500.00 x 20,000.00 = 35,000.00
50,000.00
Amount to be paid at the time of issuance of completion certificate or first occupation by builder under RCM = 35,000.00
11
Liability of tax on Builder/ land owner on
the residential/ commercial apartment
sold by them
• No liability of GST on the residential apartmentremained un-booked up to the date of issuance ofCC and sold after issuance of CC or first occupationwhichever is earlier
TIME OF SUPPLY FOR SUPPLY OF TDR
The time of supply shall arise on date of completion or firstoccupation, whichever is earlier.
12
Supply of Long Term LeaseService by way of granting of Long term lease of 30years or more
Project/PeriodOn or after 01.04.19 for construction of residentialapartments for sale
LONG TERM LEASE
05-04-2019
5
13
Residential/commercial apartment sold
before CC
Exemption available for construction of residentialapartment as per formula (#3)
GST Payable on upfront amount (called as premium, salami, cost, price, development
charges or by any other name) payable for long term lease of land for construction of the project
X(carpet area of the residential apartments in the
project/
Total carpet area of the residential & commercial apartments in the project.
(#3)
14
Liability of tax on Builder
under RCM
Liability of RCM on Pro-rata basis on such proportion of upfrontamount for residential apartments remained un-booked on thedate of issuance of CC as per the formula (#4) provided in NotiNo. 4 dated 29.03.19 but in any case the tax under RCM shallnot exceed 1% in case of affordable residential houses and5% in case of other residential house
GST Payable on upfront amount (called as premium, salami, cost, price, development
charges or by any other name) payable for long term lease of land for construction of the project)
but for the exemption contained herein)
X
(carpet area of the residential apartments in the project which remain un-booked or un-sold on
the date of issuance of completion certificate or first occupation/
Total carpet area of the residential apartments in the project.
(#4)
15
Liability of tax on Builder/ land owner on the
residential/ commercial apartment sold by them
At effective rate of 1% in case of affordable residentialhouse & at effective rate of 5% in case of other thanaffordable residential house 5%
TIME OF SUPPLY FOR SUPPLY OF TDR
The time of supply shall arise on date of completion or firstoccupation, whichever is earlier.
05-04-2019
6
16
• Value of Supply of TDR/FSI by a person to the
builder/developer
• shall be deemed to be equal to the value of similar
apartments
• charged by the builder/developer from the independent
buyers
• nearest to the date on which such TDR/FSI transferred to the
builder.
TERMINOLOGY –VALUE OF SUPPLY OF TDR/FSI FOR THE PURPOSE OF RCM
17
• Value of portion of residential or commercial apartment
• remained un-booked on the date of CC or first occupation
• shall be deemed to be equal to the value of similar apartment
• charged by the promoter nearest to the date of issuance of
CC/FO.
TERMINOLOGY –VALUE OF SUPPLY OF UN-BOOKED PORTION
18
3. The following term shall have the same meaning as
assigned it under RERA :-
a. Apartment
b. Promoter
c. Project
d. Real Estate Project (REP)
e. Carpet Area
TERMINOLOGY –DEFINITION BORROWED FROM RERA
05-04-2019
7
19
• Residential Real Estate Project (RREP) means
• REP in which carpet area of commercial apartment
• is not more than 15% of the total carpet area
• of all the apartments in the REP.
TERMINOLOGY –Ceiling of Commercial Apartment in RREP
20
• The term ‘an aprt. booked on or before the date of issuance of CC or FO
• shall mean an aprt. which meets all the following three conditions :-
a. Part of supply of construction of the apartment service has time of
supply on or before the said date; and
b. Consideration equal to at least one instalment has been credited to
the bank account of the RP on or before the said date; and
c. An allotment letter or sale agreement or any other similar
document evidencing booking of the aprt. has been issued on or
before the said date.
TERMINOLOGY –Conditions for terming the apartment as booked
21
Insertion of services for RCM u/s 9(3) of CGST Act.Noti No. 05/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
History of Liability of GST on TDR - In case of supply of services by a person to the developer for transferred of development right (TDR) or FSI for construction of a project, previously the liability was on the person who provides such services viz on the landowner.
05-04-2019
8
22
Insertion of services for RCM u/s 9(3) of CGST Act. Noti No. 05/2019-Central Tax (Rate) Cont….
More so, for supply of long term lease against consideration
in the form of upfront amount and/or periodic rent
for construction of project by a promoter,
previously the liability was on the person who provides such
services
viz on the landowner.
23
Insertion of services for RCM u/s 9(3) of CGST Act. Noti No. 05/2019 Cont…….
Now a new Entry No. 5b inserted in Noti No. 13/2017-
Central Tax (Rate) dated 28-06-17,
the liability to pay tax shifted from the person, who supplies
the services,
to the promoter who construct the project.
24
(Noti No. 06/2019-Central Tax (Rate))
Registered persons specified for liability to pay GST on receipt
of TDR/FSI/ Long Term Lease u/s 148 of GST Act.
the Central Govt., on the recommendations of the Council,
notified the following classes of RP to pay GST
on receipt of TDR/FSI/ Long Term Lease u/s 148 of GST Act.
05-04-2019
9
25Treatment of TDR/ FSI and Long term lease for projects commencing and supply of Construction service in lieu thereof-after 01.04.2019 - Noti No. 06/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
• a promoter who receives development rights or FSI
• on or after 1st April, 2019 for construction of a project
• against consideration payable or paid by him, wholly or partly,
• in the form of construction service of commercial or residential
apartments
• in the project or in any other form including in cash;
26Treatment of TDR/ FSI and Long term lease for projects commencing and supply of Construction service in lieu thereof-after 01.04.2019 - Noti No. 06/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
• a promoter, who receives long term lease of land
• on or after 1st April, 2019
• for construction of residential apartments in a project
• against consideration payable or paid by him,
• in the form of upfront amount,
27Noti No. 06/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
RP liable to pay GST on following activities -
(a) the consideration paid by him
• in the form of construction service of
• commercial or residential apartments
• in the project,
• for supply of development rights or FSI;
05-04-2019
10
28Noti No. 06/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
RP liable to pay GST on following activities -
(b) the monetary consideration paid by him,
• for supply of development rights or FSI relatable to
• construction of residential apartments in project;
29
Noti No. 06/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
RP liable to pay GST on following activities -
(c) the upfront amount paid by him for
• long term lease of land relatable to
• construction of residential apartments in the project
30Noti No. 06/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
RP liable to pay GST on following activities -
• the supply of construction service by him
• against consideration in the form of TDR or FSI,
Time of Supply
shall arise on the date of issuance of completion certificate
or on its first occupation,
whichever is earlier.
05-04-2019
11
31 Noti No. 03/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
• In case a regd. landowner transfers development right or FSI
• to a developer
• against consideration, wholly or partly,
• in the form of construction of apartments, -
• the developer has to pay tax on supply of construction of
apartment and
• the land owner shall be eligible to claim ITC of tax charged by
the developer
32 Noti No. 03/2019-Central Tax (Rate)
provided that
• the landowner further supplies such apartments
• to his buyers before issuance of completion certificate or first
occupation, whichever is earlier, and
• pays tax on the same which is not less than the amount of tax
charged from him
• on construction of such apartments by the developer
33
R.S. Goyal, Tax Practitionerswebsite : www.rsgoyal.com
e-mail : [email protected]
05-04-2019
1
Reduction in Rate of Tax
CA Krishan Garg
Effective Date and Notifications Issued
Notification No. 03-08 and 16/2019 CTR
Effective from 01/04/2019
CA Krishan Garg
05-04-2019
2
Applicability
CA Krishan Garg
Ongoing Projects(Option to be taken)
New Projects (No option)
CA Krishan Garg
Meaning of Ongoing Project (1/2)
Cons
t. Co
mm
ence
men
t Ce
rtifi
cate
Req
d. • Issued by Competent Authority on or before 31/03/2019
• Certified by Architect/ Chartered Engineer or Licensed Surveyor for start of project
Cert
ifica
te N
ot R
eqd. • Certified by
Architect/Chartered Engineer or Licensed Surveyor for start of project on or before 31/03/2019
Whe
n co
nsid
ered
to
have
st
arte
d • Earthwork for site preparation completed
• Excavation for foundation started
CA Krishan Garg
05-04-2019
3
Meaning of Ongoing Project (2/2)
• CC has not been issued
• First Occupation not taken place
CC or Ist Occupation
• Partly or• Wholly booked
on or before 31-03-2019
Appt. Partly or wholly booked • Part consideration become
due and payable • Atleast 1 inst. Credited• Allotment Letter or Sale
Agreement issued
Condition for Appt. booked
CA Krishan Garg
Ongoing projects – To decide
For continuing with existing scheme
Normal Residential Project-12%
Affordable Housing Proj-8%
Or to go with new ratesOr to go with new ratesCA Krishan Garg
Ongoing Project- If opted to continue with existing scheme
No change in rate
• Rate of Tax 8/12
ITC • Available
Rules• Existing
rules will be applicable
CA Krishan Garg
05-04-2019
4
Conditions for exercising one time option
Submit application before Commissioner in
the specific format
Last date 10/05/2019 (meanwhile invoices can be
issued as per option exercised)
Option to be exercised project wise and not on unit or company wise
If no option letter given then it will be deemed that lower
rate option exercised
How to exercise existing rate Option
CA Krishan Garg
Affordable Housing Option exercised - Existing Scheme to be followed
Existing scheme to follow
Opted for 8%
Ongoing Project
CA Krishan Garg
Ongoing Project- Effect if decided to be covered under new scheme
• RCM for shortfall in 80% criteria
• Maintain project wise accounting
• No ITC• Payment in cash
Reverse ITC
Reversal on project wise
ITC not availed to be reported
as ineligible credit
Reversal-Reverse
credit or in cash
CA Krishan Garg
05-04-2019
5
ITC Eligibility and Reversal
CA Krishan Garg
Classification of Project
• Section 2 of RERA• Development of Building for
sale
Real Estate Project (REP)
• A REP in which carpet area of commercial unit not more than 15%
Residential Real Estate Project
(RREP)CA Krishan Garg
REP Ongoing Projects : ITC attributable to Residential Portion
Existing rate option not
exercised (paying with lower rate)
Has time of Supply after 31/03/2019
Calculation project wise
CA Krishan Garg
05-04-2019
6
Situations: Till 31/03/2019
Certain % of completion is there
There is inventory in stock
Where % completion is zero but ITC availed on goods and services
received
Where % completion is zero but invoicing has been done and no
input/services received
Different Situations
CA Krishan Garg
REP Ongoing Project: Calculation of ITCWhere % completion is not zero or there is inventory
Commercial 40%
Affordable 30%
Normal 30%
ITC upto TOS 31/03/2019
ITC upto TOS 31/03/2019
Full ITC available CA Krishan Garg
Example- Project having 100000 sq. ft. Carpet Area and is 50% completeCommercial Area-50000 Sq. Ft• Booked 25000 Sq. Ft. (50%)- Total Value 10 crore• Amount due or Received – 7crore
Residential Affordable- 25000 Sq. Ft• Booked 10000 Sq. Ft. (40%)- Total Value 5 crore• Amount due or Received- 3 crore
Residential- Normal- 25000 Sq. Ft.• Booked 20000 Sq. Ft. (80%) – Total Value 10 crore• Amount due or Received- 4 crore
Total Carpet Area (C)- 50K Sq. Ft/100k Sq. Ft.
Carpet area (R) 50k sq. ft and booked 30k Sq. Ft
VOS (R) received 9 crore against total VOS – 15 crore CA Krishan Garg
05-04-2019
7
Summary: Completion percentage 50%
Nature of Activity
Carpet Area (sq. ft.)
Booked Area(sq. ft.)
% Unsold Area(sq. ft.)
Total VOS (crore)
VOS paid or payable (crore)
% of VOS paid or payable
Commercial
50000 25000 50 25000 10 7 70%
Affordable 25000 10000 40 15000 5 3 60%
Normal Residential Project
25000 20000 80 5000 10 4 40%
Total 100000 55000 55 45000 25 14 56%
CA Krishan Garg
ITC on inputs and input services attributable to Residential portion for TOS after 31/03/2019
ITC attributable to
TOS after 31/03/19 (Tx)
•Tx= Total ITC (T) – Eligible ITC (Te)
Total ITC
means
•ITC availed since 01/07/2017 including Transitional
CA Krishan Garg
How to calculate Total Eligible ITC : (Te=Tc+Tr)
CA Krishan Garg
Total Eligible ITC (Te) =
Eligible Commercial
ITC (Tc)+
Eligible Residential ITC
(Tr)
Tc=
Tr=
% completion as reported
in RERA otherwise
certified by Arch/Engg.
% completion as reported
in RERA otherwise
certified by Arch/Engg.
Total ITC
Carpet Area (C)Total Carpet Area (C+R)
Total ITC
Carpet (R)Total Carpet Area (C+R)
Booked
Total Carpet (R)
VOSTotal VOS Booked
1% of completion
05-04-2019
8
Alternate Option for calculation of Total Eligible Credit (Te)
Total eligible
(Te)=
Common Comm. Credit (Tc)+
Exclusive Comm Credit (T1)+
Eligible Residential Credit (Tr)
CA Krishan Garg
Result: Key Points
Pay Tax by reversal
or in cash
Furnish detail in Form ITC-03
If Tx is positive
In GST DRC-20
Commissioner order in GST DRC
21
Can request for instalment
CA Krishan Garg
REP Ongoing Project: Calculation of ITCWhere % completion is zero but ITC availed
Same procedure to be followed except
Modification in percentage completion
Percent Completion which can be achieved with input services received and inputs in stock to be certified by Architect/Engineer
CA Krishan Garg
05-04-2019
9
Where % completion is zero and no input/input services received but Invoicing as per TOS done
Total Eligible Credit (Te) = Eligible Commercial ITC (Tc)+Eligible Residential ITC (Tr)
Tc= ITC to be used in 2019-20*Carpet area comm/Total Carpet Area (C+R)
Tr=Tn*F1*F2*F3
Tn=Tax paid on inputs & Services in 2019-20CA Krishan Garg
Difference in percentage invoicing and percentage completion
Difference in percentage invoicing with percentage completion
If difference > 25%Then percentage invoicing deemed to be percentage completion +25%
Value of Invoices issued exceeds consideration recd.
If Difference >25%Then percentage invoicing deemed to be actual consideration received +25%
Value of inputs and services
If procurement of Inputs/services exceeds >25% of actual consumption
Te to be decided by commissioner based on actual per unit consumption duly certified by CA or CWA
CA Krishan Garg