Date post: | 16-Dec-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | victoria-underwood |
View: | 213 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Involvement of public &transparency of the planning process in
IWWs infrastructure project
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Ivan Mitrovic, Project ManagerDirectorate for Inland Waterways (Plovput), Republic of Serbia
Joint Statement5th workshop
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Content
Project area
Application of JS
Instead of conclusion
Summary
Current navigation conditions
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
01. Application of JS
JS: …supporting a dynamic equilibrium and adequate connectivity conditions…
• Adopted design approach:• Preserving connectivity
conditions
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
02. Application of JS
JS: …undisturbed longitudinal and lateral migration of all fish species and other water-related species to ensure their natural and self-sustaining development…
• Adopted design approach:• Preferring detached
structures
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
03. Application of JS
JS: …a balanced sediment budget…
• Adopted design approach:• Preserving sediment
equilibrium
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
0 6 12 18 24 30 36 42 48 54 60 66 72
Sedi
men
tatio
n [%
]
Months
Transverse [%]
Longitudinal [%]
Combined [%]
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
04. Application of JS
JS: …Establish interdisciplinary planning teams involving key stakeholders…
• Stakeholders’ Forum established
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Public participation matrix
Stage of the project when public participation is enabled
Repr
esen
tativ
enes
s of
rele
vant
st
akeh
olde
rs
Favorable position –
precondition for integrated
project planning
Early Late
Low
Hig
h
MITROVIC Ivan, MUSKATIROVIC Jasna, CURCIC Milica, OSTOJIC BARJAKTAREVIC Zaneta, ZANETTI Roberto: Integrated project planning in inland waterway project, Smart Rivers 2013
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Integrated project planning matrix
Representativeness of relevant stakeholders
Div
ersi
ficati
on o
f pro
ject
ob
jecti
ves
Favorable position - Integrated
projectplanning
Low
Hig
h
Low HighMITROVIC Ivan, MUSKATIROVIC Jasna, CURCIC Milica, OSTOJIC BARJAKTAREVIC Zaneta, ZANETTI Roberto: Integrated project planning in inland waterway project, Smart Rivers 2013
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
05. Application of JS
JS: …Set-up a transparent planning process (information/ participation)…
• Stakeholders’ Forum established• Web site, no restrictions
(2.000 hits monthly)• Serbian and English language• 9 Forum meetings• 2 site visits• 26 presentations on events• 24 articles• 1 movie
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Stakeholders’ Forum evaluation results
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
06. Application of JS
JS: …Ensure the comparability of alternatives…
• Multi-Criteria Analysis• Navigation• Environment• Technical feasibility• Costs
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
07. Application of JS
JS: …Inform and consult the international river commissions in the Danube River Basin…
• Stakeholders’ Forum
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
08. Application of JS
JS: …Seek to avoid or, if this is not possible, to minimize the impacts of structural/ hydraulic engineering interventions…
• For each of 6 sectors, at least 5 conceptual alternatives
• For conceptual alternatives, up to 35 simulations
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
09. Application of JS
Use of best practice measures to improve navigation…
• Using all available practice, to identify the most suitable solution for each sector, by case-by-case approach
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 100062
64
66
68
70
72
74
76
78
80
82
84
86EP_163.0_km_1262.825
distance from reference point left bank (m)
bed
leve
l (m
.a.s
.l.)
1987
1997
20042007
2011
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
10. Application of JS
JS: …Ensure flexible funding … to enable integrated planning and adaptive implementation & monitoring…
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
11. Application of JS
JS: …Monitor the effects of measures…
• Environmental monitoring ensured: before, during and after works• Hydro-morphology• Water and sediment quality• Biology
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
12. Application of JS
JS: …Use a case-by-case approach…
• Every critical sector analyzed by case-by-case approach
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
13. Application of JS
JS: …“working with nature” … following the principle of minimum or temporary engineering intervention…
• Mostly applied solution is dredging, with refilling the sediment back into the river
• Minimum structural interventions by application of different pilot solutions
• All structures detached
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
14. Application of JS
JS: …Integrated design of regulation structures, equally regarding hydraulic, morphological and ecological criteria…
• Multi-Criteria Analysis• Navigation• Environment• Technical feasibility• Costs
Model 1: BP-NS
Model 2 : NS-SK
#24: Preliv
#18: Susek #19: Futog
#21: Arankina Ada
#22: Cortanovci #23: Beska
Model 3 : SK-ZM
X-coordinate (m)
Y-c
oo
rdin
ate
(m
)
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
15. Application of JS
JS: …implementation of measures in an adaptive form (e.g. river bed stabilization by granulometric bed improvement, low water regulation by groynes)…
• All structures design to have impact only during low water periods
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
16. Application of JS
JS: …Optimal use of the potential for river restoration (e.g. river banks restoration) and side channel reconnection…
• Budget for (during monitoring programme) identified additional environmental compensation measures insured
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
17. Application of JS
JS: …Ensuring that flood water levels are not exacerbated and, ideally, are reduced…
• No long-term impact on water levels
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Current navigation conditionsCritical sector FUTOG – available depth, August 2012
19
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Current navigation conditionsCritical sector FUTOG – available depth, August and December 2013
19
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Instead of conclusion
• Acknowledging each others• Respecting each others• Building trust• Asking each others• Listening each others• Understanding each others• Learning from each others• Common understanding• Planning together• Working together
Zagreb,04-05th of February 2014
Project funded bythe European Union
Summary
Project area
Application of JS
Instead of conclusion
Summary
Current navigation conditions