Date post: | 27-Feb-2023 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | northcentral |
View: | 0 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 1
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers
©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A.
Presented at the 99th ASALH Convention
September 25, 2014
Paper Session: From the Civil War to Civil Rights
The Peabody Hotel, Memphis, TN
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 2
Contents
Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... 3
Literature Review ......................................................................................................................... 3
Voice Work .................................................................................................................................... 6
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ......................................................................... 7
Contemporary Voices ................................................................................................................. 15
Conclusion ................................................................................................................................... 16
References ..................................................................................................................................... 26
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 3
Abstract
Black singers in the United States emerged from Spirituals and Blues to develop Jazz.
Their free-spirited songs delivered messages of liberation, signaling to Africans in America that
they could be free. On the continent, the African voice inspired instrumentalists. Vocalese was a
dialogue between vocalists and instrumentalists. Each person had an individual sound and
instrumentalists imitated the voice’s cries, growls, moans, slurs, whispers, shouts, and wails.
Blues was the element of the American subculture created by enslaved Africans, singing European
music. Considered crude by classical listeners, Blues liberated singers from precise pitch and
calculated rhythms of European music. This paper discusses how and why Blues women were the
first civil rights workers because their lives and songs symbolized liberty in its rawest form by
tapping into the human spirit.
Literature Review
Blues were popularized by a handful of women, who were virtually unknown, nationally,
until Mamie Smith’s recording of Crazy Blues in 1920 (Obrecht, 2013). Minstrelsy produced
Gertrude “Ma” Rainey, who was born in Columbus, GA, on April 26, 1886, and lived until
December 22, 1939. From the age of 4, she traveled with her parents, singing and dancing with
them in minstrel shows and vaudeville. Known as The Mother of the Blues, Rainey was a
spokesperson for black people and a hero to them. She recorded hundreds of songs like Weepin’
Woman Blues, Broken Soul Blues, and Runaway Blues, on Paramount Records, putting that
recording company on the map. The most popular Blues singers established a rapport and rhetoric
with the crowd, winning them over like erudite politicians. Rainey took Bessie Smith under her
wing and the Blues tradition developed as one followed another (Cartwright, 2008, p. 9).
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 4
Angela Davis regarded Blues women as pre-feminists. Although “the first female anti-
slavery society was formed by Black women in 1832 in Salem Massachusetts” (Davis, 1983, p.
34), it was a Quaker minister Lucretia Mott that broke the silence endured by white women for
far too long, when she spoke out as one of four women invited to attend the founding convention
of the American Anti-Slavery Society, in 1833 (Ibid., p. 37). Mott’s Philadelphia home was the
site of an Underground Railroad station. “As they worked within the abolitionist movement,
white women learned about the nature of human oppression and . . . learned important lessons
about their own subjugation. . . . [and] exclusion from the political arena” (Ibid., p. 39).
Davis explored the lyrics of Blues singers “as examples of at least one nontraditional way
in which Black women negotiated and . . . articulated their socially constructed realities”
(Purnell, 2001, p. 262). For Europeans, music was an object of enjoyment and entertainment or
used to implement worship. So, music escaped the cultural genocide planned for slaves at the
onset of their captivity. As a result, music served as an aesthetic tool for community resistance,
which encouraged and nurtured a political community of active struggle for freedom (Davis,
1999). Davis (1999) asserted that art contains sociopolitical meanings that quicken social
progress, influence our emotions and knowledge, and propel us toward involvement in organized
movements seeking to effect radical social change.
In her book, Blues Legacies and Black Feminism: Gertrude "Ma" Rainey, Bessie Smith,
and Billie Holiday, Davis (1999) examined “blues . . . for their rhetorical significance, deeming
them worthy of critique” (Purnell, 2001, p. 262). She acknowledged Marx and Engles’
observation that art is “a form of social consciousness [that awakens] . . . those affected by it to .
. . transform their oppressive environments” (Davis, 1999). Also, Davis recognize that the
“slaveocracy failed to grasp the social function of music in all aspects of life in West African
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 5
society” (Davis, 1999), an idea that is congruent with the belief that had European slavers
understood the depth of culture to aggravate the agression of Africans, they would never have
instituted slavery at all. Herein lies the obsession with assassinating as many present-day
musicians and rappers as possible, whether physically, psychologically, psychedelically, or
otherwise.
Kalamu ya Salaam (1995) researched the social and aesthetic significance of African
American music. He found that music best communicates the reality of our existence better than
words. The most profound and serious moral lessons are articulated by the speaker’s talk-singing
style of orature (ya Salaam, 1995), which is enhanced by melodic blues accompaniment, featuring
minor chords with flatted thirds. Since African women were more apt to be applauded on
Southern stages than African men, music became the language spoken even with those who
disregarded the context of the Blues (ya Salaam, 1995), namely, liberated Africans and Euro-
Americans.
Furthermore, Blues could not have been “slave music [since] . . . Blues musicians, roaming
from town to town with guitar[s] . . . could not have existed prior to Emancipation because our
people did not enjoy freedom of movement during slavery” (ya Salaam, 1995, p. 30). Therefore,
the Blues was a musical genre of people who were prepared for and headed toward liberation.
The Blues women were the sirens of freedom, heretofore, thought of as only reachable after death,
according to the spiritualists, whose music remained in the realm of religion. Blues music, known
by religionists as Devil Music, “is a black cultural art form, blues is a ‘living archive,’ a form of
‘recollection’ that provides a ‘coded history of black injury’ resulting from historically entrenched
power relations.
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 6
The blues provides vital aural testimony of black social history in the United States in the
first half of the twentieth century” (Garabedian, 2006, p. 98). In his classes, Garabedian (2006),
alludes to the power of the Blues to convey defiance, dissimulation, and resistance. Like many
scholars, he noted that the Blues contains a code that enabled singers to “speak differently to their
friends, co-workers, parents, employers, and teachers” (Garabedian, 2006, p. 104) the same way
his students do. He encouraged his students to recognize the coded lyrics in Blues that are also
found in contemporary popular music like Hip Hop or Rap that are actually political with
overtones of protest. He concluded that “blues lyrical testimony documents the spectrum of
agency exercised by African Americans, through critical periods of struggle and solidarity in
twentieth-century US history” (Garabedian, 2006, p. 105).
Voice Work
The forced silence of women has been a subject of concern long before the age of the
suffragette. “The power of voice is a common theme in African American literature and
criticism. Enmeshed in a world of enforced silence, African American authors saw voice as a
source of personal and political agency” (Obourn, 2012, p.239). As in most women’s fiction
and feminist literature, in particular, the ability to communicate for African American writers
heralds “a search for identity and an affirmation of individual selfhood” (Obourn, 2012, p. 239).
Historically, women were “constructed as women by silencing their access to public
speech [with] a ‘split’ in voice: a ‘father tongue’ that speaks in the language of public discourse
and social power versus a ‘mother tongue’ that is interlocutionary, conversational, and that
‘expects an answer’” (Obourn, 2012, p.239). Speaking out is not an easy task and “political
freedom, including the freedom of speech, has [not] insured a person of social ability to voice
one’s sense of identity” (Obourn, 2012, p.239).
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 7
Voice work entails the manner in which an idea is politically and socially said or
understood. Voice work potentially alters “the ways in which speaking and hearing can function.
It is a term for theorizing a set of political tools that often function beyond our individual
control” (Obourn, 2012, p.239). Therefore, vocalists can be said to hold a power outside of the
realm of instrumentalists and even orators in that the musical accompaniment provides a
foundation for their rhetoric. Thus, Blues women stood on top of the pile of entertainers, often
seen as harmless by the producers and town councils that hosted minstrel shows.
Relationally, the minstrel mask worked for whites because it symbolized African
Americans as happy and fun loving. Rhetorically, the minstrel mask worked for blacks, allowing
the minstrels to patronize an audience of oppressors, while they complained about their low
social status, without fear of being arrested and tortured. However, this process did not extricate
them from the horror of their masked existence, and it functioned as a misused symbol
(Cartwright, 2009). Cultural politician Houston Baker contended that our experience of pleasure
and pain is individual, and the realm of the word is miniscule compared to the space of
wordlessness in which we exist, therefore, the minstrel mask symbolized the ritualistic repression
of the Africans' sexuality, play, id satisfaction, castration anxiety and humanity. "Its mastery,”
Houston avowed, “constituted a primary move in Afro-American discursive modernism"
(Cartwright, 2009, p. 32). The mask, then, was the precursor to African American literature,
politics, and open debate, and the Blues women grew adept at sporting it.
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers
Blues women were the first civil rights workers because their songs symbolized liberty in
its rawest form by tapping into the human spirit. Blues women spoke to and for black people,
providing them an open door to emotional escape. Ten of the most notable Blues women were:
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 8
1. Mamie Smith (OH, 1883-1946) Crazy Blues (1920)
2. Gertrude “Ma” Rainey (GA, 1886-1939) Black Bottom (1927)
3. Bessie Smith (TN, 1894-1937) Poor Man Blues (1928)
4. Alberta Hunter (TN, 1895-1984) Down-Hearted Blues (1922)
5. Ida Cox (TN, 1896-1967) Wild Women . . . (1924)
6. Ethel Waters (PA, 1900-1977) Stormy Weather (1933)
7. Josephine Baker (IL, 1906-1975) Lonesome Lovesick Blues (1927)
8. Billie Holiday (MD, 1915-1959) Strange Fruit (1939)
9. Eartha Kitt (SC, 1927-2008) St. Louis Blues (1958)
10. Nina Simone (NC, 1933-2003) Mississippi Goddam (1964)
Although most of Blues lyrics referenced unrequited love, they provided a means of
articulating pain, suffering, endurance, and overcoming. By the mere fact that these women were
permitted to sing in public forums, announced to Africans in America that they had something to
say about their treatment at the hands of slave owners, traders, rapists, and punishing spouses,
whether they were white men with whips or black men, who betrayed them. The replacement
from generation to generation of one Blues singer by another, created a heirarchy of rhetorical
agents clothed in beaded dresses of entertainers. Surely, each women understood within her soul
that she provided an emotional outlet for her people.
Blues was performed in the South, since the beginning of the 20th century, but none were
recorded “due to racism and the assumption that African-Americans couldn’t – or wouldn’t – buy
record players or 78s. [Mamie Smith’s] Crazy Blues changed all that, sparking a mad scramble
among record execs to record blues divas” (Obrecht, 2013, p.1). (See Appendix I for the lyrics
to songs by Blues women). Smith’s Crazy Blues sold 80,000 copies in one month. It
“revolutionized pop music [and] the song could be heard coming from the open windows of
virtually any black neighborhood in America” (Ibid.). According to Danny Barker, a noted jazz
musician from New Orleans, “That record turned around the recording industry [because] every
family had a phonograph in their house, specifically behind Mamie Smith’s first record” (Ibid.).
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 9
Following in Ma Rainey’s footsteps, Bessie Smith became the voice of Blacks migrating
to the North and West. In Blues Empress in Black Chattanooga: Bessie Smith and the Emerging
Urban South (2008), Michelle R. Scott outlines black life in Chattanooga, in “Ninth Street's
saloons . . . the few veiled environments in which they could be truly human, a humanity that was
powerfully expressed in the blues music that Smith perfected as a stage performer and recording
artist” (Goodson, 2010, p. 179). Bessie’s song Poor Man Blues called on the rich man to open up
his heart and mind, and give the poor man that fought WW I a chance. (See Appendix I).
For Kari Winter (1998) Alberta Hunter wrote blues lyrics that “empower the singer
toward feminist self-affirmation, agency, movement, and change” (Kuribayashi & Tharp, 1998,
p. 204). Hunter’s rough childhood, filled with abandonment, abuse, molestation, and communal
disdain, gave her the self-determination to rise to the top and stay away from trifling men, which
resulted in her inveterate lesbianism and feminist lifestyle. Her most noted song, Down-Hearted
Blues, declared that anyone who wanted her company must succumb to her command. This song
put Hunter and Bessie Smith “on the road to international fame in the 1920s” (Kuribayashi
& Tharp, 1998, p. 202).
Throughout her 77-year career, Hunter understood the power that writing weilded for
African Americans but also took precautions because the mere act connoted the connection
between freedom and “the decolonizing of identity – processes undertaken at tremendous risk
[because] literacy was outlawed [and] African Americans who wrote literally endangered their
lives with the same strokes whereby they claimed ownership of their lives” (Kuribayashi & Tharp,
1998, p. 203). As James Baldwin so aptly put it, “the blues artist risks ‘ruin, destruction, madness,
and death, in order to find new ways to make us listen’ [by encouraging her listeners] ‘to leave
the shoreline and strike out for the deep water’” (Ibid.). Having composed well into her eighties,
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 10
Hunter “participated in the blues philosophy that, resisting Master Narratives inspires energies
that undermine, bypass, subvert, and exceed patriarchal logic” (Ibid., p. 204).
Ethel Waters was a “pioneering Broadway, film, recording, and television star pioneering
Broadway, film, recording, and television star” (Frank, 2011, p. 98). Waters was the first to do
many things. “She was the first African American to be billed above the title in a Broadway
show” (Ibid.). Also, Waters was the first black woman to have a radio show and the first to sing
Am I Blue, Stormy Weather, Heat Wave, and The St. Louis Blues by W. C. Handy. In Heat Wave:
The Life and Career of Ethel Waters, biographer Donald Bogle (2011) recounted “the adulation,
the money, the critical acclaim, and the long runs [going] into great detail on how Waters rendered
a song so as to make one feel transported by it” (Gill, 2012, p. 256).
While touring Vaudeville as "Sweet Mama Stringbean", Waters encountered continuous,
life-threatening experiences. She was moved to sing Little Black Boy at the funeral of a “lynched
black youth deposited on the floor of the lobby of a theater where she was booked in Macon,
Georgia” (Saltz, 2009). As a result, “she had to plot a fast escape from the menacing theater
manager and the police” (Ibid.). Waters's dramatic performances on stage and screen included
the Broadway musical, As Thousand’s Cheer, and the films Mama's Daughters, Cabin in the Sky,
The Member of the Wedding, and Pinky (Gill, 2012) for which she was nominated for an Oscar.
Offstage, Waters was known to be mean due to a “lifetime of slights, [resulting from the]
economic, aesthetic, and racial politics of 1920s-60s popular culture” (Frank, 2011, p. 98). She
was openly bi-sexual and her voice could not be quieted. Her autobiography His Eye Is On The
Sparrow (1951) is a raw and memorable account of the injustices Waters suffered from childhood,
growing up in Chester and the ghettoes of South Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, three failed
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 11
marriages, since the age of 12, through her turbulent journey from stardom to eventual poverty,
before her death in 1977. As a postscript,
Ethel Waters should have spent her last years treated with the reverence and respect due a
person of her accomplishments. Unfortunately, she . . . distance herself from . . . militant
black colleagues by (a) starring as a maid on the TV series Beulah; (b) aligning herself
with . . . white Establishment types Billy Graham and Richard M. Nixon; and (c)
[proclaming] "I'm not concerned with civil rights. I'm concerned with God-given rights,
and they are available to everyone!" (Erickson, 2014).
The performances of singer and dancer Josephine Baker were “a popular form of
entertainment [and] tools that she used to display and communicate her resistance to ‘white
imagination’. [Baker] used nudity to display her own opposition against being placed under the
same gaze” (Bennerson, 2011, p. 9) as Sarah Bartmann, the South African woman put on display
in European side shows because of the size of her buttocks. At 11 years old, Baker witnessed
one of the worst post-WW I race riots, in 1917, in St. Louis, MO, that left thousands homeless
and at least 39 people dead. A victim of domestic abuse, from an early age, Baker “rebelled
from her teachers because she wanted to be seen; . . . rebelled from her mother because she saw
how unhappy her mother had become, and . . . rebelled from her husband because she saw
herself falling into the same trap of poverty that her mother had” (Bennerson, 2011, p. 45). Her
performance career began with a troupe known as The Jones Family. She moved from them to
the tutelage of Blues singer Clara Smith. After two failed marriages, she moved to New York to
join the casts of Shuffle Along and Chocolate Dandies, solidifying her career as a comedienne.
In 1925, Baker moved to Paris, where her illustrious career as The Banana Dancer
skyrocketed. “Her acceptance of her own sexuality suggested that Baker believed Black women
were more attractive than white women, French or American, and throughout her career she
would use herself as an example to prove it” (Bennerson, 2011, p. 50). Although many black
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 12
artists ceded to Paris, where the French marveled at the Black experience, the presence of racism
loomed large, influenced by class ranking in Parisian society (Bennerson, 2011, p. 52),
constantly reminding Baker that she was still a second-class citizen.
Ironically, this icon’s “original dancing style [and] nudity gave Baker the ability to ‘talk
back’ to her audience. By refusing to wear clothes, she challenged her audience to face their
own curiosity and fear about the black female body” (Bennerson, 2011, p. 61). Her ability to use
exaggerated eye movements, during her performance, forced the audience to reflect on their own
sexuality, placing Baker in control of the total experience. Baker “chose to go against what
people expected of her . . ., creating a platform for the future voice of resistance for those who
have not yet spoken” (Bennerson, 2011, p. 62).
Baker’s implicit control spilt over into her radical activism around racism in Europe and
the U.S., where she toured in 1950. Reportedly, Baker “demanded that she perform only for
integrated audiences at every venue. If curfew and segregation ordinances were still in place, she
requested that they be lifted for the duration of her performance in the hope that they would change
permanently” (Leigh, 2012, p. 165). Her persona as an agent of change for American blacks was
evidenced by three incidents. She “championed Willie McGee, a man accused of and convicted of
raping a white woman in Mississippi [and] . . . called attention to integrated housing in Cicero,
Illinois, while promoting integrated hiring of bus drivers in Oakland, California” (Ibid.).
Baker’s activism attracted the attention of not only the FBI but the NAACP that named May
20, 1951, Baker Day for her civil rights efforts. Baker spoke, worldwide, about the devastation of
racism. On August 28, 1963, she was the only female speaker at the March on Washington (Leigh,
2012, p. 166). Her efforts resulted in the desegregation of night clubs in Northern cities. But the
ultimate reality of Baker’s insistence on diversity was her adoption of 12 children from varying
nationalities and her insistence upon educating them within their respective cultures.
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 13
In 1939, Billie Holiday first sang Strange Fruit written by Abel Meeropol under the pen
name Lewis Allan. This was “the first significant song of the civil rights movement and the first
direct musical assault upon racial lynchings in the South” (Margolick, 2001). Holiday sang it at
Cafe Society in New York, revolutionizing the struggle it personified. Holiday’s rendition, is
“poignant and raw and saturated with pain, evok[ing] another time and place and yet is still
utterly relevant to race relations in the United States” (Casper, 2012). The song is a testament to
“the civil rights movement . . . [and] examines the lives of . . . Holiday and Meeropol, the Jewish
schoolteacher and communist sympathizer who wrote the song that impact[ed] generations of
fans, black and white” (Margolick, 2001).
The bastard child of a raped, 14-year-old cotton field worker in South Carolina, Eartha
Kitt debuted in her first film Casbah in 1948, at 16. She was a student of famed choreographer
Katherine Dunham. In 1960, she was blacklisted in the United States, after speaking out at a
Women Doer’s Luncheon at the White House, hosted by Lady Bird Johnson. Kitt explained to
the women of this elite group that some of the crime in the streets could be attributed to
“American youth . . . rebelling because of the Vietnam War” (Mezzack, 1990, p. 745).
Since 1953, Kitt taught dance to black children, who could not afford lessons. Later, in
1966, she founded the Kittsville Youth Foundation, a non-profit that served children in the
depressed neighborhoods of Watts in Los Angeles (Ibid., p. 747). Later that year, Kitt was
approached by youngsters in Anacostia, a neighborhood in Washington, D.C., to help them
fundraise for Rebels with a Cause. She contacted Congress Roman Pucinski and they went
before the House General Subcommittee on Education of the Committee on Education and Labor
regarding the Juvenile Delinquency Prevention Act of 1967, and won a grant for Rebels with a
Cause. In June, 1967, Kitt was appointed to the Citizen’s Advisory Board on Youth Opportunity
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 14
by President Lyndon Johnson, however, Kitt was not cleared to be on the board due to the
remarks she made at the Women Doer’s Luncheon in 1960.
However, in January 1968, Kitt was cleared to attend another luncheon at the White
House, where a panel of speakers discussed crime in America and the Vietnam War. Once more,
Kitt admonished the Johnsons that crime was connected to youths having to go fight an unjust
war. Although many in the room disagreed with Kitt’s statements, while hailing Mrs. Johnson
for her retort to Kitt, several citizens sent correspondence to the White House, stating that Kitt
spoke the words that millions of Americans, especially mothers of sons who had lost their lives.
One woman wrote, “So Lady Bird cried – well, doesn’t she know that the mothers of 15,000
boys MURDERED in Vietnam by her husband’s foreign policy cry every night” (Mezzack,
1990, p. 752)? Others felt that Kitt’s remarks were “a release of frustrations built up over
decades in blacks humiliated and disriminated against” (Ibid.). Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. said
that “Kitt’s remarks were ‘a very proper gesture’ and that they ‘decribed the feelings of many
persons’” (Ibid., p. 753). The leader of the Welfare Rights Movement, Etta Horn described
Kitt’s claims as beautiful, while Dick Gregory said, “Someone in Mrs. Johnson’s position ought
to be informed” (Ibid.). Baseball pioneer Jackie Robinson was quoted in an editorial in The New
York Times, stating “because whites have not experienced the pain and humiliations blacks have
suffered, they could not understand the anger” (Ibid.).
Despite disparate comments from many supporters of The Johnson, Kitt’s remarks
resounded throughout the nation, bringing awareness to the problem of crime and enlisting the
support of numerous organizations on the issue, including
15,000 chapters of the General Federation of Women’s Clubs, B’Nai B’rith, the District
of Columbia Anti-Crime Crusade, National Federation of Business and Professional
Women's Clubs (250,000 members), National Association of Colored Women’s Clubs,
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 15
Association of Junior Leagues of America, and 7 Keys to Freedom, a rehabilitation center
for ex-inmates. (Mezzack, 1990, p. 754).
Kitt’s career suffered largely because of a report generated by the FBI, Secret Service, National
Security Agency, and the CIA that was sent to the White House one week after the luncheon.
Kitt lost several contracts and a radio station KHEN in Oklahoma stopped playing her records.
Nevertheless, with all the bad publicity generated about her from her outspoken stance on “the
luncheon was symbolic of what many who were opposed to the war believed was insentivity on
the part of the White House to their views” (Mezzack, 1990, p. 745). Kitt was the voice in the
wilderness for minorities to whom it appeared the Johnsons had turned a deaf ear.
Contemporary Voices
A study of young feminists and leadership found that, when asked to identify outspoken
feminists, most young feminists point to music icons, exemplary of emotional mobilization
empowering women (Reger, 2007). In recent years, the song Wild Women Don’t Have The
Blues penned by Ida Cox in 1924, became a feminist anthem because she wrote and sang openly
about sexual freedom, a subject rarely broached by African American women of her time
(Harrison, 1988). This song was also the theme song for the W.C. Handy multi-award-winning
feminist/black power group Uppity Blues Women that morphed into Saffire, led by singer/
songwriter Gaye Adegbalola, who held that the group’s music was about empowerment,
following in the tracks of those divas in the '20s. Adegbalola and her group sang “about sex, its
joy and its pain [and] . . . topical things like 'School Teacher Blues' or 'Nothing's Changed' or '1-
800-799-7233,' the national domestic violence hotline number” (Harrington, 2005, p. 6). She
said, “the whole point of the blues is just to get the pain out."
Nina Simone “located American race relations in an international context in ways that
drew attention to gender as well as race” (Feldstein, 2005, p. 1373). Simone was one of the
“black women who evoked international [and] American issues in discussions of race” (Ibid.).
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 16
Miriam Makeba was a staunch activist against South African apartheid to the point of exile. She
joined her protests to “American calls for black power when she married Stokely Carmichael in
1968” (Ibid.). Simone’s fight for gender equity induced her to use “her body, her music, and her
words to forge links between Africa and African Americans and disseminated ideas about black
freedom that were not specifically about the U.S.” (Ibid.).
"I started to think about myself as a black person in a country run by white people and a
woman in a world run by men" (Feldstein, 2005, p. 1373), said Simone. In her song Go Limp,
“Simone played with an older tradition of African American female singers who [sang] about sex
. . . [like] second-wave feminists who would write about sex” (Feldstein, 2005, p. 1376). Their
“protest and politics converged in Simone's music [and] gender and sexuality informed her
denunciation of racial discrimination” (Ibid.). (See Appendix I for lyrics for Go Limp).
Conclusion
The Blues are neither mournful nor the cries of victims. Rather, they “articulate a hard-
won affirmation of life and self. The blues artist ‘fills the air with life,’ with her own life, which
[she] understands contains the lives of many other people as well” (Kuribayashi & Tharp, 1998,
p. 204), according to Baldwin. Most Blues singers are adept at shining light on the darkest
scenarios of existence, while simultaneously bringing laughter to center stage as a form of relief
for themselves and the entire audience, as well as the accompanying musicians. Blues women
have instituted the primary healing of the human spirit with their musical dalience that we can
forever be delighted with and grateful for. Blues is a breath of fresh air in the stagnant world of
discrimination, racism, physical and psychological abuse, and over all inhumanity towards
children, women, men, and whole groups of people. It is no wonder that Blues premeate the
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 17
planet, wherein, people from all nations and all walks of life enjoy the sound of the flatted third,
as the foundation of lyrics that can light up the face of even the most sardonic human being.
1. Mamie Smith (OH, 1883-1946) Crazy Blues (1920) 2. Gertrude “Ma” Rainey (GA, 1886-1939) Black Bottom (1927)
3. Bessie Smith (TN, 1894-1937) Poor Man Blues (1928)
4. Alberta Hunter (TN, 1895-1984) Down-Hearted Blues (1922) 5. Ida Cox (TN, 1896-1967) Wild Women . . . (1924)
6. Ethel Waters (PA, 1900-1977) Stormy Weather (1933)
7. Josephine Baker (IL, 1906-1975) Lonesome Lovesick Blues (1927) 8. Billie Holiday (MD, 1915-1959) Strange Fruit (1939)
9. Eartha Kitt (SC, 1927-2008) St. Louis Blues (1958)
10. Nina Simone (NC, 1933-2003) Mississippi Goddam (1964)
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 18
Appendix I
CRAZY BLUES by Mamie Smith (1920) I can't sleep at night
I can't eat a bite
'Cause the man I love
He don't treat me right
He makes me feel so blue
I don't know what to do
Sometime I sit and sigh
And then begin to cry
'Cause my best friend
Said his last goodbye
There's a change in the ocean
Change in the deep blue sea, my baby
I'll tell you folks, there ain't no change in me
My love for that man will always be
Now I can read his letters
I sure can't read his mind
I thought he's lovin' me
He's leavin' all the time
Now I see my poor love was blind
Now I got the crazy blues
Since my baby went away
I ain't got no time to lose
I must find him today
Now the doctor's gonna do all that he can
But what you're gonna need is an undertaker man
I ain't had nothin' but bad news
Now I got the crazy blues
BLACK BOTTOM by Gertrude “Ma” Rainey
Now, you heard the rest
Ah, boys, I'm gonna show you the best
Ma Rainey's gonna show you her black bottom
Way down south in Alabamy
I got a friend, they call dancin' Sammy
Who's crazy about all the latest dances
Black bottom stomps and the Jew baby prances
The other night at a swell affair
Soon as the boys found out that I was there
They said, "Come on, Ma let's go to the cabaret"
Where that band you ought to hear me say"
I want to see that dance you call the black bottom
I wanna learn that dance
Don't you see the dance you call your big black bottom
That'll put you in a trance
All the boys in the neighborhood
They say your black bottom is really good
Come on and show me your black bottom
I want to learn that dance
I want to see the dance you call the black bottom
I want to learn that dance
Come on and show that dance you call your big black bottom
It puts you in a trance
Early last morning 'bout the break of day
Grandpa told my grandma, I heard him say
Get up and show your old man your black bottom
I want to learn that dance
Now I'm gonna show y'all my black bottom
They stay to see that dance
Wait until you see me do my big black bottom
I'll put you in a trance
Ah, do it ma, do it, honey
Look it now Ma, you gettin' kinda rough here
You gotta be yourself now, careful now
Not too strong, not too strong, Ma
I done shown y'all my black bottom
You ought to learn that dance
Songwriter: MA RAINEY, GERTRUDE
Published by Lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Group
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 19
WILD WOMEN DON’T HAVE THE BLUES by Ida Cox
I hear these women raving 'bout their monkey men
About their trifling husbands and their no good friends
These poor women sit around all day and moan
Wondering why their wandering papa's don't come home
But wild women don't worry, wild women don't have no blues
Now when you've got a man, don't never be on the square
'Cause if you do he'll have a woman everywhere
I never was known to treat no one man right
I keep 'em working hard both day and night
'Cause wild women don't worry, wild women don't have their blues
I've got a disposition and a way of my own
When my man starts kicking I let him find another home
I get full of good liquor, walk the streets all night
Go home and put my man out if he don't act right
Wild women don't worry, wild women don't have their blues
You never get nothing by being an angel child
You better change your ways and get real wild
I wanna tell you something, I wouldn't tell you a lie
Wild women are the only kind that really get by
'Cause wild women don't worry, wild women don't have their blues
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 20
POOR MAN BLUES by Bessie Smith
Mister Rich Man, Rich Man
Open up your heart and mind
Mister Rich Man, Rich Man
Open up your heart and mind
Give the poor man a chance
Help stop these hard, hard times
While you livin' in your mansion
You don't know what hard time means
While you livin' in your mansion
You don't know what hard time means
Oh, workin' man's wife is starvin'
Your wife is livin' like a queen
Please, listen to my pleadin'
'Cause I can't stand these hard times long
Oh, listen to my pleadin'
Can't stand these hard times long
They'll make an honest man do things
That you know is wrong
All man fought all the battles
All man would fight again today
All man fought all the battles
All man would fight again today
He would do anything you ask him
In the name of the U.S.A
Now the war is over
All man must live the same as you
Now the war is over
All man must live the same as you
If it wasn't for the poor man
Mister Rich Man what would you do?
Songwriter: Bessie Smith
Published by FRANK MUSIC CORP.
DOWN-HEARTED BLUES by Alberta Hunter
My man mistreated and he drove me from his door
Lord, he mistreated me and he drove me from his door
But the Good Book says you've got
To reap just what you sow
I got the world in a jug, got the supper?
Right here in my hand
I got the world in a jug, got the supper?
Right here in my hand
And if you want me, sweet papa
You gotta come under my command
Say, I ain't never loved but three men in my life
Lord, I ain't never loved but three men in my life
'twas my father and my brother And a man that wretched my life
Lord, it may be a week and it may be a month or two
I said, it may be a week and it may be a month or two
All the dirt you're doin' to me
Sho' comin' home to you
Lord, I walked the floor, hang my head and cried
Lord, I walked the floor, hang my head and cried
Had the down hearted blues
And I couldn't be satisfied
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 21
STORMY WEATHER by Harold Arlen and Ted Koehler
(First sung by Ethel Waters in 1933)
Don't know why there's no sun up in the sky
Stormy weather
Since my man and I ain't together,
Keeps rainin' all of the time
Life is bare, gloom and mis'ry everywhere
Stormy weather
And I just can't get my poorself together,
I'm weary all the time, so weary all the time
When he went away the blues walked in and met me.
If he stays away old rockin' chair will get me.
All I do is pray the Lord above will let me
Walk in the sun once more.
I can't go on, can't go on, can't go on, ev'ry thing I had is gone
Stormy weather
Since my man and I ain't together
Keeps rainin' all the time
I walk around heavy-hearted and sad
Night comes around and I’m still feeling bad
Rain pouring me down blindin’ every hope I had
This pitterin’, patterin’, beatin’, and splatterin’ drives me mad
Love, love, love, love
This misery is just too much for me
Can’t go on, all I have in life is gone
Stormy weather
Since my man and I ain’t together
Keeps rainin’ all the time
Keeps rainin’ all the time
Stormy Weather lyrics © EMI Music Publishing
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 22
ST. LOUIS BLUES by W.C. Handy
(Sung by Bessie Smith, Billie Holiday, and Eartha Kitt)
I hate to see the ev'nin' sun go down
I hate to see the ev'nin' sun go down
It makes me think of all my left go 'round
Feelin' tomorrow like I feel today
Feelin' tomorrow like I feel today
I'll pack my trunk and make my getaway
St. Louis woman with her diamond rings
Pulls my man around by her apron strings
Wasn't for powder and his store-bought hair
The man I love, wouldn't go nowhere, nowhere
I got the St. Louis blues just as blue as I can be
He's got a heart like a rock cast in the sea
Or else he wouldn't have gone so far from me
I love my man like a school boy loves his pie
Like a Kentucky colonel loves his mintn rye
I love my baby till the day I die
STRANGE FRUIT by Abel Meeropol
(Performed and Recorded by Billie Holiday in 1939)
Southern trees bear strange fruit
Blood on the leaves and blood at the root
Black bodies swinging in the southern breeze
Strange fruit hanging from the poplar trees
Pastoral scene of the gallant south
The bulging eyes and the twisted mouth
Scent of magnolias, sweet and fresh
Then the sudden smell of burning flesh
Here is fruit for the crows to pluck
For the rain to gather, for the wind to suck
For the sun to rot, for the trees to drop
Here is a strange and bitter crop
Published by Lyrics © EMI Music Publishing
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 23
GO LIMP by Nina Simone
Oh Daughter, dear Daughter
Take warning from me
And don't you go marching
With the N-A-A-C-P.
For they'll rock you and roll you
And shove you into bed.
And if they steal your nuclear secret
You'll wish you were dead.
[Refrain:]
Singin too roo la, too roo la, too roo li ay.
Singin too roo la, too roo la, too roo li ay.
Oh Mother, dear Mother,
No, I'm not afraid.
For I'll go on that march
And I'll return a virgin maid.
With a brick in my handbag
And a smile on my face
And barbed wire in my underwear
To shed off disgrace.
[Refrain]
One day they were marching.
A young man came by
With a beard on his cheek
And a gleam in his eye.
And before she had time
To remember her brick
They were holding a sit-down
On a neighboring hay rig.
[Refrain]
For meeting is pleasure
And parting is pain.
And if I have a great concert
Maybe I won't have to sing those folk songs again.
Oh Mother, dear Mother
I'm stiff and I'm sore
From sleeping three nights
On a hard classroom floor.
[Refrain]
One day at the briefing
She'd heard a man say,
"Go perfectly limp
And be carried away."
So when this young man suggested
It was time she was kissed
She remembered her briefing
And did not resist.
[Refrain]
Oh Mother, dear Mother,
No need for distress,
For the young man has left me
His name and address.
And if we win
Tho' a baby there be
He won't have to march
Like his da-da and me.
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 26
References
Bennerson, A. J. (2011). You must not know bout me: Reviewed resistance of Sarah Bartmann,
Josephine Baker, and Beyonce Knowles. State University of New York at Buffalo). 103
p. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/879554866?accountid=28180
Bogle, Donald. (2011). Heat wave: The life and career of Ethel Waters. Harper Collins. 624 p.
ISBN: 9780061241734
Casper, M.J. (2012, April 7). On race, trauma, and "Strange Fruit". The Feminist Wire.
Retrieved from http://thefeministwire.com/2012/04/on-race-trauma-and-strange-fruit
Cartwright, J. (2009). A history of African American jazz and blues. FYI Communications, Inc.
156 p. ISBN: 9780557060108
Cartwright, J. (2008). Amazing musicwomen. FYI Communications, Inc. 112 p. ISBN: 97805570373229780557037322
Davis, A.Y. (1999). Blues legacies and black feminism: Gertrude "Ma" Rainey, Bessie Smith,
and Billie Holiday. 464 p. New York: Random House.
Davis, A.Y. (1983). Women, race, and class. Random House, NY. 271 p.
Erickson, H. (2014, September 21). Ethel Waters: Biography. The New York Times. Retrieved
from http://www.nytimes.com/movies/person/74929/Ethel-Waters/biography
Feldstein, R. (2005). "I don't trust you anymore": Nina Simone, culture, and black activism in the
1960s. The Journal of American History, 91(4), 1349-1379. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/224896917?accountid=28180
Frank, J. (2011). Heat wave: The life and career of Ethel Waters. Library Journal, 136(1), 98.
Frymer, P. (2008). Black and blue: African Americans, the labor movement, and the decline of
the Democratic Party / Paul Frymer. Princeton: Princeton University Press, c2008.
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 27
Garabedian, S. (2006). Blues testimony and black agency. Transformations, 17(1), pp. 98-106.
Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/220394164?accountid=28180
Gill, G. (2012). Heat wave: The life and career of Ethel Waters. African American
Review, 45(1/2), pp. 255-256.
Goodson, S. (2010). Blues empress in black Chattanooga: Bessie Smith and the emerging urban
south. The Journal of Southern History, 76(1), 178-179. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/215777983?accountid=28180
Hanson, J. (2003). Mary McLeod Bethune and Black women's political activism. Columbia:
University of Missouri Press. 123 p.
Harrington, R. (2005, Sep 02). Saffire lightens up the blues. The Washington Post Retrieved
from http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/409881577?accountid=28180
Harrison, D.D. (1988). Black pearls: Blues queens of the 1920s. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers
University Press.
Hayes, E.M. (2007). Songs in black and lavender: Race, sexual politics, and women's music.
African American Music in Global Perspective.
Hayes, E. & Williams, L.F. (eds.) (2007). Black women and music: More than the blues.
University of Chicago Press. 261 p.
Kuribayashi, T. & Tharp, J.A. (1998). Creating safe space: Violence and women’s writing. 239
p. ISBN: 9780791435649
Leigh, J. L. (2012). Who shall let this world be beautiful?: Seeds of black female creativity in
Josephine Baker and Octavia E. Butler. Morgan State University. 229 p. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/1030444500?accountid=28180
Margolick, D. (2001). Strange fruit: Billie Holiday, Café Society, and an early cry for civil
rights. 168 p. Harper Perennial. ISBN: 978-0060959562
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 28
Mezzack J. (1990, Fall). `Without manners you are nothing': Lady Bird Johnson, Eartha Kitt, and
the Women Doers' Luncheon. Presidential Studies Quarterly; 20(4): p. 745.
Obourn, M. (2012). Early civil rights "voice work" in Richard Wright and Zora Neale
Hurston. Twentieth Century Literature, 58(2), 238-IV. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/1391943951?accountid=28180
Obrecht, J. (2013). Mamie Smith: The first lady of the blues. Jas Obrecht Music Archive.
Retrieved from http://jasobrecht.com/mamie-smith-the-first-lady-of-the-blues
Purnell, K. L. (2001). Blues legacies and black feminism. Women's Studies in
Communication, 24(2), pp. 262-265. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/198268684?accountid=28180
Reger, J. (2007). Where are the leaders? Music, culture, and contemporary feminism. The
American Behavioral Scientist, 50(10), pp. 1350-1369. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/214762259?accountid=28180
Saltz, S. (2009, September 18). Review: Ethel Waters: His eye is on the sparrow (U.S. 1).
Retrieved from http://www.passagetheatre.org/index.php/about/press-archives/107-
review-ethel-waters-his-eye-is-on-the-sparrow-us-1
Setka, S. (2014). Haunted by the past: Traumatic rememory and black feminism in Gayl Jones's
Corregidora. Mosaic: A Journal for the Interdisciplinary Study of Literature, 47(1), pp.
129-144. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/1508688257?accountid=28180
Schueneman, M. K. (2012). A leavening force: African American women and Christian mission
in the civil rights era. Church History, 81(4), pp. 873-902.
doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S000964071200193X
Strait, J. (2012). Experiencing Blues at the Crossroads: A Place-Based Method for Teaching the
Geography of Blues Culture. Journal of Geography, 111(5), pp. 194-209.
Thaggert, M. (2012). Marriage, moynihan, mahogany: Success and the post-civil rights black
female professional in film. American Quarterly, 64(4), pp. 715-740, 917. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/1287556934?accountid=28180
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 29
Werner, C. (2012). "Meeting over yonder": Using music to teach the movement in the
north. Magazine of History, 26(1), pp. 41-45. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/921280055?accountid=28180
Wilson, Karen. (2006). Harlem wisdom in a wild woman's blues: The cool intellect of Ida Cox.
Afro-Americans in New York Life and History, 30.2. pp. 99-126.
ya Salaam, K. (1995). It didn't jes grew: The social and aesthetic significance of African
American music. African American Review, 29(2), p. 351. Retrieved from
http://search.proquest.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/docview/209795855?accountid=28180
Blues Women: The First Civil Rights Workers ©2014 Joan Cartwright, M.A. 30
SPECIAL BOOK OFFER TO SCHOOLS AND LIBRARIES: Buy 20 or more get 20% off
www.fyicomminc.com/books.html Book orders of 20 or more are offered at up to 20% discount, if prepaid FYI COMMUNICATIONS, INC. Tax ID #65-0790514 2644 Graywall Street East Point, GA 30344 954-740-3398
www.wijsf.com/musicians.htm Musicians are contracted through our 501(c)(3) non-profit organization. Women in Jazz South Florida, Inc. Tax ID #20-865-6432 2644 Graywall Street East Point, GA 30344 954-740-3398 W9 available upon request.
Diva Joan Cartwright has toured five continents and 16 countries, including
the U.S., 8 European countries, Brazil, Mexico, Ghana, Gambia, South
Africa, Jamaica, China and Japan, with her swinging brand of jazz and blues.
She performed with jazz legends Philly Joe Jones, Shirley Scott, Sonny Stitt,
Freddie Hubbard, Dr. Lonnie Smith, Lou Donaldson, Dorothy Donegan,
Oliver Jackson and hundreds of others, during the course of her career.
A Doctoral candidate at Northcentral University in Business Administration,
Joan holds a B.A. in Music and Communications from LaSalle
University in Philadelphia and a Master of Arts degree in Communications
from Florida Atlantic University in Boca Raton, Florida. Joan is a composer
and author of nine books. Her first book, IN PURSUIT OF A MELODY
contains 40 songs and lyrics to standard songs: "A Night in Tunisia" by Dizzy
Gillespie, "Blue Bossa" by Kenny Dorham, "Tune Up" by Miles Davis and
"Bessie's Blues" by John Coltrane. Her first recorded composition was
“Sweet Return” (Atlantic Records, 1983) by Freddie Hubbard and the Kool Jazz All-Stars of 1983. The
book also contains two lectures - SO, YOU WANT TO BE A SINGER? and AMAZING MUSICWOMEN,
given to over 8,000 students, in the U.S.A., Switzerland, Sicily, China and Japan. Her workshops are
dynamic and educational, highlighting the pitfalls and benefits of the music business. She contends that,
"Knowing music theory is a step in the right direction for any singer who truly wants to excel in the world
of music!"
In 2007, Cartwright founded Women in Jazz South Florida, Inc., a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization that
promotes women musicians, globally. Visit the website at www.wijsf.org.
Joan is available for bookings around the world. Her knowledge of music and her professional attitude
enables Joan to travel alone and work with professional jazz and blues musicians, wherever she is contracted
to perform. This talented lady is bound to bring a smile to your face with her swinging jazz and blues! Don't
miss the opportunity to enjoy her performance, when she comes to your side of town! Visit websites:
www.joancartwright.com, www.fyicomminc.com. Search "Joan Cartwright" on www.cdbaby.com for
FEELIN' GOOD (Sicily, 1995) and IN PURSUIT OF A MELODY (U.S., 2006).